Oct. 7, 2023

Episode #93: The Priesthood Ban Debate W/Jacob Vidrine & Justin Francom

Episode #93: The Priesthood Ban Debate W/Jacob Vidrine & Justin Francom
Episode #93: The Priesthood Ban Debate W/Jacob Vidrine & Justin Francom
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #93: The Priesthood Ban Debate W/Jacob Vidrine & Justin Francom

Go To http://patreon.com/MormonRenegade368 For Exclusive Content So you will notice that there is new intro music, I want to give a shout out to Tom Bennett for composing and recording that for me. Well today is a first for the podcast. This is the first time that I try and moderate a debate. The two men that are debating should be very familiar to the audience, they are Justin Francom and Jacob Vidrine. Now not only are you about to get a master class in Mormon history and theology but Jacob and Justin exhibit how disagree passionately and not be hateful while doing so. The topic of the debate is the Priesthood Ban. In the debate Justin & Jacob debate the Identity of Canaanites? What is The Curse of Cain? Who Revealed The Priesthood Ban in Church History, How The Ban Was Revealed and is the Priesthood Ban and the Doctrines That Surround It Really What We Have Been Taught They Were All These Years? Buckle up for a wild ride on this episode of the MRP. Go To deseretflag.com to get your Deseret Flag Today --- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support

0:05 So University of some new intro music for the podcast. I want to give a great big shout-out to Tom Bennett for composing and recording. That for me, I feel like he really nailed me and what the shows all about? Well, today is the first for the podcast. This is the first time that I will try a moderate a debate. The two men that are debating should be very familiar to the audience. They are Justin Frank him and Jacob vidrine. Now, not only are you about to get a masterclass in Mormon history and theology but Jacob and Justin exhibit, how to disagree, passionately and not be hateful while doing so the topic of the debate, the priesthood band. I mean, come on. You didn't think I was going to start with something easy. Did you in the debate? Justin, and Jacob debate. The identity of the Canaanite, what the curse of Kane is who revealed the priesthood ban in church history, how the band was revealed and is the priest should ban and the doctrines that surround it really. What we've been taught they were all these years buckle up for a wild ride on this episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast. Look, it's no secret that our society has become Much more prudent course to become and raise men and women of virtue and characters a Herculean task to help with this. I've recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility, and Decent Behavior, and Company, and conversation.

1:21 It was a book with 110 Rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society. Something that today Society is sorely, lacking. What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So, the book is laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule right below. The ad is my explanation for the 21st century. And below that, you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, you go along with this, there's a book that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids to find the book. Go to Mormon renegade.com. Go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post in order your copy today.

2:05 I can bear personal testimony from personal experience that this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character. Listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. All right, so on this episode, where did you something I've never done before.

2:56 And to be honest with you I'm a I'm a touch nervous cuz I've never monitor it and, you know, kind of moderated a debate before, but this, this is going to be fun. So I found two guys who always have their research together, they can present well and I think this is going to make for a fascinating debate and one of the, what we're going to talk about tonight is the priesthood man. And I imagine that that will cover just about everything on when it comes to the priest of dance. So, First, we got Jacob on and Jacob your it just real quick.

3:38 Your urine favor. The band correct. Yes. I'll be arguing in the affirmative or the priest, the band Justin and you're going to be off advocating against the ban. Is that correct? Okay, perfect. All right, so everybody knows you been on here. Both you what I found interesting is that you've both been on very recently actually, so that it was kind of was kind of good, you know, people people are familiar with you. So let's go ahead and we'll just kind of do like some opening stuff, right? Some opening statement, sort of stuff and Jacob will let you just go ahead and start it off.

4:18 Okay, well thanks for putting this together. I just like to start off just kind of over being what the priesthood ban is for people who might not be familiar with it. So the early Mormon isn't there was an, it was understood that there was to not just be a restoration of the Church of Christ, but there was also to be a restoration of all things, including many principles pertain to the priesthood. That you are not commonly find very explicitly in the New Testament, but seemed to be more than the Old Testament in their overview and in their nature. And one of those things that was introduced in early Mormonism with a doctrine of the what would be called the segregation of Israel or a priest and restriction where the priesthood was restricted, from individuals of African descent under the understanding that they were the descendants of Cain and ham and that does Lennie, it just did not have the right to the priesthood.

5:15 So early Mormonism had a view. There was both shows in lineage that had the right to the priesthood has mentioned. The DNC 86 that you were born heir to the priesthood. Your lawful Heir have been hidden with Christ in God, but there also was a lineage that was to not receive the priesthood. And so, this Doctrine was most explicitly stated by Brigham Young to the territorial. Legislature of Desert Rat Pack on February 5th, 1852 and end. He buried. He lays out the doctrine and very explicit terms and that's kind of when a lot of Scholars view that is when it started. But there's other views on when it started, I'm going to present kind of additional views on that. And so just to kind of start off, I'm going to be covering three main areas.

6:08 I'm going to say my issues are is appreciative and scriptural, was it implemented by Joseph Smith because there are those their debate whether it started with Joseph, Or Brigham Young and then third, should it be applicable today. So when I go to address but it is the priests of a scriptural and we're talking about in the restoration of all. Things were restoring Old Testament Doctrine. If you go back to Genesis, you can see that there is a concern about not interfering with certain languages. When you go back to the stories of Abraham, Isaac and Jacob, Genesis 24 to does an Abraham said, it said unto his Elvis Duran and out of the house. That ruled over all he had put, I pray thee, thy hand under my thigh.

6:52 I'll make these swear by the Lord, the god of Heaven and the god of art, that thou shalt not take away from this on to my son out of the daughters of the Canaanites among who might. Well without shunts, go on to my country and to my children and take away, I punch my son. Isaac, can you continue on Genesis 26? This comes up again, in the story of Jacob and Esau, when Isaac has children and their growing up and getting Do Esau actually married individuals from the daughters of Canaan and this was a thing that was upsetting to their parents Jesse's 20 through 26 verse 35, which was the grief of my data Isaac and Auntie Rebecca.

7:35 So then in the next chapter, Genesis 27, Rebecca said to Isaac, I am weary of my life because of the daughters of hat. If Jacob also take away from the daughters of had such as the image of the dogs allowed, what good shall my life due to me. So she's kind of got some concerns about, you know, that this would be very detrimental to her life. If Jacob were to marry among the descendants of the land. And you see that in Genesis 28 than Jacob, Isaac charges. Jacob saying. So not take away from the daughters of Canaan. So then you go on in the scriptures it's encoded and Deuteronomy 7, verses 1 through 3 which Institute these Metal Rooster By the law of Moses, it comes up again, in the story of numbers, 25/6 through 9, where there's actually a play gun Israel because of one of the Israelites marrying and midianites Dish women, and it was stay because Phineas killed, both the man and the woman.

8:33 And so that's that's numbers. 25/6 through 9, answer the questions, where did the start, where do the stalker and start? That start with Abraham? And if you go to Restoration scripture, if you turn to the pearl of great price, the Books of Moses and Abraham kind of detail that this went on this segregation Doctrine went on from Before. The Flood. Go to Moses 7 verse it says for behold, the Lord shall curse the land as much eating the banister and shall go forth forever. There was Blackness came up on all the children came in and they were despised among all people. Then continued verse 12. Continue to call upon all the people save it where the people of Canaan to repent the most 72026 Enoch beheld, the rest of the people, which were the sons of Adam.

9:21 And there a mixture of all the seed of Adam save. It was the seat of came for the seed of camera black and had not placed among them. So then you go to Abraham. The book of a rat Abraham chapter 1 verses 26 and 21 verses 21 through 27 is the most explicit place I believe in the scriptures outline this Doctrine explains how there was a cursed before the flood and that the curse was preserved After the flood as well. The verse when he wants is now this king of Egypt was a descendant from the loins of him with a partaker of the blood of the cainites by Burke from 22 from this to set spring, all the Egyptians and dust the blood of the cainites was preserved in the land.

10:03 The land of Egypt mean first discovered by a woman who is the daughter of him. And the daughter of Egypt is, which is in the Chaldeans signifies Egypt, which signifies that, which is forbidden when this woman, discovered that it was under water, which afterwards sell her son's in it and dust from hair. Screen. Race, which preserved the curse in the lad. Now, the first government of Egypt was established by Pharell the eldest son of a jet is the daughter of ham was after the manner of the government of ham which was patriarchal. Pero being a righteous man is stablished his kingdom and judges, people wisely, and justly, all his days, speaking earnestly to imitate the order established by the father's, in the first generation in the days of the first patriarchal, even the reign of atoms, also know his father who blessed him with the blessings of this Earth and with the blessings of wisdom.

10:49 But Christian as pertaining to the priesthood, verse 27 is key. It does not bear being of that lineage by which he could not have the right of priesthood, notwithstanding the Pharaohs would being claimed it from Nowa through have there for my father was led Away by their idolatry. And so then Jessie G of Genesis 9:30. As an addition by Joseph Smith, that people are familiar with generally, it says and he butt. And so this is a Noah is blessing and cursing his stunts and he said, blessed be the Lord God of Shannon Kane. And she'll be a servant and a veil of Darkness shall cover him and he's that he shall be known among all men. So some people try to make it out that this was mostly just for religious reasons. But there wasn't actually really a lineage aspects to this. That was a significant aspect but I would say that that's kind of flies in the face of what's in Abraham 1:21 through 27. But I also see if you look at the books of Ezra and Emma and I are in the Old Testament, it also very explicitly laces out. Azra 262 since it's basically the Israelites had come back from bondage and they were trying to rebuild the Temple in Israel and I found out that many of the Israelites had intermarried with these other races that they've been forbidden from interfering with and it was such a difficult issue for the prophet Ezra that he was literally plugging the hairs out of his beard and out

12:22 of his head and he sat down astonished you said you know it would be. So it was said it was such a difficult situation. Do astronauts, use 62 cents. I stopped at a registry among those were reckoned by Jenny ology, but they were not found their forwards day, as polluted put from the priesthood Than Ezra. 91 says, when these things were done to princess came to be saying the people of Israel and the priests and Levites and not separate themselves from the people who are doing according to their Abominations, even the cainites, the Hittites, the parents rights, the jebusites, the ammonites the moabites Egyptians in the amorites where they've taken their daughters themselves and for their son's. So that the holy seed have mingled themselves of the people of those Lads in the hands of the princes and rulers have been cheap and distressed. So then them and I are just my last few scriptures. I'm going to start them and I are 13, 27 and 28. Show me then Harkins you to do this great evil to transgress against our God and marrying strange wives. And why the sons of Joe died?

13:20 The son of Elijah by the high priest. Was son-in-law to send a hangout the horror and I therefore I Tristan from me. Remember then. Oh my God, because they have defiled, the priests in the Covenant of the priesthood, and the Levites. So I do see there being us something, there's something there in the scriptures that seems to teach this Doctrine. And I just I personally believe that we need to take a holistic approach to the scriptures. There's a statement from fruit you need except the whole truth. I think that's what the scriptures. We need to take a holistic approach, the scriptures and not just now emphasizing one part against another part. So you want me to cover my other two points? Do the started by Joseph or you want me to go on to the historical part now or do you want to hear for a second? Cuz I want Justin to times has a lot of material so I want to make sure that we're taking this kind of in bite-sized pieces, right?

14:27 Know that we're not just cuz it cuz I would hate for someone to feel like, oh, I need to respond to that and then you're on your next point, he can try but it was so let's take it and in some small bite-sized portions here. If that's alright. Jacob dusting. You good with that 20? Yeah, yes. There there's a lot to cover. I'm really not trying to just know. I know, I know. I totally understand. I totally understand. Just give you some time now to to respond to that and then that sort of stuff and when we feel like we flushed out what Jacobs presented so far, then we'll move on. Does that sound good to both of you? All right, go ahead.

15:14 Yeah well if I think what Jacob just did there was provide an excellent overview of the ideas of priest. The band that from a historical scriptural perspective. I think that Yeah, I think that's a great Foundation to to, to start, you know, the debate from. But I know I want I want introduce myself a little bit as well. To be honest, like, I'm not entirely sure why. I'm here, I'm, I'm not really a scholar, but, you know, I've got opinions as you know, and, you know, you invited me on here and I just wanted to share how I, how I got where I am cuz there's not a mean, there's not a lot of people that call themselves fundamentalist that opposed the priesthood ban. And so it actually starts with, with, with when I journey into fundamentalism when I was first, Dealing with some of the doctrines of fundamentalism.

16:07 Actually, plural marriage was one that was a little bit. It took a little bit of work to swallow, to be honest. And I remember one of the things that really helped was an argument that I heard that the manifesto the church produced is a Manifesto, but it's not a revelation, where's the Revelation? And it's the church was supposed to put aside Celestial marriage in the principal shouldn't there be a revelation stating? So and you know, I looked and I looked and I looked I could not find a revelation on that and that really for the set my way of like, okay, this is something that we can, we can question. Maybe this is something that can be challenged, was this right or wasn't too, right?

16:51 It open the door to start questioning things. And, you know, at the time, the Manifest looks very look, very similar to me. It's also, one of the best of the priests it down or the LDS churches. What is an official document saying that? They're ending the priests of band. And again, the Revelation, saying, down the back, I didn't see one, right? And so I just kind of took that as well. I took that along with the with the principal and started making my way into an acceptance of the fundamentalist beliefs and doctrines of my wife. But as time has gone on, I started finding out that you know that there's a huge huge source of evidences of Joseph Smith practicing polygamy and teaching it be on Brigham.

17:38 Young is revelation section 132 alone. But there's John Taylor's Revelations about how the principal was intended to be preserved until Christ came again. And As I learned more and more, it is bolstered my testimony of plural marriage. But at the same time, I was studying the history and I started at the same time, looking at the history of the priests to down in the origins of the priests to ban in the more and more of that in the more that I looked at it and the more history I did on it the more it didn't sit right with me and it really kind of came down to a question of. Well, wait a minute, I have I have seen tons of scriptural and revelatory answers for, why be a logical explanations for Why?

18:25 God is a stand for in to Covenant marriage? And I never found the origin of the priesthood band with the same kind of testimony with the same kind of revelatory credence that I think is absolutely important and because I'm at me, if you've ever played telephone It's amazing how in it and a small group of 10, 20 people a phrase gets twisted and distorted. Going around the circle. And when you add to that time and and hundreds and hundreds of years, there's a reason why God uses this standard of of Revelation. And scripture to establish his troops, especially on things that are really, really important. And I think that this decision of the priests of Dan is, really, really important.

19:20 If Brigham Young is correct in what he says on that. Then there are some dire consequences to opposing this but, on the other hand, if that's not right or if that was the case where where where's the revelation, Where is the inspired riding to make sure that we don't mess this up? Even even simple. It's something as simple as baptism. Even something as I mean, I just saw during covid there were these Catholic priest squirting, a baby across the room with a with a with a spray bottle to baptize that, to just like okay it's clear that with time without things getting set down clearly.

20:08 We slept, we make mistakes and when something's really important, like, baptism God. Put some pins in those things. So we don't slip on that on those issues. And we find that in the Book of Mormon, we could find that in Doctrine covenants, we don't buy Place children wife. Well, it we have that, not only do we have a revelation that we should wear, even given a theology on why and again, when it comes to this, this priest to them, I, I cannot find the Revelation, and I cannot find the scripture that says that, you know, they say the Lord. Don't you dare administer priesthood to these people are, or there's going to be consequences. And this is in, this is why he needs to be that way. And so that's basically event.

20:53 That's how it arrived at the position that I'm in. And that's why I accepted your invitation to come in and debate this site because I've studied history in the scriptures as well. And I and I have it a different perspective on. And I've got some questions that I think absolutely really need to be answered if we're going to move forward and establish line in these last days. Karachi. Okay, that's that's a great open. Now, what? Let me ask you this, was there, anything that Jacob said there that you want to address? Oh yeah, yeah, I think probably all of it, to be honest. Okay. Go ahead. Judy where to start.

21:40 I quickly ask is your position. I'm actually want to do this before I got into my position. I was wanting to know what time or what your position was like, you think that there ever were times in the history of the world, where is there? So one of the issues is it is was it introduced by Joseph Smith? And is it applicable the day and see what the scriptures? I'm kind of wondering what's applicable in, say Old Testament times. It's so maybe if you could try a cover, what you think about what weather it was applicable in certain Old Testament. There's some degree or how you have to make sense of the scripture. Okay, well, let's start then okay, well let's talk car with the car.

22:25 Since you brought up two of them, you brought up the curse of you didn't bring up the cursive can't specifically. But so we've got the first curse, right? Is the cursive on Kane himself. And afterwards his posterity, the Canaanites in Enochs time committed genocide against another tribe of people, and they were cursed. And then, as you said, the final cursing is by is by Noah on to Canaan. And that's the end. That's the one that references being a servant, right? So we've got three curses, but I don't see anywhere in those curses anything about the prohibition of priesthood. and I think that's a pretty significant Omission if if that was intended to be that way, So moving then into Abraham Abraham one up here. So, you quoted most of Abraham one there and at least as pertinent to the question of the priesthood. And I will, I will admit.

23:40 That is definitely a way to look at that. However, I don't think that is exactly what his is being said, in the, in the Scripture it says, in in first 26, Pharaoh being a righteous man established his kingdom and judged his people wisely and justly, all his days, speaking earnestly to imitate the order established by the father's, in the first generations. And in the days of the first patriarchal rain, even in the rain of Adam and also have no his father who blessed him with the blessings of the earth and with the blessings of wisdom, but cursed him as pertaining to the priesthood. So what I'm hearing, this sounds like a damn. That sounds. A lot like a father's blessing, kind of things.

24:21 The Patriarchs often gave blessings to their, to their sons and And it sounds like a pharaoh desired. A blessing of Noah and bite, it talks about him being a righteous man. This desire to imitate the order established by the father's. I think it's pretty clear that Pharaoh had a keen interest in being able to receive that priesthood. And I think what happened is he asked Noah for it and Noah, put his hands on his head and did not give it to him. I interpret that word but cursed him if it is cursed by lineage to be incapable forbidden the priesthood then why does no need to curse him individually to it to me. That's a that did.

25:08 This could be written in a way that could communicate that, but that's not. What's communicated communicated? Is that Noah first? Trimester pertain to the priest? Another words, he did not fulfill Pharaoh's Quest or desire and give him that priesthood. And then in 27, it explains now Pharaoh being of that lineage by which he could not have the right of priesthood. And then it gives an explanation. I'm going to stop right there though. It says, the right of priesthood and a right is something that is owed. That is you have it. You are entitled to write in America, hypothetically in America, I have a right to a fair trial by a jury of my peers and this isn't something a judge decides. Well, with this guy, I'm going to give him a trial of his peers and this guy, I'm not and I must may be interested and less than speaking.

26:05 This is a right that we have. We are an entitled to demand this. So what I'm saying here is The lineage by which Pharaoh came is one that doesn't have a right to the priesthood. They cannot demand the priesthood Pharaoh is not the the firstborn that the the the the what do you call a Kia? Just the kind of that the first born who, you know, how often would receive their need to know their father's inheritance and generally speaking in the in the Old Testament, that's how we see priest a transferred generally speaking. It's it's Our son has a right to that priesthood. That's why he saw so upset when he doesn't, when he doesn't, when he's not blessed with that priest that he's upset because I felt like, you know, Jacob stole it from him and technically he already sold it.

27:03 But none, the less he still, he still kind of thought that that was something he was going to get cuz he had a right to it. Now he gave up that right, but he would have had a right to it now, just because you don't have a right to something go. Doesn't mean you can't repeat it. So, I don't have a right to two for the government to, to provide for my material needs, that's not one of the rights. Spelled out in the, in the Constitution Bill of Rights. None, the less I can still have those Meade's. Net met I don't have a right to them. I don't have a right to other people's property, but I am, I am capable of receiving it. If if I see somebody who is on the streets begging, he does not have a right to my money but I can still choose to offer that to them.

27:52 So what I see here in first Abraham is a situation where you got a man who generally speaking, looks like a pretty good candidate to be able to receive the priesthood he asked for it and it's not given to him. He doesn't have a right to it though because he's not of the lineage and it tells us I believe right after that. Why you didn't receive it is right after explaining that he was not of the language that has a right to it. It says notwithstanding the Pharaohs, would Fain clean it from, Noah through him. There for my father was led Away by their idolatry. It's it's right there that you know. Apparently if Noah had given Vero the priesthood well the Pharaohs after him the other pharaohs there they were they were going to do some bad things but then they were doing all kinds of bad things with that actually fit just right above that, it talks about the priest of pharaoh committed, human sacrifice.

28:48 And that's a pretty terrible thing. And that's not, that's not something that you would give God's. Holy priest 02. So that they could then do that kind of stuff in the name of God's, holy priesthood. So, what I see here is that they don't have a right to and I don't think I have a right to be honest. Maybe Joseph Smith was of a line that had a right to that priesthood but personally, I don't feel like I have a right to that free stuff, but I still receive. None, the less Dia Revelation through inspiration of a priesthood holder who felt that it was proper to transfer that priest it to me. And so in like wise, I think that this isn't a a racial band being presented here at the tragic story of somebody who via Revelation was had the priesthood withheld and I'm totally fine with that and I think that can apply to anybody black or white. You like he's so cute he lost that he had that, right? But he didn't receive as well you could say that that That Isaac Kirsten as to the priesthood as well, because you didn't get it.

29:52 So, anyways, that's, that's kind of how I would rest. Abraham one and the nature of the curse is there anything you'd like to comment on that? I guess. Do you have anything you have any other scriptures are things that you want to bring up scriptural and all kinds of stuff like a right of the firstborn kind of thing where it's like a special Birthright that was being discussed and Abraham 1:26-27 rather than say just the priesthood in general is that kind of absolutely cuz that's that's basically what we see right happening with the priesthood going from first and the first, I mean, how many other posterity did Adam have any other sons did he have? How many other sons and their sons have? I mean, leading up to the flood, there was a massive population, right?

30:52 Of of people coming from Adam and yet the scriptures shows the lineage of Noah's line. Then that was a line that carry the priesthood and it wasn't just given to everybody. It was something that was carried down from 5. It's not at that time. So I mean I guess does that you have any questions? Any other questions with the perspective on this that I'm sure. So I've heard that perspective before, a how does it fit with saved like verses 21 through 25? Where it's kind of talking about this lineage. That's coming down, there is preserving like a curse than the land and, you know, it's kind of saying that the blood of the Canaanites, you know.

31:38 So it isn't. How does that fit with your perspective on Abraham 12060? Well, I absolutely believe that there are there was clearly other other cursings and things going on. I mean, like I said, we were mentioned. I mention three of them already, right? If we speaking though, the other thing is technically speaking, that curse on Canaan will not apply. The Pharaoh, Pharaoh, is the the son of Egypt has the daughter of Egypt. Us wife has ham, right? And Caitlin is Hamm's sun when it's ham Sons. So, the curse that that, that curse of servitude, it was explicitly, not pronounced upon him and his line, it was that curse was specifically pronounced upon Canaan and even there.

32:28 I wonder was that a curse on Canaan, the man, or was that a curse on Kanan in his posterity forever? You know, I did it's really not very explicit. And I've actually have a lot of doubts about the. So, the faster thing when I was looking up, doing research on this topic, like I did, I found that there is day, that, that that verse in Genesis 10. Where it says that Canaan is cursed to be a servant. Was basically the justification used by Christians from the early days and even in America to justify slavery, even though the terrible slavery's, the kind of things that we're going on the Christians with some, not all questions. But the questions that were in favor of slavery, would use that verse to justify it.

33:21 And the interesting thing to me is is that those that net force is applied to Canaan, not to him and Canaan lives in the land of Canaan. Right. I mean, to hit Earth is constantly dealing with the Canaanites, the rest of hams children. It's believed went down south and settled in Ethiopia and Egypt, right? As in-laws as Abraham would indicate are. The Canaanites are the ones that stuck around modern-day. Well that what do you call it? Not good to Garden Valley. Are you or not? The Jordan. I think the mountains to on the west, Busy that whole area. That's where they that's where the Canaanites settled and the interesting thing to me is that that's not where, that's not where the slaves came over from in America. Today they're the African, they were African slaves and there are people that came from Africa, not from the land of Canaan.

34:24 And the curse of servitude apparently was put upon Canon, not not Crush, not remember his misery him or the other the other sons of of ham it was specifically on Canaan and he's the one who basically stuck around and created his people in and try to take the holy land, that was ultimately promise to Abraham and they're, they're actually to this day, I was recently reading, I found some research and it was done in 2017. Where they exhume, they had some exam bodies of Canaanites from clear back. It would have been around 2,000 BC.

35:06 And they mapped their genetics and to their blood and then they took some Lebanese in and checked their blood and they found that modern-day Lebanese or 90% Canaanite that they've had some other Blood come in Venetian midnight and I think the Macedonian not midnight Macedonian and a few other places but for the most part, they're still there. And yet, so I don't think that that is he that's exactly what misunderstanding of of a people or a curse and using scriptures to justify a different treatment of people. That's an example that being abused right there in American history. So yeah.

35:54 So I would say that if there is a yes there were, there were accursed people, that's very clear. But I again the scriptures don't say anything about a priest of damn, the scripture don't say anything about them being cursed to be able to curse to be a prohibited from the priesthood. All it says, is that Daryl did not have the right because of his lineage. And I think that makes perfect sense, and fits exactly with what the, the rest of the Old Testament Story show of the lineage of the priesthood Abraham. Do it, do it like it kind of carrying this issue or if you have something to her but with yeah you can you can. But back if you would like So I guess where I would start, I'm going to address everything you said to have been reversed. So the last thing you had mentioned was that the modern-day Canaanites are the same as the Biblical context and I'm going to dispute that on the ground. That you said that there is that research that shows that you're certain.

37:02 Populations are pretty much identical racially to modern-day people living in that area. But I would say that they were a wide variety there's there's a lot of the shows that there was a wide variety of different populations that moved in and even like you look at Egypt's like Egypt was a multi-racial society for a lot of its existence where you had kind of a Dometic upper-class, your kind of all different races, kind of among the Egyptians for most of Egyptian history. I would say that Kanon is pretty similar and I would say that the other certain people who disputes the claim that you know that Biblical. Israelites are whites which is part of Mormonism is kind of going back to the kind of the Book of Mormon where the Book of Mormon identifies that the Gentiles we're going to be if I seized the Gentiles, does there white at like, like unto my people before they were slain.

38:02 And he sees the Virgin Mary, she's white and white and beautiful. And, and we told her, the Book of Mormon Joseph Smith, as coming from Britain was a descendant of Ephraim, son, of Joseph and that you'd be named after his father Joseph after Joseph is what s e 53 says, two part of Mormonism Doctrine. Is this idea that the chosen whites are part of the chosen lineages? It's not. Just those who are Jews. Do you have anything to say with that, not just real quick, I'm not saying that. I believe that ancient Jews were Black that is not what I'm saying.

38:47 What I'm saying is that so the exit has happened. Well Escape. Look at the way that it matches the history of Egypt, puts it around, 1500 1500 BC. And the Canaanites bodies that they that they are testing. We're going, we're going back to 2000 BC. So these would have been early early Canaanite, people, and if. Yes, there were a lot of people coming in, there's a lot of things happening there. Racially.

39:28 Right. But the fact is that the modern-day Lebanese having still have the 90% match so it's pretty clear. That's pathetic. And in fact, I where is that scripture? Where the scripture in the Old Testament? It actually just came up Ana and priesthood the other day and I'm like, wow, that's fascinating. If I can stop back on on your identification of the canine space and early Christian sources, dating to the first century that I set up. The first century in 3rd Century Century for Christian birth Century for Jewish guy, death by the 10-minute.

40:12 Races as being the African you know you have the black race is kind of identified as being the descendants of ham. Throughout the Bible though says that Israel went when they cross the Jordan River they went to go fight the Canaanites. It was the Canaanites that they thought they were fighting and they were told to do. Yeah, they didn't, they do not get it but they were supposed to but they didn't, it did not eradicate all of them and but later on so this is something that Josephus kind of comments that the African race used to extend all the way into the Middle East, but that it's now only in Africa. That's what he comments.

41:07 And Antiquity of the do you write the, quote, the children of ham possess the land from Syria to M&S in the mountains of living is seizing upon all that was on the Sea Coast. As far as the ocean, keeping it, as their own, 17 of its names are utterly vanished away, the others of them being changed and other sounds, giving them are hard to be discovered, a few of them, which have kept their denominations entirely for of the four sons of ham time is not all hurt the name of chess for the Ethiopians over whom ear and or even to this day both themselves to buy almond and Asia called. It's the memory also was a misery, a reserve by their name and vote for we are all who inhabit this country of Judea call d.j. Message, Olivia, o, l p.

41:50 H, u t. I from himself and he goes on. He says, he is a document, the different geographical areas and the descendants of ham, he says, but the name of it has been, let's see what has been called. Africa also said they possess possess the land from Syria and he says that they, you know, that's why I'm saying we agree and that's where it, that was his area from What modern day is right with modern Israel, it was the promised land and right here in Abraham one right before this, we read that when Abraham leave Ur, he passes through the land of Canaan. And while he's there, the Lord promises and that this is going to be his land and then eventually he moves on to Egypt but you don't even right there.

42:50 It's identified as land of Canaan, Canaan, son of ham. And the Canaanites are the ones that populate that Jordan Valley area when they when the Israelites cross over the Jordan River and they're the ones that they're fighting with and they don't completely eradicate them in that comes back to bite them again and again, and again, I'm even so much that in here in a Zachariah 14 at, there's a prophecy here in verse 21 that says every pot in Jerusalem and Judea will be holy to the Lord Almighty and all who come to sacrifice will take some of the pots and cooking them. And on that day, there will no longer be a Canaanite in the house of the Lord Almighty. why the issue with why the Canaanite, because they're the ones who were there in that area and have always been in that area and these These bodies that we're genetically tested.

43:48 Clear, back in the time. Basically, from the time around Abraham when they were hands, passing through the land of Canaan, they're genetically still the same people. The Lebanese are those Canaanites. And the curse of servitude was on Canaan, it was not on him, it was not on Kush, it was not on his room, it was on Canaan. And so, for the early Christians, to use, the curse of Canaan is justification for for the slavery that of the slaves, they were taking out of Africa is absolutely incorrect. And the only people trying to argue that that the Canaanites were anyting. Well, the only other people arguing that about the identity of the canterwood wood for the Egyptians who said that the Israelites are Canaanites as well. They just sell them all the same. Yeah because they're a bunch of different kind of peoples that we had been in that area crossover, Jordan that they're going after the Canaanites.

44:50 So I'm going to push back on you on saying that. You don't think the Africans are the Canaanites did. That's what you're arguing right. Yeah they did. The Africans would be Kush. I am I. It's okay. So how would how would you deal with say the patriarchal blessings that were consistently given in the early church to African individuals. When they have identified them, as in their lineages, they would identify them as being the lineage of Canaan, the son of ham. So for example, hiresmith told Jane Manning that she was at the lineage of Canaan, the son of ham in an indicator that she was also under the curse of chain, additionally, Walker, Lewis when she got his patriarchal blessing and 1851, he was also identified as Kane in the son of ham. In his patriarchal blessing, in those were both by the presiding patriarch of the church in the Cypress. We had higher Smith.

45:47 Say that you also add patriarch John Smith, Joseph Smith's uncle in 1851 of the author of many other African individuals throughout the history of the church. You received that identification and then climb on top of that. You kind of have a prophetic statement by Brigham Young but identifies them as being of the lineage of Kane Atwood age of have in his 1852. Speech is so, how would you address the patriarchal blessings? Because we generally see those as revelatory and we see that our lineage is being pronounced as being literally of it where an ephraimite were, you know, literally of that lineage correct. Yeah, I don't know, to be honest, I would, I would, I would presume that.

46:32 It was. Probably a mistake and misunderstanding based off of the the courts of cultural teachings of the time. and I don't think that is so invalidates the the nature of of the blessing, if it's based off of a misunderstanding of which people were, which based off of the names and labels that we use today, So what do you think of Moses? 78 saying that there would be a Blackness on the children of Canaan. So do you think that that was a literal Blackness or do you think that was something other than a literal Blackness?

47:13 I think it was a little black dress. I don't know and I don't know what else it would be. So, how would that fit with you wanted to see the Canaanites were white or? I mean modern-day, it's just the ancient Egyptians that they were white and couldn't even differentiate them from that from the Israelites, when they were enslaved, their we have and then we have the scripture telling us that came and settled in that area. And then we have the word identifying the people in that area as Canaanites who look like Israelites. So you know I don't know why they're skin color is different, maybe they were uncursed at some point. I don't have an answer for that but the scriptures that the biblical record is clear who the Canaanites are and it does not place them in Africa. New places like you like you mentioned the other sons of ham in Africa and the scriptures both restored in here in a Abraham.

48:14 And strippers ancient in the Bible identify and even prophecies later on in the Bible, all everything points to the Canaanites, are the people living around Israelites who they were, who in the later, part of that you're talking about who they were forbidden to marry. So if it was just on the can I I'm going to push back on that point. Now I'm going to say first of all, you know, the Israelites were told not to intermarry with, not just the cainites, but the cushites with the Ethiopians, the options, and according to the Jewish.

48:55 So there's Jewish commentary on the curse of Cain. It was Blackness, but they're also kind of expounds on the curse on Canaan that thing. It wasn't just on Canaan, but that was kemetic. And, in general, if you, if you read the, I have I don't particularly buy into, you know, the Jewish traditions on everything. Sometimes, there's insightful things to pull from that that can help bolster our faith and understanding of things. And sometimes, I think they're just traditions, and the fact that the Bible is explicitly clear and who is cursed Is.

49:42 I mean it's it's right there. I don't know how you can commentary your way out of that. And as far as the curse of Cain even going that the idea that the curse of Cain cause black skin will. Let me ask you this. Do you believe the Canaanites were cursed with Blackness? Like it says, do you believe that that was their skin being color? Changing, as described as Moses. But they're already black is if it came was cursed, right? Well, I, I think that came intermarried with other children and that, you know, they're probably was different with mixed ring and then later became darker because they were little and with much heat is kind of, I believe both can be true.

50:26 Just like you said, there's multiple occurrences and multiple different times so it didn't. I do think that, you know, you got to be careful with Kyle saying, a scriptural own kind of perspective. Because I do think that an Doctrine, we do have an open Canyon. And we understand that, what is in the Old Testament is very limited. And we learned that in the book of Moses and broken Abraham greatly expanding on the Canaanites and all the curses, then I can do that. But but we believe that comes to revelation. And that this business will start scripture commentating. That's what that's different from a Jewish rabbi Rabbi from 3000.

51:14 Years ago, was Genesis actually says Justice doesn't just say that because later on. So there is mention of, you know, the, the other races. So let me pull up. If you want to go over it, let's go over at the curse. It says right there and Genesis 10 or 11 and get some 10 very into Genesis but then it says it isn't the end. News 9 + 29. Yeah. 9 verse 27, God shall enlarge japheth and he shall dwell in the tents of Shem.

52:00 And Canaan shall be his servant and Noah lived after the photo that I missed. It be Canaan, a servant of servants, shall he be under his Brethren and he said, blessed be the Lord of Shem and came and shall be his servant. God shall enlarge Jay Smith and he shall dwell in the tents of Shem and Keenan shall be his servant. I see Canaan repeated three times that Kanon is who is who is cursed? It is not hand. That is cursed, it is not, it is not Kush mizoram, that is cursed, it is Canaan that has cursed know but when you look at, so first of all, I would have a Darkness.

52:41 Come bring them that you should be in referencing the, you know, blacks the dark skin purse. And then if you go to Abraham one, that's About the first lineage. And it's talking about the Egyptian and that you have the blood of the Canaanites was preserved. Its from pre-flood at the bracelet as the Canaanites who were the direct descendants of Cain, pre-flood. Jeff is the one who founded Egypt and she's thinking.

53:21 If I thought witches which is forbidden and Insulin, first 20 46, bus from Ham spring the race, which preserved in the lads or was it just came in that was kerstin thing that from him, scratching the race. So we do have revealed our Day. Scripture that says it's beyond just can it? It's my dad. Is that the best free diluvion curse on the Canaanites? That cannot mean the Canaanite the curse on Canaan son of him. Because Egypt, this I mean, Egypt has found founded Egypt. And in with the tradition of Joseph is that you're talking about, would have, that's where that's where the ham, son, miserable miserable miserable, I don't have to announce it and that's where he went. so, Canaan was would have been Egypt. This is brother.

54:17 And they settled entirely different settled in entirely different, Geographic locations. So when it says Canaan here in Abraham talking about the curse being preserved through him, it's talking about the Canaanite curse that it mentions and Moses 6. As a consequence to the genocides of those people committed and that Chris does not say that a servant of the servants that that's the curse on Canaan that Noah gives to Canaan. I can agree that the curse of your Servants of service was specifically to Canaan, but I do think that all if we accept Abraham one that the entire lineage of ham is under the pre-flood, can I curse? So again, it.

55:05 We don't even know what that Chris is. Other than that, their lands would be. Another land would be better and that there would be a Darkness coming upon them. It doesn't say again though, it doesn't say anything about priesthood, doesn't say anything about being a servant So we've got Chris's here and I'm not denying that, there are curses, I absolutely agree that there were people. So you just think that Abraham 1:21 through 25 is a different course than a g 125.6 to 27. You think that's just talking about cuz they again there too and Abraham in the, in the first section of Abraham want to talk about that, the curse preserved through and lineage. It does not mention the priests of their, it mentions, the priesthood in relation to Noah, blessing Pharaoh individually.

55:53 And then it mentions that he was cursed to the right of the priesthood because of his lineage, which I would suggest. Like, I've already said that that's coming through his lineage and it's a, it's a right that he does not have. And in this instance, Noah put his hands on his head and he did give him a blessing, and it was a positive blessing for the most part, but he Kristen us to the priesthood, so he wasn't able to receive it by Revelation. Don't so, why do you think that righteous man wouldn't be allowed to hold the priesthood? I can't say, but first of all, I don't believe that at that priest, it is intended to be given to righteous men.

56:34 It's not like it's a Worthing issue here. It's a regulatory issue. and, it says right after, like I said that that Notwithstanding the Pharaohs would Fain claim it from, Noah through him. There for my father was led Away by their idolatry. I would suggest. That is why he was not able to receive them. And that would make sense. That's why he was not allowed as a righteous man. he was living in an inner-city in a population that were separating separating themselves from God.

57:19 And in that really ties into actually with with the other scriptures that you brought forth talking about Israel, the segregation of Israel. Because again, what were the Canaanites doing? What were they doing? Among their populations. What was the issue with the Canaanites? What human sacrifice? A lot of human sacrifice? Yes, yeah. Kind of goes back to Kane and that's when you look at the Traditions about Kane, they said that his lineage was more prone to wickedness and that they passed a wicked Traditions through their lineage, you know, if if you got a wicked father, that does wicked things and teaches you to do wicked things, you could say that you're cursed, it doesn't mean that God treat you any differently or that God's going to hold you a different standard but it, but you enter this life at a disadvantage. And we all have different disadvantages. You know, I could say that I am cursed as to memory cuz I actually do not have a great specially compared to a lot of my my scholarly friends over to where I'm cursed as to being able to push away from the table after S, I have. Yeah.

58:47 So I'd like to get into the definition of course, but just going back to go to the segregation of Israel. Why certain people might be withheld from the priesthood if they're living among and idolatrous people and buy adulteress. This is incredibly Wicked, This isn't just now, these people have a lot of fancy cars. And every once in awhile day, they pray. Do you know what? You know what a picture on their wall. This is these are these are people that whenever there's a drought they gather up their children and burn them to death and fire. It's, it's absolutely horrific and the segregation at that time, makes sense in the context of keeping that from infiltrating into the Israelite culture and people.

59:38 However, we know from the actual scriptural history itself that this is not a matter of principle. It is not that there's something corrupted in the Canaanite blood that the Israelites are not allowed to mix with it is something about their culture, and their people. And this is where we do see that they're there are Converse into Judaism into individual face into whatever, whatever you call that, I don't know. Did we her come up with the word? Eva was them Judaism before the separation. What was it before this Monotheism hebrewism Uber isn't maybe I don't know.

1:00:21 Anyways, that's a bit of a tangent but again, The issue here is they don't want the command of God, is your son's, don't go Mary. Those came in women and go in and partake of those Canaanite traditions and bring those Traditions into the house in the house of Israel. And that is a matter of context, not a matter of of an absolute principle being declared. I would say it's very similar to the ban on polygamy in the Book of Mormon. By Jacob it's not an it's not a matter of principle at but given the context and where the people were at at the time and the things that we're going on the Lord, Abbot Institute a band. on something that otherwise, Doesn't have to be an issue.

1:01:12 And we, we really know this. More than anything else because we have the case up here. We've got the case of I can't remember her name. Sorry, Rahab. That the Canaanite prostitute who Jacob comes across as he's invading Jericho and who helps the spies out and is she ends up being aired? And not only is she spared the entrance into the house of Israel?

1:01:53 She marries and is actually one of the direct ancestors of Jesus Christ himself. If there was something foul in this blood on principle in this Canaanite, blood, then why would why would then add then would that not even corrupt, Jesus Christ. I think it depends on which like I said, there were multiple populations in in that. And I think, even if you look back to the time of Abraham, like there were multiple populations like you have HID lights, and Hittites and one of those are where a Semitic white race and while one of them were in so that there were a bunch of different populations and with Rahab she was considered a gentlewoman. It did say that she was well, accept that that that that is where The Lord sent the Israelites to go to feed the Canaanites.

1:03:03 Well, they're supposed to get all the other people's out of the way and, you know, it was that they were supposed to causal and they said, they were not going after every population there. It was just the land where the Canaanites left. They didn't move all the way on into in the Babylon. They didn't go all the way up. North it was and if they are identified as the Canaanites and if they're identified as the same Canaanites actually smell the scripture, they cuz they're they're even in and In Abraham's time, cuz there are prophesied to be destroyed because of their wickedness, but it's, but it would be the fourth generation.

1:03:44 So even before Israel ends up captive in Egypt, The Lord identifies. Those is Canaanites and says that they are going to be destroyed by the Israelites at a future time. I'm just going to have to disagree with you on your point about, you know, it's not necessarily blood, it's the tradition because we know from Abraham 21 through 22, that there were curses that had to do with blood literally mentions blood of the Canaanites and both of those verses. And, you know, like I said, I have to disagree with the claim that all of the people, there were of this where racially that they were all, you know, that the same because I'd I think there's plenty of evidence to go against that and I just, you know, I definitely think.

1:04:40 Do you think that the extra biblical Traditions are important? Because, you know, there is a limitation to the scriptures and young Joseph Smith found value in those extra know. If you look at saved like The Book of Enoch that I've been preserved down to us, Joseph Smith Book of Enoch doesn't match. Exactly. But there's a lot of The parallels are parallels with other, you know, apocryphal texts with what's been revealed as though. I do think that Josh, ER, which, you know, it isn't scripture but it is the Jewish commentary on the scripture. And so it's kind of actually commenting on, you know, the story of Moses where he took an Ethiopian wife in.

1:05:22 This is kind of something that was concerning to you apparently Jews. Because even Josephus, also addresses that it says, it was just a political marriage. It. And it was before he became, you know, called of God. Do Dashers 73 says, Moses took the City Bites with some of the children could place them on the throne and said kicking a king of crush and they place the Royal Crown ice and then they gave them for wife at the cushite queen wife of chicken us and Moses fear. The lord god of his fathers. We came not to her nor did he turn his eyes were for Moses. Remember. Abraham, and made us. Also, not take a woman from the daughters of khaine in for my son, Isaac also, Isaac there.

1:06:06 When Jacob is blood from his brother when he commanded I'm saying. So I'm not take away for the daughters of khaine it, nor make any alliance with any of the children had. So, there's a tradition there that last part nor make any alliance with any of the children of ham, which I'm not. I'm not sure if that's a Genesis or not, but that's matching children. Have a general in a 35 Lord, Our God gave him the son of Noah, and his children. All see displayed to the children's gym and to the children shape it then on to their seed. After them for slaves forever. There for Moses, turns his heart, nor as ice, the wife of all the days, you ran over to Josh and Moses fear. The lord has got all his life and Moses walk through for the Lord and Truth with all his heart and soul Eater, Not from the right way of the day of his life.

1:06:47 May decline. From the way either to the right or to the left and which I could grab Isaac. And Jacob had walked until he look a lot of these Jewish Traditions. They match up with what the early Christians in America under. Done about, you know, reading the Old Testament. So I I do think that is not. I think if you have overlap where you have ancient Christians and Jews and early Christians in America, all reading the same versus pretty much the same. And identifying the same people's the same. I have a hard time thinking that they got it wrong. It was just, they were still had some cultural baggage. You don't think that tradition about scripture gets the distorts, the meanings of it.

1:07:33 Well, I think I've heard of the tragic way different populations all interpreting the scripture the same way. I think there's almost kind of a collective witness there. Yeah. Well I am again even though things are sharing their you're supposed talking about very specific individuals, you're not talking about a principal, you're talking about specific individuals and it is very specific timing content content. Again if if I lived in that time and my neighbors were the Canaanites and they're doing human sacrifice and all that kind of crap. I would also be really concerned that that my boy got marry one of their girls. And that doesn't mean anything about again. This isn't anything about a priest of band. All that identifying is that their parents wanted them to have wife's.

1:08:27 That would help them in the system and keeping the Covenant and that based off of the cultural baggage of the Canaanite people around them. They're being told not to. and again, that's that's not a principle that is as far as these people are inherently bad, that is a principle of Marion the Covenant. And there was a Christian tradition, very similar to that but it it, it gets expounded. Why do you think that that is random? And I haha. It's the other basically telling that anyone who intermarried with those with, you know, and couldn't prove the genealogies of those, they intermarried with Vonage Exile, that they should not be involved with the priest that even if, you know, their fathers, you know, could prove their genealogy. Why do you think that, that would affect their ability to serve in the priesthood?

1:09:25 According to azra, I think it would have been converted to converted to Jewish practices and they're trying to serve in the temple and S was telling them not to because the Jews received a cryptic curse, Do you think that there are curses at specific times in the history of the world? Where different populations are prohibited the priests and yeah. Well as a population we actually see that with a I need to find it. I think there is one last point that you did that. You want to respond to this real quick. We got this right here.

1:10:13 Alright? Yeah. Exodus 34 says in the Lord said to Moses you the two other tables of stone like under the first and I will write upon them. Also, the words of the lock we're doing is that they were written at the first on the table, switched out brake assist, but it shall not be according to the first part. I will take away the priesthood out of their myths, there for my holy order in the ordinances thereof, shall not go before them for my present. Shall not go up in their midst, lest I destroy them. And then we have correlational DNC, 8210. They hardened their hearts and could not endure his presence there for the Lord in his wrath or his anger was kindled against the and swore that they should not enter into his rest while in the wilderness which rest is the fullness of his glory.

1:10:58 Therefore, he took Moses out of their men. That's in the Holy priesthood also and the Lesser Priests of continued which priest is hold the priesthood. Hold the keys of the ministry of angels. And of the Preparatory gospel, which gospel is the gospel of repentance and a baptism in the remission of sins in the law of carnal Commandments. Wish the Lord, and his wrath, cause to continue with the house of Arryn among the children of Israel until John and God raised up, being filled with the holy ghost from his mother's womb. So here we've got the Lesser priests did remaining and it says here the house of Arryn but we we know that it wasn't just the house of air in it. We ended up being the entire Levi tribe that received that letter priesthood, not every Israelite had But was what war were allowed to receive that letter?

1:11:46 Excuse me, that lesser priests at that time. It was the Levi. True. That's been generally the case though. There were circumstances where you had under Samuel, who was Ephraim, who is officiating the priest said you had a bit of officiating the priesthood installment, after episode, where cases. So I agree with you in general where the high priesthood and the holy ordered it for and it says, were taken from Israel in general. But that in certain cases, that they were allowed to drive. So why were they being careful about the priest it at that time, after the exit or not. After not the exits after the bondage because it was only certain tribes that were supposed to be holding that priesthood.

1:12:33 They're trying to figure that stuff out having having lost it for so long, bathing lost access to the Torah but the fascinating thing here. And, and you actually even help prove that point is that even though there was a ban on the priesthood, Among the Israelite people as a whole here, we have examples of an ephraimite who has priesthood. Even though he's not a levite, we've got the example of, Father, Lehi, in the Book of Mormon who we know, tell priesthood, Cuz they he offer sacrifices as soon as they get out of Jerusalem. And we also know that he also he was not a he was not of the the levite origin and it really goes even Beyond this so the people as a whole workers that's to that priesthood. It's s o.

1:13:23 N s e n c. A t for explicitly. This isn't a priesthood curse that we are reading into different in a reading into at through in an entirely different book. Written to a different people and trying to apply to. This is a very explicit that in it even says scope and a time it even tells us why they were cursed, what exactly they did. And yet, despite all of that, Some of the absolute greatest prophets of all time. Rose from that Rose from that period of the of these rights being cursed, Elijah, the prophet who held the ceiling power restored, this stuff to Joseph Smith.

1:14:03 In the latter days, the keys of the priesthood. He was an Israelite. He was supposedly curse this to the priesthood. He was an ephraimite it, right? Yeah. But the NCAA Elijah are not. I'm not sure he was an Israelite. He was not a Canaanite something. So I see that comparison. You're making. But I would also say that Israelites we know from earlier, on in this is still in the Old Testament today. That God saying originally, I was going to give this to all of Israel. This the right as I was going to take the first born out of every Israelite family to serve me before the Altar and said, it's only going to be that Levites.

1:14:44 It's probably at least a half-a-dozen time and we do have those exception cases, where people were having priest it at different times. But within the case of S&M and I are there, talk to their concern is about the people's, it's not about Israelites, like other is Right, lineages? Holding the fishing, in the priest, who shouldn't Dealing with them, he's saying that they intermarried with the other peoples around us which we were forbidden to intermarry and they pollute. It literally says they polluted the wholly race as what as their rights and so, you know, it wasn't just, you know, the Levites officiating but if they were concerned about the Israelites in general, having intermixed with the other races around them.

1:15:33 So yeah, that's yeah, we can come together and work Canaanites, apparently. Well, it was a listed off all the different people where they see, I find it interesting that these people are there Canaanites were cursed when when we want them to and they're not the Canaanites and first and not cursed. When we don't I think that's highly selective interpretation of of the scriptures to apply that kind of a standard. But frankly, do you really haven't explained, how how do we have Elijah holding the ceiling power? Not only did he receive the Melchizedek priesthood? He was here, he attained up homeless of it and it changes, healing power. How does he attained that if they were if you was of a raise that from Moses until John the Baptist work first?

1:16:23 as to receiving the fullness of the priesthood cuz we know from Joseph Smith that they were Jacob, repeat profits at different times you had it received the higher priesthood and it says right here in Indy NCAA, 84 verse 27, That they were, they were cursed. You had to put up with a lot of carnal Commandments in the children of Israel for their wickedness, where are forbidden for, you know. But that God says, this wasn't my original plan to prevent you. But because you think, you think God's original plan was for all of the descendants of Cain to be to be cursed, then the book of Moses that it goes back to, you know, the pre-flood.

1:17:12 That was his plan. God's plan was he wanted Kane to commit the sin so we could curse his people. Well it came was merely Chris before you been killed before, he even killed slew Abel. God told him that you are prediction for that was also before the world. So call them prediction for knowledge or knowledge. Did Cain have agency you do? Or do you believe came didn't happen? The opposition L things. Has John Taylor, explicitly said on his speeches about the, you know that you you need to have the option. If you have a chosen what? John Taylor's dad and you got both of those preserved through the blood as well.

1:17:59 Yeah, but we're not I'm not talking about did the Lord want Kane to fail? That is what? I don't think you wanted him to, but he knew that too. But isn't this just like, is, is it for Dane that Satan was going to rebell? And, you know, take a third of the host of heaven with them, you know? So, you can't, I mention I'm being selective with with, yo, can't, but the surrounding populations. I do want to go there, but you really haven't explained how Elijah has healing power. When his race was cursed as to, the why you said what God wanted to give it to him?

1:18:45 Why? I think God wanted to give the priests of Ducane and to his descendants as well? He wasn't allowed to. But he wanted to, he wasn't allowed to because the decisions that were made. Where does it say that God would have given the blood of Canaan. That's my question is, where is that stated in any of the revelations? Okay, we we know that the entrance, where the hell out of Jubilee. And God Doctrine? So Adam Adam is is, is our father, right? So can't children would be his grandchildren. Well, there's different perspectives on Cain's lineage, you know, you don't think they can come from Adam there, there are different perspectives on that. There's different Traditions have been passed down and fundamentalism that are preserving ancient Jewish and Jew and ancient Christian Traditions that the that chain was not actually the son of Adam that that was a Corruption of the biblical texts and not the opposite power came here as well.

1:19:47 But came the Adam father, The Chosen lineage and then the opposite power was the father of the cursed one inch. And this is something that Ted Jessup. And the Jessup family have preserved as something that they were taught in the coming from Bill. Baird and and Joe Thompson in the AUB in that tradition goes back to Joseph Musser and Lauren boy who you know, a lot more to Adam God and the originals of the world than what he Seattle God, doctor on April 9th 1852, but he said that, he would be the least of it if I were to tell you the whole truth.

1:20:30 So that there are, you know, different perspectives in Tradition, 7 pass down and fundamentalism. Well, that's a pretty wild take. I would say that it it kind of flies in the face of everything that we have, had him scriptures plus anything that the Joseph Smith ever restored. I mean, so Moses is not inspired or how we understand Genesis and basically admit that that is not a full account of or, you know, a fully accurate account of what was going on at the funeral that is got to say yes we do we have for the Revelation that kind of looks us to a different field of knowledge.

1:21:23 When with when Brigham Young explains the parts of the story of Adam and Eve. Are, you know. I put me on a date. He said the children stories that I don't think Moses was lying. I just think that you wasn't going to give them the full knowledge that they weren't ready for. So, but you don't have a quote from a prophet actually teaching us at that Cain is not the son of this of this was not taught by Joseph Smith. This was not taught by Brigham Young. This is not anywhere in scripture. There's no Revelation on it. Brigham Young. I think that this is like a completely different Magic by think their statements by Joseph Smith and Brigham Young, that would hints at this.

1:22:07 These ideas. Brigham Young talk about bringing. Y'all need to bring doubles for our future kingdoms. You made that number of statements that we're not just yet. We need help people. We need resurrected Devil's eukaryotic. This is what Brigham Young said the number of his sermons. I'm just saying that early fundamentalist expounded on that and I do believe in the principle of continuing Revelation. I do believe that, you know, that that you would you have any regulation on this or we it's just because it's just speculation. That is not be speculation to me, but it depends on who would prophetic statement to accept his authoritative. So if I act like I said, I have a contemporary statement in the prison Diary of Arnold boss of Joseph Musser teaching as Doctrine so in any teaches that in the authoritative way. So but like I said, this is a completely different challenge it.

1:23:06 Let's get back to hang tight. One second. Jacob cuz I have I have a couple questions for each of you and then if, if you guys are both satisfied at this point on this, on this topic, we can move on. If not, we can we can go back in and kind of Read you know how she gets out? Some more, whatever you guys want but I have a couple of questions. Justin with you. How do you denview the quotes by Brigham Young? Cuz I want I want to make this clear here by Brigham Young.

1:23:48 And John Taylor, where, where they identify the seeds of Cain is being being the the Africans. Do you think that, that is something then that They carried over from the traditions in Christianity or an end? They were mistaken that way. Or do you feel like That that, that was kind of correct. What, what's your thoughts on that? One of the things that really bothered me in the church, back when I was still in the church, was this idea of prophetic infallibility idea that every word and ideas, spoken by a man who is a prophet is somehow all the word of God is all true.

1:24:39 That they did, they do not make mistakes, they cannot be wrong. And I was kind of surprised. I kind of assumed that, you know, when I came over into fundamentalism that I get beyond that that the people would be beyond that and I've ate, it seems to be, to be honest. It seems to be even worse, in my opinion. Moses was a man, he had weaknesses, he had feelings even screwed up. He even screwed up so bad that he was forbidden to enter into the promised land. I think we have these ideas of these profits as he's infallible.

1:25:20 People who were always inspired, always speaking and teaching things that were absolutely true. And I, I do not, I do not have a testimony that I don't, I think that they are, man. I think they're trying their best. I think that they're inspired at times. I think that the spirit of the Lord rests upon them and they and they speak the Lord's work with the times, but I don't believe every single thing that they say is a d'usse at the Lord Revelation that needs to be that we need to bind ourselves to and I mean, even Joseph Smith That with the situation with the, the, the copyright of the Book of Mormon, he thought he received the revelation, 22 go up in and sell the copyright of the Book of Mormon.

1:26:02 And he came back in after that failed, he's praying about it. What went wrong? And the Lord tells him, You know, you messed up. That wasn't to me. And so, I think we need to be very, very careful about putting these men on a pedestal and not testing and trying their own words and so, yeah, I think that, and I don't think anything wrong with that. I don't think that in the gates or makes it anyway. They're prophetic calling any less to say that they grew up in a culture with ideas and unless they receive Revelation on those ideas unless they went into the Lord and pray that 22-game further light and knowledge on those and then received that Revelation that that they, they had incorrect ideas. I think that even today, we've got incorrect ideas. I think you're not throwing out everything that Brigham Young said right then?

1:26:55 No, not at all. Not at all. But I mean, specifically, even in this one twin Brigham Young first brought forth the idea of the first preached A sermon on the priesthood ban. So I got it right here if it's actually faster because he is in phatic. We Are Young. Wait. Oh no, that's not sorry. Wrong spot. So what what do you think of Brigham? Young says it. And so he says, I will say it.

1:27:35 Now, in the name of Jesus Christ, I know it is true and other stuff Christ. I understand that profits can get things wrong. Like, you know, obviously we should blindly follow every word that a prophet says, but doesn't that make him a be a false prophet? If he's announcing this doctor, in the name of Jesus Christ. It's a false Doctrine, not as he's not speaking to her. Who is Joseph Smith? A false prophet because of the Revelation, he received to sell the Book of Mormons copyright in Canada. Will he eat quickly caught himself right and bring him down with a life. I thought of false Doctrine, the people with would catch me in it and correct me. Where would they be?

1:28:18 Joseph Smith and Brigham Young actually expressed extreme concern that the people were following them blindly and would because I mean Joseph Smith described. It says that he's afraid that they were lying upon a prophet in their minds that will become dark. And if they do that, Brigham, Young was emphatic, that he's afraid. The people are going to just trust in one man and you lied straight to Hell over it. And I think that possibly, maybe we weren't LED straight to hell, but we certainly introduce some hellish doctor and as far as him saying, in the name of Jesus Christ, I believe that to be his testimony is not saved us. Stay at the Lord, under my church and spoke speak. In the name of the Lord, he said that as his testimony and that's basically what he said.

1:29:01 The first time he says, if there was never a prophet or Apostle of Jesus Christ, make it before you, I tell you that, that Just people that are commonly called Negroes, are the children of old Kane. I know they are. I know that they cannot bear rule in the priesthood for the curse on them was to remain on them until the residue of the posterity of Michael and his wife receive the blessings. I mean, this is his very clear here. He's not attributing this evening to Joseph Smith. He's not attributing it to where he's saying. He's he's taking credit for it. He's in phatic. Lee taking credit for it. And he's using very impassioned language. That doesn't mean that it's, that doesn't mean it's of the Lord.

1:29:45 So I just want to make sure sure we cover this point. So I it would be a problem for me. If it was this way, you're not throwing everything. Brigham Young said out the window right or wrong. That is not about throwing everything between you and set out the window, okay? Just just for the purposes of this conversation and debate. Justice subject. Is that right? I think that he's himself is taking ownership of K. All right. Jacob, I got one for you here in this comes out of Exodus 12:38.

1:30:26 And in this time and and I kind of did a little bit of research on the Fly here on this to to make sure that I was understanding. The scripture hear correctly in 38. This is when Israel's heading out of Egypt and it says starting in 37, in the children of Israel Journey from rameses to sekoff and about 600,000 on foot. There were men beside children and a mixed multitude, went up with them and and their flocks and herds even much cattle. That makes multitude went that include probably some Africans as well.

1:31:15 Given that time. That's an interesting question. Verse. Come up in these debates before or these discussions about the priest the band before. I can't take full credit for that one Joshua, Eric's and pointed that out on another podcast. But they did was allow place with the Israelites even though the rest of your city was being destroyed. So I do think that there were times that they did allow other races to be present. Hey, you look at in the story of David and Bathsheba does sheba's husband wasn't racially or ethnically an Israelite, right? It, it it lists his ethnicity, right? I'm trying to remember what it was your ride. Yeah.

1:32:13 So it's clear that there were people that were permitted to be among them a different name. So, the differing degrees and then just a follow-up to that. How would you explain the Ethiopian Jews then as well. Do I would explain that to my Brigham Young explain that in his sermon, on the winning out of the priest of that. He says, that there are Jews that have intermixed with every population of people on the Earth and bring them the other day. That's why that you lost the priesthood was through transgressing. The Commandment not to enter mix and you know, by information with all these different populations. Okay.

1:32:54 And then just for clarification. So so we kind of know on what basis are you. Do you follow the one drop rule that? So I personally so that I believe there's a compelling case that Wilford Woodruff Miss quoted. Brigham Young and the February 5th 1852 speech on the priesthood bad and if they not because the original, if you look at the Pitman shorthand, it says the Negro can't hold one drop of priesthood and Woodruff and said such a person with one drop of the blood can count. You see how Woodruff could have got the words jumbled up and I think there's evidence and Brigham Young's lifetime where Brigham Young didn't hold them. Extracting a policy that Brigham Young in December of 1847 said that in certain cases, the individuals of mixed ancestry to be nearly said, they might have placed in the temple is my side when that case, when the case of Enoch Enoch Louis came up by William Appleby, but I do think so. Since I don't believe I don't personally believe in the one drop rule I think it leads to some silly kind of it can lead to some silly stuff.

1:34:15 We are putting their faith into you. I was going to say Revelation by 23andMe, 23andMe over or whether you should hold the priesthood or not. So I personally I think Young held more of a Joseph F Smith position on the priesthood restriction. I'm just pulling up. Quote, real quick. Do it. It's in the count minutes of the meetings of the Quorum of The Twelve January 2nd 1902. He said he said while the children while the children are the man in whose veins made this, a single drop of negro blood might be entirely by one of his descendants, might turn out to be a pronounce negro. And the question and present Miss mine was where should we get wide enough to determine each case on its own merits? He gave his opinion.

1:35:11 But in all cases, where the blood of can shut itself. However, slight the line should be drawn there but where the children of Tainted parents were found to be Purity for my they might be admitted into the temple. I think that's very similar to what Brigham Young's position was and you cuz I think moroni's Jessup is mentioned this recently that the all-red family one of the ancestors not to not a direct descendant of ruling. All right. But one of the early Pioneer already. The woman who was the first person once the first to design the temple garment actually was Apartment lotto. And I do think that when you look at all the men who were ordained to the priesthood and Joseph Smith's lifetime.

1:35:53 It wasn't any of the full blooded Africans? They all were mixed ancestry. Elijah table was an octoroon. Joseph Chi balls sisters were all white and he was only partially black. And you see that with and every single case of men who are ordained, I do and, and, and John Taylor, kind of had the opinion that those men were ordained before, the word of the Lord was fully understood. So don't feel the same way you did not realize this, but John Taylor actually was at a more strict interpretation of the priest, the band then, bring him young, did Brigham Young. It seems certain people slide who were only partially African ancestry while. John Taylor there has been, if you read about the case of Laura Berry, she's a woman who's less than 1/8 black and she Is what she's a white woman with less than 1/8 black ancestry. And the Salt Lake City.

1:36:53 State president is bringing her case up to John Taylor because we know that her grandparent was considered to be black and and so he brought it up to John Taylor it. So you can we allow an exception in your case because she is absolutely by all outward appearance completely white. We just know she has 11 ancestor and John Taylor apparently didn't accept the request denied it. And I, I personally in this is where it comes down to it, you know, prophetic infallibility. I think John Taylor, what's inside of an opposite extreme. I take more of the Joseph F, Smith Brigham Young position. That was not a one drop rule.

1:37:35 So how about the Joseph Smith position? I want to get into this kind of a good place to segue into whether Joseph Smith priesthood, restrictions or not. I'm good with that. If you are just in unless we need to go back and rehash anything else. I still would like to see some concession that the priesthood curse on the Israelites was not a an absolute strict curse but just a general condition of the times because we have the, the prophets, all the pretty much all of the prophets of the Old Testament. Help know if the priests and contrary to pee supposed ban, which would indicate that a band was not a again. Not a principle isn't there's nothing here that somebody Incapable of holding the priesthood because of these curses there just in general the concept of a curse as a consequence.

1:38:39 Not as God's punishment. There are obviously different curses that have different limitations and I do think if you look in the Book of Mormon there there's a curse on the lamanites and there's nothing in the book invention about them being related to the priesthood. It's just that my position is there. Different degrees of curses that can get people that are cursed. And it doesn't my god with the darker-skinned who are banned from the priesthood. But all in the case of the lane, right? You have the Canaanites in the Old Testament where I don't see any Explorer, God's making any exceptions for them in my personal, the way I personally see the scriptures and now they're laid out. I don't see any curse there myself, but We can go back and forth on Abraham chapter 1, all night I think but I do see the Israelites I already conceded that I do think there was a curse on the Israelites by.

1:39:42 Don't think it was an eternal curse because we know that God said originally I was going to give you guys the priest good and we do know that there are exceptions that God the God's sanction throughout to the Old Testament. Where we have different individuals like Elijah who helped priesthood and the Melchizedek priesthood was preserved to certain degrees in among Israel, even though generally GMC, at4 Taza in general, the Israelites who had it taken away from them. So, I think that's actually a really important example, though. So Laman and Lemuel Brookhurst, right?

1:40:23 They ended up with darker skin, and there were some consequences from that, right? I think we can agree. Maybe they weren't Dan from the priesthood. But there it was a curse and there were consequences, right? Yeah, but I do. I do agree with you on Abraham. I understand your position. Abraham 1:21 through 2027, where you see it as two separate things, the blood of the Canaanites and the right of the priesthood as being separate. I personally don't see it that way. I personally see it as a continuous commentary, that all those verses are related and talking about the curse that's on that creep down the Canaanites in the descendants of ham is laid out in the Dark Crystal that they won't be enticing to the Nephites intermarry.

1:41:15 But what's interesting? And this is proof that God, you know, can't give you no just like four times that times were God, did give them the high priests that even though generally it wasn't permitted that you do have Joseph Smith received a revelation, July 18th. Everyone saying that it was good to intermarry with the lamanites so that they can become white and delightsome. So that was the word of the Lord through the Prophet. Joseph Smith, basically saying that, you know, that curse that was on them can be lifted them up due to them being more righteous than the Gentiles. So, Yeah, I think we can beat, I think we I think we could go back and forth on this all night. The Book of Mormon, explain to curse that looks from all appearances.

1:42:07 Very, very similar to other courses, it doesn't mention priesthood and yet neither does it. The other cursings? The only thing mentioning priesthood is an Abraham and then it's not that is not with a curse, a curse. The curse on the Canaanites happened in Moses six. It happens in on Kane and Genesis and it happens on on Kanan in Moses 9. If none of those places were talks about a person to say anything about priests of being forbidden. That's not fair. It's not their well but the lightest it into it and read into it, but it's not there. And that's my point, it's not there. And you know where else? It's not it's not unlimited Lemuel. Mormon, if you go to Alma 13, it does talk about the right of the priests and having to do with Ford Nation and that certain people are foreordained to have the right of the priesthood. And certain people are forwarding to not have the right of the priesthood in Alma 13 verses 3 through 5 and works. Everywhere, it mentions in the first place it's talking first place is to be understood clearly referencing first to stay everywhere.

1:43:22 It says first place. And this is after which narrowed and being called a prepared for the foundation of the world world, according to the foreknowledge of God, I counted, their seeding, faith and good works in the first place being left to choose, good or evil. Therefore, they having Chosen, good and exercising exceedingly. Great faith are called with a holy calling ye with that Holy calling, which was prepared with the according to a preparatory Redemption for such. And the US, they haven't been called up this way, calling on account of their face, While others would reject, the spirit of God, on account of the hardness of their heart and the blindness of their mind. If it had not been for this, they might have had as great privilege as their Brethren will talk about certain people who rejected the spirit of God and in the previous stints on the, because the hardness of the heart than let us in their mind. And if it had not been for that, I have had this great privileges of their Brethren S5 or confine in the first place. They were on the same standing with their Brethren. That's this voice, calling be prepared from the foundation of the world for such as without hurting their hearts being in it.

1:44:26 Through the atonement of the only begotten son who was prepared and so I do see I'm a 13 there is going into pre stood for nation and resistance was also talk Certain people are forbidden the priesthood because of their actions. While others are forwarding to hold the priesthood because of their actions, in the pre-existence, Yes, man, I don't come disagree with that. It's according to the foreknowledge of God, that it says that we were called to the. That all the prophets were called to their callings as well, that the foreknowledge of God I'm not disputing that what I'm saying is Laman and Lemuel were cursed, they were cursed with dark skin, they were separated from the Nephites And I'm saying that when you look, you're trying to say but we don't see priest and mentioned in this purse, this purse or this cursed, what we do, but you do see it and you know, Abraham one that what we're giving in Genesis chapter, 9 isn't a complete account of that. And according to Brigham Young, what we have in an earlier, DiNapoli Genesis 4 with chain and that is a complete account either, they're going to bring them young. So Okay, well but I want to go back to Lane and let me know because their posterity they are told that they are cursed but Lehi blesses them and tells them that if it were not for the concert if it were not the

1:45:56 consequences of their fathers sins that they would be just as right just as righteous as their brethren. And he basically puts that upon Lehigh's, head the consequences of that curse. And Among the Nephites at various times, including will first, you got that right there, you got Lehigh, who's desperately concerned for the posterity of Laman and Lemuel who work, because of that curse. You got Nephi. You got Jacob that tries to minister unto them and throughout all of the entire nephite history we have. The Nephites and lamanites for the most part for the most part separate.

1:46:37 And we are to understand that they are cursed and yet, none, the less than any fights labored to teach the to teach the way my 10 to bring them back in to ultimately their society accumulating with the situation where you had Alma and the sons of King Noah who were converted under the Lord, who they were not ordered by their father to go in and serve a mission. Among the the lamanites they went of her own accord because of the conversion in the, in the blessings of the Gospel that they had received as individuals, and they went to the lamanites even though they were cursed. And they taught them as possible.

1:47:18 And converted a good half of those of the population and brought them back Among the Nephites. And it says, they were not where they were, basically no longer cursed. We have the same complete reconciliation happening. In Christ time, when Christ visits any fight people. So late nights, and then the Nephites were all brought brought back the survivors. At least have the the tribulation. They're all brought back together as one people and Eventually over time they ended up separating again. So there is a curse but there's no prohibition. There is nothing forbidden that they are not allowed to preach and share the gospel, lent. It to provide those blessings to the people in the act of their own accord and go forth and do that. And I think that's an example of them to us as to what really we ought to be doing with the people that are that have been cursed.

1:48:17 And so anyway, is is given to everyone and he would say that the gospel is, and he said that, you know, she'll dry cleaning out. The priest said that you said that they can receive baptism of the Holy Ghost. They can receive those the introductory ordinances of the Gospel. He also said, 1861 East Side in the evening, presently discuss with his brother, has the character of a few partly colored brother in the present remark, that there are men who have the dark skin of pain parsley. So you may have a blood of a random enough to control themselves in righteousness and fulfill the requirements of the gospels.

1:49:09 Well, as many other wipe, some of these partly dark brother and maybe shipless, but there are many whites were also ship was the President also spoke favorably of Isaac. Colored man would work for him for many years. He also remarked that he would confer any blessing to him. He could be leading him to deserve it, but it showed that he believed that they could have the benefits statement to make that clear. You just didn't think they told the priest it or the ordinances of the temple temple. Ordinances. Sure. Have you have you have you received the time coordinates has personally have they have those things to you?

1:49:52 Have they been a blessing in your life? I mean for me I would dare say that those blessings have been vital. It to my progression and Defy is is very clear to in the Book of Mormon, when he says that baptism is the way, it's the gate, you know, Faith repentance baptism. But what do you do next? Are you done? And it has no after that, you got to fall that Holy Spirit and it will guide you. And he basically says until you entering the rest of the Lord, that's that's the process. and that process as Joseph Smith revealed to us requires further further ordinances, Yeah, but your Joseph Smith, that think that everyone would receive the higher word that says Joseph Smith on June 11th, 1843 cents in the resurrection summer race to be Angels.

1:50:45 Others are based to become Gods. These things are available most. Holy place in the temple. Prepared for that purpose. He doesn't mention in any of those statements, you was just talking generally, obviously, right? Obviously not going to be in that group gay songs. Like they're honest alive. Since I just kind of got brought up again to go first on this to argue against it or sure. Absolutely. If you want to go first on the historic city of the band in your perspective and the history of the church volume four, 2:00, whatever.

1:51:37 Onyx hot verse 2213. It's reported the first presidency given at conference in 1840. If the work rules for us with the same rapidity, that is hither, Heather for done. We may soon expect to see flocking to this place. People from every land in from every nation. The polished European, the degraded Hottentot and the Shivering laplander persons of all languages and of every tongue and of every color. Who shot with us Worship, the Lord of hosts, and His holy Temple, and offer up there or Sands in his sanctuary.

1:52:17 And this was again 1840, this is well, after Joseph Smith had translated from Abraham. And Moses. And this is as they are preparing to complete the Nauvoo Temple. Where does basically declares that the purpose of this Temple is to bring all people together to Worship in the temple in the sanctuary to offer up there, or a sense, which we can clearly understand in the context of of, of prayers in a temple to be, you know, it's a bit spur Circle. That's what, that's how we were taught to pray in the sanctuary. It in history words have that have significance, right? What what were some of those groups he was talking about their reread those again?

1:53:10 Yeah, well the polished European, that's easy. Yep, the degraded Hottentot, what is that? Do we know other Africans? It's a it's a derogatory term for people like African Negroes. Okay. And and but it also says also clearly that that for persons of all languages of every tongue not sometime. I was every tongue and of every color not some color but every color division the Joseph Smith. How did the purpose of this Temple was to bring all of God's children back together again? I reuniting a reunification and frankly, that's the same vision that I have always had of the gospel and the establishment of Zion is that the whole point of this is to bring everybody together and for us to be able to rise as high as we're going to rise. Another one along those lines.

1:54:10 Is it Revelation Joseph Smith received that we are all very familiar with, as Doctrine covenants, 12, a great and marvelous work is about to come forth among the children of men. Behold, I am God gives you to my work which is quick and Powerful sharper than a two, edged sword to the dividing asunder of both joints and Marrow, therefore, gives them to my word. Behold, the field is white all ready to harvest their for who, so desirous to reap, let him trust in his sickle with his might and reap. While the day last that he may treasure up for his soul Everlasting salvation in the kingdom of God, ye whosoever will thrust with his sickle and reap. The same is called of God.

1:54:53 Therefore, if you will ask of me, you shall receive. If you will knock, it shall be opened unto you. Now, as you have asked, behold, I say unto you keep my Commandments and seek to bring for us and establish the cause of Zion behold, I speak unto you and also all of those who have desires to bring forth and establish this work, And no one can assist in this work, except he be humble and full of love having faith, hope charity being tempered and all things whatsoever. And all things whatsoever shall be entrusted to his care behold. I am the light in the life of the world. That speak of these words, they're forgive, he'd with your might, and then they are called. Amen. What I see is qualifications here is things like Humboldt. Humility, love faith, hope charity. I don't see anything in here about a prerequisite to enter into this priesthood work of preaching, the gospel of race. It doesn't say some of you who ask will receive it doesn't say some of you willing to trust in your circle and Reaper call to God.

1:55:55 So this is also a revelation of God. True Joseph Smith. That is very clear. There's no race or there's no racial exclusion and Tori language anywhere and in the revelations that Joseph Smith received in regards to the organization of the church in this day, Joseph Smith had a vision of all the people of this Earth coming together under the auspices of the Gospel. And the priesthood to participate together in this establishment of Zion. Jacob, when he got there. Well, I'm just taking notes since he's sharing.

1:56:37 Did you have more there? Justin, I don't mean to short-circuit anybody. I'm offline. Also plan out Tuesday that it's again, it's there are no, There are no basically. Brigham Young. I at least as far as I can. I might have research more than me. I can't find a single quote from Brigham Young attributing, this talking to Joseph Smith. I found other people after Brigham Young. Saying that it was from Joseph Smith. But not in front of first-hand account just as it as a general like is if it's common knowledge, but I can't find anything to Brigham Young saying that Joseph Smith ever taught this. and it's not until after Joseph Smith's death, that that basically you know we got our first Examples of this being taught in the church. Play anything else there before Jacob response? I do think that when you're in 1840, where it talks about every race coming to Worship in the

1:58:07 temple, I do think you need to take that in the contacts and some people think that's a slam dunk, you know, that clearly there wasn't a priest, it bad because everyone's worshipping Temple. But Temple worshipped back then wasn't what it was what it became ingrained in early. Utah. Brigham Young said you have some of you think that we're going to be doing all these other things that we did and Nauvoo and didn't Kirtland in the Salt Lake Temple Aces from now on, we're only going to be building temples for priesthood ordinances and so it was a policy under Brigham Young to make the temple, be priests adornments Pacific and the Kirtland Temple, they do the sacrament meetings that they do prayer meetings, you know that they would do Is the doctor Kirtland are building?

1:58:52 The Nauvoo Temple. This is the time when everything's like it's supposed to be a place of study, like they're supposed to be like a library in the temple where people are going to be coming and studying. What modern LDS temple today has a library for four people to come and study and research and, you know, so that there is a lot of stuff is listed in the Nauvoo Temple that it was supposed to be used one day. They didn't use it for law purposes, only the upper rooms that were intended for you. They use for the endowment ordinance. And sealing ordinances that use like the main room for Sunday sermons. They used.

1:59:36 You know, they used to be baptism, baptism for the dead, but it says, who shall with us Worship. The Lord of hosts in his holy Temple, in offer up there or in his Sanctuary capitalized, his That's not the library. They're talking a whole Temple is considered a sanctuary. So since that's kind of how I would respond to you on that is that I do agree, that that was mean that all people would be invited and in Elijah able to get baptism for the dead.

2:00:16 Why even say in the sanctuary though? Crucial crucial with us Worship, the Lord of hosts in his holy Temple and offer up their orisons, why not? Just stop there. It doesn't. It says, in his Sanctuary. It's very specific. The sanctuary is not the entire Temple. The Temple of the sanctuary is where they are offering up there or Sands is where they're going to do a circle. Was here, they are a prayer. That's what the term kouros means. It just means presents for their prayers. It's not just reference to order a prayer hadn't, even been revealed to the saints that, that time. And so, I do think it's reading back into it. Something that hadn't yet been even talked to the Saints go until 1842 when do the starts and ministering, then down at the people that he starts telling them that, you know, 1841, January 1841, the Revelation lose that there's going to be a cheese given to better ask and receive an 18 42 trying about April and May just start saying, there's going to be ordinances, to better be able to ask and receive. But, or since just means prayers, and that could be representing solemn assemblies are being held, where everyone's giving that was a stout or, you know, all sorts of other young just prayers and in other circles, That's like you can do like those circumstances where they would go into the temple and do prayers before, you know, doing three baptisms for healing or other purposes.

2:01:41 So it's a lot of reading into this though. I visit very clearly that this is very clearly. The purpose of the temple was to bring all of God's people together. That's what is being attempted to be being communicated. Hear some Mike Mike. So Dover 6000 I think about 6,600 I'm not mistaken Saints received their endowments in the Nauvoo Temple of The Twelve, basically trying to get everyone through to get their endowments before going out west. But what's interesting to me is that you don't ask Then there are some very pure-blooded African individuals in the church in Nauvoo.

2:02:25 There was there was green flake, and then there was Jane Manning James, and neither of them went to the temple and got their endowments. And for me, what's what's very interesting is? I see the apostles less than 6 months or about six months after Christmas. Duh or starting to teach, you know, these explicitly, teach some of these priests and Concepts Brigham Young on in January of 1845, January 8th, 1845 set with me and I would tell your children as much as you receive this promise that if you mix your blood with the others, I will curse you in a relation to the previous. Would you be cursed and damned if the Ancients and not mixed their blood?

2:03:16 The priesthood would have never been taken from them and Number of other statements in early 1845. He's in his mention Keys of the Kingdom is connected to lineage and blood. And this is what's very interesting because you do have some knowledge is like Walker. Lewis was an elder Brigham. Young of the high priest Forum on March 9th. 1845 snow again, in less, than a year after. He says, there are many elders and I can never hold the Keys of the Kingdom until their blood becomes changed, and they become the right about the Tyre Temple or was it that there are people who won't be able to receive these ordinances.

2:04:03 So I I do think that that's a compelling. Some people that start with until 1847 or 1849 or later. But Brigham Young seems to be teaching it less than a year after and you have or sand High teaching some of these ideas. What's the year after Christmas death as well? I think we all know that. I don't think they teach these things. So, so I would say that, you know, you do have Joseph Smith statement, you have to be pretty selective. Breeding Joseph Smith to get free samples. If I don't know if you're familiar with Joseph's, Miss April 1836.

2:04:54 In the messenger and Advocate where he says, I can say that the curse has not yet taken off of the sons of Jaden and it will, it be until it's affected by his great power that causes come. And the people in her. At least of the decrees of purpose of God. In this matter, will come under the least combination before him and those who are determined to pursue pursue a course that shows an opposition Purvis wrestle against the designs to Lord will learn. That's too late for their own good. That God can do his own work without the AIDS who are not dictated by his counseling and there's another statement 1841 saying that you said that the curse was still on the children of Canaan to the present-day, a good point, though, because the context of that he is, he's referring to slavery in the question of whether they should be allowed to listen. It's true.

2:05:42 Probably misses at the church. So he doesn't say anything about priesthood there. So you said yeah we know what Brigham Young taught. It doesn't prove that Joseph Smith. Will bring him young said in the Same by the same storm. And so this experiment on February, 16th 1847, he taught that the rights to hold kingly powers and higher. Grades of the priesthood was connected to lineage and blood. And he said that the teachings. He got came from Joseph Smith movie Kingdom by the difficulty was, I could not remember as they could then, but then when it was necessary, they would not be at a loss rather standing by their record to the truth of his words, before God, to say, that I always had an understanding and everything was brought to my mind, just as he taught them to us.

2:06:29 I'm familiar, you're probably familiar with Lester bushes paper Mormonism, negro doctor in the historical overview. I thought that you did a really great job, arguing his case he tries to he really focuses in on the 18th 79 testimonies of like 70, coltrin and contrasting. And tries to try to argue against coltrin credibility, Abraham's Milton those hearings as credible. But I do think that he compiled quite a bit of information to argue against the bad. But I do think that there's been other sources that have come to light like these Brigham Young statement.

2:07:09 So, I mention that would argue that, that provides some reasonable evidence. That start with Joseph Smith. Another example, is that George had to get another in that statement. That wasn't, that was not break saying that the priest the band on on Race came from Joseph Smith. He was saying he was talking about the principles of the kingdom in the temple. Ordinances, a set of The Twelve were taught about the order of the Kingdom. In all the organ. I just keep talking about him. Receiving those organs is in the red brick store before the temple was finished and having inspiration to know how to reconstruct the endowment after Joseph Smith death. He's not talking about a racial prohibition there, that that's not there.

2:07:51 He didn't say that. I meant earlier, you apply it. Because Brigham Young was taught the band but he didn't teach the band at that time, either that the band was being taught in 1847. this wasn't early 1847 after Joe Smith death as he So we know that Joseph Smith was initially very favorable to Elijah table and wanting him to receive a sit-down with. But then there's a cop shift, sometime between 1895 and the early 1900s where Joseph Smith, went blank decided that my table didn't have the right to the priesthood and that, you know, that his priests have been withdrawn and that of the Negro can't hold the priesthood which Scholars like like Lester.

2:08:49 Bush didn't know what to make of why he had a complete flip flop on the bed and let me down. No thanks to the gorge to Cannon journals being released in this in 2018, George tucannon, testified for different times in his journal, in the 1890s that he was taught in the bad as a boy and na boo by John Taylor as coming from Joseph Smith, and it was that's fifty years later. So Got to be cautious with something 50 years later, but his testimony was credible enough that both Lorenzo Snow and Joseph F Smith who were requesting the bad like rhymes with no questioning and Joseph Smith with me against it that they both shifted their views. Thanks because of George to cancel smart. I said wow, thank you for providing that. You were told this information that's what ship did is beu and we do have money and I mean I personally don't consider a church to Cannon necessarily a particularly Authoritative source for that kind of thing.

2:09:57 First of all, he was young at that time, and he's not saying you heard from you. He's not saying he heard it from Joseph Smith, is he? You think he heard it from John? Taylor was talked to him as a boy and Abu by John, Taylor is coming from Joseph Smith, so you can hear it directly from Joseph. He said he was taught by John Taylor. I would say you should be cautious with something fifty years after the fact. But John Taylor in 1845 right for editorial. On the, on the children, the children of Noah, where he references, that have one that Tanner was Chris pertaining to the priest that he doesn't explicitly say like that.

2:10:39 It sounds explicit as some of the latest, but it references, he's cursing at you, kind of ties it to the priesthood. So I think that gives credibility to George to Cannon's recollection that this was going on. And I'll be really kind of lies in the The people who want to say that this didn't start until early Utah because this is like, we're talking George. They left Nauvoo in 1846 or less than George you can. And at the very latest would have heard it in January 1846, but probably earlier, if you was in the movie from 1843 to 1846, you know, it's only problem probably heard it at an earlier time. He's claiming he remembers learning as a boy from somebody who wasn't even Joseph Smith, that is a credit.

2:11:24 That's not that mean. That's not that's not a credible. Historic reference But he's so let's talk a little bit about the 1879 investigation because some people really like to attack Zebedee Coltrane on this because you know, because he says that he gave Elijah a table is washing and anointing and and it was the record list of there was another man who did it, and there's some other details that he got wrong. But why you think is interesting, is like John Taylor convene that meeting specifically because you heard rumors, they sent it and we're hearing rumors that you said that that you heard from Joseph Smith. That the Negro can't hold the priesthood. That when Joseph was asked about the right of the priesthood that was with African individuals.

2:12:13 Can hold the priesthood that Jose Joseph quoted from the words in Acts where it says what God has plans called out now common and so they wanted. So, John Taylor was investigating, whether the statement had veracity or not and Debbie Corcoran who Didn't know why they were calling him to the meeting, you know, he, he comes in there and they asked him that rides, meaning uses. No, I've actually received the opposite instruction for Jose but I heard him on two different occasions. Say that Africans couldn't hold the priesthood and the person interviewed was Abraham's milk and Abraham's milk. Similarly, recalled. That Joseph Smith said, you could baptized slaves with the consent of your Masters on the south Austin said their masters on South but don't compare the priest on them.

2:12:58 And so it's interesting how people really focus on Zebedee Coltrane and try to disparage. And just as well, he was he was a slaveholder in Utah. Yeah, Abraham smoke was was, was that really kind of called into question? I mean, that I mean that's the kind of conflict of interest, right? Well what's interesting is Lester, Bush found his stuff. He said that he thought like that that Abraham Smoot was credible, he just thought that it was just a policy pertaining to the South and you actually do have some contemporary Thai Heaven, read this essay that you're referring to, okay? The Sara Lee interested in his perspective on it, but I think that it's pretty clear that if somebody is a slaveholder, they're going to have a vested interest and can't get enough of the Mormon Renegade podcast.

2:13:52 Well, good news, we're on patreon and there's three packages that you can choose from the first one. The slightly Rowdy package allows you to hear the podcast without all those pesky commercials getting in the way, for those who want a slightly more in-depth experience, there's a stirring it up package where you can hear add free audio, add free video and transcripts. Finally, for those who want to go full Renegade, that package is available to where you can get everything in. Previous two packages plus an extra show where myself and been Winfield. Break down the news of the day from a very morning. Pointe of view. You also get exclusive access to Renegade, chat Inn on there, you'll be able to talk to others about the show or whatever topics are on your mind. Go to patreon today and get your exclusive content. This episode of the podcast is brought to you by Deseret flag.com.

2:14:42 I've said this before and I really mean it Mormonism isn't just a religion. It's a culture as such it has its own vernacular and practices but also its own symbols and no symbols become even more important and prominent. When you look back into our history, perhaps one of the most recognizable symbols of Mormonism is the Deseret flag. This is the flag that I use as cover are in this podcast. This was also used for a good chunk of time during the Pioneer error in Utah. Now today we have people who want to replace the existing, you talk like with some other Progressive monstrosity. Well, I think it's damn past time that we start pushing back here a little bit in Utah. Our friends at defending you two are here to help you with that. Now if you go to Deseret flag.com you can now purchase your own Deseret state flag, it's time here that we start making ourselves known and join the resistance against those who seek to rewrite, our state's history, go to Deseret flag.com or check out the link in this episodes page show notes and get yours today in anime, maintaining the the priests of band and the the racist behaviors and attitudes among that was developing among the culture at that time, which is a declaration of belief in Kirtland, Ohio and 1835, seems to support the skull Prince, recollection, about his instructions. From Joseph Smith has to preach the gospel Nation. They are going to warn the righteous to save himself and Corruption.

2:16:10 While we do not believe it right to interfere with bondservants, neither preach the gospel to nor baptize them. Contrary to the will and wishes of their masters norda metal with more influence. Annalisa Cochrane to be dissatisfied with their situations in life. Thereby jeopardizing the lives of men, such interference. We believe to be unlawful and I'm just a dangerous, the piece of every government allowing human beings to be held in servitude. So, yeah, this is matching up with what he said, where you said I could baptizing with the consent, their masters. So that's what was. We literally have is the instruction the criminal that time. So that's that's why some your historians do give credibility. So we have, you know, George Do Canon recalling. It, we have zebi call Tran, we have, but again, that's not, that's not what he said that.

2:16:58 Joseph Smith was not saying that there's a racial Twisted band. The question is, is it okay? Is it allowable to preach the gospel? And his response was that is it is allowable with the with the slave, hold with the slave owners permission. And we know that Joseph Smith was not and he was running for president on a platform of of freeing the slaves just did a different approach than then what an alternate Lee happen not through War but through basically purchasing purchasing them back but what do you think Joseph Smith meant when he said that? The when when when he debated with John C Bennett and he said that the Indians have greater cause to complain of their treatment of the whites in the Negroes are sons of Jane.

2:17:48 Why do you think you thought the Indians were more mystery to us in the Negroes and I was in a debate in 1842 and novel, you know, I don't know that it really is pregnant is it to The discussion. But it could be, you know how it is at as a descendant of set, Indians. There have been some really horrific horrific more near genocide. All history among the Native Indians. Where is the blacks were enslaved? Nobody tried to enslave the Indians. They were trying to, to kill them all, so, to speak and a worse situation to be in, then then slavery. When is a lot of those big persecutions and killing off Indians happened?

2:18:42 You know, after Joseph Smith death I know there was complex before that, but I'm talking about like, the big massacres it. It depends. And then it's hard to know with what's right in the history because it's very politicized. You've got some people trying to argue that the US government, when it was never anything, but grateful and a benevolent, father to the Indian and then you got some people to try to argue that from the moment, Columbus landed. We've been trying to murder them all and so but I mean this is a question of opinion. It sounds like Joseph Smith weighing in on his opinion on that and in his opinion he saying that he feels the Native Americans were treated worse than you and I can I can respect that opinion. I don't know if it's absolutely the truth but like I said the history of of the of what was done to the Native Americans is highly politicized.

2:19:40 So it's really hard to know. What's right or wrong and even Joseph Smith, I mean, if their story is going around, then about things that maybe weren't actually happened. You know, who knows how he landed at the opinion he landed on. But I don't, I don't see where, I don't know, I personally was seeing that as possibly referencing back to work Joseph, in April of 1836 Cairo, editorial saying that that slavery was something that was biblical, but that he said, that slave owners had to treat their slaves humanely and that like a parent. So then rather than treating them cruelly was Joseph, Smith's view on slavery was in the 1830s.

2:20:23 So but Joseph Smith even by the late in the last year, or so of his slide in the last two years while he was against slavery. He's still interested had some opinions that we're not what you would consider to be modern. And it's on a racial racial ideas do on on January, 2nd of 1843 he was asked about the situation of the Negroes, B, worse and ride and and Joseph replied. He said Give me the Wild Side, mentally and physically changed our situation of the whites. And they would be like them. They have souls are subject of Salvation, he's being great, a gallon or so I don't want them to be above me in the same validation haven't seen equal rights is us but then Joe said anything to do with the Negro.

2:21:14 I would confine them by strict lost, their own species and put them on a national Equalization to Joseph was very much against miscegenation with the with the Negroes and he said you wanted them by law to their own species and he actually did that. Bill in February of 1844 where he find to Africans in Nauvoo for attempting to marry white women. So he still held. Yeah, I think it's a mischaracterization to try to characterize. Joseph is being kind of a racial egalitarians, where he would have modern, Rachel sentiments. And I have to ask if he thought Negroes were completely equal with my to be said.

2:21:54 In this January 2nd, 1843 statement, why would he still be against inter marriage under all circumstances? You say by strict law. So perhaps because there's another statement where he suggest sending them to Mexico where all Races that are mixed with no problem. Yeah, so he wants to free the slaves and then send them, he wants them. Separate is kind of send them to Mexico, where where they're not going to be lynched for being freed slaves. Tell me where they're not going to where they don't have to deal with a of eminent racial persecution. I mean that sounds like a good idea to be too if there's someplace that they could go where they're not going to have to deal with that then yeah that sounds like a good idea. And yeah it like act like I just said why confine them to their race because they're they're likely to to face some severe backlash and persecution.

2:22:56 Otherwise I don't think that's necessarily implies in any way whatsoever. A priest band that was not mentioned or spoken of and frankly I mean in all the stuff you've been talking about lately, it seems like it has no real. I don't know. I'm not saying that I'm not seeing the connection to the priesthood band. Okay, well, I'm done talking about racial abuse in general. So for me, my personal perspective on when the priests of them was introduced is that I believe the Book of Abraham was repealed in 1835, but I don't think it was implemented immediately. That strict way because we know Elijah table is, were named in 1836. We know that Jose is missing on the patriarchal, blessing, referencing his status as an elder. What's interesting?

2:23:43 So in 1842 is when the book Abraham is finally published, and that's when Joseph is trying to introduce these Temple and it says, which Brigham Young said we're in connection to lineage and blood. Then in 1843. Elijah table was restricted to preach to his own race by the apostles. This is Raymond Joseph Smith on Lifetime, it's in this is in the book for the cause of righteousness on page to 28. It says Elijah Abel's preaching activities restricted. June. 1843. So he was a missionary and Elder. I think it was a he was a 70 by that point in early 1878 1842 was on a mission to Cincinnati the apostles met with him in June of 1843 and they told them that he was from now on only to preach to his own race and they gave him other.

2:24:38 And so brother Pat Rose at 12, it's organic sediment or their own native country of their own kin. Brother Abel's was advised to visit the colored population and advice is sanctioned by the conference and instructions were given to him concerning his mission. As I believe, it's Elijah tables priest and was restricted. I believe it was at this time where he was restricted to preach to his own race and then I didn't hear that. It sounded like he was being advised to preach the gospel to his own race. That was kind of that. I was skipping around. I wasn't reading the whole document but they said, let's see if there were several earlier place where Design. I think that would make sense.

2:25:24 You're you're you you have a connection to those people. And we want to preach the gospel to them and bring them into the fullness of the Gospel. As is being raised, was being restored and so who better than Elijah Abel a priesthood holder and a black man to go to the, to go to his own people and preach and share the gospel with them. I mean I think that's some good advice. So overall so it couldn't be a protection to him to safety to him against getting some upset. You know preaching at some white people who might be upset that you know that there's a black man running around free.

2:26:05 Well I think that what that it was it was in a city in the north so it wasn't you know like down in the South but yeah I do think it's significant that basically B there too only preached to his own race and what were they like it? And I think is really significant, is that he continued in the priest that he even continued, exercising it in the office of his priesthood, even down to his death, he was serving a mission. He got back from the final mission 2 weeks before he died. He was is preacher, was never taken away. He was even even by Brigham, Young and John Haylor. They never restricted. His priests didn't, in fact, they even sent him on another mission at the end of his life. He was allowed to hold his missionary office, but I don't know of any evidence of him performing any ordinances after this.

2:26:54 After this meeting with the apostles. So it's, it's my opinion that when the meeting occurred, that, that is when he had his Priests of the restricted and then we have Brigham Young. I mean, excuse me. Actually, he actually takes in the Quorum of 70 East Shelly still was a member of the 70 but you know he was Joseph Smith said that you sent on a mission they changed but he was not to confer the priesthood on any of the colored individuals. I wouldn't be surprised if he was actually prohibited at that point because based off of the priesthood band, which we have thus far, seen began with Brigham Young. But I don't again. You're going on a mission.

2:27:38 You're you're speaking, you're a member of the Quorum in your even presenting to that a quorum. These are things that priest of holders to say, after listening to about 70 Coltrane and Abraham smooth, listening to Elijah table and sell in his case was probably like many other things done in the early days, the church baptism for the dead. At first persons were baptized without records being taken. As the lord gave for the light and Revelation things were done with greater at work, but what has been done through lack of knowledge? That was not altogether. Correct in detail, was allowed. That probably was doing brother Abel's case. He haven't been ordained before the word of the Lord was fully understood.

2:28:18 It was allowed to remain in that was on June 4th, 1879. And so what's interesting Yeah. Go ahead. Is it 18:44? A patriarchal blessing that indicates that she came down Through the Ages that do not have the full promises given to them is busy. So she poked him. Dip down in the lineage of Canaan, the son of ham which promises the fullness thereof is not yet revealed. That statement seems to be some more in language to Brigham Young Thing. The African droids the right of receiving. The first principles of God's will, is Liberty, is held out to all the servants. They enjoy the Liberty, being baptized remission of sins. And a receiving the Holy Ghost by laying on of hands, but they cannot hold the priesthood as much as they can't bear any share in the priest in any place until the curse is removed for them.

2:29:10 And so, she's idette also, identified as being able to obtain and that blessing work, he quotes hiring in the. After he mentioned that if she was righteous, you would eventually have the curse removed, but he also gives a warning behold. I stand Accepted it. Does not well, soon live but the warning and conditional promise given to Cain and Jesse's for 7. I'm also stated that the season to place a mark upon your forehead can take it off and step up on you his own image. That's just like what Brigham Young said, where he said the curse was on the face of every African. He said he placed a mark on your forehead so he's referencing the curse of Cain right there.

2:29:54 And so hiresmith in this revelatory blessing is referencing her as, as being of these cursed one, you just do not have the full promises given to them through. This is in Joseph, Smith Lifetime with Tire, Man, as the co-president of the church, I see. This is also being evidence that this Doctrine goes back to Joseph Smith Lifetime. Well, here is his curse and I have never said there wasn't a curse. I I completely agree that there is a curse. The question is, is really here has been nature of that curse and you went back for you. Go to John Taylor. And that's actually a very fascinating case to me because this is a minute from the Quorum of The Twelve Apostles meeting, right? And what John Taylor says is it seems that in this case, it was probably like many of the things done in the early days of the church, such as baptism for the dead at first persons were baptized at Rikers, being taken, more further night and that. Yeah.

2:30:51 What you done, max out, sew-in Brothers ain't so he thought that probably it was so and brother, I mean the language he's using he is incredibly speculative. He said he wanted to interview Joseph young to to see if there was confirmation of Zebedee. Coltrane's, testimony interview Joseph young about it. The Lord. He's not saying I went and prayed about it and and dust day of the Lord. Ultimately, that really get that the Crux of this whole issue for me. Where is the Revelation if this is so important, especially as Brigham, Young describes it. Brigham Young says that if you marry outside your race, then it would be better for you.

2:31:40 Two to be killed and your wife and your children. The dire thin of interracial marriage or giving these people. The priesthood is as Brigham Young describes. It is, well, it's it's, it's hyperbolic to be honest. It's, it's really hard to take it and believe it with a straight face. It's so incendiary, and Rebecca said that her life, would it be worth anything to her? If Jacob also Mary's with among the cainites also among the Canaanites at that time were burning their children babies alive. Yeah, I would feel very similarly, I don't think this has anything to do with you.

2:32:21 He going back to that point but again, I'm not I don't see anything about that. He would be barred from the priests of the femur Decay night woman. Because they have a cursive bud line, that's not what, that's not what I see Rebecca saying here, I see Rebecca saying, is it concerned? A mom who's afraid her son is going to marry these people that murder their babies. And that's a very, very reasonable stamps to take. And so again, if this is so important, if this is so vital to the exercise of the priesthood, where is the Revelation? Why didn't Joseph Smith even presented Revelation on it? If if he knew about this, why doesn't Brigham Young for that the Revelation? Why didn't John Taylor for this to Revelation?

2:33:04 Where is the, the scriptural Revelation that was presented to the church? My position is that the word of the Lord to his German is revelation and that you know, some of the section of the doctor and come it for just the inspired me things that Joseph Smith taught that we consider you not to be a GNC 121, one of the greatest section to the doctor and come. It's just an excerpt from the letter of the DNC, 13131 are taking excerpts from those those those were all presented his Revelations and accepted by the church as Revelation that were accepted his Revelations.

2:33:47 And then, bring him young teaching, was accepted as the word of the Lord, by his contemporaries. There was no one who disputed him on introducing was somebody who was willing to Brigham Young. When he thought that Brigham, Young was contradicting, Joseph Smith, he supported the same Doctrine and he wrote about it in this year arguing that it was, it went back to the previous that they tied it into the doctor in the pre-existence, Kristen all the priests in the brake system of anything should have been suggested by us or any names mentioned except by commandment. Or they say the Lord, we do not consider it binding. Brianna said, in the name of the Lord, so You said that in the name of Jesus Christ.

2:34:29 I know it's true. Yeah, I know. It's true. That's a testimony. That is a testimony. And I believe you believe that I don't think Brigham Young was was was an evil person. I'm not from Brigham Young under the bus. But that is not a revelation that is not what the standard, the Joseph Smith established by which the church should be governed. And again if this is so vital, if this is so important, why didn't why didn't why didn't just been explicitly, teacher that you're saying, you think he knew about it, but was keeping silent and just told a few randos, I don't see. I think we're very lacking in the historical record with with where Joseph Smith Institute of different things like a deuce, though.

2:35:18 If there was a revelation produced by Joseph Smith, we would know about it, it would have been referenced. We don't have an explicit Revelation. It from Joseph Smith. Say the Lord, Adam is your father and your God. We have other Revelations that hints at the Autumn God Doctrine. But yeah, we take on Brigham's word, that Joseph Smith taught that to him. We do we take that at Brigham's word and we see how it fits in with the rest of the gospel, and the restored, scriptures, and even in need. Daniel in the Old Testament, puts forth, a pretty good case. That the Ancients of days Adam is is God our father. But what we have is just an out-of-the-blue.

2:35:59 We've got Brigham Young. Who is not claiming this was taught by Joseph saying that this is a vital vital aspect of the priesthood that if this is, if you screw this up, the entire church will be destroyed. And and the people who mess this up or where would be better off if we if we killed them. And this is all based off of, I have a testimony in the name of Jesus Christ. Not the stay at the Lord. Not the Lord unto his servants. I give them to you a warning, don't yet again his style to give his Revelation.

2:36:42 He said, if you wanted to know Revelation, you should seek the words of him, who knows the mind of God. And so he said it, brings the people on your left, condemnation to not be giving the bus at the lower Revelations that they won't follow. So I'm not having Revelations on important things. Like we think the endowment, ceremony is absolutely important. Beautiful. And vital to the gutter to the priesthood and understanding the plan of the Gospel. We think that, you know, the higher Temple ordinances are important wear it. So we have the energy, 132 laying out, Eternal Marriage, as, and it's doctrinal. MLP. EG 124 that lays out. We're going to reveal new ordinances to you and listening to the temple but we don't actually have any Revelation.

2:37:28 Weirdos. This is actually the Lord's telling me recording Revelation in his lifetime saying the Lord's Tommy actually need give the stuff to you before the temple is completed. We have to go off of other people's word such as asthma said that to them in those Polly order and we don't actually have the Revelation. Instituting, the endowment ceremony are instituting. The second anointing, we just, we, we know they're hinted at in the other Revelations, but we don't actually have, since you're the one who's that quote from Brigham Young saying that as he was working on those things that the way to reconstruct that statue atop by Joseph Smith, came back to him, right? That was coming from Brigham.

2:38:09 Young testifying that this is what brought Joseph Smith taught as far as what this is. He's not saying that it's okay to use up for the temple doctor by Brigham Young thing that he's teaching at the temple. Doctors, that these ordinances are only for those are certain lineage and blood who should receive them that you're saying that you just kind of probably making his own ideas up, this kind of what your position is well as he puts forced himself, he did not introduce the priests of bad with the temple. And you taught it before. They did the Nauvoo temple on January 1845, he said that the children is ill because they mix their blood and they lost the recent not type, did not type to Joseph Smith in his never tied it to Joseph Smith and any of his writings before the temple ordinances. So I would not be surprised that he would take those two things and put them together.

2:39:05 So as long as he doesn't, but he doesn't say if a quart of reconstructing the temple, he does not say there's a Christian band, even there, we know that he believes there's one at this point. But that that's not in the quote. He said, it's so the quote that was earlier in that same stories that I'm in time for the keys to the precinct. Going to lineage the set and blood is Thor's brother's keeper. See terrible and many others were taken King, Li power and grades of the priesthood this we would have taught in the Temple of Time at permitted. Joseph Smith was entitled to the keys, to the priests required, to blood silly with the port Sun. But when we get another temple built, we will teach you concerning these things. We talked about Lineage 2 set in blood being connected to the fire temple related ordinances. So About he's talking about his blood and Joseph Smith blood. Yeah, and Joseph Smith's blood, he didn't say that. He didn't say anything about a certain race of people that are particularly Kirsten forbidden to receive those ordinances. It is a two years earlier that's the repeat that the Israelites were not to intermarry with the other races. So two years earlier and it was referencing the same ideas about lineage descent and blood.

2:40:26 He's talking about those things. So he's got these ideas and he's in, he repeats them, he's been teaching them. But again, it doesn't matter, it does not go back to it. He says it. He almost pretty much says he does does when he when he first introduced as the priests of ban. Well, very well at the very least. He's suggesting that that this is you haven't heard this before, but trust me, trust me as a reference in the priesthood that you were referencing. The children of the Negroes, being the children of Cain and he said, no, Prophet said it before. I'm telling you it now. And let me know that Joseph Smith said that the Negro came to.

2:41:09 So what he says in that does not You're quoting from the Wilford Woodruff account. I'm, I'm, I'm reading the full, George teapot Pittman, or as he says, Lexi. Is there never was a prophet or Apostle of Jesus Christ was spoken. Before I tell you, this people that are commonly called Negroes, are the children of old Kane. I know they are.

2:41:49 I know they can a rule in the preseason for the curse on them that was remain on them until the rest of the posterity of Michael and his wife received the blessing to see if I would ever see that they had not been had they not been cursed. So that was a Christian man right there. Never was a proper apology. Just before I tell you, this people are commonly called Negroes, are the children of old came. I know they are, I know they cannot bear you on the priests of you. Staying, you knows the Negroes are the charl, okay? Because if there wasn't a proper apostolate, smoke it before. But we know that Joseph Smith said it in his lifetime that they were the children of change, that doesn't negate that That's it. This is the introduction to a sermon where he's presenting many ideas.

2:42:33 Yeah, yeah. But that's a statement to give context to where he's going. Is introducing the subject of what he's introducing as a priest to Bam. Actually, a governmental ban as well, but we know that we know that Charlie Pratt said it in, March 3rd, 1847 in reference to William, McCary, In reference to yeah, in reference to what we may carry. And that's right around the time when which other was supposed to be interesting, I've got the notes here that so, William and Harry, who was Lee.

2:43:16 McCary he was an African American who was joined the church. He was trying to pass himself off as an Indian actually made a career out. I'm going around to different places and pretending to be an Indian. Well not just any though. He was also claiming he was black. Will you read the minutes of the March? 1847 meeting with bringing young? He says that they're calling me and where I came into this world Redman. I'm going to come out right man. Minutes here. I can pull up the same minutes to. March 1847.

2:44:07 And he was complaining my self to you, as my brothers and my leader, I am satisfied by you. And then some places, I am hypocritically abused. The Bishops, have counseled, the people not to suffer such a stranger, has me in their wigwams. Some say there goes the, old n-word and his white wife today. Some of the sisters said that the man that brother Brigham tells his family to treat with disrespect several. All I ask is, will you protect me? I've come here and giving myself out to the your servant. So he's presenting himself saying I'm being persecuted. You can play me a skate, it over my rent and some people are saying that this is being sanctioned by Brigham Young. So bring me on answers says, it's nothing to do with the blood for of one.

2:45:01 Blood has God made All Flesh, we have to repent and regain. What we have lost, we have one of the best Elders, an app for Canon Lowell, a barber and not speaking of Walker Lewis. So Brigham Young's, assuring him that hey, no, no, there's nothing. There's nothing different between us and in terms of blood in regards to race. In fact, we also have an African brother Out in in Lowell. And then William replies, I thought it well to come and Report myself to the heads of the church. If I am a darky, I want to serve God and Brigham Young says amen.

2:45:42 And he goes on, I am very much obliged to meet you in love and gratitude those that are not my friends. I want them to tell me if you have anything in your hearts that you may as well. Tell me he is, I shall know in 48 hours, I want you to intercede for me. I am not a president or a leader of people but a common brother because I am a little shade darker. So again he's saying I want to be able to go back to my friends and say that you know whether you are saying sanctioning this persecution, I'm receiving I want to die when I leave here. I want to be able to say that Brigham Young told me that it's not right for you to to Traverse qme in premium, says, or is there he's asking, is there something in your hearts that, you know, that you did tell me about the situation?

2:46:29 And let's remember to that. Will you make Harry is married to a white woman. And then bringing young says, we do not care about the color. And then the Carrie says, do I hear that from all? I also all the apostles right there, agree with him and let's see who's that. CK, that's Who would that be? Okay. Don't you feel a good spirit here? Brother. William McCarey says yes, thank God. And then conversation with Emily McCarty breaking in others in the 12 Coram meetings in that is 26th of March 1847, winter quarters.

2:47:15 Now we know that would ultimately ended up happening. Was he borrowed money? I gave him a bunch of money to show Goodwill a bunch of money so that he can go out west. Meanwhile, he went around committing adultery with at least one it whatever. I want to hit him with a bunch of the women there and when bring them finds out about it, he's, he is rightfully really, really upset. He was swindled. McCary, is it like a Johnson been a type of the character here and her dinner with this false pretense. The false humility and took advantage and scammed and abused the trust that was given to him but this again is 1847 and winter quarters.

2:47:58 If You would expect that if there was some sort of a, of a priest the band that really needs to be communicated and that he really shouldn't have taken that white wife and frankly, according to pick him up later that year he should have put me Kerry and his wife and any children, he might have had to death. Work for interracial marriage. According to Brigham Young's own teachings later on that year and I think it is highly reasonable to suggest that Brigham Young. Khan's here by the sky and end in it painted. His perspective of race. Cuz right here he's here is breaking down himself saying, you know, it has nothing to do with blood, we're all of one. I've made all flash, one, glad we all have to repent and regain what we lost.

2:48:47 But there's no difference between us other than that and they describe a positive spirit having teach you this. And this is just brotherly, love this outpouring. And then it's literally In April, when you have Harley people Pratt say William Carey was a black man with the blood of Hammond him which lineage was cursed as regards to the priesthood. And that's the party wasn't the first person to mention that we, we understand that William, Applebee, in March of 1847 earlier about in March, actually, reference, the priest of that as well. I don't know that reference Is it in? So some people said, try to. Okay, so it's reference Journal, but he probably this fits more Utah.

2:49:41 Mormon. So this is probably written later. Instead of when you saying you wrote, it is kind of what they try to say, but it it's in his contemporary Journal. It doesn't show up right. And he was actually right writing a letter to bring young around that same time. About Walker Lewis saying, hey, this guy's presiding over this branch. Is it according to the laws of the church burn African to hold the hold office in an elder and show you? How does he claim? He knows this before the destruction copy the book of Abraham Abraham chapter 1 into his journal earlier and not be when you visited Nabu again that book of Abraham doesn't say that black people aren't allowed to help priest unless you interpret it that way.

2:50:26 Just somebody who interpreted it. Breathe. So that's not, that's not a threat. That's not coming from this. I've been coming from Brigham Young. You're just a thought. He had this idea that there ought to be a priest of band before parlee P Pratt taught it to the church. Yeah, and if you think probably be proud with so this is something that the I forgot the name of the historian. But there was a historian who wrote kind of a rebuttal to Lester Bush. When he wrote an alternative you and he said he didn't think the probably be Pratt was introducing. A new doctor would probably be Pratt still Justified to be introducing. A doctrine that was out of step with the other Apostles in 1847 Aces. It seems highly unlikely that you was teaching something that was out of line with what everyone else believed.

2:51:10 And so you know, you bring up the the blame and carry minutes. I do think those are definitely a challenge to the people are on my side of the issue, but the person who made me read look at them and see them in a different light was a historian named Johnny, Johnny Stevenson, or grin. Dale is an online username. He's an anti-mormon. He doesn't have a dog in the fight of the priests than either way because he himself was married to a black in his wife was, his wife is African dust. Is Blaze more of his store and he's is it was a really good historian. I respect a man who didn't have some kind of a dog and some kind of a fight with Joseph Smith and Brigham Young because they're against it either way and I think it's races, right?

2:52:02 And it starts at then it makes Brigham Young look like he's doing something different than Joseph Smith is, it seems the entirety of the restoration. So here's my point, it out about those minutes. So McCary only points out that he was being called the n-word even though he claimed to be a Native American, he said I came in as a red man that want to go out as a redneck. It's a don't least backbiters thinks I have feelings and I wasn't Edward. I got baptized, and I'm thankful for it, but I'd like to be as a n word as an Indian Many think they are one and he was trying to pass himself off as being a little shade darker as being a Native American rather than an African.

2:52:48 But Brigham Young was saying that we're welcoming to all Races that are you think it was nothing to do with what everyone is? Welcome to join our church and he said, we even having a great Elder and Walker Lewis who's a barber and he's one of the best Elders. So, you know, what I do think that's changed cuz I don't have that actually fundamentally changes in. Even if that is true, that doesn't fundamentally change anything that I, that I quoted from these men. Well, I did change the contact for Brigham Young. They're not talking about priest it at all, unless they're just talking about membership in the church and bring him. Young goes so far as to say, you were welcoming you as the Native American, what we welcome, you as an African as well.

2:53:32 It so they were welcoming all Races into the church, but I don't think, I don't think this relationship because only a month on February 16th. Connect to Delaney. It's just that. Bloody just wasn't, absolutely. I absolutely believe. That's what Brian said. He didn't say that the temple ordinances are directly tied to to a priest of any inch. Can I ask a question here real quick? Just for my own clarification on this real quick. Jacob in Brigham, Young kind of at least insinuate strongly that there was a black man that held the priesthood and he was a great Elder.

2:54:15 He says, one of our best Elders in African and Lowell Ave Barber. So I don't think it's possible that Brigham Young all the time because McCary ended up being a scoundrel decided to be racist because she knew the light table was a good guy. He knew Walker Lewis was a good guy, he wasn't crying, and he later on in early. Utah said that there are some black guys worship list, but that there's many white mentorship was too. So I don't think that you could describe Brigham, Young's attitude is William & Carey slept with a bunch of women. So Brigham Young decide to become racist. I don't find that a possible thing is after this though, I mean, Elijah able prior to this has worked his way up to become a 70. He's gone on missions.

2:55:03 He's he's converted p-please. Baptized people. 70s. In the early. There is tons of 70s in the early days of the church. It was just a traveling and I have a story. Actually, Elijah able, the member who is, who is, who is who was baptized Elijah able 1830, the early late 1830s, I understand. So that's that's doesn't have the priests that he was cursed to it, except he can speak at the seventies meeting. He goes on missions. He's, he's, he's baptizing people. He had the priest that it's very clear. He had the priests of those that he was. I think I best.

2:55:45 You could argue that these were men that were permitted as the exceptions is and that's the most, that's the best you can for a John Taylor's Steakhouse at the least at the least, the church. You don't get priest. The green flight was another. We didn't get into anything and you didn't get his hand down his everybody. Not everybody did Mike, my grandfather is real Barlow helped, build that Temple. And and I, when I went through the records his name was not on it. When I went, I went through the entire list of those early endowments and his talking with his name was not on the list.

2:56:32 We I do know from family history, it eventually did receive his endowment and a second anointing, but at that time he didn't and he helped build the temple. You can't just look at one person and say, well, that's a person who is Black. You didn't get the priests. And therefore, they must have been being prohibited. It was being done by Revelation clearly, at least that's what I believe. I believe it was being done by Revelation and if somebody was not given the priesthood prior to that point, it was because the person who is administering a priest that have not received that Revelation, but the very fact that that Elijah Abel was called into the priesthood. And worked his way up and into the priesthood as it into.

2:57:13 This is a 70 shows that either Joseph Smith was letting things go off the rails or whoever was receiving the Revelation for Dan was off the rails. Or there was no problem at that time, it was when he was 18. He was only able was only 18 lakh and like I mentioned I'm Joseph F Smith wasn't a one drop guy and I don't think Brigham Young was either and Joseph Smith, drew, the line at 112th is where is what he drew the line later on. So I wasn't able to receive these blessings because he have the white blood in him.

2:58:05 Then would it not make absolute sense than to pursue the same course that Joseph Smith? Suggested with the Native Americans is to take them as wife's. Let's interbreed so that that so that the, the blood that would allow all of them and their descendants to hold the priesthood can be can be among them and yeah, that's not what, you know. That's the exact opposite Joseph Smith said, hey, here's accursed people. Who'd been cursed and we're going to interview the way. We're going to let that curses. We're going to intermarry with them. You just believe they let her marriage with the Native Americans but with the African she said put them on can find them by strict law to their own species except when he suggested sending the Mexico United States where they could still marry in a merry.

2:58:52 Whatever I said they wanted even declares that they can marry freely mescaline sending the Mexico where that we don't have these issues. That that shows that political necessity, not not a a doctrinal Prohibition. Otherwise don't send a New Mexico. I'll be able to interbreed. There was white people. What why did he find black man for trying to marry white women in 1844? What's up? You find two black men for trying to marry white women. In February 1844. He wrote about in his journal. Was it the law at the time? It was the lava city of nobility find the one black man $5. You find the other one $25 for attempting to do it probably because that was the law. but he wanted to enforce the law and even gave one guy a bigger, find a significant that's a lot more money than today, sir but again is enforcing he's enforcing a city statute that has been set up and he hadn't he can have So we agree that Joseph wasn't really big on intermarried with the African Americans, right?

3:00:08 Yeah. But you're a butt. You're assigning motive to and I'm saying it's not fair to sign and you're signing the motives that it's because you're presuming, he knows of this curse of Canaan. This can't be allowed and I would say if that was the case, then why would he allow them to go to Mexico and the album intermarry there? Which would spread the the curse of this young so you two can among among another one. Exactly. So Again and finding them to their own race. Sending them to Mexico is not confine them to their own race. So the last thing that I feel is pretty compelling to argue that the star was Joseph Smith, is that William Smith, Joseph, Smith's brother, and his magazine. So he separate from the other Apostles in 1851, I mean, in 1845, she's me like less than a year after the next summer. He is done in and tries to take over the church gets excommunicated.

3:01:12 He starts his own church. She tries to join with us is around, but you can try to do his own church in the late 1840s early 1850s. And he interesting Lee reference and some of these Priests of racial ideas in his magazine in 1850. And this is before Brigham. Young's anyting Brigham Young said about it is published in early Utah. And so, and he had separate from the other Apostles 18-49 yet and its newspaper Harold in February, b1850 arguing and hide or any kind of attack to bring it might saying that worse than what we're date a black man to marry white women as a way to attempt to discredit which is William. I don't see any compelling evidence for but in this he references, you know he tries to attack the brink of mites the number of ways and he tries to call Brigham Brigham Young. I like the Joseph Smith.

3:02:21 Told Dave, bring a blessing saying that you was the lineage of came through the lines of him and that quote. Rest in heaven and became devil. So, it's again, referencing. Receiving the curse in the pre-existence. And so, after publishing the first two chapters of the book at Abraham Williams, Including a Q&A with rev asking questions about the doctors talk in it. It's a did Noah curse time as pertains to the priesthood at Searcy. This verse in the book of Abraham, was the lineage of ham cut from the right of the priests, it at Searcy disperse, a group of personal and answers answer, see this until the different purses and Abraham 1:26-27 and so this is another compelling. So do you miss man is a profit.

3:03:21 I'm just I'm saying where is he getting this from? If she just deciding to misinterpret the book of Abraham and coming up with the same idea lying about, is he lying, about a blessing to Brigham Young received argue against the Why would he be trying to do that? If I didn't have any weights, if you knew that, that, if you, if you went down that Joseph Smith, didn't introduce these doctrines. But instead he's arguing for these doctrines, yeah, he's arguing for these friends and he seems to be a pretty bad guy to be exact same things in 1850 that the people in the early Utah, trying to discuss and bring me, I'm starting to become very explicit about because I'll probably be proud was talking about this and 4747 So I mean, you know this is three years later. I don't like a crazy guy if he was around in Winter quarters when they were having those discussions 1845 you don't think you don't think that talk from Brigham Young that says that if you do if you cross this line we're going to kill you and your family wouldn't get around within 3 years. Why would why would William be

3:04:55 trying to just say that they're okay with ordained blacks. If you do that, Brigham Young thing that will kill you. If you do this. he's attacking Brigham Young because cuz he's using Brigham Young's own words against him because he's He's obviously supporting the band himself, which I can I do it goes to and I think it goes a long ways to show that the character of the people that are kind of proclaiming this and we have him lying about Brigham Young. So we had this already is a dishonest person of very questionable repute, somebody like a William law. And he's criticizing Brigham Young because they allowed people like Elijah table and Walker Lewis in their Church, which is a historical fact at this point.

3:05:48 I don't see, I don't see what this has to do, with Joseph Smith teaching, the band at all. I mean you already you already mentioned this other guy who does not claim it came from Joseph Smith had the idea on his own just from Reading Abraham and wrote about it in his journal. Well he said that he was Abraham and he thought that this was you wrote it down as he wasn't trying to be prejudiced against Walker Lewis. He says he was an example for his more white, his wider Brethren to follow. He wasn't trying to be right in that journal. That Joseph Smith caught it. Because he wasn't in the about you as a guy out yeast. I know.

3:06:28 Is that a yes or no? Did did. Did he say that Joseph Smith started? I am saying that you understood it and marches 1847 so I'm and he basically figured it out on his own or did he say he was taught it by Joseph Smith? So Anna and I never said that you said it was started by Joseph Smith. I didn't say that. I said, is that these ideas we're clearly being taught in early 1847 by people who weren't Brigham Young and it wouldn't be the first of all, is not, and I think probably plug specifically is deliberately calling out McKinney McKinney McKinney that the band has started somewhere between 1847 and 18 year old saying that, you know, we're all the same world, you know, God is no respecter of persons, type of language to a man who is presented them self and is complaining about being racially persecuted.

3:07:41 And and then Literally calling for the deaths of people who who violate these things months later that that that's a huge change. My opinion. I think it's if there was only maybe some evidence or some some motive on why that might have happened. Well, actually we even have possible motive because we have make any difference between them of their money and also defiling women and then we have quality prep specifically for the first time ever calling out, specifically McKinney in the context of what he had done, calling him of accursed race in their ends in for the first time in In.

3:08:29 Basically church history. Saying that blacks aren't allowed to hold the priesthood and then shortly after that we have Brigham Young coming out with a statement with fire. And you've already met some of them doesn't even mention the priesthood band, specifically, in December of 1847. He can keep reading more if you want. It's there and that's at least how Wilford Woodruff understood that. Your side could use. And I believe has used the time. We're bringing says, if they will be eunuchs for the Kingdom of Heaven sake, they may have placed in the temple. If you remember that.

3:09:09 So so let me know if I was on your side, I would use that but I see that is referencing. The I already expressed was that you have this guy living out east, who gets a hold of the book of Abraham and on his own comes up with the theory that he writes in his journal about questioning, whether black should hold. The priesthood didn't say it was taught to him by Joseph Smith, he didn't got it from In April of 1847, probably Brigham Young and based off the events that happened with William McKinney cuz that's a mediately after words as when he comes out. And I typically, who is even talking about in the context. He called them out.

3:10:02 So it starts sometime during 1847 my position is I have a lot of statements contained us to 1845 with lineage and blood with some of the your horse and Hyde started. Talking about them being cursed for their actions, in the pre-existence, in 1840 in early of 1845, there was a curse and it's the fact that there is a curse that is undeniably taught and it's really easy to say that. Hey, they're talking about a curse and then reading a priest of been into it. And yet it is not there. And I mean, are you? I mean, would you be willing to violate the priest? The band personally today, what is that something that you would be willing to do?

3:10:46 I believe we're going to watch Brigham Young. It's not supposed to be lifted until the Millennium. So this is important to you. You think this is important to a logical point. I think that what Brigham Young said in the name of Jesus Christ, you was the prophet of God to reveal to the church at wasn't disputed by any of his brother. And when he proclaimed it in 1852 and we have tons of evidence that and went back significantly. Earlier you say we don't have we don't have evidence. We have we have we have what you would call a circumstantial evidence, you have exit eisegetical evidence. You can read that into it because there is a curse discussed but it is clear from the context of any time that Joseph Smith.

3:11:29 Speaking of a curse upon the black race. He's speaking about a curse of slavery. Richard said that the children said that Joseph Smith toddler, the children receive their coming to remember to the Lord for their Final Redemption until the until the Redemption of the earth. So that's Another person who actually did the Joseph Smith who and what we do have is a geology that certainly the Native American people when they become directed beings, that they will receive white bodies. There's a person I know who would serve his mission in Brazil's at that lot of resilience believe that they would receive white bodies in the resurrection.

3:12:18 And so, I mean again, I mean, you're you're putting depriest tube and into these were into Joseph, Smith mouth into these other people free prior to Joe Smith's mouth. It's not there though. It just wanted to put it into Brigham Young's mouth and say hi. If you practiced, you can't because Brigham Young, lots of the teacher in April of 1847, even though we don't actually have any record of Brigham Young introducing it in April of 1847. We just have to keep rats. Eat chicken. Do you think that parley P Pratt in Brigham Young spoke? I think that you're you're you're making a conjecture of Brigham Young introducing. I make it to Jackson and feel the Smith. And my point really is that there are people who recall this went back to Joseph Smith and there's evidence in 1845 that these ideas were floating around to you. This is an issue of significant biological value, correct. So why don't we have a simple clear testimony of this prior to Brigham Young introducing.

3:13:30 The preacher was introduced long before Brigham Young. It was even given to people who had black skin. They continue to serve in the offices of the priesthood throughout their lives. Why is this not Numero Uno? If it's so important. Why is this not the number one priority that needs to be done? Come up a lot? Because there were a whole lot of African members of the church. Brigham Young's governing a church of thousands of members, tens of thousands and he wasn't just some guy that they didn't even know.

3:14:12 He was at a Joseph Smith, Senior his deathbed and didn't receive his endowment. Under Brigham, Young, Joseph Smith, you received the Kirtland endowment, Joseph Smith, let's be honest. Indian and I'm not and I'm not disputing. The debate here is not whether or not Brigham Young instituted, the priesthood band. That's not what we're talking about. Joseph Smith. When Joseph Smith was president of the church. When Joseph Smith was friends with Elijah Abel and his family. There is nothing that was denied, Elijah Abel outside of he wasn't in the Quorum of anointed. If you was his friend, why wasn't he in the in the corner that I wasn't William Clayton?

3:15:06 When playing did eventually get initiated? Yeah, he did. Eventually get initiated and tell them. We've got him. He's at he even knows about it. He's one of the few who even knows about it and isn't in is not a member of it. Why wasn't my great grandpa is so you know there were no Indians in the Quorum of anointed either. And we know that your journal entry by William, Applebee in May 19th 1847. Let this afternoon for a little while when I arrived for 1 hour and a half distance, 25 miles out of church members and terrible gets any Elder and Elder ordained by the church country.

3:15:52 Do to the order of the Church of all the preseason as the descendants of ham or not entitled to that privilege by the name of Walker. Lucy Pierce being meek and humble, man. An example for his wider brother and to follow, so, you know, Another interesting statement from the 1847 time. That he would have gotten it from Brigham Young. Maybelline doesn't say did. He says he didn't say it. Got it from Bill Smith either. He wasn't around like you said, he's out east. Yeah, and so then he wrote a letter to to bring him young later that month saying LOL, I followed I found a colored brother by the name of Lewis and Barbara Ann Church ordain. Some Years Ago by William Smith, this Lewis I was in form and also a son is married to a white girl in both members of the church there now. Dear brother, wish to know if this is the order of God or tolerate in this church, i e Tour de Negros to the priesthood allow amalgamation.

3:16:44 If it is, I desire to know as I've yet. Got to learn it. There we have it right there. So we know that his original entry was speculation. We know that Joseph Smith did not teach this to him cuz he's asking Brigham Young. Hey, I had this idea. Is that right? Yeah. And you know, and are getting the same ideas in April and only a few weeks earlier with Harley, Pratt over William McKay. I'm just saying that they're George Duke Allen. Testimony was significant and not that Joseph under Lorenzo Snow in Joseph Smith and might have actually pushed the rest of that wasn't for George to Cannon saying that you was taught as a boy and novel by John. Taylor is coming from Joseph Smith. So as you know, is a story now that's a that is that is very spurious claim to be making as a as a second hand and he didn't, he's not saying he didn't, he heard it from Joseph Smith? He's saying, John Taylor said that he heard it from Joseph Smith and is it something that he's recalling? It was not written down, this is not in his journal. This is something that he is your calling, from memory, 50 years later, I'm not even 50 years old yet. And I don't remember anything from a cover, let alone a specific Doctrine being taught by somebody who learned it from somebody else.

3:18:14 But I don't think Joseph Smith was easily swayed necessarily though because in 1879. When somebody Coltrane, get just text me, he wanted to say that he tries to Elijah able more than 70 call Tran. That's what it said something about George Duke and his testimony was compelling enough to him. That he felt that, you know, that changed that changes position on it and that led to the band being is doing the church for another 70 plus years. yeah, well, I mean, I think George Duke Cannon had some clear supremacist ideology going on with himself though. Anyways, Beyond even the priests of ban.

3:18:54 But did you know about John? Taylor's editorial in the times and seasons in April 1845, where he talks about the curse of on on ham and Kane and night from John Taylor. Yeah, I probably read it. But again, it's kind of supporting evidence for what Cannon's, cuz it shows that John Taylor was entertaining, these kinds of ideas. Dishonor, the holy priesthood. Know, I woke from his mind and you was younger. Son. Have it done it. And as a priest who descended from father to son he know I delivered the following first and blessings as translated by King James Wiseman recorded in Genesis he reads from Genesis 9 history and common observation show that these predictions have been fulfilled to the letter the descendants of ham inside the black skin which has ever been a curse. Those following apostate and the only person as well as a black heart have been serviceable Shem and japheth and the abolitionists are trying to make Boy The Curse Of God, but it will require more power than man possesses to counteract the decrees of Eternal wisdom.

3:20:03 Three references, as being cursed, the black skin is a curse that was followed an apostate of the Holy priest it. So it's it's supportive of cannons recollection is that makes sense? Except it doesn't refer. It doesn't reference Joseph Smith is the person who taught it. That's true. But for some reason you have all these Apostles after Joseph Smith death, start teaching these kinds of ideas. And either way, I think did have inclinations, this was a different America. This was not in America is not 2000 and and whatever. What year is a 23 where where slavery has been abolished for over fifty years and boujee where we actually. So we're probably pushing a hundred years now and you know, there's a there's a civil rights movement and that's not the world that they were living in.

3:20:56 There was already a natural inclination towards racism. At that time over will wear, what we would call racism into then at the time it was very natural. And and so I don't think it's not surprising but speaking of George Buchanan in 1857. He he he he taught run is when Western standard 22 first 22 license to marry, should not come from the priest. But from the physician It will be when the law forbids, the unhealthy to beget children. When it compels every healthy man to marry. When a refusal to do this will do bar him from holding office from voting from suing at courts of law for making contract from following any learned profession, when it's tough with no healthy girl to remain single after she becomes a proper age when no horse will be permitted to live.

3:21:49 When Alyssa intercourse will be punished with death, what we shall witness in that we shall witness any Improvement in the morals of the age. It is true such a curse, such a course would come in contact with the ridiculous, ridiculous, sentimentality of the age and heaven knows it. If it could be overturned and routed doubt it would be a substantial blessing. I mean this is full on Eugenics thinking right here this idea they said that polygamy was introduced to be a benefit for the duration of the race. Yeah, so we we can see that there is what we today can easily identify as a, a very severe bias.

3:22:30 And so no believing in Eugenics means he's going to lie about the weather is my makeup of these will have blatantly lie and say that John Taylor taught him. Something is coming from Joseph Smith, when she didn't actually come from this idea of only healthy, men should marry and that they should live polygamy was kind of in the I think it's in that same article. He says that these ideas came from Joseph Smith and allies are snow talked about pulling me being a renovation of the race also. So license to marry should not come to from the priesthood from the position. I'm it mean to upset you a bit more than what the other people are.

3:23:13 The Utah said, but a little. Are you kidding me for the Roxy Pro? You Janice. This is this is what I'm trying to say here, right? This isn't exactly. This is a different time and a different place where people had a different perspective of that, some of these values than we do. And we know that there was a, it is a natural inclination towards other than people that are different. Especially if there is a curse upon them, that makes them different from other people. That makes them look different that maybe even has a behavioral aspect. We can certainly see that there's problems today and I would say it is a curse, not of any kind of God directed curse, but just a cursive fatherlessness and it does primarily seem to a flat afflict specific races. And that's tragic but it is the the solution is at 2 to build a wall around these people.

3:24:14 It's too, is to lift them up, is to bring them in. All the ideas of eugenics, where the idea of trying to have a healthier race isn't necessarily a bad thing, it's a bad thing. If you're tying it to, we should kill off the people that are the inferior races. That's, that's when it goes in a bad Direction. Wanting to have people be healthier. I think everyone wants a more healthy population and like it has played at is that what you take you with Georgiana Court. I take issue with this that in order to have permission to marry, you got it have a physician's that was common in most of America for up until probably 50 years ago. Kind of a medical examination by a doctor to this part of getting your marriage license.

3:25:03 Pretty sure that was pretty common historically in America, that you'd be forbidden to marry without a physician. Without a physician's exam. Taya. I'll have to say I don't know if I can trust you on that one cuz I'm not telling every July 4th January, so we can trust him on this. This is to say that there is a attitude about things at the time that was is a lot more backwards. Then we met that we can understand today but there's something wrong with this.

3:25:50 This idea of taking women who are as soon as there are of marriageable age and coercing them into a marriage. Weed that, that is not. We know that that that is wrong. You think that dress you Cannon was forcing women into marriages? He was advocating for it. I must have missed that part of you that was part of the quote, but I'm pretty sure that you might be when it says, when It suffers no healthy girl to remain single, after she'd become the proper age to having crazy just said, where we are basically rent at two worst people into marriage and when they are, if they are for the men, if they qualify And for the women as soon as they come of age we're not going to allow them to stay single and we're going to kill anybody who who becomes a prostitute and playing.

3:26:46 I guess, implying that anyone who doesn't marry is going to become a prostitute. Did you know that? That was the other place said that word? I mean, I might not agree with that, that for our time but you know, who's to say? But again, the point here is that George Buchanan, had some interesting ideas on things, I think that. Yeah, these ideas can taint our perspectives and our memories that they can lead us into into the same things and two Presuming things that aren't necessarily true because our minds become darkened when we don't meet up, with the principle of agency, is being proposed to be violated here in an incredibly violent manner.

3:27:40 I really think that, you know, I think you might be taking a little bit more Liberty with that. Quote, if you don't see George Duke Cannon advocating, Opposition to free agency in marriage and other places. I think that you're probably being not very generous with them, it with this quote-unquote because we all know the temple. And you know what the hell means you. You know, that that the marriage of determining the temple is by your own free agency, in in, in in, in here says, it's compel. Do you know what that mean? In fact, he wanted something from McDonald's when he's a young guy on a mission in the 1850s to argue that we should trust his memory in the 1890s.

3:28:37 50 years later, I don't trust my memory going back, 30 years ago. I trust my memory on certain things. I don't trust my memory on other things, most people don't. It's very easy, you know? You think that all of your memories from your childhood are untrustworthy or You know. And give you are some things that you are pretty solid about in your memory. Yeah, there's a few things I'm very solid about and again not a single. One of them is a sermon by a brother in the in the church. Espousing a specific Doctrine and knowing that. That's where I learned it. Not a single, not a single one, nothing of that caliber. What I do have is memories of when I was on my mission reading the book of Mormon and learning some of these doctrines for the first time and I could have sworn later on that. I had learned something on a mission and I went back and looked at it and I didn't it was something that came to me, many, many years later and in my memory, some reason I just threw it back as that's that's something I learned back on my mission.

3:29:50 And again I'm not even that old. I think it's entirely possible to to confuse your memory. I think it's entirely possible to have a bias toward something that I think it's possible to have a good memory even fifty years later. When you look at some of the things that Benjamin F Johnson recalled about Nauvoo and Joseph Smith in his 1903, free gift letter is fairly extreme Lee Acura at some of the things that he is recalling. Everything going down with it with this priesthood band. Why didn't why didn't bring him young say? Joseph Smith taught this. Why didn't John Taylor say Joseph Smith taught this?

3:30:32 Tenant, says that John Taylor said it, but he says he's. Why didn't John Taylor say it doesn't? This is a second hand, when that's why don't we have a firsthand witness that? Why don't we have? Remember John Taylor saying that you thought they heard it from Joseph Smith and we don't have a firsthand witness of what they said regarding you know what should we do with Walker Lewis or Elijah table because there aren't perfect records. We don't have a perfect history. We are at, we have to come. Look at the historical data, we have Friday, take a holistic approach to it and, you know, it and look at the totality of the evidence and I absolutely agree but that the holistic approach requires reading into the past, we don't have no, yes, the store next to read it. But my perspective is also a way and it leads to that there. I don't think that Brigham Young all the Sunnyside, be racist 1947.

3:31:22 I think that these things were going on that. These ideas were being talked about shortly. After Joseph, Smith's dad. And those people to testify that they went back to Joseph Smith and his idea Why don't they go back to Elijah able? Why don't we have it? If you have some circumstantial evidence to pull it back to those places. But we don't have any actual either testimony from first-hand Witnesses, which should have been many. And we don't have any first-hand statements from Joseph Smith. Implying that this was ever a doctrine that he ever intended it. And we do have from Joseph Smith from from the scriptures alone is this context of that. The whole point of the whole point of the Gospel is to receive Redemption through Jesus Christ. The fullness of the Gospel is to be grafted into Abraham's family to be a taker of those blessings with him as it is adopted into his family.

3:32:20 And if we as Gentiles can be adopted into his family, I don't see why why? Well, somebody who's black, who is also a chicken simply a gentile Graham can't be adopted into Abraham's family. In fact that really is the whole point. So you know, everybody's always going to find on first Abraham. And in second Abraham, it is actually declares what these blessings are. And it says that I will make a via great nation. Dolor de Abraham, I will make a v, a great nation and I will bless thee above measure, and make thy name, great among all nations, and thou shalt be a blessing unto thy seed after the that in their hands. They shall bear this ministry and priesthood unto all nations. And I will bless them truth.

3:33:18 I name for as many receive, this gospel shall be called after thy name and shall be accounted by seed. Intro rise up and bless the as their father. I don't believe there are Canaanites in Zion just like I don't believe there's any fights or lamanites in Zion. I don't believe there are Jews in Zion. Everybody is grafted in. And into the abrahamic, Covenant and Abraham becomes their father. And I will bless them that bless thee and Kirsten that First Tee. And indeed, that is why priesthood and ends in NYC is that is buy priesthood. So is also being very clear.

3:34:02 He's talking about priesthood, hear. These people that all the people are of the Earth are going to be blessed with these things. For I give unto thee, a promise, that this right, shall continue in the, and then Vice eat after the That is to say the literal Cedar, the seat of my body show, all the families of the earth, be blessed, even with the blessings of the Gospel which are the blessings of Salvation. Even of life. Eternal Justin real quick. What that was in the end and Abraham chapter 2. What verses were those? Yeah. Starting in verse 9 and Nations. I think that's a good point but when you look what one thing that I think is interesting to consider is, you know, that there's a prophecy that japheth and Shadow Wood Wood intermix. According to you, that you have, that was at that jeep is worth while in the tents of Shem or drawing the tents of Jacob. But when she from is getting blessed in Genesis 48, when Jacob is blessing.

3:35:12 The sons of Joseph, it says his seed shall become A multitude of Nations and so, a different translation of that if you're going back to the literal Hebrew, his seed shall become a fullness of the Gentiles. So a lot of those references to Nations and Gentiles could be the fact that Ephraim mixed with these. You know, Gentile nations of the world with, you know, any information about glad we know that's Europe and we know that they mentioned mix. And that is for Hannah. Covenant says, all the nations of the run, this is Abraham, this isn't the Bible, this is Abraham, this is Joseph Smith's translation.

3:35:59 Not multitude of the Nations. But the Joseph Smith has not translated as Gentile. Well, I'm saying those words to be interchangeable and they can be in the Hebrew. And Joseph Smith was the one who translated this and he says Nation all nations of unto all nations unto all nations again and again and again and again and anybody that his literal seed can bring into the fold become adopted in and basically become joint Heirs of all the abrahamic blessings, which we know are of Salvation are the blessings of the Gospel of the Salvation And even life eternal. So the last scripture that I would use to kind of go back to give you some push back on this.

3:36:51 Let me know real quick. So So Matthew 15 verses 21 through 28. So behold as well as the part of the coast of Tire inside and behold a woman of Cannon came out of the same coast and cried on Tuesday, have mercy on me. Oh Lord, that's been a day with my daughter is grievously back to the devil. Thought he Jesus answered her. Not a word as disciples came and be thought of as they send her away before she cries after us. But you answered said, I am not set button to the lost sheep of the House of Israel.

3:37:33 Then came she and worshiped him saying, Lord help me the answer and said it is not meet to take the children's bread and to cast it to dogs and she said fruit. Ward, yet the dogs eat of the crumbs which fall from their master's table, the Jesus at the center old woman. Great is thy faith. Be under the email that will end her daughter was made from that very hour. So Jesus is there saying that the full blessings are for The Israelites. But now I see that as an analogy that you know, the full blessings are only to The Chosen lineage. And those that are adopted by that, she even as a cane, I can receive some of the blessings of the Gospel can receive the the blessings of salvation, but she can't receive the authority of the priesthood and the ordinances of Jacob.

3:38:22 I think you just proved my point actually because what we have here is Christ saying he is sent to minister unto the house of Israel. That's what he says sent to minister. Is it again that says we're not even talking about priest it here but that is who you sent to his Moore Ministry. What does Jesus do after he dies? Have you heard of the death of the day of Pentecost after the resurrection? I didn't write about the Great Commission, the Great Commission to take his gospel to again all nations. Yeah, it is real rejected him that was taken to the elevations, but he was not wanting to know a lot of people would call Jesus Christ. You're basically saying I'm only sent to the specific group of people right now, though, but but, but I can still receive the crumbs from the table and he said, because of your fate, you are more faith than most of these Israelites. I'm glad your daughter is going to be here for this very hour, you know.

3:39:32 So I definitely see you lying to his very clear there, is that the bread that's being referred to though is Christ. Ministry is not called to minister and do Miracles and to do healings among the canine people, that's what he's talking about. However, even if he's talking about something beyond that, if he means priesthood, Then. She argues that, don't we receive the crumbs of that priest. Attend. The thing is Christ. Blessed her anyways, even though she was not and she was a Canaanite, Canaanite to send you still did receive the blessings. So Washington faces and say she receive the priesthood. Can I talk here for just a second? And Justin, I really want to get get get Jacobs response to this because This this really seems to spell it out and end it and I'm not sure how to get around this. I'm willing to be wrong here but mine is he again? It says you know, he's going to make him a great nation. He's going to bless them above measure when it gets real specific in 9 and died named.

3:40:49 Great among all nations, and thou shalt be a blessing unto thy seed. After the That in their hands, meaning Abraham's seed, they shall bear the ministry and the priesthood until all the nations and then intend, he goes on to explain who that seed is. And I will bless them through thy name. For as many as received, this gospel shall be called after thy name, and she'll be accounted died seed, and she'll rise up and bless the as their father. Doesn't that way out? Kind of the terms of becoming Abraham seed in 10 and then, and 9, it tells what their responsibilities are is if they are his seed, which is to Bear the priesthood and be ministers. So again, I think it all comes down to it, bursts 9, where it if you're interpreting All Nations, you know? And that, that and your return.

3:41:51 And it says that as many as poppy in 10, for as many as received, this gospel shall be called after 9 a.m. and she'll be accounted. I see. It makes no mention of Nations, it seems to be a very individual commission. Am I right? Or am I wrong? How am I misinterpreting that? I'm not missing. I'm not saying I'm just saying that. I think it's very myopic to be trying to use Abraham chapter 2 verses 9, through 9, through 11 to argue against the plane reading of Abraham 1:21 through 27, right? In again I'm just curious how it all fits together. I'm not I'm trying to make sense of that, they're open to the gospel.

3:42:37 I I think that so this is kind of what I want. Jacob finished. Justin I want I want to go back to this as many as receive it will be counted his seat cuz 9 it says what that means to be his seed, which is to Bear the priesthood and be ministers. Well, I don't think that this is like trying to use the, so some people try to use Abraham and Hagar the Egyptian saying that, oh, she submitted.

3:43:21 So therefore, the priests of that isn't legit because he's allegedly marrying, a Dominican woman, but then he goes and forbids. His the servant from selecting a wife, from his son about Canaanite lineage. And I don't think that I don't believe in as a schizophrenic God. I think that Hagar wasn't trying to use one verse argue against the plane reading of another verse Harmonize all the verses. I said I hate you can. I've already harmonize them if you read Abraham one. As I explained what you admit. It is a possible way to interpret that. Then I think you're having to drive me to downplay Abraham, 1:21 through 24, to interpret 25 and 26 of the nation. You're the, you're at home.

3:44:17 What the curse on in the land was on the, who had the blood of the cainites? What was the curse? It doesn't say, does it first on the list and probably a curse on the land. No, they looked up the blood of the Canaanites. I I don't know what you're talk, but what are you referring to? Are you talking about multi the blood of the Canaanites was preserved in the land. So what is the point of the preserving the blood of the Canaanites in the land? If you're thinking 25 and 26 is something completely different? I don't I don't think I don't think it it was preserved. This is a mystery.

3:45:11 What, what do you mean? Why do you think they're concerned about that? And they said the curse that's from handspring, the race, which preserved the curse in the land. What curse was the blood of the Canaanites? And on the children of ham in general? Because that saying that is. Why didn't Moses it described in Moses 6? And it basically says that their land will be Barren, they will have a Blackness come upon them, and the land will not give up. Its fruit, it'll be, they will not Prosper. That is the, the curse of the Canaanites is given in Moses 6, very clearly.

3:45:51 And you do agree with Moses 7:20 to wear a neck saw that the sons of Adam, and they were a mixture of. All the seed is Adam, save it where the seat of a YouTube camera black and had not placed among them as they were being persecuted in and separated. Yeah, there was a highly appropriate in that context because I mean they did just commit genocide and this is not this is not a thousand years later after that. So you think the blood of the word preserved in Grand Chute on 21 through 25.

3:46:33 So what do you think that that segregation was still applicable in a brown? One, 21 to 25. That segregation in Moses 7 on McCain. In the segregation ended. When Wenham took egypt-us wife, right? No. Did it did actually end well did he marry him? Did he marry a Canaanite or not? What was preserving but the crush is explain why that happened. So that doesn't say that they can't intermix. That's the comes to chapter later where it says that they didn't. We don't know why it isn't it Bad to Cursed. Didn't say anything about them being not allowed to to intermarry with the other races of Adam. I think they just chose not to because I mean I mean like you wouldn't want to go in and probably marry, you know, it's a German woman during during World War II Yeah, but why you say there's this emphasis on the blood and the race. It's not just mentioning the culture of the canines as mentioned in the blood of the canines being preserved. There was a Darkness That Came Upon them right? The darkness upon their skin and it doesn't just mentioned that mentions their children which implies a genetic cursing of Darkness upon upon their skins.

3:47:59 So, like I said, I see you and I agreed that Abraham one is a continuation of the revelations in the book of Moses, where we disagree, as you think that verses 26 and 27 are disconnected from verses 21 through 25. I think they're very specific and they explain an important aspect of a priesthood and how it works and it is done there later on. It's clarified and Abraham to That ain't worth it. Go I'm just lost it. That true they bribe. And so we're even if they're even if there was a curse. I appreciated it is.

3:48:46 You are as you propose. It becomes very clear with Abraham that if there was such a curse clearly with the with the creation of the abrahamic, Covenant. And I know that's just a chapter later, but this is, you know, the timeline here is issued because right before that, we're talking about Abraham in the land of her and Potiphar's till and we know that the abrahamic Covenant came after the trial of sacrificing Isaac. So this is not to enter mixed with them was preserved After the flood. Well, that wasn't part of the curse and I think he probably was, I think it probably was preserved though.

3:49:31 But why? Again, the whole nature of curses, what is the nature of a curse? Is it that God wants bad things upon those people or is a curse God, declaring that the consequences of their fathers are going to lead to bad things upon those people. The Book of Mormon example, again, as I mentioned, really is very clear. That it was the descendants of Lena. And lamia, we're not cursed because God didn't want them to receive the fullness. They were cursed because of what their fathers agency did prevented them from being able to receive the things that God wanted them to be able to receive Yeah and you know you're reading Abraham too but I go on to Genesis where Abraham, Jacob, Isaac and Jacob, I am way more comfortable calling into question. Abraham one where we're getting some side commentary about Egypt.

3:50:22 Then I am about questioning. The literal words of the abrahamic Covenant, one of those is actually primary Central Foundation to my understanding of the gospel and how it ties from from Abraham to Christ. And that we can become a takers of the blessings of the fullness of the Gospel. That that is all predicated on that abrahamic, blessing, right there. And it is very explicit in its language. And the Very fact that there was that the idea of race was described in the chapter, right above it but is not continued. In the abrahamic. Covenant, it is. It's as clear as day.

3:51:03 It's absolutely as clear as day. One verse of scripture to argue against another scripture, but I seen that you called the question. Abraham? Chapter 1, your question, your interpretation. Cuz your interpretation of Abraham when is incompatible with the abrahamic, Covenant, my interpretation of Abraham one is not. So, what's your big on? Where was the dust at the Lord Revelation? It's doing the band was Joseph Smith. Where is it with Brigham Young? Where's the dust at the ward? Where is the explicit. Stay at the Lord saying that the, that the children of Tainted. Where'd you come into the Covenant and super be partakers of the priesthood and all the blessings and ordinances of the priests? And I don't see a single lesson 8, the Lord anyting explicit in the Old Testament in the pearl of great price in the New Testament to argue that you have to infer it based off of what you want to believe.

3:51:58 You're not seeing You're not answering his birth at all people. I have to infer that all people mean, all people, but all nations means All Nations that in your saying, that's an incorrect interpretation. I should be looking at this and it should have the correct interpretation is All Nations except Africa, all people except that race every where in scripture, every where is great condition with lifting it. But Jesus said, you have something that's implicit and Matthew 15. That's still saying I'm still there, still not getting the full blessings is what's implicit in the story, right woman interacting with Jesus again it goes back to what again, it really goes back to your concept of what a cursed thing is. I don't believe any races are cursed because that's God's desire for them.

3:52:51 I don't believe any people at any time or cursed because that's God's desire for them. They are when when, when a cursing is pronounced, it is a prophetic. A prophetic announcement of the consequences agree with Alma 13 3 through 5, teaching that summer barred from holding the priesthood because of their actions Mercury systems. I believe, well, It really is more focused on that those who do receive the priesthood had been for a Dane to that priest it, right? The corollary is that, yeah, some people aren't intended to and I and I think I sadly, that that is true. I think sadly, that is true.

3:53:36 It isn't true because that's how how, our god father, Adam desires his children to be. It's just a natural consequence of the fact that not everybody is going to even accept the gospel. But to dictate it by race to curse a specific race. When the whole Bible is about a specific race from beginning to end, it is and the purpose of that shows and lineage is to share the fullness with everybody as Abraham is abrahamic covenant. Declares. So that you it is about a chosen race, a chosen ways with a burden to lift the rest of their Nations up to bring them into the family and into the fold.

3:54:26 You say, Abraham's you into the section, the doctrine covenants, if he was 6 section, 3 it into, I'm not reading what you're saying that they say. And what nations means, what do you think that you think that means that all nations is tepid, the literal reading of all Nations is only some Nations. I don't think, I don't think that Abraham, two can be used to argue against Abraham chapter one because it's explicitly. Destroys your interpretation of Abraham 10 because you will read it. I don't know what it was.

3:55:09 I don't think God really wants to curse them. That is what your position is. Now my position is Abraham to is explicit that the blind ones explicit do and is not exposed to it. And you even can see that. That to me earlier, you admit her, I said that you had a dividing, the verses from being unrelated. No, they are related. It's were talking about Ferrell and and how he came to be and and why he's there, and what happens to him and the blessings that he didn't receive at that. So you're at your big on where's the best day of the Lord is between the bad words, with us at the word to Joseph Smith saying, to let the bat, like we're going to go either way, where's the best day of the Lord that blue-eyed people are allowed to receive their endowment?

3:56:06 Guess I guess they're going to be forbidden. Well, I'm just saying we need to do something. Then the Lord he said, tell us, we're being forbidden to do something. If so, why do you think God decided to reveal to us about not just painting. So you can say, when you read Jesse's night, it's only Canaan. That's being course, there's nothing about the other children have been cursed in a brown one, it's revealed very explicitly. The Joseph Smith to all the children of the through, have that string the race that preserve the curse of the lad. So your why do you think that was revealed to Joseph Smith?

3:56:47 If it isn't relevant to today? I'm not saying it's not relevant. And you're mixing the keenans. The curse to him son, Keenan is separate from the curb to the Canaanites. In Abraham one, we are referring to the Canaanite, the priests alluvion Canaanite people who were cursed and have preserved that yes, that. Chris was preserved through hands actions. What, why do you think the Lord thought it was important for us to know that? I don't think it was, this wasn't written for Joseph Smith. This was written. This is this is the, this is what Moses.

3:57:28 These are the writings of Moses that weird that were being translated by Joseph Smith translated in Abraham really applicable anymore. I'm not saying it's not applicable anymore. So how is it, how is it felt like a ball? I looked it up. I look at the world and I see people of different skin color and I see certain behavioral aspects and even physical physiological differences. And it's clear that the curse as described. In in scripture, not what's gets added to in in, in, in, in in. Oh, I said that if we inserted another band but the other the rest of these gross things, I believe they are real. And I believe they have consequence. And the shades of the skin existed today, Why do you think it was important?

3:58:35 So you think it was just a coincidence. It's telling us about this curse that was preserved through the blood. And then immediately afterwards talks about Pharaoh, not having, you know, he was cursed pertain the priests of not having the right of person. You think it's just a coincidence and your coven and insignificant, that's fine. But you can't argue that it is exactly as it says I'm not allowed to take it exactly as it says. because in a previous verse in commentary about Pharaoh, if possible to interpret it in a way, That negates the abrahamic curse. I'd say it's the other way around, if anything. I think the abrahamic Covenant would negate any kind of curse and ultimately, I think that is what it will do. The that cursing isn't a Prohibition of creature. That's a good two cursing.

3:59:45 Of a darkened skin of not truthful of not of your work and economy, not a and if we look around today and we look at the situations, we find a race with that kind of dark and skin, but compared to the rest of this country are not doing so hot. And I don't believe that again is because God doesn't want them to be doing. Well, I think it's because of a curse. Not across that. God places upon them. But a curse that their fathers that those before them created through their own actions and agencies that God was prohibited from interfering with that.

4:00:27 Then create generations and generations of the abuse and neglect that go in repeating Cycles. Descendants of Cain. Again I wouldn't say that not like I would say that. Well I mean there were specific consequences to King's actions. If you would if we want to call that a curse, we can call that a curse. And I believe that some of the cursed things affect our multi-generational. But again, that's not because God wants those that the generations after them to have those bad things. That's a consequence is the consequence of sin is death. So, why do you think he wanted the race to preserve the cursing allowed to continue After the flood? Why do you think.

4:01:27 If it wasn't what God did? If it's what they did to themselves? Why would God want that to be preserved After the flood? Where does God command him to marry Justice? Well it's it seems to be important that the white of the Canaanites was preserved in the land. It's important to make note of that. I don't seek out to Manning him to take Egypt us so that he's under a curse was preserved through the blood. No, I don't. I should have just let the race be wiped out with the blood.

4:02:09 I think ham made a mistake. I think you made me any mistakes in his life, one of those mistakes. Was taking to wife a woman who was not up to the standards, probably, because of a curse, not because God hated her, but because that's how she was taught. That's how she was raised. That's who her parents were. And that that pretended, it produces. There was even the physiological aspects of it that all carry down. Not because of God's will, but because of man's Rebellion. I don't believe anybody is cursed because God wants them. Cursed, cursed things are always the consequence of man's rebellion and it's never got the desire to see that those curses continue.

4:02:59 And anytime of those purses have continued lot, just like, in the Book of Mormon on the name of the money on Brookhurst, we've got any fight even though you even before they were cursed Nephi, find out, they're going to be cursed and he is pleading with the Lord that they can be reclaimed that, their descendants can be reclaimed. And all the props to the Book of Mormon are intensely focused. On teaching the gospel to their people and then also to lift the curse on the Rev. And we even have some missionaries to actually go out and accomplish it. And Christ accomplish, is it for a Time? But again, God doesn't want those people in Garden. Want the lamanites live in squalor murdering each other, doing all that stuff but that's what they were taught. That's what that's the culture.

4:03:50 Those are the things that their fathers left them. And as soon as there were men with enough inspiration and testimony and desire to sacrifice and serve on their behalf. They went to them and were able to reclaim them and remove the curse. Definitely an interesting perspective. Okay, Dave, how are you doing? It's been a marked man. I'm I'm doing. All right. I was going to say, let's I feel like we got that one. We could have got all night, I feel like but I want it. I want to push back here on Justin just for a second since I seem to open up a can of worms with Abraham to after Justin read it, but I wanted I want to go into something here.

4:04:42 A question I have about Brigham Young and Joseph. I want to go back to where it instituted and then after that I want to get our our final statements and wrap up cuz I feel like we've managed to cover just about everything we set out to cover. A kind of wandered around but I feel like we got there and then if if you guys don't feel that way then then we'll talk here before we we do our wrap-up. Thanks but I think you did a really great job, I found two guys who were extremely intelligent way smarter than I am and I let you to debate. And I got to say, It.

4:05:25 It's 8:00. Intense a little bit, but you guys have done great holding it together, so good on both of you. There was a couple of times I was like, oh well we're going to have to, you know, all get together and hug this out. But I think I think I've been buying large we've done. Well, okay, I want to talk about Joseph and bring him here for a second cuz the one thing I'll say and the reason I bring this up as this seems to be a nap, if, if this is Brigham's invention, it seems to be kind of an aberration, right? Cuz for the most part, Brigham sticks really close to with what Joseph Smith talk, right? If you go to Adam God, you have Elijah are snow that backs up, you know hey Joseph top this before Brigham did.

4:06:11 So address how it is. Then that then on this one issue, he goes Rogue. So to speak away from Joseph Smith. Does that make sense? well, and It just seems out of character for who Brigham was. Well sure, but I mean, I think it seems out of character for, for Joseph, Smith's to, to receive a false Revelation and and go to Canada, looking to sell the rights of the Book of Mormon. I mean, I guess again, these are, these are mortal men. They are ultimately, I don't think they're really that different from me. And you we like to think that they are but I don't really think they're that different. They just have that a Divine mandate which creates a burden in an expectation.

4:07:01 And for the most part I think that they live up to it it exemplary exemplary well Brigham Young Joseph Smith, I even John Taylor. I mean I mean there's a quote of John Taylor I think I think it was John Taylor talking about people on the moon. These are these are just men and when the spirit is upon them and they are preaching by the spirit of God, and that testimony comes into your heart. You can know where we expect to do. Do those things again. Joseph Smith. taught us that well, he was concerned China. somewhere, I've got some notes, but I'm not very good at organizing these things, but it did Joseph Smith was concerned that the The people were relying upon him too much, they were not seeking their own testimonies and in that state, their minds would become dark and they would be so to speak cursed. And Brigham Young also expresses dire concern about the people following, even him blindly and just accepting everything that he says, and being led astray by that. These and I understand why they would say that. Because if they had, I can't imagine the burden and responsibility that God put upon their shoulders, they had a lot of things to do.

4:08:32 A lot of important things to do, Brigham Young pretty much built the West. And that sending out the other the colonies and establishing all that, the track West was miraculous. And was highly blessed of the Lord, but that there was so much he's got the burden of not even just the, he was also the Governor at the time. So he's got all these responsibilities. All this weight. Well, he was governor in Utah, right, buttock. We so he's got a lot of responsibilities and and it's also I know of myself that once you start Sometimes when you start going down the wrong track, it can be really hard to to back out of it.

4:09:16 You can you can get to a point where you can, So to speak. Deceive yourself on his shoes and and get an I've been there before. I mean, they're there was probably a good three years of my life that I struggled with a very specific issue that I was thought I was inspired in on it when I wasn't and I, I've been there kicking against the Pricks in that regard. But again it's not I don't believe that that that Brigham Young was This wasn't the central issue. This is not the primary topic of every sermon that he ever taught it can.

4:10:02 It can seem that way when you read them because they are so in your face and it would see him a lot because the anti Mormons love to to share this stuff to shock, and awe away, people's testimonies. But I think it's absolutely. It's from within my theology from how I understand the gospel. From what I understand, the calling of an apostle and a prophet to be we can we can receive our own Revelation and you know, this is a debate, so I really don't intend to go there, but ultimately that is I am my opinion that is the ultimate answer.

4:10:44 I think took to this question and so yeah, it does that answer your question? I think so. I think so, you just think that he got off track on this one thing and kind of took too far. And I also would say as Jacob mentioned, this isn't that big of a deal. It's not like to her a lot of people out there not like you, you have a congregation that are, you know, 25% black with it, with all of them, you know? If you, I mean appealing and saying, hey, we want, we want this. We want this constantly. I mean, it wasn't an issue. That would be brought up necessarily all that often. We just at the instigation of Elijah Abel Desiring, the temple blessings Manning, requesting her feeling that she thinks you're saying, this was a major thing, you know any controversial subject Early Utah, more minutes because they they just love touching all the controversial and right.

4:11:48 We read the Journal of discourses regularly as a family. We read through different portions of the sermon. Tried to do that as frequently as we can and I and when I have friends visiting I lost and say, hey, we're still going to do this. If you want to sit down for 30 minutes and listen, listen to us through our reading and I have a very Progressive prognyl, I guess you would say friend use, you know, he's interested in Saved by the bell's. The body doesn't accept any of the, the fundamentalist beliefs and his interest in her anymore, and he's like, oh boy, what a my Bluetooth out of his eyes. Jacob. And it was just kind of like a very straightforward sermon on the simple gospel, truth, and helping others. And, and, you know, teaching the principal, the gospels is very rudimentary stuff that break them tall. And and he's like, you know, that was a really great sermon and he's like that wasn't one of the problematic one. Percent of of more than 90 per-cent of Brigham Young sermons.

4:12:51 It's just teaching simple gospel screws and it isn't the controversial stuff. I like, you know, I'll find the one or two out of God sermons in each volume of the Journal of discourses, you know about Jacob. Why don't you give us your closing statement? However, you want to put it and then we'll go to Justin and we'll wrap this bad boy up put a bow on her. So yeah just to kind of summarize. I I do think that we need to take the words of the prophets in the words of the scripture seriously and a holistic matter and I I do think this is a doctrine of of racial hatred.

4:13:34 I think that can be misconstrued I said this Doctrine was just recognizing a different people are in different places in their progression and Brigham Young said that if they live righteously they will get all the blessings they live where before eventually so I Was never about they're fundamentally worthless people. It was never anything. Like they are eternally inferior. That was not Brigham Young's teaching in anyway. And I would just like, to just comment on, you know, then bring him young said that his inspired sermons for scripture. He said, you never saw a man that was called again, Apostle you never heard or been calling his teachings.

4:14:14 Are the words of Life, the keys of life and salvation for the people to whom he spoke our life to all those who believe in, strictly obey them, but they're rejected their death. So much for those who say that Brigham is not a prophet that he'd heard, Daniel are not profit by my name scores of others demanded by their priests are called the, apostleship the words of eternal life throws at them like a river. It's the words of life. If the words of Life flowed through, then they do not live up to the Privileges that is equally true. Now to you that feel as though there have to be a great deal of preaching and new revelation Revelation I would recommend the drill discourses brother George C. W is reported my disc The others and set them to England and have them printed which cannot be obtained here in volume, take them and read them. If you can search the volumes of Eternity, the volumes of heaven and see if my teachings do not agree in principle of Truth.

4:14:59 With the words, all the words, if they do, they're the words of life and salvation to all, who believe. And every man who reject my words, rejects life and salvation to his own soul. So that's just reiterating. What's in section 67 to Firebirds of profit are, as good as scripture regardless of whether it's written in a prior scripture or not. And so the other statement and hide when they are debating atom got worse and Pratt in the eight in 1860 in the Quorum of The Twelve. His reasoning in defense of Adam God and he said they're supposed to or seems to acknowledge God and that there is a presiding power as you admit that you can advance incorrect Doctrine is to lay the acts of the root of the tree and then he goes on.

4:15:45 It says will brother. They are in the price of a horse or a house in lock button. The Revelation from God, where is the man that has given the state? The Lord, when it's not? So I cannot find one instance. And so, you're just saying that if the head of the priesthood can be foundationally wrong and he was representing out of God in that context, but I would say, it applies to Brigham Young's other controversial doctor and she says, well then that lays an axe to the root of the whole tree. And so, I do think that Brigham, I have serious reservations with people coming at things from the twentieth and twenty-first Century. Let them and Doctrine is now starting to because these ideas are socially acceptable anymore, they are very socially controversial and unpopular that, you know, people look back and think that these were just men of their times and that they're their doctrines were actually inspired of these regards.

4:16:43 I think that that is dangerous road to go down and my personal perspective. You think that we do need to hold the scriptures as our standard? We do need to hold the, the Inspire teachings of the prophets. I'm not saying that you blindly follow anything. Any profit has ever said, you need to seek your own confirmation of it, but I do think that I, I would have a hard time. Imagining Brigham Young as the man of God that he was airing in such a foundational significant matter as this issue. So, I'm grateful for this today. I'm grateful for Justin and his patience and willingness to participate in this very long evening, and thank you. Thanks, Dave, for putting this on so that I'll say thank you for coming on, man.

4:17:26 It's, it's a hot-button issue for sure. But one when I definitely want to cover. So dude, I can't tell you how much. I appreciate your being here. I really do. All right, just in your turn. My man. All right. Well, I guess for the vault, I also, I would like to thank Jacob for willing to participate with me on this end to You know, 22, been so respectful. I hope you. I hope you got that that's in for me as well. I don't feel like you've been disrespectful in any way. We might have different opinions on this, but I am. I want. I just want to be clear to, I am. Absolutely. willing to respect your opinion on this and your stance, the things that you have decided decided if this is, if this bleeding, this is unacceptable to you.

4:18:20 That's okay. That doesn't make you an enemy. That doesn't mean we can't be friends. And I and I hope that that can be extended to other direction as well. It definitely is thank you. I appreciate that. Jacob I really do because I don't I have not got such a I have not gotten that necessarily from everybody. I've tried to to share my beliefs. On this way will look. If anybody has any issues, what we do and I'm willing to do this because I believe in bringing people together, we'll just have another barbecue. I'll smoke another 40 lb. Brisket will invite everybody down that.

4:19:02 Smooths everything right, over awesome. I am, I'm all for that. So Anyway, I think it's been a good debate. I feel like, you know, we've both been able to express our ideas in our in our opinions, and ultimately I imagine our testimonies cuz at least on my side, you know, I have a testimony of the things that I've shared and I am specifically in the context of the neighbor hammock. Covenant, to me, I kind of didn't go there earlier at the time because I kind of wanted to to go there later. What is it has been a burden on me to be honest. This Doctrine. and it is a burden that despite how much I prayed about it, it is, it would never it was never made light and I have a very, very special.

4:20:09 Testimony of the blessings of the temple and the way that those things says I have changed my life and changed the life of my family and these blessings. Matter of fact, ultimately is it was the pursuit of these blessings that led me out of the church and into fundamentalism because I I realize that I'm not going be able to find those blessings there. I feel a lot like, is Nephi describe that, you know, his ABCs things, his father's received and he wants, Bill to receive those things too. And I look at the church and I look at church history and I see the things of the early registration is now I want to be able to receive those things too. And I can, I can testify that I have been greatly blessed and finding those things and receiving those things. And it's honestly because of that, this desire that because I have been given much.

4:21:01 I like to Feel that I too must give and the blessings of the Goddess was great in and it is a blessing it is baptism in the gifts in the Holy Ghost to our. I know that it is not the end and I was night when I read the scriptures, no matter where I'm reading it. Whether I'm reading in Doctrine and Covenants, whether I'm reading the New Testament, where it with her mean the Book of Mormon the central message is, is that the whole point of all of this, the whole point of the other a Priestly line and a priesthood. In general, the whole point of a God's chosen Israelite, people all of this is to bring these things to the entire Earth. Less the entire Earth. and so I guess my message, maybe to Jacob and end, it may be anybody else listening if they find themselves, you know, in this position of, if that if that gets hard to hold onto even a At a spiritual level.

4:21:59 If it's if it becomes burdensome I want you to know that I'm trying to. I'm not I'm not a scholar. This really is a little bit outside of my area of expertise but I've been trying to study this because Because of well, basically, because of what what I read in in Abraham and so my invitation is is that I want to provide an alternative explanation as solution if in your heart of hearts, this feels wrong and it feels like it's not, right? And I have seen people who have gone anti with that, but I haven't seen a lot of people actually try to come up with a sincere honest. Faith-based explanation.

4:22:46 And I know ultimately I have come out and I said, you know, I think Britain was wrong on these things. But I'm in my opinion, I'm not throwing Brigham Young under the bus. I'm, I'm throwing a specific teaching that didn't even come up a whole lot in reality, under the bus. And I personally believe that if if we can commune with Brigham Young, that this is something that he would agree with. but again, These Are Spiritual matters, but I just if you're, if you've been holding on to this and it's and it's hard and it's getting tiring and Any end it just doesn't feel right. I just want you to know that you don't have to you don't have to hold on to this.

4:23:33 There is an explanation here in the scriptures had said it's a beautiful test ammonia in the abrahamic Covenant that this is not that we don't have to we can esteem All men are brothers. We don't need, we don't need to Judge other people or try to judge a people or have to be suspicious of a people because of who their ancestry might be. That ultimately the gift of the priesthood, it is a privilege and it's a privilege that should come through, through Revelation is as clearly shown in the scriptures. No matter how you interpret them at the priesthood is not for everybody, but it is for those who God has called to it and at least for me, I'm willing to trust in that Revelation and if if a black man ever comes to me, requesting the priesthood or the blessings of the priesthood, I'm going to still pray about it but I'm going to I'm going to give it a shot and if the Lord says no every time then maybe there is a priest to ban but But otherwise I just want to share my testimony. That this isn't something that you necessarily have to hold on to and if you still if you believe the band in your interview he's that way.

4:24:53 I still I understand and I still I still respect you. I understand how Where you're coming, where you're coming from, as well. But I just wanted to be able to say that. I think there's another way. So anyways, awesome. Well the thing I got out of this is that there are two guys here that really love the gospel or passionate about it. And we'll go to the map for it every time. And even though, you know, there's differences of opinion, there's different beliefs, the end of the day, we can still call each other brother, enjoy some brisket and and carry on so gentleman.

4:25:36 Thank you, been fine, been interesting and I'm sure sure the audience feels the same way. So thanks. They said, thank you. Bye everybody.

4:26:18 Listening to the morning Renegade podcast.