Feb. 24, 2024

Episode #118: The Life & Times Of John W. Taylor Part 4-A Band Of Brothers & A Christ-Like Sacrifice W/Michael Ness

Episode #118: The Life & Times Of John W. Taylor Part 4-A Band Of Brothers & A Christ-Like Sacrifice W/Michael Ness
Episode #118: The Life & Times Of John W. Taylor Part 4-A Band Of Brothers & A Christ-Like Sacrifice W/Michael Ness
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #118: The Life & Times Of John W. Taylor Part 4-A Band Of Brothers & A Christ-Like Sacrifice W/Michael Ness

Go To http://patreon.com/MormonRenegade368 For Exclusive Content

So we are now on episode number 4 of the series we are doing on the Life and Times Of John W. Taylor. On this episode Michael Ness and I cover a part of Mormon history where the tides really begin to change on the Churches unofficial stance on plural marriage. Now there are two things that really come through on this episode. One is the “band of brothers” mentality that some of the more ardent defenders of the principle had in the quorum of the twelve and even more inspiring than that is perhaps outside of Joseph Smith a personal Christ-like sacrifice made by John W. Taylor and ultimately a betrayal of that sacrifice by some members in the quorum of the twelve that gets my blood boiling and causes me to get a little spicy.

--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support

0:12 So we're now on episode #4 of the series We're doing on the Life and Times of John W Taylor. On this episode, Michael Ness and I cover a part of Mormon history where the tide really begins to change on the church's unofficial stance on plural marriage. Now, there are two things that really come through on this episode. One is the kind of band of brothers mentality that some of the more ardent defenders of the principal had in the Quorum of the 12. And even more inspiring than that is perhaps outside of Joseph Smith, a personal Christ like sacrifice made by John W Taylor and ultimately a betrayal of that sacrifice by some members in the Quorum of the 12. That really gets my blood boiling and causes me to become just a little bit spicy. Stick around for that and more on this episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast.

0:58 Look, it's no secret that our society has become much more crude and coarse. To become and raise men and women of virtue and character is a Herculean task. To help with this, I've recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior and Company and Conversation. It was a book with 110 rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society, something that today's society is sorely lacking. What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So the book is laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule.

1:39 Right below that is my explanation for the 21st century, and below that you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, to go along with this, there's a workbook that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids. To find the book, go to mormonrenegade.com, go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post, and order your copy. Today, I can bear personal testimony from personal experience that this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character. Listening to the Mormon Renegade Podcast and we're back again. Howdy, Dave.

2:53 How's it going? Pretty good. Good. So where'd we leave off? Last time we left off where exactly? I was gonna, I was gonna ask you that question. Did we talk about the division of the Alberta stake in Canada? Yes. Yep, we did. So maybe we'll just recap there and go forward. Although I would like to make a little bit of an apology or a disclaimer. I was listening to episode 2 at work with some of my with my brother-in-law and some friends and as I was hearing our our back and forth, I I I realized I said something that I I didn't like how it came out.

3:41 I was talking about how some of my source material came from a book published by Steve Murphy and I said that he had been excommunicated from the AB and I just left it at that and it sounded that and I don't want to. I I I feel like I should say that I only stated that because that had reference to not to any moral issue, but because of the the turmoil in the AUB website that was going on for a few years when they had the split with Pinesdale and with he. If I'm if I'm remembering correctly, he had some, he caused some that he voiced his concerns regarding leadership being accountable through a trial by a high council type format. OK, And he voiced his opinions enough times on that that I believe they they they disinvited him from intending meetings and then offered a formal excommunication. And the only reason I stated that was because I I thought, well, wanted to be clear.

4:47 But also the there's a little bit of irony in the sense that fundamentalism was born out of the idea that, well, even though the Church excommunicated us, we didn't lose our priesthood. Right. I thought it was a little funny to be excommunicated formally from a priesthood group that's not technically a church. But on the other hand, I don't think that you couldn't essentially excommunicate someone through gross misconduct or or other issues. He's, you know, those those things are necessary to do sometimes. Not saying it was necessary in his case whatsoever, but he put together two really good books that I have. I mean, I've only talked to him the one time when I when I talked to him about those, but he put it together a really cool book.

5:37 I think he just called it Conference Reports, but it was essentially laid out the way Mormon Doctrine by Bruce R Mcconkey was laid out by topic, but all the references are Journal of Discourse references. And then the other one was what I've been using for some source material or the earlier episodes, which was George Q Cannon's journal that he reproduced, which was awesome. Nice. OK. No, we got that out of the way. It's always good to to lead with that sort of stuff. Yeah, no, I felt I I I listened to that and I was like oh that might might felt like a character assassination or something. And I I had no way, shape or form it to assassinate anyone's character by saying.

6:20 That OK? Yeah. No. So what was his name again? Steve Murphy. OK, He's good in our book. We'll just go with that. He's good in our book. Yep. Absolutely. All right, so leaving off. Or. Around the time we left off in August 30th 19 O3 the Alberta Steak was divided and Heber Simeon Allen was asked to be the new president of Taylor Steak in which was centered in Raymond to Alberta, Canada and a number of authorities including Matthias Cowley, John W Taylor, Anthony H Lund, Reed Smoot and Joseph F Smith came to Carsten to divide the stake.

7:02 And sometime during their visit John W Taylor and Matthias Cowley convinced Heber Allen and Edward J Wood to both enter into the principle of plural marriage. EJ Wood becomes the first president of the Carson Alberta Temple, as well as being the state president and at President Wood's death in 1956. President David O McKay, who was president of the church then, told Hubie Brown that we have never had a greater president of a stake than Edward J Wood. And he. But yeah, he was a polygamist.

7:43 Both of those got, you know, both steaks. They're presided over by polygamists and a great steak president in the case of EJ Wood. And he, he would visit his second wife in Salt Lake City at least twice a year for conferences and stay with her during those. So it was still pretty underground for the pretty much the rest of his life. And that's as crazy to me, but it shows commitment. What year did he die? 1956 OK. Put that in. Context. And he entered in, and he entered into the principal sometime after August of nineteen, O 3. Yeah. But yeah, just put that in context, right. In 56, who was president of the church? Was that David O McKay?

8:28 Yeah, OK. And he knows. There's no way he doesn't know. It's it's likely. He probably knew, Yeah. I mean I think we mentioned this last episode, but yeah, I mean we, we know from Joseph Musser's Inquisition in 19 O Nine that David O Mackay was noticeably nicer to Joseph Musser than others. You know, same with Roger Clausen and Orson F Whitney. You know, they were they were friendly even defending Brother Musser during that time period. And there are those stories about David O Mackay entering into the principal. We know that Orson F Whitney entered into the principal, and we know that Rudder Clausen entered into the principal Post Manifesto. Right, right.

9:14 And and I think I brought this up when we recapped it, there is a lot of accounts that people would go talk to to David O McKay and be like what's this Adam God stuff or you know, ask questions about polygamy and then magically though that couple would get a call from Allred or somebody else and so and so yeah, there those relationships weren't always as icy as they are today. Sure. No doubt about that. Yeah. There's a there's indication and I don't know how long he was president of Boise Steak but there was a according to those early fundamentalists, one of them being Carl Jench.

10:02 Yeah. He, he gets involved with John Wooley in 1928, you know, well, after the time period we're talking about. But he's, he talked about being told by Joseph Muster that Heber Q Hale who was president of the the Boise State, was set apart by Joseph F Smith to perpetuate plural marriage in about 1917 or so. And I don't know how long he lived or was president of Boise State, but there's that, you know. So yeah, and I don't know what activity I I haven't ever dug into that. That's something that might take, you know, future research. Let's see in on September 11th, 19 O3 Joseph F Smith told John W Taylor to authorize Patriarch John A Wolf, who was a former Bishop and member of the state presidency, to perform plural A, a plural marriage for Franklin D Levitt. 8 years later in 1911, when I asked about it, John W Taylor told The 12 that he was under orders to do that.

11:08 In particular, Matthias F Cowley was a brother-in-law to Patriarch Wolf and also made mention of it in his fellowship trial, saying all I know, I think a Brother Levitt went to President Smith and asked him if it would be all right if he referred to Brother Taylor, who had charge of all things in Canada. Yeah, that's what he said. And D Michael Quinn says supporting evidence for President Smith's authorization of these Canadian plural marriages from 19 O3 onward is found in the fact that the records of these ordinances have been kept under First Presidency control. Yeah, yeah, they they don't want that getting out, right. I mean, if that gets out, that's that's there's some real questions then starting, you know, the way the current narrative is framed, you know the the manifesto comes out and a few stragglers hold on to it and then the second manifesto comes out and we're completely done with this. This is not the case.

12:15 This is not what history. No. And we're getting into the second manifesto time period really quick. It's on, We're right in front of that right now and we're going to see just how much that it's not the case and it's going to blow your mind. But yeah, so Speaking of record books, so, So Quinn is saying that there was a record book kept of the authorized Canadian marriages. I'm assuming, and maybe I was assuming incorrectly, that that was kept by Brother Wolf. Possibly. Maybe by others like EJ Wood, who was the temple president Mistake President, I don't know. But you had. We have plenty of what they called out of temple ceiling record books.

12:55 Anthony Ivins kept 1 Alexander F, McDonald's kept one. Both of those were down in Mexico, so there's no stretch of the imagination to believe that they were keeping that in Canada as well. Matthias Cowley had a record book that was turned into the church at one point. I I wouldn't doubt that John W Taylor had one if Matthias Cowley had one. John George Buchanan's journals have been published, although some are redacted or pages have been removed. But from a book that D Michael Quinn was going to publish before he died, he stated that there is a memorandum book of George Buchanan's that is hidden away still and no one has seen it.

13:37 So it makes me wonder what's in the memorandum book. I don't know. In any case, the drama continues going into September 14th. That same year, 19 O3 leaving Canada. Joseph F Smith and those with him traveled to Wyoming, and Wyoming had been under the colonization efforts of Abraham Owen Woodruff, and in a meeting in the Bighorn Stake in Wyoming, he listened. Joseph F Smith listened to John W Taylor give a public sermon defending polygamy, after which Matthias F Cowley performed a marriage for the state president there.

