Episode #124 Plural Marriage In The Scriptures W/Jacob Vidrine
So there has been a lot of revisionist history that has made its way into Mormon circles as of late in conjunction with this, it has required those pushing these false narratives to either twist or flat out lie about what the scriptures say. With this in mind I want to address some of the lies and wishful thinking. One of the more pernicious ideas is that scripture denounces the practice of celestial plural marriage. Well today I have Jacob Vidrine back on the podcast to address this idea. Jacob and I will breakdown the scriptures (in context) to give you a fuller picture of what the scriptures have to say and not say about the practice of celestial plural marriage. Towards the end of the podcast, I name names of those pushing this narrative and also the repercussions of buying into those lies. Grab a pen and paper to take some notes so you can push back on these lies when they arise.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:04 So there's been a lot of revisionist history that's made its way into Mormon circles as of late. In conjunction with this, it's often required that those pushing those false narratives to either twist or flat out lie about what the scriptures say. With this in mind, I want to address some of the lies and wishful thinking that we see out there. One of the more pernicious ideas is that scripture denounces the practice of celestial plural marriage. Well, today I have Jacob the Dream back on the podcast to address this idea. Jacob and I will break down the scriptures in context to give you a fuller picture of what the scriptures have to say and not say about the practice of celestial plural marriage. Towards the end of the podcast, I name some names of those who are pushing these narratives and also the repercussions of buying into these lies. Grab a pen and paper to take some notes so you can push back when you see these lies arise in your circles. That's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast. So a few weeks back I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running.
1:05 Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page, or click the link in this episode's show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups and water bottles, all with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU. But you should definitely go check that out now. This is just the beginning. In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now, all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast, so head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode's show notes and get yours today. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Jacob, what's going on, man?
2:33 Getting closer to springtime though, we just got probably with a bit more snow out here so but it's all good. Did you? Well, it, dude. So I was thinking about this earlier as I was getting ready for this. The first podcast I ever published was with you. The first podcast I'll ever publish from Missouri that I've done in Missouri will be with you. I'm starting to see a little bit of a pattern emerge here, so. That's awesome and congratulations on the move. That's that's really awesome. I learned something. I have aged like, I thought back to like and I even had help this time, right, like. But I remember when I was moving to the Eastern Shore of Maryland, I loaded that big pen, you know, the big 35 foot pen ski all by myself, right? Didn't feel it was good to go, man. 20 years later I you know, like I said, I even had help.
3:24 But I was sore for three days. I mean, it sucked. I forgot how badly, how how much moving sucks it. It is not fun whatsoever. So. But no, it's it's been good so far. We've been here. We've been here now just under a month and it's it's been good. So, well, man, are Are you ready to probably not make any real friends after this episode? Too much, I don't think, I think. Or make or make the right friends. We'll make the right friends, right? One, one way or another. But I'm guessing that this will pretty well by the time the episode with Taylor gets released and then with this one with you.
4:05 I just don't think I'm gonna be on the Doctrine of Christ Christmas card list this year. I don't think I'm gonna make that cut. I think that's gonna be gonna be gone when I first hit you up about this. I'm. I'm. I'm. I'm. I'm. I'm I I'm already off their Christmas card list. In fact I I've they they've thrown me in a couple of their memes with like other people they perceive as like polygamy defenders. Even though, you know, it was just for because I participated in that debate that against the, you know the the Joseph Smith polygamy deniers, you know that got me on their crap list and I've, I've just kind of embraced it at this point so.
4:47 That's all we can do, right? I mean, look, sometimes speaking the truth can be a lonely endeavor. Fortunately, I got I got friends like you and and Taylor and and other guys out there that that it's not so lonely. But sometimes these things can can when it causes controversy can can kind of make you feel a little bit alone. But no, we're in good company for sure, my man. So I first came to you and. Yeah, well. Oh, go ahead. Sorry. Oh, no, I I was just saying, well, I'm excited to dig into what the scriptures teach on plural marriage. You know, it's something that it's not just about being opposed to somebody else, but it's about defending truth. And what is the truth? And so far in this aspect, I've been focused on what's the history of, like, Joseph Smith teaching polygamy and what was understood about it by the early brethren and what, what was doctrinal.
5:38 And I haven't ever done a too much of A deep dive into the scriptures on this. I mean, I've I've, I've been perfectly aware, I think anyone in Mormon fundamentalism is aware of all the scriptural evidence that there is a lot of scriptural evidence. But what makes this so fascinating is there's always more to dig into and more to discover when it comes to the scriptures, when it comes to this or to any other topics. So I'm excited. Absolutely. You know and and. So, so sorry I cut you off. No, you're good. You're good. I was just gonna make the point and I'm just gonna call a spade a spade here. But I remember back when my kids were going to school and really started learning about history, right?
6:22 About in high school, American history in, in particular. I mean, the whole reason I moved back to Maryland was because I'm a complete nerd when it comes to the founding period of America, right? I've. I've got that dialed in pretty good. And so my kids would come home and say things like, Dad, did you know that the Founders were nothing but rich, white slave owners. And I would, like, drop my fork and like, what the hell did you just say? And And so I started diving into what the agenda was, right? And the agenda was there was a group of people about the early 1900s, the progressives, who wanted to move past the Constitution. But they understood in order to move past the Constitution, they had to discredit the Constitution, which meant you kind of had to discredit its founders, right, the people who wrote it.
7:09 And so they went on this tangent of just tearing down anybody that had anything to do whatsoever with the Constitution. What I see in the Doctrine of Christ movement is exactly the same formula right now. They don't go directly after Joseph Smith. They just paint a different picture of who Joseph Smith is. Likewise with the early brethren there that took over after Joseph died. Brigham, John Taylor, Willard Richards, Wilford Woodruff, Excuse me, They're different. You know, they discredit them outright. And so really, if you can, if you can put into jeopardy Brigham and John Taylor, well then you can kind of remake the Restoration into whatever you want.
7:55 And that's what I feel like they're doing. And it's very, I don't know if they do it consciously or if that just seems the path of least resistance form, but it really is quite insidious and and quite honestly, a lot of their histories are are, you know, borderline flat out lies, right. I don't know how else to put it. And when Jacob Q Gets used in discrediting polygamy, and I could get it on the surface, on a cursory reading, right, if you don't pay attention to things like, you know, unless it's time to raise up seed or something like that, they they glom onto that. But really, that's the only one that the only scriptural injunction that I think I can really find. I'm sure there's someone else out there who's found it, found something else.
8:43 But that's the only scriptural prohibition against plural marriage that I think I can find anywhere. And that one's not really even a a prohibition against it. I think what they're talking about there is men using a holy principle for self gratification and so. I, I, I, I, I totally agree with you on that. And I think Orson Pratt actually similarly said that he thought this this statement. Jacob too, he thinks it's the only command on record, I believe, in which a command was ever given to any branch of Israel to be confined to a monogamy system. So, you know, it's kind of the outlier rather than the standard, right.
9:27 So, and I I totally agree with you on their view of history and I think what they're trying to do, I don't want to spend too much time psychoanalyzing. But I think that they have things they like about the Restoration and things they dislike about the Restoration or their church experience and what they have found in the history. And so the way they try to the easy path for them is to pin everything they like about the Restoration on Joseph Smith. It all the good came from Joseph Smith and anything they don't like was all of these apostles who came after him and it was all their fault for anything that makes them uncomfortable or which they find messy in, in regards to the history. So you know, I I think it's a fascinating but tragic path to go down to.
10:18 You know decide that I need to, I need to make Joseph Smith in my own image and then tarnish the image of the the men that Joseph Smith was friends with and had the highest respect for the prophet. You know, they they, you know these were men who were willing to die with the prophet. And you know to try to tarnish their legacy and their characters is something that I don't think is an honorable thing to do. You know when the script you know especially with what the Scriptures say about thou shalt not bear false witness. So absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah, that's how I can. You know, and I think last episode that I had with Taylor where we broke down his his debate he had with Justin Griffin. It shows really the flawed, the flawed. I can't even call it logic.
11:05 I mean, towards the end I was just like it was getting to be cringy right on the part of of Griffin's part. And as I looked at it, I was like, OK, we did a good job there. But when I called you, I had something else in mind which was let's dive into the scriptures and let's see what the scriptures really either have to say or let's see what they have to to, to do with polygamy here. And that's, that's what we're going to do today. We're going to breakdown polygamy from kind of a purely doctrinal, scriptural point of view. Yeah, that's awesome. And so I guess we're going to start with I think it's all you know the Old Testament's obviously the the 1st place to start, but then we can definitely you wanted to you told me you also wanted to explore you know the New Testament in the Book of Mormon and polygamy as well. We want to take a very holistic look at the scriptures rather than cherry picking because anyone can cherry pick verses in the scriptures to argue whatever they want. But the the big key thing is are you taking the totality of the scriptural witness to support your view or are you trying to find little Nuggets in the scriptures to you know, you know you can twist to support anything you want, you know. So I I think a lot of polygamy desires actually realized how hard their position is in conflict with the Old Testament and I've seen them acknowledge this. And the path that some of them try to take is they try to actually say maybe we shouldn't even trust the Old Testament. Is the is something that I've
12:37 seen more and more common, is an attack on the reliability of the Old Testament and wanting to basically consider the Book of Mormon as the only real authoritative doctrinal standard. And that's kind of what I've what I began to see. There's some who would try to argue, well, maybe like the Old Testament was corrupted to make Jacob and Abraham be polygamous. And I I think that's kind of that that's a stretch to put it nicely, right. You know, it's the the plural marriage is very integral into the Old Testament narrative and it's in the New in New Testament as well where it's, you know, the 12 tribes of Israel and you know, it's it's, you know, it's it's very, you know, integrated throughout the the narratives of the patriarchs.
13:28 And so there are people, though, who don't trust the the, the Old Testament, particularly Genesis. And I was recently reading a sermon by Brigham Young and he made this comment, and I, I, I resonate with it, he said. I know there are great many in the world who are so wise in their own eyes that they are not disposed to believe the account contained in the Bible of the creation of Adam and Eve, in the Garden of Eden, the antediluvian world, and other things. But we profess to believe, and we do or should believe these things. And this is what the Book of Mormon actually tells us to do as well. Like the the Book of Mormon. Never read the Book of Mormon. You know, cover to cover quite a few times. I've never seen anything in the Book of Mormon that indicates that it is what you should trust rather than the Bible. Instead, what I see in the Book of Mormon is an emphasis on it in the Bible are to harmonize and are to work together to teach true doctrine.
14:26 Yeah, and this is something you see from the very beginning of the Book of Mormon in in first Nephi, where the angels talking to Nephi about the Bible coming forth and this is what the the this is what the Angel says about it. And he said behold it. So this is first Nephi 1323. And he said, Behold, it proceedeth out of the mouth of a Jew. And I Nephi beheld it. He said unto me, The book that thou behold us is a record of the Jews, which contains the covenants of the Lord, which he hath made unto the House of Israel. And it also containeth many of the prophecies of the holy prophets. And it is a record like unto the engravings, which are on the plates of brass, save there are not so many. Nevertheless they contain the covenants of the Lord, which he hath made unto the House of Israel, Wherefore they are of great word to Gentiles.
15:20 So he's saying it's it's like the plates of brass but with not as meant much stuff on it is what the Angel tells Nephi and and so going on later on in that chapter verse 40 he said And the Angel spake unto he saying These last records which thou seen among the Gentiles shall establish the truth of the first which are of the 12 apostles of the Lamb, and shall make known the plain and precious things which have been taken away from them and shall be make known to all kindred tongues and people. That the Lamb of God is the Son of the eternal Father and the Savior of the world. And that all men must come into them or they cannot be saved. So again, it's about establishing the truth of the first records and you know and to and makes knowledge about the things that were taken away from the Bible rather than this idea that some have is that a bunch of false things were added to the Bible, if that makes sense.
16:13 So you know this is something, you know the reliability of the Bible is something that the early Latter Day Saints were big on. So I I think that's just something that should be a standard. If you accept the Book of Mormon as a historic, as a historical record, you got to also accept the validity of the Bible as well, in my opinion. Absolutely. Let me say this real quick, because OK, let's just go with their argument for a second. The Old Testament was corrupted, right? You can't trust it. To my knowledge, Joseph Smith retranslated it, right? And to my knowledge, none of the parts that deal with plural marriage were altered whatsoever.
16:53 So if if you're gonna say that that the Bible's in error, OK, fine, go pick up the Joseph Smith translation. Unless you don't trust Joseph Smith too. Yeah, that that's a good point. That's that's another thing that could be said to argue against their position. And I think they try to say that there are certain things in the in the Joseph Smith translation relating to polygamy that are changed. But in we'll cover at least one of those key Old Testament verses that is changed and it actually basically states the exact same thing. It's just clarified. So and that's first Kings 15-5 in in both the IT, it essentially states the same thing. That verse is so problematic to polygamy deniers that Rob Fotheringham, who's one of the key guys in a YouTube who makes videos to on the in that movement. He was he would not quote the entirety of that verse. He was so scared of what that verse says in in one of his videos on trying to argue that DNC 132 was fabricated. He was he, he would quote parts of the Joseph Smith translation of of First Kings 15-5.
18:09 But you would not quote the entirety of that verse because the entirety of that verse is, is that polygamy is OK and that David did not sin except in the matter of Uriah. I mean it's it says that he repented of his sins and except in the matter of Uriah and there he was cursed. So you know, that's just an important verse. So I guess if we're going to talk about, you know, going back to the Old Testament, I think we probably should start with the story of Abraham, right? Because that's, you know, the father of the faithful and that's, he's the, you know, we're an Abrahamic faith. And so, you know, Abraham and his life and you know, his practices is something that should weigh in the discussion of plural marriage in the Scriptures. And so Joseph Smith said that wrote wrote an editorial on on government in the Times and Seasons in July of 1842, and he's had this statement in it about Abraham. He said Abraham was guided in all his family affairs by the Lord, was conversant with angels, and by the Lord was told where to go and when to stop, and prospered exceedingly in all that he put his hand unto.
19:23 And it was because he and his family obeyed the counsels of the Lord. Now does that sound like something that some people would try to say that Abraham was just living in the culture of his day, and he was a polygamist, but God wasn't OK with it. Does that sound like Joseph Smith was OK with that, agreed with that position? Yeah, of course not. You know, if Abraham's walking and talking with God, you know in in all throughout the story of Abraham, you know God's having communion with him. If polygamy was wrong, you would think that God would have something, you know, something to say about it, you know. And instead when you read the story, you find that God actually blesses and offers blessings to them after they've their enter into plural marriage.
20:12 You know in in the marriage with Hagar. And so WW Phelps also recalled that Joseph Smith talked about Abraham's wives being something that was given by revelation, just as that's editorial said that Abraham was guided in his family affairs by the Lord. So WW Phelps, in a letter to Brigham Young on August 12th, 1861, he was discussing early plural marriage revolution that was to command the Brethren to intermarry with the Lamanites. And they were discussing that. And then he he said that you know, how are we as married men supposed to intermarry with the Lamanites? And he recalled that Joseph replied instantly, in the same manner that Abraham took Hagar and Katurna, and Jacob took Rachel, Bill, Hath and Zipla by revelation.
21:01 The Saints of the Lord are always directed by revelation. Of course, you know. Right, Joseph. Joseph Yeah. So it's. We're we're gonna practice plural marriage. That's how we're gonna intermarry with them. Yeah, and there's. So that revelation shows up late by WW Phelps, but there's a early witness to it in that a guy anti Mormon at that time references that Joseph had received a revelation to intermarry with the Lamanites. It's a there's a contemporary source, an antagonistic source and then you have the later text of it that WW Phelps kind of preserves. So that's, you know, just a tangent on that. And so the thing I would point out though, with the stories in Genesis is that what the Book of Mormon tells us is that it's incomplete, that there's a lot more to the stories than what is recorded in in in the Old Testament, you know that there was saved, that there's not so many. And so there's hints, though, throughout the different verses that you know, there was more plural marriage than, you know, even what we might be aware of.
22:09 So in the story of Abraham in Genesis 25, six, it references that Abraham had multiple concubines. It says unto the sons of the concubines which Abraham had. Abraham gave gifts and sent them away from Isaac, his son, while he which while he had lived eastward in the east country. So he said that he had children, multiple children with the concubines. And we don't really have a full history of that. So, you know, and so there is a situation in the story of Abraham where if God was to tell him that polygamy was wrong, this would have been the place to do it. And that was when Hagar fled because of Sarah's Sarah's treatment of her right and she flees and an Angel appears to her and and well, it says the Angel Yahweh. Some argue some some translations argue that the Lord she actually had a visitation of the Lord in that experience and and that's in some of those translations of Genesis 1613 the new standard version translates that as so Hagar named the Lord who spoke under you are my Elroy for she said have I really seen God and remained alive after seeing him so that's a woman in plural marriage having a visitation of the Lord and some if if you get into textual criticism of the Old Testament. I've I've seen people who are into that say that somebody later on and took a lot of these
23:43 instances where the Lord appeared to people in the Old Testament and they were uncomfortable with that and they put the Angel Yahweh appeared rather than just you know, the Lord appearing. So the Angel of the Lord appeared rather than the Lord appearing. So there's different scholars who comment on that and it says it's and Theodore Lewis commented on that passage, commenting on Elroy and how it should be interpreted as both metaphorical, as in God favoring Hagar and physical as in Hagar seeing God in a non lethal way. And you know that was the big concern in the Old Testament is can I see God and live?
24:23 So again going on to the story, so this is in Genesis 16. Does the Angel tell her to not go back to polygamy and that you know you should marry someone else? If you read that story, the Angel tells Hagar that she should return and continue to live plural marriage. So Genesis 1619 says, And the Angel the Lord said unto her, return to thy mistress and submit thyself under her hands. So And then we know that Abraham was blessed to the Lord. And this is in Genesis 26 verses 4:00 and 5:00. And I will this is the Lord saying, I will make thy seed to multiply as the stars of heaven. I will give unto thee thy seed all these countries, and in thy seed shall all the nations of the earth be blessed, because that thou that Abraham obeyed my voice, and kept my charge, my commandments, my statutes, and my laws. So does that sound like Abraham was disobeying God's law and living little marriage?
25:19 I I don't think so. No, no. And and you know, we just, we just went on a a tiny little tangent there where we talked about was it the Lord that appeared to Hagar or was it an Angel of the Lord that appeared to Hagar. Guess what? At the end of the day, doesn't matter, right? For this, for this argument, for this conversation, right. Whether the Lord says go down and talk to her or, you know what, I'm gonna go do this myself, doesn't matter. Same message is conveyed, right? And so their argument from an Old Testament standpoint, sure, it's weak, right? And I get what they'll say is like, 'cause they're going kind of going down these roads, well, that was the Old Testament.
25:59 That's the Old covenant. We're working on a different covenant now, which I would contend defeats the purpose of a restoration. But whatever floats your boat there. Well, it seems like one of the beautiful things with the Restoration is it's about taking both covenants that the, you know, a lot of Christians kind of throw out the Old Testament. But Joseph Smith and you know, the other early brethren of the Restoration taught that we need to take both the Old Testament and the New Testament. You know, it's all the word of God and all should be taken seriously by us. So, you know, one of the one of their arguments against DNC 132 is they say DNC 132 says that Isaac was a polygamist. But there's nothing in Genesis to indicate that Isaac was a polygamist.
26:42 I'm I'm sure anyone who's encountered a a person who's trying to explain why they reject DNC 132 that as as being legitimate revelation that that will be one of the things they mentioned. So I actually, you know there's actually a couple verses like I said, we don't have the full story in Genesis. There's a couple verses that imply that Isaac had a larger family than what we are told in the story of Jacob and Esau. So in Isaac's blessing to Jacob and Jesses 2729 it states let people serve thee and nations bow down to thee, thee Lord over thy brethren, and let thy mother's sons bow down to thee. Cursed be everyone that cursed thee, and blessed be he that blessed thee.
27:32 So it seems there's a reference to him having other brethren, not just one brother and thy mother's son, so multiple other sons than Esau. So that is a clear indication that you know that Isaac had a larger family than just Jacob and Esau. And then additionally, some translations of Genesis 2614 state that Isaac had quote possessions of flocks and herds and a great household. So that's an interesting statement, A great household. I wonder if having lots of, you know, multiple wives and children would be considered a great household, or only having two children and one wife would be considered a great household.
28:13 So I. I got a question for you, Jacob. OK. Why we're talking about the Old Testament. How normal was it during Old Testament times? Right past Abraham? Once you get into the establishment of the Kingdom of of Israel, how commonplace is plural marriage in those days? I I won't be able to say because I'm I'm, I, I I don't have those details. But I would say it's common enough that the Law of Moses it gives multiple provisions regarding plural marriage and and you know multiple different places. There's the stick. Yeah. Do you want do you want to go into those or or do I keep focusing on Genesis?
28:57 First, let's let's keep focusing on Genesis. But I wanted to make a point here, which is the absence of someone coming right out and saying, and this is, this is Isaac, and here is all of his wives, right? They wouldn't do that if it was the norm, right? It wouldn't say, you know, if it's not an outlier, they're not gonna make reference to it. It's normalized, right? And so a lot of times what what these folks will do is like, why is it we only have accounts of where polygamy goes wrong in the Bible? Well, 'cause those are probably the outliers, right? Those are. Those are the exceptions to the rule, not the rule themselves. Does that make sense? Yeah.
29:37 And I I I think that's a very good point to make. And I think you know the stories that we're told in in Genesis are, you know, it's it's not about a comprehensive history of each person's life, but it's about stories that were preserved because they related to the, you know, the founding of Israel. And these were like important, you know, historical aspects to, you know, with the story of Ishmael and and Hagar, you have to have that story to explain these other peoples, right. That that came from Hagar and you know that, you know you gotta look at the context. You know why different things are included. You know and it you know, I think you're absolutely right that there's a normative aspect of it where you know where where it's so normal that it isn't, you know always mentioned in detail. So when we, when we come down to Jacob, I think that's where it's, you know, very explicitly polygamous where these women are referred to as wives explicitly in the text. You know, there's a couple places where Hagar is, I think, but I think in the case of Jacob, there's a lot more. And you know, you read that story and people say, well, he was tricked into it, you know, and and that doesn't mean that it was of God.
30:54 But even if he was tricked into marrying the the wrong sister, you know, he could have just made do with that and just been accepted. I'm a monogamist. I need to be faithful to the one woman that I'm married to. But no, he he, he knew that according to the provisions of the law that he was allowed to, you know, still marry the woman that he wanted to marry, even if he ended up actually marrying someone else. Right. So I'm not going to go too much detail into the story of Jacob, but there is one verse that's I think very significant and it's the story of, you know, it's a jest is 30 or 17 through 18 and God hearken and Delaya and she concede and bear Jacob the fifth son. And Leia said God hath given me my hire because I have given my maiden to my husband.
31:42 And she called his name Issachar. So he said she's explicitly saying that God's blessing me with children because I gave my maiden as a wife to my husband. And so at the October 1869 general conference of the church, there was some hardcore sermons that were given on plural marriage in defense of plural marriage And Orrison Pratt gave a good sermon. George A Smith gave a good sermon. George George Cucan gave a good sermon. And in Orrison Pratt's sermon he he mentioned the specific verse, and he said another proof that God did not disapprove of a man having more wives than one is to be found in the fact that Rachel, after she'd had been a long time Baron, prayed to the Lord to give her seed.
32:26 The Lord hearkened to her cry and granted her prayer. And when she received seed from the Lord by her polygamist husband, she exclaimed. The Lord hath hearkened to me and have answered my prayer. Now, do you think the Lord would have done this if he considered polygamy a crime? Would he have hearkened to the prayer of this woman if Jacob had been living with her in adultery? So that story is another evidence of, you know, what, plural marriage being something that is blessed by God. So you know, there's, you know, I I think there's nothing contextually in those stories that would indicate that God disapproved of plural marriage, except if someone is like wanting to literally read into it. Look at these bad things that happen in these stories.
33:08 Therefore, plural marriage is, you know, is a bad thing. Well, I I heard the same argument. Somebody pointed this out once. You know, look at the story of Cain and Abel having two children and one of the children murdered the other one. That must show that having more than one child is, you know, something that the Lord doesn't want us to have. You know is what someone said tongue in cheek about that. So we come down to the law of Moses. And you know, there's, you know, the argument that Moses was a polygamist. But I think what's very explicit is in Exodus, the allowance for polygamy in Exodus 21, he said in verse 10, if you take him another wife, her food, her raiment and her duty of marriage shall not be diminished. So that's not forbidding a man taking another wife, but it's saying that if you take another wife, you should not neglect the wife you already have.
34:07 So. So that's another place in Deuteronomy 21 verse 15. If a man's in polygamy and he has, you know, one wife he favors and the other one he doesn't, and they have both have children, it says. And if the first born son be hers that was hated, then it shall be when he maketh his sons to inherit that which he hath. He may not make the son of the beloved first born before the son of the hated, which is indeed the first born. But he shall acknowledge the son of the hated for the first born by giving him a double portion of all that he hath. Where he is the beginning of his strength, the right of the first born is his. So that's saying that if you know if a, you know an unfortunate situation of polygamy where the man is has a favorite wife and he's biased against the first wife and he prefers the, you know, he has favoritism going with the son of the second wife, he cannot disinherit the first son from having his, you know, having his birthright basically you know that.
35:09 So it's it's that shows that polygamy had to be pretty, you know had to be practiced at such a common enough level that the Lord is making this specific provision for us, this kind of situation in polygamy and Orson Pratt common, yeah. He's basically trying to regulate it a little bit, right? The Lord's telling you this is how you live this, right? So it's not don't live it. It it's not even it's not even. Well, if you're going to live it, do this. No. The Lord's just giving you the guidelines, right? So the Lord doesn't seem to be interested in this not taking place. Quite the opposite. Yeah. And and one one thing Orson Pratt mentioned about this was he said that in according to you know the Law of Moses, you know bastards. You know, we're not to have, you know, different, you know, certain rights in the among the children of Israel. And so if if, well, if one of these children was illegitimate because a polygamy, polygamy is illegitimate, then you know they wouldn't have, you know any such rights. But clearly this statement is indicating that both the children of the first child, the first woman, married, as well as children from previous women.
36:24 You know, subsequent women would be considered legitimate in the eyes of God. And so there is the one verse that some some people use in in Deuteronomy to argue against polygamy. If you remember Deuteronomy 1717, where thou shalt a King's king, shall not multiply wives themselves. But when you look at that in context, it's talking about he shall, he shall not multiply wives himself that his heart turn away, neither shall he greatly multiply to himself silver and gold. He shall not. In the previous verse you should not, you know it. It forbids multiplying horses. So it's it's about keeping, abusing his authority right to, you know, increase, you know, having a great amount of horse, having a great amount of wives, etcetera.
37:13 And there is actually some textual arguments that Deuteronomy 17 could have been a later and and a later addition to Deuteronomy that it might not have been originally. That the case is made by some. That when you look at Deuteronomy 17, it's going through the story of Solomon and all the things that Solomon did wrong and writing those things back into the law as things that kings should not do. And so the so the argument is that there's a decent possibility that that was a later edition rather than an original part of the Law of Moses.
37:54 So obviously you know the most common place, but they'll say, OK, polygamy's permitted. Where is it commanded? You Don't you know? Where do you see it? Commanded in the Old Testament is what they will inevitably say if you're having a goodwill discussion about it. And obviously you know the verse that is the most commonly cited for polygamy being commanded in the Old Testament is in the case of liberate marriage in Deuteronomy 25 verse 5, where it says if a brethren lived together and one of them dies and has no child, the wife of the dead shall not marry without unto a stranger, but her husband's brother shall go into her and take her to wife and perform the duty of a husband's brother unto her. So this concept of raising up seed for your brother so that he will have an heir in in the House of Israel, this is something that the early Mormons actually were big on. They talked about this quite a bit and, you know, when discussing plural marriage in in the early Utah period and George Buchanan like, had a son that that lived to adulthood but didn't have any children.
39:01 And he's like, I'm going, I want my other son to marry this, marry a woman for time and have her sealed for eternity to my son. And then the children will represent, you know, the son that died. And this actually goes all the way back to Hiram Smith. Where Hiram Smith explicitly referenced this as a reason for why polygamy would be restored when he read on the same day that he read DNC 132 to the Naboo High Council, he said the so this is recorded in Franklin D Richard's scriptural items notebook. He he recorded that Hiram Smith taught that, quote, the law that a man shall take his brother's wife and raise up Sedan to him, as it was in Israel, must be again established. So, you know, Joseph and Hiram are going through the Old Testament and looking at the scriptural evidence for polygamy.
40:00 And they're not just looking at it. They're using it to try to prepare the Saints to accept, you know, these deeper doctrines that would go against their traditions, right? Right. So I guess, you know, I guess now is a good time to talk about David and Solomon because that's, you know, a hot topic with, you know, how does that, you know, how's what's in the Old Testament fit with Jacob chapter 2. So you know, Jacob chapter 2 says that the whole David and Solomon truly had many wise and porcubines. Which thing was an which thing was abominable before me saith the Lord. And in contrast to this DNC 132 says in verse 39, David's wives and concubines were given unto him of me by the hand of Nathan, my servant, and others of the prophets who had the keys of this power.
40:55 And in none of these things did he sin against me, save in the case of Uriah and his wife. And therefore he has fallen from his exaltation and received his portion, and he shall not inherit them out of the Lord, out of the world, for I gave them to another, saith the Lord. So you know, they they highlight these verses as a contradiction. But these are not actually a contradiction when you look at the previous verse, which also indicates that Solomon actually married certain wives without being authorized of God and sinned in doing so. So verse 38 of DNC 132 says David also received many wives and concubines and also Solomon and Moses my servants as also many others of my servants from the beginning of the creation into this time. And in nothing did they sin save in these those things which they received not of me.
41:43 So the Bible actually holds the key to harmonizing Jacob 224 with DNC 132 verse 39 regarding King David, and it's found in First Kings 15 verse five. It states the whole David did that which was right in the eyes of the Lord and turn not aside from anything that he commanded them all the days of his life, save only in the matter of Uriah the Hittite. So it seems pretty explicit there that David's only grievous grievous sin to the Lord was in the case of committing adultery with Uriah's wife and having Uriah murdered to try to cover up that adultery. So, you know, so there's so the polygamy deniers would try to say first kings 15-5 and the JST corrects this. And I say, why don't you quote the whole verse to me instead of just a tiny portion of the verse. So they'll quote that that that David repented of the evil all the days of his life, save only in the manner of Uriah the Hittite wherein the Lord cursed him. But that's the later half of the Joseph Smith translation. The whole verse says the because David did right in the eyes of the Lord and turned not aside from all that he commanded him to sin against the Lord, but repented of the evil all the days of his life, save only in the matter of Uriah the Hittite wherein the Lord cursed him.
43:13 So fundamentally he's saying David did right in the eyes of the Lord. He didn't turn aside from the commandments, only in this case of Uriah the Hittite. And his sin was so grievous that even though he tried to repent of it, he was cursed and he was, you know, cursed for it, you know so. So I think that you can't argue that Joseph Smith translation changes that verse, if that makes sense. Right. Let me say this, right, going back to 15-5 here in in the KGV, you know, it says that David did that which was right in the eyes of the Lord, and turned aside not from any of the things that he commanded him all the days of his life, save, you know, the the stuff with Uriah the Hittite.
43:54 If David did everything the Lord commanded him, wouldn't that kind of insinuate that he probably commanded him in terms of plural marriage as well? Oh, absolutely. I I think that's a fair inference from that verse if he's saying, you know, David was commanded by the Lord in the things that he did. So here's another key verse regarding the the story of David. So second Samuel 12 verses 7 through 11, wherein the Prophet of the Lord delivers a message to King David once he's fallen. Do you want to read that? Yeah, Second Samuel 12. What? Verses 7 through 11. OK, And Nathan said to David, Thou art the man.
44:36 Thus saith the Lord God of Israel, I anointed thee king over Israel, And I delivered thee out of the hand of Saul. And I gave thee my master, thy master's house, and thy master's wives into thy bosom, and gave thee the House of Israel and of Judah. And if that had been too little, I would, moreover, have given unto thee such and such things. Wherefore thou hast despised the commandment of the Lord to do evil in his sight. Thou hast killed Uriah the Hittite with the sword, and has taken his wife to be thy wife, and has slain him in the with the sword of the children of Ammon. Now therefore the sword shall never depart from thine house be because thou hast despised me, and has taken the wife of Uriah the Hittite, to be thy thy wife.
45:24 Thus saith the Lord, Behold, I will raise up evil against thee out of thine own house, and I will take thy wives before thine eyes, and give them unto thy neighbor. And he shall lie with thy wives in the sight of this Son. You know that that's a pretty strong condemnation there so. But I think what's interesting about the condemnation is that the Lord says that he gave him certain blessings. He said, Thus, saith the Lord God of Israel, I gave thee thy master's house and thy master's wives into thy bosom, and gave thee the House of Israel and of Judah. And if that had been too little, I would have more. I would, moreover, have given unto thee such and such things.
46:05 So Such and such things is a Hebrew phrase indicating more of what he wanted. If. And so this would have been if you would have used it for a righteous purchase. So Lord, says, I gave thee all these things. I would have given you even more if you had been righteous. So, because David became wicked in his doings. Thus saith the Lord, I will take thy thy wives before thy knight, give them unto thy neighbor, and he shall lie with thy wives in the sight of this son. So it's you know the Lord gave David his wives. That's very explicit there in verse verse eight of Second Samuel, chapter 12. And you know, I I don't see how you can get around that. I think that that's very explicit. I think First Kings 15-5 is very explicit. I think the overwhelming evidence is that the Old Testament is a pro polygamy book. And not only is a pro human polygamy, but it God is so comfortable with polygamy in the Old Testament that he even refers to himself as a polygamist and in a metaphor in both Ezekiel as well as in Jeremiah. And he references, you know, when the Kingdom of Judah splits into two kingdoms, he references, you know, I'm it's like I'm married to two women.
47:25 And so if you really think God would use that analogy if he was so against plural marriage. Right. I don't think he would. Yeah, no. If if if God Himself, if God the Father is using that terminology, that's a pretty that's a pretty damning statement to to those who want to deny it and say that it has no place within Mormonism. Yeah so so the verses Ezekiel 23 four it's it's it's an analogy of two women and the older was named Ohala and their sister was named Ohala Beba, Ohala Beba, excuse me for butchering that they became mine and gave birth to sons and daughters that's what I did is Ohala is Samaria and Oleba is Jerusalem. So God's saying these two women in this analogy are the kingdoms of Samaria and the Kingdom of Jerusalem. And then in Jeremiah he talks about Judah and his, you know, the the, you know that that Judah and Israel were, you know, multiple wives to him as well.
48:31 And that's in that analogy can be found in Jeremiah 3, six through 14 and also in Jeremiah 3131 through 34. So I've I've heard some people try to wiggle out of the liberate marriage by trying to say that well it's like a you know only if it's an unmarried brother you know if he's not married then he could fulfil that commandment even though the verse says nothing about him being unmarried. And that essentially would be like it would it would undo the purpose of of the of that provision. A lot of Moses would be robbing Peter to pay Paul by saying that he's got raise up seed for him. And so the guy who's raising up seed, if he can't live polygamy then you know you've got the same problem. Someone's gonna have to raise up seed for him as well. So I I don't buy that argument that's that I think it implicitly implies polygamy in in in that provision of the law and so there's another verse and this one's kind of interesting. I saw it first reference in an anti Mormon expose of what Joseph Smith was teaching in Nabu and he said he's using all these different Old Testament scriptures to argue for polygamy such as Hosea chapter 3.
49:48 And I'm like I've never heard Hosea used to argue for plural marriage and this actually a friend of mine actually said, doesn't the story of Hosea argue for plural marriage? And I realized actually it does, but people don't really want to use that that context of what's going on in Hosea chapter one and Hosea chapter 3 because he's being commanded by the Lord to marry prostitutes or or unclean women, basically whatever. Let's see this says the verse. The verb in verse 1, Hosea 1/2 could say marry a wife or take a woman sexually. Following the later sentence, Hosea was commanded to have sex with two unchased women, Gomer and the unnamed woman of Hosea 3. So he's basically told to marry, you know, two unchased women in these, in these, in these stories. And in either case, the reason for this unusual directive is specified in the later half of the same verse where the lamb commits great quorums by forsaking the Lord. God wanted to provide an illustration of his relationship with the people of Israel who'd been unfaithful with to him by practicing idolatry.
51:00 And so this theme is carried out through the remainder of chapter one and in the discussion of Isaiah's, excuse me, on this discussion of Israel's unfaithfulness in Chapter 2. So, So yeah, so that's he's made two different unchaste women. So that's God commanding polygamy in the case of the Prophet Hosea. So I think we've pretty clearly established that the Old Testament is very friendly to plural marriage. Right. And you know, there's there's really nothing you can of substance to argue against it. What's interesting is getting into the New Testament because this is what most Christians actually acknowledge is I think the old test, the old covenant was OK with polygamy, while the new covenant was was not OK with polygamy. So I I just would like to point out contextually is that, you know, the New Testament was still taking place in a Jewish culture of that time, right?
52:01 Jesus was a Jew. And he was, you know, even even though they were living under Roman rule, they were still under Jewish culture and many Jewish customs. And there are scholars who says who will, who will explicitly state that polygyny continued to be practiced well into the biblical period, and it's attested among Jews as late as the 2nd century CE. And so that's from scholar Michael Cogan, who I I believe is a professor at Harvard. And so the monogamy of the Roman Empire was the cause OF22 explanatory notes in the writings of Josephus describing the polygamous marriage of Herod the Great was permitted under Jewish custom. So it's interesting there that Josephus is admitting that you know that Herod was practicing polygamy because that was Jewish custom.
52:54 And so that's going getting into the New Testament time period showing that polygamy was still something that happened. So I would point out, so Jesus critiques and and corrects various interpretations and understandings of the Law of Moses, but he never corrects the Law of Moses on plural marriage. There's not a word of him condemning plural marriage in the four Gospels in the New Testament. And this is, this is common. You know polygamy deniers will cite theeing. You know there's a commandment in the DNC about cleave to your wife and none else, which they used to argue for monogamy. And there's Jacob chapter 2 in the Book of Mormon. And they cite those as the words of Jesus and like if this is the words of Jesus as the standard for all people in all times, don't you think that there would be something in the New Testament and the gospels where Jesus would say something about it if polygamy was this great wrong that needed to be corrected?
53:54 Absolutely. Here's the thing, right? So often the Savior gets painted in pastel colors in the New Testament, right? He's mild, he's meek. No, Jesus is a little radical, right? Jesus is a little in your face. And and one of the things that that he was very good at was pissing off the religious structure of his day. So if the Pharisees had glommed onto this, if the Sadducees had glommed onto this, why is it he chose to leave that alone and go after everything else? He did not have a problem questioning the religious hierarchy of his day. And if if plural marriage was one of those things that was an abomination in his sight, why not address it? He addresses marriage in a few places in the New Testament. Why not address it here?
54:44 Why not say, hey, don't do this, this, this is wrong. He never does, right? He never does and and that absence speaks volumes in my opinion. Yeah, I absolutely agree. Jesus had a lot of things to condemn about how the Jews interpreted the Law of Moses regarding divorce. He never condemns how they interpreted the Law of Moses regarding polygamy. So I I think that's something that should be pointed now and should carry a lot of weight. And even if you're one of the people who emphasizes the Book of Mormon over the New Testament, you saw it in 3rd Nephi. Jesus doesn't say anything about polygamy in 3rd Nephi against it. You know?
55:25 So, you know in the Book of Mormon there are righteous polygamists and there are, you know, unrighteous polygamists. And there's a lot of emphasis on the unrighteous polygamists and we'll get into the righteous polygamists later on. But my big thing is in the words of Jesus Christ, if if if polygamy was this great evil that was paramount to all these other. You know some of these polygamy Diaries make polygamies being they consider it to be one of the greatest crimes. You know moral crimes that could possibly be done in interpretation of of scripture and the God's commandments. And if, if that was the case, I really think that Jesus would have said more on that, would have said something very explicit on that subject and he didn't. So and in fact, there's some, you know, if you've read Ogden Kraut's book, you know, Jesus was married, there's some pretty compelling evidence that Jesus himself was actually a polygamist.
56:22 Right? You're you're familiar with that book, right? Yep. Oh, absolutely. Yeah. That's standard fairness. Yeah, it it's great. And yeah, I I I like this meme that was, you know, it's it's five guys walking down the street kind of looking, you know, wearing their suits and it's like 5 copies of Jesus Was married please. And yeah, so so yeah, it's a great book and I highly recommend it. And I'm not going to go into all the arguments because you literally could probably do an entire podcast on the subject of Jesus being married. But we're focusing on the scriptures here as there's some scriptural evidence that Jesus was a polygamist, not just the early Mormon leaders saying it, but was there some scriptural evidence to support it.
57:12 And I would say yes, there is in that there's a messianic prophecy about Christ that indicates that the the the Messiah, the Davidic, you know the fulfillment of the Davidic king in the Messiah would be a polygamist. And you find this in Hebrews chapter one, verses 8 through 9 quotes from the Psalm in the Old Testament about the Messiah. So it says but unto the Son He saith, Thy throne, O God, is forever and ever. A scepter of righteousness is in is the scepter of thy Kingdom. Thou hast loved righteousness and hated iniquity. Therefore God, even thy God, hath anointed thee with the oil of gladness above thy fellows.
58:00 So that quote in Hebrews chapter one, verses 8 through 9, is quoting Psalm 45. And if you read that, that's quoting Psalm specifically, Psalm 45, verses 6 through 7. Thy throne, O God, is forever and ever. The sceptre of thy Kingdom is a right is a right scepter. Thou loved righteousness and hated wickedness. Therefore God, thy God, anointed thee with the oil of gladness above thy fellows. But let's continue reading the next two verses. All thy garments smell of myrrh and ello, ellos and cassia, and of ivory palaces, And whereby they have made thee glad, Then, verse 9, King's daughters were among thy honorable women. Upon thy right hand did stand the Queen and gold of Ophir. So what's interesting is this Psalm is a royal wedding. And it's not just a royal wedding, it's a royal polygamist wedding.
59:00 So the King James Version is kind of obscured where it references among by honorable women, but other translations. This is something that Orson Pratt went back and he found a bunch of the older translations of the Bible where all these old translations say honorable wives over and over again. If you go on Bible Hub, you won't find those. You won't find those older translations. But there is still one kind of modern translation that is on there, the New American Bible that translates it that way. So Psalm 45-9 in the New American Bible states, daughters of Kings are your lovely wives. A Princess arrayed in Orpha's gold comes to stand at your right hand.
59:46 So this is if if we take, if we take Hebrews chapter one is authoritative is referencing, this is referring to Jesus. It's indicating that the Messiah would be a polygamist, not just married, but that he would be a polygamist. So, and this is something the early brethren picked up on, and they picked up on that, there's a lot of different places in the New Testament that hint at Christ being a polygamist in the Gospels. So Orson Hyde said this and I this is one of my favorite quotes and I'll throw this out any day when somebody's asking what proof do you have that Jesus is a polygamist? Was a polygamist, Orsenheim said. This he said, if Jesus was never married, his intimacy with Mary and Martha and the other Mary also who Jesus loved, must have been highly unbecoming and improper to say the best of it. I'll venture to say that Jesus Christ were now to pass through the most pious countries in Christendom with a train of women such as used to follow him, bondling about him, combing his hair, anointing him with precious precious ointment, washing his feet with tears and wiping them with the hair of their heads.
1:00:53 And an unmarried or even married he would be mobbed, tarred and feathered and and rode not on an ass but on a rail. So they're saying culturally, these women are acting as wise. We realized in older cultures that, you know, the conduct between men and women was a lot more regulated than in society today, that you know these. And I think actually you've pointed out, you know, different things about the Gospels that would indicate that crisis. Polygamous in previous podcasts as well. Absolutely. So what? Look, one of my there. There is a lot of evidence, especially when you get into the apocryphal works. You you start seeing things like, and we don't have the full translation yet but there are some references to Jesus kissing Mary Magdalene on the.
1:01:45 And then that part of the squirrel was gone. Right. Let's go to let's go to the let's let's go to the. The case of I can't remember if it's Mary or Martha, the one that comes out after Lazarus dies and just tears Jesus apart a little bit. But you remember the story and I'm paraphrasing here so I'm going to butcher it. But essentially Lazarus has died. Jesus is on his way to raise him from the dead. And again it's either Mary or Martha. They come out and they tear into Jesus. I mean, they're like, if you'd have been here, this wouldn't have happened right now. I took a class in in Jewish customs and Hebrew customs, right. And one of the things that that the the the professor pointed out about this story is in this time in history, if you're a woman, you don't do that to a man and especially a religious leader.
1:02:42 Right? The only thing that gives a woman a right to speak to someone like this is if it's her husband. Right. And so the fact that she feels she's got car Blanc to go out there and just let Jesus have it in front of everybody, right? People saw it. It got recorded. Right. Would indicate that he's married. Now let's go just to the resurrection, right? If Jesus isn't married, why is he not showing up to Peter? Right. Wouldn't Peter make more sense to show up to? He's gonna be the rock of the church. Instead he goes to to Mary, right? Mary's the first one he appears to, which only makes sense, right? That that he was married not just once but twice. And there's a third argument there with the feast of the the marriage feast that that applies very heavily that that Jesus is married multiple times.
1:03:40 Yeah, absolutely. And then you know it's not just appearing to Mary Magdalene, but it says that he appeared to the to women plural. He didn't just appear to Mary Magdalene. So there were you know multiple women and with the Mary Magdalene appeared you know that's I I was at an LDS soccer at meeting on Easter Sunday and it was a very cool experience where a member of the bishopric thought I read from the Gospel of John that story of Mary's and and you know, Christ appearing to Mary after the resurrection and the intimacy between Mary and and and Jesus just clearly strongly implies that they were married.
1:04:22 And I I think that's just very obvious and you know, I don't think that's disputed by people among our distinct traditions, so. I'm sure, I'm sure. We're just reading too much into it. I'm sure he was just super concerned about establishing the Relief Society, so. Yeah, but what what's interesting, there's a Joseph Smith translation correction there where I think it says in the King James touched me not and in the JSC it corrects it. And I think this is actually a correction that matches the Greek where it says hold me not. So it's a lot more intimate than just touching him. So you know, pretty interesting. So the I've had people ask however, so if Jesus had was married, if Jesus had children.
1:05:10 Why? Why, why, Why isn't it more explicit in in the scriptures? Why is it, why is it why do the scriptures leave it kind of ambiguous. I think Orson Hyde in one of his sermons actually answered this question better than anyone else that I've I've seen. So he said this. He said, I shall say here that before the Savior died, he looked upon his own natural children as we look upon ours. He saw his seed in referencing Isaiah 5310, and immediately afterwards he was cut off from the earth. But who shall declare his generations? And that's Isaiah 53. Eight. They have no father to hold them in honorable remembrance. They passed on into the shades of obscurity, never to be exposed to mortal eye as the seed of the Blessed One. For no doubt, had they been exposed to the eye of the world, those infants might have shared the same fate as the children in Jerusalem in the days of Herod, when all the children were ordered to be slain.
1:06:04 So. So he says, yeah, they had to be kept a secret lest they would have, you know, possibly been killed as well. So, you know, I thought that was, you know, they might have suffered the hands at the hands of assassin, as the sons of many kings have done who were heirs apparent to the throne of their father. And so, you know, there's obviously. Let's put this in human context for a second, right. Jesus wasn't just a religious leader. He was a friend to many of these men who would who would establish the the the church. Right. They just saw his you know their their best friend get strung up by the world power of that day. Right.
1:06:46 That's like trying to hide from the US government today. It's gonna be really, really tough. And so if you're friends of Jesus, your first top priority is we gotta get his wives and his children to safety, period. And there's plenty of evidence to suggest that that very thing did happen, right? You got things up in gall that would that would kind of insinuate that even some stuff. Interestingly, if I'm not mistaken, in Ukraine where one of the apostles goes to what is essentially modern day Kiev, right. And what's he doing over there? Maybe just preaching the gospel or he's trying to stash some kids. Right.
1:07:32 And so with with these things we we find ourselves so far removed. Right. And and you have to personalize them. What would I do in that scenario, right. You and me, you get, you get haunted down by somebody for living righteously. You know it's incumbent upon me, as as your friend, we we gotta we gotta get his wife and his kids to safety right now. That's number one priority. That's what he would want. You get that done. Yep. And it just makes sense. And yeah, the stuff about Christ's descendants in France and in other places in Europe is, you know, an extremely fascinating rabbit hole to go go down South.
1:08:16 The the new, I would say the New Testament doesn't just indicate that Christ was a polygamist. But also there's some interest, you know, in the in the fact that that that Christ was the literal son of God. It would indicate that his father was a polygamist as well. So we know that God the Father is a married man. But this is, you know, this is something that's not just in Mormonism but in ancient Jewish, you know, the ancient Jewish tradition understood that there was, you know, a Hebrew goddess, and that's something that is well established by scholars at this point. But we from the New Testament, not only is there a Hebrew gods, but we know that God the Father had another child with, you know, in the case of Jesus. And that's not some people try to pin that the natural conception of Christ as being a legitimate son of God the Father as being something that Brigham Young came up with. But a recent recently a a friend, John Peterson, pointed out this this statement by Joseph Smith indicating that you know, Joseph also taught the natural conception. So in Joseph's Plurality of God's Sermon on June 16th, 1844, he said where was there ever a son without a father? And where was there ever a father without first being a son?
1:09:34 What whenever did a tree or anything spring into existence without a progenitor And everything comes in this way. So he said, where was there anything that sprung into existence without a progenitor? So you know, reproduction, everything comes in this way. So the implications of that statement is that Jesus would had a natural conception just like everyone else. And there's actually a recollection of this is by Sarah M Granger in early Utah, she recalled. She was and she was a counselor in the Relief Society general presidency said that her brother Lafayette Granger and the late Bishop George Miller in conversation once with the Prophet Joseph Smith were told by him that when Mary the mother of Jesus was on her way to the Hill Country, she was met by God the Father and the Angel Gabriel and the latter performed the marriage between the Father and Mary. So and that's the Mormon doctrine. You know taking Joseph Smith that God the Father is a polygamist as well-being married to Mary as a as an additional wife.
1:10:44 So you know from beginning to so we've there's so much evidence for polygamy in in the Old Testament and even getting into the Gospels, there's nothing against it, you know, and actually some stuff to imply that Christ was a polygamist. But people go, well look at the epistles of Paul. There's where the the Bible's explicitly against polygamy. And what's interesting is I've I've seen Bible scholars admit that the epistles of Paul are not actually as explicitly anti polygamy as some would want you to believe. And this is actually interesting. I I recall a statement by Dan McClellan and he was actually interviewed. You know he's he's actually mentioned this a a bunch of times he's you know a Larry de St. kind of he's he's definitely very progressive but is when he's not letting his his progressivism seep into his interpretations. His interpretations can be pretty solid on on quite a number of of things with the Bible and he admits that the he admits that the Bible is explicitly a pro polygamous. You know it's it's it's explicitly pro polygamy from beginning to end and and he he says that as someone who doesn't even like polygamy.
1:12:01 He says I don't like polygamy but the Bible is very pro polygamy. That was the world view. That was the culture of that they were in, is what? How he rationalizes it. But he says, he says, except for May. What was that? Go ahead, finish your thought there. OK, he said. Except for maybe in the statement of in, in in in the pastoral epistles. I think this is in First Timothy 3, where it talks about the Bishop being a husband of only one wife. He said and but he said that's a maybe. He he says even that seems to be contextually let him be be the husband of one wife. He says contextually.
1:12:44 He thinks that the early Christian emphasis was that he better be a good faithful married man and he better not have been. You know he better not have been divorced and remarried. Basically you shouldn't have a bunch of failed marriages in his history if he's going to be a father of a congregation. And so that's that's kind of how how Dan McClellan said that's the only verse he could think of in the in the New Testament that is you know that that's questionably you know, possibly anti polygamy. But other scholars also admit the ambiguity. So this is you know this is taken from the Wikipedia article on polygamy and and and early and and Christianity.
1:13:26 It says many critics of of polygamy point to the Pauline epistles that state the church officials should be respectable, above reproach, and the husband of a single wife. The however, the Greek phrase mayas gunak Andra is an unusual Greek construction capable of being translated in multiple ways, including but not limited to a one wife man or a wife man or a first wife man. So A1 wife man would be prohibiting plural marriage if that was the interpretation. A a a wife man means requiring elders to be married, or a first wife man would be prohibiting divorce from the from from prohibiting divorces from ordination.
1:14:14 So, you know, that's kind of interesting. And Brigham Young actually argues, he says look at the context of it. He's saying you've got to be, you've got to have a responsible individual to be a father of a ward. And it's it's about he has to have at least a wife. He has to at least be married. It's not saying that he should, only she should. He should only have one wife. It's the context is all about you need to have a responsible, married man to lead a congregation. Not that you know it doesn't it it doesn't make sense if you're putting a prohibition on polygamy in a verse where you're saying that you need to have a guy who can show he can manage his family to lead a congregation. Because a person who's who's living polygamy successfully can show that he can manage a much more difficult family situation than a monogamist.
1:15:01 So I I personally agree with Brigham Young's interpretation and you know, I I think that's the ambiguity of that, that Greek indicates that you know, there's room for Brigham Young's interpretation of that, in my opinion, not just room, but it seems to be the most credible interpretation in my opinion. On a side note, Can you imagine anything more distressing, 'cause I I I follow Dan McClellan on TikTok and although I don't agree with him on everything, he is wicked smart, right? And I can think of nothing more disconcerting than when he does his videos.
1:15:43 And if my face was on there first about the Bible and then he said, OK, let's see it, I would, I would scrap my pants. I'd be like, I'm done. I retract everything. That's my bag. So. Yeah, So, so I was kind of confused though, because I I was confused why Dan would cite that verse as is possible one place in the New Testament that could be interpreted as as being against polygamy because the more common one that people actually use is First Corinthians Chapter 7. And you know this you this is going to be a fascinating chapter to talk about because the most common verse people use to argue against polygamy is First Corinthians 7 verse 2, which is which states in the King James.
1:16:31 Nevertheless to avoid fornication let every man have his own wife and every woman have her own husband So oh that that's that seems to be almost explicit there but and so I was wondering why Dan McClellan wouldn't use use that as his citation. Apparently that is not a good translation of that verse and the act of credit. I have to give credit to the book that explained this to me. There's it's a book that Taylor Smith actually recommended to me called The Great Omission by Clyde L Pinkelton Junior and he says he's he's not he's not Mormon. He's not doesn't come from an LDS background.
1:17:12 He's just going into the Bible and polygamy and he points out that the Greek is different between every husband should have, you know, you know, should have his own wife and every woman should have her own husband. The Greek actually indicates differently. It indicates that a man should have a wife and a woman, you know, should every man should have his own wife and every woman should have a husband. So you know it, it's it's constructed differently in the Greek. The the Greek words are are different and it actually implies polygamy in that proper understanding. And so there are actually several different translations in on Bible Hub that translate this more according to the Greek. The Young's Literal Translation says and because the whoredom let each man have his own wife and each woman have her proper husband, so it's saying every woman should have a proper husband that that changes that.
1:18:15 Verse a little bit, Jacob. Want more from the Mormon Renegade Podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the Fundamental News Program for free. Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button. And for $5 a month, you can have access to podcast transcripts, renegade exclusives, as well as weekly Life Stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes today. Yeah, and and this comes out in the literal standard version as well. And because of the whoredom, let each man have his own wife and let each woman have her proper husband.
1:19:00 And then the Weymouth New Testament translation says, But because there's so much fornication, every man should have a wife of his own and every woman should have a husband. So every man should have a wife of his own. So it's saying that she should not have another husband. You know, it's prohibiting a woman having multiple husbands. And that's also there's a verse in Romans prohibiting that, but it's saying that it's not prohibiting a woman from being having a husband of another wife, right. It's it's the prohibition is exclusively on the woman to only have, you know, you know to only have one husband not on the husband to have only have one wife. And so understanding that just that just blew my mind.
1:19:43 It just kind of shows you that sometimes you have to be cautious with taking a verse that's face value and you know it. It sometimes might take digging into the Greek to understand or or the Hebrew if it's still you know the Old Testament to. Make sure that that was translated correct. You know we believe in the Bible at if it is as far it is translated correctly. So what what blew my mind even further though is that this book, the great Admission argues that First Corinthians 7 is actually a place in the New Testament where polygamy is is commanded in certain circumstances. And when I, when I read this, I was just, you know, I I I was excited because I'm like there goes the the, the claim that you know leverite marriage in Deuteronomy is the only place in the Bible polygamy is commanded, you know, because this Paul gives another circumstance where he commands polygamy.
1:20:40 So. This is. Interesting. So we're going, Yep, we're in, we're in, we're in. First Corinthians Chapter 7, so continuing, he says. So verse 10, he says. And to the married I command, yet not I. But the Lord, let not the wife depart from her husband, then verse 11. But and if she depart, let her remain unmarried or be reconciled to her husband, and let not the husband put away his wife. And so there's this interesting clause specifically to the the woman, if she depart, she should remain unmarried or be reconciled to her husband, is what he he he directs, and then he gives some counsel. And you know going on into verses 12 through 15 about the case, if you're married to someone, you're Christian and you're married to someone who's a non believer, right. And he says, if a brother have a wife that believe not and she's pleased to dwell with him, let him not put her away. And the woman who had the husband that believed not if she he be pleased to dwell with her, let her not leave him. For the unbelieving husband is sanctified by the wife and the unbelieving wife is sanctified by the husband. Elsewhere your children are clean, but now they are holy. Verse 15.
1:21:56 But if the unbelieving depart, let him depart. A brother or sister is not under bondage in such cases, but God hath called us to peace. So what's interesting is Tertullian, one of the early Christian commentators in the end of the 2nd century, beginning of the 3rd century. He comments on verse 15 basically saying that if you're in a mixed faith marriage and you know and it doesn't work out, basically if your spouse leaves you over you converting to Christianity, in those contexts, they are not under bondage. They are free to remarry. If you know your conversion was the contribution to, you know, your spouse leaving you. So, so, so that's an interesting thing. But then continuing on, he gives some more directions in verse 28.
1:22:45 But and so he kind of counsels men that under the certain circumstances they were in, it's preferable to not be married, right. It's kind of. And some people twist this to be that Paul was pro celibacy. And if you read the Joseph Smith translation of this of First Corinthians Chapter 7, Joseph adds more context to this chapter than almost any other place in the New Testament. In the JST of the New Testament and the context that Doza Smith puts to it is that Paul saying it's better to be as though you're unmarried if you're in the doing missionary work. If you are in the mission field, serving a mission. It's better to not have the distractions and obligations that come with being married. But then he says it is better to marry than to commit sexual sin, right?
1:23:35 Is what Paul says earlier in that chapter. So continuing he says in verse 28, but and if, but if thou marry, thou hast not sin, and if a virgin marry, she hath not sinned. So verse 28 gives seems to be giving a blanket allowance for men to remarry and and and for and for. He said if a woman who's a virgin marries, she hath not sinned. So it seems to be kind of he's having kind of a a different center. So he's kind of basically saying that a man can remarry and he doesn't offer any qualifications. He doesn't say if you've never been married if you've you know only bet you know it you know if your wife you know hasn't left you you know it's it seems to be pre blanket allowing a marriage situation you know allowing men to marry. And so in the situation when you when we go back to the beginning and we've looked at verses 10 through 11 that he doesn't command unmarried men, that they can't remarry only to the women, he says you need to reconcile with your husband or remain unmarried.
1:24:46 And that's in verse 11. And So what happens in a situation if a husband and wife separate? And the husband, because he's not under the injunction not to remarry, he goes and gets remarried, and she's now in a situation where she must either remain unmarried or reconcile to her husband, right? And so in that specific context it seems to be a place where polygamy would be commanded, where a husband is to let his wife reconcile to him if he's remarried based on these directions of Paul and this interesting just just kind of as an anecdote.
1:25:29 This was actually how Fred Collier became a polygamist practicing polygamist. The first time he became entered into polygamy was he became a fundamentalist. He he and his his his wife divorced him over him. So. So and Fred and Fred's situation his wife divorced him over him converting to fundamentalism and he goes and he gets remarried. And then his his wife who had divorced him wanted to regretted divorcing him and wanted to reconcile and so he he accepted her back to be his wife. And so that is actually how he entered into polygamy was allowing a wife who separated to reconcile just as Paul states is you know the direction here in First Corinthians 7 verses 10 through 11. So that's.
1:26:19 Yeah. So that's another place in the New Testament. I mean in the in the Bible, where polygamy is commanded, in the case of a husband has a wife separate from him. He remarries, and if she wants the first wife wants to reconcile, he has to let her. You know, he has to become a polygamist to let her reconcile. So there's some people I just want to cover this real quick 'cause this is a little bit of a tangent. There's some people interpret First Corinthians 7 as referencing Paul being unmarried, but there seems to be a reference to Paul being married 2 chapters later in First Corinthians Chapter 9. And this is an interesting statement because it's not just saying Paul was married, but saying the other apostles were married men as well.
1:27:06 So starting with verse three, my my answer to them who do examine me is this. Have we not power to eat and to drink? Have we not power to lead about a sister, a wife, as well as other apostles, and as the brother of the Lord and Cephas or I only and Barnabas have we power to for bear working. So it's interesting, have we not the right to have a sister or a wife as well as the other apostles as well as the brethren of the Lord and Cephas or Peter? So he's saying all these men travelled with wives and you know, and so it's it's indicating they were married men and it wouldn't make sense. He's saying or or or Barnabas and I, the only ones who aren't allowed to do this, so it wouldn't make sense if they weren't married, right.
1:27:55 Right, so. Interesting. So I I think that basically we're we've pretty made it pretty compelling case that the Bible is pro polygamy, right? Yep. So a a friend of mine, Errol Amy, who likes to say the early Christian writings, actually found a couple places in the early Christian writings that were actually friendly to plural marriage as well. That would just be interesting to mention really quick. So he said Indeed. So listen to Justin Martyr, He said in in his dialogue with Trifo a Jew, he said, Indeed, gentlemen, this one transgression of David with the wife of Uriah, show that the patriarch shows that the patriarchs took many wives not to commit adultery, but that certain mysteries might be indicated by them.
1:28:44 So he's saying that that wasn't adultery for the patriarchs to take multiple wives. But he said that certain mysteries were indicated by that. And so another quote he found that's very fascinating is Tertullian in in a writing he wrote about two O 8 AD. An exhortation to chastity said this, he said. And yet you will say the blessed patriarchs contracted multiple marriages, not only with wives but even with concubines. Is it then not lawful for us to also to marry repeatedly? Certainly is lawful if your new piddles are types or symbols prefiguring something yet to come, or the ancient command increase and multiply. Genesis 128 is still valid in our own day, and not superseded by the warning that the time is short and it remains that they who have wives to act as though they have not. So he said he was trying to say that he interpreted First Corinthians 729 to, you know, the command that's better to not be married in that you know that that statement which we discussed, Joseph Smith said was in the context of missionary work.
1:29:51 So, you know, he he's saying that if the command to multiply and replenish the work earth was still in force, then polygamy and he said taking multiple wives and even concubines would still be allowed if that command is still in force. And he, he was personally interpreting, interpreting it as not being enforced. But you know, we as Larry Day Saints believe that that is absolutely still enforced. So, you know, that's just another interesting verse that goes into all of this and you know, some. So I guess one thing to kind of end our discussion on the New Testament. There's a really awesome George Buchanan sermon at the October 1869 General Conference where he says this. He says it's in the Journal of Discourses. He said, I will repeat a few verses in the 10th chapter of Mark, commencing at the 28th verse. Then Peter began to say unto him, Lo, we have left all and have followed thee.
1:30:52 And Jesus answered and said, Verily I say unto you, There is no man that hath left house, or brethren, or sisters, or father, or mother, or wife, or children, or lands, for my sake and the Gospels. But he shall receive a hundredfold. Now in this time houses, brethren, sisters, mothers, and children, and lands with persecutions, and in the world to come eternal life. So then George Ducan says this. He says, the Lord was so pleased with the faithfulness of Abraham that he gave unto him the greatest promise he could give to any human being on the face of the earth. What do you think was the nature of that promise? That he promised to Abraham a crown of eternal glory. That he promised to him that he should be in the presence of the Lamb. That he should tune his harp and sing praises to God and the Lamb throughout endless ages of eternity.
1:31:36 Let me, let me quote it to you. And it would be well if all the inhabitants of the earth would reflect upon it, said the Lord in blessing I will bless thee, and in multiplying I will multiply thy seed as the star of heavens, as the sandwiches upon the seashore, and thy seed shall possess the gate of his enemies. This is the promise which God gave to Abraham in the hour of his triumph, in the hour when there was joy in heaven over the faithfulness of one of God's noblest and most devoted sons. Think of the greatness of this blessing. Can you count the stars of heaven, or even the grains of the handful of sand? No is beyond the power of earth's most gifted sons to do either. And yet God promised to Abraham that his seed should be as innumerable as the stars of heaven or the sand on the seashore. How similar was the promise of God to Abraham through that made by Jesus as a reward for faithfulness for those who followed him, said Jesus.
1:32:26 He that forsaketh brothers or sisters, house or lands, father, mother, wives, or children, shall receive a hundredfold in this life, with persecutions and eternal life in the world to come. So he said. How similar is this promise that Jesus is making to his disciples? To the promise that God made to Abraham, he said, a very similar blessing to that which God long before had made to Abraham, and couched in very similar terms. It is. It is pertinent for us to inquire on the present occasion, how the promises made by Jesus as father in ages of the world, separate by a long interval, the one from the other, could be realized under the system which prevails. So the system of monogamy which prevails through Christendom at the present day, in the monogamic system under the present, under which the possession of more than one living wife is regarded as a crime, and as being so fearfully immoral, how could the promise of the Savior to His faithful followers that they should have a hundredfold of wives and children in the present life ever be realized? There's a way which God provided, A revelation given to this Church, in which he said, straight as the gay, straight as the gate, and narrow the way that leadeth unto the exaltation and the continuation of the lives, And few there be that find it, because He received me.
1:33:40 Not in the world, neither do ye know me. God revealed that straight and narrow way to Abraham, and taught him how he could enter. Therein He taught him the principle of the plurality of wives. Abraham practiced it, and bequeathed it to his children as a principle which they were to practice. Under such a system it was comparatively an easy matter for men to have 100 full of wives, children, fathers, mothers, brothers, sisters, and everything else in proportion, and in no other way to the promise of Jesus be realized by his followers than in the way God has provided in which he revealed to His church and people. In these latter days I felt led to dwell in these few passages from the sayings of Jesus, to show you that there are an abundance of scriptural proofs in favor of this principle, and the position of this Church is assumed in addition to those previously referred to. It is a blessed thing to know that in this, as in every other doctrine and principle taught by us as a Church, we are sustained by the revelations God gave to his people anciently. One of the strongest supporters, strongest supports the elders of this church have had in their laborers among the nations was the knowledge that the Bible and New Testament sustained every principle they advance to the people. And so you know he's referencing how that state, yeah. No, absolutely.
1:34:59 I look, yeah, I'm, I'm with you. I think at this point you can look at the totality within the Old Testament and the New Testament and make a very strong case that polygamy wasn't just something that was acceptable. It was pretty normal in those days. Yeah. And so you know that statement of Jesus about, you know they shall receive a hundredfold in this time of houses, brethren and sisters, mothers and children, lands with persecutions and the world to come, eternal life. So that statement is also in DNC 132, where verse 55, in referencing the blessings that Joseph would receive even if Emma were to, you know, Emma were to be unfaithful.
1:35:48 He said I will bless him and multiply him and give him a hundredfold in this world of fathers and mothers, brothers and sisters, houses and lands, wives and children and crowns of eternal lives in the eternal worlds. So, you know, it's, you know, in the New Testament it leaves off the word wives, but, you know, it's implied in stating, you know, all these different familial relations. Right. And so DNC 132 is, is explicitly mentioning wives in that context. Absolutely. Yeah. Interesting. Just awesome. So Are you ready to kind of dig into probably the Book of Mormon and and plural marriage in the Book of Mormon now?
1:36:30 Yeah, I think so. I think so. OK, actually I think let's just briefly touch on the DNC because there is that one person I mentioned that they said you know that the the polygamy Diaries will use in the DNC to argue against polygamy. And that is DNC 42 verse 22 saying thou shalt love thy wife with all thy heart and shalt cleave unto her and to none else. And so they see this is one of their AHA, you know, just like Jacob Two is their other AHA. But commenting so early, Latter Day Saints who practiced polygamy didn't hide from this verse. They acknowledged it. So commenting on it, Orson Pratt said, Now suppose the members of this church had undertaken to vary from this law given in 1831 to love their one wife with all their hearts and to cleave to none else. They would have come under the curse and condemnation of God's holy law.
1:37:20 And he goes on to say that was what was revealed at that time. That's where we were at according to our traditions. And the Lord had not yet seen fit to reveal the higher law, and so he saw this was a lower law, but a higher law would be given later. So according to Lyman White, Joseph Smith told the apostles, And this is you know why it wouldn't have been revealed at that early date that the principal polygamy would quote damn more men than it would save. And Brigham Young said that Joseph had to pass certain tests before certain revelations were given. And Brigham Young also said the abuse of plural marriage would send thousands to hell. So that explains why the Lord would be cautious about who he would reveal that to. So William Law actually quoted this you know DNC 42 to Joseph Smith when Joseph told him gave him the revelation on plural marriage he said and he recalled this in interview in 1887. He said when I came to Joseph and showed him the paper he said that Hiram had given him with part with DNC 132. He he he Joseph said yes that is a genuine revelation. I said to the Prophet by the book of Doctrine Covenants there's a revelation just contrary to this. Oh, said Joseph, that was given when the church was in its infancy and that then it was all right to feed the people on milk, but now it is necessary to give them strong meat. And so that statement by Joseph acknowledging that is, you know, and he's, he's rebuttaling him by referencing the verse in the, you know, verses in the New
1:38:50 Testament, the reference milk versus meat of the gospel. So you know First Corinthians 3, two states I fed you with milk, not with meat, for heretofore you are not able to bear it, neither are you now able to bear it. So. And then Hebrews 514 says strong meat belongs to them their full age, even those who by reason of use of their senses have their senses exercised to discern both good and evil. So with Jacob two verse 30, there's debate about how to interpret that, whether that is an exception clause or not. And I guess we should probably turn there just to read that, you know, just to read that verse and it's. Let's read it in context.
1:39:34 Let's try that. I know that's not popular with a lot of folks, but let's. OK, yeah, if you want let's. Let's read it in context. Let's make sure we're getting everything there. OK, so let's see where where do you want to start? You you probably read this more recently than me. I've been more. Let's just go ahead and let's let's just start in 30 and let's say let's just go through 34, right. And then that just covers our. OK, OK, so. I'll go ahead and do that for you. OK. Starting in 30. For if I will saith the Lord of hosts, raise up seed unto me, I will command my people, otherwise they shall hearken unto these things. For behold, I, the Lord, have seen the sorrow and heard the mourning of the daughters of my people in the land of Jerusalem. Yeah, and in all the lands of my people, because of the wickedness and abominations of their husbands. And I will not suffer, saith the Lord of hosts, that the cries of their of of the fair daughters of this people which I have led out of the land of Jerusalem, shall come up unto me against the men of my people, saith the Lord of hosts. For they shall not be, they shall not lead away captive the daughters of my people, because of their tenderness, save I shall visit them with a sore curse, even unto destruction. For they shall not commit whoredoms like unto them of old, saith the Lord of hosts.
1:41:06 And now behold, my brethren, ye know that these commandments were given unto our father. Lehigh, Wherefore ye have known them before? And ye have come unto great condemnation, for ye have done these things which ye ought not have done. OK, before you get your explanation, there's a couple things that jump out at me here. OK. Let's let's just look at, at 31, seeing the stars of my daughters. Yeah, in all the lands of my people and the wickedness and the abominations of their husbands, OK, The abomination of their husbands, right. It doesn't necessarily go into what those abominations are in that verse, but in 32 I think it is. Or 33.
1:42:02 Excuse me, I think it might actually give us. Captivity. Yes, lead away, captive. The daughters of my people. I'm just throwing this out there. Could this be a case of men performing Warren Jeffsie kind of acts? And yes, Warren Jeffs, so. So, yeah, like, like, like, so, like, you know, leading the captive of the daughters of my people that, you know, so kind of like sex slavery kind of basically human. So trafficking and those kinds of extreme abuses, right? Yes, yes.
1:42:45 In addition to things like Warren Jeffs did, where he used a most holy principle to manipulate people into being subject to his whims and his desires, Right. I think that could be another form of captivity here. But nothing here really leads me to believe that the Lord is necessarily saying polygamy's a bad thing. I think he's speaking to a very distinct group of people on this. He is speaking to some people who are doing some very direct things and he's got some pretty strong words to say. Do you think I'm off base there at all, Jacob? Oh, I I think that's totally valid interpretation. And you know, even if you go back to verse 23, because that's that, they'll say, you got to start with verse 23 about the word of God burdens me because of your grocer crimes before Behold, thus saith the Lord, This people begin to wax iniquity, for they understand not the Scriptures, for they seek to excuse themselves in committing whoredoms because of the things which were written concerning David and Solomon. His son.
1:43:52 The old David and Solomon truly had many wives and concubines. Which thing was an abomination before me, saith the Lord? Wherefore, Thus saith the Lord, I have led this people forth out of the land of Jerusalem by the power of mine arm that I might raise up unto me a righteous branch from the fruits of the fruit of the loins of Joseph. Wherefore I, the Lord, will not suffer this people shall do like unto them, and fold. Wherefore, my brethren, hear me and hear me, and hearken to the word of the Lord. For there shall not be any man among you save it. There shall not any man of you have save it be one wife and concubines, he shall have none. For I, the Lord God, delight in the chastity of women, and whoredoms are an abomination before me. Thus saith the Lord of Hosts. Wherefore this people shall keep my commandments, saith the Lord of Hosts, or cursed be the land for their sakes. For if I will saith the Lord of Hosts, raise up seed unto me, I will command my people, otherwise they shall hearken unto these things.
1:44:40 So like you say, there's contextual things about this that would imply we don't, you know, just like with First Corinthians 7 we were talking about, you know, there's different, well, there's missing context there. And Joseph Smith filled in the context of First Corinthians 7 explained that Paul was speaking about mystery and work in general. Right. And this seems to be contextually, if you're taking the totality of scripture, you know something they're doing in their practice of polygamy was wrong enough. And I think your interpretation is a fairly, you know, good interpretation. That's something I think we got should give credit, Ben. I think Ben Shaffer was one of the first people I heard argue that interpretation.
1:45:21 I'm not sure if he came up with it or not, but you know that these men were doing abusive things and things that, you know, you could say that there are things that David and Solomon did that were abusive and against, you know, righteous plural marriage. And so, you know, you can see these not citing back to Abraham, Isaac and Jacob. They're, you know, he's saying they're doing awful things like what David and Solomon did. So, you know, I think that's totally a fair interpretation. And so then the the battle, one of the battles is over verse 30, where if I will say at the Lord of Hosts raise up seed unto me, I will command my people, otherwise they shall hearken unto these things. Now, I actually had a fault, a guy who was more in the Denver Snuffer camp and acknowledged that he says contextually this seems to be indicating the one place in the law of Moses where polygamy is commanded. You know, it's it's like this is where the, you know, raising the leverite air airship, you know, leverite marriage would come into play for God commands the people to raise up seed. Otherwise they should hearken unto the sinks. So that's an interesting interpretation. But you know obviously we we saw other verses in the Old Testament that indicated that God commanded polygamy and other contexts And so you know God King, you know Jacob too is not giving you the full story is why. I would say first of all and I would say verse 30, there are people who are antagonistic to plural marriage who interpret this as an exception for polygamy. So I mentioned there was a
1:46:53 person who was more in the Denver Snuffer camp who interpreted it as an exception. And even William Law in one of his later art later letters in the 1880s said, I seem to remember there was a verse in the Book of Mormon that gave a a loophole exception for polygamy and he's like, I haven't read that book in decades but I remember that being there. And so he's anti polygamy and he says it, you know, and he's he sees that this verse seems to be a loophole exception for polygamy. And you know, this is actually something that we can show goes back to 1844 and actually to Joseph Smith, this interpretation. So William Smith, Joseph Smith's brother, wrote A Pro A Defense of Polygamy, A pamphlet defending polygamy called The Elder's Pocket Companion in 1844.
1:47:43 And this was eventually got published years later, even though there were references to it in 1844. But we don't actually have the text until John Sheen. So William Smith's one of the top guys who was working with William Smith when he started a church. Isaac Sheen inherited a bunch of William Smith's documents and his son John Sheen got inherited those documents from his father Isaac Sheen. And he published this Elder's Pocket companion. And in it William Smith quotes Jacob 2:30 as a verse using the different he he lists it with a number of other pro polygamy verses.
1:48:25 So he clearly saw that as an exception clause permitting polygamy. And George A Smith actually said that Joseph Smith also interpreted it that way as well. So George A Smith observed that when Joseph Smith was confronted with Jacob chapter 2 in the Book of Mormon, the prophet cited passage in the chapter that said, for if I will say at the Lord of Hosts raise up seed unto me, I will command my people. And that Joseph followed this verse by saying God has commanded us. So you know that's going back to Joseph Smith. And I think that's pretty authoritative if Joseph Smith interpreted it that way. So you know that that that deals with part of that verse.
1:49:07 So the other part that comes up in in is is a question, is verse 34 references, You know, now behold my brother and you know these commandments were given to our father Lehigh. You've known them before and you've come under great condemnation. So it's kind of vague what these commandments were. You could interpret it as just being, you know, don't commit whoredoms, don't do the sins of them of old. But if you get to chapter 3 and look at verse 5, behold, the Lamanites, your brethren, whom you hate because of their filthiness, the cursings which have come upon their skins, are more righteous than you. For they have not forgotten the commandment of the Lord, which was given unto our Father. That they should have saved were one wife and concubines they should have done, and there should be no, there should not be whoredoms committed among them. So there's a commandment that they said was given to our Father Lehigh that they should have saved but be one wife. So I don't think, I think contextually this wasn't about Lehi having one wife, but the early Nephite population. And this is where Orson Pratt says this was the only time in all of scripture that the that there was a command forbidding polygamy was given to a select group of people. And so this is what Orson Pratt said about it, and I personally tend to agree with his interpretation. He said, let us now come to the record In the Book of Mormon. When the Lord LED forth Lehigh and Nephi and Ishmael and his two sons and five daughters out of the land of Jerusalem to the land of America, the males and
1:50:38 females were about equal in number. There was Nephi, Sam, Laman, and Lemuel, the four sons of Lehigh and Zoram brought out of Jerusalem. How many daughters of Ishmael were unmarried? Just five. Would it have been just under these circumstances to ordain plurality among them? No. Why? Because the males and females were equal number, and they were all under the guidance of the Almighty. Hence it would have been unjust. And the Lord gave a revelation, the only one on record, I believe, in which a command was ever given to any branch of the of Israel to be confined to the monogamic system. In this case the Lord, through His servant Lehigh, gave a command that they should have but one wife. The Lord had a perfect right to vary the commands of this respect, acquaintance of circumstances as he did and others recorded in the Bible.
1:51:24 There we find that the domestic relations were governed according to the mind and will of God and were varied according to circumstances as he thought proper. So he basically saying they were too small of a population at that time for polygamy to work. So he sees it as a temporary command based off of the not having the the the numbers for it to really work. So, and I, I, I personally like that interpretation. You know, it's my personal opinion And it kind of goes along with something that Brigham Young said Brigham Young made this comment about. So people will say, well, how come it's just Adam and Eve at the beginning of the world, You know, if if polygamy is the eternal law, why, why? And so we have Adam having multiple wives, right, according to the Adam God doctrine and they're, you know, each wife gets her own world.
1:52:14 So the question is why does each wife get her own world? Why is there kind of this, you know, monogamy to start things off. And Brigham Young kind of said this about it. He said it is no matter with regards to the monogamy of Father Adam and Mother Eve. They were just enough to start the work of populating the earth. If man had lived as he ought to have lived, the earth would have been peopled quite soon enough and to its utmost capacity. But there is enough upon it now. And if men will hearken to obey the truth, and will cease their adulterous practices and whoredoms, cease their wickedness with the opposite sex, and repent of their sins, we will fling up at once and have but one wife and there. And if there are two or three women left about among us without husbands, we will give them to the best man we can find. The reason the Lord requires His people to practice the principle of celestial marriage is to save those who are willing to be saved, to gather the fear in heart those who will hearken to and receive the gospel.
1:53:07 We have a great many more women than men in this church, because more of them are inclined to believe the gospel. A great many more females than males leave their families and friends together with the Saints. And for this reason there are more women than men here. And they will try to rebuttal this by saying population statistics show that there were, you know, pretty close number of men and women in Utah. But that's not talking about faithful members of the church. Brigham saying that among the faithful members of the church, there's a lot more women than men. And so polygamy becomes absolutely, you know, it becomes a duty to the men to be willing to take righteous women as wives and to raise the righteous posterity with them. And sorry, I I I have my train of thought here. No, you're you're good while.
1:53:55 You. While you get that back, let me say this. The church is still facing that problem, right? It wasn't more than two or three years ago there was an article that came out that said there were more active female members of the LDS church than male, right? Or. And and that in conjunction with that, you had guys who were failing to leave home become men, those sorts of things. And they were lamenting this fact, this. I don't think it's out of the realm of reality to say women are usually way more faithful than men are when it comes to the gospel, right. And and and so we're we're not talking about the greater world, right.
1:54:38 We're not talking about New York. We're not talking about Los Angeles, right? This is different. And we're not even talking about like the state of Utah where the population probably is pretty similar, but we're talking about in the church, right. So it's you have that disparity in the church today. So it would be a blessing if that was restored for the members of the LDS Church today. And so that brings that actually brings me back to my thought. You actually caught my train back, my my mental train back on track. So Brigham Young said when it comes to accepting the principles of the gospel, there are far more women who are willing to accept it than men. So that's something that he anecdotally noticed and I I I find that pretty compelling as well. So, but what's interesting, we have this commandment to the Nephites, early Nephites to have but one wife. But there seems to be something interesting in the story of that Nephi gives at first Nephi about Lehi's family relations. That seems to kind of indicate that Lehi might have been a polygamist.
1:55:47 I don't know if you've had anyone talk to you about that before, or see the see kind of the SO in first Nephi 18 verse 17, it references Nephi saying Now my father Lehigh had said many things unto him and also unto the sons of Ishmael, but behold, they did breathe out much threats against anyone that should speak for me. My parents being stricken in years and having suffered much grief because of their children, they were brought down, yay, even upon their sick beds, they said, because then going on verse 18, because of their grief and much sorrow and the iniquity of my brethren, they were brought near even to be carried out at this time to meet their God. Yeah, their Gray hairs were about to be brought down to lie low in the dust.
1:56:31 They even, they were near to be cast with sorrow into a watery grave. So there's this context, Nephi's painting, this picture of his father and mother being elderly at that point, right. They are elderly but Neath. But Lehigh has two young sons in the wilderness, right. Joseph and Jacob and and so you gotta ask yourself, you know did he have these women with Sarah. And so Sarah, you know, we we have in the story had, you know, the the the sons and and so it would be odd. It would be kind of odd if she would have all these kind of more adult children and then all of a sudden, you know, having. I mean, it's not outside of the realm of possibility I guess, but it would at least be odd for her to all of a sudden be having more younger children in the will. You.
1:57:26 Know all of her children. Will never pick up on. That and and so the theory. Well, at least one theory is that maybe after Ishmael died that Lehigh married Ishmael's wife is 1 potential theory that you know that it's it's speculative. It's completely speculative, but it's plausible, right? And and what's interesting we're talking about Jacob and Joseph is you know, Nephi refers to. And this isn't going back to 3rd what first Nephi 1819. After referencing his parents being elderly, he says in Jacob and Joseph also being young, young, having need of much nourishment were grieved because of the afflictions of their mother. And so he's referencing their mother kind of not he says their mother, not our mother.
1:58:22 So that could be, that could be an, you know, implying plural marriage. I think that's definitely an interesting possibility in this, you know, when you're reading between the lines because, you know, the Book of Mormon makes it clear that it's trying to leave out the higher principles of the gospel, right? It's generally just about the first principles, the milk. You know, the, you know, faith in Christ, you know, repentance, baptism, you know, you know all those, you know, essential first principles. And it explicitly says that, you know, there were things that were being that they were being careful not to include in the record. And so this kind of actually gets to a little, ex the little article that Ogden Kraut wrote on the Book of Mormon and polygamy, which I think is really great. He said he wrote this.
1:59:11 He said it seems rather strange that the Nephites would include in their historical record the 3rd and 4th chapters of Isaiah, which tell about a war so terrible that six out of seven men would be killed and seven women would take hold of one man to live plural marriage. That second Nephi 14-1, quoting from Isaiah. Then the next verse says, in that day the branch of the Lord shall be beautiful and glorious. Such an inclusion would certainly encourage them to accept plural marriage as a desired, correct and honorable principle. But Nephi knew many things he could not reveal to his brothers or other family members. He said I was forbidden, that I should write the remainder of the things which I saw and heard verse Nephi 1428.
1:59:53 And again my eyes have beheld great things. Yeah, even too great for men. Therefore I was bitten that I should not write them second Nephi 425, but I said that he wanted to write more, saying I was about to write more, but I am forbidden ether 13 through 13. This appears again and again in the Nephite records. Mormon explains why only a very small part of the Savior's teachings could be recorded at that time, and this is in 3rd Nephi 26. Starting with verse 6, going to verse 11. And now there can't be written in this book even 100th part of the things which Jesus to truly teach unto the people. But behold, the plates of Nephi do contain the more part of the things which he taught the people. And these things have I written which are lesser part of the things which he taught the people. I've written them to the intent that they might be brought again unto this people from the Gentiles, according to the words which Jesus hath spoken.
2:00:47 And when they shall have received this which is expedient, that they should have first to try their faith, and if it's so be they shall believe these things, then shall the greater things be made manifest to them, And if it's so be that they will not believe these things, then shall the greater things be withheld from them unto their condemnation. Behold, I was about to write them all, which were engraven upon the plates of Nephi. But the Lord forbid it, saying I will try it the faith of my people. And so he's very explicit that he's only writing the lesser things and he's leaving out the greater principles of the gospel. And you know, this goes along with what Jesus said in Mark 727 does not meet to take the children's bed bread and cast them to dogs.
2:01:28 Or you know about the pearls, not casting your pearls before swine. So even though so continuing Ogden Crap writes that even though the Book of Mormon seemed to avoid the subject of plural marriage as much as possible and even the little that was written was half hidden in the wording, many times it would say a man had sons and daughters then describe so. So we're getting into kind of the righteous polygamist. So he says even though the Book of Mormon tries to leave out the higher principles, there's hints at them in the Book of Mormon all over the place. And one of the ways is that there are it's, I'd say, almost explicit references to righteous polygamists in the scriptures in the Book of Mormon. So for example, the Amulek who was righteous enough to have an Angel the Lord appeared to him and call him to be the missionary companion of Amulek, references the fact that he had multiple women in his family.
2:02:29 He said four. So this is Alma 1011 or behold, he hath blessed my house. He hath blessed me and my women and my children and my father and my kinsfolk. So kinsfolk would be like mother in laws and those other relatives that are women, right? It wouldn't be you wouldn't be calling your mother-in-law your women, You know, some of them might try to wiggle out of that. Yeah, even all my kindred Hathi blessed, and the blessing of the Lord rested upon us according to the words which he spake. So that seems to be a very explicit reference that Amulek had multiple women in his family. Jacob, let me let me let me say something here real quick. So I can't remember who it was on the podcast that said this, but I really liked it.
2:03:18 And this is not a knock on the Book of Mormon by any stretch, but what it said was, is that what what this gentleman said was is that the Book of Mormon deals primarily with salvation, right. But the Doctrine and Covenants is a text that deals with exaltation. And so you can see how these kind of played one with another. The the Lord basically said, I'm going to give you another book to establish these, these these lesser principles. I guess I I don't want to call them lesser, but these foundational principles that's probably better. And then we'll we'll move on to the Doctrine and Covenants which deals with exaltation. To me, Alma 1011 is something that's really hard to get around because of the grammar that's used there, just like you were saying you're not going.
2:04:09 He, he's already called out his daughters right by their their title. Daughters that you know you're not gonna call your mother-in-law or your mother your women, right. So what else is there? Right. You're not gonna refer to your sister as that. What else is there? I mean, common sense here would deduce in in In a Mormon context, he's talking about his wives. Yep. And and this is an anecdote to support this. When I started to study fundamentalism and get into, you know, studying plural marriage and all the other doctrines and you know, it was kind of making my family a bit uneasy, you know at the time with me venturing, you know, into the early teachings, you know.
2:04:57 And so my, I was still living at home and my family was doing scripture study and a Book of Mormon in a very big on studying the Book of Mormon. And they were reading the from the Book of Mormon for scripture site and they were reading Alma chapter 10. And they're they're all taking turns reading the verses. And when it came to verse 11, one of my younger sisters read that and she just kind of smirked at me because she and then laughed because she knew it was a reference to plural marriage. So it it's just it was it was obvious enough to her without me having to say it. You know she she saw it for what it was, reading it straight out of the scripture.
2:05:39 So kind of an unbiased witness there. And so riding on that, Ogden Kraut said Amulek must have been a good man because first of all he was instructed by an Angel of God. He had possibly taken his wife some of the widows left from the many wars, and Amulek blessed his wives or women as he called them. And excuse me, and Alma had blessed his wives or his women as he called them, Amulek was recognized as a righteous man by God, and obviously he would have lived righteously with these women. So another good example is in the case of the first king of the Jaredites, and the text is explicit that he was a righteous man.
2:06:19 Again, you can talk about the unrighteous polygamists and unrighteous kings in the Book of Mormon, but this is a righteous king who is clearly a polygamist, even though the text doesn't explicitly say it. It just you can tell by the number of children he has. So this is Ether 6, verse 30. And then we'll read from ether 7 verses, one or two, because they can they go together. So he says, And it came, so none of I, I think it said none of Jared's or the brother of Jared's descendants were willing to take the kingship. So they decided to choose Oriah to be the first king of the Jaredites. And verse 30 says, And it came to pass that Oriah did walk humbly before the Lord, and did remember how great things the Lord had done for his father, and also taught his people how great things the Lord had done for their fathers. And it So we then continued to verse Chapter 7, verse one. And it came to pass that Araya did execute judgment on the upon the land and righteousness all his days, whose days were exceedingly many.
2:07:24 And he begat sons and daughters. Yahy begat 30 and one among whom were 20 and three sons, so 31 children, 23 sons. That dude was obviously a polygamist, you know, And then that's me, you know, Ogden Kratt wrote with 31 children, he had to be a polygamist. And if he was a man of righteousness all his days and he had 31 children in polygamy, it must mean that the Lord was not displeased with him or his marriages. So, you know, clearly, you know, he was a polygamist. The Let's see, there's one other interesting place in so ether 14 Two references men in in the Jaredites, and it says, wherefore every man to cleave unto that which is was his own with his hands and would not borrow, neither would he lend. And every man kept the hilt of his sword in his right hand in the defense of his property and his own life and of his wives and children.
2:08:27 So that's just kind of a interesting reference to Jaredites in general practicing polygamy and the but probably the most significant jaredite to practice polygamy would be probably, you know one of the most righteous individuals in the Book of Mormon. So one of the most faithful men described in the Book of Mormon was the brother of Jared. It said of him and there it said of him that this is ether 12th, 19 through 20. And there were many whose faith was so exceedingly strong even before Christ came, who could not be kept from, who could not even not be kept from within the veil, but truly saw with their eyes the things which they had beheld with an eye of faith. And they were glad.
2:09:10 And behold, we have seen this record, that one of these was the brother of Jared. Where so great was his faith in God, that when God put forth his finger, he could not hide it from the sight of the brother of Jared, because of his words which he had spoken unto him, which word he had obtained by faith. So because of his great faith, the Lord quote could not withhold anything from his sight. Wherefore he'd showed him things, all things, and he could not be kept with without the veil. He was so inspired that quote, the things which he wrote were mighty, even as thou art unto the overpowering of the man to read them. So that's either 12/21 and verse 24. Here was a good man, a man whose conduct, who conducted his life as family according to the will of the Lord. He was worthy to raise a large family with many wives, which is what what must have happened as we read that as we read that in Ether 6/20, it states the number of the sons and daughters of the brother of Jared was 20 and two souls, indicating that he too must have had more than one wife.
2:10:09 And so that 22 children would be a lot of women. I mean a lot of children for two women, let alone one woman, you know, to give birth to. Yeah, I mean, look. So that's enough. Back to Ethan Two. If that was one woman, I apologize. I mean, that woman was tough as nails. I mean, holy cow, 31 kids. And then the brother of Jared, 20 some children. Come on. There's no way that this is happening without plural marriage. Yep. So I think that should set to rest that even in the most correct book that there are righteous polygamists there.
2:10:49 And so you can't just blanket, you know, cite all the examples of wicked polygamists in the Book of Mormon as a blanket combination of all polygamy, because we have explicit examples of righteous polygamists as well. Right dude, good stuff. So I guess one interesting thing is in the book of Moses there's a verse that can be read to imply that Noah was a polygamist as well. I'm not sure if you've this is an interesting one. So this is in Moses chapter 8, verse 12 if you want to read that one. Yep. Let me. Let me get there.
2:11:29 Moses 812. OK, Give me a second. I'm almost there. OK And Noah was 40. Go ahead. What's that? Nope, Nope, Nope. That's the right verse. I was just second guessing myself. And Noah was 450 years old and begat Japheth. And 42 years afterward he begat Shem of her who was the mother of Japheth. And when he was 500 years old, he begat Ham. Wow. So is there something interesting said there about parentage? Yeah, the he begat Sham of her. Who was the mother of Japheth? Is that what you're?
2:12:12 So why would he need to? Yeah. So why would they need to say, you know, Wouldn't it just be implied that she was that they were begotten by the same mother if if they had one argument? If he only had one wife, right? But he seems to be pointing to a certain lineage here, right? Making a connection that Shem and Japheth had the same mother. I also find it interesting here that they don't necessarily say Noah's wife, right? That would have been easy to do. That would have been keeping in with the the verbiage of the time in which this was translated. But for whatever reason, they leave that out and they they seem to be making a distinction with different parentage.
2:13:01 Yeah, it seems to be implying that Cain had a different. Not Cain. Excuse me. Ham had a different mother than Japheth and Shem. So this just kind of an interesting thing there that it's that there's more to, you know, there's more to the history of the patriarchs and the prophets in the scriptures than what is at face value. There's always a little bit more. So, you know, it's just a fascinating, you know, little nugget there. That. Someone pointed out to me years ago, so I guess we've we've done a pretty good job of covering not only the Bible but also the Book of Mormon.
2:13:43 And there's, you know, polygamy was sanctioned by God in the Bible and commanded by him. And it was there were clearly righteous polygamists in the Book of Mormon as well. But I think I think there's a fundamental reason why you know these the the certain new movement, you know the the doctrine of Christ movement are so against polygamy. And I think the core issue that is they hate polygamy because they have a modern feminist views and they just and they have extremely negative views towards the patriarchal order. The I it stated in the family Proclamation that you know the man is to preside over the family and righteousness and to be kind of a leader and a guide to his you know to his wives and his children. And this modern egalitarian feminism is trying to tear that down in any way possible And they hate polygamy because polygamy is about having strong patriarchs. You cannot I don't think it's possible to successfully lift polygamy if a husband is not being a righteous leader and strong patriarch to his wives.
2:14:56 So I I do think that that's the fundamental issue and the thing that I find deceptive by people like Michelle Stone where she's like, I'm just concerned with what the scriptures say about polygamy. I only care about the scriptures. And then she will spend hours trying to twist the scriptures out of you know, the, you know twist the story of Abraham twist, you know, you know come up with her convoluted interpretations based off of you know her how how she personally feels about it. And I only mentioned her specifically because she has specifically, you know, well she is a public figure of the movement. I think it's fair to call her out. And because she's she's she's being disingenuous when she says I just care about what the scriptures say because when I have she's quoted Brigham Young statements about you know the man being the head and and leader of the family. Right.
2:15:48 She'll quote those to criticize Brigham and I'm and I and so I one time said I said, well isn't Brigham just saying what's in the scriptures and he just quoting what's what Sarah says about Abraham what you know, Mary Magdalene says about Christ, you know and and she's like, well we have I said this is the patriarchal order. It's what the you know it's all over the scriptures and she goes well we have better views than that now or or she said that she's she said I'm glad that the the church the LDS church has more has better has better views now than what the the scriptures say. And so I'm like you can't pretend to just be about interpreting the scriptures and and taking your doctrine from the scriptures if you don't actually genuinely care about what the scriptures say about marriage.
2:16:36 You can't use this. Say I care about what the. I just care about what the scriptures say about marriage. When you're going to throw away all these scriptures that teach the patriarchal order of marriage. And you know it's it's in the Old Testament, it's in the New Testament. And, you know, some of them fight against the temple. And don't you know we'll fight against the endowment because the endowment as laid down by Joseph Smith and and the apostles after him, taught this patriarchal order. And, you know, but what's interesting is, you know, it's it's not just the early brethren that taught this, this, this goes back anciently. This is what the apostles of Jesus Christ taught as well. And so First Corinthians 11 chapter, verses 2 through 3 state Now, I praise you, brethren, that ye Remember Me in all things and keep the ordinances as I deliver them to you. So it's an interesting reference to keep the ordinances as I've delivered them to you.
2:17:31 But then he says in verse 3. But I would have you know that the head of every man is Christ, and the head of the woman is the man, and the head of Christ is God. So he's laying out the patriarchal order. I'm sure it's just, you know, the society they were in. I'm sure it has no lasting impact on us, Jacob. We could just put that to bed. Michelle Brady Stone is 100% correct. That's sarcasm. So yeah, so, so it's, you know it, that's, you know, one keep, you know, it's all over the New Testament. And some will try to dismiss it as maybe Paul's opinion. But I think the celestial order of marriage is laid out beautifully in Ephesians chapter 5, verses 22 through 28.
2:18:12 Wives, submit yourselves unto your own husbands as unto the Lord. For the husband is the head of the wife, even as Christ is the head of the church, and he is the savior of the body. Therefore, as the church is subject unto Christ, let so let the wives be be to their own husbands and everything Husbands Love your wives. Even as Christ also loved the church, and gave himself for it, that he might sanctify and cleanse it with the washing of water by the Word, that he might present to it to himself a glorious church, not having spot or wrinkle or any such thing, but that it should be holy and without blemish, so ought men to love their wives as their own bodies. He that loveth his wife loveth himself. So I I think that's you know, a beautiful illustration of what a celestial marriage should be between husband and wife.
2:18:58 And you know some people might try to think Paul might have just had his own opinion and might have just been stating his own cultural opinion. But in First Corinthians 1434 he said he said that you know women are commanded to be under obedience as also saith the law. So he's referencing, going back to the Torah, that that's what's you know in, you know, in Genesis chapter 3 and and and in other places in the Torah as well. So Paul. Paul isn't alone though, because Peter also wrote on this as well. So Peter and first Peter 3 says likewise ye wives be in subjection to your own husband's, that if any obey not the word.
2:19:39 They may without the word be won by the conversation of their wives first. Peter 37 that says, likewise he husbands dwell with them according to knowledge, giving honor unto the wife as unto the weaker vessel, and as being heirs together of the grace of life, that your prayers be not hindered. So you know, Peter kind of said that even if your husband's a non member, you might actually convert him by being, you know, obedient and faithful instead of being rebellious and fighting him, you know? And so you know that's something that's all over the scriptures. And you know, it's it's it's in the temple ordinances. It's something that Joseph Smith taught. You know, there's actually a really great Joseph Smith quote on this that he he made in 1838 and I'm just pulling this right off the top of my head. Joseph Smith, Wives, I'm just pulling this up really quickly to see if I can hear it is so.
2:20:40 This is in the Elders Journal, volume one, number four, August 1838. And so this is showing that Joseph Smith was, you know, taught this just as much as the apostles of old did. He says it's the duty of a husband to love, cherish and nourish his wife and to cleave unto her and to none else. He ought to honor her as himself, and he ought to regard her feelings with tenderness, for she is as flesh and as bones designed to be. And help me undo him, both in temporal and spiritual things, one into whose bosom he can pour all his complaints without reserve, who is willing, being designed to take part of his burden, to soothe and encourage his feelings by her gentle voice. It's the place of the man to stand at the head of his family and be Lord of his own house, not to rule over his wife as a tyrant.
2:21:24 Neither is 1 who's fearful or jealous. His wife will get it out of her place and prevent him from exercising his authority. Is a duty to is his duty to be a man of God. For a man of God is a man of wisdom, ready at all times to obtain from the Scriptures the revelations and from on high such instructions as are necessary for the edification and salvation of his household. And on the other hand is the duty of the wife to be in subjection to her husband at all times, not as a servant, neither as one that who fears A tyrant or a master, but as one who in meekness, in the love of God regards the laws and institutions of heaven, looks up to her husband for instruction, edification and comfort. So you know that's something that you know something that Joseph Smith taught as well.
2:22:09 And so one thing that's puzzled me and I've I, I, I've, you know, I I kind of was wrecked you know puzzled on this one for a little bit is I occasionally saw statements by about, and this is from the sisters in early Utah about the importance of plural marriage because they said plural marriage would redeem women from the curse of the fall. And I'm like when I've read the curse of the fall, it says, you know, the desire shall be to your thy husband and he shall rule over you. And I'm like, well, but even in the celestial order of things, you know, there's it's still the patriarchal order. So I was like how does plural marriage redeem women from the curse of the fall.
2:22:51 And I wasn't until I was reading the early Brethren talk about it that I actually, you know, finally kind of understood it. And so this is from George Cucannan. He said, I can bear testimony for myself that I know this celestial marriage is a principle which, if practice and purity and virtue as it should be, will result in the exaltation and benefit of the human family, and that it will exalt women until she is redeemed from the effects of the fall and from that curse pronounced on her. In the beginning, I believe the correct practice of this principle will redeem women from the effects of that curse. So it it sounds a bit harsh saying he shall rule over thee. I do think that there is a nugget of truth in that.
2:23:33 In the priesthood, in celestial marriage, It's not being ruled over like in the world where you know you have men who will abuse women and mistreat them and treat them terribly. In the priesthood of God you know you are, you know you. You gain your dominion through righteousness, through long-suffering, and not by, you know, through patience, meekness. You know everything that DNC 1121 lays out, and not by trying to be a dictator and a tyrant. And so, you know, I do think that in a sense that it's also redeeming them from that where if you're in celestial marriage, you know, you should have a righteous husband who isn't being a a domineering tyrant, but it's just being a righteous leader to his family. And so there's this other.
2:24:22 I'm just going to end. This is the last quote I have. This is what Brigham Young said. He said it may be all well enough if a woman can attain faith to throw off the curse, but there's one thing she cannot do away with, at least not so far as I'm concerned as and he shall rule over thee. I can do that by causing my women to do as I have a mind to, and all this time they do not know what is going on. When I say rule, I do not mean with an iron hand, but merely to take the lead, to lead them in the path I wish them to walk. They may be determined not to answer my will but they're doing it all the time without knowing it. Highness, love and affection are the best rod to use upon the refractory. So I I just think there's so much beauty in the family order that God has laid out and you know, being a righteous example and not and and I I hope we can learn from you know what the brethren laid out regarding these principles so. I I want to wrap up here it was there anything else you wanted to touch on before I kind of wrap this up? I got a few things I want to spit out here. Nope, that's good.
2:25:27 Sorry if I've been. No, no. You're you're you're you're good. You, you you put together an excellent argument here. First off, let's talk about lived experiences within plural marriage. Right. I'm a man who has two wives. I promise you, if I mistreated those women in any way, they're strong enough, they would leave. And good. Good for them. Right? Next, I agree 100% with what Brigham has said. I'll just tell you how it runs in my house. I won't speak for anybody else, but we strive for unity, the three of us, me and my two wives. And I would be a foolish, foolish man if I didn't counsel with my wives because they are some of the brightest, most intuitive people I know, period.
2:26:17 Bar none. And I'm blessed because of that. So any dude who rules his family with an iron fist that doesn't deserve to have the wives he's got, I'll just call it like I see it. You counsel with your wives, you are going to be so much better off as a family. That's first. That's the lived experience. I want to talk about unintended consequences for a minute. As people, we get very myopic when something is bugging us right? We only see what's right in front of our face, and we want to remove whatever that issue is. We don't care about the downstream consequences. We just want the thing that's making us feel bad to be gone. But that's not necessarily a great way of looking at it, right?
2:27:05 Because sometimes we have to ask ourselves, what are the consequences of just getting rid of whatever it is that's making us have doubts or making us feel uncomfortable? Let's talk about the UN, the unintended consequences here. And I'm not talking to the DOC folks. They know exactly what they're doing. They know 100% what they're doing. They want to remake the restoration into something closer to their heart's desire, not God's. And I will lay that on the table every day of the week and twice on Sunday. That's what they're about. I want to talk for just a second about to to any Mormons out there who are looking at this and and thinking this might be a good thing, going with the doctrine of Christ group, the unintended consequences are this.
2:27:52 If 132 is fraudulent, as they claim, then the unintended consequence is this. Yes, you get rid of polygamy, but you know what else you get rid of? You get rid of ceilings, you get rid of eternal families, you get rid of anything that was supernal within the restored gospel period. And this isn't a slam on Protestantism. What you get is you get Protestantism with a new book. That's what you got. So if you're thinking about going that direction, understand there are consequences that come with just kicking polygamy out the door. I understand it's hard.
2:28:32 I understand very, very well that it's that it's hard, but it's also rewarding. As Mormons, we're not tasked with just taking whatever feels good, right? This is the restoration of all things. And if it is the restoration of all things, it becomes incumbent upon us to wrestle with the things that are uncomfortable. What what the folks in the with the DOC crowd do by just getting rid of 132, remaking Joseph into something that he wasn't discrediting. The good name of Brigham Young and John Taylor and Wilfred Woodruff is they ignore the scriptural injunction that is given by Paul where he says work out your own salvation before the Lord with fear and trembling. I get it.
2:29:19 It's hard stuff. I've wrestled with these things. But the truth is the truth and it has no agenda and it doesn't care and it cuts where it lies. It simply exists because it is truth. So the likes of Justin Griffin, Michelle Brady, Stone, any of those lot, you don't want to wrestle with it, that's fine. But understand you cannot have the Restoration without this. I don't care what you say. Because as soon as you and Hitch from 1:32, when you and Hitch from good solid history and choose to believe a narrative that quite frankly is a damned lie, all you've done is you've taken out anything that made the restored gospel the restored gospel and what you have left is Protestantism with just one more book. Last thing I'm going to say, if you're one of the faces in the DOC movement, you should be flat ass ashamed of yourself. I mean, you can't the the garbage I see dribble out is beyond a simple mistake, beyond a simple misreading of history. You have to ignore key facts to get to your position. Now if you can lay your head down at night and feel good about that, I question your conscience and I question your, your, your honesty in in all these things. You are walking the same path as Korahor or anybody else that led the children of God astray,
2:30:51 Jacob. Anything you want to add before we wrap up? Amen. I would just like to say that, you know, attacking polygamy is about ultimately trying to tear down the novel restoration that Joseph Smith envisioned of, you know, the exaltation of man. The reality that we are not just great creatures created by God, but we are literally the children of God. And that beauty that we can become like him through obedience to the laws and the ordinances of the gospel and and following, you know, all of the principles that are laid out in the scriptures and laid out in the revelations. You know, it's it's attacking. Plural marriage is about ultimately attacking the temple ordinances.
2:31:35 And the temple ordinances are a vehicle that Joseph Smith restored to bring us into our exaltation. They are important. They are vital. Joseph Smith considered it vital. And you know those who are trying to tear down plural marriage ultimately are trying to tear down the temple doctrine and the Nauvoo teachings of Joseph Smith. They may pick and choose pieces they like. They might still like a Heavenly Mother, even though Brigham Young is the one who and and the wives of Joseph Smith who followed Brigham Young are the ones who gave you that doctrine of a Heavenly Mother. You might like being the spirit children of God, even though Brigham Young is the one who revealed that teaching of Joseph Smith to the Latter Day Saints.
2:32:18 You know, but the the reality is is you know. You can't just, you know, throw out, you know, a piece of this and keep the rest of it. It will slowly throw the rest of it out. It's it's intended to lead you on a path away from the Restoration and the, I would say the fullness of the Restoration that Joseph Smith enacted in Nauvoo. And so, you know, that's that's my big concern with it. So it's because I'm so, it's because I'm true to Joseph Smith that I am passionate about this topic. I don't really. You know, plural marriage isn't really a topic that concerns me personally. I'm not living it. I don't know if I'll ever be called to live it. I, I, I respect people who are called to live it.
2:33:00 I do believe it is the higher law according to what 132 says and according to what the prophets explained about it. For me, my passion is I I I want to be true to everything that Joseph Smith restored. And I I hope that all of us in the Restoration have that same kind of passion for loving Joseph Smith and loving the things that he taught. Absolutely, dude. As always when we talk, good stuff, You do your homework, you're well put together. I appreciate it, man. Well, thanks for having me on. I really enjoyed preparing for this 'cause you learn things as you put stuff together, so. Absolutely. All right, man. All right, everybody.
2:33:40 We'll see you next time. Bye. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox