Feb. 1, 2025

Episode #169: Standing With The LDS Church On Correct Principles W/Ben Winfield (NOT FOR ANYONE UNDER 16)

Episode #169: Standing With The LDS Church On Correct Principles W/Ben Winfield (NOT FOR ANYONE UNDER 16)
Episode #169: Standing With The LDS Church On Correct Principles W/Ben Winfield (NOT FOR ANYONE UNDER 16)
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #169: Standing With The LDS Church On Correct Principles W/Ben Winfield (NOT FOR ANYONE UNDER 16)

Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.

Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products

(THIS EPISODE IS FOR MORE MATURE AUDIENCES, SOME CLIPS I PLAY FROM A DIFFERENT PODCAST MAKE SEVERAL INAPPROPRIATE INNUENDOS AND I WOULD SUGGEST NOT LETTING ANYONE UNDER 16 LISTEN!!!)

While I won't play down the theological differences between Orthodox Mormonism and the LDS Church the truth is that there is a lot more that we have in common than not and as such when The LDS Church lines up with True Principles we should stand with them on that principle. This episode is one of those as me and my guest defend the LDS Church from a prominent Anti-Mormon podcaster. The LDS Church in the last couple months took a few steps in a direction I think most of us as Fundamentalists would agree with. They have presented new curriculum for their youth explaining the history around the LDS Church’s former practice of Celestial Plural Marriage. Now by presenting this information you would think that the anti/post Mormon community would be happy with this since they have been screaming for more transparency on Joseph Smith’s practice of plural marriage. However, the exact opposite is true. They railed on the curriculum material by calling it grooming. So, on this Ben Winfield and I breakdown not only the curriculum published by the LDS Church (which in my opinion is pretty darn good for LDS Youth) but also the response from a prominent anti-Mormon podcaster.

0:26 The you're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. You know, there were some things when I first started this podcast that I was fairly certain I wasn't ever going to have to do, right? Like, what's that? I thought I would never have to, you know, Well, there's a lot, but one of the things I thought I'd never have to do is like, literally like kind of stand with the LDS church on some stuff. But that's where being principled comes in, right? It's easy to to kind of draw lines in the sand and say, OK, you're with me, you're against me, that sort of a thing. But that's not always a great indicator of of where you really stand.

1:29 And and that's just more or less playing politics with people and organizations, right? And I think I think it's fundamentalist. We make the claim that we we try to stand on principle, right? We try to stand on truth, the history principle. And so sometimes you got to do things that you never thought you'd have to do. And this is going to be a little bit of a unique episode. So the church, the LDS church has come under some fire as of late from a certain O antagonist towards the church. You'll see him, don't worry, you'll see him. And we're going to go over that a little bit today. And there's two episodes we're going to look at that have just recently came out in the last few weeks, I guess.

2:16 And they deal with principles that that quite frankly, I feel like as Mormons, we should all be able to rally around, right. And so with that, we'll just kind of jump back in. Ben, it's dude, it's been a while. Yeah, it has been. Looks like you've lost some more weight. Yeah, doing well, Doing well with that. Family's doing good. Yeah, yeah, got got another baby on the way. Nice, so soon it's going to be a boy. Are you going, are you going like last time you disappointed me 'cause you didn't do the full like fundamentalist birthing thing? I mean, do you have a hand cart for your dear sweet wife to give birth in now?

3:01 Well, yeah, I mean, and it's, you know, really terrible weather. It's winter. I do plan on making her walk through the ice and when to. Oh, good, good. Not intended. Yes, yes, fantastic. All right, good. I just wanted to make sure we were, we were keeping up on things there, Ben. I didn't want you slacking it all. She's in the other room. She definitely didn't hear that. Sweetheart, we listen to this. These are all jokes. I love you so much. Yes, it's a secret between you, me, Mason and the 15,000 other people that are going to hear and see this. So I'm sure it will never get back to her because none of the things I ever say make it back to Amber and Tanya.

3:42 No, but just you know when you do listen to this sweetheart, your comfort is my highest priority and I love you. Well played, Sir, well played. So did you have to, like, lie to your wife when you came on and like, hey, I actually got to, like, go in here and like, do our bills? I mean, 'cause, you know, we haven't talked in a while. So I assume there's like a gentle feeling of relief when you haven't been talking to me now. Yeah, no, no, no, she, she's, she's pretty chill. OK, good, good. Just happy about it. I actually forgot to tell her till this morning and then I was like oh shoot. Well, you know the the girls both fell asleep. You know, we got 2 little girls and they're they're like they went to bed on time.

4:31 It was amazing so. You know, if there's one thing I. Found are perfect. That's perfect. If there's one thing I found that women really like, it's when you just spring things on them because they always like to have spontaneity, right? And there's nothing better than just coming home and being like, I got to go sequester myself in the office for a good half hour or hours, right? I mean, yeah, they love that. They say that they like spontaneity, but really I think that they just like presence, you know, because they're never really excited when you're like, hey, by the way, I'm going to go to a podcast tonight, so. Like you.

5:12 Know you're going to handle bedtime on on your own, probably. Right, right. Well, I was going to say, I suppose it depends on kind of the the husband, you are right. Like Amber and Tanya are like, oh, so you're going to be out of our hair for, I mean, gone for three hours and then they go to Joanne's and then that kind of hurts, but whatever. OK, all right, we're moving on. All right, so as we dive in here, the first place that we're going to kind of look at is the principle of plural marriage. So the church has just came out with some stuff that I felt like like there was a few things I disagreed with in there, but by and large, it was pretty good. And I just want to go over the whole thing because it's really short.

5:59 And then we'll dive into the critiques that that were made online. So let me share my screen here with you real quick, Ben. All right. And everybody else at home. OK, so, oh, there we go. There we go. Yeah, yeah, yeah. OK. You got that right? Yep. OK, perfect. So this is what the church put out and it's four kids. My, my guess is probably somewhere in the, in the 12 year old range, if I had to guess, right. But it, it does go over plural marriage. And to be fair, I, I believe this is the first time that the church actually takes steps to kind of explain plural marriage to their, to their youth in, in any sort of official capacity.

6:48 And so I just want to read through this. So here we got Joseph and I believe that's Martin Harris. I could be wrong. Who are are sitting there and they're they're going over the Bible and it says while the Prophet Joseph Smith was studying the Bible, he read about prophets like Abraham, Moses, who had been married to more than one wife. Joseph wondered how the Lord felt about it. So he decided to ask the Lord. The Lord said that usually a man should have one wife, but sometimes the Lord commanded his people to be in marriages of one man and more than one woman. This was called plural marriage. The Lord told Joseph that his people should only be in plural marriage if he commands it. Well, as as fundamentalists, we believe the Lord has commanded it.

7:38 Now the LDS Church, they don't. That's their deal, whatever that's on them. But for guys like Ben and I, we believe that this is still in force. I know the illusions they're making there to Jacob too as well. But really the the kind of main thrust there is if the Lord commands it. And 1:32 definitely says it's back on the table. So Ben, if I get anything wrong or something, you want to dive in deeper, you just jump in. Yeah, no, I mean, that's the the key to it. I mean, just kind of like, I think what's significant about all of the, the fact that the church is doing this at all is for anyone like maybe just a little bit younger than our age and older, we, this wasn't really discussed except for in passing.

8:35 If you grew up in the LDS church, like they used to have the like priesthood and relief society manuals and it was teachings of the presidents of the church. And every year was a new church president and it went through selections from their sermons about various topics. And each week you would study one and there would be kind of a biographical information thing on there. And until later, what they usually did is for all of the polygamist presidents of the church, they listed the the prophet's first wife. Let's say, you know, Wilfred Woodruff was married to so and so I think Phoebe was his first wife. And it was.

9:27 And then there'd be like a notation at the bottom where I would say like, oh, by the way, he did, you know, live plural marriage at the time. But, you know, we, we don't do that anymore. There'd be like this little footnote and then that was it. And so there really wasn't this like discussion of plural marriage. Sometimes you'd see, like for the Joseph Smith one, there was a notation that said we're just not including any teachings on plural marriage or the law of consecration because we don't do that, You know? So there was this thing where they could kind of say technically we're not like covering up the history. We're acknowledging it, but we don't want to talk about it. And we're going to move right past. And hopefully no one even read this section because it's the boring stuff that only the nerds read the beginning. Right, right, right.

10:25 Yeah, You know, look, I'll be honest, I applaud the church in this, right, Because I feel like they're being more open about it than they have been in the past, right. And they're they're they're introducing it to a younger, a younger demographic. Like I said, 12 is kind of where I thought this was appropriate. I don't know where all it's being used at in the church, but I feel like it's pretty appropriate, right? Yeah. So let let me finish read this here and then we'll kind of get the overall how, how, how we're all feeling about it. So moving on, it says a few years later, the Lord told Joseph to marry other women. Joseph didn't want to marry otherwise, but he knew it was a commandment from the Lord. When Joseph asked a woman to marry him, he told, he told her to pray about it and he wanted her to know from the Lord if it was right. This commandment was also hard for Joseph's first wife, Emma. Sometimes Emma helped Joseph decide who he shouldn't ask to marry him.

11:23 Other times, Emma did not want to Joseph to marry other women. Joseph taught the quorum of the 12 apostles about plural marriage. It was a hard commandment for them, too. Brigham Young and his wife, Mary Ann, prayed a lot to the Lord about what to do. They learned that they should obey the commandment of plural marriage. For many years, some of the Saints were asked to be in a plural marriage. In plural marriages, people outside the Church did not like plural marriage. They made laws against it. Some Saints, including church leaders, were put in prison. But the Lord blessed the families who obeyed His commandments even when it was hard.

12:03 In 1890, the Lord told Wilfred Woodruff, the president of the Church, that men should not marry more than one wife anymore. The leaders of the Church shared this commandment with the Saints. This is still the Lord's commandment today. A man should be, excuse me, a man should be married to only one wife. That's it. So let me kill this real quick. And I mean, that's that last. Part that I take issue with. Right, right, right. Yeah, Yeah. We are going to have different, different, different complaints with this. But overall, I felt like if you were introducing a group of kids to plural marriage in the from an LDS perspective.

12:44 Yeah. That's pretty good, right? I mean, that's that's out there. It's very honest. It addresses the fact that people struggled with it, that Emma struggled with it, that sometimes Joseph went ahead with plural marriages without her support. That's a touchy subject, a sensitive subject for a lot of people. And so nothing about that was dishonest. It was told in a very, I mean, it was told in a simple way. So that, yeah, probably I, I'd even say, you know, 8 to 10 year old like is going to follow that easily. And yeah, you know, so pretty, pretty honest, straightforward. OK.

13:36 All right. Mason, are you still on, Bud? Wait. No, I'm still here. I'm still. There you are any any issues you have with that from from like an LDS perspective, right. As fundamentalists, we're obviously going to take exception with a few things, but to explain it to a group of, you know, like Ben was saying somewhere between 8 and 12 year olds. Do you see anything in there that is problematic? No, I mean, I in my opinion, I think the presentation is pretty fair. It doesn't get too too deep into the history, obviously, but like Benjamin was saying, it addresses the concerns that people had. It addresses the rift that it caused between Joseph and Emma. It's not seeking to withhold any information. It's being forthright and honest, which is, ironically, what a lot of people on the other side of the fence have been asking the church to do for a very long time. Oh, you just wait.

14:32 We're about to find out how much they like this, OK? So all the, all the critics of the church must really like this. They love it. They love it, yes. They are right now like. Finally. Except for most. All of them. I mean, but minus those. Few, yeah. Bunch every, everyone's happy. All right, let me share my screen screen again here and we'll do this again. Is it? Grooming. Yes, yes. We'll, we'll hold off on that question until we get there, OK? We're we're gonna Yes, yes, it was beautiful. It was beautiful. OK, here we go.

15:12 Hello everyone and welcome to another stream of Mormon Stories podcast. I'm your host, John Delin. It's December 16th, 2024. The Mormon church has decided to teach polygamy to its children and to its adults. It's a crazy time and that's what we're covering today. So to kind of give you a tiny bit more explanation, in the recent online, I don't know, scriptures slash curriculum, there is a new sort of like cartoon styled telling brief telling of Joseph Smith's polygamy. There's a little photo of it for those joining us visually that tries to kind of communicate to kids the awesomeness and the necessity and the virtues of polygamy, which I'm just going to say at the outset, I don't sit around looking for things to complain about. I'm not a grievance seeker.

16:11 I'm. Sorry. Hang on. OK. All right. Yeah. No, I was going to stop right there, too. I would. Go the that's did did anyone get that? The did anyone read that? And they're like, yes, this is like awesome. This sounds so awesome. Like I, I, you know, like I think even a kid reading that is like, doesn't sound like a fun time. OK, yes, yes, I, I want to go over something he just said there where he said, you know, people must think I'd just sit around in my basement and look for things to be upset about. You know, like I, I'm not a grievance seeker, bro. Your whole brand is grievance seeking on Mormonism. Period.

16:56 Look, Dave and his defense, you know a fish doesn't know when it's wet. OK, All right. This is just, he's so immersed in all of this that, you know, it doesn't feel like he's looking for it, you know, 'cause that's just like his entire existence, you know? Like I have yet to see an episode of Mormon Stories where he's like, oh, well, good for you for staying in the church. Yeah, good. Congratulations on that, bro. Your whole brand, the whole thing is about grievance seeking. That's it. That's what you do. Just own it. Holy cow. Yeah, I, I make a living during this, but I, I, I promise, I, I, I, I basically do it on accident, you know? All right, all right.

17:48 So that was the first one I wanted to cover, right? Not let, let's get that out of the way. Not a grievance seeker. Well, and also like, but the the main point that he was making is that like the church is like just really trying to make believe me sound cool and hip and it's like, I don't even like, I mean, if they are, they're like, that wasn't a great way to do it, you know, I don't think. Yep, Yep, absolutely. All right, let's jump to here. Yeah, I know they were coming clean of their own volition, but we all know that it's the Internet that's forced the church to become honest. And with all the people hemorrhaging as they are leaving the church, that's probably true.

18:28 They realize they have to inoculate their youth and their children or those same people will feel betrayed when they become of age to stumble on Mormon stories of the CES Letter. So you stop. It right there. But if you just kind of. OK. So like that is the reason that he's upset is because that that I think he's correcting his assessment. That's exactly what the church is doing is that they are inoculating, which like they should. I was. Going to say is that bad? Though no, it's not a bad thing. It's bad for for them. It's bad for his brand because like, look, no fundamentalist like ever like leaves Mormonism because they were shocked to learn about polygamy, right?

19:24 Like that doesn't happen. I might leave for other reasons, but it's not because of that. It's not because they felt like they were kept in the dark because, you know, you kind of can't not see it with us. And so that's The thing is that in the church that you did, you had people like you have like general authorities whose kids are being like, you know, Joseph Smith was a polygamist, you know, and and they're like, oh, shoot, this became a problem. We were scared of people becoming fundamentalist. And we don't like being criticized. So we're just gonna like, stuff the polygamy away. And then it, and then it's like, now everyone is shocked and feels betrayed when they learn about it. And so then they're like, oh, shoot, OK, well, we do need to teach it, you know, And that's like, that's where it is. And The thing is, the reason that the that right there, the reason that he's upset with this and the reason the anti Mormons in general are upset about this is because like their biggest selling point on attacking the church is the narrative that you were lied to, you were betrayed.

20:37 This was kept from you. And if you were taught about it like right as soon as you were intellectually capable of like understanding it, then guess what? It wasn't being hidden from you and you can have whatever feelings you want about it, but you can't that that feeling that like I would, this was hidden for me just is not going to exist for future generations of the church. And that's the big like sting behind a lot of the the anti marine that kind of takes the wind out of their sails. So, so you think that that what he's really upset about is that it's going to hurt the brand? Yeah, yeah, it hurts their brand. The non grievances grievance seeking brand. Right.

21:26 Because like, yeah, maybe people are still going to be upset about thorough marriage, but what younger generations aren't going to be saying that like millennials and older were saying is Oh my gosh, I had no idea. Like that just isn't going to exist anymore. And that was like kind of the big thing that made anyone pay attention to John Dylan is like, he was the guy who was coming with the goods to tell you all the things that they weren't telling you about. Right now. I can't do that 'cause they they were. Now they're being honest about it. And yeah, like, it probably is because of the Internet, but it's that's the thing that he's upset about.

22:12 They lose the shock value. Right, right. Look, if, if, if the church is honestly concerned with its members, which I think it is, I think they see the, the errors that were perpetuated in the past with kind of deep 6 in the information, right? And so they're like, OK, well, let's keep them in the boat, right? And, and look, I think we would both agree, right? As fundamental as Ben, we would much rather see somebody in in the church then running into post Mormonism, right. We once you know that I I get it right. That's the best place for some folks. And and if that's where they're the Lord tells them to be, that's where they should be. And so if the church is trying to fulfill that part of its mission, and it is, it is, you know, noticing that people are leaving because of the shock value of all of a sudden finding out that Joseph was a polygamist, well, then, yeah, you as a responsible shepherd, you would take whatever, whatever's in front of you and and try to fix that. And, you know, granted, in a perfect world where all men were angels and everybody was always on the up and up, you'd have led with this years ago, right?

23:25 You'd have done this before it became shock value. So I don't want to completely absolve the Church of, of doing what it did. At the same time, it's trying to make corrective steps. And as they make those corrective steps, I, I think that that when it's towards the side of truth, I think you got to kind of support that a little bit. The other thing I would say here is he, he seems to by saying, yeah, it's just because of the Internet. He is like saying, well, it really doesn't count as a good thing if that's the only reason they're doing it for. Well, let's look at this from a personal standpoint. When I go to the doctor and I get a blood draw and he's like, bro, I found your problem.

24:09 There's 4 cheeseburgers, 2 pizzas and a six pack rolling around in your bloodstream. You need to stop it and you need to go to the gym. If I go to the gym for the only reason that I'm scared for my health, is that a bad thing? No, no, it, it's a corrective measure to what I was doing before. And so on an institutional level, that's what's happening here, right? For their own health and fitness, so to speak, they need to, you know, cut out all the cupcake deep sixing and all the pizzas and just come clean with the steak of truth. And so that's what we're seeing here.

24:50 Steak of truth. I like that. That's I'm going. To put that on a T-shirt. Yeah, yeah, that's a good one. Yeah. So right. And now the, I'll say even in kind of defense of that, the church has covered up stuff. And you want an example of that is you go to the Adam God doctrine. And like that the church like did their very best to put that down the 1984 memory hole. Yep they did. This doesn't exist. Anti Mormons made it up. Brigham was taken out of Brigham never said that, but he was taken out of context. That's not what he meant. OK, that is what he meant, but technically he was wrong. You know, like everything they could. So it's not like the church is like guilt free on this. But on this topic, if you go back to like the pre Internet world, this information was available, you know, you just had to work at it.

25:52 You had to go looking for it. And the church wasn't hiding it. They were not putting it front and center. They weren't making sure that you know about it. But it was out there. If if you were motivated. And I think that what they were struggling to balance is, you know, they made the deal with the devil in 1890 where they they've got to go along with Babylon, but they so they don't want people going to fundamentals. They don't want them reading Truth magazine and going off and becoming gleamous. But then they also mainly want to look good to like the modern Christian world.

26:42 And so really de emphasizing this kind of pushing it in the corner. And I think that was like their motivation, which is still wrong, but I don't think it rises to this level of like, we are trying to cover this up and hide it. So no one knows, you know? But anyway, that's all I'll say on that, all right? Let's let's move on here. Woe is Joseph, this was so hard. This is how it was presented to us, right? And and I was I was told many times, don't worry about it, Sister Helfer, don't This is we're no longer practicing at Sister Helfer. This was just in the moment.

27:28 It was difficult. But then what really kind of gets to people, and This is why I don't think it's transparent, is that you find out the truth. You find out like you read the historical journals of women who were in polygamy. He realized this is not that. The little story and how it's portrayed is not real. Yeah, Yep. And I'll just add like would if once you know the details of Joseph Smith's polygamy, and I'm sure there's a lot of you that don't know, he married 14 year old girls, He married sister pairs. He married foster children that were entrusted to his care. He he married mother, daughter pairs. And again, 22 wives were unbeknownst to his first wife, Emma.

28:22 So again, it would to call it the law of the Lord and to frame Joseph Smith's polygamy as being the law of the Lord means that God condones his profits to be sexual predators and pedophiles on children. I don't is that too extreme? Like some people don't like using the term pedophile with Joseph Smith and I I don't know what age I don't I actually don't. Maybe you know Natasha, what age counts as pedophilia and if if what he did with with 14 year olds counts as that according to your understanding?

29:03 Yeah, So this, so I do hear this a lot. And if we're going to be sticklers on vocabulary, he actually was not a pedophile. A pedophile. The the correct definition of that is sexual attraction to prepubescent children, right. So people who have not gone through puberty, a phebophilia is attraction to adolescents and minors who have gone through puberty. So even at the time, which is another way that I think this gets minimized, people will say, well, back then it was normal for girls who were 14 to be having sex and getting married. That actually was not true. There were standards of youth development even in the 1800s around what was deemed appropriate time to mate and to marry and to have sex.

29:49 Yeah, and it wasn't 14, right? But he was a predator. Yes, I do agree with that language and I do agree that. All right, I'll have to unpack there. Go ahead. Ben So yeah, I I guess it's good that she pointed out that it's not a pedophile. Like, thanks for that. That's good. He's not a predator either. Everyone like had agency in this. I think a lot of the stories get kind of manipulated in the way that they're, they're told to put pressure on it. But concerning Helen Mark Kimball, that's the that's the young wife that we actually do know stuff about. I think I I'm drawing a blank on the the other young wife. Those are about the same age.

30:54 I don't think we really just have a lot of documents from that. But Helen Mark Kimball says that they they did not have a physical relationship. Well, yeah. And go ahead. And so so she says that that's like pretty well understood by people who look into this, you know, so like, that's really not like they they just didn't. Now, I am a person who's of the opinion that if you want to know, like what Joseph Smith's practice of plural marriage would have looked like had he been free to kind of do it openly.

31:39 Like look at Brigham Young and you're going to get, I think I'm, I believe Brigham Young is a prophet. I believe he was the rightful successor to Joseph Smith. And I believe that while not a perfect person, he was sincerely doing his level best to do things the way that Joseph Smith had them done. When young marriages were allowed, the council was specifically that those marriages should not be consummated at A at a young age and like the evidence shows that that pretty well followed.

32:22 So I don't believe that Joseph and had a physical. Say that again, you kind of broke up. I said I don't believe that Joseph and Helen Mark Campbell ever had AI. Don't think there's any. No, I don't think they had a sexual relationship either. And one of the things that, and look, it's my opinion that I think these folks are falling in the same trap that a lot of people fall into, which is this idea that Joseph gets a revelation and he knows all the insurance and outs about whatever ordinance or principal he just got a revelation on, right? I think what history tends to show if, if you're looking at honest history and trying to do an assessment there, it's that he would receive a revelation and then often go back with more questions for clarification and start working out the details, right?

33:18 I think a good example of this is when baptism for the dead kicks off, right? And everyone just rushes down to the Mississippi and they just go at it, right? And Joseph has to come along and go, whoa, whoa, whoa. I don't think this is what the Lord meant. Let's back it up a little bit and let's let's talk about this. So I think with sealing today in Mormon culture, we tend to look at ceilings as kind of a romantic thing, right? It is a husband and wife who have fallen in love who are now going to the appropriate place with the appropriate authority to become husband and wife. My contention is, is I'm not sure that when when this idea of sealing first comes out along with plural marriage, that that there's a really good understanding of what it looks like, Right?

34:09 And so if you read a lot of Joseph Smith, he's talking about sealing not just his family together, but all the families in the church together, right? And so I think I think what, what what we're looking at here is, is kind of almost an adoption thing in some ways with some, not all of them, right? I want to be clear on that, right? I do believe that Joseph Smith did practice plural marriage and had romantic relations with some of his wives, but I think there's some of that that's doesn't fall under that category. So to blatantly put this on Joseph that hey, he's just this old dude out there gooning after a younger, you know, adolescent girl just doesn't hold water with what all we know. The other thing I'll say is is you know, it, it talks about, you know, and, and I'll just kind of be it to the punch here, the polyandry stuff with Joseph.

35:08 I think almost all of the women that he, he was sealed to that already had husbands. We know Joseph had the ability to have children, right? Him and Emma had biological children. Why is it we can't find any heirs from those women, right, or from Helen Mark Kimball or something like that? The reason is is because it probably didn't happen. Yeah, that's well. And that's my. Thoughts on it? And that's the point that the polygamy deniers like to to bring up. And, you know, the the problem with that is that, you know, it's kind of hard to like prove like two people did or didn't have sex 200 years ago.

35:58 You know, like, OK, well, they didn't have children. It's like, all right, Well, you know, having children, it's like a really good evidence that you did, but not having them isn't necessarily evidence that you you did or didn't. So like that's kind of sparky there. And, and I, I do want to be careful cause a lot of like the polygamy denier go to this like, 'cause when you press them on ceilings, they're like, Oh, well, yeah, it was just this dynastic thing, which there is a dynastic element to it, but they try to just like shovel that away.

36:40 Now, what I'll say is like a good example of what you're talking about is Fanny Young, Brigham Young's older sister. The story goes that Brigham and, and Joseph are talking to her. She's older. I think she's like 13 years older than Brigham Young. And she has had a a couple of unhappy marriages. I think 1 ended in death and another divorce. And it was. And so Joseph teaches, yeah, you need to be married and sealed for exaltation. And she basically says, count me out. I would rather just be a ministering Angel. You know, I don't want to do marriage again. Didn't work out.

37:30 And Joseph basically says, no, you don't know what you're talking about. Like, please don't deprive yourself that blessing. And he says to Brigham, I want you to seal her to me now so that she has that as a as a an option for the next life. I'm like, they were sealed. And that is basically the extent of that marriage as far as like this mortal life is concerned. So there there was like sometimes there were ceilings that were just for the ordinance, like so that could be done. And then other times, yeah, there there were ceilings and it was a full like cohabitating marriage that we'd expect.

38:17 And so I think, you know, when you have it, that many wives, you have that many relationships, they're all different. This is all being done in secret. So I really don't like when people just sort of like muddy the waters and try and make them all the the same thing. You really? Got to look at like a, they're going to be as individual as any other marriage, right? And and that's, that's kind of the bottom line. Mason, is there anything you want to add to that? You know, there is. I've been stealing on this for a minute. You know a careful reading of Doctrine Covenant section 132. This is verse 60. It reads. Let no one therefore set on my servant Joseph, for I will justify him, for he shall do the sacrifice which I required his hands for his transgression, saith the Lord your God.

39:07 We don't follow like the Sunnah of Joseph Smith. You know we. Don't we don't look to him as like this perfect figure in our religion that's we did. We don't think about him in the same way that the Muslims look to Muhammad. So it's perfectly understandable. And we have documented history of Joseph being rebuked in the scriptures, examples like the one that I just read where the Lord references his transgressions. And so we, we don't need to die on this hill that he did everything perfectly, but there's no error in his revelation. You know, at the end of the day, even if there were mishaps or mistakes in the implementation, that doesn't mean that plural marriage is not a true principle or that the doctrine outlined in section 132 is not the way that the universe is governed.

40:04 You know it. That's that's all a secondary historical issue. And we read in the Scriptures history of the prophets who received revelations, and they. They didn't act on them like Jonah who ran from his calling or they failed to implement them properly. Like that's a huge theme in Exodus where Moses is struggling to get the Israelites to do what the Lord is commanding them to do. And I just, I don't understand where, where they're coming from with this. They're basically holding him to a higher standard than they would any other biblical figure. You know, nobody talks about how Moses did this or Abraham did this because it's evident that they were men, even though they handed, they held such a high calling and they they made mistakes in that office.

41:02 But Even so, they held that office. And the doctrine they they produced is still true. David lost his exultation and we still read the songs to this day. You know, yeah. It's that's a really good point. And they're just to like go along with that. Joseph made that point explicitly. And the book Remembering Joseph, it's a great book. It's just a collection of people, individual people's recollections of their experiences with Joseph Smith. And there's a story that gets told in Zion's camp where Joseph is teaching about how you shouldn't kill animals wastefully, like you shouldn't just kill them for sport. If you kill an animal, you should use it. You should eat the meat.

41:51 Like, you know, you should do that with gratitude. And he completes the sermon, and then he walks away. He sees a squirrel in the tree. He shoots it down, and then he just walks past and just leaves it there. And so then the brethren got up and they picked up the squirrel. They prepared it, they cooked it, and they ate it. And Joseph said that that was good. He said that he was happy to see that they learned by principle and not by example. He he, he did that explicitly to say, if you see me doing something wrong, are you going to follow my example or are you going to follow the precept?

42:35 So yeah, you study Section 132, I think. I don't know that anyone really knows what was going on with those like, you know, polyandrous marriages is their term. Section 132 doesn't allow it. Like the law that Joseph gave us from the Lord that it it does not allow it. So yeah, I don't know what's going on. Maybe there are other circumstances. Maybe just was wrong. I don't I don't fully understand that and I haven't talked to anyone who I felt did. But yeah, that's that's correct. I think I'm really gotten Mason about that. Perfect. All right, let's continue on here. Let me go down to the next one.

43:22 And so that scripture was saying, don't be a polygamist. And then for the first several decades in the Mormon church's history, the doctrine of Covenants itself said that men should only have one wife and women one husband. And so. Right, let's see. Oh, this is a picture of. Describe Joseph's picture. He is devastated. He is sitting kneeling by his bed with his head in his hands. He is distressed. He is tormented at this horrible commandment that God gives. Exactly because as as long as we can imagine Joseph to be a victim, then we can just forget that the other people in this story are also victims and we can feel bad for Joseph and just be like wow, God is such a sneaky guy OK.

44:07 Is this picture making you tear up at Joseph Smith and Tasha? It's. Just making me so sad for his hardness. OK, keep. Going a few years later, the Lord told Joseph to marry other women. Poor Joe Joseph didn't want to marry other wives, but he knew it was a commandment from the Lord. He had no choice. That was my, that was my addition. When Joseph asked a woman to marry him, he told her to pray about it. He wanted her to know from the Lord that it was right. All right, any what? What don't you like about that, Alyssa? OK. I mean, I think it is misleading, kind of going back to Natasha's point that this is not necessarily a transparent scripture story that Joseph is asking other women to to pray about it because many times the women would pray about it, say, no, this happened, you know, repeatedly. And Lucy Walker's the first person I'm thinking of right now.

45:06 And then he would basically say, like, oh, you need ask again. And then then they would say that it was OK or he would threaten physical violence if she didn't marry him. And so then she would say, OK, so it's this, you know, coerced coercion rather than actual consent that they are just trying to spin around into being. Oh, yeah. As long as she knew it was right also. Totally. It was totally fine. He was sad and the woman was totally fine, is kind of how this slide reads. Yeah, and and if you read some of the accounts, he was like mayor, like head of the Nabu Legion prophet, like Chief Justice. He held all the titles.

45:49 And then he'll corner this teenage girl in a room, close the door, parents aren't there, literally a minor. And then say, hey, God told God told me that I need to marry you. And if you do it, he would add, not only you, but all your parents and posterity will be saved in the highest degree of heaven. And if you and if you don't, then I, I don't know that you'll be damned. I mean, that's the implication. I don't know whether you're centered or not. So it's just a awfully, horribly coercive proposal. So that I don't like, he's like. No, just think. About it and if. It all right, Ben?

46:30 Yeah. So, yeah, I don't know if you actually said that, like maybe maybe you should look into that first. Yeah. Again, like you're completing a lot of different stories or he's completing a lot of different stories together in the the same thing there. And you know, like in the case of like the only one that I'm aware of where Joseph says like, not only you, but your family will be exalted because of this is Helen Mark Kimball. Again.

47:10 And what is often left out of that scenario is the reason kind of why that was said is it was it wasn't Joseph who sought marriage to Helen Mark Kimball. It was it was her father, it was Heber C Kimball who wanted to have his daughter sealed to the prophet. And so like, it really was the the family was kind of doing this together, like they, they were involved in it. And that's why, like, Joseph is recognizing that they are making a sacrifice, like together, they're like displaying an act of faith all together.

47:58 And he is promising them blessings because of that, You know, like, that's what happened. And then, you know, when you take like, oh, he's like, he didn't corner her. He didn't threaten her with violence like that. That isn't at all what happened. It was like Heber C Campbell goes to his wife and his daughter, they all go to Joseph and he gives them this blessing because of their active faith. Like that's how about it? I have like the levels at which they go here in describing this.

48:39 I'm just left going, how do you know? How do you know? Do you have documents that that you know? And maybe they do, but I doubt it. There's nothing that I have read that would indicate that this was a predatory kind of a thing, right? That that Joseph was using his position of power to acquire wives, right? Well, and we also have evidence like to the contrary and the case of like Hubert J Grant's mother, Rachel Ivins. She was a a woman that Joseph proposed to and she said no and that was respected, you know, and so much so that like after his passing, she requested to be sealed to him vicariously.

49:32 So like, you know, like she doesn't come with any story of like Joseph threaten me. He cornered me like, you know, like, or I just, I just had to because he was the mayor, you know, like, like that's. Six dig mayors Ben there's I mean, that's. OK, well, yeah, but you know, again. Look that. Doesn't mean that like consent can't happen. Mayors are allowed to to fight love. OK, we we don't once you become the mayor, we don't lock you up and say hey, don't. You're this is a bone I.

50:18 Think I think it's a little obscure doctrine, kind of like Catholic priests. Once you become mayor, mayor, you become celibate. I think it's in there somewhere, I think. It's that if, well, if you were an ethical person and you were a mayor, you would, you would become celibate. You know, you're like, you just go to even if you're married, you turn to your wife and say, look, now that I'm mayor, there's an unhealthy power imbalance in our marriage. We can never have sex again. I'm sorry. This is the way it's got to be. I am the mayor and it would be unethical for us to have a relationship with this power imbalance that we have. Right, right. If you yes, yes.

50:58 So I mean, there there is that you know, the only problem I see with their argument right there is that it just does not seem to be the majority of the experiences that are had, right. You have women who will say, look, that was me and Joseph's marriage. I'm not going to talk about it again. Other women who talk about it in, in glowing terms being being sealed to, to Joseph Smith. There's, there's a lot out there and I feel like they, they take maybe the lowest hanging fruit, if you will, the the one that's the most scandalous and then they build their narrative around that. Well, and they can't even be honest about it because that one is I, I think probably the most controversial of Joseph's wives is Hella Mark Campbell.

51:53 And they can't even be honest about her because they, you know, like, for a long time, they would take like, she wrote these poems when she was a teenager about how she felt like she was a bird locked in a cage. And they tried to, like, show that that was, like, her way of describing her trauma and having being forced in this sexual relationship. And really, like, in context, it's actually quite clear that she was mad because her dad wouldn't let her. One, she wasn't cohabitating with Joseph.

52:34 And two, she was mad that her dad wouldn't let her go to dances anymore because he said, well, yeah, I know. But still, technically you're you're a married woman. It's not appropriate for you to go be dancing with boys. So I I don't want you going to dances like that. Was it She was mad that she couldn't go to a dance Like it was like and and that gets twisted. And the other thing that they they drop Helen Mark Kimball really quick that they only are interested in her at this young point in her life. They don't want to find anything about what happened to the rest of her life because she grew up to be one of the most outspoken advocates for plural marriage that the church has ever had. She she wrote extensively about it. She was politically active in defending plural marriage when she she got married.

53:31 Later, she insisted that her husband live plural marriage. She pushed him and encouraged him to to take other wives like she was 100% on board. She said that she would never want to live in a monogamous marriage, ever. So what you're saying is, is that for Helen Mark Kimball, it was so bad she did it all over again? Yeah, like she insisted her husband was not, like, super excited about it, you know, like he, she was the one who was, like, really pushing it. And if this had been this horrible thing, like she had ample opportunity to, like, not go along with it. And you can say, oh, well, she was Heber C Campbell's daughter. It's like, yeah, but he had kids who left the church. Yeah, then they didn't, they didn't stick the Danites after them.

54:26 No, like it was fine. This was something that was very clearly she was convicted of and passionate about. And if that's ever mentioned, it is glossed over. They try to kind of insinuate that maybe it was Stockholm syndrome or something like that. It's just they're, they're, they either completely ignore the totality of her life or they they lie about it. Yep, absolutely. And and you're 100% correct. I've had Hannah Stoddard on here and we did a whole episode about Helen Mark Kimble and and I've I've talked with oh, I'm blanking.

55:16 Sucks getting old. Oh, Kimberly Watson Smith, man, Sorry about that, folks. Yeah, Kimberly Watson Smith. We've talked about the women of Mormondum, you know, who were advocates of plural marriage on this podcast. And those are very inconvenient narratives for for people who who want to find fault with plural marriage and its principle. Because if, if you have faith promoting testimonies of it from the women who are the ones who were supposed to be oppressed in this, it, it doesn't bode real well for your argument, right? Yeah. And they won't. Like you said, they cut that off as quickly as they can. Cause the last thing they want is for you to see the rest of Helen Mark Kimball's life.

56:03 Well, you know, they've got, they've got a narrative to promote and and that becomes really clear because if you are, if you're after the truth and you come across something that contradicts your beliefs, if you're an honest person, you're like, well, that isn't what I expected. You know, you don't have to change your beliefs. I've run into stuff all the time. We like, acknowledge that just just in this episode, we don't really know what was going on with polyandry. I don't like it. I don't. I don't fully know exactly what was going on with that, you know, but like, because I'm an honest person, I acknowledge.

56:44 Yeah, like, that's a thing that conflicts with my beliefs, and it's there. I don't know what the full story going on, you know? And if you're this person who wants Helen Mark Kimball to be a victim, if you're honest, you have to say OK. The whole rest of her life entirely goes against what I believe about her. Yep. And if you're not doing that, if you're refusing to do that, you aren't honest. You're promoting a narrative, and you're only selecting the stuff that agrees with what you want. You know, I am concerned for you, Ben, because you said you're not totally, you know, understanding of the whole polyandry thing and you don't like it.

57:27 I feel like what you need to do is start your own podcast and just, you know, come out with all these sensational claims. I mean. There may. Or may not be money in that I don't know yet. You know, there there could be a whole subsection of a people. I would never want to accuse you of being a grievance seeker, but I'm just saying there may be some money there. I don't know. Was hurt by Joseph Spaley. Andrew, you know, I haven't been as active on TikTok lately, what with the whole, like, band thing, but I hear that there's a new Chinese app that everyone's like jumping onto. So maybe I'll go talk to the the Chinese about Yeah, on Red Note.

58:13 Yeah, I think the Chinese are super concerned with Joseph Smith's polyandry. I think that they want to know. I think, I think the people want to know, Yeah. Mason, you got anything you want to add there, bud? No, I think we've pretty much covered everything there. OK, good enough. All right, here we go. Let's let's go ahead and let's move on again. You know, actually, before we move on, I want to say one other thing. They they sat there and kind of mocked Joseph like, oh, I'm sure it was so tough for him. Look, this is a dude that's had the crap kicked out of him for simply introducing a new Scripture, right? And so I can only imagine how excited he must be truly to go and upset Victorian society by introducing a new a new, new form of marriage, right? That goes against Victorian sensibilities. And I think it's I think it's pretty disingenuous if you know, you're trying to do honest history here a little bit and look at it and say, well, maybe it was tough, right? I wouldn't want to introduce that Ben. I mean, maybe he would, but I I'd be like, Nope, not me. Sorry you got the wrong dude.

59:31 Well, and, you know, it's, it's one thing to say like, Oh yeah, you know, guys, 'cause we know about like guys that cheat on their wives and their pastors that, you know, give these like fearful confessions about how they, you know, were unfaithful to their, their wives and all this stuff. So it's not as if like that stuff doesn't happen. But man, this seems like a bad way to go about like if that's what you're, if you're just. You know, aren't happy with your wife and, and you're you're looking for more. This seems like just about the worst possible way to to go about that. There's just a lot easier ways that are more socially acceptable.

1:00:19 And even back then, like it's it's never been the case that adultery has been more offensive to American Society than plural marriage and that and like really like people should stop and contemplate that just a bit like a man can abandoned his wife and children and go marry a younger, hotter woman. And at most he gets kind of tut tutted. But it's 100% legal and pretty much everyone's going to go along with it, right? And so like, we're OK with broken homes, we're OK with, I mean, and a man can do that multiple. You can have, you can have 3 or 4 wives in a row. But like, we're going to lose our minds if like, why is it that if let's just make it simple with two wives, why is it worse for a man to have two wives where he cares for them, cares for their children, They're all together, it's all open and honest, They're living in harmony. Why is that worse than breaking up a marriage, destroying a family, having all this like heartache and then going on to to someone else?

1:01:51 Like why is it that like that second one is the one that our society prefers, right? That's a horrible situation. It's bad for kids. It's terrible. But like American Society looks at the first one and says, Oh my gosh, that's horrible When like they're they're fine. Maybe they don't like it kinda, but like not really, right? Right. Nope, I agree. I agree. And and I want to point something else out here just so I I feel like I have to make this disclaimer so everybody knows I am not espousing marrying underage girls, right? That is bad.

1:02:34 Do not do that. Right. Don't. It's, it's a scuzzy thing to do today. Don't do it, right? Frontier America is a little different than 2025, right? Right. Don't. Don't. I'm not, I'm not advocating for marrying underage brides and I don't think you are either, Brent. So no. And. Mike yeah, don't do it. Don't just bad, don't do it. We don't need to overanalyze that one. No, no. All right, here we go. Moving on. OK, this one, Joseph. And this is also just visually interesting considering that the idea of plural marriage is about a man with with multiple women, and we never see an image of that. Interestingly enough, we do see an image of Joseph standing in the center of a group of men who are the 12 apostles, which just kind of made me chuckle a little bit that that even in a story that's all about multiple women, we're still quite literally centering the.

1:03:37 Man. Standing in the middle of a circle of men, so that that was just, it was like almost funny. That's a good point, I didn't think of that. There's no photo of Joseph with this 32 wives or Brigham. Yeah. With this or even 5 wives or two. Wives. Yeah. We, we don't see them. We don't. We don't. They're never named. None of them. Right. We never hear. It may name one. It may name. One it may, perhaps they do OK, OK. Anyway, circle of men. Very, very Mormon, right? Natasha? Does that look familiar to you, Natasha? I'll just be. Quiet, you're about to expose. Yeah, we're all very familiar and comfortable with this image, so. OK, you're about. I can see you just like wanting to erupt. Yes, yes.

1:04:20 So First off, what do you want, right? That's the question I want to ask them. What do you want? Right, we want to be mad. Right. I'm like, I do not understand what you want. Like holy cow. So the church like comes out and does what you want, right? Be more transparent, not transparent enough. And gosh darn it, Ben, there's the patriarchy gag and just trying to keep women down, you know, 'cause it's just showing Joseph teaching the 12 apostles. Hold on.

1:05:03 The whole name of that segment is Joseph teaches the Quorum of the 12 Apostles. You know what? If you want women in the apostlehood, the RLDS are right down the road. You can go jam with them. They're there. Well, that's not what they really want. No, no, that's not what they want. And now here is where I think we and, and this is the whole reason I wanted to bring this segment up. There is a whole segment of post Mormonism now that is into some crazy swinger kind of stuff, right? It's it's almost a meme at this point. It is.

1:05:44 It is. So that's OK. But the second a man takes care of more than one woman, that's when the feminists come out with their fangs bared, ready to go for the throat, right? So just do me a favor on the other side of that argument. Just be consistent, right? That's all I asked for. Be consistent. Don't now one. Thing. Oh, go ahead. Don't. Don't couch your hedonism as trying to be more moral than a family system. Right, Because one side will produce children, one side will have, can have happy, healthy families. Are there bad polygamist families? You bet.

1:06:27 Just like there's bad monogamist families, right? What? What you're really complaining about here is the fact that you just can't get rid of the patriarchy, I think is what is spoiling. Yeah, well, they, they want to be mad no matter what. Now, like the I'm kind of with her a little bit to begin with, where I I would actually really like to see more artistic depictions of plural marriage, especially in historical settings. I like that image of Joseph with all of his wives. I would love to see that.

1:07:09 That would that would be great. You know, like boy in my house. And to like present and and and it is kind of a fairpoint to like for them to criticize the church that like there is no actual depiction of multiple wives in this. And I think, and this sort of goes against like the anti's narrative that the church is like promoting plural marriage here because they're, they're very careful not to depict that, right? Because what they want to do is they want to kind of release the, the tension, get rid of the, the shock value, make sure that like people are aware that this happened, but they don't want it to look attractive and they don't, they don't want you to have a visual of a happy plural family, right? They, they, they don't want that. And so that, that, that really isn't, and I would like to see that.

1:08:21 I, I would 100% love to see more of those kinds of depictions in, in art. That'd be great. My only push back to her argument on that 'cause I agree, right? I would like to see more artwork that depicts healthy plural families right? However it. Isn't quite ready. I've tried. What's that? I said AI isn't quite ready for the task. I've I've tried you've. Tried. You've tried. OK, fair. Fair enough. We'll, I'm sure it'll get there. But I think it's important to remember that this was meant for youth, right? That you're diving into a youth thing. This is, look, it's sketched like a cartoon for a reason, right?

1:09:07 They're trying to present this in such a way that, as we've said, an 8 to 12 year old can wrap their minds around it and be like, OK, this is what happened. The other thing I would say about that, about the whole picture thing, is they may not be shown, at least back in the day for a reason, right? I mean, Joseph was killed, right? You know, you don't want to just show who his family was in those days because you don't know. Who Joseph never did live openly with his Yep. Absolutely, Mason. Anything you want to chime in there bud? You know, I think another kind of topic for discussion here is that plural marriage isn't just something that happened in the past, right?

1:10:03 It's it's a very much an ongoing thing, although it's not I. Had no idea, but it's right. And it's like we're. Completely ignoring everything we have about it today. You know, we can, I've, I've been and I've observed happy people in plural marriage. I've seen well functioning plural families. It it exists, You know, we don't need to look into the past to try to find it. We don't need to look into the past to find justification. We're standing in front of it. You know, we're having this this lofty historical debate about the way that it was introduced and whether or not it can stand on its leg historically.

1:10:48 But the fact of the matter is we have it standing right in front of us. And although there are occasions where it's proven to be a great detriment to the people involved, like in the case of Warren Jeffs, for example, those are primarily what everyone would consider to be perversions of a very sacred practice. And then more often than not, you know, from what I understand, most practicing fundamentalists, especially people who have actually entered in the principal, don't really belong to any organized group. They're just independents living on their own. You actually go into their homes, you visit with them, you speak with them and you observe their conditions generally and you're able to see that it's not that different from any other family like. We're we're.

1:11:38 Making something way, way more foreign than it actually is because they're I, I say we because they're thinking about it as though it happened only in the past. Only something that we can understand through the past, through through these glasses where we don't know what's going on very well. But it's right here. You know what I'm saying? Yep. Yep, I do, I do. All right, let's go ahead and let's let's move on here. There's a whole other video I want to get to tonight. Oh yeah, we got BYU professors. Yeah, No, we're going to do 2 more sections out of this.

1:12:21 And then for the sake of time, we're going to move on to to the other video. Moving on, we have for many years some of the Saints were asked to be in plural marriages and this is I think when it starts to get a little bit interesting. Oh it it hasn't been interesting so far. Yeah, so far it's been. Just nothing, OK. People outside the church did not like plural marriage. They made laws against it. Some Saints, including church leaders, were put in prison. But the Lord blessed the families who obeyed His commandments even when it was hard. Can't leave that word. Alone. No, they're really doubling down. I just can't. Yeah.

1:13:06 And you know, OK, Natasha, you were mentioning this previously, but I've actually researched. So my maternal grandmother, Karma Benson Parkinson, she's cousins to former Mormon prophet Ashtab Benson. She was the daughter of a third wife and there were 4 total wives in my great grandfather. My great grandparents marriage there ended up being 4 wives. My grandma Karma was the daughter of of a third wife and I've studied the lives of the four my 4 great grandmothers on my mom's side. OK and this idea that the the Lord bless the families who obeyed his commandments not true. Not true in my case, not true.

1:13:56 So as an example, after my great grandpa had married two of the women, somehow he like, goes off on a mission to Europe while he's got 2 wives and, you know, kids at home and one of them was pregnant. One of his wives, they were living in poverty, you know, impoverished circumstances while he's gallivanting around Europe. The second wife, if my memory is correct, loses the baby while he's gone. So not only does the baby die, but he's not even there when she's, you know, when she loses the baby. Then when he moves on to his third and 4th wives, it's not like he stayed connected to the first two wives.

1:14:41 It was like, OK, they're established, she's older, they've got the nice house and the kids are older. They can help out. He moves on to the younger wives and stops coming around with the older wives. And then and then the fourth wife who we brought on late, she ended up, you know, having health problems. They ended up getting divorced. It was this huge public scandal. She got addicted to opiates and she ended up like, you know, being run off to Oregon, embarrassed in this, you know, Cash Valley wide scandal, cursing her former husband and, you know, her, her involvement in the Mormon church ever so just in my family's case, it was a disaster for several of the families in many ways. All right, Ben, go ahead.

1:15:42 So yeah, this whole thing is like, oh, here's a situation with plural marriage where people experienced some level of unhappiness, therefore it is bad. It's like we don't apply that standard to monogamy. I don't know, keep the feminists another six months, They'll get there. Well, yeah, I mean, and a lot of them do. Some of the hardcore feminists do like they they do say like, oh, look, there's this domestic violence thing. There's this, there's that we we can't have any, any kind of marriage at all.

1:16:25 There, there are like there are, there are, there's a strain of feminism that says that you're not a true feminist if you aren't a lesbian. But like, it's out there. I know, I know it is. But this is where they're they're going at it. Like I know of monogamous couples where someone got addicted to substances and it destroyed their their marriage. I know monogamous marriages where husband was not attentive to his wife and ignored her and went on to, you know, like there are a lot of bad monogamous situations and like just be consistent in your, your logic.

1:17:19 If you can say, hey, here's a bad situation, therefore it's bad for everyone. Even if it's good for you, it's still bad for you because it was bad for this person, right? Because that's what you're doing with, with plural marriage. And like Mason was talking about, like when people bring this up, I, I always say like, OK, like how many plural, how many polygamous friends do you have? Like, tell me what plural family you have, like gone into their home and had dinner with, you know, like tell me what plural family where you know the names of their children. Right. You know, and because when you actually know people and you get to see them, you see it's a different situation. And yeah, there is a, there's a huge variety and there are, there are abuses, but there's a lot of like really good, honest people.

1:18:18 And I'd, I'd say that that's going to be the majority of the plural families that you're going to meet is like pretty decent, shockingly normal people who, who are doing this. And you know, like, and even if you want to go historical, like Brigham Young, there were marriages that didn't work out with him, but he also had wives who sung his praises and spoke of how how much they loved him. You know, like, if you if you are actually like, oh, I want the truth of it, you need to examine the things that go against what you want.

1:19:01 And in their case it is happy polygamist who like their situation. Yep, they want those to not exist. You know, you know, there's two names that they do not ever bring up when it comes to criticizing plural marriage. One of them is Eliza Arsenault and the other is Martha Hughes Canon. Are you familiar familiar with Martha Hughes Canon? I not, not really. Well, I think I once you get going, I'll probably. OK, Martha, this is, you know, I, I'm painting a picture on the other side of the spectrum, right? So again, we just got a, a, a sample of how it could go wrong. Now I want to show you how just how oppressed poor Martha Hughes Cannon was.

1:19:54 So she she was born in 1897, lived, lived. Where'd it go? No. Excuse me. She was born in 1857 and she lived until 1932. She was educated at the University of Utah, the University of Michigan, the University of Pennsylvania. She had a master's, an MDA bachelor's, and she was also on the National School of looks like or oratory. So she was she had ABA in that as well. And she was a polygamous wife to Angus M Young. Here's where it gets impressive.

1:20:40 She is the first woman to serve in the United States State Senate. She was elected in Utah as a state senator. And this is how abused she was. Ben, the, the guy she beat for the Senate seat was her husband. It was her husband who was the state president, state president at the time of the Salt Lake Stake, you know, downtown, right where everything was. She was so oppressed that that she felt like she could challenge her own husband in a electoral race and then wins and then stays stays married to him.

1:21:26 Yeah, which I would have loved to like be at that dinner table like. There's one I like. The one I wanted to be at was like, after he lost, you know, his boys, all his buddies at church were like, what's the matter, Angus can't get your house in order, right? I mean, probably just gave it to him hard in a fun way. But, you know, really, really let him kind of have it there a little bit. But my point in showing that is that they're they're you can pick extremes on both sides, right? And then in the middle is where everyone is. And guess what? Just like most marriages, it's it ebbs and flows, right?

1:22:08 There are good times, there are bad times, but you stick it out 'cause you're married, right? Are there bad? Are there bad husbands in plural marriage? Damn straight. Are there bad husbands and monogamous, monogamous marriages? Damn straight. Bad wives in polygamy? Yep. Bad wives in monogamy. Yep, it's a human deal, right? This is not a problem with the principal. This is a problem with guys who either take on more than they can handle, right? And let's be clear, Joseph Ann Brigham both said plural marriage will damn more men than it saves, right? Because it is hard, it's rewarding, it's a great way of life, but it it takes a lot of work.

1:22:53 And because somebody else couldn't hack it is not a reason to not apply the principle, right? It's, it's simply how things went in that marriage at that time, in that circumstance, No more, no less. You cannot indict the the principle of celestial plural marriage based off of even half, let's just say half the accounts were bad. OK, You can't, you can't indict the whole system for that. You just have to say, well, yeah, we kind of knew going in, based off what Joseph and Brigham said, this was going to be a tough thing and this was going to kind of kind of, you know, weed some guys out, so to speak, right? Weed, weed some people out.

1:23:37 And and that's just what it is. Well, and you know what, this can be like a really sensitive area where like people bring their own experiences and their own emotions to things. And so like if you have, if if you have are a woman who's been abused before or if someone you love has been. And that's something that you're like close to and sensitive about when you hear people say, oh, well, but there are all these good experiences, something you might feel like that's being brushed aside or minimized or whatever.

1:24:20 And you know, like it's a difficult thing because like, if we are being analytical and we are just looking at it like we have to honestly say there's a lot of both, you know, and just because like there was someone who's really successful and did it really well, that doesn't mean like the person who went through some horrifying evil experience, doesn't mean that that didn't really happen to them and that it wasn't really terrible. And you know, that there, there weren't these issues with it. It just means like, if we're looking at the full story, we, we got to look at the full story. And the other thing is that like happy marriages are kind of boring.

1:25:08 You know, like not a, not a lot. Like it doesn't make the news, you know, like you you never here like on the 9 O clock news like oh, OK. Well, this, this couple, you know, they just, they like each other. And. You know, like, there's again, you know, like, you know, Florida man appears to be quite happy with his wife, you know, like. Nope, that's not. Let's talk about Florida man's ever up to so like people just aren't that. That isn't shocking. It's not interesting. Like, so if I tell you, well, here's my friend who has three wives and a bunch of kids and they get along really well.

1:25:54 There's very seldom arguments or or fighting like they they're really happy people. It's like, well, I can't make like a a Netflix documentary about that. Like. That's kind of boring. Yep, Yep, absolutely, absolutely, Mason. What do you got bud? You know, I think, I think pretty much anything, everything was touched on generally there. Perfect. All right, let's go to the last part of this video I want to cover before we move on to the other one. The Elizabeth Smart example. OK, he's asking right here if this counts as grooming, so let me back up just a little bit. Yes, absolutely.

1:26:37 So even the examples that you're showing, like the Elizabeth Smart example, the the recent example, just what's being shown on this cartoon, what was happening before, and even our, our conversation about not being able to challenge LDS leaders because it's so interesting with the Sam Young and with my case in particular, I think, well, many cases, it's not so much that we denounced like Mormon theology or that we denounced our testimonies. We were denouncing policy and policy was going against the leaders. And so in both I think my apostasy charge and also Sam Young's apostasy charge, it was very much this idea that you're going against church leaders, which I'm like, yeah, isn't that part of sustaining church leaders when you know that they're making huge mistakes saying there's a problem?

1:27:32 But they didn't buy that that was that was not an OK enough reason. So. They were still caught up on you calling them a patriarchal prick. That too. Yeah, that really, that really. Yeah, that really pricked them anyway, So, but, but this idea of grooming, so again, going back to Rain's definition and the patterns that they say, one of the patterns of grooming is that you're gaining access and isolation of the victim. And what you're describing just in a church interview where a Bishop is going to ask sexually inappropriate questions, that fits that grooming criteria to the T, to the T, you now have access to a vulnerable person.

1:28:15 And you know, I think many bishops don't take advantage of that. Many bishops have and other people who will mimic those types of meetings as well. And so you have a huge problem there. I also want to say that over 90% of sexual assault happens with people that we know. So that's another thing is that grooming requires for the person to have trust. And this is what the church is saying, trust us, trust the Lord, trust Joseph Smith, trust your Bishop, trust the young men's leader, trust the young women's leader, trust them over yourself time and time again. So now we have this trust issue, this gaining access issue. Now there's victim selection, right? So how do groomers and perpetrators usually select victims?

1:28:59 They're usually vulnerable. They're usually maybe got some type of developmental issue or emotional issue where that makes them more vulnerable victim than others. So when I think about a 14 year old in Joseph Smith's home who's actually dependent on her living and eating and ability to survive on this family, who's taking care of her or. Foster children. That is whose? Parents have died. So now we're looking at very vulnerable victims, right? And so you just, and then desensitization. This is what's happening in this cartoon. It's desensitizing a problematic thing, which again, I'm realizing so many years later that this is what happened to me for years, for years as an LDS member, I would have said many things to defend the church in this particular situation. What I'm realizing now is that I was being desensitized to my own discomfort because again, Natasha, your discomfort is prideful.

1:29:57 It's egotistical. It's influenced by the world. So you have to ignore those discomfort, uncomfortable feelings and instead be humble and go along with and say yes even when you want to say no. So these are grimy tactics. One O 1. And then the the last point that they make is they attempt to make their behavior seem natural to avoid raising suspicion. Well, what is this cartoon doing? More than anything, it's making it natural. Sometimes this happens sometimes. Sometimes God just wants you to totally ignore your bodily autonomy. That's sometimes what is going to happen and that is normalizing. Sometimes God's gonna want.

1:30:43 That right and and desensitizing behavior that is absolutely atrocious and abusive and making it normal. Yeah. So thank you, Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, for making sexual assault normal and blaming God on top of it. Shame on you. Four children. Two children. Shame on you. Yeah, yeah. Well, we've got some cartoons of sort of satirical responses. All right, Ben, go ahead. Yeah. All right. So the first thing, like she is 100% correct about the 1st, not everything, but the first point that she makes is that the overwhelming majority of sexual assault, it happens because from someone that you trust, that's the case with like, I'm pretty confident that's the case with violent crimes in general. You know, like, you know, someone said that, you know, most murders are not committed by well trained assassins. It's by friends and family, you know that that do that and you know, it's true.

1:32:07 So like that is a thing that people should be aware of the the guy who's going to jump out from behind the Bush and snatch you. That's extremely rare. A very very tiny portion of assaults. Like it is usually the case that someone is exploiting a position of trust. Now that does It does not follow that everyone who has a position of trust has it for nefarious purposes. Like there's a lot of very legitimate reasons for people to trust one another.

1:32:58 You know, parents need to have the trust of their children, like good parents who love their kids and take care of them. Like that's, that's trust. Like the reason I can get my, my daughter to brush her teeth even though she's 3 and she doesn't want to, is because she trusts me, you know, like, and I'm using that trust to get her to brush her teeth. So like, it isn't, you know, we shouldn't, we should be aware, you know, we should watch if someone is who is trusted is doing something that doesn't look right.

1:33:41 You know, you should trust your guts on that and all that. But you shouldn't just say like, oh, that person appears trustworthy. He must be up to no good. So yeah. That was my you. Go ahead. So here, here's the issue I had. First, the woman who was talking there, Natasha Helfer, she was excommunicated for she's a sex sex therapist by by profession, right? If she was excommunicated for a number of reasons, one of those being her stance that gay marriage should should be a thing in the church, right? Right. She was.

1:34:22 She was all for that. So that does go against the doctrine which she says. So. But here's the thing, and and I think this is a big tale here. Do you notice about half of what she said was about her in that in that little blurp, right? That had nothing to do a lot of it with anything that they were talking about. Maybe a little bit of a grievance seeker, I don't know. But anyway, again, that's on brand for for this particular podcast, right? And so it was all about her. The other thing I would say, them telling the church that they are, you know, them saying that the church is using this to groom their youth is laughable when many of the people that have been on that particular podcast that I just referenced and maybe even the host himself. You've had some allegations that look credible. Well, that and I think, I think, don't quote me, I've been looking at for this all day and I haven't been able to find one way or another.

1:35:30 It's kind of leaning towards this direction. But I think they're all about being OK with taking your kids to a pride parade, right? I think they're OK with medical transitioning your child, right? So who's the groomer here? Right? Let's, let's get real. If, if we want to go down this road, we can. But I promise you're going to lose on this one because 100%. Have there been, has there been abuse in the LDS church? You bet. You bet. Has there been abuse in fundamentalism? Absolutely. However, and if you want to talk raw numbers, I think it's, you know, we can have that discussion about kind of the left-leaning LGBTQ movement along with with the, the, the trans community.

1:36:18 There's way more grooming going on that side than there is here. I don't see anything in what was presented by the church in any way whatsoever as a grooming. In fact, to me it takes steps to make sure that doesn't happen by coming out in the last part and saying we no longer practice plural marriage right in the SO to make the claim that this is grooming is laughable given who it's coming from, as well as just patently false. And you have to be, I can't even say you're mistaken. You have to kind of be wanting to say something false to a tribute grooming to this thing. Well, and they're, they're exploiting like traumatized people because you know, like, if this is something that you're close to where you've either experienced an assault yourself or like someone that you love and and care for has that's going to be something really sensitive. So if you can kind of tie whatever the church is doing into that, it kind of lowers like your critical thinking because now you're, you're dealing with the emotions of fear of anger, of sadness, like because you're hooking into this like emotionally triggering topic, which a lot of people have some kind of, I think

1:37:51 almost everyone, if you haven't experienced something like that, someone you care about probably has. And so that's going to override like your critical thinking and and then you're just going to be feeling all this rage and, and anger towards the church. It isn't grooming like just because like there are like there are nefarious people who can exploit your beliefs in order to harm you and take advantage of you. And that is a concern that people should care about. But because a belief can be exploited does not mean that that's the purpose of that belief and that that's like what it does.

1:38:42 So teaching children, hey, here's like a basic introductory explanation of plural marriage. This was hard for people to do, blah, blah, blah. We don't do it anymore. But this is what happened at a very basic level. Like no, like that. No, it's not, It's not grooming. It's not, you know, and that it's still not grooming. Even if there's a scenario where like some creepy dude takes advantage of someone and tries to use plural marriage to, to make it OK, like that's wrong, should be punished, all that, but that's, that's not, it's just not what's going on here.

1:39:36 And I, I think this is extremely manipulative. And also like the existence of a power dynamic does not mean that people have been harmed. Like power dynamics exist in nature and they can be exploited. And so we should be watchful and careful, but like I'm. Bigger and stronger and taller than my wife is like I am by nature. If I wanted to, I could use that to hurt her. Like that is something that is physically possible there. That is a power dynamic.

1:40:16 It's not bad because I don't. I use that like that's something that she actually quite likes, that I'm taller and stronger than her. You know, it's one of the things that she enjoys about me. So because I use that to serve her and to benefit her. And so it isn't like automatic, like we shouldn't just like, oh, let's abolish all power dynamics. It's like, well, no, be aware. They can be exploited. But like, that doesn't mean they shouldn't exist, or that it would even be possible for them not to. Mason, anything you want to add to this before we move on? I get the feeling that the church does have a problem with sexual abuse, but that has like no bearing on the conversation that they're having.

1:41:05 They're talking about the church teaching its history, which is something that from the very beginning of this podcast, I pointed out is something that they ostensibly want the church to be doing. They say, oh, the church needs to be more transparent with its history. They say that people convert in ignorance. They don't know anything about Joseph Smith and or his life. And as a missionary or as a former missionary, I tend to agree with that. But now that the church is taking steps in that direction of actually educating the youth and trying to be more forthright with what happened there, pulling on other things that are going wrong in the church right now. Like if if you genuinely want the church to be better as an institution, which I think the three of us do, you have to give them props where props are due.

1:41:58 They're doing better at telling the history as it actually happened. Obviously it's simplified because it's too young audience. Of course they're not going to get crazy in detail, but props where props reduce still, you know what I mean? It it just, it has no bearing on the conversation to say that the church has a sex abuse problem or to to talk about grooming because this, this has nothing to do with grooming. It's just complying with what needs to be done. And you know, yeah. And and to go along with that, I guarantee you that this was probably put together because a survey was taken by the church and some, you know, there was enough people that said, hey, we feel like you're hiding stuff. And so they said, well, then we'll, we'll get more forward with it, right.

1:42:49 I don't think the church has I'll intent in this. I I just think they're trying to maybe do the best they can with what they got. And I, I think this speaks to the larger narrative here of this, like there is nothing that the church or Mormons at large will ever be able to do other than disavow the faith that will make this side of the argument happy, right? Yeah, and. That's it. That's what they want. They don't, you know it. It's almost like because I've heard, I've heard this come from from this particular podcast several times where they said, well, gosh, we just want the church to get better. So what?

1:43:31 What are you saying we need to like paint a few more buildings? No, just take a can of gasoline and some matches to it. That'll make it better, right? Yeah. Go ahead. Well, and, and like you mentioned the Community of Christ earlier, they've made every single change that every one of these critics have levelled at the church and they don't go there, you know, like they, they, they, when they leave the LDS church, they don't say, OK, well, what I want is a Mormonism that's friendly to LGBTQ, that is progressive, that ordains women Da, da, da, da, da doesn't have, you know, the issues that you have with the temple, whatever the case doesn't endorse, like the historicity of the Book of Mormon, all these issues that they've got, guess what? You can go right over to the community of Christ. They they've never taught polygamy. Like you can go right there, they'll welcome you with open arms.

1:44:33 They're generally friendly people from my experience. But these people don't go there because that isn't what they want. They're just angry that the church exists. Like they want to destroy what they don't like. They're not interested in finding what they do like. Yeah, no, I agree. I agree. All right, let's go ahead and let's move on to the other video because I feel like it's going to be just as good here. Probably won't take nearly as long to break this one down, but I do believe it's worth worth talking. Oh yeah.

1:45:22 All right, so. I might have a different take on this than you. OK, All right, We'll we'll this will be good then. OK, here we go. Hello everyone, and welcome to another edition of Mormon Stories podcast. I'm your host, John Delin. It is January 6th, 2025, Happy New Year. And today we are going to be covering an episode that the thumbnail basically says Harvard's Clark Gilbert terrorizes BYU professors. The real impetus for this this episode comes from a Salt Lake Tribune article that dropped just over the weekend. The Salt Lake Tribune article says dark days, new rules have BYU professors running scared.

1:46:12 Clark Gilbert, the Mormon Church's education commissioner, is determined to have faculty members who support the faith's teachings, or at least how his office interprets those teachings. So, you know, as someone who attended BYU, as someone who felt like he got a really good education at BYUI, met my wife Margie, at BYUI, I've historically been someone who's cared pretty deeply about BYU and, and its progress. And so I think this is an important topic to cover. What I'm basically going to be going to be doing today is doing a combination of reading the Salt Lake Tribune article and also I'm playing some clips and also sharing some comments that we've been able to cull off the Internet and, and some personal comments that have been sent to me as well. I'm going to ask Julie and Maven to please star. We want we want to welcome our live audience and any really good stories or comments or questions that are shared in the live stream either on Facebook or on YouTube. I'm going to ask Julie and Maven. OK, just to give some of you a sense for who this Clark Gilbert person is.

1:47:39 This is from Clark Gilbert's bio on the LDS Church's website. It basically says Clark G Gilbert was sustained as a General Authority 70 of the LDS Church in April 3rd, 2021. As far as his church service goes, Clark G Gilbert was sustained to General Authority 70 again in April 3rd, 2021. He currently serves as the Commissioner of the Church Education System. At the time of his call, he had been serving as an Area 70 in the Utah area. Elder Clark Gilbert has served in a number of church colleagues including full time missionary in Japan, Kobe Mission Elders Corn president, counselor, stake presidency and Bishop.

1:48:24 For those who don't know, the church education system is the organization in the Mormon church that overseas Brigham Young University in Provo, Brigham Young University, Hawaii, Brigham Young University, Idaho, which. OK, I'm now I'm going to go on to where he reads the article. Dark days, New rules at BYU. Yeah. That the popular Apostles uncharacteristically harsh rhetoric was an omen of the next three years under Gilbert's leadership. Yet Bergman felt a growing unease. Bergman, who had been teaching trumpet at a prestigious Texas university in 2018 when BYU recruited him, bristled at the increasing clampdown on LGBTQ plus activism he saw on BYU campus, which eventually would include shutting down Y mountain to rainbow colors.

1:49:18 So for those of you who don't know, BYU has this big, huge letter, white letter Y, that's up on the side of a mountain right there, very prominently displayed on BYU campus. And over the years, LGBTQ students and allies have found different ways to either paint or project rainbow colors on to that big why? Just to just show their support for LGBTQ people at BYU. And it's been a long standing controversy. And you know that's. What they're just staying for private property that's.

1:50:00 What's being talked about there, it goes on to say. And the denial of racism and misogyny that still existed. So basically some of the main cultural points that we're talking about with all this cultural controversy are, you know, racism the way the church treat teaches about people of color and treats people of color. The way the Mormon church treats women and how to use feminism and the teachings about Mother in Heaven and how how it treats teaches its members and its doctrine around LGBT, gay, lesbian, transgender individuals as well. Those are three of kind of the main Mormon teachings or doctrines or pieces of theology that are that are prominently featured in sort of these cultural clashes at BYU, Bergman writes. Quote, I had LGBTQ students and saw how they suffered. I started to pay attention to how people of color and women were treated.

1:51:02 It was and continues to be hard for them. Then in 2022 came a new employment contract, a sort of loyalty oath in which faculty members incoming in current were expected to attest to their support of the Mormon Church's position on marriage, family and gender. Too many, like Bergman, who felt pressured to agree it went beyond the church's own stance and seemed to carry an implicit threat. You can't advance if you don't sign off. So that's disturbing to a lot of people that you know. OK, we'll stop right there. That's enough of that. So basically here it is.

1:51:42 The LDS Church has finally, in my opinion, and this is a good thing, has come out and basically said, look, there's certain things we're not going to allow the professors to get away with anymore. They're going to kind of toe the the line a little bit here as far as as, you know, lining up with with LDS teachings. Now I want to say this obviously, Ben, that's going to maybe be a a little bit of a problem for guys like you and I in the sense of their, you know, when it comes to the the study of our religion, you're not going to get the full story right. You just won't. Sure, But at the same time, I don't think it's entirely bad if those who were on the on on more of the, the, the side of, you know, trying to figure out how to justify same sex marriage in the church.

1:52:39 I I'm all for the church being able to to get rid of those those professors if they have to. Yeah, right. So that essentially like what they're complaining about is that they're they're upset that the church wants its employees to not oppose them. Right. And like to to not like actively fight against their interest. And like, I hate to break it to you, but like that's pretty standard for basically all employed. Like if I started speaking badly about my employer, like I should expect to not stay there for much longer, you know, like that's that's just pretty that's pretty normal, you know, like, and also why do you want to work at a place that you like fundamentally disagree with like on a on like core? Like if the if the Democratic Party like offered you a job, would you take it?

1:53:53 Dave? No, right. Like, you know, like it. Like why would you work for an organization that like you fundamentally disagree with? OK. And also it's like this, this whole thing, oh, I'm being threatened with my job. Why are you working? There. Well, I I think you're leaving out an important caveat to that. I don't know if you have ever watched the fantastic. It's it's second only to the Office, this fantastic sitcom Parks and Rec. And when Ron Swanson works for the Parks Department and says I am here to bring down the system from the inside. So I mean, I suppose you had that. I mean which?

1:54:40 But no. To be fair, I think that's exactly what's going on here with some of these professors, but I'll let. You know your thought, well, there, there's two dynamics going on. So yeah, there's that. Like there, there are some that are like actively there because they want to undermine the church. There's the the church should be aware of and like traditionalists within the church should be aware of this too, because the more like progressive lefty side of the church, they know that the church responds to pressure like they know the church does not like getting bad press. The church doesn't like when they're being criticized. They especially don't like legal battles. And so, like, they know that the church will, at a minimum, moderate the position and sometimes change based on pressure from the outside.

1:55:39 They know that that's a fact. Traditionalists in the church insist that that's not true. And because they insist that that's not true, when it happens, they will say, oh, this leftist thing that I've always opposed, It's now what God wants. And so that's kind of the, the situation where you, the, the like you've got professors who are coming in there to put that pressure to kind of seed the next generation towards this. And so that's the one dynamic. Then the other dynamic is it's hard to get a job in at universities today. Enrollments are down.

1:56:32 Like people are finding out that it is not as good an investment as they were led to believe. And BYU offers a a place where if you're a member of the church, you can get employment there a little more easier than you would and a lot of other universities if you are kind of a mediocre teacher. And if you're pretty mediocre, you're terrified of getting fired, like most people who are like committed progressives and who do fundamentally disagree with the church they don't want, and they are like competent in their profession.

1:57:24 They are just going to go work somewhere else, right? But if you are not competent and you know you're not, and you know no one else is going to hire you if you get fired, then you are going to kick and scream and cry and whine, do everything you can to hold on to your nice cushy job at BYU. Because like, if you really actually oppose them and you're not like on, on this like mission to infiltrate them, go get another job. You're kind of a loser if you don't, you know? No, I, I agree. I agree. Look, I, I've, I've thought about this a little bit, right? Because look, if, if everything was, was where it was supposed to be within society, I've got no problem with my kid. If you know, when I send a kid off to school, off to college, I want my kid to be challenged on what he believes a little bit, right?

1:58:20 I, I want him to have to kind of be, and this is figuratively speaking, not literally, but kind of be put up against the wall a little bit and say, tell me why it is you believe what you believe. I think that's a healthy thing, right? Why is it you believe this? The problem is, is that at BYU, at, at most universities, it's not that. What it is, is it's an indoctrination camp, right? And so you go on to most major universities and what are you going to see? You're going to see a lot of leftist Marxism. You're going to see a lot of feminism, you're going to see a lot of pro LGBTQ stuff going on, right?

1:59:00 And it's, it's less about how to think and more about what to think. And they're going to tell you exactly what to think. Right. Well, diversity is people who look different saying the same thing, right? Right. And, and so if if that's kind of what you're going to get there at BYU, you're going there understanding that it's a little bit different, right? And so when someone comes out and says, I'm shocked that they don't dig on my LGBTQ stance. No, bro, you knew exactly what you were getting into 100%. And the only difference now is, is that it looks like the church is about to get serious in, in getting rid of some of that, right? And good for them, right?

1:59:50 Because that old adage, the hand that rocks the cradle is the hand that rules the world is true, right? And we're seeing the repercussions of that coming out of other universities right now, right? Kids coming out of school. It's, it's a different breed, right? They've been taught certain things that's much different than what what has been around predominantly up until now, right. And while I'm certainly in favor of newer, better practices, that sort of thing, there's some time tested things that that while you can certainly question, I'd be very nervous about getting rid of. The other thing that makes BYU a little bit different is that you are expected to be a member in good standing, which means you hold the temple recommend not only for the students but for the professors as well.

2:00:41 Some exemptions are made for non LDS professors that come in right. They're pretty accommodating that way. Yeah. But none the less you. Still got a quick coffee? What's that? You still have to quick coffee. Yeah, or at least drink it on the DL, right? You you have to like actually pour into a swig cup and then drink it out of a squid cup. But at any rate, at any rate there, there's some there. God bless his Diet Coke. Yes, Sir, as I just finished a bottle of Diet Coke. But anyway, they the thing that makes BYU, it makes it worse at BYU when this stuff is taught isn't the fact that it's being taught, it's the fact that it's being taught from a person who allegedly is in good standing with the church, working for a church institution. So you bring those kids in and you give them that, that you know, and you know that that idea that, hey, you know what, maybe gays can be married in the LDS church. Maybe they should be able to be sealed. Now you're getting a mixed message, right? And that.

2:01:50 Sounds like someone exploiting a position of trust. Yeah, it does, doesn't it the. Opposite thing that they committed to do. Kind of like grooming. In order to influence young people behave in a certain way. Would would that classify as grooming Ben? I I don't know. To me that that sounds. Does it sound? Groomy, groomy, groomy. It sounds kind groomy. Yes. Groomy. A little groomy. We just made-up a new word here. Yeah, it it's bad, right? Because it it really does send the mixed messages, right. So you might be cranking out people who are more able to fit into the world, but that's not what BYU was set up for, right?

2:02:33 BYU was set up to to advance education in the backdrop of religion, right? And those two were going to to walk hand in hand, essentially. And so as you do this, it sends mixed messages. And what, you know what? Let me ask you this question, Ben. What's more insidious, a lie that's 100% true, or a lie that's 90% true? It's a, it's a 90% true. One, it's the 90% true, right? And that's kind of the same analogy at BYU, right, is that they might, because they're in the guise of saying all the right things about the institution, right? The LDS Church, they can say messages that are contrary to that.

2:03:25 And the kids walk out of there feeling like, oh, it's just going to be my job to push the church farther down the line. Yeah. And there has been a disconnect for a while between what happens in Salt Lake and what happens with the church educational system. And my gut feeling is, is that the the the higher ups in the LDS church are now trying to get a handle on this. So that's what it looks like. This is where I think I I got a different view on it. So the the church, a lot of times when I talk to people who are also like who are still in the church, but like maybe not all the way fundamentalist, but at least like just more traditionalist conservative, they tend to think that the brethren are like on their side, But for some reason they got to be like real secret about it, right? And they're not.

2:04:27 I just, I just don't think they are like, I think it's, it's either the case that if something is happening at in the church and at BYU, it is either the case that the brethren support it or they are powerless to stop it. And it it has to be one of those. And neither of those are very good, right? They're they're, they're just not. And you got to grapple with that. I don't think that the brethren are like, and I, I, I believe that some of them are honourable men. I'm not like, I'm not like calling them out. I believe there is corruption in the church. I'm not going to like sort through who's what.

2:05:11 But yeah, like that, that that's just what it comes down to. They either support what's happening in the church or they're powerless to stop it. And, and that's all that it is. Now what I think is going on at BYU is I think very little is actually going to change. I think maybe if there's like a couple of really outspoken critics of the church who are on staff, they, they might get fired. I I don't think that look, the progressives are still complaining about like one time in the 80s that.

2:05:54 September 6th. The September 6th, the church again, that's kind of embarrassing to the church. Look, if it were up to me, you'd have trouble staffing BYU with how many people get excommunicated. I'd be like, I'd be like, what? You're going to say anything bad about Brigham Young? You're out. You would be like the Oprah of excommunications. You get your walking papers and you get your walking papers. I'd be like, look whose name is on university, Brigham Young. You go in your that math class and you teach the Adam God doctrine, but you're out. But like, it's, it's not going to happen. What's what's happening?

2:06:40 My theory is that the church is waiting for the boomers to die. They're waiting for the boomers to die. The it's going to be a very, very different church when that happens because the right now, that's who's most upset about these videos that are coming out of BYU of professors speaking against the family proclamation or promoting communism or, or whatever else. Boomers are upset. They are talking, they're talking about like not sending their kids to, to BYU, their grandkids, whatever.

2:07:25 They're talking about not supporting it. Church is very sensitive to that. Because like, while the church, like their impulse is to appease people who are criticizing them from the left, They know that if they did every single thing that John Delyn wants them to do, he will not come back. Right. Like if if they give in to every single demand that critics of the church have, they're not going to come back. They're not going to start paying tithing. They're not going to send their kids on missions. But if they do, they're going to drive out all of the people who are actually making the church happen, right? You know, like the the people who are like, I believe in the doctrine. So I'm going to have a bunch of kids, I'm going to teach them, I'm going to pay tithing.

2:08:12 We're going to sacrifice, we're going to serve in callings and my kids are going to go on missions. Like those people are the ones that you lose. Those people tend to be conservative and they tend to be older. Now, if you make those types of people too angry, you lose what actually like funds BYU and makes it work when the boomers are dead. And I am a millennial. But once my generation gets in power, I I think it's going to be a problem.

2:08:53 And I think that's when the church is going to start making huge radical changes. I think that they will cave on plural marriage and they'll endorse it. They'll, they'll cave. They, they will and they, they just won't, don't want to take off the boomers once the boomers are dead and it shifts and you've got the millennials that are like, well, we probably should let the gays get married in the temple and they will. So I'm, I'm much more pessimistic about BYU. Maybe in the short term it improves a little bit. I don't think that it's going to be mass firings and all this stuff.

2:09:35 Like that's just. I don't think that's going to happen. They might get rid of a couple, like, outspoken critics at best. Yeah. And I think what they're trying to do is just mollify the older generation. But once they're all dead or in homes or something and they stop paying attention, then the church is just going to go right back and a piece left. So I I think you're probably right there, but I guess my point in this is to be like, I think this is one of those places where at the moment they deserve another attaboy on this right? And and and let let me say this right obviously, obviously me and you our opinions ain't carrying a lot of weight. So it you know, could but for you know, a good percentage of my audience is active LDS, right card carrying members go to the temple the whole thing.

2:10:33 If these are changes that you like, right, especially here at BYU, just like the brethren listen when you complain, they they will also listen when you do, right. And sometimes where the church is now, I think the membership has to kind of empower the leadership right now. It shouldn't be that way, but I think that's where it is right now. And so this to a certain extent, you know, if, if I was still living in Utah and I was, you know, still an active member of the LDS Church, and I was a more from the more conservative old school line of thought. Make sure that those in BYU understand that you're you're all for this, right? Because I do think the church will go where they feel like the most support is there.

2:11:21 And you don't necessarily have to have the numbers. If you are the loud minority, that could be enough to get it done right. And so back them up on these things. Yeah. Like, yeah, put in a little bit of the effort that the the left puts in, you know, like, Yep. Because here's the thing I should add is that nothing would make me happier than to be proven wrong, right? You know, like, I will not be bitter and upset at all if I find out that the church stays the course and does not cave on gay marriage. I, I would, I would love to be wrong about that.

2:12:02 I don't think I will be, but I would, I would absolutely love it. And if that does happen, it will be because the actual believers in the gospel make their voices known and they speak up and they say so. And you know, and you can do that respectfully if you're, if you get a little too carried away, they they might excommunicate you, but that's OK. You can hang out with us. We'll be your friends. But it generally, yeah, if if you let let it known that this is what you want to see, that if the the church, you know, holds the line that they're going to get support.

2:12:50 And if you do that, then yeah, you're going to see more of those things happen. Yep, Yep. And, and, and that's, that's the other thing, right? Is that there? There's this misconception that because we're fundamentalists, we want to see the church go away and nothing could be. Not from the truth. I, I don't want to see that. I don't right? And, and I said this for a long time on this podcast and I truly believe it. Whether we're different groups of fundamentalists or we're fundamentalists and we're LDS, you know, we're probably not going to hug it out on every issue on Sundays, but we better figure out how to start working together and having a barbecue on Saturday, right?

2:13:32 And, and look, I will just like I'm trying to, to, to demonstrate here, I'll back the church's play when they do something right, right. I'm never rejoining. But when they do something right, I'll back their play. I'll back their play every day, twice on Sunday, if they do the right thing, right. And, you know, and, and so I feel like it's important for us as fundamentalists to be able to look at our LDS brothers and sisters and go, good on you, keep going. Don't stop, right? Hold the line on this. Just be strong. Don't don't give any more ground.

2:14:12 Because here, here's the thing, right in all of this. If someone was to ask me what the church's fatal flaw was here on on how they've dealt with all these issues, the LGBTQ issue, the the stuff they're facing at BYU, The fatal flaw is this understand who it is that's going to war against you, right And understand what it is they ultimately want. I feel like for a while the church really did really was trying to be accommodating to a certain degree and just be like, let's live and let live. I think the failed calculus happened when they they didn't understand who it was they were dealing with while they were trying to play nice and be like, no, you know what, they probably, you know, we should probably make sure that they don't get cast out of where they live or, or you know what, you know, that they could buy a house if they could have a job, those sorts of things.

2:15:12 Why they were doing that. The other side was like, we're playing to win, right? And nothing less than bowing the knee and, and swearing allegiance to that side would suffice. And so I, you know, my hope is, is that maybe with, with what we're seeing here now, with, with being a little more open about talking about plural marriage and maybe trying to, to weed out some of the bad actors at BYU, we're seeing maybe a recognition of really what's going on. And and maybe they're starting to think, OK, maybe we need to push back a little more here and and a recognition of what it is the other side really wants. Yeah. And you know, and I'm like, I just want to echo like I'm not an enemy to the church.

2:15:56 I don't view myself as an enemy to the church, certainly. And you know, when I kind of when I became a fundamentalist or I guess I always kind of felt like I, I always was and just didn't know, know it. But once I, you know, came to that realization, I decided early on, like, I'm not going to make an enemy out of someone who agrees with like 80 to 90 what I believe. You know, like I'm, I'm, I'm not, I'm gonna, like, I'm glad that the, the church teaches the Book of Mormon and I'm, you know, like I, I live in an area where I'm not around a lot of fundamentalists.

2:16:39 So my wife and I will attend the, the local LDS ward and you know, there's, there's friendly terms there, there's good people there. And you know, even when I was excommunicated, you know, that was something that it was kind of a, a weird situation. I didn't put any kind of defense up at all. I just said do what you're going to do. And when my, when my state president let me know, like, I, I gave him a hug and I, I said, I love you. Don't feel bad.

2:17:22 It's OK. We can still be friends. And, and, and that's just how I, I wanted to treat it. I didn't want anyone. I didn't want anyone there to think that you were bitter. Yeah, that I've got this hatred or whatever. It's like I know where I stand with the Lord. And so really like, part of why I was able to do that is because I was like, I don't think you guys actually have the authority to say anything about my standing with the Lord. So you can say whatever you want and it just doesn't really mean a whole lot to me. I just want you to know I still love you, right? And you know, and, and that's the attitude I've tried to, to cultivate. So, but I see the church doing something good. I'm always going to be like, yes, keep that up. Had a boy.

2:18:12 But I also, I don't know, in the short term it's probably a good thing. And but I, I still think long term, I think they're going to cave. But I would, you know, look, look, I. You know, I, I think you're probably right, but but again, I, I just feel like this like if, if, if the more traditional side of the church was looking for an opportunity to get some ground back. This is it, right? This is it. This is your time. Understand what time it is on the clock. And you now get to play a little bit of offense. Make sure you let your leaders know that you are good, you are fine. You are happy with the decision to weed out the leftist activist teachers at Brigham Young University. And likewise, you know, let them know that you're happy with the new curriculum that you put out for the kids. That you're, you know, that, that you're happy that they're being more transparent and talking about plural marriage in a way that that's not catching them off guard. That that, you know, they can understand it a little bit all the way through their, their church career, so to speak, and, and back their play on that.

2:19:26 We don't have like the just iron willed Brigham Young or John Taylor at the head of the church anymore. Like these aren't the kinds of men who are going to do what God wants no matter what. These are men who need encouragement, you know, and I'm sorry if that like offends people. I just that's I maybe I'm wrong about that. I don't see that in modern church theaters. I don't see that like that steel in them and. So, yeah, you got to kind of let them know because if if they're only hearing criticism, they're only hearing people say, oh, why aren't you friendly to the gays?

2:20:12 They're going to think that that's what people want. Another like thing that I had recently when we we attended our local LDS ward is a speaker. I think they were trying to, in their defense, they're trying to make so weird point and just kind of came at it wrong. But he said the statement, we now know that people can choose their genders. And I think I think his point kind of got jumbled because he had a hard time getting back around to that. It wasn't really clear what he was trying to say. But I have like a 10 year old son who's like kind of pays attention at church now, which is cool.

2:20:59 And he like listens and we talk about what is said. And so like, that was something I like leaned over to him and I'm like, that's not true. Like that's false doctrine. And he's like, OK, dad. And then we had a little conversation about that. And but I, I brought it up to the, the state president who was presiding at the meeting afterwards, because he didn't say anything like that. It wasn't corrected. And I asked him about that. And he's like, well, you know, I think, you know, that's not what he was really trying to say. And I'm like, fair enough. But I do have a 10 year old and he is listening to this stuff.

2:21:41 And I would really like it if messages are like clear. Right. I don't want, I don't want to have to like, no, I that's a doctrine that's so basic that I want the church to be good on that. You know, I don't really have to like fight that. And and he sent me like the church's like updated policy on transgender issues and stuff. And they have become that. It's not what I would like, I would like, I would like to excommunicate anyone and everyone who supports in any way transitioning Enders at all. Yep.

2:22:23 They're not doing that, but they they have swung way more toward the side of sanity. And he sent that to me. And he's like, well, you know, this did upset a lot of people, but I think the church did the right thing. And I was like, yeah, like, this is definitely in the direction and of what I want because I don't want to have to like, explain to my kids like, that's us being created at church. So, you know, you can do this in a respectful way where you let people know like, hey, this is this is what we want to see. We want to see the Scriptures thought.

2:23:03 We want to see the doctrine that we were raised with. That's what we want to stick with you. Know. Yep, Yep. Yeah, I think to sum all this up for me, you know, going back to the, to the whole thing with the, the plural marriage curriculum there, don't be distracted by those who are on who from the ex most side of things, right? The ex Mormon crowds gonna do what they're gonna do, right? They have a different agenda and their agenda is to discredit not just the church, but the gospel entirely. And so no amount of pandering to them is going to make it better, right? You, you, you know, the church did a good thing with coming out in this curriculum.

2:23:49 They, I think they needed, they need to be applauded on that, getting rid of some, some really lefty professors. They need to be applauded on that. And members of the LDS church who feel that way need to get more vocal. I mean, I look, I know that us on the right side of the spectrum, both religiously and and politically, I know we're busy doing things like having jobs and raising kids and we don't have time to be, what had John Dylan put it, grievance, whatever grievance seekers, right? We don't have that kind of time. So when we have the opportunity here to tell the church they did right and help prop them up a little bit, I think we need to do it. And that was pretty much it.

2:24:37 Ben, anything else you want to say in conclusion? Well, as a fundamentalist, I really just want to like highlight the problem that you ought to have with that cartoon is the whole 1890, we're getting rid of plural marriage thing, right? That's the thing that should upset you. By the way, I want you, I invite all of our LDS corporate church friends to just really hone in on that There's. Five whole episodes that I did with Michael Ness about post manifesto polygamy. Go back and listen to him, guys. I'm not about to rehash it all here. I'm just going to reiterate that it's been said many times by fundamentalists that the manifesto is addressed to whom it may concern, and it does not concern me and it shouldn't concern you.

2:25:34 Yeah, absolutely awesome. All right, big dog. That was fun. Yeah. Never thought I'd see the day when I had to do one of these, but I'm. I'm glad we did it. So. All right, Awesome, Ben. We'll talk at you next time all. Right. Bye everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.