14:25 While Joseph F Smith was there. While Joseph F Smith was there, yeah. Interesting. The date I have for Sean W Taylor performing that plural marriage for the new president of the Taylor Stake up in Canada is five days after that sermon. So I guess he goes back up to Canada and performs a plural marriage for Hebrew S Allen and his second wife. So then later that month to September 25th, 1903, a general board member of the YMMIAI believe is the the Young Men's Mutual Improvement Association.

15:08 A guy named Joseph W Summerhays marries his fifth wife. Now, if you remember from last episode, he had had a conversation with a Bishop from Springville and Joseph F Smith five years previously about whether it was OK to enter into plural marriage. And he was told he was told by President Smith that there was ways that that could be accomplished. So five years after that, he is married to his fifth wife in Chicago, IL by Matthias Kelly. Wow in Chicago. Yeah, it must have been some sort of business trip. Yeah, there was some business, yeah. There's some that's that's for sure the Lord's business. Yeah, yeah.

15:51 There was some business happening, the Lord's business. There's a journal entry in Rugger Clawson's journal in October 10th, 1903 where he writes that he talked with one of his wives about marrying another plural wife and received her permission to do so. It's all over the place, right? I mean, it just doesn't end. It's it just like those who are desirous to enter the principal at this time period, All you got to do is ask, bro, right? Like we're not. We're not telling you you should, but all you got to do is ask and things will happen. The the unfortunate thing is that probably because of that we get the problems in the Reed Smith hearings that come at the very end of this year, which we're approaching, which gets the 2nd manifesto essentially.

16:43 But we're going to get to that really quick. November 3rd, 19 O 3 the grandfather of current member of the First Presidency Henry B. Iring Edward Iring is sealed by Abraham Owen Woodruff in Colonia Juarez to his second wife. And I believe, and I'm not entirely sure, that he ends up with a third wife too but I don't recall at this exact moment. But he writes in his journal. This is Edward Iring writes in 19 O3. I decided to try and enter into the holy order of plural marriage. So with the help of my wife, I was able to woo my wife's sister Emma, after considerable persuasion, married her in November.

17:25 Wow. And so Owen Woodruff sealed it, and Ivan's reported it in his record book. So they're keeping records of all this. So they're they're still under the understanding or or this idea that just hold on these records because right around the corner this is coming back and we'll need all these records and we make sure you guys keep a hold of all these records so that when this happens we can all bring it back in. No. And and look at the family relation Henry B. Iring living today. His grandfather. That was his grandpa. Rampa, right? That's like one person ago. Yeah, that's one person ago. He probably knew his grandpa, You know what I mean? Exactly.

18:09 Yeah. And so, so think about this, right? Think about this. I'm. I'm only speculating. Maybe one of them died before Henry was born. But there's a good likelihood that Henry B Eyring, he's hanging out with some peligs. Oh. Same time. Hitting on his grandfather's knee and like, oh, she's my grandma and she's my grandma. I mean, just again, one person ago. This is not ancient history. This is very recent. No. Well, and you, when you see all the people that his grandfather's hanging out with, you know, I think I got some of that in here. We're gonna get into that. So the day after that, we see in Anthony Ivan's journal, because he's writing down this, you know, this, that marriage. The day before he writes.

18:57 We started for Sonora this morning and nooned about 8 miles West of Ramos, camped on the Janus River. Our party consisted of Apostle John W Taylor and wife Nellie, Apostle Owen Woodruff and wife Avery and John M Cannon and wife Bishop Bentley, now Bishop Bentley. Joseph Bentley had at least two or three wives post manifesto sealed to him by the way his wife Maggie and four of her children and sister Cannon's daughter Margaret and sister Irene. So one of one of brother Irene's wives traveling with Owen Woodruff, George M or John M Cannon, who we know is friends with Joseph Muster and John W Taylor and John W Taylor's there himself.

19:47 And how many? Wives, Wilson. How many wives did I ring end up with? At least two, maybe three, I don't know. But at least two. We might cover him. Taking another one in a minute, I don't recall. But they're also traveling with Guy C Wilson. Who had at least two or three wives, Two of them I believe believe being Post Manifesto and brother Helam and Pratt, son of Parley P Pratt, who also was a Post Manifesto polygamist and brothers Dan Skousen and brother Joseph C Davis and Don Maroni Lebaron. Who is an uncle today? Or Lebaron? Interesting.

20:28 So a who's who of not only church membership, but of future fundamentalists as well, or people. Related to future fundamentalists, yes, I have no indication that Don Lebaron was ever involved in fundamentalism, but you can't expect me to believe that nephew and uncle never talked. No, no, no, no. No, no, no, no. Right. Like, like for some, I get it. They want to keep the blinders on and be like, but it was never talked about. And I'm like I Ring was sitting on his grandfather's lap most likely. Maybe he died before he was born, I don't know. But the point I'm making this is all in close, close proximity, time wise and all the big names within the church today and prominent fundamentalists.

21:21 They're rubbing elbows. Yeah, so let's look at the prominent names here. We got Lebaron, Skousen, Frat Cannon, Woodruff, and Taylor and Ivins. Yeah, it's crazy. Six days after that, Abraham Owen Woodruff seals a plural marriage to the residence down in colonial Oaxaca. Over a period of 15 days that is included in those two entries, Owen Woodruff had performed 3 plural ceilings, so he's done 3 down there on that trip.

22:04 Now entering into the new year, we're in 19 O four. There was a meeting of after after a meeting of the Quorum of the 12, Matthias Cowley and two other members of the corps met in the Salt Lake Temple to perform plural marriages. I don't have any more record of who was involved or who wasn't besides that, but Mathias Cowley and two others accepting and it was not that. That's not including John W Taylor because John W Taylor cautioned them, the three of them, whoever they were, about being so active in promoting new plural marriage. So John W Taylor's kind of being a voice of caution in that instance, saying, hey, you're in the temple, whatever you're doing, just don't get caught, you know? Which if John W Taylor has to warn you about being discreet, you might be being being a little loud, right? I mean, John W Taylor is not quiet, right? He doesn't mind rocking the boat a little bit. So it it would be a lot like me telling somebody else to watch what they eat.

23:05 It just, you know, if I have to tell you, maybe you shouldn't have that next Snickers bar. You may want to listen because look at how out of shape I am. So just take that. You bring up a point I hadn't thought of there before that if John. Yeah, if he's warning you, that's a good question because. Or a good thing to consider because it's. Yeah, he he does not. He's not afraid to say what he needs to say when he needs to say it. So now we're getting into the Reed Smoot hearings on January 16th, 1904. Senator Reid Smoot and Senator Reid Smoot is a member of the Quorum of the 12 Apostles. I believe he's the only monogamist of the Quorum of the 12 at this point.

23:50 He issues a flat denial to the Senate Committee, which was investigating whether the Church was continuing plural marriage, and says underoath that none of the First Presidency or the 12 had taken plural lives or lived with their plural lives since the Manifesto of 1890. That is a bold faced lie. Brothers, that we've just we've we've disproved seven ways to Sunday up to this point in the series. Yeah, we we we remember that Wilford Woodruff underoath said the same thing in 1891, but then he turned around in private meetings and said any man who abandons his wives will be handled for their fellowship. Yeah.

24:33 Let let me ask you a question about Reed Smoot, 'cause I find it interesting. I mean, I I have my theories, but they're just theories, right? If, if they want, if the church wanted to place someone in there who was devout, there would have been better candidates than Smoot, right? Because somebody who's not in the quorum of the 12 part of me doesn't wonder if they didn't have the idea. And and again, this is just speculation Michael, but but if they thought well we'll just get one of our boys up there and maybe we can make some inroads that way. You mean someone willing to compromise? Someone who was willing to maybe make some inroads to take the pressure off of this whole plural marriage thing so they could start practicing it again more openly. Well, I yeah, it's possible because, you know, before this you had a big what to do with BH Roberts, who was applying to be a state senator as well, but he was a polygamist and they didn't like that.

25:36 And then there was a whole deal with with him running for that office. And so this was kind of their second attempt of getting one of their guys into into public office in the government. Right. OK. Yeah, just just the thought I had right, 'cause if you were looking at just finding somebody who was a devout, was a monogamist, it would have been way easier to put in somebody else who was maybe prominent in the community but not necessarily that close to church leadership. I I I only imagine that it would have you wouldn't have had the hearings right by placing a member of the Quorum of the 12. Oh, sure.

26:16 Yeah. No, that was. That you're begging for it so somewhere along the lines they're feeling like this is gonna be worth it right. And and my the only thing I can come to is, OK, what's the thought process behind this And it's it's maybe you know we get our boy in there who who is a monogamist but might be a little sympathetic towards towards people living plural marriage and maybe make some inroads there with with the government. Yeah, that might have been how it started out with, I I don't know. I I haven't researched the recent hearings in depth on, you know, for any other reason than what's tangential to the topic that we're on that could probably merit its own S series. So it went on for three years, give or take. The hearings did, and there's thousands of pages of testimonials.

27:08 That's a lot of pages for dude just to dodge questions. Oh dude, we're going to get into some of the pertinent stuff and it's you're going to love it. It's hilarious. And one of the first things it's hilarious to me, being right after Reed. Smooth issues that flat out denial. Joseph F Smith was the first witness called, and he flatly admitted afterwards that he had had five of his wives give him eleven children since 1890, which he just straight up contradicted the testimony that Reed Smoke gave that he had not been living with his wives, that none of the authorities had been living with their wives, and he so he's had eleven children. We know that Lorenzo Snow, who's dead at this point. He had fathered a few children through that time period, and Heber J.

28:01 Grant was trying to and he got caught up into this scenario and he had to pay a fine and he told them underoath. He said yes. I've I'm. I'm living with my wives and I want to continue to live with my wives until I have a son and he paid his fine $5000 I think 500 to $5000 and paid his fine for breaking the law and went on his way. Is it bad? When I think of Heber J. Grant I just imagine there's like an Anakin Evil Emperor sort of scenario somewhere where Heber J. Grant just basically pledges his loyalty to the other side. I mean, it's the only thing I can come up with, right? Because he starts out so on board and then by the end he's a completely different person.

28:53 Yeah, that's weird. Man, that's weird. I don't know what complete. I mean, I have a guess and we talked about this a little bit. You know, it was with that Matthias Cowley promising him, you know, to be a wingman and help him out and then it never happened. But anyways, onwards we're continuing with the reeds throughout hearings to get down to the bottom of it. Because the the whole nation want us to know. You know, before they admitted Apostle Senator Reed Smoot into the into the US Senate whether the church was going to be sincere in its rejection of polygamy, they issued subpoenas for Matthias F Cowley and John W Taylor to appear and testify in Washington DC. Neither of them obeyed the subpoenas. Reed Smoot's secretary named Carl Badger, who was compelled by his position to follow the testimony in the hearings. Daily expressed his frustration to Franklin S Richards, which was Smooth's attorney, and he wrote in on March in March of nineteen O 4, The committee is insisting that John W Taylor and Brother Callie come, and they ought to, but I do not want them to come and lie, and I do not know whether I want them to come and tell the truth.

30:22 So there you are. It's not as ridiculous. That's fascinating. So during the Reed Smoot hearings, are there any indications that Smoot's testimony rubs? Maybe some of those who are practicing plural marriage within the quorum the wrong way. Oh, Matthias Cowley and John W Taylor very much felt pretty grieved at this whole thing because it becomes a very a very much a personal ambition for Reed. Smooth by the end of it. Where they're where he's He's going to get that seat in the Senate no matter what it costs anyone else. And it.

31:07 Ends up and it ends up costing with IS Cali and John W Taylor their positions in the form of the 12th. Oh, that's so fascinating. I would have loved to have seen what their reaction was, as maybe they're reading the papers and some of this is coming out. That's a good question, Carl Badger writes to a guy named Ed Jenkins, who was another political associate of Reed Smooths in Salt Lake the same month, which is March 19 O 4, saying very few of our people have been willing to admit that the manifesto was a revelation. But I want to see Brother Taylor compelled to make this admission. I think we are getting indebted.

31:49 I think we are greatly indebted to him for all this unpleasantness, if you can refer to a national scandal as such. So Carl Badger is getting pretty frustrated with John W Taylor in any case, thinking he's to blame over this and not Smoot, which is I I guess you're entitled to your opinion. Here, here's an interesting thing and I have never held Smoot in high regard. I'll get this out of the way right now for a couple of reasons, but one of them was is I don't think he was a great legislator. So in 1930, Smoot authors a bill that's backed by Howley called the Smoot Hawley Tariff Act of 1930, that makes the Great Depression way worse than it was going to be.

32:38 That's terrible. But that's the truth. You can look it up. He he was he was the guy who helped write the bill. He Co sponsored it. It raised tariffs on over 20,000 items. And what that did is because they were in the very beginnings of the Depression and it drove the Depression even harder because you limited competition in the marketplace. And so however you feel about, you know, what he did up there on Capitol Hill, there's no doubt that he was not a great legislator. And you can make an argument that he is one of the people responsible for the length and the depth that the Great Depression and ended up being.

33:26 That's a pretty black mark to have. Yeah, yeah. But he, I, I look at Smoot and I don't think. I don't think he's one of one of the boys, right? I don't think. He's Nor do nor do I. He came from good heritage. He, I think he was the son of Abraham Owen Smoot. Who? Abraham Owen Woodruff was named after, you know, and they were, they were related in by marriage to the Woodruff family, I believe. In any case, here's a fun little too bit of information. So, yeah, John John W Taylor was living in Canada during all this because you know that I guess that's probably the only way he could hide from, you know, pretty well from the subpoena that's issued for him to appear in DC.

34:16 Although he would, he would evade detection and he would travel down to Salt Lake City to see his families down there in Utah, and he would pretend to be his younger brother, Moses W Taylor. And he would. He taught. He taught his kids to call him Uncle Mosey while they were out in public. That's back when you could get away with it before facial recognition software. Yeah, he'd he'd go around in disguise as pretending to be his brother or something. And anyways that that was pretty fun.

34:58 So all this attention brings about what we call the 2nd Manifesto, in which was delivered in conference on April 6th, 19. O Four, President Smith wrote to Reed Smooth that the conference action regarding the Declaration was spontaneous, and D Michael Quinn writes, President of President of the 70 Seymour B. Young's diary states that those who seconded the motion to sustain the 2nd Manifesto did so quote per arrangement. Among these seconds, meaning people who sustained the vote were Seymour B. Young, who had performed 2 plural marriages in Mexico under Joseph S Smith's direction, which we covered already.

35:44 Anthony W Ivins, who had performed dozens of plural marriages in Mexico by First Presidency authorization. Angus M Cannon, who was a brother to no uncle, Uncle to Abraham H Cannon, brother to George Buchanan and Jesse and Smith, and Moses W Taylor, brother of John Y John W Taylor and Frank Y Taylor. So Seymour B Young's diary insinuates that Joseph F Smith gave instructions for that thing to be carried through on a vote. Let let me ask you this. Do you think Joseph F Smith has a change of heart or do you think do you think it's one of these things?

36:26 Like, well, one manifesto seemed to do the trick for a while of getting them off our back? Maybe a second will. I want to see what your answer to that question is going to be as we go on, he continues. By writing by way, by the way, he orchestrated the sustaining of the Second Manifesto. Joseph F Smith sent unspoken but public reassurance to those who had conscientiously entered plural marriage. After the Manifesto, it is not surprising that some Latter Day Saints interpreted the covert message of the 6th of April 1904 as applying to future polygamous marriages. The reverse of the documents overt statements and therefore regarded the 2nd Manifesto as no more restrictive of new polygamy than the first. Even when he told Anthony W Ivins that the that the Nineteen O 4 declaration applied to Mexico, President Smith qualified it by saying quote for the time being. OK, all right.

37:21 So, so it is an attempt to be like, OK, the first manifesto got us, got the government off our back, maybe the second one will do the same thing. Yeah. And I want to recap that last bit for the listeners in my own words. But it looks like Anthony W Ivins and Joseph S Smith get into a conversation after this because we know that some people view the First Manifesto as only applying to the United States and therefore Canada and Mexico was a different situation. So Anthony Ivins, knowing that was some of the opinion being held, asks President Smith, does the second declaration affect Mexico? And President Smith tells him for the time being.

38:03 OK. Do you think he meant that for the time being or do you think he just thought business as usual after that? It's hard to know exactly because it looks like things are pretty hot at this exact moment. So. So I could see it being a cooler Jets everyone for now we were we're under, you know, we're under the lamp, you know, or under the magnifying glass. And I would like to read it. I suppose we could read it. The 2nd Manifesto reads, inasmuch as there are numerous reports in circulation, that plural marriages have been entered into contrary to the official declaration of President Woodruff of September 24th, 1890, commonly called the Manifesto, which was issued by President Woodruff and adopted by Church by the Church at its General Conference, October 6th, 1890, which forbade any marriages violative of the laws of the land. I Joseph F Smith, President of the Church of Jesus Christ of the Latter Day Saints, hereby affirm and declare that no such marriages have been solemnized with the sanction, consent, or knowledge of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. And I hereby announce that all such marriages are prohibited. And if any officer or member of the Church shall assume to solemnize or enter into any marriage such marriage, he will be deemed in transgression against the Church, and will be liable to be dealt with according to the rules and regulations thereof and excommunicated therefrom. Signed by President Smith.

39:36 Interesting. OK, it often makes me curious why that didn't make it in as official declaration #3. Or two, and then have official declaration being 2. Excuse me. Yeah, I think it might actually be under official declaration one in some of the footnotes or something. OK. I'm not entirely sure. It might be in there. You're going to look it up. I'm. Going to look it up. I'm curious. All right, but go so four days after the second Manifesto is issued, general Superintendent of the church schools named Joseph M Tanner marries his fifth wife in Canada's Northwest Territory, which is later the Alberta province, by apostle Matthias F Cowley. OK.

40:39 And they're still members of the core of the 12 at this point, by the way. But so. But right after four days after the second manifesto, Matthias Calley is marrying the Superintendent of the church schools to his fifth wife. Oh, OK. Yeah. All right, the day after that, President Joseph F Smith sends a letter to mission president. He's Joseph E Robinson. If you remember him. He is the mission president of the California mission. Joseph F Smith advises him to send his girls to Mexico.

41:20 And his wives. Interesting. So looking there is no. It's not there. It's not there. OK, maybe they left it out because nobody wanted to raise the question of, well, what was going on there that they had to do a second manifesto. Oh, man, I mean, that's a that's a that's probably true. All right. So there's some interesting activity right on the heels within 5 days of the second manifesto, about a month later. We're in May and I find this kind of hilarious. May 26th, 19 O 4, Apostle Reed Smoot complained to the First Presidency that Abraham Owen Woodruff had proposed polygamously to his wife's niece. His only wife.

42:14 His his wife's only niece, which was her name was Clara Pratt Eldridge. So he's he's upset about this Woodruff or or Smoot? Smoot. Yeah, smooth. Yeah, Smooth's upset about Owen Woodruff proposing to his wife's knees. But but that's also on the heels of the Second Manifesto. So we have our boy Owen Woodruff seeking to he's already a Post Manifesto polygamist, but he's trying to be a post Second Manifesto polygamist now. Well, Michael, if you're going to excel, you got to aim high, right? You can't, you can't be half assing this.

42:56 You've got to go hard in the pain if you want to achieve greatness. Let, let me let me ask you this, 'cause we know that their Commission was kept very compartmentalized within the quorum of the 12, right? Which I could see as being smart, right? If you're trying to do stuff on the down low, you don't want everybody knowing everything, right? You want to contain the damage where you can? Sure. Let let me ask you this, do we have any records of Smoot performing plural marriages? Not that I've seen. So he might be the first guy who's serious about getting rid of this.

43:39 That's kind of the way I've understood things. OK now. Then you have others who were for it, turn against it. You know, the the Reed Smoot hearings were all that. That's kind of what got Francis Lyman, You know, in that camp, you know, 'cause we know that he performed that carriage ride ceiling for John W Taylor. OK. So yeah, Brother apostle Owen Woodruff is seeking to get a third wife. But sadly, on a trip to Mexico the next month in June, he dies. Who dies? Owen Woodruff. OK, that's right. And it they they deem that appendicitis? Right. I don't think it was appendicitis.

44:19 I think it was flu, Spanish flu going around at that time. OK. Sorry about that, I think. I'm not entirely sure, but he was about 31 or 32 years old. That's still awful young to be dying from the flu. Yeah, I don't know, I don't know. Terrible, terrible history. Would be so different if he had lived, I think July 4th, 19 O 4, Don Maroni Lebaron, age 46, marries his third wife in Burnham, San Juan County, New Mexico, by a verbal agreement or solemn covenant. Nice. I like that. He's he's he's a post Second Manifesto polygamist.

45:02 On July 9th, 19 O 4, Francis M Lyman writes to apostle George Teasdale who's, you know, resident apostle down in Mexico. And he's he writes to him saying what has already been done regarding new plural marriages is shaking the confidence of the Latter Day Saints. We are considered as two faced and insincere, and that's the moment, I believe, where he flips. Where? Where? Where? Lyman. Flips, Francis. Lyman flips. So it he flips because he's worried about the integrity of the church, right? And and the. Public optics and. The members and see this is this is one of those points in this conversation where I go back to don't surrender an inch, not an inch. If it's a true principle, do not hedge, because this kind of duplicity always comes back to haunt you. Always.

46:07 I oh, I completely agree. I completely agree with you. I. I understand that that that that Wilford's a good man right? And and he had the best of intentions in signing the first Manifesto. But in doing so he he he kicked down the door for just this very thing and and it it if you surrender that inch you can bank the mile. It's coming shortly thereafter. I 1000% agree with you. It's it's hard looking at all this, but we have a few more years of hope before it gets completely dismal. Case in point, August 3rd, 19 O 4 Apostle Roderick Clawson marries his third wife in Pearl Udall in looks like Grand Junction, Mesa County, Colorado by Apostle Matthias F Cowley. After that marriage it looks like to keep things on the down low, that Anthony H Lund who was second counselor in the First Presidency, began to act as a go between for the letters between Rutgers Lawson and his new wife.

47:24 And so she or he would write letters to Anthony H Lund, a member of the First Presidency on behalf of an Apostle who just married his third wife. A second A post second Manifesto wife in order to keep things from being discovered. Well, and that makes sense, 'cause if I'm not mistaken, it was Lund who had the meeting in the temple two years. Before this. Yeah, with all those proto fundamentalists muster be in one of one of them, right? Yep. Yep. So, Anthony? Salon. Is our, is our boy and. It's and it's at that point that one says Keep your records 'cause this is gonna be over soon. Yep, absolutely. We have in addition to that, I love this Joseph E Robinson, who was mission President to the California Mission all the way into Nineteen O 8. When Roger Clausen is visiting California, he takes his wife with him and he arranges that the hotel that Roger Clausen staying at has the adjoining but connected rooms with her listed as a, you know, she's probably listed as a single lady or whatever, but he made sure that their rooms were adjoining, you know, while he was out visiting.

48:45 So did that shows you that there's some, there's there's a network going on here, the people that got each other's backs? Yeah, and. And not only that, I think this lends credibility to the idea that this isn't something that they take lightly, right? They're willing to go Incognito for this. They're willing to go, you know, cloak and dagger over this issue, which shouldn't press on everybody. This idea that this was more than just a wink and a nod if you so desired, this was something that they felt like we got to do whatever we can to keep this thing going.

49:27 And if that means we have to send letters through the 1st presidency, if this is somebody's got to arrange for my wife to have the room next to me and my first wife, so be it. They're they're they are not going to go quietly into the night on this. And so that brings me to the question rhetorically for for you and I who were either raised and you were converted to the LDS Church, we're told one thing, and we're told that it stopped in 1890. But learning these things, we either learned that either the Manifesto was a revelation from God and the Brethren were disobedient to it, or it wasn't a revelation from revelation from God, and they never stopped it, so why should we?

50:13 Yeah, that's that's exactly right. You're 100% correct. And and look, not that I would ever compare myself to those men, because those men in, in a very gospel and holy sense were the baddest of badasses. They just were right. They're like, we're going to keep this going come hell or high water. OK? If it's good enough for them to have to find some workarounds, what does that mean for guys like you and I? Exactly. Those are the questions we should be asking ourselves. Yep, absolutely, 100%. Because here's the other thing.

50:56 These guys are getting up there in age, right? They probably could have kept this on the down low and and if they were all about stopping this, they could have said, you know what, we got our wives. This was great while it lasted. Now let us just kind of ride off into the sunset, so to speak. We'll fulfill our callings. We're just the leftovers. I don't think that's the case given their age at this time. I mean, muster not being one of them, excluding muster. I'm talking just the quorum of the 12 now, right? Generally, generally speaking, you know, let's see, John W Taylor at this point would be 47, OK.

51:40 And so he's probably on the younger side. But President Smith, Joseph F Smith would be nearly 70, maybe 69 at this point, if my memory serves me. Here's the thing. At their age, and let's put this into perspective, this is the early 1900s, right? At 47, you can maybe bank that. You might. If you've taken really good care of yourself, you got another 20 years. Sure. Right. They're not worried about them. They're worried about us, right? They're worried about their kids. They're worried about this. Practice has to continue for them, right? And I think, I think we lose track of of that fact and we let others frame the narrative that these are just very amorous men who want to continue this practice for their own gratification. My argument is Joseph Smith is 70. Lund is probably approaching that John W Taylor who's on the younger side at 47 maybe another 20 years left right and and so then then what's the end goal if you're if if it was just you, dude, dust your hands off.

52:58 You've had a great run, right? I mean you got your you got your big family like you wanted. You can just fulfill your callings be the quote leftovers from this archaic practice and you get to just do your thing. No, no, no, no, no, no. If you're going to this length in your twilight years, you're doing it with the idea of the next generation in mind. Yeah, and we should keep your remarks in mind as we go forward, because you're going to see evidence for exactly that if we get far enough. In August, on August 11th, 19 O 4, Brother Taylor marries a counselor in the state presidency to his fourth wife. In September of nineteen O 4, John W Taylor performs 4 marriages.

53:48 So he performs one in August. So he's performed 6 or 7 up to this point in his life and then one in August right there. I think that is number 7. And then there's four more between September 20th and September 26th for A George H Budd and his second wife and her and yeah, his second wife, and two ceremonies for Edward or Edwin T Benyon, who was another count who was a counselor in the another counselor in the Taylor State presidency. And he married both of his wives on the same day. Wow.

54:32 And then the last marriage out of that group was for John W Taylor's brother, Frank White Taylor. So yeah, they're still going for it. They're still going for it. Second Manifesto or not? On October 8th, 19 O 4, Carl A Badger, whose secretary to Reed Smoot writes in his diary, and this is awesome, he writes AB Irving told me that Apostle Owen Woodruff told him that a certain number of worthy people had been commissioned to keep alive the principle of plural marriage. This was in reference to new marriages about which gossip was rife.

55:19 So that's a good source. Yep. Owen Woodruff told was telling people that people have been commissioned to keep alive the principle of plural marriage. Not only did he prophecy that in Mexico, you know, also reiterating what Apostle Mariner Merrill had said, but he was in the know that people had been specifically commissioned. September 26th, 19 O 4, President Joseph F Smith releases a statement to certain authorities wherein he states that he's withdrawing authority from President that President Woodruff and President Snow delegated to authorize some of the Apostles and others to perform ceilings for time and for eternity. That's interesting.

56:02 I would love to get my hands on that letter, because what it does is it admits that Woodruff and and Snow authorized certain members of the 12 to perform those marriages. And in Quinn's book on LDS church authority and post manifesto plural marriages, he notes that while while this says that he is rescinding the authority of Presidents Woodruff and Snow, it conspicuously says nothing about authority that he himself extended to any right. Yeah. So in the in the world that they live in of clandestine operations and, oh, you know, almost spy thriller events, you're kind of forced to read in the lines of OK, well, I was, I wasn't commissioned by President Woodruff from President Snow.

56:51 I was commissioned by President Smith. So I guess that means I'm still good there, you know? Yeah. Yeah, absolutely, absolutely. And and man, the the amount of hoops and and in all honesty, it makes me respect these guys more, right? Because not only are they doing mental gymnastics to to figure all this out, keep all these moving parts and pieces kind of coherent, but they're doing things like delivering letters. They're doing things like arranging, you know, places to stay for other men engaged in plural marriage and and I can only imagine the amount of love that these men had for each other as well, right? No.

57:44 Doubt about it. Like I I'm gonna go. These are your ride and die homies, right? These were the guys that that that have your back and you have theirs to the end. And so I can only imagine the amount of camaraderie and brotherhood that's there. I completely agree. There's a you remind me by saying that of a of one of the statements I think I alluded to or at least a statement similar to one I alluded to earlier where I quoted President Smith saying in a talk in Idaho. Remember that where he said I will lie like hell to protect my brethren. Yeah, there is one where he where in a letter to Anthony W Ivan's Joseph F Smith writes that his motto quote is always and always has been to protect to the uttermost in my power the rights and the secrets, if secrets there may be, of my friends and the friends of the Kingdom of God. Yeah, yeah, I can only imagine, right? Because look, it's not really war per Southeast. So it's got to develop that same kind of Band of Brothers mentality, right?

59:02 Like it's US against the world Bros we're we're we're going for it, here we go. And I'll be darned if they didn't actually stick it out together. I think a lot of them did. The problem is, realistically, as you noted earlier, a lot of these men, so well respected in a position of authority, are kind of elderly, and as they die out, the torch was not carried as sufficiently as maybe it could have been. OK, now I'm going to say something that's going to piss some people off, and I want to apologize ahead of time. Not that I'm saying it, but I have to say, just like there were elderly men who tried to keep the principle of plural marriage alive today, I believe that within the LDS Church, there are elderly men trying to preserve marriage between men and women.

1:00:05 And that torch will not be passed to this next generation because this next generation doesn't want the torch. And I think this is, in a weird way, a repeat of what happened with plural marriage. That's a good point. That's a really good parallel to draw. But as we've seen a lot of stuff the last few weeks as you and I noted earlier in in our own talking together. But the church is like it's struggling. The optics of ARE are confusing to everyone and in my generation I can speak for my generation from what I see from my peers and those younger, they're mental.

1:00:52 I don't understand. I don't understand where they're coming from with with the trans activity and the you know and and you know what we what is what is coined as gay civil rights or what have you. I do not understand. It has no place in the plan of salvation except for if you struggle with those things, you need to repent and you need to make covenants with your God that will exalt you by living your covenants. And there's no other way. You and I have to be chased, you know. Look. I I'm going to, I'm going to point them out and then I challenge anybody to tell me that, yeah, yeah, all is well. In Zion, you have the new public, the the new director of public relations for the LDS Church who is an avowed trans activist, not trans himself, but trans activist all over Twitter or X.

1:01:52 You know, celebrating gay marriage, celebrating trans rights, the whole ball of wax. That's your boy that's going to go out and talk to the public. OK, next you have a dude, and yes, it's still a dude. I don't care if you did get your junk chopped off, you're still a dude in Arizona who gets baptized. And we also know that there's a second one, and I can't remember where it's from. Where The first Presidency gives the authority for them to be baptized. OK, now we know of at least four couples who are practicing homosexuals, married, participating in church, partaking of the sacrament, and holding callings. The writing's on the wall on this. This is coming, and I didn't plan on going in this direction, but seeing the parallels, it's too striking. If you think somebody's going to ride into the rescue on this, you are sadly mistaken.

1:02:55 If you're LDS and you want to preserve what's left in the LDS church, you better start getting darn vocal right now. You better become a major pain in the butt to your superior, so to speak, or else this thing's on the way. Period. History bears us out. This is like we saw with with plural marriage. The guys coming up don't want the torch. Want to get more out of listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast? Then go to the Mormon Renegade Patreon page or click the link in this episode Show notes for access to one of three packages for $3 a month. Slightly rowdy options will give you access to add free audio.

1:03:37 Still not enough? Then for $6 a month, sign up for the Stirring it Up options, which gives you add free audio and video as well as transcripts. Finally, for those who really want to get crazy, sign up for the $12.00 a month full Renegade option which will give everything in the previous two plans, plus access to a weekly news program which will break down the news of the day from a Mormon point of view, as well as access to a community page where you can talk about all things Mormon in private. Go to the Mormon Renegade Patreon page or click the link in this episode. Show notes and Sign up today. The guys coming up don't want the torch. I know. And people that will carry it will be deemed as radicals. Or, you know, if the word fundamentalist hadn't been, you know, stolen by people like us already, they would be termed fundamentalists.

1:04:27 Yeah, which? You know, Dean notes A. It's a it's a negative connotation for extremism, you know, which that's the way the world views that term, you know, But that's how they would be labeled and that's how they will be labeled, even if that term isn't applied. Yeah, absolutely, absolutely. It it it's on the way. It's not, it's no longer a distant mile marker down the road. It's kicking in the door now. Yeah, I don't disagree with you. Are you ready for some laughs now? I am. I am. I So. Fire. Yeah, no, I'm glad you did.

1:05:07 I got a little thing from the Reedsmooth hearings of testimony given by George Reynolds, which is very pertinent. It's very eye opening and it's very funny. Pres. George Reynolds is secretary to the First Presidency as well as being a President of the 70s and the Read Smooth Investigation Committee, which is examining all, you know, everything at the church, is doing that they're trying to hide. They interviewed him to find out whether the manifesto was intended to be a subterfuge to the outside world or worse, was it a revelation from God which was being violated? So a Mr. Worthington asks George George Reynolds, You said something about helping to write the manifesto. Will you explain that?

1:06:00 And George Reynolds says President Woodruff wrote it in his own hand. And he was a very poor writer, worse, I believe, than Horace Greeley. And he gave it into the hands of three of the elders and prepare it for to prepare it for the press. I was one of those three. Mr. Worthington asks. Who were the three? Mr. Reynolds says, Charles W Penrose, John R Winder and myself. Mr. Worthington asks, What did you do? You said you helped write the manifesto, and I want to have an understanding of what you meant by that, Mister Reynolds says. The answer came from the fact of the question coming to me, whether I had read it and understood it, and I answered that I had assisted in writing it.

1:06:48 Mr. Worthington asks. Did you 3 then transcribe these notes of President Woodruff, or did you rewrite it or what? George Reynolds says we transcribe the notes and change the language slightly to adapt it for publication. Mr. Worthington asks. They contain the substance. George Reynolds says yes, they contain the substance. And then a senator named Mccomas asks, did you, in transcribing the utterance of President Woodruff, make such change of phraseology as would make it ambiguous, so that it might apply to marriages subsequent and not now, to living with wives who had been married prior?

1:07:34 George Reynolds says no, Sir. Senator McConnell asks. It must have come to your mind when you were copying and changing the phraseology whether this applied. This is to apply to the future and whether the past is to be expected is did or not. George Reynolds says No, Sir, I have told you honestly what my feelings and opinions were. Senator Mccomas asks. It did not occur to you then, No Sir, that required years. George Reynolds says this. Yes Sir, when you wrote it, as we understood the president intended with his manuscript before us? The chairman of the committee then asks.

1:08:14 I do not know, but I may have misunderstood. I understood that this manifesto was inspired and George Reynolds says, well, yes, The chairman asks. That is your understanding of it, George Reynolds says My understanding was that it was inspired. The chairman then asks. And when it was handed to you, it was an inspiration, as you understand from on high, was it not? George Reynolds says yes. The chairman then asks what business had you changing it, and George Reynolds asks or says we did not change the meaning. The chairman says You just stated you changed it. George Reynolds replies, Not the sense, Sir.

1:08:56 I didn't state that we changed the sense, the chairman says. But you did change the phraseology, Mr. Reynolds says. We Simply put it in shape for publication, corrected possibly the grammar, and wrote it so that. So there he's interrupted. You cut off and the chairman says You mean to say that in an inspired communication from the Almighty, the grammar was bad. Well, is it? You corrected the grammar of the Almighty, did you? It's it's hilarious that that this senator is basically saying the same things we are at the moment, right?

1:09:38 I I I do find that very funny. I find that very ironic. Yeah, no. And and we discussed earlier how Wolford Woodruff wrote a what was going to be the manifesto. And then it was, and it was written down by George Q Cannon in his journal. And then they destroyed the original copy. And then John R Winder and Charles Penrose and George Reynolds wrote it the way that you know that it stands currently. And I think I read over the original. I don't know if I did, but I guess you can say that the sense was the same. And George Reynolds isn't lying in that sense. But it definitely shows you some of the logical fallacy that we go through to the people in the church go through to, you know, that it was a revelation abolishing plural marriage, which definitely was not understood by the people at this point in time.

1:10:41 In fact, we're going to see literally right after this, George Reynolds is going to perform a plural marriage. He's like, excuse me, Senator, I got to go marry a couple, yeah. No, I'm not even kidding you, dude. It's You can't make this up. Oh, that's awesome. That's awesome. Excuse me, senator, I have to go now. I got some church duties I need to attend to. Wink and out the door he goes. Perfect. Oh man. So going on from that point, we're in the new year again, January 1st, 19 O 5. This is an interesting statement that I I found this from a book called The Read through hearings and some other subtitles that I'll now recall.

1:11:31 But in one of the appendixes, it says that on January 1st, 19 O five, that President Smith told a bunch of temple workers, ordinance workers in the Salt Lake Temple quote, that the ordinances of God are more seriously threatened than ever before. Since the days of Nauvoo, we have not only the hatred of outsiders, but of men and women professing to be Mormons. Interesting. Interesting. Oh, that. That. OK, let me get my tinfoil hat on for a minute. OK, if you remember there's a story, I believe Ezra Taft Benson, but don't quote me, where someone asked him if he was worried about someone taking his life and he pointed to the church building and said I'm more concerned about what's going on in there in that.

1:12:26 I have heard that story before. Than I am to to outsiders this might be the first time that the utterance has been given that pardon the phraseology, the Barbarians have broke down the gate and they now are entrenched in the church and and this will play out again and again within the church where there's this idea of we just got to keep this together till these old men die and then we can re mold the church into something closer to our hearts desire. There's a there's an interesting parallel here, and I can't say that it's cause and effect or that it's correlated at all, but it is interesting to note the nineteen O 5 is the year that it looks like the temple or the the lecture at the veil in the Saint George Temple was removed.

1:13:32 Yep. As well. So it's been told to me that President Joseph F Smith in his later years was not a bit big proponent of the Adam God doctrine. I've never looked into that a whole lot and this makes me want to almost re evaluate that. If it's connected, it might not be correlated as I said for him to say that the ordinances are under threat. But that is the same year that the lecture of the real with the Adam God doctrine being explained was removed, which is an interesting idiot. Secrecy or synchronicity, I guess you can call. It look, these doctrines are so tightly tied together, right? Adam, God, celestial, plural marriage, all these things are tied kind of at the hip.

1:14:22 And it's been my contention for a long time that a lot of the temple changes were in an were an effort to get rid of the Adam, God doctrine. Because if you go back to the old endowment and you take a look, or if you've happened to participate in an old endowment, it is a master class on Adam God, and the lecture at the veil was the most explicit moment in the temple when Adam God was caught plainly. Yep, Where it explained that the things that you saw about being molded out of a out of clay was symbolic in its nature. And that Adam was born of celestial parents on another world, being made of the dust of that earth, but not of this earth, you know, and so forth and so on.

1:15:07 And that he was classified amongst the gods came to Eden with the celestial body. Yeah, no, it it is. It is the bow that wraps it all together. And you walk out of the temple in those days understanding the mysteries of godliness like never before. And and my my assertation to all this has been or my assertion, excuse me, has been, that all these temple changes that we have seen have been for one reason and one reason alone and that is to distance ourselves as far as we can from the Adam God doctrine period. And you can't have, you can't have the Adam God doctrine without plural marriage.

1:15:55 I really believe that. I agree. They're they're tied so tightly together. And when when when they're done, like I fully expect at some point they will gut the endowment entirely and maybe it'll be about Christ, right. And and that's not to say that things being about the Savior are bad. I I like that. But that's not what was restored, right? That's not what was there. Indeed. And, and at some point, I think a major gutting is going to have to happen. If that's what the church's end goal is, why else would you get rid of the murals out of the Salt Lake Temple?

1:16:40 It's going to, yeah, something's going to happen one way or another. But I do know from my own experiences that the 2019 changes definitely removed atom theistic elements that were present when I was in doubt in 2015. Were removed. Yeah. Yep. Things that were very exalting of Adam in 2015 were no longer there in 2019. Yep. And then there's been more changes since then. So going forward, still in January 19, O 5, Francis Lyman goes up to Carsten to tell John W Taylor that he has been summoned to testify in the Reed Smoot hearings before the US Senate. And in their conversation, John W Taylor reluctantly agrees to go.

1:17:33 Although he tells Francis M Lyman, I will tell the truth, I warn you, I'm going to tell the truth. And that night, as Apostle Apostle, Lyman had a dream of a disaster that would result from John W Taylor truthfully testifying in Washington, DC. And the next morning, as John W Taylor was in route to the railroad, Lyman flips his horse and buggy around to intercept him and tells him not to go. Look, if if if your goal is to kind of whitewash things, that's not a bad thing because I I have a feeling that that Taylor would, he would kick over the tables a little bit, right?

1:18:15 He would let you know exactly kind of where where things stood because because when you read John W Taylor again, he's not a bashful guy, right? And there's only so much sidestepping that I feel like he's going to do before he's like, OK, let me break this down for you and. I I always want to know how it would have played out. That would have been something. I mean that would have been more that would have been funnier than what we just read about George Reynolds, Correct. You know, writing the manifesto. Dude, when I get on the other side, I want to hang with W Taylor for a little while, right? I would. I I I want to be like, please regale me with some of your stories.

1:18:59 Me too, man. Me too, during this time. Well, you know, John W Taylor's away in Canada. He's got family down there in Utah. Still, he's able to kind of go down pretending to be his brother, as we discussed. But from time to time, but other times when he when his family needed help, John M Cannon would come and help out. And with Frank White Taylor, John WS brother and do things like minister to the sick children, you know, take care of the family while while John was in hiding. Here is something that Matthias Cowley wrote to his family regarding the Reed Smooth hearings afterwards. So Matthias Cowley, in Remembering the Reed Smoot Trial wrote in 19 O 5.

1:19:50 The agitation of hireling priests and many misguided people was strong against the seating of Apostle Reed Smoot in the United States Senate. The hue and cry was that many individuals had entered into plural marriage since the Manifesto, among others, Brother Taylor and myself. It was therefore thought advisable for us to to resign our places in the Council of the 12. But before doing so, President BH Roberts had made a speech, I understand by the request of the Presidency, in which he said that unless, unless individuals would shoulder the responsibility of these marriages, the Church had not a foot of ground to stand on, and that they were guilty of duplicity and double dealing. We had meetings with the 12 for about 6 days, which the presidency did not attend except a pair, a part of the first one. No minutes of these meetings were kept. That's interesting, in one of these meetings, Elder Penrose said, referring to Elder John W Taylor and myself. And these are very nearly his words, but I don't say them verbatim, he said.

1:20:57 These brethren are not on trial. They are not charged with disobedience nor transgression. But we've all got in a box with the government and something must be done to meet this fight. And if these brethren are willing to be humiliated, they can be reinstalled, Whereupon Brother John Henry Smith threw up both hands and said yes, I'll vote for them with both hands. This was the spirit of the occasion. We had no arguments against our brethren. After the last meeting, which meetings were held in the temple, Brother Penrose brought our resignations to us all, written with no suggestion from us. Although Brother Taylor desired to write his own, we signed them, and after doing so Brother Penrose said he had no idea that they would go into effect and would not unless matters came to the last ditch of necessity. This was in the fall of nineteen O 5 and at April conference of 19 O six.

1:21:54 They were made public and became of effect. Holy crap. Holy crap. So they prepare letters of resignation from the quorum. Yep. In October of 19 O five that were held on to for six months until April of nineteen O 6 when they were issued this is it was it was a it was the trump card it was the last ditch effort they were basically they told Matthias Cowley and and and John W we're not going to use this unless we absolutely need to do. You think anybody really meant that from on high from there any indication, Is there any indication in that six month window that things got worse and they had to do this? I don't know about worse as much as they didn't get better than they were.

1:22:49 But I do believe that individuals like John Henry Smith, Roderick Clawson, George Teasdale, Mariner Merrill, I cannot believe that those men would not have wanted those men, John W and Matthias Cowley, to be reinstated. And that's what Charles Penrose said to them, is that you can be reinstated when things calm down. That's what they said as well. So even we're not even going to do this right unless we need to. And then when things calm down, we'll reinstate you, if it even comes to that. That's what they were told. OK, now I'm going to make a bold statement here. Couple of them. OK. 1 The men that signed that resignation letter performed an act of sacrifice that I believe is is very Christ like.

1:23:40 Yeah, I would agree. I would agree. They they suffered humiliation for this principle. Yep. When asked to make maybe not the ultimate sacrifice, but close, but close, they were like, OK, OK, next. This is what you get when you surrender ground. Every time. Every single time. And like, looking back now, it's madding, right? It's like, stop, just stop.

1:24:22 OK, you surrendered. This, you're you're you're on the DLI. Get it? Let's stop. No more, no more. And good on those guys for making, making the hardest of choices that not only affect them, it affects their their wives, it affects their children, right? I mean, Salt Lake's not that big of a community in these days, right? I mean, and and the reverberations of this echo across Utah and across the Mormon corridor. Good on them.

1:25:04 But shame on the powers that be. Shame on the powers that be. No, I I agree with your observations and I like your reminder of that Christ, like sacrifice because as we noted earlier in that first episode, that that seems to be the pattern for John W Taylor's life in a big way that mirrors the Savior. And it was their work. And it wasn't just their work, but they they they bore the brunt of the humiliation and the sacrifice. But them and others were what, you know, there were others who were willing to do as much, I'm sure, and that allowed the principal to go forward. And I will.

1:25:46 I would like to pause from our narrative to make a remark on why that's important. Why is it important that the principle of celestial plural marriage go forward? Because if you go back to the Journal of Discourses and read John Taylor Pres, you know, father of John W Taylor read his testimony. And I'm sure there's other testimonies that bear this out. But John Taylor said that after we had been instructed by Joseph Smith and Nauvoo about the principle of plural marriage, we were essentially in all this is paraphrasing. We were offended in our in our feelings enough that we wanted to put off the evil day as far as we could, because they'd grown up in a society where a certain idea of chastity and virtue was held up as paramount and anything you know else was offensive.

1:26:38 And so they put off entering into the principal, until one day John Taylor was riding his horse outside of Nauvoo and met Joseph Smith by the graveyard. And Joseph told John Taylor, if you do not enter into this principle, soon the keys will be turned against you. But what does that mean? Well, a key unlocks or locks a door. Yep. So he's saying that key will be turned against you locking that door. You're damned. Yep, you'll be damned. The priests and keys will be turned against you. Meaning you can't walk through that door exercising them anymore. Yeah, So what does? What does our what does Brother Malachi in the Old Testament say? Behold, I will reveal unto you the priesthood by the hand of the prophet Elijah, and he'll place the promises made to the fathers and the hearts of the children. And the hearts of the children will turn to the fathers. Were it not so, the earth will be utterly wasted. That is coming, meaning the Lord's coming. And so if those keys were lost, you have two options, but one's really not an option.

1:27:49 The two. The hypothetical is they would have to be re restored otherwise the earth is wasted but or they need to stay here. So it's one of the what's one of the two, but it can't be re restored because otherwise Joseph Smith did not fulfill his mission in restoring all the keys for the last time. Furthermore, it turns the Lord into a liar because the Lord gave us assurances that the keys would never be taken from the earth again. Absolutely. And so the only other option is that it has to continue on. And gosh, sometimes I'm even astounded by my level of nerdness. It's like that scene out of the first Star Wars where he tells Vader, strike me down and I'll just become stronger.

1:28:33 And ultimately that's what happens with Taylor. You know, he doesn't see it in his lifetime, but. But it's John W Taylor that really sets the precedent. And that's the other thing. This act of selfless sacrifice and bravery then sets an example for the rest of us. Right? Like, what are you going to say when John W Taylor, the son of a prophet, says, you know what? You want to take my membership. You want to kick me out of the quorum? OK, But I'm going to die on the hill of principle over and over and over. Now let's look at the reverse of this.

1:29:15 What does this ultimately do? This sets a pattern that I'm sorry, the LDS church has fallen into over and over, which is capitulation, which is weak. Need look, if I may have to edit this later, but I'm going to say it now, for so long. I was waiting for somebody up top to let the other nut drop and become a man and stand up for principle. And it just wouldn't happen. It just wouldn't happen. And I figured out after looking at the history, OK, you want the gospel fullness, you better be willing to give some stuff up. You better be willing to walk through the fire, and you better be willing to hold your head high while doing it.

1:29:58 Or else this it won't work. And that's just where it is. On one side you had a guy who made sure that those keys stayed on earth to fulfill prophecy, and on the other side you had weak knees, and that weak knee led to the situation we're in, yeah. Well, I'm certainly grateful for all that was done to perpetuate the priesthood on earth. And we're going to, and that's what we're that's what we're studying right here. And I hope it's insightful to those people who are listening. So that was, we kind of jumped ahead in our narrative. So that was October of nineteen O 5 when those statements were signed.

1:30:45 But go backing up to February of 19 O 5A post manifesto polygamist named Josiah E Hickman writes in his journal. Oh, but our people are howling over the supposed marriages Since the manifesto it is principally those who never believed or entered into plural marriage. It seems that a large percentage of our people are joining hands with our enemies to fight those who have entered into this principle. There is a division between or among the leaders of the Church. I am fearful of the threatened consequences. So that's a full six months before that. Those resignations are prepared April of nineteen O 5 in general conference, contrary to Apostle.

1:31:32 Read Smooth's wishes because he's running for, you know, Senator Still, Mathias Cowley and John W Taylor were presented as General Authorities, But I suppose Brother Smoot had asked them not to be sustained as General Authorities, but they were presented as General Authorities regardless. And after one of the sessions, a son of President Anthony H Wand, told Reed Smoot, Secretary Carl Badger, quote John W Taylor has done right whatever he has done in reference to the subject of polygamy. Woo, spitting some fire.

1:32:14 So the Lunge family is pretty strong it looks like on that one, August 5th, 19 O 5, Fred W Merrill, son of Mariner W Merrill, marries his second wife and they are married in the Logan Temple by his father Mariner W Merrill. So you have Apostle Mariner Merrill helping his son become a Post Second Manifesto polygamist. Yeah, but somehow he escapes the wrath. Yeah, yeah. Interesting. September 6th, 19 O 5 Apparently I didn't realize this. My notes say that this is information coming from the diary of Edward J Wood, who's president of the Alberta Steak and Future Temple President up there a the Superintendent of Church Schools. And Joseph M Tanner marries his sixth wife up there in Cardston, AB, Canada.

1:33:15 Whoa, yeah, Post Second manifesto. Post second so his post 1st and post second because he married his fifth wife back in like 19 O one or nineteen O 319 O3. When we first started the podcast, he came up on this episode September 16th, 10 days after that, the Apostle Matthias F Cowley marries his fourth wife in Cardston. It's performed by John A Wolf, who was set apart by John W Taylor and Joseph F Smith. Patriarch Wolf also marries Ernest Guy Taylor and third wife to his third wife, Lily Susanna Hicks, and down in Colonia Juarez in Mexico, on the other side of North America, President Joseph F Smith publicly announces So on the same day that Patriarch Wolf is performing plural marriages in Canada, he and President Smith announces, quote, there are no plural marriages being performed at present in the church in Mexico or anywhere else.

1:34:26 Hours hours later, after he says that in the home of President Anthony W Ivins, he authorizes Joseph W Summerhays, who asked back in 1898 and took his second or third whatever was his a for a life. I think it was his third life. In 19 O3, he authorizes Joseph Summerhays to marry a former mission president, William J or William G Sears, down there in Mexico right after telling the people there's no plural marriages. Look, I don't blame people for being confused during that time period.

1:35:11 I'm confused now. I'm like, does Joseph F Smith mean this? And then maybe it's happening unbeknownst to him. What is going on? That stops. But I mean, but here these guys like Joseph Summer Hayes, Joseph M Tanner, Henry S Tanner, Joseph E Robinson, who's helping out with, you know, Brother Clawson. You know, like these people are interconnected at this level where it's OK, at least four. I mean to be instructive not not only. I mean the the traditions that we get the things that we've heard is when when Matthias Callie or John W Taylor would go to President Smith and ask can I can I take another wife as president of the church.

1:35:58 I can't tell you. You can't. Right. You know, but then here we have him explicitly instructing Joseph Summer Hayes, who was traveling with him on this trip to Mexico to go perform a plural marriage. Yeah, yeah. Do you think Joseph F Smith dies Holding on to this, probably from. From what I've heard, yeah, pretty much OK. From. What I've heard, what I know, I absolutely think so October the see we we're back to October. Now that's when the Council of 12 meets to deal with Matthias Cowley and John W Taylor.

1:36:43 They signed that on October 18th and 19th 19 O 5 December of nineteen O 5, George F Gibbs, a Secretary to the First Presidency Rights to Senator Smoot, saying Brethren beginning to feel that John W Taylor and Callie should not be sacrificed unless required by the Committee of privileges and Ejections to save you. So it's against the the feel of the quorum, generally speaking to to even announce that that had happened on December 8th. He sends George F Gibbs, Secretary to the First Presidency sends an encrypted Telegraph to Apostle Smoot advising him.

1:37:31 When you become convinced the action should not be delayed any longer, let us know. And I feel to say to you that if you will cast aside forever all thought of making a sacrifice out of apostles Taylor and Cowley, you will begin to see your way brighten. For such a thing cannot be done simply in the hope of avoiding drastic legislation, nor for the purpose of convincing friends that Joseph F Smith is honest. So the the he's, they're flat out, they're getting warned. Don't do this. And if you don't do this, you can expect blessings to come. Yep. So that's probably coming from President Smith trying to save Taylor and Cowley's butt. Yeah.

1:38:15 Because, as we saw from Matthias Cowley earlier, the First Presidency did not attend those meetings of the Quorum of the 12 where that was discussed. OK again, Tinfoil Hat time. Now you have to wonder, was this the moment that there was a takeover by the 12 in spite of the First Presidency? It could be. I think Francis M Lyman is president of the Coral of the 12. I can double check that real quick if you want me to. Yeah, because I think this shows motive and intent, right? If if the First Presidency is not Privy to this message to this meeting and next thing you know they're they're given a document that because now I'm, I'm having second thoughts right now, I'm like, OK, maybe they were serious that yes, you'll you'll have to be humiliated for a while but then we'll bring you right back up. I'm starting to think they never had any intent of bringing them back aboard.

1:39:21 So let's look at the roster here of General Authorities at this point in time that we're dealing with this. Francis M Lyman is President of the Quorum of the 12. He became President of the Quorum of the 12 after the death of Brigham Young Junior on April 11th, 1903. So Brigham Young Junior was President of the Quorum of the 12 up to that point from whenever he became President of the Quorum. Members of the Quorum of the 12 at this point are Francis M Lyman, John Henry Smith, he's pro polygamy. George Teasdale, he's pro polygamy. Heber J. Grant has been pro polygamy up to this point.

1:40:04 John W Taylor, Mariner Merrill, Mathias F Callie, Rodger Clawson and then the next four junior to them are Reed Smoot, Hiram Mack Smith, George Albert Smith and Charles W Penrose. And all of those are for or against those last four. Charles Penrose had in his youth always been very pro polygamy. I don't, I believe he was probably a practicing polygamist, but at this point being made a general authority is probably toeing the line of public appeal because he's also one of the attorneys and he wrote the manifesto and helped write it. So I think that's kind of the way he's going more with that. I know that George Albert Smith was kind of friends with Joseph Mosser and and George George Albert Smith is the son of John Henry Smith but he would never entered the principal and Hiram Max Smith I think was is Hiram Max Smith is a son of Joseph F Smith and brother to future president of the church Joseph Fielding Smith.

1:41:16 OK. And he never entered the principal either. But I don't know if I could say that he was against it. But being a junior member and probably not being aware of the these intricate inner circles that we've been discussing, probably wasn't in favor of it either. Yeah, he wasn't against it. It wasn't promoting it, I should say. So you think Lyman could have had influence over those junior members? Easy. Easy. Him And with him and between him and Penrose, if they were agreed, yeah, they they would have. So you have a split right down the middle, 6:00 to 6:00. And Penrose is problematic because I know that when the Church stopped conferring priesthood and just started ordaining right to the office, that was according to Penrose. So Heber J.

1:42:06 Grant would say, I'm not a theologian. When it comes to matters of theology, I defer to Penrose, right? There's a there's a beautiful talk on the Godhead in the last volume of the Journal of Discourses that I really love from Charles Penrose. It's about it's about the Godhead and exaltation and how we've become exalted and all that. It's really, it's really a good talk, you know, given in about 1886 or so, you know, But I saw, I don't know fully what the deal was or what happened. And I'm not saying Charles Penrose is a bad person, but yeah, definitely not our guy in this fight, for sure. Right.

1:42:48 Definitely not our guy or the continuation of conferring priesthood. Either. No, no. So we're split down the middle. We So from 19 O1 we went with a complete unanimous to 19 O five. We're split right down the middle, which is going to change because Matthias Cowley and John W Taylor get dropped right after this, right? They haven't been dropped yet, but they sign their resignation letters. Yeah. Members of the First Presidency, however, are Joseph F Smith and Anthony Chalund and John R Winder. Those are faithful people right there. Right. So we have We have letters from the First Presidency secretary telling Reed Smith not to sacrifice Kelly and Taylor Family tradition from the Taylor family says that Janet Taylor or Nettie Taylor, you know Nettie Woolley.

1:43:40 Taylor told her son that Joseph F Smith at the time of the resignations in 19 O five had said to John W and Callie quote, You brethren, are called upon to make the sacrifice, but you will lose nothing from it. When things quiet down, you will be reinstated. Interesting. How would how would they have done that? I don't know. How would they have done that? Because you're you're gonna find replacements for those, yeah? That's true. That's true. Unless brought into the first presidency. Maybe. Counselors. Yeah, Maybe. Perhaps, Yeah.

1:44:20 But that would have been, but that would have been a public outrage. Have they done that? Oh, I don't know. I would have loved to have seen it though. Oh yeah. I mean for after all that being said and done in the Reef Snow hearings, for President Smith to bring John W and Matthias Cowley into the First Presidency, yeah, that would have been great. Well, I just can. We. I just can't shake the feeling that that Lyman is behind all of this. I'm guessing he's already got anti polygamy guys waiting in the wings to take those seats. Yeah, that's that's possibly true.

1:45:01 I'm just guessing I'm theorizing. Let's see. Well, well, well, yes and no, because who replaces them are George F Richards. He's again, he's kind of against it. And he was responsible for changing the temple ordinances in 1923. So George F Richards, Orson F Whitney, and David O McKay. OK, David O McKay, we've already covered, is kind of sympathetic. And so is Orson F Whitney. OK. So very, just very interesting. Let's see, Matthias Cowley writes to one of John W Taylor's sons later in 1937 and says regarding these events.

1:45:44 When we were in council relative to our trouble, Brother Penrose remarked. These brethren are not on trial, nor have they committed any offense, but if they are willing to offer the sacrifice and stand the embarrassment, we will admit them back after the situation clears or words to that effect. Is there any indication that that John W Taylor really thinks this is going to happen, that he's going to be reinstated? Is there anything from his journals that state yeah, Oh yeah I'm I'm good. I I would be to know what what his what his thoughts were about him signing this resignation if he honestly thought he'd be brought back in.

1:46:26 In his own words, at one point where I have been sacrificed for Reed Smoot's political ambitions. You want to talk about the biggest? The 11 of the moments that has to backfire is not only do we as Mormons during this time period sacrifice a a good man so that Reed Smoot could get elected, but later Reed Smoot would single handedly be responsible for the deepening of a loss of wealth that this country hasn't seen ever since. Talk about reaping what you sow. That's that's a good correlation. Like we was, you know, like you said. I think I would share one more thing. And I think maybe we stopped this episode because it's a good stopping point and we can discuss it obviously and just go where it takes us.

1:47:23 But so we're entering into nineteen O 6. We know what has been decided by the form of the 12, and this is what Hebrew J Grant has to say about it at this point in his life. He writes in his journal on January 5th, 19 O 6, What they have done, I have done or intended to do. And in so doing I would have done what I thought had the approval of my brethren. Brother John Henry can tell you of the Brown and Romney cases when we were in Mexico and of my protest, and of the final action before I went to Japan. My president intimated that I had better take the action needed to increase my family.

1:48:08 It is circumstances that have prevented me from being guilty. I claim no credit. So he's almost lamenting that he wasn't in the same position as they were, you know, or he's wishing that he had been as valiant as they had been. And he says the only difference is between me and them. I would have done what they did. I had no opportunity with the same motive. Oh, is this is this where Hebrew you think kind of starts to go sour? I. I. Start to see from the journal records I have about. In about a year or two, the tone starts to change, but it's not fully right now to. Me, this?

1:48:56 This smacks of a man who has some envy, right? And later, I think that envy will turn into something like if we can just forget about this, maybe I can forget about my own shame. I think it really is a tragedy to see a man who's called by revelation like he was with. And you have, you can see the counterpart with George Teasdale and he's been pretty faithful and it looks like the Hebrew J would have been faithful too. And I don't know, maybe it's he says, you know, and he's lamenting over the lack of opportunity. But what could have been different maybe if the pursuits of his own life had been a little different in regards to business versus being more active in in going for those kind of things.

1:49:50 Those things don't just, I mean they'll come to you if you're lucky. I'm not saying that they don't ever come to you, but you got to work for them generally. You can't say it's just going to come to you if it, you know put it in the Lord's hand. You know it's you have every once in a while that an Angel will come where a visitor will tell you this is or a vision will be given to you that has saying this is the wife that you'll marry or this is the husband that you'll have but he's already married to another lady. You know in the case for them, yeah, but it's those things have to be worked for and labored for if you want them. But generally speaking.

1:50:31 And it looks like what we see is a lot of people, and we will see this in the future going forward. Is people asking, People are asking, can this be done? You know, Joseph Summerhays asked Joseph F Smith, can this be done? And six years later, he's performing. He's being pulled by President Smith to go to perform plural marriages down in Mexico. Yeah, 'cause we don't, we don't have a lot. Do we have many records? I I should probably phrase this in a question, 'cause I don't know. Do we have a lot of evidence that Hebrew J. Grant was performing plural marriages.

1:51:12 We have the one that he mentions with He married a brother Brown and a brother Romney in Mexico under the direction of John Henry Smith. It looks like while there was initial protest, it's causing him to have a lot of sympathy for Brother Taylor and Brother Callie at this exact moment in history. But he also remember when he was in California, as in the mission field, he told some of the missionaries who were in the field who had wives at home, who could not have children, that if you come to me, we can go down to Mexico and we can take care of, we can get you another wife so that you can have some children.

1:51:55 So he was in favor of that. He told in the Reedspoot hearings that he was going to continue to marry and cohabitate with his wives until he had a son, because the sons that he had had up to this point had died in their youth. And there is even a story told by ruling Allred that in about 1923, when Hebrew J Grant was president of the church and when the Cardston Temple was dedicated, that Byron Harvey, Allred junior, who had married Mary Evelyn Clark, Ruling's mother in Mexico. They had found their way up to Canada. And Byron Allred goes to President Grant. Who's there for the dedication?

1:52:39 He asks. He asks Heber J. Grant. This was done down there in Mexico. Can we redo it? Can we have it redone in the temple now? And Heber J Grant said yes. What? We can reseal that, make it a matter of record. He is so he's such an enigma because I, I we have our theories about when he turns. But but it's like he turns and then he turns back, right? And there's this tension with Heber that we never really get fully resolved on when he he just flips that that switch. Yeah, I I don't know.

1:53:20 I The epistle of James in the New Testament says that a double minded man is unstable in all of his ways. Well, yeah, and that's what it sounds like to me. And but at the same time, I can't say he didn't do some good work, you know, And there's a but there definitely was a turning point and I think even before 1923, there it was. He had pretty much changed his mind. I think Byron all Byron Allred was given an exception because his marriage to the second wife had occurred in 19 O 1.

1:54:02 So it's before 2nd manifesto that ends up kind of being the litmus test for how things are handled in. So what happens is jumping forward in the future, in 19 O 9, Francis M Lyman starts to do serious investigations regarding everything that's happening with new plural marriages. And basically the line of demarcation is if it was before April 6th, 19 O four, we will not excommunicate you, but if it's found out to be publicized that you have taken a wife between the Woodruff Manifesto and the 2nd Manifesto, we'll keep you in the church. But if you have a calling of high leadership. We're.

1:54:49 We're going to ask you to leave your We're going to drop you from your calling, but you retain your membership. But if it's after the second one, you lose your membership. See, and that's fascinating because that's the exact opposite of what originally happened under Brigham Young when he thought like the practice was just not being lived, where he said if you don't, you know, he was looking at people who were in, in high leadership, stake presidents, those sorts of things. Bishops, if you don't take another wife, we're going to get rid of you. I find that it's fascinating how those tables turned that quick. Yeah, me too. Me too. But we're going to get into, in the next episode, some more of the catalysts. Basically what I think are the seeds of the of the fundamentalist movement that are born in this area, I'd really think that that's we're gonna start to cover the marriage is done by Judson Tolman in the next episode. OK.

1:55:50 Awesome. Judson Judson Tolman was patriarch of Davis County and which is where John Wooley ends up being patriarch as well. Yeah. Dude man, this has been so fascinating to to like. I really don't think even those who know about post manifesto polygamy, the the level of carefulness and dogged determination to keep this thing going is insane. And to see, to see these men fight for it in such a way and to have the story I think finally told in its completeness, right without spin, without just honest history, is something that I don't think we as a community have had before. And and dude, you're doing a great job and I can't wait for our next conversation.

1:56:52 Sweet. Hey, I appreciate the opportunity to get this out there. That's I I don't know if I've told you this or the listeners this before, but I've wanted to do something on this time period ever since I pretty much came into fundamentalism. And I'm just grateful to the Lord that he's allowed me to to compile it, because I had no idea where to start and things just fell into place when I I had a friend ask me one question and I said I'll try to put something together on you. And it just spiraled into this the whole deal after I was trying to answer that question and so. Well, and and I think this should men like Cowie and and Taylor and Joseph F Smith going back, we owe them such a debt of gratitude. Such a debt of gratitude.

1:57:49 And it's been an an unfortunate outcome that within a lot of Mormonism, these men's names have just been lost. And I hope that this changes it. I I hope that this maybe puts them back into their proper light. Well, on that note, I want to read something. I thought it was. I thought it was funny and I couldn't. Let us sit. And it has a reference to the Matthias Cowley, and so it's might as well just bring it up now based on what you just said. I was on Facebook and let's see if I can find them.

1:58:36 Someone posted a quotation from a letter that Matthias Callie wrote to Byron Harvey, Allred junior that's ruled Allred's dad in 1925. And I'm going to see if I can find so December 8th, 1925, Matthias Cowley writes to to Byron Harvey Allred. And sorry to spoil some things, but this is 11 years after he practically sued for his life to retain his church membership. And he says to Byron Allred, who, by the way, Byron Harvey Allred was mission companions to Lauren Wooley and obviously heavily into fundamentalism.

1:59:19 Later he writes to him saying, if the authorities of the Church make mistakes, it is not our prerogative to set them right. And when we consider how well the Church General authorities have lived good, clean, chaste lives, been faithful to the duties of their ministry at home and abroad, we must admit that if any man or set of men are worthy to know God's will, it is they to whom we vote to uphold and sustain. And that with all their failings they are the best men in the earth and in the world. And so, dear brother, let us not be doubtful of them, but true and faithful to them. And I promise you this, in the name of the Lord, if you stand by and uphold the authorities of this Church, God himself will stand by you and sustain you in this net in this life and exalt you in the life to come. So that got cited by someone in the Church showing that even Cowley changed his mind near the end of his life, You know, or in an effort basically to support the attitude. That we're here to protest a little bit, which is follow your leaders blindly, follow arbitrary counsel, Just do what you're said.

2:00:25 The Lord will bless you. But that's not what brother Cowley's saying at all. But my counter in the in public on the Internet was posting another quote of Matthias Cowley that he gave in 19 O1 at the Logan Temple, saying none of the revelations of the prophets, either past or present, have been repealed. If you have a teacher in your Sunday schools who would encourage you to disregard or disrespect a single doctrine of the church, plural marriage and all, turn them out. They have no right in the priesthood. Oh, oh.

2:01:08 Weighing it down. So that's how he felt, really. And that's what got him into trouble. But that was he would have continued down that road and I believe he he we're contrary to what people citing that letter would want it to make it what they would like it to make it seem like. We see Matthias Cowley traveling with pro fundamentalist people as late as 1922 in his life. OK, OK, so he never lost that zeal. Not fully, Not completely, He After 1922, he didn't want to be involved with organizing when Lauren Wooley started to want to organize. But I don't think he ever lost a connection to that community that was the underground community or his own duties in the priesthood.

2:02:03 Because he was told that we're skipping away at heading up about what he got into it. He was told not to exercise his priesthood for years when he was. He retained his membership in 1911, when he was disfellowships, but he was not allowed to exercise his priesthood. But we see from Nathaniel Baldwin's journals in the 1920s that he was going around giving blessings. It's good for him. Yep. Good for him. Good for him. Because despite what some would have you say, priesthood does exist outside the the Church. Yep, and contrary to or according to family tradition is in addition to what is recorded in those journals about him exercising as priesthood. In that instance, he also had a ceremony with John W Taylor. According to Taylor family tradition at in Utah Lake, where him and a president of a state re baptized John W Taylor back into the church after his excommunication, which was likely, if I were to venture a guess, was probably his brother Frank White Taylor being the stake president, right? But I don't.

2:03:12 I don't know that entirely. Fascinating stuff. And we'll cover that more, I'm guessing, in an episode or so. Sure, yeah. Absolutely. Awesome. All right, dude. Thanks a lot. No problem at all. All right. Bye, everybody.

2:04:01 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade Podcast.