Episode #121: The Life & Times Of John W. Taylor Part 5-Inquistion & The Emergence Of Mormon Fundamentalism W/Michael Ness
Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content
So here we are at the conclusion of the series on the Life & Times Of John W. Taylor. As Michael Ness finish up our conversation there is some amazing historical information dropped that should forever change the conversation around how much Joseph F. Smith new about Post-Manifesto Plural Marriage during his administration. We then dive into the fall out of John W. Taylors excommunication, Francis Lyman’s inquisition of those living and solemnizing plural marriages and along the way there is some pretty pointed questions asked about Mormon hierarchy during this time, and we wrap it all up by talking about what John W. Taylors impact was on not only Mormon Fundamentalists but also the LDS Church as well. That’s next on this episode of the MRP.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:04 So here we are at the conclusion of the series on the Life and Times of John W Taylor. As Michael Ness and I finish up our conversation, there's some amazing historical information drop that should forever change the conversation around how much Joseph F Smith either know, knew, or didn't know about post manifesto plural marriage during his administration. We then dive into the fallout from John W Taylor's excommunication, Francis Lyman's inquisition of those living and solemnizing plural marriages. And along the way there's some pretty pointed questions that have to be asked about Mormon hierarchy during this time. We then wrap it all up by talking about what John W Taylor's impact was not only on Mormon fundamentalist, but also the LDS Church as well.
0:46 That's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast. Look, it's no secret that our society has become much more crude and coarse. To become and raise men and women of virtue and character is a Herculean task. To help with this, I've recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior and Company and Conversation. It was a book with 110 rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society, something that today's society is sorely lacking. What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So the book is laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule.
1:31 Right below that is my explanation for the 21st century, and below that you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, to go along with this, there's a workbook that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids. To find the book, go to mormonrenegade.com. Go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post, and order your copy today. I can bear personal testimony from personal experience that this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character.
2:32 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Dude, Part 5, the last episode the last. Installment I hope you're ready for this roller coaster. We're in the home stretch. Dude, you look, I've had to deal with this for a little while now, so I'm going to do this to everyone else out there. You're going to want to listen to this really closely because there's some stuff here that's going to kind of blow your mind a little bit as we wrap this up. So this, this ought to be good stuff. So Michael, as we as we ended last episode, we kind of ended with with those resignation letters that that were really prepared for for Taylor and and Matthias Cowley.
3:22 And it was done in in, in my opinion, in a really dirty way, 'cause it was like, look, this is just in case things get bad, right? This is like break in case of fire and just like six months later, they're like, oh, the fire's here, Sorry you guys got to go. But don't worry, we'll bring you right back in and that's kind of where we left off at there with that. Yeah, they held on to those resignation letters for six months. They were prepared in October of nineteen O 5 and they were released in April conference nineteen O 6, which we're going to get to in a minute. So we know they're already there. It's it's been left up to Reed Smooth's discretion whether to use them or not. But we also went over how Reed Smooth started to get telegrams and letters from Joseph F Smith through George Reynolds or George F Gibbs, who were Secretaries to the First Presidency, saying the Lord will bless you if you don't sacrifice these brethren.
4:22 Right. Anyway, we're going to, we're going to get into that in just a second, real quick. I wanted to go over 3 characters names real quick that will appear just for a refresher, so you understand. So we understand what their positions were in the church. There was Joseph W Summer Hayes who was a general board member of the YMMA and he took his fifth wife as a post manifesto wife and he was a traveling companion of Joseph F Smith. During this time period and during the last episode we covered how Joseph Summer Hayes travelled with Joseph F Smith and Matthias F Cowley and I think John W Taylor up to Canada. That when they went down to the Bighorn Basin in Wyoming where Matthias Cowley performed a plural ceiling for the state President Byron Sessions.
5:11 And then they went down to Mexico traveling together and Joseph F Smith gave Summer Hayes a charge to perform a plural marriage for a Bishop Sears. Another character that will appear a lot in the next in this episode and has been around and the others is Joseph M Tanner who was the general Superintendent of church schools and he took his first plural life post manifesto. No I don't think it was his first plural life but he took his first post manifesto plural life in 19 O1. And Henry S Tanner see if Joseph M Tanner and Henry S Tanner they are probably related. I don't know that for a fact. They don't seem to be super near relations. I just want to lay that out so that they're not confused. So Joseph M Tanner is a general Superintendent of church schools.
6:02 His I believe, I believe his sister married or Nathan Clark's sister. He married Nathan Clark's sister. So that's important I believe later or during this time period. And Henry S Tanner was a local 70s president. He was a judge and he takes his second and third wife in 19 O1. He was. He was. I found out today the former mission president of California before Joseph E Robinson, who we've discussed at length, was the mission president of California who he was, he was setting up Roger Clawson, right. Remember that with the hotel rooms, with his post. Second Manifesto wife Henry S Tanner also served another mission for the church after he was released as mission president in the northern, in the Northern States Mission. And he had two wives sealed to him by Matthias Cowley up to this point.
6:53 Nice. OK, so that's what I wanted to cover there. Now moving back into the narrative, right. So into the new year 19 O 6 the bad news Apostle Mariner W Merrill dies on February 6th 19 O 6 Some information on on Mariner Merrill to have the last word on him because he'll no longer really appear in this narrative. I discovered the reason I think I believe why he was so adamant about his position on maintaining celestial plural marriage despite the manifestos. He he was born in Canada, a non member. He joined the church in 1853 of when he when missionaries came and taught him and then he moved to Utah.
7:39 He became a Bishop up by Cache Valley and then he became the temple president of the Logan Temple before he was ordained a member of the Quorum of the 12th. But the reason he joined the church was because when he was a young boy, he had a vision where he saw himself and other members of his family living plural marriage. And as a boy, young boy or a, you know, teenager maybe, maybe younger than that, but you know, And so he went and asked his mom, you know, mother, why don't we live polygamy like the patriarchs in the Bible? And she didn't have an answer for him. And he just kind of kept it under his hat. What I read earlier about that is he was told not to reveal more about what he knew about that from what he was shown in his vision.
8:29 But he he asked, he asked that question to his mom, Why don't we live plural marriage like they do in the Bible? And so he knew that he knew by a revelation from God that that principle was holy. And so when he was taught by the elders as a young man, he joined the church because he found these people that were living this way that he, that God had showed him as a young man or young boy. And so he was all for it, you know. Then just he knew that was where he needed to be and he moved to Utah. So I can see with that development in his youth why he would be a die hard for the principal. Oh, yeah, because that's, you know, that's that's a direct revelation. And that's one of those things that that was a recognizable trait, right. And we could see why.
9:16 You know, if the Lord, if the Lord was quote after him, so to speak, that would be a dead giveaway. There weren't too many other Christian Sikhs of the time, you know, promulgating plural marriage by any stretch. The other thing that I wonder about is his mom must have thought, what are you talking about, son? I mean, this is Victorian America, right? So, So when you're when you're you know 12 or 13 year old runs up and like why aren't we doing this multiple wives thing that that must have like freaked her out a little bit I would imagine. I I wish I would have done the family history on this, but he I am descended through like a brother or a cousin of his. OK.
10:01 And so that that is like I'm not church royalty, but that's like the closest I am to to church you know leadership in in my own family is through brother Meryl. In any case, that's fun. And so it makes sense why he would be one of those to write in his journal after the first Manifesto. I do not believe the manifesto to be a revelation from God, because he had it on authority from God himself that that was the principle to live. Yeah, And as we covered earlier, he he was the first apostle to perform a plural marriage in Utah, after the First Manifesto as well. Nice. Nice.
10:41 Well, you could see why it would be near and dear to his heart, right. And in some ways watching this come to pass, you know, the manifesto and stuff it it. That must have been hugely disconcerting for him, right? Because oh sure, this yeah, he he that was the entry point. He he refused to play ball with any of the politics afterwards either, like when people are being called into the stand and when you asked what the scope of it was and they were kind of being very political and even lying, he's like, no, absolutely not. I'm not going to be involved with that. Yeah. Wow. Wow. Yeah. No, I get it. Doesn't make me feel so alone. That's how I ended up joining.
11:24 Fundamentalism was at first so. Anyways, I just like to shout out and thank you to to Brother Merrill for all of his diligent hard work up to that point. Moving on, we get into the the Judson Tolman marriages, so we know now that Matthias Cowley and John W Taylor have signed the resignation letters. But on February 14th, 8 days after Brother Merrill dies, state patriarch of Davis Steak Judson A Tolman, who is age 79 at this point, marries his fifth wife in Bountiful, Davis County, Utah, at the residents of another state patriarch named Samuel Bryson by ward of Bishop of West Bountiful Ward.
12:17 Dan Muir. Super Interesting Muir. Dan Muir. Muir. Muir. Oh, OK Dan Muir has a brother named Leo J Muir, who many years later, when ruling Allred, was getting involved with the fundamentalists and was pursuing a testimony of the principal and struggling with that and trying to get his wife to come along. You know, and I don't know if you know this, but ruling Allred separated from his first wife because she would not follow him down that road in any case. She reported him to their state president in California, who was Leo J Muir, who was, you know, the brother to this guy that that married Judson told him to his fifth wife and brother.
13:10 Leo Muir pretty much gave it, you know, pretty scathing, you know, instructions and even publicly it was like we are not entering into plural marriage anymore and all of this. And he told Rulon Allred that you're going to be excommunicated if you follow this route and all of that and basically entirely discouraged him. And then Rulon Allred again. This is according to Rulon Allred's You know, you can find this in treasures of knowledge and telling the story, he then tells President Muir. I have a testimony of this and God revealed it to me, and it's at that point that Leo J Muir says, God bless you, Brother Allred, I hope that he'll protect you. Holy cow. Yeah, I mean just the, I mean the the, the, the kind of going from 1 extreme to another on this where you got to keep the public face, right?
13:59 So you got to like, really give it to him. And then you almost have whiplash when they turn around. Be like, OK, you're willing to to go through the fire for this. God bless you and off you. Yeah. So it's like it it it's like the test you know and the AUB does this with converts is they'll give you the cold shoulder when you when you express any interest and they want you to knock down their door over and over and over again before they you know pretty much allow you to have any progress investigating. You know it's it's kind of a that that test thing. You know the CU, are you truly committed? And obviously brother Leo, Jamie were had knowledge of what was going on at least in his brother's life previous decades earlier, which we're covering now. Right.
14:43 And so when he saw that ruling, Alwyn had a testimony, You know, the facade dropped. Right. OK, so that's a fun little little story. You know, and and this is something that I've seen that's kind of overarching through this, this time period in history, but I still think it's the test today, right? Where if you're coming out of the church, you are very much like Adam and Eve, right? You have essentially been given 2 commandments that can't be obeyed simultaneously, right? One is, you know, follow the prophet at all costs, and then the other is, you know, to live this principle or get OK with this principle, which requires you to to be like, OK, so which one is it? It's very much the same kind of test that Adam and Eve faced in the garden.
15:42 I think so as well. So back to Brother Tolman about four years after all this, he, you know, because he gets exposed and he's eventually excommunicated when he's being interviewed by the 12. They ask him, did any member of the 12 or First Presidency give you authority to do this thing, meaning the marriages that he's going to be involved with. And he said no, Sir. Now that's fascinating to me because I we're going to go over the the evidence. I think that points to the fact that Matthias Cowley and John W Taylor set him apart to do that because they were not. He's not lying by saying no Sir, because they were not members of the form of the 12 right at this point.
16:27 Right. So they ask him. Go go. Go ahead, finish your thought. I was. Just gonna reiterate. Who? Who was? Who was? Was Joseph Smith still profit at this time? Yep. Absolutely. A part of it could be, you know, and and this is, this is something else to keep in mind as well here, right, is that this is a time period within the church. Now I think we've entered that point to where the house is divided against itself. Yeah, it is. And. So it very much is. In in some ways, I wonder if by him answering that he's trying to protect the president of the church, he's trying to protect members of the 12, right.
17:11 I mean this well, there's where it's really cloak and dagger at this point. I think even within it is in within the church. There's there's circumstantial evidence that he was protecting John W Taylor and and and Joseph F Smith and especially Joseph F Smith and because there's circumstantial evidence that Joseph F Smith was involved and protected other men that he helped that Tolman officiated for. And we're going to cover that. But yeah, he him answering no Sir to that question is, you know, pretty interesting because we know that Judson Tolman was five years previous to this at the meetings that John W Taylor was having, which were David West Jeff's called patriarchal meetings and Judson Tolman told him in 19 O1 told David West Jeff's you will enter into the principle of plural marriage, you know, prophesying, prophesying to him.
18:04 Right. So we have that connection. You know, John W Taylor had a home in that stake. Judson Tolman was going to those meetings. He's now performing these plural marriages in that stake where John John W Taylor has a house and was living for years. Anyway, we'll come back to that. February 21st. 19 O 6 is when Joseph W Summer Hayes goes down to Mexico to marry to basically fulfill the Commission that he got from Joseph F Smith to marry a second wife to William G Sears.
18:44 According to D Michael Quinn, President Joseph F Smith was pretty upset that Summer Hayes delayed the ceremony from the time that they took the trip together till this point that he actually officiated. The reason that Summer Hayes delayed was because she had not yet received her endowments. And I guess under the circumstances, Joseph F Smith's opinion would be that it was more expedient to get married than to make sure that that it was done in in the order that it's normally ideal and. That that brings up a question I I want to ask you. Sure. Throughout history, and I'm not talking just this time period, but maybe even going back to to Joseph Smith's time period.
19:25 What was it always customary that a woman takes out her endowments first before she gets gets sealed? Or was there some flexibility there in that? I mean, Joseph Joseph Smith definitely was having those marriages done for himself before they were administering endowments, OK, To everyone. You know, there was the holy order and there was people who and like the apostles and those in the inner circle, them and their wives started to get their endowments like the last year of Joseph's life. But we know he was teaching polygamy the last three years. Right. You know, And so, yeah, there was that was happening before. And even on the plains, westward, and on the way to winter quarters and to Utah, plural marriages were being solemnized to people who had not received their endowments yet. OK, all right.
20:15 I just find that awesome because I think a lot of us are raised with the LDS customs, right? And and I've seen it within fundamentalism and it made me go back and look and I couldn't find it anywhere either, where where it was ever said it has to be in this order, it doesn't seem. I think it's. I personally think it's more ideal to have your endowment first. But I know a fundamental I know, I know a fundamentalist leader who told me specifically his thoughts were that you should not have your endowment until you enter into the principle interesting. That's then that's those that was, that was his take on it. Interesting.
20:57 OK, interesting. I tend to be somewhat libertarian so to speak on this where I'm like, look, this is probably not A1 size fits all answer as far as the order of things right and circumstances have to play a part in that. I agree. I completely agree. So yeah, so Joseph W Summer Hayes performs at Ceiling Down in Mexico. This was brought up to the Formula 12 when they started investigating new plural marriages a few years later. And basically Joseph F Smith went to Bath for Joseph W Summer Hayes and Bishop Sears and they were exonerated. They were never excommunicated.
21:42 Neither of them were ever excommunicated. That was in 1910, and on the heels of that, around 1912 President Smith. This is according to D Michael Quinn, President Smith told Joseph E Robinson, whom he had allowed to begin a polygamous courtship in September of nineteen O 7 quote. It is hard to make some people see the difference between cases that you will permit this one but won't or can't. That or yeah, but that one, Yeah, so. It's. Interesting. So yeah, Joseph F Smith went to bat for them and got them off the hook. He was not able to do that in every case.
22:23 What? What? Let me ask you this, who are the ones that are really pushing for the excommunications? Well, that's where it gets. Tricky, because in 19 O 9 on you know, which is what would have brought up these these things, Joseph F Smith authorized Francis M Lyman and another apostle or two, I think James E Town, which was one of them to start investigating new plural marriages and to start excommunicating members of the church. Who? Were doing that. And and this is happening at the same time period where where Joseph F Smith is, is okaying some of these. Right. And so President Smith tells Robinson, it's hard to make some people see the difference between this case or that case, how it can be allowed this case or can't be allowed or won't be allowed or encouraged in this case.
23:08 In another case, we're going to get down later down the road. There's a journal entry from Joseph Robinson as well where he says that President Joseph F Smith and Anthony H Lund and I understand each other. OK you know so it can't it's it's like Joseph Smith was telling some people one thing like these guys. Summer Hayes, Robinson, the Tanners, Joseph Musser, they're getting encouraged. But when the threat to the public face of the church is is is there, he tells the official arm of the church being led by the the quorums of the church And their presidents like Francis M Laimaniecco take care of this.
23:53 They're breaking the rules of the church. And I I can see why because he'd kind of have to be forced to acknowledge it, you know, otherwise it would look suspicious, you know. And SO11 historian noted that Joseph F Smith divided was actually responsible for dividing the church against itself because he had two distinctly opposite motives. One was to preserve the legal identity and the physical state of the church, and the other goal was to perpetuate plural marriage no matter what. And at this point in time, those those two things could not be reconciled. But he even basically those who wanted to fall into the camp of preserving the church no matter what he's told them, do whatever you need to do to preserve the church, no matter what. And to those preserving plural marriage, he said preserve plural marriage no matter what.
24:47 That's what it looks like. Wow. Now let let me ask you this question. During this time period, is Joseph F Smith signing off on every one of these plural marriages? Because we know for our last one of our last conversations, we know that he compartmentalizes this right? He makes sure it looks like he makes sure that that that in this case, you know, the left hand doesn't know what the right hand is doing, so to speak, for plausible deniability. So is he, is he Privy to every one of the marriages that John W Taylor is performing, that Matthias Callaway is performing? Is does he look at them and say, OK, they're more mature within the quorum and they can they can they have discernment good enough to tell if this is going to be good or bad or whatever?
25:37 So I will comment on that by remarking, Do you remember John Taylor's stance in the 1880s when he was subpoenaed into court to testify And he basically says, I have studiously avoided knowing these things and I don't know if that was exactly Joseph SF Smith's stance. It would definitely not be accurate to say that he knew of all of these indications, especially because you have people entering into solemn covenants without another officiator going on like Don Maro and I, Lebaron and and others who were doing it that way. And maybe he knew about those, maybe he didn't, maybe he encouraged that Joe John W Taylor later and we're getting ahead of ourselves. But.
26:27 He said to the. Formula 12 when he was on trial that he had never married anyone without the permission of President Smith. OK. Now, D Michael Quinn, if I recall, and his work on this says that that might not have been entirely accurate, but I would say it's at least mostly accurate. In most cases. John W Taylor was making sure he was working with. Full. You know in full report with with Joseph F In any case, we know that Joseph E Robinson and Joseph Summer Hayes were involved with Joseph F Smith apart from, but also kind of intertwined with with Matthias Cowley and John W Taylor.
27:12 Following these events, April 6th, 19 O 6, Matthias Cowley and John W Taylor's resignation letters were read at general conference. John W Taylor tells one of his wives, quote I was sacrificed for Reed Smoot's personal ambition. Only to have that guy later thrust the United States and do. The Depression? Yeah. Now I would like to read some journal entries from some prominent people in the church to know how they felt about this. Presentation Do we when when they resigned from the church, do we have those letters? Yes, I believe. I believe they are in the copies that I know of I think are published in Drew Drew Briany's book Apostles on Trial, I believe. And and what was the tone of those letters? I mean, was it like we screwed up, we're out? Or is it like we are resigning for reasons unknown or I don't? Recall Matthias Cowley's per SE.
28:13 But John, there was some element in John W Taylor's resignation letter that said we have been found out of harmony for our understandings of the application of the manifesto, not applying to countries outside the United States and basically apologizing for putting the church in that position. You know, it wasn't fully apologizing, but basically it was political. It was a little political maneuvering. Yeah. But yeah, basically I'm saying, you know, we were involved in this and it was because we didn't understand the intention of the leaders in the church and the scope of the manifesto. Gotcha.
28:59 OK. In any case, J Golden Kimball writes on April 8th, 19 O 6 apostles John W Taylor and Matthias F Cowley resigned from the apostleship. It is a political move to protect the Church of Latter Day Saints as the Church is on trial before Congress. Brother Taylor and Cowley are Rams caught in the thicket and are offered as a sacrifice so he knows he knows what's up, Orson F Whitney writes on April 9th, 19 O 6, Brother George F Richards succeeds. The late apostle mariner Would Merrill. I am put in the place of John W Taylor resigned and Brother David O McKay in place of Matthias F Cowley resigned 19 years ago this coming summer, Apostle John W Taylor predicted, predicted to me that I would be an apostle. We were travelling together South and we're on a train opposite of Murray.
29:59 I little dreamed, nor did he, that I would succeed him in the Quorum. He was always very good to me. You know, it's one thing to see a prophecy come to fulfillment that always brings joy. But this one, you you get the feeling that there's a somber tone to it, right? That I didn't think it would go this way. Oh no, no, yeah, absolutely not. And we know that Orson F Whitney had had taken at least one Post manifesto wife during this time period and and he was always sympathetic to the people who were getting caught on the carpet. You know, that I know of, you know, like Joseph Muster for example. When that happens, coming up remembering, you know, what we discussed with Joseph Muster is he said that David O McKay and Orson F Whitney and Roger Clausson were very good to me. Right.
30:52 You know, on April 10th in 19 O 6, Joseph E Robinson told in a meeting with eight of the apostles and several mission presidents, he told them, quote, President Taylor died in exile for this principle and he gave men authority to perform the ceremony of marriage, which authority I have been told was never revoked it. It really does what does. That sound like. What's that? Well, what does that sound like? Sounds like a guy who's fully committed to the principle. And he and he's relating something that sounds very similar to the 1886 story, yeah.
31:37 Absolutely, absolutely. I I kind of took that for granted. But absolutely. Just the amount of division now that we're starting to see within the church is, is fascinating and and I think it's playing out again to be honest with you, right. I think there's still some, you know, different issue, but I think we can look at certain members of the First Presidency, certain members of the 12, although they're getting few in number now who who really have issue with, you know, the trans movement, the LGBTQ movement and you get the feeling that much. I just find the the parallels from then to today, even though it's different issues striking very.
32:25 It is, yeah. If, for example, you know, I believe Holland is pretty strong on the traditional stance. If he never, if he dies before he becomes president of the church, I think it's game over. You're more hopeful. Than him. If he becomes president of the church, we may see some conservative reforms, very much like when President Nelson took over. We've seen liberal reforms since Monson, right? That would be my prediction in any case. The 8 apostles who were in that meeting that Joseph E Robinson said and disclosed that John Taylor had said apartment to perpetuate plural marriage which was never revoked.
33:06 He that they were Francis and Lyman, John Henry Smith, Rodger Clawson, Hiram Max Smith, George Albert Smith, Charles W Penrose, and George F George F Richards and Orson F Whitney. And so you have a pretty evenly mixed throw and against mixed, you know, it's a mixed audience for that kind of information for sure, yeah. I can't. I can't imagine what those meetings must have looked like, right? I How wow. I mean, if they're that evenly divided. Well, on on the heels of that, just a few days later, actually 2 weeks later, two weeks after Joseph E Robinson tells those guys that authority has been perpetuated.
33:54 And knowing that John Taylor, John W Taylor, Matthias Cowley have just resigned, Orson F Whitney records in his diary that he and Roger Clausen, at his suggestion, were up in the historian's office. And we sat for half an hour or more talking of brother John W Taylor and Matthias F Cowley, et cetera. So they're talking about what's going on, and we know that both Roger Clausen and Orson F Whitney are sympathetic. Or. Completely cooperative with new polygamy. Gosh, I would love to get inside the mind of of a couple of those guys, right, 'cause the the old crap meter must be going off pretty heavily, right? You just saw two of the stalwarts being asked to resign, right?
34:44 And it's probably becoming clear now that that thing that was told to them that, hey, we're going to bring you right back in isn't happening. And so now now you're you're you're watching this go down and all of a sudden the quorum is evenly split. Joseph F Smith is being duplicitous. And I get that right. I get what he's trying to do there. At the same time, the writing's on the wall at this point, right? Anybody can see it now? And we can read into. This conversation like what else are they talking about besides their own polygamy and the topic of polygamy? Because both of them are violators of the law and they've entered into and of the rule of the church, which was that no plural marriages were going on in in the church. Jeez.
35:35 And yeah, I mean they, they got to be worried about them, their families, I mean. Yep. John, John and Matthias just got cut off. Maybe we're next, You know, Maybe that's what they're talking about. I would imagine, right. It has to. It has to be on their mind. I mean, it would have been different had. And and this is where I leaned towards, there was a takeover at some point in the church, right? Hardcore takeover A couple things that we talked about the last episode in the last episode that got me was the Quorum of the 12 has a meeting without the First Presidency where where this has come to pass. It just smacks of of a couple of apostles who I think hatched a plan, knew what they had to do, and then just got it done right.
36:30 And the writing's on the wall now. It's not like they replaced John W Taylor and Matthias Cowley with other strong supporters of new polygamy. They made sure they went the other direction. Orson F Whitney being the exception maybe, but not likely that they knew that. But fundamentalist tradition states that Francis M Lyman and other leaders of the Church were at one point trying to basically find out whether or not Joseph F Smith was encouraging these new this new polygamy. And if they found the evidence for it, they were going to impeach him as president of the church according to section One O 7, What you Can Do. And then they were going to have him locked up in jail. Holy crap, that is a bold move.
37:16 And again, I call it a takeover because it's going in the exact opposite direction that had been established since the first manifesto, right? So now all of a sudden, and I'll just call it like I see it, couple guys made a deal with the devil, so to speak and they found themselves in positions of power and I'm sorry, but the set of cojones on that, they'll let that guy to be like, OK, next in our site is Joseph F Smith. If we can come up with the with the ammo, I mean, I'd take some serious intestinal fortitude to go that way.
37:58 Can you imagine the crisis that would have happened had they got that done? Oh dude. Oh man. I mean here, here's the thing, right? And and I'm I'm glad that they didn't get that done because dude that had that had the that had the the ability to entirely wreck Mormonism. It may happen. On the other hand, we wouldn't have the dogma of prophetic infallibility in the Church because it would be on the history that we we we disfellowshipped or removed the president of the Church from office. That's that's a good point too, right in the other direction. I just can't imagine the fallout from impeaching a sitting church president.
38:41 That would have been that would have been catastrophic it. Would have been absolutely on June 14th, 19 O 6, Patriarch Judson Tolman marries his sixth wife. The marriage is also solemnized and performed by a Bishop, Dan Muir of the West Bountiful ward at another state patriarchs house, Israel Barlow Junior, at his house in Bountiful. On the same day, Dan Muir married his second wife, Georgina Barlow, which was Patriarch Israel Barlow, Junior's niece, and they were sealed together by Judson Tolman. All right.
39:26 They're doing some cooperative efforts. Right. OK, moving on. According to D Michael Quinn, on June 23rd, 19 O 6, according to the diary of Mission President Joseph E Robinson recently released, Apostle Matthias F Cowley made the first earliest verified distribution of a copy of the 1886 revelation given to President John Taylor on the New and Everlasting Covenant. So that's a that's a fun one. So what happens with that story? Because John W Taylor common comments on that later during his trial. So Joseph Robinson writes in his journal that something regarding Matthias Cowley distributing the copy to the revelation. What happened?
40:11 Was Joseph E Robinson hearing from? Other people that the authority had been passed on, like we discussed and he went and told the 12, you know, and some mission presidents that the authority has been perpetuated. He's now trying to find the source material, and he goes and asks Matthias Cowley about it, and Matthias Cowley then refers him to John W Taylor's brother-in-law, Rodney Badger. And Rodney Badger had the original, you know, the original revelation in his possession at that point in time. And he made a copy of For Brother Robinson. Is there any indication that this was ever that that revelation was ever circulated throughout the church?
40:53 It's. Well like like Quinn is saying the the earliest verification that it's being distributed now underground widely is it's we're in June of nineteen O 6 and so, so thinking but look at the writing on the walls here. Taylor and Callie have just been cut off and that's you know, they've now allegedly, I'm alleging that they authorized Pullman to to do his work as he's starting to do this. John Wooley's about to start as well. And so the pieces fit that even though that they got cut off from the 12, they actually still and in church writings they were referred to as apostles still even though they were outside the corner of the 12. So it's really interesting.
41:36 In a priesthood, in Passion, you have two apostles which we know can operate outside the Quorum of the 12 because they're not the first ones. You had Daniel H Wells, who led the novel Legion during the Utah War against Johnson's Army. He was never a quorum of the 12 member. Brigham Young ordained three of his sons apostles, two of which never became members of the Quorum of the 12. Brigham Junior, the Third was not originally made a member of the Quorum of the 12, but later was added when there was a vacancy and Joseph F Smith himself was ordained an apostle secretly outside the member of the outside the membership of the Quorum of the 12, and was also added in later when there was a vacancy. And so this thing is not without precedent. But now, legally speaking, holding the virtue of their apostleship, they still holding that virtue are not technically bound by the orders of conferring with their quorum, because they don't belong to a quorum. So they've in some ways they've been set free in. Some ways they've been set free and that's the way I look at this.
42:44 Right. And so they're still magnifying their duties to build up the Kingdom of God by making sure a holy principle does not diminish or die from off the earth. And this is the way that they're doing it, is by distributing the 1886 revelation, OK? As well as helping people find the right channels to people that have got this authority, like Tolman, Woolley or what have you, whoever else. So would you, would you call this maybe the first major schism that we're seeing with authority now from the Church? I think this is the beginning of it, Yeah, absolutely. And you know, especially when we look at the characters, it's, we know it's. So in this case we would break this down. Callie is recommending to Joseph E Robinson, who is in the personal inner circle with Joseph F Smith, to go to John W Taylor's brother-in-law to get a copy of the revelation. We also know that John W Taylor was holding meetings with Judson Tolman.
43:39 So these things all connect to John W Taylor in some way, form or fashion. And it's going to get more intricate by the way, where as we get on because they're all more connections just like that. And I will. I will point those out as we get to it. Also, you know, July the next month after you know Robinson gets a copy of the 1886 Revelation. John Wooley in the East Bountiful Ward makes a talk, gives a talk wherein he says he thought that there was a great responsibility placed upon his shoulders and prayed to God to bless all, Quinn writes aside from his alleged ordination in September of 1886, he might have been thinking of the patriarchal blessing that Joseph Smith senior gave to him when he was 8 years old on March 19th, 1840. Quote, thou wilt receive keys and words of knowledge and power, and thou will be called the Lord's Anointed Wow. In addition to that meeting.
44:46 I do really think that John Wooley was also in connection with Judson Tolman and and John W Taylor and Matthias Cowley and we're and had this responsibility placed upon his shoulders, which is what he's remarking on. Because, I mean, this is right on the heels of it's two months after Cowley and Taylor just got cut off and now he's saying I have a great responsibility placed on my shoulders two months after they have been shown to resign. You know, he's he's admitting that or saying that. Yeah. So in some ways it's insinuating Taylor's going to work now. I mean, you're there's no more. The dog's off the chain, so to speak, and can can do what he needs to do. Yep.
45:31 Further evidence to that is Quinn states that in August 6th, 19 O 6, John W Taylor encourages and provides for one of his friends in Canada to marry epiclygamously. So the month after that, you know, he's he's still helping people. A month after that, September 2nd, 19 O 6, Judson Tolman marries a stake presidency counselor named James A Eldridge. He was Reed Smooth's brother-in-law. Anyways, Judson Tolman marries him to his second wife, Joseph F Smith, also in 1911. You know, five years down the road also dissuaded the apostles from punishing Eldridge, and he was allowed to remain in his position as a president, a counselor to a state presidency until 1915.
46:27 Wow. So he he was off the hook. Even even after Pullman gets excommunicated and they start finding out about all the marriages that he performs, this guy was left completely unharmed. It makes me wonder what what Joseph F Smith's criteria was right And and I I think some of it and and correct me if I'm wrong, I mean, I think some of it might be can you keep your mouth shut, right? Can you not 'cause the church undue harm? Sure. I'm sure that was part of it. Can you be low key enough to to not do this? Yeah, absolutely. And I the, you know, as we've remarked once, we're on the other side what we should definitely do an interview with Joseph F Smith too, 'cause I always want to know what he's thinking too at some of these instances.
47:14 Not that I don't, not that I don't understand already, but I would just like to hear it from him anyways. In getting into nineteen O 7, this is when John W Taylor now. So he's he's removed from all leadership positions in the church. That gives him a lot more freedom. He ends up moving all of his families together in Provo. Yeah, he for his entire life up to this point, he's had one wife in this city, one wife in this country. And he he moves all of his wives to Provo, UT with the help of Nathan Clark, who was his neighbor in Farmington. And because of his, the lack of responsibilities, he's able to bring his family into harmony, you know, and there's no more fear of being found out, of hiding. It's all out in the open right at this point. And so this is the environment that Samuel Wooley Taylor was born into.
48:16 And he, he writes about his own life saying that. And he was born in 19 O 7. That's that first year that they moved down there. He said, in my early years, we were all one big family. All my siblings were siblings. There was nothing half about it. You can't help but think that in some ways, even though he was cut off from the church, that this in some way was a reward. That's exactly what I was going to get to. That that this is a time at which John W Taylor has has fought the fight for so long to to preserve this principle, yet keep everything on the down low and now he can just be with his family.
49:00 Yeah. And he's and he was not immune to the strife that came with the jealousies or the insecurities that his wives felt about the other wives. And there was times, there was years where Nettie, Nettie, Wooley Taylor never talked to the first two wives years and now everyone's there. And Samuel, you know, one of one of Nettie's youngest remarks, and you have entire you have an entire generation or an older, a crop of the older kids that are now in adulthood, one of his first two wives, or even from his third wife. Young adults anyways, who lived in separation. But now the younger kids are all family. They're all siblings.
49:44 OK. I'm I'm gonna, I'm going to get up on my soapbox here for a minute, so you're going to have to bear with me on this. You're just fine. OK, first, to those out there struggling right now, and I know you're out there where you're living a life where you have a couple of wives and you're trying to hold this on the down low. Just stop. Just stop. You've done enough. It's time for you to come out. It's time for you to just be able to be you. We live in a time now. Where? Everything goes on the left. You want to marry a mop that's on the table. So it's it's, it's, you know, we should have equal representation. And it's exhausted.
50:32 I've done the whole hiding thing. It is horribly exhausting. Next, I know of a situation where the kids did not even know who their dad was. Thought this was just a guy who would come over every so often and spend the night. Enough. Enough. I don't want to hear one more damn word about being scared. Part of this podcast is to kick down the door so this crap never has to happen ever again. Kick it down. Get out of the shadows, because only bad crap happens in the shadows.
51:15 And live your life, period. If you're letting fear dictate what you do, you're in a sad state of affairs. I get it. We owe a debt to our progenitors who, and I shouldn't even say ma, are a lot of people's progenitors who kept this alive, who were worried about their children and did have to hide out of necessity. But those days are over. If you're on the up and up and there's no abuse, you have no issues. No issues. And it's time to put this to bed because we're doing damage to families and it's just time to come out. And I can testify to this there is no better feeling in all the world than just being free to do you to live according to your principles or the principles God has given you and just say to the hell with everybody else.
52:11 It is absolutely liberating. And it's time we get there as a people pay homage to our to to the ancestors who came before us, to kept keep this alive in the shadows. But we owe it to them now, in a weird way, to start getting more vocal than we've ever done before. I'm done. You can continue my. I apologize. No, I love it. I love it. And I wholly agree. The same year, 19 O 7, John W Taylor tried to persuade future church apostle Hubie Brown to marry two wives at the same time after he got off his mission. Way to get after it. Wow, look at him. Unfortunately, he didn't. And that's an interesting thing to consider, that, I mean, Hubie Brown was from Canada and John W Taylor had a lot of things going on in Canada for a long time. But we see later on that even Hubie Brown's father was look at the Advocate Post Manifesto and he's hanging out. His name was Homer Brown and he was a patriarch in Granite Stake, I believe.
53:18 It's so interesting how they set up these certain stakes to be safe havens. Yeah, yeah. And so Homer Brown is traveling in the 1920s with Matthias Cowley. And they're doing things like administering to the sick, to children who are in these underground families, you know, and which, you know, Matthias Cowley was not allowed to use as priesthood according to the verdict of the trial he attended in 1911. So I'm happy that he was ignoring that because, and I'll just remark here, Matthias Cowley and John W Taylor were tried for their membership or their fellowship by the form of the 12, which, technically speaking, is illegal, right?
54:10 It should have gone to a High Council. Yep. And so you could make the argument, according to the laws of the church, that the verdict and the outcome of those trials was illegal and null. Right, right. Well, I I also find it interesting that nowhere in the Doctrine Covenants where it deals with this sort of thing that we ever see anything where quote, somebody's priesthood is revoked by another man, right. What we come up with is that the Lord is saying Amen to the power of that priesthood if you're in transgression. And so this idea of priesthood only existing within the confines of a branch of Mormonism, I just don't think hold water right now. Certainly that branch has car Blanc to either recognize or not recognize that authority.
55:04 But to me, from what I can see in scripture, the Lord is the only one that can revoke it, so to speak. Sure. Absolutely, and I concur with you. Unfortunately, despite his father's sponsorship of new polygamy, Hugh B. Brown, when he was later a member of the First Presidency, helped write the law in 1935, making plural marriage a felony in Utah instead of a misdemeanor, which was worse than it ever had been back in the 1880s and up to 1935. Very sad. That same year, 19 O 7 is when First Presidency Secretary and President of the 70, George Reynolds, performs a plural marriage, more than likely under the direction of Joseph F Smith or another member of the First Presidency. I would guess Anthony H Lund, I don't know that for a fact. I don't have that information.
56:01 But if you recall from last episode, you know he was the one in the read through hearing saying I helped write the manifesto, right. And now he's And now he's performing a plural marriage. 9 February 21st, 19 O 7 Carl Badger, who is a secretary to Senator Reid Smoot, writes a letter to his wife saying I must confess that the situation is beyond me. Reid Smoot has just said that he intends to tell the brethren when he gets home that if they want to continue this polygamy business, they must leave the United States. I asked if he meant unlawful cohabitation and he said no. Well, I am dumbfounded that there should be the least suggestion of the possibility of the church attempting to establish polygamy, that it should be thought of for a moment.
56:52 The Senator also says that a John W Taylor and Matthias F Cowley are brought back and placed in the Quorum of the Apostles. Nothing will save us from the wrath of the American people. AI cannot entertain the thought that such a thing is possible. To think of it as being possible is to make the Church out a hypocrite, A hypocritical fraud. But there is this. But here is the senator talking about the calamity as though it were a possibility. You know this this might be you know that time in which I know from speaking to certain bishops and stake presidents there's a lot of pressure put on those guys to preserve quote the good name of the church. And and this might be really it's it's first iteration in in modern day so to speak where it's it's all about the perception right and and if we don't have the right perception we're gonna be in trouble.
57:51 Yep. I never gave too much of A care for that. But I do understand it. 21st of February 19, O Seven, we have a recorded instance of another polygamy advocate who was a patriarch named Harrison Sperry. And he would go around giving patriarchal blessings to children who were in these underground families because they have no access to patriarchs in the church, legally speaking, right. It's not going to some of these people who you know are not being born or they're, as we know from Anthony H London, Joseph muster.
58:35 The parents are keeping the records, but they're not on the records of the church. Right. And so this this man, God bless him, was doing a very great work in providing patriarchal blessings for the family members in those situations. Just think about how crazy this time is, right? I mean you have you have families living on the underground and it takes somebody who's moved by the Lord to feel, to feel sympathy towards them and then goes and has to administer blessings on the down low. Their whole world must have seemed upside down. Oh, sure, Oh, sure.
59:16 Do you know who Harrison Sperry is? Or who is the OR have you ever, have you ever heard of Sydney B Sperry? No. Oh, so, so this Harrison Sperry doing this great work here is the father of Sydney B Sperry, who was basically like the first two nibbly, OK he died in, I want to say like 1967 or something like that. He got his bachelor's degree in chemistry in the eight in the 1800s still. And then he ends up he ends up teaching at BYU and then he gets a doctorate from the University of Chicago in ancient languages and biblical studies and stuff like that.
59:58 And he becomes basically he's famous in the church for his Old Testament biblical scholarship. Yeah, so basically, yeah. Like I said, the first Q Nibbly, lots of cools. I've seen some cool stuff from him. It's been a while since I've looked into that. Q Nibbly had nothing but praise for Sydney B Sperry, and even to this day I believe BYU holds a yearly historical symposium named after I. Was going to say the Sperry Symposium, right? Yeah, yeah. OK. And so this is his his father that's doing this underground polygamy work. Nice, nice. And any idea how his son felt about any of this stuff? No idea.
1:00:43 I'd love to know if he was in the know on that, but I don't. That's a future research for another day, OK? Also in this year, Joseph Musser marries his third wife under the ceiling authority of Patriarch Judson Tolman, and the marriage is performed at Joseph Musser's house. Now apparently I I have one more quick question. I'm sorry I keep doing this to you. Sure Taylor, I think it was 2 episodes ago. Now Taylor seems to go out of his way to to say OK, who can who can still get this done? And for some reason, he feels prompted to go to patriarchs. Yeah.
1:01:32 That's an interesting thing. Any idea why patriarchs and not somebody else? Why not find certain stake presidents or something like that? Well, it looks like Joseph S Smith did a little bit about that too. I mean, you have Frank Y Taylor and John M Cannon who were in the members of the Granite Stake presidency. There was Hebert Hale, who was the president of Boise State. But as far as the Patriarchs go, I I couldn't tell you that I know for sure, but I have two guesses. Joseph F Smith, one being extremely sympathetic to the position of Church Patriarch because he's the son and grandson of the 1st 2:00.
1:02:20 Right to. The church, you know, Hiram and Joseph Senior and his brother John Smith was the patriarch at this point. And then his son ends up or Grant his grandson ends up being the next patriarch of the church. Also during Joseph F Smith's life, Joseph F Smith also made a remark in one conference that technically speaking, the office of Patriarch to the church is above president of the Church. And he said we're not going to have a reformation over this right now. But that's my understanding essentially is that the office of Patriarch is actually a head of President of the Church, which is just really interesting on several levels. But also according to Section 124 in where it's declared through revelation from the Lord of Joseph Smith Junior, that Hiram should step forward and receive the mantle of prophets here and Revelator. It basically says, I give unto you, Joseph Hiram Smith, to be Patriarch unto you and to exercise the ceiling keys over my church.
1:03:28 And so was there some extrapolation that according to section 124, section 124, verse 124 that the office of Patriarchs held ceiling keys? It could be that there was some extrapolation later on. We had a lot of denials from church leaders saying, no, that's not what that means, but I don't know. I couldn't tell you. I'm hesitant to endorse those remarks for obvious reasons. Right. Interesting, but we we I sent you that text from Heber J. Grant. You know, that message from the First Presidency in 1921 where he just says we've had to cut off all these patriarchs in the church for thinking they have a right to perform plural marriage. Well, why did they think they have the right? Right, right.
1:04:17 And and this, this goes to, and This is why I find what Drew Brownie is doing, Shout out to Drew Brownie with the Doctrine and Covenants, right, with his annotated version of the Doctrine and Covenants. Not only will you be able to see the text, but you're going to see what the common understanding was amongst people for that time. Right. And I tend to think you're that far back in history, you're that much closer to the font, so to speak, that that springs forth in Joseph Smith that what they think isn't conceived in a vacuum, right. They're obviously getting these ideas, most likely from Joseph himself or other high-ranking early leaders.
1:05:01 And and it it it it, it goes to show that that even though the word stays the same, the meanings have a way of changing. So I will note on this topic of the Patriarch office that Joe after Joseph Smith started having the quorum of the 12 sustained in church conferences as Prophet Sears and revelators. He had his brother Hiram. I don't know about his, I don't know about his father, but Hiram was when the authorities of the church were presented in order from President. Patriarch was next after President before the Quorum of the 12th that was continued down the line even when Brigham Young was President of the Church. That when John Smith, Joseph Smith seniors brother was placed as page work to the church after Hiram died he was sustained as an authority in the church over the Quorum of the 12 after the First Presidency.
1:06:05 That changed after John Smith, uncle John Smith died and John Smith, son of Hiram Smith became President Patriarch of the church. But not immediately. There was some personality issues between Brigham Young and John Smith, and after enough years had passed, they decided to stop emphasizing that that office during that time period. But while as soon as Joseph F Smith was back, you know, was himself in office, he changed it back and he started having his brother John Smith to Brigham Young, De emphasized, brought back into that sustained same sustaining order.
1:06:48 And even in meetings, had the tear he would have, he would have his brother meet with the form of the 12 jointly with the First Presidency in those meetings, and his brother would sit next to him in prominence. Wow. And so, so Joseph S Smith had very, very much so believed that there was some. There was a certain dignity, at least for that office that is not talked about in the in the church today. No. And if I'm not mistaken, the church since, oh what was his name? I can't think of what his what his last name was. Now they they've basically done away with that office entirely. Now Patriarch of the Church, they. Got rid of it in 70. 8 Yep, Yep.
1:07:30 And. And I know the guy died in the early 2000s and they just never. He didn't. He died in 2013. He was over 100 years old. Wow. Wow, I thought it was the early 2000s and. He is the elder G Smith and he. Is thank you he. Is the longest running general authority, you know person to have office as a general authority in the church. If you, if you count all those years, even after he was retired because he kept, he kept his status as MRI emeritus. Is that how you say that emeritus? Yeah, Emeritus, Yeah, Emeritus. He had the emeritus status, but it's still technically general authority. So he was the longest running general authority in church history.
1:08:17 Wow. And. And to me that took fortitude to just say, yeah, we're not we're going to do away with this office and not not put it back. Yeah, when that. Was Kimball? Yep, that was Spencer. Spencer Woolley. Kimball. You know, one one of the things I've often wondered is if if the patriarchs didn't have weren't a a good outlet because certainly while there's those above them, they don't really report to anybody outside the you know, the Quorum of the 12, right? And to me it's if. If even than that, I don't even know if they were doing that at this at any given point. Right. And so they they kind of have a blank check so to speak that's been yeah been signed to him and and they and it wouldn't look out of place to go to somebody's home to give a blessing and and get done right. And so it was, it was probably one of those things that that it just made sense as well as as you were alluding to in in 121, there seems to be something there with ceiling keys being given to patriarchs.
1:09:29 Yeah, I think so. I think that there's definitely, if it wasn't believed by those who were consulting with these patriarchs that there was already authority inherent in the office, it was definitely being applied to them, maybe by by virtue of that verse that we discussed as well. It says that they can hold ceiling keys, so might as well just reconfer it on them, you know? You know the other thing fascinating about 1/21 is that you you have essentially 2 simultaneously 2 presidents of the church operating at the same time.
1:10:11 Joseph and Hiram both kind of throws a monkey wrench into the whole one man thing. Yeah. Yes, it does. So, yeah, so we're back in with Joseph Musser. He's entering into. These. Into this work with Judson Tolman and likely was recommended by Matthias Cowley. Later on when Tolman's excommunicated, he told the 12 that those marriages that he performed, the marriages he performed, were done upon recommendations from either Cowley, Henry S Tanner, or Nathan Clark. I personally believe, I theorize or hypothesize that really the recommendations that Judson Tolman was getting through Nathan Clark were from John W Taylor.
1:11:00 That's my theory, I. And so it's another layer of protection, right? You know. Right. Well, that's. Been really. That's got to really irritate those six apostles who thought, OK, we're done with John W Taylor, but he's just out there doing his thing. Yeah. And he's working through these channels that they're. I mean you see you already see this network that's forming. You got Henry S Tanner, Callie Clark Robinson, Rodney Badger. And it's going to, it's going to widen here. But yeah, we got Sperry Brown, John M Cannon, Joseph Musser is brought into this.
1:11:43 Now this is where he gets brought into it. You know as this movement that's roto fundamentalist movement. It's not just, you know, the that first marriage that he had from was was endorsed by the form of the 12th quite highly. You know we had John, John Henry Smith and Roger Clawson and Matthias Calley when they were when he was in fellowship saying yes, we'll help you live this law, but now it's even more on the fringe than than ever before. He gets caught, though, and this is so interesting to me. In July of 19 O 7, Salt Lake Tribune writes, Joseph W Musser is the Chief clerk and assistant secretary of the Utah Light and Railway Company. His father is assistant historian and political mouthpiece of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints.
1:12:34 He himself is a high ecclesiast in the church because he was serving on the High Council on Granite State, though about so but about 40 years of age. He is high counselor, yeah, of Granite Stake, and as such passes on the difference between the Saints of his stake and the decisions are final, save that an appeal may be taken to the First Presidency. The president of Granite Stake, Frank Y Taylor, and his second counselor, John M Cannon, are publicly known to have recently contracted plural marriages. So have Sunday School. So have the Sunday School Superintendent and others of this stake. In fact, Granite Stake is a hotbed of new polygamy and forestdale, which is where which is a part of the stake is often times spoken of as polygamy, Ville in as much as it is refuge of those who are violating the laws by living their religion. Also, at this point, John W Taylor had a house in forestdale.
1:13:32 Nice. Yeah, nice. And Grant, so that comes out. And so put a pin in that idea. So it's publicized, it's just been published, that Joseph Mustard just taken another wife. And we're going to come back to that probably pretty soon. September 1st, 19 O 7, Anthony Ivins writes. John W Taylor came to my office, had been in connection with Bishop Bentley and Matthias F Cowley, accused me of connecting him with a Bishop Robinson case. Said I wanted to make a capital with the present quorum of apostles by going to President Joseph F Smith with the story would soon be vacancies to fill the quorum of the 12 apostles.
1:14:14 In the evening met with Bentley, Wilson at Taylor and Callie. So interesting stuff going on, but a Bishop Robinson, not Joseph E Robinson. Samuel John Robinson, who I don't recall if they're related. He took a plural life in Mexico. He's a Bishop down in Colonia Dubon and the 12 at this point are now deliberating and meet and meeting together to know whether they should cut off Samuel Robinson from the church. And so John W Taylor comes into Anthony Ivan's office to talk about it, basically to convince him not to do it.
1:14:54 Right, right. And and this is a big step too, because I think this is the first time from the way you and I have talked that they're now talking about disciplinary actions outside of the United States. Right. Yep. Heber J. Grant. This is interesting too, right? Heber J. Grant writes in his journal. December 4th, 1907 attended a regular meeting of the General Board of the YMN by A. After this meeting had a talk of nearly two hours with Roger Clausen on the status of John W Taylor and Matthias F Cowley. My heart goes out in sympathy to these brethren, so he's not fully turned against them at this.
1:15:38 Point. He just seems to be so all over the map. Grant does just you can't get a good beat on him. No, not not quite. Following that George Albert Smith is down in Mexico and has a priest, a meeting down there to reorganize the bishopric. And so, I don't know, I don't think Samuel Robinson gets cut off from the church, but he is removed from his office as Bishop and they they get rid of him down there. Why'd I put that there? I didn't put a date but also going getting into Jan the New Year 19 O 8 Patriarch Judson Tolman marries Israel Bob Barr Israel Barlow the 3rd to Alice Belva Welling at Henry S Tanner's office.
1:16:31 So we know that two marriages have been performed at Israel Barlow Junior's house two years previous to this. He is now marrying Israel Barlow's son, the you know to his second wife Israel Barlow. The third is a brother to John Y Barlow and I anthis Barlow and Edmund Barlow, I think, who become prominent fundamentalist leaders down the road. Gotcha. Seven out of the 18 marriages that Tolman performs before he gets caught off from the church are done at Henry S Tanner's office, the first of which the first marriage. So sometime during nineteen O 8 before he marries Israel Barlow the third, he performs a ceiling for Alpha J Higgs and marries 2 wives to Tanner himself in his office. So Henry S Tanner has gotten 2 wives through the help of Matthias Cowley and two wives through the help of Judson Pullman.
1:17:37 Alpha J Higgs marries Rodney Badger's daughter. Do you remember who Rodney Badger is? Refresh my memory. Rodney Badger's a brother-in-law to John W Taylor. OK, Rodney. Rodney Badger married John W Taylor's sister. Alpha J Higgs marries not John W Taylor's niece, but a daughter of Rod niece from a different wife. Not not, not Taylor's sister, but you can't help but see that maybe Alpha J Higgs was and Rodney but Badger were connected by John W Taylor in that instance near family relationship and is sent to Judson Pullman.
1:18:18 And as Judson Pullman told the 12 I never performed a ceiling but for anyone that was not recommended to me by Matthias Talley, Nathan Clark or Henry S Tanner, you know, so it all fits really well. And Henry S Tanner and John W Taylor, sure. I mean I I think the writing is on the wall that they were friends. Later on, we are going to see some pretty strong remarks in favor of Tanner by Taylor, I believe. It almost sounds like now Taylor is beginning to take on kind of a new mantle, right? He seems to be the for lack of a better term. I'm not saying this was official or anything else, but he really seems to be the first fundamentalist leader now that has emerged.
1:19:07 He's outside the he's out. He's not completely outside the church, he's outside the quorum, right? I don't think he's been exed yet, but he's orchestrating things behind the scenes now. He's orchestrating things behind the scenes, but when things. Really get Yeah, Leader. I might not say, but he could have been. And I guess for all intents and purposes he is leading the charge. Fast forward March 2nd, 19 O 9. This is when David West Jeff's also a brother-in-law to John W Taylor, because he married Nettie Woolley's sister Phoebe. He marries his second and third wife, which was performed by Jensen Tolman. He marries his second wife, Nettie Lenora Timpson, and they were married in Salt Lake City and David West, Jeffs writes. In his reminiscences of his life that he was introduced to Tolman through John W Wooley, which is interesting although they would, that was probably before they were all attending those patriarchal meetings in 19 O1 together. So Judson Tolman prophesied 8 years before this point the Jeffs would enter into plural marriage. It's taken 8 years, but he is now taken two additional wives. Quinn writes that the meeting was arranged between Matthias F Cowley and John W Wooley that
1:20:37 Brother Judson come to the home of Brother Cowley, where Brother Jeff was married to his to his. Man, and and now you start seeing names that are prominent and fundamentalism really begin to crop up. Yes, I do. Yep. Maybe I should read some? Of this. But yeah, so in David West Jeff's journal, he writes, my wife, Phoebe came to me one evening at Iona, Idaho, in 19 O 6 and told me she had been shown that I should enter into this law of plural marriage and that she had been impressed who it should be. Even Lenora Timpson, this all came to me impressively, as my mind had been engaged in so many church duties and also so much business responsibilities, that I had not been considering nor thinking about complying with the law which will increase the possibilities of entering into the highest degree of glory in the celestial Kingdom of God. Notwithstanding the fact that Brother Jonathan D Wood, the second Counselor in the Bishop Brick of Farmington, upon one occasion in the year 1900 before I left for Idaho and shaking my hand, said, Brother Jess, I have had inspiration concerning you. And I prophecy in the name of the Lord that the time will come when you will be inspired to enter into this law of plural marriage.
1:21:56 Wow. So if you don't know, do you know the name Timpson as well? Oh yeah. Yeah. So yeah, so Lenora Timpson was Alma Adelbert, Timpson's sister, OK? Who is her? Apostle on the The priest of counsel. Yep, prominent names down South. Still, if I'm not mistaken. Yeah, and this. And so Lenora Timpson is the mother of ruling Timpson Jeffs. OK. Also, he writes, when Lenora's father heard of it, we went to Bishop Rockwood and gave him the understanding that Apostle John W Taylor. Yeah. When Lenora's father heard of it, he went to the Bishop and gave him the understanding that Apostle Taylor or my father had married us.
1:22:41 The Bishop asked me to come to his home one evening and meet with him and his first counselor, which I did in the upstairs of my Bishop's home. He told me what Lenora's father had told him and wanted to know if I was married to Lenora by either Apostle John W Taylor or my father who was a patriarch. And I told them it was not true that we were not married. And they said that was all they wanted to know. So to my knowledge, he was probably cut off when he joined the fundamentalist movement many years down the road. But he he escaped at that point. I do. Believe. So now, now this is interesting because now there's there's active hunting going on, if you will. Right there is, and the Salt Lake Tribune's publishing crap like crazy at this point.
1:23:29 They published that thing on muster in 19 O 7 when he went to Pullman to get his marriage done, and things are just coming out like crazy at this point. I don't have the documentation for that handy, but there was a serious campaign from the Salt Lake Tribune around this time which was pretty much putting the church on blast again, just like it was during the Reed smoke hearings and just like it was in 1890, right? So you're saying the only thing that really is that you can really count on is death, taxes, and the Salt Lake Tribune will always be a piece of crap rag that just has it out for the church pretty much in general? Pretty much.
1:24:13 This is where it gets super interesting. We're going. I love it. I love the stuff about Alpha J Higgs. So Alpha J Higgs was a secretary to Heber J. Grant when Heber J. Grant was serving as mission president in England in on March 16th, 19 O 9, Hebrew J. Grant writes in his diary, had a long talk with brother Alpha J Higgs regarding the manifesto issued by the Church. I learned that some people think that there is still a chance for plural marriages to be performed. Notwithstanding this manifesto and all the declarations that have been made by the Presidency and the Apostles, Brother Higgs assured me that he would use his influence to correct any such impressions. That is nice.
1:24:59 Nice little little does he know at this point. June 23rd, 19 O 9, John W Taylor marries his sixth wife, Ellen G Sandberg. According to D Michael Quinn, this earns John W Taylor the distinction of being the only recorded man to have been married to four post manifesto plural wives. He married Ellen Georgina Sandberg, possibly without asking permission of Joseph F Smith. Apostle Cali performed the ceremony, and Judson Tolman performed a plural marriage for John W Taylor's sister-in-law earlier that month.
1:25:39 I don't know which marriage that was, but also another connection of Tolman and Taylor. Yeah, yeah, they the the the network is in place now, right? You can see it. It may not have complete form, but the the players are in place. It's not organization in the set in the sense that they're trying to be the leaders of the church. No. Or a separate organization. It is purely to keep the principle of plural marriage alive until the circumstances are right for the Church to re adopt it. Right. Which which you know we have per our conversation about Joseph Musser that was the the understanding right is at some point this'll and and the feeling was it would be sooner than later. Anyways, the cat gets out of the bag at some point and members of the Forum of the 12 find out that John W Taylor married, hit another wife.
1:26:41 And according to John W Taylor and other sources, Apostle George Albert Smith, future president of the Church, condemned John W Taylor for that marriage and suggested that this was adultery. And for this, John W Taylor threatened, threatened to kill him in a moment of passion, but instead used his priesthood to curse him in the name of the Lord. And John W Taylor, according to D Michael Quinn, says that George Albert Smith's nervous breakdown from the period of time from 1909 to 1911 was a direct result of that curse. Wow.
1:27:23 Wow. John W curses George Albert in the name of the Lord and has A and he has a mental breakdown the last at least two years. Yeah, yeah. And if I'm not mistaken, he struggles with it throughout the rest of his life, right? It's not as bad as breakdown, but he still is dealing with anxiety and depression through most of his life. If I'm not. Mistaken. I think I heard that before. I wanted to read something to you that kind of shed some light on why it is appropriate that John W Taylor did such a thing to curse someone, an apostle, in the church. There is something that has been done in the very much, at least in the higher circles of the church and is done in the higher circles of fundamentalism. It has been perpetuated to this day in some. In some circles it started with Joseph Smith, and you can actually find it in the teachings of the Prophet Joseph Smith on page one O 6.
1:28:23 But it's called, well, fundamentalists call it the oath of brotherhood. But basically the way it reads is and so Joseph Smith put people under this covenant before he gave them their washing of the feet. And the covenant goes, and I will now covenant with you before God, that I will not listen to or credit any derogatory report against any of you, nor condemn you upon any testimony beneath the heavens, short of that testimony, which is infallible, until I can see you face to face, and no of a surety. And I do place unremitted confidence in your word. For I believe you to be men of truth. And I ask the same of you when I tell you anything that you place equal confidence in my word.
1:29:10 For I will not tell you I know anything that I do not know. And so George Albert Smith was in violation of a bill with the Brotherhood by by slandering John W Taylor without going to him face to face and hearing about it. Well, and and look at some level, I mean, John WS got to be getting tired of it, right. He's resigned. He's he's, you know, probably maligned in a lot of circles within the church. And quite frankly, I mean, Joseph F Smith is still alive at this point, right?
1:29:53 Yep. And so he probably feels like, yeah, I was a RAM in the thicket, but I'm still operating based on the call I got. Yep. So we covered that on July 6th, 1909, Hebridge, a grant writes in his diary. This morning I had a visit from Carl A Badger, and his mother Louisa A Badger. From them I learned the sad news that Bessie Badger had no doubt been married to Alpha J Higgs. After all the warnings that I had given to Brother Higgs in Liverpool, and since his return that no person should enter into plural marriages, I feel outraged at his conduct and hope and pray that we may be able to discover who performed the marriage, as I feel that the man who performed such a ceremony, as well as those entering into a relation of this kind, ought to be excommunicated from the Church. And that's Heber J Grant, right?
1:30:48 Yeah. So is this the Heber? Is this the first time you can see Grant going full tilt the other direction now? Yeah. And yeah, it's because of a former a friend and a former secretary of his pretty much had lied to him, you know, about discouraging people into, you know, entering into the principal. He'd entered into the principal himself, and it's coming out. So now the witch Hunt's gonna begin for Jensen Tolman because I want to find out who who officiated for Brother Higgs. On July 8th, 19 O nine in a meeting of the Formula 12 Grant writes in his diary that Brother Lyman called upon each and everyone of the Brethren to give him their aid in stopping plural marriages in the future.
1:31:33 The Brethren were all united in condemning the course of Brother Higgs had a talk with Brother Alpha J Higgs. He positively refused to confess whether he was married or had any relations whatever with Bessie Badger. I had another talk with Ralph and Carl Badger that those would be her brothers who called at my home this evening, and from what they tell me I am convinced that their sister has been married to Brother Higgs. The next day, Grant writes in his diary, had another talk with Higgs, but utterly failed to get any information from him. I forbade him from entering the temple or attending any of my prayer circle meetings. He is a member of my circle. I gave him plainly to understand that I considered that he was worthy of excommunication from the Church. So Alpha J Higgs was a member of Hebrew J Grant's personal true order of prayer quorum as well.
1:32:25 Wow. So, so maybe just speculating here. Maybe it's not so much that he was spurned with a certain lady. Maybe I played some of it, but maybe it's the fact he's feeling threatened in his authority somewhat. Maybe. Maybe. Six days after that, he writes in his journal. This morning and afternoon, seven of the apostles met in the temple. Bishop Joseph Christensen, Benjamin S Goddard, Charles Martin JH Martineau, and others of the Brethren were examined as to their knowledge regarding the alleged marriage of Brother Higgs. None of them had any actual knowledge of the case, but all seemed to believe that somebody had presumed to marry him and claimed that it was all right the next day after that, Heber J.
1:33:19 Grant writes in his journal that quote, Kelsch thought Higgs was married and if it was done properly and revealed to Higgs, he did not object. Now that would be a reference to Lewis Alma Kelsch Senior, who was also opposed to polygamist and father to future apostle Lewis Kelsch Junior. And he's telling Heber J Grant straight up and well, if it was done properly and if it was revealed to him, it's all good, right? Yeah, and. Almost not like he's he. He sounds almost oblivious. Right, of what's going on, right? Like I don't see what the big deal is.
1:33:59 That or he's brave and he's very strongly asserting that this, that he that's the way he feels right in any case. So Kelsch is also on the general board of the YNMIA at this time. There's a lot of those guys who are getting cut off or going to get cut off because they're entering into plural marriage, which is super interesting. Joseph Tanner is one of them, and Kelsch and Higgs. They all were members of the YMMIA. And the YMMIA, that's the Young Men's Mutual Improvement Association, right? Correct. Now, would they be considered the forerunners to like CESI? Don't know.
1:34:44 That's a good question. That's a good question. I don't know the answer to that. On July 20th, 19 O 9, Heber J. Grant writes, had a talk with BH Roberts and Ida Duesenberry regarding plural marriages that are being performed at the present time. And I learned that Brother Callie was supposed to be quoted as saying that these marriages could be performed today as well as they ever could, and that it was all right to perform them. These reports had come to Brother Roberts and Sister Duesenberry and I am hoping that they are not true because if Brother Callie is saying anything of this kind it is an outrage. I would naturally think that after having been dropped from the Quorum of the 12 that he would not pressure to make any such remarks. I understand he is a very sick man or I would investigate the case at once.
1:35:33 Now that's an interesting that's an interesting way that he phrased that right. Resign versus drop, right. It's almost like in this one entry he shows his cards right where they were. They were kicked out. They weren't necessarily, we allowed them to say, resign to save face, but so so that that would lend credence to the idea that maybe Hebrew J Grant had some some foreknowledge of maybe this plan that was hatched to move the church in the direction of monogamy being the rule. At this point, it's more likely that that's the right direction that he wants to go.
1:36:19 In July 22nd, 19 O 9, Anthony Ivins writes, met at 9:00 AM to continue the investigation of the Alpha J Higgs case. Brother Joseph Summerhayes was the first person examined. So they're going over all the people that they know that are have been involved, right? He's able to keep his membership. Brother Clark from Farmington, UT was the next person examined. So now they got Nathan G Clark that they're investigating over Higgs marriage. Both men refused to answer questions asked. They thought men were justified in taking plural wives now, provided they could get them properly.
1:36:59 Thought there might be a proper way to get a plural life. At 4:00 PM reconvened. Rodney Badger first examined. He knew nothing in regard to the marriage of his daughter Bessie and Alpha J Higgs. Hugh J Cannon had taken no wife and had given no encouragement to anyone to take plural wives. So I remember correctly, Hugh J Cannon was a son of George Buchanan, who George Buchanan helped enter into the principal right before he died, along with John M Cannon, who was his nephew. So that's a lie. Yeah 'cause you. Anyways, can we pause there for a second? I I could use a break.
1:37:45 Yeah, absolutely. All right, I'll. I'll be right back, All right. OK, so getting back into the the Inquisition time time period with Alpha J Higgs and they haven't found Judson Tulman yet, but they're going to assume. Interesting sidebar August 15th, 19, 19 O 9 John M Whitaker who is a Bishop in Granite Stake. He's not a friend of ours, unfortunately, but this is interesting. Historically, he writes in his diary. I have had some serious time lately with some brethren who are determined to privately take plural wives against the solemn pledge that the Church has made. And I have met with them and done all I could to get them to be true to their to their first wife. And under the instructions from the President to the Church, I finally told them if they took another wife while their wife was living, we would have to handle them for their fellowship.
1:38:43 But even this is not sufficient in some cases. The presidency said many times this must stop during the balance of the summer Was extremely busy in my ward stake and social affairs. I had several talks with the state presidency over my attitude towards some who are in polygamy, stating that all who took wives since the manifesto were living in adultery and some of the leading men in the stake who had done so protested. And in the High Council, I explained my position and the president of the stake asked me why I took such a stand and he said he and John M Cannon had been advised by one of the general authorities to do so. So he's telling his state President and his and counselor that you're living in adultery because it's Frank Y Taylor and John M Cannon, right? Anyways, explaining that they did so, and that the manner had been taken up by the Council of the 12, and in as much as they did so immediately after the Manifesto, and had made all arrangements in good faith to do so when the Manifesto was passed, that unless someone made complaint against them, so far as the Council was concerned, no action would be taken. We have had many meetings on the matter and I was told by President Joseph F Smith, no matter who they were to handle, all who had taken a wife after the manifesto or he would handle me.
1:40:02 This thing must stop. And later one of the members of the ward, Willard Richards, came and asked me why I favored my brother-in-law, who was a member of my ward and also state president, and not make fish of one and foul of another. And he said. He knew that Frank White Taylor had taken one sense and I said to him, Are you sure? Yes, I am sure. Then I said, if you will file a complaint against President Frank White Taylor or anyone else in my ward, I would at once try the case. I'll do nothing of the kind, said he then said I Then keep your mouth shut and don't go and try to destroy the character of anyone. If you will not take your part in stopping such things, it is such men as you and others who talk and slander others, but unwilling to help put a stop to such things. And you and all you and all such are bringing the church into disrepute and give license for the for the stranger to find fault and say the church is not keeping its oath. President Smith told me personally when I took Nicole Hood before the presidency in 12 some time ago. The man is not living and the man is not dead. Who can ever say that?
1:41:10 I have ever approved of a single plural marriage since the Manifesto and I believe him so that's what that's what John Whitaker says. President Smith told him that there is not a man living or dead that told that I told could enter into full marriage since the manifesto. And I told him that President Taylor was good and a faithful man and always wanted to do the right thing. Then I went to President Taylor myself and told him a complaint was about to be filed against him. He said, Well, Bishop Whitaker, you won't try the case, will you? Yes. Anyone filing such a deposition, I am bound to hear. Then he said. Well, Bishop, if such a thing happened, I guess I will have to take my medicine.
1:41:50 But no one ever filed A complaint, so the matter was dropped. But I shall do as the President of the Church asks me. As long as I am Bishop, I feel that it is right, and there is no one so great but the that the Lord can raise up another to carry on the work. This is not a one man church, and every member has equal rights before the Lord. I have had many sleepless nights over my determination to do my full duty in the face of a great and of great odds. But I shall always stand for the right and will express my honest opinions whenever and wherever I have opportunity. And it is my duty to do so. I cannot do otherwise and maintain myself respect before men and my Father in heaven. Let me ask, Oh, go ahead.
1:42:35 Not as interesting. There you go. Any idea who called Whitaker as Bishop? No idea, because he seems out of place, right? And he seems. Unusually, he seems unusually bold to call out his direct superior, so to speak, right. He seems this. Look, we all understand Mormon hierarchy, right? Whether you're in or out of the mainstream church, we get it that there are channels and that there is a proper procedure. But he seems awfully emboldened, right? He seems like he's very willing to go out and challenge his direct superior within that hierarchy, which to me tells me that he was maybe put in there in hopes of stemming some of the plural marriage that's happening in polygamy, Ville. It's quite possible, but I don't know. Yeah, I don't know entirely.
1:43:40 Anyway, that's super interesting stuff. September 1st, 19 O 9, Hebrew J Grant writes in his diary. Long discussion. Higgs case concerned that Tanner and Kelsch should resign from the general boards. He means from the YNMI. A the next. Day, Grant writes. Long talk afternoon with BH Roberts. He was glad something was to be done in the case of Tanner and Kelsch. Two days after that, on the 4th, Joseph F Smith and Huber J. Grant and BH Roberts signed a letter to Louis A Kelsch saying evidences are at hand. Going to show that A at a comparatively recent date of plural marriage was entered into and from a report made to us by a committee of the Quorum of the 12 as a result of their investigations, you are implicated as having encouraged the belief that plural marriages may still be consummated, notwithstanding the declarations of the presiding authorities of the Church to the contrary.
1:44:35 For this reason we cannot sustain you as a member of the General Board of the Young Men's Mutual Improvement Association, and you are there but for hereby released as a member of that Board. Wow, so, so brother, it's it's it's happening now, right? The the the witch hunt is on. Yeah, Kelshen and Tanner I believe get dropped from their position there, although I don't believe they ever get excommunicated. On October 6th, 1909, Heber J. Grant writes in his diary after a conference at President Lyman's with some of the Apostle Apostles and Bishops building with President Welling of Bear River Stake was sorry to learn that he believed that Brother Israel Barlow, the third of Bountiful Ward, had married and for a wife.
1:45:19 We will no doubt have one more man to cut off the church. And Heber doesn't seem to have any time for it now. He's. He's over, Yeah. The next day, he writes, met at President Lyman's some of the apostles. Brother Israel Barlow, the third there, refused to give to answer any questions regarding his reported marriage. All of our quorum who were there believe him guilty. Has there been any change in the constitution of the 12? Has anyone else been dropped? Has anyone died? Have they added more and pull up polygamists? Yeah, let me. Let me pull up who is in at this point in 19 O 9. Then I'll give you a rundown. As of August of nineteen O 9, the quorum of the 12 reads the Francis Lyman, John Henry Smith, Heber J. Grant, Rodger Clawson, Reed Smith, Hiram Max Smith, George Albert Smith, Charles Penrose, George F Richards, Orson, F Whitney, David O McKay, and Anthony W Ivins. So against it you have Lyman, Grant Smoot, George A Smith, Penrose and George F Richards and Ivins. That's a majority of seven on the fence kind of sort of would be John Henry Smith, possibly hire a Max Smith, although I don't fully know, and David O
1:46:49 McKay, so, so three or four and then fro, yeah, three and a pro would be Roger Clausen and Orson F Whitney. So they're really outnumbered now. Yeah. On October 6th, 19 O 9, George F Richards writes in his journal. I attended the four and afternoon meeting of conference and at 4:00 PM met with the 12 at President Francis M Lyman's office and heard what President Milton H Welling had to tell about his sister's relation with Brother Israel Barlow. A suspicious case indicating a marriage with a married man adjourned until until 10:00 AM tomorrow when Brother Barlow will meet with us.
1:47:29 I got word to him through brother Benjamin Goddard, Thomas Clawson writes in his journal, Essay and Day. The names of Alpha J Higgs, Henry S Tanner and Louis A Kelsch were not sustained on the General Board of the YMMIA because of the scandal arising out of the Higgs affair. President Joseph F Smith then made the closing remarks, the conference in which he gave a most scathing rebuke to Brother BH Roberts and said that the Lord that if the Lord had anything to say to the church, he would send it through the proper channel. So I guess BH Roberts said something at that conference that really was incendiary.
1:48:10 I don't know what it was, but that's interesting. But in any case, Alpha J Higgs, Henry Tanner, and Louis Kelch get dropped from their positions in The Lion and not YNNIA officially. The next day after that Thomas A Clawson, which is probably a near relative of Rodger Clawson, although I don't know, writes in his journal, went to circle meeting at President Francis M Lyman's spoke spoke at Francis M Lyman spoke upon the subject of loyalty to him and the circle, remarking that four members of the circle had gotten into difficulties through their not following the counsel of the leaders of the Church. They were Joseph W Musser, Joseph M Tanner, Louis A Kelsch, and Birdly.
1:49:03 Whoever that is, he hopes that in the future that all the brethren of the circle would live as to retain the his fullest confidence and would do nothing to bring themselves into trouble, the Church into disrepute. So maybe I'm skipping over where I want to talk about muster more. Maybe. Or maybe it's coming up. I don't know. We'll just get to it now. But yeah, so muster Tanner Joseph M Tanner and Louis Akelsch were all part of Francis Lyman's private True order of Prayer Corps. Those three And another guy with the last name of Early apparently got into plural marriages around this time. Joe's. This is the time that Joseph Muster was brought into the court with the 12.
1:49:44 It was during the Higgs case stuff and if you recall they asked him, do you know brother Alpha J Higgs And he said that they had been personal friends for years which that's like a no brainer to me. If they if Joseph muster, well I guess Higgs is not a member. Higgs is not a member of this quorum. Muster is a member of la Diamond's quorum. Higgs is a member of Grant's forum true order of prayer circle forum. But yeah so Higgs and Muster have been friends for years. That's the way he answers them. They ask him, well, have you talked about this topic? He says basically. Well, I can't say they asked Muster to put a, you know, help us in putting it down. Muster says I can't do that.
1:50:25 Anyways, we discussed that at length before, but what? What's your question? It's more of an observation. For some reason, I bristle at the way Wyman puts it, where he says, oh, you have not been loyal to me. And I'm like, is this the Godfather, right? Is this like you know? You come to me on my wedding day. And you know what is this exactly? What do you mean? Loyal to you? Right? That's an interesting statement. I I'm more concerned with someone being loyal to God rather than loyal to me. Well. I would say that those four individuals were being pretty loyal to the Lord.
1:51:06 Yep, three of them are very prominent in the story. I don't know who Urdly is, but but have three names like that all engaged in this underground priesthood work and two of which have serious relations to later fundamentalism. Is this super interesting that that's that happened in that scenario? Is this super fascinating? Yep. Later on, when Joseph Muster is on the priesthood council, he sends Joseph Lyman, Jessup and Arnold Boss, who was kind of the resident historian of the priesthood group at that point up to Canada in the 1930s, to go find Alpha J Higgs. Because he had moved up to Canada to bring him into the priesthood work, just so you know. OK, so so Higgs is laying low, is what he's doing. Yeah, yeah, he's.
1:51:58 Yeah, he well, he says. Or maybe it was Boss or Muster, you know? So Muster sends them off on that mission to go find Alpha J Higgs and Alpha J Higgs told Arnold, Boss and Lyman Jessup that he was instructed to go hide in Canada. OK Yeah, by by probably Joseph F Smith. Gotcha. Gotcha. He's coming on Get out of town. Yep. And so yeah, we see this is coming down both sides. Hebrew J Grant writes on his journal on October 17th, 19 O 9 that I that you know they they were meeting on the Higgs case again and on Tanner and Kelsh.
1:52:41 It's around this time that Nathan Clark was trying to obtain permission from Joseph F Smith and John W Taylor to marry Alta Taylor, John WS daughter he got permission from. Want more from the Mormon Renegade Podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the Fundamental News Program for free. Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button. And for $5 a month, you can have access to podcast transcripts, renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders.
1:53:25 Click the link in this episode's show notes today. John WI don't know if he was able to obtain permission from Alta to court or, but it looks like Joseph F Smith said that that would not be wise at this point in time. It's kind of understandable that we answered that question. Now that you asked before maybe why he couldn't get permission because that all this is going on right now. I mean literally, you have Biggs's marriage was probably helped arranged by Taylor because he married his brother in law's daughter going on December 8th, 19 O 9, George F Gibbs writes a letter to Lauren Merrill, who is probably a son of Mariner Merrill. Say he writes.
1:54:08 Word has come to this office from quite a reliable source to the effect that your counselor, Brother Borkman, has the idea that plural marriages are still being solemnized by and with the sanction of authorities of the Church, and that in this understanding he is paying his addresses to a young. Woman. With a view to marriage, provided he can get a competent person to perform the marriage ceremony. It is also being told that you were encouraging Brother Borkman and the idea you are reported to have said other things as well. Along this line going to convey the idea that you knew personally of such things and could enumerate a very large number of such marriages since the since President Wilford Woodruff's Manifesto, I am instructed to say to you that no plural marriage can be entered into by and with the sanction of Church authority, and that any person found doing so will be dealt with on his fellowship in the Church. This applies to the party solemnizing the plural marriage, and you were requested by the Presidency to so inform Brother Borkman and his wife as well.
1:55:13 So that's another tie in to Brother Merrill has a wide knowledge. Right. Pertaining to those events and affairs. So now getting into 1910 January, they start investigating Israel Barlow, the Third's case. Let's see if I need to say read any of this. So this is interesting. I can't. I couldn't find. I swear I read something along these lines, but I I was looking for it before we got on. So yeah, with with Israel Barlow the Third getting into this these his inquisitions, his stake president was Joseph Hiram Grant who was a brother to Hebrew J Grant.
1:56:02 I swear there is a statement for me to Judson Tolman or from Israel Barlow the 3rd, that Joseph Hiram Grant's brother, the Hebrew J grant, encouraged that marriage. Thanksgiving dinner just got interesting. Right. And they have, because he's a stake president. They have Joseph Hiram Grant sitting, sitting in on this meeting, and things could be probably very uncomfortable for him anyway. So they're investigating Israel. Barlow declines to answer any of the questions, and they decide to disfellowship him.
1:56:44 And if he continues to refuse to answer, then in 30 days they will cause him to reappear in a meeting and show why. You know, basically they're going to say he should show us why we shouldn't just excommunicate him from the church in 30 days, Anthony W Ivins writes. Same thing. OK, let's. Can you keep, can you keep your camera down a little bit there, Mike? Oh, sorry, No, you're good. But this is interesting. OK, February 27th, as they're going through the Israel Barlow case, George F Richards had a dream. I don't know the interpretation, but it's very interesting. Last night I dreamed a dream in which I saw the 12 who had been digging for some time had found the grave which contains the body for which they have been looking. The Barlow case and the subject of secret plural marriages were associated in my dream with the case, IE the dream, if it had any significance, refers to that matter. I dreamed that I had been absent for some time, and on my return I saw a long and deep trench, dug as indicated by the dirt throwing up.
1:57:58 I had seen that we were in counsel, and that I had been absent from and from a drawer. I extracted some papers which throw some light upon the case under consideration, and it was apparent that one of our number, Orson F Whitney, had tried to keep this information in obscurity. On the diggings I saw one who was persistent and humming out loud as he worked. Notwithstanding we were to work in the quiet, he was nevertheless as much interested in our search as any others. President Francis and Lyman was working hard when I came up and on the lead, and I put to work with him, and presidently working backwards, I discovered a loose sod as if it had formerly been removed.
1:58:41 Investigating further, I found that a grave had been dug and covered over with sods, but that it had been sunken distinctly. President Lyman saw it and seemed it seemed that, but that was the thing which we had been looking for, IE in that grave was the body we've been looking for. I then asked President Lyman if I should cover up the diggings, to which he referred and answered No, I want to show. It to them. I thought I saw that there were a good number of men otherwise who had secretly hid this body from us, and I could see their anxiety over the matter and how disconcerted they felt. While we were digging, I saw a shovel, a spade and a grubbing hoe which had been used in the diggings and which it seemed I had used in the commencement of the work. So that's really fascinating.
1:59:33 What are your thoughts on that? Boy, I think, I think just just my opinion. I think that that what they're they're looking for is plural marriages, right? And and as soon as they find it, you know, there's some men who are bothered by the fact that it was found, which probably lends to this idea that again, they're not 100% united on this, right. I'm guessing those two men that you mentioned that were the only two left holding the line, so to speak, are those guys.
2:00:15 Well, that was that fits really well with what we went over with the membership of the Quorum at this point because the people he mentioned are, although the one, the one that they mentions it's Orson F Whitney who is one that we know is sympathetic and the other one is Roger Clawson that we isn't mentioned in the stream, but we know that he would also. Probably. Be very wary as well. And I'm just thinking, looking, you know, digging below the surface, people are in the underground. I think it carries a lot of symbology there. It's really interesting. It's why the Lord would show him that, I don't know. Some would probably think that as a vindication that the Lord was against the priest to work.
2:01:02 I would disagree, obviously, but they could be looked at that way. But interesting nonetheless, considering how accurate. It I think there's something else telling in that dream. And the one who seems most excited about finding the body, so to speak is, is Lyman, which tells me that that maybe he was the mastermind of this from the get go. Yeah, a lot of. I think it would. It would make a lot of sense if that were the case. I'll say that much. I couldn't prove that, but it would make a lot of sense. Nor have I ever attempted to research that There was a plot.
2:01:43 Of any. In any case, but that. Is I could, I could be up in the night on this, right? I I I really could be up in the night. Well, it just seems too orchestrated for me. It's definitely orchestrated at a certain level, and I'll give him the benefit of saying the the the pathway to hell is paved with good intentions. And I'm sure he had good intentions and that he wasn't completely evil in doing this 'cause he's trying to do something he believes in, which is to save the church and disrepute. But I definitely think he's gone beyond the spirit of the Lord at this point as well. You know, I think this is a good spot to to maybe mention saving at what extent?
2:02:28 To what extent, right. Because if he gets his way, the the church as those people have known it to, that time is over, right? That's like saying I'm going to attempt this Mustang by throwing in a Pinto engine, right? Yeah, you may have saved the outward appearance, but it's not the same car. You're absolutely right about that going forward. This is extremely interesting timing wise. So September 28th on the heels of this, let's see what's when was this dream, this dream. So a year later, almost so February that that dream was February 27th. On September 28th they officially excommunicate Israel Barlow, the third from the church, by October 3rd. Just a few days after that, Johnson Tolman is excommunicated from the church.
2:03:27 Interesting. So boom. According to D Michael Flynnn in October, which is that again that same month that that Tolman is excommunicated in October of 1910. John W Taylor. He's I'll just read what he says. John W Taylor was circulating that 1886 revelation which the apostles saw as kind of sedition as a kind of effort to undermine the church. And then they heard in October of 1910, when the First Presidency announced a letter to all state presidents, for state presidents to take action against anyone entering into plural marriages. After nineteen O 4, John Taylor said, quote, this church is going to divide into and there will be a monogamous church and there will be a polygamist underground.
2:04:19 End Quote, I guess. And when that was reported back to the form of the 12, they regarded John W Taylor as not simply a rebel, but as a potential or actual leader of a movement that the apostles could only see as an apostate group. So it was basically a foregone conclusion that he would be excommunicated when he came before the Quorum of the 12. Wow. And so, So on the heels of Israel Barlow the third being X and Patriarch Tolman being X, the First Presidency is compelled, I would say, to issue a statement to the state presidents to fellow to to exercise judgment when cases come up to them.
2:05:01 And John W Taylor makes that prophecy that there will be a polygamous faction in the Church from this point forward and that the Church will be divided into Now that is again just fascinating and fits with the narrative that we're uncovering. Any any sort of idea what's happening with Joseph F Smith? Do we have any journal entries that show any sort of, you know, lamentations about, you know, we've lost it? Anything that that can really tip his hand about where he's standing at this point? I've never seen any journal entries from him on anything like that. If there if they exist, they're probably not definitely not available. I will state that out of the 18 marriages that Tolman performed between February of nineteen O 6 and when he's excommunicated in 1910, it includes Joseph Muster.
2:06:00 Joseph Muster is not excommunicated for the marriages performed by Tolman. Very interesting, right? Right. James A Eldridge was also protected by Joseph F Smith and was not excommunicated. Neither was Dan Muir, who was the Bishop that would help Judson Tolman take two wives. He was not excommunicated from the Church, and neither was Henry S Tanner excommunicated from the Church, despite the fact that when Pullman is brought into account for all that, and after he admits all this, all that information is before the Quorum of the 12. Do you think that the Quorum of the 12 is thinking at this point we kind of have bigger fish to fry, right?
2:06:44 Like if kind of like that? I hate to use this analogy, but I don't know how else to use it. There was a point during the drug war in America where it was like go after the cartels, right? Get get rid of the supplier. Are they looking at maybe John W Taylor and Matthias Callie as kind of being being like the suppliers to this? And thoughts are if we can get rid of the the figureheads, the rest will fall in line. There's definitely a. Little bit of that. At this point, it's looking like that the 12 think that Callie is more responsible than Taylor. OK. I don't know if that's true.
2:07:25 I think he's more of the boots on the ground and Taylor's more directing from behind at this point. I don't know how completely in union they are either, but we. But like I said, I I I very much think that any of Nathan Clark's suggestions to Judson Tolman was actually really Taylor's. And we see that after Judson Tolman is excommunicated, he being patriarch to the church. I don't know if there was anyone in the interim placed in that position, but in 1913 John W Wooley is placed in the position of patriarch to Davis state that Jensen Tolman was occupying. OK.
2:08:06 Interesting that they replaced. Him with a wooley. Well, yeah, with also connections to John W But yeah, as you were saying that the bigger fish to fry, we're getting into that point in time where we're in the end of 1910 and the summons for Taylor and Callaway to appear on trial were in February of 1911. OK. Do I need a pause? I need a pause. No problem. OK, where was I? So Quinn writes the Before his membership trial, John W Taylor wrote a letter to Joseph F Smith wherein he referred to him as, quote, prophet, president, and King.
2:08:48 In the same letter, he asks Joseph F Smith to convene the Council of 50 to protect John W Taylor from discipline by the Quorum of the 12. President Smith responds, quote, not granted. I think the demand most absurd. Although the request was denied, it strongly suggests that Apostle Taylor believed that there was a reasonable possibility that Joseph F Smith would take his side and protect him against the membership trials. So I'm going to ask a real blank question now. Did, in your opinion, did Joseph F Smith throw Taylor to the wolves at this point? I don't know throwing him to the wolves is the right answer, but it's like my hands are tied.
2:09:36 OK. Which is? Which is fascinating, right? Because we again, thinking about Mormon hierarchy, especially within the Church, he can pull rank. He can pull rank unless he's not really in control. Right. Yeah, you're absolutely right. And that goes back to that tradition that Francis Lyman was trying to find evidence to lock up Joseph F Smith because he suspected Joseph F was involved with these things. And look, I'm a guy who believes that organizations, businesses, whatever, have a kind of DNA to them, OK? And if if that's the DNA that is there now, I'm not sure that just goes away, Michael.
2:10:28 I I think that sticks around, right. And so now we have to this. This has some implications for our day, Who really has the power and who really is pulling all the levers. You're asking the right questions. I don't have the I I don't have the specific answers, but I know what you're putting down. I know what you're putting down. There may or may not be another episode coming that may dive in. I'm not saying there is, but you should probably count on it. But anyway, fair enough, Fair enough. Back to Israel Barlow's case.
2:11:09 I forgot about this part. They they're having him back to talk about why he felt justified in in taking another wife. Interesting scenario he he forges A postscript or APS you know at the end of a letter that he had from Owen Woodruff back when Owen Woodruff was alive. That Owen Woodruff had written to him from when when Owen was in Colorado. And he has secretary like type A on A put the paper back in A or a copy of that paper back in a typewriter and type the PS with instructions from Owen Woodruff to take his second wife and go down to Mexico or something like that.
2:12:00 In any case, he presents that as evidence kind of lay the blame on Owen Woodruff. Who's dead and? Heber J. Grant discerns when looking at the paper that the, that the type was different, you know, OK And it was detected as a falsehood, unfortunately. And so he couldn't salvage his membership at that level. But just an interesting little footnote. So we're getting into the trials now, but I don't where did I? Yeah, OK. I'm not going to go into the reading or any of the trial because, well, maybe a little bit, but because that would take probably 2 episodes, so maybe with one it would take a whole episode to do.
2:12:47 And it's not really relevant in its entirety to this topic, but I will. I do have Cliff notes to John W Taylor's trial and I believe it was February 11th, 1911. No, February 22nd was probably the second date because they broke it up into two different days. So February 1911, the Cliff Notes are Joseph Fielding Smith, which is son of President Joseph Smith, admits to making a copy of the 1886 revelation that he got from Rodney Badger, who is brother-in-law, the John W Taylor, and who's the father of Al Jay Higgs, second wife. Right.
2:13:29 So that's there's that connection. The apostles spend all the time inquiring to John W Taylor's personal activities. They asked him about Patriarch John A Wolf in Canada who had been set apart by John W Taylor and Joseph F Smith. They talk about that for a bit. They ask him personal questions about him marrying his sixth wife, Ellen Sandberg Taylor, and he refuses to answer any questions regarding that, though he does give some information regarding other plural marriages. He refuses to utterly say anything about his own personal affairs, and he cites pleading the 5th from the Constitution has, you know, reason to do so. They and they asked him why, you know, why are you pleading the 5th in a ecclesiastical meeting?
2:14:21 You know, and he tells them, because it any quotes section 98 of the Doctrine and Covenants, where it says from the Lord that you should require nothing of anyone that is not, that is less than or more than the Constitution, the law of the United States, which is lawful. Dude, that makes my heart swell with joy. And this is going to make it even better. Do you know who advised him as his legal counsel to? Do that, John. M Cannon. Nice, nice. So, so. Brother John M Cannon tells Taylor to cite the 5th Amendment to not to answer any of those questions as he shouldn't be forced to perjure himself.
2:15:08 John W Taylor tells the form of the 12 that he had a 3 1/2 hour conversation with President Joseph F Smith and John Henry Smith between the sessions of the two trial. Between the two sessions of the trial. In that, he also asked President Smith to reconvene the Council of 50. And interestingly enough, he also questioned Joseph F Smith directly, saying Do you believe in the revelation that my father got in 1886, to which Joseph F Smith told him, Yes, I do believe it was a revelation from God. Then John W Taylor asks President Smith, then why aren't you doing anything to facilitate it? Wow, what support there at that, at least up to that level they are.
2:16:00 They are now seemingly not in harmony, when it seems like there had been harmony and understanding before. What was Smith's response? Do we know? I don't know. I don't know, besides the fact that a few years later, Joseph F Smith and John Wooley appoint Nathan G Clark and Joseph Musser to perform the priesthood work. After the excommunication of John W Taylor. Correct. I'm sorry. It's smacks of a man who no longer has the authority to do what he wants to do. Yeah. No, you're. I don't disagree with that. Oh. Jeez, and I find it an interesting omission. Look, the absence of evidence usually isn't evidence in and of itself, but in this at at this stage they're they're going to excommunicate Taylor and then continue to work and give commissions to men to keep doing plural marriage on the down low. The other thing I find interesting is that Taylor calls for the council of 50 to be reinstituted, right. I think at this point Taylor understands and and I this is pure speculation on my part.
2:17:15 I think Taylor understands that the quorum of the 12 and the churches we've known it to this point is gone and the only thing that can bring this back is kind of a higher council now, which would be the council of 50. Well, which is designed to protect everyone in their civil rights, You know, their civil rights, Yeah. Yeah. And which, even if he's at variance with the position of the Quorum of the 12, he still has the right to his own pursuit of happiness, right? Right. And yeah, I don't know how they would do that because that's that's a dicey situation. So can the Council of 50 judge that in the church? Can the Because the Council of 50 is. Not a church, I don't know like.
2:18:08 And now we get into speculation about just how much sway Joseph intended the Council of 50 to have in these matters. Right. Another historical note is that the Council of 50 has not been operative till since at least 1892, right? True again, it just I, I I know I'm beating a dead horse here but everything just points to kind of a takeover. I don't know how else to say it and and Taylor's doing trying to pull out every stop he can make to to to reverse this and it's just not happening. Yeah, so that's an interesting footnote, skipping to Matthias Cowley's trial and then back. But at Matthias Cowley's trial, which I believe was in May of 1911, they asked him if he had heard of a ring of people in the church who thought that John W Taylor would one day be the president of the church now.
2:19:06 That is. That is very striking. At least this is it's very it's this is very interesting information for several reasons. Because we have that prophecy from John W Taylor that there's going to be a schism in the church with two factions 1. Monogamist 1 polygamist. We have knowledge that John W Taylor has a network, if you can call it such, of people perpetuating Celestials liberal marriage. And there is a story told in Family Kingdom by Samuel Wooley Taylor, John WS Son, that around this time a fundamentalist leader came to John W Taylor, asking him to spearhead and be the figurehead for the movement and the dialogue between them. It goes such as the trial was not legal because it wasn't. It was not a high council.
2:20:02 Therefore you know you're not cut off. It also seems to insinuate that you have higher priesthood keys and blessings anyways, which can't be taken from you, right? No matter. And you have a duty to to lead this people. The people will flock to your banner and so forth and so on. Samuel Wooley Taylor takes the, you know, because he is, first of all, to say, a fundamentalist leader or anything like that is kind of anachronistic because fundamentalism hasn't happened yet. And Marky Peterson wasn't even a member of the form of the 12 yet, and he coined the term Mormon fundamentalist.
2:20:43 So you got to take some things said in that account by Samuel Wooley Taylor with some skepticism. But the themes across the board are very consistent from what I see. And that is, there probably was people from that network who were waiting for John W Taylor to just come and lead the people. I don't like Moses. I don't know, Out of Egypt, so to speak. It would be interesting to know what Taylor's thoughts are on that right, because for a long time, and I and I would contend probably certainly into Brigham and Taylor's presidencies, Wilford's as well, There's this thing of just trying to hold the church together.
2:21:30 Mm hmm. Right. And so now you're starting to come to a point at which they're like, well, maybe there needs to be a divorce, an ecclesiastical divorce. And it's interesting that Taylor doesn't pick up that banner. And I'm wondering why not? Well, I personally I think the the truth is probably less less the direction that Samuel Taylor takes it. He basically, Samuel Wooley Taylor paints it in such a way that John W Taylor did not want to divide the church and that part's true, but that he also encouraged people not to form a group and that he had a testimony of the church and those there are kernels of truth in.
2:22:20 That I believe John W Taylor had the discernment to know now was not right, not the right time, and that with his charisma it would have split the church before it was ready to be split, I guess. No, that makes sense. That makes sense. OK. And he would die within a few years at that point anyways, and so it would have been a short lived. His tenure as a A leader officially would have been short lived anyways. Right. So he could. Yeah. No, that makes sense. OK. No, that makes sense. All right, but interesting nonetheless that they ask him about if Matthias.
2:23:05 They asked Callie if he'd ever heard talk about Taylor being president of the church. Back to Taylor's account. Super interesting. I never would have caught this if I hadn't read the book Apostles on Trial by Drew Briny. Shout out to Drew Briny again, right? He points out something super interesting in the flow, like there's a deletion of part of the trial and it resumes with Charles Penrose saying I motion that we delete that or remove that from the record. Sit. As John W Taylor said, he will claim all responsibility. And then which John W Taylor follows in the transcript, I will assume all responsibility. So do you think he says that he got his his Commission from Joseph F Smith?
2:23:58 No, I do not believe he said that because then that would have played into Francis M Lyman's alleged. That's a good point. That's a good point. What do you think it says? I think he tells them about the Judson Tolman thing. And interestingly enough if I can't quite make sense of this, but I'd love to see some original source documents. And not just the the digital source documents that I have of minutes of the quorum of the 12 from this time period, but in Charles Penrose's diary. Because Penrose again is the one who motions that this part be stricken from a record. But in his journal, he writes February 22nd arrived with the John W Taylor nine of the 12 present at AS. Taylor refused to comment on allegations that he continued to perform plural marriages and was taking additional wives on the grounds that he wanted to legally protect himself. However, Taylor complained of church influence in politics and admitted.
2:24:59 To giving patriarch. John W Wooley, Authority to perform Plural marriages, producing a copy of the Revelation to his father, John Taylor. He interpreted interpreted it to mean that the man who stood at the head of the church was relieved of the responsibility of holding the keys and free agency was given, to quote all my people. OK, so he walked. Up there, Yeah, yeah, Well, and. And my mind immediately goes back to that conversation that we talked about on a previous episode between Joseph Smith and John Taylor, where he says if these keys aren't used, they'll be turned against you.
2:25:45 Yes, absolutely. And and at at that level, it basically means, well, concerning this principle, it's kind of been turned against you. It's it's no longer within your purview as president of the church. Very interesting, and I would not disagree with that. And it that that interpretation fits with the 1882 revelation, which is you are not fit to preside in my priesthood if you do not live my law. Right, right, absolutely. So interesting. So according to Penrose, and like I said, I would love to see a handwritten version of that, but I got that electronically where he says that Joe, that John W Taylor authorized John W Wooley to perform plural marriages. So I think he talked about that at the very least and that was the part that was deleted.
2:26:35 What makes me wonder why that is is or how that could be is because if John W Taylor admits to that in 1911, why is it not that John W Wooley isn't excommunicated until December of 1914? Maybe they maybe they wanted to see, look they the church has some inkling here now the the Quorum of the 12 does that. Taylor seems to be the guy, right. They ask questions about, you know, have you heard anything about Taylor starting his own church or that he'll become president of of the of the church? Maybe their thought is if we lop off this figurehead, the rest will fall into line.
2:27:21 Yeah, that's very true. That's very possible. Absolutely. In that trial, John W Taylor also says that it was one of the greatest tragedies in the church that Bishop Samuel Robinson was cut off from the church. And maybe he was cut off from the church, but he was the Bishop in Mexico that George Albert Smith went to go replace. Right. So. So John W Taylor says that it was a great, the greatest tragedy in the church. That. Was cut off. That's probably a bit of an exaggeration, right? Right. And he and he goes on to say that he admires men like Henry Tanner and Nathan Clark. He also tells the 12 that at this point in time that he endorsed Nathan Clark's worship of his daughter Alta. He tells the 12 in this meeting that Joseph Robinson, from the mission president from California, right, asked for a copy of the 1886 revelation with Matthias Cowley and got it from John's brother-in-law, Rodney Badger. They asked if he had married his typewriter as a plural wife. Her name?
2:28:28 Yeah, Ellen Sandberg. Her sisters, as we discussed earlier, married Walter W Steed, who also lived in Farmington up in Davis County, And another sister married Thomas J Steed. And when Thomas J Steed died, she remarried Nathaniel Baldwin as his second wife. Wow. So that's super interesting. So Nathaniel Baldwin was the the altruistic polygamist benefactor of the 1920s with the Radio Plant put all the polygamists to work. Help to build. Their subsidized the building of their houses in forestdale. His second wife was so he he basically becomes a brother-in-law to John W Taylor.
2:29:17 He's hey, Brother Taylor's dead at that point. But that's all I'm saying, dude. The connections to John W Taylor are everywhere in this. All roads lead lead to Taylor, yeah. His first wife, if I remember correctly, as a fun fact for other fundamentalists listening to this, was an oler, which is a big name in First Word. Or the FLDS, OK. Or up in UP in Canada. So that's how the that's how I. Think how the Olers get involved? Was that Nathaniel Baldwin's first wife? Wasn't the Sandberg family? So those three sisters, right, that are have been married to John W and the steeds and Nathaniel Baldwin come up in Baldwin's journal with Cowley and patriarch Homer Brown, father of future apostle Hugh B. Brown, giving blessings to members of that family. John W Taylor tells The 12 that he has never married anyone without the permission of the president of the church in that meeting, which seriously upset Hiram Max Smith, who's you know, because Hiram Max Smith's father is the president of the church. I'll read that part to you, Hiram Max Smith says. Quote I.
2:30:35 Think you have. Implied in your attitude that President Smith has not told the truth, I feel that Brother Taylor desires to imply that President Joseph F Smith gave him the authority, but will deny, will not deny or affirm it, John W Taylor says, Brother Hiram, if I should turn my tongue loose, there would be the damnedest time in this state you have ever had, Hiram Max Smith says. I think you're the creating the damnedest time by keeping still so Hiram Hiram Smith's getting upset with Taylor, insinuating that President Smith is behind everything but not admitting it. That's an interesting that's that's an interesting snippet, right? Because it sounds like Hiram has no idea that his dad, Joseph, has been engaged in the work like he has been. Yeah, and he thinks it's absolutely silly, right? They think so, but I don't think it's silly whatsoever. Let's see.
2:31:36 Anthony Ivans mentions in the trial that when they cut off Bishop Samuel Robinson, Samuel Robinson told the 12 that he had gotten the right to enter into a plural marriage from John W Taylor. So he got implicated in that association as well that way, Ivan said. I was instructed of President Smith to depose him from his bishopric, and I would like to know where the outrage exists, John W Taylor says. I remember consulting with brother Ivan's about Robinson's case, he having been promised long before President Smith's declaration that he should have another wife. And I referred to him. I referred him to President Smith and he came to Salt Lake and saw the President and I returned to my home in Provo where he called upon me one day in the field.
2:32:25 And while take while talking he broke down in tears and I thought he was sad but he said he was crying for joy. He said that President Smith told him to hunt out the way and if he could find the way, the president said, God bless you. He said he had found the way and asked if he could send his wife to me. And I told him yes, I would and I will care for her as long as I could. And John said that he had no idea who married Robinson to his new wife. Probably John Wooley, right? That's my guess. Could have been told, but I don't recall seeing his name on the Tollman ceiling record that I have. But so that's really interesting. So you have.
2:33:07 Yeah. Ivan saying that Robinson told the 12 that he got the right from Taylor. Taylor's recalling that all the interaction he had with Robinson was that Robinson had gone to President Joseph F Smith and said and he had been told to hunt the way out. Right. And God bless you, yeah, some dialogue worth noting between Charles Penrose and John W Taylor. Charles Penrose asks John. Now, under this purported revelation from your father, do you think this authority is given to anyone to perform a plural marriage on their own free agency? John responds if a man had been authorized in any way by authority to perform a marriage under that revelation.
2:33:54 He would be. Charles Penrose then said, if a man had received authority at some time in the past, would he have authority now, Notwithstanding the declarations of President Snow and Smith? John says it would depend upon the circumstances as to what was said to him at the time he received the authority and the condition under which he received it. I think there may be cases where a man might be justified in exercising the authority if he had the authority given to him at one time. I think the president of the Church should give the authority to every man who performs a plural marriage. I would not take, I would not take advantage of this revelation after the opinion of your brethren and your ideas expressed here, George F Richards then asked Taylor.
2:34:43 Have you, brethren ever talked about a question of a division in the church and there being 2 factions in the church? So there that that topic comes up again in Taylor's meeting as well. It would be interesting to see on the temple recommend interview questions when they said you know there's that one question in the in the church where they ask do you sustain so and so As the only person authorized on earth to exercise all the keys of the priesthood, I'd be fascinated to know when that question originated on a recommended interview I. Think during Hebrew J Grant's presidency. And that's interesting to know the time period, right? Absolutely.
2:35:30 Now for the verdict. The verdict of the trial as stated in the official papers and all that is quote. This is from Francis Lyman. Francis Lyman presented the following. Brother Taylor admitted of wrongs in Canada and Davis County. He tacked 10, tactically admits his late marriage with his typewriter. He has cursed and threatened his brethren. He has put out a purported revelation of his father's, which his father never presented to the church, nor his brethren. His construction upon it is very mischievous and against the position and discipline of the Church by the living oracles. It was in his power to have restrained Brother Cowley and Woodruff, meaning Owen Woodruff, right? But instead his course lent encouragement to them. He has had no change of heart since he resigned his position in the Council.
2:36:25 He has not met with us in a friendly manner and penitent spirit. He blames us instead of himself for his troubles. He said he never wants to be associated with the 12 in time or eternity. When his brethren reported his cursing of George Albert Smith, he said that they were liars, the action of the state presidency and High Council. In the case of Bishop Bishop Robinson, he denounces as the damnedest outrage ever perpetuated. In a threatening manner he tells us of the awful things that would happen to the Church if he should open his mouth and tell what he knows. He greatly admires Henry S Tanner and Nathan Clark, who we have found to be unsafe man. His examples and words give comfort and encouragement to those inclined to override the discipline of the Church. So any idea if it was unanimous or if it was a simple majority? It was unanimous in his case.
2:37:21 Cowley's case was different. I don't remember off the top of my head if there was a difference in who was there for, you know, vice versa, you know, 'cause I don't believe it was a full quorum. In either case, it was enough to constitute a quorum meaning 7, or present, which is the bare minimum to have a legal action for a quorum, at least in the case of the 12, but I did not believe it was a full quorum. John W Taylor is therefore excommunicated or it's announced in March 28th, 1911. But I want to go back to that verdict, which I believe he supports.
2:38:04 My theory about that deletion because Lyman presents that the verdict is that he admitted wrong. He's getting excommunicated partly for admitting wrongs in Canada and Davis County. Now what happened in Davis County, Dave? Joseph Wooley I can't remember the first name. Wooley Wooley succeeds Judson as patriot, right? So I'm guessing that his admission that that authority stems from him, so to speak. I believe so. Was was what did it. Yeah, I think the there's a lot of really good connections there that makes perfect sense to me. In any case, I you know I could be wrong, but I don't think I'm wrong on that one.
2:38:52 No there there seems to be a lot of corroborating evidence that would that would bear that out. Yep. And we're going to get to more of it too, by the way. So he's excommunicated some tradition states that after his excommunication, he begins more fully to refer men to John W Wooley for their blessings on April 11th, 1911. This is so interesting to me because it validates a lot of what we've talked about the last five episodes. On April 11th, 1911, President Joseph F Smith acknowledges in a telegram to Senator Reed Smoot that Taylor's understanding of the scope of the 1890 manifesto was not maverick.
2:39:39 I'm and I'm quoting Quinn, by the way, but this is what the telegram says. If President Roosevelt inquires about new polygamy, tell him the truth. Tell him that President George Q Cannon was the first to conceive the idea that we would that we could consistently countenance polygamy beyond the confines of the Republic where we have no chartered law against it. And consequently he authorized the solemnization of polygamy in Mexico and Canada after the Manifesto of 1890 and the men occupying presiding positions. Who became polygamists since the Manifesto did it in good faith? Wow. That's a heck of an admission that that they entered it in good faith.
2:40:24 Yeah, and I mean, that was a telegram to Smoot, so obviously that guy buried until Quinn found it. Smoot never put that out, probably, but that's hugely telling. And I think it's a bit of a gloss because I think Joseph F Smith was just as involved as George Buchanan was, although he probably took a junior role because George Q Cannon was senior by ordination. But he's literally saying George Q Cannon orchestrated this whole thing, which he was at John Wooley's house in 1886 when the 1886 revelation was received. We have Matthias Cowley his testimony on during his trial that George Q Cannon gave him the authority and got him as his go to.
2:41:13 For all the marriages that were performed the last few years of of Cannon's life, you know he performed 40, at least 45 plural marriages in a span of three years. That we know of Holy cow that is almost one plural marriage a month. I was. I was doing the math in my head here, yeah, 52 weeks in a year, last three years of his life. He's going to town. It's more It's more than one month because three years is 36 months. 45 marriages. Yeah. Holy cow. Whoo, he's busy. So that was Cannon and Cowley May 10th, 1911. Matthias Cowley during his trial tells them I was told to keep my own counsel and was severely censured one time by Brother George Q Cannon for consulting someone else, meaning someone else other than him for regarding a certain marriage.
2:42:07 Brother Penrose told me once in the City of Mexico that he had written the manifesto and it was gotten up so that it did not mean anything. And President Joseph F Smith told me the same. I mentioned these things only to show the training I have had from those over me. So Callie tells the Quorum of the 12 in his trial. Penrose told me he wrote the manifesto. We know that's true because George Reynolds told them the Senate during the Reed Smoot hearings that he and Charles Penrose and Franklin S Richards wrote the manifesto. But also, we know from the history that President Smith never believes the manifesto was a revelation abolishing plural marriage. And he said as much in a meeting of the form of the 12 in 1891. Man, I mean, it's like at the end, the smoking gun is found, right?
2:42:57 We, we know who's responsible. We know who continues to authorize it. There's no doubts. Absolutely, I agree. One thing also they asked him about a certain marriage. That was that they found out was performed for a Peter K Lemon Junior, but they couldn't find out who performed the marriage. He didn't know or maybe he did, I don't know. He denied knowing who did it and they were. They were married sometime obviously before May of 1911 and it was performed in Centerville by John W Wooley who admitted it to the apostles when he was excommunicated a few years down the line.
2:43:40 Also around this time period, Judd Judson Tolman has been excommunicated already, but he gets brought back into meetings. On January 12th, 1912, Judson Tolman signs an affidavit saying I the undersigned Judson Tolman. So by these present confess and acknowledge in all sincerity and humility that since the first part of the year 19 O four I have married. I have had married to me two women by Bishop Daniel Muir. That I have had at. Different times and places Married 18 couples as follows. Holy Cow, Bishop Daniel 8.
2:44:26 Bishop Daniel Muir, James A Eldridge, Samuel Howard, Alpha J Higgs, Henry S Tanner with two women. Charles Waldenden, Israel Barlow, the third A brother Evans, Joseph W Musser, a brother Jess to two women. Doctor Donald A McGregor, Brother Simmons, a brother Gamble, a brother Merrill, and a brother Wells, and a brother Christensen in 1910, all of whom were recommended to me, my brothers Matthias F Cowley, Henry S Tanner, or Nathan Clark.
2:45:06 When I was investigated on the question of marrying these parties, I deliberately lied to the Council of the 12 Apostles and thus deceive them. Later, when I was again given a hearing, I acknowledged to marry, but again willfully lied to the council by telling them. I performed all those marriages before the declaration of Joseph F Smith of April 19, O 4. When they were all performed after that date, all these pretended marriages were done without any right or authority under the law of God or man. For all these great sins I do now humble myself before God, and ask his forgiveness and mercy, and also for the forgiveness of my brethren, whom I so wickedly deceived. I make this confession and acknowledgement of my own free will, that my conscience may be free, for I have stood condemned before before it, since my first appearance before the Council. I wish all my brethren who have been sinners with me would do as I have done and obtain forgiveness. And it's signed Johnson, Tolman and Jason Tolman, David Tolman and Joseph Hiram Grant.
2:46:11 Wait, wait, wait, why would. OK. Why would Tolman do this? Because he's already X, right? I mean. Sure. What? What's the motivation here? Is he trying to get back into the church? What's What's going on? He was petitioning for re baptism back into the church at this point, Absolutely in where he says that he lied. The first defense he made, which I believe I have on my phone, if I can pull that up, I don't have it on my computer, but I think I have that in front of me, he told The 12. I believe that Mariner Merrill gave him the authority the for the end.
2:46:55 So yeah, just like Israel Barlow tried to put the put the responsibility in the weight back on Abraham alone. Woodruff. Right, You know. Judson Tolman was counseled, I believe, by Henry Tanner, who was a lawyer, to put the burden on a Mariner Merrill, who was dead because Mariner Merrill can't be tried. Put it on, put it on a dead man and and call it good essential, yeah. Yeah. And so that's the thing that he lied about. But I definitely think the rest of this was just an attempt to get into the church. I don't think he really regretted it. And like we've we've seen the evidence points that there was a Commission of authority and him not admitting to who I really was.
2:47:44 You know, he admits that he lied about Brother Meryl commissioning him, but I think he really was protecting Joseph F Smith. Because remember, half half the people that Judson Tolman married never got cut off the church, you know? Oh yeah, I mean, I get it. I'm a little disappointed in Tolman that he went this route. Not sure I I'm a little, I'm a little bummed out. But what it is, what it is, right? And I can't judge what what his intent was or or anything like that. It just seems, I mean, you've already been axed, right? I mean, you're you're done, essentially. And it wouldn't be too much longer before we'd start seeing a leap from proto fundamentalism to full on fundamentalism in in short order.
2:48:38 It's very true. He's not gonna live that long. I mean, he was already 79, I think, in 1906, so Tolman wouldn't live to see that day. But I I definitely don't think that that admission was done in any way, shape or form other than to try to get back on the church membership records before he died. OK. All right. And and to do and doing it in a way to protect Joseph F Smith as we've discussed because all signs kind of point to him being involved. With the two right. And like we said, Joseph Muster wasn't excommunicated from Tolman's marriages.
2:49:20 Henry Tanner wasn't. James A Eldridge wasn't. And there was another one, that which we've already mentioned. Let me see if I can find more on Tolman from my phone. Maybe it's not Tolman. I might just have to read. We might come back to that. Hold on, four days later President Lyman in a member in a meeting of the form of the 12 says We have learned the first marriage he was connected with was when Bishop Daniel Muir was married to a wife, married a wife to him. Brother Tolman married the Williams woman first the 1st in 1904 and the next in 1906.
2:50:01 That's actually not sure they were both done in 1906, but he placed the marriage back further to kind of protect himself. Gotcha. The 1st in February was a woman by the name of Laxman. Bishop Muir was not the Bishop of my ward Joseph Hiram Grant said. It was 19 O 19 O one or nineteen O 2 that Brother Tolman came to him and made the statement about Sister Babbitt. Brother Tolman said Sister Babbitt is sealed to brother of George Teasdale. He was dead. But we we love him anyways. We he was not quite clear whether he was married before or after Brother Muir. There's a historical note that I have here that Brother Daniel Meaver appeared at the same meeting and said that he had married his wife in in 19 O3 and denied performing marriages for Tolman, which is also a lie. But he never got, but he never got excommunicated. For it either.
2:50:59 George F Richards writes in his journal. I met with President Francis and Wyman and Joseph Fielding Smith Junior and James E Tallmadge and heard President Joseph H Grant report on Judson Tulman, and Daniel and Daniel Muir meet this morning. There are many developments in our investigations of a startling and astonishing character which I do not record in my journal. Most of the proceedings of our investigations are taken in shorthand and transcribed and are kept for a future reference. So that So what? If so, this is already after Taylor's been excommunicated. What if that whole thing that we just read was a gloss the cover up that to tell Tolman if you want any shot of being back in the church before you die, you need to sign this affidavit. That's.
2:51:47 Kind of where I was thinking. That reads this way, while the truth is that George F Richards is saying that all this astonishing and startling stuff is coming out which we can't record. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. No, they had. They had him on the ropes, right? Tolman wants back in the church before he dies, right? And then Holman spills his guts. And at that point, there's too much there that they don't record right, that they're like, oh crap, if this gets out, we got some serious problems, right? And so on this note also May 1st, 1912, on the heels of all this information, our boy Joseph E Robinson writes in his diary, quote, he could not talk at all to Francis M Lyman, President of the 12, who had been especially active in hunting down certain cases of new polygamy, but that he and Joseph F Smith and President Lund understood one another. Read that one more time for me.
2:52:58 I wanna make sure I got that. Joseph E Robinson writes, Quote He could not talk at all to Francis M Lyman, Presidents of the Quorum of the 12. Who had been? Especially active in hunting down certain cases of new polygamy, etcetera, but that he, Joseph F Smith, and President Lund understood one another. So I'm gonna. I'm gonna see if I understand this correctly. Forgive me, I'm slow. Is he saying that Joseph S Smith couldn't talk to Lyman? Yes. And But that first counselor, Lund and Joseph Smith, Joseph S Smith understood each other? Yep. Correct in. Conjunction with Robinson, Yes.
2:53:39 Yeah, mutual understanding. Oh, holy cow. And like I pointed out a million times already, Robinson went to Cali to get the 1886 revelation, which they got from. From from John W Taylor's brother-in-law. Yeah. Robinson told eight members of the Formula 12 that John Taylor died for this principle. And that authority has been given. That's never been revoked. He's helping Rodger Clawson live with his plural wife in hotel rooms in in California. Right. You know, he's doing all the legwork, you know? Oh man, this, this just well, and the other thing I think it does show, I think it does cement that at this point, the office of the First Presidency of the Church and the Quorum of the 12 under the direction of Francis Lyman are completely at odds.
2:54:40 They're they're essentially functioning AS2 separate governing bodies with different agendas. That's what it seems like. I don't know what John Winder is. A is the other counselor in the First Presidency at this point. I know he was involved with Legal what? I don't believe he performed any plural ceilings. But if I remember correctly, what he did do was he officiated as a justice of the peace for people who were in a plural situation, that once the first wife died, he married OK wife legally to her husband.
2:55:23 Gotcha. Gotcha. He. He. Did one or two of those. But in addition, in relation to what we just read about Joseph Robinson, this is interesting, which supports your comments. Quinn says that in relation to this, beginning in October of 19, O Four First Counselor Anthony H Lund had acted as a go between for letters to Apostle Roger Clausen in care of the Presidency's office from the plural wife. Clausen married four months after the Second Manifesto. Post Manifesto polygamist Joseph E Robinson was not released as a mission president until after Joseph F Smith died, despite apostle Francis M Lyman repeatingly asking Smith to drop him.
2:56:10 The fallout. From This is Massive. Yeah. We we are getting now a look inside inside of of leadership on both on both fronts, the the First Presidency as well as the quorum of the 12. That is absolutely breathtaking in scope because what we find is not what's purported, that there's always unity, that the First Presidency is marching orders and the 12 carries it out. Oh no, I'm. Sorry, yeah. No, I mean, that's the image that's portrayed. So, yeah, no, no, no way. I don't, I don't even think today. No way. How much longer does Joseph F Smith live after the excommunication of John W Taylor? Seven years.
2:56:59 OK. On March 21st, 1913, Local 70s Forum Secretary and Salt Lake Temple Square Missionary Nathan G Clark marries his second wife Cleo Afton Call in the Salt Lake Temple by John W Woolley. Oh, so Woolley doesn't doesn't kind of really go on the down low a whole bunch, right? I mean, he's sealing a second wife inside the Salt Lake Temple, Yeah. And he's he was.
2:57:41 He was a temple worker at this point, set apart as a temple worker I believe, and so he had access to do that, I guess. Another connection to John W Taylor with this though is not only did Nathan Clark try to not not only was Nathan Clark neighbors to John W Taylor in Farmington, not only did he, you know, express interest in courting John W Taylor's daughter Alta. Not only did he personally help John W Taylor move his families to Provo and establish their homesteads down there. After John W Taylor was moved removed from the form of the 12 he his second wife is Cleo Afton Call who is the daughter of Anson be Call from Mexico who had that vision. If you remember where John W Taylor was revealed to him to be the the keeper of that book of life. Yeah, that's right.
2:58:42 Absolutely. I forgot about that. And so Nathan Clark marries Anson B, calls daughter Cleo. Which I just blew my mind when I when I found that out. Yeah, which did. That just shows me that and that John W Taylor was pulling those strings still with his relationship with. Absolutely. Clark, but with also with Anne, with his close relationship with Anson B. Call, who he helped enter into the principal in Mexico. Yeah, man. So what What the? Go ahead, it's. Like this. This is like the retroactive evidence I have for why I really think Nathan Clark's recommendations to Tolman were Taylors.
2:59:27 John W Taylor's. Yeah, yeah, all those, all those things. Man, So what was your what? What? What's happening with Taylor after this after he's been excommunicated? Tradition states that he's recommending people to John Wooley to get married, which that stands to reason with what we just read. But ultimately he just, he had some businesses his family was involved with, you know, some you know, like, I don't know. Their farming fruit, fruit, fruit and produce kind of stuff, Farmer, farmers market type stuff. I guess they made quite a bit of. I think they made a fairly decent doing that. It was a whole family enterprise with all the different plural families he had down there.
3:00:14 He had adjoining farms that he offers wives. And then what about? Do we have any record how he was received by others in the community? Other Mormons? Did it have a chilling effect on his standing in the community? Did people still 'cause, as we discussed about Joseph Musser, even after his excommunication, he's still invited to sit on the stand in in like conferences, right? There's nothing I've seen that him as a hero. In fact, they he told them in the form of the 12 that I rarely go to church because when I go there I'm asked to speak, you know, and stuff like that, you know. OK, all right.
3:01:01 So he's he's. Kind of almost a folk hero at. This point? Yeah, living. Living folk, hero. On the heels of this, we're getting into into 1914. January 23rd. Something I haven't heard talked about hardly. I mean, actually I don't even think ever until I did research on this for myself. But. 1914 Matthias Cali gets drugged back into a trial for a a second time and but he's already he's already been exed, right? He never got excommunicated. He was. He was. Disfellowshipped. And for I. Think forbidden from taking the sacrament and. Exercising priesthood OK, all right. OK, so he gets struck back in.
3:01:47 Yeah, he gets struck. He gets struck back into. In 1914, because Francis Lyman thinks that he's still helping people enter into the principal. Lyman is relentless. Yeah. Holy cow. So. So I was wrong. Let me. Amend John Wooley was not excommunicated in October of 1914, he. Was. Excommunicated March 30th, 1914 OK, well, this is the point we're getting to, Heber J. Grant writes in his diary. My office till 10, then meeting at the Bishops Building, the cases of John W Wooley and Matthias Cowley considered so these things are going on in conjunction with each other. Ten of the 12.
3:02:28 Joseph H Grant and George J. Cannon. Present After lunch, only members of the Our Council were present. All spoke and it was voted to cut Brother Wooley off. The church concluded that we needed a little bit more evidence in Brother Matthias Cowley's case. So he he gets put on the hot seat again, and they start asking him questions about how he's involved with John W Wooley's plural. Marriages. But. They can't. Find enough. Evidence to excommunicate him, OK. And so I might read. A bit of those off my phone. Let's see on January. 16th John 1914 John Wooley signs an affidavit which states Centreville, Davis County, Utah on the 16th day of. January. 1914 President Francis M Lyman and Anthony W Ivans called at my home and an answer to question asked. I made the following statement some months ago. I met Matthias F Cowley on the street and he asked me if I was familiar with the sealing ceremony. I told him I was.
3:03:36 He said if any good man come to you, don't turn them down. I believed from that statement that it was still proper that plural marriages be sole alized and that President Joseph F Smith had authorized Callie to instruct me. Since that time, I have married wives to Nathan G Clark, Joseph A. Silver Reuben G Miller. Peter. Kimball Lemon Senior and the ceremony in the case of Miller was performed at the southeast part of Salt Lake, the woman being a widow whose. Name. I don't know. The lemon ceremony was in Centreville. The name of the woman I think being Johnson, signed John Wooley, Francis Lyman and Witness. Anthony W Ivins. A few days later in Matthias Cowley's trial. Matthias Cowley says Brother.
3:04:26 John Wooley said to me that he thought it was all right and related to me how President John Taylor had spent the whole night at his place and the president he had said in the morning that the principal would not be done away with. And I told Brother Woolly that I could have nothing to do with it, President Francis and Lyman said. Brother Judson Tolman also claimed that you had you sent men to him. Cowley says this. I never did. I never sent a man to Brother Tolman Matthias Cowley says. In answer. To Brother Huber J. Grant I deny that I ever asked Brother Woolley if he was familiar with the sealing ordinance. Or. That I told him not to turn a good man down if he came to him.
3:05:08 Brother Reuben G Miller explained. That Brother Woolley had told him how abolishing, how the abolishing of plural marriage was being agitated by the legal advisors of the Church, and how President Taylor had spent the entire night in pondering over the question. And in the morning came into the room where Brother Woolley was with his face illuminated and said this principle was not to be done away with but to remain on the earth. And this has strengthened Brother Wooley and believing that the practice should be maintained and also had influenced brother Miller. So we have some really strong evidence, not from Lauren Wooley, but from John Wooley, about the 1886 events right there. Yeah. Yeah.
3:05:49 And it's it's pretty consistent with the. Account that was given. And these are official. Minutes of the form of the 12 that I was reading from official. The official minutes. The official. Minutes. So I don't know what the unofficial. Minutes say, but this? Wow, what? Was it? Yeah, that's minutes. That was the Minutes. In February of 1914. This is Anthony Ivan's diary. He writes. The Brother Francis or he says John Wooley stated to Brother Francis. M Lyman and.
3:06:31 Me that Brother Matthias F Cowley did. Say to him in. Conversation which took place on southeast corner of the temple block that if any good man comes to you, don't turn him down. That was the only thing Callie said to him on the subject. He would not have assumed to solemnize a marriage had it not been for that remark. He thought President Joseph F Smith had authorized Callie to speak, could not remember just when this conversation took place, but it was before he solemnized marriages. So we. Have a case of either Callie or Sorry John W Wooley has been approached by both John W Taylor and Matthias Callie or John Wooley is avoiding the truth and. Giving a calculated answer to.
3:07:20 Shoulder the burden on Matthias. Cowley, who's already been? You know, dealt with, Yeah. And protect Joseph F Smith, I'm guessing, and protect. Joseph F Smith, Yep. And and see, I have nothing to back this up, right? But I can only imagine that these guys know that that Francis Lyman's gunning for Joseph F Smith and they. Understand the stakes are. High. And that. They are going. To protect it at all costs for the. Sake of the Church, right? Understanding now that that post manifesto polygamy has come to an end in the LDS Church, let's try to preserve what's left. Do you know the ocony about Francis M Lyman's crusade against polygamy is What's that?
3:08:17 Do you know what the irony? Of Francis. Lyman's crusade is what's that? His son, Richard R. Lyman when. He was. Made a member of the form of the 12. Entered into a polygamous marriage by solemn by solemn Covenant in 1925. Holy cow, he was the last. Apostle. Who's ever been excommunicated from the church, and he was excommunicated. In 1943 when? Was that the guy that was like drug out in his underwear after? I don't think so there. Was there was an apostle? If I'm not mistaken I'll I'll have to look this up. Give me just a second here.
3:08:58 There was an apostle who was doing this about that time, and they had the police. Go and arrest. Him for illegal. Cohabitation. And drug him out in his underwear. Yeah, that was it. That was it. OK. All right, I OK, I was working. In the Salt Lake County recorder. 'S office and someone, someone just showed it to me. There was just an old newspaper clipping. But sure enough, dude, they perp locked him. I mean, they found out that he was living this plural marriage.
3:09:40 His wife knew his first wife. They sent out spies. After him. Right. They did. They. They. Knew that he was up to something. When? When they finally find. Him and. It was a widow, right? That he'd actually interacted with, if I'm not mistaken, even back when he was a Bishop and they they got married and then sure enough, the spies catch him. Going in there during the night. And the church calls the. Cops. Yes, they do. They perp walk him. I mean, they absolutely perp walk this dude and he's just humiliated the. I was reading up on this recently. The guy who led the raid was a former. Member of his ward when he was Bishop. I if I remember correctly, and he said if I had known it was Richard Lyman I never would have entered the house because the church, the church did not tell him that it was an apostle. Let.
3:10:49 Alone. Richard R Lyman in There they just. Said go and deal with it or whatever. I don't even know what probable cause they gave to them, but he he said. I would never have entered the house. If I had known it was. Richard R Lyman and see, this goes back to for good and bad, right? I I want to say that there. Can't be good that comes out of this. But This is why I think that the founders were maybe on to something with the separation of church and state until you can have a full Theo democracy, right. I mean, because you essentially get marching orders from church headquarters, go get him right, whoever him is, and they go in there and they perp, walk this guy, right, and absolutely devastate him and his entire family. And it it was dirty.
3:11:39 It was so dirty when when I read about this. Oh, I'm glad that you were read up on it and that you corrected me. That's good. So. Richard R Lyman also has. Interactions with Nathan. Clark later, too. Really. Yeah. At least one. Instance that I'm aware of, boy, his old man was. Pissed. Oh yeah, it's just. So it's wild, dude. You couldn't make this up so. Anthony. Ivan's writes on his journal in March 1st, 1914 in the evening. Peter K Lemon. At called at the hotel I served notice on him to appear before the Council of the 12th and to show cause why he should not be excommunicated for unlawfully taking a wife. He stated to me that Nathan G Clark had written him that if he wished to take a plural wife to come to Centerville. Utah.
3:12:35 Where he Clark would meet him at a house two blocks West. He followed directions and went to the House of a young man named Woolly and told him what he come for. The young man said that there would be a man there soon to attend to the matter for him, and later an older man came to him and performed the ceremony. So yeah, probably Lauren and John Woolly there, right? This is interesting too, in that conversation. With. Anthony W Ivins. Peter K Levin. Says he had never talked with Brother Matthias F Cowley on the subject. He he said that he would appear before the council and make a full statement of facts.
3:13:16 He had met Brother Joseph W Musser at the Fisher home some time ago and he told him that John Wooley had given the whole thing away, that John Wooley had given it all the way. Yeah, but interesting that that place is Joseph. Muster and Jean Wooley into association. With each. Other as early as whenever that marriage took place before 1914, right before March of 19. 14 for sure. March 30th, 1914. From the Minutes. Of the quorum of the 12. The Minutes state Brother John Wooley stated some time ago that he went up to the president's office to talk with Joseph F Smith as he was intending to take a trip to the Sandwich Islands for his health. President Anthony H London James E Town, which were present at the time.
3:14:06 The conversation was not very long. As he got up to go, President Smith asked him what about the Joseph Silver case and I told him about it and he said, didn't you think you were doing wrong? I said I didn't think I was doing very wrong at the time. That's interesting. So but James E Town, which was there, I will just point that out. So I said putting on the show. Yep, Yep. And Talmage was a hater of polygamy, if I'm not mistaken. Yeah, yeah, he was. He was definitely tasked a lot of the. Time with dealing with the. Early. Those are these early cases that we're talking about. I don't know if there's any personal motivation or grudges. I I don't know if there was or not. Or if he's just doing his duty being a good soldier.
3:14:48 No. Yeah, let's see what else I got. The minutes. Of April. Second states. That on Monday the. 12 Sat in. Council on the cases of Matthias F Cowley and John W Wooley, but failed to bring out evidence enough to justify the Council in taking action against Brother Cowley, although some things went to indicate that he was responsible for Brother John Wooley's operations. Action was taken against Brother Wooley on his own confession and he was excommunicated from the Church, but he wanted to share the responsibility of his transgression with Brother Cowley. Brother Callie denied everything and was willing to take an oath that he had not encouraged anybody to enter plural marriage since action was taken on his case.
3:15:35 But I will state both guns are pointing on Callie's involvement from from Johnson and Woolley saying that. He. Was involved. So I'm just, I'm just throwing it out there. So do you think that what's your opinion there? Do you think Callie's just trying to preserve himself? Absolutely. Absolutely, I do. They were. All. In it together that one point and then when? Things got things. Began to be haunted. Down. There was probably some fragmentation in their, you know, relationships.
3:16:19 In August of 19. 16 John W Taylor was baptized by his brother Joseph. No, sorry, His brother, Moses W Taylor. With John. M Cannon and others present in Utah Lake tradition states that Matthias Cowley performed the marriage. And that two state presidents were. Were present baptism. What I say marriage. Yes. Thank you for thank you for correcting me. Yeah. Fundamentalist tradition. States that.
3:17:00 The RE baptism. Which was clandestine. Was done by Cowley at Utah Lake with two stake presidents. I found in James E Talmage's diary that the whole situation was done by Moses W Taylor who was told by John M Cannon to re baptize John W Taylor and Moses W Taylor told James E Talmadge. That when John M Cannon had. Gone to If I'm getting this right, I'd probably put it in here. Let me just make sure I'm getting this information right I. Forgot about.
3:17:40 That. Can't find it in any case. Either. John M Cannon, OR. Moses W. Taylor. Had also. Gone to Joseph. F Smith asking what could be? Done. For John W Taylor, in his case, and I think it was Moses, Moses W Taylor went to Joseph F Smith and. Joseph F. Smith told Moses W Taylor. Do you know what authority you have? And while I cannot, I can tell you that nothing can be done in the church for Brother Taylor. But then. Something along the lines of but I but I think I don't need to tell you what you can do for your brother.
3:18:22 You know interesting. And so they went and performed that re baptism which was not accepted by the Church. And was not. No record was made of it and it caused quite the scandal. In fact, there was public announcements. Made after John. W Taylor died regarding this that addressing rumors because rumors had started to circulate that John W. Taylor had been accepted back. Into the Church before he died secretly. Although fundamentalist tradition does state also all right, I shouldn't say fundamentalist Taylor family tradition states that Joseph F Smith delivered temple garments and robes.
3:19:09 To. Nettie Taylor Wooly Taylor to bury her husband in at the funeral, which was a closed casket so that he could be buried in his temple robes. Dude. Like even in death, the poor guy can't get. Get get just some recognition. I mean just. Close the casket right, we don't want. Anyone seeing He's in his temple robes. Yeah, that's tough. But on the same on on the other hand I mean the. The cards show that while while these things couldn't be acknowledged, it shows that I I think it validates Brother Taylor, especially in the eyes of the president of the church.
3:19:57 Sure it does. It shows his valiance. It shows the belief that Joseph F Smith and others had. That the Lord. The Lord. Understood, John, you know. What? Let's say John W. Taylor's life and name. Is written on the books of the of the Lamb of. God. And it doesn't need to be on them. The the membership records of the church, it again boggles my mind that that. Joseph F You. Said it was. Joseph F Smith, who delivered it? The President of the Church personally. Delivers. The. Garments and the temple robes, but yet still feels compelled to tell his wife. Nettie, make sure you close that casket. It just smacks.
3:20:48 Of a man who's not in control? Yep. No, you're absolutely correct, Fundamentalist tradition states. That. Before John W Taylor died. That. The tradition states that John W Taylor met Francis Lyman on the street shortly before his death and informed him, Francis, I am not going to be here on earth much longer, and when I go, I am going to send for you to stand before the great judge and account for the things you've done to me. And while President, Lyman outwardly appeared to be in good health.
3:21:29 In that season of his life. A few weeks. Later John died on October 10th, 1916 of cancer and a month following it President Lyman died as well on November 18th, 1916. Oh man. I wonder what lat crossing over looked like. Yeah, however. John W Taylor has been RE. Added to the membership of the church and a Reba baptism was done by Joseph Fielding Smith, President Joseph Fielding Smith.
3:22:13 I don't he was not present to the church yet. It was under. It was under. David O Mckay's. Presidency and Joe Apostle Joseph Fielding Smith officiated, I believe re baptizing Raymond Taylor, his son, as proxy for John W Taylor and conferring, reconfirming the priesthood upon John W Taylor, and so his name is on the records of the Church. Now. And those things are restored interesting. I would dare to say they never left right. I oh, I would totally. Agree with that? That's not even. Not even kidding you. So what do you think?
3:22:53 Oh, go ahead. No, you got. No, I was going to do a wrap up question. I thought you were done. We're not done. We are done with John W Taylor. But there's a few. Other points of post manifesto Polygamy. I would like to cover, yeah, for the context sake. However, I would like to read a few things that people said about John W Taylor after he died. OK, Josiah E Hickman, who we understand was a post. Manifesto polygamist, he appeared. In some of these episodes, and he was accused of being part of the circle of network that we've talked about, and he probably was. If he was accused.
3:23:35 Of being it. But any case, he writes in his journal on October 12th, 2 days. So October 12th, 1916, two days after John W. Taylor dies, he writes. John W Taylor, former apostle, died Tuesday. His death caused a profound sorrow in my heart. I have loved him for his integrity and the great prophetic power he has once possessed. He was true. To his convictions, life or death, he has been excommunicated from the Church. Yet he was firm in his belief and still held that our leaders sacrificed principle for policy. He felt the Manifesto was a snare and a delusion, and he could never accept of it, but held to God's revelation to his Father.
3:24:23 I have this revelation in my possession, and in it God especially says that he does not wish this people to sacrifice the principle of plural marriage or make further promises to their enemies. He was true to his belief, and testified to his death to the truthfulness of the gospel, and a great. Undying. Faith that all would be right at a time. His death was due to a cancerous condition condition of his intestines. He left five wives. It was really six and between 20 and 30 children, Apostle Lyman once told me some 20 years ago. Apostle Lyman.
3:25:05 Once told me some 20. Years ago that John W Taylor was the most spiritually minded. Man of the Quorum. He said, Quote, He is our prophet. Wow. So at one point, Francis M Lyman was calling John W Taylor. Our Prophet. Meaning the. Nickname. That he had, which was the prophet of the Quorum. Yeah, Isn't that a sad tale of betrayal? Hoof. Where did Lyman go wrong? It was that Reed Smoot hearings, dude, I'm convinced. Of it? There's the public shame, stupid. Stupid. That's what I keep coming back to.
3:25:46 Just dumb. I mean, you you're worried about public perception? Yeah. I don't know man. I I don't know why was it, was it more than that? Was it entangled with? More of a fear of the fallout of the well. Of the. Temporal well-being. Of the rest of the members of the church. Or the? The idea that maybe people's salvation would be at stake because of the church fractured the general membership who were too weak in their faith would not have a rod to cling to. Maybe that's the case. And I mean, I know at least AUB rhetoric is that the Church is doing a mission. Of a.
3:26:30 Terrestrial order still allowing the the. Gospel as taught. In the Book of Mormon, to be promulgated and to bring people into a higher degree of glory than they would have, even though they've abandoned plural marriage, which will exalt you. Right. And that you need to go to the priesthood group to get that done. I don't know. What was that, that kind of forethought at that at this early time period that justified these things? That's probably the best motivation that there could have been. And I hope it wasn't anything less than, besides personal, you know, ownership of material things or prosperity. Yeah, I don't know. Lyman seems awfully sneaky, though I can't say he wasn't a good man in most junctures of his life.
3:27:10 But yes, I would agree, by the end of his life he was acting. Like a snake. And he was very vindictive. And Joseph Mustard tells us that from his interview as well. Down. The line in reminiscence told by Price Johnson in 1971. There's an interview done by Rhea Allred Koons of On Price Johnson, Bria Allred. Coons asks. Do you know when? Nathan Clark received. His authority. Price, Johnson says. Yes, he. Told me the whole story. He was called with Joseph Muster to be a missionary on the Temple Block.
3:27:53 John W Woolley and Joseph F Smith later laid their hands on him and ordained him to perform plural marriages. This was at the same time that they ordained Joseph Muster. Nathan told me that story. I've discussed it with him many times, Rhea Koons asked. Do you know when this authority was given Price? Johnson says. Let's see here. It was about 7. There was about seven years, and he told me in 1923, seven years. So that puts. Seven years between. 9 before 1923 fits well with. Joseph. Muster saying that he received his keys of Elijah in 1915. Right now I found Talmage's diary about the baptism.
3:28:39 But. I think we all went over that, so we. Don't need to rehash that in 1921 March. 15th. Heber J. Grant writes in his journal, A President Frank White Taylor and his counselor called and explained the status of Joseph Musser, of the of the Joseph Musser case, and Brother Penrose and I assured then that while we felt their evidence would not be accepted in a court of law, it was sufficient, in addition to the inspiration of the Spirit of the Lord, to excommunicate muster from the Church. So that's when Joseph. Muster gets excommunicated from the church. He was attempting to take a fourth wife.
3:29:19 We know. That around March or May of nine, No, sorry, of 1922. A year later than that, Lauren Wooley is actively relating and proselyte proselyting the 1886 events at the Nathaniel Baldwin radio plant, also at the same. Time. That Joseph muster is being excommunicated. They also excommunicated Patriarch Israel Barlow Junior for helping people enter into plural marriage in 1921. So they excommunicated his son in 1910. And they. Excommunicated him in in 1921. So they're just going they're they're still cleaning this up, right?
3:30:07 They're. Still. Cleaning this up and these are just all the people. That were involved with those early. Those early days before the fundamentalist movement. Came out right and we're really getting to the point where it really is emerging now I I. Just wanted to. Bring this up so there's more full context. Let's see in Richard R Lyman's diary quoted. In the Minutes of the quorum. Of the 12 Apostles, the electronic edition Richard Lyman writes on March 27th, 1921. Nathan G. Clark says he was. Advised by President Joseph F Smith to make himself a sacrifice, and he is telling that it is all right for men to take plural lives. If they will do it quietly, the Church will sanction it. So that might have been the influence for Richard Lyman to enter into his union.
3:31:00 Absolutely it was. Absolutely it was. Without a. Doubt right? He's thinking to himself, OK? How do I? Do this well. You know everyone. Knows who Nathan. G Clark is. Let's go talk to him. And then it's. It's it's game on, right? The Solemn Covenant is made. Sure. Keep it quiet in the church like Nathan Clark is saying in Heber J Grant's. Diary Heber. Writes on. April 29th, 19. 31. This morning, a man.
3:31:41 By the name of Muir. Called and I had a long talk with him. He manifested a very fine spirit. He explained that Brother Matthias F Cowley had tried to convert him to plural marriage in 1910 after he had been dropped from the Council of the 12:00, and had pledged himself that if we would not cut him off the Church, he would. Stop. Teaching that it was right to practice plural marriage, so that that's an additional witness that Cowley was involved with all that despite his despite his protests. And. Denials in 1933. Hebrew J Grant writes in his journal that. Joseph Fielding Smith called and expressed his regret at the speeches of Bishop Archie Graham, telling of his, oh, his paraphrase. Archie Graham was telling of an event where he kind of had some astral projection stuff going on, like where you could see the spirit world or something.
3:32:39 In any case, it was really popular and he was going around giving these lectures and Joseph Joseph Fielding Smith because President Smith's dead. At this point. Joseph Fielding Smith is talking to Hebrew Jay Grant, saying that this shouldn't really be going on. And so Hebrew Jay Grant calls Bishop Archie Graham in and has a talk with him. The Journal entry says, quote I explained about the manifestations and the private meetings of the patriarchs in Davis County with brother John W Taylor and how they thought they were more spiritually minded than others and that these identical patriarchs got off their hooks and performed illegal plural marriages, etcetera. Wow.
3:33:26 So this leaves a mark on the man who really tried to stamp this out, right? And. And. Boy, in some ways I think this is probably the birth of, you know, correlation. Oh yeah, right. They're like we can't leave these people just to read their scriptures and. And. Actually do what? They say, yeah, all right, maybe. We. Should close. This with the words. Of Joseph Musser. How about that? OK, in Truth Magazine, volume 6, Joseph Muster writes a little editorial recalling John W Taylor. In it, Muster writes, during his mortal career, he was perhaps the leader among the brethren of his quorum in the prophetic gifts.
3:34:16 He was designated the prophet of the Quorum by Hebrew J Grant in a letter from England to President Joseph F Smith. John W Taylor was a true apostle of the Lord Jesus Christ. He lived for the gospel, his devotion to the. Kingdom of God was. Paramount. He entertained no thoughts nor ambitions, countering his loyalty to God. Wherever his lot was cast, he defended the truth. In his missionary work, he was a living prototype of Paul the Apostle. With him truth was life, his very existence. He could no more be wrong to his conceptions of right than he could change the law. Of gravity. He was a true. Son of a noble Sire.
3:34:57 And in this life the light and lives of all the prophets of God were reflected with him. There were no classes among true Latter Day Saints. He followed the example of his worthy father, the Prophet. John Taylor. When reference was made before the latter to the common people of the Church, he replied with emphasis. Well, there are no common people among true Latter Day Saints. All are on the same footing. All are of a royal class. Apostle Taylor heeded the same. Truth he. Saw among the humblest of the Saints, the Princess and princesses of Heaven. Well, many arrogant and affluent types he marked as failures. OK, I'm going to ask you a couple of quick questions. Yeah, let's reach out.
3:35:42 Sure. No doubt. And then? I have. Something just occurred to me that I I want to. Run by you sure. First, what are the repercussions too fundamentalists for the work that John W Taylor did? I have a great question. I honestly don't know if things would have turned out the way they did with the. Priesthood work barring divine intervention. If he had not been involved without his example and public and private encouragement of polygamy all the years of his life, despite the manifestos, I don't know, and it's maybe they would have. But would men like John Wooley have had the strength to carry on right that burden alone, but when you have such a freaking monolith to look up to? You.
3:36:33 Don't want to let them down? And you're. Encouraged to shoulder that burden and carry on the. Work when they're gone, Absolutely. I I I. Could not tell you I mean. If there, if there were three pillars to Mormon. Fundamentalism I. Would probably say, and this may be subject to reflection of you know, if I wasn't so tired at this point in time, but if I were to say the three pillar, there they were probably John W Taylor. John Wooley and Lauren Wooley. No. And Joseph Mustard. Sorry, John Wooley. John W Taylor and Joseph Mustard. Not to discount Lauren Wooley, not to discount others, but those three people without their willingness and and just the certain circumstances. They were placed.
3:37:18 In with the things that they did, not that someone else couldn't have done them, but they did them. They did those things that allowed the work to carry on. I just, like I said, someone else could have been raised up to do it. Obviously there was authority being compartmentalized and spread around, but I really think any way you trace it, even especially if you don't believe in the Lord and wooly story which the Church has tried to malign. And I'm not saying I don't believe in it, because I do. But this whole situation brings an interesting redundancy. Or fail safe. Program to the keys being passed on whether you want.
3:37:58 To claim it. Coming from the LDS Church or outside from the Woollies? There's there's a line. To trace, there's a line to trace it to another Apostle of the Lord, which is has been underrated. Which is John W Taylor. Yeah. His apostleship is just as good as any other apostleship, in my opinion. Yep. Yep, absolutely. I look at it as. You have. In my opinion. 2 lines of authority. That you could really in in this case. Speaking of this. Case There's two lines of authority that you can cling to.
3:38:40 You can cling to the woolies, right? If you think the church lost everything in in 1886. Or you could say, Nope, the church still had it and there's an apostle that branches off, so to speak, and keeps it alive. So I agree with a fail safe. Let me ask you this question. What do you think the legacy of John W Taylor is within the LDS Church? Oh, I know I Growing up, I never heard about him. The first time I ever heard about him was when I was on my mission and the Church published. What they called Gospel Topics essays and they addressed polygamy after the Manifesto.
3:39:24 And they literally just placed it just on Matthias Cowley and John W Taylor and said it was nothing more than just a few plural marriages as we have discussed. Nothing to be further from the truth, right? I think John W Taylor is. Really. Probably kind of. Responsible. For. The. Church doing a couple of. Things one is this big push for correlation, right where we're going to be the same everywhere across the board, 'cause we can't have a rogue element again. Like we just saw. Sure. And I also think that John W Taylor and and I'm not saying that these are bad things that Taylor did not by any stretch of the imagination.
3:40:13 I'm just saying this is what his opponents did because of it, because of his actions of holding to the to the truth and and erring on the side of right. So correlation, the other thing I think that John W Taylor forces the church to do, and maybe that's a better way of putting it right, I think John Taylor. Forces the church to go. To a correlation model because you can't have rogue elements, so to speak. Just picking up the scriptures and being like, well, that's what it says, let's do that. The other thing I think he does is he forces the church to start instituting loyalty tests to the man in charge, right?
3:41:01 And I think he he forces them to change from. A place and and. This may upset some people. I apologize. This is just how I see it. It forces the church to move from a church founded in principle to a church. Of men. Right. Doesn't matter what the guy before you did. It only matters what the guy right now does. Oh my yes. And? And I think that's a direct result of Taylor's doggedness and determination to serve the Lord at any cost. Even if it flies in. The face of what is said publicly, I I want to know I'm.
3:41:43 Making my own comment. To tour to our listeners on that or something you brought up about. Following the. Living profit or following the living oracles and the rhetoric is that those are the dead profits follow the living profit, right? I will state to you right now, just because they're dead doesn't mean they're wrong, right? Absolutely, absolutely. 100%. And look, let's parse out. Some words here, right? I mean the other. Side likes to do that. Sure. Those past prophets, they're not dead. They're just on the other side of the veil, right? Or your living prophet's just gonna be a dead prophet one day.
3:42:25 So then why even listen to his words now? Absolutely. Chuck it. Chuck it in the trash bin. Yeah. Because nothing's permanent. Yep. The other. Thing I will say is that after. John W Taylor and his Generation. I know there was one in. There at the same time he was that went. Through but I can't. Think of too many Youngs or Taylors being called to the Quorum of the 12 after this. Sure. No, you're right. You're right about that. I think this is my opinion. I think he. Scared the crap out of the organization and they.
3:43:08 Were like if we want to move forward, if we want to quote progress, we cannot be having this these families be in leadership any longer. That's a good point. And. Because after this I know there's. A young on there. At that point. But. Bring him, bring him after him. I don't see anybody. Else. There might have been one more young Was there a? There might have been a Dilworth young. I want to. Say but OK. You might be right, but I don't know. Certainly don't see any more Taylors. Not that I recall.
3:43:50 You don't. See any more Woodruffs? No. And we'll we'll just say. OK, there was. One more young after. That. Maybe but. Since then, no, I think, I think John. W Taylor single handedly. Scared the crap out of the church and said, and the church said we can't have the the, you know, the, the, the, the blood legacy of these people, the. The posterity of of. These early leaders throw monkey wrenches. Into what we want. To do from this point. Forward that's potentially a very fair observation. The other thing I'll say is that we would not have. What we have now today as fundamentalists. Without John W Taylor it just doesn't happen. I hear you.
3:44:42 Best case scenario it would have happened some other way, but like I've stated before. He laid in a similitude to Christ as a true prophet of God. Should be. And his life was that way. In ways that are way beyond his circumstances and control, he was willing to lay down his. Life for the. Perpetuation of the priesthood as that we that we can be exalted. Yep. Yep, 100 percent, 100% and he's indispensable for his time as. Much as. Brigham Young was indispensable for his time. Amen. John W Taylor was the indispensable man for his time, and I'm sure it must have hurt his children somewhat to have to see their dad pass away in the circumstances that he did. But a funny thing is that because of God and because of honest history, the truth always comes out. The truth always comes out.
3:45:38 And I would dare to say that in going forward we'll look at guys like Taylor and Musser and Woolly a lot more frequently than what we have up to this point because. Quite frankly, I think we're. Gonna need need their examples more and more sure and and I think that's really the legacy come what may come hell or high water. Just stand. For what you know is right and let let the consequences fall, consequences be damned. So rage it. That's right, dude. I'll. Tell you what, this was good. Stuff. I always enjoy it every.
3:46:19 Single time So. Anything you want? No, I don't know. I'm. I'm too tired of thinking much. Besides saying you're all. Caught up for now, yeah. That's all. That's all I got, I think. Awesome. Awesome. All right, man. Well. I. Guess I'll see you in a few days now. Sounds great. Can't wait. Awesome. Bye everybody.
3:47:13 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox