Episode #204: The Restored Scriptures W/Drew Briney & Joshua Winchell
One of the features of the Restoration was new scripture coming forth along with translations of existing scripture and Joseph Smith defiantly did those things. But have you ever stopped to ask yourself if the format we have them is now the most conducive way to read and study them? On this episdoe I have on Drew Briney and Joshua Winchell to talk about an ambitious project that was just finished. The Restored Scriptures are scriptures put back in its original format with the edits that were made by Joseph Smith. During the course of our conversation Drew layout his thought and decision-making process as he put the scriptures back into the format the early Mormon leaders would have recognized, along with a lot of history thrown in along the way.
restoredscriptures.com1830 Mercantile.orgmormonlegacy.org
0:26 The you're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. What's going on, man? So much stuff I can never keep track. How are you? I'm doing good. I'm, I'm excited to talk to you about this. We kind of talked about this earlier on and it, it was right when you were kind of in the in the middle of the process itself, right, So. We. We didn't, we didn't get a chance to see that through the completion. So I'm super excited for this. And then so obviously everyone knows what Drew's done on this project. And we're talking about the the, where do we call them these again, Drew, the restored version, the restored version of the scriptures. In previous podcasts, we've spoken about it as the Joseph Smith version.
1:19 That was kind of our initial thought, but we kept expanding a little bit, so now it's the restored version. Gotcha. Well, look, knowing who you are, Drew, who is a guy who quite frankly makes the rest of us look kind of, I don't know, lazy because you put out, I don't know, a book every six weeks that like literally I was. So I was at the gym the other day and they had this show. I don't even know what show it was, but it showed this one guy running and then there was another guy running beside him and he kept passing him and he said on your left. And he kept doing that to the one point where the guy just got irritated. And I'm like, that's kind of like Drew with printing books, right?
2:01 Like I'll, I'll be halfway through a podcast and I think Drew passes me as he wrote another book. Like it's crazy the amount of work you do and it's good, solid work, right? It's work that helps people and and gosh, I'm sure thankful for it so. It's good to have you here. I appreciate that. I've I've been a bit discouraged. I've been so slow getting this stuff finished up. So I appreciate those those thoughts. Well, I look at those things as a chance for a guy like me to catch up to what you've done. So that's that's absolutely awesome. So Josh Winchell, Sir, you are here. Yes, Sir. I'm here as support as I always have been and to kind of guide you through the process from say you're in my perspective because your assessment of Drew is correct.
2:48 I You'd be hard. Pressed, I think. In our communities on denominations to find someone who knows the subtleties of either Joseph's writings or the the Diaries of the second hand, third hand sources of Joseph's writings, you'd be probably hard pressed to find somebody as knowledgeable or even equally knowledgeable as I'd say Drew. I mean, there probably are, but certainly not at the level even amongst the academics that I've read that that understand the nuances of what he's saying juxtaposed against all of the revelations that he gave. So there's there's a spiritual aspect to this that's non academic, that's essential for our, as you said earlier in your prayer, that's essential for our doctrinal well-being. He understands how it we all do, but I think he he understands the nuances of that.
3:38 So I mean, if I were to to to laud Drew, I would laud his ability to piece together all that information he worked so hard for in a way that's doctor and elite coherent. Perfect. We'll we'll move on to your role in this in just a second, but I want to drop, drop back here to Drew real quick. So, Drew, when we left off in our last conversation, we were you were still in the in the middle of just compiling everything, getting everything ready, putting the finishing touches on a few things. Where do we stand right now with this? Well, if, if I may, I think what you said might, might be a little bit inaccurate. I, I published and, and I think we talked about on your podcast, though I'm, I'm not 100% positive, so I may be incorrect correction, but I, I previously, I published 1840 Book of Mormon along with the changes made by Joseph and, and those changes were both in 1837 and changes that he missed because he used two different manuscripts.
4:45 So he changed things twice sometimes. So I, I document all those missed instances from the original manuscript as well as the 1837 change, as well as 1840 changes that are substantive in the Book of Mormon. And honestly, it it wasn't tons. And I, I believe I may have also mentioned in a previous podcast that I used that text then to create a modern English version of the Book of Mormon, mostly for kids in ESL. Right, I remember that. Yep. OK, so we did that. And then also I, I put out the text for the, for the Doctrine of Covenants and 87 of Joseph Smith's revelations that were not previously canonized and that, that that hasn't really changed other than I'm adding I, I don't know exactly.
5:39 I haven't kind of lost count. And I, I had some mistakes in my records telling me what it is. So somewhere between 35 and 40 revelations of Wilford Woodruff, John Taylor, Brigham Young, Oliver Caldery, other members of the 12, I think there's one from Joseph F Smith that's pretty early on, late 1800s or something. At any rate, those are all going to be, there is an appendix as well. And of course the DNC also has the lectures on faith. If I, if I may, I've, I've had a lot of surprise questions come in to me recently in my inbox because of the RV, the restored version that we're doing. So I, I've had people being confused between my work of Doctrine Covenants Annotated, which will be 7 or 8 volumes and the restored version.
6:30 And you know, they, they've asked if I quit that project or what's happening. And, and the answer is no. This is the same project in, in, in part meaning the, the RV text for the Doctrine of Covenants will be what I'm using for the annotated version moving forward. And I've also been asked, although I, I don't know if it's official, I'm doing it anyways to, to prepare historical headers for each section of the DNC. And I'll, I'll be preparing those for the, for the, for the same kind of both uses as it were. So there, there's quite a bit of crossover for that particular volume. So I haven't given that up.
7:17 And I'm actually working on DNC 132 on the side. Just did a couple podcasts on that if anybody's interested in kind of catching up because there's some new research by some polygamy deniers, namely Jeremy Hoop that suggested DNC 132 might be might have proved manuscripts were backwards and the original was not the original, vice versa. And that could change everything. So I went back and re looked at every verse in paragraph and letter to see if it changed anything at any rate. So then what have we done since then? That was our last podcast. We've we finished the Pearl of grey price, which is the 1851 version, which obviously Joseph didn't quote UN quote approve because he wasn't there.
8:09 So changes made to, for instance, the book of Genesis, sorry, Moses, which is really the Joseph Smith translation of the book of Genesis, changes to that made in 1851 verses what was made by Joseph. I did not annotate those because Joseph didn't do it. But I did annotate all the changes Joseph Smith made to Genesis through the Joseph Smith translation. Also did the book of Abraham and also did Joseph Smith's history. I'm still waiting on final approval from committee members as to if we're going to include stuff that was not in the 1851 version but was in church history on that specific detail and then one hymn and articles of Faith. The rest of the Pearl of Great Price in 1851 was multiple pieces and parts of sections of the Doctrine of Covenants that are already included earlier in the work with annotations. So rather than have 1851 changes not approved by Joseph annotated in the original, DNC just ignored them completely because they were post Joseph.
9:22 Gotcha, Gotcha. But you said that there are things in the Pearl great price. And forgive me if I'm misunderstanding here, Drew, you did say there were things in the 1851 that that you left in with the Pearl. Great price, right? The 1851 Pearl Great Prize to to clarify was the Book of Moses, which is included the Book of Abraham, which is included the Articles of Faith, which is included as well as a footnote because I know a lot of people heard there's a 14th article of faith and can't ever find it. So I footnote that 14th. Well, the alleged 14th article of faith in there and then Joseph Smith history, which is as I said, I've been waiting for the committee to tell me if we're going to do the entire just Smith history.
10:13 That was that was there just the 1851 pieces of it and and then it won him the rest of it. The rest of the 1851 Pearl great price was pieces of parts of the DNC that we have elsewhere. OK, maybe DNC 89 was included or something and and then you know that would just be a duplicate of our DNC 89. So I just got rid of it. But in and that's a bad example because that was included in the 1844 DNC. But the the point is in 1851, the point of the Pearl of Great Price was to say these are hard to find revelations.
10:54 It's almost an attempt to update the Doctrine of Covenants with sections that hadn't been published yet. And you know, things that are things that were kind of hard to find. And you know, some of those things were harder to find maybe in England than they were in American, vice versa. And so they just kind of put together what they could to make it easier access for the Saints. In retrospective, from today's perspective, those things are already in the DNC, so I didn't duplicate them. Gotcha. OK, no, that makes sense. I I apologize I I got hung up there somewhere. No, that's OK. It happens all the time. If you thought that somebody else did too, I guarantee it.
11:36 All right, So real quick before because I got some real specific questions for you here, Drew. But first I want to turn to Josh here real quick. Josh, what was your role in in this project? Well, to give you that, let me give you a little bit of a history. About a year and a half ago, we were working together. There's a there's a fellow by the name of Michael Sundell myself, and then there was Kevin and Drew. But there were a few of us that were working together. We were a little bit unsatisfied with what we call the 1981 LDS scriptures, and a lot of it had to do with diversification and the breaking up of thought ideas, as well as some of the the nuances, and we can get into that on the Book of Mormon.
12:22 We didn't really like the way that that the 1981 had split those things up and kind of Jarred ideas into small little bites instead of giving a more holistic or a more complete approach. To to. To the writings, to the, to the prophecies and to a lot of the doctrines. And so we got together and we said, hey, what we really need is we need a clean version, a Joseph Smith version, a, an original restorative version of the Book of Mormon. And as those conversations came out, we really felt there were a couple of of telephone meetings and a couple of the very, very strong spirit of of togetherness and unity on this. That brought us to the point where we said, Hey, do we do a quad?
13:10 How about a triple? What did we bring in the Doctrine and Covenants? What about the uncanonized revelations? And it kind of blossomed from there. But it was the Book of Mormon that really stood out. And you know, that was you talking about the impetus and how it brought it together. It was we wanted what we what we called clean, but was a more complete restorative Joseph Smith version of the Book of Mormon that flowed with thoughts, ideas and readability, but still allowed, say, the 1876 versifications of Orson Pratt so that we could all be on the same page.
13:51 If I say first Nephi 316, you can look down the paragraph, find it, and somebody with the 1981 can find it and there's continuity to it. So that's what started it. And as it went through, there was a process of growth, I think on all sides, but especially on the side of us learning as Drew kind of helped us to, to see his perspective on the way Joseph would approach, say, a Book of Mormon, clear, a clear Book of Mormon. And, and there was a lot of growth in it. And I've, I've got a lot to say on that because I basically answered all the questions that you have. I got answered through the process. I was Dave Sanders as it were approaching this saying, Hey, you know, I, I really am in love with the original grammar and syntax and even spelling errors of the 1830 because it's just so unique and so spiritually powerful to me. And we you walk through the fact and Drew helps and says, well, you know that Brandon was was responsible for a lot of that stylist or not stylistic, but syntax and a lot of the formatting.
15:01 Of that it didn't. Come from Joseph, it didn't come from Oliver, it didn't come from an LDS person. And you'll learn as you go. And so you start seeing it, you know, and you read it and you reread it and you reread it and finally you really appreciate where we're going with it. So it's kind of a long winded, I hope that I answered your question, but that's where we came from and what we ended up is with is a triple, it's a triple combination. It's clean. It's what we would say is a Joseph Smith version or the the best version we can find that would be contiguous to what Joseph would be preaching, saying, and even editing. Oh, I appreciate the background there, but but my question was what was your role in this process? OK, So I brought to the table, I was kind of a unifying member in that we had the, there's two of us, well, a few of us that had the resources to really get this off the ground. Drew's in a position where he, he loves the work that he does, but he also needs to sustain himself and, and, and his, and his livelihood, his way of life.
16:05 So we had to support on that side. And also we had the the rigors of both marketing and getting out there and really trying to help unify people behind this to both with Kevin, myself, Michael, you know, just basically shaking hands, you know, beating the concrete, calling up people and saying, Hey, we, we really, really want to put these things in your hands. We want you to appreciate it. I kind of served as a as a, a litmus test against what either fundamentalists from even mainstreamers might say when they're approaching all the annotations in here, because you're going to get lengthy explanations as to why decisions were made.
16:51 And I was kind of on the other side on that. I was the one saying, I like to get my hands into this stuff. I really like to figure things out for myself. But for the sake of contention and argument, you do need Drew there saying the decision was made to add these words because Joseph did this and it, it clarifies it for you and it, it takes away the disputation and allows you to really trust in the scriptures themselves and in the version that we're offering. So I was kind of brought slowly and weaned into this and I was like, you know, for the first, for the first issue, we, we might need some annotations to keep people on the same page. So that's what I served as. I served as a litmus test or a board that that says, Hey, I'm just your average fundamentalist and I want to understand why this book is better than say, the 1981 version of the scriptures.
17:46 And if it went through and it answers all those questions through Drew's words and through, we did a lot of copy editing and a lot of air proof. Not not copy editing, but spelling errors walking through, making sure there were consistencies and dates and the rest of it. We're kind of like his support staff. Got you. OK, so, Drew, I, I want to, I want to go back to you now because now I got some kind of technical questions here. Yeah. So Josh alluded to he, he really enjoyed the 1830 version of the Book of Mormon, right? Which if I'm not mistaken, is, is a it, it reads like a novel, right? Or at least that's the replica that I have, right?
18:28 It's got chapters, but it's not. It's not. Doesn't have verses. In it or. Anything else? Now. That's not the way it's going to read though, right? Or did did you put in versification or did you go back to that 1830 format? Great. So it wasn't just the 1830 and 1837 and 1840 versions were also paragraph formatted. Ours was sort of the Doctrine of Covenants and just Smith history and some other things. That was just the way they read back then. And I think it's a better way of reading than the very disjunct verse by verse. So we kept paragraphing.
19:08 However, I, I put AI put a chart at the beginning of each book of Scripture and said it, I'm answering your question, but I'm taking a step back to run. And it says, what did Joseph Smith contribute to this book? And what did the RV have to do with this book? So the first, and this is something we, we looked at as a committee and I spent a lot of time talking to everybody about explaining that, you know, we talked about the 1830 version as, as being the perfect version, but it had a lot of errors. When Oliver Cowdery transferred the original manuscript to the printer's manuscript, that was then changed by the printer for the 1830 Book of Mormon, Oliver Cowdery averaged 3 errors per page. And then the printer made.
20:02 Changes and errors as well. So that's why in 1830, that's one of the reasons why in 1837 Joseph went through and revamped it. And again in 1840, So at the beginning of the Book of Mormon, for instance, it said, what did Joseph Smith contribute to this book? Did he contribute the text? And the answer is yes. He's the one who revealed the text. He spoke the text. It was written down, chances that it was written down word for word it pretty much beat been 100% debunked by scholars and I I would agree with all of them if there's no way it was done word for word from for multiple reasons looking at the manuscripts and changes that were made and and edits and so forth.
20:46 If you want more information on that you can read. Dang not clear on Skazen. It's his son's name. Royal Royal Skousen. Yes, it's 1830 edition of the Book of Mormon. Fabulous research, incredible resource. So then, then we say, did Joseph contribute to the paragraphing? The answer is no, he had nothing to do with it. Did he contribute to the spelling? No, Very, very few instances that he had anything to do with spelling error ever. Which is probably a very good thing if you read the stuff that he wrote in his own hand. Spelling was not standardized, which alone is reason to ignore spelling.
21:29 But Joseph's spelling was also very poor. So did he contribute the spelling? No. Did he contribute the punctuation? No. And so then we go back and say what did? Who did? Well, the printer did the paragraphing and the printer did the paragraphing in the Book of Mormon by saying, oh, it says, and it came to pass. So let's make that a new paragraph. That was it pretty much like 8090% of the time, whatever it was very high percentage. I think Royal Skousen states it to sound like it was every single time he did that. That's that's the only paragraphing. And that may or may not be an accurate understanding of what he wrote. That's that's what I gathered from it. That said, the the paragraphing is therefore clearly not inspired unless you're bound and determined to think the printer was inspired, in which case I invite you to look at all of his airs.
22:26 So and Joseph also. I believe the number is 67. I could be wrong. And somewhere around there he deleted the words and it came to pass like 67 times in his editing of the Book of Mormon, which is fascinating for lots of reasons. So anyway, we took, and it was a pretty big work to take clans or Royal Skousen's paragraphing and incorporated that into the restored version. I have a lot of admiration for Cleon Skousen. And it's pretty clear that Royal Skousen did not far away, fall far away from the apple tree, as it were. That old saying. He's clearly has a very strong testimony of the Book of Mormon. I think he did a great job.
23:08 There were a number of instances where his formatting and paragraphing didn't work for our version because we have modern verses and modern chapters put in as opposed to the old original that nobody can use for reference anymore. And and that modified sometimes not very most time, not very significantly, but sometimes a little bit significantly how we broke up the paragraphs. But we used his as a, as a model largely because he went through and said, when does the sense of the story change? And that's how we do it today, right? And so so he did that.
23:51 So it reads very much smoothly, like a novel, if you will, without disjunct brakes. But we have small Gray mini verses to indicate the new modern versification, as Joshua mentioned, much like Christians do in their in their Bibles. So it's easy both to find the verses that you're looking for. If you're if you're looking up scholarly work and somebody says, hey, I'm quoting second Messiah or first Mosiah 25, you can easily find it. Whereas if you looked at it 18401837 or 1830 Book of Mormon lithographic version, you would not have that ability. So it makes it both clean like the original and usable for reference like any modern versus scripture. So anyway, I think that only partially answered your question, but if you want to restate it, I'll finish. Oh, I can't.
24:46 To be honest with you, I I can't even remember now. It's something about readability and paragraphing and. Yeah, the the, the versification in there, right, Because versification did lend itself to being able to find things a little easier, right, Because you broke them down by chapter and verse. Is there something that still does that without versification? Without versification, no, I, I, I really don't think so. We, we looked at it at doing alternate versions, but the fact of the matter is you've got thousands of thousands of periodicals of books that will say 351112. And if you can't find 351112 in your version of scriptures used for study, you're going to have to rely on something else. And frankly, I, I believe this version is not only restoring every word, every contribution of Joseph Smith and annotating all of his changes.
25:44 I, I, I think it's far superior in that way. And it's a better resource to read as kind of a purists version of the scriptures. You're happy the descriptions have been changed and you're glad every time there's a new edition and they get rid of some doctrine you don't like, this restored version is not for you. If you have a testimony of Joseph Smith's work and you say don't tamper and mess with it, then this, this version is exactly what you want. And and you know, frankly, there's still some errors that were left by Joseph that we could have inserted and changed the grammar or something to make it make sense better, but we didn't. In very few instances we put in a word with brackets like the word are, you know, we are going or something instead of we going.
26:37 We did a few, very few of those just because it's so confusing to read without it that I had to go back and look and say, you know, this, this TypeScript I got of AOCR version of the original 1840 bookworm. And is it is it that they make a mistake here? The ground was so bad doesn't make any sense at all. So there were a few of those, but for the, for the vast, vast, vast majority of it, that it's Joseph's words, period, done, no changes. Because that's what that's what I wanted and that's what the rest of the team wanted from the very beginning. That's what we call it, a clean version, a peer version, whatever you want to call it. The idea is this is what Joseph wrote, this is what he approved. And if he changed anything at all, it's footnoted. So you can see what he changed when he changed it and why he changed it.
27:26 Well, maybe not always why, but you can kind of infer that and so on so forth. So let let me ask you this. Did you give as you were going through sources right and you're comparing the 1830 and and I can't remember? 1837 and 1840. Right. Did you like weight 1840 higher than say, you would the 1830 version or whatever? Because it was later in Joseph's life. Yes. So if for instance, the the 1840 version book of the Book of Mormons says they were white and delightsome or sorry, the 1840 version says pure and delightsome, right?
28:07 So because Joseph changed that it wasn't a committee even it was Joseph. So it would the word pure and delightsome. The word pure would have a footnote and it would say the original manuscript said light white and delightsome, right? So you can see Joseph, obviously he's the one that said white and delightsome. It wasn't Oliver County wasn't described, presumably possible, but presumably. But when Joseph looked at, he said the intention of that word was pure. And you know, I for whatever ever reason it grabbed his attention, whether he felt it was racist or whether he felt it was just misleading or distracting or whatever, he changed it. So we went with his 1840 change, italicized the word he changed, and footnoted the earlier versions of what he changed, which sometimes is 3 or 4 changes. For instance, 8 the original manuscript might say one thing, the printer's manuscript might might say another. 1837 might have made a change, but then it used the printer's manuscript, and then the 1840 used the original manuscript. So he might have gone back to the original version, skipped the change he made from the printer's manuscript, and used the original version.
29:26 But all of those would be annotated so you would see the progression of changes. Now we did not annotate non substantive changes. And for people who don't know that word very well, if it doesn't change the meaning, I didn't annotate it. But with a degree in logic and a degree in philosophy and a degree in law, I looked at everything and said does this comma change the meaning? Possibly. And if I could come up with a not a very good, but it somewhat reasonable rational reason why somebody in the RLDS movement or somebody in the Snuffer movement or somebody in the AUB might say, yeah, that changes the meaning. Here's why.
30:15 Then I I annotated that, yeah. And then my next question here, and, and I'm going to ask you, I'm going to ask you to jump into kind of, I don't want to say speculative mode, but an educated guess. I, you know, for lack of a better term, as you went through those changes from 1830 to all the way to 1840, what do you notice at the end that Joseph is changing most in the Book of Mormon? I'm glad you asked that in in the Book of Mormon. Honestly, there are fewer substantive changes than anywhere else. First of all, there were tons of changes in the DNC and for lots of reasons we can we can talk about, but sticking specifically to the Book of Mormon, Joseph Smith was trying to make it easier to read.
31:13 There's in several articles have pointed this out, but there's clearly Hick language from time to time. There's clearly very poor grammar. From time to time you can, and people can get upset. Well, don't you remember the doctor in covenance? That guy got in trouble 'cause he tried to correct Lord's grammar and blah blah blah. That assumes that the Book of Mormon was written word by word, which is a later hearsay account that conflicts with other accounts of how the Book of Mormon was received. And it ignores the fact that Joseph Smith made lots of changes. Not just substantive changes, lots of changes. One of the very interesting things and I, I believe Royal Skousen is the one that talks about this. I'd have to double check that citation, but I'm pretty sure he's the 1 and I it's, it's in one of our appendices.
31:59 Anyways, I cite the correct source because it's straight in my brain at the time. But any rate, he, I believe it's Royal Skousen that notes that Joseph Smith got rid of many places Old English and was bringing forth Modern English to make it easier to read. He also was systematically going through phrases and sentences that were difficult passages to understand grammatically where people were having a hard time understanding it and saying what this doesn't make any sense. Kind of like DNC 132 verse 7. It's just the worst grammar ever. And so he would go through those and say, this is hard to understand.
32:42 Let me add this word or two that makes it easier to understand. And that was his change. And so there was a lot of effort. And this was really kind of surprising to me. But as you go through, you see all the changes. It's pretty clear he was trying to make it easier to read, which to me Harkins back to William Tyndale. And I, I doubt, I don't know if Joseph knew who William Tyndale was or if he had any inclination to do the same thing, but William Tendo is the first one to translate the Bible into English from Greek and a little bit from the Hebrew. And when he did, he said I wanted to be easy enough for the plowboy to understand. And what that reference was for people that maybe that sounds obscure is I want the uneducated guy to understand this very well. I, I don't want this to be something the academic can read. I don't want it to be something that somebody super educated can figure out.
33:39 I want the average person without an education to be able to read this and understand it. And I, I see that very much in Joseph's efforts. And I believe it was Royal Scouts and I mentioned the same thing. And to me, I very much appreciate that because one of one of the most important pieces I found in doing this research is, is, is, I believe it's a letter from Joseph Smith to either WWE Phelps or Carly P Pratt. Pardon me for forgetting, but anyway, he says you're part of the scripture committee. You're going to be, you're going to you're going to what's the word? I believe you just said the word correct.
34:19 But they were supposed to choose the revelations to use and then correct them was the verbiage. And he says the letter says that's the DNC that commands them to do that. He says when you're doing that, make sure not to change the sense or in other words, the, the interpretation of that passage, that you're just correcting your grammar or a comma or whatever to make it more readable. And to me that's a very significant thing. I, I personally believe God wants scripture to be easy to read. It doesn't have to be 600 year old language. And I know that if anybody wants to correct me, I know that the King James Version wasn't done in 1400s, but it's uses old language for King James time dating dating back to the 1400s. So we're looking at 600 year old language. A lot of people can't understand ESL, people can't understand it, children can't understand it.
35:21 I think Joseph was making an effort to fix that as he realized it was a challenge. And that was a, a surprise to me, but I was very gratified because I, I think that's how God wants it to be easy to understand, not obtuse. Got you. No, absolutely. I see your hand up Josh. I'm going to get to you in just one second. I got one follow up question here though, before I lose my train of thought, and that is Drew and, and the reason I ask about those changes is, is that we see Joseph's theology develop and become more enhanced more. I don't want to use the word complicated because I don't think that's it maybe more intricate, right? As as we go, as we go from from Palmyra into Pennsylvania up to Ohio into Missouri and then finally into Nauvoo, his his the the doctrine that Joseph's revealing is is constantly being expanded, right? Do we get a sense that some of those those same doctrinal revelations that Joseph has influences the way that he does those later, and it's in the Book of Mormon in 1840? I don't I, I, I see almost no evidence of that. There is of course, the famous God came down among men and was sacrificed and you know, this, this stuff in first Nephi and the tree of tree of life vision,
36:52 I believe it's in Christina by 10 or 11. That obviously is doctrinally significant at a major level, but the Book of Mormon really doesn't address very many topics that he was teaching in Nauvoo. So I, I just don't see very many edits from him that that may manifest deeper understandings. If we're talking about the doctrine of covenants, I have a totally different answer, but for the Book of Mormon I don't think it really affected much. That's interesting and and that would to be honest, that would kind of make sense to me for a while now. I've been certainly there are allusions to exaltation in the Bible and the Book of Mormon, but I don't think we really start dealing with exaltation till we get to the Doctrine and Covenants and Pearl a great price. I, I still contend that that, and, and this isn't crap talking either one of those books of scripture, right? They're vital, they're important, they're needed, but they're, they're still Vidic texts, right? They deal with salvation, not exaltation. So I was curious if any of that made its way. And we'll go to the Doctrine and Covenants here in just a second. I want to go to Josh now.
38:00 He's been patient. I saw his hand up. Well, I just wanted to go back and kind of reiterate and then distinguish some of the things that Drew said. He's absolutely correct about Joseph Smith. Even with the King James Version. If you look at the translations that Joseph made to the King James Version, especially if you look at say Genesis 14 with the with the full fleshing out of the city of Salem and Melchizedek and all of that, you'll see that his language is a lot clearer than the, than the writings of say the King James original version. Now, having said that, a portion of my family history reaches into the Hebrew side of things and there are passages in the Book of Mormon that I just, I, I couldn't fathom living without. There is poetic devices.
38:53 There's chiasmus. Oh, that I were an Angel. When you read that and when you read Nephi and he starts going into those chiasmus roles and they're absolutely poetic. And you're looking at a farm boy with the 6th grade education and he's writing these chiasmus rules. They're translating them. Excuse me. Those things are absolutely necessary for my spiritual well-being. Poetic and and there are other things. Too that are Old Testament about it it just it speaks volumes to the Judaic or to the Hebrew history actually the Abrahamic history of our of our. Covenants and our people. And so I'm glad in this version you're going to when you read the Book of Mormon in this, in the revert, in this restored version, you're going to be a chapter and 1/2 in before you even know where you're at.
39:44 It's going to read that smooth and the retention. I know this because I've done it twice. You're going to be at least a half a chapter into a into the Book of Mormon and say, whoa, where's the time? What number? Oh, I'm in, I'm in 14 first neat by chapter 14. It's that smooth. It reads that smoothly. I am I am grateful for the updates for that, but there are certain aspects of those scriptures that we have retained that flavor and I think should be retained. So I mean, I just kind of wanted to point that out. And Drew Drew actually does that. He does a very good job in there with the footnote saying, hey, we can weigh this against modern, modern language and we can lose some poetry if you want to do it too much and hit the blend is just really nice.
40:30 So that that was my my comments. Gotcha, gotcha. So Drew, let's move on to the Doctrine and Covenants because this one is like the DNC is really interesting because I don't think there's another book of Scripture out there that you hear the Lord's first person as much as you do in the Doctrine and Covenants, right? I think that that this is a unique set of Scripture because what it is, is the Lord educating Joseph on how the church and the Kingdom are are supposed to operate. So as you started to approach the Doctrine and Covenants here doing much the same thing again, how did you wait? Evidence, that sort of thing.
41:15 Yeah. So I had to make it one this this decision early on in, in making that decision, and I really agonized it over it and had to spend a considerable amount of time just just reading over the the DNC changes and asking myself kind of what you're just asking. So here's here's the tricky part of this. So, so the, the short answer is I, I, I same as the Book of Mormon. I, I went for the 1844. That's the last one. He had his hands on Joseph. So the tricky part is and, and you can read a little bit about this in the Joseph Smith Papers project online.
42:01 They they do a good job of talking about some of the detail. They of course are very deferential to Joseph as as I am, but you can make an argument that Joseph didn't have anything to do with 1844 version. He wrote a couple letters, he talked to people, but we don't have record of him touching anything but like 2 sentences for the whole thing. Now you can come to two conclusions from that and say, well, just because we don't have a record of it doesn't mean it didn't happen. Maybe there's a lot of talking between Oliver Cattery and Joseph. And you know, Oliver Cattery was maybe very meticulous taking notes and and we have his notes recording the things Joseph said and those are what made it into the 1844 Doctrine Covenants. Or you could take the cynical view and say it was mostly Oliver cadre and the team, the committee appointed, by the way, in revelation of the Doctrine of Covenants, the committee was appointed who made the changes and Joseph really didn't see it much.
43:11 You could excuse me. Those are kind of two extended arguments that you can make. I assume looking at the historical Joseph, looking at the entirety of what he did, what he stood for, arguments he made, how he thought, all those types of things, that he would have taken this revision of the DNC very seriously and would not have in any way thought Oliver County did a good enough job. I don't need to worry about it. I don't see that personality. I don't see that in his, his historical Joseph. I understand he was busy, he got lynched, he got mobbed. He had, you know, internal struggles and he had new problems with polygamy and had people trying to kill him. And parts of this, you know, part of part of the time he was very distracted for sure.
44:07 But I, I don't believe that he just kind of handed it over and let them do everything and didn't worry about it. I just, I just don't see that as a, as a real possibility. So that said, there is evidence and very clear evidence that in some places an English committee member is editing because they put English spelling into the Doctrine of Covenants and they leave the Old English. Whereas another place, place, sorry, you see American spelling and you see them get rid of Old English and incorporate more modern English as Joseph was doing in the Book of Mormon. There's actually quite a bit of that in it is more frequent and common than the other way around. So looking, looking at those things, I, I come to the conclusion Joseph either was directly or indirectly or involved to a significant, to a significant enough degree that I say in, in the appendices, it may say Joseph retained this change, but arguably an academic could come in and say, I'm positive that was Oliver Counter. You change that was not Joseph.
45:27 Yeah, I, I can't, I, I don't think anybody could definitively say that, but you could go argue it And, and, you know, somebody came and made that argument and gave me sophisticated reason. I can say, ah, I can see where you're coming from. That doesn't mean Joseph didn't approve it, but I can see that's Oliver Counter's handwriting. It's his, it's his way of speaking or something. But you we also know that Joseph was directing Oliver Calgary to do specific things in specific sections and in a doing so we you know, we can look at those changes and say Joseph directed them if not approved them. So I presume therefore, and I I make very clear this assumption in the appendices that Joseph either guided or approved of the changes made in DNC 1844 version.
46:24 Gotcha, gotcha. He didn't do that to once he didn't reveal and they were published after he died. But at least for his own revelations, I I presume that's true. OK. And then now you, you said something interesting, right when when I asked where was back when we were talking about the Book of Mormon, if you noticed anything of the changes he made that really showed his doctrinal maturation, right? His maturing in the doctrine, that doctrine being expanded. And you said not so much in the Book of Mormon, but definitely in the Doctrine and Covenants. What kind of changes did you see that really tips tips his hand that he did that?
47:08 Shoot several examples. I, I, I talked to you a little bit about this before. So if if anybody wants a deeper discussion, they can go back to your earlier podcast when I would talk about DNC 42 and 7642 is a really, really good example of a section that was massively changed. A lot of it's not arguably not substantive, It doesn't change doctrine, but what it does do is update that scripture to reflect new revelations about administrative affairs of the church. So the original might say, you know, get 2 elders and they will judge this matter.
47:50 And then the, the version in 1844 that we'll read today will say give the matter to the high council and they'll judge or something like that. Or, you know, organize a, a council of high priests and they'll judge the matter or something like that. So over and over, like literally every couple few verses, there are changes in DNC 42. It's almost as much footnote as it is as text, which I really wanted to avoid. But that's just an artifact of that particular section. There were many, many, many changes because it's an administrative section. It's talking about how to do consecration, how to apply the principle. And in doing so, it might have said an elder now says Bishop, might have said two elders now says high council. Things like that were changed a lot. And so, you know, that's his changing understanding of how the church operates on an administrative level. And and there may be some doctrinal things in there that aren't coming to my mind this very instant. But DNC 76 is a different matter. There we, we have a number of places where that the change could arguably make a very big doctrinal change. And the, the one that I, I discussed with you last time on 70 sixes is the most significant to me. Although I could make an argument looking back at at some earlier sections where the same
49:22 change was made that it, it isn't as doctrinally substantive as I believe it is or as I argued last time. But here's what it is. Joseph Smith's changed the word Holy Ghost to say Holy Spirit. He does that many times in the doctrine of covenants. And and by many, I don't mean 100. I don't know even know if it's mentioned that many times, but a good 1520 something times. And The thing is, today for most people that are like So what, that there's no difference. But the early brethren distinguished a difference. Joseph showed the difference and his changes in the doctrine of covenant seem to acknowledge in my estimation, later discourses of the early brethren say the Holy Spirit properly refers to the Spirit of Christ.
50:15 It properly does not refer to the personage of the Holy Ghost. They also acknowledged we use the two interchangeably and improperly so. But if we're going to be accurate and careful about things, the Holy Ghost is a personage. The Holy Spirit is, you know, untabernacled intelligences flowing through everything. So there's a huge difference. Now, if you say the sin against the Holy Ghost and you change it to say sin against the Holy Spirit, there's a very different meaning there. And I think that's fascinating to explore doctrinally.
50:59 And, and you know, you could agree or disagree with me, but just for the sake of, of giving an example, if I sin against the Holy Ghost, that's a personage, I have to apologize to that personage if I make a mistake, right? And and it's never defined really well anyways, what's the sin against the Holy Ghost? You can, I should say, take that back. It's never consistently defined. Well, as to what the case said against the Holy Ghost is, I can find some really good quotes, but I can find something to argue the opposite based on somebody else's quote. And I'm talking about the early brethren and all the way through Joseph F Smith or especially even later. The doctrine never is consistent throughout the history of the LDS Church. Few years back I started to get the feeling that we, as fundamentalists and orthodox Mormons, we need our own stuff. Up to now, we've been able to buy and purchase all of our scriptures, books, art, and music from other restoration organizations, and that's been good. But there's no guarantee it's going to remain that way. Also, it can be a bit tricky as you scour the Internet trying to find all the books from your favorite fundamentalist or orthodox Mormon authors.
52:08 As I thought about this, I feel like I was really given a solution now through the hard work of others, because let's face it, I'm the guy least qualified in all the world to build a website. I'm happy to present to you 1830 mercantile.org. Right now on the website you can see that we have all the books have ever been written by 4 authors, including names like Drew, Briny and Ogdenkraut. Also very soon there will be a link to buy art and music all produced by Mormons with a deep love for the restored gospel. There's also places for you to get free resources where you can find podcasts, videos, classes, and other presentations. Also coming very soon there will be a place for events where you can list the events from your organization so that you can get the most out of that attendance. Now this can be as big as you want it to be. It's all up to you guys out there if you want to buy and post things on here.
53:03 Now, if you're someone who produces something that you feel like others can benefit from, 1830 Mercantile is a place where you can make all of those products available for purchase. All you need to do is drop me an e-mail at mormonrenegade@gmail.com and put 1830 in in the title of that e-mail with a short message and either myself or someone else from the 1830 Mercantile team will reach out to you so we can get your product up there on the site. Now to make sure that all the products that we offer are affordable and to ensure that the vast majority of the profits go to the producer, the website percentage is only three to 4% of the total cost. And that's just so I can pay the pros that have created this website and keep the lights on the website itself. Finally, by making some of your purchases at 1830 mercantile.org, you'll be supporting folks whose principles and morals are close, if not the same as yours. At the same time not giving your money away to people who stand against everything you stand for. So no matter if you're looking to make a purchase or you're a seller that wants to get your products listed, head on over to 1830 mercantile.org today.
54:15 Drop me an e-mail and we'll make sure that we get back out to you. Now back to the show. But if I if I take the early brethren's perspective and bring him in specifically preach this and you can find it in DNC 76 annotated under the section Celestial Kingdom. He specifically taught our our purpose. The plan of salvation is to discover truth, accept truth, and then live truth. Now, I, I never saw that on the plan of Salvation chart before, but that's a very different perspective of things. And it makes a lot of sense. You know, it's, if I discover baptism, I accept baptism and then I keep my baptismal covenant.
54:57 And then later I discover there's an endowment. I received the endowment covenant and then I live and keep the endowment covenant. You can see how his approach to looking at the plan of salvation looks like from a modern perspective, but from a broader perspective of people who regularly taught we must accept all truth. All truth belongs to Mormonism, but we also need to accept it and live it. So then if you take that understanding that the early brethren consistently preached and say the sin against the Holy Spirit, which they would also say it would be synonymous, would be sinning against truth.
55:42 Excuse me, It's sending against the spirit of truth. That would be just basically reversing course, right? Going from accepting, finding, accepting and living truth to denying, rejecting and ignoring truth or accepting, adopting and receiving and living falsehood. So arguably, it's a very, very different perspective of what it means to to sit against the Holy Spirit. Person is the Holy Ghost. That's not the only significant change that you can take from that, but it's a very important one. Gotcha. Josh, I thought I heard you say something. Is there something you want to add to that? Oh, I, I had mentioned I just kind of blurted. It just says it's terrifying when you think about the implications of sinning against the Holy Spirit. I did want to add one thing and it it kind of dovetails into your question, David.
56:39 It's in the Doctrine and Covenants in the restored version, as I'm thinking in 1/21 here, additions are made of a well, it's additional, the additional or complete writings of Joseph on the matter are added into the footnotes. In some cases, the footnotes go pages and those additions, they do two things when you read them, they clarify because you're so used to 121 in the spiritual force of that. You know, it says thou art not like Job and it talks about all the hardships, but it also shows you when Joseph is imbued with this kind of Holy Spirit so that you can feel his writings.
57:20 You can feel his teachings juxtaposed against when he's just talking about the day-to-day mundane things. And there are so many clarifications that give you insight as to the problems he was having in and I believe it was liberty. So I'm using one that is at 121, Drew, I think I'm right. It's 121 where you added those like. 3 or 4. Paragraphs and they were so clarifying because he was he was so depressed. And then he starts talking about how, you know, the flotsam and all of this is that it just clears the log jams and he's going he's going down and talking about how his his heart is just clearing out. You just get this. You get a full. Perspective of how that 121 must have felt for him. So that is added to these.
58:05 You're going to have those in the in these doctrine covers. So like those 4 verses that you spoke about, there were those verses that were originally in and then were removed, Drew, or is this I'm, I'm having a hard time following here a little bit. Is that supplemental? Is that supplemental material that that Joseph talks about afterwards? Is that actual verbiage that went with the doc? With the? With the revelation. Right. So what happened was DNC 1/21 was not a quote UN quote revelation. DNC 121 is taken from a long letter written to I believe it's probably P Pratt and it's extremely long revelation or letter.
58:48 I mean, it's pages and pages long and whoever decided to publish it took pieces and parts of it and then kind of amalgamated them together. And in some places it makes sense because he's, he's talking about something and he says, oh, by the way, make sure to tell brother Orson that, you know, his, his wife is doing fine and they stop by and what it whatever, just I'm making that up. He's it's just random stuff. And then he goes back to preaching and then he starts while he's preaching and teaching, he starts waxing revelatory and expanding and offering new doctrine. And that's, that makes it in the DNC. But then that he goes on in places and clarifies or gives context for those things.
59:39 And those things were redacted from DNC 121 when it was published. And I, I totally agree with Joshua. I was reading it was like, Oh my gosh, you get rid of all this context. It changes how you read this scripture enormously. Like I've got a much dramatically changed perspective when I read this interim text that was omitted. So not only in in just as A to be fair, not only art was that material omitted in DNC 121 and put in the footnote to make it easier to just read. All together. So you're not going from the the the text of the footnote to the text of the footnote to that becomes difficult too.
1:00:24 So some of that there's an additional entire revelation after a couple of the sections that was omitted. But in the for the restored version, not my JSV version, but we decided in the restored version to to duplicate that material and just put it all in just Smith revelation, whatever it is, 37 or something from beginning to end. So you can read it without going back and forth between the footnotes. That I think is the only thing that's really duplicative in the entire volume. But we felt one, it wasn't a cost problem, which I assumed it was. And so that's why I did the way I did it. And plus that's just the normal academic way of doing it. But then I also included some of the extra revelation that wasn't included at the end and the Joseph Smith uncanonized revelation.
1:01:16 But when talking to Kevin, he said that's not going to change the price. If we could put it all together in one spot, make it easy to read, that would be very helpful for a lot of people. So and then we thought, well, maybe just footnotes to go see Joseph Smith hit whatever 37. But a lot of people aren't going to do that either. So we just put it both places. Gotcha, gotcha. Oh, it makes sense. There are several and by the way, a places where the DNC is not one revelation, it's three. And they were just slammed together and their places. I, I've had people kind of the, the hate trolls, you know, get on my case and say, you know, you can't do this to the revelations, you know, blah, blah, blah.
1:02:01 And, and, and in my forgotten, the forgotten teachings of Joseph Smith say these aren't revelations because, you know, they're for personal journals, so they don't matter. And those what those people don't realize is the original text for different sections of the Doctrine Covenants come from journals. DNC 130 I believe it's verse 22 for instance, and I can verify that while we're talking the DNC 130 verse 22 comes from Wayne Clayton's journal and originally it said the the father had the father has a body of flesh and bone as tangible as man's and the son also, but the Holy Ghost is not a body of flesh and bones.
1:02:52 But and then continues this. However, this verse coming from Williams Clayton's journal was changed in 1854. So the original or sorry, the the the modified version of it reads because the I'd have to kind of go back and forth. Oh, here it is the original and a person cannot have the personage of the Holy Ghost in his heart. That's the original was changed on July 27th, 1854 by George A Smith and Thomas Bullock, apparently approved by Brigham Young and Jedidiah Grant. But we don't know that for positive. But it reads the opposite and it was perpetuated in later published versions.
1:03:38 So it says. Were it not so, the Holy Ghost could not dwell on us. As opposed to saying a personage cannot have the person personage of the a person cannot have the personage of the Holy Ghost in his heart. So directly changes the meaning to be the exact opposite. Gotcha, Josh. I was just going to say when the the beauty of the clarity of what he's saying is when you, when you see this four or five times, you get the full flavor of a Joseph revelation. It, it, it comes at you like, like the tide it comes in and, and you, you're going to hear all of the, all of the revelation that you're used to, but you're going to get all this clarification coming.
1:04:23 And So what you do is when you read other revelations, you just intuitively know, you can say, I bet if I was there in 18341836, Joseph would be there for an extra 20 minutes just loading us down with all of the meanings and the subtleties of that. And, and so I guess what I'm saying is I do appreciate, I do appreciate the work that's been done here. I think we've been careful to keep it to what we call the canonized or the, the, the Church accepted group. But these clarifications and these expansions are so essential because the being at the being at a meeting with Joseph Smith in 1838, we would have heard the whole thing that they were writing down in journals.
1:05:07 And you get that flavor. Gotcha, thank you. I, I have suddenly add there that I is is of significance. During this entire project, I never once referred to a modern version of the DNC or Book of Mormon to compare what I was doing in, in any way that I, I, I might have, I might have looked it up in both to see if the, if I was had the right verse number, you know, because in case I made a mistake and had to check something. But other than that, I never looked at the verbiage of the modern scriptures versus what Joseph approved in 1844. And I thought it was ironic because Michael Sundell's one of our partners, he went through later and said, Drew, I love this part because I believe it was DNC 121 somewhere else. He's he's he's saying the the original is so dramatically different than what we read today. And I hadn't noticed because I wasn't reading the modern version.
1:06:17 I was just looking at the original. But he was very, very much right where it says let virtue garnish thy thoughts unceasingly. That's not the original. Doesn't say let virtue garnished says let your thoughts be garnished unceasingly or something like that, or garnish your thoughts unceasingly. Says nothing about virtue, which, you know, it's not like that's a bad thing, but it's broader than just virtue, unless you mean all morally virtuous thoughts, you know, and I know a lot of people that I've spoken to over the past many years in the, in the mainstream LDS church read virtue to mean sexual virtue or something related to that. And if you're reading it from that perspective, you're missing a lot of what it was intended to say in the original. So at any rate, I did not look at, did not take advisement under did not reconsider any verse ever because of somethings that that is was changed in later editions. And I personally don't know how significant changes were after 1844 to 1981 or 2012 or whenever the last version they did was I, I just didn't look.
1:07:29 And I honestly, I just don't care. I'm a purist. I want to see the, the, the, the, the depth of the fountain. And for me, that's Joseph, what he thought. I, I, I admire and appreciate 10 times what any modern revelatory in any group would say. So for for clarification purposes and understanding the restored version, it is not a revision of the modern version. It is a forget the modern version. We don't look at it at all. We're looking at the original manuscripts. And you know, in, in some of these instances too, Dave, I, I didn't mention, but I started this project about 15 years ago and, and I, I, I've just dabbled in it. So when Joshua and Michael came to me and said, Hey, we would like you to look at doing this, I was like, great, I'm already doing it.
1:08:26 I just have never been able to, to get around to really full time do it because it's too big of a project without anybody financially backing it at all. It's it's, it was just too huge. It took me the greater part of a year when I'd already spent time organizing materials and doing stuff to, to go back to the original OCR materials that I had. Compare them with everything on the Joseph Smith Papers project. Look at Royal Skousen's work on the Book of Mormon and other scholarly works. See if there's anything really need to look at carefully, and so on and so forth. So let. Me ask this question about the Doctrine and Covenants and then I want to kind of move on to the to the unpublished revelations that will be available now.
1:09:12 Yeah. I'm, I'm kind of weird when I go on a deep dive reading the scriptures, right? If I'm reading the, the New Testament, I'll look at words that I get focused on for whatever reason and I'll take it back to the Greek and you know, if need be, I'll take it back to the Hebrew and the Old Testament. Definitely going back to Hebrew, the Doctrine and Covenants is unique because we don't have the filter of, of a complete separate language. However, English, unlike Latin or something like that, isn't a dead language, right? It's continuing to change. And so my, my question is, is do you, did you ever have to go back and go, OK, what does this word mean? And then like for me, I usually crack the 1828. Right.
1:10:00 Because those words do have a few of those words do have different meanings than what they do today. Yes, yeah, I did in. In fact, the, the, the first one, I'm, I'm trying to remember the context, but I, I think it says the Bessem of destruction. And I, I looked and said, is that a bad spelling? But it turns out Bessem is a broomstick. And it's specifically in 1828 had a connotation of being a witch's broom. And so when, when I read that into the passage, and I'm sorry, I can't remember what it is right now. I think it's one of the unpublished revelations, to be honest. It it made perfect sense in that context for something like that to be referred to.
1:10:49 I wouldn't have got that without 1828 dictionary. I think they're about four or five places in the DNC and and then published revelations. Maybe also the Book of Mormon. Maybe there's a a half dozen if you include that. I, I honestly don't recall, but it's not a significant amount. But I did refer to the 1828 dictionary just for the purpose of you can, you can have some people not know that word means something different back then than it does now. And it's worth being aware of. And we debated a little bit about should that footnote be there? It's not a change Joseph made. He didn't make any commentary on it. But last word I got, we'd say to keep those because, you know, if you didn't know, I was talking about a witch's broom and you thought Bassam was a was a misprint and it was supposed to say bosom of destruction.
1:11:44 You're going to have a very different understanding of that verse. There were a few instances like that and also instances where change in, you know, the the modernization of the standardization of, of, of spelling makes a big difference. Where you see the difference? Straight, Strait, change to straight, STRAIGHT and sometimes vice versa or just ignored. Those are different words, they mean different things and you know you see changes made to those words in different versions, but honestly they probably didn't know the difference in the first place.
1:12:29 And you know, they probably intended STRAIGHT as the modern one says, but the other one could work. It would just be redundant. So I believe I dropped one footnote about that, that this is shows up six times in the Book of Mormon. But just as the way I, I've heard that argument so many times in the church that STRIT is probably the proper way because means both straight and tight narrow. So I I put it there just because there's a lot of argument about that in the church, or at least there was when I was there, people arguing about that scripture. So anyway, that's just directed to your question. Yeah, we we've got roughly half a dozen footnotes that address those those types of things.
1:13:16 Got you, Josh. I saw your hand go up. Yeah, there was A and I'm I'm looking through the DNC right now, but there was that Drew, maybe you can remember there was that one word that was just so strange. It didn't even sound English. And it was written and, and, and I, I have a pretty strong vocabulary. I mean, I, I, I speak a couple languages and I know my English. And you went back into the 1828 and defined that word, which I don't think anybody would even know what that is. Do you remember that? I think it started with an S. What was that word? It was that one. What? What was it? You know, I, I, I know exactly which one you're talking about, but I can't remember the word because I looked at it and I said, this doesn't sound right. I, I, I don't, I don't think I'm understanding this properly. I looked into it.
1:14:07 I ended up taking a deep dive beyond grammar and into Old English. And it it might have had some maritime thing or they had to go in there or something. Joseph had to have heard it from like an uncle that was in the was in like a a Navy or something. Like it was wild, David, it was wild. When you read it, you're like, wow, is this German? Yeah, yeah. That I, I, I, I wish either of us could remember the verse because there was definitely something really, really fun that happened there. And I was excited to, after I researched it to write the footnote because I thought, I bet nobody captures this. That's awesome. It's probably not the same in the modern version or, or it would be more familiar to us, but so it's probably changed again.
1:14:51 I also found. Sorry. No, you're good. I wish I could give the the precise example, but I also found a place where one of the words that was used was an uncommon word and oh, I think this one made it on the scriptures. Proprietor, yes, but it was spelled proprietor or something. And so the modern version makes it sound like the preparator, somebody who prepared it, is talking about hell, but the word is spelled improperly. It's supposed to say proprietor, which is the creator or the the person who built it of hell.
1:15:36 And speaking, the adversary is the person who built it, not who prepared it, but who built it. At any rate, that was another really weird spelling that I I footnoted down and said this is what it is. I didn't pay any attention to what the modern version said. That was brought to my attention later by Michael, but didn't note that there was something in the 1840. It changed a couple times. Joseph wrote Father, then changed it back, and I don't remember which what he ended up with, but they all kind of mean a similar thing. But the modern version does not mean a similar thing at all. Preparator doesn't just mean somebody who prepared. It means something else when you look it up. I don't remember what it was, but it's nothing to do with the context.
1:16:22 It's it's not a very good translation, right? Moving on to to those unpublished revelations. Did those pose? Any challenge figuring out what was revelation and what's what's not? And, and the reason I ask it like that is because Mormonism has a unique view on scripture, right? The the quad is the Canon of scripture, right? That's what's been accepted into the Canon, but per the Doctrine and Covenants scripture is anything that the servants of the Lord are, say that when moved upon by the Holy Ghost. So as you started going towards those unpublished revelations, how were you able to decipher between what was somebody's recollection of something Joseph said that sounded inspired versus what was what was real revelation?
1:17:19 Does that make sense, Drew? Yeah, yeah, it makes sense and I'm glad you asked that. I want to give you kind of a preface to, first of all, the original Doctrine and Covenants. I believe it mentions in Section 78. I could be wrong but I've got a whole appendix on the subject talks about the correction and the continual updating of scriptures. There was a specific society created to a printing society created to make sure the scriptures were updated from time to time. That that understanding of it was removed in later editions of scripture when it fell apart and was just modified to read Holy Firm or Holy Order. Talking about a United order so completely loses its its original intent.
1:18:11 So first of all, there's there was a commandment to update the scriptures, update the revelations specifically. So that was a a significant impetus for me back 1015 years ago that we needed an updated DNC to include revelations that were not originally included. Now the next question is, well, isn't that the Prophet's job to determine what's what should be included or not? Joseph skipped revelation several times. Maybe they should never not be included, blah, blah, blah. But the answer was the early brethren talked about these things and, and you know, sometimes they didn't print something because it was specific to an individual, but sometimes they put stuff in the Doctrine of Covenants that was very much specific to an individual. We have to extrapolate how to apply that to us and vice versa. So early on, looking at those things, I, I, I decided to, to use a principle that I based this entire pro the, the, the entire project on and that, that we all talked about and agreed as part of the restored version.
1:19:21 And that is this. We want a version of scripture that every restorationist can trust. So I don't care if you're RLDS, if you're Kinks tonight, if you're the the Branch, if you're Centennial Park, if you're AUB, if you're mainstream Mormon, or if you're Strangite or rigged tonight. I I don't care. This version, we document everything that happens so that you can trust it. This is what Joseph approved or would have approved when he died. That's assuming he would approve his own revelations. But the printing of them is the only real question.
1:20:01 And at that point I could, I could do like most scholars do and say, well, my personal belief is this scripture, this, this revelation was probably influenced by so and so and and it wasn't written down by Joseph. We don't have a signature at the bottom. So I think it's kind of sketchy. I don't. I'm not going to include it in my compilation of scriptures that Joseph Oregon revelations Joseph received. I I do not play arbiter at all. This is how we decided if it was written down as Joseph's revelation, it's included in the original 65 revelations, Joseph Smith and they're numbered Joseph Smith #1 Joseph Smith #2 Jose Smith #3 I did we decided to do that because Dr. Cummins 139 one 4150.
1:20:47 That's going to just kind of rub some groups wrong and make it confusing for other people and so on so forth. And wait a second, who decided what went in there and what order? So we just didn't chronologically. Joseph Smith one, Joseph Smith 2, Joseph Smith 3. Now there's a couple of them that some people have argued Joseph Smith received this revelation. Some said no, Oliver Counter did. Some say, well, Oliver Counter received some of it, but it was at the direction of Joseph and Joseph used some of that in other sections. D&C. So Joseph approved it as his own revelation and presented it as such a pieces of parts, blah, blah, blah. So I just footnote the dispute, put it in there for Joseph. That's primarily just the first one and and not so much the others.
1:21:31 So if it was written down, we have a copy of it in somebody's handwriting purporting to be a revelation from Joseph Smith. You will find it. So that's that's the first threshold issue. The recent book, Jeez, I should remember. Dang it, I just tore down my library recently for some remodeling, so I don't have it in front of me. But there's a recent volume done by a couple brethren that included, I think 42 unpublished revelations. Joseph Smith. They, they did a really good job of what they did, but in my estimation, they played arbiter and said, you know, this will, this will hurt your testimony. You can't read this. And we don't believe it because later prophets proved it was wrong or something. And that may be oversimplifying their reasoning, but that's what it looked like to me.
1:22:19 So versus there 42, we have 65. Also the second thing I put in a separate section when somebody said I was there when Joseph received thus and so revelation, and this is what it said. That's in a separate section. And we label those hearsay revelations because we don't have the original writing, but we do have somebody saying Joseph received this revelation. I was there and it it doesn't matter where I fall on the spectrum. If I don't, I look at it and say, you know, I think that brother was wrong. I don't think that's what Joseph said. I think he misunderstood him. I don't care. I included it word for word with whatever source journal, whatever we have, that's what's there.
1:23:04 And often times we actually have four to five different people recording the exact same thing. So, and we talked about should we include that or not include those because they're, we don't have the original revelation. We just have a journal. But DNC 1/30/22 comes from a journal. So there is that. So what we ultimately decided was to include all of those and just put them in a separate section because some people are going to say where's the revelation about Joseph talking about blacks and the priesthood? Well, that's actually a journal entry. It's actually coming from Zebedee Coltran. He's saying he was arguing with the Elder Green over whether or not black should have the priesthood.
1:23:48 And Elder Green said, well, I'm going to take this to Joseph and tell him that you think black should have the priest because you're wrong. And Zebedee Coltrane records that they took it to Joseph. Joseph prayed and he said Elder Coltrane's right, the blacks have no right to the priesthood. Now that's a super controversial topic. I'm not coming down one way or the other. It's what Coltrane said, and so I included as a hearsay revelation. We don't have Joseph's words or at best we have a hearsay recounting of his words and we don't have the original writing. There probably never was original writing and that's all we've got on it. So if that goes in its own section and I we do not footnote thousands of people who agreed later or whatever.
1:24:36 The only thing that I include with things like that is I was there when Joseph received this or Joseph said thus and so was a revelation. He told me he received this as a revelation, so on, so forth. So King Fall at this course isn't there. I believe we could receive that as a piece of scripture, but it's not there because he doesn't say this is a revelation of God to me. Nobody claimed that was Joseph receiving revelation speaking it to the Saints, although many people believe it is revelatory that. But anyway, that's that's how we made those distinctions that keeps us from including a bunch of prophecies of Joseph, which is a volume by itself and similar types of readings. All of those, however, if known if I discovered them, are in the Forgot Teachings of Joseph Smith's volumes I published a couple years ago.
1:25:30 There's 1000 pages of those got. You. I saw your hand go up there, Josh. I was just going to add that Drew and the committee themselves, but Drew especially, we were very, very young with, with the what we call the hearsay, That's the legal term. Both Drew and I are lawyers, so I don't like using that term in general because it makes it sound illegal or unevidentiary. But it's just, it's a third party that heard somebody say something. There's no writing there. So it's our way of saying that we can't trace it back to the horse's mouth. I wish there was an easier word to describe it, but we were very conscientious not to, not to put in what are truly evocative or provocative.
1:26:14 The ones like, like, let me just throw this out for you guys. For me, I'm one that does follow the the White Horse prophecy, but the White Horse prophecy is not going to be in here. And there are several others that people they enjoy or they read or that they find constitutionally, you know, contiguous to their thoughts. What we did is we tried to, we replaced all of the revelations in there that we felt had a consistent and a unifying effect, notwithstanding a lot of our intellectual debates. So I think it was, I think it was, I think you'll find it was really well done. Yeah, I, I, I could, I could envision a study version in the future including some of those other, other writings.
1:27:04 But the, the, the bar that we used was, did somebody call it a revelation and say Joseph received it? And if so that it was included? There were only 22 of those outside of the written 65 above and beyond the original DNC. We could have called them second hand accounts of revelations, but then nobody would remember what to call it. Gotcha. So gotcha. Well, let me ask you this. What about things that went beyond Joseph Smith? Like I'm thinking the 1886 revelation, the Woodruff revelation. Did those make their way into there? 35 to 40 of them we have. And yes, they're, they're going to be there. And some of those are a little tricky. I'm thinking especially one of Brigham Young where he says, I, I rarely speak of visions and revelations and so forth and such, but I've never looked upon this piece of ground but that I don't see the Salt Lake Temple.
1:27:58 And he refers to it as a revelation And, and so in in keeping with Joseph Smith's hearsay version, except for that's directly from him. So it's not a hearsay revelation, but I treated it much the same. And I, I, I hope it, it, this is a frustration. Anytime you publish something, I hope somebody comes to me a year from now and says, Drew, why didn't you include Wolfer Woodruff's 1854 revelation that nobody has seen before? I'd love to see that. Then we can add it to, you know, 'cause I'm sure I'll miss something.
1:28:39 There's so much obscure stuff, and every once in a while things pop up. For instance, Joseph Smith, you know, gives a revelation to Whitney about these are the words that you shall give to your daughter to do the ceiling ordinance with me. And, and you know, that's there. There are other places where it's referred to as a revelation. So that's there. And you can look at it, compare it to the original ordinance and see if that's a template or a word for word thing or what is that supposed to be? Whatever. But things like that, you know, something else could pop out next year the, the day after we publish.
1:29:21 And if we do future editions, we will add those things. But until then, it's just kind of like the best we can do right now. If, if the church was transparent and said here, all the all the revelations we have, they claim they've got a lot more that have never been published and haven't seen the light of day. And if they ever decide to pull those out of the archive vaults and publish them and we do another version, that those will be included again. Our purpose is not to be the arbiter of is that a false revelation or a true revelation, or should it have been published or not because it was intended for a specific group of people or what not?
1:30:04 I, I don't think that's as relevant in our day and age for purists like you and I. I want to see whatever revelation he received and let me discern on my own. If that was for an individual and doesn't pertain to me, that's something we can decide. But where they've been hidden for many, many decades and not allowed to see the light of day except they're very rare circumstances. I, I think we want, most of us want to see those things and know for ourselves and not have somebody else be the arbiter of that. And, and, and when I publish those things, I, I never want to be that person. I don't believe that's true. So I'm not going to publish it.
1:30:44 That's no thanks. Not not me. Right, right. No, there. Look, as a surveyor, one of the guys who who I worked with, who trained me, he used to say something really interesting and he said, no one can ever call you a liar for showing what you found, right. And so it's kind of like a a you report, you know, we report, you decide sort of a thing. And, and I like that approach to it a lot. Let's shift gears here a little bit. Is there anything else on the Doctrine and Covenants you wanted to mention, either you or Drew or Josh?
1:31:27 I had one thing and I, I may have discussed this with you previously, but but it's, it's something that hit me very profoundly. And, and if I did, I apologize for being repetitive. And if I didn't, then great. You know, they're, they're, I, I alluded to this earlier. There are a lot of rumors, as it were, that Joseph Smith translated the Book of Mormon word for word. And, you know, academics have gone to ridiculous links not to disprove that, but just to see what happened to those original texts. And when you do that work, you pretty much cannot help but conclude that it was not received word for word. And if it was received word for word, Joseph didn't respect it as a word for word revelation because he changed it. And the same thing is true, the Doctrine of Covenants. He's writing things, you know, he's got a scribe writing things down and he changes it anyways.
1:32:34 But that message he gave to, I believe it was probably P prouder. William W Phelps, When you're editing the scriptures, make sure not to change the sense. Arguably they didn't follow that objective. I could, as a philosopher, argue that changed the meeting, what they wrote there, and therefore they disobeyed Joseph's adjunction and therefore the original should stand that the change should not. I don't think that's true, though. I think what they did is they changed it to clarify what had been a problem. For instance, there were challenges about the the law of consecration. They said, wait, does DNC 142 mean this or this? Surely it doesn't mean this.
1:33:21 That's too hard to live. We don't want to say that. And that type of questioning. We could go back in history and look and see he was being bombarded with questions. What does this mean? Should we do this or this? Does it mean this or this like tithing, you know, have that letter to Edward Partridge clarifying what it meant. And that's not what most people interpret. DNC 19 verse 7 and in previous and following verses show the same clarification of the misunderstanding of the word eternal punishment. So we see places where Joseph is trying to clarify the meaning in a couple of his discourses, one in particular, and I should memorize again on the top of my head, 'cause I think about it frequently.
1:34:11 He says I could have rendered A plainer translation of this, but it will suffice for today's purposes. I believe that might have been the Elias Elijah discourse on March 10th. I could become conflating two different ones, but I believe that's the date for that one. But in other words, his point is there are different applications of the same scripture in different circumstances. And I can give a translation for both circumstances that's going to be different one from another. And that's OK. And so as I, as I've gone over every single comment and, and that word and sometimes two or three or four times because you, you get tired, you've been at it for six or eight hours. You're like, oh, OK, again, reread that paragraph all over again.
1:35:03 And, and you know, you're looking for one thing and then you have to fix another. I'm correcting all the capital letters to small case or something. And then I'm going back and then I'm doing punctuation separately. And then I'm going back and putting footnotes, then I'm looking at the changes. This type of thing. You, there's always going to be a mistake. But having gone through as diligently as I could, which by the way, is why Royal Skousen's work took him 30 years of research before he published that paper, you got to admire somebody like that. At the same time, we just like, dude, we want to see that. 20 years ago it would have been OK if I had five mistakes, man. Anyway, my point is, I, looking at this, see Joseph as a revelator differently than when I started the project.
1:35:53 The reason is I wondered, for instance, did Joseph translate it word for word? Because there are mistakes in there. And is is that the Lord's bad grammar? And why would he speak in grammar not this just was bad by modern standards, but that doesn't make any sense. I can't even understand the syntax in a few places. It's just weird, you know? Why would why would the Lord speak so vaguely? To confuse us on purpose? Or at least, no, we're going to be confused. And there's no way without our own revelation to know how to interpret that puppy. And so when I started seeing more and more is a Joseph Smith, who he's listening to the Spirit, teaching concepts and ideas, expresses it in his own language.
1:36:44 And then later people say, what did that mean? And he said, oh, my understanding wasn't what you just said. It was this other thing I see. And, you know, I, I think everybody who's given a priesthood blessing, who's been inspired, has given a priest a blessing where somewhere you, you tell somebody something and then they ask you a question. You're like, oh, no, that I, I had a really clear impression about that. This is what I understood. But they understood your words differently. And now I see Joseph as a revelator where he's expressing the ideas, he's expressing concepts in his own words. And they're, they're showing up in the DNC. It gets published in 1835, for instance, which was technically a book of commandments, not DNC, but I don't know that matters to anybody except for scholar.
1:37:32 But just for, for to be clear. And it gets published in 1835 And people start asking him questions. Joseph, this is kind of unclear. Is this being this or this? And pretty soon there are 1520 people all asking the same questions. And he stops and says, man, next time that gets edited, I'm fixing that. I don't want to ask a question anymore. And so he does. And that to a lot of people I see struggle seeing changes being made to scriptures saying, oh, it wasn't inspired, you know, or this is some sort of conspiracy or whatever. But my my project here wasn't saying, well, what about the 1912 scripture editing committee? Was Talmage being deceptive or tricky when he changed this thing?
1:38:20 Or, you know, was he inspired or did so and so give him direction? I don't care about it and all that. I'm only looking at what Joseph changed and in doing that and looking at it from that lens, my take away from all of that is Joseph is a revelator. Revelator was not giving word for word instructions. We're we're being fair cycle and pedantic when we really look at it that way. We need to look at the concepts and ideas and seeing what he's trying to express and and use that as our our take away, which I frankly think is a good approach to all scripture. But especially with Joseph being more modernized, we can we can see that easier.
1:39:03 And I think that's very helpful. I recently bought a new study Bible. It's a sociological background. Yeah, I think sociological background study Bible. And in it the, the guy introducing it says the Bible was written for us, but it was not written to us. Unless we understand who it's written to, we're not receiving the word that was intended for us. And I see the same thing with Joseph Smith. If we're looking at, I'm going to get really pedantic about this word and really upset that this was, he changed it from father to proprietor, proprietor to father. And that proves he's a fallen prophet or whatever.
1:39:45 I think we're really getting too Pharasaical. Really we need to say is what's the, the broad meaning of both of those words? And how do those convey an understanding of who Lucifer is in relation to Hell? And when we start looking at it that way, you you see the changes trying to give a a concept to us, the principle to us, not specific words. And you know, and that's, I'll get to you here in a second, Josh, that is so important because I think we all do this to some degree. We, we superimpose upon Joseph what we think revelation should look like or what it should, how it should be communicated, right? We see this most often in that we don't give the profit enough room to grow, right?
1:40:39 We assume that he receives the fullness of everything and one shot and it's all there. And what, what I tend to see, and I'm not a scholar, right? I'll, I'll be the first guy to admit that. But what I do see is I do see Joseph begin to to change like you would expect anybody to change, right? As the Lord reveals something new, he goes, oh, that's interesting. What's the implications for that? And just how he receives the revelation. It's not word for word. It's it's ideas, right? Or sometimes, as we see in 76, it's what he saw, right? And so he's giving a first hand account of what he sees, not necessarily words that are dictated to him.
1:41:21 Josh, would would you have there? I was just going to add, with the DNC especially, you're going to notice in the Book of Mormon at the very beginning, there's a lot of commentary and annotations. There's a lot of commentary and annotations throughout this, but there aren't as many footnotes as there are in the DNC. You're going to see a lot of footnotes, which we also call annotations. And I just wanted to, I wanted to explain why I initially was against, and Drew knows this. I was initially against all the annotations or as many annotations as we had or footnotes.
1:42:02 But now I believe that they're necessary. They're, they're not there to instruct us or tell us what to believe. They're there to allow us to trust the words or the selection of words that we found that Joseph used and and Drew just explained why that was necessary, clarifying his revelatory understanding and he was growing in his academic abilities. If you look at Joseph in 1820 and then look at him in 1843, even as an orator or even as a transcriber offering words describes, he was a much different person, far more sophisticated and far more capable.
1:42:43 I mean, he was dictating things as mayor, then dictating things as a prophet. And he was very, very accomplished in those years juxtaposed against 18, what is it, 18231827 when, when they were doing those things at that time. So we have to allow for that. The annotations, the footnotes and the commentaries you're going to read aren't going to instruct you what to believe. They're going to allow you to trust the selections that we found that Joseph would approve of. And, and there's going to be a lot there. You're going to, you're going to have several pages at the beginning of the Book of Mormon explaining it and then not as many footnotes. But at the beginning of the DNC, you'll have several pages and a lot of footnotes.
1:43:27 And again, for those that are listening to this, we do intend to proper a, an issue or a printing of this that limits them, that limits as many annotations and commentaries so that you can just have the pure scriptures. But we really wanted you to see and understand Joseph Smith at a level that say Drew and, and some of the rest of us understand him so that you can trust the restored version. And, and actually, when you, when that happens, then we, we can, we can remove a lot of that. I was just going to put a quick plug in here. Restored Scriptures is the website that you can go to. I don't know if they I'll. Get to that towards the end.
1:44:09 Oh yeah, yeah. But we get that. Towards the end, yeah, we'll, we'll, we'll get there. We'll tell everyone where to find them and where to purchase them and all, and all those other things when when we get there. Back to the footnotes thing, I think those are so vitally important. Unlike a lot of other scriptures that is within the Judeo-christian tradition, they're by different authors, right? Mormonism is kind of unique in that most of the scripture we get that is outside the Bible, and even some inside the Bible with the inspired version comes from one guy, right? So understanding as much as we can what's going on around him at that time can definitely give us some, some information and inform us on how maybe we should look at those things based on how we can conclude or, or hope to get close to what Joseph was thinking.
1:45:06 But Drew, let's let's go ahead and let's move on now to the Pearl of great price, 'cause this one really fascinates me. The Pearl of great price really fascinates me for for a couple reasons. One is, is, I mean, you start diving into the Pearl of great price, you're starting to dive into some temple stuff, right? It, I think it's really in the Pearl of great price where we start to see, you know, the doctrine, the covenants definitely, but along with the Pearl great price exaltation start to become a thing within the theology. So Drew, as you went back to the Pearl great price, what were some of the challenges you faced there and what were some of your bigger doctrinal takeaways as you you started that process and and throughout?
1:45:54 Each each book was different. So in the book of Abraham, for instance, I was surprised very few changes. Joseph published some of it fairly. We have some early man is restate that we have some early manuscripts of Joseph in the 1830s, but then he basically had to put this the project on hold for not quite a decade, but for a long time. And I expected to see more changes. But I I don't think he really had the opportunity to go back sit, edit it carefully like he did some of the other things. So the original manuscripts versus what was published in 1851.
1:46:39 Not a much, just not a lot of annotations. It's just not there that there are some for sure. I'm, I'm by no means would say there are not, but definitely not the same kind of number we see in the DNC, probably more page wise per page than you'd expect in the book. Then you'd see in the Book of Mormon a bit not not tons. So I, I feel like with the book of Abraham, a lot of that's a little bit more original. That's, that's not to say there aren't any significant changes. It's just to say they're numerically smaller in amount then then you get to see in the DNC, which may be partially because the DNC isn't just Joseph Smith's revelation. It's Joseph Smith's revelation as published in the Times and Season as published over in Liverpool, England, as published in Nauvoo, as published also in Missouri. And then also we have somebody made a copy of it because it's an early revelation.
1:47:40 So it's literally comparing 6 or 7 manuscripts for each revelation for the earlier sections of Doctor Covenants, which was extremely tedious because you know, sometimes 3 versions would be almost identical and there would just be one or two changes. And they didn't really change anything. They were just editorial type changes. So at any rate, we don't have a lot of that in the, in the book of Abraham, which is nice in the, in the book of Moses. I was not surprised by anything. And the reason is I, I finished that work 20 years ago and 15 years ago with, you know, I was just kind of up updating research I'd done when I was on my mission.
1:48:27 I found out about that you could buy a Joseph Smith translation in that they were available for sale. So I bought 1 and I was super excited to have it and, and started marking verse reverse changes. So by the time I got to college, I, I was privileged to take a class from Robert J Matthews, who is the scholar who basically made the JST available to the church and said, yes, this is true. In fact, what the original manuscripts say. And he did a whole his, I think it was his senior thesis on it. So there's a whole thick book that he wrote on it and published.
1:49:10 It's called A Planar Translation by Robert J Matthews with a long subtitle and any rate. So I studied with him for his class. He likes people to just highlight the verses of each verse that was changed at 3410 of them. But I agree, showed him that I already done a bunch of that and could I just underline every word that was changed? So I'd already done that. So when I got to this version of it, I'd already compared the the verses numbers side by side. So I had both of them showing King James versus Joseph Smith verse. I already had italicized or underlined the words word for word and it already paid somebody type it up for me about 10-15 years ago. And so I just took that manuscript. I had italicized versus underline the changes, double checked everything for editing purposes and, and moved on. So because I'd done that so for so many years, but ahead of time, nothing surprised me.
1:50:13 And, and honestly, it's, it's so stuck in my head that I couldn't, couldn't tell you a whole lot of changes that are really super interesting because it's just normal to me. However, I will mention one and and and I didn't notice that this part did surprise because I think there were some side notes didn't make the original manuscripts and they may not to my knowledge, don't even show up in the Joseph Smith papers. But some maybe some scraps of paper or something that that added a change or two that I did not see and or annotate because I couldn't find the original material for the restored version. That's, that's this when Enoch is talking with God and seeing the wickedness of the people.
1:51:06 It, it originally says there, there's varying versions there. There's a version where Enoch cries and says, this is awful. I can't believe how wicked your children are. Then there's a revision of it that says God was crying because of the wickedness of the people. Then there's another revision and I think this is one that finally makes it in there, says God cries and Enoch cries because of the wickedness of the people. But then God steps forward and says, all right, Neph Cran, get your stuff together. We're going to move on. Other things to talk about. And so looking at those changes, that's a really substantive change from the original. And I'm, I'm curious about what Joseph saw that made him write it like that.
1:51:55 And for viewers or listeners, sorry, who haven't gone into this too much, I'll point a little bit of history that explains that a little bit better. So Joseph said and it's recorded and this is also and forgot teachings of Joseph Smith and the two volumes I published, Joseph recording said I read the entire Bible with the Urim and Thummim. I saw it all in panoramic vision. I believe that's paraphrasing, but pretty close to his original words. Later people said, Joseph, did you use the Urim and Thummim to translate the Bible? And he said no and they said why not. And incidentally, when he quit using the seer stone in the Urim and Thummim, I believe it was early Nauvoo. A lot of the Saints really struggled with that said how can you be a seer if you're not using a seer stone? But when Joseph replied about the book, about the Bible, he said, I didn't need it because I grew the principle of revelation that I no longer needed those tools. And and so when he changes, Enoch cried, No, God cried. No, they both cried.
1:53:04 I, I wonder, you know, he's remembering back when he saw the vision, writing down part of it say, Oh, wait, you know, and it changes something. And again, oh, wait, it wasn't just Enoch. It was both of them. And then God's because God said this time he said, stop weeping. And you know, because in Enoch says, how can they weep? And he said, I forgot to mention God was weeping or, or whatever. I, I read that now again, from that perspective of Joseph saw things, he wrote it down later. He said, oh, I didn't, I didn't write that well, I forgot about that part. And you know, there were years between when he sees a panoramic vision from when he translates as he calls it. And and so again, I see that that revelatory influence.
1:53:46 I was talking about earlier concepts and ideas that could use clarification later, but that's particularly interesting one and, and one that's way easier to argue. Joseph's the following prophet is just making crap up and that sort of thing. But I think with the lens that that I have, it's a, it's a much more you can if you're skeptical, it's a naive perspective. And if you're not skeptical, I I think it's a more kind perspective towards how how he's recording these things. Few weeks back I had Justin Frankham on the podcast where he laid out a bold plan to help people and families from all areas of the restoration that are looking for a new home in Mormonism. Mormon Legacy Ministries is an online multi faith effort to be a place where folks can come and learn and have fellowship while they find their new church home.
1:54:41 Now it doesn't matter if folks end up back in the LDS Church, a fundamentalist church, or an independent. We just want people to go where it is that the Lord tells them to go where they can do the most good. Now as of last Saturday, a few of those meetings are now up and running. So there are four meetings that are available to you on the 2nd and 4th Saturday of every month at 3:00 PM Mountain Standard Time. A Sacrament meeting is available on Monday nights at 7:00 PM Mountain Standard Time is a men's meeting on Thursday night at 6:00 PM Mountain Standard Time. A Gospel Fundamentals class is available then on the 1st and Tuesday of every month at 7:00 PM Mountain Standard Time.
1:55:23 Starting in October, a Women Women's meeting will be held. Now it doesn't matter if you are a member of the LDS Church, a fundamentalist, a person from other Restoration branches and investigator, or a never Mormon, these meetings are available to all. Now it doesn't even matter where you live, East Coast, West Coast, Midwest, Canada, Mexico, Europe, you name it, you have access to all these meetings. All you need to do is to go to mormonlegacy.org, scroll to the bottom of the landing page and just click the link of the meeting you want to join. That's it. So whether you want a soft place to land while you look for your new church home, you're curious about early Mormon teachings, or you just really want to be part of something and they're already member of a church and want to stay there but want more opportunities to serve, this could be the place for you.
1:56:15 Again, you can access all those meetings and reach out to anybody with the ministry by going to mormonlegacy.org or by clicking the link in this episode. Show notes. Thank you. Sure. Yeah. No, absolutely. I can see that. So with that there, there's one other thing in the Pearl Great price that I was curious about in thinking about this, this our conversation here and that is the first vision, right, that's included in the Pearl great price. Is that going to be in there as well, the Joseph Smith history? I think so and I say I think so because I finished this months ago and that I, I included the 1851 version and I believe that includes the first vision. But I say that because I've I've I compiled an understanding Adam God teaching some 15 or 18 different versions of the first vision.
1:57:16 Right. That was my next question. That's where I was going. I was wondering how you handled that. Yeah. And I think there's also similarly those are in the forgotten Mormon teachings, but with maybe, maybe not the full context. And I've got a a book that's just all the different versions of it all the way through, which was tedious and boring and doesn't really explain much in some places. I think all the all the fun stuff is is in my previous publications. But what I did was reproduce the 1851 version of the Pearl. Great Price and didn't stray or annotate beyond that.
1:57:56 So yes, we have other versions. Yes, there are other copies of it, but no, I didn't compare them because 1851 was the first Pearl of Great Price and our intention was to recreate the earliest version of Scripture as was published and and not to deeply annotate it. Now, that said, if the guys came along and said we're going to postpone publishing for a month because that's how long it's going to take me to do that, let's put in all the versions of the first vision from beginning to end. And no, no ellipses and skipping stuff that's boring. Just get it all there and, and annotate it. I'd be I'd be happy to do it.
1:58:37 I think there's a lot of really interesting stuff there. But again, it's not in the original Pearl Great price. It's not even in later versions of the Pearl Great Price where we see all those different versions. So the scope of the project being it was, whether it was those were not included, no, it makes perfect. Based on the growing, changing attitude of the committee, I could see a future version including all that as an appendix. Right. And if if there was a high demand and people started complaining about it and I'd be happy to do it. But anyway, we take at least at least a month probably to put that all together. Sure.
1:59:19 And did you do anything with the Bible? Is there going to be a restored version of the of the Bible? Josh? Hold on, Josh, do. You mind, Drew that I that I take this he and I OK, so this we were I was going to wait and tease this out at the end, but as soon as this triple the restored version comes out Drew and I I don't even know that we've really discussed this in committee. So I don't know that Michael or Kevin even know about this, but I had made the suggestion that we go through and, and take, take your time and, and myself and 'cause I have AI have a burning interest in the Joseph Smith translation. Joseph Smith, as you may know, may or may not know, called the German Bible, which would have been the Luther Bible. That what he called the German Bible. He said that was actually the most correct. There are a couple of statements to that effect. Nevertheless, he approved of the King James and then made the Joseph Smith translations of the King James and what I was hoping and drew found interesting.
2:00:32 I'll let him kind of follow up is a, is a Bible that is the Joseph Smith translation of the Bible with annotations, additions and in the form of footnotes. Or if, if the if the record reflects it clearly enough, making the changes all together to reflect the accuracies that Joseph Smith listed with what he called the German Bible, which is the Luther Bible. So yes, I, I hope that that's coming. Hasn't been discussed in committee, but Drew and I have discussed it a little bit. I'll table that one. We may have to have a separate podcast for that one. Drew, what we're going to mention on that. OK, so two things.
2:01:14 First of all, the book of Moses is the Josh Smith translation Genesis. A lot of people don't know that, but I, I make that explicitly clear in the Pearl of great price that these are JST versus King James Version or just Bible verses. And in some places the Moses chapters are different. So I, I, I know know all of those. So you can find it no matter which one you're referring to. Also, Joseph Smith, Matthew verses 24 was part of the Pearl of great price still is. That was such a bear to edit because not only did Joseph add, delete and change versus, he also rearranged versus.
2:01:55 And so that's a little bit of a bit of a bear to follow. But anyway, so those are there as to what what Joshua was just talking about. One of the things I mentioned to him, some people feel like such a work is not necessary because there's a parallel version of the Joseph Smith translation with the Bible. And my response to that is that's a horrific volume and I hate it. 100% would never own it, would never recommend it. Here's why. As I mentioned earlier, there are 3410 verses where Joseph changed the Bible. However, that parallel version includes every change also in spelling from the American version to the English version, meaning Britain.
2:02:44 Joseph used an American version, the person who made that volume used a British version, and so Savior was changed from SAVIOUR to SAVIOR. He attributed that to Joseph and put it in the parallel version, but nothing else changed. And so there are thousands of verses in there that are not changes that Joseph did anything with. So it's a complete disaster and awful. I also personally believe if Joseph Smith were alive, being so interested in the original languages and proper translations and offering various translations, and now we absolutely 100% academically know the King James Version is the most inaccurate set of manuscripts of any Bible version on the market today. I don't think Joseph would use it. The others were not available at his time. I think you'd probably use an NRSV, maybe an RSV, but certainly not the King James Version. Because it has the most corruptions of any Bible that we have.
2:03:48 It includes most of the corruptions from from manuscripts as late as 7th, 8th, and even like 12th century manuscript copies that added change stuff. King James has it all whereas a lot of the other translations don't. So I personally think he would be using a different translation. But I'm very interested in recreating that parallel column version without the parallel columns. And just saying here the verses of Joseph changed so that you can see what he changed, where he changed it can compare it to your Bible, whichever translation you use. I don't read German, so I don't know if Joshua reads German, but if if he wants to input on the German stuff that's great, but otherwise I don't read it enough.
2:04:33 I couldn't. As I understand it, there is no anglicized version of the Luther Bible, so that would be quite. And it's it was published originally in the 1500s, so there's no copyright problem with that. But that is, that is a very highly ambitious endeavor. You know. That's highly ambitious. Yeah, that version of it I would not be qualified to do, but I would be happy to write down those 3410 verses with changes just like I did for this project for the for the Genesis slash Moses chapters. So you can see what it would look like. Italicized text is what he changed or added and then footnotes were necessary of what he deleted or something like that.
2:05:17 So yeah, that could be a future quad version. We'll we'll see what what happens. Gotcha, gotcha. All right here before before we move on here to to the final part, telling people where they can grab the book and you grab the the triple and that sort of stuff. I would be remiss if I didn't ask this, and I want to say this on the outset. I mean no disrespect to any of the men here that that I'm going to be. Here we go. Fair enough. But there, there is, as you said, there, there is kind of a a group that's that's doing this right there. There's you, there's Kevin Kraut, there's Joshua Winchell, Michael Sundell.
2:06:06 My question is this in this process and and let me just say this, people are very familiar and comfortable with the name Drew Briny and Ogden slash Kevin Kraut, right? They have been staples in in the in the the the community for quite some time. Yeah. We're less familiar with Joshua and Michael, and I'm not saying they're bad guys. I don't get, you know, that's not what I'm saying at all. I've known Joshua for about a year and a half, two years now. We've talked off and on. But in this process as, as you know, Drew's going through this stuff and he's putting this together, what is the process like? Like when when Drew submits his stuff to to the border or however you guys refer to it, does that board have input on what gets put in and what doesn't? And then if so, how does that affect the final product? Great question.
2:07:13 Do you want to hit that first, Josh, or should I grab that? I'll just kind of segue into, into what you're saying when you say the board, the board is for people and what what that is, is our impetus. Our desire was to arrive at what we call the Joseph Smith version at first. Now, we ended up not using that for the Scriptures. We we believe that that was a little bit pretentious in light of some of the differing denominations. We didn't want, we didn't want any kind of, you know, acrimony over saying, hey, they call Mr. Joseph Smith version where we all believe Joseph Smith is the dispensation leader. What makes this so, so great? Our hope was to offer what we called a clean set of scriptures that Joseph would approve of.
2:07:59 Now, we knew that Drew had the knowledge that the tenacity and the tedious nature to go through and do all of this. So when you say that he proffers it to us for correction, I don't think, I mean there were, I'll just be honest, there were two discussions early on about a year and two months ago where it got to a level for about 3 minutes where we were, where we were a little bit. There was a misunderstanding and A and a desire. And Drew was very patient. He walked through categorically. There were like 5 points and the four points that we were talking about.
2:08:39 This had to do with Joseph's input on formatting. And he just, he walked through, he just said, OK, then let's go through the dates On this date. He wrote this, On this date, this, and I can get you these things. We can go ahead and keep this original formatting if this is what you guys want because you believe in the sacred nature of the 1830s, or we can add these things. And I think by the end of that discussion, both Sundell, myself and I think even Kevin came to the conclusion that that it wasn't Drew's intellect. It was all of the exhaustive research and the overwhelming evidence of what he was saying. So I think there's a humility on our side.
2:09:20 Yes. Are we new to the community? I, I would have to say yes. You've known me for two years. I don't think I've done anything that to, you know, extirpate myself or create any kind of division, you know it within the the fundamentalist or the orthodox Mormon community. But you're absolutely right. So those discussions, they did exist. They lasted I think about 3 to 6 minutes. And then it became daunting or overwhelming the amount of evidence that that was being presented to us. So what we did is we always relied on the research and on what we could ascertain as to what his original intentions were.
2:10:01 And there were no dogfights. It wasn't Drew versus US, US versus Drew. We're going to withhold this if Drew doesn't do what we want to do. It was always about getting the clean version out. And there was a strong outpouring, especially at first, of the Holy Ghost, that we just wanted Joseph's words clearly out there in a cogent way. As far as what I bring, all I can say is it's not tenacity with me. I bring a a burning abiding hope that if we can get a set of scriptures that are trusted within our communities, especially in light of some of the civic developments that are happening in the civilized nations around the world.
2:10:42 If there's ever any crises, a hope that we can consolidate under a dispensation leader in a way that's respectful and doesn't have much acrimony where we can understand each other. I think we will all as fundamentalist or orthodox or formative Mormons, I think we will all be better off. So no, I don't. I don't have a dogfight. I'm not looking to to express or impose my my views or the force of my opinions on people. We want Joseph Smith's words in your hands. It is that pretty accurate, Drew. I mean, you know my personality.
2:11:23 Hold on, Hold on, hold on. Josh. You said something there. And I think Drew knows exactly where I'm going. I, I want to, I want, I want to explore this a little bit here, right? Just in the in, in terms of intention, you said you wanted a clean set of scriptures so that as things go bad we could all consolidate under 11 prophetic leader or something of that. Nature. No, no, you misunderstood. I, I I'm an independent. Currently I'm an independent. I don't have intention as far as under one leader. I said the dispensation leader, who is Joseph Smith, but I think we all look to. So no, I mean, I know you, David. I know people have had this conversation. I'm not steering clear of it.
2:12:12 I'm I've always told you, you know, as it's joking on the side, I'm not the one mighty and strong. I'm. Not the. Guy out there that's going to that's going to bring the folks this, that and the other. I'm saying we can consolidate. Under the Under Joe Joseph Smith as the dispensation leader. I see. I see what you meant. Under. Under Joseph Smith. No. OK, I got you. OK. Fair enough. Sorry, Drew, I didn't mean to cut you off. I just wanted to get that taken care of there a little bit. That's fine. Yeah. OK. So I would just make one clarification and then I'll kind of go back to your original question. There was at one point a strong feeling to use the original punctuation.
2:12:59 And so I did the entire, I'd already started changing the punctuation to modernize it because it just, I, I understood that's what everybody wanted. And then the, the feeling was, no, we, we use original punctuation. So I did the entire Doctrine of Covenants and Book of Mormon with original punctuation and but I showed several places where the punctuation was really, really bad, ambiguous, and clearly changed the meaning in some instances to be really egregious to to something that Joseph clearly would not support. And frankly, that doesn't mean anybody would read it that way because a lot of people just ignore punctuation in the 1st place.
2:13:44 But if you understand punctuation, it was, it was clearly contradicting itself in, in a few instances. And there were examples that I brought to the table that were egregious enough. Everybody said, you're right, let's do that. And I, I bring that correction to the table because it took me two months to go back and make those changes. When you're in the middle of the project, it's easier to change punctuation as you go because you're really looking at the meaning and, and this change that change talsize this versus number goes here. You, you have to slow down. And so when you're there, it's easy to change the punctuation going back and doing it after the fact, very tedious. So, so that's the, the, the axe forgets the tree. Remember situation there.
2:14:33 But that was never contentious at all. I was just like, OK, I, I disagree, but that's what we'll do. And I, I see some people preferring one way and some people preferring the other. I I prefer whatever offers people the original intention. And since the punctuation was not done by Joseph, we don't even understand honestly what punctuation they intended with what they used because they were not any of them a doctoral, you know, English major, which we could at least go back and say at the time they were teaching doctoral English majors these set of rules. We had a printer, we've got a committee of like 6 people in Oliver, Calgary.
2:15:16 And all of them had different ideas, changed each other's punctuations from time to time. So, so at any rate, going back on a broader base level, I think if you were going to say what was everybody's participation and what's their function, I think all of us had the same vision. We want to produce an original version of Joseph's scriptures as he would have approved them, as he did approve them. What does that look like? Is that a 1840 lithographic reprint without verses? Is that a 1830 lithograph reprint without verses? Do we OCR that and add verses?
2:16:00 Do we keep a paragraph or keep the same paragraphs? Those were the questions we all talked about and is a committee for. We discussed all of those decisions. To my knowledge, we've either and or both discussed today and previous times when I talked about the JSV, there's I don't think any decision that that we haven't covered some of the decisions. Decisions were, for instance, we're only going to use Joseph's unpublished revelations. I finished the entire project. Everybody said that's the case, that's what we're going to do. And then they said, you know what, let's put the other ones in there too. All right, give me a couple months. And then they also said, you know, it'd be nice to have some historical introductions, headings to the DNCI didn't do any of that because that was just not part of the project. But now I'm trying to do that before a deadline. That's what I'm working on on the side. So I'm, I'm, I'm not being lazy if anybody's worried about that. So, so if you want to say nuts and bolts, Kevin did did not do any revisions.
2:17:08 We consulted him on every decision in every corner as we were just discussing and he's doing making all the decisions for printing. So if, if he says 6 by 9, we're doing 6 by 9. If he says sum by 10, we're doing sum by 10, which by the way, we're doing 6 by 9. But you know, who's, who are we going to use and why That's his, that's his input, input, input. And that's what we're going with. All four of us talked about how we were going to approach it globally. As we've discussed today, Josh is Josh. Sorry, I keep saying Josh, because anyway, don't mean to be disrespectful, but Joshua sent me edits, you know, a couple of punctuation things. And do we really want to include this? This wasn't Joseph's change.
2:18:00 It's a 1828 dictionary. Should we vote on this? You know, a couple things like that, but you know, he read through it and as an attorney, I, I felt like it was really helpful to have a fellow attorney read through and because we tend to be meticulous with commas and crap or spelling or whatever. So he did that. Michael went through and did the same thing for editing. But what Michael brought to the table was about, I would say 7 to 800 suggestions to change my footnotes and, and a lot of those were really helpful. He said, this is maybe too obtuse for a teenager. You're using big word here.
2:18:42 Let's we consider something easier. I didn't understand this footnote. It was unclear to me which manuscript you were talking about. Can you clarify stuff like that? And so I went through and I spent about two weeks, I think, reading each of his footnote suggestions, thoughts, responding to them and saying here's here's why I'm not going to change that because that makes it inaccurate or clarified, which most of the time I just chose clarified. There are a few instances when he misunderstood the footnote and wanted me to change something to make it would have been inaccurate. So I just clarified it to be accurate and said I'm not going to change it like you said, and here's why. And he is happy with all of those. So as far as the text goes, that's the contribution of everybody.
2:19:33 Also Michael's in charge of marketing website that sort of stuff. And then you know, financial contributions were a big part of, of what those guys were doing as well. And I've, it's been my hands on the text almost exclusively. And in no place has there been any argument ever. I think you, you got to change this footnote. No, I don't want to change it. Let's take it to the committee. It's, it's really been, this is just a suggestion or I'm pretty sure this is a typo. Can double check and that sort of thing. I I will make one closing comment to that because as we're doing all of this together, I had a really big conflict.
2:20:23 That I had to deal with that I, I didn't really share. I might have mentioned it to Michael and that's on the web page. He, he says this is by far the best triple combination that's ever been produced. And, and then he also talks about being the most transparent work that's ever been done on the scriptures. And at any rate, I thought that was embarrassing. And I asked myself, could I possibly market this as if I wrote that personally, because I was asked to make a flyer for a, a local group. And I took his words to as as the foundation for that flyer. And I was like, oh, shoot.
2:21:09 And these people know me too. What do I, what do I put that, you know, So I had to think about that a lot. And I, I have to say that even though I found it embarrassing, I, I 100% agree with that sentiment. I don't think there's another triple combination anywhere that's near as good that provides the light and knowledge or that provides the clarity of format while also preserving the original text. It doesn't exist. I, I think we're, we're using beautiful fonts. I would have loved if we had another $10,000 to hire somebody to create a font special for this version and then format the entire thing with some beautiful, you know, illustrations on the side or sorry, that's what the early people call it, just that, that some, you know, some nice borders or some colors. So we don't have that.
2:22:08 But if you're just looking at the text, it's easy to read, it's clean, the formatting is, is easy to follow, and it's Joseph's original text with Joseph's changes annotated. And to me, nothing comes close to to even comparing. There's nothing else out there that I, I will ever use again besides the set, the set of work. So even though I originally thought it was kind of embarrassing to say it that way, I thought it, it really is true. If those are your values, if you want Joseph is the restored prophet in his words. And that's and that's not saying Orson Pratt didn't make a good change in 1879 somewhere maybe he did. But if you want Joseph's words and you want it easy to read in the format he was producing, with the language he produced, there's there's nothing better.
2:23:03 You're just not going to find it. Awesome, Josh. Yeah. I just, I, I want to, I want to kind of back up the sentiment that we're saying you are going to read a lot of commentary and a lot of annotations. I've said this at least four times. I just want to want to close my, my kind of not my argument, but my sales pitch. I was the one in the group probably next to Michael. That was, well, that was me saying we don't need this. And I changed that because you do you, you're going to read a lot of commentary and a lot of annotations and the rest of it for the, the, the dropping of the book or the opening of the book or the the giving of the restored version.
2:23:46 You're going to see that it's going to help you to have that. It's not going to get in the way. It'll buttress that if we have our way or if I have any sway at all. Some later print will have less annotations. Once it's a once the trusting once people begin to trust this restored version. But everything he said is true. I lost myself for the first time in the Book of Mormon. When I say lost myself, I could read as though not. I don't like using the word novel. I could flow the ideas so coherently as to just as to just drink in the Book of Mormon. It's, it's a, it's a, it's a, it's, it's a beautiful feeling.
2:24:30 The Doctrine and Covenants, they just open up in it and the doctrines expose them cells, especially in light of the additional revelations and the annotations that, that clarify a lot of these things. It's going to be a work that you're going to want. And if you're like me and you can wait a year or two, we can get you a, a version that won't have the annotations, but you're going to want this, you're going to want this one so that you can learn to trust it. And when you do, I think you will. And, and so I guess I, I'm saying I trust Drew, but I think Drew and I both trying to tell you that we trust Joseph Smith as our dispensation lead as the prophet of the restoration.
2:25:11 And I think you will too through this restored version. That's that's the pitch we're making got. You all right, before we move on to tell folks where to, where to pick this up, We've kind of been over the process of how it's come together and then the the, the format as far as how you got, how the, how the committee worked together on this. Is there anything else you want to mention before we go on to to to where people can find it? Yeah, I've, I've had some people ask me, you know, what's the difference between the GSV and the RV? Because I did publish the Book of Mormon GSV or the DNC last year. We as a committee talked about that a little bit and said, you know, we are creating the scripture bound version of this.
2:26:01 If people want a paperback version because it's cheap and that's what they're going to buy for their 8 year old kid who hasn't proven themselves to be good steward yet, they'll they can buy Drew's version. And I had a bunch of people request at least on a temporary basis, hardback version, which I may or may not just pull once this is available. But the, the, the main question people said, is there a difference between that that's been published as a paperback already versus what's going to be published is the RV. And the answer is almost nothing changes to footnotes to make them clarified. As I mentioned earlier, those will be there and the introductory material in those books is going to be appendicized in the very back.
2:26:49 And I I honestly for for triple, I think that's a great change. Makes a lot of sense for the individual books that didn't make as much sense. So that those are the the main differences. Text formatting, pretty much everything's identical. If you want to see like what are the guts look like, you can look on Amazon and see that we also have some of that stuff on restored scriptures from each one at any rate. So that's an addition. And there's also a request to do an appendix that I'm or an index that I'm hoping to have done as well. So those are the differences and and most people I think don't care aren't really looking at that frankly.
2:27:30 The virtually no volumes of have flown off the shelves. I haven't advertised it at all just so there's just a few of those here and there. But for those who have been asking, those are the differences. Yeah, I think that's it. And one more very small item I mentioned I'm doing an index for the triple. I don't have the manpower to have cross references for C first Nephi 32, that's what's you know, that's that's the cross reference. The index is going to be on page 47. Right.
2:28:12 It's not going to give a first number because that that takes a committee and a lot of manpower. Also, just one clarification. This is a minor small thing, but Josh said Joshua said two things that are important to keep in context. 1, he lost track of time when he was reading and 2, immediately when you start reading, you'll see the annotations In the Book of Mormon. There are two footnotes until chapter 8. So it shows what he's reading. He got he got sucked into it really fast. And then there's quite a few for a while and they back off after a while. But you know, the, the division of the tree of life, there's a number of changes in there that are substantive too, like Fred Collier originally noted back in the 80s and that I mentioned earlier today too.
2:28:58 So if, if you're expecting a lot of annotations immediately there, there's, there's not really very many until about chapter 8. And also, I think there are less than I think I want to say there's 67 or 81. So whatever it is, somewhere around 80 in the entire Book of Mormon as opposed to something like 900 in the DNC. Yeah, that's, that's a that that is a lot different. Yeah. Holy cow. Well, awesome. All right, so I guess we're on to the big question. Where do people go to find this? You want to take that, Joshua? Sure. restoredscriptures.com, Open that up. You're going to see a website where you can order. It's going to have down at the bottom. It'll have a Oh, where is it at?
2:29:53 PDF Preview. PDF previews down there, Sample context contents Third knee by 12 lectures on faith DNC one. We have an uncanonized revelation. We have Abraham one in there. Just that it'll flip through. You make little noises like it's switching the page, but that's what you're going to get. This is going to be done in, well, they've got a 360 RV design down there done, I believe in taupe or Gray. I'm colorblind, but it has the gold embossing in the gilded edges. So you can press play on that in the screen and it'll do a 360 for you. So that's pretty much what you're going to get. And that's the RV version.
2:30:36 That's our triple. That's the triple that we're offering to you and love to get these into everybody's hands, get a good idea of what they think and feel about this. But I, I mean it, just reading the Book of Mormon alone has been a joy and the understanding and the expansion of what you called exalted doctrine in the DNC has I mean it, it I, I read through, I did the last fifty, I edited the last fifty of the regular canonized and I did the entire uncanonized. And there's been some, some deep, profound changes in my, in my faith because of it. So it's helped.
2:31:18 Yeah. Are they going to be available for in print or is this just electronic? So yes, right now you can pre sale order scripture version, meaning faux leather bound. And we decided faux leather over leather because it doesn't rot, it doesn't age and doesn't it last longer and you can get some really nice versions. So you can order right now for for it's 60 bucks, which I don't even know how we got such an amazing deal to do a triple for 60 bucks. But I mean, I could, I could barely get a hardbound from Amazon at that price. So I was really happy about that because I've got at least nine kids who are going to want to copy.
2:32:01 So at any rate, that's what you can order right now. There will be multiple color options later. We will e-mail you later and give you the chance to choose what colors end up being available. We've got to do some final minute negotiations there. So you will just be ordering a faux leather bound gilded edges, beautiful nice, like the 360 thing you showed you or I was mentioning. That's what it's going to look like. So that said, if you order pre-order right now, meaning till it's over, which is probably at least a month or so, you we will give you a discount code. You can get an epub version for free of each of the books. So it you go to my site and you have a discount code that gives you 100% off so you can get a Book of Mormon doctorate covenant's program price and all the appendices, separate epubs, you can just read them like that. So you get a free digital version. If, and I don't know if Michael's got this live on site or not, but if you either one, purchase enough copies or two, refer enough people and they buy, then we're also giving out free Doctrine Covenant 76 annotated epub forgotten teachings of Joseph Smith at the 1000 pages of, of teachings that aren't in the TPGSI referred to you earlier. We're going to offer that in epub for various gradations of, of, of pre-orders.
2:33:29 This pre-order time right now is super, super helpful for us. It's, it's very expensive to, to pre-order. You're, you're talking like 20 grand to, to get a printer to do it at a bulk price so that we can offer it at these prices. So the pre-order allows us to, to not have to put all that money up front. So it's a super big help to do pre-orders. Now the quality, you can look again on the website, see exactly what you're going to be getting on the in the guts for part of it. And also if you look on Amazon, somebody's like, I want to read, you know, and see what Messiah 2 says. I want to see if Drew got this particular change in there or not. In fact, I got interviewed by a guy who does different versions of the Book of Mormon.
2:34:13 That's all he does is podcast that. And so he was looking at specific things like that. If you want that, it's on Amazon, you could probably check and it's got a larger preview. And if you're super curious, just ask me. I'll look at it for you and tell you. But but that's where you can see exactly what you're getting, what it looks like. Sorry. And one more thing that we did not mention that's important for some people is the Lectures on Faith is part of the Doctrine Covenants. It was a. Rich. Way there we did not admit it. That didn't happen till 1921 and Hebrew J Grant took it out because arguments about that was teaching false doctrine about the nature of the Holy Ghost.
2:34:53 I do annotate those passages or footnote those and say this is a passage you got taken out of the original Doctrine Covenants because the controversy at any rate. But also show contextually why that may be misinterpreted and shouldn't have been taken out in the first place because it may not be teaching what they thought it was. Again, Holy Ghost versus Holy Spirit misunderstandings. So interesting stuff there in those footnotes as well. And if anybody's questioning about the colors, we're looking at hoping for black, grey, brown. It's been talking about a cream, but burgundy, green and blue are the top color options. We're hearing.
2:35:37 If anybody says everybody in my group wants a pink one, we'll probably add a pre-order of pink. If you could, you know if you want to give us 100 copies or 100 orders that will definitely do pink. No, I like it. So if someone was to order pre-order today, how long before they have a hot copy in their hand? Shoot, Michael knows that. Do you know that, Josh Joshua, I think it's a number of months. We're, we're currently there, there's, there's an, we're in negotiations with two and I think the outset was four months. And I believe the other one, which is a very viable option is a is a little bit shorter than that. I don't want to give, I'm giving you out the the lengthy 1. I don't know how quickly the other one can get it to us, but both of them are of similar high quality. That's what's what's most important to us is that these last a long time and that they're valued in your home. So we, we we'd insisted on all the quotes using the same types of products, Winters and company faux leather that they're the nice stuff.
2:36:41 So. Yeah. And which is also that delay is part of the reason why we decided to do the epub. So you get that, have it in your hands, you can look at it, read it. And we also know it's not everybody's favorite, but it's, it's a, it's a, you know, I can at least have it now. Yep, absolutely. All right, Well, guys, good stuff. I, I'm excited to, to see this. I think, I think this, this could be an answer to, to a lot of questions that I think people have had for a while concerning the, the state of our scriptures, right where, where the can, where the Canon sets now that that sort of thing. So I'm, I'm super excited for this. Drew man, your workhorse, bro. I, I can't even imagine trying to tackle that, that project. So good on you.
2:37:30 Glad you're here. Anything else you guys want to add before we wrap it up? Just appreciate you, David, appreciate your podcast and what you stand for and thankful to be on here be able to talk to you with Drew. So thank you. Awesome. Yeah, likewise, I'm super excited. You got that website up and running and and happening too. I'm excited to see that expand and include whatever products. I, I, I know there have been times we've been independent. We're like, who do we talk to that would know where to get this stuff? Right, right. No, we're. I'm trying to have that available. Yeah, I know. I'm trying to, to get, get it so people can just find it in one spot instead of having to scour the Internet.
2:38:12 So and and likewise, you know, when that time comes, when you guys are ready, let me know. I'd love to throw a link up on that side as well so folks can find that. But guys, I appreciate you. I appreciate the work you put in. Hang out for 5 minutes, all right. Yeah, we'll do. Thanks. All right. Bye everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox