Episode #157: The Testimonies Of Women From The Early Restoration W/Kimberly Watson Smith
Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.
Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products
Right now, the Plural Marriages deniers are coming out in full force to try and damage the testimony of the truth in as many people as they can. One of the tactics that are used is that they will say that the early sisters that practiced the principle of Celestial Plural Marriage where oppressed, weak, silent women who would never choose such a marriage. Man, if only we had access to those early Sisters thoughts and feelings……oh wait we do! Today on the podcast Kimberly Watson Smith joins me again where we read those early Sisters words (in context) and let those sisters from Church history speak for themselves. Through our conversation what we find is that these women left all of us in the Restoration a proud heritage of faith and that should inspire, uplift, and strengthen our testimonies of not only the principle of Celestial Plural Marriage but also the whole of the teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:05 Right now, the plural marriage deniers are coming out in full force to try to damage the testimony of the truth and as many people as they can. Now, one of the tactics that they're used is that they will say that the early sisters that practice the principle of celestial plural marriage were all oppressed, weak, silent women who would never have chosen a marriage system such as that man. If only we had access to those early sisters thoughts and feelings. Oh wait, we do. Today on the podcast, Kimberly Watson Smith joins me again where we read those early sisters words in context and let those sisters from church history speak for themselves through our conversation. What we find is that these women left us all in the restoration of proud heritage of faith that should inspire, uplift, and strengthen our testimonies, not only of the principle of celestial plural marriage, but also the whole of the teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith.
0:59 Get ready for an epic conversation on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. So a few weeks back, I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running. Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page or click the link in this episode show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups, and water bottles, all with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU, but you should definitely go check that out. Now, this is just the beginning.
1:44 In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast, so head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode show notes and get yours today. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Kimberly, what's going on?
2:38 Hey, Dave, how are you? I'm good it I'll tell you what I was telling you before this and and I really mean it. I love these conversations we have because every time we have them, I walk away with two things. One, having my mind blown just by the stuff, you know, and then going I need to study more because she can absolutely go circles around me. So it's just a it's always a yawn. It really is. Well, thank you. I appreciate that. I'm excited to be on. I have, I've just felt this like a sense of urgency just to basically just share what I've learned, especially about the women of the restoration, just because I feel like their voices are being silenced and they're being misrepresented and in many cases they're being slandered and defamed. And I, and I just, it, it's kind of heartbreaking to me as a woman, especially as I've, you know, I, I look to the women of the restoration to they're as role models essentially. So just to, I mean, I look to them to know what it means to be a woman of the covenant, what it means to be a woman of faith and, and learning about their lives and who they are just as individuals has just really strengthened my faith. And, and just to see that, that this, there's this conversation going on out there about the historical practice of our marriage.
4:08 And then everybody wants to talk about women, but they're not actually listening to what they ever said, if that makes sense. You know, I was thinking about this today. This, this very thing. It wasn't too long ago that we went through the Me too movement, right? And you remember what one of the big rallying cries was for that which was believe all women, right? And now we have in this case first hand, historical data on on what these early pioneer women had to say on certain topics, on plural marriage being one of them. But for whatever reason, you can't believe those women, right? You're supposed to believe everybody else, but you can't believe those women because it doesn't fit the narrative, right?
4:57 And I find that very fascinating that, you know, when, when when I talk about the left, I'm not talking just about the political left. There is a religious left as well, right? And it's especially found its way into Mormonism of all branches. It's not unique to the LDS Church. And and so there's this idea of it. You got to believe all women unless what that woman is saying does not fit the narrative that the left wants to push in this instant. Does that kind of make sense? Exactly. It's like the women of faith. We don't want to believe those women, but any woman who stands against purity, holiness, religion, we, we don't want to believe those women. We want to shun them.
5:41 And in essence that they, you know, they, they don't just silence them, but they, it, it's just a fascinating phenomenon. How it's it, you know how they say that, you know, women in religion, they're, you know, they're, what's the word? I can't think of the word for some reason. Subservient. Yeah, subservient or you know, they don't have. You know, they don't, they can't speak for themselves. And so then you have these women of faith who actually did speak for themselves. And we then say, no, we can't listen to what they say. So oppression, that's the word I was looking for.
6:25 So essentially we, we call women of religion, we call them oppressed, right? And then, and but yet we're now oppressing these women by not letting them speak. Right, No, it's, it's an interesting paradox for sure. And and quite frankly, a little hypocritical. So this this will be great to get into because it's always good when you can get into primary voices, right. When, when I nerded out, you know, better part of 20 years ago now on the, the founders and, and the, the, the count constitution, I was like, I want to know what those guys said. I want to see the argument, right?
7:05 That led me to Madison's notes, that led me to other things. Because so often we tend to look at history and even the best of us. I think presentism always creeps in a little bit, right? I think it's really hard to always filter that out. And so when you can get back to those primary voices and and in the first person hear about what they had to say, I think it's enlightening it it shows what they were thinking and not so much what we think about or think they must have been thinking about. That was a word salad. Holy cow. So yeah. Right. And so I just want to just preface before we get into it. So again, this, this podcast or this discussion is going to be about the women, especially those that live the plural marriage covenant and I but before we get into talking about, you know, their statements or what they said, I, I just want your listeners to know that that these women, they make, they're so much more than just plural marriage.
8:10 They are, they're women of faith. They're women of like, they're of honor, of nobility. They were deeply religious. They were scriptorians. They knew the Bible. They had a had an understanding of the ancient covenants. They understood, they pretty much understood like Hebrew, the Hebrew life, they were educated on the Bible. They understood rituals. These are just incredible women. So they are more than just for marriage. And while we we will talk about that and we will talk about their experiences with it and their testimonies, I just want your listeners to know that these are women are more than just for wives.
9:00 Yep, Yep, I couldn't agree more. I mean, we, you look at some of the stuff that that Eliza R Snow wrote. I mean, she would have rivaled any man of the day in, in her ability to put together words, you know, poems, hymns, dissertations. I mean, you stack her up against anybody and she she can hang with them. And, and a lot of those women were, were very much that same way. Yes. So these these were women that actually did have the gift of prophecy and they they enjoyed gifts of the Spirit that I think that we think don't exist anymore.
9:43 And to such a degree that, you know, they had, they had power. And, and we'll get into that as we, we get, we get into some of these women. So I don't want to like give it away all upfront. But I also did want to preface because I am a woman and I, I talk to a lot of women, especially about the historical practice of her marriage. And I just want women to know, especially those listening, that as a woman, I, I have empathy for those that do struggle to understand this principle or to understand why it was introduced. And I especially have empathy for women who just have this paralyzing fear of that, you know, their their future or their eternity is going to be for marriage and that they will have no say in the matter.
10:35 And I just want them to know first of all, that that that isn't the gospel of Jesus Christ. That isn't the character of God. He doesn't force anybody into relationships they don't want to be in. And So what I want them to take away from this hopefully is just to understand that that these women, they chose these relationships and they acted with on their full agency and with knowledge. They had actual knowledge of this practice. Why God was asking them to enter into this in into this order. And they did so with, like I said, complete understanding and with a desire to be obedient to what God had had required of them.
11:26 Awesome. And so again, when I, I, I talked to a lot of women, for example, I was at the Book of Mormon Evidence Conference about a week ago and this woman came up to me and she was just complete fear in her eyes. It was, I was trying to talk to her about plumage that that was her big issue. She wanted to understand it, but she just couldn't even, I couldn't even get a word out. And she was just, there was just this fear that took over. And I and I was trying to explain to her that does not come from the Lord. So where is this fear coming from? The Joseph Smith Foundation has a model that says facts fortify faith.
12:12 And so I truly believe that this fear that women have come because they are given wrong information. And so I really do believe it's true that facts really do fortify faith. In fact, the Prophet Joseph Smith said, he said that knowledge is power. And he, he who has the greatest knowledge has the greatest power. And then he went on to say, a man is saved no faster than he gets knowledge. For if he does not get knowledge, he will be brought into captivity by some evil power. And I really truly have seen. And so I, I just, I can stand as a witness of this. I have seen those who lack understanding and who lack knowledge and, and no further their own that they really are, they are held captive by the devil, especially over this principle.
13:08 And, and I've seen it time and time again with these women and men too. And, and so I've watched as this anti polygamy movement has, has, has grown, right. I've watched it grow over the last four years like exponentially. And those in this anti polygamy movement, they are in bondage. That is the only way I can describe it. I've they, they truly think that by believing Joseph Smith wasn't a polygamist that they they have been set free. I've seen so many of them say I'm the truth has set me free. I no longer believe Joseph Smith was a polygamist, but they're not really free.
13:51 They are now in bondage to this new ideology, right? This new version of history. And it's become kind of like their identity in a way, if I could say that. And and so with this new identity, they are now deconstructing their faith. They were rejecting their temple covenants and they're rejecting almost every other teaching, a principle that was taught by the Prophet Joseph Smith. Well, yeah, and, and this idea of, of being free, right? Like I once heard someone say, the truth will set you free, but it's going to make you miserable first, right?
14:33 And certainly I can attest to that as a guy who came into Mormonism cold, right? I didn't have anybody in my inner circle that was Mormon. My family certainly certainly wasn't Mormon, but there was a moment at which I had to take a look in the mirror and go, I might be kind of a dirtbag, right? And then make those changes. And that's painful. And that made me miserable. First, right now, the truth will set you free, but you have to contend with it, right? And that's one of the things I've said is that you have to wrestle with this a little bit, but you're not really free if you simply give up an ideology that you struggled with that has its basis in, in historical fact and evidence and truth. And then you go to another narrative that is liberating or, or seems liberating or made him feel liberating for a while. But at the end of the day, you're still trading in that, that bondage, right?
15:39 You're, you're trading in the, the bondage of fear in this case, right? I, I, I and 'cause I sympathize with this too. And, and I'm a guy who lives the principle, but I've seen it cripple people and, and especially our sisters with, with absolute fear. So they trade in that fear that, that bondage of fear for a bondage of a false narrative and a lie is still bondage. And so you have to be able to be free, but you have to be free through the truth or else it's it's a facade of not being in bondage. Yeah, that's that's correct. And so, like I said, I've I've just watched this it it's just taking over and it consumes people to the point where, like I said, this anti polygamy narrative becomes our identity and and they literally cannot function unless they're constantly like I, I sometimes use the phrase that they just, they constantly have to beat you over the head with it, right.
16:38 It's it's brought up in you just any like LES Facebook group there someone always, no matter what the conversation is that you see that you have this anti polygamist matter woman. They'll come in and they have to turn the conversation around to be about Joseph didn't practice polygamy and it right. They just turn it. It's just the craziest thing. So interesting to watch. And it's, it's actually kind of frustrating 'cause you're like, can we please talk about something other than, you know, plural marriage? And, and it's so it is. It just becomes this identity and it's who they are. They talk about nothing else about then Joseph Smith wasn't a polygamist. And I just have to prove it to the world.
17:18 And again, I feel like they are in bondage to Satan. They've pretty much now got their marching orders from the adversary because they they've allowed the evil 1 to take over, right? And Joseph Smith said if you reject any principle that's revealed from heaven, the devil takes power. Because they're not just rejecting this idea for marriage. It what comes with it. Again, it's, they're rejecting temple ordinances, temple covenants, they're rejecting other revelations to the Prophet Joseph Smith. They're, they're deconstructing every part of Mormonism that they don't like. So I see that there's a real danger in this, a spiritual danger.
18:02 And, and so I, I just hope once again that if they just by just, you know, getting to know the women a little bit, those that entered into this practice, that I, I'm hoping it can alleviate some of the, those fears that women have and, and they can actually be proud of the heritage that they, they come from. Absolutely, absolutely. You did bring up an an interesting point because I've noticed the same thing. It's like I've always said, if you have to come and tear down somebody else's creed or where they worship or any of those other things, that tells me one thing that you're not real secure in your own beliefs, but rather you're, you're, you have to tear down the others for it to work, right. And there's also something I've noticed that's really fascinating, which is I, I think on a subconscious level, those behind this movement understand it cannot work unless it has a massive amount of buy in from a lot of people, right? Because I, I think subconsciously there's a thought of if we say it long enough and we say it loud enough, the facts won't matter because people will just accept it. And so that's, that's been the other insidious part of this that I've noticed is that it's not enough for somebody just to believe this or a group of
19:35 people to believe this. They understand there has to be massive buy in. And and likewise, it's imperative that for them that they get as many people wrapped up into this as they can. Yeah, that's correct. And it's interesting because I I've watched Jacob Hanson with thoughtful faith, if you're familiar with him at all. I am Yep, and. He's trying to take on the, the, you know, this anti polygamy movement. And I watched him go into certain groups of the, you know, the leaders in this movement and he just asks historical questions. What about the this? And I just love reading the comments. Well, I don't love it. It's it's kind of entertaining and it's kind of sad at the same time.
20:20 You just watch them and all they can do is Heckle. Whenever he has, he brings up a really good historical point. What about this source? Or why did this person say this? It's then they just begin with the heckling and they don't ever answer the question. They don't they don't offer like a rational explanation. If they offer any explanation at all, it's usually, oh, they were just toeing the line or oh, this was part of the rewriting of history, or these were, you know, Brigham, you know, part of Brigham Young's cabal or, you know, just and you're just like, this is not even logical. It's not rational. There's no reason behind it. This isn't faith promoting. Where is Christ in all of this?
21:04 It's, it's said, insidious. Yeah, Yep, it is so all right. Awesome. So let's get into it. So I just had to get that, you know? No, you're good now do you? Our. Chest do you need to share any slides or anything like that? I I didn't. I was under the impression that this was just like a voice recording, so I didn't. OK, no, that's that's just fine. You're just fine. I mean, I, I would have loved to have slides. I think that they're. No, you're good. You're good. What it whatever works well. I'm I'm flexible. So I before I begin, because so again, we're going to be talking about the women, right?
21:45 And so like, and it's not just women saying, yes, I was married to the Prophet Joseph Smith. We're going to be talking about what these women knew about the historical practice of her marriage. So I just want to lay a little bit of groundwork that I think is going to be important as we get into these women's testimonies. So for so in order to lay the groundwork right, first we're going to go back to Nauvoo. Joseph Smith is revealing in Nauvoo for the first time, the concept of eternal marriage. So for us, you know, the church has been established for over 200 years. We've, you know, we, we grew up understanding about eternal marriage, but this was a new concept for the first time learning about any kind of, you know, marriage for eternity, families for eternity.
22:41 So anyway, does that make sense? Yep, it absolutely does. So just a new concept. So I just want so just we we need to go back and and kind of put ourselves in their shoes for a little bit. I guess is is that they're learning for the first time. Just this concept of not only is marriage ordained of God, but it is, it's an it's eternal. Right. So revelation given to the Prophet Joseph Smith taught that marriage was ordained of God unto man, and under the law of God that relationship was to extend into eternity without end.
23:22 So in other words, those who are married by the power and authority of the priesthood in this life continue without committing, continue without committing, the sin against the Holy Ghost will continue to increase and have children in the celestial glory. So that's what they was being revealed to them for the first time. Right. So again, we have the advantage of being immersed in this understanding as we were born in this covenant and we inherited this faith from our fathers, so we understand this concept, but for them this was something that was new. Yeah, and, and in some ways it was absolutely revolutionary cause most, most Christian creeds of the time are operating under the assumption that what Christ said in the New Testament about neither being married nor given in marriage after the resurrection was, was the predominant thought. So this is radical revolutionary stuff, and I don't think that could be overstated as well.
24:26 Yeah, and that that again, you said it perfectly. This was radical, right? This was new. This was they had to wrap their minds around it. And so I I just want us. And even even with our understanding that marriage is eternal and that the highest ordinance in the temple is a man and a woman are still together as husband and wife. Even with that understanding, I have noticed that even as Saints we are still very narrow minded. And I want to bring up this point because I even feel like before we can get into these women's testimonies, we have to understand something that I think is very important. So I hear so many people say with even with all of the evidence, even with I can tell them Eliza Arsenal said this, right? She testified of her primary to Joseph Smith and I still get, but Joseph Smith didn't have any kids with anybody but Emma. And so and I'm like, OK, here we go into this. How are we as Latter Day Saints with our understanding that marriage is eternal?
25:34 How do we come back with he didn't have any kids with anyone but Emma. So therefore he he was not married with anyone with Emma because what is eternal marriage? What what was Joseph his saying? He said that those that are married by the power and authority of the priesthood in this life, they will continue in the next life to increase and have children in celestial glory. So Joseph Smith being sealed to Emma and to all of his other poor wives, those relationships will continue into eternity. And what will they produce in eternity? Children.
26:21 Exactly right. And so for me, I'm, I'm sitting there going, OK, wait a minute. Joseph Smith is in Nauvoo in 1841, takes his first poor wife in Nauvoo in 1841. He's killed three years later. When did you in, in, in, in in those three years? He's essentially he can't live with any of the women. Nope. When exactly did you expect him to be having children with these women? Right. And I'm not saying that there was no consummations of marriages because we know that there were, because women did testify. And I'm not saying there were no children. I'm just saying that this idea, if you, you this idea that you're so narrow minded thinking he didn't have, he didn't produce any seed that we know of with anyone but Emma. Therefore he couldn't have been married. I just think I, I just want to just kind of squash that right now because that is a lack of understanding of what eternal marriage is.
27:31 The purpose of it is that your life with your spouse continues into the eternity and you will increase and have children in celestial glory. Yep. I think it's important to note here too, is that so often we make this assumption that Joseph has everything figured out at the exact moment that the, that the revelation is given, right? And that's not the, the, the historical. Sometimes it is, but more times than not, that's not what the historical evidence points to. It points to a revelation will come Joseph, just like we all do, will have more questions and go back and there's a refinement of those revelations, right?
28:17 More revelation is giving clarification is had and those things are done. So there's a lot of those marriages that I wonder. I've, I've wondered personally, and this is just, you know, the book of Dave Page 1. So huge grain of salt here. It he's figuring this out in real time, right? And now to, to make that even more complex, he's figuring it out at the height of Victorian sensibilities, right? And this is going to upset the apple cart in all of of Christendom. The stuff he's talking about is absolutely revolutionary within Christian thought. And so there there may be a little hesitancy for Joseph to even I'm just throwing this out, there may be some hesitancy on even consummating some of those marriages up front, right 'cause Joseph has to understand, oh, this is this has got trouble written all over it.
29:15 Are Are you ready to for me to blow your mind? Yes, yes, OK. So you said, OK, so you said, and I think you're partially right where you said that he's figuring this out. So and I and obviously how how to live this revelation in a telestial fallen world where you're being hunted by, you know, anti Mormon mobs, dissenters. I I think is, is that was the challenge. But let me just blame your mind for a minute. Did you actually know that when Joseph Smith first received the revelation on poor marriage, the Lord actually revealed to him the women he was supposed to enter into that practice with? No, but it wouldn't surprise me either. But yeah, my OK, let me get some duct tape 'cause I'm gonna have to like that's actually.
30:09 What I want to talk about this is this is going to be kind of the heart of this, of this discussion because again, we are Joseph Smith is revealing for the first time this concept of eternal marriage. So like I said before, we have even with our understanding of of eternal marriage or you know, the marriage is beyond this life, we still have a very narrow minded view of eternity. What is eternity? Eternity has no beginning and it has no end. Right. So we, we have this in our mind that OK, from this, this moment going forward, eternity is going to begin. Joseph Smith is revealing eternal marriage for the first time.
30:52 So therefore, I'm gonna be sealed and from here on out, eternal, eternally, I'll be married to this person. But what Joseph Smith was actually revealing is that these relationships existed before this life. OK. I see where you're going. OK. And, and I just want to point out, so, so let's just start with the first pro I've Mary Elizabeth Rollins Lightner. And This is why I think listening to the women is important because if you had if we had listened to what Mary Elizabeth Rollins Lightner said, we would have known that Joseph Smith knew who his wives were before coming to this life. Because she was actually the first woman Joseph command was commanded by God to take as a plural wife. He actually was commanded in 1834 to God had commanded him in 1834.
31:52 She is one of the women you are to enter into this practice with. And so, but he had gotten afraid at that time again, he's still trying to figure out how am I supposed to approach this Puritan Victorian woman that she needs to be a wife, right? And so he's figuring out how to approach her. So he gets afraid. And in 1834, he doesn't do it right. He doesn't follow the command. And the next time he sees Elizabeth Rollins Leitner, she's married to Adam Leitner. And so in his mind, he's thinking, OK, then I guess I don't have to do it. There's, you know, there's nothing I can do now. And but God is saying, no, you still have to because so let's listen to what she her, her version of the story, right? Her testimony.
32:44 So like I said, Mary Elizabeth Rollins Leitner was married to Adam Leitner when Joseph Smith approached her to become his plural wife. And in it so in 1834. So this is Mary Elizabeth Rollins Leitner's what she wrote about this experience. So again, we're listening to the women. She said In 1834, Joseph Smith was commanded to take me for a wife. I was 1000 miles from him and he got afraid. The Angel came to him three times, the last time with a drawn sword and threatened his life. Joseph made known to me that God had commanded him in July of 1834 to take me for a wife, but he had not dared to make it known to me, for when he received the revelation I was in Missouri, and when he did see me I was married.
33:35 But he was again commanded to fulfill the first revelation or suffer condemnation, for I was created for him before the foundation of the earth was laid. So he's obviously related, related this to her and then she's received her own testimony of it this, this union that stretches back. Back, she says I was created for him before the foundation. That's an interesting way of putting it. Yep, and and so this is what she's telling. So have you ever wondered then we what did, what was Joseph Smith telling these women?
34:17 What, what was that like? Well, again you go to the women 'cause they they will tell you. Right. And, and, and so again, I just want to, the reason why I want to read these testimonies is because they do teach us about eternity. They, they do reveal to us the celestial family organization as it, it was organized before the foundation of the world. We sometimes forget that Joseph Smith is a restorer of all things. He's not just restoring the gospel. He's not just restoring a church. He is restoring this, a celestial family organization as it existed before this life. Right.
35:04 Because that's what eternal marriage is, right? It's it's a celestial order. It's a celestial family order. Yep. OK so she goes on and at first she says I did not believe him. If God told him so, why did he not come and tell me? The Angel told him that I should have a witness. And an Angel came to me. It went through me like lightning. I was afraid. Joseph said he came with more revelation and knowledge than Joseph ever dare reveal. And then he said Joseph. Then she said, Joseph said I was his before I came here. And he said all the devils in hell should never get me from him.
35:47 Wow. So, Elizabeth Rowans Lightner, she has an experience where an immortal being comes to her and gives her more revelation and knowledge than Joseph Smith ever dared reveal to anybody. True. So again, when we talked about these women and what I I very much dislike is that in all the conversations with the women, there's a lot of inferring, oh, the women, they some of them it depend hang on who you're talking with, the anti polygamists. They'll just say these women flat out lied. OK, that's what they say.
36:34 Then you have just even even like historians or scholars that, you know, say the historical record is plain that he entered into her marriage. But when you ask him about the women, they'll say they, they kind of also downplay that the women. And I've heard a lot of, you know, historians and scholars say, why would the, you know, why would the women enter into this, into this, into this practice? And it's, oh, they, you know, they didn't know any better or they, they were just doing it on faith or they just, you know, following their leaders, you know, and I'm like, no, they had knowledge. They had more knowledge concerning this practice than Joseph ever dared reveal to anybody.
37:21 And in fact, Joseph Smith said that when one the Section 132 was being copied, he said that that was only but a portion of the revelation that he received. Wow. So we don't even have everything that Joseph Smith had revealed, that the Lord had revealed to Joseph Smith. But when you read the women's testimony, that other portion was revealed to them either by God, by angels, by visions, and I, I, it just blows my mind. So when when we read these testimonies, it's again, we're learning something about the premortal life. We are learning that a marriage extended before we came here, and is that not a principle of the gospel we learned? The absolutely.
38:14 Yeah, We learned in the Doctrine Covenants that the same sociality that exists here will exist there. Well, if it if it exists here, didn't exist before. It has to it, it has to by nature. So let me ask you this, do any of the women that we'll talk about tonight and and we don't need to skip to it. I'm just curious, do they ever tip their hand into some of that knowledge that's not in 132? Well, right. Like I feel like, again, I feel like right here that Mary did And and yeah, we'll talk about that as we go. That's why I'm saying you go to the women and, and, and like I said, they, the women for me are more than just plural wives.
38:58 I started studying the women just because I wanted a role model. I want, like I, I said at the beginning, I wanted to know what it means to be a woman of faith. But in, in reading these women and their life's history and their life's story, I gained an understanding of what our marriage is, why God commanded it. And that's, that's how I gained my testimony of it. That's why I defend it so ardently. I mean, I'm a the church and you know, we don't live for marriage. And but I defend ardently because I know that these women were commanded by God, and I know that they entered into that practice with, like I said, a full knowledge and understanding of what they were doing and why.
39:49 Right, right now that. That makes perfect sense in it. Look, we'll talk about it later, but it's that kind of knowledge, and I won't speak for you. I'll ask you about later, but it's got to help to clean up some of the fear that surrounds it. So yeah. Right. And so she goes on and she says, so she said I was not going to be sealed to Joseph Smith until I had a witness for myself. And so she describes and she says, so I told Joseph Smith I would never be sealed to him until I had a witness. Said he, you have a witness, I made it. And he said, you shall have a witness. So promising her, you know, if if you want your witness, you will have one.
40:34 And so she said, I made it a subject of prayer. And I worried about it because I did not dare speak to a living being. I went out and got between three haystacks where no one could see me. As I knelt down, I thought, why not pray as Moses did. He prayed with his hands raised. When his hands were raised, Israel was victorious, but when they were not raised, the Philistines were victorious. I lifted my hands and I have and I have heard Joseph say that angels cover their faces. I knelt down in it. If ever a poor mortal prayed, I did. And so she prayed right, and she receives her witness. She has an immortal being basically come to her and like she said, gave her more knowledge than Joseph Smith ever dare reveal.
41:18 Wow. And I, and I think some of this knowledge is sacred. And so I, I know a lot of it that they don't reveal because it is sacred. Right. This was this idea of if Joseph Smith didn't reveal it to us, they're not going to reveal everything that they learned, but they're giving us a witness that they did have that knowledge. Excellent. Yeah, Yeah. No, absolutely. So does does Mary Leitner ever recount on any of her assertions in this? No. And I'm so glad you asked that because it's so interesting to me that one of the other arguments that I hear them make is, for example, they'll say that the women said that they were their wives of Joseph Smith because it gave them a prominent position in Utah.
42:11 And if you know the story of Elizabeth, Mary Elizabeth Rollins Leitner, she actually lived in poverty in Utah. She lived, I think she lived in southern Utah. I can't remember it was Cedar City or Saint George. So while we have like the prominent women like Helen Mark Kimball and Eliza R Snow and Elizabeth Whitney, and that had prominence and had positions of honor in the church, you have Mary Elizabeth Rollins Leitner, who basically lived apart from these women. She's living in poverty. And when Joseph Smith the third comes to Utah and sends missionaries, she writes, she basically writes to the women's exponent. We'll talk about that later.
43:04 And she says, well, here I just want no one's asked me. I never got a chance to speak to Joseph Smith the third, but I here's my testimony, you know, use it as you will. And so she recounts this testimony and she writes this in and she's like, here's my testimony. Use it as you will. So there you go. Why? So if the reason they assigned to the women of saying they're married to Joseph Smith is that they have a place of prominence, why is Mary Elizabeth Rollins Lightner living in poverty, not enjoying the this prominence that other women enjoyed? Why is she still right testifying of her relationship with Joseph Smith?
43:48 Especially in the Utah period, right? Because look, it's not scoring any points with the federal government or the population at large outside of Utah to be a plural wife, right? So you've got to be really committed to this in order to to do it right. And I don't see anyone wanting to ride that out through poverty, through everything that comes, unless you've got a burning testimony of this. Right. Yep. And so like, I just, I really like that example just because she's also a controversial wife, just because she was married to Adam Leitner.
44:30 And what's interesting is that again, if you talk to Mary Elizabeth, what about Adam, right. And she said, and so she, she talks about Adam and she says my husband did not belong to the Church. I begged him and plead with him to join, but he would not. He said he did not believe in it, though he thought a great deal of Joseph. He sacrificed his property rather than testify against Joseph Hiram and George A Smith. After he said this, I went forward and was sealed to Joseph for eternity. So Adam Leitner's basically giving his consent. He's not a member of the church and he, but he wouldn't testify against Joseph Smith.
45:12 He never said, oh, he came in and took my wife. Nothing He gives. He, like I said, he gives his consent. He, he actually sacrificed for Joseph Smith. And so she went forward and was still to Joseph Smith for eternity. You know, and I, I want to say this, this, this is interesting because a couple things I picked up on there. One, she mentions I was sealed to Joseph Smith for eternity, right? She doesn't say typically when we talk about eternal marriage, especially in a sacred context, we tend to throw in two words today, time and eternity, right?
45:52 All time and eternity. She leaves out that time part, which I find very interesting. Right, Because I can only assume that that's referring to this temporal existence. The the next thing I'll say is that it would strike me as odd that any man, much less a man who, even though he might think Joseph Smith's a great guy, obviously doesn't believe his doctrine. Though is is kind of OK with this arrangement, right? That tells me that there's people who are looking for the illicit there. Right back to the question of why isn't we, why don't we see more kids from Joseph, plural Joseph plural plural wives running around? Well, this, this would probably fall as to potentially 1 answer for in at least one case concerning the Lightner's. So I I find all those things very interesting. Yeah, so she does.
46:52 She does stay married to Adam, obviously and you know, continues to have kids with him and so and. He moves to Utah. That's a good question. I believe so I I think he died early on. It is interesting to note that she was worried about Adam and there's a letter. So again, there are so many testimonies of, of women. We, I, I just want to throw this in really quickly as I, as I introduced this, what I was going to say about Adam is that I hear a lot of the, the leading voices of the anti polygamy movement, namely another woman who's very vocal, has her own podcast.
47:40 I don't know if you've heard of her. Excuse, excuse me, tell Brady Stone I'm so sorry I got so. When you listen to her podcast, she always says the only testimonies we have of the women are the affidavits and they are signed by they're, they're not even signed by the women. They're, you know, they're test, their signatures are forged. And I'm that is the biggest fallacy ever because there are journals, there are Diaries, there are hundreds of letters, dozens because I've transcribed them. There are biographies, women wrote their biographies.
48:20 We're going to get into the women's exponent, the women publishing their testimonies and their and their witnesses and the women's exponent. But there is a letter that Mary Elizabeth Rollins Leitner writes. And I want to believe it's to Eliza or Snow. And she talks about how that before Joseph died, he actually sealed Adam to him as a son in the law of adoption. Interesting. So like we, you know, we think of well, poor Adam, but he's actually sealed in this celestial family organization now with Joseph Smith, as, you know, his priesthood head and, you know.
49:08 That is fascinating, especially when when we consider that he's not a member. Right, Right. That is fascinating. Because I think with the idea that one day he may accept the gospel and that right, he would be sealed. He would be sealed to a family that he, you know, he's not just he, Joseph didn't just come in and take Adam's wife and leave him, you know, high and dry. He's now sealed in this priesthood organization. You know, he joins as a if he decides to accept the gospel, and which I think he will be as Joseph Smith as his head, he will, you know, be be blessed to be still to to a woman at some point. So it's not like he's left without a family. And and I think that's important to understand too. It's not just Joseph Smith coming in and taking wives from other men.
50:01 Again, he's restoring a family as it existed prior. And like he told that Mary Elizabeth, no, nothing can take you from me. We're sealed. We were sealed before we came here. We're husband and wife, right? Right. And take another man's wife. Right. So technically he she never belongs to Adam. Here. Here's the other fascinating thing, I think. Another doctrinal insight here a little bit, and it's not cut and dry, but so often we say, well, you know this, maybe this guy lived around Mormons his whole life. He should have known the doctrine. Is he worthy to have his temple work done? Well, here's a guy who is familiar with Joseph Smith, familiar with the doctrine, knows it in this life, passes on.
50:51 And the idea is, is that he could still have his work done. And I find that interesting, too, and should be a little nugget for us to carry forward as we go into temples and do vicarious work for the dead. That we don't know all the circumstances, right? There was obviously a circumstance there that prevented Adam Leitner from being able to accept the gospel in that time. But I think it maybe should show us that we maybe need a little more liberality and making sure that we take the right names to the temple. Exactly and and and I think Joseph Smith knew knew his heart and we don't circumstances prevented him from gaining a a a testimony in this life.
51:33 But for sure, I think on the other side, he's. Right, absolutely. All right. Good stuff. Hey, so I you know, I don't know how much time you want to spend on. I can look you. We've done this before. I can go as long as we need to. You get to tell me when it's time to shut it down. So I'm just going to go through again. So I've chosen now this isn't a comprehensive right list of women because like I said, there are, there are dozens and, and we've been left with the impression from leading voices like Michelle Brady Stone that the women only signed affidavits and they were fraudulent.
52:15 And that's all we have. When in reality, there is so many things written and said by the women. And so this isn't comprehensive by any, any means. I've I've tried to choose testimonies where it teaches us a principle or teaches us something about eternity that we can learn from, because I think that's the value of listening to the women and actually trying to go to the women to understand their marriage. Right. Because again, if you were, if we wanted to know what Joseph Smith taught outside of Section 132 about poor marriage, don't you want to go to the people he taught it to? Absolutely. Exactly.
52:56 And so who are the women he's talking to or who are the ones he's talking to? It's. His wives. His wives right women and I mean we, we get a lot from Brigham Young and Heber C Kimball, but but I really think the women have it's just so profound what they what they shared with us. Absolutely. So I chose Lucy Walker Smith for a specific reason. She was a plural wife of Joseph Smith and her I think that just her experience of praying with real intent illustrates an important principle for for all of us. So again, she, she's being taught the principle of her marriage. And first she's like, this is not for me, right? Like she has.
53:44 I think the and, and that's what I love about the women is you hear like they make you, you know, they make you feel seen and heard that, wait, these women have the same reaction as I would, right? Or that I'm like, no way would I ever consider this. So she said so as she's relating her experience, she said that of course she's being taught the principal encouraged, you have to pray about it. Go get your own witness, just like in any principle of the gospel. And she says, I felt I prayed sincerely but was so unwilling to consider the matter favorable that I fear I did not ask in faith or light.
54:25 Growth, starkness instead of light took possession of my mind. I was tempted and tortured beyond endurance until life was not desirable. So what? What did we learn from that experience? Well, oh, sorry, I thought that that was rhetorical. Go ahead. No, that was a question. Go ahead. I to me, one of the things that that really stick out to me are, are two one, if you're going to ask a question to the Lord, you had better be sincere, right? You had better not come with any preconceived notions. And certainly I'm, I'm guilty of that from time to time. I think we all are right.
55:07 We all have desires and wants that we want to have fulfilled. But sometimes though, that's not what's best for us. So when you go to prayer, when you go to receive, ask for knowledge and that sort of thing, you had better be able to really make a good case and and then be able to to accept the answer that comes the next question. The next thing that that really jumps out at me is this idea of wrestling with things, right? It wasn't a one off thing I asked. No, didn't like it. So I'm done. Continue to wrestle with it.
55:49 Right. I was just reading here the other day that the word wrestle and embrace are fairly similar in the Hebrew. And so as I've looked at at the story of, of Jacob wrestling with the Angel, you know, I, I was like, OK, so is that wrestle or is that embrace? Well, sometimes I think it's a matter of timing on that, right? Maybe it's you start out as wrestling with things that you later come to embrace as you gain more light and knowledge and more understanding on the subject. Those were the two things that jumped out at me. Yeah, that's, that's exactly. And I and that's why I wanted to share that because I think that's just this important principle of even in the Book of Mormon, when Morona is asking us to pray, he says you have to pray with a sincere heart and real intent. And then so, then Lucy Walker, she's so. She shares that.
56:42 And then she goes on to say, oh, how I prayed earnestly for a manifestation of the will of God concerning me. It was nearer dawn after another sleepless night, when my room was lighted up by a heavenly influence To me. It was, in comparison, like the brilliant sun bursting through the darkest cloud. My soul was filled with the calm, sweet peace that I never knew. Supreme happiness took possession of me, and I received a powerful, powerful, and irresistible testimony of the truth of poor marriage, which has been like an anchor to my soul. True, yeah.
57:27 And then gets gets the answer that that is the truth. Not what. Maybe not what she wanted at first, but the truth. Right. And she even says that it was. What did she say? So first she's in darkness and she said she was tempted and tortured and it was made life undesirable. And now she's saying supreme happiness took possession of me. And and then she goes on to say, as I was praying this last time, an Angel of the Lord appeared to me and told me the principle was of God, and for me to accept it. Wow, wow. Right. So again, we don't know.
58:07 And so God, I am a firm believer that God never gives a revelation without reasons for understanding it. So I don't think the Angel just said it's true. Accept it. We know that at that moment she received knowledge from this Angel. Right. Who and and what who, if it's OK to ask who, who is she exactly right. It's one thing to read about this one instance in her life, which is super important. I don't want to downplay that. But as you were alluding to before, she's more than just a plural wife, right? She's got a story to tell. Who? Who is she?
58:50 Lucy Walker. Yeah. Well I mean, she wouldn't. Was she married to afterwards? Was she married? I'm trying to remember if she's one of the women that does testify that she consummated the marriage with Joseph Smith. OK. And so we know that about her for sure. She's, I think she goes on to be married to, to Brigham Young and, and why, why do you think that's important? I think this is this is my opinion on why she's she marries Brigham Young. I think 1. As has been stated, she gains a burning testimony of this.
59:34 But I've often wondered at times if if Brigham did not feel because we know how Brigham felt about Joseph, right? That's that's that's his ride or die. He he would go to the ends of the earth for Joseph Smith. And I think probably it was a way that Brigham could ensure her safety. I would imagine on some level those are my answers. She's got a testimony of it, and then Brigham wants to ensure her safety. Yes. And, and also we know that there's quotes from Hiram Smith that said that that the principle of the leave rate marriage would be restored.
1:00:18 OK. And that would fall into that? Yep. Yep, and she was actually so I was just wanting to make sure I didn't I represented her well that I was just looking up. It says that it she appears to be no, we talked about Mary Elizabeth Leitner was one of the first women God commanded for him to take. But of course we know that at that time he didn't he he didn't obey at that time. But Lucy Walker was one of the first women that was taught the principal of the of the restoration of her marriage. Let's see. Yeah. So she's again burning testimony. She remains faithful to it throughout her life. Again.
1:01:02 So again, why would you marry Brigham Young? Why not now? The. She's a widow. If once Joseph Smith passes away, she's a widow. She could go out and have, you know, you think if this was about romance, she could then go out and marry somebody else for time. But she chooses to to marry Brigham Young. And I think that it speaks to, again, this idea that she understood. She understands the purpose on a level that we don't even understand. Like, I can't say what she knew because she doesn't tell us. She is. All she says is that an Angel appeared to me and told me that it was true. Can I ask you a question that may take us on a tangent for just a minute? Yeah.
1:01:46 Because you brought you brought up something interesting. And I, and I want to say this from the outset, I am a guy who believes that no man should arrange a marriage for other people. I think that that's only a recipe for disaster, but something that was said that you said in there, I think it is, is super important. It's something I've been looking at a lot lately, especially since I have kids now of marrying age. And that is we, we look at ceilings and eternal marriage now from a very romantic point of view, right.
1:02:29 And I'm not saying that that's bad, but also I think there needs to be a, a longer view of this, right? You got to play the long game in it. And, and sometimes I think because of our, our, the, the day and age that we live in, I think a lot of people want the the notebook version, Mormon style, right? Where it's this really low, you know, super romantic thing. But I often wonder if sometimes we're not, we're, we're not served well with that mentality, right? Rather is, is this the person I'm supposed to be with? And again, I'm not for arranged marriages.
1:03:10 I, I, I parted ways with with certain people over this issue because I find it so repugnant when someone else arranges it. But people, I think as, as they pick a spouse and something I've counseled my kids on is make sure that you're playing the long game here. Look, looks fade. You know, I I've told my boy, someday this is what you're going to look like. I hate to break it to you. This is who you are. So you better have something else in place other than just raw desire and and romance in that place. Is that making sense? Yeah, for sure. And I and I would just say too that I think that we also have AI guess a corrupted definition of what love is. Yeah, like we, I don't think we understand what true love is. Like true love is sacrificial love. It's about laying down your life for another person. It's about putting somebody else first, right? It's about, it's just, it's the kind of love that Jesus Christ has.
1:04:13 Right. Absolutely. Church, right So. Yeah, yeah. No, absolutely. OK. That was it. That was my side tangent. That's that's one of the smallest tangents I go on. And, and this idea too, that like you, then you don't, you know, like then people think, well, were these women then just stuck in these loveless marriages? And again, I think it's because it's about this sacrificial love what, what they knew what this was designed to accomplish. And, and again, so why were they doing it? Was it so they they could have like the, you know, the romantic where we walk on the beach and we have, you know, Sunday picnics or you can have this eternal marriage where you obtain celestial glory. And I just think that we do not understand what marriage is like in heaven.
1:05:11 So, but obviously these women did, otherwise they wouldn't have done it because they did have a choice. And and that's I guess what I'm hoping that we, we understand about these women. And so, and some of these I'm not I, these women, I just, I shared just their testimonies, OK, Some of them are not as, as elaborate as others. But for example, Desdemona Fulmer, I chose her because I feel like her, she's an interesting, she was a plural wife of Joseph Smith. But I feel like if you understood her life before she became a member of the church, I think it's very important because she actually had similar religious experiences like Joseph Smith, for example, she was one that was actually searching for the truth, like Joseph Smith. And so she said she began to read the Bible and then she received what she termed was a promise from the Lord that she would be saved in the Kingdom of God. And so she then continued seeking. So she's like, I'm not going to join any church. I need to join a church or religion where I this promise can be fulfilled.
1:06:27 And so she said, she continued seeking. And she said, quote, I was looking forward to a time when the knowledge of God would cover the earth. She used a couple of very key Mormon terms in there long before she was a Mormon, right? This idea of the Kingdom, right? I mean, in Mormon, especially early Mormonism, that's a huge point right there. There is a difference between the church and the Kingdom, so to speak, right? And so she in that term, and she's talking about being saved in the Kingdom. The the other thing is this, this idea of the truth covering the earth, very, very reminiscent of things Joseph had said and prophesied about Mormonism. Fascinating stuff.
1:07:15 Right. And so we have to remember again, these were women that were educated on the Bible and so they understood this covenant, this ancient covenant. They knew these prophecies of the last days. They were not ignorant. They they were actually so knowledgeable. And that's what I love about learning about these women, about how how much that they, you know, they are. I feel like these are like the women you read about in the Scripture. Right. And so her testimony is is quite simple. So that was her before this was, you know, so she continued looking. So then, you know, we know she joins the church. She becomes a plural wife of Joseph Smith. And she said, she just said simply, she testified that she had a night vision and an Angel appeared to her and told her that the principle is true. And so she said, having been convinced to the truth of polygamy, I therefore entered into that order and that that was all she gave us.
1:08:17 But again, she had a night vision. We don't know what she saw in that night vision. But when God gives you a vision, it's usually he reveals things to you that you don't you you you don't know before, right? Right, right, right. And it's kind of pointless to argue at that point that's that's, that's over. Yeah, and then and and and Angel appeared to her. So she's having these, they're having these heavenly experiences as what I guess I want, I want to point out they're having and they're worthy of them, right? I thought, I don't think that an Angel just appears to anybody to tell an Angel doesn't didn't come to me to tell me the Book of Mormon was true. I got my testimony through the Holy Ghost, which is perfectly fine.
1:09:05 But what is it about these women that that they're getting these heavenly experiences? They're essentially getting the same experiences as Joseph Smith. Joseph Smith had angels coming to him to teach him. They're getting the same experiences. What does this tell us about who these women are? Well, I think it I think it points to two things. One, you can't just make the assumption here that these women are uneducated, which has been another slam on on plural marriage for a long time, right? They're just uneducated. I mean, they don't know any better, right?
1:09:46 They're they're not. Maybe they're, their mental prowess isn't there and and they can't do that. That doesn't seem to be the case 'cause they all are intelligent, intellectual, as we're seeing here, as you quote them, articulate women who have done the homework, so to speak. The other thing I would say is I think even more than the intellectual capacity and honesty, there's got to be something deeper on the inside, right? A heart that's willing to accept truth, consequences be damned. You know what I mean? Just willing to go for it. Yep. And, and, and that's why I think it's like, again, that's why I have the hardest time watching just this conversation about PLUR marriage when we don't talk about the women, because the women are the second-half of the restoration. Yeah, absolutely.
1:10:45 And and I'm not a feminist. I don't, I'm not here to be like rah, rah women's rights. I'm just here to say that women have an important role in the Kingdom of God. That that like I said, they are the second-half of the restoration. The restoration did not happen without these women. We even go back to Mary Elizabeth Rawlins Leitner. Well, who was she? She's the the girl at 12 years old who saves the book of commandments. So we, we tell, right, we tell that story in church history and we, oh, she's, she saves the book of commandments. She's 12. She takes the manuscript and she runs from the mob and, you know, and hides and she saves the book of commandments.
1:11:28 Well, because she's of such a character that she prized the revelations of God enough to risk her life to preserve them and to save them. Absolutely. You know, and you say something very, you said something very interesting there that women are the second-half of the the restoration. That's that's a big statement. But yet I'm not sure that even does it real justice, right? Because from, from a very practical standpoint, I can testify that this whole thing as far as plural marriage and that sort of stuff, it falls apart if women are not amenable to it, right? If they do not have a burning testimony of it. And so this idea that they were duped or they were just kind of tricked into it, that doesn't hold water either. Because the look, the truth always comes out. No matter what, it always comes out. And if, if this was just a Joseph thing, if this was just, hey, he's got a cult of personality, right? He's, he's really smooth.
1:12:38 That's going to wear off when he's dead right and they have other viable options but yet still choose this. So the idea that they're just duped, that doesn't hold water. Right now when you start to read their testimonies, and that's why I can see why Michelle Brady Stone, she runs from the women's testimonies. She doesn't, she doesn't want to talk about them. She she pretends they don't exist. She pretends they're not there. And when you do point out any like, well, I was having a conversation with her one day just online. Obviously she doesn't. We don't talk in person. You don't hang out, you don't you don't like, do you? You don't have lunch dates. I'm shocked.
1:13:19 I I don't know what to do. I don't know why we'd get along great. Not just kidding, but I was pointing out, I'm like, well, what about Elizabeth Whitney? She's the mother of Sarah Ann Whitney, who was a plurality to Joseph Smith, and she wrote her an autobiography and she related the experience of Joseph Smith teaching her family her marriage and then her giving her daughter in marriage to the Prophet Joseph Smith. What about that? And I you could not believe the just the mental gymnastics she went from everything to that's a forgery to oh, she was forced to write that. Like, I'm like, OK, you can infer that, right? You you can say that all you want and you can't even believe it, but where's the evidence?
1:14:07 Right. Right. And and that's, that's the part that drives me nuts, right? Because look, we do have record of women living, leaving plural marriage that they weren't, they weren't a fan of it, right? Even some of Brigham's wife's just leave 'cause they're not a fan of it. That's cool. You do you, right? I mean, what? Whatever it takes, but in the absence of any other evidence to just call it a forgery. Where's your proof? Where's your proof that it's a forgery? I've heard the claims. You know, Michelle Brady Stone is really good at making claims, but she stinks on ice when it comes time to back those claims up.
1:14:49 And that's something I'm willing to go to the mat on here on this one, because she really is. Wait. OK, look, at this point, I can't even say she's just horribly mistaken. We're crossing into the lines now that that quite frankly are just lies. And, and that is the most disturbing part to me is, is just the, the willingness to just continue to lie about it, knowing you got to know at this point that it's, it's the, the stuff she's saying is false when when the only thing she can do is claim that it's a forgery and not produce any evidence that it is a forgery if it should fall on deaf ears at that point.
1:15:36 Yeah, it's, it was, it's just frustrating 'cause obviously the that's what people want to hear. OK, I can dismiss this woman because Michelle said it's a forgery, but I what I really liked what? Have you ever read the book or are you aware of the book The Women of Mormondem? Yes, I have read excerpts. I haven't went all the way through, but I'll be honest with you when when I want to get inside, I shouldn't say get inside the mind of, but understand what Joseph was really talking about. Tend to go to that one because there is a lot in there. And just like all men do we confide in our wives, right? There's they are absolutely the ones we go to when when things get the toughest and there are a lot of Nuggets from Joseph Smith in that book. It is phenomenal.
1:16:27 I keep it by the side of my bed. I I refer to it often. I just I love that book and I loved at what, what's his name? Edward Tulage. He's the author. And it was, he did write that under, you know, the direction of Elizar Snow. And the women did have input because obviously this is a history of their lives. But I really liked what he said in the introduction. He said, He said, the record of their lives. Speaking about the women, it is now sent unto you that you may have an opportunity to judge them in the spirit of righteousness. So shall you be judged by Him whom they have honored, whose glory they have sought, and whose name they have magnified. And so I don't care if you disagree with these women, but you cannot judge them in the spirit of righteousness if you have not listened to their testimonies and their witnesses of what they knew to be true.
1:17:24 So for Michelle to just claim that was a forgery, she was trauma bonded, she was forced to do this, she was lying. She cannot do that in the spirit of righteousness if she does not even acknowledge that these testimonies exist, that these women left a record of their testimony that we don't. They're not just affidavits that were signed that don't have their real signatures, that they are actual witness statements from the women. Want more from the Mormon Renegade podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the fundamental news program for. Free.
1:18:09 Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button and for $5.00 a month you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes today. Claim that was a forgery. She was trauma bonded. She was forced to do this. She was lying. She cannot do that in the spirit of righteousness if she does not even acknowledge that these testimonies exist, that these women left a record of their testimony that we don't. They're not just affidavits that were signed that don't have their real signatures that they are actual witness statements from the women, if that makes sense. Absolutely it does 100%.
1:19:03 I couldn't agree with you more. Yeah. And so I, I just, yeah, again, it's about we have, I think we have a duty and a responsibility to seek out these testimonies, to seek out what the women said. OK, So just going on 'cause I, I really do want to get to Eliza Arsenault because, you know, as we know, she's the most celebrated woman in Mormon history for good reason. But I really like what she taught us in her testimony of her marriage, 'cause she said, and, and again, you listen to her as she grew in knowledge. And again, she's like any any other woman where she's first introduced to the practice and she recorded in her journal, she said The subject was very repugnant to my feelings.
1:19:57 This is just a natural reaction and I love that these women are honest. So she goes on to write, though, she says. But later, after growing in her understanding of the principle through the instruction of the Holy Ghost, she wrote. Quote As I increased in knowledge concerning the principal and the design of her marriage, I grew in love with it and today esteem it as a precious sacred principle. Wow, that's. Interesting. Does she, does she ever have like, because, because we saw with, with Lucy Walker Smith and and Desdemona Fulmer that they kind of have heavenly visitations, right? Does Eliza, because she seems to say through the spirit, right? And and I'm fascinated with the different mechanism there. Yeah, so, well, I'll do so in her testimony. She doesn't ever allude to that, but I did want to share an experience that she had after actually after the death of the Prophet Joseph Smith.
1:21:12 So before I get to that, I just wanted to I if I could just finish reading her testimony. Sorry, sorry about that. Oh, no, you didn't jump. I was just, I just wanted to finish reading it 'cause like I said it, it what they say in these testimony again is teaching us something about the order of Heaven, right. And so she goes on to say, you know, she, she grows in the, in the knowledge, she increases in knowledge. So this was, so I will say this. So like where other women say they had these heavenly visions and they had angels coming to him, she's saying that she increases in knowledge to the spirit.
1:21:56 So she's learning line upon line, precept upon precept, kind of like how we're supposed to learn. So I, I love that too, that here's a different experience where she doesn't get the heavenly vision that we know of because she doesn't say that, but she still increases in knowledge of it. So she's being taught throughout her life. And, and so I, I love that. And so she said in Nauvoo, I first understood the practice of plurality of wives was to be introduced in the church. The subject was very repudnant to my feelings. And then she goes on to say, But when I reflected that I was living in the dispensation of the fullness of times, embracing all other dispensations, surely poor marriage must necessarily be included. So again, this idea that these women were educated in the Bible.
1:22:51 He's. Saying, well, if this is the fullness of times and we know that it happened anciently, it must be part of. Yeah, it's got to come back. There's no way if if Abraham practiced that in in faithfulness, which I believe he did, if if we know that David had problems, but plural marriage doesn't seem to be one of them. I believe Moses was was living that principle as well. We know that he did it in righteousness. So it's got to be a true principle. And if it's a true principle and then going on to say that this is the dispensation of the fullness of times, it's got to, it's got to make a return.
1:23:36 It has. To Yeah. And so another highlight of her testimony. Again, I think this speaks to the character of the women, she says. It was not long, however, after I received this first intimation, before the announcement reached me that the set time had come that God had commanded His servants to establish the order by taking additional wives. I knew that God was speaking. So there to me what stands out to me? And then you can tell me what? Well, first tell me what you what stands out to you in that last part of her testimony?
1:24:16 He seems to get something that it's made known to her that quote, the set time had arrived right that that she is somehow Privy to something that maybe others weren't. That was the thing that jumped out to me on that and that she had heard it from the voice of God himself right. She said that she heard that voice. Now what mechanism is that? Is that from the pulpit as Joseph is, is preaching? Is that a a, you know, a a her hearing a voice and and some of her quiet reflection or meditation or prayer? I'm not sure.
1:24:58 But it seems to be that she has one some idea that this is coming and then that that quote set time had arrived. Almost like she was being prepared right? And then also hearing the voice of God somehow. Yes, and she said she knew that it was God of those speaking. And what I liked about that is because I think often and there's a scripture and I'm probably going to butcher it where it says how does a man, how does a man know a master? He has not served or something. And so I'm like she, if she can, she recognized the voice of God, it's because she has been serving God. He's not just a she's not just this Sinner who was converted to Christianity.
1:25:51 She's not a Christian converted to the Book of Mormon. She is a woman that has that knows God, she knows his voice. She knows the scriptures. She understands the the role of Joseph Smith in and restoring the fullness of the dispensation of times. So and again, so if we want to understand the restoration, why will we not go to, to those men and women who knew absolutely right. They weren't just like, oh, I don't know what's going on here as these things are happening. No, they're, they're, they're seeing and experiencing, right? Especially the wives of Joseph.
1:26:41 They're they're the experiences that they're having are beyond just seen, right? They are understanding at a much deeper level what is happening here, which again, and I want to say this too, right, oftentimes in Christendom, up until quite frankly, Joseph Smith, the idea was, well, the world's the way it is because Eve screwed up, right? This flies in the face of that, right? This is on par, in my opinion, with the savior showing up and we, you know, it, it'd be a conversation for a later day.
1:27:24 We can talk about why that is, but it's on par with the savior showing up first to announce himself to a woman right after his resurrection. It's it's putting women back in, in their their proper elevated station, in my opinion, within the gospel and, and it it's showing how God feels about his daughters and that they're not, they're not what Christendom had painted them to be as the bane of of this existence. Cause evade the fruit. Exactly. And yeah, like I like they're restoring women to their.
1:28:07 Yep. High Holy positions as priestesses and prophetesses, Queens and priestess unto God. And so a lot of people, you know, there's a lot of accusations made against Eliza or Snow that she's part of this push to, you know, convince women to lie and part of, you know, Brigham Young's cabal. And, and I, I just take so such great offense because of who Elizar Snow is as a woman. She, she even said that plural marriage did not hurt her.
1:28:48 She said polygamy did not hurt me, but to be looked upon as a woman of light character did hurt me. The very idea of my not being a virtuous woman. Wow. Yeah, so you can see that she's what was worse to her, like the plural marriage was, you know, wasn't. I know the least least of her concerns, right? She has a good, good grasp on it. Right. Let let me ask you this about Eliza R Snow. Does she ever have children? No, she does not have children. And, and there's, there's, I think there's pretty good history to back up the fact that she was gang raped.
1:29:31 And so I think that left her unable to have children. And you know, 'cause when we talk about, I always say the part of, of history that's whitewashed is the part that that we don't tell of what really happened when the Saints were driven out of Missouri and we we whitewashed the fact that women were raped. Being raped. Children were raped. Men were raped and and that's the part we white Ross. And so unfortunately, I think that she experienced that and was unable to conceive children. I know there's a story of of supposedly a light Emma throwing her down the stairs that she was pregnant, but I, I she never writes about that in her journal.
1:30:19 So if she doesn't write about it, I think that either it didn't happen or she just didn't want us to know that. So I, I personally, I don't propagate that correct story because I it doesn't come from her. So and I think if anyone, she should be the one to tell it if it happened and and she doesn't tell it. So I just. Sure. I just don't give that any credence. So, but I do also want to point out that again, there's a lot of I've heard a lot of excuses that people make that she was just still to Joseph and it wasn't a marriage, but she does say quote, I was still to the Prophet Joseph Smith for time and eternity in accordance with the celestial law of marriage which God had revealed the ceremony being performed by a servant of the most high authorized to officiate in sacred ordinances. This one of the most important events of my life I have never caused to regret.
1:31:18 Wow. Yep, and she writes of Joseph Smith saying he's my beloved husband, the choice of my heart and the crown of my life. I I have another question and this is just me wondering because I haven't been able to find anything here. What's her relationship with Brigham like? Because I know she marries Brigham later, right? Do we get an idea of, of what their, their marital life was like? I mean, were they, were they close? I mean, Brigham had a lot of wives, right? And on some level I almost get the sense that this is, this is the way that, that Brigham is honestly taking care of a lot of single women, right? Do we know what, what their, what their relationship was like at all?
1:32:04 Do we have anything from her journals that give us any insight there? Oh, absolutely. So this is an interesting dynamic. Again, a lot of people like to make up things about Eliza or Snow, but what we do know just from the writings in Brigham Young's I she was married to Brigham Young, but I don't get the sense that they were. It was a conjugal relationship. That's what I got too, but I was curious if you found anything to the contrary. So we do know that she lived in in the the Lion House. That's what it was called, right? The Lion House, sorry.
1:32:46 So we do know that she lived in there, but so she takes an interesting role where she's kind of like a counselor to Brigham Young. So she's kind of like, almost like in Brigham Young's writings, you see how he's like, OK, we're going to establish the first Deseret, you know, hospital. But I'm not going to do it unless Eliza Arsenault agrees to, you know, basically be on the board. Interesting. Because she is and, and this is going and I'm going to tell you why. So when we get this is the experience I wanted to share with you. And I think this is going to give us a sense of why Because after the death of Joseph Smith, she becomes so distraught.
1:33:32 And this actually speaks to her closeness to Joseph Smith because she becomes so distraught that she begins praying night and day for God to like let her die. Like she does not want to live anymore. He's like, I can't this, I'm in grief. I can't live without my husband, which tells us that they had an intimate relationship. They did? Yep. I mean, she did live in his house for a time. She was, we know that she did teach his children. But so she goes on to say that. So then she has a dream and she's visited by Joseph Smith in a dream and she said that God has plans for you.
1:34:16 He said Joseph told her that this work upon the earth was that his work upon the earth was completed as far as the mortal Tabernacle was concerned, but hers was not. The Lord desired her, and so did her husband, to live many years and to assist in carrying on the great latter day work which Joseph had been chosen to establish. Yeah. And so after that, she ever since then it, she appears that she was consoled by that and she let go of her loneliness and her bereavement and she resigned her life to, to serving God. And so we see that in her life, right? We see that she is, she carries on, she carries on the release society.
1:35:05 She spends her life working in the endowment house, administering the endowment. She's establishes the release society. She goes and she travels throughout the Utah Territory establishing the Release Society in the different wards. She gives up her life for the establishment of the work of God, right? So she'd be she completes the work that Joseph had begun, and the Release Society was an important part of the Kingdom. Yeah, yeah. No, Look, I know Brigham suspended it for a time, right? And, and for reasons that that we can get in another time. But he does reinstitute it and it does begin to function much the same way that Joseph Joseph had. And there's some interesting stuff concerning women in the priesthood that come out of some of those early Utah period accounts of, of society.
1:36:03 One last thing I wanted to point out here that that I just found absolutely interesting. And I think it speaks not so much to to just women, but to the human condition in general. I look at what happens to Eliza Arsenal in Missouri, right? Horrific. And then I look at someone like Margaret Sanger, who something very similar happened to her in her childhood. And it's interesting how I think we all go through times in our lives, hopefully never to that extreme. Most of us won't today won't have to ever think about that. But when faced with that, it's we, we have choices as a human being, right?
1:36:52 We can either decide to wallow in that darkness and that you know, look, in the case of Margaret Sanger, it's still happening today. Thousands of deaths of the most innocent or Eliza R Snow, who says I'm going to throw myself into the work of God in service of my my fellow brothers and sisters. And, and I find it a very fascinating comparison because they go through similar things, but they end up so far apart and, and what they what they use on that. Wow. I didn't. I didn't know that about Margaret Singer. So that yeah, that is.
1:37:34 Oh, don't, yeah, don't look into Sanger. I did that once and went down that rabbit hole and that was horrific. Don't, don't do that. That's. Yeah, this a stark contrast for sure. And and the thing about Eliza is I want to point out is like when you talk, you brought up the women and the priesthood. And so Eliza or Snow, what makes the Release Society successful is because she in Nauvoo, she's the secretary of the Release Society. So she had kept all the minutes and she carried those across the plains. And so the only reason we have the teachings of Joseph Smith to the release Release Society today is because of Eliza or Snow. So without Eliza or Snow, there would be no Release Society. We would know what Joseph Smith was teaching the women.
1:38:18 And, and what's interesting to me too. So we're talking about, you know, Eliza or Snow's kind of like a counselor to Brigham Young. She kind of feels that role. And you see, what you see in Eliza's life is that actually she's humble and she's submissive and she's obedient to the righteous counsel of the priesthood. And that is actually how she gains her gifts of the Spirit. And she has. So for example, just read a few excerpts from her journal where she's she talks about. So again, she says, let me get to it. She says on June 2nd, 1847, I spent the afternoon with Lucy and company of Zaina, Louisa and Emily. Emily and myself spoke in the gift of tongues on June 3rd of that year.
1:39:12 She said Sister Sessions, Kimball, Whitney and myself spent the evening at Sarah Ann's had a powerful time. Deep things were brought forth or which were not to be spoken. Yeah. To be a family on that wall. Yeah. So you see, she is these gifts of the Spirit, this, this priesthood, 'cause she's, she's ordained, she has her second anointing. She's ordained a priestess, she's ordained a queen in the priestess. Whereas in the, in the Elias Church today we're only ordained to become such. So she, she becomes a priestess and a prophetess of the restoration. And then at another time, she said on June 6th, she says a time of blessing at Sister Kimball's Sister Sessions and myself, Blessed Helen.
1:40:01 So here we see them exercising. The the gift of healing. And they're laying their heads upon the women. And she said I spoke and she interpreted. I then blessed the girls in a song, singing to each in rotation. So yeah, you know, you see the gift of. Oh, go ahead, finish. I'm sorry. Oh, I was just gonna just say the gift of prophecy in tongues were like, they're very familiar to these women. Absolutely. The other thing that this brings out, right, 'cause let's face it, the favorite whipping boy of, of stone and that and, and those who who align with her is Brigham Young, right?
1:40:44 That's who they love to flog more than anybody else. But, and, and one of the things they level is he's so misogynistic, right? That's one of the things I hear get tossed around really frequently. That's a tough accusation to make if if he's essentially counseling with Eliza R Snow on things and he's saying, look, I'm not I'm, I'm not touching this hospital project unless she's on the board, right? That's not a misogynistic guy. I'm sorry. It's just not that's a guy. And and there's other things there. And and that's some of those stories that need to be told, right? Because not only do we get a sense of just how amazing these women were and how spiritually gifted they were and how important they are to the restoration, but they also, by their own voice, testify of who these early leaders of the church were.
1:41:39 Yeah. And I always, I've always said, and I always try to help people understand that under the ordained leadership of Brigham Young, these women flourished. It wasn't just a Lysar Snow on the board. It was an all women board. And these women flourished. Not only did they have the the the they start the hospital and run it. Brigham Young is sending women back east to go to Med school. I mean, we hear of women becoming midwives, but he was sending them to become doctors. He's encouraging women to become, he's like study accounting. You can become better businessman than your husband's. He's encouraging them to go into politics. They Yeah, beats your own husband, right? Yeah, the the, the fallen side of me wishes I could have heard what, what her husband, what what kind of raft he got from some of the guys in his ward when that when that death settled.
1:42:36 But yeah, you're you're a spot on. Yeah, and I, and I do want to get to the women's exponent because this is very, very important. So the women, they start the the woman's exponent. This is a woman's journal, like in all of Christendom. Do you ever hear of a woman having their own journal, their own writings? And. And so you have Elizar Snow as an editor and Emmeline B Wells. And what? Do you even know why the woman's exponent was started? I don't. It was started because of all of the anti polygamy sediments we have. We have not just the RLDS missionaries coming to convince that they're trying to convert members to go back to Nauvoo, but then you have there were organizations that were starting in Utah that from non members that were they were jealous of the Relief Society and they saw the influence that women had in Utah.
1:43:44 And so they tried to start their own organization to rival the Relief Society. And so they started what they called this anti polygamy standard where they, the women and these are non Mormon women, they started collecting these anonymous affidavits to slander Utah polygamist women. So it's really fascinating that they they, they get together and they start the women's exponent. And this was like in 1972 when I get the exact date. So I think it's June 1st or sorry, 1872. I don't know what I said. You said it's OK, we knew what you meant. OK, sorry, I'm like. Oh, you're good, You're good.
1:44:27 Hey, and I, I'm so fascinated. So this is just this is what and another thing that gets me is the again, the leading voices in the anti polygamy movement do not talk about the women's exponent. They do not want you to know about the women's exponent because so Helen Mark Kimball, another per Rifa Joseph Smith, she now she's I'm not going to stand for this. I am going to use my pan and I'm going to use it to to basically raise my voice. And so she's in in defense of poor marriage.
1:45:09 And so she writes. This is what she writes. She says the conflict. So she's she's speaking about all these people that are now persecuting these polygamous women and slandering them and trying to make them look like, you know, they are oppressed and they're ignorant and they're in this horrible system of her marriage. And she writes, the conflict is between them and our God, who has never forsaken his people. But he does not expect us to sit quietly down and fold their hands in idleness while our enemies are publishing their outrageous falsehoods. To blind the eyes of the week, incredulous to the most glorious truths of heaven, and to throw ignominy and dishonor upon our people, as our slanderers are on the road to perdition, but to use every honorable means to defend ourselves against their vile attacks. I love that fire, that love that fire. I love it so much.
1:46:07 And so they start the women's exponent and it's a woman's journal. They this is where the women are start. They come out and they're like I'm publishing my testimony, I'm publishing my witness. I was taught pre marriage by Joseph Smith and I want the world to know and they're publishing this to the world. Every week something goes out from these women. And so these aren't women that are oppressed. These aren't women that are being coerced and forced. Right, right. No, they're, look, they're taking to heart what it says in the DNC that you should be actively engaged in a good 'cause, right? And I can imagine that, that I don't know for certain, you probably have more information on that than I do.
1:46:52 To me, this sounds kind of like a grassroots movement among those group of sisters, right? And, and let's face it, and, and, and I've said this for a while too, right? You will never, you will never catch me trying to tell a, a woman how great plural marriage is because it's kind of a bad look, right? And I'm a dude, right? And people are going to be like, well, of course you're for it, right? There is something more potent when women step up to make to make that that claim. It is more potent because it's their voice, not not the dudes.
1:47:39 Yeah, and it's so interesting that listening again, I she's just the leading voice. So we've got to call it out because she's the leading voice. Michelle Brady Stone is the leading voice against these women. And it's interesting to me that she uses the anti polygamy standard to to basically convince her audience. Look how bad her marriage is. That anti polygamy standard was started by women who weren't even members of the church and they were attacking the women in Utah. So again, this is, you know, like Michelle is all about women empowerment. She's all about feminism.
1:48:21 And here she is using women who aren't even her religion. There aren't even members of the church that are are writing anonymous affidavits slandering Utah women and trying to distort people's perceptions of of poor marriage. That's what she uses as sources. And it's just so frustrating. Instead of going to the women's exponent saying, well, what did the women say to defend themselves? What did they teach in the women's exponent? Yeah, she look in her quest, as you put it, to, to, to make sure that women's empowerment has a place and, and, and, and in Mormonism and feminism and, and all those other things, she has to discredit other women, right. And to me, that's, that's the insane part of the whole thing, right?
1:49:21 Is that to get where you want to go, you've got to step over, step over women and their testimonies and what they believed was true. And it just doesn't hold water and it's despicable on some level. And you know, Dave, I know we're getting close to two hours, but I there's just two things I want to share. Take all the time you need. I only put two hours down there 'cause I got to put something on the invite. So you take whatever time you need. Kimberly. OK, because I, I again, I just, I want to make sure I again, this cannot be comprehensive. That if, if you know, if, if anyone's interested in learning more about these women, I'm happy to point them in, in the right direction and give them, you know, resources and places they can look. But so there's just two really important things I again, I want to hopefully represent tonight.
1:50:14 So not only the women's exponent, which I think what is a huge source for the women's testimonies like major like I could, I'll just give you one example of someone who wrote in to give her testimony and she's and her name is Helen M Callister. So she's not even a a women that you know that is is noteworthy or you know one of those prominent women. She's just your average latter day St. who's living her religion and she writes in and she says to raise my voice in public has ever been a source of much embarrassment to my sensitive nature. Indeed, I always feel my inability to address even my sisters in this capacity. But duty and justice demand that my voice should now be heard, and would that my words of faith in defense of my religion might re echo and find accordance in every heart of every true hearted woman.
1:51:13 And then she goes on to say, I know the principle of plur marriage to be the truth. I have lived in polygamy for the last 33 years and was among the first to enter into that sacred principle. Yeah. I can, I can kind of identify with that voice, right? Not wanting to do it right. Not your thing, but the times call for it. Now you don't get to just stay on the sidelines any longer. Now you got to get in the game. Yeah, and that's why I wish in this discussion we that we would let the women speak. Let them. And and so people can actually decide. So if you're going to have a debate about poor marriage, you have Michelle's voice. Michelle Brady Stone again, because she's the leading voice. She's made herself a public figure. She's representing, she claims to represent the women, but then let people hear their voice so they can decide which voice they're going to follow.
1:52:13 Whose testimony are they going to believe? And I just, so that's just again, my frustration is that not very many people have heard these testimonies. And then something I think is of of noteworthy to add is that if we haven't heard enough of the women in the great in the women's exponent in on January 6th, 1870, do you know what happened that on that date? Enlighten me please. So there was this mass meeting of women. It was called the Great Indignation Meeting, and 5000 women Mormon women came to sign the petition to protest a government bill that would make polygamy in Utah illegal.
1:53:06 Wow, so the women showed up for it? 5000 Mormon women lined the streets of Utah to sign a petition to protest a government bill which was going to make polygamy illegal. If you are oppressed, if polygamy is such this horrible system and Brigham Young is a tyrant, church leaders or tyrants, wouldn't you welcome this government bill to make it illegal? Yeah, yeah, it's your perfect out right If you if you are in bondage, you don't even have to take responsibility for being set free. You can just be like, sorry, dude, not my not not my doing if I'd say.
1:53:52 But you know, the government says, you know, we got to be done with this instead. Well, and here's the here's the other fascinating thing. I'm just thinking about the numbers in 1870, right? Saints show up in Utah 47. So you're you're about 30 years, right? I'm guessing that not even all the women there are probably in the principle even, right? But there are women that probably are either aspiring to or at least the very least want to respect their sisters enough to be like, this is their choice. This is what they want. I'm here to support them. It's it's a fascinating moment in time where you hear the women's voice come through in defense of this. Yeah, and what's fascinating, too. Again, we're talking about, you know, women. This was a meeting of women.
1:54:49 And so they hold this, So they sign this petition and then they hold this, what they call the great indignation meeting. It was this mass meeting. So you have again, so the federal government is involved. So you have major press there, press from, you know, back East everywhere. And they listen to these women as they gather together. And then they, they, they stand up on over the pulpit and they begin to bear witness of their religious rights, the right to practice this principle and then to bear witness of the principle. And I just wanted to give this testimony of this woman. Her name is, she doesn't give her first name. She's, it's Missus Wilmarth East. So she's going by her husband's name, Missus Wilmarth E. She gets up in this meeting and she says, this is what she says. I am thankful today that I have had the privilege of living the religion of Jesus, our Savior.
1:55:46 I'm thankful today that I have. I have the honored privilege of being the happy recipient of one of the greatest principles ever revealed to man for his redemption and exaltation in the Kingdom of God, namely plurality of wives. And I am thankful today that I know God is at the helm and will defend His people. True man. And it's just passed out. It's never revisited. That kind of passion is never given It's it's due. These women don't ever get their quite frankly, the recognition that they deserve right. Look, it's one thing to do it today. I don't want to lessen that or cheapen that at all. It's a hard way of life.
1:56:36 Not always right. I don't want want to seem like it's miserable. I know again, women are free to to leave, right, just as the men are, but they're doing it in a time when it's brand new, right? This is the first time in mass that this principles attempted to being lived again. And they don't even they don't even have the the gift of anonymity at this point, right? If you live in Utah in the 1870s, everybody knows right from San Francisco to New York, everybody knows what's happening. And it shows an extreme amount of intestinal fortitude to stand up at this time and bear testimony like that.
1:57:27 And for, for those you know, in, in, in the, the polygamy denial camp to just toss those aside. It's despicable. I and, and quite frankly, and, and these are my words, not yours. You're kind of a despicable human being if you can just toss this aside. Yeah, and toss it aside, especially given the fact that these women made incredible sacrifices like and Zaina de Huntington, she said. She even mentions, 'cause you're like, you said, that there's no anonymity. Anonymity. Sorry.
1:58:07 It's right, I struggled with it too. And she said I made a greater sacrifice than to give my life, for I never anticipated again to be looked upon as an honorable woman by those I dearly loved. How can I compromise conscience and lay aside the sure testimony, the Spirit of God, for the glory of this world? Wow, yeah, someone needs to write a book about this. Right? Like just following it. I mean, the I'm going to say something now that that may it'll get me in some trouble, but that's OK. I'm used to those waters. This might really be the first suffrage movement for women in America. I can't think of another one before this. And this time it's it's a movement to just let them practice their religion and live what to the dictates of their own conscience in a marital practice that the rest of the world the pours.
1:59:06 Yeah, and what's interesting to me is that that's what Joseph Smith gave his life for. He he gave his life. He wanted everybody to be free to live their religion. And, and now modern Latter Day Saints are turning on the, the, you know, the founders of their own religion and, and trying to defame them and shame them and bring dishonor upon them for living their religion, living what they, what was their conscience, what they, they testify came from God. So it's just, it's just frustrating to me. I don't even have the right words.
1:59:47 It's, it's heartbreaking. It it, it actually does bring me a lot of sadness, actually. Did that sadness come from a place of just watching the these women's words and their their emotion and their passion just being tossed aside? Is is that where the sadness comes from? Because I, I'm, I feel like, you know, I, I was born in the church, but you know, I didn't, I, I guess I, I feel like I'm, I'm in a position where I was born kind of in a, in a family that was inactive. And, you know, I come from a broken home. I had divorced parents. I lost my mother at a young age. And, and so I wanted the gospel.
2:00:32 You know, I was looking for that eternal family. I was looking for, like it said, what these women sacrificed for. I wanted the power and the authority and I wanted the eternal families and I, and so I fought really hard for it. I, I fought to, you know, gain my testimony. I fought to, to try to live the gospel the best I could so I could marry in the temple. And, and then I see all of these, you know, Latter Day Saints not only born in the covenant, but are literal descendants of these men and women. There's Brigham Young descendants that are turning on him. There's, you know, John Taylor descendants that are saying, I'll, I'm ashamed of my ancestor for living plural marriage.
2:01:13 And they're, and they, because I feel like I was blessed with this gospel and this covenant because they made that sacrifice. How can I turn on them? And so it brings me sadness to see these Latter Day Saints not value what they have and and the heritage they're part of. I'm, I'm right there with you as a first generation Mormon ever. There's times I just watched the one where there was a descendant of Brigham Young who was, you know, really coming hard after, after him. And I'm like, if you don't like your place in that family, can I have it 'cause I'd kind of killed for, you know, to go back a ways in, in the restored gospel, right. It is sad and it it's quite frankly on par with what we're dealing with today, right?
2:02:06 It is a an unhinging of of good history, true history, and a an embracing of lies and falsehoods and all things that are fake. And and it's exact is exactly right. So I'm just like, what does for example, what does Michelle Brady Stone have to offer you is like, so these women, I feel like we through these women, we've inherited this covenant. What do you inherit from Michelle Bruce? Like what does she offer you? Like instead of Mormonism, what what do you get? What what covenant do you get?
2:02:50 What priesthood do you get? Like what? At the end of the day, what is she offering you? Absolutely, absolutely. And and here here's I lately I've been studying a lot on unintended consequences, right. I look back at at World War One, you know, they, they just decimate Germany with, with sanctions for the First World War. Well, what's the unintended consequence of that? Well, eventually you cause hunger in Germany, which leads to a guy being able to stand up and say follow me, and that leads to the Holocaust.
2:03:32 OK, that's an unintended consequence. Let's just game plan this out, right? What are the unintended consequences of espousing what Michelle Brady Stone is selling? It's this. You want to get rid of plural marriage, That's fine. But in order to do it, you got to get rid of 132. You get rid of 132, what's the unintended consequence? You get rid of eternal families, period, right? That's not a thing anymore because the same revelation that outlines plural marriage is also the same revelation that outlines eternal families ceilings.
2:04:15 And once you take that away, what do you got left? Well, and and please, for those who are the Protestant faith that listen, don't take this as a slam because I don't mean it to be. But what you're left with is you're left with Protestantism, with some really cool buildings and and an additional book of scripture. That's what you've got, the mysteries of godliness that can be revealed outside the temple. You know, I love the Book of Mormon. I do, I value that book. I read that book daily. But if you're looking for the mysteries of godliness and scripture outside the temple, that's only found in the Doctrine and Covenants and especially once you get to the to the Nauvoo period, right, and all the writings of Joseph Smith.
2:05:02 So if you want to detach from that, understand there's consequences to be had in doing that. You will get rid and you will gut out of Mormonism anything uniquely Mormon and you will be left with Protestantism with a really cool book and some really extravagant buildings. So what you got? No power, no authority, no priesthood. So we know in the Bible that Jesus Christ said I am the vine and you are the branches. And then, you know, he talks about, he's explaining that relationship between himself and his followers. And he's basically saying that, you know, if you remain in me and I in you, you will bear much fruit.
2:05:47 But then he says, if you do not remain in me, you are like a branch that is thrown away and Withers, right? And and I really, if we can just, we can end on this high note because Eliza Snow, she writes this poem called The Tree, the Tree of Life. Can I 'cause I got just two questions I want to ask you before we wrap up. And then, and then I want to hear, hear that poem. But first, I, I want, I, I need to ask these two questions. One, why haven't we ever read about these women, these early women in Mormonism, right? Why is it that they have not been featured more prominently within Mormon circles?
2:06:32 And I'm not just pointing at the LDS Church, I'm pointing in general at at all expressions of the Restoration. Why are we not hearing this more? That is a good question. And it that is my frustration, to be honest. Like I know that a year ago or whatever you had Hannah Stoddard on your podcast talking about the Helen Mark Kimball book. And I think that was the reason why, you know, she started out wanting to write about these women is because we women need heroes. We have a lot of scriptural examples, you know, of men. And I'm by no means a, a feminist, so I'm not saying that that's bad. I'm just saying, but women need heroes. Women need a good examples of what true womanhood look like. What true what what does it mean to be a mother in Zion? And, and, and so I don't know what we need these. We need to tell the stories of these women because they forged the path for us.
2:07:39 Right. They laid the foundation of the Kingdom of God, and without them, they're for women. There is no Kingdom. Without them, there's no Kingdom for a man. Just that's that's what it is. We look that's we can't dudes can't get there by themselves, right? Women can't get by themselves right. You want to quote equalize the sexes. Welcome to Mormonism. We've been doing it for a while, even with icky plural marriage as some people like to look at it right. It's an It's absolutely an equalization. Neither, neither gender, and news flash area really is only two. Neither gender can get to where they want to go without each other.
2:08:29 Period. Exactly. I mean that that's the capstone of the of the Restoration, right, Is the eternal marriage, joining of the sexes. So and that's the Kingdom. Yep. A a man cannot attain the fullness of the priesthood without the woman. And then the woman with the man, she obtains the fullness of the priesthood. She becomes a queen and a priestess in, in the fullness of the priesthood in God's Kingdom. She is a queen and a priestess to rule and reign over the House of Israel. And so without, without any. Yeah, I, I would love it if there's, if you, there's some talented men or women out there, preferably women that want to take this project down and study the life of one of these women and write a book about her.
2:09:17 I think that would just, we need that actually, we, we need the, these women need women need women. And I, and I believe that with all my heart, I as a woman myself, I, it just, I, there's no one for me to look to in modern society that I can say this is what a godly woman looks like. This is what a holy woman looks like that I want to be like her. But we have those examples and we need, so they need to be lifted up so we can see them and we can learn from them. Yeah. So I I do love that in the early days of the church when these women were entered into these covenants and they were given their patriarchal blessings, I was just going to be one of the women were told, she said. One of the women was told, Thou shalt be numbered among the mothers in Israel, for thou shalt have knowledge by which thou shalt teach the daughters of Zion how to live. Wow.
2:10:25 Yeah. So you know the these are the examples. These are when we think of the Millennium and who's going to reign in the Millennium, Who is going to going to be by Joseph Smith's side. His wives. His wives. And so at some point or another, you're going to have to, if you want to be in Zion, you have to accept the fact that Joseph Smith is going to be there with his wives. Right. Absolutely. And, and then he'll be having children with these wives, with these women. And you're going to have to accept the fact that that it's, you know, these other women having children with Joseph Smith. That it's a fully functional marriage.
2:11:07 Yep, absolutely. OK, let me ask you this question, and this one's a little more personal, but as you 'cause you, you come in from a place as, as you noted that you weren't, weren't necessarily your, your family may have been Mormon by birth, but you guys weren't necessarily practicing, right? Did you ever struggle with the polygamy thing? Did you ever look at it and, and kind of wither and say, oh man, that's that's rough. I don't want to look at that. So I really apologize. I know that some women might not like my answer, OK, but I'm just going to be honest. OK.
2:11:51 So I again, because I feel like I had to fight basically for a testimony and I had to search it out because I wasn't being, it wasn't like I was being handed the gospel at at home. And so I wanted to know everything about my religion. So I studied early on, like in high school. I'm just, I read the history of the church. I I read the scriptures, I read doctrine comments 132 and that actually became my favorite scripture and so in but in my mind I'm like, OK, that happened.
2:12:35 There was a reason for it. The church doesn't live it now, so I don't have to worry about it. And then I just left it alone and I did. It didn't bother me. OK. Until about 2000, I want to say 12 between about the years 2012 and 2015, I had a really, really, really strong prompting and impression from the Spirit that if I wanted a strong and lasting testimony of the gospel of the Restoration, I needed to have a testimony of every single revelation that came through the Joseph through Joseph Smith. And so I knew that I had to gain a testimony for myself that poor marriage was true, that it was a revelation that came from God. I didn't just have like a, a knowledge that happened right? I before it was just like, yeah, I know that it happened historically.
2:13:38 I had to gain that witness for myself. Gotcha. And oh, sorry, go ahead, finish. No, go ahead. Did it scare you when when you got that prompting? Did you ever feel in bondage to that fear? I I wasn't scared. I was just wondering. I'm like, OK, so it and and it turned out to a little bit be prophetic, right, Because I had no idea what was coming down the Pike. What was coming. An attack on poor marriage. Our marriage is being used as a, as a, like I've said it before, a theological weapon against the church.
2:14:21 It's being used as a theological weapon against the Restoration, against the character of Brigham Young and John Taylor. And had I not gained that testimony when I did and listened to that prompting, I might be a polygamy denier right now. Right, right. And and I feel like it was a blessing and so I wasn't afraid of it. And and The thing is, again, what happens when you gain a testimony, when you gain a witness by the spirit, I can testify like these women, it brings you peace. God helps you to understand it. That it that when you have knowledge, you have power.
2:15:04 You have it brings peace and joy And and I'm not a like again, I'm a mainstream member. I, I have, I live in monogamy. I'm not saying I'm looking forward to living polygamy. I'm not saying I, well, I can't wait to die and go to the special Kingdom and have and live polygamy. I'm not, you know, I'm not saying that at all. What I'm saying is, is that having an understanding that this revelation came from God and that the men and women of the Restoration were men and women of honor and integrity and live the commandments, and we're obedient to every word that proceeded out of the word, the mouth of God, that gave me hope.
2:15:48 OK. It cemented my testimony that the restoration it is the foundation of the Kingdom of God and it's solid. Right. Absolutely. And and that's, that's what I think the big take away should be on this right, is that don't trade one form of bondage, that of being scared of of the doctrine for another form of bondage, which is being ensnared in something that's blatantly false, that's peddled by people such as Michelle Brady Stone. But rather wrestle with the truth. Wrestle with the truth, because you, you will start by wrestling and then at some point you will embrace it, right? What starts out as a tussle will end up in as an embrace. But you got to put in the work, right? Just like he talked about, you got to put the work in. If you don't, if you do and you still walk away from it. Hey, I get it.
2:16:53 It's rough and and I, I don't bear judgement on anybody, man or woman who who shies away from it. It, it can be, it can be rough to think about and, and it's I get it, I understand it, but it doesn't mean it's not true. And just cause something challenges us doesn't mean it's not true. So. Right. And I've, I've tried to just share that with women that just having the knowledge that it it came from God. Does that mean that you have to live? It doesn't mean that God is then going to turn around and say now you have to live this. It just means that then you have knowledge. Again, knowledge is power. That the Restoration is actually true, the Brigham Young is actually a prophet of God, that John Taylor is actually a prophet of God.
2:17:42 That these women were actually wholly consecrated women who loved the Lord, and they sacrificed everything to lay the foundation of the Kingdom of God. And from them we inherit the covenant. We. Inherit this covenant that we need that we have to have in order to be saved. Absolutely. All right, those, those were my two questions. Let's go ahead and go to that poem, 'cause I, it's I. If it's the one I'm thinking of, it'll be a great place to to wrap this all up. Yeah. And and I do want to wrap it up with this because again, Elizar Snow, she's the prophetess of the Restoration. She's actually was set apart by Joseph Smith in Nauvoo to be Zion's poetess.
2:18:33 And so through her poetry, this is where she reveals the doctrine. So this poem, I think, is so profound. And again, it ties in to what Jesus taught about you were the I am the vine and you were the branches. So she's it's called the tree of life. And so she says the tree of life's an emblem, one that shows the principle on which existence flows the trunk, the center issuing from the root from which 12 branches bear twelve kinds of fruit, the root, the spring, the fountain or the head from which the Spirit, life, light, knowledge spread will and to him the eternal God compare diffusing life and blessings everywhere.
2:19:23 The trump to Christ who is living, who is the living vine to whom as branches his apostles join, partake his Spirit and and the fruit they bear is through their lineage scattered here and there. So this is the this is just the first part. So again, she's comparing right? She's saying this tree is Christ and these branches are what his 12 apostles. So again, it's what he's saying. I'm the vine, you are the branches. If you cut yourself off, you're going to wither and die. If you. Stay in this trunk with and again with the 12 apostles anciently and in the restoration, right? You stay, you're part of this tree, this vine, and you partake of spirit, life, light knowledge, right? Then she goes on.
2:20:19 This is the part I think, I just think it's so beautiful. So she gets, she goes on, and she says again, We'll thus compare the tree of life, the trunk husband, every branch a wife grafted in him the fruit posterity partaking life and fatness from the tree, the leaves, the holy priesthood that will rest upon that fruit by lineal behest and through the perfect laws of purity, will for the healing of the nations be. And thus will Joseph Brigham, Heber 2, and many more that practice as they do, as stems, as trunks, as heads, as centers, stand and spread their righteous branches over the land, through limb to limb be grafted on, until the spreading boughs shall all the garden feel. However far the utmost limbs extend the trunk, it SAP through every fiber sins.
2:21:25 Wow. Oh, and then sorry, there was one more part. She says Christ is the holy branch from Jesse's root. Twas said that that from his roots a stem would shoot. From that same stem, the Saviors will come forth on Mount and Zion's mount to sanctify the earth. Oh, illusions to temple work as well. Oh, there, there's, there's a lot there that is absolutely beautiful. And the fact that she couples that with just stay true to the gospel, but also understand what a how big of a role plural, celestial plural marriage plays in this, right?
2:22:08 She goes on. And, and I think it's a beautiful allegory where she talks about, you know, the, the, the, the wives being grafted with the husbands and the posterity being the fruit and the priesthood being the leaves and, and leaves kind of protect that fruit. And yeah. And then makes allusions to, if I'm not mistaken, that that last part there talks about kind of a lineage of the savior, right? Standing as saviors on Mount Zion temple work, that sort of thing. We, we had a previous podcast where we talked about the reasons for plural marriage and you did an excellent job and, and laying that out about preserving the the posterity back, back to Adam, right? You have to look at the whole picture to understand what, what's going on here.
2:23:00 Because if you just say, well, it's just about multiple wives, well, yeah, it's going to be easy to get rid of at that point. But you have to understand the underpinnings of what's happening and the plan that the Lord has or you're you're kind of doomed. You're kind of doomed to end up in Michelle Brady Stone's camp. I don't know how else to say it. You have to understand the doctrine. You have to understand what it was, what was being taught in conjunction with this practice period. It would be like doing temple work without understanding what vicarious work for the dead is. It would. It would be pointless.
2:23:42 Right and and right, it's, it's all about the priesthood. I remember, you know, Jesus Christ said, I will make, you know, the covenant that God made with Israel is that I will make you a nation of kings and priests. That's a, that's a priesthood. How, how is the Kingdom going to how are we going to, you know, how, how is the Kingdom going to put all other, you know, all other nations are going to be under the Kingdom of God? How is that going to happen? Unless the priesthood is like it says in that poem, it's going to extend throughout the whole world, essentially. Absolutely, absolutely. Well, Kimberly, anything else you want to wrap up with? I the only thing I would just add again, is I that my hope for doing this podcast is, is I hope that when people listen to this, they just walk away with that eternal hope that you know, again, that the gospel is true, that the restoration is true, that temple ordinances are of God, and that they don't have to be afraid of the historical practice of plural marriage. Absolutely.
2:24:50 And and that because of the sacrifices of these women, we get to enjoy the fruits of the gospel. Absolutely. I want to say just a few things here before we wrap up, and I want to make it abundantly clear that these are my words. They're not Kimber Kimberly's. There's nobody else's. If you're on the fence here and you're you're looking at Michelle Brady Stone and you're looking at Justin Griffin and you're looking at a host of polygamy deniers. And quite frankly, it's not I, I, I think even that term, you know, polygamy denier doesn't tell the full story of what you're going to be up against.
2:25:38 You you are in actively engaged in taking out the underpinnings of what the restoration is really all about. And it's not just plural marriage, it's ceilings. It's it's all those things I alluded to in in an in those unintended consequences of trying to to get rid of this. Just know that the history is overwhelming, that Joseph not only taught but practice plural marriage. Overwhelming. You have to be.
2:26:20 We are past, hey, is this a possibility? Questioning. We are now into your you're lying. And if you ever wanted to know which side you'd be on in the Book of Mormon when core horror came creeping around, this is your time to show it. Because if you fall for this enticing. And I get it. I've been through the ringer studying Mormonism and all the stuff that I perceived as problematic. I understand the the, the unsettling feelings that come, but I also understand the benefits of sticking with it and working through those things.
2:27:03 And I'm not saying you're going to go my direction, right? I'm not telling anybody. Oh, OK, now, now you understand. So just jump on the Fundy train. We'll all go together. It's not what I'm saying. What I'm saying is you have to understand it if you want to understand the gospel and the restoration as taught as revealed by Joseph Smith. And I hear a lot of people saying, gosh, how could people fall for that when Cora whore came around? Well, here's your opportunity because Michelle Brady Stone is a Cora whore. I don't know how else to put it. Justin Griffin is a Cora whore and and the people who lead out in that are absolutely a Cora whore.
2:27:46 And they're praying, quite frankly, on some of the weakest of us. They rely on people having a faith crisis and then capitalizing on that faith crisis. And they also are using the same deplorable tactics that were used on the Founding Fathers, right? The left understood entirely, If you want to get rid of the Constitution, you have to progress past it. And the only way you can progress past it is by discrediting the founders. Now, they're not out and outright discrediting Joseph Smith. They're just painting you a very different picture of Joseph, who Joseph Smith is, one that's not based in truth. And then they're out and out discrediting and attacking Brigham Young.
2:28:35 So understand that if you're on the fence, and if you are on the fence and you are, you're concerned and you don't know where to turn, go seek out those sources. Kimberly is, is the book Women of Mormon available today? Where do they find that? I'm pretty sure you can still find it on Amazon so it's definitely available. I'm there. I think you can even get APDF online so if you don't want a hard copy just Google woman of more of them and. I'll try to hunt that down and put in the show notes on this episode. What about the women's exponent? It's yes, you can buy. You definitely can't. Yes, it's called The Woman's View and I think it, it was I, I bought my copy off Amazon.
2:29:23 So yeah, you can definitely get the Women's exponent. I recommend just I, I actually recommend all the poems by Eliza R Snow. They were published. Someone's published them again, because she's teaching the doctrine, she's revealing the doctrine through poetry. So you can learn so much about the gospel through just reading her poems. Yeah. Helen Mark Kimball. Joseph Smith Foundation published the book a year or so ago. I recommend that book. I'm learning about Helen Mark Kimball 'cause she is one of those voices of, of her marriage. And she was, she's actually a historian herself, Helen Mark Kimball.
2:30:06 So she documents the history, 'cause she, she pretty much lived the history, right. She grew up in the gospel. So she lived every major event in history. So she's definitely a source. Her her journals are published. So yeah. Awesome. Anything else before we wrap up, Kimberly? No, I just appreciate this opportunity and I appreciate the conversation and I hope it's edifying to your listeners. I'm sure it will be. I know my mind's blown every time we talk. Hang out for 5 minutes. I just got a few more things I want to go over with you. OK. All right. Bye everybody.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox