Episode #149: The Prophet Enoch Installment #3 In The Old Testament Series W/Michael Ness
Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.
Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products
So if you remember a few months back I released an episode about the books of Enoch. In that episode we broke down the history of the books from a scholarly perspective. Now today we are going to do a deep dive on what the Books of Enoch teach us as Michael Ness and I continue our series on the Old Testament. During our conversation we parse out who Enoch was, how he fits in the timeline of the patriarchs, what some of his heavenly visitations can teach us, and then wrap it all up by talking about what Enoch means to adherents to the restoration.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:05 So if you remember a few months back, I released an episode about the Books of Enoch. In that episode, we broke down the history of the books from a very scholarly perspective. Now today, we're going to take a deep dive on what the Books of Enoch have to teach us as Michael Ness and I continue our series on the Old Testament. During our conversation, we parse out who Enoch was, how he fits in the timeline of the patriarchs, what some of his heavenly visitations can teach us, and then wrap it all up by talking about what Enoch should mean to each one of us as adherence to the Restoration. That and much, much more on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. So a few weeks back, I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running.
0:46 Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page or click the link in this episode show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups, and water bottles, all with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU. But you should definitely go check that out now. This is just the beginning. In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now, all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast. So head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode show notes and get yours today.
2:05 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast, Lesson 3. Lesson 3. Lesson 3 Who are we talking about? We're talking about Enoch. Enoch, dude, I'll tell you what, that has to be one of the men that I wish we just had more on. I know Joseph gives us some. I know that we get some from various books of Enoch. But man, there, there's some stuff there, right? Especially as Mormons, I think because we know that Melchizedek had a successful society and there's been some speculation that his city was taken up, right? We don't have know that for certain, but they're just there and then they're gone. I like the way that Joseph Smith translation reads with him. It says that they sought the city of Enoch, and it says that they did obtain heaven as what it does. Yep.
2:56 But Enoch, Enoch and his city, we know for certain got there. And maybe this is just the the surveyor slash planner in me, but I would love to know what the ordinances of that city were, right? Not not ordinances in terms of like temple ordinances, but how was the city governed? Yeah, civil laws all that. Yeah, unfortunately the the extra canonical non biblical books of Enoch don't really go into the city aspect because right, this is not there. But hopefully we can kind of derive some of sure the name Enoch On a thought. I was just barely looking that up. It seems like the name Enoch means initiated, dedicated, or inaugurated.
3:39 But I vaguely remember that he nibbles a mean that meant consecrated. So even the name for Enoch meant consecrated. So it's interesting that he is the ideal for consecration. Right, which actually as you said, that does lend itself to the belief in certain ordinances making a man dedicated more consecrated. Initiated. Initiated, right? Those are those are all things as Mormons we should be very familiar with, especially if we're familiar with temple liturgy and those sorts of things. Yeah, dude, temple liturgies everywhere. You know, we've been going through that in our lessons, right? Like all the early Christian scriptures, the Adamic stuff, the Adam literature, it's got all the ordinances spelled out practically right through there.
4:23 Interesting. So yeah, I'm geeked up for this one. Yeah, you know, it's it's going to be a good one. So we left off with last time kind of with the idea that the Pearl great price is the answer to Nephi's conundrum that the plain and precious or things were removed or even covenants of the Lord are removed. So not necessarily plain and precious, but when the Angel showing him in first Nephi 13 and he sees the book that'll come forth among the Gentiles and then to his people, that Angel tells him it was complete, but then it's been, it's been taken apart. And Nephi remarks that it contained the covenants of the Lord only there were not so many. So the Bible didn't even have as many as the brass plates had, right?
5:14 He nibly says the Pearl of great price is the only thing that restores what was lost from the Bible because the Book of Mormon does not restore what was lost from the Bible, right? And so we're kind of dealing with that more in that sphere this time for sure, whether it's what we're getting from Joseph Smith, but we're also going to dive into the Books of Enoch. Too as well. Nice. We'll do. Let's tear it. All right. We'll take a look at what's in our polar grid price first. Do you need a set of scriptures or anything? I don't. I mean, I got it on my phone besides my notes here at the end of where things are kind of moving along after Cain kills Abel, it says that Adam blessed. Adam was blessed and the gospel was preached, you know, the all things were confirmed unto Adam, it says by a holy ordinance. And the gospel preached preached in a decree sent forth that it should be in the world until the end thereof. And thus it was.
6:17 And Adam hearkened them the voice of God and called upon his sons to repent. And Adam knew his wife again and she bare a son and called his name Seth and Adam glorify the name of God, for he said God had a hath appointed me another seed instead of Abel whom Cain slew. So that's important because in the class, I don't think we covered it in the podcast, but in the class we were, I was showing the the early Adam literature where Michael the Archangel is sent by God to go talk to Adam after Cain kills Abel. And he says, don't reveal the mysteries to Cain, you will have another heir. Because that was kind of the contention, right? As we discovered, you know, that Cain wants to, he wanted to be the patriarch over the priesthood. And so that fits, although, you know, squinting at it, you kind of got to say, oh, Cain already had the ordinances to be where he was, right?
7:07 But nonetheless, that element is in that liturgy, or that the Scripture is interesting. Adam was told that he'd have another error. How do you square that with the Adam God doctrine? Right, because you have Michael coming to talk to Adam. In LDS theology, Michael is Adam. So. Are you thinking more offices here as well? I don't know if we need to go into offices. I think in our world offices is the the typical explanation and that's fine, but I think, you know, in in the lessons, I really went into like the linguistic approach to like the names of God being, you know, as a different approach for identities of the personages. In this instance, though, So we covered the Adam literature and like the discourse on Avaton and and stuff where the Jews have, you know, like the what was it called the divine investiture of Michael.
8:04 That is crazy, right? Where you have the, you see the figures of both Michael and Adam, though they are separate in that framework, they're both being exalted to basically the identical position. And you and I are squinting at it and reading in between the lines and like, what's really going on here, right? Is it that they were viewed as separate? Or maybe some people really had the esoteric knowledge that they were the same when they were kind of bound in the culture, to put it into different terms. But as I've been reading the book The Enoch Stuff, I have a new approach. Really. Yeah, that's interesting. OK. I'm sure we'll get there that. No, no, we can go into it now. The the Jews and the Christians got rid of the idea of a pre existence. Right.
8:49 But for a while it existed among both groups. In fact I want to say the Jews actually have that longer. That might be not true, but but both originally believed in that and as an outgrowth of a belief in a pre existence is that we exist. It was our own entity before we came here. I think we see, as I've been studying the books of Enoch and stuff like that is we have heavenly counterparts. OK. And so not only were they viewed as oh, that was me before this now, but like, I still exist there. Oh, OK. Yeah. And so that that could you could be seeing some of that element, like fascinating. Yeah, Enoch has his heavenly counterparts in these stories. OK.
9:38 And it's kind of veiled, like at one sense he's seeing the Son of Man, which we're like, oh, that's Christ. And in some instances it when he's interacting with the Son of Man in heaven, because Enoch's being brought into heaven, it's like, Oh yeah, that's a separate person, but then personage. But then it like, starts blending, like Enoch is the Son of Man, and the Son of Man is his heavenly identity workout. Interesting. Yeah, it's weird and but that's one approach. That's. Just the way that they looked at things, you know? Right? But I almost want to write a scholarly paper that for example, on the Adam God doctrine in light of what the scholars would term Second Temple Judaism. Are you familiar with what that term means? Right.
10:25 So the Second Temple, and we'll talk more about that is the period between 500 ish AD when they rebuilt the temple after the Babylonian relativity and Christ, right? And so that's that era, which is the better documented era of Judaism, right? But like all the literature from that point to me when I look at that, Michael the Archangel is nigh unto God, if not viewed as God in literature. And it's because the Greek philosophy at the time was, you know, when people think of Greeks, they think of like Greek mythology and like, Oh yeah, Zeus and the pantheon. And you got as humidly puts it like you got the night life of the gods and there's booze in it and sling, you know, hanging around and, and sometimes they're violent.
11:12 They like to fight, you know, the competitions. And so the Greek philosophy is different, though. And so it's, it's actually monotheism, the philosophical monotheist God idea in Greek theology was kind of almost a, and it permeated the rest of the world, but it was the outgrowth of the idea is there can really only be one God, because if there was more than one, they'd do all this and then there'd be just chaos and they'd be competing and fighting and all. They can only be 1. And that one would have to be all powerful, right? That's the ideology that then permeates into Judaism and Christianity, but it's also the attached ideas of he can't have a body and you can't know him, and therefore God gets removed and now he has to have intercessors between himself and humanity.
11:59 And Michael the Archangel. And there are other archangels, but Michael is always kind of the lead. The chief, He's the chief. And so he is essentially taking on the role of God because God's been removed in all that context. So I find that fascinating. That is fascinating. Anyway, that's a tangent right off the bat. Back to the Pearl Crate Price. This is like if I have a pet doctrine. What we're about to get into here is my pet doctrine. All right, I like it. And so I hope I can do this well. We see in Moses chapter 6 the IT says, and a book of remembrance was kept in the which was recorded in the language of Adam.
12:51 For it was given unto as many as called upon God to write by the spirit of inspiration. And by them their children were taught to read and write, having a language which was pure and undefiled. Now this same priesthood which was in the beginning, shall be in the end of the world also. Now this prophecy Adam spake as he was moved upon by the Holy Ghost. I think all those are tied together. OK, that the priesthood that Adam is talking to him and he's making a prophecy. Now this same priesthood which was that a book of remembrance was kept, recorded and given unto as many as called upon God to write by the spirit of inspiration, and their children were taught to read and write having a language which was appeared undefiled. When you set the terms, define things in the Society of Babylon around you can't define things you can see you can see the benefit that your children would have from that teaching, learning out of those books, right? But writing by the spirit of inspiration is super interesting.
13:47 We're going to the the books of Enoch itself. These these pseudopigraphal books really fall in line with this concept. And we can get into that in a minute. But Adam says that this priesthood will be in the end of the world. Also that you'll write by the spirit of inspiration. Isn't that fast? In the hereafter. It says that this is this priesthood, which was in the beginning what they're operating on, which I believe is having to do with the records and writing by inspiration writing Scripture shall be in the end of the world also, which is OK, let's say the latter days, OK, the end of the world. Also interesting and contingent with that was it says Anna genealogy was kept to the children of God and then this was the book of the generations of and it goes forth.
14:36 And so those two ideas are intertwined, but they're a little different. So the genealogy, but also writing scripture, right, parables or proverbs or revelation, but you know. All right. So let's get into Enoch, the Books of Enoch. So Enoch, the figure that we're aware of, the 7th from Adam, he would have lived approximately 5400 years ago, right? The books of Enoch that we have were written between 2 and 300 years from Christ. OK, so did Enoch write them? Probably. Not from that viewpoint, no, he didn't, Right. And so you have other people, not Enoch, riding by the spirit of inspiration, as Adam is saying. And they're writing these books, they're writing the Scripture and the parallels are dead on with what Joseph Smith is getting.
15:31 He's doing the same thing. He's my view on the Pearl of great price. You know, we call it the Genesis, right? Or the book of Moses. And but I like how he nibbly kind of breaks it down. He says, well, really, we have a book of Moses. We have a book of Adam. We have a book of Enoch, book of Noah. And even if Joseph Smith, Matthew, we have the restored words of Christ, they have all these different authors. What Joseph Smith is doing is he's channeling this idea, and not that he's reproducing the whole book of Adam, the whole book of Enoch, the whole book of Noah, but he's taking the fragments of those and he's splicing it back into Genesis. Right, so.
16:13 So he's making an inspired version of Genesis because it's an amalgamation like Mormon does with the right, with the bridging all the plates. This is going to be interesting, right? Because if Joseph's getting stuff on Enoch, we need to pay attention to Enoch. There is something there that, and, and it's been my contention for a while that we haven't given Enoch his due, right? I think because there are different books of Enoch, it, it does create a bit of a conundrum for us to wrap our mind around, right? You have the Ethiopian 1, you have a couple other translations and then you have Joseph Smith stuff. I think, OK, let me phrase this for a guy like me who's super lazy, just going with Joseph like that newest, newest is, you know, it's good enough.
16:57 It, it, it creates an opportunity to do that. But I don't think we do him justice as what the Lord's trying to get across without going to this. Right. And so we can view the latter day restoration, obviously when we get through Joseph Smith's going to be a lot more authentic, right, First off, right. And so the the question becomes when we read this older stuff that's produced by a source that we don't know about what's authentic, what's not right, and we just got to compare notes. Yep, at that point. And and I'll say on the outset here. There's a lot of Bull's eyes. Right. And and I covered this with a guy named Adam Stokes. There's no way Joseph would have had a manuscript of the Book of Enoch, just wouldn't. We know that there was a copy out in France at this time during during Joseph Smith's lifetime. But Joseph was having a hard enough time writing English. I don't think he was necessarily diving into the French, right? No, no, no.
18:00 So the fact he does hit all those bull's eyes, that should stand as a testimony. To to this day, there's modern scholars who say that Joseph Smith had to have had because there's no other way when they say that there's no other way that he could have and then when you. Pin him down and say OK, but where's he getting it? I don't I don't know some other fragment. That that we don't know about is what they'll say, right? Exactly. And so when when the best you got as a trained historian is some other fragment we don't know about, I tend to call BS because look, we have a pretty good idea of what folks were reading in those days, right? It's not a mystery. Here's 1 rebuttal. To this too, Enoch was not popular, no, in the Christian world and the Jewish world at this point in time and for a long time before that. The reason why the scholarship was sleeping on it like the why there was one copy in French and and in France was because no one wanted to touch it and it was locked away and you had to go through hell to even go see it.
19:02 It was because and. Because it. Wasn't of interest to anyone. So for so to take the viewpoint that Joseph Smith was just aspiring and a charlatan or opportunistic, whatever he would have been working in the framework of what are my audience going to be? What? What are they interested in? What can I capitalize? Enoch's not the thing to capitalize on because no one gives a care, no. Because realistically in in the old New Testaments, he's mentioned a handful of times, right? He it's not like, and if you go back to Enoch, you see this, right? It's not that they're short, quick blurbs and there's maybe a handful of them. Yeah, all the. Scholars who looked at the Book of Enoch at the point of Joseph Smith hated it because of all the astronomical stuff in it, all the cosmic awful stuff.
19:49 And like that they said, this has no bearing in the gospel. This is just rubbish, right? Yeah, absolutely. Absolutely, and it's interesting that it is referred to in the Bible but does not make its way into the Canon. Right, and this is where I take exception with sectarian Christianity. Right. When they say that the Bible is the inerrant word of God, I'm like, bro, that thing, that thing was created for a political purpose. Let's not pretend that this was done because various bishops got together and said, boy, we really need to unify things. No, Constantine was looking for a A1 religion that he could rally the troops behind, and it was political. And Enoch throws curveballs all the way through, right? Like it does not fit with a trinitarian view of God. It doesn't fit with a God who cannot be known. It is troublesome.
20:55 Yeah, all the. Way around it is. And so, yeah, Joseph Smith. Would. Not have copied Enoch to or any benefit. No. One time no. And I don't think. There's a ton of French converts running around in those days either, right? Like, no, there weren't. If if you try to just pin down where, let's just take the the scholarly consensus and say, OK, if he did have a fragment, where's that fragment coming from? Well, he's not, he's not. They're not tearing the French out of France to come join the Mormons, right? That's not happening. It hadn't been translated at that point. And then? The next fragment we got was from like the orthodox side of things and that wasn't definitely not American, no Eastern Europe, no, no.
21:42 No. So there's this. Like, if you ever want to get into a debate with someone and prove Joseph Smith more than a charlatan or a fake Enoch's your your boy, you're going to want to pay attention. Oh dude, you're. Going to love this son. All right, well, let's continue with the the probably great price before we get into the Enoch, the Books of Enoch. Hugh Nibbly says in Enoch the Prophet, it all begins on earth with the book of the generations of Adam, a complete record of names and events and of God's dealings with his children on the earth. He requires the Saints in every age to keep such a book, or rather to continue the original, adding their own names and histories to it as they arranged by law. The inheritances of the Saints whose names are found and the names of their fathers and of their children enrolled in the book of the Law of God.
22:30 That's section 85, which is the same as the Book of Remembrance, which is also section 85. So that's the your one mighty and strong section, right, which goes back to Adam and is also the genealogy of the sons of Adam. Enoch reads from the books to remind his people of the commandments which I God gave unto their Father Adam. That's Moses 628 when he called upon our Father Adam by his own voice, and ordered them to pass it on, saying, Teach these things freely unto your children, and in time they are to reach us. The rule is that many books of every kind are handed down from one generation to another, even until they the people have fallen into transgression.
23:11 That's he woman 3:15 at which time they disappear, until another prophet brings them forth. Next to Enoch himself, the greatest transmitter of the records would seem to be Moses, by whose hand we receive the records that came through Enoch and his successors. And it is Moses who gives us the key to the whole thing. And now, Moses my son, thou shalt write the things which I shall speak. And in a day when the children of men shall esteem my words is not, and take many of them from the book which thou shalt write, behold, I will raise up another like unto thee, and they shall be had again among the children of men, among as many as shall believe. So quick question there. Nibley says that Moses essentially has the records from Adam through Enoch.
24:00 That or. Or he's getting the he's. Getting it by Revelation, he's getting it by. The revelation and I kind of view that like we talked about heavenly counterparts with person just right like there's also the heavenly counterpart in my opinion, to what gets written by inspiration on the earth too. So it's never lost fully, right, Because the angels are also the scribes, right? They're. They're taking it down too. So the idea that that Moses may get a record from heaven and have it taken back up isn't out of the realm of possibility. Not at all. And so. It's super interesting though that Nibley points out that next to Enoch, Moses is the guy, but we see strong similarities in other places with Enoch and Moses.
24:41 Like all the people hate me for I am slow of speech. And. God tells Moses and Enoch the same thing, except in Moses's case he required he asked for a spokesperson anyways. Right. But interesting that that parallel is there. Yeah, we covered in our Old Testament classes that and we see that according to the Pearl great price here, Adam's writing a book, keeping records in the in the Adam literature, Seth makes a record after Adam dies and that's passed down and it makes it all the way to the temple of Solomon. You recall that? Yep, I do.
25:22 And Enoch is making the records too, right. And we see this in the doctrine of Covenants. Now Adam on Diamond, it says three years previous to the death of Adam, he called Seth, Enos, Canaan, Mahalaleel, Jared, Enoch, and Methuselah, who are all high priests with the residue of his posterity, who are righteous into the valley of Adam on Niomen, etcetera. And these things were written in the book of Enoch and are to be testified of in due time. So there is a book of Enoch, an actual book of Enoch, that our historical figure Enoch wrote that we don't have, that is not these pseudepigraphal books of Enoch. That we're going to talk about and. Pseudepigrapha is a fun term that smart people with degrees use that basically is literature that was written between 200 years of Christ, Christ's life. So whether before either side, either side, that's attributed to an earlier figure, usually a patriarch. Got you.
26:19 OK, that makes sense. And so a. Scholar today, although it's the definition would have to be broader if they do this, but they they could say that our book of Moses is pseudepigrapha because Joseph Smith is producing Yeah, that's. True of a book in the. Name of book Moses, right? Right. They wouldn't want to give him that on there though. No, but. Yeah, it's interesting. You have to consider. Because it goes back to this tradition. Writing by the spirit of inspiration, yeah. Also fun. To note, Adam would be if the if the timelines are right, inaccurate, Adam would be 622 years old when Enoch was born.
26:59 Adam was 687 years old when Enoch had his calling and ascension into the presence of when he was when Enoch was 65. Right. Enoch would have been 305 years old when Adam blessed the residue of his posterity at Adam on diamond. And Enoch was 308 years old when Adam ascended back into heaven. And. Adam's ascension into heaven is 122 years before the city of enoch's ascension into heaven man that puts. Everything in some proximity, right? You start to understand the generations. Yeah. So the calling, the calling of Enoch. God says to Enoch, And for these many generations, ever since the day that I created them, have they gone astray, and have denied me, and sought their own counsels in the dark, and in their own abominations have they devised murder, and not kept the commandments which I gave to their father Adam. Wherefore they have forsworn themselves, and by their oaths they have brought upon themselves death, and the hell I have prepared for them, if they repent not. And when Enoch had heard these words, he bowed himself to the earth before the Lord, and spake before the Lord, saying, Why is it that I have found favor in thy sight, and am but a lad, and all the people hate me, for I am slow of speech, Wherefore am I thy servant?
28:21 And the Lord said unto Enoch, Go forth, and do as I have commanded thee, and no man shall Pierce thee. Open my mouth, and it shall be filled, and I will give thee utterance, for all flesh is in my hands, and I will do as seemeth me good. Say unto this people, Choose ye this day to serve the Lord God who made you. Behold, my spirit is upon you. Wherefore wherefore all thy words will I justify, And the mountains shall flee before you, and the rivers shall turn from their course, and thou shalt abide in me, and I in you. Therefore walk with me. So back to the oaths, he says by your oaths you have brought upon yourselves death. So that's interesting because in a way that that kind of Harkins to the Enoch literature about the angels, right? Swearing an.
29:07 Oath to themselves. They come down upon what's called Mount Hermon and you know, 200 watchers or whatever, and they make a covenant with each other saying, you know, we're going to go down and do this and we're going to go take the daughters of men. Then we're going to go raise up children and we're going to go live upon the earth. And they made an oath to do that. Let me ask by their. Oaths they have brought up themselves. Death. Let me ask you this, just just a thought. When when we enter the temple, when we start dealing with that part of the gospel, we make oaths there as well. Yep. Is. There any possibility that these oaths that they're talking about, the reason they're oaths, oaths of death, so to speak, is because they made a holy covenant and then just ignore them. There's that.
29:51 There's also I was going to bring up that we see the counterfeit priesthood from Cain in this era, which there and not only imitation oaths of the temple, but the secret combination oaths just going to refer to the secret combination oath to murder and get gained. It just is the same. But in any case, there's an oath is the the prominent theme. Gotcha. Gotcha. OK. The the other thing that I find fascinating and we see this with Moses, we see this with other prophets, everybody seems to be reluctant, right? And and that gives me a little bit of hope for my own destination, right? Because I'll be honest, there's been times he's asked me to do things and I've argued, right?
30:40 I'm like, Nope, Nope, you got the wrong dude. You got to go find somebody else. I know nothing. About whatever it is you want me to do, you're going to have to go find someone else, I think. I think, I think that that the way this goes is why they question the calling, right? I don't think it's with these prophets. I don't think it's out of laziness or just an undesired. I think it's you got the wrong guy because I'm not qualified. Sure. And you see with Moses, you know the man is man is nothing, which thing I've never before supposed, right? Because they when they have an experience, they realize that they are nothing to the majesty of God, right?
31:21 Yep. And so I think that's something we can draw out from there. When he tells you to do something, don't worry about being qualified. Just go get it done. Yeah, and. And you'll make up the difference. I will. Justify your words right exactly exactly No, I love all of that so and that this part here thou shalt abide in me and I and you therefore walk with me. We'll touch more on what it means to walk with God. Actually, I think I have that later. It's somewhere in there. But so we have Enoch face to face with God, who is. Is the. Question right how does this the age-old question to Adam God believers, for example, is if Adam is God, then how come Enoch is talking to to God or whatever you know you know there's.
32:13 A there's there's a few possibilities here, right? And at some level, I think is Adam God believers. If you, it's never bad to question those things, right? I'm a big believer that that's one of the gifts of Mormonism. There's plenty for you to explore, but I've I've struggled with the same thing and to be honest, I'm like, doesn't matter. Does it matter if he gets his charge from Adam? Does it matter if he gets a charge from Adam's God? Doesn't really matter. It's still the same charge from a line of proper authority and you got to go. So we'll read a. Statement from Brigham Young and I really like when he addresses this, but before that we're going to analyze in my opinion, which God, this isn't OK, you know, process of elimination.
32:57 This God is not Jesus Christ. This is not the anti mortal Christ. Why is it not the anti mortal Christ? Well, we go back to the Book of Mormon in the Book of Ether and you have the brother, brother of Jared and his experience. I'm going to read that. That's in ether through chapter 3, verse 14 and 15, when when the brother of Jared has the veil lifted and has that experience, Christ tells him, Behold, I am Jesus Christ, I am the Father and the Son in me shall all mankind have life, and that eternally, even they who shall believe on my name, and they shall become my sons and daughters. And never have I shown myself unto man whom I have created, for never has man believed in me.
33:40 As thou hast seest that thou, that thou, that ye are created after my own image. Yeah, even all men were created in the beginning after my own image. And so, OK, I believe in the Book of Mormon, right? So Christ is telling you, the brother of Jared. I've never shown myself on demand. Is that problematic? The way I reconcile that, oh, does that mean no one had ever seen Christ? I would say that if God had revealed Christ to some patriarchs, then that wouldn't contradict this. Nope. No, but because he says. I've never shown myself, I've never introduced myself, but we see a pattern in the scriptures in.
34:21 The new. Testament in the Book of Mormon, Joseph Smith, right, the father's introducing the son and testifying of the son, right? And so that would not break this pattern. In fact, this is the break in the pattern that the brother of Jared is seeing Christ introduce himself and that's why. Christ goes out of his way to say right. Never before have I shown. Myself on. It so. Enoch would not be seeing Christ, who has in this instance, who has never revealed himself, right. Nope, that makes sense also. This is a hang up scripture of some people with weird trinitarian adjacent ideas. Sure, but using Christ's own words to define what he means by I am the Father and the Son. He qualifies that in this passage we just read He says they shall become my sons and my daughters. That's.
35:13 Right, it's right there. I am the father because they shall become, not that they are, because we're not right yet. Right in the process of becoming. Yep. OK, and so he defines the term right. I see. I. Really agree he's defining. Yep. What he means by he's the Father and the Son, Brigham Young said. I will tell you about the God with which you and I worship. It is a being that was on an earth like this. He had been clothed in mortality the same as we have been, and he has had devils to fight the same as we have. But I do not expect that they were the same devils that we have. That God says that I am your God and there is none else.
35:55 Let us worship Him and none else. He is the God that we have, no matter what gods. Enoch saw when the heavens were opened unto him, if the God that he saw have been exalted 1,000,000 millions of years before our God was, he also would have had to occupy an earth like ourselves. And we shall find out at some period. And this is all the mystery there is about it. And if we are faithful, we in our turn shall be exalted and become gods. And there will be no mystery about about it when we understand it. So he's under he's addressing the Adam God doctrine there because he's been teaching the Adam God doctrine for publicly for eight years by the point that he gave that little excerpt and he's kind of addressing what probably was brought up, right? You know, how is this work with what Enoch? And he says it doesn't matter what God's Enoch saw, right? You know.
36:45 Our God, it was exalted on the same principle. The gods that Enoch saw were exalted upon the same principle. Doesn't matter if it was a million years before our God was exalted, we're going to be in the same position. So his. Answer was pretty much close to what I was. Yeah, doesn't really matter. Absolutely, yeah. It's a family, it's a family business, a family affair. So walking with God is interesting. So Abraham says, Abraham says something like this is the God before whom I walk. And that's. Different than walking with God a little, right? And so walking with God denotes not that Abraham wasn't extremely righteous, but Enoch, you know, being extremely righteous, that God walks with him as well, and that Enoch is also a celestial traveller, just as God is. Interesting that's.
37:40 Yeah, that's an interesting way to define that term, right, Is now that Enoch walking with God isn't just, oh, I've talked to him, but I'm walking about the universe just the same as God does, because you're seeing everything gets taken into heaven and all the literature that we're going to get into. That's a big theme. So let me ask you this then. Where does that place Enoch? Does that mean that he's translated? Does that mean he's resurrected? I mean, what does that mean if he's walking in the same place as God is? It's a great question. There's some implications to that statement. The literature. Straight up. Insinuates he's exalted the way that we would term it.
38:23 I'm not talking about what Joseph Smith taught, but I'm talking about what the pseudepigraphal stuff says. Enoch is straight up exalted, is the way that we have to describe how it's. But we know talking about it, we do know he was born here. Oh yes, yes. Which is even. More interesting, right, Because it is, it's deification or apotheosis, you know, early Christianity. Absolutely. Yeah. We're going to talk a lot about that. But yeah, so Joseph Smith said Enoch's in a translated state. He also said that that's a there it's not the final state that there has to be another transition to, you know, a fullness of glory. We just don't know what that looks like.
39:03 I kind of take the stance personally, like, OK, maybe that has happened. I don't know, or something close to it. Maybe not fully. Maybe he can't fully attain to the all the privileges of the godhead in his own sphere because this work hasn't been done on this earth yet. But he's essentially the got the promise of it at the very least, right. So as far as his actual state, I couldn't tell you besides that he has been translated. Maybe a step beyond that, maybe in queue to active God Mode, right? Right, right. OK.
39:43 You know, because. The Christ hasn't even received the fullness, and he presents his Kingdom to the godhood in. Ezra, Right, Right. But yeah, I just. Thought that was fascinating to define that walking with God as Enoch being the celestial traveler All right I'm going to read some of from a scholarly article on the books of Enoch and I this was from what was it called this is a paper called the evolution of the patriarch Enoch in Jewish tradition by a guy named Miller so the. Book. Before we jump into that, the the Books of Enoch, the first book of Enoch, the what we call one Enoch or first Enoch, the Ethiopian version, it's the oldest one that we're aware of.
40:29 It's got like parts like other books within the book, right? So we have something called the astronomical book, which is probably the oldest or among the oldest literature, which some people think is about 300 BC. OK, other elements were written more like 100 BC, and it all gets stitched together, right? It's like a complete thing, probably by the time of Christ. But it's written on that spectrum between 300 and 100, the 1st century BC, right? So astronomical book. There's a book of similitudes, there's the Book of Noah, there's what was called the animal apocalypse, and then there's parables. There might be others, I don't recall any case, the scholar guy says.
41:14 In the astronomical book, which is first Enoch chapter 72 through 82, also known as the Book of the Luminaries, we learn what may have meant the Enoch walk with God. Here we follow him on an angelically guided tour of the heavenly sphere. The angels meticulously this meticulously describe the celestial mechanics, the laws of the sun and the moon, their phases and time keeping, along with a prediction that in the days of the sinners, the heavenly bodies will begin to fall out of phase and an evolving chaos will envelope the earth as both nature and humanity grow out of sync with their prescribed order. This is the stuff that all the Christians hated, right?
41:55 That stuff. Once Enoch is LED away from God's presence, he witnesses again the basic mechanics of the universe, the places where the winds are stored, the foundation of the earth and the and the cornerstones of heaven and the paths of the angels. The place of the punishment for rebellious stars, which deviated from God's timetable, the captivity of wicked angels and the enclosures for human souls where their spirits are separated into good and evil until the great day of judgment. So yeah, there's like this idea, for example, there's like heavenly storehouses that contain things like wind, rain, the elements. He sees these things, you know, they're putting it, you know, the author is putting into terms that we don't understand that right now, but you know, and we have other ways of describing that, right? But that's what he's.
42:44 That's what he had. Yeah, the idea. Is that Yeah, he's being shown just the way nature works, right? Right through all of. This he is guided by angels who write down information for him and answer his questions. Enoch is relentlessly curious, repeatedly probing the angels for information about the things that he sees, and it provides a new take on the origin of evil. No longer are Adam and Eve to blame, but the fallen angels who led humanity astray. These elements, which present a challenge to the received biblical tradition, indicate an outsider nature typical of apocalyptic literature, which finds fault in the world and contemporaneous society. And it is not surprising that we find the literature among the separatist Qumran community. Dead Sea Scrolls, right?
43:31 He travels through the heavens, witnessing secrets unknown by other humans. He is the scribe, recording the order of the cosmos and history, and absorbing the angelic duty of documenting the actions of human beings. So after going through with the angels who are writing things down, he kind of takes up the scribal role, right? Continuing, he says he is righteous and has a special role in regard to the righteous. Who can be? Identified as the People of Israel, or at least those among them who obediently keep God's laws, there is a primordial placement in which he was intended to to fulfill as this righteous and chosen exemplar, which has by the time of the similitudes a hint of angelic status which positions him as a judge of humankind and an inaugurator, inaugurator of the of the end of days. From the second.
44:22 Century BC onwards, the assault of the unrighteous grows, as does the description of their punishment, indicating the tension which the authors perceive in the world. So like, you know, break there. If this is being written 2nd century, 1st century BC, what's happening in Judea? 1st and 2nd century Judea. They're under Roman occupation, right? And you have all these different sects of Judaism. Right. You got the atheists, you got the Pharisees, the Pharisees, Sadducees. I think this is the same time where the the the well Gnostics are starting to come to play. All these groups out there and they're all claiming to be the inheritor of the truth and so and the other sex are bad and they're and they're apostate and they're corrupting it and some cases that was probably true. And so that's the way that the Qumran community would the Essenes and others associate with. That's how they look.
45:18 They were the the, the, the righteous recluses and prophets who had left the society and were waiting for Babylon to be destroyed. And then they'd go back and build up a heavenly Jerusalem on earth, right? But the new temple and all of that. You know this. Is fascinating and I feel like that this has some some very pointed commentary that we as fundamentalists need to make make note of. Right, because with and, and Justin Franken and I, I just released an episode this Saturday about the splits in, in Christianity, right? And it's eerily similar, right? Eerily similar to what we have in Mormonism today.
45:59 But with the Asceans, the Gnostics, those folks out there and come wrong. What you get is that you get a people that says no, no, no, we're we're going to go do it the right way. The unfortunate part is their right way isn't always so right either, right? And I think that we need to be very careful as fundamentalist that we don't fall into that same trap. Some have and and some have, right? We got to be very careful that that that we don't just say, well, we're apart from them. So that must make us right because that's a very shaky standard to be using. Yep, but on. The same hand I get separating yourself and saying I want to do right and I can't do right if I'm associated with these guys, so I want to leave.
46:44 No, no. I. I agree with the separation portion. What I don't, what I what I'm always careful of, is separation does not necessarily mean correctness. Right do correct. To be correct, you have to. Be correct in order to be correct. And that's that's where I think the warning should come in with fundamentalists, right. I'm not saying that that we shouldn't have broken with the LDS church. I'm just saying that we need to be very careful that we don't use the separation as the litmus test for what is correct. No, but we. We are following kind of some of the same ground there, right, with, you know, we're analogous to the Essenes to the Pharisees in a sense coming out of the church, right, or Sadducees, whatever parallel you want to make, right? It's.
47:30 Yeah, it's fascinating to me to and and if once we're done with this series, however long it goes, I would even love to do a dive on the Judaic sex of this time. Absolutely too. That that'd be super fun to me. But yeah, so you see, in First Enoch, it's all hell, fire and damnation because the people who are holding this book of Scripture are anticipating God's impending judgement on all of the guys who are wrong, you know, all the other groups. You know, it's straight up dude, it's so this guy, you know, back to the article, right? Is as the assault of the unrighteousness grow, which is all the apostates, if not also the Roman oppressors, right? The description of their punishment grows in the literature, right?
48:17 Those those two things are related. The unrighteousness growing in the punishment also becomes more severe, indicating the tension which the authors perceived in their world. The land of Israel was in turmoil at this time, subject to conquest after conquest, conquest as the people suffered under the harsh vicissitudes of different rulers. The authors are keen to see the final judgement, when God will reward the faithful and punish those who persecuted them. We also see that the person and nature of Enoch grows more central as the textual tradition evolves. Where the astrological book and the Book of the Watchers, that's another one of the books. Yeah. The Book of the Watchers in First Enoch are principally concerned with the cosmos, and Enoch functions as a messenger and recorder of certain revelations. By the time of the Book of Similitudes, it is he as the chosen one who has become the subject of revelation, the one hidden before time, who will only be revealed when his influence is required.
49:14 So that's where he kind of assumes the Son of Man, right Mantle, right? And while the first booklets place Enoch as a witness and recorder of the sins and virtues of human beings, by the latest he himself enacts the judgement for those actions. So he goes from being the witness of the virtues and and vices to being the the guy who deals out the judgement in the end. Enoch does. Yeah, in this literature. And you kind of see that spectrum. It's not just in first Enoch, but like, it becomes more pronounced right throughout all three, you know, first one, 1-2 and three Enoch. The purpose of Enoch's elevation is unremarked until on the brink of the 7th heaven, Gabriel commands him to stand up and come with him and stand in the face of the Lord forever. And this is a quote in order to be presented before God. No, I guess it's not.
50:06 I just have it in bold here. In order to be presented before God, Enoch is redressed in clothes, in clothes of glory and anointed, whereby I had become like one of his glorious ones. That's a quote, and there was no observable difference. The. Identification with the angelic host is foreshadowed in the previous literature, but from this point Enoch takes on a primordial function which quickly surpasses what we might have expected. Initially. He has made a recorder, writing the entire course of history, natural and human, the fate of All Souls and even every language and the rules that humanity lives by. After this indoctrination, God personally begins to educate Enoch and shares with him the secrets of the process of creation to which not even the angels were Privy. Enoch now knows everything.
50:53 He reels off a list of His knowledge which encompasses both time and space for either or either the from the lips of the Lord, or else. My eyes have seen from the beginning even to the end, the heavens in their boundaries and their contents. Enoch. Has again undergone a physical transformation in his encounter with God when he returns to the world having completed his testimony. I love this part. His face is chilled in order that humans can safely look at him chilled. So. He. Yeah. And there's two, you know, that's not the part that I recalled when I first read that passage, but I that part, that passage when I was reading the first book of Enoch, distinctly stuck out to me because it's actually his face is also chilled when he gets into the presence of God.
51:39 And I'm like, oh. Well, he has to be preserved because God's face is burning glory, right? So to his face is he's transfigured. That's where you put it, right? And then when he goes back to earth, he's shining like Moses, and he has to be chilled so he doesn't irritate them or, you know, whatever, you know what I mean, so that they can even look at him because they can't even they can't behold the glory that's on Enoch when he returns from heaven. This is the. Stuff where I, I start to wonder, am I really going to make it? Because my first thought is, is that you got guys just down there in Enoch City working and then Enoch comes back and he's maybe unaware that he's like shining and everyone's just kind of looking away and causes some self-conscious kind of things and.
52:24 And once he has declared his moral missive, the people embrace him and adorn him with yet another accolade. Now he is the one who carries away the sin of mankind. This salvific role, while a logical conclusion from his capacity in prescribing righteous behavior, is yet another step forward to a nature which could not have been predicted from the earliest books. He is no longer a human taken to heaven and transformed into an Angel, but a celestial being exalted above the angelic world. And so. Bearing in mind so there's a definite. Deification. No, there's a straight up, it's going. To get heavy too. We're not even fully there yet. But it's in an age, right? We're talking about when this book is being written like 2 centuries before Christ under Roman occupation. What were the Jews looking for?
53:12 They were looking for a political Messiah. They were looking for one who would Vanquish the Romans, reinstate the rule of the of the House of David. And so the Enoch becomes the figure in the pictures being used because this was scripture at this point. Maybe it was debated in some schools. Maybe the Pharisees didn't like it, for example. I can almost guarantee you the Sadducees probably hated it. The scenes loved it. But in any case, Enoch is being, you know, assigned the Messiah role that they're waiting for. It's also interesting that there might be other utility, so to speak, in making this book of Enoch for them. Because what were the Sadducees all about?
53:53 They're about Law of Moses, Law of Moses, Law of Moses, if they can ascribe an authority to themselves that predates Moses and say our authority comes from Enoch. They can. Supersede the other guys that they don't agree with in Jerusalem saying we're following, we're following Moses because the priesthood of the Levites was yeah, anyways, we're going to. So is there? Any scholarly work to give credence to that thought? Yeah, I read some of. It I don't have it quoted here too, but that's why I'm bringing it up because you have in the book, I think it's second Enoch. I could be wrong on that, but maybe it's first too. You have I think it is second Enoch, second Enoch you have or is it third? It's in one of them, but Enoch goes up to one of the mountains and or Enoch descends from heaven on the one on the mountain.
54:44 Someone else is up there, and Enoch has brought the Torah from the heavens. And so that. Is A1 upping of the Moses tradition, so to speak, that was prevalent at the time. That's essentially saying we have access to heaven and heavenly laws. Maybe you've changed the Torah. We have the original that Enoch gave us, you know, all those things. And that's the and so you have this explicit mention of Enoch being the 1st to deliver the Torah in one of those Books of Enoch. To the people. So let me ask you this because this is always where it gets dicey, right? Because we know the book itself isn't really written like you were saying until 200 years either side of Christ doesn't mean the oral tradition wasn't true. That's true.
55:32 Or components. Of it right Or components of it? But still, how much weight do you give that right? I mean because it is coming from a pseudo pickerful source. And on a certain yeah, So on a certain level, I'm just addressing that like scholarly, like this is what it's being used as, to like one up the claims of the priesthood authority that they don't agree with and and right, because it's a. Anyways I. Lost my train of thought there, but you have a in one of them, one of these books, you second Enoch starts describing one of the names Sadiq Zadiq to Enoch, which means righteous, righteous one. Well, that's Melchizedek, right?
56:17 And so it's also this tradition that Enoch, Melchizedek priesthood were trumping your Levitical Auronic priesthood. OK. And it's also interesting that the Essenes, some of them, I don't know if all of them were this way, but some, you know, I don't know how much variance there was flexibility in that culture. I don't know how correlated it is to use that word that, you know, where everything in the church today is super, super correlated. I don't know how correlated that community was as far as respecting certain ideas and traditions. But it looks like in that area that certain descendants of Zadok, the priest that was priest during David and Solomon's reign, they had they had gotten kicked out from Jerusalem.
57:04 And that was the line that had ruled in Jerusalem for forever as priests. And so you had the under the Maccabees, a new line was was put in one, you know, and so you have these Zadok is also the second part of Melchizedek Zadok, right? And so you have the Zadok I exile priests saying the Enoch is the Zadiq, the righteous one. Are they claiming Melchizedek priesthood? Or is that how the scholars are just seeing? And maybe there was something there that there was actually Melchizedek priesthood being restored to the right that did supersede. It's super interesting to put these these terms into our the. Ocular language as Mormons?
57:51 Yeah, absolutely. Well, the implications are high, too. Yeah. I mean the. Implications are absolutely yeah 'cause they're. Talking about an Enoch figure as a Messiah, he's being also associated with Enoch and Melchizedek are being associated together. That was another big figure at the time, you know, and you have Paul talking about how Melchizedek was just the type for Christ. But it's all that Messiah imagery. That's really, that's what their focus is at this point. Well, and. And we use the term the Messiah and we're very specific with it, right? I don't think that that that same specificity existed during this time period, right?
58:35 And so when, when we talk about the Messiah, we're talking about a spiritual deliverer that will someday be a, a, a physical or temporal deliverer. In the last days, during this time, especially around Jesus's time, they're looking for somebody physical. They, you know, they want someone to ride in triumphant with a sword drawn and to put down the oppressors. Yeah. And that's what they expected Enoch to come and do, although there is some intimation that he was going to do some saving from sin there too, from what we were reading, right. So yeah, yeah, he yeah, that he and but he was also going to be completely relentless on the wicked and the apostates just the same. Second Enoch, this guy says, draws significantly on popular Jewish Jewish philosophy which the author recasts in a mythical setting.
59:28 While the booklets of First Enoch were preserved by sectarians such as the Qumran community, something which indicates outsider background of a group unhappy with the direction of Israel's religion and offering an alternative narrative as we just discussed. Second, Enoch manages manages to take these traditions and incorporate them into a somewhat middle class, Hellenized atmosphere, which, although still not at one with popular religion in Judea, is relatively content with the current state of society and religion. Enoch's testimony does not damn the unrighteous but encourages personal good deeds, and the fire and brimstone of First Enoch's later strata are replaced with a complex and philosophically inclined depiction of the creation of the visible world. From the.
1:00:12 Invisible. This new emphasis, combined with a Hellenistic individualism, may have helped solidify the focus on the person of Enoch as a kind of mediator of redemption. The absence of nationalistic Hebrew history is only part of a dynamic which is both personal and universal. However, this development would not have been possible without the transformation that takes place in the Book of Similitudes, which was in First Enoch. For it is only here if that Enoch first became a person of cosmic importance rather than simply a prophet. It is because of Enoch's elevation to the status of Chosen One that he can, in second Enoch, take the new role as one of the heavenly host, a translation which also pay paves the way for later developments. Let's get this into Third Enoch.
1:01:01 Third Enoch he gets. He's basically God at this level, right? And. Then he gets a fun name. Kind of sounds like a transformer if the audience knows what I mean, but they call them Metatron. OK. Now this is interesting. So we all just read this, but at some point, Enoch's elevation into heaven and incorporation into the angelic retinue earns him a new name, Metatron, in the most textually solid and singular work, the Zephyr. Heck, a lot. That's what the that's like the book of holy places is what that translates to, I think, or hecal in in this word, Hecalot is a can mean a palace or a big room or a hall or temple. OK, so in the Sepher Hecalot or 30 Enoch, that's the scholarly designation.
1:01:55 Metatron tells his own history of having been taken from Earth as a human when he was Enoch, the sole righteous member of his generation. And Rabbi Ishmael, who's writing the book, stands mute as Metatron recounts his blessings, saying, With a throne like God's own. Oh, sorry. With a throne like God's own at the entrance to the 7th heaven, a robe and a crown fashioned by God himself, transformed into fire and made Prince and ruler over all angels. One could. Perhaps be forgiven for thinking Enoch has now reached his apogee and if this were not enough, God titles him the lesser Jehovah.
1:02:37 So anytime the Tetragrammaton shows up, I'm just going to say Jehovah, you're not going to catch me saying Yahweh. I'm not going to go into why I just don't like it. But so Jehovah. So he's getting the title Lesser Jehovah. Is he getting called Metatron? So third, Enoch is written by a guy who was born in 90 AD. His name is. We just call him Rabbi Ishmael. Was Rabbi Ishmael Ben Joseph something something? Something. Whatever. Born in 9080, so he's right in the 2nd century after Christ. Scholars say that this book 30. Enoch has undergone multiple receptions or redactions at its essentially at least until 5th or 6th century BC or 80, Sorry. So it's getting toyed with until about 580 it's getting. So it's been altered for 500 years. Yeah, at the very.
1:03:34 Least it's also super convoluted in my period and like in my opinion, I could not get through it, but there are like 2 redeeming elements of it I think. Anyways, we'll jump into that in a second. Finishing this this stuff. Well, actually no pause. So Ishmael, Rabbi Ishmael is taking the role similarly to what Enoch is in in First and 2nd Enoch, he's a man being taken into the heavens. By. Angels, Michael, Gabriel, Raphael, seeing God now Ishmael is being taken into the presence of Enoch by angels and Enoch is or Metatron is relating how he came to that position.
1:04:20 This is talking about exaltation, right? Right in our vernacular language. Yeah, that's one of the redeeming elements of it. And again, the implications are kind of earth shattering, right? They are huge. They're huge, yeah. The things I don't like that's convoluted about it is it just goes through ridiculous amounts of hierarchies of angels and things that are, in my mind, incomprehensible. They're just. Too complicated to right? You know, and maybe it's because I don't understand Hebrew and the translation, a lot of that is just like literally transliterated into English and like not interpreted.
1:05:01 Like it's a really strong translation, like literal translation. So maybe that's part of it. I think the answer. Is you just got to take more Hebrew, Michael. Yeah, I don't want to do it that. Sounds like a lot of work. You should do that. So the guy Miller continues. While Enoch was guided around by heaven by angels in his earlier literature, it is now Metatron who leads the Rabbi Ishmael, offering many of the same visions as he himself had. He enumerates leagues of angelic beings who preside over the aspects of heaven, ensuring its daily functioning. The souls of the righteous and the wicked have not who that have not yet been created and the souls of the patriarchs, Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, the history of Adam or the history of humanity from Adam to the Messiahs.
1:05:48 And that means Messiah Ben Joseph and Messiah Ben David or Judah. So that's where you start seeing in this start of the community of the dual Messiah idea there that that pops. I thought that was interesting. This is all a long way from the initial conception of Enoch as simply a patriarch, even a particularly righteous one. But we can recall from the conclusion of similitudes where Enoch is named before the sun and the moon were created and by the time of second Enoch, he is who would heal humanity's primal sin. It is surely no accident that in his function as the first man, Metatron is also named Zadiq or the righteous one, which gets back into the Melchizedek thing that were you know that this primordial heavenly Melchizedek, right? And so yeah.
1:06:35 And 2nd Enoch, you start seeing stuff like pre existence. It's all throughout all actually. But where Enoch is seeing that he was named before the moon and the sun were created, right? You know, before the planet was, That's all scarfly Mormon, right? I'm, I'm trying to wrap my mind around all the implications of this. Right? Yeah, we should hear. You talk for a second. Because. Here, here's some of the questions that this brings up right? And it's something I'm not completely comfortable with. So I'll, I'll await your explanation on this. But they seem to be turning Enoch into kind of a, a savior, right? But that seems to fly in the face of Jesus being the savior, does it not?
1:07:20 Oh. It sure does. And and and. So at that point you have to say and. And this is where these kind of sources get iffy, right? Because big time to me. Because you got. You got to endorsing that. Wholesale, right? No, I didn't. I didn't think you were, but how? How do you wrap your mind around this then? Right? What? At what point do you say this is hyper? You know ancient hyperbole, right? Or is this inspired? Truth. That's coming to us. How do you tear that apart so I. I'm a big fan of taking a step back and looking at types and shadows. Psychology calls archetypes, you know, figures like that and saying where, what are the, what is the, what's the moral? What's the archetype and the symbolism saying and how can I apply that generally?
1:08:11 Maybe I can see a better picture. How do I apply the archetype in a construct of Mormonism? In my own. Vernacular. How can I reconstruct that using well, I know is strongly rooted for through Joseph Smith, but it requires looking at a step back through archetypes. I think the historical context really helps about talking about like this late second Temple Judaism and the royal occupation and you're seeing a competition between sects and their priesthoods. And you see I think that really helps you interpret what's really being said here. But also this idea it you're, you're right on the head that we need to understand the Jews did not stop being Jews when Christ came on the earth, right?
1:08:54 They were still looking for a Messiah and they did not think Christ fit the bill, right? And so to Rabbi Ishmael, you know, he's going to be growing up reading 1st and 2nd Enoch and he's even extrapolating on that more so, which is interesting. But they're in their mind, they're still looking for that other kind of Messiah figure and whether maybe Enoch just becomes the heavenly counterpart to some future, you know, zealot type hero that's going to liberate them from the Romans or what or whatever. You know, I don't know how that all works out, but it helps to see what these, what is the text talking about? What is it criticizing?
1:09:44 Right. And it's in some instances, I think that some of this is criticizing Christ. And I think because they did not agree with Christianity. And so you have, I will tell anyone who is reading this Enochian literature that you got to be careful with it because I think some of it is Antichrist. Yeah, to an extent. But. I think some of it can also be helpful. Well, and. And I think that that kind of hits, hits the nail on the head, right? And this is where I've always told people you're going to want to be real grounded in in in those basic things because you're going to need that tether when you start diving into this, right? Because you're going to always need to to do various check with me sort of thing. Like, OK, Jesus is still in Christ. Joseph's work probably takes precedent over anything this old.
1:10:35 But nonetheless, there are some things that I think can be, like you were saying, can be drawn out to lend credence and support to Mormonism's claims. Oh yeah, big time. And even Christianity's claims too, like the the stuff was popular to to them. And so you could see, like Jude or others who quote the Book of Enoch, they're kind of reverse engineering some of these things and applying it to Christ. Absolutely, absolutely. The tone does change between, you know, 1st and and 3rd Enoch, obviously, right?
1:11:15 I, I tend to be, and, and granted, I probably haven't done nearly the research that you have. I tend to be way more comfortable with first Enoch than I do with the other books, right, Because, and, and it, I want to say this, it could be just the, the way it reads, right? Enoch seems to be more approachable in those and it reminds me more of the Enoch that Joseph Smith lays out. Yeah, absolutely. So we talked about the some fun things that 30 Enoch has to summarize. You have the two Messiahs, which, you know, if you, for those who don't know, there's an idea in rabbinic Judaism that there's supposed to be a Messiah figure raised up out of the tribe of Judah and Joseph.
1:12:01 And that's kind of a interestingly cool parallel for Joseph Smith, being of the descent out of the tribes of Joseph, you know, Ephraim. Especially when you start looking at what the Messiah Ben Joseph's supposed to do, right? Like very much a restore kind of figure Enoch. In by third, by third Enoch he, you know, we see as we covered, you know, he's taken on the godly role because in Hellenistic Judaism, God's become more drawn back. And so you have to have a mediator figure that was caused by the Greek philosophy, but you also have not just a knee jerk reaction, not knee jerk, but a calculated reactionary dogma being asserted against Christianity intentionally, right? But also they're dealing with by the time that Rabbi Ishmael is around, the temple's gone, right? The temple's destroyed and the priesthood's gone. And so there's some of that that's going there. The third Enoch comes up as a way, it's new revelation for the Jews.
1:13:14 Not it's not the gospel, it's not what I'm saying, but it's revelation in quotes for them to deal with the crappy world that they're in right now. And I. Was just going to say you cannot undersell the blow that the psyche of Judaism took by the priesthood being decimated and the temple being gone. Yeah, they had to. Completely. Rework that what their religion meant to them, right? And this is one of those books. That did that, absolutely. And so when, when you're approaching, especially 2nd and 3rd in it, you have to look at that, you have to understand that context because they are grasping for something, anything to hold on to. Judaism has to redefine itself now because.
1:13:59 Your stuff is. Gone. Your homeland is gone, the temple is gone. Your ruling factions are gone. How do you then bounce back right. And and and and a lot of these these these books, what what I find is trying to establish a new identity in the dysphoria. That's exactly that's. Exactly what it is and and that's. That's going to come with some pain. Yeah, so you. See this imagery in second and third Enoch for sure, or Enoch's going through the seven heavens. Sometimes there's three. I don't know. I think maybe first Enoch, it's three. I don't know if it's seven in that one as well.
1:14:42 Stuff I was reading was interesting because I've been reading a lot about temple stuff in ancient Judaism recently and the Temple was divided into three parts and in this ascent literature and it's not always Enoch in some of the stuff you see these guys like Paul I've I was in the third heavens. Well what is that really saying talking about the temple Yep the three the three-part space that's in the temple. Some scholars have said that in the latest period before the Temple was destroyed, maybe it was actually separated into seven parts. And what we're seeing here with in 3rd Enoch and maybe maybe even in second as well if it's undergone some later changes, is because there's no earthly temple. They're having to describe temple adjacent ideas in your mind by you're envisioning someone else passing through the temple.
1:15:39 Well, OK, Rabbi Ishmael is going through the temple through the 7th because Enoch went through. So it's kind. Of a temple parable. It's a temple. Parable because the temple's gone. Yep. And it's a way to kind of preserve esoterically some of the stuff that was maybe going on, but there's also no one to officiate, right? And so it's all just a construct. The scripture is there to provide a mental construct to teach something right. Interesting. Oh, super fascinating, Yeah. Yeah, because you don't just get theology, you get the sociopolitical climate of what this is coming to and the the corresponding holy writ that will now redefine Judaism. The cool thing about the Enochian text with Rabbi Ishmael, there's, I don't know if it's in 30 Enoch or if it's a separate book that Rabbi Ishmael wrote. It's called the Shirakama.
1:16:42 But Rabbi Ishmael describes an anthropomorphic, corporeal God. And in fact, there's a guy, a famous, famous, famous rabbi, later Maimonides, which is like, if you read, if you see the name, you might be tempted to pronounce it Maimonides or Maimonides. But it's my Maimonides. He hated the this book, you know, by Rabbi Ishmaeli. So that's absolute heresy to sin. God had a corporeal anthropomorphic body.
1:17:22 I think there's plenty of. Evidence and and even proto kind of proto Hebrew ISM, if you will, that that that wasn't so far fetched. No, but yeah. Anyways, but that was kind of late. You know, this is kind of late for, I mean, he's like 5th or 6th century. And that's when this third book of Enoch is undergoing its latest edits. But Ishmael is saying God has a corporeal body. Let's see. He, Enoch, is described nonetheless as a lesser Jehovah. He's on a throne in the 7th heaven. He's wearing a robe in a crown fashioned by God. It even.
1:18:03 Cites Deuteronomy Enoch cites Deuteronomy chapter 22 or whatever. There's AI should have picked up the actual verse, but there's a it's when during the Exodus where God is just getting fed up with with Israel because there is yeah, there is not listening. And. He takes a step back and he says. You know. I'm gonna here's this Angel, he's gonna lead you, and you better do what he says, because he will not pardon you because my name is in him. You know. So the divine name, the name of Jehovah is being placed in this Angel. My take on that, That's Christ. Christ is now leading the exodus because they've also did not. They've rejected the priesthood that brought them into the presence of the Father.
1:18:53 And so you have. Rabbi. Ishmael ascribing that verse to Enoch, You know he's the he's the Angel of the Lord's presence, right? He's the Angel that the Lord's name, is it, right? You know, with, with the imagery that's given there of Enoch being crowned with, you know, a crown in a robe and sitting on the throne, right? The, the, the Messiah kind of imagery or the, the godly kind of imagery, I can kind of see where that comes from, right? Because let's, let's face it, at this, at this time period, we've already lost some stuff, right?
1:19:33 There's no doubt about that, right? Humanity has lost some of this stuff. So if you're a dude who's trying to put the pieces back together and someone says, well, Enoch in the city was taking up, your first thought is, oh, he's he's become a God in the full sense of the word. And it's not till Joseph Smith comes around and he's like, no, no, no, there's degrees to this thing, right? There's translation. I think this is the genius of Joseph Smith too, right? And and what was revealed to Joseph is is just those designations so you don't get confused with this stuff. Because let's face it, if this all is all you had to work with, you'd be hard pressed to to try to.
1:20:14 If I was. In I was thinking about the second car ride down here tonight. If I was in a place where I was trying to reconstruct Christianity, not, you know, and we take out the fact that I, you know, let's say the restoration didn't happen and I was inspired, maybe not inspired, whatever, but I was using my own mental faculties to kind of, but I knew something was wrong and I was trying to restore ancient Judaism of Christianity. I totally. Understand how after reading some of this Second Temple Judaism stuff, how the Jehovah's Witnesses got Jesus Christ and Michael the Archangel together. That's no close to the Adam God doctrine, but I can see that because Michael gets the intercessor position.
1:20:54 Christ is the intercessor position. I could, I would have totally endorsed that position if I was just reconstructing something and and now. Yeah, and that's that's where I say paying attention to what Joseph taught and revealed about the orders of Heaven translation versus exaltation becomes. Super. Important. They do, yeah. And yeah. And so Joseph Smith is my lit in this test. To me, Joseph Smith, I'm with you, is the he is the Moses of our generation. And that's the measuring stick. I love what Brigham Young said that he was paraphrasing off of a verse in the First Epistle of John. John was dealing with these Gnostics, right? And he makes a statement which is kind of funny if we don't understand the historical context. He says any person who does not or any spirit who does not confess that Jesus Christ came in the flesh is Antichrist. Well, what the heck does that mean? Does that mean that I can go down the the street to the evangelical church and they're going to say Jesus Christ came in the flesh?
1:22:00 And does that mean whatever they say because they're saying, yeah, praise Jesus is that, you know, they're they're totally good. No, but the Gnostics believed that Christ because they believed in this, this super hellenized idea that God can't be corporeal, that Christ was just a spirit the whole time and resurrection doesn't make sense because matter is bad. And so John is leveling against them a heresy. You know, whoever does not say that Jesus Christ was born literally tangibly in the flesh and resurrected his Antichrist and said Brigham Young uses that, but he updates the litmus test because that first, you know, John is not relevant to us today because we're not dealing with that kind of philosophy, right?
1:22:43 But he says any spirit who does not confess that Joseph Smith lived and died a prophet of God is Antichrist. And I love. Him absolutely, absolutely that. I love that. Yep. And I would. Go on to add to that my testimony is any spirit that does not confess that Joseph Smith lived and died a prophet of God and that he restored the temple endowment. And. Laws of God like consecration and celestial plural marriage that get you into the presence of God. If you don't believe in those things, then it's Antichrist. I'm looking at you, Michelle Brady Stone. Yeah, that's what Brigham Young called the measures of Joseph.
1:23:23 Yeah, I don't think. That's unreasonable, right? I think not only do I think it's not unreasonable because of some things that I believe about Joseph Smith, it's there's, there's some far reaching things. I I know where Brigham's going with this. Any further comments? Formula. Nope, I'm good. So Metatron. I'll try to breeze through this. Possible etymology or the meaning or origin of the name? Some people have postulated it can mean behind the throne in Greek. One thing I found fascinating is the gematria values of the name for Metatron and Shaddai are equivalent.
1:24:05 So the gematria value in esoteric Judaism is all the letters in Hebrew have a numerical value, and so you can make fun little like footnotes to other things or literary connections between ideas that might not be so. Apparent exactly. And like serpent and Messiah have the same numerical value and you see that imagery with the brazen serpent and on the pole and Moses being the the children of Israel that they who look on it and and Nephi use that in the Book of Mormon. Well, should I, which is the God of Abraham, El Shaddai, you know, God Almighty.
1:24:47 That's when you read in the King James Version that whenever it says God Almighty, that's Shaddai. OK, Metatron and Shaddai are equivalent. So Ishmael is definitely equating Metatron with God, right? Which he's not. But he's not saying he is God, he's equating him. It's that's gets back into the doctrine of exaltation, right? This esoteric remnant of truth. There's a lot of convoluted crap in there, but that's the redeeming thing. Right. Throughout the whole book is that just is there? If you're looking for it, let's skip some of that. Let's see in 3rd.
1:25:28 Enoch Oh also third Enoch calls. Even though Enoch is like literally God and above the angels, it's interesting that all the angels call him the youth or the lad, which is what Enoch says to God. In our full of great price. I am but Aladdin old people make me interesting. It's the only time that that appears. And Rabbi Ishmael asks him, why did they call you the lad? And he says, well, because, you know, I came from the earth and I was younger than all of them. You know, I'm the I'm the new guy, but he's also, you know, above them all.
1:26:08 Anyway, Third Enoch chapter 48 says I made honor, majesty and glory his garment. So this is God talking to Rabbi Ishmael. I believe I made honor, majesty, and glory his garment, beauty, pride and strength, His outer robe and a kingly crown. I bestowed upon him some of My majesty, some of My magnificence, some of the splendor of my glory, which is on the throne of glory. And I called him by my name the lesser Jehovah, the Prince of the Divine Presence, knower of secrets. Every secret that I have revealed to Him in love, every mystery I have made not known unto him in uprightness, so call so. Let's hit.
1:26:54 That, yeah, I want to make. Sure, I'm understanding. So this is the God, so to speak, talking about Enoch. Now when he starts talking about a lesser glory, a lesser whatever, that to me smacks of translation over exaltation. OK, Does that seem reasonable? Yeah. In our turn, well. I see what you're. Putting down but at the same time reading through this like he's definitely this is talking more about the process of exaltation into godhood and obtaining the throne of the Godhead to me than just being brought back into the presence of God. OK.
1:27:35 All right. And but yeah, but I'm definitely understanding that we definitely should not be equating Enoch with God ourselves. But here's the part that blew my mind, that came to my mind when I was reading this. Enoch, in this imagery throughout, is repeatedly clothed in new garments with glory, crowned, anointed sometimes, and the name of God is being put upon him. And it occurred to me, and there's a striking connection that maybe we haven't realized with Mormonism in the garments, with that in the name of God being put upon you, the tetragrammaton. Do you know what that means?
1:28:17 So that's the, that's what the Jews call the name of God. It's Yad. Hey Vaad. Hey, 4 letters. It's four. It's four letter name, right? 4. Characters 4 marks 4 marks on the garment and guess what? In the tetragrammaton, 2 of the letters are the same. On the garment, 2 of the marks are the same. I I'm sure it's a coincidence. That blew my mind. Yeah, thinking about that dude, that's nuts. That's nuts now and brought into. The presence of God crowned. Yeah. No, all of it. It's consistent. That's consistent. I'm just with us, with our theology. I'm just. Saying here if if. On the surface, that seems pretty. That's that's.
1:29:02 A That's a dunk, dude. That's a yeah, that's. That's a dunk now, because I'm always a guy who looks at both sides. The blessing and the curse of this right? I I'm like, OK, so if you take that name upon you and then you take them off, so to speak, and you just stop, what's the, what's the ramifications of that? I like that comment. Right. What's the ramifications of that? If if if you have taken on that name and? Put it away and then put it. Away. Big Yikes. Oh yeah, that's AI like that. So I actually do have that quote from one of these scholars who his name is Harold Bloom.
1:29:51 And. This is so freaking funny to me, he says about Joseph Smith. I can only attribute to his genius or Damon's, his uncanny recovery of elements in ancient Jewish theology that have ceased to be available to either Judaism or to Christianity, and that had survived only in esoteric traditions unlikely to have been touched, to have touched Smith directly. It's not the one I was thinking of, but yeah, that's that's a good one though. Yeah, he's, he's struggling with Joseph right there. Yeah, big. Time. He's struggling. With him, he, he doesn't want to admit it, but he he has to begrudgingly is, is what it feels like. Yeah, yeah. Because. He's not going to on the other side. It's he must have had manuscripts. And he's like, I know Foley.
1:30:33 Well, he didn't. So he's either genius or he's literally talking the spirits. Damons, as he you know, or demons. Yeah, as he's calling it. Yep. But yeah, so, so interesting. Because he can't just be. What he says he is. No, I mean that that's not going to hold weight. Because, well, he's a professor somewhere on the East Coast and couldn't go say that, right? Right, that's his way of. Saying it without trying to, yeah, I don't know. But you had a. You had an experience with a college professor? I did. I did. Yeah, I I was back in Maryland. We did some some side work for the University of Maryland as a perk, you could, you know, take a corset discounted and I wanted to take Jacksonian America because you can't really talk about Jacksonian America without talking about the Mormons.
1:31:21 And when we start covering the burned over district in New York and that that sort of time period, this professor and and look, Mormons are pretty sparse for the most part. Once you get get really and you know, past into Pennsylvania, right? I mean, we thin out quite a bit, maybe some some pockets and metroplexes and that sort of thing. Yeah, DC. 'S got a temple, Yeah, Yes, yes they do. But he he opens up by saying this, when you're Speaking of Joseph Smith, you have to come to one of two conclusions want. More from the Mormon Renegade Podcast Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the fundamental news program for free.
1:32:10 Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button. And for $5.00 a month, you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes. Today he he. Opens up by saying this, when you're Speaking of Joseph Smith, you have to come to one of two conclusions. He is either the most raw genius that certainly America, if not the world has ever produced, or he was what he says he was. So I'm not going to tip.
1:32:51 I'm not going to tip my hand. You know, I'm, I'm thinking I'm not going to tip my hand that I'm a Mormon right now, right? But towards the end of the of, of the semester, I did approach him and I said, OK, I'm going to hold your feet to the fire. Which one is he for you? And I'll never forget it. He just kind of leans back in his chair and he looks at me and he gets kind of a a wry smile on his face and he says I just don't ask the question. All right, so that was a. Lot of the history, especially on the Jewish and early Christian side, we're going to get back into the theology. OK. And pearly great price, I mean, actually kind of all of it. But comparison of the theologies between our pearly great price and what we see in the first book of Enoch especially. I think most of the rest is probably first Enoch, which came to be my favorite.
1:33:39 It's a little clunky, at least the translation I read. You know, I don't know what Ethiopian looks like. Maybe that can be forgiven. But in any case, we're going to get into the fun, weird stuff now. Yeah. Yeah, I was going to say, I, I think I said it earlier. First, Enoch is by far my favorite because it's an Enoch that I recognize from Joseph Smith, right? And it's not an Enoch that seems to be deified as heavily. I didn't. Mind Second Enoch. Too bad, but yeah, First Enoch was definitely my favorite. And you're right, it is funky, but what can you expect from oral tradition passed down until 200 years either side of Christ? It's, it's a little it, it's supposed to be clunky, so. We're going to get into the Giants and the Watchers, possibly, maybe one of the most taboo subjects in. I think I don't know why we're still discussing this, because I'm fairly sure that Russell Crowe and Darren Ornoski in the movie Noah has answered this question for us. They were big rock people, big rock people. They were big rock people, Michael. That's what they were.
1:34:53 So I had questions in our class and so I had to answer them and I put I put this guy off for like 2 months because I think he might have even he might have even asked them during like. Our Adam. Lesson you know, but any in any case, the giants so. We. See the giants of the offspring of. Angels. Apparently, allegedly, Genesis 6 says the sons of God came down and married the daughters of men. And then there was the Edgar glory. I think it was I was pronounced in the, OR the Gibrine and and they're mighty men of renown and heroes of old. And so it's like, OK, well, can this work with Mormonism or, or, you know, or, you know, some of the rabbis and early church fathers started saying, oh, these were the, the righteous posterity of the of Seth who married uncovenant people and there was a apostasy.
1:35:57 And is that true? It seems like however, viewing things through a smart people with degrees kind of lens when you look at the religion of the ancient Near East. It. Looks like the religion of that time period when you look at places like you Grit, which is about 100 or so miles north of Jerusalem, just South of Mount Zafan, which was the Mount Olympus of like the Phoenicians and that, you know, right with Baal and all that. The father of the gods and the father of humanity was called El, sometimes El AB Adam or Abu Adami, Father Adam, father of mankind, you know, but he had seventy sons who are also gods and he had like 3 wives. So he's polygamist fun.
1:36:50 That's a side note, but OK, So yeah. What? Is this is called the Divine Assembly or the congregation of the, you know, divine congregation? This seems that like the literature is clearly referring to the idea that this is from, it's referring to the congregation, right, Right. The idea, then, scholars say, is as the Israelite religion evolved into monotheism, these gods, these seventy sons which were also gods, devolved into angels. OK. And so these angels, which were once gods, you know, left. Right the.
1:37:36 The heavens went down to Mount Hermon, which is actually in the South in the Enoch text that was it was Mount Hermon. But then they went and did what they did and, and some said however, too. And I thought this was interesting that this was a rebuttal to the Greek world in a way, because at this time the Enoch is being written. Judaism is steeped in Greek philosophy and the nations around. And it's even been older than that though too. Babylon had their version, and Egypt. Actually, I don't know if Egypt had their version of demigods, but Babylon and Greece for sure had demigods, the heroes. Well, yeah, if you look at Gilgamesh, Gilgamesh is depicted large enough that he's holding a full scale lion and it looks like a kitten, right?
1:38:28 I mean, and so yeah, the. Authors or the scholars are saying this is a rebuttal to the Greeks and Babylonians who are saying, look at all these heroes that are the sons of gods, right? And the Jews are saying, no, these are bad, right? Don't get involved in this demigod hero story stuff. I could see. I see I could. See that, but I think we're at a time in in in Jewish. Look, the Pharisees and Sadducees have no cult problems calling BS when they see it, right? So it seems a little less direct to me for them to be doing that. Does that make sense?
1:39:11 Sure, sure. But I thought that opinion was interesting at the very least. I think it's just as valid as any of the other ones. Let's be honest. I think it seems like in the Jewish camp and the Christian camp, the earliest interpretations also were that it was a divine assembly situation and not an apostasy situation. Although, and I don't know for a fact on the when the Jews changed their tune, but some of the Jews eventually started changing their tune because it's problematic. And then they eventually just disregarded the Book of Enoch as a whole. Anyways, get rid of the whole problem. But when Jerome translated the Bible into the Latin Vulgate, he was the one who actually started to, in the early church, postulate the idea that it was an apostasy situation.
1:39:59 So before that, it was definitely a divine congregation problem, an apostasy from on high, so to speak, for them to Jerome and to the rest of the church. OK. After the 5th century, it became, now these are sets where we're children. But that doesn't really answer the giants thing, right? That's one, that's the criticism levelled against that opinion, right? Is it gets rid of this supposed mystical or supernatural element of the the offspring being giants. And so you have to interpret that allegorically, right? Which is fine if you do, but that just means you have to interpret it allegorically, not literally, right? All right, So I don't usually do this with with guys. Where do you fall on?
1:40:42 It man, why'd you have? To do that, I don't have. I don't know if I have a particular stance besides just addressing the arguments. I would say that Joseph Smith did mention in Nauvoo that in reference to Genesis 6, he did say that this in fact, I have the floor there. We're about to get into that. So let's read it. This is in George Lobbs journal, George Labro that Joseph Smith said angels came down and took themselves wives of the daughters of men. See Genesis 6 verse one through 2. These were resurrected bodies violated celestial laws. That's what George Labrov.
1:41:29 Now I've had people in last class, in fact I believe it was last class pointed out that seems to be a contradiction with Section 130, which says that there is no angels who minister to this earth, but who do who or who have belonged to it. And so if the resurrection had become taken place yet, how is it that the resurrected angels on this earth siring children? So that's the one problem with that. First off, that's one seeming addiction that I just need to point out. Let's see before I do I skip over anything. But the book of Moses says the giants are valid and it says in Chapter 7, verse 15.
1:42:18 And the giants of the land also stood afar off and there went forth a curse upon all the people that fought against God. So OK, there were giants according to our foul Jerry Price. So I guess we can't really throw that out. And I guess it's already throughout the Old Testament to, you know, you have David and Goliath and the, the the Rephaeum and you know, the the children of Esau go and comp, you know, the zoo Zazim or whatever. All those guys that were out living in the land of Edom right up by Mount Seir, they were destroyed by by Esau's and Ishmael's children. You know, I think we. Have to have to wonder where, you know, what are they defining as giants right now?
1:43:03 Look, I'm a pretty big guy. I go 62, about 300 lbs. But next to Shaquille O'Neal, right, I mean. Oh, sure, yeah. I'm not, I'm definitely a skeptical on like the like I've heard like 40 foot tall or 4400 feet tall or 4 miles high giants that we're talking about. I'm like, yeah, it's a load, right? I'm not yeah, I definitely don't think that's what they're dealing with. But like a Wyatt size, right? About 12 feet tall. I I could see that you. Yeah. I mean, look it, it's possible, certainly in the realm of, of, of, of possibility, right? I mean, George Washington was described as a giant, right? He stood 6 foot two for his time and most guys were 59. Also, I think, I think, you know, the term giant can have different connotations as well, right?
1:43:49 We, we often look at like if somebody's really good in their business, he's a Titan of industry. He's a giant in the industry. And so I think those are those are terms that that we have to realize are the kind of loaded terms at times. So. And the second. The second critique. I would have of interpreting angels coming with resurrected bodies violating celestial laws is I'm a believer that lineage is somewhat foreordained by covenant and for a group of apostate angels who are resurrected to go to the earth inside our children, you're bringing spirits into the world.
1:44:29 Through. Lineages that were not covenanted or planned and I don't know how that works. And that would require revelation. Now I'm open if that's true. I just God hasn't said how that works yet. And I will be totally open to hearing from the Lord how that works and that would be just fine. I just don't understand how. How does people outside of the plan of God bring children into this world? What caliber or class of spirits does that bring in this Enoch literature? It's like these were actually demons. And to this day, because they got locked up in Tartarus, you know, their spirits are the evil spirits that are on the earth.
1:45:09 That's what Enoch said. The books of Enoch say about that. And that's the cause of evil, you know? You know, OK, maybe that's the case. But to me, it's like introducing a virus into the computer program, right? And maybe that's what happened, and maybe that's why God had to wipe things out with the the flood and then the conquest of the promised land under Joshua. I don't or whatever. Yeah, I don't know. But that's one critique I have about that paradigm in general, right as it seems like that's that's pretty heavy. But since we're in it, we can address possible. We can, we can address what might make it work, right? So let's do that.
1:45:57 Joseph Smith said the world and earth are not synonymous terms. Oh, OK, yeah, OK now. We're getting into stuff. Yeah. So yeah, second thirty says in answer to the question is not God, is not the reckoning of God's time, angels, time, prophets, time and man's time according to the planet on which they reside. I answer yes, but there are no angels who minister to this earth, but those who do do belong or have belong to it. Joseph Smith also said the world and earth are not synonymous terms. The world is the human family. This earth was organized or formed out of other planets which were broke up and remodeled to make the into the one on which we live. And that's from words of Joseph Smith on January 5th 1841. He also said in remarking upon the opening verses of Genesis, he said in the translation where it says without form and void, it should read empty and desolate. The word created should be formed or organized. He also said on January 5th, 1841, God did not make the earth out of nothing, for it is contrary to a rational mind and reason that something could be brought from a nothing. Also it is contrary to the principle and means by which God does work.
1:47:14 Also, this earth has been organized out of the portions of other globes that have been disorganized. Interesting, very interesting. What? Are we talking other worlds that have been disorganized, which we saw from Enoch earlier? See if I can find it. I might have it actually. Later. Too I, I. Want to just for a moment, and this is this is where I think the first book of Enoch and Joseph Smith are so good together. I'll let you find it and read it and then I got it. So he says in the last days that in the days of sinners, the heavenly bodies will begin to fall out of phase and an evolving chaos will envelope the earth as both nature and humanity grow out of sync with their prescribed order.
1:48:02 And in another place, Enoch sees that God has prepared a place in the cosmos for the punishment of rebellious stars, which deviated from God's timetable. So God is destroying stars, right? Who don't, Who do not follow. Yep, his. Ordained will. Yep, this is. Where Joseph Smith and the book of Enoch. This is where I really riff on this, right? Because if if we just go back to that first part where where Joseph Smith says the term world and what was the earth have two different connotations.
1:48:43 That begins. To open up a realm of possibilities that, quite frankly, are mind blowing, right? Because if, as Joseph Smith says, the term world really means. Just the. People who inhabit it. Well, that leaves open the. Possibility that perhaps others inhabited it before Adam did. Yep. We're going to get there and. And this sort of thing. And This is why I, this is just a theory. So if there's an archaeologist out there who wants to yell at me later, he can. But this is one of the reasons I wonder if they don't really dislike Joseph Smith.
1:49:23 Because right now, as we speak, new things are being discovered that cause things to become older, right? Just as an example. Boy, I'm going down a weird. Rabbit hole now. Now you're going to get a look at what Dave reads in his spare time as well as gospel stuff. If you look at the base of the Sphinx, it is significantly older than the Sphinx that sits on top of it by thousands of years, pushing the dates back clear back. Are you familiar? With the London Hammer, that one too. Do you know the dates on that one? I don't offhand. I don't offhand. That one's like, it's like there used to be a date postulated like where the origin of humanity was. And this like predates that kind of thing, yes. And then also, when you look at finds like Gobekli Tepe, which seemed to have been buried on purpose, all of a sudden, human, human expansion.
1:50:24 Well, I shouldn't say, well, yeah, we can say human. Human expansion and human fingerprints. Get whale. Now we know that current archaeologists hate this. And now I'm going to start getting real nerdy. It upsets Clovis first, right? The model that the Clovis people were the first ones to hit America. They're the the ones primarily responsible. That. Upends all of that. Well, if you got this guy out here in 18th century America's 19th century America talking about the definition of worlds, things get a little spicy.
1:51:05 Very. Spicy for Christianity, which believed that the earth was created 6000 years ago out of nothing, right? And the. Pushback, even the Mormonism, you know, we have certain leaders in the church like Joseph Fielding Smith Junior, who was definitely a believer of a strict and I think this, I think this is emblematic Mormonism generally speaking, is that there was no death before Adam. So how can any of this work, right? You know 'cause it says Adam was the first flesh upon the earth, which means the first mortal first to die. Right, right. And so how does that all work? Well, Joseph Smith says above that it was desolate and empty, which to me that that reads like it was destroyed and then started over. And so if you view it that way, then there's no contradiction, right?
1:51:55 Right, and everything starts to. Piece. Together a little easier with the dates that they're finding as well yeah and we also. Have the scary thoughts from Malachi's Promise which says this is still relatable. Joseph Smith says what are we to understand by this? In the last days, in the days of Noah, God destroyed the world by a flood and has promised to destroy it by fire in the last days, but before it took place, Elijah should come first and turn the hearts of the fathers to the children. Now comes the point. What is the office work of Elijah to make sure that that doesn't happen right? Yep, and. This is where I get on my soapbox. I'll match you OK all the temp.
1:52:37 I didn't really want to go here but I have to. Oh, it's too late. You know the name of the show, You're good all the temple. Work that the church is doing doesn't matter a damn. It doesn't matter a damn right now because they've changed the ordinances and they're not efficacious. And. We, you and I, if we were to go through, if we hadn't been endowed and we went through, we're not making the same covenants that the pioneer generation made. We cannot be saved on the same laws and principles that they were covenanting to be under. We're not going to the same Kingdom of glory, right? And. Therefore the earth will be utterly wasted if our hearts, the hearts of the children, are not turned to the promises made to the fathers. The earth will be utterly wasted at my coming and. I'll take it even a step backwards further. This doesn't begin in the temple. This has to begin by digging up your records. Your family's.
1:53:28 Records, right? I think a large portion because. I I. I'm not a believer that that that the promise by Malachi is simply you're going to do their ordinance work. When he starts talking about the heart, he's talking about something different, right? So in doing your own genealogy, your own family history, there has to be a connection made, there has to be a love there that's involved to get to the heart and the way that the way that quite frankly, in an LDS temple, you just go in and draw a name. Doesn't do it. Doesn't do it, no. And I don't dispute that at all.
1:54:10 But I do know that Joseph Smith said that all men must be saved on the same principles. And he said that in connection with temple ordinances being revealed the same way from heaven. So if you change that, we're no longer being, according to Joseph Smith, we're no longer being saved according to the same principles as others. And that causes a no welding link, as Joseph Smith said. And it's all separate. And we're told that our hearts need to be made to the promises of the Fathers, not the promises being made in our generation. Our. Hearts need to be. In the promises made to our fathers, which is the old endowment, the old doctrines, that's plural marriage, that's law of consecration. And if we do not do all those three things, the, the ordinances, plural marriage and law of consecration, the promises made to the fathers to be saved on the same principles, then our earth is going to be destroyed.
1:55:05 And I've seen this, it's all over in the Enoch literature about the stars being destroyed. It's a there's a when I was looking at Jewish Kabbalah stuff for the other lessons in the Zohar, I believe it says literally and Moses says this, that worlds without number have passed away, right? And. The Zohar says that worlds are being destroyed all the time because God refuses to visit them. Yep. Yep. And and I was going to say, it has a cascading effect, right? It's not just a one. Boom, you're done. There's a cascading effect. Joseph Smith, I think, alludes to this when he says when there's no change in ordinances, there's no change of priesthood. But when there is a change in ordinances, there is a change in priesthood. Exactly the corollary, right?
1:55:49 And so you you get a cascading event of disasters that come by changing those and that fits. With again reading that again the heavenly bodies fall out of phase in the days of the sinners, where humanity also grows out of sync, the same as the stars do with their prescribed order. And so. Yeah, back to the church. The church thinks it's, oh, priest has been restored, Follow the prophet. Just go to your temple work once a month or whatever, whenever you can spare the time. And we got the keys and it's all good. But and they never take this Malachi's promise in the light that I'm presenting it. And I I want to really double down on how important that is, because what would it mean?
1:56:36 If. What's being done in the temples in the LDS church? We're not being accepted by the Lord. What does it mean now? Yep, it means. That we are up for that utter wasting? Yep. Orson Hyde taught this too. He says the earth you remember was void and empty until our first parents began at the Garden of Eden. What does the term replenish mean? This word is derived from the Latin re and plenus. Re denotes repetition, iteration, and plenus signifies full, complete. Then the meaning of the word replenish is to refill, recomplete. Now go forth, says the Lord, and replenish the earth. For it was covered with gloomy cloud, clouds of darkness excluded from the light of heaven, and darkness brooded upon the face of the deep.
1:57:23 The world was populate, was peopled before the days of Adam, as much so as it was before the days of Noah. It was said that Noah became the father of a new world, but it was the same old world still, or same old earth still, to use that term to to substitute, and will continue to be, though it may pass through many changes. When God said go forth and replenish the earth, it was to replenish the inhabitants of the human species and make it as it was before. Our first parents then were commanded to multiply and replenish the earth. Dude, there is so much there that I think I am in such a weird spot because I there's so much I want to say, but I don't want to freak people out either.
1:58:05 I probably did that for you. No, Oh no, that we don't where I'm going is is far, far bigger than that. We'll get we'll get into that maybe another time. So. In support of all this, Orson F Whitney, who is a grandson of Hebrew C Kimball and Newell K Whitney, said on August 19th, 1888. The Prophet Joseph also declares that this earth is composed of the broken up fragments of other earths. But why were these other earths broken up and destroyed? Was it because they were disobedient and kept not the law? But now the Lord says that the earth obeys the celestial law, and therefore it shall be sanctified and make glorious, that those who have kept the celestial law may inherit it. These things are worth our serious consideration. If we fall short in our obedience and faithfulness, we are taking the terrible risk of being deprived of our eternal inheritance on this earth, which is to be our heaven. They who break the Sabbath are taking a course that perchance may enable the earth to rise up and testify against them and spurn them from its presence as unfit to dwell upon its glorified surface.
1:59:12 So he addresses another key point to me, which is this earth apparently in section 76, I think, has a promise that it will be celestialized. We, however, don't have a promise that will be there, right? And we don't. And if we don't quicken it, then it might just go through another round of creation. Like Orson Hyde says we're undergoing one that's subsequent to the previous one. And it's just, it's it, it's promised its ultimate exaltation for some reason, but doesn't need to wait until it has a people ready to live on it. We don't have to be that people if we don't live, right? Yeah. If we're not 5th to live there, we're not going to live there. So let me. Ask you this question, we're we're told that the Earth will be celestialized. What does that mean then?
1:59:58 If you're an inhabitant of this earth, but then you fall into one of those other two kingdoms, does that mean you still live on this? Earth, I don't think so. You're kicked off to live somewhere else, the terrestrial or T lestrial world perhaps. OK, another. Thought this part I might edit out. See, This is why I love Enoch and Joseph Smith because this. Just it goes on forever. When you think of a Kingdom, what do you think of? I don't know. You got a king, you got a society, you got order, structure, Ki. Like where you're going there? So often we tend to think of a Kingdom in terms of geographical boundaries. Sure, sometimes.
2:00:43 Though I think a Kingdom can be more about people who adhere to certain laws and ordinances. Perhaps it's less about geographical boundary and more about rights and privileges. And if that's the case, because we know it is said that that those of the celestial world can go to the other two degrees, it's just that those in the other two degrees can't go to the celestial. So I've been wondering is, is, is it less about geographical location and more about rights and privileges? Could be.
2:01:27 Just. Again, thoughts I have late at night when I can't sleep. So let's get into Nibbly on the Watchers. So we've dealt with apparent contradictions and apparent reconciliations, right? We've talked about, OK, maybe it is possible that angels from this earth, from a previous world, however, but still relative to this earth who come and do this, right? Nibbly says finding apocalyptic writing at all in the Bible is amazing. And for those who don't know, apocalyptic just means revelation. Then suddenly they discovered that the whole thing is apocalyptic. All our scriptures here are apocalyptic. That means they are brought forth by times of pressure and crisis.
2:02:10 They always come forth on the eve of great destructions. That's why they are given to us. Read the first section of the doctrinal covenants. Harken ye people of the earth. Therefore ye people fear and tremble. That's the theme in verse seven of the 1st chapter. Wherefore fear and tremble, O ye people, this is the message. Because these things always come when they are badly needed, when the world has been going wrong. When when the world has. Been going the wrong way for a long time and it is time to set things right again. But it's always accompanied by violent upheavals of nature and world upheavals, political, international and everything else. We are going to get a lot of that here. We see it in the days of Adam and we see it in the days of Enoch. This gets quite lively.
2:02:51 You notice here the the fierce anger is kindled from verse 27 following. I just noted some things here to be able to do it more rapidly. The difference from people from is that people are following their system. He says they are not following the system I gave them. I gave them a plan, I gave them instructions. They pay no attention to it. They think that they know better and they are doing it their way. This is a constant theme in all this Enoch literature we put on the board last time. That is one of the great crimes. The classic theme that comes in here, and it usually comes a little later, is the watchers. They have this crash program that begins here when Satan has great dominion and the gospel began to be preached.
2:03:32 Holy angels were sent forth from the presence of God and by his own voice and the gift of the Holy Ghost and his prophets. In this crash program. They sent down angels to preach and put the people right. Now this is a tradition that you will find spread everywhere, including in non Jewish sources at a very early time. These were the watchers, the agrigori. They come down to observe and then went back to report as things as how things were going. They came down to instruct the human race and put them all back on the planet of the gospel again. But many of them, 200 of them, according to tradition, fell away, were tempted by the daughters of men, joined with them and sinned terribly. These were the terrible watchers. They knew too much and that made them very dangerous. The Watchers are responsible for a lot of trouble here. You're going to run into them all the time. We are told that they come down on top of Mount Hermon, the highest mountain in Palestine, which means mountain of the Oath. 200 of them came down.
2:04:30 There and they. Took their oaths and covenants. They gave away the rights of the temple and they perverted them. The whole thing is a right of perversion. They had the same things, but they perverted them and claim that they are being holy, that they had the priesthood, and that they had the covenants. This was their great, great crime, of course, that they had perverted the real thing. Fortunately, we are told that they didn't have enough knowledge. Their knowledge was limited, so they weren't able to destroy everything. Quote, They knew not the mind of God. End Quote, as we are told in this book. So their system was not the system God gave Adam. There's a lot to unpack there, and for as much as I love Nibby Nibbly and I love Nibbly, it's a there.
2:05:16 It's hard to tell when he is speculating himself and when he's just putting forward old literature, and so I'm not 100% sure on what to make of all of that. How about you? I think it's reasonable at the same time we're we're dealing with, we've seen several different interpretations of the watchers thing go on. And so whether it's the sons of Cain or children of Cain offer like the oath thing is what's consistent, like whether it's the sons of Cain administering oaths of darkness that God is pissed off at, or whether it's angels literally who are living in celestial glory breaking their oath by swearing an oath to to go down, or whether it's by revealing temple oaths.
2:06:01 It could be exclusive. It could be both at the same time and I could see that and it's the they're just doing their own counterfeit thing, just like Cain seemed to do with his own counterfeit gospel, which we were able to pretty well elucidate was happening. I think they're or it's just men, the earthly men apostatizing as well. I think the thing, the moral to get out of this generally is watch what oaths you're making and don't reveal sacred things to those who are not ready for it, because that can be destructive. So that's the. Moral yeah, you're you're just taking a good newscast a a good news reporter. We report, you decide sort of a thing. That's what I'm.
2:06:46 Taking yeah, I, I yeah, no, that's, that's. Probably a good safe, safe place. Yeah, dude, to be honest with you, when you get to the Watchers, it's so I'm not sure we'll ever have a definitive answer on that until till the hereafter. But I think there's I think there's wisdom to be taken from no matter which camp you want to espouse on. Absolutely there is. And so that that's what I'd say study, study all the camps, right. Take take all the knowledge you can from this and and apply it where it needs to be. I absolutely. Agree with that. Let's see, we also have an interesting reversal too of what is the what became no, you know, like the the idea and interpretation that's made popular by Jerome of that it's just men.
2:07:38 But we see a reversal of that actually in the book of Moses where it says in chapter 8, verse 13 through 15, it says Noah and his sons. But this is different, right? Noah and his sons hearkened unto the Lord and gave heed and they were called the sons of God. And when these man men began to multiply on the face of the earth, and daughters were born unto them, and the sons of men saw that those daughters were fair, and took them wives even as they chose. And the Lord said unto Noah, The daughters of thy sons have sold themselves. For behold, my angers kindled against the sons of men, for they will not hearken unto my voice. So this is obviously different than what Enoch is seeing about the giants, because we see we read earlier that there was giants in the land in the days of Enoch, and that seems to go with the watchers and their aggregory. But then you know, Noah is the great grandson of Enoch and his granddaughters marry outside the covenant and the sons of men. And that was that did not make the Lord happy either. So you have a reversal as as well going on later down the road where it's not the sons of God marrying the daughters of men, but the daughters of the sons of God marrying the sons of men.
2:08:48 It's all. Jacked up. It was getting all jacked up anyway. Just something interesting to note. OK, next section, switching topics kind of stuff back to the Pearl. A great price. Enoch's interaction with the, the Lord who, and I don't just mean the Lord he's been talking to, but actually I think that there's an Adam God stuff in here that's overlooked. And I, I think he's actually talking to Adam as the Ancient of Days at certain points because we go back, right? So let's see, Adam's ascension to heaven was 122 years before the city of Enoch left, right. So there's 122 year period at the end of Enoch's life where Adam's in heaven where he could have resumed his position as God.
2:09:41 Yeah, right. So Moses 717 through 19, this is around the time period that the city of Enoch is actually being caught up. I believe it says the fear of the Lord is upon all nations. And so great was the glory of the Lord, which is upon his people. And the Lord blessed the land, and they were blessed upon the mountains and upon the high places, and did flourish. And the Lord called his people Zion, because they were one heart and one mind, and dwelt in righteousness, and there was no poor among them. And Enoch continued in his preaching and righteousness unto the people of God, and they came to pass in his days. He built a city that was called a city of holiness, even Zion. And it came to. Pass the Enoch looked, and from Noah he beheld so he's as they're being caught up, he's seeing the right and from Noah he beheld all the families of the earth.
2:10:29 And he cried unto the Lord, saying, One shall the day of the Lord come, one shall the blood of the righteous be shed, that all they, that all they that mourn, may be sanctified and have eternal life. And the Lord said, it shall be in the Meridian of time. So Enoch, as the city is being lifted up, is having a dialogue with God, and he's asking one Christ to make. God. Answers that in the Meridian of time. And then it follows that Enoch saw the day of the coming of the Son of Man even in the flesh, and his soul rejoiced, saying, the righteous is lifted up and the Lamb is slain from the foundation of the world. And then it gets interesting.
2:11:12 And. He called unto the Lord, saying, Wilt thou not come again upon the earth? For as much as thou art God, and I know thee, and thou hast sworn unto me, and commanded me that I should ask in the name of thine, only begotten thou hast made me, and given me a right unto thy throne, not of myself, but through thine own grace. Wherefore I ask thee, if thou will not come again on the earth? OK, so he he right there, he says in the name. You've asked me to ask you in the name of your only begotten, and I'm asking you. Are you going to come again? So he's not. Talking to Christ, he's. Talking exactly. Exactly he's talking to a God saying inasmuch as you are God and I know you and again, they knew each other.
2:11:58 If if this God is Adam, they knew each other for well, all of you in life three, 365 years and he's asking are you going to and and he's been gone. You know God's been if he's Adam, he's been gone for 122 years. Are you going to come back again again, right. And he says, the Lord said unto Enoch, as I live. Even so, I will come in the last days, in the days of wickedness and vengeance, to fulfill the oath which I have made unto you. And see, there's so much there, especially when you start unpacking the ancient a dazed stuff in Daniel and then. And then when? You go and you unpack Revelations, right? And it talks about Michael being the one who vanquishes Lucifer, right?
2:12:40 All the sudden you're looking at the return of two gods, Jesus Christ and God the Father himself and now and, and if if you're going to say that God the Father is coming as well, which is which it says there in the Pearl of great price, you then have to give credence to the word again. Does the word again, and also in the days of wickedness and vengeance, remember that? Because in Daniel 7 it says, I saw in the night visions, and behold, one like the Son of Man came with the clouds of heaven, and came to the Ancient of days, and brought him near before him the Ancient of Days. And there was given him dominion, glory, and a Kingdom, and all people, nations and languages should serve him.
2:13:25 His dominion is an everlasting dominion, etcetera. And then in chapter 12, it says, And at that time shall Michael stand up the great Prince which standeth for the children of thy people, and there shall be a time of trouble such as never was. So in the days of wickedness and vengeance. And Daniel says that Michael will stand up in the ancient days will come at a time of trouble such as never was. So that's rhetorically connected. Furthermore, in like first Enoch chapter 14, Enoch is talking to the Ancient of Days and he's the one that's telling Enoch, I'm going to send the flood.
2:14:06 And so we're dealing with a conversation in the Perla great price. That's literally preceding the flood and seeing Noah and the flood and then the rest of the history of the world and then in the book of Enoch Enochs and dialogue with the ancient of days in a very similar conversation and the ancient of days saying I'm going to send the flood. You know any latter day St. should take very seriously Ancient of Days stuff in other literature. Because Christians and Jews knew that was God. Yes, and Joseph Smith said that was Adam. Yep. Yep, absolutely. And if I'm not mistaken, there's some Christians who actually hypothesized the Ancient of Days being Adam. Yep.
2:14:49 I've heard that, I've heard Gabel and I've heard the Son of Man is presented as being able to like vice versa. Sometimes it's Enoch, right? But yeah, but no, I have. I have heard that and so. Like all of a sudden Adam God starts to pop in restoration scriptures. And that's that's huge, right? And it's so subtle, right? So subtle. Oh, but if you understand it, if you understand Adam God, if if you understand, understand ancient days, Michael's role in Revelation, this starts this stuff starts to come forward. So I skipped over earlier. Back when we were talking about Metatron and Should I? Yeah, there's other books that that mentioned Metatron.
2:15:31 That's not Books of Enoch. Like there's there's like a 7th century Jewish text called the Apocalypse of Zerubabel. Zerubabel was the temple architect in the you know, so it's also, it's attributing stuff to to him pseudographically, right, right. But in that Metatron is Michael. And so you, you're now basically dealing with the connection of Metatron, Shaddai, the name of God, and Michael all being wrapped into there. That's that's potent. Yeah. This is interesting. So we talked a little bit about how impossible it is for Joseph Smith to have had access to the records.
2:16:15 Right. Well, I have another approach to this too. That validates it. It's a it's a, it's not an apologetic, apologetic tactic I've heard used before. OK. And so I thought it was interesting, but in any case, in if you go through teachings of Joseph Smith, which I consider like a fifth standard work, it's basically scripture in my opinion. I think so because, I mean, look, there was work both both its predecessor words of Joseph Smith as well as as the teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith. Those were verified pretty well, right? No, they're huge. Yeah. Those those weren't just, hey, some dude remembered him saying this. No. Teachings has a gloss or two that come to mind. The biggest one, in my opinion, is like what people critiquing our position say.
2:17:04 Like we're oh, you know, assuredly that anyone who rises against the church while he he's, you know, saying that they are out of the way while he himself is righteous, he's on the High Road to apostasy. That like we have no original source quote for that. Adjacent to that idea is where he says Harkin E12 and E elders, any man who betrays his brethren know that he's on a High Road to apostasy. You know, betrays the brethren, right? Is what it says. In the teachings, that's a. Gloss and it doesn't say that in the original account, which comes from Wilfred Woodruff, which the original quote from Wilford Woodruff that he wrote down in his journal and you can go look this up because it's all online.
2:17:47 He's Joseph Smith says this is a paraphrase, but it don't I'm thinking it's a very good close paraphrase. He says, Hearken E12 And all ye elders, do not betray the revelations that God has given to you, whether they be in the Book of Mormon, the Doctrine Covenants, the Bible, or any other revelations that he may give to you. And do. Not betray your brethren. That reads differently. Yeah, not the brethren, not the hierarchy. But don't betray your brethren and don't betray the revelations, Right it that's the mark of apostasy is betraying the revelations and betraying your brethren. In any case, he goes on.
2:18:32 And when he's talking about Paul and he says in the Epistle of Hebrews that Paul's, you know, he's describing the authorship of Hebrews to Paul. And he says that when he says that the blood of Christ has made a better atonement than the blood of Abel, you know, for offerings for sin or whatever, well, Joseph then ruminates and says, well, how does Paul know so much about Abel? Because there's like one or two instances. And he says well, because Abel ministered to him. Interesting. And then he. Also, I think he says the same thing about Jude and Enoch. And he? Says that, you know, because Jude says in the 1 chapter epistle that he has, he says quite bluntly, he says and from the 7th, from Adam we know this prophecy.
2:19:21 And then he let's see, do I have it? I think I do have it here. No, I don't. But I'll just pull it up. Hold that thought. No, I do. It was also these that Enoch, the 7th generation from Adam prophesied saying, See the Lord is coming with 10 thousands of his holy ones to execute judgement on all, and to convict everyone of all the deeds of ungodliness that they have committed in such an ungodly way, and of all the harsh things that the ungodly sinners have spoken against him. And so First off, Enoch's quoting Daniel type literature about the Ancient of Days, 10 thousands or millions or whatever the various translations. Many a multitude of angels are attending the Ancient of days when he comes.
2:20:03 But Enoch he's quoting Enoch here saying that the day will come that 10,000 the Lord with 10,000 or many of his holy ones will come. And so Joseph Smith's like, well, how did Jude, how do you? Know. Yeah, Enoch, talk to him. And so Joseph Smith, what does that mean? Oh, you're fine. Joseph Smith wasn't taking the scholarly approach now saying because when now we know Jude is actually quoting the first book of. Joseph Smith. 'S not saying Oh well, how did how did Jude know he had the book of Enoch? He didn't even know about it. And so for me, the point to get a I'm getting across here is that's a very convoluted red heifer or red herring.
2:20:49 Sorry. Yeah. That's a very convoluted red herring to throw out there to people. If he was just, if he had supposedly had access to these Enochian records that he himself was copying, saying, well, how did Jude know that what Enoch said, oh, he must have talked to him when he himself had the Book of Enoch and was quoting from it in the Book of Moses. Yeah, right. You think that's likely? So we have Joseph Smith admitting that he didn't even know that there was a book of Enoch essentially right in the teachings, in his own words. He didn't know there's a book of Enoch that Jude was quoting from. So there you go. You like that it gets better.
2:21:29 It just continues to get better. Yeah, I've never heard anyone tackle that angle, no. No, but that, that's. It's kind of game. Set match right? I think so. But here's what Enoch says, the brook Venick. So I'll read Jude again, then I'll read Enoch. Jude says it was also about these. The Enoch in the 7th generation from Adam prophesied saying, See, the Lord is coming with 10,000 of his holy ones to execute judgment on all and to convict everyone of all the deeds of ungodliness that they have committed in such an ungodly way, and of all the harsh things that ungodly sinners have spoken against him. Enoch says, behold, he comes with myriads of his holy ones to execute judgment on all and to destroy the wicked and to convict all flesh for all the wicked deeds that they have done and the proud and hard words that wicked sinners spoke against him. That's all the money.
2:22:20 Yeah, that's nearly verbatim. Yep, absolutely it is. I'm sure he's just a good guesser. I wouldn't read into that too much, Michael. So some other fun stuff for proving Joseph Smith being inspired, or a really good guesser as Dave puts it. Abinadiah alludes to Enoch. Really, it's not a direct. Quote. It's not as good as a direct quote as the last one, but like we covered earlier, OK, it looks like some of the first books of Enoch were written about 300 BC. Well, if this is true, if Abenadi is quoting it, that means fragments of it were actually on the brass plates and are actually older. Much older 600 BC at least, right? Yeah, at least, at least at least right. That's best.
2:23:10 That's the best case scenario because 600 would have been about the time that if I would have got the. Plates, Yep. So they had to already been on there and so or or they're coming from direct Revelation to Benedadi, I guess maybe, maybe. But I'm going to go with the brass plates thing anyway, Abinadi says. When he's preaching to King Noah, he says, And it shall come to pass that I will smite this people with sore afflictions, yeah, with famine and with pestilence. And it shall come to pass that I will send forth hail among them, and it shall smite them. And they shall also be smitten with the east wind. And insects shall pester their land also, and devour their grain. In First Enoch 76, Five and 10 says, And this alludes to the storehouse idea that contains the elements.
2:23:55 But the east wind comes forth through the 1st portal or storehouse which is in the east. From it comes forth desolation, drought, heat and destruction. And after these the north winds. From the 7th portal in the east come dew and rain, locust and desolation. So Enoch is saying that the east wind brings desolation, drought, heat and destruction. And then comes rain, locust and desolation and the Benedai saying famine, pestilence, the east wind and insects will pester your land and devour their grain. So it's all, it's all the pain associated with the east wind, you know. Coming from the.
2:24:38 Storehouses of Heaven, so yeah. Chances are he's quoting directly from the Book of Enoch alluding. Or paraphrasing too. But yes, it's not super tight but the imagery is extremely consistent. It's tight enough but it gets better. Because Samuel the Lamanite does quote. Really. Yeah. All right, let's see it. Samuel The. Lamanite, when he's on the wall giving his, his dissertation to the Nephites who are wicked, he's and it makes sense because prophets do this all the time. You know, you see Amos and Isaiah and I think there's another one, Micah. Amos, Isaiah and Micah all say the same thing. It's in the last days. The mountain of the Lord's house shall be established in the, in the top of the mountains.
2:25:19 They all say that and we don't know who's quoting who, who said it first. They're all about the same time period. We don't know who said it for are they all quoting Isaiah or is Amos first? We don't know, but they all put it in there. So prophets do that. They quote each other. Good Christ. Christ quoted the prophets when he when he was repelling the the, the temptations by the adversary, He quotes Yep. Deuteronomy and Exodus. Yep, Yep. Yeah, absolutely. And so Samuel Lamanite says. And behold, a curse shall come upon the land, saith the Lord of Hosts, because of this people's sake who are upon the land, yeah, because of their wickedness and their abominations. And it shall come to pass, say at the Lord of hosts, yeah, our great and true God, that whoso shall hide up treasures in the earth shall find them again no more, because of the great curse of the land, save he be a righteous man, and shall hide it up to the Lord. He also says, Behold ye the people of this great city, and hearken unto my words.
2:26:19 Yeah, hearken unto the words which the Lord saith, for behold, he saith, Ye are cursed because of your riches, and also are your riches cursed because you have set your hearts upon them, and have not hearkened unto the words of Him who gave them to you. You do not remember the Lord your God, and the things which He has, He has blessed you. But you do always remember your riches, not to thank the Lord your God for them. Yeah, your hearts are not drawn out unto the Lord, but they do swell with great pride unto boasting, and unto great swellings and beings, stripes, malice, persecutions and murders, in all manner of iniquities. For this cause has the Lord God, 'cause that a curse shall come upon the land, and also upon your riches, and this because of your iniquities.
2:27:02 Enoch says. Any saying to those in the Maybe it's in his day or those in the last days, I don't recall. But he says, Woe unto you, ye rich, for ye have trusted in your riches, and from you your riches shall ye depart. That's a direct quote, yeah. Because you have not remembered the Most High that. In the days. Of your riches, that is the state, yeah, in the days of your riches you have not remembered the Most High and your riches are going to be slippery, is the That's what Samuel says. But he says your riches shall depart from you. Enoch says. He's also goes and says, Woe unto you who acquire silver and gold in unrighteousness, For your riches shall not abide, but speedily ascend from you, and ye shall be given over to a great curse.
2:27:50 So a supernatural slant is being given by Enoch, that your riches will ascend from you or depart from you. Yeah. Because they do not remember the Lord in the days of their riches. So it's it's direct, it is correct. Yep. Let's see, do. I have what Christ do. I have all the things that Christ quoted. It's like. So First off, some people do think Christ quoted Enoch as well. In fact, he nibbly said that the book of Enoch is quoted 128 times in the New Testament. But when the Pharisees or scribes come to him and ask him, if a woman marries 7 men, who is she in the you know, who does she belong to in the resurrection?
2:28:33 And Christ says do not know they, you know, that they'd be like the angels and they don't marry. That's like a a kind of an illusion almost. Yeah. To what we saw about the watchers, right? Shouldn't do that, right? You know, and Orson. Pratt would say his apologetic to that because it's been a big criticism from sectarian Christianity against Mormonism. As you believe you can be married in heaven, Orson Pratt said. Yeah, but our marriages aren't done in heaven, they're done on earth, right? And. Sealed. For heaven, right? And so. Christ is possibly alluding to the book of Enoch there, right? He says also, Oh boy, where was it? Second, Enoch 49, one through 3 says, I swear to you, my children, but I swear not by an oath, neither by heaven nor by earth, nor by any other creatures which God has created. The Lord said there is no oath in me, nor injustice, but truth. If there is no truth in men, let them swear by the words. Yeah, yeah, or else, Nay, nay, so that's so. He's quoting Enoch on the sermon on the. Mount.
2:29:47 Yeah, and. He also. Quotes Enoch in when he's talking about Judas being the son of Perdition and he says it'd be better for him ever to have been born. That phrase is also in Enoch as well. That'll be better for them. Never those who depart from the truth once they had it. It'll be better for them now not to be born. Wow. Yeah, holy cow. So it's good enough. For the Savior, it's good enough. For the Savior First Enoch anyways. Fascinating and 1st Enoch prophecies of the Book of Mormon coming forth. OK, let's hear it. Enoch says, And now I know this mystery, that sinners will alter and pervert the words of righteousness in many ways, and will speak wicked words, and lie and practice great deceits, and write books concerning their words. But when they write down truthfully all my words in their languages, and do not change or minish ought from my words, but write them down all truthfully, all that I first testified concerning them.
2:30:47 Then I know another mystery, that books will be given to the righteous and the why and the wise to become A cause of joy and uprightness and much wisdom. And to them shall books be given, and they shall believe in them and rejoice over them. And then shall the righteous, who have learnt therefore, or learned therefrom all the paths of uprightness, be recompensed. That might not just be the Book of Mormon either. That could be the Restoration. Of the restoration of the scriptures, yeah. Holy cow, that's fascinating. And all of a sudden, Enoch starts taking on more importance. I think so, right?
2:31:27 If if several Book of Mormon prophets are are are quoting him or if Christ is quoting him, if Enoch is talking about latter day revelation and latter day scripture, that's huge. That's huge. And also continues to show the continuity of a plan that Joseph said was has been in place forever. Yeah, yeah, it's literally. Yeah, prophesying and foretelling a restoration, which, OK, if it didn't come through Joseph Smith, who's it going to come through, right? Nobody else has made that point. No the, the and. The fact that the Book of Mormon quotes it coming from Joseph Smith too. It's like 2. The two things are just testifying of each other. Yep. Absolutely. So we're nearing the end here, but some fun things from the Book of No, you're good.
2:32:17 In First Enoch chapter 10, Michael the Archangel is the one that binds the Watchers into hell. So that hearkens back to the imagery of Michael conquering the devil. Yep, Yeah, being in charge of that whole scenario, right. In Enoch 14 verse 22, you see the imagery of the Ancient of Days. So Enoch is seeing the same thing that Daniel's seeing in Enoch 20. This says that. Michael the Archangel is over the best of men, and he's over chaos. So. Also an interesting theme. First Enoch 25 gives a tree of life and temple imagery. This is interesting.
2:33:01 This says. And he said unto me. Enoch. Why does thou ask me regarding the fragrance of the tree? And why does that wish to learn the truth? Then I answered him, saying, I wish to know about everything, but especially about this tree. And he answered, saying, This is Raphael, I believe, talking to him. This high mountain which which thou has seen, whose summit is like the throne of God, is His throne, where the holy Great One, the Lord of Glory, the Eternal King, will sit. And when he shall come down to visit the earth with goodness and. And As for this fragrant tree, no mortal is permitted to touch it till the great Judgement, when he takes, when he shall take vengeance on all, and bring everything to its consummation forever. It shall then be given to the righteous and holy. Its fruit shall be food for the elect. It shall be.
2:33:50 Transplanted to the holy place, to the temple of the Lord, the eternal King. Then shall they rejoice with joy and be glad, and into the holy place shall they enter. And it's fragrant fragrance shall be in their bones, and they shall live long on the earth. So that is stark temple imagery. Yep, and it hearkens to the revelation of John at the end of the Testament where the Tree of Life is in the New Jerusalem, which its architecture is identical to the Holy of Holies of the Temple of the Perfect Cube. The, the temple in Solomon's Temple was, I don't want to say 10 cubits high, I don't know, maybe it was 20, but 1010 cubits cubed all the way around the perfect cube. The new Jerusalem John sees is 1500 miles cubed. But the Tree of Life is there.
2:34:46 And we know that the Tree of Life was a relic or something, the menorah, right, representing the, the Tree of life was a relic in the Holy of Holies. And so this is temple literature that Enoch is seeing. It's the restoration of the Temple. And when we realized also, we talked about how First Enoch was something that was held to by people like the Essenes, who are temple exiles, right, Priest exiles. They're looking forward to the restoration of the temple. Yes, in its true sense, in the last days, that's what they're seeing here, OK, and writing about. Who and they're seeing that in Enoch. Wow. And. That's what John is saying is going to happen too. The rest it's the restoration of the novel. Two or three witnesses, Yeah, absolutely. In first Enoch 32, the tree of knowledge of good and evil is called simply the Tree of Wisdom. So we dealt with the tree of life a second ago. But Enoch says how beautiful is the tree and how attractive is its look.
2:35:44 Then Raphael, the holy Angel, who was with me, answered and said, This is the tree of wisdom, of which thy father of old, and thy aged mother who were before the have eaten. And they learned wisdom and their eyes were opened and they knew that they were naked and were driven out of the garden. So I just like that treated wisdom. Yep. Absolutely, absolutely. I think that's much better. The. 1st. Enoch 46 The Ancient of Days. They call him the head of days in this, but he says, And I saw one who had a head of days, and his head was like wool, and with him was another being, whose countenance had the appearance of a man, and his face with full was full of graciousness, like one of the holy angels.
2:36:29 And I asked the Angel who went with me, and showed me all the hidden things concerning that Son of man, who he was, and whence he was, and why he went with the head of Days. And he answered and said unto me, This is the Son of man, who hath righteousness, with whom dwelleth righteousness, and who revealeth all the treasures of that which is hidden, because the Lord of Spirits has chosen him, and whose lot hath the pre eminence before the Lord of spirits and uprightness forever. And he goes on to talk about how the Son of Man was named in the presence of the Lord of spirits even before the sun and the constellations were created and before the stars of heaven were made. So the Son of Man was named before all of that. He sees stuff.
2:37:15 It's all Daniel 7 imagery. And in those days, I saw the head of days sit down on the throne of his glory in the books of the living were opened in front of him, and all of his host, which dwell in the heavens above, and his counsel were standing in front of him. And so this goes all way back to the books that we talked about at the very beginning of the podcast, the books of the records of Adam and Adam and Seth and Enoch, all writing, right? The things that we're going to be judged out of. And at that hour the Son of Man was named in the presence of the Lord of Spirits. And in those. Days, the Chosen One will sit on his throne, the Head of Days, and all the secrets of wisdom will flow out from the counsel of his mouth, For the Lord of Spirits hath appointed him and glorified him. That is all Daniel's stuff isn't. It in first Enoch's chapter 65.
2:38:07 It's the book of Noah. In the Book of Enoch, we see Noah crying out to Enoch. He was already ascended into heaven. He's gone. You know Noah is crying out to Enoch three times in prayer with his arms outstretched. Familiar. Yeah, familiar. And he says ruin is accomplished because the angels have revealed the mysteries. They have no place of repentance forever because they have shown them what was hidden and they are damned. But As for thee, my son, that's Enoch speaking to Noah. The Lord of Spirits knows that thou art pure and guiltless of this reproach concerning the secrets. So that insinuates that there's some temple stuff being revealed there. And then in response, Noah gets a book of secrets from Enoch, who he's given heavenly books from Enoch during this dialogue. Also, the author of the of the first Enoch ascribes that the watchers were the first people to show. They were the first to show people how to commit abortions. Oh.
2:39:15 You have that, I don't have the. Verse here, but I just have the footnote in my in my notes here. Really. I could try to look. For it if you. Yeah, yeah. OK. I'll pull it up. Because this one's near and dear. In my heart, I know it is. That's why I brought it up, and it is to me too. Yeah. So I'm talking about the different Princess of the 200 angels. And he says, And the 5th was Cass de Ha. This is he who showed the children of men all the wicked smitings of spirits and demons, and the smitings of the embryo in the womb that it that it may pass away, and the smitings of the soul, the bites of the serpent, and the smitings which befall through the noontide heat.
2:39:55 The son of the serpent named Taba ET So yeah, the smitings of the of the embryo in the womb. OK, so a couple things jump out to me here. First off, when when do we figure first Enoch was was written 300 BC, but between? The different fragments were written between 301 in the 1st century BC. That's awfully early to be understanding. A fertilized egg as an embryo, that's. True, that's. Awfully early, which means that that knowledge was definitely handed down. OK, that speaks to the veracity.
2:40:39 The other thing I'll say is that if they had an understanding of the embryo, all of a sudden you have a time frame in which you're working with on when it's, quote, acceptable. And I'm not seeing very much the wiggle room there, like moment of conception kind of stuff. The other thing I'll say is that when you start talking about abortion, you're now dealing with a much more ancient evil. Yeah, and, and, and for some reason, the more ancient it is, the darker it feels. That's fascinating stuff, I. Think so too.
2:41:20 And if that's one of the sins that caused God to be like flooded, Yep, flooded. Yeah, we're. And that means we're near for a burning in our world well. I I flooded again, so it's. Going to be burning this. Time. Look, there's a pattern set in the Old Testament. Every time the children of Israel start screwing around with ball and his pantheons, crap go sideways, right? You can bet destructions at the door. And God being no respecter of persons, I would expect the same same thing on our end. So. Around this time, too, you know that the angels are leaving heaven and they're making their oath to go, you know, to do what they're doing.
2:42:07 One of the angels is appointed, I guess, to go talk to Michael, and they asked him to reveal a hidden name associated with an oath. And it says that the power of the oath was in the hand of Michael, and through that oath brought forth creation and governed creation. And so actually I think I have the whole thing here. And this one told the holy Michael that he should show him the secret name, so that they might mention it in the oath, so that those who showed the sons of men everything that is secret trembled before that name and oath. And this is the power of that oath, for it is powerful and strong. And he placed this oath in charge. May God place this oath in the charge of the Holy Michael. And these are the secrets of this oath, and they are strong through this oath.
2:43:00 And heaven was suspended before the world was created, and forever through the oath, right. And through it the earth was founded upon the water. And from the hidden recesses of the mountains come beautiful waters. And from the creation of the world and forever and through that oath, the sea was created, and its foundation for the time of anger. He placed it for it, the sand, and it does not go beyond it. From the creation of the world and forever and through that oath, the deeps were made firm. And they stand and do not move from their place and the creation of the world, From the creation of the world and forever. And through that oath, the sun and the moon complete their course and do not transgress, transgress their command. From the creation of the world and forever. And through that oath, the stars complete their course. And he calls their names and they answer him from the creation of the world and forever. And so the angels are asking Michael to reveal certain things so they can do other certain things. So yeah, just interesting.
2:44:02 Can't wait to. Get the full back story. Yeah, and Michael the. Archangel's got the oath. That's got the power of creation right. Right, and the name. Associated Yeah, yeah. In Enoch 71, Enoch is traveling through the seven heavens, and Michael's the guide. And so Michael takes him into the, you know, into the highest right, You know, And so that's cool. Let's see first Enoch 99 also talking about the the the watchers revealing secrets. He says, woe unto them that pervert the words of uprightness and transgress the eternal law and transform them into what they are not. It's interesting to note here, too, that the the angels who went and made this oath to break their oaths that they had made allegedly did so seemingly.
2:45:01 Like they thought that the Lord would forgive them because, like, the Lord forgives, right? Yeah. You repent. That's part of the gospel. And so they ask Enoch. A lot of the dialogue is, you know, when after Enoch's traveling through the stars and the heavens and stuff like that, the Lord sends him to go talk to the watchers who are in hell, essentially. And they ask Enoch to intercede on their behalf. Like, can you ask the Lord to forgive us? We'll repent. You know, like it was premeditated. But yeah, there's, it just shows you there's some things you can't come back from that are, you know, taken very seriously. Yeah.
2:45:41 Yeah, there's yeah. And revealing. Those things, the holy things are. Kind of one. Of them? You mean like stuff? In the temple, yeah, stuff that. Used to have penalties but don't they don't longer have penalties, right? Yeah. Yeah. It was a big. Deal to the Lord is what I'm saying, yeah. Yeah, I mean. In Enoch 22nd Enoch, we're in second Enoch. I found this interesting. 22 verse 8 And the Lord said to Michael to go and take Enoch from out of his earthly garments, and anoint him with my sweet ointment, and put him in the garments of my glory. Second, Enoch 31 three and he was continually in paradise.
2:46:23 And the. Devil understood that I wanted to create another world because Adam was Lord on earth to rule and control it. And so they're talking about the Satan's interloping, right? And God is telling Enoch that Satan knew I was creating another world, and so he was trying to mess up the program. So the fact that there's other worlds and there's so much, yeah, that's huge in these. Last, in these last little bits, what we're getting is a ton of temple imagery. Yeah, that should leave little to the imagination of the initiated. Yes, very little of second Enoch 33 verse 5 he taught God talks to Enoch about the destruction of creation that we talked about and it's a right of the world. He says if I turn away my face then all things will be destroyed.
2:47:19 You know, which goes back to the Zohar where God doesn't. If God decides for some reason, I don't know if it was ever, you know, where I when I was reading it, it didn't elucidate what the reasons were. But if God does not go visit those worlds, they're destroyed. Yeah. Which? Goes back to Malachi's promise to me well. And and this, this is interesting too, in, in the sense of what we do as a people, right? Because my contention is, is that for a long while now, American, certainly the world has tried to throw God out. You know, whether he doesn't visit us of his own accord or we just say we don't want him here, The end, the end result is the same.
2:48:05 Is the same no matter what. Yeah. That's very true. This is kind of fun. Second, Enoch 3311 gives a funky name to Michael, But it's cool when you break it down. He says to Enoch, I will give to you, Enoch, my intercessor, the Arcus. Arcus strategy, Michael, for the handwriting of your father's, Adam, Seth, Enos, Kanan, Mahaliel, and Jared, your father. So he's saying he's going to give the writings of all these holy men into the custody of Michael, but he gives them this weird name, the Arcus strategy. As I broke that down, Arch is obviously chief primary or first, but the other words, you know, strategy is like a general or military leader. Well, that's just fascinating to me because, and this is like I said earlier, like I want to write a paper on the intersection of like Mormon fundamentalism, belief in Adam, God and like Second Temple Judaism and Michael being the intercessor of God.
2:49:06 Because, OK, what does Joshua say in the book or about Michael or about when they're going to go take Jericho and level it? He sees a man with a an armor and drawn sword. And this man says, take your shoes off where you're standing on the holy ground. And he worships him. And he says, who are you? And he says, I am captain of the Lord's host. And then Joshua says, the captain of the Lord's host is the Lord. Right, right, so and so again, drawing another parallel to Michael right back, captain of the Lord's host. Is the Lord. That's right. There. Yep. Absolutely wow. Let's see, this is cool.
2:49:49 Too, this is a this is a very Christ like teaching, but this is in second Enoch 45. Enoch tells his sons after he's after he's ascended to heaven and come back down and he's telling his sons, you know, I'm I'm going to be gone forever. You know, I'm going, I'm going to dwell up on high right. And he says that the Lord doesn't want sacrifices of bread, candles, or the flesh of beasts, but the sacrifice that he wants are the pure hearts of men. Interesting drawing parallels to that broken heart in contrary. Yeah, that Christ. Talks about in 3rd Nephi, right? Yeah. Back to the books. Imagery. Second Enoch 47. Take these heavenly books of your Father's handwriting and read them, for the books are many, and in them you will learn all of the Lord's works, all that has been from the creation, and all that will be till the end of time.
2:50:41 Thus I make known unto you My children, and distribute the books to your children into all your generations and amongst the nations who shall have the sense to fear God. Let them receive them, and may they come to love them more than any food or earthly sweets, and read them and apply themselves to them talking. About scripture I assume? Yep. And 2nd Enoch 52 there's a straight up beatitude type format given that also hearkens to the Sermon on the Mount. Blessed is he who keeps the foundations of his father's made from the beginning. Cursed is he who perverts the decrees of his forefathers. Now that's. Interesting because right now I'm listening to a book and I can't remember who the author is, but basically, and it was called In the language of Adam, I'm reading that. Too.
2:51:27 Yeah, and it. Basically makes the case that perhaps the Sermon on the Mount is, temple ordinances is. Temple. Ordinances now I'm not sure how much weight I'm willing to put into it yet. I'm a big fan but that OK I haven't. Got all the way through it yet? I haven't. But what's interesting is that when you go to get to the yay, yay, nay, nay part, that's very temple oriented. Yeah, yeah, absolutely. And so that's just one excerpt, but yeah, in that chapter and around it, it's always blessed are they who do this? Blessed are they? And Enoch is telling his children that these are turned down from heaven before he goes back up again and cursed are they who do this. And it's it's very much is the Beatitude type format. Yep. Absolutely in second. Enoch when, when Enoch ascends to heavens and is, you know, when that business is done and he's left, you know, Methuselah builds an altar or a temple at the site, right, which I thought was cool and.
2:52:28 Then. Methuselah dresses up as a king with beautiful garments and prays at the altar that they had built, and others of his sons and grandsons form a circle around him, and he raises his hands up to heaven, praying where have. I seen such things, so yeah. They built the temple and they're doing temple stuff at the place that eunuch ascended to heaven. And. This is where it gets into it's weird, but it's also kind of fun. Methuselah consecrates his grandson Nur, who is a brother of Noah, a younger brother, as the priest to to succeed him. And. Nur's wife was old and barren and she hasn't had any children. But then they get a promise from the Lord that she'll conceive a miraculous conception, and it's Melchizedek. Interesting.
2:53:18 Yeah. And so who knows whether this is, you know, does this predate Christ or is this like stuff like, OK. For example this. Is second Enoch right? So this is Slavonic Enoch. It was discovered in the 7th or 8th century or it's it was discovered in some catacombs or monastery, whatever. In in Eastern Christianity, Eastern Europe it dates to about 7th or 8th century. I don't know when it was discovered way later than that. And so they're like, is this just spurious or whatever? But they found that Christians, Coptic Christians in Alexandria, Egypt, had Greek fragments of it. Really. Yeah, so it. Goes back actually, at least to 1st century. AD second Enoch.
2:54:01 Does, but we don't know. Does it start out as a Christian text or does it start out as a Jewish text that Christians in Alexandria then adopted and then like? Do Jews then Co opted back? Right. You know, like. How much bleeding through? Is there? We don't know. Yeah. And. Then that, that that becomes problematic because you're like, OK, because, look, I don't think anyone just takes it and leaves it, right? If somebody's making notes and commentary and if it bleeds back through that, yeah. But Melchizedek being more of a miraculous conception to a priest that that it's a synergy of John the Baptist in Christ. Yep. Right there and.
2:54:43 So. But you get into weird problems. OK, now Melchizedek's born before the flood, and so how does he get preserved or whatever? And so Michael the Archangel actually goes and like translates him and brings him to heaven. And then after the flood, Michael brings Melchizedek back down. OK, in this story, right, the Lord sends Michael to retrieve Melchizedek, preserve him in the heavenly Eden, that he may be a priest of priests forever. And I will consecrate him and will appoint him over the people being made greatly holy. And I will establish another race, and Melchizedek shall be the chief of the priests in that family, just as Seth is to me in this family.
2:55:27 And so, yeah, Melchizedek was serving in the temple that Methuselah made until the flood and then gets translated and brought back down. Let's see, we kind of touched on that a little bit worried that in 3rd Enoch we alluded this bull, this quote, Rabbi Ishmael said. I asked Metatron and said to him, Why art thou called by the name of thy Creator by 70 names? Thou art greater than all the Princess, higher than all the angels, beloved, more than all the servants, honored, above all the mighty ones, in king, in kingship, greatness and glory. Why do they call you youth in the high heavens? And it says lad in other places too, right? He.
2:56:15 Answered and said to me because I am Enoch the son of Jared. So anyways, just Yep, that fits with Joseph Smith and the lad and I'm put a lad, Yeah. And 3rd Enoch Metatron takes the Torah out of one of the heavenly storehouses and gives it to Moses. I don't have a reference, but that isn't that one for sure is where that comes from. That is a super interesting that they do that that Rabbi. So if that's Rabbi Ishmael saying that that Metatron brought out the Torah, it is in a way circumventing the Moses story, but it's at a time where the Temple's already gone anyway, that's it's interesting to ruminate on Hugh Nibley.
2:57:00 Maybe we'll end with him. This is a quote from Investments, which I believe is in Temple and Cosmos. Enoch says I was clothed upon with glory, therefore I could stand in the presence of God. Otherwise he could not. It is the garments that gives confidence in the presence of God. One does not feel too exposed. That garment is the garment that awaits us above, the official garment of heaven, the garment of divinity. So as Enoch says, I was clothed upon with glory, and saw the Lord just as Moses saw him face to face, and the glory of God was upon Moses. Therefore Moses could endure his presence. In second Enoch discovered in 1892, we read the Lord, spake to me with his own mouth, take Enoch and remove his earthly garments, and anoint him with holy oil, and clothe him in his garments of glory.
2:57:51 And I looked at myself, and I looked like one of the glorious ones, being no different from him in appearance. He is. Qualified now in the manner of initiation, he can go back and join them because he has received a particular garment of glory. Wow. Anyways. That's all my notes dude. There you go. That's I've got no notes. You kidding me? I let everybody else do the hard work and then I just come on here and talk junk into a mic. I just wanted to. Hear you're closing marks. I got a closing question for you. Sure. What's the big take away for me, Nick? Well, I think. It's interesting to tie all that we've learned back to the beginning with the name.
2:58:33 It means initiated, inaugurated, dedicated, consecrated. And we see, I actually, you know, I'm seeing more temple stuff in it than I was even as I was compiling it and that. The. That whole theme is, is consistent throughout. And we see in ourselves, we're told in the Temple to consider ourselves as if we were Adam and Eve, right? But in a sense, we're also like Rabbi Ishmael the Enoch going through the same thing, right? Hopefully to our exaltation, right? Right, absolutely. I, I think for me, Enoch is expansive in its, well, it's huge, dude.
2:59:21 In, in, in its application and in its meaning, right. Because while certainly the temple stuff is amazing, you can't quote that enough when you start doing what you did and taking apart all of this and you start seeing that Enoch plays a far bigger role in the ancient prophets. Yeah, like Samuel. And abeda. Yes, Christ. Christ. And then you see the breath at which these books cover, right? I mean, as we just pointed out, everything from testifying of the Book of Mormon, temple stuff, dealing with abortion.
3:00:02 I mean, there there's it's expansive, a higher priesthood. Than the priesthood given to the children of Israel at the time of Moses, yes. It it's expansive, right? And Enoch is fascinating to me because. It. It's, it's pretty Jewish, right? I mean, that's the thing that's amazing is that it goes even before the Hebrew nation. It is before all of that. And I love learning about the Hebrews, right? I I feel like there's a lot there, but Enoch predates that and by doing so provides a lot of connections clear back to Adam, more so than we have in any other book.
3:00:52 And coupled with Joseph Smith, it just paints a picture that is hard to deny. It testifies of Joseph Smith's role, testifies of Christ's role, testifies of the temple. You go down the list and it can't be overstated. It's. I don't want to get too weird here, but it's. It's. Something that was pointed out in a way by a, you know, non Mormon scholar that I found profoundly interesting. I don't agree with all that he said, but he he said how it seems that even Joseph Smith felt maybe a kinship with Enoch himself, you know, being called as a young lad, young boy, he's shown heavenly things. He's being given books.
3:01:39 That of things. That have been recorded from the father's all the way down, as well as having his own experiences and he, at least in our circles, he has attained a certain form of unification, just like Enoch did. Absolutely. And and his, his mission is similar in a lot of ways, right? I mean, Joseph wasn't necessarily too concerned with churches as we think of them today as structures, right? He was in the building communities. And if you look at Enoch, that's what he did. And I, I don't think that Enoch's importance can be overstated it, it needs to be approached with some caution, right?
3:02:22 Like we talked about earlier, but there's too many fruits to just ignore it. And I think that's, that's really what, what we come down to. We do ourselves a disservice as Mormons when we want to just shelve it. Hugh Nibley was all about that, he said. Why aren't we paying attention to more of this Enoch stuff? You know, because we were promised that all these books would come forth and his whole thing was if we don't take advantage of it, we're going to have what we have taken away from us. Absolutely. Absolutely. And we see that. We see that with the. We're living in that. Absolutely. We're living in a point where the temple liturgy is being butchered. Right, you know the.
3:03:04 Temple liturgy restored by Joseph Smith and perpetuated by Brigham Young and formalized by Brigham Young as being absolutely butchered and aborted itself. Right. You know, we're seeing as Nephi or Alma. Alma says that to them that harden their hearts against the truth. The portion that was revealed to them will be taken away. Absolutely, dude. Good stuff as always. If anybody wants the link to the class, they can reach out to me, or they can find Michael on Facebook and reach out for that dude. What's next month? Noah. Nice.
3:03:45 Noah. And maybe the Tower of Babel. I don't know. I like it. Well, to see. I like it. I'm not that far yet. That's all right. That's all right. You seem to put these together with resounding speed and accuracy, so thank you. But anyway, awesome. All right, Well, dude, we'll see you next time. Bye everybody.
3:04:33 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox