Episode #94 Addendum #2
Addendum On George Q Cannon
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:02 Taylor, what's going on, man? Hey Dave, thanks so much again for having me back. So I've I've just had someone something else get brought to my attention that I need to correct from the the long podcast we did last week. So there was one point where I was talking about George Q Cannon, and I brought up some history from the early 1900s and. I I accused George Cucannan of being a hypocrite because he was publicly teaching that you had to live plural marriage in this life where you couldn't receive exultation while at the same time actively persecuting and excommunicating post Second Manifesto polygamist and and then secretly making sure his own sons got sealed to plural wives right? And and so.
0:48 OK, so now if this were true would be one thing, but I want to set the record straight and make sure everyone knows that. I was wrong. I misremembered a very crucial detail. So. So there was a man who did exactly what I said happened, but it was not George Buchanan. His name. The person who did those things was Francis Marion Lyman and he was the president of the Quorum of the 12 from 19 O 3 to 1916. And and I didn't write about this in my essay. So I hadn't reviewed the information prior to the podcast and it was just going off of my memory alone, like when I talked about it there in the moment. And unfortunately I had crossed some wires in my head. So cuz I mean I first studied this history about 10 or 11 years ago when I read two books by Drew Bryony called Apostles On Trial was the first one and Silencing Mormon Polygamy was the second one.
1:41 OK. And and and so Drew goes through a ton of evidence from that period of church history. And I highly recommend these books to anyone interested in learning more about the subject. So again, I sincerely misremembered the actions of Francis M Lyman and got him confused with George Q Cannon. And when I mentioned that on the podcast, it was an honest mistake, which is kind of interesting if you think about it, because it's only been 10-11 years. Since I'd read that, and Can you imagine what I might have thought 20 or 30 or 50 years later if if I hadn't had friends bring to my attention that I was wrong on that? And then I went back and checked the sources. Sure enough. So in fact, since it's possible that, like, people could stumble across that episode maybe like next year or something down the road and might not notice or listen to this correction, would you, Dave, be willing to edit the original podcast to take just those comments out? Yeah, yeah.
2:37 And then just leave the addendums up, right? Exactly. Yeah. So it's so yeah, because perfect. I don't want to. I'm not trying to memory hole this mistake or anything like this. This public correction will be eternal proof of my fallibility. But in the interest of of truth, I don't want to leave that. What? What? Since I now know that that was false information in the original podcast, I don't want to leave it there because I don't want to misinform anyone or distract from the rest of the message down the road. Sure enough, yeah, no, we can do that. We can do that. We'll we'll be able to to correct that so that it's not out there hanging out and then someone doesn't listen to the addendums. But we'll leave the addendums up to just kind of show that hey, there was a mistake made and we'll go from there. Absolutely.
3:21 And I'll make sure that maybe I'll put into those show notes. I'll edit those show notes to say see addendums one and two and that should that should clear it up. So. Right on. So I I guess just in closing, I I apologize one last time for wrongfully accusing George Cuchanan of crimes he did not commit. I shouldn't have done it. It was an honest mistake and and since I made that publicly, I really appreciate you giving me the chance to fix that mistake publicly. And you know, I I still, I still have some pretty major concerns about George Cuchanan, especially in regard to his positions on eugenics as well as his role in in getting the 1890 manifesto signed.
4:01 Which maybe we can discuss in greater some other time, in greater depth some other time. But. But for right now, I'm more than happy to just set the record straight. He is not guilty of the crimes and hypocrisy that Francis M Lyman did. Perfect. I like it. All right. Anything else? No, thank you, Sir. Awesome. Appreciate you. You too.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox