Aug. 9, 2025

Episode #196: A Conversation W/Steve Pynakker Host of Mormon Book Reviews

Episode #196: A Conversation W/Steve Pynakker Host of Mormon Book Reviews
Episode #196: A Conversation W/Steve Pynakker Host of Mormon Book Reviews
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #196: A Conversation W/Steve Pynakker Host of Mormon Book Reviews

On this episode I sit down and have a conversation with Steve Pynakker. Steve is the host of a podcast on youtube titled Mormon Book Reviews. Now Steve while is not a member of any Restoration group he is fascinated with the Restoration as revealed by Joseph Smith. Because he is able to maintain an observes view of Mormonism his insights into the various groups and churches makes for fascinating conversation. As we have our conversation we cover everything from the state of various Joseph Smith Restoration groups and churches to how he became fascinated with Joseph Smith & Mormonism.

0:09 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast, Steve, how's it going? I'm well, my friend and yourself. Just busy, but that's good because they say that it's supposed to keep you out of trouble. Although it's not what I find right. Usually the the busier I get, just the more hornet's nests I seem to kick up. Right. Yeah, there's, yeah, especially in this world. It's a minefield in the podcast world and, you know, just trying to be somebody who's trying to be fair to everybody and unbiased.

0:51 Still, sometimes things blow up and you can't, you don't have any control over it. And you just got to learn to put things in God's hands because you can't do everything. So yeah, just this can be a difficult space to be in. But it's a fun space to be in though, right? Especially today, right? Like I was, I was thinking about that like just a few days ago is that I'm not sure we've seen this much movement out of Mormonism in general, right across the board from, from kind of the, the, the Brighamite branches on down to, to, you know, the reorganized groups. I think there's just a lot popping off and it always seems like it's something. Yeah, that's, that's, that's true. And I think that it seems like all the different restoration groups that I'm encountering are doing things that are they are anticipating things and they're doing things differently than they had done in the past.

1:49 For instance, you got the bigger tonight's who up until 4-5 years ago, we're not engaging any of the groups in the restoration. But then they received a word from the Lord, a revelation saying they need to start engaging other registration groups as well as other Christian group, you know, outside of the restoration. And then that kind of stem, you know, I come into their their space, the very first restoration group that I ever attend their service is there. And essentially that's kind of happened with that group. And then you see the Snuffer right movement who are in the stages of coming closer and closer to building a temple. And I just remember asking Denver, I said, Denver. I said, you know, if you guys build your temple, should we start anticipating the return of Christ?

2:32 And he says, yeah. And then you have your group in Missouri or Missouri, depending on where you're at, which has done an unprecedented, unprecedented thing in the fundamentalist world in which you guys have built a temple and dedicated it for the service of all those who believe in, in the principal or who believe in Mormonism in general. And, and it's open to everyone. And, and your group is unique that you don't have a one man leader. It's, it's done by committee, it's done by, it's a cooperative. And you guys built a temple that looks like something that was built by the Utah branch, by the Brighamite Church, but it actually is built by your group and it's an impressive structure that you have built.

3:17 And it was all done by volunteers and donations, much like the Kirtland Temple. So it seems reflective of that. Then you have all this interesting stuff going on in Independence, MO, where you have a lot of people moving there from all different branches. You have, you have a lot of cross pollination between my world, the Pentecostal world and the charismatic world and the restoration groups there in independence. Because I always tell people, so what's so fascinating about independence is that it's, it's the restoration right in the middle of the in, in the right in the buckle, the belt buckle of the Bible Belt, right?

3:58 It's right there. So you have this interesting convergence of people who are not necessarily believers in the Restoration, but might be believers in the Book of Mormon or, or, or, or accepting of people who are believers in the Book of Mormon. And so you have that kind of stuff happening. So yes, I see. And being of somebody who's kind of an outsider observing, I'm able to see all these different moves happening. And I thought there's something going on and I'm sure I could. Well look, the community of Christ, they sold their all. They sold their birthright, everything that made them unique in the sense that they were part of the restoration. They have essentially, in my mind, in some ways, have made a clean break with the restoration and seem to be heading direction of just becoming a mainline Protestant denomination.

4:43 And who knows if 10 years from now there will even be a church called the Community of Christ. Perhaps they'll just merge with the United Methodist Church or something like that. That's speculation on my part, but it just seems to be like that, that they're just unprecedented changes and moves have been happening. We also know that a lot of things, interesting things have happening with the main church, you know, the, the largest church, the Church of Jesus Christ, Latter Day Saints. It looks to me like that church is going through a transition. Of course, they've made temple changes. They have, they've been braced almost in one sense, Holy Week for Easter in a way that wasn't before. They've they've switched off the Moroni tag for their locations, for their, for their, for their wards and chapels and to replace it with a cross.

5:31 So many things are happening just in the last few years that are unprecedented, I think, for most of these groups and very interesting. You know, it, it's fascinating too, because as I watch this and I watch all this play out, it, it, it seems to me like, like the restoration as a whole is going through some things and there's a reordering almost that's happening, right? And everybody now is kind of, I don't want to say picking a side, but maybe finding their niche, right? And, and whatever it's going to look like. And I can't help but wonder what it was that that really prompted all of this, because it all comes about at roughly the same time, right?

6:17 And that's the other thing is that it all comes about at the same time, which which is very curious to look at. So, and, and let's not also, you know, I'll be remiss to, to ignore this growing movement of people who say that Joseph Smith did not practice polygamy, monogamy, right? And that's become a thing. I mean, just look at the, the, the, the Gospel typics essay. It was just released this week. It was a direct response to that movement. And you know what's so fascinating, Dave, I think that a lot of this I, I, I, when I talk to so many people just just entering into this space after COVID, But I think everything seemed to really change for a lot of people in 2020.

7:03 And, and, and it was the IT was the vaccine thing in which the church basically was saying you need to get vaccinated and a lot of people pushed back. And for the first time, you've had schism in the past, but typically was from more progressive, you know, more people would question the brethren, right? It was more of a progressive left wing thing. For the first time, you had people on the right, the more orthodox TBM community starting to question the brethren. And that's never happened before. And that really opened up a can of worms. And I'm telling you right now, there are a lot of people in the ex Mormon community that will tell you and they won't tell you publicly, but they'll tell me privately that what did it for them was the vaccine thing.

7:47 And that's what led them out of the church. But they don't want to be accused of being an anti vaxxer or something like that in that in that community. So they don't bring that up. But some of the biggest high profile people that have left the church over the last few years, it was also the vaccine thing that made them question things as well. It caused them to say, I need to start looking into things like, why? Why do I believe what I believe? Why did? Why do I have all this faith in the brethren? If they're telling me something that I disagree with, how do I handle that? And so people just had different conversations that they never had before. So I think I think really that was the impetus for a lot of people to kind of reassess what they believe and what their relationship was with the church.

8:28 You know it, it's fascinating in that in that regard too. And I agree with you as I think this has been a slow build up, right? I think I think this has been something that has been taken a while to build up. And I think now we're at a tipping point. And I think that it really started about the time the Internet becomes ubiquitous, right? Because I think for whether you want to look at it as lies or whether you want to look at it more as trying to condense the narrative. The church for a while, the the the big Brighamite church was able to shouldn't say Brighamite the the church, Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.

9:10 They were able to to pretty much craft a narrative and because people didn't have access to the vaults or, or, you know, they just didn't have time because they were raising six kids and, you know, got their church callings and jobs and all this, that history was largely unavailable, right. You did have Gerald and Sandra Tanner Tanner out there who were, were publishing some of these older things, but they were instructed to stay away from, from those folks because, you know, they they were anti Mormon. Well, when the Internet comes along, doesn't take long and it, we're, we're starting to get to a point where there's no more secrets, right? And so all these things that I think the, the LDS church took for granted that they could just own the narrative on, well, that's not the case anymore.

10:02 And now, and, and so people started to see that inconsistency and it just kept building and building and building. And you're right, in 2020, I think that was that was the thing that set most of this in motion. Because I think a couple things happened, right? All the sudden, I think during the lockdown, I think there were a lot of people that went, wait a second, maybe the LDS Church does not have the monopoly on Mormonism. Perhaps, perhaps this can be done in more than one way. And I think that really was was kind of the undoing and all the sudden the questions that nobody wanted to ask are is now public, right?

10:46 And, and I certainly saw that when I first started the podcast. Like I honestly thought that the podcast was predominantly for fundamentalists. Well, that's not the case anymore. Mine seems to be, you know, I got a big healthy percentage that's that's active members of the church and they're asking questions and they're unsettled. And I don't think that's going away anytime soon. I think the genie's out of the bottle on that. You know, I, and to, to piggyback on what you're saying is that I think that the rise of the, you know, the ubiquitous information that's out there on the Internet would, has been there for a while, But I'll, I'll relay a story to you. I think what happened was during COVID, people had time to start researching and looking at these things. And a perfect example is actually right here is I was on one of my trips to Utah on my way back. I was sitting in the back row next to a Southwest Airlines pilot.

11:43 And and I probably told you the story off camera, but until it on camera is this, this pilot was sitting next to me. And I told him what I was I do. And he said, yeah, I used to be a latter day St. I'm like, OK. And he said, yeah. Then COVID happened and I had a lot of time on my hands. So I picked up the first volume of Saints and I read through it and I I was out. He had been so exposed to such a whitewashed history, very correlated history, that he probably only knew about Mormon history based on what he was hearing in his ward, that when he was exposed to some church approved historical materials, it was enough to cause him to question everything, have his shelf break and leave the church. And I think the church definitely recognizes this and realizes that we need to inoculate people, especially the youth. And and that's why I think that's part of the reason I was invited to go on Saints unscripted LDS youth channel. It was kind of the church saying you can learn about the history of your church from Steve's channel to the LDS youth. And so I think that they want people to be exposed to everything that's being talked about in Mormon stories. I have many of the same guests on Mormon stories that that you know, that that a typical latter day St. wouldn't watch, but they'll watch it on my on my program. And again, I'm not here to weaponize Mormon history against any church, any movement.

13:01 I just tell people as a ladder saying it's your birthright to know the to know the history of your church. And I think that there's so many great sources out there and to not know anything about all the other branches of the restoration that are really, I think, important in many ways and have made contributions. I'm trying to open up the dialogue so we can get all these different branches and get together. And I will tell you that there are many people who have gotten involved in other branches of the restoration as a result of being exposed to these ideas on my program. And so that's, you know, what we try to do is just be, be a, a safe space for everybody. I'm respectful for where people are at. I don't try to proselytize. I don't try to get people to go into a church or leave a church. I just want to be somebody that they can listen, that I will listen to and, and hear their stories. Sometimes they'll the story will be told on my channel. Often it will just be behind the scenes. And that's kind of the ministry aspect of this too, because there's a lot of people who, when they're exposed to a lot of things they hadn't heard before, sometimes feel betrayed and they're very hurt and they, they, they need a place to go. Like, you know, my shelf is really heavy or my shelf is broke or I don't even know if I believe in God anymore. And it's like, there's so much of that stuff going on that I feel like that's part of the ministry here is to let people say you don't have to throw the baby out with the bathwater. There's no institution really that can get in between you and your relationship with the Savior And that and that that's really what's the most important thing and how you choose to worship God and what building

14:33 you go to on Sunday or Saturday or whatever that's that's between you and God. And don't let anybody else get in the way of that. And so that's kind of the approach that I take. So I'm just judgement free on people. However somebody chooses to encounter the divine is that's their prerogative. So like I'm friends with with people like you who are polygamous. And then I'm, but I'm but an hour from now maybe or a couple hours from now, maybe I'm on the phone with somebody who's part of the polygamy, A firmer group, right? And, and, and, and both would feel that they're being treated fairly in, in this space. And that's what I strive for because I just want to listen and I want to learn. Oh, you're right.

15:14 And and. You know that's. That's the thing that got me too, especially when I was about, when I was about two years into this thing, I really noticed that the tones of the emails changed from the LDS side of things. Right when, when I first started, it was more I, I think for whatever reason, people felt like, OK, I can probably talk to this guy, right? I, I need some answers on things. Well, I'll give you an example. When I first started the podcast, it was like weeks before the series Under the Banner of Heaven came out. OK. Right. And then all of a sudden it pops up on the scene and I'm, you know, literally six weeks into it and I'm like, uh, oh, I got to, I got to contend with this.

16:00 And so I actually do an episode on it. It was a good episode. I felt like. And I had a young couple reach out to me from the LDS church. The, the, the husband had served a mission, went to BYU, found his wife. They got married. They had two little kids. And I had just gotten home from a trip and I checked my e-mail and he, this young father basically just spills, you know, says I don't know if I can be a Mormon anymore, right? And I was like, well, that let's see what's going on. And so I message him back and then we have a phone call and he basically says, I watched it under the banner of heaven. And I don't recognize that gospel, right? I don't recognize that Mormonism. And I said, OK, what's your, what's your big, what's the one that's hurting you the most here? And he said, well, it's blood atonement. I said, OK, let me go, let me go dig up some records here, let me look at some stuff and let me get back with you. So we, we got back, I got back to him and I basically, you know, found all the documents, found all the instances I, I could find where it was both done kind of, Aspergam had said. And then those who who took it and ran with it without really knowing what it was about, when you break it all down, it's essentially capital punishment inside of a theocracy, right? And so as as we show this, he's

17:33 like, OK, OK, I think I think I'm OK. And he goes back to church and I get an e-mail a few weeks later, he says, hey, everything is going great. I appreciate your help. And PS, my Bishop says thank you too. And that was that was kind of it, right? And so at the beginning it was a lot of that like, I don't understand this, I don't recognize this. Can you give me some documents that can help me put this in the framework of the restoration? Then it went to like, what are the brethren doing at the top right? Questioning anxiety. And this last go round with the 1886 revelation. People are pissed now because you got the receipts right.

18:15 There's no doubt what happened. You absolutely had the receipts and that has caused people's, the tones of the emails have changed at this point. And I'm I'm, I'm both nervous and, and excited. There's I, I think, I think the ramifications of this are just now beginning to to come out. And I think the Oslo, of course, you came on panel discussion recently in which we talked about the Heavenly Mother's comment and you have the 1886 revelation being by the church, which in the 1930s they were saying it was a pretended revelation. Now in in the catalog, it says 1886 revelation of John Jeep or John Taylor, right?

19:08 So now it's an acknowledgement that, yes, he did have a revelation about this being an eternal principle. And to me, it's almost like, you know, if this is something, and let's not beat around the Bush, this was about polygamy, OK. And then to be very explicit about this, people understood what this revelation at the time was. And so for people to be exposed to these ideas, they would be, some of them felt a conviction, convicted to continue the principle no matter what. And then Anthony Ivins was in the Mexican temple telling them then no matter what happens stateside, you know, you continue this, you keep it going. OK.

19:48 So they had, you know, Apostolic permission, if you will, or commands to condemn. Yeah. And and to do this and. And so to push the polygamist and fundamentalist to the side and make them out to be these freaks. When in many ways they were just following the prophet and and and and, and they were, they're continuing with, with an eternal principle and so. Yeah, I, I think you're 100% right. And I think to go along with that, it's not, I mean, the revelation itself is about plural marriage. There's no doubt, right, like you were saying.

20:30 But what are really the implications for today? Why does it matter today? Well, I think it has to do with power, to be honest with you. Because all of the sudden from outside of the structure, well, from inside the structure, you now have the man at the top essentially authorize and Commission a group to operate outside the church. And when you do that, you have now removed a portion of the power that was centered in that office, and it now is free on the outside to do what it needs to do.

21:12 And I think that's where I think a lot of the rub comes in. It's not necessarily about plural marriage, right? The validity of the doctrine itself. It's more about the power structure and what this revelation says about that power. Yeah, that's that's that's an interesting way to look at it. And of course, we do see the church evolve during this period of time. They become a corporation in the 1920s. They, they enforced the Word of Wisdom in the way that they never had before. You have, well, then around this time, they then they removed the lectures on faith from the Canon.

21:53 So, so in many ways, you see this church transitioning, going in a different direction. And then it really the becomes formalized in many ways with David O McKay, where he says, OK, we're we're going to, we are going to mainstream ourselves. We're going to become Protestant middle class church. So guys, shave off your beards. We're going to be presentable to polite society and we're going to take a lot of these kooky doctrines, if you will, that are being taught in, in, in various words. And we're going to basically correlate everything and just kind of whitewash our history so that it becomes more palatable and acceptable to mainstream Protestant America. And so that's what happens.

22:44 And and so you have like a further break from 19th century Mormonism in the attempts to become a 20th century church. And it seems to be now even more so in the 21st century. You've seen this transition where they want to become more and more mainstream and shed a lot of the baggage, if you will, that how they would look at it. That's keeping them from being accepted by other Christian groups. And they'll say, hi, we're being discriminated against because we're Mormon and we're Christian and we're this and that. But then at the same time, they're doing to you in many ways much worse than anything the evangelicals had done to the Mormon church in the 21st century, in the 20th and 21st century. And they, they treat you guys.

23:29 I mean, they were cracking down on you guys in the 1950s, dividing families. You guys were the, the main church was the most anti polygamist group in the country. And so they persecuted you guys in a way that evangelicals never did and saw on some level. So it's so funny how on one hand they want to be accepted by we were over Christians just like you. And then they treat you guys so horribly in my mind and like they're just embarrassed by the, the mere fact that you guys exist. And, and I will tell you, you know, I, I had AI had a conversation. We've talked about this on the phone where I was, I was talking to an individual and I'm not going to give too much information here. But recently I had a conversation with an individual who we were just talking and she was asking me questions about my podcast. And she's just regular LDS, you know, And we were talking and I was and, and she said, yeah, I I had a grandfather who's practiced polygamy.

24:25 I'm like, oh, really? And she said, yeah, an Angel appeared to him, told him to practice polygamy. I'm like, huh. I said that he's like, start a group that he, you know, is he is he known? And she said, oh, yeah, he's his. Yeah. She. She says his name's Rulon Allred. I'm like, oh, wow. And then she's like, but our side of the family has nothing to do with him. And I was like, oh, that's really interesting. And then I told her, I said, you know, I've had one of Rulon Allard's granddaughters come on my program and give a presentation about Rulon Allard. And I'll tell you, let me tell you, Rulon Allard was probably one of the most ethical, decent, moral men that I've ever encountered within the Restoration. There was, nobody said one bad, harsh word against him. He was well regarded in the community and every and he there was no abuse going on in that church when he was the prophets. And I said, he's just like Ogden Kraut. I said, a real man of integrity who I've really learned to respect as a result.

25:28 And she looks at me and she says, that's the first time I've ever heard somebody say a nice thing about my grandfather isn't. I'm so glad to hear this story. And I thought to myself, how sad that their family was torn apart and they and, and and she never got to know her grandfather and, and find out that, yeah, he actually was a pretty good guy. And the demonization that was going on about him was was not true. And she would, you could tell she it touched her that she realized that, Oh, my grandfather wasn't the monster that it was portrayed to me to be. Yeah, no, I, it's, it's interesting. And, and I've rehearsed a similar story on, on my podcast with an e-mail that I got very, very similar name wasn't as recognizable, but still pretty much the same thing. And that's, that's the sad part, right? Because there's sometimes where, where I kind of have a holy envy of Catholicism, right?

26:24 Because at least in Catholicism, even though there's massive disagreement, there's a whole bunch of different orders, there's a whole bunch of different angles and that sort of thing. And they figured it out and they made it work, right? Sometimes I wonder if if we couldn't have done that as a people, right? Just been like, OK, every Friday, it's fun day Friday at the temple, right? And they're going to use this liturgy. And so if this offends you, don't go there. But it just didn't didn't break that way. But. No, it is. Oh, go ahead. I sometimes I even told people, I said, you know, you really need to realize the, how important it is to not try to go so far in One Direction or the other.

27:10 And I said, if you, if you strictly just want to be conservative and orthodox and, and, and, and push out the progressives or vice versa, you're actually doing damage to the church. It, I like the idea of, of a Catholic Church in which you can be Gary Wills, who very is a member of the Catholic Church, but very, very critical. And he wrote a book called Papal Sin like 20 years ago. He was never excommunicated from the church and and he was coming from a progressive Catholic view. And I thought that's what we need more of that. I think, I think this this need to try to excommunicate and push out people with different views. Is this actually a sign of immaturity? This used to be very prevalent in Protestant churches too. Even my mom growing up with the Christian Reformed Church, it wasn't uncommon for them to announce who's been excommunicated this week, right?

27:58 Kind of a similarly to what the church was, has done, a lot of churches have moved away from that because they have recognized that the process of excommunication should be extremely rare and in in just very unique circumstances and should not be applied a lot. And it should be a very like something of a last resort. And so the Catholic Church still does excommunicate people, but you have to do something so bad that that it just requires it. And I would rather that be the position because I think if people are professors are afraid of what they're going to say in their classrooms at BYU, because they could have a meeting with their Bishop and they could lose their temple Larka men and they could therefore lose your their job. I think that's that's a little too oppressive. And I think and and and I think ideas, especially on campuses, ideas need to be put out there.

28:46 And even if the professor says something that you might disagree with, to rather have that space where they can say things like that rather than look, I've had professors off the record tell me I've had the self censor what I say in my classroom because I'm afraid I'll get reported and that I just don't like that. I've I like pre exchange of ideas. I like the idea of having challenge students and, and, and if they can't do that anymore, then I feel, I feel that the institution is, is just going to become another kind of like a Liberty University or a Bob Jones University where orthodoxy is more important than anything. I think orthodoxy is important, but I also think having ideas to kind of push back and challenge students is also a necessary place in a institution of higher learning.

29:35 You know I I don't have a problem with a private university toeing a line, right? That's their right. That's their right to. Yep, Yep, Yep. And and so I don't necessarily have a problem with that, but I will say this, right, I do think that it, it's somewhat defeats the purpose of, of a university experience, right? I know I had AI, had a son and this was when I was still in the LDS church who wanted to go to BYU. And we talked about it and I said, look, if you're going to, if you're going to go, go to go to college, right, You're going to go to a major university, go to go to the University of Utah, go to go to, to, to, to Utah State, go to a different college. And, and when we have the discussion and he asked me why I said this should be a time where you're challenged on what you believe, right?

30:31 And this, this is AI think it's healthy from time to time to have your back against the wall. Not, not physically, of course, not physical violence, but but theologically speaking, have your, have your back against the law and, and be forced to defend what it is you believe. I don't think that there's any damage in that. And so I feel like the, that, that BYU has every right to do what they're doing, but I think it, it's, it's not really doing what we'd hoped. So I, I, I think you can skirt that line. It's just a matter of finding the balance. I do think, I do think having your beliefs challenged is, is in general a good thing. It forces you to re evaluate.

31:14 But so dude, you've, you've, you've done quite a few podcasts now, you've talked to a lot of different people, but how'd you find yourself in the space? You're an evangelical, right? Yeah, well, and I would say, you know, a deconstructed 1. You know why? I went through a deconstruction process myself. I was an atheist for about 13 years. And I've had a interesting journey. But one thing is I've just always had a, a, a real interest in, in, in general. I've just always been like a history buff. I've also just really been fascinated by religion in general. And so like for years you had it every every few years there would be this edition called The Hand book of US denominations. And it would be a, a book detailing every single denomination in the United States. And it would include a latter day St. church and probably the community of Christ.

32:07 I don't think much more than those two. And, and so I was able, I was just, that would be my reading. Would I just read about all these different churches and I and and and and, and I'd go through and read and I could never find a single church that I could have like, OK, this is a church that believes just what I believe. Like I was always looking for that church, you know, So actually as a result, even I don't personally believe in church membership. So I've never been a member of a church. I've attended churches in church services and I attended church here in Sarasota. But and actually my even to ask my pastor, do you what what about church members? He's he's like, oh, we don't believe in church membership. I said, OK, good. I think I found a home here, but I've always been interested in all these different religions. And I for a while I, I, I kind of studied a lot about the Jehovah's Witnesses because I had some ex Jehovah's Witness friends that I used to hang out with and studied that pretty thoroughly.

33:00 And he even told me this is the only way you could know more about Jehovah's Witnesses is if you were a member of yourself. And in many ways probably knew more than most Jehovah's Witnesses because they were only exposed to a slice of their history as well. And so I've, I've studied all these different religions, but it was in particular the Church of Jesus Christ, Latter Day Saints and the restoration in general that kept pulling me back in. It was such a fascinating thing. It's like this rabbit hole can't look, I give me 15 minutes on Scientology. I can tell you right? That's all I need. But to know what Scientology is really all about Mormonism, you'll never ever have it figured out. You'll, once you think you've got it figured out, some new bit of information will come out that is a paradigm shifter.

33:47 You know, I tell people, I said there are addicts in Independence, MO where there's items in those attics that could change the course of Mormon history. And I mean, I even had a Bishop going to be said. Why do you spend so much time talking to these other groups? Wake up, wake up 99%. Why do you spend so much time with these groups? For that reason. There's a for that reason, there is that last year John Highchuck came on my program. He's a stray guy, one of those small groups that I shouldn't be paying attention to. And I break the story through with John Highcheck coming on my platform, breaking one of the biggest stories in history of the restoration, the sail of the Kirtland Temple. I had to I I, I was the first person to come out released before anybody else had it out there.

34:33 So that's why because I want it I, I want the next thing big story to come through MBR as well. Because of the relationships and trust that I'm cultivating with these other groups. I treat them with equal respect. So like prophet Shiloh, I'm going to treat him the same way as I would a general authority or I would with Matthew Gill or with Denver Snuffer. I, I don't, I'm, I feel like everybody's making similar claims to Joseph Smith and I can't just go and say, well, I accept this claim that Joseph's made, but I'm not going to those claims like, well, I'm going to treat them the same. And I'm going to treat like, I can't interview, I can't interview Joseph Smith, but I can interview Matthew Gill, who claims to have had plates and the Urim and Thummim that he translated with.

35:16 OK, well, let's talk about that. You know, what was the translation process like all these kind of things. That's, that's what interests me is that there's so many different voices and different perspectives that we can, we can get in here. And all of them claim that their church was founded on April 6th, 1830 and they are the true successor of that church on some level. So Joseph. So they all have that commonality as well. And I also think that the beautiful thing about Mormon history and I, I, I kind of like to divvy it up. The couple things, as I tell people have said, you can kind of see the what ifs of what would have happened if our church had this direction by these different groups. So the April I call the the Church of Jesus Christ the bicker tonight's are the April 6th 1830 church. So I tell if you want to go to an April 6th, 1830 service, visit the bicker tonight's I say the temple lot, Church of Christ temple lot are the 1833 church.

36:13 Why? Because they have the book of commandments in the Book of Mormon. And of course the bigger tonight they just have the Bible in the Book of Mormon. OK. And then if you want to see an 1836 church, you could look at the RLDS Trinity. Basically Joseph Smith the third said when he was reorganizing the church said, OK, we have disagreements here. We have Strangites, We have all these other people who let's all agree that on April 6, I mean, the 1836 temple dedication in Kirtland, let's go back to the beliefs of that church because we can all agree with that on that. And so that was kind of the organizing principle of the reorganization. Then if you want to see what the 1844 church looks like, you could look at the Brighamite tradition, right?

36:55 So, and that would include the fundamentalists as well, right? It wouldn't just be the Church of Jesus Christ Latter Day Saints and you can then go see, OK, what would have been if it was just a Bible Book of Mormon church. That's the bigger of tonight's. What if it was just early days of this church? What if it was the Kirtland Temple as opposed to Nabu Temple writes? What would it look like RLDS and you can just see the different paths where they went and and how they evolved. And it's just, it's still fascinating to be able to see this mapped out in, in actual churches that you can visit this Sunday and, and had those experiences and see the different compare and contrast to different theology, these, the different beliefs, the, the different canons that they have and just be able to say, wow, like, wow, you know, like the bicker tonight's are so close to being an evangelical Protestant church. It's hardly I, I have to remind myself, I'm in, I'm in a restoration church or I don't have to remind myself, I'll be like, wow, this is like the church I grew up in. This is great.

37:49 And then I hear the preacher say, and we expect the sealed portion to be revealed soon. I'm like, Oh, that's right. I'm in a restoration. I forgot for a second there. And so that, that to me is fascinating. And, and I, and I, I kind of break it down that way and I, and I kind of how I analyze the church history and, and, and I think it's, it's a good way to go about it, you know, kind of helps add clarification. Then of course, we have other break offs in other groups and they're doing their own thing. And it's the restoration could be just as messy as Protestantism in so many ways. Absolutely. Absolutely. What was it about his doctrine that that drew you to it? You know, I think, I think the original drawing in was the Book of Mormon itself.

38:41 And I just remember as a little kid, and this would have been like maybe 9-10 years old, I don't know. I just remember thinking we need another Bible because the Bible we have doesn't seem to be working anymore because people aren't following the Bible. It seems like it's out of date and we almost need another Bible. And then I hear about this other young man who also had this encounter with these other scriptures, another Bible, if you will. And that was an intriguing thing to me. That's what makes Mormonism so unique is that, you know, you have a lot of different groups come and go, but this guy had the audacity to produce new scripture in a world in which you didn't do that.

39:29 That was verboten. And and that was an audacious thing for him to do. And so I also think, you know, so that that's an interesting thing. And what was so interesting was that the Book of Mormon was, especially to a 19th century audience, was very relevant for the time because it seemed to address all of the modern day things that were happening. The doctrinal disputes, proper modes of baptism, all these different types of doctrines that they were talking about that were even Alexander Campbell said. It seemed like the Book of Mormon addresses all of the current disputations of our day. Well, that was kind of the same mindset I had, like maybe we need another Bible to kind of clarify things and be relevant to a 20th century audience. And so that that to me is probably the big, the big thing for me is the Book of Mormon itself. And, and, and what, what the implications are of what does new scripture look like?

40:25 And, and is that that's a, that is a type of theology because you asked specifically what kind of theology? Well, even as a kid, I recognized that when people with the the Book of Revelation saying you should not add or or or subtract anything from this book, I knew earlier on that that was referencing the Book of Revelation. It was not book, it was not referencing the rest. So when other Christians would bring that verse, I would say that has nothing to do with it. I also come from, you know, kind of a charismatic Pentecostal tradition which believes in modern day Revelation, modern day apostles and prophets, right? But also I never could understand why Protestants accepted that the Canon was closed because that was via the Council of Trent.

41:12 The Council of Trent was the counter reformation and push back on on on on Protestantism. That's when the Canon was closed and the Protestants accepted that. And I'm like, I feel like the God could communicate to our world any way he wants. And if it includes new scripture, so be it. We don't have the right to say to God, no, we can't have no more scripture, a Bible, a Bible. We already got a Bible. No, I, I think that that it's important that we realize that God can still communicate to us, I believe through new scriptures. I think to limit God is to limit God. And, and I actually think that's, that's blasphemous. So that's kind of how I approach the book of Mormons. So that's and the theology, right? There's theological implications in the idea of an open Canon, in the idea of having modern revelation, modern prophets, modern apostles.

42:10 There's implications there, theological implications for both good and bad. We can see abuses that have taken place. We can see other pretenders who have claimed to translate plates or done stuff. We also see that some of them were very manipulative, evil people that have done harm. That's, that's one of the downsides to the restoration. It's, it's this idea that because this we have this idea of an open cannon and prophets and apostles that we've had throughout the years, people make these claims. And literally, and not only within the Brighamite tradition, but even in the Josephite tradition in the 1980s, where you have these cults, these personality cults, and they often lead to murder and death through a justification of of Nephi with Laden, you know, he was justified in killing him by the Holy Spirit.

43:02 So they felt justified in doing that as well. So we also, and it's so fascinating because I love this book of Pentecostal reads, the Book of Mormon friend Christopher Thomas, who's the stepped down. He was the founding president of the Book of Mormon Studies Association. And he has a chapter in this book about the misapplication of the Book of Mormon that has caused problems. Of course, we see the same thing happen our world with the Bible as well. So it's not just a Mormon thing. So there's, there's, there's a danger also, we have to acknowledge that if you're willing to accept new scriptures, new revelations, apostles and prophets, that they're also outcomes that can happen as well. You've seen it in the fundamentalist world and I've seen it in my as well.

43:44 So that that we should always be aware of the the downfall or some of the dark side of our movements as well. You know, a lot of times I, I feel like when you start parsing out Mormon history and Mormonism in general, you have to parse out, parse it out in a couple ways. You got parse out the doctrine, then you need to parse out the history. And this is going to address some of that, right? Because people have asked, well, why do you put so much weight on what Joseph said, right? Well, there's the, the, the doctrinal standpoint that I have, which is he's the dispensation head, right? He's the guy that God chose to talk to on this.

44:25 But from a historical standpoint, right, If you want to measure fruit, if you will, right, Who's producing good fruit? What do I see from that time period in Mormonism with Joseph? I see a guy who is able to rally people, appeal to people's better nature in many instances, and manage to move people not just not just spiritually, but physically, right. OK, now we're going to move to Kirtland. Now we're going to move to Illinois. Right? And what's fascinating is, is that you get it with Joseph because Joseph is charismatic. He's loved by people, even people who don't agree with his theology.

45:10 You know, he, he, he's very affable and people rally to him. But what's what gets interesting is after he passes and Brigham Young picks up the mantle, Brigham is not Joseph Smith. He and, and he and to his credit, he doesn't try to be Joseph Smith. He, Brigham is his own man. But nonetheless, the same fruit seems to be apparent, right? And so as I start parsing out doctrine and, and look, Mormonism is interesting because you can't parse out the doctrine without the history. You got to have the context behind it. And so when I start trying to parse out the doctrine and I start giving doctrinal weight to to certain actors within the Restoration, that's why Peg kind of kind of set the bar at Joseph and Brigham and John Taylor, because the same spirit, the same fruit is there with different leadership, which shows God's hand, in my opinion, behind it. OK.

46:16 And, and it's fascinating that you can't get that without the history on it. I think, yeah. And that's, that's so important. And of course, we have so many contemporary counts. This is the beauty of the restoration is that we don't have this in the 1st century of the Christian Church. We don't have Mormonism, Mormonism unveiled, written while Jesus's ministry is still going on or Christianity unveiled, if you will, right? So, so we, we, it's a different, you know, like Phon Brody said, you know, the audacity to start a religion during the era of the printing press, right? And I think that there, there are so many things and there's so many ways you can interpret it too. Like, like I, I'm, I'm partial. I mean, I'm, I'm very open to talking to other groups.

46:56 And, and, and, and what's so interesting is about the Saints who stayed back, who refused to participate in polygamy and join Brigham's church. They kind of look at it and say, that's a different church. The warmer in Reformation, literally they got baptized into a different church in their mind and that they feel that their church is the original successor because they, they never got re baptized. They, they have the original baptism of, of the Josephite tradition. And so they feel like they've taken, they've gone down a different direction. And so the the church is it's so fascinating to see all these different groups, how they are influenced, but how so divergent? You know, what is it the divergent paths of the restoration by Steve Shields, right? I mean, there's over 100 different groups, you know, identified in this and there's probably hundreds more that he's not aware of or who sprung out since he's written these books, maybe dozens more.

47:48 But I, I think that for you, going down the Brighamite path and going down and accepting, you know, polygamy as being an eternal principle. And that was, that was originated with Joseph Smith. I can totally understand how you could see how Joseph Brigham and John Taylor all lined up with each other and that your movement is just continuing what the, this new dispensation was all about. And and so I can see how you would understand yourselves as being really in spirit, the true successors in many ways to Joseph in in his mantle and his teachings on some level, right?

48:28 I mean, your movement in general. So that's the other thing too, is, you know, what makes the restoration so difficult, especially when we're trying to get groups. And then this is what I love about what you guys are doing in Missouri is you have this one thing, this one true church ISM, as I call it, we're the one true church. One of these groups claims to be the one true church and it makes for dialogue that much more difficult as a result between these groups because it's like, well, you, you have to get re baptized, don't recognize it. And so it makes it so there there's so many barriers that don't exist in my world. If you didn't like what the Wesley brothers were teaching at the Methodist Church, you just go down the street and go to the Presbyterian Church, no problem.

49:12 But in your world, it's it's, it's, it's there are consequences if you lead another group even within the Restoration. I'm blabbering here, but I'm just kind of just kind of throwing a lot of stuff out here. But I'm this is kind of stream of consciousness, if you will. But there's no it's good. What's going on? With the restoration, I find absolutely fascinating and compelling. And as an outsider, I I'm like, like, what, what is the true church? What, who, what church would Joseph recognize as his church, right. How you know, and, and what's so fascinating is like when I had, and I think this was a keen insight, I was, I was having dinner with Denver Snuffer and he went to me and he said if Joseph Smith came back today and became the prophet of the, he said the church would be bankrupt within five years because he said he would just give so much away.

50:04 Like that's just the way he was. He was a completely different person than what the church is today. It's a it's a completely different way of operating. Well, I just being able to kind of try to understand the prophet and what the movement was all about. He was a rough and tumble kind of guy. He the Kendall image that the correlated Kendall image the church has given us has a lot of people don't accept this photograph. And I tell people, even if this isn't a photo of Smith, he probably looked a lot more like this guy than the Kendall image that the church has been promoting throughout the. So I think it's I think that once we realized that Joseph Smith was truly human being, never in the movies is the everything shown with a limp.

50:46 I mean, he had a limp. He was he, he needed a cane. He was he, he probably looked a lot like this guy in this fold because he'd spent time in jail. He would have been tarred and feathered. He'd been assaulted. He was on the run. That would age you real fast. And so I think that to best understand the restoration is to understand Joseph Smith the man and recognize that he was a man with flaws. But still that does not disqualify him from being a scripture producer or prophet because there are plenty of scoundrels who wrote scripture in the Bible as well. And I'm not saying Joseph's a scoundrel, but I'm saying is if the standard is the Bible, Bible writers, Joseph Smith in many ways was was superior to them in in many ways too. So in in in his morals.

51:35 So that's that's kind of how I see it and just kind of engage it that way. So either way, I'm sorry I blabbered on there. Oh no, you're good. That was that was excellent. Just to give you a heads up, it looks I'm getting a message here saying your bandwidth is low on your end. OK. Am I coming through OK though? Your audio's great, your video kind of freezes now and again, but OK, we're good. OK, good. Yeah, as long as the audio's fine, I don't care if there's a few glitches or anything, so. Yeah, to go along with that and, and go back to your original point about the nasty things that that have happened within Mormonism. And look, we've, we've got to acknowledge that, right? We have to say, look, we're not a perfect people. We have screwed up.

52:16 We have made mistakes from time to time. However, I, I do, I do think a lot of that is because a lot of ideas weren't stress tested against, especially Joseph, right? Like if, if you have an idea, you should be like, OK, how's the square with what, what Joseph taught? How's the square with what Brigham taught? I think you could avoid a lot of the heartache that we see if you stress tested the ideas, not only with, with revealed Canon of scripture, but also with the things that Joseph and, and those early guys had to say. I think, I think there's safety there, you know, there.

52:57 I'll just give you one in particular, and it's one that I use quite, quite a bit, right? Where it's where Joseph has a quote, and I'm paraphrasing, where he says heaven will never intervene when there's an authorized representative on the earth. Right. And, well, you want to start parsing out all the guys who claim that they're the one mighty and strong. OK, Well, is the authority that is on the earth, did they receive it from there? No, Well, there's proper authority on the earth, so I can discount that, right? So you can prevent yourself from going down a lot of bad paths if you just understand what the dispensation head had to say about a lot of this. But unfortunately that stuff gets tossed to the wind. And, and you're right that that is the, that is the precarious nature of still, of saying, hey, God still talks to man, which I believe he does, but I don't think that means it's a free for all, right?

53:54 I do think that it is a House of orders still. You just got to be able to parse that out and and make sure that it's matching up with with what the the dispensation had had to say about it. You know, it's, it's, that's, that's that I think discernment is really important. I think, I think we need to remind ourselves, OK, not that long ago, Tim Ballard was claiming that Jesus appeared to him. Yep, that he wanted him to run for the United States Senate and that he would be elected. And he was telling this to people. And it was it was out there and shortly thereafter. And then not only was he making these claims, but he was not not necessarily publicly, but we know that it's been leaked that he was making these claims. But at the same time, he's promoting his movie and he's getting all these people, all these Mormon podcasters are having them on the program.

54:50 And I had a check in my spirit about the man. I was like, I don't know if I want him to come on my program because I think there's something not quite right here. Well, to see him go on all these programs with priesthood holders who supposedly have discernment, I was like, why is it that I have better discernment on Tim than these priesthood holders? So that was kind of one of those moments because then later on, everything just explodes and it becomes this disaster. And I had friends who were who were very close to him, who defended him to the very end until those affidavits came out which were damning. OK.

55:33 So we can even see not necessarily a person who claims to be a prophet or the one that might be strong, but if those if those affidavits don't come out and those lawsuits aren't filed, we may very well have had AUS senator from Utah who believed that he was going to be essentially probably the president United States and people had prophesied to him. Actually, I guess people also did say that he would also become the president United States and also would become the prophet of the church. So I guess in one sense he probably was kind of gunning for that a little bit. But that's just that's just an example of a person who just a couple years ago was huge, even in the evangelical world, had this big movie that was well promoted.

56:16 And yet Glenn Beck on board. He had all these leaders, you know, all excited. You had Tim Ballard meeting with the Quorum of the 12. So, so it was all there. And now we know what we know about him. And so I think that's the danger of falling for a charismatic individual who people believe. And this, and this is the most interesting thing about Dan Vogel's book Charisma under Pressure, his newest book about Joseph Smith, and I did, and this really gives one of the key takeaways of this book was charisma is not necessarily the charisma that is exudes from the leader. It is the audience projecting the charisma on to the leader and and that and and actually that makes a lot of sense. And so I think a lot of people projected a lot of things on the Tim Ballard and others and that that gives them even more power. So I think we just need to be cautious about these things. You know, and again, for those of you who very few people are defending Tim Ballard anymore, even people who were defending Tim to the very bitter end have since moved away from this guy. I mean, I think he he was a very dangerous man who needs to get some help and we need to keep him in our prayers. But it's just an example of somebody who, you know, if it wasn't for a few things, who knows where he'd be right now. He could be serving in the Senate right now. And so that's, that's an important not only thing for the restoration, but also for Christians and people in general that we need to be very careful

57:49 not to project too much onto the leader or this person who's going to be the savior of America, who's going to make this country great again, right? We need to be very careful that we don't fall into idolatry. And I think that's a, that's a dangerous thing that's happening in our nation as we speak. And by the way, it's not just Republicans. We saw Obama was a messianic character to a lot of Democrats when he first got elected too. So this is, this is, this is a natural human thing. I just think we have to be very careful that we have our priorities in the right place. And remember the Christ is King and, and, and we shouldn't look for other men to save us and give us all the answers and everything like that. You know, I, I, that's always an interesting thing, right? When someone crops up and says, well, I'm the new man, I'm always like, well, one, if you're jockeying for that, I automatically just trust you because I am way too lazy to ever want that.

58:51 So instantly you, you got my ears perked up, right? Like I can, I can't imagine someone that would want that. And I think if someone does want that, I'm kind of like, yeah, you're probably a little, little bit of a psychopath, right? And Mormonism, you know, for a, for a while, there was always this push about who's the one mighty and strong, right? And my take away was, you know, I certainly have my doctrinal positions on that. But I, I tend to to say this, if someone has to tell you they're the one mighty and strong, they're not the one mighty and strong. And then to to wrap this up, when, when you look at religious leaders, especially ones like Joseph Smith, you have to, you have to understand that it's a lot like looking at first round draft picks for quarterbacks, right?

59:39 For every Peyton Manning you have, you're going to have seven or eight guys who just are busts. They wash out, right? And so for every Joseph Smith you find, you can bet that the vast majority of those that that that make similar claims aren't going to pan out as well, right? And you can in the world of religion, you can go down the list, right? Jim Jones, Koresh, just go down the list, right? And and that does make the honest dealers and the dealers who have tapped into something that much more impressive because it didn't go ugly like that, because by all accounts, Mormonism should have died with Joseph Smith. If it was, if it was all about charisma, it should have Joseph established something that was bigger than him. And that's hard to.

1:00:35 That's that's so true, because very few religions, if they're especially let's say very few cults make it past, you know, their their original leader. And and so that did that is that does say something to the staying power of the restoration also says something to the staying power of the Book of Mormon. There have been many pretended scriptures that have come out throughout the years that have come and gone that we forget about. We don't remember anymore. But there have been other, you know, books that have been made claims about things. But in one sense, the Book of Mormon has kind of stood the test of time in a way those those other scriptures haven't. So there look, we're 200 years into this and it doesn't appear to be going anywhere gets here to stay.

1:01:19 And I think that we, we as outsiders need to try to find an accommodation for the restoration within the broader Christian community. I think that, you know, I think we can't just exclude them understanding fully that you're it's a non credo movement. It's non typically non trinitarian. So there are issues that do separate it from Orthodox Christianity, but I also think at the same time, the demonization of the restoration, he needs to stop. And we need to just have better dialogue and more Christian civil discourse between our communities. Because when the world looks at this, they don't look at us. They say all look at those crazy Christians fighting each other, whether it's us Protestants fighting each other or fighting the Catholics or we're fighting you guys. That just makes us look like we lack salt and light in the world.

1:02:10 And what kind the testimony, what kind of what kind of testimony are we really presenting to the world if we can't get our act together and we just get into arguments and debates and and say horrible things to each other? I think that needs to stop too. Oh, I agree. I agree. I think, I think that that, that we, we have enough of, of actual things that divide us that, that we don't, we don't need to invent more, right. And, and I think sometimes it has to do with misunderstanding. I do want to, I do want to acknowledge something here, right? I, I think I'm a little different from most other Mormon podcasters who are, who are still in the faith, so to speak, right?

1:02:53 I'm not sure that that as Mormons we should be pining for that title of Christian, right? I don't think, I don't know that's, that's not a slam on Christianity, Steve. I, I don't want anyone to think it is. I that's not what I'm saying. What I am saying, though, is that there's enough different differences between the two that I think it's not intellectually honest to try to pine for that title. So I think that's fair, especially the Brighamite wing overall, because it is so different. I think you can make arguments that, you know, the the Church of Jesus Christ are pretty close to being Orthodox Christians. I think there would be accommodations in that church for somebody who might even accept the Trinity. The 1833 a church, the temple lot, they're trinitarian. The 1836 church is essentially become a mainline Protestant church.

1:03:58 So all those groups are definitely more closer to mainstream Christianity than the Nauvoo era Brighamite Church. And so which in which we need to acknowledge Jill Smith. It's not just bring Young Young's originated all this kind of stuff like, you know, Joseph Smith played a hand in a lot of these doctrinal innovations, obviously. And it does those those later days definitely do differentiate the latter day St. movement, in particular your movement from the rest of Christianity. And I think that needs to be acknowledged. I just like to put in there that I look at the restoration as a whole and so that it would include those other groups that maybe can I think a case can be made. They are Christian churches on some level, maybe small C, but but that that to me is an argument. But yeah, I certainly see that there's a lot of there are just look, idea of Heavenly Mother or mothers, those are foreign concepts, the idea of, you know, plural marriage on some level. Although I have to say that there have been some Protestant communities that have experienced that have experimented with the principal in the past. And and so so this has happened.

1:05:15 This is not, you know, that that is a manifestation that it has occurred in our movement as well. Yeah. So there's there's enough different stuff there. But then at the same time, I can look at similarities between the charismatic movement, the modern charismatic Pentecostal movement and and your church. OK, I always tell people, I say in my movement got a guy named Benny Hinn who believes in multiple godhead. You have a guy named Kenneth Copeland who essentially who believes that we will become gods and also basically teaches A doctrine that's basically Adam God doctrine. You have Pat Robertson, who ran for president of the United States. You had you have oh, who else?

1:06:02 There's a few couple more people. Well, in other words, we have these characters that all rolled up in the oh, you have Jim Baker, who was a city builder, right? Right. Right. So, so I see all, it's like, oh, I know Joseph, I can see him. There's so many similarities with some of these really important leaders. You know, you had Oral Roberts claim to have seen a 200 foot Jesus to talk to him. That seems even more implausible than the first vision, right? So, so, so, so like in my movement, it's like, oh, a lot of these, a lot of these little doctrines have found their way in some ways in our in our movement. You have the even even the idea of, of tithing and it giving you blessings.

1:06:44 You have the prosperity gospel. So there are you do find AI can actually find a lot of different ideas that Joseph was the originator of or the OR the person who was kind of taking in from different places as well have found their way in the charismatic movement, interestingly enough. Oh, that's interesting. It's almost like, well, you can have the title of Christian as long as you don't have all the crazy beliefs in one guy, right? You can have some of the different beliefs spread out. Oh, it's different guys and it's fine, but you got you one right. But that isn't, that is an interesting point though, right? Because all the things that we've seen, like you just laid out, which look, I'll be honest, I was unaware of some of them. But you start looking at, at some of that and you're like, oh, well, that was what happened like 200 years ago with, except it was one guy, right?

1:07:37 Again, it's one of those things like, well, maybe he was ahead of his time, right? And, and, and that's, that's, that's interesting too. So let me ask you this. You occupy an interesting space because, so to speak, you don't have a dog in the fight, right? You're, you're, you're, you're removed from the theological aspect of things, which can work some folks up, which has got to give you a, a different lens in which to view the landscape of Mormonism. Now I'm going to ask you a question and and if you're uncomfortable answering it, you don't have to. But I'm interested on your take here. When you look at the restoration as a whole, what do you think is coming in the near future for it?

1:08:25 Boy, that's such a, that's such an interesting question. So I think in the near future, the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints will continue its conservative, orthodox entrenchment. It will continue to double down on the more conservative aspects. It's very similar to what happened in the 70s and 80s with the Southern Baptist Convention. The Missouri church, Missouri Lutheran Church, Missouri Synod, and the evangelical movement in general will add this real hard swing to the right in which they basically got rid of all the progressives out of their theological institutions and colleges and replace them with orthodox conservatives, which is what we're seeing in the bringing. So they're using the same playbook the evangelicals were using back in the day.

1:09:18 The church is, is following a very similar pattern. I think that, and that's just one aspect. I think that the community of Christ, and this is just my opinion, but I think it's based on a well informed opinion and based on my conversations with multiple people and sources and including in the church. I don't know if that church is going to be around 10 years from now. I, I, I, I don't know. I have reports that they're expecting in some regions to close 80% of their congregations within the next five years, Which it, it's plausible that with it, I thought maybe 100 years from now, but it's plausible that within the next 10 to 15 years, the bigger tonight's might be the second largest church in the restoration over the Community of Christ, which is just mind blowing to think about. I think that the bigger tonight's, there is a move going on there that I think is pretty remarkable. I attended their general conference and there was multiple instances of tongue speech. There were revelations, there were visions. I saw in my mind.

1:10:26 I'm like, man, this feels very much like early days early. And what was so interesting is they actually had a conference here at my Christian community, a regional conference. And I took my my mom and my 100 and year one year old prophetess missionary friend Yanni, who was involved in the early days of the charismatic movement, including my mom was too. She attended their service and she said, Steve, this is like the early days, the early days of our movement. And so to be able to have the privilege to attend their general conference and engage the people, there was a power there that was remarkable. And I have to tell you that I, I, I can, and I'll just be honest with you, the very first church and restoration that I ever darkened the door of was that church. They have a congregation about 90 minutes away from here. I thought this would be a good starting point. And this is early days of my channel. My channel had been around for a couple months. And I walk in there and I have to say, it was, it really struck me and I felt the Holy Spirit and I felt the anointing, if you will.

1:11:33 And my mom's even claimed, she's also said she's felt the anointing in those services as well. And it changed, changed me and it changed my channel. And then what was so interesting is a couple weeks later, I, the God told me he's like, you need to go to the Mormon History Association. I wasn't going to go. But after I attended that service, I got, I had $1500 saved to get new rims for my car. And instead, I chose to invest that money into my channel so that I could attend the Mormon History Association. It was a direct result of God saying I kept on because God told me not to make any plans. And I I kept on pushing back. Rick Bennett was getting on me. Go to MHA. Go to MHA. No, I can't do it. I can't do it. I can't do it. Well, after I attended that service is like, oh, OK, I got confirmation I'm supposed to attend to MHA.

1:12:15 And that changed the trajectory of my channel because that that of course, gets me to book Richard Bushman, which then causes a lot of people to say, hey, wait, who is this guy? Bushman hasn't done the podcast in years. So I think the hand of God was in that. But then I go and attend Rick Bennett's church in Lehigh and I love Rick Bennett and I I really do, but I go to intend that service and I was like, man, this is that is a doornail. These people could use a cup of coffee. So, and, and, and it was just such a different experience for me and it, and, and I'm really grateful that I got to attend that bicker tonight church because I saw they are like, and this, this, there was a power there that I saw that I felt that the, the, the spirit was operational in a way that was unique and even more look, even I'm, I'm saying the spirit was operating there. That won't be 9.9% of the church services I've attended in my life.

1:13:09 So I'm not just isn't just a, a bash on in any particular church. This is just, I, I'm just, I experienced what I experienced. So, so I think that the bigger tonight's are a movement that that will continue to grow and I think that they very well could be in the next 1020 years become the second largest branch in restoration. I think that, you know, I tell people because people go out to me and saying like, look, I was kind of told don't platform the polygamy deniers as they were called, so don't platform them. And then as I studied it and looked into it, I realized, you know, when they write the chapter for, for the early, early 21st century history of the, of the restoration movement, they're going to have a chapter about this, this group. And so to ignore that group was actually going against the idea of my channel, which is all the voices of the restoration will be heard here.

1:14:03 So then I started engaging Michelle Brady Stone and others. And I felt like I was, it wasn't fair that I kind of didn't engage them. And I'm glad that I did and I'm glad I have a good relationship with those people. I think that's a movement that's going to continue on. It's on a different trajectory. I don't know, could this ultimately lead to another church being started? I don't know. I think Denver Snuffer and his movement are are fascinating group. I mean they're making claims. Some people believe that Denver is the Davidic servant. I think it's really fascinating that one of Denver Snuffer's right hand man, Matthew Lowmeyer was recently appointed as the Under Secretary of the US Air Force. So if I was a follower of Denver Snuffer, and I believe that the second coming is coming soon and I have a very close associate of Denver Snuffers that has the ear of the most powerful man in the world, I would think that there's with a within their belief system, things are coming into a head. I also think that what's so fascinating is just seeing all these movements, including your own, which in and of itself is remarkable to have all these other fundamentalist groups coming together and being able to go through the original endowment ceremony.

1:15:24 That's that's, that's revelatory in some sense. And so it seems to indicate so it is the Church of Jesus Christ, Latter Day Saints and we're coming on the 200 anniversaries of both just that have passed and are coming of some really important dates within the movement. So I think that there's a general anticipation that things are winding down and today's and it's, it's coming. So what does the future look like for the, for the restoration? Well, maybe the things wrapped up and the second coming is, is happening. And so then we're talking about Millennium now or maybe the second coming doesn't, maybe it's not for another couple thousand years. So now we have to look at, you know, what does, what does, what does the restoration look like if it's we're still here 100 years from now, right?

1:16:15 And that's that's kind of where we have to look at it like, you know, we have a church that is one of the most, you know, wealthiest churches in the world that could go hundreds of years without accepting any tithe money and just work off the money that they have, you know, stored up. So you have that. And so it in and of itself that church is not going anywhere. And so a lot, but there's other groups that probably won't make it 100 years from now. I, I love the community of Christ, but just seeing the direction it's going and I'm hope I'm wrong. Prove me wrong, please. Do I think you're an important voice. And I, I do appreciate the community of Christ immensely. But I just seen the trajectory of that church and, and I'm very concerned about it.

1:16:57 And, and there's many people in that church are also very concerned about the trajectory of that church. So I hope I answered your question there because I think it's it's it's I can't just talk about one church. Oh no, that's not what I'm. Asking Restoration. Restoration as a whole is, but I do, I do see that there seems to be this convergence of a belief that something is happening, that there's changes going on, that the sealed portion is about to be revealed, that maybe the choice seer. So within, within the, within the Bickertonite tradition, they believe that there will be a choice seer named Joseph who will be a Native American who will reveal, reveal new records.

1:17:40 That's, that's their anticipation. You have other groups that believe in the future one and one, it might be strong. They're anticipating that. I've spoken to others who believe that Joseph Smith will return or in one case a person who says Joseph Smith already has returned. So you have a lot of these different interpretations and all these things that are going on. And so I don't know, I think that we will continue to see the rise of the ex Mormon movement that will be around that's here to stay. But I also think because the, you know, you've had this, this a large amount of people that have left the movement, in particular church use Christ Latter day Saints.

1:18:29 I think that the, that, that the amount of people that will be leaving the church will be slowing down. So I, I think that, that it, it has lost some momentum because what we have seen just overall throughout the world, there's been a push back of the growth of atheism and we actually are now seeing the pendulum swing. We're now, we're seeing an increase in church membership now throughout the world in the Christian Church in general. And we're seeing it even church. So I think we're, we're having a push back against the new atheist movement and, and, and so the so the churches are kind of putting out a counter offensive that that started happening, you know, about 20 years ago with the rise of the theists and stuff like that. And I also think that people realize the importance of having faith and becoming a nihilistic atheist. This is dark can, can be a very dark space to be in. And so they've sometimes and realize that in many cases, the ex Mormon community in in and of itself is its own religion. It has its own.

1:19:26 Well, really it does. I mean like. It is No, you're you're I I laugh because I made that point on the podcast. Somebody else? But well, they that you can be excommunicated from the ex Mormon community. That's the crazy thing. Like, you know, they, they, you can be cancelled, excommunicated, But the, the difference is there's no, because it's primarily atheist, it's there's no redemption, there's no second chances. It's like once you're cancelled, you're it. And I feel like so often there is a there's a toxicity in that can be look, I, I love the ex Mormon community in many ways. I'm friends with many people in there. I'm not, this is not, I'm not implicating. I totally understand why you would maybe take that path because I was an atheist for 13 years. So I ain't going to hate on atheists. I ain't going to hate on ex Mormons. I understand that space you're in, but sometimes people occupy that space, that angry atheist phase for too long. I understand if you need to be the angry atheist for a while. I was too.

1:20:16 But you got it from that too, because it can do a lot of damage to your soul hatred. It, I don't care what the hatred is directed towards, hatred is still hatred and it will do damage to your soul, period. So even if you hate Joseph Smith, even if you hate the Church of Jesus Christ, Latter Day Saints, and maybe you have good reasons to feel that way, you need to move on because you're doing damage to yourself. And hate is a very destructive thing. So I don't know, that's just an overview of a lot of different things. No, no, that's, that's excellent. You know, I want to I want to touch on a few things you said there. One is the idea that that Jesus is coming back tomorrow, right? I've always said this, you should live like that's exactly what's going to happen. But you should also plan on planting your apple trees and that sort of thing, right, 'cause I, I, I, I've called it playing pin the tail on the Apocalypse, right? Too often that's a losing game, right? And, and I don't, I don't spend a lot of time. Now, let me rephrase this.

1:21:16 I do think about it, and I like talking about it, right? But keep that in the realm of ideas, right? Like I'm always nervous when someone says it's going to happen next year or five years from now. I'm like, yeah, just just relax on that. That's that's the world I grew up in. That's the world I grew up in. Like absolutely great Planet Earth was the top selling book period of the 70s and basically was that Jesus was going to be coming in the year 1988. That's basically why, you know, and that's why I became such a big seller. I grew up in the world in which the second second coming was right around the corner. The idea that we'd even see the year 2000 was ridiculous. Like it was, there's no way we're going to make it to the year 2000. Like Jesus is going to come before that. So, yeah, I grew up in that world. So I've learned to be much more grounded on this whole thing. Yes, susceptible to looking for being a sign seeker or whatever. I'm, I'm, I'm more of one of those people that's like, I'm, I'm observing.

1:22:14 I've, I've essentially moved into the post millennial camp myself. So I'm, I'm an optimistic post millennialist, if you will. So that doesn't really fit within the world view of the restoration movement at all because you guys are premillennial. But I tend to be more comfortable in a partial preterist post millennial space. That's that's where I land in that category. Yeah, no, absolutely. I so, so that's, that's that for that. I believe the second coming will happen. I think, I think all those events will take place, but I don't allow myself to spend an inordinate amount of time thinking about it. But back to where I think the restoration is heading with that question.

1:22:58 I read an interesting article. Oh, I want to say just last month and, and I should say this, I've changed my views a little bit on the younger generation. OK. I was always like just, you know, 'cause I come from a poor background, right? And, and managed to get myself out of poverty and, and those sorts of things. So I was always like, just work harder, right? You'll, you'll get there. Just put, put more elbow grease into it. I will say this, I think, I think after looking at it and it came from personal experience with, with a young man that I know back in Utah and start looking at it. And yeah, the deck is kind of stacked against him a little bit, right? And but also I, I took a deeper look at why church attendance was down everywhere, right?

1:23:48 Not just Mormonism, but everywhere. And as I start talking, because most of the guys I either work with or, or some of the guys that that I hang out with, they're a little bit younger than I am. And what I was discovering is that they're not leaving church because they want to go do something different, right? They're leaving church because they don't feel like they're making an impact there, right? For this younger generation, they're very, they want to know whatever they're doing is contributing to the good of the society they're in.

1:24:28 And I think what's going to happen to the restoration, especially those who aren't super organized, I think they're going to get a bump really soon because I think that younger generation wants to be involved in something that's bigger than them, right? And if we look at what Joseph's original thrust was, he didn't care about churches, right? He, he built exactly 0 just ward chapels or meeting houses. What he did build was communities and temples. And that's a different view than a lot of other, other than a lot of the rest of Christianity. And that's not a slam.

1:25:08 I'm just saying the view was different from Joseph's perspective. And so I think that some of those youth, if we, if we who, who look, I'm talking to fundamentalists, I'm talking to independents, right? Those, if you can, if we can line up and have a positive impact or on, on the community in which we reside. I, I think some of these, these other doctrines that we think might be a barrier to entry aren't necessarily a barrier to entry for the younger generation. They just want to know that what they're doing is, is having a positive impact on the society in general. And there is some danger in that, right. You got to be able to keep because, look, if, if you just throw all orthodoxy out the window, what are you left with?

1:25:54 Well, you're, you're not really left with a church any longer. You're left with a social club, right? And so you're going to have to walk a fine line there. But if, if we can do that and, and get out of the way and not be so concerned with hierarchy and start being more concerned with, are we having, are we being the, the light on the hill that that Christ asked us to be? I think I think things are good there. So I do think that as I look at it, I think the more hierarchical structures are going to suffer in the short term. I think, I think those who are a little less organized but maybe a little more service minded or trying to get back to the original message, I think those will flourish for a. While I think this is the, I call DIY Mormonism or non denominational Mormonism, I think that that's there's a rise of that and I'm glad you brought that up because I think that's a, that's a growing movement as well.

1:26:46 People that are just kind of doing their own type of Mormonism on an individual level. It's very Protestant, it's very evangelical. And, and I've, I've spoken to many people off the record who are basically non denominational Mormons are just kind of doing their own thing. And that's a really fascinating facet of, of that. And so, yeah, there's and let's, let's not also ignore the fact that there is a rise of progressive Mormons that I want to continue who like the reformed Mormonism movement, which Rob Raoul Lauer is involved in. Of course, my friend Evan Charlie's involved. They're, they're doing the endowment ceremony. They believe in the doctrines, you know, many, many ways they probably are in line with you guys on doctrine and theology more so than the main church.

1:27:32 Absolutely. And, and so I think it's really, but it's a progressive take on it. It's, it's, it's a different manifestation of the restoration, but it is truly fascinating to essentially accept a lot of the 19th century doctrine as being part of their church, but kind of putting a 21st century twist on it, but still practicing a lot of the principles of, of, of the 19th century Mormonism. So it's, it's, it's just really kind of in my mind, it's kind of a cool experiment to see what's going on. But I also realized that I got, I got to be, I don't want to come across as an anthropologist who's just kind of standing here and watching things like, oh, isn't this interesting? Oh, isn't this exciting because I recognize like these are human beings and this is about their faith and this is what they believe and this is what makes them who they are. So I have to be honoring and respecting of all these different views it without trying to come across as some kind of outsider who thinks, I'll look at, you know, oh, I'm just observing things and kind of ecologist and kind of scribing them.

1:28:36 I'm like, no, I'm, I'm living it too. I'm attending the services, I'm praying with them. I'm, I'm, I'm fellowshipping with them and I'm engaging with restoration in a way that I think is so important that if you're going to be the religious group, you can't just be an outsider. You need to be a participant on some level. And that's what I try to do. I consider that what I'm doing here is, is a sacred thing, having a conversation with you. And I'm honored that you would have me on your program. And I'm honored about all the wonderful people that have been on my program because it's just, it's, it's a sacred conversation that we're having. It's a very human conversation as well, but it's sacred because we're all image bearers. So any time we're engaging each other as image bearers, it is a sacred moment, especially when we're talking about sacred things.

1:29:24 And, and I think that that's really, I think that's what, if you will, Heavenly Father wants for his children. Stopping the bicker tonight, not the bickering, not the bicker tonight's stopping the disputations. And one of the, one of the words that I feel the Lord gave me was a couple years ago, I was speaking at the Book of Mormon rally in Independence, MO. And they're all different groups. And I remember standing there and I said, you know, in the Book of Mormon, we have what is called a, what I call a proto Millennium, which we have this 200 years of peace. And one of the key things that brought this about was one of the key verses was and there were no more matter of ites. And then I'm like, but I'm looking in this crowd and I see Brighamites, Josephites, Cutlerites, Strangites, Bickertonites, all these matter of Ites. You know, it's almost like it was a, a call to the restoration that if you believe in bringing forth Zion, if you believe in bringing forth the, the Millennium and the, and all these kind of things, we got to get rid of all these Ites. As long as there's Ites, the restoration will not be ready for what they believe will be coming. And and so I think that that's a key thing too. And I think the Book of Mormon even tells us it's a condemnation, if you will, on some level of the Restoration that we have all these matter of Ites when it makes it very clear in the Book of Mormon there can't be any more rights. That, that's a tall order,

1:30:57 right? Because there's a guy who's inside of of the community, if you were to do something like that, I think you all have to agree on a standard at some level, right? And look, let's let's be fair, a lot of the, a lot of those groups that that maybe spring from Emma Smith, I don't know how else to put it, right? I know my family wouldn't be welcome there, right? I mean, that's just what it is. It's it's a, it's a very uncomfortable conversations. We're going to have to be, but I think it's time for the adults to start talking. You know, I think that's really important. I think. And I also think that, you know, if you, if you believe the Book of Mormon and if you believe in the restoration, I think that it, it really it, it, it's a very compelling thing that, that it condemns ITS.

1:31:47 And yet there has been all these. And again, the whole idea of the restoration was we're going to get rid of the confusion. We're going to get rid of, we're going to, we're going to have standard, we're going to have like this church is a mess. That's why we need a restoration. And then I look at the restoration and, and in 200 years it's, it's, it's probably, there are probably more sex of the restoration in the 200 years of the church than there were in the 1st 200 years of the Christian Church. Sure. So, and if it continues to, to trajectory, you'll probably be even more so than Protestants and everything. So I think that that's that is a, you know, when Azertec Benson said the church is under condemnation and still is, I think I think there's something to that.

1:32:27 Sure, sure. No, I think, I think there's so many people that are so widely different in their theologies and their doctrines that it's hard to to wrap everyone's mind around it. Right. And, and it's an interesting thing that that you did bring up earlier, What I tend to see in these different splits is everyone picks their favorite time period. Yes, right. Yep, precisely just. Just as you put it out out there, right, a lot of people don't like the Nauvoo period. Well, I'm sorry, it is a period of Joseph's life, right? And if you, you know, a guy like myself, I tend to look at that and say he Joseph during the Nauvoo period is probably operating at his highest point, right? He's been, he's been seasoned through experience. We know that line upon line, precept upon precept is a heavy thing in Mormonism when you start talking about progression. And, and so to, to just discard that as bad. Likewise, though, we can't just discard the lessons of Kirtland and the lessons of, of Missouri and the lessons of of Pennsylvania and New York, right? You, you have to, you have to understand that. And so it, that would, that would be a tall order, but it, but it, if it can happen, I'm, I'm there for it. But it would, it would be a tall order 'cause you're either going to have to have a standard or you're going to have to have a lot of grace from person to

1:33:58 person. Yeah. Which, you know, I, I don't mind saying that that a bicker tonight is part of the Restoration. I disagree with some of their doctrine, right? They would disagree with some of mine, and that's OK. I don't think we have to be enemies in that. And I think this also goes to what does Unity really look like, right? I think sometimes we all have this idea of what, what Unity is going to look like, but maybe it's not quite what we're thinking it is. But I, I do want to it it that would, that would be awesome to happen. But I do think, I do think we have to acknowledge the doctrinal differences and figure out how to navigate those. Certainly.

1:34:40 So, So what was it that as you started the podcast, what were some of the challenges you first encountered? Well, I think when I first started, it was interesting because I actually my first interactions with the restoration when I was starting, before I started up my channel was primarily people independence, independence based Saints. I, I, what happened was I, I was going to launch my channel and before I did, I actually participated in a, a weekly zoom call with the community of Christ. That was book club that was doing a, a, we were, we were reading the book Joseph Smith, the third Pragmatic Prophet by Rodger Launius, and we did a couple chapters each week and I introduced myself.

1:35:37 And that's when I first met Lachlan Mackay and Barbara Walden, who are with the history department in the church and Lachlan, of course, being a direct descendant of Joseph and everything like that. And so I was like, wow, you know, maybe this is where maybe I'm supposed to just be more like, like encountering, you know, the, the community of Christ, which and, and the, and that movement in general. And the people were just so lovely. Lovely and engaging to me that I always feel I have a soft spot in my heart for the community of Christ. When I first started the channel, what was so interesting to me was that I had a couple dozen subscribers and John Dylan's radar, like when I had like a couple dozen subscribers, we started communicating to each other first.

1:36:30 This is I remember the first night I'm talking to John de Lynn on Reddit and you were going back and forth and I was like, Oh my gosh, like I can't. I went to my mom the next morning. I said, mom, you wouldn't believe this. I was in communication with with John and I always tell people, imagine starting a podcast. You have a couple dozen subscribers and Joe Rogan is, is engaging you that that's kind right in our space. He's the Joe Rogan, right? And then the next day, I get a friend request from Sandra Tanner on Facebook, like, well, how did I get on her radar screen? Right. And, and so that's when I realized like, oh, there might be something special, something special here. And, and so it was like, OK, well, let's just continue. And my mom caught this on early, early on. So when I was a young man, I was a teenager and I was really involved in politics during my younger years. And I was doing a house group fellowship and I was giving a presentation about why Christians should get involved in politics.

1:37:34 And there was a gentleman there who's the vice president of one of the banks in the community. And he was he was in the in the room as I get my presentation. Now this is like this is like pre cell phone days in one sense, except he had one. I get a call, he leaves and I'm still at the house and he calls the house and says I want to talk to Steve. So he says, I, I, the Lord gave me a word for you and he said that the work you're going to do is like you're going to be a modern day Daniel. This is what he prophesied over me. And you will have the ear of very powerful people. So at this time we're like, and I told my parents about this and like so and so gave you that prophecy. And this is a very prominent individual in the community. But back then a bank vice president was a big deal, you know, and, and so I forgot about the prophecy. I got burned out of politics.

1:38:30 By the time I was in my mid 20s, run for office, did political consulting. I was like, man, I, I don't know if I can do this anymore. I get burned out kind of move away from that period of my life. And it was early on, first couple months of this channel. And again, just dozens of subscribers where my mom goes to me, she says the prophecy is being fulfilled. Steve, we thought it was about politics, but the prophecy was about your role in this in in what you're supposed to do. And since then, I've had engagements with general authorities President Elder Anderson. We've had two great communications with each other.

1:39:10 He's watched the channel, he's told me his own son told me that he's he's watched my channel. So I can tell you there's a member of the Quorum of the 12 who's aware of my channel and has watched it, but I've also had engagements with all these different leaders within the movement. And, and so I think on one level, you know, people have, you know, again, this is this is where it gets really sensitive. And actually I want to make it very clear to you, Dave. So less than a little over a year from the time I started my channel, I was a guest for a full week on Mormon Stories. But a few, few times a guest has probably been given a full week on that, on that platform. And one of the things I did was I went to John and I said, you know, when I was a little kid, I went to a friend and said, and this is like 3rd, 4th grade, I said I would make a great cult leader.

1:40:00 I, yes, I, I recognized that as a child. Well, I specifically went and said that on Mormon Stories. To serve as a guardrail to so that I don't be tempted to become that cult leader. Because I can tell you that so many people and I and I tell people so that if I was a person that was a malevolent person, I could take advantage of people. I've had people from just about every movement of the restoration tell me, I believe that you're going to play a role in bringing forth Zion, telling that to me, an outsider. I had another person go to me, say I believe that you might be Joseph Smith reincarnated. This person believes in multiple mortal probations. I've had all these different manifestations of the restoration tell me this.

1:40:46 If I wanted to become a prophet, I could, but I don't believe that. That's my role. But I also recognize again, the charisma people projecting onto a person has happened to me first hand, you know, where people are projecting onto me something. So when somebody says we believe you're going to bring forth Zion, I don't know what that means, but they're projecting that on to me. So I just, you know, God told me early on, he said, you know, don't make any plans and and just follow my lead. So that's always that the guiding principle that I've been following early days. Everything came easy. The last year and a half has been a real struggle for me. I believe I'm in my just my trial, my period trials that I'm going through, but it's humbled me and it's and it's kept me. I think, I think, I think I'm glad that I've experienced what I've experienced over the last year and a half because I think I needed that.

1:41:41 I think sometimes being a male, sometimes your ego can be stoked and people are saying all these things about you and you're having all these great guests on and people are telling you how wonderful you are. I think I needed to have some setbacks up in my life as a reminder. See, the problem was, is that Dave, last year, little over a year ago, I started making plans. I had a lot of plans. I, I, I was, I was, I was going to be one of the keynote speakers at Rob Meldrum's conference. I was going to then fly out to speak at a Fuko Mormon rally in Independence. I was like, wow, this. Then I woke up 1 morning, the loud screaming in my ear and I realized that my life had changed because I, I lost almost all my hearing in my right ear and it was replaced with a loud screaming of tinnitus.

1:42:24 Well, with hypokesis, which means I'm sensitive to sound as well. And I was bedridden for like a month and a half last year. And I sat in bed thinking, God, I don't want it to end this way because I, I couldn't, I couldn't talk. My mom and I would talk in whispers or we'd text each other because that, that's how bad it was. I couldn't walk outside because the sound of my neighbor. I couldn't sit in my living room because my, my neighbor's air conditioner would kick on. It would be too much for me to have to go to my room. That's how bad it was. So I had a lot of time to think of things through and I was like, OK, this is bad, but this isn't nearly as bad as my darkest times in my life. So that was a good thing. But I also realized like, you know, God, I, I started making plans and you told me not to.

1:43:07 And so I, I feel like that was kind of like him telling me, Steve, I'm, I'm serious, don't make plans. And so that's kind of how I operate. So I try not to let this get to my head. I think maybe some of that was happening and I started making plans and God humbled me. He literally brought me down to my knees. Right. You know, that's why that's sometimes people think I just ignore. And I don't necessarily ignore. But what I do do is I never read the comments, right? Because only two things are going to happen, right? One is you're going to get an ego boost. Nobody needs that. Nobody or someone's going to say something really stupid and you're going to be like OK, and you're going to get involved in a squabble that's going to make you look silly too. Just posting ghost bro, right?

1:43:59 Because like you'll drive yourself nuts reading the comments or nothing good comes from that right? I just. I, I, I I do. Read You're going to hate and that's just all there is to it. I, I do read the comments, but I don't let them affect me. And, and actually, the few times I have engaged, especially like on Facebook or Reddit, it, it was like, man, I just wasted a lot of time here. I like nothing good out of this conversation. So I refused to engage. And actually, when people start getting nasty with me, I'm like, here's a zoom link. You can say it to my face. Are you man enough to say it to my face? It's the zoom link challenge. And, and, and the only person I've done this dozens of times. The only person that took me up on that offer offer offer was Chino Blanco, the founder of the ex Mormon Reddit. And we went on a zoom a couple years ago, 2-3 years ago now, because he had some said some critical stuff of my to me and we had a wonderful conversation.

1:44:58 And last year right before Sunstone, he came on my program to give an oral history of the ex Mormon Reddit. And I think that's an important episode because people need to know like what what was the early days like in this movement? And got to hear from one of the early voices in this movement and got a nice oral history of the early days of the Reddit ex Mormon Reddit. And that's the only second interview he's ever given. He's gave his first interview, the Mormon stories and he says this will probably be the last interview he'll ever give. So positive can even come out of conflict if if people are willing to have good faith conversations and and shout out to him because he was willing to have a good faith conversation with me. And and that's all I'm striving for. Dude is that.

1:45:38 But yeah, that's The thing is it just, you know, I get people like want some some some people send me screenshots of comments that were sent about them and I'm like on a video. And it was being so innocuous. I'm like, OK, like, but you are in this space. You chose to come into this space. So you need to put your big boy pants on and and deal with it. You gotta have some tough skin. You gotta have some tough skin. The things that have been said about me are horrendous. The accusations made against me have been disgusting and vile. And I'm, I still plod along and I, I feel hurt sometimes by it, but I just, I just move on. And it, it's a very tough space to be in, especially when you're trying to facilitate conversations between warring, warring factions. And sometimes if those conversations go sideways, I, I become collateral damage or you know, where those, they'll attack me, even though if I'm just delivering the message or I'm just trying to facilitate stuff. So it can, it can be hurtful too, to be in this, in this neutral space that I occupy in this, in this world. And but it it's not an easy, it's not an easy space to be in at all.

1:46:45 It can be very stressful at times as well. Oh, absolutely. No, There's, there's, I've said this, if you're going to podcast about Mormonism, I hope you approach it as a calling, Right. I know you, you, you made allusions to that. I definitely felt that way. And and I think you have to, right, because look, you are going to get some pushback. You're going to get some arrows flowing your direction. It's just the price of doing business. And then you got to have some tough skin to be able just to let that I've told people, look, I'm fine with you insulting me because someday I'm going to publish a book of all the best and wittiest insults.

1:47:25 So if you're going to do it, just come with some wit and some humor, really make it worth my while to read. Don't, don't, don't, don't do that halfway. Go go all in. But you know, no, you do have to have some tough skin. Let's wrap up with this one. Where do you think? What's your hopes for the channel? You know, I feel like the channel and maybe not everybody's going to agree with this, but I think that I'm in the exact same spot that I was in when I first turned on the camera and did my very first book review. I think my heart's in the same space. I think that if you read my, if you go on my description of my channel, I wrote that before I started filming and doing a channel, but I kind of wrote down, OK, this is what the channel is going to be about.

1:48:19 And essentially it is that it's, it's, it's, it's, it's, I don't feel like I've deviated from what the channel was what my, where I thought the channel was going to play a role. Now, I had no idea that, look, my goal was my goal, if you will, my plans, if you will, was there's this guy named that had a YouTube channel, he's since moved to Missouri called LDS Book Reviews. And this guy had like 200 subscribers. And I thought to myself, well, let me look up and see if Mormon book reviews is, is, is available. And it was and then also the domain name. So I got those and I was like, wow, wouldn't it be great to have a YouTube channel with a couple 100 subscribers and I can just talk about the books in my collection. And even in my very first episode I said, and maybe I'll even occasionally interview people. Well, very quickly I realized that it wasn't the book reviews people were interested in.

1:49:14 They were interested in the interviews. I never, I never interviewed anybody. So if you want to go and see, the very first time I ever interviewed somebody period was when I had Rick Benedon of Gospel Tangents. At that moment, I had no idea if I had any talent for it. And you know, but I, I did OK. And I was surprised because I never, I have no experience interviewing people. And so where do I see this channel going? I know I, I think it continues on the trajectory that it's in, which is to continue to strive to have dialogue, be be civil. You know, that panel discussion you were on a couple weeks ago, like people said, no other channel could have put together a panel discussion like that with that group of people. And so I just want to strive to have those conversations, whether they're on camera or off camera and to continue to expose people to ideas.

1:50:12 So, so, so there's a lot of Latter Day Saints because my largest single group, the people who watch the channel are members of the Church of Jesus Christ, Latter Day Saints. And to hear a feminist perspective on Mother Heavenly Mother, to hear a, a, a fundamentalist perspective on Heavenly Mothers, to hear different voices. They're being exposed to the ideas for the probably for the first time. And, and so I, I take great, great pride, if you will, and it's a real privileged place to be to be able to put together these unique groups of people with different voices and have people be able to be exposed to different ideas that I think it's so more important I tell people, I said, I am here to challenge your faith, not to hurt your faith, but to strengthen your faith.

1:50:59 And challenging can be a good thing. Get the wheels turning, make you start questioning things. Don't just take everything like that one airline pilot. He was just accepting what was being told. And then he picks up a church history book and realizes like, this is nothing like I was told and ends up leaving. So I want to I want to help people, maybe strengthen their shelves. I want people to, you know, I, I had this great, I was actually interviewed by, well, I was on Jim Bennett's program Inside Out with Ian Wilkes was the main host on that episode. And it was Jim and I talking about the Book of Mormon. And I talk a lot about a lot of different things, different perspectives. Is this a fictional account? Is this an ancient record?

1:51:39 Is this a 19th century production? What about the plates? And we talked about it. We took all these different angles. And afterwards I was talking to Ian. I said, Ian, I said, what I would like to do is when this episode is released, my hope is, is that we'll be hearing from people who will say, I was almost out of the church. But now you've given me a way to approach the Book of Mormon that bolsters my faith and is able to keep me in. And that would be a success story because I, I tell people I said I, I don't want, I don't want somebody to leave the church because of something I said, said it did on my channel, because I know what that means. And I got, I got nailed by the Christian apologist for saying that. But they, but they don't, they don't.

1:52:20 They're just using AI and doing quote mining on me. They're not actually doing any research, even though research is in the name. What I was saying was if somebody were to leave the church because of something I said or did, I understand what that means. Potential job loss, Maybe they get shunned from their family, maybe they get divorced. Maybe all this stuff happens because of some some statement I said on my channel. No, I don't want to throw somebody's life in that predicament. I want them to be informed about this stuff so that they don't have their shelves break. Like, I want them to be exposed to all these different ideas and realize that a lot of things that they were told isn't necessarily correct or maybe has been misrepresented to them.

1:53:03 And I, I said, listen, I can still engage the restoration and look at all the warts and flaws and then still walk away with an admiration for Joseph Smith, a love for the Book of Mormon, and more importantly, a love for the people of the Restoration. So I guess my goal is, is for people just to see how much I love and appreciate them. And I want to be a source for them to, you know, I've had Latter Day Saints tell me I watch your channel because at any moment the Holy Ghost might show up. Well, that that's an honor and a privilege to be able to also spiritually affect the lives of people. Originally, this is going to be a secular scholarly channel, but then I had a phone call from a Bishop or from the apostle in Independence, MO, who started telling me about the songs as I am.

1:53:47 The supernaturally created hymn book made me realize at that moment like, oh, yes, secular, the, yes, scholarly, but we also have make room for the Spirit. And so that's what we continue to do here at NPR. Yep, no. And, and look, I, I will say this, I, I think that there's probably no other religion in Christianity that seems to incorporate everything from doctrine to, to almost theocracy at times. And then the history that goes along that is fascinating. So there's no, there's no, there's no lack of material, right? I know when I started mine, I'm like, look, I go a year, been a success, right? Going now on 4 and you know, it blew up, right? And, and so I, I get it, I get it. I get exactly what you're talking about. And I've also learned this, if I've made everybody mad at me, chances are I'm probably over the target a little bit, right when everybody is upset.

1:54:56 OK, I obviously I've, I've poked a button there that everybody's sensitive to and probably deserves looked at. So. But anyway, it's fun stuff. Well, Dave, I just want to close with just, I, I want to say something I think that important, especially for this this particular podcast. Well, first of all, I want to have you back on my channel again, by the way, So you're open, you're invited to the console. Let's plan. I appreciate that you you, you're welcome back here anytime. I also just wanted to say that, you know, I tell people, I said when I, I've spent years, decades really studying Rep Mormonism, history, theology. And so most of what I've learned about Mormonism was before I started this channel, but the one area that I've learned more about is polygamy since I started the channel. And I tell people one of the most important moments of my channel was a Saturday night in which there's was an engagement. And of course, I had been interviewing Benjamin Schaefer. And I found them to be a really pleasant guy. I remember the first time I ever met him, I was that it was just a few months into the channel.

1:56:05 I read he was at the firm foundation manning a booth. I'm like, I know who you are. I watched you on gospel tangents. And he's like, OK, Steve, he said just don't tell him that I'm, you know, let anybody know what you know, that I'm a polygamist. I say, don't worry, it's our secret, you know. And then that led to us doing a series of interviews. And then that led for there to be a conversation with members of Christ branch, which of course, at the time you were a member of. And I didn't know. It was like they lined him up and just put him in front of me and talk from like a 17 year old teenage girl to the last plural wife of the founding prophet of the church who was in her mid to upper 80s and everybody in between.

1:56:48 And I also remember seeing you in the background, this big guy sitting back there and it seemed like like Benjamin was kind of like, you know, somebody else would come in and say, wait, wait, wait. And then finally, you got on there and we had a great conversation. And so I was honored and privileged to have those conversations because I realized that was when I really realized that polygamists or fundamentalists are really truly some of the most wonderful people I've engaged in restoration. Well, I appreciate that and and it really. Opened my eyes and I think that also led to some great conversations that I've had with oh, Ann Wilde, the first wife of Ogden Kraut.

1:57:32 I had Liz Phillips come on a few times to talk about the AUB and her grandfather Rulon Allred. I've had Ivan Kraut's son come on and talk about some really important stuff, including about the dream mine. And, and so it really opened up to me this world that I realized that a lot of the stuff that had been said about your people have been it's, it's like liable is to say the least. And, and I think you guys have been really mistreated unfairly and misrepresented. And so I just want to say that my engagement with you and people in your movement have been a real blessing in my life.

1:58:16 Oh. Well, I appreciate. That I'll forever be grateful to the love that's been extended to me. And I know that they have many people in the fundamentalist community appreciate what I'm doing here too. So I just want to honor, honor you as as a as a. People, I appreciate that. And you know, I think some of this it, it's interesting, right, Because I, I come, I come to fundamentalism, not being a Mormon of of any stripe, right? I, I, I was baptized into the LDS church as a young man, worked the program there. And so when I come into fundamentalism, I, I, it's, it's easy to see that there's a little bit of societal scarring that has happened, right? These are people who have had their kids taken away. And so we a lot, a lot of them, a lot of us weren't necessarily lining up to be public, right?

1:59:08 Because, well, we know how that game ends. And it, it's hard, it's hard to break that down. But, but I think because of what Warren Jeffs did and look, I mean, I had Warren's son on the program, right? Who who found his way back to the faith despite everything his dad had done. They, you know, he did some damage, right? But I do believe that we're in a time now where, quite frankly, our voices are kind of needed, right? Not mine, but our voices collectively, because I do think that it's interesting, I think we, the, I think the LDS Church especially is in a place where you almost need a little bit of fundamentalism in there to address some of these topics that quite frankly seem to have been forgotten by all but scholars now, right?

2:00:01 The things that scholars tend to know, a lot of them are everyday things that fundamentalists know, right? Things like women in the priesthood, Heavenly Mother, those are things we all have answers on. If, if someone wants that answer, it's just it's an interesting time. And I think our voices are needing that needed now more than ever. But it's come with its own challenges. And so venues like yours is allowed, allowed that message to be out that, hey, we're not all Warren Jeffs. Yes, I Yep, Yep. I certainly, I certainly hope that's. That was huge. So yeah. Yeah, no, I, I appreciate that. And yeah, I, I really feel like that's, you know, I, I wouldn't have imagined when I was engaged in the community of Christ that I would then be talking to all these fundamentalists.

2:00:49 You know, it's just, it's amazing the diversity within the movement and all that. And so, yeah, it's been a, it's been a real privilege to be in the space. You know, I feel people, God, I, I feel like God said, you know, like what? No, I not, God never said this, but I said this myself. I said, you know, maybe I'm only going to do this for a season. Maybe the door will be shut. So I don't know how much longer this goes. I hope that it continues. I hope I do this for the rest of my life. But if God tells me it's time to move on, then I'll move on. But I hope to be in, I hope to be a voice in this in this world, and I hope to continue to give, give voice to the voiceless when a lot of people don't. You know, I can book any big name I want, but I, I'm more interested in having people on it. Nobody's ever heard of to give their story, their position, their, their, their views on things. That that to me, I think is, is much more I, I, I get more joy in that than.

2:01:41 More than anything, Absolutely, absolutely. Well bro, it was fun. We should do it again. Yeah, this is fun. Thanks. I love this kind of stuff. I love open-ended conversations and this was fun. So thank you so much for having me on today. You bet. Let's do it again. Stick around for 5 minutes. Bye everybody. The.

2:02:50 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.