July 8, 2023

Episode #78: The Historicity Of The Book Of Abraham W/Ken Peterson

Episode #78: The Historicity Of The Book Of Abraham W/Ken Peterson
Episode #78: The Historicity Of The Book Of Abraham W/Ken Peterson
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #78: The Historicity Of The Book Of Abraham W/Ken Peterson

Ok if you haven’t gone to the Mormon Renegdae Patreon Page and signed up for at least the 6 dollar package you might want to do that for this episode. One of the tactics commonly used by detractors of the Restored Gospel is to call into question the veracity of the Book of Abraham. They will tell you that it was simply a work of fiction based on the imagination of the Prophet Joseph Smith when he bought some Mummies. However, those detractors aren’t giving you the full story or being completely forth coming with all the evidence. This serves to cause some people to doubt and lose their testimony of the Restored Gospel without ever hearing the full story. Well on this episode I have Ken Peterson back on the podcast and we are going to do our best Paul Harvey and give the rest of the story on the Book of Abraham with all the information in context. By the end of this podcast, you will be able to come away not only still believing in the Book of Abraham but also knowing that the books historicity is not in doubt. --- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support

0:04 OK, if you haven't gone to the Mormon Renegade Patreon page and signed up for at least a $6 package, you might want to do that right now. This episode has a lot of cool slides in the video that you're going to want to keep a hold of, one of the tactics commonly used by detractors of the restored gospels to call into question the veracity of the Book of Abraham. They will tell you that is simply a work of fiction based on the imagination of the Prophet Joseph Smith when he bought some mummies. However, those detractors aren't giving you the full story or being completely forthcoming with all the evidence. This serves to cause some to doubt their testimony of the restored gospel without ever hearing the full story. Well, on this episode I have Ken Peterson back on the podcast and we're going to do our best Paul Harvey and give you the rest of the story on the Book of Abraham.

0:47 With all the information and context, by the end of this podcast you'll be able to come away not only still believing in the Book of Abraham, but also knowing that the book's historicity is not in doubt. And that's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. Look, it's no secret that our society has become much more crude and coarse to become and raise men and women of virtue and characters, a Herculean task. To help with this, I've recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior and Company and Conversation. It was a book with 110 rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society, something that today's society is sorely lacking.

1:32 What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So the book is laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule. Right below that is my explanation for the 21st century, and below that you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, to go along with this, there's a workbook that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids. To find the book, go to mormonrenegade.com, go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post, and order your copy. Today, I can bear personal testimony from personal experience. That this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character.

2:35 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. And my man, dude, I got to tell you, when I was down for the Glenn Beck thing earlier this week, it was so nice to meet you in person. Likewise and it was so fun to visit with you in person and to realize you're just as nice in person as you are over zoom. Well, I kind of felt bad for you, right? Because I'm like, coming in your house and you're like, whoa, his waistline's way larger than I would have imagined from the same. Way No way. I didn't feel that at all. It was it was great fun and was especially I know how busy you are and how many things you had planned.

3:20 So I was especially flattered that you would take time out of your busy schedule. You kid me, man, You're one of my favorites. Thank. You I'll take that opportunity anytime I get so as as we got talking on our last episode at the end because newsflash for everybody else when I wrap up and say see everybody later. That's not the end for me and my guest. We we chat a little bit afterwards and Ken had like some amazing ideas and one of those that he had was something that trips a lot of Mormons up and that is the Book of Abraham and the historicity of the Book of Abraham.

4:02 Because Ken correct me if I'm wrong, that's like one of the main things that the the both the never Mormons and the disgruntled. Faction of Mormonism I guess Love to attack, right? For a while they glommed on really hard to the CES letter and then through the work of like folks like Sarah Allen. She's done a great job in defending that. And then oh, by the way, we found horses you know in in in pre Columbus America. That poses a problem, right. So but Book of Abraham, they really glom onto an attack. That's been my experience.

4:42 In fact, I have a good friend who confided in me that he had his name removed from the records of the church because of the Book of Abraham. And I said, well, you know, the whole story, right? And he goes, what do you mean? And I told the whole story and I was like, wow, I didn't know that. And so and the information. Well, and anytime we talk about things like this of a scholarly nature and people say, well, I've done my research and left the church. My question to them is when you say research, did you fully examine both sides? Because if you haven't, that's not research, that's propaganda.

5:26 And both sides are amply represented online if you know where to look and. And I'm one who encourages people, just like Joseph Smith did, to live how you choose. We claim the privilege of worshipping the God Almighty according to the dictates of our own conscience, and we want all others to do the same. And we'll and we'll fight for others to do that. But I think the only thing that gets to me is when people make those decisions without having investigated everything. You know which is called, which is called deception. You know, and what you will find and what you will see in tonight's discussion.

6:15 Critics of the Church, in particular things related to the Book of Abraham, are very good at not telling you everything. They only tell you the things that would manipulate you to do what they want you to do and why. There are people out there who want to crush. Poor Mormons testimonies. I don't fully understand that. But there I know for a fact that there are those in this world that is their desire. They dream of such things. They they enjoy that it's really sick. But it is kind of sick. No, it really is because the the I love what you said there when people say they've done their research. Usually what that means is they've encountered, like White House Ministries, or they've encountered an Egyptologist who said, Oh no, that that facsimiles from the Book of the The Egyptian Book of the Dead.

7:17 They haven't spent any time researching both sides of the argument, right? They feel like they've gotten the full story on the Book of Abraham without ever. Diving in and really doing the scholarly work to find out if it's true or not. And there's a certain amount of hubris involved in that, A certain amount of I mean, do they really believe they're the only Mormon who has ever lived, who has gumbled across these things? Are they not aware that there are old Mormons like me out there who read everything already? And much of what what I'm going to refer to today, that was available knowledge in 1987? That was the first book I read and probably the most informative book I read on the facsimility on the facsimiles in their interpretation.

8:04 So I mean if if it were me stumbling across this stuff, I would think certainly there are Latter Day Saints out there who have answers or who can explain both sides of this. So before I do anything rash or run crying to my mommy, that wasn't a nice thing to say. Why don't I investigate this and talk to people who've been down this path before? Because as you and I have talked before, there are people out there who know more than all of us put together and are devout, more devout as Latter Day Saints. As statistics have demonstrated, the more educated. And this is contrary to the statistics of all other Christian faiths or religiosities in the United States at least. That in the Latter Day Saints faith, the more education you have, the more devote, the more devout you are, which is contrary to other faiths.

9:01 The more education they have, the less devout they are. And that's not true with Mormonism, and it has to do with LDS scholarship. You know, and and here's the thing when when people, when people, when people criticize like this, I I don't get offended, right. I'm like, OK, well let's look at the evidence, right. Yeah. One is, is that I've been through the fire a little bit, so I know what it's like to have your back up against the wall and have to reexamine everything you believe, right? I remember when I first came into Mormonism well, and this was a little bit before, right? Like, I stopped drinking, I stopped doing drugs, and then I started reading a whole bunch. And like, I think I freaked the person out at Barnes and Noble because I'm like, okay.

9:45 I'm going to find the truth of everything no matter where it is. So, like, I must have had like the. The, the, the reading library of a schizophrenic because I would go from like, you know, the Communist Manifesto to Adam Smith and the Wealth of Nations, right. And so it was just, I was like, we're going to find out where this, where this goes. And I would say this, if if you're finding something that's challenging here, that's a good sign. I think that's something that tells you you're a thinker, right? Yeah. Before, but I would caution before you just throw the baby out with the bathwater, do your homework right. Don't take what I have to say is gospel.

10:27 Ever. I am a flawed man with many, many character flaws. Ken is way better than I am, but he's still not. Go. Go. Do your own research, right. Don't just take our word for. It. The nature of true scholarship is to fully investigate all sides before you make a decision, and I think that's one of the reasons why you and I hit it off from the very beginning. We tend to think alike, and I was going, as I was going over the mountains of information in preparation for tonight, reviewing all of these things and trying to put it together in a useful fashion. Once again, my skeptical mind is overwhelmed with the impossibility of what Joseph Smith did, as we will see. It's almost as if he was showing up. I mean, of course he wasn't.

11:16 He was acting as a prophet. But it is, it's to this day, it boggles my mind that he was able to do what he did. Yeah. Or I should say that God was able to do what he did absolutely through immortal Joseph. Absolutely. So real quick, give us a rundown of what, what the Book of Abraham is. Where did we get it? Let's just assume nobody has that back story. Awesome. And this is. Let's start there. So you see the screen, what we're going to talk about tonight, given time an introduction to the whole topic. Then we'll dive right into the criticism starting from the worst of the best.

11:57 Then my favorite, we're going to dive into the home runs, the impossible, bull's eyes, whatever you want to call them. And inevitably there's going to be some overlap because in answering the criticisms. Which is, Which has always been the rewarding thing for me as I study criticisms of the restoration is that in answering in when you when you get past the half truth and get the whole answer, it's miraculous. The vindication is it it? I always kind of come out of it like I did tonight. Again, just reviewing this stuff, going I can't believe it. I can't believe how true this whole thing is. Anyway, and then once we get past the home runs, if there's still time around midnight, I want to get into the profound doctrines.

12:44 I mean it. It's fun for me to talk about the ins and outs and the criticisms and the reputations, the Book of Abraham, Abraham. But it's true value to us is the doctrines that we get from it, which is really kind of amazing. And there, without getting specific, there's so much overlap. Between the temple ceremony and and the book of Abraham, right? Now you're getting into one of the other topics on the list. OK. I'll, I'll, I'll back off. I'll back off. All right, let's. Oh, no, no. But I want to. I want to address that because we do. I want to talk about that another time. But what most people don't understand, in fact, this is a topic I didn't put on that list.

13:24 I gave you the Freemasonry and the temple, you know, but that's not anti. Love to jump on that bandwagon and say, you know those Mormons, they just stole everything from Freemasonry. So I'm in a nutshell. Yeah, I'm not ready to go out with this full tilt, but you and I are going to talk for about 5 minutes after the podcast because I have a theory and I want to run it by you. Well, for Father's Day, I just got Jeffrey Bradshaw's latest. 400 page volume on Freemasonry, the oldest temple which and the the arguments of the issues involved I've been familiar with for some time, but of course he he's very good at documenting everything so I can't wait to tear into that.

14:10 But in a nutshell, less than 2% of what occurs within our temple rights has any similarity at all to Freemasonry. And close to 100% of what we do you will find in these ancient extra canonical texts in my book, 50 pages of it. How do you explain that number 1, #2 Joseph Smith didn't enter the temple until 1840. It didn't become a Freemason till 1842. The significant restored temple teachings. He was teaching and studying in 1835, seven years ahead of the game, because of the Book of Abraham, because of his work on that.

15:03 Right, right. But we'll see how significant this is. Well, to get into it, right? So So what is the book of Abraham? Well, in here you can see the map. This is a map of Egypt, Ancient Egypt, so in 1835 while in Kirtland. Joseph Smith, on behalf of the church purchased 4 Egyptian mummies and each mummy had their own papyrus, at least one from a guy named Michael Chandler. We'll get to that back story. They paid $2400 in 1835 for that collection. Now remember how the Saints were living in Kirtland? They were paupers.

15:48 They had nothing. They were struggling just for housing. And somehow they coughed up what today the equivalent would be $82,000 to purchase 4 mummies in their papyri. How curious. How? I mean, why would they do that? Why were they $82,000? People were just struggling to live and they coughed up 82 grand for some old mummies in papyri. They didn't even know how many papyri because the papyri were were tucked inside the mummies. Right. Anyway, this Michael Chandler had acquired them in 1833. He acquired 11 of them and he'd been touring throughout the the United States with the time, which is East Coast making money off of him.

16:37 He had already sold seven prior to meeting Joseph Smith. He had four left and he sold the remaining mummies and the accompanying papyri and a hypocephalus. A little an amulet, a plaster amulet that would either go under the head or on the chest of the mummy to remind the deceased of of how to pass into the eternal world, which is also very, very interesting. We'll get to that. When Joseph Smith had acquired them, he announced that they contained some of the writings of the patriarchs Abraham and Joseph, both of whom had lived in Egypt. Let me interject here, because this I didn't include this as part of the presentation. So we have the Book of Abraham.

17:19 He said the writings of Jonas Joseph were there too. Where's that? We don't have that? There are three facsimiles in our Book of Abraham. The Book of Abraham only talks about the first facsimile. The 2nd 2 have no accompanying text. John Gee, A preeminent Egyptologist and a lot of the Saint has estimated well, it's believed that Joseph Smith had. Finished translating both of those books, Abraham and Joseph, but before his death he was only able to publish in the Times and Seasons the book of Abram that we have. It is estimated that between 2/3 and 3/4 or between 66 and 75% of what he translated is still out. There somewhere, and we have no idea where it's at. No, it's probably in your great grandma's attic. Everybody goes.

18:19 Look at your grandma's ad right, right now. How's the podcast? Go to your grandma's attic and start rummaging around. Because if they are related to facsimile 2 and facsimile 3, it's talking about astronomy, astronomy of God, wow wow. Anyway, so if we look at this map here on the left of your screen, the area in the red. Is where they were discovered. We'll go into more details. So this is referred to as the Upper Nile or Upper Egypt. And the ancient Egyptian capital was Thebes. And here's a closer map of that area.

19:01 On the right hand side of the map you'll see Karnak, which the other one on my list is the Egyptian Endowment. There are two ancient. Egyptian temples dating to the time period of Moses that predate the more ostentatious Egyptian temples that where the the Pharaohs are building them unto themselves. There are two smaller temples Karnak and Medina taboo which are almost identical. You newbly said about these ancient Egyptian temples and their rights said in doubt. Latter Day Saints require no explanation. So when you go through those temples and the reliefs and what you're instructed to do room by room, you're washed, you're annointed your clothes, and you go room by room and you make progressive covenants.

19:57 Then you pass through the veil in these ancient temples and you go sit down on the throne with God. I mean, there are accompanying pictures of that, that piece of date, so. I think Karnak and where I see Karnak, I think of that. And anyway across the Nile river from Karnak is thieves. They don't know exactly where they were discovered because the Italian guy Antonio La Bolo, who was in exile from France, well, in exile because of I think, revolutionary activities. He was working like this is a crazy thing, history. And we, and this is probably good preface to the whole discussion, nobody alive at the time of Joseph Smith knew anything about ancient Egypt.

20:48 They had no knowledge of how to read hieroglyphic. None. Even the native Egyptians you know, that walk past these Egyptian ruins and look at the hieroglyphs and think what what that says. Well, yeah, and and it's not. Too long before or too long before Joseph Smith, that Napoleon and his crew roll up on the Rosetta Stone and everyone thinks, oh, we got this Rosetta Stone and and that that's how they translated it. That was a process that did not come overnight. So Champoleon, who was the Frenchman who cracked the Rosetta Stone, was a contemporary of Joseph Smith. But even his ideas did not get traction until 1850.

21:31 Well after. So when we talked about what Joseph Smith was attempting to do with this Egyptian stuff and isn't an interesting, so Napoleon, the result of Napoleon's campaigns into Egypt, was the rediscovery of all these Egyptian antiquities and brought all of this to our attention. But Joseph Smith was at least 10 to 20 years ahead of the curve and getting it what this. Meant and the true significance in regard to the restoration. Anyway. So on this West Bank of the Nile discovered he discovered 11 mummies, and those red dots represent where they possibly were. He had over 100 men working, several hundred men working for him excavating, so he couldn't keep track of exactly where these eleven were discovered.

22:30 He died, and the mummies were shipped to New York City to sell them to anybody who would pay the appropriate sum. The proceeds were sent to Livolo's HEIRS, Chandler required. Can I ask a quick question real quick? And this is going to sound kind of silly, and it and it may be one of those things we just don't have an answer to. Do we know how the mummies were positioned in relation to Karnac? Oh, which direction They were lying and that sort of thing. Yeah. No, for I don't. I'm not thinking. But as they don't even know where they were found. So I mean what they were doing and and Antonio La Bolo's day wasn't archaeology.

23:13 It was grave. It was looting. Right, right. They weren't keeping the best notes, they were just trying to smuggle out the antiquities. Yeah, they weren't keeping any notes. I mean, the whole idea of archaeology wasn't even a study until the 20th century. Yeah. People forget archaeology as a quote. Science has only been around for about 100 years, right. And I'm always fascinated when the archaeologists go, well, this is how it is and I'm like, really? That's how it is. Are you sure? I mean 100 years it it it's almost arrogant that the position that we take that. Oh well, we know the breadth of human history in the last 100 years, so.

24:01 My experience has been that the the scientists, the archaeologists and the scholars who are at the leading edge of the science are the ones most open to change because of the most educated, and they know exactly what they don't know. Right. It's the people who are, you know, two or three rows back, you know, teaching in the school systems that become these. Hardened disciples of whatever is currently popular. Even since you and I talked about a Book of Mormon evidences months ago, there have been 2 brand new Lidar studies in Meso America with the exact same results. Northern Guatemala and another place on the Yucatan, just the one in northern Guatemala.

24:48 They found 140 miles of highways connecting like these seven cities. So we're much more advanced, much earlier than anybody thought the Mayan is and they have, they're revising everything. Yep. Everything anyway. And it it'll take probably a decade for all that information trickle into the textbooks. You know we're. Teaching our kids in the schools, right? So Chandler gets these mummies. In 1833, he claimed that Labola was his uncle, but that hasn't been confirmed. It might have just been adding to his story. You never know, right? Gotcha. Here's the 1st and the coolest criticism.

25:29 So, so real quick, but before we dive into the to the. Criticism. Let me ask you this. Joseph Smith receives this papyra from the mummies. He then goes to work to translate them. He gets the Book of Abraham, the Book of Moses from. No, the Book of Moses did not come from the pirate. Really. And where we'll talk about that Book of Moses. Oh, I love that book even more than Abraham. Book of Moses was the result of his the Joseph Smith translation of the Bible. OK. All right. Now he now this is significant. He called the book of Moses a translation. What was he translating?

26:15 The Bible, Buckus. He wasn't translating anything. It was straight up revelation. That he received while studying the Old Testament. All that stuff was given to him. Pure revelation. Why would he, Why would he call it a translation? That gives us insight, very significant insight into what he was doing with the Book of Mormon and with the Book of Abraham, it was less. He didn't translate like a scholar would, you know, take one word, translate the word and write it down. That's not. He wasn't a scholarly translator. He did not have those abilities. He wanted to be. They tried to study he and his counterparts. They studied Egyptian.

26:56 They studied Hebrew. They wanted to learn Egyptian. Which is weird because nobody knew it then. But so when he calls the Book of Abraham a translation and the Book of Mormon a translation, we know that he had gold plates, But he wasn't translating from the characters on the plates. He was translating from the Urem thumb or the Sears stone. Gotcha. Yeah. So, so real quick, what happens to those papyri after Joseph's done with them? Oh, I love this story. So when they first got them, there were 4 mummies, presumably 4 scrolls, and there were some. And of course they are thousands of years old. And so the edges of them have become worn and ragged. And in it, in an attempt to preserve those ragged edges, they cut them off and glued them to parchment, as you can see in this photograph.

27:58 This is an actual photograph of the Joseph Smith papari in possession of the church. So you can see where it's worn. And they glued it, you know, as best they could in the 1830s, to this paper to try and preserve it. So what they inadvertently did was divide the collect, divide the whole collection into two. They had the large scrolls that were still intact, they had these trimmings and they had the mummies. After his death, his mother, Lucy Mack, continued to show them to people in order to try and earn a living. Upon her death they went to Emma. Upon Emma's death, her second husband, Louis Biteman. Sold them to some guy in Saint Louis whose name I forget. And then he subsequently sold them to the Chicago the I think it's the Woodward Museum in Chicago, but apparently not all of the collection.

28:57 He kept these trimmed sections that had been glued to parchment and framed. He kept those, and this picture is of one of those. And those are called the Joseph Snip Up all right. The bulk of the collection that he sold to the Woodward Museum, the four mummies and the bulk of the four scrolls ultimately went up in smoke in the Great Chicago Flyer of 1871. Right. So, so and and the reason I think that's important is to to showcase the idea that people are coming up with with their criticisms. Based off of incomplete data.

29:40 And that's calculated. I mean, that's my question to people. They're not telling you everything. Is it because they don't know everything or because they don't want you to know everything, right. And so here, This is why this is criticism #1. This is for people who are not prepared or maybe who want to leave. This is the perfect excuse because guess the perfect test of Joseph Smith's claim to. And being a prophet is this. He claimed to have translated the book of Abraham from these papyri. Lo and behold, in 1967 the Metropolitan Museum of Art discovered them, these these remnants and gifted them to the church quite kindly.

30:24 I mean there was there was nothing nefarious about it and the church didn't hide that fact at all. The Church made them available to every for everyone to see, to look at and to translate, including you and Italy. And here's the one thing that in going over this that I had taken for granted this whole time prior to the discovery of these, we'll call them the Joseph Smith Papyre. We did not have any evidence whatsoever that Joseph Smith ever really possessed any Egyptian artifacts or scrolls. We had none. Now we do. He really did have, he really did have these, that story. That part of the story is true, and that's very exciting.

31:06 And the church itself published an article in 1968 as soon as they could about the discovery of these and okay. So here's the test. Finally, we're going to translate these scrolls that Joseph Smith had. Because now we know how to read Egyptian hieroglyph, and we're going to see if he was a prophet or a liar. And what do you think they translated? And they all agreed, You nibbling everybody. It's exactly what you would expect from a mummy. Their funeral texts, burial texts, the Book of Breathings and the Book of the Dead, the two of them.

31:50 And there are other examples, and not very many of the Book of Breathings, by the way, which were all discovered after this. And in terms of their archaeological dates, they're all later than this. This snippet we have of the Book of Breathings is the oldest one of existence. That's pretty cool, yeah. You know, and and I think before we jump into the criticisms, I think it's important that we. We mentioned what the Book of the Dead was, right? Especially So the Book of the Dead was a book that was supposed to be like a how to manual, if I understand correctly, on how to navigate the the the afterworld.

32:30 The. Yeah, the Afterworld, right. You're going to encounter this and then you're going to do that, right? And then you're going to go to here and then you're going to do this. Now, it there are some striking parallels to the LDS endowment, I should say, in those in that book. But nonetheless it is somewhat different. So people have gone down to this idea that that well, it's not exact, so it can't be correct, right. And I'm sure we'll cover all that. But well, I I was very interested. I I've read through both. And by the way the Book of the Dead and the Book of readings, they're not like. Perfectly accurate reprintings of one another, right?

33:11 They're all a little bit different because they were all handwritten by a priest. Scribes who would take liberties. And some scribes are better than others, and the handwriting is better than others. So we'll see that it wasn't we. This is another case of presentism. Because of copyright and exactness, we can't steal people's words. We can't misrepresent words. We fight over articles in the King James Version, or any biblical version for that matter. I mean, we're very precise about the printed material. In ancient Egypt, that wasn't necessarily the case. I mean, they were as careful and as cautious as anyone of their time. And as one scholar put it, it's not that the Egyptians were bad at at keeping things. What they were, their problem was they kept everything and started.

33:59 And so their religion just continued to proliferate until King Tut's dad Akhenaten. When he came to power, he decided he was going to return them to monotheism, to to the sun God, and he was hated. They hated him because the pantheon of gods was big business. For the priest cast and for the idol makers, you know he was killing their business. Anyway. He, I think he was pharaoh for about 7 years, had seven or eight or nine kids, King Tut being the next heir and when he died they erased him. In.

34:44 Fact, it wasn't until this century that we even knew he existed and he had to restore him that he was reviled for that. That's crazy anyway. Very interesting stuff. All right. So I think that answers the question of what it is, where it came from and what happened to it, right. It's it's it's something that comes out of Egypt. Joseph manages to put the money together with all the Saints, they. $82,000 at today's money. Right. And and keep in mind, this is a time when when men and women, especially the sisters, were grinding up their plates for the mortar. Interior mortar of the of the Kirtland temple to to make it shine a little bit right.

35:28 These are these are poor and destitute people. So I don't know. You know, I think I don't think anyone has the the answers. I'm sure Joseph saw him and recognized their worth and then had to go raise funds for that. Nonetheless, Joseph knew they were important and had to be translated. When you look what came from them, you can't argue that. Right. Absolutely priceless, right. Which is why it's called the Pearl of Great Price. Yep, Yep. Priceless. Joseph dies, the the the mummies go eventually through bitumen and what not to the the Chicago Museum, the the Great Fire. Chicago Fire happens, and most everything, except with the exception of a few things, goes up in smoke. Correct.

36:21 So and and out of this, the Book of Abraham details Abraham's time in Egypt as well as other crucial events. So. So let's let's talk about some of the criticisms now. So the biggest one, and the one I mentioned to my friend that threw him was, you know, that Joseph failed the test because we now have the proprietors who translated him, and it's not the Book of Abraham. I guess Joseph Smith is a failure. What's the rest of the story? Joseph Smith had in his possession three or four or more long scrolls, plus the hypocephalus, the the round the 2nd facsimile right, which is an amulet of plaster, and they found lots of those.

37:10 Of these original materials, only a handful of the fragments fragments, an estimated 10%, were recovered at the Metropolitan Museum. So those frayed edges that were trimmed off. Mounted and put in, put in frames is all that was left there. There's a wonderful graphic I want that's it's quite informative. The majority of the papyri remains lost and it has likely been destroyed. Critics who claim that all or a majority of the papyri possessed by Joseph Smith are mistaken. As expected, the mummies were buried with common funerary text. But. As archaeologist John G points out, Egyptian priests of the time were often buried with a variety of different texts, all written on the same for pirates roll one after the other. We call that today cutting and pasting. They would do that.

38:07 They would cut and paste those vignettes. But we call facsimiles now. So here's this is the most interesting graphic I've seen on it. It represents the four scrolls that he had in his possession. We know their names. The Scroll of Whore. It was 13 centimeters wide and about 10 feet in length. And those scraps. So those brown colored pieces, those are what we have. That's the Joseph Smith Papyri 123. And that Facts of the Facsility #1. So we have a very small sample size. 10% is the estimate, 10%. So if you were just placing bets in Vegas, 90% that this is not what he translated from.

39:07 We'll talk more about that. But the other three, the top, the Scroll of horror, was where we get the first facsimile. We don't even know if the whole scroll was the book of Readings or if it was something else. The Scroll of Semenies, 32 centimeters wide, much wider. Early accounts indicate that this scroll may have been extended twice as long, as shown here, it could have been 20 feet long. Then the third scroll, Nufia Loop, again, very wide, 10 feet long. And the last one we have nothing of and we have the hypocephalus. So let me ask you this.

39:54 Can the scroll of horror, the scroll of seminists? I'm only even pretend to pronounce the third. Or the That's a tough one. But but have have those been found with any other mummies? Well, no, because the names of these scrolls are the names of the mummies that they belong to. They were mentioned by them, right? So they're unique to that mummy. Now inevitably they were cutting and pasting from something else, as we will see, but we we have no idea of really knowing exactly what those were, their ideas. But this, this graphic is probably the most insightful thing I've seen in regard to this issue and this. It's showing the big lie.

40:39 That critics want you to hoodwink you with that all we have, all of his, we have all of his paparai and he just he really fouled up and he's just making it up. We don't know that John Gee, eyewitness accounts from Joseph Smith state agree that the Book of Mormon, the Book of Abraham was on the long roll. People who saw it. So yeah he was working on the long one. Maybe the second one, the 20 foot long one. Through museum documents we can corroborate that the long roll was sold to the Chicago museum. Unfortunately, it was destroyed by fire in 1871. The small portion on the outside of the roll seems to have been cut off and mounted for its protection. It is always the outermost edge of a scroll that is damaged the most, and Joseph must have felt that this damaged beast needed preservation efforts because this part of the scroll was glued to paper.

41:37 That dates back to the Kirtland period. They know where that paper came from, so it was done very early on. John G again, according to a newfound Mormon, non Mormon eyewitness account, The Book of Abram seems to have been on a very long and completely intact role. So it's probably could have been the 4th one and therefore not even on the same scroll as the fragments we have. Let me pause here. The reason critics like to presume that Joseph Smith was translating from these fragments is because that first fragment contains facsimile #1. And so they. Oh, see, so that was the one. Well, if that's true, where are the other two facsimiles? You know, but we'll we'll talk more about that. They were cutting and pasting text. They're also cutting and pasting pictures and there is significant precedent of them moving. But then yet the the the drawings around having nothing to do with the adjacent text, It was like decoration into some extent.

42:44 And this in turn means that none of the fragments of the Joseph Smith prior that we have is from the same scroll as the Book of Abraham. And if none of the fragments that we have comes from the same scroll as the Book of Abraham, then the fact that none of the text on the matches the Book of Abraham is not a problem. Critics of the Church have presumed that the Book of Abram must be on the fragments that we currently have. Why they assumed that is beyond me. Historical evidence is against such a conclusion, and he goes on. There is still more evidence that Joseph Smith had additional propiry edition. Propirous documents almost universally pertain to only one individual, one document per individual. So from an Egyptological perspective, how many propyary do we know that Joseph Smith had? We know that there was a Book of Breathing Belongs to Whore, Book of the Dead belonging to Tara Shitmin, Book of the Dead belonging to nefernoob Hyposylephus, belonging to Shayshank, and Document belonging to Amantatep, the son of four.

43:50 Here we have documents from at least five different individuals. If we have all the propyre Joseph Smith had. Where? We might ask? Our facsimile is 2 and three the role belonging to Aman hotel or all the strange vignettes which those who saw the Propari now who describe if there are documents we do not have by what clairvoyance do critics proclaim what was or was not on them. They don't. That's it's a biased presumption which brings us to this topic we talked about earlier. Joseph referred also referred to the Book of Moses as a translation, knowing full well he didn't translate it in the sense of transcribing it from an original document. The only eye witness to the translation process to describe it was Joseph Smith's scribe Warren Parrish, who claimed after he left the church.

44:44 Famously I have sat by his Joseph side and pinned down the translation of the Egyptian hieroglyphics as he claimed to receive it. By direct inspiration from heaven. Now if that is true, none of the squirrels had to have the Book of Abraham up technically. So then the question is, well, how do we know? I mean, let's assume for the sake of discussion that none of the scrolls had it. He was just receiving revelation like he did for the Book of Moses. How do we evaluate then whether the Book of Abraham is a valuable or truthful text at all?

45:25 OK, so can I play devil's advocate that to that then real quick? You better sure. So let's say someone says the following Well, if it's not a direct translation right, then what were the purposes of the mummies in the PIE ride to begin with? That's the same question that's been asked about the Book of Mormon and I. My answer is twofold #1 The Book of Mormon, The Plates of. The golden appearing plates were evidence that it was there really was a physical record which was critical. But when it comes to the 8 witnesses, the 11 witnesses of the others who saw them, there really was a record. Did Joseph Smith have even begin to have the ability to translate any of that?

46:18 No, not as a scholar or as a person. Now, in terms of the and the other reason was as a catalyst. Joseph Smith never received revelation without first asking the question. So he receives, I mean Section 132, celestial marriage was given because he said what's what's this whole thing about Abraham having more than one wife? And God says, let me tell you about eternal marriage. Boom and just opens the floodgates. Right, So so here is with these mummies which came from Egypt, and he knows that Abraham went down to Egypt. Was that just a catalyst for him to start asking the questions To which Book of Abraham was an answer? Nobody knows the answer to that question. I'm inclined, because of what we're going to discuss in a minute, to believe that he really did have Abrahamic documents amongst those scrolls.

47:20 Because because of evidence we have found to demonstrate that the ancient Egyptians were very well aware of who Abraham was, and that ancient Egyptian and ancient extra canonical texts agree exactly with what Joseph Smith gave us in our Book of Abraham when the rest of the world had no clue. Yeah, so that's exciting stuff. Well, in the proof of this would really be in. Later, when we get down to the home run section of things right is that, you know, regardless of what somebody favors from a historical standpoint of how Joseph Smith translated these documents, the proof should be found within the correlations between Egyptian religious rights and Mormon religious rights.

48:14 Right. Proof is in the pudding, ultimately. Yep. I mean, let's let's just assume he he got it out of thin air like he did the book of Moses. What he gave us, how did he, how did he get those bullseyes, Not just the text, but his interpretation of the facsimiles, which, which is even trickier because most of the facsimile, well, all of the interpretations of facsimiles. He wasn't interpreting hieroglyphics, he was interpreting ideagrams, representative images of the significance of them, which don't always. They're not as concrete as hieroglyphics. All right, the criticism #2. What most people don't know is that the original Joseph Smith papare, the trimmed edges, were damaged, and one of those damaged pieces was first facsimile, the first ideogram.

49:07 So when the image you're looking at, the image on the left is the actual papare, you can see that the head of the priest and the hand of the priest are missing. Yet in our facsimile, they're not. So why is that? Well, when they when they printed the the Book of Abraham, the person was his name. Head Headlock Hedrick. Well it's I'll. I have it in print later. They filled in the blanks just so it would look nice, so it wouldn't look like a ripped up papyrus. I got you. Now, we do not know how much part Joseph Smith had to do with that or how much the printer Hedrick, I think, was his name had to do with it.

49:54 But there therein lies some criticism that, you know, Joseph Smith was so dumb he didn't even know what these meant or how to fill them in. And therefore he's not a prophet. So we're going to talk about why that. You know what all that is? One of the criticisms is? The priest's head was not a bald headed priest. It was the head of a Jackal, a mask that they wore because there are other images and we're going to see a very interesting one where he is wearing a mask of a Jackal, OK? And that it was an embalming scene, that this wasn't a it wasn't a sacrificial knife and that sort of thing. John Gigan assumed for the sake of argument that the head on facsimile, one figure is correct. What are the implications of the figure being a bald man? Shaving was a common feature of initiation into the priesthood from the Old Kingdom through the Roman period. Since complete shaving with the head was another mark of the male Isaac Votary and priest, the bald figure would then be a priest.

51:06 So there is historical precedent for having a bald priest. How would Joseph Smith know that? And assume on the other hand that the head affects simile 1. Figure 3 is out of a Jackal. We have representations of priest wearing masks. One example of an actual mask literary accounts from non Egyptians about a jiffy priest wearing masks. Thus however the restoration is made, the individual shown effect, Simile one figure 3 is a priest whether he's a baldy or Jackal, and the entire question of which head should be on the figure is moot so far as identifying the figure. Identifying the figure is concerned. The entire debate has been a waste of ink. They're actually images and I forgot to include when you're putting this together, showing this bald headed priest a cutaway showing on the Jackal mask. So whether they wore the mask or not, they were priests. Then we get to the knife.

52:05 First. There is the question as to whether the knife being held by three could plausibly. Have been in the original vignette or illustration. This is very interesting. The existence of the knife has been doubted by many because it does not conform to what other Egyptian papyri would lead us to expect. And so some Egyptologists have denied the possibility that the knife was original to this illustration. At least two different 19th century eyewitnesses to this scroll who examined the papyri, including one who was not a Latter day St. Reported seeing quote a priest with a knife in his hand or a man standing by him with a drawn knife. So apparently when Joseph Smith had them, that part of the school was still intact showing the knife. The significance of this is that the presence of the knife in the original papyrus has here been described by a non Mormon witness, eyewitnesses whose description of the storage and preservation pyro matches.

53:10 That of independent contemporary accounts. It also matches the description another eyewitness made before Ruben headlock. Ruben Headlock was the one who cut those those facsimiles who had to be carved into wood to be printed. The fact that they're accurate at all is miraculous. This gives us two independent eyewitness to the presence of a knife on facsimile One, regardless of what we might otherwise think. So here's the image of the knife. Furthermore, the Crescent shape of this knife is consistent with the shape of ancient Egyptian Flint knives, which were used from prehistoric times to the Middle Kingdom, among other activities, ritual slaughter and execration rites.

54:01 This reinforces the likelihood that the knife was original to the scene. So here's that knife in an actual Egyptian. Representation. There's the actual Flint knife up there. You can see how it was chipped away to sharpen the blade. Wow. Just like ancient Mesoamericans. That's crazy. Criticism #3 This is the dumbest. 1 Critics of Joseph Smith have ridiculed the claim that the Book of Abraham was purportedly written by his own hands upon papyrus, which is what it says in the introduction. And the criticism has been repeated in many parts of the Internet and beyond, usually run something like this one. Joseph Smith claimed Book of Abraham was written by his own hand to pump a pirates, meaning Abraham himself hand wrote the text Joseph Smith translated. 2 They're surviving for pyrite fragments date to around 201 fifty BC. Abraham, by contrast, is usually dated to having lived around 2000 BC.

55:03 Therefore, Joseph misclaims that the Book of Amer is written by his own hand. Papyrus is false. Therefore the book of a member is not authentic. Therefore Justice Smith was a false prophet. That that is a dumb argument, because look, I'm just going to say it like this if you pick up a copy of Uncle Tom's Cabin, right? That book was written by I think it's Harriet Beecher Stoll. I could be wrong. I'm I'm blanking on the name real quick of the author. But that book was written. 100, you know, 100 years ago plus, right? You pick up a copy today.

55:44 You don't say, well, this isn't really Uncle Tom's Cabin, right? This, this isn't really the book. And so we know the Egyptians were master record keepers, right? If you listen to some of the reports from the, you know, before it was burnt down the the, the library at Alexandria. Right. They were. They were and. Everything, yeah. Right. So just cuz it's a copy doesn't mean that it's inauthentic. I think of the New Testament. You know my right, a New Testament. Paul talks about himself first person. Oh, he must have written my copy, of course. That's stupid, right? But that's that's that argument. There are two preeminent Egyptologists today who are LDS. Who have written extensively about all of this stuff. John G and the others.

56:37 Kerry Mills, I think he's called. I think he pronounced his name Mulstein. You know the German name, says Milstein. But in any case, he answers it this way. By the way, people have wondered why more Egyptologists have not weighed in on this topic. Can you imagine what a hot potato this topic is? Oh yeah, Can you imagine canceled culture going against anybody who would dare weigh in on this? Well, and and let's just say that you. Especially in favor of the of this Latter Day Saints. I I was going to say, look, I've seen enough from from archaeology that you got to kind of look at archaeology with a little bit of stink eye from time to time, right. You know, with a raised eyebrow.

57:23 Because they're they're. Let's just take Clovis, the Clovis first model as an example, right? They have said for years and years the first people that ever be on the continent were were the Clovis people, right? They find these same shaped spearheads on the Delmarva Peninsula as they do out in Clovis, NM and they're like, oh, this must have been the first people until a roadway project and they find out, oh, there was someone else here. And they still they still fought against. That happens almost every day. They they still fought against the new narrative, right? That this new discovery, so.

58:06 Pre I have to say, prehistory is the most interesting puzzle. Yeah, I know. Yeah. That in cosmology. Yeah. And so when you start looking at this, I think because if you you do bring up a different. A different paradigm than what's accepted there is a certain amount of exclusion You get or ridicule for bringing that up. It's not an open science like we'd hoped. There, There is a network there. So if you're an if you're an Egyptologist and you're doing this work and you're like, you know, this sounds awfully close to what the Mormons think, right, you can bet you're going to have your credentials looked at very seriously.

58:50 Even if you're LDS, which is my point. And the fact that Carrie and John are willing to risk their professional reputations to say anything about this. Even though they're LDS, they don't make their living doing this stuff. They don't make any money from these books. They're doing it as a service to people like me, and they're castigated by Mormons and non Mormons alike who fall on both sides of the issue. You know, and and here's the thing. So that that that takes a certain amount of courage for them to speak out at all. Well, you you mentioned they're not making a ton of money off those books. Let's be honest, no money. With the exception of you, me, and probably 12 other people, there's nobody else getting getting excited about Egyptology from a Mormon point of view, right? You Nibbly definitely John G.

59:45 A couple other scholars. And it's not like it's a a hotbed of activity for literate. True, true. But I am so grateful for them and from their perspective I just. I wish I could tell them both. Thank you for sticking your neck out and explaining some of this stuff, you know? Anyway, he says. Who said this particular papyrus was written by Abraham himself? The heading does not indicate that Abraham had written the particular copy, but he was. He was the author of the original, and he goes on, he concludes, when the heading states that the text was written by Abraham's On the hand, it notes who the author is not, who copied down the particular manuscript that came into Joe's specific anyway.

1:00:34 But you know how many people get thrown by that? Too many. Yeah. Too many? Now we get to the Kirtland Egyptian paper. There were a collection of documents that were discovered dealing with Egyptian and an attempt to translate Egyptian characters that had been taken from those for pyrite. And so people think, aha, this is evidence that Joseph Smith was not by revelation but physically working out how to translate. And of course it's wrong. You look at the KEP, this is what it's called for short. And each Egyptian, each Egyptian glyph has like multiple sentences of meaning to it, right? And it that's not so the the Kirtland Egyptian papers were produced, and this is significant. After the Book of Abraham was dictated, that's significant too.

1:01:39 Some source material used in the KEP is taken from sections of the Doctrine and Covenants. Some of the Kirtland Egyptian papers do not contain any Egyptian at all. There are some really deep concepts, and we talked about someday about cosmology and the restored gospel, the KEP says. Really amazing stuff about that. I mean, just snippets, amazing. And for the placement of a translation of the Book of Abraham prior to the to the production of the KEP renders the entire discussion regarding which document came before which of the documents irrelevant, Richard Bushman, author of Rough Stone Rolling, he said while working on the Book of Mormon in 1829, Joseph invited Oliver Cowdry to try to translate.

1:02:30 We all know how that went. He tried and failed now with the Egyptian papara before them. Joseph again let the men with the greatest interest within such undertakings Caldary and WW Phelps, Warren Parrish, and Frederick Williams, attempt translations of the text. Why would he do that? I could think of a couple reasons. So that they wouldn't take for granted what he was doing, and to try and encourage them to become to prepare to when he ultimately when he was gone. To do some of the things that he that they would need to do. You know, we we forget that Joseph had said on more than one occasion, Oh, if all men could be prophets, right? This Joseph was not a guy who was threatened by somebody else's spiritual experiences, right? It was.

1:03:25 Very clear. He was very clear about the order of priesthood, right? There's only one man at a time. He receives verbally. That's that's what the order of the priest said means Mine house is a House of order. But he was trying to create a Kingdom of prophets. Yeah. Anyway, these guys seem to have copied lines of Egyptian from the papyrus and worked out stories to go with the text. Or they wrote down an Egyptian character and attempted various conditions. One can imagine these men staring at the characters. Jotting down ideas that occurred to them, hoping for a burning confirmation, they tried one approach after another. Eventually, they pulled their work together into a collection that they called Grammar and Alphabet of the Egyptian Language, and it was written in the handwriting of WW Phelps and Warren Parrish, not Joseph Smith's.

1:04:20 So that theory goes by the wayside That criticism is dead. Criticism #5. Biblical Abraham had nothing to do with ancient Egypt. Now this image that we're looking at has to be one of my favorite images in regard to this ever. This is another papyrus. This is not the Joseph Smith papyrus. It's called the Leiden Papyrus in the Netherlands. It dates to the 3rd century. It's written in Greek. Notice what the what the vignette is. On another lion couch, another person lying on the couch, you can see the priest standing over him with a Jackal mask.

1:05:06 And what is that? A knife in his hand. And you can see the person lying down with his hands up in the air, like in the Joseph's hippocyrus, like in our facsimile one. You know what the biggest difference is between these images? At the bottom of that image, you see that outlined in red? That's Greek. For Abraham, really, you can't make this stuff up. That's awesome, So we'll just file that one away as we go through. We're going to talk about it again.

1:05:47 Anyway, the outline marks Abraham's name. Now this this papyrus is from the 3rd century. It's like. The four to five centuries after the Joseph Smithville pirate, there are dozens. And this is John G again. This is published in The Enzyme in 1992. There are dozens of references to Abraham in Egyptian texts. Here we mentioned six of them and we won't go through those tonight. And those mentions date to the 3rd century AD, the same time as his pirates. And most of them came from Thebes, the same place Joseph where the Joseph Smith pyrite came from. So the whole talk, you know, ancient Egypt didn't even know who Abraham was.

1:06:31 That's crap. They knew exactly who he was. I won't mention the name of an anti Mormon amateur Egyptologist to criticize this study. He said they were talking about Biblical Abraham. The Egyptians had incantations, magic words. When we say abracadabra, that's an ancient Egyptian magic word, Abarakadavara. And so he said, yeah, the Abraham, that was just a magic word. And we talked about this in your city on my couch. John Gee responded to that criticism with a very sarcastically titled article saying. Abracadabra Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob. Right.

1:07:22 Clearly they had context cuz they mentioned Abraham, Isaac and Jacob together. There's no magic word. No. I mean they may have been using it as an incantation, but they knew who it was cuz there was context. Or at least early on they did, right? We don't know what what preceding generations, but just like we have sayings in our. And are vernacular that we don't often think about where they came from, right? It's true. That's true, but this laiden for pirates, I mean, what a gift. It's the Joseph Smith fire I with labels. It's amazing criticism #6 the lion couch that Abraham was lying on. Effects of.

1:08:07 It was never used for sacrifice. It was just for embalming. Large alabaster tables found in Memphis, Egypt, with the lion design carved in relief on their sides, were rarely used for evolving. These the research of this guy in 1948, Mustafa, I wish my name was Mustafa, concerning the Apes Bowl at Memphis revealed that these tables were used daily to wash the living apes, the sacrificial bowl and also to form form, sacrifice. Amir described an offering table with lions carved on its sides. Located near an inscription of dedication to the living bowl Avis And here are the photographs of those alabaster tables.

1:08:50 You see the lion couch relief. And there's the base of it down here, where the blood would drain into into a bowl. And here it is. From the top you see how the catch base it would catch the blood. It would drain down to the bottom. And everything also. And don't tell me the line catch was never used for sacrifice, and there's textual evidence for that. Also, just like all sciences, as time progresses the earlier assumptions are being disproven and almost and always in the favor of Joseph Smith, which is the part that boggles my mind. Criticism #7 The Book of Abraham is not on the Joseph Smith for Pyri.

1:09:39 Containing Facsimile One. There again they're saying because the Joseph Smith papyri has Facsimile One on it, where's the Book of Abraham? It should be there. Egyptologist Carrie Millstein again. The immediate assumption was that the text adjacent to Facsimile One must have been the text from which Joseph Smith translated the Book of Abraham. I couldn't understand why they would think that, while at first glance it seems reasonable. To assume that the text adjoining facsimile one would be the place to look for the source of the Book of Abraham. There are many reasons to discard that assumption #1. Dissonance or differences between the text and the adjacent picture is even more pronounced.

1:10:22 With ancient propriety it is common to find the picture some distance from the text. Such incongruity was especially endemic to the Ptolemaic era. Which happens to be the time period during which the Joseph Smith papyri were created and to the type of text we find next to facsimile one. In this case, the Joseph Smith papyri turns out to be exactly like most papyri of its day, so most of them were incongruent. They were disconnected #2. Furthermore, during the time period it was Joseph Smith Pyro created, it was common, not only the text and its accompanying picture to be separated from each other. But also for the wrong vignette to be associated with the text, or for vignettes and text to be completely misaligned. On a long scroll, the content of a vignette and the content of the text frequently lack any apparent connection. This is particularly common in books of breathing the type of text which is adjacent to facsimile one on the Joseph Smith propyre.

1:11:27 So I imagine there are these priests. And they might be low because they weren't doing the stuff for the pharaoh, the lower level presubscribes, maybe not even understanding what there it was just decoration. Yeah, this will look nice on the scroll here, you know it's a possibility #3. There is no known case of anything yet remotely like facsimile one that is associated with the type of text that it is adjacent to. So the presumption there is no evidence for at all. No other copies of the Book of Readings contain anything similar. Based on ancient parallels to the Book of Readings, the most likely conclusion is that the picture next to the text was not associated with the text at all.

1:12:13 So the evidence is precisely opposite of the presumption. Gotcha. Now we're to the really fun stuff, Criticism #8. Shows us misinterpretations of the facsimiles are all wrong, wrong, wrong, wrong right. And that's usually where the critics stop. They don't go into any detail. Why? Because if they go into detail, they're going to find, they're going to expose the the fallacy that they're putting out there. Or they don't have any detail. It's just too easy to believe and I understand. If I didn't know what I know, I believe that too. I was a crackpot.

1:12:58 He's a crank just making this stuff up, which is it leads right into the home run section. The home runs come in three categories in my view that the critics will not ever tell you because they don't know or they don't want you to know Joseph Smith's bulls eyes regarding the interpretation of specific elements of the facsimiles. Your Joseph Smith. You have practically no education, nobody knows anything about Egyptian, and you're taking a stab at ideagrams. Not even hieroglyphics. You shouldn't even be in the ballpark. Right. Do you? I remembered as a young age flipping through my copy descriptions, which I hadn't even done, and seeing those facsimiles for the first time, being bored at sacred meeting. I'm going.

1:13:52 What can this mean? I'm going to try and figure it out myself, you know, and try and take guesses at it. I understand where the early viewers, you know, WW Phelps and Moore and Parish were coming from. What is this? And my guesses are stupid relative to what that really is about. Joseph Smith weren't anyway second category the utter vindication. Of the notion that Abraham was ever on a lying couch in Egypt. By the discovery of authentic pari vignettes labeled with Abraham's name, we saw it And three the numerous unmistakable parallels between our Book of Abraham and extra canonical texts that were unknown to Joseph Smith, which are fully documented in my book, Back Simile #1. So I give you the full facsimile on the right and then the the particular image that we're talking about. So facsimile.

1:14:54 One figure one is this bird, which Joseph Smith says is the Angel of the Lord, who would say that a bird. So here's now the the interpretation through an Egyptological lens. It is not a bobbird, as it might have been in the original vignette, but is a hawk any Falconoid bird the sign of a powerful divine or celestial being? In Egyptian mythology, it is Horace the hawk who delivers his father Osiris from death, Divine being. OK now, when we play this game, you get to be Simon Cowell. So we're going to read, we're going to read Joseph's misinterpretation, then we're going to read the Egyptological interpretation, and you get to go Ding, Ding, Ding, Ding if it matches or burn if it doesn't.

1:15:55 You ready? So here's the first one. Ding, Ding or burn. You're bad. You're horrible at this. I know, I know. I'm trying. To think Angel of the Lord, a powerful divine or celestial being. That's I couldn't. That's not the same at all. Yeah. So and and here's the thing. I'm trying to see it from the other side. Right. I'm a big believer in trying to to understand where they're coming from because I I want to assume the best that nobody's out to do somebody intentionally, right. And but but when you get down to these these facsimiles. These hieroglyphs, you have to look at like another language, right?

1:16:43 So just as we have a word for Angel in our vernacular, yeah, so does, so does German, so does French, whatever. But we know they're describing the same thing. And I think with these vignettes here, especially, you know, when we start looking at it and you start seeing what Joseph said and what. You know current Egyptologists have said and when they they they match up, you have to put some level of of at least coincidence. I shouldn't even say at least coincidence. You have to look at it in terms of okay he hit that right.

1:17:27 He, he absolutely, 100% hit that and that's right. We're coming just from Joseph Smith now. It's coming from Egyptologist, so that's absolutely a hit. And I will remind us of this fact. Joseph Smith had no business even being close. He had no business even being close. Here he is and this is not the best one. Well, and and let's let's stop here for a second, right? We also know. That from the account of Jesus's baptism that the Holy Ghost was represented by not a hawk. But it does. A bird, right? So it's not the first time an airborne creature was used to describe a divine being. Very, very good.

1:18:18 Very good. Can't get enough of the Mormon Renegade podcast? Well, good news, we're on Patreon and there's three packages that you can choose from. The first one, the Slightly Rowdy package, allows you to hear the podcast without all those pesky commercials getting in the way. For those who want a slightly more indepth experience, there's the Stirring It Up package where you can hear adfree audio, adfree video, and transcripts. Finally, for those who want to go full Renegade, that package is available to where you can get everything in the previous two packages, plus an extra show where myself and Ben Winfield break down the news of the day from a very Mormon point of view. You'll also get exclusive access to Renegade Chat, and on there you'll be able to talk to others about the show or whatever topics are on your mind. Go to Patreon today and get your exclusive content. Very, very good.

1:19:11 Very good facsimile. One figure 2. Abraham fastened upon an altar. Everybody says that's a joke. Well, we've already seen why it's not a joke, because we have a nearly identical authentic. For pirates, that names the person on the altar right as being Abraham, right? Yeah, going back to that Greek, that one that was that had the the Greek Greek script at the bottom that said Abraham. That one. No. No. Yeah, exactly. Go back to that last one, because I think there's something here we need to point out. And that is the bald head. Okay.

1:19:52 Now, if what was Abraham on a quest for? He was on a quest for priesthood, right? He wanted the blessings of the father, so that in turn would make him a priest. If this was fashioned by an Egyptian, which lends itself that it was fashioned by an Egyptian right, a bald head with denote. Abraham had some sort of priesthood lineage or priesthood standing. Oh, his bald head. Very interesting indeed. Yeah, I hadn't even thought about that. Now here's something else pointed out about this picture. The position of Abraham's hands is not, is not incidental, Abraham said.

1:20:42 Behold, I lifted up my voice to the Lord God. The sign illustrating Abraham's supplication to God is not only compatible with the message of the text, the upbraised hands. But it is an authentic hieroglyphic sign, properly used by a man who is accused of not knowing anything about Egyptian signs. So. Do I get the bell or the buzzer? You get the bell on that? One, you're no fun at all. The altar for sacrifice. And we talked about this already in defense of this idea. Experts have been unwilling to acknowledge that this item could be anything but an embalming table.

1:21:26 Certainly it can represent an embalming table, sure, but as a symbol it is not restricted to that interpretation. I mean, even the beds that they slept on were lying couches, so they were used for all kinds of things. And then we have the large alabaster tables that we looked at already. Photos of them again. Yep, go back to that. I got a question I want to ask you about that vignette. And no one's been able to answer this for me. Abraham appears, appears to be wearing something. If you look at his below the knee, he doesn't have the the the diagonal hatching that he has on his body. Have you been able to dig up anything on what that could be? I have failed.

1:22:18 I have no idea. None at all. I've never, I haven't read anything regarding his apparel. I have read you see the apparel that the priest is wearing. Yeah. That's a leopard skin K, which is what they really wore. Here's here's the other thing. If it's If this is embalming, why would they have clothes on a corpse? That's a good point. But here's the other thing, It might also have to do with just reproduction of these wood cuts. Gotcha. Let's go back. I want to go back to the original Pyri. Yeah, they're lines on the Pyri itself. It's not, it's not just an artifact of the woodcut. No.

1:23:10 Yeah, very good. It just struck me as odd. Right. Well, next time. Next time you visit, I expect an answer. Well, can I come to you for the answer? Well, it's in my head now. I just talk smack with a microphone. That's what I do. I get people way smarter than me on to talk about this stuff. But it's a gift, brother. It's a gift. All right. Now let's see. Couch. Yeah. Now we get to these figures beneath the lion Couch. Joseph Smith says the idolatros God of Elkanah, Idolatros, God of Libna Idolatros, God of Mackmara, and the idolatros God of Cora. Where in the heck is he pulling these names out of? They represent 4 canopic jars correctly identified by Joseph Smith as representing gods not very often in an embalming ceremony.

1:24:10 They were jars and then put the viscera. The guts of the embalmed into these jars, but there were also numerous examples of them. It's not being jars at all, being solid figurines like that. Right. Go back to that picture one more time, Ken. So I'm also noticing just looking here, there seemed to be some sort of writing on three of the four of those. It looks like 1/2 and on two of them and then like in or or a half a I should say it's got like that almost like the alpha sign yeah yeah and then like yeah and then like an N almost on the other. Any ideas have you been able to come up well the the. Compass and the square figure prominently in Egyptian culture as symbols of power and authority. And yeah.

1:25:11 OK, so, so yeah. You shoot from the hip on that, but yeah, you're ahead of me again. So I I don't know for sure. That's a good question and then very good question. Did Joseph hit those names correctly? Here we go, here we go. He correctly identified them as representing gods. How would he have known that? And he would have said those are just animal statues, right? Nibbly identified the names of these gods. Collectively called the Sons of Horus as gods, identified with the four lands adjacent to Egypt. These same gods are represented in the second facsimile, the Hypocephalus, where Joe's again hits a nail on the head. They're the same, only in a different context, so Elkana. So they're identified with the four lands that border Egypt, representing the cardinal directions. El Cannah is Canaan on the West, Libnah, Libya on the north, Momakura, Anatolia on the South, on the north, I'm sorry, I'm on the east, Canaan on the West, Libya on the north Anatolia and on the South Korosh or Kush.

1:26:25 The east, West, North and South orientation of these lands is consistent with the tradition that these sons of forest. Or guardians of the Pillars, which formed the four cardinal points. I'm sure it's just a coincidence. That's Bell. That's a bell ringer for sure. Ding I'm. Sure. It's just a coincidence, Ken. You're not playing my game, right? I'm sorry. I'm sorry. It is a hit. It is a hit. Now just say Ding Ding once. Let me hear what that sounds like. Ding, Ding. No, you don't do that anymore. Don't do that anymore. Fair. Enough. I was trying to save you from that, but you. So here they have in the exact same order.

1:27:07 These were not placed there by some Mormon. This is what you see from the British Museum, these four gods. Now, I think we haven't answered you a question about those marks. Those aren't marks that look like a sash. Yeah. Interesting. Now here's one of my favorite ones. Look at Figure 9, which Joseph Smith says is the idolatrous God of Pharaoh. That creature right there. It looks like an alligator or a crocodile. I would have said a mole because it's under the ground or something.

1:27:48 I didn't, doesn't. I didn't see alligator crocodile. Right. I'm just looking at the tip of the tail down there and it's. Got. Yeah. Yeah. Ohh, there you go. So Joseph, I could be wrong. But who in the right mind? Or say, oh, that's that's the God of Pharaoh, right? We know who that is. Egyptian history historians now know it's Sebek, or more contemporary, they call it Sobek the Crocodile, appropriately identified by Joseph Smith as the adulter scholar of Pharaoh, according to thebe and tradition, the capital of ancient Egypt, the pharaoh's claim upon the throne. Was based upon his relationship with the Crocodile God Civic, or Sobic, the Crocodile God who helped Horace take his seat upon the throne of his father, Osiris. Obviously, then, there is fitting reason to call Civic the God of Pharaoh.

1:28:39 Gotcha. That's a that's a big hit. Ding, Ding, Ding, Ding. How many, how many we going to give Joseph Smith before we say all right, OK, OK, he somehow knew this. How many? I think we're at that limit. What are we? I can't see we're. I think we're four out of four, yeah. Now, down here at the very bottom, these pillars still looking Why are pillars under the ground? I would never say that I would, I would just. I would think that wasn't just an artifact of decoration. Right. But the fact is that's commonly understood, so common.

1:29:20 No one has ever challenged, chose this misinterpretation of this before anything new. Anybody knew anything about Egyptology? These pillars are appropriately placed under the heavens. Oh, so Sobek, my daughter Scott of Pharaoh is in the heavens. What are the heavens doing underneath the cow? That's just what the Egyptians do. How would Joseph Smith know that what that guy had such an instinct guesser. It was amazing. Pretty good guesser. The pillars there, even though the heavens portrayed appear beneath the earth, but he nailed it straight up.

1:30:01 That's still not my favorite one though, so the author of this book from which I'm getting there was printed in 1987. It was really quite amazing. He concludes there is nothing no thing in the interpretation of Facsimile One or in the text of the first chapter of Abraham that is not appropriately represented by the Egyptian symbols. In this vignette one must also add that during the months of March and May of 1842, Joseph Smith published all the material that now constitutes the Book of Abraham in the times and seasons. That's that's where we got it.

1:30:42 Symbols that were damaged and replaced by Joseph Smith or by his inspiration. He was capable of making accurate and reasonable judgments concerning the meaning or form of the hieroglyphic science. It is difficult to believe that this outcome could be achieved by anyone except the prophet of God. Look, if you just start taking statistics right? Let's look at the sciences. Statistical probability. The fact that Joseph Smith is going to hit that right? And and look, it's not like he's hitting it in the day that this information is known. He's hitting this long before Egypt. Egyptology was really a thing, right? Yeah, and the other cool thing about it, I mean, Abraham has reference to the Restore Gospel, but the other aspects of it, like the four gods of the cardinal directions, doesn't have anything to do or Sobeck.

1:31:39 That doesn't have anything to do with the restored gospel. He was just showing off. It's not necessary knowledge. He was just, we've been able to do this one for give him a freebie, you know, that's crazy. I love this. I love this. We're going to start, by the way, when you look at this hypocephalus, which is Greek for under hypocephalus, the head. This amulet which is gone, you know where it is. It's ashes, I suppose. On this hypocephalus you will see vignettes or ideograms, and then you will see actual hieroglyphics.

1:32:26 The fact that we can read the hieroglyphics at all is a miracle, because the original scribe who knows what his penmanship was like, and then what was his name? Hedrick Headlock. The guy who did, who knows if his carvings were accurate, right? So when we get into Fact simile 3, there's actually an issue of how actually to interpret those. And to interpret them, you have to have some contextual ideas. So Egyptology is really if you're going to take a crack at it, you got to know some of that stuff. In any case, the outer ring of this amulet starts at the very top, and it's read counterclockwise. Joseph Smith said to be given in the own due time of the Lord, and that's what he said.

1:33:15 You'll see. That's Hieroglyphic. This section is hieroglyphic. This section is hieroglyphic. This section is hieroglyphic. He didn't interpret any of the hieroglyphs, said the same thing about all of them. In the own Due Time of the Lord. He did interpret all of the ideagrams, all of vignettes, which is very, also very interesting, but. What does that outer ring say? The inscription written around the outer edge of the the hypocephalus represents the Eye of RAW. So when you go to the Saint George tab on that Tavern, actually the Allseeing eye up on the wall, which weirds people out, that's the eye. That's the eye of God borrowed from. Yeah, it's on the dollar bill.

1:33:57 All this sort of stuff. The eye on the Joseph Hypo brought together the God Osiris, raw named Giebati. With the primal beginning in Heliopolis and the reenactment of the that creative moment in behalf of the deceased owner of the hypocephalus, what vicarious stuff? And the owner of the hypocephalus was Osiris Shashank. So his proper name was Shashank. Poor guy. Sorry, I'm going to go there. Well, that's really interesting. Is that he is added to his proper name, God's name. He's taken upon himself the name of God. Right, that sounds.

1:34:47 He's never heard of that. Thus, in doing so, Sheshank is identified with the gods. Which is what in subsequent discussions about the Gypsian Nadalla, that's very big deal. His very name, Debathi, is the name of the robing room. In the temples of Heliopolis and in both Karnak and Medina Abu that I talked about, you can't enter the temple until you've been washed, anointed and robed, clothed. But for some reason it sounds so familiar. Where have I heard that before? I can't remember. You're just imagining stuff. Right.

1:35:28 My bad, my bad. The temples of Heliopolis, the place of endowment, where he receives powers. And attributes of divinity, when we get to that other topic, there's a my favorite photograph in Hugh Nibley's Egyptian endowment of the initiate. At the end of making all of these covenants in that temple at the very end, before he enters the the throne room is what they call it. They call it the Holy Foleys if we're passing through the veil. It shows him embracing the God of the temple, a very specific embrace. And it says what the God of the temple is whispering in the ear of the initiate.

1:36:20 Any endowed latter day St. would read that and go Holy smokes. Yeah, yeah, the. The. Same stuff in the same. Order, look and. And here's the thing, right. We know, and this is the part of the story we didn't really go into, we know that Abraham was in Egypt for for a while, right? Even though we have an abbreviated version in in Genesis. And I would even say it's somewhat abbreviated in the Pearl of Great Prize, right? Of course it is. All of our scriptures are abbreviated all of them. We know that he taught them astronomy.

1:37:02 We know that he taught them many things, and I would imagine that Abraham, like any good minister of the Gospel, is looking for converts. He's doing his missionary work. And in so doing, if Abraham was really there, we should expect to see these things line up, right? We should expect to see echoes of the knowledge that was passed on. The number of mentions in ancient literature of Abraham in Egypt number in the hundreds, hundreds. There's a whole book about it about just that thing. Let's not forget that that Egypt, for whatever reason, seems to be very prominent throughout all of of the Hebrew scriptures.

1:37:52 Certainly right you have Joseph that gets sold into Egypt later becomes Egypt's hero. Then Egypt, you know, figures in prominently by enslaving the Hebrews. And then Christ goes back to Egypt. I shouldn't say back. He goes to Egypt as a young child to save his life. And so in, in many ways, we should very much expect to see these echoes coming out of Egypt, right? It seems to figure in very prominently within the Hebrew story. The book of Abraham, ironically, is the one that gives us the origin of Egypt, who found it, how they found it, and that Noah himself went there and blessed the first Pharaoh, and comment and praise the Pharaoh for being a wise and a just man.

1:38:49 And and that Pharaoh intentionally attempted to duplicate the order of the priest and of the fathers, even though he did not have that authority. He was still trying to do a good thing. So we asked why should there be any similarity between the early Egyptian rights and the Endowment? That's why. Right. That first Pharaoh was trying to duplicate it, and how would he know? Because he'd seen Noah do it. And and the implications for this are huge, which I think look most of the time I don't think it's a. Good. Ham knew it. Sorry. What's that? And Ham knew it. I'm sorry. I was. It's a. Was a big, big missing link and knew it initially.

1:39:31 Yeah, the the implications to this are huge. I don't feel like most of the time people who who try to say hey, but the book Abraham is false are sitting around a smoke filled backroom making the stories up. I mean, maybe there's a couple, but I think most people. Are just kind of playing right into the adversary's hands. Because here here's the thing. If this is what it appears to be, what I believe it to be, then the implications are massive, right. We we all of a sudden have record of an endowment that is ancient, right?

1:40:18 So many and and I think they try their best. So I don't want to bag on them as. As guys out there intentionally, you know, spreading falsehood. But I've I've heard some LDS scholars and some Mormon scholars claim that you know well, the LDS endowment is for us today. It doesn't have ancient roots. Well, I I beg to differ on this. If, if this is what it appears to be, and then we have all this other supporting evidence, the implications are huge. The implications then then become you can see the consistent. The way God has dealt with his children all the way through. Oh my goodness the the the temple rights are so foreign to modern humans they're so different.

1:41:07 President Nelson at a recent within the past few years, when he was prophet or when he Lolly was prophet at the end of the general Conference, he said. I testify, and this is out of the blue, unrelated to his talk, but he said I testify that our temple ordinances are of ancient origin. I got. I was like, yes, he's reading it too. This is awesome. He's no dummy. They know. And for me in in my book Right Under Temple Rights, I list all of the congruences. And every aspect of what we do is there. I you know, I don't connect the dots, so I don't give him anything away that I'm not supposed to. But that section of my book alone is 50 pages. And for me to read the most exciting ones are the accounts of Jesus Christ himself teaching temple rights to his disciples. I get so excited about doing that myself in the temple. Because I'm not just going through it out of a sense of duty.

1:42:21 I'm going through it with my eyes open, knowing full well that Jesus taught the very same things, the same covenants, the same symbols, the. Same clothing well and and they did. It they did it as anciently as Egypt for kind out love. Well, and and and here's an important thing too that that I have talked with a buddy of mine on on the podcast before, Joshua Erickson. Who seeks to keep a lot of Hebrewism alive within Mormonism? Is that Mormonism and he and and and the the Jewish religion share a lot of common traits, right? One of those traits are we come to know our ancestors through experience, right?

1:43:12 We try to experience the same things they did. Right. If you look at like the Passover, right, all those things are are are trying to get you to put yourself into their place. Now me and you, our views of Adam are going to be a little different. When are we going to have that conversation? We'll have it someday, but not. Today but. What what I'll say is, is no matter how you view Abraham, I mean, excuse me, Adam, you're putting yourself in his place through the endowment. It is a very Hebrew. It is a very Jewish way of teaching. And it predates the Jews.

1:44:00 Yes. Yes, that's. That's the thing I love about it. It's not tied to any culture. It's not tied to the Jews. It's not tied to the Egyptians. It's not tied to the Americans. It's consistent, and that's that. That's why. That's, I think, probably my favorite section of my book. You see that consistent thread running through all these different cultures, teaching the same exact covenants? Yep, same symbols, same verbiage. Yep. Same context. It's mind blowing. Same. Clothing, yeah. Yeah. It is so exciting to have that knowledge when you're doing it, and the fervor that you feel with that knowledge that you're not doing something phony, you're doing something that was instituted specifically by God to help you consciously choose to follow Him in very specific ways. I love that.

1:44:59 Speaking of that outer ring again, this translation of the text begins near the top of the outer ring, continues counterclockwise around the ring. Following is a transliteration and accompanying translation of that text by Egyptologist Michael Rhodes. I so starting up here I am Debati, who is adorned or clothed in the robing room in the house bend bend. In the house bend bend is the temple. So I am a Cyrus. I'm this God who is clothed in the robing room in the temple in Heliopolis. The House of Bendin was the temple of the office in which the Holy of Holies was occupied by the pyramid shaped Ben Ben stone which represents creation. So in the own due time of the Lord, well when you go to the temple, that's the time of Lord when you learn exactly what that outer ring is talking.

1:45:58 And we can talk more about some of these other Egyptian things, but in the interest of time. We won't, but it talks about the sacred taking upon yourself a Sacred Name facsimile 2 figure. What does that say? One. It's blocked by my zoom thing for signifying the first creation nearest to the Celestial or the residence of God. Is that Cola the God represented with the two ram horned heads? Is Numera, the Great Creator. Often portrayed at a Potter's wheel, fashioning human beings, Numera is he who shines upon the earth and is creator of all things. Then this guy sitting on a boat, That sceptre that he's holding is an Egyptian hieroglyph, a symbol of power. And I don't know a lot of Egyptian, but there are ones that you see over and over again that have particular significance.

1:47:05 I want to show you one just for just for fun. It is this one here. It's the looks like a cross but with a loop on it on the top that's called the Onk and that's the symbol of eternal life. That's fascinating. And what we will see in the Egyptian endowment conversation we'll have later is that when the initiate goes through the temple, their images of the God putting the onk in the initiates mouth, symbolic of bestowing eternal life, God sitting upon his throne clothes with power and authority, with a crown of eternal light upon his head, representing also the grand keywords. Of the holy priesthood, Egyptologist will save the hawkheaded raw with the sun disk on his head. Sun disk crown of eternal light.

1:48:08 Yeah. Seated on the solar bark, which we're going to learn the significance of later in his hand he holds the scepter, symbol of dominion power, God sitting upon his throne. With a crown of, he turned a light upon his head. Wow, he's good. He's a pretty good guesser. This is my favorite one. All right, I'm going to give you a stab. Use the spirit. Tell me what Figure 4 is.

1:48:49 See I This is why I would make a crappy profit. Right, but that's my point. Who would? I mean, you know, if you if we were just taking a stab at this. Well, it looks like a hood ornament to me on a rocking chair. I don't know, it's just dumb stuff. Well, this is and and here, here's the other thing, right, is that it's not like Joseph was kind of like, well, maybe it means this. He was bold, right? He put it out there. Very succinctly, yeah. He he put his rear out there and said no, no, that's what that is right, and said it with confidence and with with conviction, not knowing it wouldn't be proven correct for 100 years or better.

1:49:38 Yes, yes, yes. Because I mean, if you were just faking it, surely somebody's going to find out about it sooner or later, right? So this symbol signifies 2 things. Expanse or the firmament of the heavens and also Egyptian, meaning 1000. How the hell do we get that? Egyptologists say the mummified hawk is what it is, is a symbol of the sky or as a representation of the expanse of heaven with wings outstretched while there's one? The SEC Air boat that it's sitting on is called the Ship of 1000.

1:50:28 Stop. Wow. That's a. That's a double. That's a double bonus. That's a hell of a bull's eye. Wow. Let's let's assume that he was only kind of close with the others, but nailed this one. It would still make you squint and go. How did he do that? Yeah. And here we have the sons of Horace again, which here he labels the earth and it's four quarters. Does he mean by the four quarters? OK, so yeah, tying right back. To the the border cardinal direction. Yeah, OK.

1:51:16 So he and the author of the book, he said. The consistency between those two is stunning. That's another lucky guess. Now now let me ask you this, is there any significance that that portion of of of the vignette there is like inverted? I read once, I think it's just, I don't think so. I think it's just because it's on the bottom and I think that, well, if you go around the ring on the circle I'm pointing with my finger, you can't see that. And those hieroglyphs are upside down also, so maybe I don't know. I don't. If there is a significance, I'm not aware of it.

1:51:59 Now we get to the most controversial facsimile of all, facsimile #3. Abraham's sitting on Pharaoh's throne. Not only that, he's gender confused, he's calling girls boys, but fit right in today. The Figure 1. Abraham sits upon Pharaoh's throne by the plights of the king with a crown upon his head, representing the priesthood as emblematic of the grand presidency in heaven, with the scepter of justice and judgment in his hand. There are enough instances where Abraham appears in context normally occupied by Osiris that we must conclude Egyptians did see some sort of connection between Pharaoh and Abraham. It is especially noteworthy, as seen above, that Abraham appears as a substitute for Osiris in ways associated with the judgment of the dead or a postmortem declaration. Of the deceased's worthiness, this next one was probably the weirdest one of all, boy or girl. I mean, look, it's a.

1:53:31 Girl, it's a girl. And look, she's got the onk in her hand. The key to return alive anyway. What's that say? I can't see his son whose name is given in the characters above his head, can you? What is that? I can't even remember what I put there and look it up real quick. With the idea of the Great Lady Isis actually personifying the throne and not. At the very top. In fact similar 3 Figure 2 something something whose name is given. And the characters above his head.

1:54:11 King oh, King Pharaoh, King Pharaoh. So Joseph is taking this girl and double whammied himself. No, this is King Pharaoh and whose name is given in the characters above his head, which people have interpreted. We've read that. And it doesn't say Pharaoh. It says ISIS. What's going on with the idea of the great Lady Isis actually personifying the throne and thereby the Egyptian kingship? The incongruity?

1:54:53 Because there's precedent that ISIS represents kingship. The the incongruity of Joseph Smith's identification. Figure 2. In fact, simile as king, Pharaoh begins to dissolve. But I read something very interesting. That's another possibility. And I I remember getting I got this off of some debate page and I couldn't source it again. I'm glad I copied it. But these aren't my words. I've had them quotations, but I don't know who was that said it because it's as the Internet goes, it's gone. Right. It makes it very interesting point. Here's what Joseph Smith actually said.

1:55:35 In his Facsimile 3, Figure 2 Explanation King Pharaoh whose name is given in the characters above his head, Joseph's use of the word head in Figure 2 should stick out like a sore thumb, in contrast to his use of the word hand in other instances. And all the other figures he said the name is above their hand. It's above their hand. It's above their hand. In the case of figure two, he didn't say that. In figures four and five, Joseph refers to the characters above the hand and above his hand respectively. But in figure two, he says above his head, not above his hand. If Joseph wanted to refer to the characters above figure Two's hand, he could have said hand like he did in the other cases, but he didn't.

1:56:24 So what is above figure Two's head that? So his. Name. His name is given in the characters above his head. The characters above the hand don't give the name of Pharaoh, but the characters above the head give some interesting convergences with Joseph explanation. The symbol is a sun disc with horns which often represents the House of Horace, Egypt and Horace is who the king. Egyptologists might not recognize it as representing that in this context, but it does nevertheless have that underlying meaning, thus giving a convergence with the name of Pharaoh, which is Horace. As Joseph Smith said, that's cool. That was not too long ago.

1:57:18 I learned that that was really neat. Oh, Figure 5, that stupid hat. Hey, I would wear that hat in public. I would pay for you to wear that hat and take a photograph. Shulam signifying the the principal waiters Shulam so he act. Joseph actually gives a name to this character Shulam as John G has documented this name. Shulam where did he get that name? Probably a neighboring town in upstate New York or something. Ohio, Yes.

1:58:01 Shulum, Ohio, right? No doubt, As John Gee has documented, this name is widely attested in Semitic languages from the time of Abraham. That's like kidding, the bullseye of the bullseye. This includes attestations in Old Acadian, Old Assyrian, Old Babylonian, Middle Babylonian. Ebli, eit and Ugoritic, so that name was all over the place. Why? Additionally, Shulam's title The King's Principal Waiter is arguably attested in ancient Egypt. In particular, the title Butler of the Ruler is a fairly close match to King's principal waiter and is attested during the time of Abraham.

1:58:59 Man, he hit 3 targets in a row. Bam, bam bam just by pulling the name Shulam out of the hat. Yeah, and it's so random, right? I mean, it's not like it's not even one of the primary players, if you will. Right. It's not significant to the plan of salvation. He's just showing off. He's not showing off. He's just. What has impressed me in my studies over the years? You know, you always believe in inspiration, revelation. But what I have learned about the revelation given to Joseph Smith is how specific it is. The degree of specificity is down to the very text, to the very word, to the very spelling of a word, when I can recognize in the Dead Sea Scrolls a phrase from the veil at the temple.

1:59:56 As being almost identical in context and in order. Revelation is very specific, right down to the names. So back up there a second. Up there above everybody's heads and hands, you see all the inscriptions? Do we know what any of those mean? I'm sure we do. And I was. I knew that you were going to ask me something that I was not prepared to answer and that's one of them. I I haven't. I don't have anything identifying what those hieroglyphs, because they're hieroglyphs of those are. Except for the except for the one who identifies ISIS. Anyway, in the opening chapter, the Book of Abraham mentions a location named the plane.

2:00:50 Of Olesham. There's Joseph Smith making up names again like his crazy Book of Mormon names. Core horror. Aha, right? That's in Abraham chapter one, verse 10. This plane of Olesham was near according to the book Fair, was near Abraham's homeland of or of the Chaldees according to the Book of Abraham in 1985. That was a good year for me. The latterday St. archaeologist named John Lundquist published a pioneering article situated the Book of Abraham in a plausible ancient geographical and cultural environment in northern Mesopotamia. Among the points discussed by Lundquist was the plausible identification of Olysham, identifying where the planes were, identifying it with an ancient place name called Ulyssum or Ulyssum.

2:01:47 Lindquist pointed to inscriptional evidence dating to the time of the Acadian King not on sin, who reigned around the time of. Abraham. Which spoke of Ulasam in what is today northern Syria or southern Turkey. Furthermore, in 2013 non LDS excavators at the Turkish site of Oyla Moroyuk near the Syrian border. Announced that it was the ancient Ulasham mentioned in the inscription of not on scene, and identified it as the city of Abraham.

2:02:31 Oh, that's nuts. You had enough. I think this is my last section. You know, again, we look at this. And I don't want anyone who's listening or watching to take for granted how absolutely stupid the idea is that somebody from the 1830s is going to have that. It's, it's it's absolutely asinine. But yet there it is. Right? Not backed up by some remote Hebrew scholar somewhere by modern day Egyptologist.

2:03:14 Who? Who see the same who who come back to prove Joseph Smith correct with no vested interest in doing so. Yeah. Now take what you just said. Add to that an unprecedented knowledge of ancient American culture and archaeology, plus ancient knowledge that no one else had of Enoch or Moses that is verified. I mean, that's. My stupid book 179 of those teachings that came to us through Joseph Smith have been attested thousands of times in books that he had zero access to.

2:04:02 And that's why Joseph Smith was so good. Because if I had that kind of capability, you bet you I'd be visiting a bookie. And that's what was cool about him, too. He didn't didn't abuse it. Well, no, he didn't really care about money and stuff. He cared about money in regard to building up with the Kingdom. He's always giving his away. He was terrible with money, but I have to like that. All right, so this will take you straight out of my book. Some of these special proof is in the pudding and Abraham won 1516. Abraham says. I lifted up my voice unto the Lord my God, Lord Harkin had heard.

2:04:44 He filled me with the vision of the Almighty. The Angel of his presence stood by me. So he's, he's being sacrificed, right? And this happens. And immediately unloosed my bands, and his voice was unto me. Abraham, Abraham, behold, my name is Jehovah and I have heard thee. There is a ancient authentic text called the Apocalypse of Abraham. A little bit about it, because it's referred to a lot. Very exciting. The Apocalypse of Abraham survives in six manuscripts written in Old Slavonic, although the Slavonic version of the Apocalypse of Abraham was made in the 11th or 12th century AD, The original language of the Apocalypse of Abraham is Hebrew and was most likely composed in Palestine at the end of the 1st century.

2:05:38 Very old. And again, it's most likely a copy of the original account. Original account of Abraham. This is what it says. Look how it's sorry Apocalypse of Abraham was not translated by a Mormon. And it came to pass. I had this conversation with my good Christian friend who was making fun of the 1300 and some and it came to passes in the Book of Mormon. I said, you know what that means, right? The further back you go in time, the closer you get to Egyptian culture, the more and it came to pass, you see, showing up the literature because that's how they wrote, because they had no punctuation. And then and So what happened?

2:06:29 And it came to pass and it came to pass as I was thinking things like these with regard to my father Tara, in the court of my house. The voice of the mighty One came down from heavens in a stream of fire, filler of fire, saying and calling Abraham, Abraham. And later on then a voice came speaking to me twice. Abraham, Abraham, not just. Any chance any chance that Joseph Smith had access to the Apocalypse of Abraham 0? Zero. It hadn't been discovered yet. The only of of these, all of these ancient texts I I cite 66 in my book.

2:07:18 The only one that been translated into English during Joseph Smith's lifetime was First Enoch in 18. It had been translated in 1821 by an Episcopalian. A priest who was castigated for it for me, and it sat in manuscript form, gathering dust until after Joseph Smith knew about it, It being translated into English and published by trying to remember off the top of my head, I think by the late 1830s. But there is no possible way he had access. The first Enoch.

2:08:07 Before, then before the Book of Mormon. Doctrine Covenants, Pro great Price. All of those predate that. And the sudden the Book of Abraham starting to seem a lot more durable than what a lot of people were. Hoping I know so many people run away from it, but the evidence for it is overwhelming. But it's so obscure that nobody wants to touch it. I mean, because you got to dig. And the debates, the discussions, the criticisms are a little bit convoluted. Because of the ancient Egyptian stuff. But the evidence is all in favor in Abraham chapter one, verse two, what we were talking about earlier. Abraham desires great knowledge. I sought for the blessings of the fathers and the right, where unto I should be ordained to administer the same, having been myself a follower of righteousness, desiring also to be one who possessed great knowledge. And to be a follower of righteous, and to possess a greater knowledge, and to be a father of many nations that are Prince of peace, desiring to receive instructions and to keep the commands, God, I became a rightful heir, a high priest holding the right, belonging to the fathers. In another ancient apocryphal text of Abraham called The Testament of Abraham, it says.

2:09:25 And now I'm asked. Lord, heed my plea. Well, I am. Yet in this body I wish to see all the inhabited world. And all the created things which you established master through one word. And when I have seen these things, then if I depart from life, I shall have no sorrow. He wanted to see that vision that was granted. And to Moses and others he learns astronomy from God, according to the book of Abraham. I Abraham had the German thumb of which God, which the Lord my God had given unto me. And or of the Kaldis. And I saw the stars that they were very great. One of them was nearest the throne of God, and there were many great ones which were near onto it. Astronomy.

2:10:08 Apocalypse of Abraham I the Angel will ascend on the wings of birds. That sounds like something we we saw just a few moments ago, right? To show you, Abraham, what is in the heavens, on the earth, and in the sea, and in the abyss, and in the lower depths. In the Garden of Eden and in its rivers, in the fullness of the universe, And you will see its circles, which I would interpret as orbits. Right? All Abraham receives the Angel from God, which you read about. And so it happened here. And behold, there was no breath of man. And my spirit was amazed.

2:10:50 My soul fled for me. I became like a stone. I fell face on the earth. There was I was no longer strength to stand up, and while I was faced out on the ground or heard the voice speaking, go EOL of the same name through the me. So this is God sending the Angel whose name is EOL through the mediation of my ineffable name Christ consecrate this man Abraham for me and strengthen him against his trembling the Angel he sent to me in the likeness of a man. Came and he took me by my right hand, and stood me on my feet, and said to me, Stand up, Abraham, friend of God, who has loved you, Let human trembling nod and fold you.

2:11:34 For though I am sent to you, to strengthen you, to bless you in the name of God, Creator of heaven and earth, I thinks who has loved you. Be bold and hastened to him. I am EOLI was called so by him who causes those with me on the 7th. Expands, or as Paul called it, the 7th heaven on the firmament to shake a power through the immediate ineffable name. In me Abraham seeks one true God. You are searching for the God of gods, the Creator, in the understanding of your heart. I am he, I am. And here again, here I am.

2:12:16 The old desire for I am the I am before the world and mighty, the God who created previously, before the light of the age, and so on and so forth. Because you desired to search for me, and I called you my beloved. How was this showing him the last days? And he may see the whole world Abraham.

2:13:01 Here's the very significant reference that in in in the facsimile #3 where Abraham sitting on the throne and teaching astronomy to Pharaoh's court. In this text pseudo Eupole Eupolemus. Abraham lived in Heliopolis where the temple is. With the Egyptian priests and taught them much. He explained astrology and the other sciences to them, saying that the Babylonians and he himself had obtained this knowledge. However, he attributed the discovery of them to Enoch. Enoch first discovered astrology, not the Egyptians. Did you mean astronomy or isn't?

2:13:49 Well, they say astrology, but in the ancient. In the ancient world, I think they were very, I mean, they were inevitable. You couldn't really talk about one without talking about the other. So, all right, so summing this all up, John Gee, how could Joseph Smith have known this material? Joseph Smith published the Book of Abraham in 1842. It was 1851. When Heinrich Brusch first translated a hieratic papyrus into a European language, that was the first time anybody had translated Egyptian.

2:14:30 It was 1852, when Emmanuel the Rouge translated the first hieroglyphic inscription into a modern language. The inscriptions that tell us about the Egyptians ruling over ancient Syria and Abraham's Day was first published in 2008. The first inscription mentioning Olsen, was published in 1928. The A Dreamy autobiography was first published in 1949. The Reality of Human SAC. We didn't even talk about that. Book of Abraham says that Egyptians practiced human sacrifice. Everybody goes. No, they didn't. They kind of did. The reality of human sacrifice in ancient Egypt was established in 1993. The work on covenants was first put together in 2012. And our knowledge of the Canaanite dynasties in Egypt came in 1997.

2:15:23 So Joseph Smith published the Book of Abraham about 160 years too early. He could not have known about these things, and we can't compare them to those things because the Book of Abraham is true. Carrie Milstein. Each of the three Egyptian representations or facsimiles Joseph Smith said were associated with Abraham actually was associated with him by ancient Egyptians. No plausible explanations have been posed for the many striking consistencies in the Book of Abraham with non biblical traditions regarding Abraham.

2:16:07 A few such traditions that were not known in Joseph Smith's day, but which agree with the Book of Abraham are that one. Those who were disrupting the worship of idols in Abraham society were killed. 2. Abraham prayed for deliverance when he was about to be killed because of his disruption vital worship. Three, the priest or leader who was trying to kill him was killed instead. 4 Abraham was heir to the priest of because of his father's. 5 Abraham possessed to German thummim What 6 people think like Mormons invented the concept of German thump. I know. I know that. And why that is I do not know, but it's mentioned in the Old Testament. Yeah, it's obscure, but it's there. 6 Abraham possessed records of his father's seven There was a famine in Abraham's homeland 8 and Haram died in in the famine. The fact that Joseph Smith did not know of these details and other similarities from ancient sources, yet they agree so well with ancient sources is striking understatement of the evening. That's all I have to say.

2:17:16 Okay. So I feel like you've given the audience enough ammo that they can stand up to anybody on this issue. This was thorough, This was well done and well thought out. Thank you. Thank you for that. But let me ask. I do I I forgot people who want to source this stuff for themselves. There are two simple resources. The first one is easy and absolutely free. Pearl of great price central.org. Yeah, Dang it. Org or com prorate price central.com. 111 or the other I mean.

2:18:05 Yeah. Anyway, that gives all this stuff with pictures. It's beautiful. And it talks about Book of All and it's amazing. The other is John Geese, brief and insightful An Introduction to the Book of Abraham where he talks about all of these items with pictures. So. Ken would the book Mormon Doctrine in the Apocrypha and a concordance of the teachings. Oh, and another book. Let me show you that picture. Would that be there too? I'm just curious. Here's a nice book.

2:18:46 That one right there. Where would somebody find that book? Well, if they come to my house, I'll give them a copy. Or you can get it on Amazon. I would go to Amazon and can you have me to talk about being a capitalist when we're done with this one? It's a funny little book and it has a really long title, but it's full of fascinating things that I didn't write. I found them. So let me ask you this. Like I said, this was well thought out, this was well done. You really did your homework on this. What would you tell someone who came to you and said, look, I'm really struggling with this Book of Abraham thing because even though this was well put together, if if you just throw this at them, you're going to overwhelm them, right?

2:19:31 So how, how, how do we navigate those waters with people then when they're having those kind of doubts? The first thing I say to people like that is, well, a couple of things. Number one, you're not the first person to have these questions. People have been studying these issues for decades. I began my study of it in 1987 and before #2. There are answers for every single one of these issues, and they are free to access.

2:20:15 The other resource I forgot is Fair Latter Day st.com. Fair Latter day saints.org.com. Well, I'm such an idiot. Oh well, I've been. I've been here. Let me find it here because I have sources all over the place in here. Pearl of Great Price central.org is the one. And fair Latter Day Saints together, they deal with every single Dow, every single question. They give thorough and scholarly answers, and they're not rude about it, you know, they're they're very scholarly. They intend to be scholarly.

2:21:02 The second the third thing is find somebody, I mean. The first reassurance is you need to know that these questions have already been answered many times by people far smarter than any of us and who've spent their lives and professionals who have studied this out. OK, and the the third thing is you of course, as the questioner, are free to live as you choose. And I will fight for your right to do that. All I would say is I hope that you make those decisions in an informed way, so you don't jump to a life's choice and later come to learn that you had been to see, right.

2:21:56 So take, just slow down, take your time. It's very important not only to find the online resources, but to find someone you can trust. To hear you out, and to not judge you, and to not. But who has experience with this these things, so they can calmly guide you through the questions and at the very least give you the other side of the story. Absolutely. I then then make your choice, Yeah. I I deal with. With probably 3 to 4 emails a week with people really struggling with their testimony of the gospel as a whole and and my first piece of advice is, I know it feels like your world is collapsing, but just breathe and sit with that for a moment right? I I've also told people the fact you're asking questions shows a level of maturity.

2:22:57 The questions are good. They are good. You should ask those questions because if you are basing your life around this, you should absolutely ask some very pointed questions to make sure that it's true. And there are answers to everything except why Abraham was wearing striped clothing. We don't know that somebody, I'm going to get somebody, does his. Taylor His Taylor needs to be brought to justice for that. But. But but. But look, as as Ken and I have said, don't take our word for it, right, We'll point you in a direction, right. Here's all the data.

2:23:37 Go look at it. Anybody who tell comes to you. And this, and this is my other big warning, anybody who comes to you and says authoritatively, you can just take what I say here. Yeah, I never trust anybody who says trust me. Right. No. Don't trust anybody. Don't trust me. I'm a clown with a microphone. Right. I'm in between me and Ken. You can probably hit your wagon to Ken a little bit, but don't. Don't do it to me. You're going to be sorely, sorely disappointed. But don't allow yourself to to be coopted by somebody else's movement, is the other thing I'd say. Yeah, right.

2:24:18 Do your own homework and do an honest assessment. By honest assessment, like we said at the beginning, if you haven't examined both sides or all sides of a question or an issue, you're not prepared to make an informed decision. No. And and you're you're very nice. You keep saying that people aren't out there trying to deceive you. There's a few. I'm not the most part that's true, but I I will quote to you. The one of the founders of exmormon.org said that he fantasized those. These are his words. He fantasized about a full blown faith destroying session with Mormons or. Well my first thought is is once he discovers girls his fantasies will go other places but.

2:25:09 Well, that along those lines, a less sophisticated that a student or a friend of my ward. Did in high school. Had a friend in high school who said I want to break as many Mormon girls as I can. Geez. So yeah, there's some for sure. And. Look, I don't, and I don't think there are few. You don't. No, I want to. Believe the best, right? I I do. Well, I appreciate that Satan seeks to sift us as wheat. Right. He's saying he's not going after sinners, he's going after good people.

2:25:52 He's the Destroyer. And he has minions, some of whom are doing it cognizantly, some of them who are doing so ignorantly and out of selfishness. But we have to. We have to How does Paul put in Ephesians? Work out our own salvation with fear and truth gird. Yourselves, gird yourselves with the armor of God, the helmet of salvation, right breastplate of righteousness, your feet shot with the preparation of peace, and most of all, the sword of truth. You know, I go back to something that Thomas Jefferson once said, and he was writing a letter. I could, I could be misquoting here, but I believe it was his nephew.

2:26:42 His parents had died and he was he was of age, but he was still a young man, and Jefferson wrote him this letter. And he said, look, when it comes to mathematics, know these when studying philosophy. Know this in matters of religion, question with boldness the very existence of God, because God would surely welcome honest questioning over blindfolded fear. I also agree with what Jay Ruben Clark once said, which is if we have the truth, we shouldn't, we shouldn't be bothered with this idea of scrutiny, right? Because if it's true, it can't be harmed.

2:27:24 And if it's not true, well, it kind of should, right? But the key there. Nothing to fear in the truth. Right the the the key there is to do honest research. Right. Do not. Do not start with. Well this has to be false. So I'm going to look for that evidence, right. Start with the the If you're honestly questioning go with that. You don't know that's okay. Listen to to the anti Mormon side. Listen to the evidence Ken just laid out and then make your decision. But. Sometimes it's also a matter of being brutally honest with yourself, right? I have.

2:28:08 I have friends who have left the faith because they wanted they they wanted the great and spacious building and everything that goes along with that and the anti Mormon criticisms were convenient way for them to do that. And you know what? That's okay too. I mean God will force no man to heaven. Your will, your will is the one thing God will never force himself upon. He'll He'll part the Red Sea. He will cause miracles to happen, man in a fall from heaven, but will never violate your free will.

2:28:53 Yeah, the self determination. Yeah, the self determination has been the rule from from eternities. I mean, it is the Prime Directive, right? Right. You have the right to choose your own destiny, and God will never forego that because guess what? It doesn't work. Nope, never has and it never will. So, well, Ken, this was awesome. And for everyone listening, Ken and I have a few other subjects we're going to broach together throughout the year that I think you guys are going to be very interested in hearing. So. So stay tuned for all that. Ken, is there anything else you wanted to say as we we wrap this up?

2:29:40 Just thank you. Thank you. Sometimes I wish we could just sitting around as a big group and just about it, you know? I know. But the thing I love about this is, especially with the slides that there's I prepared for almost anything in the discussion because I got all my ducks in a row and and just the opportunity to. Review all this literature and put it down in one big presentable package. There's a lot of work, but a lot of fun and exhilarating. Exhilarating. My my stupid skeptical mind. It keeps reverting to the skepticism. Not like I quit or have doubts of that sort of thing, but your mind gets calloused because you forget.

2:30:23 But when you go over these things point by point, all in one sitting, it is overwhelming. Right. Overwhelmingly exciting to think that the restored gospel and the plan of salvation and eternal life and exaltation potentially is our destiny. It's absolutely it's the truth. Absolutely. It's not the greatest fairy tale ever told. No, no. And and yeah. Yep. No, I agree with you wholeheartedly. And I can't deny it. Even if I wanted to, even if I was the guy who protected the fruit of the tree of fruit of the tree of life and said no, I'm going to go to the great spacious building. Even if I was that guy, I could not deny the truth of what I know and it would would not go well for me knowing all that. But fortunately, as I was telling my son in school class, I like being with.

2:31:28 Other Saints, I love the goodness. I like being a faithful husband. I like trying to be a good dad and loving my kids and having a my wife is my best friend and all that entails and looking forward to an eternity of goodness and service. To the extent that I'm able, you know? Right. And and especially looking forward. My My secret dream is that the Millennium will come and save me from becoming old and decrepit. I have. I don't know. I just. Well, I think it's to. Raise your kids in the Millennium. How cool would that be?

2:32:09 Well, right. As far as old and decrepit, I will say I I always defer back to what Indiana Jones said. It's more about the mileage than the years, so but awesome. Well, Ken, dude, great stuff as always. I appreciate it, man. My pleasure. Thank you, David. All right. Bye everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.