Episode #31: Answers to Mormon Fundamentalist Questions W/ William Dummkopf, Michael Ness, & Jacob Vidrine
So I have a question….What happens when a Lutheran interested in Mormonism has a discussion with three Mormon fundamentalists? Well you are about to find out. A few months back I had a man named Billy reach out to me with some questions about Mormonism, Fundamentalism, and the LDS Church. Now one of the things I like about Billy is that he is an honest seeker. He wants to understand without playing “gottcha games”. Billy eventually had the idea of wanting to come on the podcast and ask some questions about Mormon Fundamentalism. Now because I like Billy I thought he deserves to talk to someone way smarter than a clown with a microphone so I reached out to two guys way smarter than me Michael Ness and Jacob Vidrine. So on this episode myself, Billy Michael and Jacob sit down and answer Billy’s questions. We end up having a fascinating conversation and deep diving on some pretty interesting topics.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:04 So, I have a question. What happens when a Lutheran interested in Mormonism? Has a discussion with three, Mormon fundamentalist, well, stick around because you're about to find out a few months back. I demand named Billy, reach out to me with some questions about Mormonism, fundamentalism and the LDS church. Now, one of the things I like about Billy is that he is an honest Seeker. He wants to understand without playing quote, gotcha Games, Billy eventually have the idea of wanting to come on the podcast and ask some of those questions. About Mormon fundamentalism now because I like Billy, I thought he deserves to talk to someone way smarter than a clown with a microphone. So I reached out to two guys, way smarter than I am and that's Michael NASA and Jacob the dream.
0:45 So on this episode myself Billy Michael and Jacob sit down and answer Billy's questions. We end up having a fascinating conversation and deep diving on some pretty interesting topics. And that's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast. So, I just want to take a moment to thank you. The Listener, when I started this podcast I wasn't sure if anyone would really listen. Now to my surprise, this thing has taken on a life of its own and that's all due to you the listener, spending your time here with me, and it means a great deal to me now, as a husband and father, I'm keenly aware of how important time is. It feels like there's just never enough of it. So when you are spending your time here, listening to this podcast, I feel a responsibility to never waste your time in that Spirit as this podcast has grown. I feel like I need to do you The Listener. Just This, I want to continue to produce good content and upgrade the audio quality that takes better equipment and better software and that all takes money. Now, I've tried to advertise, but you'd be surprised. There's not a lot of people want to advertise on a Mormon fundamentalist podcast.
1:52 I know surprising right now if you want to help support the podcast, you can do that. One of two ways. The first is go over to Mormon Renegade.com and hit the Donate tab there. You can make a one-time donation or you can go ahead. And set it up to be a monthly recurring, donation your choice entirely now. Option number two because I'm a capitalist. If you want to head on over to Mormon Renegade.com, click on the store button. You're going to find that. We've got some new swag out, we got some T-shirts, we have a tote, we have cell phone cases, water bottles, coffee cups. We got a bunch of stuff in Morse going to be on the way. So if you feel like that's something you could do again, head on over to Mormon Renegade and check all that stuff out.
2:36 If you're not in that position to do. So I completely understand. We're all squeezed right now with high gas prices and high inflation. So even if you can't please keep listening and maybe keep the podcast in your prayers, so we can continue to grow produce. Good content and better audio quality. Thank you. Your listing to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Welcome back to the Mormon Renegade podcast as always you can get ahold of me either by email at Mormon Renegade at gmail.com.
3:34 You can also get a hold of me on Instagram and Twitter and getter under the handle. Mormon Renegade. Also we have a website up and that's Mormon Renegade.com, so go check that out. Okay, so on today's episode, I've been super excited for this. And for about a month. And the reason it is, is I get to talk to three people who I just enjoy talking to you about, I would say, Two months ago, a gentleman and we'll just call him Billy reached out to me with some questions about fundamentalism now, Billy's, not a Mormon of any stripe.
4:14 He's he's he is Lutheran if I'm not mistaken and Billy you can correct me if I'm wrong there. But he's fascinated by the restored gospel and these ideas that are presented in the restored gospel. And what I find. So refreshing about Billy is that he is a Honest Seeker, right. He's not someone out here with an agenda. He's not trying to trip anybody up. He just wants to know and I dig that and I can totally get behind that. So, we talked it, you know, as I try to answer his questions, he kind of started listening to the podcast a little bit and said, you know, maybe we should do this on the podcast and I was like, that's good, but I was thinking Billy deserve someone way smarter than me. So that's why I brought on Michael Ness and Jacob the dream because they're both way smarter than I am. And so there, what we're going to do is Billy's got some questions and at we're going to go through those questions and we're Michael and Jacob are going to take turns answering and we're going to have a discussion on them. So this is unlike anything I've ever done before, but I think it's going to be absolutely amazing. So, with that first, Lee.
5:32 Thanks a lot for being here, man. I really, really appreciate it. And again, I think you're cool. Just, you know, because you're an honest Seeker, you don't have an agenda and I think that's so refreshing. Thanks, Don. I appreciate it. My quarter being here. Well, I'm glad Michael. I'm I'm always glad to talk to you brother. You're you're you and Jacob are some of my favorites because you guys are just one you're good, guys. You know, your stuff and I just enjoy the heck out of here. And you. So thanks for being here, fellas. I'm glad to be here as well. Can't wait good to be on. All right. Fantastic. All right, well, let's just get into it Billy, why don't you? Go ahead and ask your first question and then we'll let Michael take the opening crack at answering these questions. Sure.
6:22 All right, so let's just start with the basics and just on the outset as Dave mentioned, this is not me trying One up anyone. This is not overly polemical. This is just me trying to understand what you guys believe and so to start, I would ask. What is the gospel? All right. Hopefully, my I have the strength to my voice to carry on this whole deal. I've been feeling a bit under the weather, so I throw that out there in the first place, but I'll actually love this question. And I wrote something out on this because in fundamentalism, I find that because so many for generations of East, on certain things like polygamy. Certain key, Cornerstone gospel, tenants have not been taught and perpetuated.
7:11 And so, the gospel in a nutshell I would say, is first faith in Jesus Christ, and in his atonement, his sacrifice, the second principle is repentance from your sins. The third is receiving baptism and Confirmation by the gift of the Holy Ghost, by the legal administrators holding the priesthood. And then from that point, it's enduring To the end of your life. By keeping your covenants, keeping the Commandments that God has given to the scriptures and learning how to love the Lord, with all your heart, might mind and strength, learning, to love your neighbor as yourself. And I like to apply what Peter says. And the second Peter first chapter where he says, add to your faith virtue to Virtue knowledge, and to knowledge Temperance, and to Temperance, patience and to patience godliness and to Godliness.
8:04 I'll do this brotherly kindness and to brotherly kindness charity. And then what James says to visit the fatherless and the widows in their Affliction and to keep himself unspotted from the vices of the world to me, that is a comprehensive view of what the gospel teaches you to do socially with your life. That's the good news of the Gospel. You're becoming more christ-like in your, in your identity if you apply those principles. And it's, that's the gospel. Yeah, that's the gospel of Christ, in a nutshell And I will, I'll leave that there. Cool. Now is someone else going to?
8:44 And think that if we're okay, go ahead. Yeah I thought that was, I thought it was a great overview, just perfect overview laying out, you know, in a concise summary what it is. I would say just to add just a few other perspectives to it, I would add that. I think that the good news, the gospel means, good news of Jesus Christ. Is that You can be Sanctified and cleansed from our sins through Jesus. Christ's atonement. And that through that helmet, we can receive a Celestial. Resurrection, if we strive to keep his Commandments and, and really have that relationship with Jesus Christ through his teachings and the ordinances of the gospel. And so, really, you can say the gospel is, I would say in Mormonism, we have what we would call this the First principles of the Gospel, there are other principles that pertain to Mormonism but are more higher principles. We also, so, you could basically say there's a gospel of Salvation and a gospel of exaltation and a lot of the things, some people will say the Book of Mormon, does it contain everything unique about, Mormon Doctrine? If you've read the book of Mormon, you're going to be like, this is just, you know, a lot of the basic stuff that mostly you can find in the New Testament.
10:02 And the reason for that is it's just restating the gospel of salvation It's not getting into any of the higher teachings. It's kind of what I would say. All you is, is, did you feel like you had a good answer off that oars or heck? Yeah. Heck yeah. Now that was great and and this will kind of maybe bleed into the next question a little bit. And certainly as a Lutheran this is kind of maybe a fundamental perspective and this comes the question of baptism and so what exactly is baptism? I know like as Christians have different takes on that but as a Lutheran, we view baptism as the Forgiveness of sins. And so what is that? As in from your perspective.
10:45 Well, my on the early Mormons understood that baptism, is it states in the New Testament? That baptism is for the remission of sins and that is fundamentally. What baptism is about is it's for remission of your sins. If you have repented sincerely, repented and turned to God with your heart that God promises that through that ordered, that ordinance of Legally administered you gain, retain a remission of your sins and that's called baptismal. Regeneration is the technical Term for it in early Christian Studies and that is I think that's just fundamental but there's so many Christians who I would say low Church Protestants. I would guess it would be the ones who really helped lately. The other efficacy of baptism but Mormonism is really big on baptism is for the remission of your sins and to enter into the Covenant path of the Gospel basically Excellent. They thought sad on that Michael. Yeah, so yeah.
11:45 We're talking about In Christianity, there's been a debate. I think between this idea of faith and works, right? And so baptism is, is like the first work, you know in the gospel and it's the first ordinance of the priesthood that's administered. When someone wants to join the church of Christ or you know, and begin that Covenant path is Jacob to saying as that's the first step and it's a token and it's a sign that you're willing to lay down your life in a similar to die as Christ. Did you know, and become Um, you know, become like him. Follow his example, you're trying to incorporate his attributes into yourself and that, you know, and Mormonism takes that to that extreme like we touched on earlier is like the gospel is a as we outlined the first principles.
12:32 These are the stepping stones, but they ultimately bring you into a very literal promise that you will be like the Savior that you will. He's the pattern for an exalted being relative to us and we are trying to obtain what he is. That actually brings that brings to mind something else to add on that subject. There's always the debate on salvation, whether there's salvation whether there's present salvation, where mainstream a lot of mainstream Christians would say, are you saved Now versus future salvation. Are you going to be saved in the kingdom of God? And there's kind of this debate where it seems like Catholics really emphasize the future salvation. While your average Evangelical will emphasize present salvation, I've learned from studying Scholars who study the early Christian writings is the idea that there's two phases of Salvation, there's an initial salvation, present salvation, that comes when you have faith in Jesus Christ, you repent of your sins and your baptized and through the grace of Christ, you are saved from that moment and you will if you die after being baptized, you know, that you're going to go to paradise and you're on track for the Celestial Kingdom. But then there's maintaining your safe condition through obedience to the Commandments and striving to continue on that path of the gospel.
13:57 And there's a really good Brigham Young quote on this where he set and this is in Journal of discourses volume 8 page 124. Yeah, he said if a person with an honest heart, a broken contract and pure spirit and all fervency and honesty of Soul presents himself and says he wishes to be baptized for the remission of his sins. And the ordinance is administered by one having Authority. Is that man saved? Yes, to that period of time. Should the Lord see property taken from the earth? That man is believed and been baptized? And is a subject is a fit subject for heaven. A candidate for the kingdom of God was Lester world because he's repented and done all that is required to him from that hour, but after he is, baptized and hands have been laid upon them for the reception of the Holy Ghost, suppose. The next day, he's commanded to go forth and preach the gospel or teaches family where system Billy have the kingdom of God or take a substance and give it to the poor. And he says, I will not do it.
14:49 His baptism and Confirmation would depart from him, and he would be in. He says, he'd be left as a son of perdition, but if he says with a willing heart in mind, here's my substance. I will not only pay attempt of it, but the whole of it is at your feet. Do with it. As you, please, does. He not continue to be saved? Yes, and so that's something I've seen in the Journal of this course, a number of times where they talk both about present salvation, as well as future salvation. So just a thought that came to mind, Michael. I saw, you raise your hand. Did you have something? Oh, that was probably me to scratch an itch. No, I did not have anything to add that. I thought that was pretty great. Actually, that was that was very well put, you know, it's I think it's kind of a good thing and this is another reason that I'm so thankful that Billy reached out because sometimes especially as fundamentalist we get in this stage of where we're constantly deep diving into to quote, the mysteries of godliness.
15:46 And that's a Good thing, right? I think that's, that's a great thing. But sometimes we need to go back and we need to revisit these first initial steps we took on our path of discipleship, because I feel like if we can recapture that Spirit, it kind of lights that fire again, Billy. Did you have any thoughts hat or anything else you wanted to take further with that? I mean, so obviously there's disagreement from a Lutheran perspective. Baptism from the Lutheran Perspective is the fundamental thing that we look to for our Salvation. And so Martin Luther is quoted by saying, you know, when you Splash your face and your more and with water in the morning, remember your baptism.
16:30 And it's where God Saves you but, you know, some of the similarities is interesting. And so I think as we one of the questions I have after this is about re-baptism and I know Ogden crowd has Rhythm book on that. And so, I guess, how would you understand? Re-baptism? And certainly, if I can, maybe throw a verse out there in Ephesians 4:5, it's one Lord, One Faith, one baptism. And so what is re-baptism and and how does that fit in with the salvific perspective? Well, I think Jacob has a more sound re-baptism from the Ogden Kraut perspective than I do. I know that he's pretty fond of that book. My response, however, though, would be in reference to that scripture.
17:23 There is there's only one legal Channel. Authorized by God. And that's why, that's why the priesthood, you know. And so when I hear Ephesians 4:5 and it's one thing, it's one Lord, one baptism, there's one priesthood, it's one ordinance. You know what, that can't be changed. There's a very strict, you know, it's a minister, very strictly and its forms and patterns and and you know, we have one Lord that's the these, the Chief Cornerstone of our faith. And to me, that's That's how I would interpret that scripture. Not how that you couldn't be baptized more than once. Speaking of Mormonism, you know, the It wasn't abnormal to be re-baptized in the early days, if one was impressed, too. I also know that Joseph and Oliver baptized themselves when they had a, they had John the Baptist visit them but then they were re-baptized for record sake when they Incorporated the Church of Christ in New York in 1830 and that was for, you know, to go through that form and it's a record state, but the ordinance was still the same.
18:35 You know, each time I had another comment though, and I wish I had actually gone to the book of Acts to see how it reads there. But I was, I was looking through a speech that Joseph Smith gave and he was quoting in Acts or talking about the when Paul was going to Corinth. The re-baptism, an act, right right there, and he didn't. And he goes, and he asks, you know, what were you guys baptized into? And, and they say we're about, you know, these disciples, they say we're born in the John's baptism and, and or know Paul asks, have you received the Holy Ghost since you believed and were converted right?
19:25 And they say no we have not heard so much of this. Holy Ghost, Paul asks, who baptizes you then. They said oh we were baptized to John's baptism and he says you know this is how Joseph Smith puts he says, no not so my friends, John did not baptize you for. He did his work right and you would have heard of the Holy Ghost but you've been duped by some designing knave who has come in the name of John as an imposter, you know, and he says, oh how did Paul know it? Because John was always saying, while baptize you with water and then somewhat Theo, someone after me who is greater than me, will come and baptize you with fire and B. So that they knew They knew the or Paul knew that since they didn't even know who the what the Holy Ghost was that you know, that they were not baptized authoritatively. So what did he do?
20:10 He baptized them right there and that's that's essentially all I had enough. So let me, let me ask you something. Does baptism have to be administered by a specific person or can a layperson administer baptism who can actually baptized so and that's a great question, because There's going to be a difference between what you would consider a layperson and then what we would consider like lay people with in Mormonism, right? Because with in evangelicalism, you usually have a chief Pastor or something like that, right? With in Mormonism, we strive to give every word, you know, every word email the the priesthood, right? So when you say a Layperson.
21:07 Well, yeah, anybody having that Authority, right? And so it's often been said of mormonism's of every Mormonism of every stripe, that that it's all lay clergy for the most part. And that for the most part is true. So while yes a number of people can perform that is there still a question of priesthood Authority, their fellows. Do you think I answered that? All right there. Yeah, I think that's good. I think the other thing I would add to how early Mormons would understand one Faith, one Lord, one baptism. When I've seen them, talk about that verse in the scriptures.
21:49 They emphasize that one baptism means, there's one mode of baptism and that is described in the Book of Romans is being buried in the water. Like Christ was buried. It's, it's in a similar food of his death. And so, there isn't this pouring, or sprinkling, they Its own. There's only one form of baptism and that is to be immersed in the water and that's why John was baptizing. I believe it's in John chapter 3 where it says that John the Baptist was baptizing a certain area because there was much water there and re-baptism well I don't see it in early Christianity, that's I see it hinted in the New Testament in Revelation 2:5 where the Apostle John is writing to the churches and he says As this is the King James version. Remember from whence Thou Art fallen and repent and do the first works or else, I will come unto thee quickly, and will remove thy Candlestick out of his place except thou repent. And so redoing, your first works. I see is the reference to re-baptism and, you know, I do think that re baptism is the ordinance for the remission of sins.
22:58 And I like that Martin Luther says that you should always be focused on your Baptist. And I think re-baptism is pointing back to Are you know, that you might receive the ordinance several times, but just like, you know, there's only one Lord's Supper, you're just repeating the ordinance on a regular basis and re-baptism is it necessarily on as frequent basis? It's, you know, all depends on the individual and the fundamentalist Community, some people might do it every, you know, a couple times in their lives, others might do it more frequently than that. But yeah, it's the ordinance for the remission of sins. So I think Think you know the getting baptized as H and Mormonism you get baptized at age 8 but I think most of us make our bigger biggest sins later on in our lives before.
23:46 You know not you know you're getting baptized but you're going to make all your mistakes after your initial baptism. So I see re-baptism as a logical principle of the gospel and in understanding that ordinance. So just to clarify let's say I get baptized Eight years old and I said, I steal from my local grocery store. What I expected to be. Baptized again, like is it like sin re-baptism? Is it? How does that work? Or is it up left up to the individual conscience? I don't think that it's necessarily, you know, every time you sin right? Because there's there's other ordinances that helped us through that the sacrament being one of them as I've looked Back at historical accounts, there certainly are times. And again, fellas Jacob, Michael jump in here if I'm wrong on this.
24:42 But as I've seen it, you would essentially get re-baptized at Big moments in life a lot, right? That's where you hear about it. The most is, you know, somebody gets a new calling, somebody's about to get married. Somebody is about to get your endowment and down and join, right? I don't know. And so a lot of times, these were things that re-baptism is something you would do to kind of recommit yourself and maybe start this new portion of your life on the right foot fellows. It does that seem off base at all. No no touched on in early Mormonism.
25:24 The Saints kind of. It looks like after a significant population was developed in the Salt Lake Valley. It was observed that there was some negligence on certain things. And there was What's called the Mormon reformation and it was very much encouraged to enter into re-baptism so much, so that they became so much of a fervent Spirit, you know, that one of the, one of the Apostles and the first presidency gendered, I am Grant ended up dying from exposure administering, baptisms in a river in November by belief. And but this was because the leadership encouraged it basically, as a okay let's go. Let's take these come once more.
26:06 Seriously, we're trying to build a temple here. We want people to be prepared for this, you know, we don't, we can't administer these things that we wanted to involve you. We had to leave Malibu before we could attend to all these things and we don't want to be negligent on you know, in the wilderness as we're waiting, to build another Temple so we can show you the things that can only be showed. There is how I kind of look at that. Yeah, and the other thing on the point is it's not about every time you commit an act of sin. It's about some Baptism symbolizes having Death to Your former sinful life and repenting and taking on a new holy or nature. And so baptism is about your, you know, it's sinful act like you go and, you know, commit sin and then be like, oh if I can just get baptized afterwards for that.
26:51 That's not what it's about. It's about changing your sinful nature and being more repentant and more, holy and more Sanctified. And I think that's part what part of why they stopped doing re-baptism. The 1890s was, they felt that there were certain Folks, who are abusing the principal re-baptism and saying, oh, I can commit Grievous sins. I could just get baptized later on in the first presidency was like we don't approve of that abuse of the principle of baptism. Very interesting. You know it concur with up. So one of the things that actually I was happy about is when I first met some Mormon missionaries, one of my first questions was like well so what do you guys do with the Lord's supper? And she's like well We use bread and water as a. Okay.
27:37 Bread and water. No, and I found out you guys actually use bread and wine. So what is the Lord's supper for you guys? And maybe moving into the Lord's Supper, the next Sacrament, how do you guys do that for lutherans? This is the Pinnacle of the worship service. We praise God. We hear the word preached and then we remember our Savior by taking the Lord's supper, and we actually have a view of the real presence. You actually believe that Christ is literally present but how would you guys use the Lord's Supper? Yeah. So with fundamentalist, I think fundamentals take it a bit more serious than the. I think the LDS church in many ways is copied low-level protestantism in there.
28:24 Some of their worship services and I think that's evident in the sacrament and I think that open communion actually is part of that by saying, you know anyone, everyone can take the Sacrament, unless say, the Bishops explicitly forbids. Absolutely, well, yeah, and that open communion. Is it taking it as serious, you know, in the scripture that talks about how serious it is to be properly worthy to partake of the sacrament. And so, thus I've seen sources in early Mormonism that originally they did have close communion and they actually would do their preaching sir their sermons at one meeting and then their Sacrament meetings would actually be in a separate occasions just to make sure that they're only inviting people. They're in really good Fellowship you know that they know are improper.
29:07 Holy Fellowship to receive the sacrament and so I agree that I don't like, there's the Revelation, there's a revelation, the DNC saying that you shouldn't buy wine of your enemies and so it doesn't matter what you use. But still the DNC prescribes that wine is the proper emblem to use in the sacrament. And there's a number of statements by Joseph Smith on that in the school of the prophets under John. Are they talked about Joseph? Smith's teachings on the sacrament and this is a quote from, I believe Zebedee, Coltrane recalling it. He said, quote, the sacrament is also missed yours at times when the Prophet Joseph appointed after the Ancient Order that is warm bread to break easily was provided and broken into pieces as large as my fist. And each person had a glass of wine and satin ate the bread and drank the wine.
29:56 And Joseph said, this was the way that Jesus's disciples / took in the bread and wine and thus was the order of the church ancient lie until the church went into darkness. So I do think that's the proper order and I purse, I'm an outlier in this. I really like studying the early Christians, so I really have personally hold real presence view. I don't believe in transubstantiation, but I think that when you read the scriptures and like Brigham, Young would say it's so that we have a spiritual union with Jesus Christ through the ordinance of the sacrament and it's to have his spirit with us. And so, I do really like the real Presents View and that's just kind of my take on it. Oh that's awesome.
30:40 Most Mormons don't hold really as they think it's just symbolic but I think it's an important salvific symbol. So sure. Michael. What do you got on that buddy? Um I definitely think one should be using hot water. I'll say that first off but it's obviously ordinances. These things are meant to be symbolic. And ideal was obviously instituted for a reason wine looks like blood and these changing from ordinances should not be taken lightly. Although as Jacob mentioned there was a revelation which the church uses to excuse themselves in using water and also the the prohibition post-prohibition church under Heber J.
31:26 Grant you know they started moving away from a mild acceptance of alcohol before that point in the 1920s. When the, when the, when the federal government repealed that act of the earth. You know, that article in the Constitution Heber J Grant was kind of vindictive, that kind of wanted to show the rest of the world. And we're going to hang on to this. So that's kind of some historical context for the the church departing away from using wine in there, sacrament to water because there was a general over focus of moving away from. Yeah, they had a mild tolerance and alcohol. At least wine and beer, but we can under circumstances I think use whatever's convenient and it's to attend to that because we are trying to remember the covenants we've made. I don't know if you've ever reviewed the prayers that, you know, the we recite when we do, when we do the, the sacrament, I think, Donna, how much explode would you like me to? That look that up.
32:36 Yeah. Please do right? Right. And Mauro night at the very end of the Book of Mormon. Yeah, I was a well, They got some they got that on the LDS app somewhere by themselves, pretty easy. Anyway, said that when your blessing the bread it was says, o God, the Eternal Father. We ask thee in the name of thy son, Jesus Christ to bless and sanctify. This bread to The Souls of all those who partake in it. That they may eat in remembrance of the body of thy son and witness unto thee. O God, the Eternal Father that they are willing to take upon them. The name of thy son and always remember him and keep his Commandments which he has given them. That they may always have his Spirit to be with them. Amen.
33:19 Then the blessing for the wine is O God the Eternal Father. We ask thee in the name of thy son, Jesus Christ to bless and sanctify. His wine to The Souls of all those who drink of it that they may do it in remembrance of the blood of thy son, which was shed for them, that they may witness unto thee. O God, the Eternal Father that they do, always remember him that they may have his Spirit to be with them. Amen. And so it's very much present there, you know that we want the spirit of the Lord, as you know, to be with us always as we're as we're taking of those emblems and I don't know, so much about real presence. I definitely don't view it as in a trance substantial ISM. Just things just to be clear as a Lutheran. We don't believe in transubstantiation either. That's a Catholic notion that kind of was in. It over time, like with Aristotelian, logic and categories and things like that.
34:21 So we just state with Christ states that it is his body and we kind of leave it there to a mystery. So just want to clarify that. One thing I found that was interesting and doing some research on and I don't know if it's always been done this way but the way I saw done in the LDS church and it's pretty, you know, that's typical I guess. I don't know. Some some fundamentalist might do A different way. I think it's interesting though. We have an altar and we put the bread and the wine on this on this alter the priests and behind it. And they blessed in the congregation is on the other side from the altar, you know, from the from the priest, from the priesthood there and they'll usually aren't, you know, there's a cloth over the altar. They'll uncover one the other bread first, then cover it and then do the wine.
35:14 I think it's interesting. Thing about had pointed out to me and I don't know if it was intentional but it probably was. But it hasn't really been explained this way that it's almost as if the two priests, you know, at the altar represent, the two angels who go to the tomb and and they are, they are administering, Christ's body back to the church, you know, the and there, you know. So in one sense, the the altar represents the veil. And these angels are the, you know, the two priests, you know, they're administering the body. Of Christ from out of the out, the tomb, that way. And I thought that was pretty profound when I realized that and even I saw in my ward houses, you know, Christ when he was buried he had a napkin right for the head and we had another napkin that was placed and I don't know if you guys do that or what, but there was a napkin that was placed with with the emblems in the sacrament and when Christ when the disciples went to the tomb and they saw that their my understanding is that That was that was emblematic.
36:17 Also of a Jewish custom that if someone was to leave the dinner table, That was a sign that you're not done eating yet. You're going to be back, right? So that was a sign that Christ absolutely like like he's going to be back, that's really cool. Actually, we do cover our Sacrament with a napkin and so I actually never heard that explanation before and I'm going to look into that if that's why we do it, so interesting, I keep on learning stuff with you guys, but keep on going. Well, I'm glad you're you're you're learning. Something I learned something. Every time I talk to Jacob and Michael I'm constantly reminded when I'm talking these guys how much further I have to go something else I want to say on the sacrament is that sometimes and and I'll just speak from my own experience. We get into a routine with it right and it almost becomes kind of a spectator sport.
37:13 I don't think that's how the sacrament supposed to be. I think in some ways we are meant to be active. Participants And I think how we do that and I think this is one of those ways that we could really invite the Lord or the spirit of the Lord to be there during our Sacrament meetings. And when we partake of it is making sure that that we're being truly repentant in that time, really focusing on. Do we have that broken heart and a contrite spirit? Otherwise we're just going through the motions as far as the emblems go. I agree with both Jacob and Michael the Doctrine and Covenants. Hence, the, the New Testament, The Book of Mormon during Christ visitation was very clear on wine.
37:57 And unless it's an extraordinary circumstance, I think you stay with that. Having said that are there exceptions. Sure. I mean, I remember reading a story about a set of Mormon pows, who all they could ration was water, and whatever else they could find. I think, in those circumstances, the Lord is more than willing to to work with us on that, on that point. That's last month. Caught one quick question Billy. Yeah, go ahead but I studied the early Christians. So I really like getting, what's the universal belief of all the, in the pre, niceand Christians, you know, all over the world. Because that's usually means it goes back to the apostles. If everyone all across the ancient Christian World held the same beliefs, one of the things they often did, was they mentioned wind, they mentioned, Also mentioned water on some occasions.
38:50 Some, but some authors mentioned water. Mixed with wine is that something Lutheran's do mixing do water and wine mixed, or Idaho? I have heard of that. Although, that's not practice and our Synod. We usually just take one but I have heard of that. Okay, yeah, yeah, getting back to what? What are you guys said about? Open Community. That's a pretty big thing too, because Paul speaks about like keeping judgment on yourself it. Thew partake, wrongly and so Dave, what you said is like, you know, make sure you come to the supper penitent. That's you don't want to take that stuff lightly, you know, and so I appreciate that. So, should I move it to the yeah? Let's let's, let's move right along and I apologize for the delay because we were all muting here and unmuting. So I apologize.
39:42 It's all good, it's all good. And so, as I as I kind of maybe progress in this, like they may seem a little more polemical, but these are just questions that, as I read the book of Mormon, as I learn the Mormon faith, these are just things that strike me. I'm like, what What is going on here? Is and so let me just move right into the first question and that has to deal with Celestial marriage. And so the question is asked of Jesus, I think it's by the Sanhedrin and obviously they don't believe in the resurrection and they give him this question about a wife who marries someone and then the brother dies and she marries. The other brother I think it like goes through like six iterations or something like that and then Jesus, basically, at the end of that, they ask, who is she married to in the kingdom of heaven?
40:38 And so Jesus gives this statement when the dead rise they will neither marry nor are given in. Marriage are like the angels in heaven and that's in Mark 12 25. And so understanding like trying to learn about Celestial marriage and then looking at what Jesus says, it's almost like there was a perfect time to teach on that and it doesn't seem to fit these Gather, where am I missing that? Yeah, I love to build. I've actually we've talked about this one before and my answer is the same on that the the brethren, in the early Brethren and the Mormon Church taught, you know, essentially what Christ was doing was not throwing Pearls Before Swine. They didn't even believe in a resurrection at this point but what he said was not a lie, you know, there is no marrying or attending to a marriage, you know? As a verb in heaven.
41:34 You're married on Earth. Yeah, and we believe in the in ceiling keys in the priesthood, and these marriages are done in earth on Earth, so that they can continue that state can continue in heaven, but there are there's no more marriages done. That has to be done on Earth as it maintains its its status, its contract, you can read that in section 132 where it talks about the eternity of the marriage, covenant. And so Christ wasn't Because he doesn't. Yeah I don't think he's saying that the state of marriage doesn't exist but you know it's like we will not build, we won't be giving in marriage, you know anymore. And and to me it was a really political answer because he wasn't a waste his time. Talking about educating people about the mysteries of godliness when they didn't even believe in a literal Resurrection anymore. Interesting.
42:24 Okay. and so, The angels in heaven. How does that compare to the Saints? Who died? Do we become ain't like, I know Marone, I, for example, was a saying to became an angel. Do we become Angels or no, or is that a possibility for us? That's a really good question, and Probably a lot of good answers for that. I do see a problem because according to the way Joseph Smith used that term there was some fluidity and some, there were some flux to the way he used the word Angel as a term. Sometimes he just, you know, it's, it's usually applied to a resurrected being who's a messenger, right or even a spirit.
43:12 That's just somebody that's a messenger. So I should say, most generally, an angel is someone who's delivering a message. And his own personal salvation, and exaltation isn't necessarily the big question regarding his message. But in some instances in the revelations that says that angels are resurrected beings in the next, you know, after this judgment. But they won't they'll be single and they won't have an exaltation. They won't be as the gods are, you know, but they'll be servants to the gods and so that's an angel and in different contexts as well. And so it depends if you know, what do you what are we going to become? It really depends on. Glory. We attend to and where we're going to be sorted in, you know, in that Vision, that Joseph Smith and Sidney Rigdon have ahead of the three degrees of, you know, of Glory with a Three Kingdoms.
43:59 And it was it's been taught that Celestial beings will Minister as angels to terrestrial worlds and terrestrial. You know, beings will ministers angels to the teal astral world's even, you know? And so there is some variety in degrees there. Yeah, I think Michael covered it, pretty Great. I would just add that Eternal Marriage was introduced by Joseph Smith as a secret teaching. It wasn't something that he really publicly taught about until July of 1843 met of 1843 he hints at it. July 1843 gives a sermon but he says I can't reveal the fullness of this until the temple is completed. And so this was considered a more esoteric teaching that pertain to exaltation.
44:47 That Joseph was Tended, to be more of a temple teaching. And so, similarly, when I look at the New Testament that passage, I don't see Jesus, it's like Michael said throwing his Pearls Before Swine the the Eternal Marriage, only belongs to the Melchizedek priesthood, like in order to pull in order to be in an Eternal Marriage, a man has to hold the high priesthood and it takes using the sign. The the endowment, the the milk has that portion of the temple Endowment in Mormonism. In order to perform being perform an eternal marriage. And so I don't think Jesus was going to do that, you know, he I don't think the Sadducees even knew that he had received this higher priesthood, he kept his authority at secret. He said they're like by what Authority does he do these things?
45:37 And Jesus says, if you tell me whether John the Baptist was called of God or called a bit by man, that I'll Tell You by my authority and they the the Pharisees didn't want to answer him on that and And the we can't answer you and so he says, neither do I answer you? So Jesus didn't go into detail about his authority, and I believe that Eternal Marriage would have been among the secret teachings that he taught to his disciples. But was it a public teaching? And I would say that there were early Christians, who didn't think that Jesus is teachings of the New Testament. Contradicted, the idea of an Eternal Marriage, Killian believed in Eternal Marriage. He said, they're really being one in the Lord because I think it's incorrect things where it says, neither is The Man Without The woman in the Lord and so he thought that there was room for it in Christian theology.
46:23 So interesting, Would you say, would you say this is my comment on that? Yeah. Go ahead. Oh no I'm First Corinthians Jacob just fraud of First Corinthians, right? And quotes Paul saying that a man is not without the woman in the Lord and neither is a woman without the man. This is so interesting to me and I want to I want to harp on a pet peeve of mine. It's I think that's First Corinthians chapter 11 the first few verses. And that what Jacob quoted is preceded by something that I think is absolutely profound and Mormon circles right now. Because Paul says Brethren, I would exhort that you keep the Winces as I delivered them unto you, remember that the head of woman is the man that had of man is Christ and the head of Christ is God. And and so there's like this height is there's a marriage hierarchy you know, and love will be tiant's, that's listed there.
47:19 And I love how he proceeds that with keep the ordinances. As I delivered them unto you in the temple context, there is a law that says that you Covenant, to make according to according to that pattern, the church church. The LDS church has since changed that I think it's, you know, it's very much in the New Testament context. I think that fits with Mormon theology that way when you take the statement that a man isn't without the woman, and the woman isn't without the man and those other scriptures about hierarchy and Authority. I think that blends very well with, you know, we we are, we are trying to become one, you know. And how do we do that? You know, the criteria of the woman Yes, mr.
48:02 Husband, and righteousness the, the husband submits to Christ and following his Commandments, and all things and then you know, in Christ. What did he do? He followed, he did everything that the father told him to do, you know, and through that we either can't move, we become one. And so this might be a good place to just because Mo a lot of evangelicals /. Catholics who listen to this or probably not even going to think of this. But you guys believe Jesus was married, right? Absolutely, yes. Okay, cool. I actually just got through Ogden crowds book on that and so, you know, it's interesting stuff. One of the things I guess I wrestle with his. I mean, you have this, I guess this tradition within rabbis, having to be married, but For me, you don't necessarily see it in the New Testament.
48:57 So I really had to think to myself. Alright, would this change anything for me? If I found out Jesus was married and I asked some Catholic friends who are just like, absolutely the Christian faith is the bunk. I'm like, well, why I mean? Marriage is a natural thing. It's a beautiful thing and then upon examining this, I learned Paul was married. That was like a big thing. They're like, holy crud. This is, this is amazing. Like, because I always, We thought he was like a celibate, you know, you have that teaching and printing. So which is Corinthians 8 or Corinthians chapter 9 where he says that? Don't we have the right to lead a wife with us. The brothers of Jesus, and the other Apostles did, I think that might be in Philippians flipping seven, maybe Corinthians Keys more. So talking to like, the widows of the church and he, you know, he basically says I desire, everyone to be like myself that he's unmarried, it's so that Doctrine has become may be the centerfold amongst forth and Oscar, she and I said that small low as to say like to be unmarried is more spiritual and then Luther Kind of changed that. Obviously, you got as soon as he left the Catholic church, he married a Roman Catholic nun nun. And so the marriage is state is viewed as spiritual. And so I don't have a negative view of that. I'm willing to challenge myself
50:28 on it. Go ahead. Can I say just a few things here? Because this this has been super fascinating one thing I'll say is that Is plenty of references to Jesus being married even in the New Testament. I had a good buddy and I'm glad that that I have this opportunity whose dad was a rabbi and we would sit down for hours and talk about the scriptures and one thing that he brought up that you know led him to believe that Jesus was married was the way that it was either marry or Martha. I can't remember forgive me but after Lazarus dies she Comes out and she reims. The savior in front of everybody, right?
51:10 If you'd have been here, this would not have happened if you'd have been around. And, and the way this was described to me as like, you don't speak to a religious leader like that, especially a man in that time period and get away with it, unless he's your husband. The other one, the other one is in the the marriage Feast where Jesus first, miracle happens. Mary the mother of Jesus comes to Jesus very upset about the wine, right? It was the groom's parents responsibilities Supply, the wine at a marriage ceremony So it could have been his brother but it also could have been him as well.
52:00 So I think there's a luge ins there but we're not going to pick that up unless we have a semi working knowledge of Jewish custom and Jewish Jewish tradition, you know, it's interesting and I don't know how true this is because I've been kind of a lot of this stuff is brand-new to me. And so, like hearing Jesus is married, was kind of like, what the heck is going on here? But as I looked into Jewish custom, I think there's some strains of Jewish tradition, that believe the Messiah will be married. Could be wrong about that, but that's, that's totally true. Kevin crowd is told the story before where he said that some Jews actually, reject Jesus being the Messiah because he had the Messiah has to be married. You know, he has to be keeping all the Commandments and so, and, and part of it is because of, I think Isaiah speaks as Isaiah 53.
52:55 I think we're Talks about, he will see his offspring. So he and so Christians have spiritual eyes that and say, oh, seeing his seed seeing his offspring. That's his, you know, that's just the church that's, you know, his disciples and spiritual followers but the Jews interpret that very literally as being his literal Offspring. So and just to be clear because there is a strain of like I'm sorry to cut you off Gnostic teaching that says like DaVinci Code bloodline. Do you guys go down that route or is that like something you guys like? Because there are people who like kind of obsessed about that stuff like, oh, Jesus would really married and there's some blood lines that you can find and they're really the world or something like that, you know. Like some crazy stuff.
53:41 Listen to Michael and Sean Anderson's podcast they did with Dave were Sean goes into all that. It was really cool you know. I don't Sean to do great treatment on that. I don't think it's a rabbit hole for Mormonism, right? I think it might be a rabbit hole for putting in quotations and I don't mean this by any disrespect, my William was all good traditional Christianity. It might be way bigger of an issue than it is for Mormons, right? Because there is such an emphasis placed on Eternal Marriage and eternal family. So with with that in mind, we don't necessarily have to go down, quote, The Rabbit Hole. Hmm, to find that perfect.
54:25 Acceptable. Does that make sense sure? Yeah, absolutely. And what you were talking about extra-canonical sources and I would say this and I'm actually going to have a podcast with another gentleman I'd done before about Mormon teachings within the Apocrypha right now. You always got to be somewhat careful with the Apocrypha but I don't know about anybody else. I am a firm believer in the truth. Has a certain ring to it and I think there is treasure there to be found and And one of those is a book within the Apocrypha and don't quote me, I you'll hear more about it in the next podcast but I believe it was the pistol. Sofia, that talked about, these are the things that Jesus talked about in his 40 days during his resurrection and some of that had to do with marriage as well, you know, and Michael go ahead. Yeah, I mean, listen, I really this this Doctrine in particular, really Arms me because I really had to ask myself.
55:28 Would it change anything? And it absolutely wouldn't change anything. And I have like a lot of Catholic friends and so I know one of their pushbacks are is going to be. You don't see it really in scripture, although it, maybe you gave those two examples and there's probably more that you would pull out. But what about the early church? Is there any type of evidence? Early church, you know, pre Nicene collars or anything like that? Michael. You had something. I'm going to let you take this and then Jacob. Don't have an address. Your question that you just read barely asked bill but I did have comments. You know, the other thing with what is this a rabbit hole? I just wanted to share an anecdote from. It's very much, a reminiscent of old school Mormonism and I'm very shocked.
56:15 I saw it in my own life when I was serving a mission for the church they, you know, we have a mission conference and some authorities came. And for those in the church who are listening to this, you know this was the wife of Elder, Larry Lawrence of the 70s, gave this talk and the so sister Lawrence was talking to us missionaries about how it's the blood of Israel. Yeah she called him the doctrine of believing blood and it's the blood of Israel that you know because of the Covenant that God made with Abraham and because God has respect to that Covenant that those as with the literal bloodline of that Covenant will hear and receive a testimony regarding the truth of the gospel and and will become converted by the Holy Ghost. You know, I didn't know be led to do the things like baptism and you entering into the kingdom of God and in early Mormonism, one of my favorite quotes from Orson Heights kind of touched his on this and he says you know we will find out that God in reality is you are father or grandfather or great-grandfather and those who do not Believe this doctrine that is because they have none of the blood of Christ in them, you know, meaning that they didn't have. They were not going to believe that because they didn't have the believing blood.
57:32 So I always thought that was a fascinating element in Mormon Doctrine. And I was very shocked as a 20 year old 6 years ago. Hearing that in a modern Church setting for missionaries. Absolutely a must I can text me. Is that something you guys believe that you would have to have the blood of The believer, is that something not? So this is really the blood of Christ. But the blood of Israel was, is an advantage. I would say to hearing and receiving a testimony and being converted by the Holy Ghost. So a lot of early Mormons believe that, you know, that they said that Joseph Smith taught that, you know, they were the seed of Christ and I found that to be, you know it sounds hard to believe except the the Traditions when you get into Kind of these Jesus was married and had Offspring. The Traditions are that the psalm 45 was flipped build where Jesus is descendants, married and became royalty. And Europe is fulfilling the Kings, you know, your instead of your descendants, your posterity will be royalty basically. And because, because, this property, they believed that his descendants went into Europe and the royalty or the earliest royalty, and the ancient century These were the descendants of Christ and the upper classes in Europe actually out bread, the lower classes.
59:01 And so actually there would have been a genetic replacement of most of Europe, through the centuries of the outbreeding basically the upper class outbreeding, the lower class. And so that's makes it more believable. In my opinion, this idea of that Jesus blood line actually mixed with the seed of Ephraim we Mormons Leave that kind of British Israeli ISM. It is kind of the concept that is kind of been incorporated into Mormonism and that the blood of Israel is throughout Europe and that we are the descendants of Ephraim, which was the chosen Birthright, according to the Old Testament. So sorry, that was a little does just a tangent. No, no lasting.
59:45 That's all right cause I'm about to go on one here for just a second to. There we go. I think I think it's important to also in this this Discussion. Because when you start talking about the blood of Israel coming over to the new world, right? You have it both in the Book of Mormon, we believe that, but if you look back at the early founders of the country, especially if you go back to like Winthrop, right? If you go read, Winthrop City on the hill speech. And just, you know, check that against like, passages out of the Book of Mormon where Alma's baptizing at the Waters of Mormon. It's the same Covenant, right? And went through up talks about, you know, if we if we Embrace these covenants and we live up to these covenants, we can expect the god of Israel to dwell amongst us. So even those coming across at the very beginning of the settlement of the new world in the, you know, latter half of the back, 2,000 years since Christ. They definitely saw themselves as a continuation. Action of the story of Israel, which I find absolutely amazing biliary answering these for you.
1:01:00 Yeah, feel free to dive in deeper and you know what's up for not getting? I'm not, I'm not here. I'm here to learn, and I'm here not to push my own perspective and just just hear what you guys believe and be good with that. And so, you know, I'm taking notes going to dive into this stuff and continue. You know, I just want to make sure that we're answering your questions here. Absolutely now. Yeah, we kind of, we kind of went off on a tangent with the last one about evidence for Jesus being married and you were asking about the church fathers or if there's anything outside of the New Testament. Sure. Yeah. And I would say that there isn't actually any thing among the earliest Christians on that, they believe that the pot they took for granted that the apostles were married men but they didn't seem to I'm too, I think Clement of Alexandria believe that Jesus wasn't married but you know, that's getting that he's the first one to kind of imply that and that's getting like to the end of the about 200 ad.
1:02:04 So that's over 150 years later. So what Orson High believed and said, was that The Offspring of Christ would have been kept a secret, his family would have been kept hidden knowledge and so that they wouldn't befall the same fate that has befallen many other. Families basically throughout the ages, in the history of the world. And so the children would have been kept secret in Orson. Hide also commented on the New Testament saying that if Jesus was at married then Mary and Martha following him around everywhere. These women combing, his hair, and washing, his feet would be very inappropriate. And he said, even in today's world, like the modern Christian world, would probably ride him on a rail if you were to come and have women fondling, Tim Cook anointing, the anointing them with precious oil Etc. He would be mobs tarred and feathered and brode, not on an ass, but on a rail as what Orson Heights said on that. And then I do think there is in Mormonism. We emphasize marriage.
1:03:07 So important because of Eternal Marriage but early, Christianity really had their was placed in the church for people who were single as well was. Another thing there are people who could be called, by God to not be married, is something that I see. In the early Christian rice, That's goes back to Jesus, where Jesus said that some will be made eunuchs for the kingdom sake and and we Mormon sometimes lose sight of that. But Brigham Young made several comments on occasions that yes we're commanded to live polygamy but if God we're to command us to be single and to be without a family and preach the gospel, our whole lives, we should be equally willing to do that if God commanded us to do that.
1:03:48 This leads. Perfect. My next question. So we believe I mean, you guys believe Jesus had multiple wives or which is Mary and Martha, right? Yeah. Okay. And so my next question is regarding polygamy. If polygamy is something to be sought. After why does Paul say the Elders of the church? Should just be of One Life and then also in First Corinthians 7:1, he says it's good not to marry. Well, so if how would you guys respond to that? Whose turn is it? Michael's are Jacobs turn, I can't remember Jacob's. Okay, Jacob Europe, I'm so for that one.
1:04:31 There's different Mormon perspectives on the be, the husband of one wife of a wife in the New Testament, where it says about the priesthood in the Journal of discourses or some hype actually preaches. A sermon saying that he his opinion on that it is that they were living. In Roman society, with monogamy being the law. And so if they were living polygamy, they would have had to have kept it a secret and he said, just like, we had to keep it a secret and Nabu when we were living under the Gentile law there and the Brigham Young actually got up right after Orson hide and he said, I don't interpret that passage in the New Testament, the way Elder High does, he says, I see it as saying according to the context that verse that says that he must have a wife to prove that he can manage a family in righteousness. Before he can be trusted to manage a Church of God. And so it's the Brigham Young said, it's not saying he can only have one wife.
1:05:25 It's saying he must have at least one wife. And so the Greek is kind of actually just the Greek. You can interpret it a number of ways. It could either mean never been divorced or and you know, only only been married. It could mean, you know, not, I actually think Joshua Erickson touched on this and in one of his pockets are not going to tell anyone to have to. Dig through the for our interview with Dave on that but hey that was a great episode. That was a good episode. But yeah there's the number of different ways and I agree with Brigham Young that contextually the versus just saying that the priesthood should be married to demonstrate that, you know, that they can handle a family and righteousness before they can be entrusted with the flock of God. And if Michael has anything you want sad, I don't have it. I couldn't say that better than myself. I thought that was Tastic.
1:06:21 Obviously, I've you With the Eternal plan of the Gospel that when I see statements like that in the New Testament, I have to say, there's more there, that's not obvious. You know, because I, you know, I have a testimony very firmly that it's that it's a good thing to be married. But also there was another verse there, that you mentioned Bill, where it's, you know, that you should that's good. Not to marry. And I think, you know, I've heard some people explain and I like the state because I have been a missionary before is that You there's a certain blessing attached to being so focused and not have to provide for the temple. Well, temporal welfare of a family that you can go and just preach the gospel and not worry about certain things and and just be completely consecrated to that and it makes it easier in that circumstance of being single, you know, to that. And that's why the church calls young men to go. Serve missions and not married men anymore, although I don't think Think that they should have made that you know a hard rule by any means.
1:07:31 I think there probably were more successful in the early days having experienced married. Men also go on missions personally. Yeah, this, this is actually an interesting topic and we could we could spend some time here. Regarding just marriage in general. You know so much of the early Christian Church is like people like Jerome they value virginity on this level that's almost absurd and it's more byproduct of the culture. They're living in with the Greeks and Romans and the priesthood that they have. And so you know looking into this Luther actually performed a polygamous marriage.
1:08:17 Judge and much to the maybe joy of the Catholic church because they use that to say well look so you can see the movement. He starting he's, you know you know, bringing back polygamy and so Luther actually had a search. The scriptures and said, I can't say I see anything wrong with it. And so that's kind of where I wouldn't necessarily say. I view it as something that should be sought after but I can't say like just Scriptural. I can't say it's sinful because God blesses people with polygamy and so that's been an interesting eye-opener. I was unaware that that Luther actually performed a plural marriage.
1:09:00 That's that's interesting. The either you guys know that Miker Jacob I knew he talked about how he couldn't find a problem with this scripturally when it was brought up. But I didn't know that. He actually went ahead and perform the marriage. Yeah, that was actually new to me. I knew that he argued it. Theoretically, I didn't know that he actually performed it until fairly recently. That wasn't the case. I think of what was it the context that the man couldn't have children with his wife. And so, yeah, he was a political figure. He was like a princess today. Stop. Yeah I would. And so that's scripturally on that, you know much like Luther probably saw, you know. With Abraham's promise is truly interesting because, you know, he married Hagar, you know, his second wife and because of domestic disputes.
1:09:54 She was just she left the house and an angel of the Lord came back and told her you know go back to your fate you know. And you go back to Sarah, go back to Abraham and then the Lord came the Abraham right after that and made this Covenant with something that your seed, your children will be more numerous than the stars in heaven. Now beeper, He commands them to be perfect but what that the angel just did told Hagar go back and be in their family and, you know, they would have a really great time for you to the angel or the Lord making that Covenant, with Abraham to say, there's an obstacle here, preventing you from being perfect, Abraham. That's the fact that you're, you know, second wife, you know, and but no it was blessed and Ishmael, you know, the receives huge blessings just by being associated with his father by lineage.
1:10:45 Yeah, I think I think it's also important here to point out that oftentimes because of the way it's translated the word perfect is often used in. It's the it's the same word that can be used for whole, right? And so, I think, sometimes we can get hung up on that word, perfect. And maybe, because of our Western definition were like, okay, we, you know, we need to be. No, no, be whole Be whole, right? And and I think that that Michael points out something beautiful there, that I think, I think he's telling telling Abraham be whole be a husband. Be a husband twice.
1:11:28 Be a father twice, right? Bebe whole, I think there's there's a certain Beauty to that. One comment, I'd like to add on, you know, when we look at Genesis and we see these men who walked and talked and with God and were given great blessings from God living plural marriage, you know, so one of the common objections is look at the marital difficulties that existed with Abraham and Hagar. Look at the conflicts and problems in Jacobs family, you know, that shows that polygamy. You know, these bad stories are evidence. That plagued me obviously. That great thing. But yeah, that's the case. When you see the story of Esau and Isaac and the story of Joseph and his siblings, there's conflict and violence, and threats of violence, between those those children.
1:12:19 So, clearly, God is putting those stories in there to tell us that we should only have one child. That's, that's the reason God's having those stories of conflict with multiple children, is because you only wants us to have one child. I thought that was a clever rebuttal to the nope. You brought up a good point, so I made a post on Facebook regarding that. So I got a lot of pushback, visceral like visceral reactions on this topic, which is kind of surprising. But people were messaging me. And one of the questions I got was ad when God instituted marriage, he did it between Adam and even somewhat. So, the New Covenant is kind of coming back to that perspective. As to say like Israel got lost in the wilderness. Polygamy was allowed because just culturally it was hard to survive.
1:13:10 But now as we you know, in the age of the church, we're going back to that thing between Adam and Eve. How would you respond to God? Just instituting instituting, the marriage between Adam and he's Michael. I think that's on, it's your turn buddy. That's a that's a tough one. I would say specifically, you know, we're Christianity for sure, you know and Mormonism being adjacent to that in this context is looking for a millennial Earth. And what accompanies the the transformation of this Earth until Millennial Earth is the city of Zion company or the New Jerusalem that comes down from heaven. And literally it's got Gates named after the polygamous Sons, you know, you know, go and this is this is symbolic of The new and Everlasting Covenant, you know these, We Believe. You know, in the restored Gospel of these promises. Yeah.
1:14:11 You can find these types and shadows with these. These these these hearken back to these promises that you can inherit the same glories that Abraham Isaac and Jacob had by doing the works of Abraham, you know. And then if you want to be like God, you need to do the works of Abraham. Yeah. I think goes back to what Dave is saying about being whole, you know, how can you expect to be whole less you do and Abraham did to be whole, you know? And so, when you look at those things in the context Even in a covenant structure. When you know, God gave this God gave his Covenant to Israel and what happened after Solomon died, the kingdom split and you can see and Hosea and other scriptures that gone maintains this Covenant relationship with two women, two wives, two Nations, yeah. Israel in the northern kingdom and Judah and the southern Kingdom.
1:15:00 And he treats them both like wives and he speaks to them like that and he, you know, he he talks to Judah like you're more faithful than your sister Israel and who's backsliding and going after Abominations and whoring after other gods you know she's cheating on me because and that that Motif is the same thing with the church and Christianity. That the church is the bride of Christ. Well, Israel and Judah were the were the brides and wives of God, you know? And so and it's so interesting to me to see this Covenant relationship is repeated, you know, in types and shadows throughout the scriptures. Interesting. Very interesting.
1:15:41 Jacob, do you have anything to add? Um, I would just say that if, you know, there is this theory, that yes polygamy was permitted in the Old Testament, but the New Testament is against it, but the best you got in the New Testament, it is kind of implicit statements that are implying against it. And I think First Corinthians 7 and the ones you quoted where they say, husband of one wife for the priesthood. And I Nothing really explicit and anything. Jesus said where he said, hey we're not supposed to have plural marriage anymore, so I would think that there would be a bit something a bit more direct if that was, if Jesus was changing the marriage law, I would think there would be something in the New Testament.
1:16:23 It explicitly staying that in the instead of. And when I met my first Corinthians 7, where it says, let every man have his own wife and every woman have her own husband and defraud not each other but, you know, take care of each other and your needs. And so, Oh, that's not really even an explicit. If that's the strongest, the New Testament, kind of implying against polygamy. That's not really even that strong in my opinion. Interesting. I can shift gears into a another question. Yeah, let's roll on sticking with the marriage. Topic was married with Mary married to. Or did she have sexual relations with God, the Father for the birth of Jesus?
1:17:15 Is she still his wife mrs. Rushfield Kingdom I know there's that thought there that God the father took Mary. So, hey, this is Dave, this is how you started our second atom God, or if you were really was. Yeah, I kind of smiled, just like you just threw that out there. You didn't give me any heads-up on that question. Like okay, that's how we're starting them, but you're welcome. I was going for the effect. You're welcome. So So, so yes, that's the Mormon view is that it was a natural conception and, you know, I've seen, I've personally see. So as I answered today, when he asked me that back, you know, months ago in the atom God interview, my answer is Mormons, just believe more in the Luke.
1:18:07 I think it's Luke 1:35. I think where it says the the Holy Ghost shall come upon the power of the most high shall overshadow. The indices shall be called The Son of God and so the idea is, it's not the child of the Holy Ghost, it's the literal chop Jesus. The literal Son of God. He is literally Divine, and this kind of might go into one of your other questions where he said is Jesus both fully God and fully man. Hmm. And that's part of what Mormons believe is. That he is 100. He is The Offspring of God, literally. So he is literally a God In the Flesh. You know, that's The Offspring of God, the Father.
1:18:49 All right? Can I can I maybe do a little bit of a gotcha. Okay. And Isaiah 7:14, the prophecy for Jesus. It says a virgin shall conceive. So how could she remain a virgin if her in the father? Actually knew each other. So that, that's a good question and that's also in the Book of Mormon. So I would say that contextually in Isaiah that that originally, that prophecy is so that the early Christians did was, they would take a lot of Old Testament prophecies and reinterpret. Real reframe them to Jesus Christ.
1:19:30 And so, I think that that prophecy was actually referring to a young according to the Hebrew it. Actually means a young woman, I understand, according to the Jewish texts of that, and not a virgin, that that word can be interpreted interpreted, you know, different ways and different time periods. I understand if you get into the text role of it and so I understand the Virgin birth tradition and I also mentioned this to Dave and the other podcast where my personal a theory that I like that I heard from some other Mormon fundamentals is because the Book of Mormon Also talks about she shall be a virgin and a theory is that there's there's something to there's something about the conception of Christ, that was beyond what we understand. And what we know in this mortality in that she was carried away in the spirit and then she is is with the with with child and so the idea I've heard is that maybe it wasn't some spiritual way that God the father had natural relations with her and but she Was left.
1:20:38 Physically? Still a virgin is the the theory that I heard that I personally like us, Michael has any other thoughts on that particular? I don't I have I've heard the same as you related regarding that, the context and the Hebrew Hebrew scriptures kind of give a different connotation and nomenclature. Gets really interesting when you know, and causes problems in the English language when you have, we have this, we have this connotation denotation with words, like and it leads you to make assumptions about that means versus what the word meant, obviously, in that culture and I mean, I definitely don't think she wasn't a virgin you know. I think she was definitely probably a virgin before she met God, the Father, you know?
1:21:24 And so I don't really see it being a far cry from that. You know, that was and this this this goes into this, this Motif that you see in the scriptures right, where it's Christ. Is symbolic of the firstborn, right? You know, and so he needs to all things need to follow that type. What are the what elements need to combine together to make that happen, right? So she does need, he does lead Literally be the first born, you know, you need to literally be the father Mormons, believe the priesthood is patriarchal, and that essentially all blessings that we receive after this life, come down through patriarchal means. And so, when I look at the Grand scope of things in Mormonism in context of the Temple of the endowment and for us to be joint heirs with Christ, I see that he has to be a literal.
1:22:17 Irritable are patriarchy of God, the father and that's the only way for him to receive those blessings from God. The father, is that he need to be born under a marriage, covenant to inherit that legally and lawfully. And I'm through adoption, we become The Heirs with Christ that way. But Christ couldn't even Extend that Covenant us, if he was not qualified for it. And so being the first form of a veritable marriage, he has that sealed on him so to speak and then he can see us as his you know through obeying the gospel and making those same covenants and and we then are promised you know as we become Christ children you know and then we get to rule over our children.
1:23:04 We get to keep our children in eternity. T, you know, is kind of this idea but I definitely see that Christ had to be an absolute literal Son of God for that to even work for us. Yes, it's certainly interesting. I don't know if you guys seen that cartoon, it's like a 1980s cartoon and it has like really bad animation. As God, the Father walking into like a room with me. The goddamn fuckers. Yeah. I guess that's what people might think when they hear this type of thing, but you're saying that it could be more mystery mysterious in some sense. Miraculous.
1:23:46 Perhaps, I don't know. Jacob, what's your thoughts ICU and muted? Oh, I was, I was just agreeing with that and you know with Brigham Young, he kind of said that when in the lecture at the veil where he canonized, Adam God Doctrine, the temple ceremony he talked about how when Adam and Eve died, they didn't lay their body sound the dust but they return to the spirit world from whence they came and so I somehow correlate that with Mary also being carried away in the spirit for and then and then the Nephi sees in the Book of Mormon is that then she has the child in her arms who is, you know, the Son of God. So I think there's something Mysteries to it that we don't understand Michael. How about you anything that Jacob and I said there that you don't necessarily agree with or anything like that. I'll just I'll just take a very blunt approach. I absolutely think that Mary was indeed a wife of God, the Father.
1:24:40 I think that they are sealed to this day and I think it's you know, to put it in a Joking and maybe other blunt manner, you know, Joseph the carpenter will be looking for another wife. Yeah. Show me. Oh, and I absolutely, I absolutely believe that those things are gonna, you know, Provisions will be made for Joseph being a righteous Steward over the Christ in his formative development. But I definitely you can almost see the veneration. That was given to marry you as a mother of Christ as a Queen of Heaven. That's almost reminiscent of okay. How did that evolve the? This evolved from the idea that she is literally she inherited being this queen.
1:25:21 And by being married to God, the father and, you know, and she will go and participate with God and future creations, and creating, you know, more spiritual oldrin and and going down as I believe, as a, you know, as an atom and and been doing this whole thing over again, adding to his posterity. I also, I seem to remember Hugh Nibley pointed out, you know, in some, you know, pseudepigrapha, other stuff that the apostles Christ a left, you know, they got in this prayer circle and matter is there, and they're, they're basically praying. And they asked Mario, they ask Mary to tell them, you know, how how Christ was conceived, and she's about to tell them a story and Christ, cuffs got some, don't don't tell, don't tell him anymore. You know what's going on?
1:26:14 And I also think it's interesting that I think in that same Passage that in that prayer circle, the person that was acting as the mouth represents Adam, you know, the place of Adam as well, which is very consistent with Mormon temple arrangements. And so yeah, that's that's kind of my position on that is, you know, that they're sealed. They're married and that's all part of the divine plan. And I thank God for it because it wouldn't have a savior without her being willing to go forth and do that. You know, I view the angel, Gabriel coming. As she says, he's proposing to marry on behalf of the Lord to see if she's willing to do that. And I believe that she was a, she was prepared for that. Jacob, I saw you were a muted there, would you got? This is Michael mentioned, Hugh Nibley, another thought came to mind and this is kind of a tangent, but just a quick one is Hugh Nibley reference.
1:27:11 There's early Christian work that references Mary was actually serving in the temple as like a priestess unto God. In the temple, which is significant, you know, that's not. I don't think that would have been normal Jewish custom bird to be acting as a priest. But so there was something special about her status to God. And I also think that kind of debunks that tradition that she was like this 12 year old girl when she got married. I don't believe, I don't think that's a true tradition. I if she's acting as a priestess in the temple I think she was fully developed, you know, adult woman when she Was chosen to be the wife of God, the father. So know you can, you can actually see that that's possible to consider your family Elizabeth and Zachariah seeing the, you know, in the priesthood. Yeah, I could absolutely see.
1:28:03 Mary being part of that Royal lineage somehow or Priestly lineage. I can absolutely see that happening. It's my bleeding to my next question. Getting to the idea of the physicality of God, certainly. That's the I mean that's a that's a topic that's out rightly rejected by any Orthodox Christian. So right in the Bible as they first Timothy 616 no man has seen God I guess you could maybe use man or woman there but how would you guys understood that especially Joseph Smith? And the first Fishman?
1:28:44 I believe he sees God the Father and Jesus, right? And so how would you guys understand that verse? Read that last part you talk about the first Vision. Sorry. I did, I didn't clock out. There's for a second. Yeah, no problem. The question was basically. So you have you have Mary seeing the father. You have Joseph Smith seeing God, the Father. Certainly in the Christian position, like the Orthodox Christian position is that God is not a physical being and we believe that because several verses, but in 1st Timothy, it says, no man has seen God or no man can see God. He's a spirit.
1:29:25 So, how would you guys take The physicality of God or the fact that no one can actually see him and in the Bible. How would you understand that first? I would say, based on Modern scripture through the to the restoration section, 84 of the Doctrine. And Covenants says that the keys of the Melchizedek priesthood, holds the keys to the mysteries of the knowledge of God and Mormons. Believe that at Mount Sinai, the children of Israel rejected, the Melchizedek priesthood, Covenant and You know, God had given these tables of stone with it, with the Commandments on them, but they also had the temple ordinances written on them though the ordinances of the Holy order and he broke them, anyone up to Mount Sinai again to get another set of tablets and this time, they didn't have the priesthood and lower order of priesthood.
1:30:20 The priesthood of Aaron was instituted with a caramel law to keep them in. Remembrance of the time that Christ would come and redeem them. but because the Melchizedek priesthood was taken from the for the first time, And because we in our present day, have inherited only scripture that is kind of relied on the tradition that came from those people that lost the priesthood. I think, without the knowledge of the mysteries of God, those things you can see elements. I think I could point out, almonds out in the scriptures, what I see, certain things like that, but it comes through looking through a glass Darkly as Paul says, at this point in time, I think. And as I Solutely do believe that God is tabernacled or embodied.
1:31:07 Even in First Corinthians chapter 15 and talks about the resurrection and Frames it. As you'll be raised from incorrupt, from corruption to incorruption. And you'll receive, you know, a body that is Mortal, you know, carnal or however puts it, then you'll be raised into a body spiritual, right? And so the, so when it says, God is a spirit, you know, and then you but we're gonna be raised a spiritual body is I see it as the same thing, you know, God himself, you know says it says The first Adam was of the Earthly and in the second man or second, Adam is of, is the Lord From Heaven, you know, the spiritual man is the Lord From Heaven. And I see that as a, you know, to be the Lord of Heaven, you have to be resurrected, you have to be hit, be a spiritual body. Michael.
1:31:54 There's something else here, there's something else here that did I always found interesting and this is in Exodus 33, chapter 11, chapter 33, verse 11, And here it says and the Lord spake unto Moses face to face as a man speaketh unto his friend. Okay? The fact that the scripture calls out face-to-face, right? This is the scriptures not describing simply a movement of a spirit. They're saying Moses is talking to God face to face, right? As a as one friend talks to another. I think that shows that there is you know God has a physical presence, a body.
1:32:48 It also it also mentions in in Exodus you think I'll start about Sinai and they see this Throne you know you know it's always and you see that in other places throughout the scriptures you know God is enthroned. He you know what is that That you know I have a hard time doing that is just purely symbolic. Like this is you know and while their symbolism to that but it's pretty basic completely immaterial. I don't, I don't get that. I don't buy that, you know, God is enthroned. It says that when Moses went up there with the with the 78 princes of Israel that they saw work of sapphire under his feet. You know, like these are these are attributes of a embodied individual. The other thing I would say is that, if God's plan is to bring us back to him, And we're all going to have a body but he's not, he doesn't, it seems to defeat the purpose someone or at least that's that's my take on it. One thing I would add is that on the subject of the god, having a body is, there's just so much in the scriptures that reference him having a body but to address first, the god, Spirit because that's a common one.
1:34:02 Thrown at Christians. You read that verse in its context. John 4:24 God is a spirit and those that must worship that worship Him must worship Him in spirit and Truth. Does that mean that we have to not have a body in order to be able to worship God? I think it means that God is a spiritual being. And so we also have to be Spiritual Beings in order to be able to worship God. And so it seems like in the throughout the scriptures that there that God says, you know? You can't see me, but there are other times where he says you can see me the fact that the father, one of the verses in the New Testament I think is the most explicit that the father has a body is Hebrews 13. Where it references Jesus Christ, as being in the brightness of his glory and the express image of his person. So that's clearly I think if it's saying that Jesus Christ is in the express image of God, the father that means he looks like God, the father and I don't Joseph Smith is a loan and seeing the father and the son, you see, it's Stephen when he was stoned, he said that he was full of the Holy Spirit looked intent and into heaven and saw the glory of God and Jesus standing on the right hand of God. So people can see God at certain times and other times they can't, I think it's due to wickedness. Another interesting verse is the calling of Gideon and judges 6:22 Where he he's he's actually
1:35:34 called by an Angel of the Lord. And he's he's afraid he's going to die. He's like, he's like, he's like this is judges 6. 22 and 23 when getting perceived, he was an angel of the Lord Gideon, said alas, O Lord God for because I have seen an angel of the Lord face to face, and he was afraid, he was going to die in the next verse says, but the Lord said unto a peace be with, you being afraid for you will not die. So, there's this fear of encountering the Divine because there's this Don't chance of death but there are you know there's so many instances in the scriptures where individuals interact with God and that indicate he has a Corporal body. I think Abraham's the most explicit where he's washes, God's feet and eat some meal with him at one time and then there's obviously the accounts of Moses you have Isaiah saw God and he said, I am a man of unclean lips for I have seen the the king the Lord of hosts. So I do think there are There's plenty in the scriptures to show that there are times that people can see God. There are other times that they can't. And with the early Christians, I would say that origin admitted. It was a settled matter among the earliest Christians, whether God the father had a body or not. He argued against it personally because of his philosophical ideas but you admitted that there were some of our people, I Christians who believe that God had a body and one of them was the second century Bishop Milito, he said believed that God had a body.
1:37:00 Man were made after the image of his body and threw out the first. Several centuries of the church, there were various different Christians at different times who believe that God had a body though? I will admit that, it wasn't a popular view among the church fathers, and I would argue. That's because of the Greek philosophical ideas, about God had really influence them. Is my opinion, you know? And I think I think also that this is a spot where I want to point out how thankful I am for the restored gospel, right? Right. Because this idea that that are our Humanity has to be an impediment to our spiritual growth, always struck me as as wrong. And, and I think that, that one of the things that Joseph restored is this idea that your body doesn't have to be an impediment to righteousness.
1:37:51 In fact, your Humanity can be holy Michael. I saw you raise a finger there, would you have I love what you're touching on right there. And you can we see the scroll? And Jacob mentioned it. It kind of allows me to segue into this, in the New Testament. You have these gnostics that should open all this Greek philosophy and, and have a lot of truth, but then they start teaching things. Like, you know, Christ didn't come in the flesh literally because the flatly believe that this flesh is evil. Like you're saying Dave. Like this flesh is an impediment to our spiritual progress. Listen to us, we got these teachings from the apostles. You know, we have these keys and we can teach This immaterial world, you know? And we can shed these bodies that we have because the our bodies are made from a they're made from a fallen God you know are an evil demiurge you know and the apostles talk about this and they said you know John and his epistle say any man that comes and says that Christ did not come in his body.
1:38:47 You know he says this is this is evil. You know this is in this is Antichrist is what he says, and Peter talks about it, I think Jude taught, you know, You know, Peter, James and John and Jude. All talk about these gnostics that come in and saying that, this Resurrection isn't literal. And that the about, you know, that the or like Christ didn't literally come in body and they thought it was heresy. And so, if we can take that as the word of God and Views that that doctrine of being Tavern, a folder of being embodied as heresy. And then extend that to God, yeah, I think that makes a good rhetorical logical sense, you know, to see that it would be good for. And natural for him to have what we have.
1:39:30 Yep, that old ice time. What one of the things that attracted me to the Lutheran tradition is it's almost the anti atonic tradition out there, it's very firmly rooted in God, working through matter, God made matter, matter is a good thing and so like I said we look at baptism with a very high view. We look at the Lord's Supper preaching of the The word which is basically God using Airwaves to reach our heart and but let me ask you something about. This is like, as you guys are talking, I'm just trying to spin my wheels.
1:40:10 What is then? The Holy Spirit. What is so we have God being matter. I know Ogden crowd, almost talks about the spirit being almost like a form of matter itself. Except our senses can perceive It's almost like we can't appear clean verify it and in some way. And so what is the holy spirit? If God is matter? Whose turn is it? Start? I forgot. I don't know where I'm at. I don't either Jacob. That means it's on you, buddy. Okay, that's a good question. There's different Mormons that have different philosophical ideas about the doctrine of the holy spirit. That does seem that there is a that that there is a teaching from Joseph Smith that there, is this spiritual element that is diffused, throughout the creation. And, and throughout the universe that this is a channel through which light and red, Ation and you know, different spiritual things have are, you know, it's a spiritual agent to be utilized as God sees fit and early Mormons would argue it's similar to like electricity where, you know, there's these energies in forces in the universe that we don't necessarily, you know, are able to see, but we know that they exist. And so there is that via the Holy Spirit. But there's also the very real view that there is a personage as the holy Spirit and I would
1:41:42 harmonize the two different ideas and that there is this element of spirit that is used. But there also is a third member of the Trinity. The godhead who is a disembodied spirit and and does, all the does fulfills the nature of his office and testifying and witnessing of the truth and comforting us. There's different views on how exactly that works. Modern Mormons would say it's like the sun. You know, the Rays of the sun can be shining and felt in many places even though there's only the sons only in one place. One thing that Brigham Young believe is that and this is I see this in the scriptures and different places. And so there's actually many, holy spirits that act under the Holy Ghost.
1:42:32 And I think in Book of Revelation, it talks about, you know, seven different, Holy Spirit, sent to different churches. And so that's something that Brigham Young said is that he says, by Holy Ghost, I mean, Holy Spirits. I don't pretend to know how many spirits that the Lord has set forth. So that's just a couple ideas on the Holy Spirit. Maybe Michael has some additional thoughts on it. So I love what Jacob said, he's absolutely right. There's been different. There's been different perspectives, regarding our philosophy schools of thought, you know, regarding the Holy Ghost in Mormonism. And I think like Jacob I take a take a look, that kind of synchronizes and Both on together.
1:43:13 There's a quote from before I get into that, that the way I've heard it described and it's probably Joseph Fielding Smith. Who kind of puts it this way, where he says the Holy Spirit. There's a difference between the Holy Spirit and the whole and a personage of the Holy Ghost and the Holy Spirit is also kind of synonymous with what Mormons call The Light of Christ, or the spirit of Truth, which is essentially law, its The law that the Universe operates around or the laws that the Universe operates around to create life and not entropy is how I would maybe put that out there because there is laws that if you know if you do or if you break them, I believe that they causes entropy. There's a there's a quote from a someone who's kind of important and Mormon fundamentalism Ross.
1:44:03 LeBaron, I've always loved when it comes to this and he says that which is beyond the Realms of reason we attribute to God. Therefore two, most intelligent beings, God is the creative law of nature. This God if I may call us such is the most powerful law and Authority in all time in space. No one disobeys without paying the exact penalty, this God is the most most ruthless force in existence and also the kindest for a gives us life Everlasting. This God is a law and not a personality. Personal gods are those who are who by obedience to law have gone ahead of the ones that they preside over. If a man knows more than others, does he not have more power and more glory and so with this view of things in mind, the Holy Spirit, or this, or this, the what is true? Truth is law.
1:45:00 Yeah. And there are these Eternal laws that everything is predicated on and So Orson Pratt kind of had this idea that you know everything has you know that the spirit element, this fundamental matter is that's more pure and not the gross stuff that our bodies are made of is is part of its in everything, right? And everything has an intelligence. And so in that way, It's all kind of like an unconscious entity in a sense and so that gets really, really philosophical, right? But I absolutely love. There's a there's another, there's another Revelation that works in Pratt reads in the Journal of discourses, its Volume 2 page 334 through.
1:45:45 You know, 347 is the speech. Any Source impressed says, there's one Revelation that this people are not generally acquainted with. I think it has never been published but Probably be in the church history, it is given in questions and answers. The first question is, what is the name of God in the pure language? The answer says, almond, what is the name of the son of God answer? Son, almond. The greatest of all the parts of God accepting almond? What is the name of men? Son? Zaman is the answer. What is the name of Angels in the pure language? Anglo man, the Rev load the Revelation and then this is Orson. The Revelation goes on to say that Sons almond or the greatest of all the Parts of God accepting Sun Amon and Amon me or the father and the son. And so there's this view of that, we're all kind of part of the same, you know, intelligence structure, you know, or the Holy Spirit?
1:46:43 We're all connected that way. And I can almost even see that in the lectures on faith, which, which, unfortunately, the poop and put out of the cannon and LBS circles that I think it was dropped in 1923. But in the lectures on faith lecture, 5 Joseph Smith says that the holy spirit is the mind. And of the unity between God, the father and God the son, and it's really interesting that the rest of the lectures on faith. Go about, how do we obtain the mind and the attributes of the Sun? And in the sense, we're becoming the Holy Ghost by that, you know, if we, he defines it, being the mind of God and or the mind of the shared mind of the god, of God and the son, and we get that, then we're almost philosophically in that, you know, this is kind of esoteric. We're filling that role of the third. You know, of the third God in the Trinity that way. And I've always kind of liked that that view, but I do very firmly.
1:47:41 Also, personally believe that there is the third God in the presidency of the godhead. And it's not just representative, but it is also an office, but I also believe that the other two positions are offices as well. So, that's what I got. I think I'd like to add on that is, you know, we since Orson Pratt came up in his holy spirit, Doctrine came up, I would say the thing that got condemned about it was he said that we should worship this Spirit wherever it is. You know, this, this element and Brigham Young said, no, that's, you know, we worship God our father because he is our father, in our career, we don't just worship elements is kind of what Brigham Young said.
1:48:24 And that's why he condemned or some On that point. So underrated, I absolutely agree with Brigham's point on the rebuttal to Orson on that I love reading the exchanges and Billy this, this is stuff that you'll have to dig into because it's fascinating. Oftentimes Mormonism is looked at this super hard hierarchical structure and you can't go against anybody above you. Well, Orson Pratt. Prove that wrong, right? I mean these two guys, Brigham Young and Orson Pratt, they were in the Quorum of The Twelve together. They work side by side but man did they have their differences? And they went to the mat form and you can, it's often Interesting to see how their differences kind of played off of each other a little bit to lessen. A, I think this might lead into the next topic quite, well, you guys alluded to it.
1:49:28 And certainly any Evangelical / Catholic listening to be scratching their head when you guys called father, Adam, and then refer to God as Adam and things like that. So you guys ready to jump and Adam God? Oh yeah. All right. He's so, I mean, I have the questions laid out, but let me try to steal man to perspective before we go into it and just to make sure I understand it. Adam is God, the Father, who was essentially another being on another planet who is went through the same trials and tribulations that we go through was resurrected. By God, his father and brought to this planet to start the human race and so they brought plants, he brought plants with him.
1:50:23 Not sure if he brought animals, but brought things with him and kind of started the production of this planet, would that be correct? I think that's a really, I think it's correct. And I also think it's a very simple view fellas, what do you think jumping here, either one? You I think that's pretty correct. Act what I see I see the atom God auction and developing out of this idea that the gospel is eternal better reproduces as we become joint, heirs with God. You know this cosmology develops of. What does that mean?
1:51:04 What does that? What does an inheritance in the heavens look like, you know, and so We're promised Eternal posterity and with a priest and being patriarchal. It kind of, you know, what this these ideas were as they were explained and revealed to the Latter-Day Saints that, you know, to me became a no-brainer that this came up that okay patriarch Lee. Speaking, you know, if the, if the hierarchy structure is patriarchal than the God is ultimately you know literally the father, right? With the view of the marriage, covenant it In particular was without of being the first man, and Joseph Smith taught this Joseph Smith taught that Adam was the first to whom these spiritual blessings were revealed, you know, by Covenant, then he presides by Eternal all over the spirits of all his children. And would that not make him a God does, you know? And that's what I see.
1:52:02 And we have the privilege of doing likewise, is not shelf, the atom God Doctrine. Is that Adam, and Eve was like, We're like us, they didn't have these blessings that are eternal. they were Celestial, you know, when they when they came to this world I had a had a experience with my brother. I'd share. I got off my mission and I have been really. I recently just barely converted to the atom. God Doctrine by my own studies. And by the spirit and it was, it blew my mind because I had read everything from a church perspective and I had a testimony now that completely went opposed to what I've been taught. And I was like, okay, father.
1:52:45 I have no problem. Receiving this testimony but I do have a problem with explaining it. How like how do I reconcile this? How do I be in the teacher? And I was taking my brother to a sack from a meeting and we had to leave early and this is my brother is he's really smart but he's not studious in the in the sources and things like I am. And the spirit told me, teach your brother, the young God doctor. And I told the spirit fat chance, he's not gonna understand what's what we're talking about. And in spirit is told me to do it. And so, I asked him essentially, you know, do you believe that God has all power and of course he says, well yeah, I do.
1:53:34 And I said, do you think that means that God can become mortal her change himself into a mortal being? And he says, well, I suppose he could, but why would he want to And I told him the president Brigham Young explain to the saints that father Adam was a Celestial being and that having had spiritual children, came down to this earth to, you know, to start this world. And he had everything click like it all fit. All the puzzle pieces came together, but first conversation I Ever Had A Samana and he just said, it would make sense. That the father of our Spirits would want to be the father of our bodies as well.
1:54:17 And and to me that was he got a testimony that from that moment. And so that's this idea. Is it brings man and God into A singularity that officer right word, but we become the same that way. Yeah, we have brought to our remembrance, our divine identity essentially, would you be excommunicated for holding or proposing this view to your church. If you were a mainstream LDS, Depends on how you want about it. If I just gave that discourse over a over, a Sacrament pulpit, and I would get it. I would get a talk for my bishop and if I did not tell him, I would never say that again.
1:55:04 I would be excommunicated. Yeah. It all depends on the area and how lenient they are. You know, towards you know, having unorthodox for use, there's not really a uniform enforcement of policy on beliefs. It's all comes down to your area, your Bishop, your steak present, and sometimes it's how outspoken you are, because if you are too Spoken your bishop and stake. President might have their hands tied by the general Authority saying you have to execute this guy. Even if you don't want to sew it, all it all depends on the circumstances of the individual. When you say unorthodox, it means just you're going against the current teaching, but this is the Orthodox teaching of the LDS church, you are good on you first.
1:55:51 Good on the irony, good on you. Right. One of the things the Orthodox, right? And so when they talk about an orthodox Mormonism, nowadays, it means any Mormon, that's not aligned with the LDS Church. Yeah, and I think listen, if if you just quickly read the early Mormons and that's what I was doing and I was like talking to missionaries and mainstream LDS people and I'm like, something's missing here like something happened. I don't know what happened and so that's kind of how I fell into. I'm like well these guys actually know their history and so it's very interesting.
1:56:40 Jacob, did you have anything to add about the atom God before we jump into questions? Yeah, I think Michael covered it really. Well the the thing I would add for a non-mormon audience is, you know, in the New Testament and in certain places in the Old Testament, there's this idea of being the spiritual children of God, you know, the spirit bear witness with our spirit, that we are the children of God. Most Christians, only think of that as applying to Christians as being adopted. Children through becoming Christians but I think there's a there's verses that indicate a much wider parentage of God, the Father, for example, Hebrews 12 9 saying, furthermore, we have our fathers of our flesh which corrected us and we gave them. Reverence, shall we not much rather be subject unto the father of spirits and live and similarly Mormons interpret Genesis chapter 1 verses?
1:57:36 I believe 25 to 28 very seriously, very literally about About being made in the image and likeness of God. And then you go keep reading in Genesis and Adam create Seth and his image and likeness using very similar words, you know, almost identical words there. And so we understand that you know, Jesse's one is teaching that we are the spiritual children of God. And if God is the father of our Spirits, why wouldn't he also want to be the physical father of his human fat of Of the Human family you know Jenny logically come down and start the process and teach his first children.
1:58:17 You know the missed you know the ways of the gospel and the mysteries of God is so I see the am God is just kind of being logical. Conclusion of the fatherhood of God, my opinion. Gotcha well, jumping jumping into the first question and just to show my hand on this issue. Genesis is a very important book to me, I take a literal view which is kind of frowned upon against Moe would like intellectuals. I went to like the ark Museum in Kentucky and so I read Genesis as like a literal Six-Day creation account. I think that's the Orc, understanding of the church. And so, how would you guys understand Genesis, and maybe let me also go into my second question is, I know, Brigham Young says this should be like, it was almost taught as a fairy tale to the Israelites.
1:59:21 So how would you guys understand? Genesis, is it literal allegorical? So I think some parts are literal. Some parts are allegorical. My understanding of the creation is I believe in an old Earth young Creation in that. I think that the material that make up this Earth is very ancient. Joseph Smith said, it was made out of pre-existing materials from other planets as what Joseph Smith taught and with the creation, I don't personally think there's the That in the Bible that says, you know, day with God is a thousand years. So I think it was about 6,000.
2:00:02 Your creation is my personal opinion on it and I think that I don't think that's what Brigham Young meant was being not literal. I think Brigham Young thought that was literal. That's it's taught some in a similar way. In the temple in the Mormon Temple endowment, the creation is an important part of it. He was just saying that certain aspects of the Adam and Eve story worked literal there. Our parts are very literal and there's parts that are figurative. And there's parts that Christians take is figurative. But Brigham Young said was very literal and there's parts that Christians take as literal. But Brigham Young thought was figurative and his Dave. And I talked about the atom God, Doctrine, and Genesis in a previous discussion, it's ultimately takes the spirit to help figure out what is literal and what isn't in Reading scripture, and there's obviously different interpretations, but Think they're obviously was a very literal Adam and Eve, and I think most of the garden of each eat Garden of Eden story is historical.
2:01:08 It's my opinion. I don't know with Michael as any other thoughts on that or date. Yeah, I'm a. I also view it being allegorical and and literal maybe even more a little bit allegorical. I know in the book of Abraham account of the creation, when the gods are engaged in these laborers, then They say call your labor or is it the endowment? The idea. Now, and they say, call your Labor's the first day, the second day, the third day and so your titling, I almost like you're on a work project. What these these phases for the creation in your calling them days in the book of Abraham? It says that the gods went down the first time. The second time, the third time, the fourth time, you know, and so on. And so it's indefinite, but they're dead. What it shows is that the gods were Sing it and returning to the heavens and descending.
2:02:01 Each time to do to do this work and I wouldn't put a wouldn't put a you know being a day or a thousand years on on it although you know I understand where those interpretations come from. I also agree with Jacob on the Older as young creation kind of a thing and you can kind of maybe even see that and read that into in Genesis, where it says the Earth was already there. When the gods came, it was just without it was it was empty and desolate, as you know, it's not gets rendered, you know, the best, you know, Gods came down, it was it was empty and desolate when they got there and Joseph Smith taught that it was, it had been created from the remnants of other worlds which even. Yeah, I won't go into that but that's that's all. I can see that.
2:02:50 I think that's all I got on that. I think I had something but it slipped my mind. So we'll just go from there. Yeah, and so go ahead. I think also this this also goes to, you know, it in your question of, is it allegorical or literal? I agree with both Michael and and Jacob that it's both, right? When you start talking about the Adam and Eve story in depth, you really do start dealing with Melchizedek priesthood kind of stuff, right? Often It's associated with in Mormonism with temple, rights, and Temple endowments, and those sorts of things. And so those aren't things that we just toss around lightly. And if this is the restoration of the Gospel, I think we could have expected.
2:03:37 Moses, who wrote this stuff down, also would have treated it with a certain amount of sanctity and reverence in. How he approached it Michael, I saw you had your hand raised. Would you have your reminds me of what I wanted to say? So we're talking about Melchizedek priesthood items and maybe you know, although I'm sure some what I think you know, based off of this but you nibbly points out in, in the work that he did to defend the book of Abraham, you know, and he had the Egyptian Book of the Dead and the, you know, the horse book a breathing's and all that stuff. And he did some brilliant work there. I loved it and he brings out how you know You know, so the book of Abraham was a catalyst for Joseph Smith, developing the endowment and what we're in what was in among those, those papers the papyri were was the Egyptian Book of, you know, the book of breathing's which is the endowment where when a person is going to die, they give them their endowment and the person takes the initiate. Takes the role of God or a God and you go through this drama, as you prepare for your burial and there's something striking there.
2:04:50 R where you lay down as a, as a, as you're being reformed, as you're being resurrected in this, in the ceremony, you've, you're going in as a God, but you've died. You're being resurrected now. And the other gods come and you're laying down and they make your body out of dirt out of clay. Yeah, like an adobe and then they breathe the breath of life into you, you know, the gods do. And you see that. And I believe, you know, we see this in the Book of Mormon with this reform to Russian stuff. And I see some how I can tie that into my own theology like when Moses was giving this Parable story to the children of Israel coming out of Egypt, how could he teach them?
2:05:31 The gospel esoterically in a way that they can understand, he would use what they were teaching in Egypt and put in this. How God your father Adam what you know the story about him is at what I believe is an allegory of him being made out of the clay is really what they would understand of the god. Gods are actually resurrecting him and putting his Spirit back at him. And so, he actually came here as a resurrected being and that's how I view. Yeah, I've made that connection there with what Hugh Nibley said. He didn't explicitly say that this was Adam God, but I knew enough to think what he was, you know, to see what he was putting down there. So you're saying that Moses was getting his endowment from the Egyptians.
2:06:15 Would you say that the Egyptians got it from? Abraham is kind of the other thing that Hugh Nibley argues, well, whatever, whatever the Egyptians had, obviously can't. Yeah, we see that in the book of Abraham, like you're saying, like, they faint claim, the priesthood through through Noah, you know, the imitated their government after the priesthood that was the first rain the patriarchal reign of Adam. You know they imitated those things and so that's how Apostasy works, is you start out with all this truth? And then the truth disseminates, although you adulterated with other elements, but then it takes a restoration to purge out the dross and you get back to that original stuff and so, yeah, I think that. Yeah, the, the Egyptians got it from Abraham and they sought to imitate the first train, and then Moses took that and put it into the creation story to teach them. Anyone who had eyes to see, you know, because they took the key of knowledge I believe for the know. The priest of the way but they still left those little breadcrumb trails in the scriptures. I believe it would be interesting to do a deep dive on like Egyptian creation stories.
2:07:21 You know to look at that. Bye. You guys kind of answered some of my questions, you know, Adam being created from the dust while also, so you're saying, Basically. Adam was a resurrected being but maybe came into this planet. And how would you guys understand in Genesis 3:19? It says he was created from the dust. I I like what Michael said, where it's referencing his resurrection and that he he was created from the dust on just Brigham Young would say he was created from the dust of the of the earth, just not of this Earth, he would say he was created from the Dust.
2:08:06 Another is what Brigham Young would say on that. So, another couple things that Brigham Young would use to argue for, well, to say that, the atom God Doctrine is hidden in the Genesis account is the reference to, you know, that. So so easy would point out that Adam and Eve were familiar with God enough, that they just needed to hear his footsteps to know, that know who it was, who is coming to him and he said and so Brigham Young with Say that's proof that Adam and Eve really knew God from a previous time before being in the Garden of Eden that they had a relationship with them.
2:08:46 And they really knew their God long before they were placed in the garden. The other thing that Reagan would use is the creation of Eve or Eve is presented to Adam. He would obviously say the rib story was metaphorical or figurative but he says that she's presented to him as his wife. There is a he says and so he said Some perhaps would say there was a great marriage ceremony in the garden. He says, I don't see any marriage ceremony in the garden. This is just gotten Adams God, saying done. Here's the wife, you have had for so long, your bone of your bone, flesh of your flesh, you know, and he's just giving him presenting to him his own wife, that he's already had. And another verse that I would use to support this idea of the atom.
2:09:30 God, Doctrine is a verse that Christians would generally take metaphorically or As a prophet prophetically and not literally, but we're Adam said that right after. That, Adam says, therefore, shall a man, leave his father and mother and shall cleave unto his wife and be one flesh. So that's indicates that Adam had both a father and a mother that he is leaving to cleave unto Eve his wife. And so I would use that to argue both The Offspring of God idea is hidden in there. And that, you know, the idea of both having it heavenly father and a heavenly mother has hidden in that. Prophetic verse in Genesis.
2:10:10 yeah, I think if there's if there's any part of the Adam God doctrine that Begins to Boggle my mind. It's the idea of Adam one being our Father God, but then he has a father and mother and then Adams follow. It's almost like this infinite progression. And so, Do you see Adam's father throughout the rest of scripture is that. Like so obviously I when Adam is in the garden he's talking and here's the footsteps of his father. How does that play out in the rest of scripture? Is that, is that another God?
2:10:53 I know, there's like a trinity of gods. How does that work? I think go ahead Jacob. Well Dave and I actually talked about this a bit in our Adam God discussion in depth but the my opinion and that I think David greed with me was this idea that while Adam is in mortality that his father acted in his stead for him as God and their statements by like Brigham Young, where he says that whatever God's Enix are the ones that we implied. Different gods and that Enoch saw at that time than the ones that we know. And so, yeah, I don't know.
2:11:37 Dave, do you want to give a answer or Michael either of you? Yeah, yeah, I think, I think there's two things to keep in mind here as we're discussing this. And, and that is kind of a cursory understanding for any of the listeners who maybe haven't listened to those other podcaster done. A deep dive on. Adam God, that themselves is that this is very much a family affair, right? So as as Adam is, is performing his task on this Earth. His father is filling in for him. In in the other Realms so to speak, right? He's he's performing that task.
2:12:22 So oftentimes when we look at Adam God Doctrine and then that inevitably leads to the same kind of questions that you had Billy, I those aren't under uncommon questions when you first encounter this, it's a family affair. So yes, Adam has a God and while Adam is fulfilling his role as the progenitor of the human race, it's his Other that steps inform Michael Jacob. Do you guys have? Is there anything in that answer that you would take exception with? No. No, I didn't want to add one thing to what. Jacob. Jacob ended was quoting Genesis 3. You know.
2:13:05 The Adam says, a man will leave his father and mother and be one flesh. It's also interesting, there's an atom God, you know. Kind of scripture in Matthew 19 where Christ is talking to the Pharisees and Sadducees, don't remember which, and he quotes that and he says, do you not know, remember how it is said that? He at the beginning, who created them said, let no Mia, let them leave their father, and their mother, you know, and cleave unto their life and is literally a quote from Adam. Yeah. And sort of Christ is almost putting that. And, you know, is that the atom, the one who said, this quote, is he that created them? Female from the beginning. And I think that's interesting with Luke chapter 3. You know a says you get this Jenny ology and it says Adam was the son of God and you know and so I do think that as we're touched on like there's this whole Dynasty, this Royal Dynasty above the If you don't believe that they are invested in their children, you're a fool is what I would say. You know, they, they get there.
2:14:15 They get their next round of posterity through us being glorified in them. You know. Brigham Young one said something. You know, he says that your kingdom will be your posterity and he says, well could I be vindictive a centering cut off all my posterity from my from the blessings that they would have? Why would I do that? I would rather be annihilated than being in in such a condition not to have my posterity, you know, to to have in the eternity' and to give those blessings to and to mutually glorify them and then they add glory to him. And that's the whole idea with exaltation is we're actually adding glory to the father and God says to you know to us through the scriptures. You know this is my beloved Son in whom I am well pleased in whom I have glorified my own name you know and so God is glorifying himself and this goes back to Joseph Smith saying self-aggrandizement is a correct Principle as As you use it to build up others.
2:15:20 I would also just add. I mean it's a it's a section of scripture that we as Mormons quote as nauseam, but God says, in the Pro, a great price, you know, this is my work and this is my glory to bring to pass the immortality of man. I think that gets quoted so often that we really miss the true, significance of what God is saying, it's for us, right? And, and if Live correct will have that same opportunity. He does of us working for the glory of our children. I think I think we're well we're either all our fathers or we will be Father's at some point and there is nothing I wouldn't do for my kids, right? And they really are my work and my glory, everything I do at sand at some level is for them and if God really is our father, how much more must he feel than what we can feel in this in on this planet.
2:16:30 Yeah, I think hearing this the biggest push back. Christian's would have or evangelicals would have would be or even Catholics would be the idea that there might be greater God's because throughout scripture, you have this idea of like, God is God Almighty, the most powerful, Deuteronomy 10:17, the Lord, your God is your God and God of Lord of lords. So this Supremacy supremacy of God the father and so, One of the, the hard part's is like how do you make sense of that? If God the father has a father who might be more wise than him who's who's live longer, who might be more powerful, who is experienced more creations and things like this? And so how would you guys understand that? Because I think that's going to be the hardest part for anyone hearing this.
2:17:34 Well, for me, I as I've thought about that and again Jacob and Michael jump in. You have my girls but Michael gets answer this one first but I was just going to say, does this go along with your Isaiah 43:10 question about? No, God, formed before him nor will be the what there one after him. I'm Billy. Yeah, you know what, a 10, it certainly can. I mean that's just playing into this idea that there's like, it seems like this thematic structure throughout the old and new. Estimate of like there is no Gods before me and things like this and so yeah. Absolutely. We could combine those questions. Oh, I'd love to take a step that context with Old Testament. Israel is so important that it's not like we were as Mormons believe that Bales are real entity or that you know Molech or day off.
2:18:22 And these are these are these are false gods in the scriptures. Tell us that these were wife was Idols that people are putting their faith in right as their God is very concerned about putting their faith in something that was going to be. Actually going to benefit them you know but in the eternity' you know which is beyond the scope of what they were what was revealed to them. I think there's some there's some different rules and there's some play there. There's a but address. The question that the last asks us here is like what do we do with these? This idea that other gods no more than are our personal God. I think that's a wonderful question. Yeah, that's exactly. It's like this idea that there are greater gods that no more, that has experienced more I, I don't know if I can take that away because that's this, I do believe that that's the case.
2:19:13 But let me give you some something. I read the BYU, put out back in the 1960s for the best things I've ever done. By a professor named James Harris in 1963 or 67. I want to say, and he called this, this paper, This research paper called The Eternal progression and foreknowledge of God. And in it, he starts out this paper by listing all the quotes from General Authorities saying that God possesses all knowledge and that he'll never learn that. He has all these things that they that basically. So you can put all your faith in him and then there's no variableness simmer in him or shadow of changing. Then he looks all the quotes from from General Authorities in the church saying that God can progress that he will increase in his attributes of Knowledge, as the eternities Roll On, And even points out how sometimes there's the same person if this is the same person saying, you know, something in each campsite, right?
2:20:17 And so, then he goes on in the rest of the papers. How do we reconcile list? And I absolutely love that paper. The way the kind of the conclusion, That he brings up his. The and he has a diagram that he creates and I wish I could like throw it on the screen and show you. But there's this idea that there's that each God, who obtains, his exaltation has obtained, his exaltation through the personal experiences that he's had through that mortality and he's obtained that Resurrection. But so then you would have to ask the question. What does that you know, how you live one life or whatever? And so what are you going to do when something happens on the world's that you're creating that you have no experience?
2:21:02 How are you going to deal with that? And he says, well you have a universe full of exalted fathers that have all obtain their exaltation based on their own experiences and through Consecration and of intelligence, every exalted, father has access to all the experiences of all the other exalted father's, you know. So if one thing were too, so each God, while there might be other gods above him in a hierarchy, patriarch lie, God has all access through all experienced in all knowledge through his family, through all, those who have gone before him. And so, while he hadn't experienced that personally per se, I love that that it's a, you know, the business Divine Storehouse of the mind of the Holy Spirit of knowledge and that God, then that allows us to put all this Things in perspective that God is individually still progressing in attaining, New Heights and new glories, but he has all access to information necessary for us to put faith in him.
2:22:08 Understand unto our salvation, and exaltation Very interesting. Take up. You have anything to add? Yeah I would say what the early Mormons would say about God. The father is I couldn't have confidence in a god that is putting me through all these trials and hardships and experience. I kind of I can't have confidence that he really feels and understands what I'm going through unless he has been through a similar experience, is what they said. And so we don't and so like, Orson, I would say we don't serve General. Who has who wouldn't do what he sending others to do. We serve a general who has gone through what we have experienced. I think that philosophically is the strongest philosophical argument for God having once been a man and progress to godhood.
2:23:00 I agree that it's probably the hardest thing that and teaching different people Mormon fundamentalism, who come from a non-mormon background, that's definitely. I agreed that they say that's the hardest thing is this The idea of God's above God, the Father, this idea of, you know, this is totally different cosmology and it's not really in the Bible and I agree. It's not stated in the Bible but you know, according to Mormonism. This is the dispensation where things that you know that there would be hidden mysteries revealed about the nature of God and the nature of you know that there would be new knowledge given in this. Dispensation though I do think that there are things in Should tradition and in the scriptures that would hint at God. Having once gone through a mortal existence, what Joseph Smith cited in the king, Follett discourse was John 5:19 where Jesus himself says that the sun does do with nothing but what he is sees the father doing.
2:23:59 So he's saying that you know he's doing what he saw his father do. And so Joseph Smith would say and so what did the father do? He had power to lay down his life and redeem a world and And so, Jesus Christ also has the power to lay down his life and raise it up again redeeming an earth. So that, that's how I would look at the gods above God, the Father doctrinally to answer the other question about the scriptures about there, only being one God. And I think the best way to look at it is the I think it's called Mono. That can't forget, I can't use that. I can't remember the exact term but Is another term that similar called henotheism. The idea that there's only what there's only a got certain God for us, but there are other jobs out there is the I think the other terms model are he isn't mono lateral ISM model, laterals and thanks Michael.
2:25:00 So in First Corinthians chapter 8 there's this verse after Paul's talking about you know I you know as two sacrifices to Idols. We know that I idols Thing in the world and there's none other God. But 14, though there be that call for though there be that are called God's whether in heaven and earth or in earth as there be God's many and Lords many. But to us, there's one God, the father of whom are all things and we in him and one Lord Jesus Christ by whom are all things and we by him. So what's significant here is he says there are those are called God's whether in heaven or on Earth, would a false god be in heaven.
2:25:40 And I would say no, there that is. They're in heaven. They have to be a true God and, you know, the false gods would be the ones on Earth. And he says, indeed, there are God's many and Lords. Many's what is, is its translated, awkwardly in the King James, but that's what's put in parentheses. Right there is after saying, you know, but to us, there is one God and one Lord. So it's this idea of there are many gods, but that to us there is, you know, one God that we worship, who is our father and creator. Until the early Christians. Interestingly, an ancient Jews did have a polytheism in a sense that they believe that there are many Divine beings that were God's underneath God, the father and their statements like origin and Clement of Alexandria and Justin Martyr. Oh there's a lot of different early Christian quotes on this. I'm just for sake of time.
2:26:33 I'm just going to read one. We're redoing the Divine Council right? Yeah. Divine Council he says There are some gods of whom God is God, as we hear in Prophecy. Quote, Psalm 136 to thank. He the god of gods and Psalm 51, the god of gods have spoken and called the earth. Now, God, according to the gospel, is not the god of the dead, but of the living, those Gods then are living in whom God is God, the Apostle Paul to writing to the Corinthians says, there are God's many and Lords. Many. And so, we have spoken of these Gods as really existing. And so, in Orange. InStyle clogged with hurt her at Clyde's, which was an early Christian dialogue. That was before the whole church of Alexandria they discussed. He was saying that there was starting to be some controversy over the godhead and how to interpret their being one God. But then we have both the father and the son is two distinct beings.
2:27:31 And so he agreed with her Clyde's, the bishop in origin goes from just being distinct from the Father. The Son is himself. Also God, her Clyde said he is himself. Also, God origin says in these two Gods becoming Unity parrot. Clyde said yes. Origin says, we profess to God's heraklion says yes. But the power is one origin goes but since our brothers are shocked at the statement, there are two Gods, we must treat this matter, carefully and point out in what respect there too. And in what respect these, two are one God. Now the holy scriptures of time many instances to being one and not just two. But in some cases they have taught us that more than two and even a great number one. He goes on to give some scriptural evidences of like the man and his A wife are one flesh and he goes on a quotes, like, John 17 about the, the union of Jesus, and the father, and the disciples. And so, then he goes on what then is the meaning of such sacred texts.
2:28:24 As before me, no other God was formed, nor shall there be any after he and the text. I even, I am he and there is no God beside me. And these texts one is not to think that the unity refers to the god of the universe has Purity apart from Christ nor that refers to Christ apart from God. But will he say, The stress is Jesus, expresses that the father and I are one. So, the idea is that the gods and the kingdom of heaven are perfectly United and it's their United as one God and they, this gets into, you know, some deeper Mormon doctrine, of divine investiture, where the gods are so perfectly United, that they share the glory, they share the credit for everything that they do, and they can act in the stead of each other.
2:29:09 So, I hope that kind of answers the Ian. Yeah, absolutely. Yeah. Can I take that further? You can see you can see what Jacobs talking about there in John 17. Even, you know, Christ is praying to the father, you know, the great high priest, intercessory prayer, their knees praying that his brother and might be one. Not literally. I see his little, you know, yeah, the Mormons had fun with this scripture a lot, but Christ is a clearly praying that the disciples will be one. In purpose as the Christ was one in purpose to Father. Otherwise, if you interpreted Christ in one was called, literally, then to Christ to be praying that the disciples would literally become one in body with God.
2:29:51 That would make a pretty big God. Yes, it's just talked about, but you see this since insincerity, this prayer that the apostles become United and see you see, this is what I say. What I see in this is that you is this Evolution from priesthood to godhood. Usually a body of precedent to God there and I'll tackle this scripture in Isaiah to from the New Testament perspective. You know, in Philippians 2 says let this mind be in you which was also in Christ. Jesus who being in the form of God, thought it not robbery to be equal with God. And Jesus says, in John 10, I and my father are one.
2:30:32 And I would say that me and Joseph Smith taught that that means that they are agreed, you know. So that Jesus says, I am my father are one and then the Jews took up stones again to Stone him and Jesus answered them. Many good works have. I shown you from the father for which of those Works. Do you Stone me the Jews? Answered him saying for a good work, we Stone thee, not but for blasphemy and because that thou being a man makest himself God and Jesus answered them, is it not written in your law? I said that your Gods. If he called them Gods unto whom the word of God came and the scripture Cannot be broken and solves 82, which he's quoting from.
2:31:14 He says that God, says stands in the congregation amongst the gods and judges amongst the gods, ER, Chile are the children of the most high you know or the most high God. So you see this plurality of gods or this this idea that you can inherit that position I think in the teachings of Christ, very specifically. Yeah, it's fascinating just one. Just a thought on the doctrine that saltation or the osis as it's called in the you know Christian tradition is when I've been studying it there's a lot of different quotes on it from the early fathers and you know there's actually different opinions on it and but you know I thought you're a gnaeus was the most explicit where he said that God is able to bridge.
2:32:03 The gap between us as the creation and him as the Creator that you know through The through Christ that he is able to make us for take completely of the nature of what he is. And there are different Christians at different ideas. On that Clement of Alexandria didn't think that we could fully become at exactly as God. The father. He thought that we could become as far as possible but irenaeus and reading him he was like very explicit that he's going to make us be absolutely everything. He is in his nature and you know that God became man, slut men can become. God's is, you know, one of many different quotes on that subject, their quote, from Lorenzo Snow as well.
2:32:49 So, one of the questions I have is, did we know our father Adam in heaven? Like the, we knew him as a resurrected being, right? And we were spiritual drain and to get our bodies, we came here that way you got to leave. That's what I believe. I won't think somebody else, but that's yeah, that's absolutely what I believe, but sounds like the right idea to me. Okay. All right. So, how would you guys Define sin? I would think a willful deliberate act against God, the father.
2:33:31 Now, can I ask you a quick question? Is this in regards to your question of did Adam sinned? Okay, so let me, let me ask you a couple questions here so I think this will help. Okay. What two Commandments were given to Adam and Eve in the garden. First one would be be fruitful and multiply. Okay, what was the second one? Do not eat of the tree of knowledge with evil. Okay. Is there any record to Adam and Eve had children in the garden? Now when do children begin to come forth from Adam and Eve You see that after they after the attack a caption, right?
2:34:18 Yeah. So I don't think Adam sinned. I think he was given a commandment to Commandments but they could not be filled simultaneously gentlemen, Michael Jacob. Does that seem out of whack with either of you? Nope, doesn't seem now. Walk with me, I would Define sin is transgression of law, is the way I and it specifically. We like to think of moral law the laws that God has instituted or he discovered that our for our well-being and benefit. And, and I like what Ogden cop went, where he saw the transgression of Adam and Eve in particular, Fruit was a transgression of a law of nature not a moral law that it was Trenton was it was a lot.
2:35:16 Breaking a law of nature by following from Immortal Celestial states, to following into. Mortality, is kind of what is what, Ogden Kraut, it's how he explained it. So, there's a difference between, you know, willfully breaking, moral commandment versus, you know what? What happened to the Garden of Eden was anything like willful Rebellion against God? It was you know, Eve was tricked and Adam said, well she's going. I have to go to, right? Okay, so let me so Eve was tricked. But didn't they know the plan?
2:35:57 Like they knew the plan that they were coming to do was to create the human race. And so did she have some knowledge of what would happen? Like, how do you fit the the that whole narratives between the serpent in the eaves? So I think she definitely did have a some you know she had a degree of knowledge and say and did it ever will he didn't? He presented half-truths, he would say you won't die was just But he told her but, you know, obviously cheaper took of it and God Said, Yes, actually, you are going to die, I don't know. Michael, you have any other thoughts on that? But I decided some quotes, especially for a, the allotted a state body on the scene from Joseph Fielding Smith, he related in a and Institute class.
2:36:47 He said, why did Adam come here not subject to death when when he was placed on the earth, there had to come A change in his body through the / taking of this element whatever you want to call it fruit that brought blood into his body and that blood became the wife of the body, instead of the spirit, and the blood has in it, the seeds of death. Some moral element mortality was created through eating of the forbidden fruit, if you want to call it forbidden, but I think that the Lord made it clear that it was not forbidden. He merely said to Adam, if you want to stay here in this situation, you know, if so don't eat it. And he also said, you know, answers to gospel questions, Adam. And Eve did not come here in a moral State. They had to come in the manner in which they did and then transgress the law.
2:37:36 So again, like you're saying Jacob it's a, it's a transgression of a law and not necessarily a moral sin. And he goes on to say the Trap that transgression of that law, contrary to the view of many was not a sin, it was not a sin anymore than the transgression in the laboratory by a chemist in combining two. Distances and creating another entirely different from the first. It was not a sin to buy a to bring to pass mortality. A condition which was essential to the Eternal welfare of man the fall change, the nature of Adam and Eve to fit them for the condition in which we are. Now in this, I view my view that story with that, in mind, that there was a transgression of physical law that changed the chemical substance allowed them, which allowed them to bring us forth, and our situation.
2:38:26 So we can be tested and tried to get the bodies. Yeah, live the gospel, it's still definitely, don't view that Adam sinned. So your least reading the book of Nephi, it almost seems to frame what happened there. As a good thing that almost to have knowledge of Good and Evil gives you free will and so therefore then you can go. And actually please God forget the actual Passage. Called the Felix culpa. It might be marching fall. Yeah, so that's something that's had and Christian tradition to differing degrees. But the Book of Mormon definitely canonize has that as being a scriptural Doctrine.
2:39:13 Right? And second, he fi chapter 2. Yeah. Yep. And so it is, is the fall a bad thing? It's almost like you get this duel notion. It's like, well they sin. They brought death into the world but it's a good thing but they transgress. So That's where my, that's where I struggle with this. I think it's absolutely a good thing, right? I mean we call it the fall but it's absolutely a good thing and it's necessary without it we don't have us, right? We're not here doing this because Adam and Eve were in a state of being which, you know, they weren't having physical children and the only way for them to have Children was to partake of that fruit or those Elements, which then allowed them to, to have children and to begin to populate the race.
2:40:09 It allowed us to have agency allows us to, as you said. And I think it was an eloquent way. You put it Billy to please, God to choose to please God. So yeah, I think it was absolutely a good thing. Michael. Jacob you have anything to add to that I would shortly. I just it's in my estimation second e Phi chapter 2 is the greatest treatment philosophical philosophically on why there's evil. Why there's good while you need to opposition all things that's actually what converted me to Mormonism. I was raised in the church, that's what I read that. What about being about, 19 years old. Like that's the first time. I remember being really fully converted in my adult life was reading.
2:40:54 Second if I you're too and it was so profound to me that It solves the problem of evil philosophically Christianity. Because Christianity has to deal with that, right? I did God create Lucifer them as God is God, accountable and responsible for for introducing evil you can't adjust and true and got a good god actually introduced evil into the world, Mormonism solves that philosophically by saying these these two things, the oppositional things. It's always been that way it's and it's necessary. Otherwise there could be no existence. The entire other, the two pillars of Eternity. Yeah, that all of creation stands on and you can't do without it. And so absolves God of the and us, you know, not it doesn't absolve us but it gives us the knowledge and it tells us how important knowledge has because you can't, can you truly have agency without knowledge is what I would ask, you know? So that's my thoughts.
2:41:52 Yeah, this may be bleeds into the next question of A big Doctrine within Christianity. Is the sin nature, original sin. So, do you guys believe that we have original sin, does it affect, or will in any way thinking of Luther's, bondage of the will, if you ever read it how to send actually affect Generations after Adam. So, I definitely disagree with a what I considered, you know, what's gonna explain What original sin is is that we inherit the sin of Adam, I definitely don't believe. Well, first off, I don't believe it that there was a moral sin there, but the scriptures in the pearl of great price, you know? It lays out some really interesting things about how kind of the things go.
2:42:44 You know, how things kind of went after the fall. One thing it kind of delineates is that, you know, Adam was instructed on how to teach his children, the gospel and as he's presenting the gospel and pointing their minds to towards the Savior, Satan comes among the children and says, believe it or not, and they believe did not write it like this. This Angel masquerading as an angel of light masquerading as the angel of the Lord tells Adams posterity not to believe. And it also, you know, Enoch is giving a speech in the pearl of great price. And he says, as we are born into this world, sin begins to conceive in our hearts and a gross, right? And so it's There is something about being in this Fallen Earth where were that?
2:43:32 The scriptures is a sin conceives in our hearts. But then I would say it's our choice, whether we nourish that or not or if we prune it and pointed Point our hearts towards God and Christ instead, you know, and the way that the gospel was revealed do you have essentially accountability on each bus but I do believe that intrinsically most Are probably good enough depraved but do you the devil does exist. You mind if I read Romans 5, this is kind of like the go-to passage Romans 5:12. Therefore just as Sin came into the world through one man and death through sin, so death spread to all men because all had sinned for sin.
2:44:17 Indeed was in the world before the law was given. But sin is not counted. Where there is no law. It death reigned from Adam to Moses. Even those who sitting was not like the transgression of Adam, who is a type of the one to come. and so that, that is just From my perspective, used to illustrate that. We all sin, we all fall short, but sin is actually this thing that brings forth death to Future generations. And so I guess you guys said that partaking of the fruit is the partaking of humanity in a way of him becoming more human.
2:44:59 Is that how would you understand Sim? Well, I wouldn't say that he needed to become more human than he already was. But in order for us to come down and become more human. Yes, and so in a way it's in does become. Through that door. It does, it did come through Adam but not because he's sinned, but the opportunity was presented for us to to have our own since, that's how I. Yeah, I actually have, I wondered about Romans 5 there and I think it's actually pretty weak for arguing that, you know, that sin is imputed upon everyone, but I read it, you know, very much just a you know, through what Adam did the opportunity for sin is there for us and we We do damn ourselves and cut ourselves off from Life.
2:45:46 Yo, life Everlasting. If we do sin, and we don't repent, and we don't obey the gospel. Yeah, I would say from Romans 5, is we inherit the effects of the transgression, the Garden of Eden, and everyone inherits those effects, you know? But we don't inherit the blame for that. We inherit a sinful nature through, you know, which is we have a On nature that's prone to to be sinful. But you know we are accountable for our own sins. I see that from understand that both the Eastern Orthodox, as well as the early Christians were big on, WE inheriting the effects of the original sin, but not necessarily the blame. And so the early Christians believed like children for example, if a child dies they're innocent and they're going to go to heaven is something that I see very clear from the Early Christians up until I think Augustine has different ideas. If I understand right?
2:46:47 I haven't studied his writings but That's just kind of my thoughts on it. Well, I like that and it goes back to that article of faith, you know, that we believed we were accountable for our own sins and not Adam's transgression and so it kind of just kind of claws. They're almost Preparatory for the atom, God doctrine that I like a lot there, you know, is this is a transgression but we're accountable for our own sins, right? And a weird was that differently? And I like that. Yeah, I did you say I think Right on the head. So I think you guys are spot-on. Only thing I can say to that is. Amen. So if Adam brought death into the world, does he need to be Redeemed by the cross with that? I don't.
2:47:35 I think that his transgression wasn't so there are different fundamentalist takes on that. I've heard some fundamentalist think that yes Adam needed Christ to his father needed Redemption from his own son. Is what I think that's a minority view. I personally don't hold to the I think that Adam was act and you know and that he is Brigham Young taught. He said he didn't think the atom actually died. He thought that Adam would just return to the spirit world from whence he came and, you know, in the Bible it says Adam died. And similarly says that Moses died. You can you can.
2:48:15 There's different ways that Mormons would explain that, for example, with, with Moses, in the Book of Mormon actually says that they have a tradition that Moses was actually. Insulated and didn't actually lay his body down in the dust. And so there's this idea and Mormonism that you know the scriptures are always translated correctly and possibly both Moses and Adam did actually lay their bodies down in the dust. But went back to, you know, we're translated and Moses is case to go into a terrestrial world or in Adams case to return to the celestial world where he came is, my kind of view, Yeah, I completely do is Jacob. I either see it as being a type in a sense. For Christ laid his body down for three days if he was to die. According to old age after having retain his mortality, that he would have been transfigured back to a Celestial glory.
2:49:13 After a certain amount of time that his body did not Decay or that he particular. The fruit of the tree of life and was granted access That which would Purge out the blood and bring spiritual fluids back into his body to give that give him the action of Life, by spirits of my blood. It's kind of my take on that. Yeah, I agree with both of you guys on that, I think that's, that's spot-on. All right. Well, Pretty much made it through all my questions. And I mean, I could just end on maybe some Personal things and maybe some things that I wrestle with. As I view your tradition and Faith, but maybe do you guys, obviously you all believe in polygamy, how does your wives feel about?
2:50:14 That's a big thing like how would your wives feel about that or how do they feel about that? I know Dave, you you maybe talk about that on your podcast a little bit? Key. I do Chi was the one that introduced me to it. So I mean it was, it was, it was yeah, I I'm not sure. My story is necessarily indicative of how that normally happens. But gosh, my wife and polygamy. We definitely hope. That we get to have that opportunity again. My wife describes that period in our lives as we were living plural, marriage as definitely some of the most spiritually rewarding times we ever had. That doesn't mean it was without struggle but what she said is that we grew closer together all of us, did we cleaved to one another we grew in truth together and we Rejoice together.
2:51:23 It was some of the most Peaceful times some of the most fulfilling times that I have had and we were all emotionally open and raw with one another and there were so many blessings to be had because it took added communication. It took added feeling, and it took added work on the part of all of us and so we, we hope for that again. Will it happen? I don't know. I hope so. But yeah, it was it was definitely rewarding on a lot of different levels.
2:52:04 Does that answer your question? Absolutely. Yeah, I know it's very interesting. I mean, most people obviously when you talk to them about this type of thing, there their immediate, if it's a guy, it's like I can't handle that or that, you know, that would be too much work and you know, if you talk to maybe women, it's a jealousy issue or sharing the husband and things like that. And so, you know, it just it's curious to me. It's a total different world for me. And so peek my head into this kind of bubbles, very interesting. You either you fellas have anything to add. I mean as I mean look it's no secret. Right?
2:52:51 I mean how do your wife feel about it? my wife grew up around it, and she's told me that while she's You know, she has the natural feelings that a woman normally feels regarding that hasn't and see you know and wondering how you know what's how's it going to work and you know you know are we going to feel the same and all of that she has expressed to me that she feel you know, that we didn't enter into it. She feels like she missing something, you know cult you know especially I think culturally from what she's in, you know this she feels that if we didn't go there someday that will be missing opportunities.
2:53:35 And as you'll regret it but at the same time that's cut. Yeah, it's kind of equally balanced with the with insecurities as well. I would say that's fair, I think it's totally fair because men have insecurities regarding it to. I know for a fact I do. I will admit that. How do you treat? How do you become such a just person that you can, that you can just stand on truth and not be not be swayed, you know, in your hearts going to make your heart is absolutely. Salute going to ache and you're going to have to be firm and immovable and hopefully, then you know, the wives will learn, oh he's he's fixed. His eyes are on God and and you know, and that's a safety net for me, you know, and I can follow that and that's kind of what I think it's supposed to do is, as Dave said. It brings us family close together, under under God. You know, and that's my testimony. I've seen it, I've lived in a household that's plural with throw wives and I've seen a Celestial family that way and I have a testimony of it and I know the hard but it's a purification thing partly to its to see. How are you going to?
2:54:50 It's like that Joseph Smith, actually he liked and is under the parable of talents you know it's a he says he who has just one Out of it taken what he has had and will be given to another. He doesn't magnify it, right? And, and, and those who do well will be blessed to be rules over many, right? That's kind of how he taught polygamy. My wife also grew up around polygamy, and it's something that she seen both the struggles and hardship that can happen in an ideal circumstances. And she's also seeing families in her family, Circle and circle of families and friends. That That did polygamy really well, and that's what really gave her testimony of it.
2:55:34 As a principle is seeing those who do plural marriage. Well, but as a close friend, of mine says, he says, even in the most ideal circumstances, it's hard. There's you know, challenges and difficulties that you don't encounter in monogamy. And so everyone, I think who's not in polygamy. But think, you know, they expecting, they might be called to it by the Lord has that insecurity. Of will we be able to handle the challenges that come with it? Both, you know, on the husband's part to be loving and caring and just in in how he treats his wives and his children and being responsible for them, you know, having to provide for them and for women, you know, obviously the insecurities that come with jealousy that can occur or you know the other, you know, the problems that the husband's going to have to shoulder so well.
2:56:30 Someone will someone be able to someone like myself would someone like myself, who has a single wife, be able to make it to the Celestial Kingdom in your view? In my view? I think Brigham Young said that everyone who is faithful and goes through those ordeals prepared for the Church of the firstborn, will be able to inherit the glory of the father and the son. But what Ely also weighed say is that that fact that polygamous would have a greater In the Celestial Kingdom is what he said are a higher exaltation is what both lime and white and Brigham Young taught. And so my opinion is that there can be monogamous in the Celestial Kingdom, but everyone has to advance to plural marriage in order to become a God and part of that is because it's, you know, God is as a much larger family than any of us can even imagine, and Joseph Smith said that the way we learn how to become God's is he says to know, Oh God, learn how to become God's.
2:57:31 God is exalted by the addition of subjects to his family or Kingdom. So we are commanded in the scriptures to multiply replenish, the are commanded to have families and to have children and to deal with those trials and difficulties that comes from having children, of course, we also get the rewards and the blessings that come with with having children and having large families and flow marriage, just magnifies that, you know, both The difficulties and the blessings if done successfully is my opinion. And so that's how why I see polygamy is a stepping stone to exaltation is because it's about having learning how to govern large family kingdom in righteousness because God himself has a large family. So Very, very cool.
2:58:25 I think one of one of the things that at least he see portrayed in the media is that either people are doing this purely for sexual motivation motivations or there is some type of wicked cult you know the Warren Jeffs on Netflix. And so the the idea that the public has is like it either. One of those two options like the TLC version of and I haven't watched the show, but people have told me you know, this guy's kind of just sex-crazed to some extent or you have some profit in the wilderness. You just takes a bunch of people wants to, you know, take a bunch of wives.
2:59:07 And so you guys, I don't think your perspective is really out there. The fact that there are practicing polygamists to Are just quiet live low to the ground just do their thing and maybe not known to the broader public. Well yeah I think the majority of polygamists are living low to the ground trying to take care of their families doing the best. They can this idea that that polygamy is about self gratification. There's a lot easier ways to get sex than taking on another family. I mean it that that is this Earliest idea I've ever heard.
2:59:50 The other thing I'll say, is that, if a man's going to live plural marriage, he had better have God fixed in his sights. Because if you do not, you will lose everything. I have no doubt about that. I was fortunate that, you know, my entire family didn't blow apart when when my plural marriage ended. I've shared the story before, but I'll share it again because I don't think I've ever shared it with you Billy. When there was a moment where it all made sense to me, and that was, I was watching my wife's, we had this five acre spread where we lived at the time.
3:00:38 And as usually is the case, I have a lot of epiphany standing in front of the grill. And if you could really see me in full breath, you'd understand, I stand at the grill often so it makes sense. I guess Revelation there. Anyway, I was there and I was watching all the kids play together. I was watching the girls kind of laughing and giggling off by themselves and it was the funniest thought that occurred to me, I haven't been golfing in probably a year and a half and you know what? I didn't care, I didn't care because in that moment, There's nothing more. I want to do than to serve my family. And so what gets portrayed in the media? What gets portrayed in the news is a small slanted sample size. and so, I learned how to be selfless through plural, marriage, to put all of my wants and my desires on the back burner, to serve my family.
3:01:45 And and I think you only get there by having your eyes fixed on God. Very interesting. I absolutely agree with that. Like there's a lot of talk of family first and obviously family comes before your church or your country, but I agree with Dave, that obviously God comes before family in, that's where you need to have your heart in your mind, centered on is serving God, no matter what, and I'm trusting in Him and that's what it's It's, you know, to have that Faith to be able to, you know, do hard things and accomplish, you know, in some sometimes I've seen plural families. I'm like that seems impossible.
3:02:31 And you need God in order to make things that appear impossible be possible and not only possible but blessings, right? So, There's that story of I think Joseph and Hyrum and I think Joseph revealed the doctrine of polygamy and Hiram's like all about it very excited about it. I think Joseph's like kind of like slap them on the hand a little bit. It was like no you're too excited about it maybe for the wrong reasons. Is that is that true? I haven't heard that story before, but I do think I do think he was converted. He was very converted and he He's the one who's like, I, if I can be converted than everyone else can be converted. I'm going to read DNC 132 to everyone. And that's how polygamy blew up.
3:03:20 And novel was really Hiram, trying to get everyone else on board and unfortunately, there were high, you know, Emma obviously wasn't on board. William law was on board and they cause things to blow up out of control because they were on board with it. But, you know, of a similar story like he's talking about Michael and Not, it's not coming to my house. I haven't heard that with him being overly eager, I do know the context of his conversion. I think happened to be that he had a wife, Donna died, and he was married to a second wife, you know, it was a second marriage when he was taught this. This, you know, that Joseph is brother came to him and said, look marriage can be Eternal. You can have both you know and he loved his other wife so much and this one you know Mary Fielding You know so much and it just he was converted because he loved both of them so much and he's I can have them both in eternity. Not just in this life, you know.
3:04:20 And that to me, was he and you're right, he absolutely was the one who You know, it was such it was so crazy because he was against what he perceived jhansi Bennett was doing here. Jhansi Bennett was brought into that program a little bit earlier by Joseph Smith and then he caused it to be whoredom in adultery and then hire, you know, so hyphen was going around the steak trying to get rid of jhansi, Bennett's BS, and kind of everyone was kind of on the lookout because they knew he was Joseph's brother. But Brigham of The Twelve were kind of Of in on it and those kind of I think uncomfortable for a little bit right there. But then when it was explained to him and it was the same with parley P prep, our leafy Pratt had. It was his second marriage by the time, it was explained to him and they were just converted to the idea that this this idea that marriage can exist in your family, in your children, you can have all of them together and so I think that's pretty interesting.
3:05:20 I think what you're thinking of is the story of all of our cowdrey Brigham Young tells us, Worried that when Joseph, for Scott, the principle of celestial marriage, while I think translating you to the Book of Mormon or the Joseph Smith translation of the Bible that he got a revelation on, you know, plural marriage under authorized circumstance and Oliver want to run with it is what Brigham Young or called and he said that Oliver ran ran with it. Contrary to Joseph's Council and he saw sorrow and woe for it. It's what Brigham Young recalled I may have gotten the names. Mixed up. But I personally like Brigham's response when he said he first learned about it, he said he learned about it and then he stepped outside and he saw a funeral procession and he said he envied the body inside the casket. So I mean Brigham was was a little apprehensive at first as well.
3:06:18 I think. Yeah. I think a righteous man is it? He sees what a trial. So the wicked man sees it. She's pull marriage and goes. Woo hoo sex with a lot of women. This is going to be so fun. This is going to be so great and he's the right and so he's got the total around attitude about it and that's what I believe. Jacob, chapter 2 and the Book of Mormon is condemning, the righteous man looks at and says, look at that responsibility, that's now going to be on my shoulders. And the the the financial responsibility, the emotional responsibility. Of taking care of and the hardship that could happen to the women involved emotionally.
3:07:02 He looks at it and he says, I don't want to have to do that is what the righteous man does. But he says I'm willing to do what God promises, will bring the greatest happiness, right? I'm willing to do the hard things that will bring greater happiness. So, I think maybe maybe this could ended too is if you guys want to wrap it in on one question, you know? My journey into this world has really been eye-opening and interesting. I met a lot of great people, but one of the things that I look at is, The worldview that gets built from.
3:07:50 From the these Concepts. And so when we look at polygamy, when we look at Adam God, they get introduced the church and it almost seems like automatically within decades, the church stamps down on these doctrines. And so for an outsider looking in, if God is truly behind this movement of restoration, what what happened? What the heck happened and that's always been Like a reoccurring thought of my mind is like you kind of almost measure things by their fruit or test things by their fruit. And so maybe if you guys want to end it here and let me also say this one last thing is as a Lutheran, I think there are a lot of similarities between how we kind of approach this thing. It's almost like the Catholic church had gone astray and so we looked at the Lutheran confession often uses patristics in order to make their argument to say We're not teaching anything new.
3:08:50 This is kind of getting back to the old stuff. You know, they're quoting the word of God. And so in a similar way, you guys are going back to the early Mormon, Founders and quoting. And so there is that parallel between us and in terms of how we approach the faith, but how would you guys view the fact that the church is in the state where of maybe disarray right now, Michael, I saw your Ergo up like you wanted to take this 10 ISO, do I am passionate about this one growing up in the church especially and finding, you know, fundamentalism and Jacobs the same way and he grew up in the church and I think we were late on that so much, but we But I know that I have a testimony of these principles.
3:09:42 Brigham Young said to the saints that the saints were going to get Revelations. And at the Saints did not accept the revelations. Then they would be sent all the revelations, not the spirit of God, and they would believe those Revelations and that goes online with Thessalonians, right? Where God says, you know, they love Ally will be sent strong delusions. So they will be double, leave that life that they want to, they do. I want the truth and so in a big instant you know, unfortunately the case a lot of Mormons towards the turn of the century, they got no point I think where they didn't want the truth and I do that the priesthood and the church are separate and the church is an appendage, the priesthood. And Brigham Young taught that in the, you know, with this great apostasy to happen the last time that it wasn't that the priesthood was taken out of the church. It's that the church that Christ established went away from the priest of, they went away from the laws in the ordinances, and that's what happened first.
3:10:48 So, that's what in this case. It's the same thing. I believe that Authority was maintained and to perpetuate it, you know, ordinances like, plural, marriage. So that can continue and there have been men from, you know, that kind of in this Middle Ground, you know, between the Pioneer era and the modern era who were willing to stand on, this is what we were taught. This is what we're going to stick to and this is what we're going to teach our children. No matter what. Yeah, what is taught in general conferences now. Yeah, because you had a huge, you had a huge turnout change of policy and everything, under Heber J. Grant in the 1920s that completely reinvented Mormonism, I think.
3:11:33 And so, I really think it goes back to the fact that you over you will believe strong delusions. If you don't want the truth and and Brigham Young also said that, by the time you get into that condition. Yeah. You're the leaders. Are just going to lead you because they're blind themselves, you know, and you're just going to follow them. Sorry, it was really interesting to see. Someone like, I guess, Bruce are McConkey and he, you know, in his BYU speech, just totally bashed. Adam God Doctrine. It's like this is a Doctrine that's taught by Brigham Young. And so, it's like kind of this weird. I don't understand it, but go ahead, Jacob. Yeah, he said, I won't throw stones at Brigham Young, but anyone who believes that now isn't going to know if they've been through.
3:12:27 The endowment, they don't deserve salvation is what, you know, the irony of saying, I won't condemn Brigham Young for what he taught, but I condemn anyone who believes it now. So we believe that the gospel is something that's not supposed to be changed. That, you know, the truth is our true today were true. 100 years ago were true 200 years ago, where true 1,000 2,000 years ago and so, you know, that's what we're seeking after is truth. And it's kind of in the scriptures, the pattern of Different dispensations, that they start off with a grand restoration, but then there is gradual, apostasy that Creeps in or abrupt. Apostasy, in the case of Moses. He said, the children of Israel were not worthy of the higher things and he broke the first tablets and he cursed them and it that's kind of more direct and LDS scriptures but in the what's in the Bible?
3:13:22 You can still see that they didn't get God's original plan with where God said I was To take the firstborn of all of Israel and have them all, be priests to me, of all the tribes. But because instead, I am only going to do the Levites. And I personally think that's because when the sin of Israel happened like the Senate at the golden calf that Levites were the ones least in transgression. And so God said they're still going to be able to get pulled, the Priestly Authority. And so I see with early Christianity, you have a lot of great truths that over time. You start to see Innovations Crypt creep in. And as you say as a Lutheran you also you know, see that the Catholic Church changed Doctrine and things gradually became different and with the LDS church, it's no different.
3:14:10 I see, that's just the pattern of every dispensation, what Mormon fundamentalist believe is that we believe that the truth that were restored through Joseph, Brigham and, and they're worthy, contemporaries were restored to stay on the earth this time and not to be lost again. And at the priesthood this time, even if the church goes into apostasy that the priesthood is to be preserved, and that there will be a people that will build up Zion and received the choicest blessings of the Lord. And so, I hope that we can all strive to, you know, be as I and like people, you know, that in the, that's a term in Mormon, scripture, people were called Zion because they're one heart and one mind.
3:14:52 Where is that priesthood? If you had a breach that I'm, I'm glad he didn't get to win the Prix. In the pre message list. There was like, living prophets. How do you discern a true Prophet from a false prophet? Where are the keys? That's like a whole other. Okay, well, we can discuss, you know, it will leave that for part 2. I think that would be a good part 2. That's funny. All right, you know as as far as what's what happened with the church? You've heard really to eloquent answers from Michael and Jacob. Now you're going to get the rough version. Billy are you old enough to remember New Coke? I've never tried it.
3:15:41 I know like that whole marketing scheme though they did. Yeah they like took the original formula and really screwed with it and it just tasted horrible. Like he wanted to lick your own armpit to get the taste out of your mouth right now. I believe the LDS church and they've been doing it for a while. A lot of people are getting new Coke version of Mormonism, right? It's just not what it was meant to be. And I think, I think the how we got here and I say we as Mormons in general is I think we got sick of being weird, right? Because let's face it when when, when the manifesto the second or third or fourth, whatever time came out that they were serious, that time there wasn't a lot of outcry from the members, right?
3:16:32 And so when the Lord sets up a people and he's always done this, he said you're going to be strange. Going to be peculiar, you're going to be different. And I think that unless you're in it for the long haul, you get sick of being different really quickly. And when you start to compromise your beliefs or your convictions, even a little bit, you've put yourself on a slippery slope and so I think I think the church got sick of being viewed as weird. I think they were aiming for some political things and I think that's ultimately how we Here. The I mean, goodness out of better myself, an outsider looking in, you know, one of the things I do appreciate about you guys is the community that you have the identity of a more like a Mormon, identity, and you guys built something, you guys built a city, and I so wish Christians do that. It seems like we've lost that drive, we kind of just become so fragmented, but you know, meeting me. Like Mormon missionaries and looking into this about like the general conference.
3:17:44 You guys, the mainstream church has turned into, like, almost American evangelicalism like, like kind of corny, you know, suit and tie and you read about these, these early Mormons, they're like Cowboys, they're like chewing tobacco going out into the Wilderness communing with God, their kind of, you know, bad ass. If I could say, And and there's a disconnect between what happened then and now and so it's interesting looking at that historical perspective Shameless plug almost like they were Renegades stairs myself.
3:18:27 But I appreciate you guys having me on and we'll certainly have to do. You mean there's so many things that we didn't hit, you know, the life of Joseph Smith and things like this. You know, things that we just get lost on but we'll certainly have to do it Park. Do and thank you for having me on. Absolutely look. Jacob, why don't you go ahead and say what you wanted to say at the end here? And we'll move to Michael and then I'll finish her up. Well, I've just I've really enjoyed this conversation Billy. I'm appreciate the invite to be a part of this. Dave, it's been a pleasure. I haven't enjoyed this and I'm glad we can you know the original list of questions.
3:19:09 I was like man, these are you know, cover a wide array of topics and I'm glad that this time we kind of we kind of focus on Shoes. And I thought, I think it's I think it's just been a great conversation. I've really enjoyed it and I'm grateful to have diff, you know, conversations that are Pleasant and enjoyable and we're having fun. Even if we don't agree on everything, you know, I think that's during one of the breaks. That was something. I think you guys mentioned that, you know, that people need to be able to have conversations even if they disagree with other people and they need to have civil discussions and not get two heated, but have fun with it, right? Absolutely. - look, that's it was a good time. I think it flowed really good the whole deal and we didn't depart from the list that we we received. But I think that I think it went organically and I think we had some great back and forth every single way, you know, whether it was Bill pushing back or, or Jacob. And I answering I think I think there were some good stuff in there, boy.
3:20:17 So I really appreciate that. Absolutely, guys, thank you. Absolutely look, Billy. It's always refreshing to come across someone who's just an honest seeker. And that's what I see in. You is just somebody who, who wants to find out for himself, and that's so admirable. Admirable in today's world. Jacob, we've had some epic conversations. I love your perspectives. I love your, your takes on things Michael. You were I think the second or third guy interviewed and so again just I love the way you present the gospel, love the way that you communicate. I think it's great and I love all three. Are you guys I really do and I can't tell you how much I appreciate just being able to be a part of this and hang out with you guys.
3:21:02 It's been the highlight of my week, definitely. So other than that, let's look forward to part two. Let's keep in touch and let's, let's set that up. All right. Gentlemen, good night. Thank you so much. We'll have to do part 2. Absolutely. Alright. Bye everybody.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox