Episode #97 What Does The Word Of Wisdom Really Say About The Consumption of Meat W/Joshua Erickson
Go To http://patreon.com/MormonRenegade368 For Exclusive Content
I am a man of simple tastes. I love hanging out with my family, I love learning about the Gospel, I like watching football while eating Doritos and washing it down with an ice-cold diet Pepsi and really like smoking brisket and grilling steak. But if you like me maybe you have stopped and asked the question…. Am I eating meat “sparingly”? Well fellow carnivores rejoice!! Today on the podcast I have Joshua Erickson back on the podcast and we take a deep dive into the Word of Wisdom and really look at that portion where it talks about the consumption of meat.
Go To deseretflag.com to get your Deseret Flag Today
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:04 I enjoy doing this podcast each and every single episode, but some are just kind of fun and light hearted and this is going to be one of those. I'm a man of simple taste. I enjoy hanging out with my family. I enjoy learning about the gospel. I like watching football while eating a bag of Doritos and washing it down with an ice cold Diet Pepsi. But what I really like to do when I'm not sitting in front of a hot mic is smoking brisket or grilling steak. But if you're like me, you've stopped a couple times and asked the question, am I eating meat sparingly? Well, fellow carnivores, rejoice. Today on the podcast I have Joshua Erickson on as we take a deep dive into the Word of Wisdom and really take a good look at that portion where it talks about the consumption of meat. So get ready for a delicious episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast.
0:55 Look, it's no secret that our society has become much more crude and coarse. To become and raise men and women of virtue and character is a Herculean task. To help with this, I've recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior and Company and Conversation. It was a book with 110 rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society, something that today's society is sorely lacking. What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So the book is laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule.
1:35 Right below that is my explanation for the 21st century, and below that you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, to go along with this, there's a workbook that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids. To find the book, go to mormonrenegade.com. Go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post, and order your copy today. I can bear personal testimony from personal experience that this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character.
2:36 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. So did my fellow carnivores. All those folks that just love a good steak, Maybe some brisket, some chicken. I have got some great news for you. Yay, this episode. You could really call the gospel what it is. The good news. So Joshua, when? When? This is some. This is some meaty, juicy stuff. Meat. Juicy, right? Meaty. Like like savory over the fire kind of stuff. So sweet.
3:20 Savour. Sweet. Savour. Yes, yes. So if you're a vegetarian, First off, if you're a vegetarian for the reasons I think most people listen to this podcast are, you could be a little disappointed. I want to throw that out there right away. If you're a vegetarian because you have ethical problems killing animals, you are a rock star. I get it. But I'm not that guy. So this may not be the episode for you if you're a vegetarian. But none the less, in all seriousness, I want to say this. When I first heard Joshua here give give this presentation at the at the Torah conference, one I was just extremely happy. I went home with my faith, renewed my cup. It overflowed.
4:15 But it it does actually point to some misunderstandings we might have about the Word of Wisdom, specifically the part having to do with eating meat. So with that Joshua, why don't you just take it from there? Start out there. OK, First off, what got you interested in this right? Yeah, OK. That's a good question. Yeah, I will say it was a it was a struggle that I had a a difficulty in interpreting the scriptures because my and I've talked about this before, my faith is that the the God that we worship does not change, does not change his mind about things. About his commandments, about what is pleasing and not. He doesn't.
5:10 Yeah, So. And yet, when, you know, when I read the Doctrine Covenants, when I read Section 89 in times past, not anymore, but in times past, I read some things in there that didn't seem to harmonize with some of the things in the Old Testament especially so. You know in section 89 I've got here word of Wisdom. Before you go there, I want to share just a quick personal experience with this 'cause I too had a a few issues with with the Word of Wisdom as far as the the eating of meat and this comes from a real world experience of mine.
5:54 So this was about a year before I started the podcast and my doctor, he's like, you know, you're you're like 43, not going to lie. You're chunky, right? You, you you got some girth to you. I'm bigger. I was bigger than than I am now he's like, let's get some blood work. So he takes some blood work and he said you need to get. Back in here, OK, I was like, uh, oh, and he's like, bring your wife. Now me and my doctor, he's kind of an old school doctor, so he knew damn well if he doesn't. Want to follow the doctor's orders? I'm not going to follow. Right. He's going to have my wife in there, right?
6:34 So Amber comes with me and the doctor says, look, you want to cut down on how badly you feel? Because I had, I tore an ACL and I had constant inflammation. No good. He's like, so we need to figure out what we're going to do. And I said, OK, let me guess, all vegetables and blah, blah, blah. He said, well, most guys, I say yes, he said. But because I know that you're not going to follow that anyway, I want to kind of run an experiment with you and we'll keep we'll we'll keep close tabs on you and we'll go from there. Now I have a buddy won't name the university because I don't want to get him in trouble, but he he he's in kinesiology. I talked to him about it and he said, yeah, go for it. So the experiment was this.
7:28 My doctor had this idea that the food pyramid as we use it now, isn't correct. Well you can almost bet that like and and and he said that that in his studies he found that the the study that was done that pegged sclerosis of the arteries built plaque in your arteries was the second study that was done. The first study that was done pointed to refined sugars and refined carbs right pastas, breads you know candy that sort of stuff.
8:09 When when that came back, that particular lobby went, I got a pile full of money here. That bets you can come up with a better study. And then the animal fats were were to blame. So he said, what I want to do, this is my doctor to me. He says I want to put you on a high protein diet and with just raw vegetables, if you have a hankering for something sweet, some honey or fruit, that's what it was. So I was like, so I still get to eat steak? Yes, you still get to eat steak. I'm good now. When I left the doctor's office that day, I had high blood pressure, high cholesterol and I weighed about £35 more than what I do right now.
8:56 We coupled that with exercise as well and those were the only things we changed. And my my exercise routine is a lot of heavyweight lifting and some intense interval training as far as cardio. I do that for three weeks and I go back in and have my cholesterol checked. The cholesterol is back down to where it should be. Good cholesterol, bad cholesterol. High blood pressure is gone. The hypertension is completely gone. My testosterone raised by a whole bunch. Kudos to that doctor for not just. Yeah, and. So prescribing you a drug for those things, right, That's. A. That's a rare, yeah. And so as as I looked at that and and I did that, I was super happy with the outcome and and I felt different.
9:43 All the inflammation left, right. I didn't have the knee problems. I didn't have the the chronic pain I was having. I didn't have crashes throughout the day, you know, 'cause normally about 2:00 I could count on just wanting to take a nap. I didn't have that anymore and I was full all day. I wasn't feeling hungry all the time and but it still presented something that somewhat of of a conflict with the word of Wisdom I felt I felt like it was a conflict because it said to eat meat sparingly and we'll get into that too here later. So when you gave this talk at Sunstone I I just resigned myself to say OK not Sunstone excuse me the I apologize for that I I don't mean to fly the they still want.
10:33 People to go look for it. Yeah, the the the Torah conference. It was it was really a testimony builder to me that that that maybe we got some things wrong with this. And just just a little teaser Keep out for keep an ear out for the name Heber J Grant in this 'cause I think that comes up here at some point. All right. Go ahead. OK, so like I said, it was, you know, it's you felt some tension, right, with this diet that you were given and yet? And yet it was the results were real, right, Tangible, right. You experienced that Not just in my blood work, how I felt, how I was able to function as a human being.
11:19 Right. I mean, and that's, I mean, I I think it's, I think the blood work's even more amazing, actually, because it's like this is not just changing your attitude, this is changing your chemistry, right. Like that's something. I mean, that's that's hard to fake, you know? You can say, Oh yeah, I feel better today. But you know you draw your blood and measure, right. Whatever all the things that they're measuring and you can't fake that. So, so so that's I mean that's a that's a testimony right there of that what there was there was some true principles behind what you were doing. So I didn't.
11:59 I never had had that kind of experience, but. But when I when I kind of came into this idea of loving the Torah and believing that's like the foundation and that those things still apply as as far as possible, then and and then also knowing the kind of standard interpretation of the Word of Wisdom, especially with the eating meat, then in my mind there's a conflict there and but I just kind of kept wrestling with it. And which is I think a healthy thing to do, is when you have what seems like a contradiction.
12:44 If you can, if you can manage to kind of hold those contradictory ideas in your mind without like falling to pieces and just giving up on everything, then eventually if you just hold on to it long enough and investigate it long enough, then you'll be able to see how things fit together. I mean, I've, I've experienced that before. Probably you've experienced things like that before. So and that's OK. I mean, you know what Israel means? Like the name Israel to wrestle with God. Wrestle with God. Yeah. So those who are Israelites wrestle with God. They don't just fall in line or whatever and necessarily believe everything without trying it.
13:28 I think. I think. I think God appreciates a good. Wrestle, whether that's a physical wrestle or a, you know, in your mind with your faith or whatever. So, so this was kind of one of my wrestles and I thought this would be a good, a good one to present. So yeah, so so going to the to the Word of Wisdom verse 12 and 13 there say and you know we've all read this 1000 * 1000 times. Yeah, it's a short section and it's. So prevalent. It's such a prevalent part of Mormon culture, so I'll but I'll read it anyway. Yeah, flesh, also a beast. And of the fowls of the air I, the Lord, have ordained for the use of man with Thanksgiving. Nevertheless, they are to be used sparingly, and it is pleasing unto me that they should not be used only in times of winter, or of cold, or of famine. OK.
14:22 And you know, there's. You know verse 14 and 15 kind of kind of repeat that or it seems like it repeats it, so we'll get into that later. But but those verses, they seemed in my mind. They seem to contradict what I call like the good old way that Father Abraham lived, where he was sitting in his tent in the this in Genesis says in the heat of the day. So this is not winter, nor cold, nor famine. I mean, Abram was rich, that was he's had flocks and herds plenty. This was he was not experiencing famine.
15:04 And then he has the the three visitors. And right away who are who are angels, right? The Lord himself is one of them. And right away he kills a fatted calf, makes him unleavened bread, right. And. And you know, so you know, in the Word of Wisdom here it says, verse 13 says, it is pleasing unto me that they, meaning the beast field with thousands of the air, should not be used only in times of winter, cold or famine. So the question in my mind or one question that you could ask is was that pleasing what Abram did? And you know what I gave in at the at the Torah conference? I think it was, Benjamin said.
15:50 He seemed to please him. He seemed to enjoy it, right? Yeah. Which is you know an excellent way to put it. So has what pleases the Lord changed or or is there something maybe that that we're not understanding. So that's kind of the the crux you know. And there's there's other things too in the in the Old Testament I I love the Passover. We've done an episode about Passover and. You know, and we we keep the Passover, but the Passover is in the spring. You know, it's not in winter. And we're definitely not starving. So there's none of that other stuff either. And so, but we, you know, we have a lamb and we roast it and we, we eat it and we invite our friends over and have a party, you know, and that I want to say this too, that's unusual for ritualistic sacrifice. If you look at the bulk of ritualistic sacrifice throughout other denominations, whether that was the Phoenicians, whether that was the Romans, those things didn't get consumed.
16:53 Those were supposed to be consumed by by whatever God you were going to. So the fact that the Lord is saying. Let's share. Let's have a meal. Let's have a meal right I find interesting. That is interesting. So now, you know, you could just say, and many people do, not necessarily about the Word of Wisdom, but you could say, yeah, you know, back then. They did that. But that stuff's been done away, you know. But that's not. I can't, I can't lean on that. That's not part of my faith. I think. I don't. I don't agree with that. So. So how do I reconcile with God saying in Exodus do this Passover thing forever, and then in the Word of Wisdom saying it's not pleasing to me for you to eat meat except in winter time or whatever?
17:46 So, but, you know, Joseph Smith said kind of famously said by proving contraries, truth is made manifest. So we take things that seem contrary. We butt them up against one another and push them around and look at them from different angles and eventually, you know, we'll find the truth. So there's and you know, Speaking of the the Passover, I mean the Word of Wisdom references the Passover directly, right in his promises. At the end it says. The very last verse I, the Lord, give unto them a promise. Well, let's see verse 18. Sorry for 18. It says those who I'll just paraphrase those who do the Word of Wisdom and keep the commandments, then they get these promises.
18:30 Verse 21 says one of the promises is that the destroying angels shall pass by them as the children of Israel and not slay them. So this is like directly connected to the Passover, which is again just a weird thing if you think like the promises of the Passover are in here. Right, but God is saying the thing that brought about the promise is not pleasing to me, right? Like that's that doesn't, that doesn't jive, yeah. And again and again, you could say, you could fall back again, like, yeah, but the the actual Passover is done away or something. And, you know, there's just these kind of spiritualized promises or whatever, but.
19:15 You know, but I read in Luke at the Last Supper, the Last Supper was just, I believe there is some controversy on this, but I believe it was immediately before, like the night before Passover, right? Right. And then Jesus was actually crucified on Passover, right. So in Luke, Luke 22, they're having the Last Supper, Jesus says. With desire I have desire to eat this Passover with you before I suffer, For I say unto you, And now here's the JST comes in, I say unto you, I will not anymore eat thereof of the Passover until it be, until it be fulfilled, which was written in the prophets concerning me then.
20:02 I will partake with you in the Kingdom of God. Basically he's saying when, so when the Kingdom of God comes and which is at his return. Right when he When I return. When I come back, I'm going to eat this Passover with you that I have that I desire to eat but I'm not going to get to because I'm going to be the Passover, right. But he's yeah. So Jesus is planning. Which actually answers that question that I've heard many times. What was that? Will we eat and drink? Oh, wow. Well, Jesus did. Yeah. Did you just prove. He's like, he's like, feel me oh, you see me. Oh, you don't believe, feel. Oh, you don't believe. Give me some fish and honeycomb.
20:44 Yep. Like I am real inside and out. Yep. Yeah, So yeah, he says. So that's what the JST kind of adds like makes it more clear. You're just in the King James, you might not catch it and you might be excused for, you know, our Christian friends might be excused for not seeing the future fulfillment in that, but like the the full fulfillment, right. But I don't think the JST leaves any doubt that Jesus is going to eat the Passover when he returns and and that's going to be, again, it's going to be in the spring, right, not in the winter. So, so all kinds of things.
21:24 Now let's see. So I don't know how much of this I want to get into, basically. So I I will bring this up. This is a this is a quote from Joseph Fielding Smith. He says it makes no difference what is written or what anyone has said. If what has been said is in conflict with what the Lord has revealed, we can set it aside. If Joseph Fielding Smith writes something which is out of harmony with the revelations, then every member of the Church is duty bound to reject it. If he writes that which is in perfect harmony with the revealed word of the Lord, then it should be accepted. So.
22:08 So there you go. So it there's all kinds of opinions about things, even opinions by General Authorities and they'll write commentaries on the scripture or whatever. But I think the, you know, my faith is, and Joseph Fielding's faith is also that even if someone in authority writes things that are out of harmony, then then you reject them. Now I will say we do have to. I'm not saying that. Well, let me just, I'll just say you have to be kind of careful with that because because at first glance it seems like the Doctrine Covenants is out of harmony with the Torah, right.
22:53 And so and so you could say one or the other is mistaken and reject it, you know, based on what Joseph Fielding just said. But a lot of times I think it a better policy is yes, maybe something seems to be contradictory, but let's just slow down a minute and study that out a little more. And maybe, maybe when we do that, we find out that it is in harmony and maybe we don't. Yeah, but. But let's not make We don't want to jump to any hasty. Conclusion I was going to say. I think this falls into that camp, but just be patient. Right. Pursue it, yeah. Pursue it with ferocity, but do not be so quick to just call one or the other bad, right?
23:37 In the end, everyone has to has to follow their conscience, right? And do what they think the scriptures and they're and revelation and you know the direction from their authorities like you have to kind of yeah find a balance between those sources of inspiration. Yep and so and everyone's I'm not anyone's judge so but but anyway I do want to I do want to mention just a word about about the Torah. I I've said it before on here before I think. But it it is kind of important to know what I'm talking about when I say the Torah or the law because there is some disagreement about that between like Jews and Christians or you know Mormons too.
24:30 The because the when we think of the law and I I knew when I was a child thinking back on like Sunday school lessons I had. I had lessons actually I had. I had one really good teacher and I remember he gave a lesson about keeping the Sabbath day holy and he talked about the laws that the Jews follow and he had us he had us like fill out a a tithing envelope, you know and then said you know that in doing that you just broke the Sabbath according to Jewish laws. Because you're not supposed to. Because you're actually like doing work.
25:12 Because you're creating something like you're writing and then you're also like sealing an envelope, which is also not allowed. Like you can't like bind or loose anything. So and like you know, tying tying knots is forbidden. So like, put it on your necktie to go to church, like according to the rabbis that's that is breaking the Sabbath. And so he told us all these interesting things. You know, unless you do it with one hand, like you can tie knots only with one hand not two or you know, there's all the kinds of things. I don't remember the whole lesson, but just like regular going to church in the eyes of the rabbis is breaking it. Like things that we do at church are is breaking the Sabbath in many ways. So to my young mind it's like, whoa, wow, a lot of Moses really hard.
25:59 That's that's kind of ridiculous stuff. Like that's really burdensoming. And what's the problem with filling out a tithing, you know, envelope or whatever? Later on though, you know, as I read the scripture for myself and do some studying, I realized that none of those things are actually in the law. That's not what the law says, right? That is what the rabbis say is a law. And the rabbi and the Pharisees, Pharisees in Jesus Day, the unique thing about them and the modern Rabbinical Judaism is a descendant of Pharisaical Judaism. And The thing is, they say that there was two laws, There was 2. Taurus 2. Laws of Moses. One was the written which we have in the five books of Moses. And then there was the Oral Law which was given and passed down as tradition but it but it was originated with Moses and it is equally authoritative.
26:54 And all of these additional rules, those all have their have their roots in the the Oral Torah. So when I when I speak of the the Torah and the Law of Moses, I'm actually Speaking of something different than the Rabbis are now. The the things that the things that the rabbis do and say are beautiful and useful. But the problem is when we make, when we turn traditions into commandments, right. So there's nothing wrong with tradition. I love tradition, Tradition's beautiful. But when when we try to enforce it, then, then we have problems. And this is actually Jesus had problems with the rabbis over this all the time.
27:43 Yeah, your traditions are causing you causing us friction here. So OK, so the the traditions, I don't believe those are in force. We're not bound by those, they're not binding. But what is written? I do believe it's binding. So, OK, and I'm gonna move along here a little bit. So let's get let's just go right to this, I guess. Well, OK. So I wanna say, I wanna say one other thing about cleanliness. You know in Section 42 of the Doctrine and Covenants it says let all things be done in cleanliness before me. So cleanliness in the scriptures means several things, but one of them is related to our diet, like clean eating kosher. Kosher yeah, not kosher but kosher yes, but kosher no. So actually leads right into the next little story and that is that is having to do with which animals you know are clean or not, or what we can do as far as our diets. Now in in Acts chapter 10, Peter
29:17 has his vision right. He sees the all these animals come down and there's a voice that says rise Peter Slay and eat. And Peter says not so Lord. And he says, never at any time have I eaten anything that is unclean nor common. And then and then the voice says, what God has made clean, do not call common. So there wasn't there wasn't an argument about the unclean. The argument was about the argument that Peter was having with the Lord was about what the comment, what common is right or whether he should eat those things that are common.
30:04 So, so just So what is common then common has to do with the term you just said kosher so and kosher things that are kosher follow the laws of cash root. So this is a whole body of rules that have to do with clean eating basically. But it's it's way more than clove and hoove chews it's cud you know or fins and scales if it's in in the water cash root has has even deals with the way that the that the animal is killed. Right. So so the there are special kinds of rabbis called sokhets and and these are trained rabbis and like not just anyone can kill a lamb a sheep or a cow to to eat it or chicken or whatever. You have to be specially trained rabbi and there's all these additional rules you have to follow. You have to you know you say these blessings you you have to immerse yourself in the mikvah before you you do it and have a special knife.
31:10 It's a certain size depending on the animal and you know the tip of the knife can never be. You know you can't plunge the knife into the neck cause the the tip of the knife is not allowed to be covered by feathers or fur or flesh. So and you have to, you know cut in a certain place, you know, not too high, not too low, not too deep and not too shallow. Like you cut too deep, like if you cut too deep and you cut, if you touch your bone, then that animal is not kosher anymore. Oh wow. So anyway there's a there's I'll go through all the rules and I don't know all the rules but there's there's quite a few and and if if any of the rules are violated then the animal is unfit for consumption.
31:54 It's what we would call in in the terms of in the words that Peter used we would call it common gotcha. So those those are things that the the Jews sell to the Gentiles like we can't we can't eat. That is unlawful for us to eat that. Now the scripture doesn't actually say that's unlawful but that's the the environment that Peter's living in. Right says rise, slay and eat. He's like I'm not I'm not a specially trained rabbi. I don't have the ceremonial knife. I haven't done the mikvah, you know. And if I if I kill it, it will be considered common. And I have never eaten anything common nor unclean either, either one.
32:35 So what the Lord says, what I said is clean is like that's good enough. I said you can eat sheep, you can eat cows. Then don't complain about you know, don't tell me that you can't eat a cow when I said you could. Gotcha. So. So what the Lord's doing here is, is the Lord himself through this dream is breaking the the false tradition. That's right. Now it's interesting. Some people will say that Peter's dream was about food and some people say no, no, it was about people. Because of course Cornelius comes right after that, right? And it's interesting when Peter goes to Cornelius House and he steps in the house and he says something amazing, he says, he says, you and I both know that what I'm doing is against the law.
33:30 It's unlawful. But you read again, you read the scriptures, and there's. There's nothing in there. There's nothing in there about. You can't. Israelites can't fraternize with Gentiles under any or, you know, or vice versa. There's nothing about that. In fact, Gentiles are welcome and you know but but there were laws about that. But these are again, these are traditions that had become laws and become an impediment to spreading the gospel. Right. And so in this one dream, basically I some people say it's again about animals, some people say it's about food. And I think it was actually about traditions. And but the traditions just happened to touch on both of these topics. So all that, all that is, you know, partly to say that, you know, there are traditions associated with our keeping of the word wisdom.
34:21 And and there are also again laws from ancient times that I don't believe Peter's dream does away with anything. Like Peter's dream isn't OK, you can go ahead and eat horses and snails and swine. Those things are still off the table, so to speak. And so we want to interpret the OR I want to anyway. I want to interpret the Word of Wisdom in light of all the laws that God has given having to do with diets and find out if if it if I can make it fit, you know, and interpret it in with through that lens.
35:03 OK, so so Jesus Abraham was not a vegetarian. Jesus was not a vegetarian. Even the resurrected Jesus was not a vegetarian. He only asked He only, as far as we know, as far as we have record of he ate two things, fish and honey. Fish and honeycomb. Neither of which is a vegan, right? Nor, you know, nor vegetarian. Well, the honeys might be vegetarian, but right? Definitely not not vegetables, right? They're both in animal and animal. Yeah. So yeah. And when Jesus is coming back, he's gonna eat the Passover and all that.
35:48 So. So now there were, there were and there have been religious, you know vegetarian movements. Sure. One of them was the was the Shakers. OK. And we have in our Doctrine Covenants, section 49, which was addressed to the Shakers in Ohio there, And you know, verse 18 and 19 of of section 89, section 49, sorry, say, whoso forbiddeth to abstain from meats, that man should not eat. The same is not ordained of God. For behold the beast of the field and the fowls of the air, and that which cometh of the earth is ordained for the use of man for food and for raiment, and that he might have in abundance.
36:38 So, so we have that and yet and yet there still seems to be this lingering or persistent interpretation of the word wisdom. So one issue is in verse 13. There's a controversy about the comma in the comma in between the words used, and only and commas can you know, punctuation can make. It can. In the English language. It can be huge, that's correct. Like a comma can actually change the meaning to its complete opposite. Yep, that's right. So with the comma. With the comma, and it is pleasing unto me that they, meaning the beasts and fowls mentioned in verse 12. It is pleasing unto me that they should not be used. Stop.
37:34 Right. There's a pause only in times of winter or cold or famine. What? What that? That basically means accept as that comma stands right now, right. So it's saying unless it's winter or famine, you can't, you shouldn't be eating meat. That's right. That's the modern interpretation according to where that comma is placed right now. Yeah, yeah. And that's that's that's a very common interpretation. But this just. Can't get enough of the Mormon Renegade podcast? Well, good news, we're on Patreon and there's three packages that you can choose from. The first one, the Slightly rowdy package, allows you to hear the podcast without all those pesky commercials getting in the way.
38:20 For those who want a slightly more in depth experience, there's the Stirring It Up package where you can hear ad free audio, ad free video and transcripts. Finally, for those who want to go full Renegade. That package is available too, where you can get everything in the previous two packages, plus an extra show where myself and Ben Winfield breakdown the news of the day from a very Mormon point of view. You will also get exclusive access to Renegade chat, and on there you'll be able to talk to others about the show or whatever topics are on your mind. Go to Patreon today and get your exclusive content. This episode of the podcast is brought to you by Deseret flag.com. I've said this before, and I really mean it.
39:00 Mormonism isn't just a religion, it's a culture. As such, it has its own vernacular and practices, but also its own symbols. And those symbols become even more important and prominent when you look back into our history. Perhaps one of the most recognizable symbols of Mormonism is the Deseret flag. This is the flag that I use as cover art in this podcast. This was also used for a good chunk of time during the Pioneer era in Utah. Now today we have people who want to replace the existing Utah flag with some other progressive monstrosity. Well, I think it's damp past time that we start pushing back here a little bit in Utah. Our friends at Defending Utah are here to help you with that. Now if you go to deseretflag.com, you can now purchase your own Deseret State flag.
39:43 It's time here that we start making ourselves known and join the resistance against those who seek to rewrite our state's history. Go to deseretflag.com or check out the link in this episode's page. Show notes and get yours today. In my mind, and this is the the, you know, the thing that triggered this wrestle, is that that seems to contradict those other things that we read in the New Testament and the Old Testament about Passover and Abraham and. And the Doctrine in Covenants 49 even. Yes, right, right. So we want whatever interpretation we pick, we we need it to be consistent across every place where the Lord is spoken. Coherent we need everything to come together and knit together, rather than having like fragmented scriptures that we interpreted this way one time and this way another time. So this this comma though is kind of controversial because it is not in the original Revelation. The comma is absent actually from all of all of the original sources that we have.
40:50 So in Revelation Book one and Revelation Book two and The Sydney Gilbert Notebook, and we have an old copy of Wilford Woodruff's Book of Commandments, which was given like the Word of Wisdom was not in the Book of Commandments, but it was given after, and there was blank pages at the end. And he wrote the Word of Wisdom in there, and there's no comma there between before only, So there's no pause there. So if we read it, if we read it in that way, was also no pause. There I'll read it again. And it is pleasing unto me that they should not be used only in times of winter, or cold or famine. So if you read it that way, it could, it could, you could read it as I don't want you to save them for emergencies, right? It is pleasing to me.
41:49 For them to be used at other times as well, Well and and here's the thing I I just have racing thoughts on this too. What does in in the parable of the prodigal son? What does the Father do when the Son comes back? Yeah, kills a fatted calf. Kill the fatted calf. We're, you know, we're we're going to eat tonight. We're going to eat well, right? And that is, that is something that's lost on us. Now tell me about the history of that comma. Then where does that comma come from? Yeah. Oh, OK Yeah. Yeah. Heber J. Grant, you're most that son of a bitch. OK, now we I, I.
42:32 We don't know if it was Heber J. Grant necessarily, but in the originals and in all of the printed versions up until 1920, the comma was absent. And so it shows up in 1920, and no one actually knows for sure who put it in there. It may even have just been like a stray mark that got accidentally turned into a coma. That's a possibility I want to add some historical context to, this time in the 20s. OK, up until this point, it's important to note that the Word of Wisdom was never on any Temple recommended interview.
43:17 It was absolutely. It was one of those things that you were encouraged to look at, to live by, but it was never on a recommended interview. So what's happening in the 20s in American Society? It's prohibition. Well, there's prohibition, but there's also other things happening. What we're seeing now is that there's a move in society towards a more grain based. Diet. There's a whole like health. This is a whole health thing, right? The 7th Day Adventist during this time come forward front and Center for their the way they they live and the way they eat. Very similar in a lot of ways, but there's also entire retreats set up around eating clean during the same time.
44:08 In my opinion, looking at all that data, it's never there before 1920. It shows up during 1920. We know that there's a big push within the LDS leadership to get America, I mean, get the church more American, so to speak, right? Prohibition is huge and they sign up for this wholeheartedly. And my opinion is this is one of those instances where we see the church trying to cozy up to the culture. And and I mean, it's fascinating history as you look at it. There's whole resorts where, you know, that's where cornflakes comes from.
44:55 That's where great Nuts comes from. Yes, this is the time. Of yes, yes, this, this all comes in that same time. Period. Which does not fit with everything else before, and now all of a sudden it becomes a thing. Interesting. Yeah. So there's a there's a bigger, there are bigger pressures like societal, societal movements that are happening. Exactly, yes. Interesting. So yeah, anyway, it it shows up and now there is there is another another controversy because even even with the comma, it can still be read a couple of different ways and that's. What you think only means, right, They should not be used only in times of winter.
45:45 So only could mean except as we mentioned before, but only could also mean solely like. So except as like excluding other things but solely is kind of looking at the other way of saying just this thing only, right? This thing solely and. If you if you kind of like make a substitution there and and some people have argued for this, they're like, yeah, the comma got put in, it wasn't in the original. But the word only actually means accept, and if it means accept then the meet then the comma does not change the meaning. So I'm going to read it.
46:26 I'm going to read it with and without the comma, but using the word accept instead of only and you tell me if like to your ear if they sound the same. It is pleasing unto me that they should not be used except in times of winter cold or famine, OK or is pleasing unto me. They should not be used except in times of winter, cold or famine. So if you if the if only means accept, then it is true that the comma doesn't actually change the meat, and it means meat should be limited to these emergency times. OK now. The the problem is that it can also mean solely. So we'll put I'll put that in there, OK, pleasing unto me that they should not be used.
47:15 Let's see, we'll do with the with the comma, without the comma, so comma first, pleasing unto me that they should not be used solely in times of winter, cold, or famine, or which kind of means, again, that it it's limited. But if I say it's pleasing to me that they should not be used solely in times of winter, cold or famine, then that means meat should be eaten at all times, right? So that So if if it means solely rather than accept, then the meaning kind of does flip with it. So how can we tell which of those is the the better reading? So there are arguments saying look.
47:59 It it definitely means accept and. And I've seen interesting arguments they've gone to like other sections in the Doctrine Covenants where it clearly means where only means accept clearly. But it's interesting because just in the same section, just a verse over in verse 15 it also uses the word only, so it's. It's a very close verse and also it's a very similar sounding verse to verse 13. Right? Verse 13 says it is pleasing unto me that they should not be used only in times of winter, cold or famine. Verse 15.
48:40 These hath God made for the use of man only in times of famine and excess hunger. So they're like they're very similar verses. So it seems like what whatever, whatever only means in 13, it's going to mean the same thing in 15. Yeah, it seems like a reasonable thing. That's a that's a reasonable assumption. OK, and and also whatever it means, whatever. Whatever you decide only means. Verse 13 and verse 15 are going to mean opposite things, because verse 13 says not only and verse 15 just says only. So whatever, whatever it is, those two verses are going to be the opposite thing because because they're not.
49:27 OK. So, so then all we have to do is we kind of we kind of plug in the meanings of accept, sorry, the meanings of only into these two verses and understand that they are supposed to mean something opposite and see if we get something ridiculous or something that makes sense, right. That's, that's, that's my, that's my process. It's a Lubnis test. It's a good Lubnis test. So it's a. Kind of a logical problem, a logic problem. So verse 13. We're going to say only means accept. OK, OK, And. And we're going to and we're going to get rid of the We're going to get rid of the comma. OK for these readings here.
50:10 So OK, so we already we'll all read it again. 13 It's pleasing unto me that they should not be used except should not be used except in times of winter cold or famine. So that means meat should be limited, right? OK, but verse 15. These have God made for the use of man except in times of famine and excess hunger. So what that is saying is that these so the animals God has made for the use of man, man can use them except when it's famine or they're hungry. Which to me sounds like a a ridiculous reading. Like why would God say?
50:54 You can go ahead and use what whatever the animals are. You can use these animals as long as you're not starving. But if you are starving, then these animals are off limits. Yeah, it doesn't make any. Sense. That's a That's a ridiculous reading. Yeah. So which which means that to to my logic that means the word only cannot mean accept. Because if we, if we plug in, accept into both of those verses and then interpret it in a, you know, read it in a consistent way, then we end up with a ridiculous result, right? OK, so let's try the other sense of the word only, which is solely so verse 13, pleasing unto me that they should not be used solely, not be used solely, in times of winter colder famine. So that means meat should not be limited to winter, colder famine.
51:45 And then verse 15. These hath God made for the use of man solely in times of famine and excess hunger. So these, whatever these is, there's some animals that God wants you to save or leave for times when you really need it, Right. Which is not a ridiculous reading, OK, But we just need to know what these are. Yeah. OK, so it seems like solely is the proper way to. There's a proper sense of only because we don't get something ridiculous, obviously ridiculous. So but then that brings up the next problem is we need to know. In verse 13 it says they should not be used and in verse 15 it says these should be used or you know, are used in solely or only in times of famine and excess hunter. So we need to know what they and these mean. Right.
52:44 So go to verse 13. What is they? Well, it's referring to verse 12. Beasts and fowls of the air. They they are to be used sparingly. OK, so they in verse 13 is the the beasts and the fowls. And so is. Is that consistent with other sections in the Doctrine Covenants? Yes, in section 49. Which we read a little bit of already. It says, behold, the beasts of the field and the fowls of the air are ordained for the use of man for food that he might have in abundance. But woe unto that man that sheddeth blood or wastes of flesh and hath no need.
53:30 So that's that actually sounds very similar. Yeah. Verse 9. This is 19 and 21 of section 49. Sound very similar to 12 and 13. East of the field foul is the heir. Those are given to man even to have an for food, even in abundance. But don't be wasting them. That's what Section 49 seems to say, and I think that's totally consistent with Section 89 here too. I find the use of the word abundance interesting there, right? I feel like the word abundance could have several connotations here, right? One of them is abundance being enough right that that you have enough sustenance scientifically speaking.
54:17 I know people say well you can get protein from beans and they're right, but it's a far less effective and I've done some research and homework on this. It's a far less desirable mechanism for delivering it because the body's got to work so much harder to extract that protein. When you're talking about protein, which every human body needs, it's the right down to the DNA level. Right, protein delivers a lot of those amino acids. A lot of those. You need nitrogen to be nitrogen, Yeah. And so the, the preferred delivery mechanism for our biology is meat. And so he talks about that.
55:02 The other thing that I think and and this popped out to me, when I had my experience with my doctor, I had never more abundance of health. Oh, that's interesting. You might have in abundance that yes, not just in not just in health, but free of pain not. Just in calories, but in free of pain. Free of. I wasn't having those crashes. I had an abundance of energy. So I find the word abundance in 49 to be very telling. And I look here, here's the thing, I I'm not so dogmatic on this as to say could some people do better on a vegetarian diet given their makeup? I I'm, I'm OK if that works for you, great. But speaking generally, you can tell what a vegan looks like, or a vegetarian, right?
55:56 They they don't look necessarily healthy. Yeah, depending on how strict they are. Yeah, they don't look like they're living an abundant life, right? So I tend. I tend that. That word abundant, I think, carries some important connotation that I think deserves a second look. I love that. You know what else I I want to say? And I I said this the last time I was on your podcast. It was. Every, every true principle, even scientific principles, which a new nutrition is. Yeah, I mean, the science of nutrition is the science of chemistry and Physiology, right. Every true scientific principle is a gospel principle. Yeah.
56:38 And so, so it we need, we need the, we need the scriptures not only to harmonize with the previously given things, but we need to harmonize with, yeah. Scientific principles. Absolutely. Yep. And. And it's. Yeah. And if it doesn't, then, then we have to look at more times than not. It's our own interpretation, It's our own traditions, It's what we've been brought up with that that deserve, that deserve that second look. An understanding problem? Yep. So I find. So not only section 49 but section 59 as well. You know this is 16 through 20, says.
57:19 The fullness of the earth is yours, the beasts of the field, fowls of the air for food, for raiment. And verse 20. It pleases God. It pleases God that he hath given all these things unto man. You know so verse 13 you know. That's verse 13 in the Word in the Word of Wisdom. It's pleasing unto me that they should be used in a certain way. Races verse or section 59 says it pleases God that he has given these things unto man. For this and they were made to be used. They were made to be used with judgment. But again, it's kind of like the sparingly here. It says in section 59 it says not to excess, neither by extortion. And in verse 49 or section 49 it says not to waste flesh. If you have no need, you know.
58:09 So you know, when I read that, I think about. You know, I've read the accounts of that first, that advanced wagon train that came across the plains in 1847. And they would, they would hunt along the way. And there were some of the some of the men who who wanted to just shoot bison and antelope and deer just for fun and like. And I was like. We do not do that. You you may like you should I I will not allow you to kill more game than we can eat. Because if we just waste that flesh and you're wasting your ammunition and you're wasting your time. Besides, like we got things to do. Yes, those are for us to eat.
58:57 Don't, don't kill more than than you can use. Look, I mean, that's what it means. I think you're talking to a guy who up until about, I don't know, probably 10 years ago, avid hunter, right? I love game. Even in those days I couldn't get behind the idea of sport hunting, right? It just did not sit well with me. I didn't like it usually because those guys and pardon the expression, we're full of douchebagging us, right? I mean they look like they stepped right out of a Cabela's catalogue, right? They can't hunt in the last year's fashions, right? And and so but I couldn't get behind right. I I felt like the animal itself deserved more reverence than than what was being afforded to it. To be interesting to to that and and yeah so yeah I I I would agree with with that.
1:00:00 I've never been a hunter really. I have been hunting once but it was a total flop. But yeah, but I have known you know I have uncles and stuff that are hunters and I and I've and but I yeah, I've known that they're very respectful. Oh yeah, they use the animal and it's great. But yeah, but I have known others who other hunters that will just. They're kind of bloodthirsty, bloodthirsty. And they'll just abuse the they. They won't. I know. I know one guy who like, he won't take the time to sight in his gun. Oh, no. So he's just like shooting him in the gut.
1:00:43 And then they they run away and he shoots another one, you know, because that one ran away. And it's like you are abusing those animals. That's that's crime, you know? Yeah. So anyway we'll get we'll we're gonna get into hunting here very shortly So 'cause I think, I think the word of Wisdom actually speaks on that. So OK, so we we kind of, I think we established what they is in verse 13 E of the field fouls of the air. And then so we need to know what these is in verse 15. And I think kind of what we did in verse 13 is we went to the verse previous. In verse 15 we go to the verse previous and the verse previous mentions beasts.
1:01:31 Let's see beasts and fowls again. But we kind of already we already covered that in verse 12 and 13 and we know that verse 15 because of the little logic problem we did with the the. Not only we know that verse 15 means the opposite. So. So verse 15's I don't think is talking about the beasts and the the beasts of the field and the fowls of the air. I think what it's talking about is the the immediate antecedent there, which in verse 14 it says all wild animals that run or creep on the earth. So I'll read verse 14 and 15 together. All grain is ordained for the use of man and of beasts to be the staff of life, not only for man, but for the beasts of the field, and the fowls of heaven, and all wild animals that run and creep on the earth.
1:02:24 And these hath God made for the use of man only in times of famine and excess of hunger. So I think that. He's obviously not talking about the grains, right? Right, so which I actually have heard people interpret it that way as well. But yeah, I think the the most sense, the most logical, the most coherent way to read all this is that verse 15 Bees is talking about that little parenthetical statement added about the wild animals. So I think these is the wild animals as opposed to the beasts and the fowls, right. So, So here's where we get so God expects us to use these two kind of if there's three, three, well, let's just say 2 categories of animals in a different manner. We have the beasts and the fowls and those are good. It is pleasing to God if we use those all the time and not save them for winter, colder famine.
1:03:26 So we can have the Passover and we can, you know Abram can feed his three heavenly guests in the feed in the day. Do you? Smoke 40 pounds of brisket for for for his brethren, yes, for his brethren, yeah, And and the prodigal son can have the fat calf killed. And it's all pleasing. Then the other category of animals is the wild animals, and these meaning the wild animals God has reserved for emergency use. So another way of separating this, I think, is domesticated animals and the wild animals. And there are clean animals in both categories, right? But domesticated animals, the cows and the sheep and the chickens and the turkeys and and the goats and whatever, yeah, have those, have those all the time. Have a party.
1:04:21 Those are given to you to use for your daily life and also for these celebrations. Celebratory times when you have angelic visitors. Yeah, then you'll pull out a steak. Dave, if you, if the three heavenly visitors come to you, you better pull out a steak and serve a time, you know, You know, I can give them a plate of vegetables. You might end up like able, you know. Like cane cane, rather rather. Than yeah well and and and I was just thinking that right this the use of animals goes way back. Right. And I find it odd that we would say that it's not well to consume animals, but yet that was the sacrifice that was accepted right by the Lord.
1:05:10 So. So just to kind of sum up now, so we're going to so using solely and also understanding what the verses are referring to, we have verse 13 which is referring to clean domesticated animals. OK. It is pleasing unto me that they should not be used solely in times of winter cooler fam. So use the domesticated animals all the time. That is pleasing unto me. We are, we are, we're not supposed to waste them. That is true. But they are for our use all the time. Then in verse 15 and these meaning wild animals, these hath God made for the use of man solely in times of famine and excess of hunger. So in emergency situations, that's when you, that's when. That's when the wild game is there for you to eat in winter cold or famine, OK, and excess hunger. Can I ask you a question back in 12? Yeah.
1:06:14 What do you make of the word sparingly? OK, so I I do think it has a double meaning. OK, it's kind of like your analysis of the word abundant. I really like that. So in on one hand, I do think it means not to excess, like not not wasting, not wasting the even even the animals that we are given not wasting them. And I think that actually applies to everything that the Lord has put into our stewardship, whether it's food. Like I don't think we should waste vegetables even if we can avoid it or grain, right? We don't waste any of that including, but even maybe more, especially because of the with the animals because they're. Sent to you.
1:07:01 They're, they're, they're a little closer. They're higher form of right. Yeah, that's exactly right. So I had read something a few years back. That the word sparingly has changed since the 1800s a little bit and sparingly back then was just that. Use As much of the animal as you can, is how it would apply into the into this not sparingly in terms of as little as possible, as little as possible. But to make sure that you are consuming. Wasting as little as possible? Yes. Using as much of the animal as possible so sparingly has changed a little bit over the last 200 years or so. Is that in the Webster's 1828I?
1:07:53 Can't remember it might be. I have to look that up. It might be. I had one other question for you here, and this goes a little bit off topic, but still in the word of wisdom here and. This is one that I think I could get some Flack for. But this talks about wine, right? And it's first five that in as much as any man drinketh wine or strong strong drink among you, behold, is not good. Neither meet in the sight of your father, only in assembling yourselves together to OfferUp your sacraments before him. The word I find interesting. There are sacraments, plural. That's correct. We're going to have to do a whole podcast.
1:08:35 Long line. OK, we we might have to do that. But if it was for the sacrament, right? I think that that makes sense. But sacraments, plural, all the sudden that makes me wonder about wedding celebrations, right? Weddings are a sacrament, absolutely. Right. And and some other things. It's good enough for Jesus. Right. And just just throwing it out there. That's right. Yeah. Yeah, yeah, we we'll have to, we'll have to talk about that, but that you're you're spot on there. Sacraments, I'll just, I will mention this. In Mormon speak, we tend to use the word ordinance right to when we're talking about ceremonies, you know, priesthood ceremonies, so, so baptism and ordinance and ceilings and baby blessings and blessing the sick, like those are all ordinances, you know, ordaining to the priesthood and so on. In in most of the rest of the Christian world, those things are called sacraments.
1:09:48 Yeah. So it will be the sacrament of baptism and the sacrament of the Lord's Supper and the sacrament of ordination and the sacrament of marriage and so on. And so our words, our words have changed a little bit in that respect. But yeah, but you go back to the you kind of the original meaning and sacraments meant these, these religious ceremonies. And yeah, so that that includes baptisms, that includes the sacrament of the Lord's Supper, that includes Passover, that includes, you know, and many other examples of things. The the thing that that I think we miss a lot with the Word of Wisdom is 1, going back to that word abundance. And I understand it's not in this particular section, but it's in 49.
1:10:42 It's in 59. The Lord is telling you that I've set things up so you don't have to merely survive, yeah. Right. Your life is meant to be celebrated, right? The, the, the other thing is we focus a low a lot on this in terms of the the prohibitions, yeah. Right. I think Joseph's driving. I think the Lord is driving something far more important to Joseph in this section than simply don't drink coffee, Right? So yeah, I agree. I think.
1:11:24 I mean, the Word of Wisdom is telling us how to celebrate. Yeah, if you read it, I mean, the sacraments are celebrations as well, right? Right. Those are occasions for parties. Yeah, yeah, something else. Where? Where it talks in here, here it is in verse 4. Behold, Verily, thus saith the Lord unto you. In consequence of evils and designs which do and will exist in the hearts of conspiring men. In the last days I've warned you and forewarn you by giving unto you this Word of Wisdom by revelation. Look, I'm, I'm going to go out on a limb here. I don't know how you feel, but I think a lot of our food supply is tainted and the more you can get away from the processed and the refined. Quote Refinement.
1:12:12 Yeah, I think the better off you're gonna be. And I think that's another thing Joseph's talking about. Oh, absolutely, Yeah. I think. I think the scriptures have plenty of things to say about producing things yourself as much as possible. And, and I know it sounds weird too, but one of the the things I found most interesting in my in my blood work was the amount of testosterone that raised. Oh yeah, just. Just by eating kind of a cleaner diet, right? Not, not a lot of refined crap, a lot of protein, a lot of vegetables. So very cool. Yeah. Abundant. Abundant. So going back to sparingly. And you say in in one sense it means not wasting something.
1:12:57 And it's interesting what you said about how that's changed a little bit. In another sense of the word, sparing means saving something. It has to do with salvation. And so in Exodus chapter 12. Again, this is a Passover reference, Exodus 1230, verse 26. And when your children say to you, what do you mean by this service, you shall say it is the sacrifice of the Lord's Passover. For he passed over the houses of the people of Israel in Egypt when he struck the Egyptians, but spared our houses. So in some sense eating like they ate the Passover, they ate the lamb in a sparing sense of the word, because they were being spared while they while they ate it. And it was pleasing to God that they ate it, sparing in this right by this sense of the word.
1:13:59 So I do think that there is kind of a a Sacramento sense. It's a little bit hidden I will admit, but but I think it can be read that way. So which is kind of a beautiful thing actually be because as in in Jewish tradition, like meat and wine like those are those together are like the most joyful thing like that that represents the best kind of party And and this isn't just a a party for any old thing. Like we're talking about parties where we're celebrating.
1:14:41 We have some holy reason to celebrate, right. The return of the prodigal son, a wedding feast, the Passover. And you know, whatever else it is, we're, you know, the angelic visitors. We're having this meal and we have the the most joyful elements there, the wine and the meat, and that is that is pleasing to the Lord to use these things that He's given us for the the highest possible purpose right now. One thing I do want to make sure that I make clear. So although I do believe verse 15 is talking about not eating wild animals except in these emergency situations, I will also say that the Word of Wisdom is not saying that hunting is sinful, right?
1:15:38 Because that would if we, if we took that as the interpretation, that would also contradict the scripture. Because you know Nephi, you know Lehigh and his family, they're going through wilderness, they're hunting for their sustenance, right? And and never at any point is, is hunting by itself condemned. The only thing that's condemned is if you're wasting, well, the animals. And and I think this even goes back to one of the first commandments that Adam's God ever gave him, which was to tend the garden. Certainly if we if you take the the scripture literal, that man was made Lord over the whole earth. Right, he It's not simply a a a blank check to go rape whatever you want from it.
1:16:40 There is a sense of caretaking here involved. We tend as well. And we tend as well. And sometimes that means when things get out of balance, you got to put them back in balance. And when it comes to hunting, I tend to to often think. It's probably a mechanism to keep all that working and tend to that garden. Yeah, sure. Yeah. I mean that you could totally read the Word of Wisdom to say like that. Yeah, that, that, that. There is a time. There is a time, right? To haunt the animals. And I do find it interesting that in today's modern society we there is a time for that, right where where we say it is lawful.
1:17:22 It's interesting also that we we make hunting season in the cold parts of the yes. Don't we? Yeah, we do. And so I I I do find that rather interesting. I I think that I I just find that that sometimes as Mormons and we fall into maybe the old Puritan trap of the more we the more we suffer, the more holier we are. And certainly there's something to be said for holy suffering. I do believe that such a thing exists, but sometimes it borders on the the, the, the line of, you know, whipping ourselves, so to speak, right, Where I sometimes feel like the Lord's like, what are you doing?
1:18:11 I, I, I, I tried to make this not what I said, right, not what I said. And I want you to be happy. Interesting. OK, so let me finish this thought here. Sorry, I keep No, no, this is great. Hunting is not sinful. However, this is the Word of Wisdom. So right right up front of the Word of the Word of Wisdom says this is not by way of commandment, but this is a word of wisdom. So this is this is something wise I don't want. And we're looking at this one piece in particular. I don't want you to use the the wild animals unless you need to or unless it's that time of year. So we look in the in the, in the scriptures in general, there are commandments given, but there's also wisdom given too, things that are not commandments.
1:19:08 But we can learn by people's examples, right? A lot of times the the Bible and the Book of Mormon two a lot of times there'll be stories and this thing will happen and then the Bible doesn't actually say whether it was good or bad. It just says what happened. But we but I think we're meant to like learn wisdom from that like we see how things we see the fruit that comes of it right. So so we so we look in the scriptures and for the most part those guys that are shepherds that have domesticated animals they are righteous. So we have Abel right versus Cain and we have Moses and Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, David.
1:19:54 And even Jesus is called himself the Good Shepherd. Right. So like shepherds, not always but the the the main thrust of the scriptures is like shepherds are righteous right. And then on the other hand we have we have hunters and they are portrayed as wicked. So Nimrod and Esau. And in the Book of Mormon it's just like says the Lamanites were I mean the Lamanites were hunters went out looking for you know beasts in the field and and and we have Enos even right. He goes out to hunt and it doesn't say he's wicked, but it we we understand that he's not.
1:20:35 You it's implied. He's not on a repenting right. He's not on a good when he starts that hunt. He's not on a good foundation with the Lord and he has his he has his wrestle and then he doesn't finish his hunk, right? Or we don't. He doesn't read it. He doesn't tell us that he he had this experience with the Lord and then he got that that deer that he was looking for, right? Doesn't say that. So anyway again so these are the these are the wicked people or people who need to repent. Now again there are there are wicked shepherds too. The Bible also talks about the the the evil shepherds of Israel who are abusing the flock and stuff and there's also righteous examples of hunting.
1:21:19 I mentioned Nephi with his beau, right? So it's it's not always, but it's just it's a it's a it's a matter of wisdom. Again, I think the scriptures are showing by example, not by commandment but by example that of like the kind of behavior to model. And I will say also that as far as as far as the commandments are concerned, shepherds are necessary, right. Because those those sacrifices, you know, the Passover needs to be a lamb. It's not, you know, a a moose is not allowed. So. So we are allowed to hunt, but we are required to shepherd.
1:22:02 Yeah. But in a In a word, Yep. Absolutely So And this is actually the the Jewish understanding that actually mirrors, they look at the scriptures and say Jews should not be hunters, Jews should be shepherds. And there are various reasons for that they say that, but one of them is the example that's set scriptures. So, OK, I mean I think that's it's pretty much the crux of it. Dude, Adam was awesome because I think. I think for a lot of people, me included, this was something that that I wrestled with, right? That I tried to square up with my religion that just didn't seem to fit.
1:22:53 Yeah, go ahead. I remembered some. Finish your thought. And then I I remembered something. Else I was just going to say it was, it was. I think this was good because if if we don't, if we don't look at this with a little bit of a critical eye. It's like you said. It seems like Scripture contradicts itself. And if Scripture contradicts itself, God contradicts himself, and then he becomes a God you can't trust. That's exactly right. Now there's another question is like, well, what do you do with like statements from the leaders, church presidents or whatever so on.
1:23:34 On one hand, we have what Joseph Fielding said, like even if our leaders say something, if it doesn't square up, then we set it aside. So maybe there is some of that. But also I think there's the what we talked about before, like don't be too hasty though. So one I know one of the most famous experiences that's related is I think it was Lorenzo Snow. He was out hunting and he basically has this revelation and and it's impressed upon his mind like that he is doing something wicked and he realizes like he's convicted in his own soul that what he was doing was wrong. He was out there hunting for the blood of little birds or something and and so he just like he has this this experience and he, you know, puts his rifle back on his shoulder and walks home and says he's never felt the need to to do that again. I don't, I don't have to quote in front of me, but I think a lot of times like that kind of gets extrapolated to well, we shouldn't eat animals because of this revelation that Lorenzo Snow had while he was out hunting. But if you read it the way that I'm reading it, then his revelation is perfectly consistent with this reading that yeah, maybe he was going
1:25:05 out to hunt and maybe it wasn't right time and maybe it wasn't to eat. He just was doing it for sport. And that is a wicked thing, that that. But we have to be careful that we don't take that revelation that was given for that specific time and purpose to that. One man to that one man and like apply that broadly and to every situation. When I believe that the Revelations actually make the distinction between domesticated and wild animals in the world wisdom and in the examples given in the scriptures about shepherds versus hunters and and in the Revelation given to you know this inspiration.
1:25:47 I guess it wasn't like thus said at the Lord but it was this inspiration that Lorenzo Snow has. I think it just fits, actually. It actually, on the face it might seem like it supports vegetarianism, but actually I think it supports a more nuanced. I think so. And and harmonious reading of the scriptures. Yep, I think so. So that's what I would do with those statements from the prophets, the presidents of the church or whatever. Apostles. I think many of them actually harmonize with this beautifully if you actually look at them a little more. Closely. A little more critically, yeah. I don't.
1:26:27 Yeah. So I'm not, I'm not saying anything against, you know, what the leaders of the church have said. But I am speaking against one of 1 popular interpretation of the word it. Was absolutely couldn't agree with you more. And I think we're living in such time now where again, I really believe our food supply is tainted and it comes with a lot of consequences that makes it hard for us to be able to hear the Lord. If you're in pain, if you struggle with chronic fatigue and pain, it's hard to concentrate on anything wholly or higher. And and I can just say from my own experience that that switching things up has has been a godsend.
1:27:10 Look, I couldn't do what I do now if I felt like I did. 3-4 years ago, I believe it. I couldn't work a nine to five, I couldn't have a side job and I definitely wouldn't have had the energy to do a podcast right. But things have changed, and thankfully enough I I went ahead and and prayed and got my own revelation and went forward with it despite my. Apprehension that hey, this doesn't square up real well. Well, it did square up. Well, it was just. I didn't understand, Right. That's a beautiful thing. And and that's that is a good thing. So yeah, dude, this was awesome. I appreciate you so much. I always love our talks. So if anyone's feeling bad out there, eat some steak and lift some weights.
1:27:53 So, all right, see everybody next time. See ya. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox