Episode #133: The Forgotten Teachings Of Joseph Smith W/Drew Briney
Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.
Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products
So, when we talk about the revelations of Joseph Smith where does your mind go? If you’re anything like me, it goes to the Doctrine & Covenants. Now you’re not wrong in this but what if I said that there was a whole bunch more revelations and teachings from Joseph Smith that rarely ever get looked at because of the hours it would take to catalog and publish those teachings. Man, if only there was a guy who would want to endure that kind of pain to publish those things from Joseph……well luck for us there is. Drew Briney joins me again on the podcast as we talk about his new books the Forgotten Teachings and Insights of Joseph Smith. We talk about how the book came together, how he sourced all the material and how he went about putting the book together. We then go over a few pages of the book and along the way find ourselves in some pretty deep doctrinal discussions as we talk about the Forgotten Teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:07 So when we talk about the revelations of Joseph Smith, where does your mind go? Well, if you're anything like me, it goes directly to the Doctrine and Covenants. Now, you're not wrong in thinking this, but what if I said that there was a whole bunch more revelations and teachings from Joseph Smith that really get looked at? Because of the. Hours it would take to catalogue and publish those teachings. Man, if there was only a guy that we knew who would want to endure that kind of pain to publish these things from Joseph, Well, lucky. For us there is. Drew Brownie joins me again on the podcast as we talk about his new books, The Forgotten Teachings and Insights of Joseph Smith. We talk about how the book came together, how he sources material, and how he went about putting the book together.
0:48 We then go over a few pages of the book and along the way find ourselves in some pretty deep doctrinal discussions as we talk about the forgotten teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith. That and more on this episode of The Mormon Renegade. Podcast. So a few weeks back I told you. About a new online merch store I was putting. Together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running. Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page or click the link in this episode's show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups, and water bottles all with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU, But you should definitely go check that.
1:38 Out now, this is just the beginning. In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now, all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast. So head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade Supply button or click the link in this episode's show notes and get yours today. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. How's it going, Drew?
2:35 I'm mostly fabulous, thanks. How are you? Dude, do you ever get caught like just horrible cramps in your hands? I mean, I, I think you put out like a book a week. Yeah, well, I get more leg cramps than than hand cramps from sitting too long, I guess, but holy cow. Yeah, I've been working super long hours for a long time just trying to get things to where I can. I can write without it being the sidebar, you know? I can just write full time and survive. That would make me happy. I'm not there yet, but I I keep pretending I am so. Well, dude, you keep writing like this, it's a matter of time, right? Like it's not a matter of if you are prolific, brother. And it's awesome to see 'cause it's stuff that we really need out here in in the fundamentalist world. Yeah, I'm, I'm particularly excited about the the last volume.
3:30 It's it, it's what I fussed with margins and that sort of stuff. It's over 1000 pages and I went back to the same problem I had when I did Adam God teachings. I thought, nobody's going to read this, it's too long. So I split it in two volumes. I think that helps some. But I thought, you know, this is, this is a super important topic. This isn't one people can blow off and say I don't need to know this, so maybe it'll do better, but not anyway, remains to be seen. But super, super interesting stuff. Lots of gold. Lots and lots of gold. Nice. What was the what was the name of the book again? Drew, It's two books, right? Right.
4:11 So it's part of my Joseph Smith Doctrines and Insights series. But these two volumes are called The Forgotten Teachings that focuses on the journals and memoirs of Joseph Smith. Not his personal journals and memoirs, but people memoiring and journaling about him and his and specifically his teachings. Not just anecdotal, you know, he was nice to a child type stuff, but then, you know, in fact, he had something that he was teaching. I'm going to do another two volumes after this. That's going to take probably at least a year to get done. But that volume will be called the The Forgotten Writings. And that will be focusing on periodicals and, you know, articles that he wrote, teachings that were found in in quorum meetings and that sort of thing. Thank you.
5:03 Once once that's done, then I'll, I'll have other volumes. I'm comparing the original sources of the teachings of the Prophet Joe Smith with the published teachings of the Prophet Joe Smith, noting all the changes. I'm gonna be doing a book comparing the changes, but in the final volume, I will just have those noted what was changed along with these four volumes that I'm doing right now. I expect it'll be two to 3000 pages with annotation annotations and that will be the complete teachings of Joseph Smith. So that's that's what I'm working toward and what I'm hoping to do. Dude, that's that's quite an undertaking. So where are you taking most of your source material from? Oh, this particular one has just been all over the place. I've had a a few people say, aren't you just revamping the words of Joseph Smith and the answer is no. And aren't you just getting it all from the the papers of Joseph Smith?
6:00 And the answer to that is also no. I've been compiling a lot of this stuff literally for a couple decades. And I've got a bunch of journals and memoirs and that sort of stuff in, in, in the database format. And so I've been pulling from that. That said, I ended up using a, a whole bunch of material from the book Remembering Joseph I. As soon as I got that book, I loved it. I was, I was so impressed with just the, the quality of material in there. You know, I've done a lot of reading in the early journals and he's done a good job of kind of pulling out the, the good stuff.
6:40 That said, the digital version is about 900 pages. The published version is about 400 pages, maybe 5. And so there's tons of stuff digitally that you have to sort through that aren't in his normal places. And so since he had access to some of the original sources better than I did apparently, or thought I did at least, I, I used his as an original resource. But you know, after I combed through all that, I also had already compiled stuff from a book called They Knew the Prophet by Hiram Andress. And there's some challenges with that source. So whenever I could, I would prefer my own notes or remembering Joseph's notes.
7:23 And then a third major book is called Joseph the Seer, and the latter 2 books are a little bit more free in what they report. So I think it's Mark Mcconkey does remembering Joseph. But he openly acknowledges in there, you know, something he's not faith promoting or doesn't sound actually right. He's going to scream through it. And I, I really hate that approach. And honestly, I, I, I, I don't know what sources he had and what he screamed through, but I don't think there are probably tons of them that he, he cut short. There may be more likely just journals that he didn't even use at all.
8:10 So then I went back to my databases, did that. I did go through Words of Joseph Smith. However, Words of Joseph Smith includes stuff that was source material for teachings of Prophet Joseph Smith, which is what I don't want in my book. And for all the stuff that they report of the teachings of Joseph Smith, a lot of it has no teachings at all. It just says Joseph spoke today or Joseph taught parable talents today and that's it. And if that's the case, I'm not going to include that account 'cause there's no teaching and that's the whole point of this book. So I also did use source material from the Joseph Smith papers, although not tons.
8:53 I, I use that primarily. You know, if I find a source, I see if they've got it so I can check back with the original and if they've got it great. And if not, then you know they don't. So at any rate, so tons of different source materials is is the end result. The ones that were most helpful were remembering Joseph words of Joseph Smith and you know, hire managers says they need the profit probably come in 3rd. I will learn more heavily on Joseph Smith Papers project with the next two volumes because they do have a lot of that material online. But for journals and memoirs, a lot of that stuff is post Joseph. So that's not on their database at all. They're they're looking for stuff from Joseph to Joseph, contemporary to Joseph, not somebody who says, oh, I remember 10 years ago we went to Zions camp. You know, they're not going to have most of that type of material there, at at least not yet. I know they're working on it, but it's not. There's not much there yet.
9:55 Right. I'm curious, as you're sorting through all these original sources, how are you 'cause like I, I never wanna call I, I don't think people intentionally lie about this stuff. I think what happens is over time the, the memory degrades, right? How do you sort through that, right? I mean, how do you get to a point to where you can trust a journal entry from someone from 20 years back going, I remember the Prophet had said whatever, how do you get there? Right. Yeah, thank you. That's actually a really good question that I wasn't going to address 'cause I kind of forgot about it.
10:36 I do address that quite a bit in my introduction. If I was going to be doing a book where I was trying to do what was only reliable, I would have created a very different book. So to be completely fair and, and, and in all honesty, it would probably be only less than 10% smaller because I didn't make that judgment call. I didn't want to make that judgment call. I'm frankly tired of people making that judgment call for me. And, and like, you know, and I, I don't know Mark Mcconkey, I just love his book. So this, this is not personal at all, but I really don't like his approach saying, well, I am the gatekeeper as to what's doctrinal and what's not. I know because I don't know his uncle or dad or somebody's Bruce R Mcconkey and you know, his book says this or whatever. I, I don't care what their approach is. That doesn't make it doctrinal for me. It doesn't make it doctrinal for the world just because somebody said so.
11:44 You know, unless we have a common agreed upon key holder that everybody acknowledges, yes, Sir, you have the keys and we know that you've seen the Savior and he's laid his hands upon you and we all trust your word as coming from God. When you say thus saith the Lord, unless we have that person on earth that everybody can agree to how, how do we make those determinations? I I don't think we can really do that. And so instead of doing that, I just include everything. If it purports to be a teaching or a doctrine, then I put it there. And if it's clearly, if there's something clearly making it not a reliable source, then I will footnote that, you know, this contradicts the account, blah, blah, blah.
12:36 You know, we've got records, contemporary records that show this was the wrong date or what have you. I do a lot of footnotes until I did the audio book version and I deleted my 1400 footnotes and 1400 topical tags, I didn't know how much I was really delighting. I think I have about 25% of the book as references and stuff like that. So at any rate, so I do do a lot of notes and, and things to kind of help out with that. That said, there, there are LDS things there. There are things that support Joseph Smith the 3rd as being the successor of Joseph. Not a lot, but there's, there's some stuff there. There's stuff that's very sounds very mainstream and there's stuff that sounds really whacking out there. And I, I just, I let it sit.
13:24 I'm not the arbiter of truth. I'm just, I'm just presenting everything. When I have everything, then I, you know, maybe I can organize it a little bit better so you can determine that. That said, I did something I don't think anybody's ever done before, at least not Mormon circles. And I think that will help people to discern that on their own better. And that is this. I did a ridiculously complex index. So one of those things that most people might never notice because who reads the index? You know, you want to look at something once a year you do, but otherwise you forget it. But I literally spent, man, I, I can't remember. At one point I wrote it down.
14:07 It was like 40 to 60 hours just on the index and I did two things for it to make it really worthwhile. And and it's kind of hard to gauge even then because I hand wrote topical tags for every entry in the entire book. So I would read the entry and I would say, you know, if I was studying women in the priesthood, I would want this account. It doesn't really teach that. And I can make the rebuttal argument, and frankly, I think this is referring to something else, but if I was studying that topic, I would want to know. So I put women in priesthood is a topical tag at the top of that entry. So when I did my index, I created my index around all of those topical entries and added them to what was my normal exhaustive index that I've been curating for a couple dozen years now. So when I did the index, it would automatically pick up all those topical tags.
15:03 And therefore, you know, their accounts that you know, they're, they're, if you look up blood atonement or something in the back, it will take you to certain pages that you might read and say that's, that's not blood atonement. And I, I would say I agree. But if I was studying that topic, this specific clause and phrase in here really implicates the Denites as being involved in this thing. And that would be a blood atonement study issue. So I hand basically did the entire index. On top of that, I had the computer digitize, you know what it does? And I sorted out people from topics and it's still like, I don't know, 25 pages long or something. It's really, really long.
15:45 Then I did something else and I, I didn't do this exhaustively, but I think it's still helpful. I underlined entries in the in in the in the index, and I put an entry for all the references in the TPGS and WGS on that topic in the index. You can cross reference them. So let's say for example, you're like, I want to know where dedication to home shows up in teachings Prophet Joe Smith. It doesn't. Let's say it did right. Then there's an entry there that says go to TPGS and you can go follow it. I also did that for individual entries. So I spent an enormous amount of time trying to provide cross references for every topic I could so that somebody looking to say, is this reliable or not? That's where this all goes back to. Is this entry reliable or is it contradictory? Or do I put this on the shelf?
16:39 Where does this go? They've got a reasonable head start in figuring that out on their own and and without me shoving it down their throat. This is my belief. So you have to have it in my book. I just didn't want to make that call so I just put it all in there. You know, there's a kind of a technique, I guess you could say within surveying, whereas if you find a discrepancy, a sizable discrepancy, you will often times show everything that you found. And I remember the guy who trained me said, it's really hard for someone to call you a liar if you show them everything you found. And exactly. And I think that that that what you're describing there probably encapsulate encapulates that perfectly because again, you're not making the judgment call. You're just saying, you're just saying, hey, this is this is what I found.
17:33 This is what's here and take it or leave it. Exactly, And if I missed something, then second edition, it will be there. And as kind of evidence of my good faith on that, I, I found every reference I could have last charge and put it in volume one. That the one that we, you know, we did podcast about a year ago. And literally, you know, not long after I got kind of chewed out for by somebody for I said kind of 'cause it was not aggressive. But at any rate, you know, he said everybody always misses this quote. And I'm like, I specifically asked you to give me all the quotes you had if I missed anything.
18:15 But but so he posted it didn't, didn't, didn't give it to me directly, but I went and I I added that to this book. That quote is now in this one because it's one of the teachings that was of Joseph. And so if I miss it, I will, I will fix it in future editions for sure. And I expect I'll have to continue to do that. This type of stuff gets published year after year and you never know what's going to be missed, you know, And so five years from now, somebody's going to publish a journal by somebody. We don't even know who it is. And we're gonna find out that they were a friend of a friend of Joseph's and they're gonna have some really interesting material in there. And it won't be in my book.
18:55 So I'll continually have to update a source like this. There's just no getting around that. And, and I, I resolved myself to that early on, but I thought, you know, here we are how many decades into the restoration and we don't know where to find stuff that Joseph taught. I, I had an experience and it's kind of a Daydream, I guess. I, it certainly wasn't an open vision or anything like that, but it's kind of thinking about things. And I, and I just had this impression this, this, like I said, like a Daydream and I, I just envisioned the savior coming down the second coming and saying, did not my, my servant Joseph teach us? And so just like he does with Nephi, where is it written? And I thought if he did that, we don't have any answer as a group of people.
19:49 We could not point to a source where we said, oh, well, if Joseph taught it, we know where to find it. It's in this book. We don't have that. You know, if he said, did I not teach my servant Joseph the proper way to dedicate a house if it's got evil spirits in it? If we came and told you that, said, Dave, where do you find that before this book? You'd be like, I don't know. Where is it? And I thought about this on multiple issues. And, and you know, we, I think it's a pretty poor statement of Mormonism that here we are nearly 200 years from the martyrdom and we don't even have a comprehensive source of his teachings.
20:33 We've got comprehensive discourses of Brigham Young, but we don't have comprehensive discourses of Joseph. We just have, you know, the official TPGS, which frankly is missing a lot of material, tons, thousands of pages of material, and it's been changed and altered from the original. So why is this resource not there? And as soon as I got on that train of thought, I thought, all right, I, I know this, I, I, I want this book and I want to read it. And so now I've got to write it. Let me ask you this question. I got a couple of questions for you, then we'll dive into the book a little bit. Why is it you don't think we have nearly the sources on Joseph that we do on Brigham? Now obviously Brigham had a lot more time to talk and get get wrote down, so to speak, right?
21:25 But Joseph, we have surprisingly little in just as you were moving to. Why is that? Oh that's a really good question. I think there are about 3 or 4 answers. One is I don't think they had a good stenographer. Joseph's time, you know, Brigham's time, they've got a couple people that can do shorthand, they can do stenography and they're pretty talented at it. In Joseph's time, you know, we don't have anybody like that. We don't have anybody that's regularly keeping track of Joseph's talks. That's that's reason one. And what, what talks we do have are usually a compilation of two or four sources, you know, 2-3 or four sources of different journals that people have written.
22:11 And, you know, maybe somebody gave it a, a certain account and took really good notes and they amalgamated them. And that's the TP Jess. Rarely do we actually have a sermon word for word of what he spoke. It just pretty much doesn't exist. So that's the reason. Number one reason #2 is Joseph didn't give public discourses on a, on a good tight schedule. And you know it. There's there are several accounts that I found even in this book where people said, Joseph, we've got 20 people here. That's enough for a meeting. Teach us something, you know, or the brethren be out in the field. They'd be Joseph teach us. And so he'd just start teaching them while they're working. And, you know, the people would go home that night. They'd write down what he thought. But, you know, there might be 30 people who were listening and he was giving a talk to all these brethren, but it wasn't a formal talk.
23:01 And, and, you know, sometimes he would show up in town and, and they would just be Joseph. These people just showed up. They want to hear the gospel. He'd be like, all right. And so he'd just start preaching to them. Wasn't prepared. He didn't have any plan. Not tomorrow at 7:00, I'm going to go give a talk. He just ended up talking kind of spontaneously. And, you know, as far as I can tell from the record, that happened quite a lot. I, I was really surprised as I looked into what was happening or what was being recorded then that was pretty frequent, you know, so he, he didn't have somebody say, you know, come along with me and be my scribe. He just started giving a talk and, and off they went.
23:45 So I, I think that's another major reason. And the third reason is actually, I'll, I'll read a quote to answer it because I think it really addresses the issue very succinctly. Both of these are from Oliver B Huntington. They're both in the book and the one is kind of famous. So I'll I'll address that in a second. But he says I write this journal to comply with a requirement OFT repeated by the Prophet Joseph that every man should keep a journal. He'll say, well, that doesn't tell me a whole lot. This next entry does Joseph taught your journals will be sought after is history and scripture.
24:25 That's the way the New Testament came. What we have of it though, much of the matter was written by the apostles from their memory of what had been done because they were not prompt in keeping their journals. OK, I told you that was kind of a famous quote because it showed up in the Young Women's Journal over a four year period 8 times. It was quoted again and again and again. And I think this is fascinating and I, I wanna give both sides of the arguments there. You could say at one, at one point, OK, that's what the TPGS came from. So it's, we count that as scripture. I mean, not everybody does, but I, I think if we call it Scripture, not most everybody who's fundamentalist accepts it quote as scripture pretty close in as far as it was translated correctly or whatever. But but I, I think it extends far beyond this. The teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith, that's never been canonized.
25:18 It's not formally scripture, but Joseph, I don't think really cared that much about formalized canonization anyway. It was it was that was a formality. And I don't think that's what he meant. I think what he meant was they they need to know where doctrine is and they're going to find it in the journals. And moreover, he told people he taught people in private things he was unwilling to teach in public. I've got roughly 35 quotes, maybe 40I. I honestly don't know for sure. Quotes of of accounts of Joseph saying. I'm so frustrated. I want to teach the people more, but they're not ready, they're not listening, They're not able to get past their traditions.
26:04 They're stuck on their ideas of things. And they can't just receive truth. And he was super frustrated about it. We've got several accounts talking about is it like an iron cage? And then he felt squished. He was constricted. You know, it was, you know, the, the famous quote about the hemlock knot and the, the dodge for beetle and cornbread for dodge and watermelon for beetle and all these quotes over and over again. He's just lamenting and super frustrated. And so I believe what was going on. It said it off, repeated. Every man should keep a journal. And then he's told them you need to keep a journal because people are gonna search it for history, which happens all the time. No, no controversy there. But also for Scripture, because some people are looking at the church narrative and saying this isn't all the truth. This, this is not everything.
26:53 There's more to this and we want more. We're ready for more. And where do we find it? We find it in the journals and the Mars, that's where we find it. And, and some of it granted. Yeah, some of that is, you know, Joseph's preaching to people on the moon. And some of that is, you know, really heart warming, clear, strong doctrinal advice he's giving people going through difficult circumstances. So I think we get it all in, in, in these accounts. And I'm by no means saying it's exhaustive. I, I honestly think that I could keep searching daily for four or five more months and every day find something new is I'm searching the Internet for difficult or rare, hard to find doctrines and, you know, reading extra journals or dialogue or, you know, with all these, all these random articles that people write and they find this rare journal that came from their friend who happened to be on involved in the subject.
27:50 And nobody else has ever had access to it before. You know what I mean? There's just, there are all these rare sources that you can keep finding, but you have to read the entire database of Mormon literature to find them. And at some point I just had to stop and say, this is, this is pretty much all I'm gonna find in a reasonable amount of time. I spent literally 7 full time months preparing this book, working on it, preparing it. And you know, I'm, I'm sure I can do that again for the next two volumes. And it's, it's still, you're in a never ending vortex. You're just never going to get all of it. So the best you can do is just document everything that you've done, have it easily to easily research. So I can check and see if I've got that quote or if there's another version of the quote and then go from there.
28:36 Which, by the way, I'll I'll add something to this is something else I did to help me create the book, But that is a is a is a great benefit for any of the readers. And I will say to anybody who wants to buy the book, the version of the book is not as good as my personal version. But those who subscribe to my newsletter on sub stack, I give the full beefy, perfect, awesome, you know, in progress still, but a lot, lot more information on version and that's this. So I did a chart. I compared the source of the TPGS, which is usually church history in the chart and and then the TPGS and then the WBGS so that you can page for page look and compare where to find different discourses. And these are all organized by the date of the discourses that we know Joseph gave.
29:29 So most of my book is not trying to identify here's a formal discourse Joseph gave in public. I, I frankly don't care about that so much. That's important and I'm grateful for the resource. The WJS does that from the Nauvoo period and it's one of my favorite books and I admire Ehad Cook for making it, but that's not what I'm doing here. So, but that said, sometimes, Dang, it's like that sounds like, you know, the, the Elijah discourse he was given. I wonder if that's the date, you know, the, the, the, the, if this is another account of that and it's just not dated properly. So I, I, I do cross references and stuff with the index to make it so you can compare those.
30:12 But in the chart, when I found something that I absolutely know, this was this date, this is, you know, the, the discourse that they're referring to, Then I add that to the chart. So not only do you have the, the, the church history and the TPGS and the WGS all cross referenced, but now you have George Lob's account and Eliza R Snow's account and Allen Babbitt's account or whatever all also listed. So that you can then go to that account, read it in the WJSTPJS and think, now you can go to my book and you can find three other accounts that teach the same discourse. So they were not contemporaneous writings in all instances.
30:55 And so some of those would not have been included in the WHS anyway. But now you can find them there. And, you know, as I move along, I'll continue to improve upon and perfect that chart. It also has other dates and, and, you know, stuff with it that to make it more useful. But that's the basic gist of it. I do a free PDF version of that to anybody who subscribes to my newsletter. That's a free subscription. So it doesn't cost anything. It's just trying to, you know, bless people to get the information out there. And frankly, the chart was just too beefy for my book. I'd have to have it 8 1/2 by 11 to really pull, pull it off. And I thought about doing that. I prepared to do that, but for logistical reasons I didn't do that. And so anyway, so that that's there's that. Wow.
31:43 Dude, that's good stuff. I would imagine that every book present its own presents its own separate challenges in getting it wrote right. What was this one's big challenge? What was the big hurdle you had to overcome on this one? You know, I that's a good question too. There are two things. One, I think I discovered on this that writing 1000 pages of book is about 10 times harder than writing 2500 page books. Really it, I had to keep track of so much more information in my head. And frankly, I'm sure if I sat down with, if I, if I had a hard copy, which I never printed a hard copy to work from, which is not my normal modus operandi, but just what happened this time?
32:30 If I sat down with a hard copy and started cross referencing and using the index and, and doing all that sort of stuff, I bet you I would add a boatload of cross references in my topical tags and that sort of thing because there's just so much material to try and keep straight in my head. OK, what was the date where he talks about the, the, the three spirits of Elias, Elijah and Messiah? Was, was, was that March 10th? Was that April 7th? Dang it, I can't remember, right. Just little details like that bog you down. So you got to look it up. You got to have. That's why I made the chart. When was King Fall at Discourse? Was that April 7? April 10? Dang, you can't remember so I have to look it up. But then on top of that, you've got hundreds of topics that you're trying to keep track of so you can cross rest or reference all of them without using the index.
33:19 Because I haven't created it yet because I haven't finished the book. That gets complicated, man. There's a lot of stuff to keep track of. So that was #1 it was just, it's just big and it, it's, it's a lot of extra work just because of that. That surprised me. The, the number two thing was it was really difficult to know how to stop and when to stop. I felt like I could keep going. And, and I knew that when I first started it, like I wrote the introduction to it, part of it like four years ago or something, when I was just starting this project, knowing what my limitations would be and what I'd have to accept moving into it 'cause otherwise you, you get lost in, I don't know what to do with the next stage of it. So it's kind of like prepping for it, you know, So I write introductions to my books, prepping myself to know what are my limitations, What am I going to do? And I knew I'm never gonna have everything. There's no way I'm ever gonna get everything in the first volume, you know, even though it's 1000 pages. And it sounds like that just should have everything. I know it's not.
34:20 And so, but then, you know, I would be like, I'll give you an instance. I was, I was doing cross references for the story of the Angel with the drawn sword, right. The Angel comes to Joseph somewhere in 1834, talks to him, tells him he's gonna live for marriage, he's gonna be in trouble. Angel comes up, comes again like three times, I think. And then 1842 comes to him last time, says you better teach us or else. And there's actually some fascinating details that you put it all together that gets out of that. So I was looking that trying to make sure I had everything. And I discovered Brian Hales had done a paper on it. And it was like, Oh my gosh, you know, he's got to have some references I don't have, you know, because this is a really narrow niche and you're not going to publish a narrow niche like that unless you really push it. And so I looked up and sure enough, he had some some references I didn't have.
35:16 And I was like, sweet. So I added to them, right. But when do you stop? I thought there were, you know, maybe a handful of quotes about the Constitution hanging by a thread. No, I've got maybe 20, maybe even 30 quotes about that. But, you know, do I go online and search for more? And when, when do I quit? You know, when do I say, OK, if I ever find that, it'll be volume or second edition. That's, that's really hard for me. I, I tend to be OCDI want to double check everything. I want to triple check things. Some things I can't do that didn't don't have access, you know? And So what do you do? You know, you just cite this guy said so and quoted it in his book. And like, I'm just gonna trust it because it's in a family heirloom safe that they keep to the family. It's not in the library.
36:07 I can go check out. So I just hope it's right. You know, sometimes you have to make decisions and that one's relatively easy. But when do you stop looking for quotes about, you know, the word of wisdom was specifically referring to coffee? OK, I've got two that I know say that, but maybe there are five. Do I look up for articles on that issue? Do I do Reddit threads and then quadruple check their stuff because people just put crap up there? You know, that's that's where it gets complicated when when you're doing kind of more modern research and you know, you can find stuff, but then you can't find the source for it. But then you've got this quote that maybe is not reliable. Do you include it or not?
36:49 You know, those those were the harder the the harder questions for me to to deal with for this book. Gotcha. True. Dude, that was a Herculean undertaking that you that you did there. I mean, that's a lot of work. Yeah, I, I, I, I felt kind of overwhelmed for about four months. I thought I would have it done. I thought I would have it done a couple months before I actually finished it and was really upset at myself that I was slower. And I, yeah, it, it kind of messed up my finances because I, I was relying on some pre sales to make that happen or to, to, you know, fund what I was doing. And so being late, I was just pushing to try and get that done.
37:33 But then the pre sale didn't happen like it was planned and I ended up kind of biting the bullet a little bit. So yeah, it was, it was, it was a little bit tricky. I almost like it. And then you know. Oh, go ahead. I was gonna say, but then you know, people, people will, you know, you do posts and you say it's on sale here. It's on sale here. This is where you can get a copy. And they're like, you know, you're trying to get paid for writing works of God. Like, am I the only one that writes books that expects that people buy the book? I mean, where do these comments come from? You're like, if you work for seven months straight, would you like just assume that you know you're not gonna get paid anything for the labor? Weird.
38:18 Crazy. Don't listen to that. I've had to deal with don't, don't even listen to that. It's not even worth, it's not even worth listening to. Look, I'll be honest with you, typically, unless it's something very egregious, typically, dude, my MO is to post and ghost 'cause look, only one of two things are gonna happen and they're both bad. Either people are gonna tell you how great you are and nobody needs that ego bump, right, or you're gonna get wrapped up in arguing with an idiot in his mom's basement who doesn't have a time job. So it's it's just not worth it. So yeah, no, dude, don't, don't even read that stuff. It's not worth it at all.
39:01 But dude, I, I'm super excited to get my hands on this one. So as we talked about this this episode here, we talked about maybe just looking at a few of the the things that you think are kind of maybe highlights or or something like that. So what? What do you got behind there? OK, I, I probably prepared too much of that, but I'll, I'll share a couple of things to start off with. One, one I, I put in my introduction and I, and I particularly like this specific quote because it went to the question of what do I include in the book? And it also went to the, the very heart of who Joseph was.
39:45 So this is from the journal of Andrew Workman, who if you ask me who's that? I'd say, I don't know, it's just some guy, but this is what he says. I was at Joseph's house. He was there and several men were sitting on the fence. Joseph came out and spoke to us all pretty soon. And by the way, this was a pretty common thing. Some of the workers would say that they would just show up at Joseph's house and sit on the fence and hope he'd come out and teach him. And so, you know, every once in a while it happened. Pretty soon a man came up and said that poor brother who lived out some distance from town, it had his house burned down the night before. Nearly all the men said they felt sorry for the man. Joseph put his hand in his pocket, took $5 out and said, I feel sorry for this brother in the amount of $5.00. How much do you feel sorry?
40:35 So love that quote. Such a good, good quote, but it really goes to the heart of who Joseph was. And, you know, and I don't, I don't remember, I've got a footnote that says, but I think that's something like 135 or $235 in today's coin, something like that. So, you know, I mean, if that's what was in his pocket, it's, it's not like he was saying this is all I'm willing to do or, you know, I've calculated this carefully and thought about it. He just says, you know, look, it's, it's great to have thoughts and feelings, but who's gonna help him? What are we gonna do to help him? The, the only thing that's really gonna help us rather it's money. So get, get your money out of your pockets and quit gossiping and, you know, do something about it. So I really love that it's, you know, do you include that in, in the teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith? You know, it's not a discourse, it's not a formal talk. It's not a sermon, but it sure as heck is a teaching. And if I'm, if I'm looking at the situation, saying what can I learn from this?
41:39 You know, I, I think there's a profound lesson there that's easy to forget about And it's a good reminder. You know, sometimes we do that. Oh, for our brothers. So and so man, daughter's in the hospital again. That must be rough. So did you been loan some money or you just feel sorry for him? Anyway, so I love that quote. You had you had a thought there something. Yeah, it it's those, it's those personal accounts that I think are every bit as important as some of the stuff that Joseph actually quote preaches, right. Because. Yeah, because here we have, we have an opportunity to see the guy who's talking about the religion living the religion, right. And it's always a certain gravity that is added to the messenger's message when you know that he abides the same message.
42:34 Yeah, not to. Say that. Joseph was perfect, but but we get a rare glimpse into how the man actually conducted himself and that speaks as much as the things that he he he gave discourses on. Yeah, exactly. It's like the story, and that's also my book, of where Anthony is selling alcoholic beverages on Sunday and he gets fined and they bring Joseph in about it. And he says, well, I'm sorry, you broke the line. And then you're gonna, you're gonna have to accept the fine, which was pretty hefty. But then the next day he shows up to Anthony and gives him a really big horse worth quite a bit and says sell this horse. And, and you know, 'cause Anthony was trying to get his son out of slavery, he's trying to buy his freedom. So Joseph gives him his horse so he can get his son out of freedom and pay the fine for selling alcohol on Sunday. That says a lot about him, too.
43:32 There's a similar account where these these guys are coming in from out of town. Their brother joined the church. They're not in the church. And they need some money. They need, you know, they're they've traveled far and wide and now they need to get a job and get started. And they said, well, let's ask brother Joseph if he's got a job for us. And so they went to him. He said, can you, can you dig a ditch? And they said, yeah. He said, can you dig it straight? And they said, yeah, so he went out and he showed him what he wanted, got a line and chalk and all that sort of stuff to show him how he wanted it done. And then he came back at the end of the day and said, boys, you did just as good a job as I would have done. Let's get you paid. So he took him to the store and said, you know, pick out, pick out whatever ham you want and whatever, 25 bag of meal. And, you know, it's not fair.
44:19 And they said, absolutely. And one of the guys writing in his journal is saying it was very generous. It was more than I expected, you know, but then he said, but I can't hardly choose brother Joseph. So he says Joseph went, grabbed the biggest, nicest hams, one for each of them and gave it to him and then gave him their 2550 bag pound of flour, whatever it was that they earned and sent them on their way. And they, they just felt it was super gracious and well, that's kind of a consistent behavior we see with him. He also at one point that there was some brother working on the temple and that that they were behind paying some of the temple debt. And, you know, part of that's because somebody had been collecting temple monies who wasn't giving it to the temple committee. And I, I never have tracked that down. I didn't look to track it down, but I just know that was happening.
45:05 And Joseph, you know, said only give it to the 12. They're the trustworthy people and let's get this done. But somebody hadn't done that. And he said, if any of you are tired or hungry, come to me and I'll feed you and give you housing. But we're doing the best we can. If you're gonna complain about it at all, Basically beat you up. He threatened that on occasion to a number of people. So that's kind of a funny contrasting thing. But he didn't like people that were ungrateful. OK, so here's another one there. There. There's a series of these. I've got four of them. Well, no, I take it back. There's just three ones just kind of long that that I think are really interesting. I've I've had a lot of experiences talking to people who have had experiences with these things, but we don't talk about a church fundamentalist, maybe talk about it more mainstreamers.
45:58 But you know, we talk about doing a dedication for house. We just kind of say a prayer and it's good. That's it, that's all. But you know, it doesn't always work that smoothly. And, and so there are a couple quotes that talk about that that I wanted to address. One of them is not specifically on that topic, but is an issue of discernment. When I'm reading these things, it doesn't say Joseph said this, Joseph said that all the time. I've cut those down to try and make them shorter, but it's always Joseph speaking. When you have a dream that troubles you, you may know it is from evil spirits. Be careful of your health and do not do too much hard work. So that's just a little quick thing of Joseph saying, look, I'm trying to help you discern and to recognize when there are bad spirits around. And we sometimes think, Oh, well, it's got to be somebody getting thrown across the room or, you know, some nasty thing happening or whatever.
46:49 And he's saying, no, It's these simple things. He taught on an A number of occasions the more evil spirits around than there are Mormons. And and so we should expect our fair share. OK, so here's George Q Cannon. I have no doubt that many. Sorry, it's George Q Cannon. When I say the word, that's not who's talking. That's who's recording Joseph. I have no doubt that many of the brother and sisters have sensibly felt in various places and at various time, evil influences around them. Those he says sensibly felt. This is like a visceral thing, right? It's not just a discernment issue. Brother Joseph gave an explanation of this. There are places in the Mississippi Valley where the influence or the presence of invisible spirits are very perceptibly felt, he said.
47:35 Numbers had been slain there in war, and there were evil influences or spirits which affect the spirits of those who have tabernacles on earth, George Cacanan says. I myself have felt those influences in other places besides the continent of America. I felt them on battle grounds as the Sandwich Islands, which is Hawaii. This is Oliver B Huntington, he's the same one said the journals will be sought after for doctrine. On an occasion when I was a boy, sorry I heard Joseph say, speaking with regard to moving into old houses that other people had lived in, that had been inhabited by wicked people. They leave spirits in the house like unto themselves. And as the wicked are always opposed to God and the good, we ought to dispossess the spirits of wicked persons before we move into their haunts, or else they will try and kill the most innocent pure.
48:26 Now you can read that and say, oh, that's sounding Yamadyville Horror esque. And you know, this is getting a little bit silly, but I'm gonna read another account where he's actually saying that evil spirits have the power given to them to make us ill and have illness to death. One occasion I'll mention, and I didn't pull this quote. I wish I would have now that I thought about it. But one occasion he had, I think he adopted a boy or something, he had a lot of people stay in his house for short periods of time or sometimes for months. And there's a small child and it got sick. So he came in and gave it a blessing and immediately was healed. He went outside and the child was immediately sick again. And so they called Joseph in and he's like, he was fine just a minute ago. Goes back in, the kids got a fever, he's having a hard time, he's super sick, heals the child again and he goes back outside and third time comes back and says, OK, what's going on here? So he goes and prays and says, father, what's going on here? And he said, there's an evil spirit making this child sick. So then he rebukes the evil spirit, casts it out, and then he heals the child and the child stays healed. Interesting story.
49:37 OK when wicked. Oh, go ahead. Sorry about that. I thought you were done. Sorry. Go ahead, Jer. I was just gonna start another account that's kind of a similar thing. So when wicked men and women inhabit a house, invisible spirits congregate there also that are the same stamp as the living. Kindred spirits mingle together, and the invisible look on, laugh at, and enjoy the wicked sports of the living. And when the living or people and bodies move away, the others often stay in the house, having required a sort of right of possession. And they're the agents by which others that move in are afflicted, meaning they are given sicknesses and illnesses from those evil spirits. When the Saints moved to Nauvoo or Commerce, and it was as it was then called, it might be called a deserted town, or partly so at least is There were many empty houses, mostly built of logs, that had stood so long that the mud had fallen from the spaces between them. The Saints, just driven from Missouri, were glad to get such shelters.
50:34 These old houses could afford, and they were all soon filled, sometimes two and three families in one house. Some houses had no floors, some no doors. Soon the inmates became sick. Sickness increased, until Joseph began to be alarmed, and saw something very unusual in the new affliction. He looked into the matter as only a prophet and Seer could look. He saw the trouble of where it came from. Those houses had been dens of iniquity. He instituted means to empty them again by moving the people into tents and doubling up families in better houses. My father's family he took into his own house and tent. I once heard him say concerning houses that have been inhabited by wicked people, that before the Saints moved in they could be thoroughly. They should be thoroughly cleansed, then fumigated with brimstone and whitewash.
51:21 Afterwards there should be a season of prayer in the house, and it should be dedicated unto Lord for the use they designated it to be used for. Those old houses had been owned or occupied by wicked, unprincipled men, gamblers, outlaws, licentious robbers, etcetera, and those that were of the same stamp had met there for evil practices and criminal purposes that were carried on their orgies. While this was the past time of men and women and bodies, disembodied spirits of the same ilk stood around in the highest Glee. In a various way manifested one another their enjoyment of the performance of the violist of sins. So then he goes on and says, when the owners or occupants of the houses were dead, they enjoyed each other's society with their new pals in the spirit state. And when the righteous took possession of their old houses, all combined to kill the new inhabitants. And hence so much sickness.
52:12 For all evil spirits, whether in the body or out of the body, are opposed to this work. And this people and the spirits in the spirit world have means by which they can affect people on earth, and are as diligent there as here to do good or evil. So it goes on and talk about this. And they actually had one woman who could not get rid of the evil spirit. They tried all sorts of things. They couldn't do it. And finally Joseph got her convinced to do it. They had to knock down the roof because it was illegal to burn with the roof. And they burned the house down and made her a new house because they could not get them to leave, which I think is a really, really interesting commentary on how severe the problem they had with this.
52:55 And, and one final word, and this is just about evil spirits. I don't want to spend too much time on it, but it's one of those things that they taught quite a bit and they had to discern a bit and had to deal with quite a lot. Especially we read this in the early part of the Doctrine Covenants when Joseph went on a a visit and when he left, all sorts of evil spirits started manifesting. This again is Oliver B Huntington recording Joseph Smith talking about evil spirits. When I related to Brother Joseph the view I had of certain evil spirits in England, meaning of vision he'd had, he said that the closer we observe the celestial law, the more opposition we shall meet. OK, so the opposition he's talking about here is specifically, you know, evil spirits. That's what brought up the topic. But that again, is one of those things that sometimes, you know, I talked to brethren and they're like, man, I have tried so hard my whole life to be good.
53:48 I've, I've done this, I've done this, I've tried to teach my family, go to church, blah, blah, blah. And I just can't seem to get a break. And people are like, man, you must just be wicked, You know, then there's something bad you're doing 'cause you're not getting blessed to the Lord. And Oliver B Huntington's statement is the, the closer you get to God, the harder the, the opposing forces will be against you. And so interesting teaching. It's not in the TPS. You know that that last part you talked about has some pretty far reaching repercussions because sometimes I think as Mormons we get this idea like, OK, if we just live the gospel, if we do XY and Z, it should be smooth sailing 'cause I'm doing what the Lord wants, right? And so it becomes kind of a prosperity gospel, right? So that's that.
54:43 If we're not careful and we buy into that kind of narrative, what we'll see is we'll start to cast judgment upon our brethren. It's a sneaky here, right? We'll say we'll see. Look, Dave, Dave's over there. He's, you know, he's not really burning down, burning up the world. You know, he seems to be struggling a bit financially. He must, he must not have his house in order, right? He he must, he must be wicked and or deficient in one of these areas. Now, the truth is I'm deficient in a few areas. I'm well aware of that, but but that's not the point. The point is, is that's a tool by which, if you embrace a prosperity kind of gospel, that makes it real easy to start mislabeling people and quite frankly, judging people in ways that that aren't so Christ like.
55:35 Yes, yeah, exactly. I've I've got a a couple quotes that address that specifically as well as a follow up. All of these come from John Taylor who made I think 5 different records of this topic. I also mentioned this in my introduction as an example, but without going into the details, but it's really cool teachings here. The first one I'll read is the most poignant. I heard the Prophet Joseph say in speaking to the 12 on one occasion. You will have all kinds of trials to pass through and it is quite as necessary for you to be tried as it was for Abraham and other men of God. And said he, God will feel after you.
56:16 He will take hold of you and wrench your very heartstrings. And if you cannot stand it, you will not be fit for an inheritance in the celestial Kingdom of God. Now that we also find in the lectures of faith, and it's kind of a famous quotation, but he adds something here. Some people have wondered why so many of the 12 fall away or fell away. God tries people according to the position they occupy. So really strong statement there that you know, the more righteous we become, the more you'll be tried. Just like Oliver B Huntington said a minute ago. And here's an even more poignant statement. This is where there I said there are five of these. The Lord's command to Abraham to sacrifice his son Isaac in and of itself rendered at one of the most severe and painful trials that could be placed upon man.
57:05 So we talked about that. It's the ultimate sacrifice. It's called the Abrahamic sacrifice. It's, it's the, the, the, the standard bearer by which all of us are being judged, right? I mean, he says if you, if you want to blessings Abraham, he has to do the works of Abraham. So, you know, he kind of brings up the standard here in this discussion. But then he says this. But there was something else connected with this that was explained by the Prophet Joseph, who when Speaking of these things, said God was determined in these days to have a tried people as He had in former times, and that he would feel after their heartstrings and try them in every way possible for them to be tried. And if he could have invented anything that would have been more keen, more cute and more trying than that which he required of Abraham, he would have done it. But that no doubt, was one of the greatest trials that could have been inflicted on any human being. So I've got three more of those, and they all have little tiny nuances.
58:05 But you know that that last little bit is summarized another quote. I'll read it and kind of call that quits. If God had known any other way whereby he could have touched Abraham's feelings more acutely and more keenly, he would have done so. So you know that that tells us an awful lot. Yeah, it does. If you're in a position of authority, if you're in a position of leadership, if you're in a position of you're just a Dang good guy and people don't appreciate how well you really live the gospel because all Hell's falling around you and your family's falling apart because all hell is beating them apart and they can't appreciate it. Then they can stand and look at your house and say, well, maybe he's actually doing really well.
58:51 Not my spot to judge. Maybe God's just tearing him to pieces because he can take it and he's gonna earn, you know, the job award or whatever. You know, the modern job anyway does give you a different perspective and does offer some consolation because I, I think there are a lot of men out there and probably women too. But I, I know men have this propensity to say, you know, I, I just feel like I must be failing God in some way because just, everything falls apart all the time and I just can't seem to get ahead. And the more I, the harder I try, the more things fall apart around me. And gosh, I must be doing something wrong. And, and maybe that's true.
59:35 Only they know, right? But at some level, if you're one of those men, you're sitting down and you really look deep in your heart and you're really self introspecting and you say, you know, my heart's only been for the Zion and to do what's right. And if you can honestly truly say that, you've got a doctrine here that tells you why. And yeah, God's just wanting to try generation, so that's super cool. Can I share one other set? Yeah, Yep. OK, great. I have on my mission, and I'm gonna tell you the story because I, I, I spent the greater part of almost 30 years hunting down the coal. True.
1:00:18 Does this have to do with the the previous subject we were talking about? Ish. Yeah. And it's a, it's a follow up on it, but we could, we could, you could hold off for a second. Yeah, before we move on to that, let me say this. For so long, that was one of the things when I was in the LDS Church that really perplexed me. Right, Joseph, the the theology that Joseph reveals from the Lord is one in which there is a great struggle that continues right between light and dark. And my time in the LDS church, it felt more like a traditional and, and this isn't a slam on Protestantism, but it film felt more like a Protestant kind of church when it came to, to talking about that kind of of spiritual warfare, I guess, for lack of a better term. And and the answer always was, did Joseph not have anything to say about this?
1:01:15 I mean, are, if we're living right, are these things that just don't happen to us? And, you know, I, I have seen certain members who have struggled with something like that. And what ends up happening is, is, is the, the, the cloud and dispersion is usually put over those folks, right? Like, what'd you do to invite this in? What did you do to 'cause this? And here Joseph's saying, look, this is this is kind of the price of admission, right? If you're gonna, if you're gonna set your hand to something light, you can bet that you're going to struggle against something that's dark. And the fact that Joseph kind of illustrates us and then not just illustrates us, but shows us how to deal with it, that's pretty cool. And that's something that I feel like has been missing from Mormonism for a long time.
1:02:04 Yeah, Yeah, I think there are, there are certain, there's certain doctrines that haven't been emphasized for a very long time. And one of them is what I was about to talk about. And I think it's, it's because it, it empowers the individual too much and makes it difficult to have a strong hierarchy of leadership, which I don't think Joseph really intended to have other than in, in certain administrative ways. So, so I, I, and I think in a situation like that, you know, it's very easy, easy to blackball somebody and give them the scarlet letter and say, this brother's got so many trials, he must be wicked.
1:03:01 So take what he says with grain salt and boom, he has no credibility anymore. When really, you know, sometimes that might be the person that first of all, that that's the person that needs you to come show up at your door and, you know, bring a little bit of healthy food and say, hey brother, I know, you know, you've had a lot of challenges, just brought over some food and if you need it here, let me know. You know, that's, that's the guy who really needs that and he's not getting it 'cause he must be doing something wicked. So I think that's the deficit. It keeps us from doing some of those things that we, we ought to be doing. This other doctrine I think is really similar. And I learned it in the mission field and I, I read it with my own eyes.
1:03:49 So I know that I saw the quote somewhere, but I've never been able to find it since. And I've asked several quorums, you know, when I've gone to different branches and said, Hey, has anybody ever heard this quote? And I've met somebody that said, yes, that same thing. I've been looking for that quote for like 20 years and I haven't been able to find it. And, and I still never found it, but I kind of did. So here's what the quote said, if you will follow the first impressions that you have of the Spirit 9 times out of the 10. So, so the first impressions that you receive, you're like asking for impression 9 times out of 10. That will be the God's Spirit. And so that's a good clue and and frankly, that's that teaches some doctrine that I find all over the scriptures.
1:04:33 For instance, in the book of Moses, which is just Genesis, just just Smith translation. But in the book of Moses, we read that Adam and Eve taught their children, but then it says what did Lucifer say? He didn't teach them. Contrarily, he said, believe it not his job is take away truth. We see this in the forefront of the, of the Dachshund covenant several times shows up in Alma twelve, 9:00 to 12:00 very, very clearly that the Lucifer's job is to take away like knowledge from us. And if, if he gets us to reject one truth, it can take a second truth. So it kind of makes sense that the first thing that you're going to get for an oppression is the Holy Ghost. And the second thing you're going to get is the adversary saying, no, don't do that. So anyway, I, I, I learned this, I had been taught this, I read this and I really wanted to have a perfect track record And I had a companion who was amenable.
1:05:27 So he made agreement that we would follow any prompting that we received, no matter what it was. If it was stupid, it didn't matter. We would support each other, right? Had some amazing experiences doing this. Had a guy one time it was, you know, after hours and he said, elder, I've got him prompting you to go back and like, but elder, it's past curfew. We're gonna not make curfew if we go back up there. He said, feel like I gotta do it. You promised. All right, We promised. Went up. The guy was gonna commit suicide. Going back stopped it. So we had lots of different cool experiences that happened from this specific pact that we made with each other. But you know, after about a month, and our agreement was we'd do it for a month in review. After about a month of this, we became so much more attuned to the spirit that we'd be like, OK, that that was the one out of 10.
1:06:23 I'm not gonna do that. One month is over. I recognize now that's the adversary trying to get me to do something stupid made me look bad. This however, this prompting, I felt clarity of thought even though it was quiet. I recognize that's the spirit. And so we, we developed a lot in discernment, had a lot of really neat experiences because of that. But 20 years later, 30 years later, still can't find that quote. But I did find these and all of them come from John Taylor and they were all counsel given to John Taylor from Joseph Smith. And, and they kind of they, they teach the same principle even though it doesn't have the details. So here it is now, Brother Taylor, listen to the dictates of that spirit and cultivate it and it will become a spirit of revelation.
1:07:09 Another account I will remember a mark Josephs made to me upwards of 40 years ago, said he. Elder Taylor, you've been baptized, you've had hands laid upon your head for the reception, the Holy Ghost. You've been ordained to the holy priesthood. Now, if you will continue to follow the leadings of that spirit, it will always lead you, right? Sometimes it might be contrary to your judgment. Never mind that. Follow its dictates. And if you be true to its whisperings, it will in time become in you a principle of revelation so that you will know all things. OK, so lovely set of teachings there. I mean, that's Alma 12/9 to 12. It's Miro night 10, four to five all mixed up together.
1:07:51 Basically though, he's just saying you can learn to have more revelation by following the Spirit and recognizing it. Just like he says the TPGS is a 191 or 149. I can never get those two straight. But any rate, he says, you know, by noticing the first instances of pure intelligence coming into your head, you'll grow in the principle revelation. Similar type of teaching here, but frankly this is more helpful, I think in giving direction. Then here's another cap. Joseph Smith upwards of 40 years ago said to me, Brother Taylor, you've received the Holy Ghost, now follow the influence of that Spirit and it will lead you into all truth until by and by it will become in you a principle of revelation.
1:08:35 Then he told me, never rise in the morning without banging before the Lord and dedicating myself during that day. Another interesting detail that you don't really find all that all that often. Dedicating yourself. Yeah, it says before you when you get up in the morning, dedicate yourself to the Lord and say I'll do what you want me to do. How many of us say, OK, this is my plan, this is my goal is what I'm going to get up and do. I think motivated people can be like that, Entrepreneurs and business owners and people are just self motivated. You're like, all right, you know, I've got my To Do List, whatever that is. You know, you're going to hit on it. And in, in variations of that, you know, I, I've, I, I learned to have principles.
1:09:19 A really cool story actually, about a railroad owner. But he said, I, I only make A to do list of the three most important things to get done that day. And I won't do anything else. I won't take any distractions unless those three things are done. And he said it was worth millions learning that lessons. Huge lesson. I, I do that. I've got my To Do List and then I mark the top three and I try not do anything till those are done and I get a lot more done. Super, super productive. So so, you know, a lot of us are like that, but that's different, isn't it, than saying, OK, Lord, here's my To Do List. Here's my top three things. But what do you want me to do? I want you to call sister so and so make sure she's doing all right.
1:09:59 Well, I don't have time for that. I want you to go visit brother or so and so or give him a call like he's having a hard time and you'll, you'll never know unless you give him a call. Well, that's not on my list, you know, and, and now that it's on my list, is that in my top three? Can I wait till after dinner? When do I do, you know, you've got a totally different approach to your day. Now You have to really think through and, and, and ask, start asking some other questions. OK, that conflicts with my top three. So where do you want me to fit that in? How do I do that? Where do you want me to go? That attitude's very, very different than, you know, how we tend to do things. And you know, on the other hand, if you've got somebody who's maybe not so self motivated to get up in the morning, don't know what they're gonna do, that's a good thing to get them some direction too.
1:10:47 But it's not something we preach a lot. You know, it's obvious. It's you can just hear it and say that's obviously true principle and Joseph taught it and I believe that's true. So fine. But implementing it totally different thing. Absolutely, dude. And, and again, these are the things that we don't get to hear about a lot, right? It ranges from the deeply spiritual to the this is how you get your day going, right? You, you, you get kind of, you know, a list together and then dedicate it before the Lord, dedicate yourself before the Lord and get his direction for your day. Yeah. And, you know, I mean, you could gather that teaching from follow the Spirit or, you know, pray in the morning and at night or whatever, But it is more explicit.
1:11:37 And I, I think it's, it's helpful sometimes to hear things in different, in different ways. So on the, on a deeper end of things, I, I found some quotes that I thought were particularly interesting, which also were John Taylor. It wasn't intended to be a John Taylor fest. Just some of the more interesting things happen to have his name tagged on him. But, you know, I, I read some stories and, and I've had some, some people talking to me about divorce issues and who's sealed to whom and, you know, they got a release, you know, all these types of things. And though there are usually some hard questions there. And I, I ran into some teachings from the early brethren that consistently had certain verbiage.
1:12:23 And I thought, where does that come from? Where, where does that word come from? You know? And so I'm gonna give you a couple examples. On the one hand, we have anecdotal information, which by the way, I believe, but we have anecdotal information in this anecdotal story where it showed up. And I think in the Emma movie where Joseph's outside and he's beating a carpet with a carpet with a little looks like a giant spatula spade or something. And the brother comes up to him and says, Brother Joseph, what are you doing this woman's work for? You know, my wife, my wife works twice as hard as your wife. And you should be doing more important things.
1:13:05 And you remember what he says. Something to the effect of any man that that can't make his wife happy here shouldn't expect to have one in the hereafter or something like that, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah, he he says. I know something you don't know. And that's in the next life, the women get to choose if they stay with their husband or not. And, and in a different place. This is exactly what you're saying. So there's one principle, but then there's this other principle that shows up. And sometimes, you know, we get opposing principles and you have to say, OK, so how does this mesh together? And this was one of those issues that I, I can't find in conflicting accounts. So I was reading, I think it was the Saint George Temple minutes.
1:13:47 And they're saying, OK, this woman left and she married, you know, she left her husband. Her husband's good man didn't break his covenants. You know, she couldn't get a release from him for doing anything bad. But nevertheless, she moved and she got married to this guy and convinced the sealer to sealer to this guy, you know, some in some other city. And it says now she's claiming the children are sealed to her and wanting to have them sealed. And we're reviewing the records, seeing the problem. What do we do? And the response that they got back and I think it was Wolfer Wood, you don't quote me on the details 'cause it's been a long time since I've read this, but this is where the principles started arising in my studies.
1:14:29 He says if the brethren, if the brother has not broken his covenants, he has claimed upon her in the next life, and the children ceiling stays with the husband. So everybody remembers Joshua Erickson. I've had him on the podcast quite a few times. And I think. Highly of both him and his family. They're some of the best people I know now. Every year they host an event where speakers give talks on a variety of gospel topics. This year, the 2024 Restoration Tour Conference will be happening on June 14th and 15th. On the schedule. This year there are 14 speakers on a variety of topics. Now you can attend either in person or virtually, and while it's always free to attend, I couldn't strongly recommend you enough to go ahead and donate because things like this aren't easy to put on, nor are they cheap.
1:15:17 So head on over to restorationtourconference.org or hit the link in this episode show notes and get all the details and Sign up today. Want more from the Mormon Renegade podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the fundamental news program for free. Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button. And for $5.00 a month, you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly Life stream show with the host, Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes.
1:15:57 Today in the next life in the children ceiling stays with the husband. And so I thought, OK, that's interesting. That's, you know, one case and but he labels it, talks about it as a principle. So I'm, I'm noting this a little bit extra. I see a couple instances like that where he says a righteous man will have claim upon his wife regardless of what she does, chooses in this life. So I'm like, OK, there's that principle again. Then I found this, this third story and it was, it's kind of a, a, it's one of those stories. You're like, man, could you have just spent, spent five more minutes in your journal and got this down better because I have all these questions about what happened here.
1:16:43 So this guy suffered a, a divorce. I say suffered because it sounds like he didn't want it. He, he had a divorce. He wasn't happy about it. And he tried at all costs to avoid his, his ex-wife to just they tried not to see each other, not to run into each other. So he's downtown, walking around Temple Square, walks around the corner and his ex-wife is standing there, her walking there with her new boyfriend husband. And she starts talking and guessing from experience that sometimes exes aren't as nice as they could be and sometimes they're sweet as pie, but sometimes not. She starts poking him, prodding him and saying stuff. And that's where we're missing some of the story. And he turns to her and he says, you can play pretend that you're married to him all you want, but in the eternities I have claim over you and you're my wife.
1:17:34 And then he walked away and I said, there's no word again. It's got to claim upon her. Where's that coming from? Who taught that? Where's that coming from? And you know, and you know, if, if she gets to choose in the next life who her husband is, then why does he have claim upon her? Is that choosing only if he's not righteous? Is that you know? Does she have to give it a try? Unless, you know, for a certain amount of time if he is righteous before she can choose? But we don't know. None of those teachings are really clear. But I found this quote by or this talk by John Taylor that frankly, I should have found before. Who knows why I missed it?
1:18:14 Probably 'cause I haven't read the entire Journal of Discourses yet, which I I gotta get on task, get that done sooner or later. Since I'm independently wealthy, I won't do that. So this is what John Taylor says. What are the covenants we enter into it? Why is it that Joseph said that unless this principle and Speaking of plural marriage was entered into, this Kingdom could not proceed? We ought to know the whys and wherefores in relation to these matters and understand something about the principle enunciated. These are simply words. We wish to know their signification. So I love that. I mean, where is that attitude in modern Mormonism? Yeah, we know the words. We know what was said, but what do they really mean? Let's dig deeper.
1:18:56 I love that. So here he says, where is there in the world of people that make any pretension to have a claim upon their wives and eternity? There's the word, where is the priest in all Christendom that teaches anything of this kind? You cannot find him. Marriage is solemnized until death do them part. And when death comes to either party, there's an end to the whole matter. And what comes after death is in the dark to them. It was so with us up to the time of the giving of that revelation, meaning DNC 132. We had no claim upon one life in eternity. It was necessary that one grand truth should be unlocked, which is that men and women are destined to live together and have a claim upon each other in eternity. OK, when she elaborated on that, he doesn't, but he does clarify some issues, so keep going.
1:19:47 Previous to this revelation, DC132, who in all the world had any claim upon their wives in the eternal world? Or what wife had a claim upon her husband? Whoever taught them any such principle? Nobody. And I'll add there as an interesting aside, some of the Saints were really ticked off about DNC 132, not because it was teaching plurality of wives, but because they said they had to be married to get in heaven, right? And that really ticked off a lot of people. They're like, I don't want to be married and I want to go to heaven anyways. And nobody teaches this doctrine that you have to be married. We're angels strumming on a harp. We're not going to have kids. What is this teaching that you have to be married and to be exalted and then you have to continue to have children for eternity?
1:20:32 This sounds like work. We don't like it. I wish we had more accounts of what how that went down. But we do have some accounts saying people were upset about it. So this is, you know, a a thing in John John Taylor's time that he's saying nobody teaches that and all you Protestants are used to that. He's then he goes on. Our position was just as Joseph said, If we could not receive the gospel, which is an everlasting gospel, if we cannot receive the dictum of a priesthood that administers in time and eternity, if we could not receive a principle that would save us in the eternal world and our wives and children with us, we were not fit to hold that Kingdom and could not hold it, for it would be taken from us and given to others. Then what did this principle open to our view? So this is his concluding thought, which I wish was more explicit, but it is what it is, that our wives would reign with us in the eternal kingdoms of God and that they should be sealed to us not only for time and for all eternity. This unfolded to us the eternal fitness and relationship of things as they exist on the earth of man to man, meaning the law of adoption and of husband to wife. It unfolds, and this is the key, I think, of how he's, how he expresses it here.
1:21:46 It unfolds the relationship they should occupy in time to each other and the relationship that will continue to exist in eternity. Hence, it is emphatically a religious subject that is so deep, sacred and profound, so extensive and far reaching that it is one of the greatest principles ever revealed to men. OK, so there we have, you know, John Taylor saying righteous spouses have claimed upon each other in eternity through the sealing covenant. So if you have a a wayward spouse and you've been sealed for eternity, you have claim upon them in the eternal, in the eternal worlds. Now will you choose them?
1:22:30 Maybe not. Maybe they broke the covenant too far. They they're not even qualified, but you have a claim upon them to say we have an eternal ceiling. We have unfinished business because you took off and, you know, wanted more money and I didn't make it, whatever it was. That's the most common reason that we have failed marriages as men get older. So here we have a teaching that that tempers the other one. Yes, woman gets to choosing the eternities if she stays with her husband, but he has a claim on her as well. That's the tempered side. Does that last for 10 years, 100 years? Thousand years in eternity is a blink of an eye. So how long does that last?
1:23:14 We know nothing when that's when, when, when is that claim Nolan Boyd and she could move on and go somewhere else. We don't know. We don't have that explicitly laid out before us. What we have is 2 teachings, one of which is very anecdotal. We, I, I haven't been able to track down a really good journal entry or something that I know this is word for word what was written and taught. We don't have that for that quote that the women can choose right, But we do have John Taylor teaching this and we do have some temple minute teachings and recommendations for the brethren saying that the men if the righteous have claimed upon their wives and that the sealing of the children follows the righteous parent. Well, that's really hard in today's society because sometimes and I don't know how prevalent this is in the church. I've just read people complaining about it and Facebook, but, and well, and I've met a couple people, but OK, so the church just gave a release to my wife. It wasn't warranted and I, I opposed it, but they did it anyways.
1:24:20 And she now got resealed to somebody in the temple and goes to church every week and he goes to church every week. Seems like a good guy. Where's the, where's the ceiling? You know, is does he have claim on her or not? Does she have claim on him? They're both purportedly righteous, you know, but nobody, nobody looks at that. They just say, well, the person in authority makes the decision. That's it. Well, is is that true principle is the true principle depend on the righteousness of the individual and the judge of that may or may not be who's judging in the eternal world that gets sorted out. Those are questions that these teachings leave to us to to review and consider. And of course, it's an easy answer.
1:25:01 If you remember the church and you believe that, you know, Nelson's the prophet, you say, well, he's got the right he can make decision. You know, this supersedes these teachings of Joseph. You know, you get outside of the mainstream church, it gets a little bit more complicated. Well, yes, brother, so and so I accept you as a leader of this Mormon fundamentalist group, but I'm not sure that you can make this decision because you're related to my wife and you don't have a dust at the Lord and you know, this sort of stuff. Yeah. And and also you were saying you couldn't find the spot where it exactly says that, that a woman has claim on her husband as well. But Taylor alludes to it there, right.
1:25:42 He says they have claim on each other. If I oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, no. So let me, let me correct that. I didn't say that that she didn't have claim on him. What I was saying was that Joseph says that she can choose somebody else in the next life if she's not satisfied. That's where we don't have it kneeled down. But we do have kneeled down with Taylor, yes. OK. All right. That makes sense. No, and and that's fascinating. And you're right, that leaves you wanting more like, dude, could you spend 10 more minutes, just 10 more minutes before bed? I I'd have bought the extra candle so you could have rode a little. Longer. Yep exactly. There's so many places that I read the old accounts and journals. I'm like, no, no, that sounds really exciting and almost teaches me what I've been looking for for 10 years, but it doesn't say it but. But.
1:26:30 You know they're. There might be wisdom in that too, though, Drew, right, Because even though as, as people and, and especially Mormons, right because of the way we were brought up, if you spent time in the LDS Church, we kind of like policy, right? Policy makes it easy, right? Well, this is the rule. This is what we go by it. It's I, I've often said policy and you'll like this 'cause you're an attorney. Policy within it, within the church is a lot like starry decisis within, within the legal field, right? It provides a nice framework where you can get, for the most part, a lot of continuity and you can kind of expect what's coming.
1:27:16 However, history doesn't do that for us. And, and maybe one of the reasons this isn't so flushed out is because we're taking something that's really kind of personal, right? And, and not personal as in we don't talk about it, but personal as in it's gonna vary case to case, right? And just like, you know, no two families and no two couples are going to be exactly the same. Those are probably items best left with the Lord, I would think. And then we. Have to muddle out, muddle it out ourselves down here while while in mortality. Yeah, yeah.
1:27:59 In fact, interestingly, it appears that Old Testament laws and ancient Near Eastern laws that they were based upon were treated more like case law in modern jurisprudence. And case law is, it's like, OK, here's the specific ruling that we might have, but or you can say in matters like this, it's good to consider all these factors and balance them out based upon the circumstances. That tends to be more what we see of Old Testament law. And in fact, that's the whole basis between an eye for an eye. It's not, you know, go poke each other's eye out in this silliness that people talk about. The idea is make it just, but not excessive. Right.
1:28:42 Somebody, somebody beats you up, don't cut off their fingers. You know, other ancient near Eastern places would do that. It's like that's excessive. It's it's more than compensatory. You know, just do something that's relatively just where the parties feel satisfied at the result. And, you know, they looked at a lot of things like that and, and that attitude recognizes something about celestial law, or at least mortal, mortal law that we don't often talk about. And that is there, there are limitations to them and they conflict with one another. You know, you know, in, in Alma, I think it's, gosh, I wanna say it's 34, but it could be 4042. It's talking about justice and mercy and in, in terms of the atonement and saying, you know, both have to be satisfied. But there's a balancing act there. There's at some point mercy comes from the Savior and justice comes because he paid the price. That's also the mercy.
1:29:48 But we can't always get this perfect balance. So we'd have to kind of look at case by case and say, OK, what's justice? What's mercy? What's the best scenario here? And that's not an easy, quick policy decision. It's it's not like that. Absolutely, dude. It's fascinating stuff. What else you got in there? All right, well, I, I, I, I tried to start off with kind of some basic easy stuff and then have tougher stuff at the end. So I'm going to throw out something controversial. So when I was, when I was part of the AUBI heard a lot that Joseph Smith was the Holy Ghost.
1:30:31 Now I've found compilations of this and they're usually 5 to 8 quotes, sometimes 10. I've got at least 20 in the book, but I also have a few of them that have a surprising alliance that was formed and and that alliance was between Orson Pratt and Brigham Young, shockingly. Dude, those guys never got along. I know. So that leads a lot of credence to this, right. So it's, it was formal issue doctrine when I was part of AUB that Joseph Smith was in fact the Holy Ghost at some point, you know, that he fulfilled that office. And a lot of people believe that. So in fact, I, I found some evidence of this in the Reed Smoot hearings and, you know, wrote up some of those that weren't actually attributed to Joseph. So it's not in the book, but it's, I think it's in balance more than pulling me footnotes 680 or something. I don't know.
1:31:29 It's somewhere buried, but at any rate, you know, Orson Hyde was teaching this. A bunch of people were teaching this there, there. I've got quotes from newspaper articles saying Joseph's wives think this Holy Ghost is a bedfellow. And, you know, quotes from all sorts of people suggesting Joseph was a Holy Ghost because he said you don't know who I am. And he said the Holy Ghost is now I'm looking for or is going to take upon him a Tabernacle so that he can progress just as the sun progressed. So there are all these quotes that suggest Joseph Smith is the Holy Ghost. He also, and you can add these to those other quotes that says I have to die because the without the testator dying, there is no sealing of my testimony. So it says, oh, the Holy Ghost is a testator. Joseph Smith is martyr's testator. It must be the same person.
1:32:24 So what I was surprised to learn from this book, however, was that this wasn't just something that came up in Mormon fundamentalism. And I say that a little bit tongue in cheek, but this was something that people believed at Joseph's times quite a lot. And so here's a quote by Brigham Young. Wait, wait. Wait, wait, wait, wait, wait. I want, I want to make sure we get this right. During his lifetime, people had thought this. Oh, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. During Joseph's lifetime to like, he's making these statements and people are like, oh, he's he's trying to say he's the Holy Ghost. And so, so here's the quote that Brigham Young says that that solidifies that Joseph told you. You do not know who he was. Some thought he was the Holy Ghost and actually taught it. But I will tell you what he meant. He had reference to the blood.
1:33:15 Now I found one of these quotes while I was in AUB and I read it in the priesthood session once and and felt like I got some stink eye for for it because Brigham Young's basically saying Joseph isn't the Holy Ghost. That's not what he meant. And so it's kind of going against, I believe there. But I'm just like, this is what Brigham said. I you know, I'm not saying what's true or not. That's just what he taught. So but he goes on the he expands upon this and so does Oliver B Huntington. And, and anyway, so I'll just read a couple more. Brigham says I'm entitled to the keys of the priesthood according to lineage, descent, and blood. So is Brother Hebrew, C Kimball's and many other. We have taken kingly power and grades of the priesthood. This we would have taught in the temple if time had permitted. Joseph was entitled to the keys of the priesthood according to blood.
1:34:06 Still he was the 4th son. But when we get another temple built, we will teach you. OK? Oliver B Huntington Records. This is Joseph speaking. I am tired. I've been mobbed. I've suffered so much. Some of the brethren think they can carry this workout better than I can. Far better. I have asked the Lord to Take Me Out of this world. I have stood all I can. I have sealed. I have to seal my testimony of this generation with my blood. For this work will never progress until the testator is dead. People little know who I am when they talk to me. And they never will know until they see me weighted in the balance in the Kingdom of God. Then they will know who I am. I dare not tell them and they do not know me.
1:34:48 These words were spoken with such power, they penetrated the heart of every soul that believed on him. OK, so notice, you know, here this is this is one of those quotes that sounds like he's saying, you know, that he maybe is the Holy Ghost 'cause they don't know who he is. But then we've got these other claims that are a little, little bit different that provide balance. So here's WW Phelps, he calls him one of the Royal 70 commissioned by the High Council of Heaven. By the way, the High Council of Heaven, which was a word that they used to refer to as Elohim, was spoken about quite a bit. I've, I would venture bet I've probably got 8 or 10 quotes to talk about the High Council of Heaven or the Grand Council of Heaven or something like that in these, this book or these volumes. And one of them specifically says, this is George Lobbs, a digital version of the king fallout discourse is that Lucifer was one of the members of that grand council in heaven and that he rebelled against the entire council. So interesting stuff there.
1:35:52 But WW Phelps just simply calls him one of the royal 70, which means he's got, you know, some special priesthood. We don't know what that is. That's just what he what he labels it here. So Brigham Young says this, I remember Joseph saying, and if I were as pure and holy as you wished me to be, I could not stay with you. Not an interesting statement. People like had this idea of what he was like, and sometimes he would just do something ornery just so they would remember he was a man. He said, I couldn't stay with you, I should not be here to guide and direct you, for the Lord would take me from you. But Brigham says, but the Lord did take him and the people were not worthy of him. You did not know who you had amongst you. Joseph so loved this people.
1:36:35 He gave his life for them. Joseph and Hiram have given their lives for the Church, but very few knew Joseph's character. He loved you unto death. You did not know it until after his death. He's now sealed his testimony with the blood. If the 12 had been here, we would not have given him up. He should not have been given up. He was in your midst, but you did not know him. He has been taken away, for the people are not worthy of him. So he's not super explicit there either, but all all those kind of call us together to give you this bigger picture that Brigham saying, yeah, there was something really special about Joseph and you don't know who he was really, but we're going to teach you in the temple. And one of the things that we see coming out and and this is not in the book, but she try and remember his name. Dang it, really neat guy Curator Springville Art Museum for a long time wrote a book, Holy Blood, Holy Grail. I want to say Verrill Sanders, but that's not right. At any rate, he wrote a whole book talking about the bloodline of Joseph being taught as being through Christ. And those teachings primarily are not attributed to Joseph teaching those things.
1:37:54 They're attributed to Brigham teaching those things. But here in these quotes that I read, the two in particular, he's saying Joseph taught us these things. And when we get the temple belt, another one will teach you more. So what he's intimating, as far as I can tell, putting everything together, is he's saying Joseph was a direct descendant of Christ and was in a preserved lineage, as are some of the rest of the 12 and some of the other high-ranking, you know, members of the church at that time. And we're entitled to the priesthood by right of birth. And that's what he meant anyway. Take it or leave it. It's a controversial topic. You can say no, Joseph is, you know, on, you know, Brigham just didn't like Joseph having a higher position than him or whatever you want to believe.
1:38:41 But it's it's interesting. Again, I just would like to get all the quotes I can and if they're a little tangential or not, if they, if they shape and form the doctrine to give me a better picture. I want to put them all together so I can see them, put them together and say, what were they really teaching here? And sometimes it's quite clear. In this instance, I don't think it's super clear unless you just totally trust Brigham, and in which case, you know, that's what he was teaching, that Joseph wasn't the Holy Ghost. He was, in fact, a descendant of Christ. It's not like he. Couldn't be both? That's just what Brigham's teaching. And here, as a point of controversy, good material. Dude, you and you know that's what I'm about, right?
1:39:23 If someone's not yelling at me, I feel like I've done my job. But, but let me say this right, 'cause I think this is something I've been wanting to talk about for, for a little while here. And I think I feel like this is probably what you just brought up is a good place, right? And, and in Full disclosure, I am one of the guys that, that that buys into the theory that Joseph probably was the whole testator now. And just as Drew alluded, you could take any of those comments and it would probably work out in whatever camp you're in, right? Because they are kind of ambiguous, however. Although Orson, Pratt and Brigham together disputed it. Yeah, that's I didn't need Orson's coming. That's that's by itself is so miraculous. It's got to be true.
1:40:13 That's that's interesting too. But I think this. I think this speaks to something deeper right within all of humanity. This is not just a Mormon problem. And and that is this is that I think that we all have those certain bedrock truths that we build our testimony on that we can say we have experienced this, right. When when I got up after praying about the Book of Mormon, I can't tell you exactly how that that feeling came, You know, Well, I can tell you it was from the Holy Ghost, but I can't tell you the mechanisms by which it uses to prick my heart. But I had tangible evidence from that point forward that became a bedrock part of who I was Now.
1:41:04 Yeah. And this is super important when you dive into fundamentalism because there's gonna be people purporting revelation everywhere. There are those bedrock, solid ideas that you should absolutely be willing to build your life around. Joseph was a prophet. He restored the priesthood, the Book of Mormon, all those things, right? Temple ordinances all the way down. But then there's this other stuff that's kind of off to the side. And I've seen this trap happen more times than I care to admit, where someone will glom onto what amounts to an idea, and they won't test that idea the same way they've tested these other things, but they'll treat them as such. And what that does is you.
1:41:54 You basically now built a part of who you are around an idea. And unlike those bedrock truths, those ideas, those can shift as new evidence comes to light. And So what? You it's really a dogma that you're treating is doctrine. Right. You're holding on to them and, and you become naturally defensive, right? And so it's something that I, I have to work on and I am by no means perfect, but sometimes you guys parse out, OK, what is it that is really at my core? And then what else are just ideas, right? And and you never, in my opinion, you never want to cling too hard to something that's not bedrock or that is just an idea because as new evidence comes, you can't get moved off that spot.
1:42:41 There are things that I believe are true, but I have to admit, at the end of the day, they're ideas, right? And we all have them right. And I'm not asking for anyone to tell me what theirs are. You know what they are. You can work that out yourself. But but I think this is one of those places where it's probably good to realize, look, history can be a lot like science in some ways. It's never really completely settled. A lot of things are because we've seen just evidence after evidence amount and we're like, OK, it would take a massive shock, a massive stroke of knowledge to overturn all this. But there's a lot of other things that we grab a hold of that that I'm often left like, why are we arguing about this?
1:43:26 This doesn't seem like it is worthy of going to war over. And so I think we have to be very careful there with with with with that. And I I think this could be one of those things as well. Well, and that goes back to what we were talking about earlier where you were saying, well, how did you determine what to put in the book or not? And I said, well, I'll leave that to the reader. You know, there there's some things, you know, if I, if I found a quote that well, and I I've got quotes in there that says Joseph never taught form be us. You know, if if anybody believes that frankly, they haven't done their homework and they're so biased against the truth that they can't even bother to study history carefully, that they deserve to believe that. Garbage.
1:44:10 History just doesn't doesn't go there even if I wanted it to. It doesn't go there but but I still include it in the book 'cause it's evidence. You know it's there and you, you, you weigh it and maybe that makes you not trust that source as much later or maybe that makes you understand a nuance or something. But some of these non core principles where they're just like you said, ideas that aren't fleshed out well, Joseph didn't bear his testimony. He's explaining something. We've got somebody's 30 year old reminiscent account saying this is what he taught. Gosh, what exactly was that? It's good to know.
1:44:50 It's good to be aware, it's good to be educated. It's good to have it on your belt. It's good to have it in your arsenal, however you want to describe that. But you've got to recognize it's not doctrine until the Spirit teaches you. Or at least you shouldn't treat it as doctrine until the Spirit teaches you, unless it's just so clear that the Spirit should need to teach you. I'm sorry to $5. How much are you sorry? You know, I don't need the Spirit to prick me. Tell me that's true principle. I just need to say, yeah, you're right. How how much badly does how badly does he need it versus how badly do I do? I love my brothers. Might be itself or not. This is just how I need to apply this. But yeah, there are a lot of lot of teachings like that. And frankly, in this book, I've got quotes and I could find you a whole bunch more, but they're not attributed to Joseph. So they're not in the book where, you know, you've got people saying, well, you get, you experience the probation as a Holy Ghost, you experience probation as a Savior, and then you experience of probation as an atom. Then you're exalted, fully exalted or level 5-6 or whatever.
1:45:53 So you've got those two and you know, with with that, maybe Joseph was saying I'm the next Holy Ghost or maybe I fulfilled that part of probation for 1000 years and now I'm doing the next level it, you know, of being the testator of who knows, we just don't have that information. And, and maybe Brigham was was trying to protect that doctrine from being public. And so he told another truth. You know, there's that possibility too. So I think it's important not to become dogmatic with a lot of these things regardless of the evidence at some level, because it's just not super clear in some instances. Absolutely.
1:46:34 So if we have time, I I had a couple more stories that I thought were interesting. Absolutely. We've got all. The time in the world one quote I thought Mason's in his early 20s, he can he can walk this off true so. He can, he can added everything. OK. So Joseph when he was leaving to the martyrdom, first of all, you know, I had heard and read and I it's not been a point of interest to me. So honestly, I haven't studied it carefully, but you know, heard about Joseph talking about going to the Rockies, everything that I'd read on it, which again, wasn't something that I I've studied carefully, but just read a couple articles or something. Sound like there's maybe five maybe 10 you know sources that talk about it not so I I don't know how many have got 30-40 a lot.
1:47:31 But it wasn't just that Joseph said we're going to go to the Rockies. Joseph actually instituted a group of men and called people to a calling to scout out to go West to find the Rocky Mountains for the Saints to live there. And this we have from one of the brethren who said Joseph gave me this specific calling before he died. And no, this wasn't really bring his ideas. People say it was Joseph was the one calling us to the Rockies. We also have an account of somebody saying Joseph Smith senior was being a bit coy in a meeting and and being a quiet and they said how long are we going to be live here in Nauvoo? And he said Joseph said six years, but don't let that out.
1:48:13 He doesn't want people to get discouraged because we've just suffered all these losses of getting kicked out of Missouri, but we'll only be here six years. So that was early on. And then later we have people testifying. Not only did Joseph prepare a company of people to go out West to the Rockies, but he drew a map and told them which passes to use, You know, which directions to go to end up in the Salt Lake Valley. It's a little bit unclear as to whether or not he actually designated the Salt Lake Valley versus Provo Valley or something. But the basic ending area was somewhere that Joseph designated and told them this is where you're going to end up. So that was interesting as a detail of something that Joseph was doing.
1:48:58 So, you know, they come to get Joseph and arrest him. He, he gets set free. He starts going to the Rocky Mountains. He wasn't just headed West. He wasn't just escaping the law for five or 10 minutes. He was going and he was going to start the track to go West to the Rocky Mountains on his own and have some of that brotherhood catch up and do a scouting mission and bring the Saints with him. That's what he was doing. So when he was on his way, we have accounts in, you know, the famous one, of course, is Emma. There were a couple people that came and convinced him to go back, but Emma and I can't remember the name of the brotherhood specifically, but Emma was really distraught that Joseph had left.
1:49:41 And when this brother and showed up in town, she says, oh, I'm so grateful. So brother so and so came into town. He'll convince Joseph, if anybody can, to get him to come back. So she sent him and somebody else to go get Joseph and basically tell Joseph he was a coward. So you always promised us that you would die for us, which he had just given a speech about that a couple days earlier. He told the Navajo Legion, I will die for you and I will no longer suffer persecutions that I will fight to the death for you to have your freedoms. There comes a point when suffering persecutions is no longer justifiable before God. We've arrived at that place and I will fight to death for you. So they said that's what you said, but now you're being a coward and you're going off to to to Rocky Mountains.
1:50:25 And that's when he says famously, if my life is of no value to my brethren, it is of no value to me. So then he starts heading back and when he heads back, he tells somebody and maybe it's just before he left. I'm not sure about that detail. So, you know, don't get Hiccup too, too hard on that. Anybody listening to the podcast? But just when he left or when he came back in that area of time, it's like one day some he told somebody, he said, I hadn't received a promise of the Lord that if I wanted to stay and lead the Saints, the Lord would give me five years, but no longer. So when Joseph comes back, he's deciding against that five years. What a difference that might have made for Joseph to lead the Saints across the Rocky Mountains and had five more years of teachings from him, especially he did Rocky Mountains, yes, because he's got. Encumbered by Victorian society any longer? Right do exactly like Brigham did hey, But except for he had more sway over the people.
1:51:31 So so he's coming back and he sees Emma and Emma says I want a blessing and this is where my timeline could be a little bit tiny off. But the idea is here. Emma says I want a blessing. He said I can't give you one right now, but write down everything that you want. Come visit me Carthage jail and I will sign the blessing. Now, this is an interesting concept that I, I mentioned this in my, my little mini podcast that I do, I say mini 'cause they're like 5-10 minutes long. But this idea of concept of writing down a, a blessing is kind of unusual. But here he's saying write down what you want and I'll bless you with it. Well, that's really, really interesting for about 5 reasons. That first reason is his father as patriarch of the church used to tell people that.
1:52:22 And in this, in the accounts, they say, Father Smith used to tell us if I'd forgotten anything or if there's a special blessing that you want, write it down and I will sign my name to it because I know that if you will live for a blessing, you will receive it. And so that that was the principle and the idea. And this we find in DNC 130 verse is 22, Let's get it wrong, where he says all laws are predicated or all blessings are predicated upon the law and obedience to law brings the blessing, right? So that's basically what it's teaching. Trouble, of course, is knowing what law is to get the blessing we want isn't outlined anywhere for a lot of blessings.
1:53:02 And so that becomes the trick. But that's what he told Emma. So Emma went home and she wrote down this big long blessing of what she wanted, and it never got signed because Joseph died because she called him back. So really, really interesting. Her blessing specifically asked that she would have courage to live what what she was supposed to live and to, you know, have the integrity to, to do whatever was asked of her. And, you know, stuff that she'd been struggling with sounds really very much like she's talking about plural marriage, but she doesn't specifically say that, although it's kind of hard not to see it. So anyway, that was a really, really interesting thing. But then later, you know, somebody was asking Joseph to pray about something and they remarked that Joseph said, I have not been able to receive revelation since he agreed to go to Carthage.
1:53:55 And like the heavens were darkness before him, which kind of sounds like he made the wrong choice. He should have gone W for the Rockies and he still would have been a martyr. You know, that was his calling. That was something he had to do. And, you know, it was required of him, but he could have had five extra years. But he was like, I read earlier today, too, he said, I've had so many persecutions. I'm done. I just want reprieve. Benjamin F Johnson gives us a similar count. He said, I've suffered so much. I just don't have it in me to take anymore. I just want to go home. So, you know, he clearly just reached that end. And when the opportunity was there, he said, look, if I sacrifice myself.
1:54:38 And he says he teaches us they'll leave the Saints alone and there doesn't have to be more bloodshed. So he just decides to to go to the martyrdom. So interesting factoid. Couple couple of things that I I jumped out at me as you as you rehearse that one is, is Joseph's statement. And I'm gonna, I'm gonna compare this to something else here in a second where he when he goes back, he says since I've been in Carthage, the heavens have been darkened right now. That's or on the way is ish. What's that or on the way to cartilage. It's an ish thing. I, I don't have that detail grained in my head tightly enough to promise, but it's that that's the the general timeline, yes.
1:55:26 OK, so that's an interesting statement. If you look at what the Savior said in his darkest hour on the cross or one of his darkest where he says, Father, why have you forsaken me? Right? There seems to be something, there seems to be something here of a pattern that when, when that's why I never asked to be too much like Joseph or Brigham. But when when you go through something like that, it seems like you were kind of left on your own a little bit when you're making a sacrifice like that, right? Like.
1:56:06 Yeah. Have to endure this, which I find interesting. Yeah, well, he's, he's gonna wrench your heartstrings to the utmost ability possible. Yep, yeah, Yep. Oh, that's fascinating stuff. Sorry, I didn't mean to cut you off. I just wanted to throw that out. I found that fascinating. No, that's great. Yeah, I I totally agree. Other interesting thing is, and I, and to be honest, I haven't read Brian Hales's account of the Angel with the drawn sword. It sounded like he was going to kind of Pooh, Pooh some of the stuff as lore, the folklore that developed as time went on. And I, I think that's bad history to assume that I, I, I don't like that attitude. And so I didn't, I didn't finish reading it. And, and also I just wasn't that interested, frankly, in the topic.
1:56:59 I'm, I'm happier to read the original accounts to make my own thoughts and stuff. But I, I mentioned that because you can read the evidence that way, it's reasonable to say, well, these accounts were later. This account was super late and this detail wasn't found out till then. So it's all made-up. I think you got to be super careful doing that because that's just crap history and, and every good historian knows that. And I, I addressed that one of my many podcasts as well. But, you know, if grandpa tells you a story and all the kids are listening, what happens at the end of the story? Well, Grandpa, what happened to so And so? You said this happened, but what about this detail?
1:57:40 You didn't tell us about that detail. And they start asking questions, right? So that's just a natural thing that happens. You know, Joseph tells the story, somebody asks one question, he answers it, tells the story again, somebody else, they have totally different questions. They answer it. And then, you know, somebody doesn't write down, but he told them is their answer until 30 years later. Now you got a memory issue, But it's that doesn't make it not true. It just makes it a question mark if it's reliable. So I think we've got to be careful with the stories. If, if, if calling it folklore, it's made-up because Oh my gosh, there's a miracle and it can't be true, you know, But at any rate, I, I say that just to be fair, you can read it that way.
1:58:24 I don't, I don't read it that way. So Joseph in 1834 was visited by the Angel, tells him you've got to teach this and love it, right? OK, so he sort of does. Other than Fanny Auger, it appears that by the time the Angel came again, he'd taken 9 plural wives, but all of them were married to somebody else. He wasn't living with them. It was like married to somebody else for time and to him for eternity. He's kind of the backup husband, right? Right. So this marriage isn't going to work, but you've got kids. Live your life out. But I'll, I'll be your husband in eternities. And the Angel comes as not good enough. And I think there's some really interesting things in the accounts that we can argue about as to what the Angel, in fact, was telling me, had to do. But at one point, Joseph Smith arranged a meeting with the Quorum of 12.
1:59:13 Maybe not everybody, I'm pretty sure is unlike 9 of them, but he had a meeting arranged with them to teach them about plural marriage. Because the Angel, you know, to get your butt in gear, you got to do it. So he starts going to the meeting and he chickens out. He said no, I'm not going to do it. He turns around and he starts riding his horse away from the meeting. As he's riding away, the Angel is standing on the ground in front of him and stops him from progressing on the path where he's riding. Joseph gets off the horse, kneels down on the ground. The Angel hovers over him with the sword drawn and says, If you don't go back and teach them, I will take away your priesthood.
2:00:00 And I will destroy you right now. And so Joseph begs for his life, begs for mercy. He goes back and teaches that lesson to to the at that meeting. That's that's what I'm gathering from the accounts. There's some little details there that you might say, well, maybe it was the next day or he recalled the meeting later that night, or we don't really have some of the details there. But I think it's really, really interesting that that was how it went down. And according if you believe all the accounts, if you accept all of them is true, that's, you know, that's part of the caveat that I was talking about Brian Hills earlier is you don't have to read it that way. But I think it's really interesting because we've got accounts of people saying Joseph never shirked from his responsibilities.
2:00:45 And Joseph said late in his life, I believe after this, he said, I've made this my rule when God commands, I do it. But it took this very real, legitimate threat to his life from an Angel before he finally coughed up and said, OK, fine, you know, but he had, this was so hard for him to reveal. It's so hard for him to choke up and, and talk to people about that. He just, you know, he, he failed on that, on that issue. And so to say, Joseph never shirked except on this one thing. He just couldn't do it because he saw the trouble it would cause. He saw the pain it would cause and the challenges that would cause and that it would bring it into his own life that he just, he kept arguing against the Angel. In fact, he quoted, oh, shoot, not gonna sound stupid, but I can't remember where it says the Jacob 2, where it says I commanded you shall only have one wife unless I command otherwise.
2:01:43 Right? And he's rebuking the Nephites for their abuses. So he says wait. Wait, wait, wait. Joseph tries to use Jacob Two to get out of it. Yeah, he argues with the Angel and says the scripture says not to live this way. Yeah, funny, huh, That. Is kind of funny. He was. To say he did not win the argument. Yeah, yeah. You know, I, I think this is important too, because if there's one thing we're good at, it's turning our, our predecessors into marble statues, right? We, we did it with Washington, right? It's taking so much scholarship to show the humanity of Washington again. And we run a similar risk with Joseph when we don't get these stories of not seeing his humanity. Yes.
2:02:36 And that's, that's important because there are many times, especially in the Doctrine and Covenants, right? And the Doctrine and Covenants is such a unique book in all of religion because you have the Lord speaking first person, perhaps more in that book than any other. And, and but what that is coming out of is Joseph reaching for the Savior like the rest of us are right now. His circumstances are different. He's like, how in the hell do I run a church? Right? And so the Lord's kind of, you know, telling him how to do it. But through that process, you, you see the, the, that Joseph is struggling with, with a lot of the same things.
2:03:21 I think we struggle with in some ways, right? Maybe not as long, maybe not as repetitive. He seems to be a quick learner that way, so to speak. But but it, it's good to see the humanity so we can relate to him. It's the same reason I like the Adam God doctrine and and I know it to be true. It it, it, it puts deity in proximity to the rest of us. These kind of stories with Joseph, it gives us proximity to him, right? It gives us. Yeah, like Brigham said. Hallelujah every time. I know that I knew the man, I could use him. An imperfect guy, maybe. Me too. Yep, Yeah, yeah. No, I, I think these kind of stories are so vital so we can keep showing not just Joseph the statue, but Joseph the man, because I think that's where the wisdom really lies. So I love that there's a a story by Joseph F Smith and Joseph F Smith is talking about a specific instance where Joseph beats somebody up and he he, he puts it like this. He said, you know, he was his uncle Joseph, right? So he says he was playing outside marbles by the fence with some of his friends.
2:04:42 And all of a sudden there's this big ruckus. And Dang, now I can't remember the name of the pastor that he kicked up and beat up, but he said, the first thing I see is, is Joseph is helping this man out the door with the with the leather of his boot. And the guy didn't lead fast enough, so he picked him up and kicked him over the fence, you know, or through the gate or whatever it was, you know, that that level. And just he just basically is beating him up on his way out and hurrying him out, hurrying him up. And Joseph F Smith said, now some of the you may be caused struggle with that and look and say, how could a man who had seen the Savior had seen God behave such and treat people like that?
2:05:27 And he said, but I saw things that you didn't see. He said, I saw that man went through so much testing and so much trial and hardship. And when somebody is suffering like that. And then this guy goes into his house, Joseph feeds him, treats him like a king, serves him and treats him kindly. And the man just sits there and complaints and tells you you're a liar and that you're, you know, you're a fraud and all that says there comes a point when you cease to be a man if you don't just respond by beating the hell out of somebody.
2:06:08 You know, he said he would have been a less a man if he would have just withstood it. And, and but I love how his perspective there is, instead of saying, yeah, maybe Joseph was a little overzealous with the pastor. You know, he could have just pushed him or something. Didn't have to kick him so hard. But he doesn't say that, you know, he's like you. You could push a good man so far and and at some point he becomes emasculated if he doesn't fight back. And Joseph teaches that same principle in Nauvoo to the Nauvoo Legion the day or two before the martyrdom. I've got the exact date in my chart for anybody who's still interested.
2:06:53 But he says that there comes a time when, when receiving persecution goes so far that it's no longer a virtue to turn the other cheek. And you have to defend your family. You have to defend others. You have to defend the principle of freedom, or, you know, the title of liberty. Whatever it is, you want to describe it that way. There comes a point when you have to stand up and be a man and fight. And, you know, he had that very real struggle. And he did, in fact, during the martyrdom shoot back and reportedly shot and killed one of the men who was in the mob down below. So, yeah, but there's so many fabulous stories like this peppered throughout the book that and and and I try not to just have, like you're saying, faith promoting stories, but stories that teach a lesson and and not just, well, I could extrapolate some random theme from this, but a clearly something that he's teaching.
2:07:55 That's, that's the focus of both volumes and, and I think, you know, the actual page length of the, the actual teachings and not the, you know, the introduction and the concordance, all that is something like 870 pages, you know, but, but frankly, a big chunk of the introduction is just quotes from, you know, other parts of the book. So it's, that's, that's a massive amount of material and it covers a massive number of topics and it, it just goes on and on. You know, I, I didn't, we haven't talked anything about it, but there's dozens of entries about Zion's camp and how they, they got cholera and some of them died because they were complaining.
2:08:42 But there are also two accounts of Joseph sealing up the entire camp to eternal life. The constitution hanging by a thread. Man, there are a lot of quotes about that and a lot of little details about how the Saints will save those principles. And there's talk about a second civil war in the United States, hundreds of quotes about the last charge and similar teachings and stuff that are mostly covered in volume one that are repeated here without all the commentary and, you know, organization stuff to make you understand the principles better. So, you know, we could, we could literally go on for hours if anybody's interested and not sold that they want to buy the book, which I hate to say that because frankly, you should just buy the book, you know, and there's certain books, you know, if, if somebody's not interested in DNC 76, I get it fine.
2:09:39 They don't want to buy changing ordinances, changing priesthood, I get it fine. But if you are a Mormon, then you need to have teachings of Joseph. So. But if you're not yet sold on that idea, I will. I will say that if you go to drewbriny.substack.com, I have big chunks on audiobook that are previewable for free subscription. Just read them paid subscription, you can listen to the whole thing. I'm I've only uploaded through R right now. So S is coming up maybe tomorrow, but you know, you can hear some more of these stories on your own kind of get a better flavor of, you know, if you think it's worth it or not and that sort of stuff.
2:10:20 I, I would, I would hope this is, this is one of those books I really think belongs on everybody's shelves. And I've never ever said that about anything that I've written or compiled before, but this I really think it fits. It's it's such important material for everybody to have so. Let me ask you just a couple quick questions here as we wrap up then. Drew, uh huh. First, what, what was your big take away from this book? Preparing these books? What what, What jumped out at you about Joseph that maybe you hadn't anticipated learning? Gosh, I don't know. You stumped me. The first thing that comes to my mind is, you know, you know, he was really, I upset Emma when she tried to poison him the first time and called him before counsel and rebuked her and, and said all sorts of stuff and went to the extent of saying where she bought the poison and who she got it from. She administered too much and that's what made him throw it up instead of dying.
2:11:26 And, you know, all these little details. I, I think what if if anything, surprised me. It was kind of seeing more of what we're talking about these, these bits of humanity. But I, I, I don't know if that's a perfect answer either. Because all of these things I'd read before, it was just a matter of putting them all together and making the index and, and, and trying to make sure that, you know, I've looked at every facet of the quote, trimming things down so that it's not super long winded and only has stuff material to the teaching. But enough of the context that you understand the teaching and those types of tricks. But I'd read it all before.
2:12:08 And so I think just putting it all together, I, I, I, I don't know, maybe I could better describe it like this. When I first read the teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith, I was 18 years old. I joined the church without a really strong testimony of Joseph. And as I got toward the very end of my King Fala, you know, the spirit of Elias, Elias, Elijah and the Messiah. And you know, some of these really big talks at the end And the spirit came over me and said, no man can teach these things unless he's a prophet. And I, I, I just, there was nothing in my soul that could resist the power of that statement. It just was so obvious to me and you know, everybody gets testimony differently and, and on different issues, But for me, that testimony of Joseph really made a big difference and impact on me.
2:13:07 And I was I was just astounded at the the depth and breadth of his teaching. And I think reading this or, or writing this as it were, I'm I'm more editor than a writer in this book. The thing that really astounded me and and hit me harder than anything else was the what I compiled in the in the introduction, all those quotes where he said I had so much more of the God taught me visions that I wanted to share teachings and revelations. I want to share, but you won't let me teach you and it wasn't this is actually good. It's OK that the Saints need time to receive this. He was frustrated.
2:13:55 He wanted to teach us more, but we wouldn't receive it from him. We were too stuck in traditions. And those, those ideas you were talking about that we become dogmatic about, but they're not core parts of our gospel. And we can't open our eyes and our minds to stretch far enough to receive all of the things that he had to teach. And those teachings, a lot of them are in the journals. Not all of them for sure, but a lot of them are in the journals and we have little snippets of them from a conversation he had with brother so and so. And we just, he didn't have a good journal entry, but we've got a little snippet of it to make us say, ah, there's something else to pray about. There's tons more to the gospel than we have. And, and I'm speaking fundamentalists as well as mainstreamers who don't have the same breadth of topics to study as fundamentalists do.
2:14:54 They may consider it just as deep, but they certainly don't have as many topics because those are postdoctorine or something, you know, So I'm saying I'm speaking to both. There are things that he was teaching that none of the groups really address well. Maybe Collier's group accepted they've, they've got some really good scholars in that group, have always had somebody that's, you know, really well read. But absent, absent a few places, nobody's really studied the breadth of this stuff very well. And that wasn't even the full breadth of what Joseph was receiving. He's like, I can teach you 100 times more than I did DNC 76, but I can't 'cause you're not ready.
2:15:35 You don't want it. And it's just gonna make you upset. It's gonna hurt your testimony. So it's better not to tell the truth sometimes because it's, it'll damage somebody, hurt them. So I'm holding it back. But when I saw all the, I thought I'm compiling these codes. I'm gonna have good, you know, dozen of them, and it'll make the point that that I'm trying to make right now. That's what I thought when I started, when I finished the book, I was like, it's too big. I just quit adding stuff to it. You know, it's, it's kind of like beating a dead horse. I don't know how many I've got. I think there are like 35 statements in the beginning section that Joseph complaining that he wanted to teach more. Adding fifteen more just gets obnoxious, you know, And so they're not there, they're just in the book. But you can find them in the index and I've got a special place for it and it's marked so you can find it easier. But I think that was the biggest thing that really struck me is that it wasn't just a thing, you know, sure like to teach him more.
2:16:28 It was a burden for him to, to know so much and not be able to share. And I, I, it, it drives me very intensely to want to know what did he know that he couldn't share? I don't have in, in my estimation of my own self being self introspective. I don't have all these traditions. I'm a convert and I keep going from thing to thing to thing and learning some new, new doctrine and new ideas. And I, I just, I'll read whatever it is with the belief that I could be wrong in believing whatever I thought before. So I'll take it to Lord and be careful and I pray and study it out, but I'm open to learning and I just, I just have the strong drive to find out.
2:17:14 What else did you teach? What else is there? What are we, what are we missing? You know, in the next couple volumes, I'm going to be exploring stuff that shouldn't be shocking, you know, shouldn't be too many surprises, but I bet I'll find some in the process and, and find some more general entries in the process that'll that, you know, should have gone to this book and edit through that later. But I, I just really want to know what were those things and why isn't that more engaging to more people? I, I did some Facebook ads and tested, you know, what are people interested in on these topics? And, you know, there's a certain amount of interest in all of them. But I was surprised. For me, the number one thing is what did Joseph teach secretly that he wanted to teach everybody else? You know, that's not how I worded it in the ad, of course, because it's got to be succinct.
2:18:02 But like, what was Joseph secretly teaching? What did he want? What did he want to teach us more? What was it? But that's not the, that's not the biggest catch for most people. You know, the, the biggest catch, sadly, is what's the church hiding? And you know, some of these feelings of frustration and, and I think, you know, I understand that feeling. I've been there too. But I, I think our bigger thing should be, I want to know all the truth. Where is it? Where can I find it? And, and that's really, that's really what kind of hits me with this book. And I I still want to know so much more. Absolutely, yeah.
2:18:44 What do you hope people take away from it? From the book. Yeah. You know, I, I think there's this attitude and it's more in mainstreamers than it is in fundamentalists. So to be fair, but there's, it's also in, in, in, in fundamentalists. There's this attitude, a Bible, a Bible. We've got a Bible. We don't need any more Bible. I don't know how that sticks in in modern Mormonism, but it's sure there. You know, we don't study the mysteries. You know, the brethren said you don't study the mysteries. Well, Joseph said study the mysteries. I'm sorry, get the teachings of Prophet Joseph Smith.
2:19:25 He very clearly says go study the mysteries. But the we don't study mysteries is basically a Bible Bible. We've got a Bible. You know, we the the brethren will teach us what we need to know in general conference and I can read the book Mormon half hour a day and I don't have to do anything else. Well, how are you gonna become a God that knows everything if you don't have any more curiosity than that? I understand. And this idea that just because it's in a journal means it's not credible. If it was credible, the brethren would have published it in the TPGS. I would have. A big take away would be Joseph wanted to teach a whole lot more.
2:20:07 He was teaching a whole lot more. And he would have included it in the Doctrine Covenants if the people were ready and would listen. And frankly, my my studies and publications on DNC annotated with commentary are are proving that more to me every single day. I just put out for my followers who were who were helping with The Who were buying those books 10 more sections of the doctrine in the covenants today. I was shocked how much changes Joseph made to those first ten sections of the Doctrine Covenants. It's not a trivial amount. He made a lot of clarifications and corrections or Oliver Cadre made them and Joseph approved them. Either way, same thing.
2:20:50 There's so much more to the gospel he wanted to share. And if, if we could get out of this attitude while the brethren teach me everything I'm supposed to learn and get into the attitude of how do I grow as close as possible to my Father in heaven and to my Savior by learning who they are and by understanding these teachings of the prophet. That's that's should be our attitude, right? I want to learn everything I can about how to be like them. And there's a lot of material in this book or these putu books to get you there. And it's not me preaching. It's not even Brigham preaching. It's Joseph.
2:21:31 And he had a lot to say. And I, I just really wish people could have the same breadth of admiration for who he was that I have had in, in studying him like this. I, I, I used to take, I, I took a course from Susan Easton Black. And if you guys don't know who she is, you need to find out. She's really, she's a funny woman. She's, she was such a joy to, to be in her classes at BYUI. Think she's still teaching there she was just she's just such a hoot and she knew just about everything there was to know about Joseph and and she used to joke. I hope it was 100% a joke, but she used to joke that she would tell her husband.
2:22:19 You know, I, I really love you, but if there's any way that I can be unsealed from you and be sealed to Joseph in the eternities, that's what's going to happen. Because she, she admired him so much and she just loved all these stories about him and you know, who he was and all that sort of stuff. And, and I think, you know, as somebody who's obviously not interested in the marriage with him, I just, I just can't imagine anybody that I admire more other than the Savior or, you know, Father in heaven or something. But frankly, we don't know as much about them as we know about Joseph. So that makes a really unique the relationship we have in studying their lives of who they truly were.
2:23:03 So in any rate, I hope, I hope then that the book will just have that effect on people to have a a better appreciation of who he really was. And I think you can get a lot of that from books like remembering Joseph and they knew the prophet, you know, especially digital version, they knew the OR remembering Joseph because it's so long, But at some level, so many descriptions of how his forehead sighs and his blue eyes. And, you know, he, he went to this meeting. That meeting is not as impactful as when he's actually teaching doctrine and and offering it to us. Absolutely Drew, where can people find your sub stack again?
2:23:45 Drew Briny just spelled like my name DREWBRIN ey.substack.com on there. I do mini podcasts like usually four to 10 minutes and they're just whatever I'm studying at the moment. So I I, I did one today about the apocalypse of Moses and things that that are found in that apocryphal writing that were written by the very first group of Christians who left Jerusalem before it was sacked the Nazarenes. Let me say this in a better way. The the, the writings of this group of people who are the first Christians who left Jerusalem because Christ said it would be destroyed, wrote a book called the Apocalypse of Moses.
2:24:28 It teaches lots of temple endowment stuff. It wasn't discovered too long after Joseph's dead. So I, I, I did the second in a series of of of stuff where I teach that kind of stuff. Like, you know what, what things about the endowment are showing up in Jewish Christian writings that are unearthed after Joseph's dead and reveals the endowment, whatever it is I'm studying, That's what I do when people request that I teach something. I, I do a topic on that. But they're, they're usually just short little bursts. And I've, I'm putting my whole audiobook of teachings of the forgotten Teachings of Joseph Smith on there. And when I finish that, I'm gonna do audiobooks for paid subscribers, which is as little as $5.00 a month or as much as you want.
2:25:12 I'm going to be doing all my books, audiobook with AI stuff that I bought that's super high quality. It's they, they be better than I do, to be honest. I've been doing my own recordings. They sound better than I do. So, so I'm going to be putting those up there. And yeah, it's, it's been really, it's been really neat experience interacting with people more talking, talking to them about what I'm learning. So and name of the book and. Then name of the book and where they can find it. OK, it's only on Amazon right now. It's called The Forgotten Teachings. It's part of Joseph Smith's Doctrines and Insight series. So they're going to be about 6 books total that'll culminate with the complete teachings of Joseph Smith if and if people buy it.
2:25:57 And otherwise my family has to starve, complain at me, and I have to go get a real job. So my wife was getting upset at me for saying that. I'm just teasing but. They're not all, they're not all cracked up in all what they have to be so. Yeah, so, so at any rate that the series is called Joseph Smith Doctrines and Insight series. This is volume 2A and 2B, but the, the subtitle that it's marketed under is the Forgotten Teachings. And if you just type in Drew Briny the Forgotten Teachings or Drew Briny Joseph Smith, it it'll pop up. It'll. Be there. I'll throw a link in the in this episode's show notes. So dude, as always, great stuff.
2:26:41 I love our conversations man. Yeah, it's always fun to be a be be a have a like minded person chat with. Well, dude, I'll tell you what, if you keep on pace next week, give me a call and we'll get you back on talking about your other book, I you. Know right, right. I'm actually, I'm actually pretty close to a book called The Essential Essential Look. That was a joke. That was a joke. OK, I'm just saying. No, no, it's good. It's good. Go ahead and and and and tell us the name of that one that you're working on. Right, I'm doing, I'm doing 2 actually, what's called the essential teaching, essential understanding, sorry, essential Adam, God teachings.
2:27:22 It's basically instead of reading my thousand page, you know, whatever turned out to be oversized, it was 1000 pages, 6 by 9. Instead of reading all that, it's just the essentials. It's for teens who are fundamentalists who believe in it but just want to know the basics and for converts or people who just like I, I just want to run down to what really is this without all the junk. And then I'm doing at the same time because it's pragmatically, I'm just writing at the same time. I'm doing one called shoot, what am I calling it? Well, I guess it's not a very good title.
2:28:02 I need to rethink it. That's exploring. It's called exploring Adam Got Teachings. And basically it's everything that I've heard anybody speculate about, consider, ponder, and you know, cross reference this with this. Any ideas that I've heard in the last 30 years about Adam Got Teachings and is not easily disproven will be in that book. So that one will be longer and more heavy and frankly will include stuff I don't believe but other people do. Is is just to explore in depth and learn everything you can about it and decide what you believe is true. And the other one's just the the sheer basics. That one's frankly pretty much done. If I wasn't working on other projects it would have been out published by now, Sure, but yeah. All right, as always, good stuff man. Great.
2:29:02 Thanks a lot. Thanks. Bye everybody. Take care, God bless.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox