Episode #114: The Life & Times Of John W Taylor Part 2-Post Manifesto Polygamy In The LDS Church W/Michael Ness
Go To http://patreon.com/MormonRenegade368 For Exclusive Content
Today we continue with our series on John W. Taylor and the history that surrounds his life. On today’s episode we cover a truly fascinating time in Mormon History. We left off last time right as the LDS Church was about to sign the Manifesto. Well today we are going to go over that and also how the LDS Church continued to perform Plural Marriages. We cover how the LDS Church tried to keep this practice hidden, the colonies in Mexico and Canada, and how the LDS Church compartmentalized information so that the practice could continue. If you have ever wondered just how much the LDS Church was involved in Post-Manifesto Plural Marriage stick around and prepare to have your perceptions shattered.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:04 Today we're going to continue our series on John W Taylor and the history that surrounded his life. On today's episode, we cover a truly fascinating period in Mormon history. Now we left off last time, right as the LDS Church was about to sign the manifesto. Well, today we're going to cover that and also how the LDS Church continued to perform plural marriages. We cover how the LDS Church tried to keep this practice hidden, the colonies in Mexico and Canada, and how the LDS church compartmentalized information so that the practice could continue. Now, if you ever wondered how the LDS Church was involved in post manifesto plural marriage, stick around and get ready to have all your preconceived notions shattered. And that's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. Look, it's no secret that our society has become much more crude and coarse.
0:54 To become and raise men and women of virtue and character is a Herculean task. To help with this, I've recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior and Company and Conversation. It was a book with 110 rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society, something that today's society is sorely lacking. What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So the book is laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule. Right below that is my explanation for the 21st century, and below that you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, to go along with this, there's a workbook that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids. To find the book, go to mormonrenegade.com. Go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post, and order your copy today.
1:52 I can bear personal testimony from personal experience that this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Michael back for round two.
2:43 Round two, round three. We'll see how many of you get down. You you know what, I I was thinking about this last last night. These are, I think so important because I think fundamentalism stands at a funny place where if we're not careful, we could start losing some of our own history just due to time and distance. And so I I feel like these are super important because this gives us A-frame of reference, right. We certainly share history with the LDS Church on a lot of things, right? We share it on, you know, like the Willie Martin Handcart Company. But really, fundamentalism has its own unique history. Once that split starts, and I feel like like we really need to, to make sure that we're preserving some of that. So I I really do feel like this is invaluable and important stuff and I'm I'm thankful for you and for the the the time you take in putting this together.
3:45 Thank you. I certainly appreciate that. And I think any group of people is pretty much in constant danger of losing their history if they're not careful. And we can see parallels in our more ancient history, you know, with our ancestors and looking at the Book of Mormon, you know Levi and and his colony leaving Jerusalem and they were told to go back and get your history you. Know. And it turned out to be their family history, not just the Old Testament as was currently written up to that point. And it had prophets like Zenoch, Zenos, and and others who were probably either Manasseh or Ephraim from those tribes instead of from Judah.
4:32 And they weren't Levites or what have you. And the Jews didn't preserve the words of those prophets that were in this family line of Lehigh somewhere or someone in their family took down the words of those prophets. And it would have been absolutely lost if if the Lord hadn't told them to go back and get that family history, which is we. We can, we can see what could happen to us if we were negligent in in looking at our own history and keeping it. Absolutely, absolutely. Well, good stuff. So we left off last time right after the manifesto has been published.
5:15 We're kind of we were kind of getting some of the feelings of of some of those brethren that were in the 12 about what this meant. And really the overarching idea was once this manifesto was was published, it seems like everybody was on the same page of music here that we're just going to let stuff blow over. We're going to continue to practice this and then as soon as the federal government's off our back, we'll go ahead and we will, we'll start this again outright for everybody. Pretty much. I'd like to recap a little bit. But before we do that, yeah, I would say my observation from that time period right around the time of the manifesto is it seems very heavily that Wilford Woodruff is definitely the most stressed out out of anyone, understandably so. George Q Cannon comes out being very political, but as far as the way he words things, but he is definitely not in favor of the manifesto, right?
6:19 And he is only supporting it and carrying it through because President Woodruff wants to shove it through essentially, and make that concession. And yeah, let's just go back to some of the context really quick. You know, the Cliff Notes. So around February of 1887, George Buchanan writes in his journal that public clamor demands and will not be satisfied with anything less than a complete cessation of plural marriages and a renunciation of that practice by us. We are told that public opinion is Chris. It is crystallized in regard to Mormonism.
6:59 If it is, it is plain to be seen from every expression made upon the subject that nothing less than the complete destruction of our system of plural marriages will appease the popular demand. We have decided that we cannot do anything more than we have done towards consolidating public opinion upon this question. And whatever may be the results to us and to the people, we must trust to the Lord to sustain and deliver us. So that was the way he felt about it. Shortly after that you had the Edmonds Tucker Act, which amended and increased the the penalties of the Edmonds Tucker Bill. In November of 1887 we see Joseph F Smith goes to live with John Wooley for a while and in December of 1888 we see a government sanctioned or written document makes its way to church offices and Wilford Woodruff calls a meeting of the members of the Quorum of the 12. Now there was no First Presidency at this point because John Taylor had died and they had not reconvened The First Presidency and nine of the 12 were present, including Wilford Woodruff.
8:11 And he presents this government sent document and it is unanimously rejected by every single one of the members of the of the Quorum. And Wilford Woodruff says, had we yielded to that document, every man of us would have been under condemnation before God. The Lord will never give a revelation to abandon plural marriage. It's so crazy that they go from from the Lord will never give a revelation banning plural marriage to just a few, a few months later essentially that hey, here, here comes the manifesto. Yeah, we're dealing.
8:56 So that was December of 1888. So yeah, you're dealing with almost two years, almost a full 2 years till September of 1890. And the pressure gets crazy. It's it's a it just gets hotter and hotter and hotter. But in addition to that meeting where it was unanimously rejected by those present, there was another meeting held. And I want to find where that is. Let's see if I can find that. October 2nd, 1889, there's another meeting of the 12 and they were, they were discussing the recent arrest of Hans Jesperson. Around that time period we talked about, right. Hans Jesperson and Matthias Calley both had taken plural lives and it got out that they were doing that because the previous policy had been over the last few years, even before the manifesto was given.
9:58 That if we don't want to be caught or, you know, legally with anything going on right now, if you are going to enter into the principal, you're going to do it in Mexico and you were going to stay there, right? Right. And so they're discussing this policy in a meeting and Wilfred Woodruff on October 2nd, 1889 is essentially saying really we need to only be doing this in Canada or Mexico. We just got caught with with Hans Jesperson and John W Taylor says in that meeting, this is something I never expected to hear discussed in the slide. I have understood it was policy for the brethren to take wives outside the United States. You could not publish that you would not give your consent that plural marriages should be consummated and at the same time have the marriages consummated in Canada or Mexico.
10:45 I think it would be best policy to let the matter rest without saying anything about it, because if plural marriages are solemnized, it will soon be known and we will be considered insincere. I feel to have faith in the Lord and that He will bring something about for our deliverance. If we publish anything on this matter, it will be impossible for us or the elders to fully explain to the Saints, and much confusion will ensue. So he brings that up because Lorenzo Snow wanted to make a public announcement that don't worry, we're not doing this in America, we're just doing it in Mexico or Canada, right? And I was like, no, let's say nothing whatsoever about this because either we're, we're just not going to be able to explain anything that will our motivations are behind this, right?
11:33 In any case, the reason I bring that up again this meeting was also because I neglected to mention that this is the very first meeting John W Taylor presents the 1886 revelation to the form of the 12 according to research that D Michael Quinn did on a book that he was writing about John Wooley. So that's October 2nd, 1889. And then the next time you have John W Taylor mentioning the 1886 revelation is right after Wolford Woodruff announces to the 12 that they're going to issue a manifesto. And in that, in that meeting in particular, John Taylor didn't just bring up the 1886 revelation, He also brought up Wilford Woodruff's 1889 revelation, which he had had after, you know, this October 2nd, 1889 meeting. And they were promised to that the Lord would take care of them if they did not make, if the priesthood did not make any further concessions to their enemies. Right.
12:38 Yeah, yeah. And yeah, I find it interesting that John, John W Taylor's idea is just don't say anything, right. Don't, don't come out and say we're doing it and don't say that we're not doing it. Just don't say anything at all. Violence is golden in this. No. OK, the OK, the natural man in me, when you start talking about ceilings down in Mexico, you know plural ceilings, I would have been the guy that would have been like so why don't we just buy Baja, right. Let's just go out someplace nice to the coast. We get to keep our wives and also we don't have to deal with winter anymore. I I see that as a win, Win.
13:22 So John Taylor, right as we discussed last episode, bought about 100,000 acres in Chihuahua, Mexico, in the book Kingdom or Nothing by Samuel Wooley Taylor. When writing about that point in John Taylor's life when he was in hiding, he says that there was also another deal on the table that was further South, I believe towards the coast, the Baja Gulf. Not Baja per SE, not the not the peninsula, but towards the other side of the of the goal where there was 1,000,000 acres for sale, so 10 times the land, right? It should have took that, should have took that. I just signed up for that in a heartbeat. I would have too.
14:06 The one of the issues was that was kind of where some of the Mexican, Indian reservations were, I guess whatever whatever the equivalent was. And there was some concern that pouring white settlers onto Indian land down there would have been a cause for concern to everyone. And I don't know if that was a right or wrong move. I'm just throwing that out there. Because it's interesting that could have been. I'm just saying this sounds a lot more fun to be celebrating, you know, Christmas in Baja with your entire family then, then. And part of that could be it's like snowing right now.
14:49 And so, yeah, disappear too. Yeah, I I might be looking outside going. We may have screwed the pooch on this one, Michael. We should have took Baja. Yeah, a part of me agrees. I kind of. I mean, I like the mountains, but Mexico's got mountains. So I could probably live somewhere warm as long as it had mountains. But I don't know what a million acres looks like as far as like for context, if I were to see that like overlapped on a map, like, how, how does that relate to the size of the state of Texas? I don't know how big that you know, but Samuel Wooley Taylor's insinuated at that point, 1,000,000 acres would have easily held every single member of the Church at that point.
15:30 I'm fighting off feelings of getting gypped right at the moment. I'm sorry, dude. No. No, I no, I it it's just an interesting thought, right? Like boy, it it it probably wasn't a stretch to think that they were probably thinking about it a little bit, right? At least send everything. Down there another another one of the guys that brought the deal I think was was it Sam Samuel Brennan or the guy that was the guy that led the that ship voyage to San Francisco?
16:10 I know who you're talking about, yeah. Yeah, during during the Gold Rush and the Mormon Battalion era, you know, and he left the church and he found John Taylor by letter, you know, or whatever. And he was living down in Mexico and he offered that deal to to John Taylor. And so that John Taylor also might have felt maybe this is too good to be true to in order to pursue it. In any case, that's what I remember from the deal. Gotcha. All right, so right before the manifesto, we have a test. The test of the constitutionality of the Edmonds Tucker Act was challenged, and in May of 1890, the Supreme Court ruled that it was constitutional, which officially disenfranchised and disincorporated the LDS Church.
17:04 And then August 30th, the Brethren receive a notice that there will be an attempt to seize the Saint George, Logan and Manti temples in August 30th, 1890. So we see the context. It's written on the walls. What happens here? Yeah, it was this thing was not created in the in a vacuum. It did not just suddenly happen. So I contest, you know, I contest the the narrative that God just revealed to Wilford Woodruff. This Do you need to to do this? And as we discussed earlier, I think it's really a free agency thing.
17:47 Like I've told you my will, my word concerning this thing. Nevertheless it is given unto you and I can't, I can't stop you. Right. I'll show you what will happen if you do and you don't, but that's that's what the Lord, I think that was the deal that the Lord gave to Wilford Woodruff, and Wilford Woodruff made a choice. And we see the reaction in Psalm the 12, as you were saying, you know, for the most part, it's pretty unanimous that they didn't consider this to be a revelation. Afterwards, you know, Mariner Merrill wrote that this is, it was deemed more important to keep the temples and the work for the dead alive than plural marriage for the present. That's a direct quote.
18:29 And Hebert J Grant, in fact, even said, I feel that this is merely a public announcement to the course which we already decided in our private councils. And yet I believe that greater troubles will arise because of our course in announcing this policy and then in the meeting in August 20th, 1891, Mariner Merrill says point blank in his journal. I don't believe the Revel. The manifesto is a revelation from God and we start to see not a quick turn around. There's pretty much silence right after the manifesto, besides the fact that the Supreme Court and others in the Territory government basically started asking members of the church, do you really intend to stick by this?
19:22 Yeah, yeah. Let me ask you this question real quick. Did Wilford Woodruff believe it was a revelation? That's a tricky one for me to answer, because by a year later he's saying that the Lord revealed to me to do this, and I have a hard time with that because I I know the Lord revealed to him in 1889 not to do this right? And so how? And I like what John W Taylor said when he was first told of the manifesto. My first thought was to say, damn it, you know, how is how is God? Is God like a child, that he can change his mind, you know, and he doesn't? And he didn't believe that.
20:06 It was a rhetorical question. And so I'm led to think the same thing. I know that God couldn't change his mind after giving the 1886 and 1889 revelation. So what is the true situation if God's not changing his mind? It has to be. Something similar to Joseph Smith being led to ask the Lord three times about giving the the Lehigh manuscript to Martin Harris and his wife, right? Right and. There's been other examples of this principle. You know, and here's the thing, we see this repeating today, right? Let's go back to the 2015 announcement that the LDS Church wasn't going to allow children of gay couples to be baptized.
20:53 Now, the church got a lot of heat for that. I tended to kind of agree with the church, right? That, hey, we don't want to be causing divisions inside of even though we don't recognize them as legitimate families, right? Yeah, as in the kids. We don't want to be making a kid disavow his parents until that kids 18 and can make that decision. But Russell M Nelson came out and said, well that was that was a revelation from God and then a few short years later reverses it. Right. So these patterns don't just go away Michael. They continue to crop up time and again when it suits the leadership's political leanings, I guess. And and those are or public outcry or public opinion. So yeah, I I find that fascinating that that this is the first time we see that kind of capitulation. Maybe assigning something as a revelation that may not be that may be more of a policy and then trying to reverse it. Yeah, I I definitely don't want to cast any blame on President Woodruff, though, for this.
22:05 I think he was a very valiant man, and we're going to see the evidence that he, he didn't believe the manifesto was a revelation abolishing plural marriage. You would say that the Lord, the Lord told me to issue the manifesto. That is a different thing than saying the Lord is taking away plural marriage. Well, that's that's a good point too. And and I'm not trying to throw Wilford under the bus. What I am trying to show though is that there are consequences to to to capitulation. And one of those consequences seems to be that taking place in the in the Mother Church, over and over and over. Oh sure.
22:48 Or in the name, the name changing or the rebranding that the church is going through, which I never thought I would see in my day. You know, it's to me, it's reminiscent of the the the 1980s with the reorganized church turning into the community of Christ. And so we've disavowed the the name Mormon for. Right. And it's. I can't understand. I mean, I understand the emphasis on Christ, don't get me wrong. But I've never sought this received validation from others regarding how my testimony is. My personal testimony is no, You know, you can't be an effective missionary. You send out however many hundreds of thousands young men and women out there to preach the gospel and all nations in the world, and they're not going to do good if they're seeking validation for a label. Yeah.
23:41 Instead of proclaiming that no this is my testimony and I don't care if you call me a Mormon or you know sure I am a Mormon but I'm my testimony isn't is in Jesus Christ and you don't need to go so far as to say that you guess what Christians you are right we don't believe in the same Jesus because I believe that my Jesus Christ wasn't celibate and you know whatever you want to go to you know but and they're the ones that like to twist that but it's actually it's funny because it's true because but I wouldn't want to believe in the the Christ of the creeds you know I mean. No, no, I I've. I said for a long time before I ever left the church. You you don't want to call us a Christian.
24:22 That's OK. Go down to the deep, Deep South and see if you want that moniker. Sure. I'm fine being a Mormon. I'm me. Too. So, all right, so so Wilford's went ahead. He's published this. What happens next? We see in September of 1891. So a full year later, George Q Cannon gives a letter to John Henry Smith. Now, do you remember who John Henry Smith is? Oh. No refresh my memory.
25:04 So John Henry Smith is the son of George A Smith, which was first cousins with Joseph and Hiram, son of John Smith who was brothers to Joseph Smith senior, right? Right. And John Henry Smith is also the father of future president of the Church, George Albert Smith, and he is very important in the next few years. And he is one of the brethren who was instrumental in getting Joseph Musser into the principal later, if you recall that. Yep, I do recall that now. So he gets a he gets a letter from George Q Cannon basically saying you have authority to perform ceilings for any couples who, through through poverty or any other impediment, are prevented from going to the temple. Oh, through poverty.
26:08 So there's a lot of things that go on, like there's a a lot of who else was it patriarch Alexander F McDonald and George Teasdale down in Mexico. They also begin getting letters of recommends from George Buchanan, basically with similar language. Like in a week or two, this brother is going to come down with his family. Give them all that you can you know or take care of them to the best of your ability. You know, coded language or whatever. Basically saying you were authorized to perform these ceremonies. I wanna go back to something though. You said I I found that that thing about despite any of their challenges, whether they be too poor to go to the temple or something like that. What's he referring to there?
27:04 I was gonna say well, so or other impediment. I was gonna say you're it's too soon to be taking, you know, your plural life to be into the temple to to have this dealt with. So therefore we're giving you this authority to kind of oversee those matters indiscretion. I got. You what? What? What were you thinking? Well, that thing where it said poverty, I'm, I'm, I'm like, are they saying that if someone can't pay their tithing and they can't go through the temple, I'm wondering what that poverty remark was.
27:45 This is what it says. I can read the whole thing if you want, no? No, that's good. I was just curious. Any case, so yeah, that happens. Wilford Woodruff is brought to testify in October 19th, 1891 to asking them, like I said, point blank, you know, are you going to live up to your end of the bargain? And they asked him, quote, do you understand that the manifesto applies to the cohabitation of men and women in plural marriage where it already exists? And he answered, I could not see how it could be otherwise. Rough, right? Yeah. And this is the part that's the most heartbreaking, right?
28:27 It's one thing to discontinue the practice. It's another thing to be like, OK, now you got to pick a wife and just pick that one and you know that's what it's going to take to come into order, so to speak. Well, he tells the rest of the Quorum of the 12 that he said that under duress later. OK Abraham H Cannon records in his journal that I attended my council meeting. The matter of the Manifesto and the extent of its meaning was then discussed. So they're having this discussion, right? And President Woodruff said that he was placed in such a position on the witness stand that he could not answer other than he did.
29:08 Yeah, any man who deserts, neglects, neglects his wives or children because of the Manifesto should be handled for his fellowship. So you're going to be excommunicator or disfellowshipped if you do not live with your wives and take care of your wives and children, but you're going to go to jail if you're just caught doing? It really is kind of the same choice Eve was presented. Adam and Eve, I mean it. It's very much pick one, It's not gonna. Yeah, pick one. There's there's consequences to both. Yeah. So in July of 1892, we see George Buchanan write a letter to apostle George Teasdale authorizing him to do deal with the plural marriages in Mexico.
29:52 And then we move into 1893. Now, according to the book Family Kingdom written by Samuel Wooley Taylor, he says that in the year in spring of 19 or 1893, Lauren Wooley told Nettie or Janet Janet. Janet Marie Wooley Taylor, now right married to apostle John W Taylor, told her a strange tale of a secret revelation about the principle. Lauren said that right next door on the adjoining farm of the of John W Wooley, President John John Taylor was in hiding the night of September 26th, 1886 when he received a revelation concerning the principle and set men apart to continue it regardless of what the church might do officially on the matter. Lauren said that he was one of the men set apart. OK, so from almost the get go there starts to be information leaked that hey, there's ways around. This.
30:58 So yes, you know this is what would this be seven years later? Now the source is second hand late because the book This book was published in 1948, OK and it's the it's the family reminiscence of John W Taylor and the Woolley family and all the interconnectedness of it. The funny thing is that Samuel Woolley Taylor is kind of a Jack Mormon. So it's. Like what skin do you have in the game to be thrown out, you know this element into the book. That's kind of where I what I look at there. And because he was very nominal, he was never cut off from the church, but he was very nominal in his membership, you know, and he moved out to California and he got in a lot of trouble when he went to BYU as a, you know, young man.
31:44 And he didn't really have a whole lot to do with with the church except for he would occasionally write a few books. Gotcha, you know, history. And. But I really like what he has to say. And I do believe that his mom who was cousins to Lauren Wooley, was probably told that. And I have no reason to doubt why she would tell him that either. Now, around this time, Janet Marie Marie Wooley begins to go by the name Nettie. You know, Janet Nettie, you know, because it's it's your underground now and you're hiding. So they call her basically for the rest of her life. Nettie Mae Taylor.
32:29 And so I will now refer to her in the narrative as Nettie Nettie Taylor. Right. Let's see right after this point in time, John W Taylor took his second in his third life. That's Nellie, Nellie Todd and and Nettie Taylor to to man tie to do baptisms for the dead and they baptized the President of Mexico by proxy in the Manti Temple. John W Taylor apparently felt that that would be instrumental in opening the doors to to work amongst the Lamanites from having help from the other side.
33:11 OK. On the other side of the veil. So I thought that was interesting. That's cool. Yeah, that's. Cool. In 1893, you have the dedication of the Salt Lake Temple now. And so the government didn't seize the temples. And however, we are reaping in the benefits from peace, right. And there's some interesting conversation as alluded to in the book. But what ends up happening is, is John W Taylor ends up taking all three of his wife's dedication and remembering that, you know, that's a little controversial because, I mean, probably no one even knew that he had two before the manifesto, let alone 3IN any case. So he takes all three of them there, and I would like to say his his The system for for plural marriage was that each wife had her own home.
34:20 What do you think about that? Look, I I think, I think those kinds of arrangements are going to be unique to each family, right. I can tell you from from my standpoint and and Amber my my first wife feels this way as well is that if we can get everybody under one roof, at least for us, right. I'm not saying this is a hard and fast rule by any stretch. Everyone's got to figure this out on their own. But for us it will only help to foster a a cohesive family culture. Now I know that that's not always possible. I I know that that doesn't work for some people.
35:01 And so I I'm kind of like, you got to do what you got to do to make peace and harmony inside the family and whatever that that looks like, I I tend to stay out of that. That's none of my business. No, it's I I just wanted to flesh that out a little bit. No, I think you're absolutely right. You know, Brigham Young had most of his wives in one home, you know, the lion house and but John Taylor had Taylor Rowe which was a row of nine houses on the same St. you know, which that's probably whatever he wants. The women in a plural family are probably going to like that idea the most, on the same street but our own house. That's neat, you know, good luck, I would say, in modern times of accomplishing such a thing. But I think you're absolutely right that circumstances change and are dependent upon the individuals. But at this point, you have all sorts of people, not just John W Taylor.
35:58 You got one wife in one state, one wife in another state, one wife in one country, one wife in another country, right. He's got one wife in Salt Lake. He's got one wife in Canada, and he's got Nettie living wherever she's living at this point. Now, I'm not entirely sure. I don't remember, but different all different places. And that's the way it starts. And that was kind of his. And I don't know if it's right or wrong to say this, but it's it's kind of like I will provide this for you. You will have your own space. You can be the queen of your own world, and if you don't want having to have anything to do with them, you don't have anything. You don't have to have anything to do with them. It's kind of the way that it was approached, right? And that's definitely not ideal to choose that. But I guess no matter what way you slice it, it's got to be true, because you can't force anyone to do it. No, no, no, no, you can't.
36:55 I will say this, I I have a newfound respect for John W Taylor taking all three wives to the dedication. I the the first. OK. This is going to make I, I, I know this is going to make some people mad. But when I practice plural marriage the first time I took both of my wife's through a session in the Salt Lake Temple and yeah. Oh yeah, I did. You know I was. I look back at those days and I'm like, I was, I was like flirting with disaster all the time, you know, 'cause that first time, I mean, I was, I didn't have anywhere to go.
37:36 I didn't, I didn't know people, right. I was kind of out on my own. So I'm like, well, we'll just stay in the church and do this in the church. And yeah, dude, I would go to the temple with each wife. I mean, I I was, yeah. No, now, now looking back, I'm like, OK, well, maybe I wasn't so, so much up in the night. John W pulled it off. I I'd pulled it off for a little while. Most I I think John W had you beat. You know, you took the name Mormon Renegade, but I really think that he was probably. He was he was he was. He's my man. There's no doubt I'm I'm I'm I'm slowly developing A and the dude had a kick ass mustache. I mean, that stash is rocked that that thing was was epic. I mean, it made Magnum Pi look like a prepubescent teen mustache dude.
38:22 Some people can pull it off and it's a hard it's a hard thing to to know when you can. Absolutely. I I genuinely prefer I I prefer wearing a fold beer. But. Yeah, yeah, so do I. But but he pulled it off. I mean, to his credit, he he rocked that thing. He did. He was, according to his son and probably through his what you know, son being told what mom said about it is John W wore the mustache because otherwise he felt he would look too young for leadership. Gotcha, gotcha. OK, All right. I could, I guess I could kind of see that. But he, he really was the first Renegade. I mean as as I've done just a little bit of research, I'm like, oh, I feel a certain kinship with this man. This man is is rocking it hard.
39:14 Oh yeah, and he is. And so Nettie was also pregnant during that during the dedication with our first child and and so that kind of adds a little bit to the to the conversation too. She's like, are you serious? You want me to show up with the other two looking like this? Absolutely. You in a sense, just by the way he talks, right? As you've read the few things that he has said that this is not a bashful guy, right. He's going to be kind of in your face a little bit. If you are. If you are someone who thinks that monogamy should be the standard within within the the the Mormon world, he's going to challenge you on that.
39:59 He's going to challenge you by the things he says and he's going to challenge you by the things that he does. And I find that amazing. Yep, he is. And and the wives didn't always, you know, they had their struggles too with it, you know. And with him being so gung ho about it, by the way, because and you can probably see this with at least most ladies as you want comfort and stability and when you got your husband rocked in the boat like he is, it's like stop, you know. Absolutely. Absolutely. Yeah, I know he's he's he's a stud. I mean, I I hope I get to do podcast from the other side because I really want to talk to John Taylor. I want to be like, all right, dude, pull up Billy up to this microphone.
40:50 We got some things to talk about, so. All right, so going forward, at least in the case of Nettie Woolley, right? She seems to have enough spiritual experiences to kind of lead her through the trials. And Samuel, in recalling his life and the life of his father, doesn't mention the other wives too much. And it's understandable that's not the line he comes through. But in 1893, Nettie has a dream where she she is shown the 4th wife that John will marry. Right. And they do not meet her for another eight years, but she has the dream eight years before they meet.
41:35 OK. That John W will marry another wife. OK, at least one. Right. Later that spring their first child was born and I believe they named him Joseph Bruce, you know named him after the prophet Joseph Smith and humor he. So John W Taylor was not able to be there for the birth, and they were he was planning to be. But because she was on the underground, they were moving her from from somewhere in Utah to Wyoming. And they had bought a ranch and it was her idea. And she just wanted to be out there in the country and she just wanted to be away from the possibility of being caught and raise her family out there.
42:25 And he was called to do some church business in Canada and was not able to make it. And she also had it. She had the baby on route in the wagon to the property in Wyoming. And in any case, they get to the property and he meets his son, you know, for the first time, you know. And and he says that he's the spitting image of the Prophet Joseph Smith. That's awesome. Which obviously shows you that John W Taylor had some experience knowing what Joseph Smith looked like. Although I don't know, I mean how you can say a baby would look like that, but I, you know, I can. But I also can see.
43:13 In any case, that's kind of fun. Let's see, on the heels of all that, in February and March, the temple law case comes around. Do you know about that? Go ahead and fill me in. The Temple Law case was controversy between essentially who was going to be recognized as the legal successor to the church that Joseph Smith started in in New York, right.
43:53 And so at this point you have the the reorganized church, you have the Temple Law church and you have the church in Utah and people are brought, you know, into court and to testify and we're they, you know, you're telling the stories and you're laying your claims before the people and all that. But but hold on one second. The the I don't want to say ownership of the church, but the the the legal church doesn't follow Brigham Young necessarily. From New York to Utah, No. No, it doesn't. Especially not after the government disincorporated.
44:35 OK, that's, yeah, that's a good point. I guess the government would have have dissolved that and then essentially a new church had to come up. So the first church was incorporated as Church of Christ. And then they, Joseph Smith, did reincorporate another church organization in Missouri called the Church of the Latter Day Saints, and then that evolved into the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints by revelation. That was what the Lord wanted him to call it after that point. But like, like we said, the government kind of destroyed that one. And on the books in this ruling, the federal government ruled that the reorganized church was the legal successor to Joseph Smith's real restoration. It did.
45:27 It did. Wow. Yeah, so we got screwed over on that one, but whatever. In any case, I bring it up because Lorenzo Snow testified and made an observation regarding polygamy being against the rules of the Church in the days of Joseph Smith, when the doctrine was not yet revealed publicly. He noted that those married polygamously before 1843, quote, would have violated the laws of the Church and been guilt guilty of adultery and would have meet. And he immediately therefore conceded that Joseph Smith married Eliza R Snow prior to the giving of the 1843 revelation, which is DNC 132.
46:10 Right? And following up on the logical consequences of such a testimony, the attorney asked and what sort of position that put Joseph Smith Junior and Eliza R Snow in and President Snow responded. It put them in a first rate splendid condition for time and eternity. Nice. Nice. So you have, you have that admission that yes, this was not against the rules of the Church, but it was, it was a revelation from God because it was not yet revealed. But it sets the framework for the idea that the IT can be underground, right? Yeah, because that way it was practiced by Joseph Smith. And when asked by the attorney what position does it put Joseph in and and and Lorenzo Snow's sister Eliza puts him in a first rate, splendid condition for time and eternity.
47:01 I love it. Let's see, in June of 1894, on a trip to Mexico, Brigham Young Junior and John Henry Smith go down. They go down there and they perform at least five plural marriages. And one of them was the the stake high Councilman or a a Stake high, a stake stake high Councilman who went down there to get a wife. And he later wrote, When I took my second wife, I had a letter signed by President Woodruff himself and a personal letter from President George Q Cannon.
47:42 Wow. Authorizing that. And so up to that point, stuff's going down low key in Mexico. It's not super often from what I can tell. Like I said, George Teasdale performed 15-O marriages from 1893 to 95, and Brigham Young Junior and John Henry Smith do five, and in May and June of 1894. The first instance of a plural marriage being done back in the state of Utah that I'm aware of is in July of 1894. So a good four years after the manifesto. Practically. And do you want to venture any guess who does it? Is it my boy John W?
48:23 No, it's not. And unfortunately we'll know. I'll make note of this. Now the interesting thing is, despite how vocal he was publicly and privately, he actually performed far less post manifesto plural marriages than most of the others himself. He performed them. He performed less ceremonies, but he highly encouraged others. Was it Wilford? It was not. It was Mariner Merrill, the same guy writing in his journal. I did not believe. OK. There comes Manifesto is a revelation from God. He's acting as president of the Logan Temple and he goes to Wilfred Woodruff alone and talks with him and got a recommend from George Buchanan on behalf of his daughter because he has a daughter who is interested in entering into another man's family. And so he seals his daughter in the Logan Temple as a plural wife on July 16th.
49:29 OK, let's see. In 1895, February 15th, George Buchanan takes another wife. And this is an interesting situation because it's not. No ceiling is done. And this is going to fly in the face of a lot of tradition. And I guess I'm not here to argue whether it's right or wrong so much, but what they did was enter into a solemn covenant with each other without no any other officiator.
50:11 Now, now the the reason I fist pump right there is because that's how the first time around I I did my my plural family. Sure. And I've had people say where where, where is the scriptural? There's some stuff pointed to by by, oh, Ogden Kraut and as well, what's his name the historian for the church for a while. Michael Quinn, he he points to it. Where where can someone find that solemn covenant thing? Do you?
50:52 What record is that? Well, I'll I was about to read the entry from George Q Cannon's own journal, which I got a copy of excerpts of his journal and his son Abraham H Cannon's journal that was published by Stephen Murphy. Who was? Excommunicated from the AUB perfect. And but also there is a book also called Solemn Covenant by B Harman Cardi and there is a paper which was published in dialogue OK that you're referring to I think which is called plural marriages between 1890 and 19 O four with LDS church authority.
51:35 OK perfect. It's like where he goes over a ton of the sanctioned plural marriages done, you know, in this time period where, and I have a copy of that, and it is where a lot of my research comes from. Awesome. I just need to know where to point some listeners to because I I think they were politely telling me I was full of it. Sure. So George Q Cannon writes in his journal, had an interview with Sister Amelia Frost. We George Q Cannon and Amelia Frost, known as Amelia Frost Madsen, members of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints and believers in the doctrine of of marriage for eternity being prevented by the laws of the land from carrying out our purpose while we are both alive. Take this method of making known our wishes concerning the relations we desire established between us for eternity, so that in the event of the demise of one or both of us, our wishes may be carried out by our representatives or heirs. The said.
52:37 Amelia Frost has expressed the desire to be united to the Senate George Q Cannon as his wife for eternity. And the said George Q. Cannon, being desirous that she should be sealed to him as a wife for eternity, mutually covenant and agree to be thus married for eternity by the authority of the Holy Priesthood through the sealing ordinance which the Lord has revealed. The object of this paper is to enjoin upon our representatives or heirs, to take the necessary steps to have this marriage for eternity solemnized in one of the temples. So where do you fall on that, Michael? Do you feel like that that's a valid thing, I mean? I think it's. I think it certainly is if you if it's if the situation was well, I don't really foresee myself living in a situation where I wasn't going to live with her as my wife.
53:29 And I was going to say if you're not going to live with her and act as husband and wife, then sure, then absolutely this is going to be yeah maybe you're just making known to your posterity you want this done. Easy peasy. But if the Lord told me that that was the way to do it, I have no issue with taking, taking her as an actual wife and living with her as a wife raising children. I now I would like to say though, you know, I'm very cautious when I do anything that's against standard protocol myself or when when I contemplate doing things that are normally against standard protocol. I would never like to abuse things that are revealed in a certain pattern, but I could understand that this could be done as a prelude to a more ideal circumstance.
54:25 I I agree with you wholeheartedly. I I look, look, I was. I was so careful when tried to be as careful as I could be when I entered it. The principal the first time. But even back in 2007, right, 2008 when I when I entered this thing, it wasn't like fundamentalists are today. I mean, there's been radical change in that short time period. Today I would say if you want to find someone with proper authority to steal you, that's way easier. Now, if you're some convert that is living in, you know, Philadelphia, someplace like that where there's not a lot of fundies hanging out, right? I could see where doing that would be wisdom until someone with proper priesthood authority can be located. I I wouldn't say this is the ideal. I wouldn't say that this is something that you should just bank on forever necessarily.
55:31 You should. You should at least be in the mode of trying to find somebody to come, Celia. But I I feel like it's it's not out of the pale of Orthodoxy to live it in that fashion until you can find that that that authority. So as someone who's been endowed, it's interesting because there's almost more prohibitions regarding what you can and can't do in relation to the a common law type marriage or solemn covenant. Because you covenant either in the Church that you will not have sexual relations with any person who is not married, you know, given to you by the holy priesthood or the Church, depending on if you've been through a fundamentalist endowment or a church endowment. Both are limited in scope and according to the section 132. It also says interesting things regarding what conditions you place yourself under depending on the vows you make when you're married.
56:27 Right. And so a man and a woman who are married and desire to enter. You know, a man who's already married desires to take another wife, but he is not under a vow that it says that he is justified. Meaning if you're not breaking your your vow to your first wife, you can take more. Right. Yep. You know, and so that's completely correct in the sight of the Lord. But he says if it is not entered into by these conditions, you have no promise in the life to come that it's eternal. Right, right. Yeah, it it. And it's interesting that the Lord brings that up in 132, because he's almost he's almost planning ahead for these days in some ways. Yeah, I I think so.
57:18 Let's see next on the list in the history. January 4th, 1896 Utah becomes the 45th state in the Union. I'm not going to clap for that. Look, I'm a very patriotic guy. I kind of side with some of those territories who are like, we don't want to become a state. I get it. I get it. I'm not. I'm not sure that was a great move necessarily. Yeah, well, I definitely don't think it was a great move for the members of the church or the Mormon people in general, but I wish I thought I had it written here, the statistic I mentioned in the last episode. But after the state of Utah is admitted into the union, the percentage of post manifesto plural marriages skyrockets because we got what we wanted.
58:13 Oh, I see. OK, right after the right after this, you know, John W Taylor brings Nettie back from Wyoming or wherever they're at to, and he buys her a house in Farmington, UT. OK. You know, Farmington, UT is Yep. Oh yeah. Yeah, up there by lagoon. Yeah. Do you know, do you know what county that's in? That, if I'm not mistaken, is Davis County. It is Davis County, so remember that. And. This is me foreshadowing something. Some people just will already know what who's in Davis County but go up.
58:59 Well, no, I wasn't thinking about that. That and this that they don't happen till what? Later, But the Woolley family, you know John W Woolley, you know, lives in Davis County and is on the Davis State High Council by the way, at this point. Let's see, I thought this was funny. Around this time period. I took a little excerpt from Family Kingdom. Again, Samuel Woolley Taylor notes that around this time his grandfather or or his father began chafing under the new policies of the Church after the manifesto, and he didn't really mind what toes he stepped on.
59:42 And when a new apostle was being ordained into the quorum 1 by 1 in order of seniority, the others of the 12 arose to lob the new members virtues. And when it came to father's turn, he said all new babies look alike to me. They're red and ugly and they have to be tended and they do a lot of bawling. Wow. Now, I don't know who exactly he's talking about at that point in time. It could have been Mythias Callie, but I doubt it because they're good friends at this point. But on the other hand, I could also see it being a reference to Abraham Owen Woodruff, who enters the Quorum of the 12 at this point, and he looks remarkably babyface. And so I can see that being tongue in cheek humor for for young Owen Woodruff.
1:00:29 But other apostles who get out of at that point in time are Reed Smoot, Hiram, Max Smith, George Albert Smith, and Charles Penrose. And how many of those new ones are are distinctly in the no polygamy camp? Hiram M Smith seem to be kind of not necessarily against it, but definitely not for it. In the short time he died pretty, pretty young. He got replaced. Charles Penrose was told the line we're not going to do this anymore after the Reed Smoot hearings, right? Like we're not quite there yet, aware that the 12 itself start turning against the principal, but people who do end up being in that position are now entering into the form of the 12. But on the other hand, Matthias Cowley, Anton H Lund, Manor Merrill, Owen, Woodruff, Rudder, Clausen, That's five. John W Taylor.
1:01:34 Those are all six very strong pro polygamy proponents that are still in the quorum at the least at this point. Around this time, John W Taylor makes remarks like Esau sold his birthright for a mess of pottage and I will, and it will yet appear in the history of the Saints that many have sold their inheritances for 30 pieces of silver. In referring to Judith giving up the principle of plural marriage. In December of 1896, he is called to organize a mission in Colorado. OK. And so the next few years, he acts as a mission president and he takes one of his wives with him, which is Nettie or Janet Woolley, to be mission president's wife in that mission.
1:02:27 Right. And let's see, we'll talk more about that in a minute. But I had to bring this up to February 22nd, 1897 Miles P Romney, which obviously has some in relation to other prominent Romneys we know, marries his fifth wife, Emily Henrietta. I ring. Any relation to, well, it's got to have relation to. Yeah, so you got a Romney marrying his fifth wife and I ring sealed by apostle Heber J Grant in colonial Juarez, Apostle John Henry Smith basically commissioning slash compelling Heber J Grant to perform that ceremony.
1:03:19 All right, now I did. This time, Heber's a polygamist, right? Yeah, he is. He had three wives at this point. OK. Yeah, And he wasn't, you know, he wasn't against the principal for himself. And he later on in the Reed Smoot hearings was pretty defiant and said darn, and I want to keep taking wives until I have a son, because he had had some sons but they had actually died, or at least if he had that news as one. But in any case, by that point in the Reed Scoot hearings he had no male errors and he told them to finally, I'll pay my fine, then I'll do do my dues. But I'm not going to stop living in polygamy until I have a until I have a son.
1:04:03 And sad to say, he never did again. None of his wives were able to bear him any sons after that point. But I mean, if you hadn't been so opposed to polygamy, you could have, probably your odds would have been in his favor. Right, right. Yeah. OK, and she's that Lady is not the only hiring by the way. We're going to mention some other hirings in the the hiring family that are involved with post manifesto polygamy around April of 1897 when. Can't get enough of the Mormon Renegade podcast? Well, good news, we're on Patreon and there's three packages that you can choose from.
1:04:47 The first one, the Slightly rowdy package, allows you to hear the podcast without all those pesky commercials getting in the way. For those who want a slightly more in depth experience, there's the Stirring It Up package where you can hear ad free audio, ad free video and transcripts. Finally, for those who want to go full Renegade, that package is available too, where you can get everything in the previous two packages, plus an extra show where myself and Ben Winfield breakdown the news of the day from a very Mormon point of view. You will also get exclusive access to Renegade chat, and on there you'll be able to talk to others about the show or whatever topics are on your mind. Go to Patreon today and get your exclusive content.
1:05:30 Went away from the mission, you know, John Taylor was serving as mission president when he was sent away because he still had to do other things that apostles normally do, right? He wrote a letter. I found it was pretty sweet, because now Nettie was expecting her third child, and he writes a letter to her saying what in all the world could compare with the bright, intelligent sunbeam coming forth from one probation to another. Clothed in an embryo with every attribute of its creator. Being innocent from the beginning, coming to us as a gift for time and eternity, Clothed with the elements of eternal and everlasting life, with power to grow and develop and go on and on, increasing and progressing from one stage of perfection to another until it becomes even as our Father in Heaven is perfect.
1:06:18 Think of it, my dear beloved wife, that you have the honor of becoming the Mother, and I the Father of one who has power, if directed right to attain all intelligence, all power, all knowledge, and all glory, possessing Thrones, principalities, and eternal life, who shall in the great future preside over its posterity as our own Heavenly Father presides over us? I say again, dear one, I think or think of these things, when the hour of pain and sorrow comes in bearing the fruit of your loins, remember the reward and bear up under your temporary affliction. For sacrifice brings forth the blessings of heaven. And how we will rejoice when we can unite in beholding a new messenger from heaven, clothed with the intelligence of our Father and Mother in heaven and all our own, or all our own.
1:07:04 Not a gift to pass away with time, but one that is ours forever. Batman is a smooth criminal. Yeah, he is. You know, I like this because this humanizes the principle, right? So often from the outside looking in, it seems very cold and academic. Sometimes in the way that it's portrayed, sure. But here we get a glimpse into the feeling of the man's soul, right? What this principle really means to him and what it's really all about. It's about eternal posterity. It's about eternal families. It's not about self aggrandizement in the vain sense of the word.
1:07:48 This is about all those things that we as Mormons hold most dear and cherish most above all other things, The this idea of an eternal posterity and eternal families. It certainly is. That's, you know. And when you when you, it all ties back to the plan of salvation, right. And you learn that as a Mormon, you know and pretty much any slice of the the restoration that you follow and you it's the most beautiful thing in the world. To to understand that you have the promise of having an eternal family and it answers the questions that sectarian Christianity with their philosophy was not able to answer.
1:08:32 And I well, there probably are branches of the restoration that I don't know what they do with that because they reject even eternal marriages. And what a dismal thing to. Yeah. To contemplate, I mean, look it, it's that doctrine that that makes all the other stuff we deal with as Mormons that that's that's the reward, right? I mean that's that's what it's about. That's why you do all these other things. Mm hmm. From from baptism to temple work. That's why we do all these other things, is to have those crowning blessings.
1:09:13 Yeah. And so I I thought that was neat for him to, to write a letter consoling his wife that he wouldn't be there, you know, again, and duty calls. And it's a hard thing because it is hard to put the Lord first when you've got your family on the line. Yeah. And the tender feelings no. Of your young lady or or maybe not so tender expression of those feelings because they can get pretty upset sometimes too. And when you when you but you need to do those things and you need to put the Lord 1st and hope that they will also put the Lord 1st. And in any case, I'm sure it broke his heart though, to do that.
1:10:01 And let's see, moving on from that point, by this point, there was a stake organized in Mexico. And so it goes from being a Mission District presided over by an apostle to having Anthony W Ivins being the stake president. And he kind of takes care of the majority of the ceilings down there from that point, although Alexander McDonald still does. And on occasion, visiting apostles will also take care of certain things. Let's see it'll.
1:10:45 In fact, one of my notes here says Anthony W Ivins married a couple, Walter W Steed and his second wife Susan Alice Bell Clark, which is sister of Nathan Clark. Do you know any of those names, Nathan? Clark. Nathan Clark. That sounds familiar, but I couldn't play some. OK, we're going to get more into Nathan Clark later. And Walter Steed, you know, is one of the ancestors of a lot of steeds that are in fundamentalism today. It's a big family name. Yep. In any case, he he was married to Nathan Clark's sister, and he also lived in Davis County, by the way.
1:11:35 You know, going to the Steed name it. It took me a few years to to get the connection. But if you remember right, when I joined the church in 1995, there was a series of books that had just come out called The Work and the Glory. Sure, yeah. And do no matter what anybody says, I still think those are great books and and I owe a lot of my me being able to recognize and and kind of claim that history is my own a little bit through those books. Right.
1:12:17 Those really caught me up as far as church history. What I find interesting is that the name of the family that those books follow are steeds, right? And I've. I've drawn that connection as well. And I've often wondered from time to time, like is there Part 2 to this? I mean, is there like another series of books where they? Do a fundamentalist history version of the of the same state. Family I I have been so tempted at times. Call up the I mean, Gerald run. Was it Gerald Lund that wrote those books? Yeah. It was. It was Gerald and Lund. Yep. And so he's probably dead at this point. But I wonder what his connection Gerald Lund's was to Anthony H Lund who was involved in these very events.
1:13:00 Yeah, no, I've wondered that same thing. Because it's a funny name to pick out, right? You could have picked a ton of other historical names to go through this thing with, but he went out of his way to pick Steed. Yeah, yeah. I mean, they're the only historical Steed family I know, and I don't know when the Steed family convert, this particular historical Steed family converted to the church. But in any case, we'll talk more about the steeds in a few years at this point. So summer of 1897, John W Taylor tells his wife that we're going to go fishing out in San Luis Valley. We're going to have a fun time.
1:13:45 And, you know, we never really got a honeymoon because if you recall, they were married by Francis M Lyman at night in a carriage while they were driving around the park in Salt Lake. Yep, very unorthodox. And then she got dropped off at home. Yep. And so he's basically making up like, OK, like, let's go on a real honeymoon. We're going to go out into the mountains and we're going to go fishing, and it'll just be us. And it doesn't really turn out that way. Coincidentally, there were other Mormon settlements in the San Luis Valley at this point and they had grown pretty cold in the faith, you could say. And the, the basically some of the in the back of his mind intention was I'm going to go, I want to go revive, you know, the spirit, some of these people.
1:14:38 And they go to a town called Manasseh and it's still there, by the way, Manassa, Colorado. And if you look on Google Maps and find that town, it is laid out just like a Utah town in the grid. Yep. Yeah, awesome. And they're staying there in Manassa, but they have a campsite out in the Conejos Canyon. And then all of a sudden prominent leaders from the church start showing up, you know to where these meetings are and he's he's starting to hold meetings. And in any case you got all the Mormons from the towns in the San Luis Valley coming out to be the brethren there. John W Taylor's there and Gentiles end up flocking to the the meetings in the Canyon and apparently turned into quite a big deal.
1:15:27 And hundreds of converts were baptized and after an outpouring of the Spirit, John W Taylor prophesied that a temple would be built in that town if the if the people were faithful. Wow. And it hasn't happened yet, but. Hasn't happened yet, but I have an interesting historical anecdote regarding John W Taylor and temples. OK, so we know from the last podcast that he also prophesied the spot of the Alberta Cardston Temple. Yep, and it was built on the very spot, actually, that he predicted it would be when the church had another spot in mind. For a long time, actually. But then it ended up being the the other spot that he predicted.
1:16:10 But I there's there's at least another town and I think he would probably do this. And I don't want to say he made a system of doing this, but I think I could I I believe he was inspired to the Lord do this too. But he made another promise in Safford, Arizona. One point where he was visiting there and I don't remember what the year was and he promised them if they were faithful on condition of faithfulness, right, that you will have a temple in this town. I know of a man who came out with his family from the AUB named Ted Jessup who, when looking to to do things that he was called to do, was looking towards Safford, Arizona and the Gila River valley area.
1:17:01 Because he knew John W Taylor had prophesied that a temple would be built in that area and there was not yet a temple there. And he said in one of the meetings that he was holding that the church was going to build one there. But Hebrew J Grant made it so that the Mesa Temple was built first in order that John W Taylor wouldn't be vindicated in prophesying that. Interesting. That's what Ted Jessup said in the 90s. But he But if you go look on the church websites, there is a Gila River Valley temple between Thatcher and Safford, Arizona. And it says on the website that John W Taylor promised them that they would have a temple there.
1:17:48 So yeah, so at some point between the 90s and now, they, the church, did build a temple there. But I would just say, you know, if there's any people fleeing out into the wilderness that need to take the priesthood with them, make you have a claim, maybe you should look at Manassa Colorado. I don't know. Yeah. Fulfilled prophecy. I just, I don't know. I just think there's something poetic to that. You know if you're. I mean that kind of goes to it's it's an interesting question of yeah, the philosophical question of how much do we do to fulfill prophecy ourselves or whatever, you know self fulfilling prophecy or whatnot what have you.
1:18:37 In any case that one's hanging over Manassa, Colorado is all I'm saying. Let's see around this time I might have been in Colorado in one of the branches he's, I took the snippet out of Family Kingdom. He says get married. You men are only Half Men without wives. And don't be bashful about the girls. They're just as anxious to get married as you are. Look around you men at the girls sitting here. Pick out the one you'd like. Now watch her. If she smiles, she'll listen to a proposal. Well, look at that. Every girl in this place is smiling. And now I'll tell you. And now I'll tell you if she'll accept you. If she laughs, now she will.
1:19:23 Nice. Well, brothers and sisters, it looks like we're. Going to have a flock. Of marriages you can see. You can see why people Yeah, you could see. Why People were drawn to him, right This is the guy that's going to preach the gospel, but yet this is still a guy who, who, who, who's rooted in? In. And being human, right? This is a guy who's not interested in becoming a marble statue. This is a guy who is very much trying to to lead a people and do it in a very loving, good-natured, jovial way. And again, I really, I love the humanity that comes through with these stories.
1:20:14 Me too. And dude, that is psychologically so sly. To I mean to, yeah, to. To the point where he's embarrassing both. The young men. And the young women, but he's getting them. But he does it in such a right way, way where I could see one not giving the confidence to the young man to actually, OK, maybe I should go out and ask this young lady, Yeah, you know, and it's dude, it's a perfect icebreaker right there. Like like this apostle in the church just broke the ice for every single person in that ward or whatever to go and talk about things like that. That apostle was those young men's ultimate. Wingman, right. Like, beat that. Wingman, right. No, you can't. You can't beat it. Yeah, it's done right.
1:20:55 I mean game. Over you know who my. Wingman is it's Sean W Taylor. He just totally opened this bad boy up for me. So yeah, and it's. It's. Awesome the the way. That he takes that work. So seriously, and it's it's no, there's no outright mention of the principle there. But that very well could have been part of the reason, right, Right. You know that he's trying to get these, He's trying to get people to enter into it. Let's see, in October 1897, in conference he gives a talk about the Law of Abraham. You know which we know what that is by code language. And I never went back to find it to see if I could find it in any conference reports.
1:21:42 But apparently he got kind of trouble after that one because it was too on the nose, you know, for a public discourse. But in that same conference where he's talking about the the Law of Abraham, that's when Matthias F Cowley and Abraham Owen Woodruff are ordained to the 12th. Now, Matthias Calley's got at least two wives at this point. And Owen Woodruff, who is son of President Wolford Woodruff, is he's pretty young. He's. I don't think he's quite 30 yet, probably 2728, but he's got one wife, no kids, OK? And I don't know how long.
1:22:26 He's been married but. They had a They had a problem with fertility and they were not able to have kids for a while. And we're going to get back to that in a minute. Or yeah, right after conference, apostle George Teasdale marries another wife and yes, indeed in January of 1898. So a good three or four months after young Owen Woodruff enters into the form of the 12th January of 1898, John W Taylor prophesied the Helen Helen Winters, wife of Apostle Abraham. Owen Woodruff would bear children, and in fact her first child would be a son.
1:23:10 And beyond that, that the son would be born with a cow lick. Wow, it's pretty specific. And he was right on. All counts. Wow. Holy cow. And this would be. Nearly two years later, that she. Had the that Son, holy cow so in late, late 1899. So, yeah, so there. Was a they had a a while to let that that promise marinate. And so he would have been 30 years old with a before Owen Woodruff had his first child. And there's other meetings where I think he would kind of, you know, Owen Woodruff. Would kind of talk to.
1:23:57 Others on the form of the 12th and say you know, like I'm just, I'm, I'm distraught, you know, we're not having any kids no matter, you know, what we do. And I think Franklin D Richards was one of them if it wasn't. Him. It was Mariner. Merrill, you know, reminded him, hey, look at look at the precedent we have in the faithful women that had struggled with with childbearing in the scriptures and who more. You know, US, you know, essentially our our entire lineage comes from from those, those mothers. In February of 1898, the family of a Bishop named Lauren Harmer of Springville claimed that Joseph F Smith encouraged him to enter into plural marriage in 1897 while they were both in New York City on a trip.
1:24:47 He says that in February of 1898, Joseph W Summerhays, he's important, later talked some private business over with President Smith, told him. I told him some of the brethren were getting wives, and I asked him if it would be all right if I took one. He said it would be under certain conditions. Interesting. And see Joseph F Smith. Has has an interesting history, right? Not only do we have this coming out now, but I know he was renowned for if somebody came up to him and said hey, you know, not in the 12 or something like that and said I want to enter. You know the principle he would say something to the effect of, well, if you can find someone to do it, God bless you, and then would walk away and then I'll be darned. If someone's not knocking on his door going, I was directed to your home because you needed an ordinance done sort of a thing. And so he was.
1:25:46 He was smooth as well with with this whole thing, he was. And I wish I would have footnoted. It or or recorded it. I remember seeing in the days where he's president of the church and he's not quite president of the church yet. He's in the first presidency at this point. But when he's president of the church, when he's out speaking in a branch in Idaho, he says, point blank, I will lie like hell to defend my brethren. Yeah. And and I think that's even. An echoing. Or a repetition of statements that Joseph Smith made in his own life. You know, And so when you take those things into consideration, the writing's on the wall. You know, he did make also a ton of public denials. Or, you know, declarations that we are not doing this anymore. We are not practicing plural marriage. But like he said, I will lie like hell to protect my brethren.
1:26:42 Yep, Yep. No this this is such. A fascinating time in in Mormon history because it it's a time of high intrigue. It's a time of like double agents, right? I mean, seriously, there is stuff going on. Super compartmentalized. Yeah. There's like one group here and they don't know about the other guys being commissioned by the same person, right? You know, it's like a spy movie, Like you're putting it down. It really is. And. And. Yeah, it it's a fascinating time. That really sets up precedent for what becomes the the the modern Mormon fundamentalist experience.
1:27:28 Yeah, it's fascinating. Let's see. So that was in. 8 February 1890. 8 When Bishop Lauren Harmer and Summer Hayes Joseph Summer Hayes go and talk to President Smith, February in March of 1898, John W Taylor and Apostle John Henry Smith go down to Mexico and Arizona, and while on that circuit from visiting the branches in Arizona and Mexico, they perform over 90 marriages, many of which were plural.
1:28:09 Right. I don't have an exact figure of how many were. Plural but. I do know, yeah. This is when John W Taylor begins to perform the first plural marriages post manifesto that he performs, he performs. One for the first one is February. 22nd George. Washington's Birthday on 1898 for Charles Whipple and Mary Walser March 8th, 1898 for Anson B. Call sealed to his third wife, Dora Pratt and. Three days before that, he sealed Fred. Heaton to Abigail Cox.
1:29:00 And then actually. There was 3 on the same day. In fact, I'm. Looking at this, so the first one was February 22nd, the second one was March 5th, and then he performed 3 plural ceremonies for three different men. On the same day, March 8th, 1898. Holy cow. And then a sixth one. On March 10th. Two days after that. So one of those. So I found some interesting stuff here. OK, so one of those was Anson B Call and I think he's the son of the Anson Call that lived in the days of Joseph Smith.
1:29:40 But he he brother Call, this was not the first plural wife that he had taken. He had taken a second wife in Mexico already when the like. He went down to Mexico when the manifesto was first issued. We're eight years removed from that now, right? But I don't know if they were able to have any children before. And in any case, she dies her second, his second wife does. And so he's getting permission to get, you know, to enter into the principal again. And John Taylor, John W Taylor was able to do that for him. In any case, in his own family history, I found he has some interesting reminiscences about some visitations or experiences he had in Mexico that I felt was very interesting. In his own memoir, Anson B Call writes, sometime during the night, a personage appeared at the foot of my bed. I raised up and sat up in bed and discovered that it was my father.
1:30:43 He held a book under his arm. He took the book out and opened it and told me that it was an account of my life. It showed me the debits and credits of my life and. Appeared to me to. Be about 1/3 full. I thought that the debit side exceeded the credit side and that my record was very bad as the last entry made on the debit side was very large, the largest in the whole of the book. My father told me that the Lord is very displeased because I had not acknowledged his hand in taking Haiti, which was his second wife, I guess, and that the last large figure represented this. I attempted to add the debits in the book, but my father closed the book and said no one but the custodian of that book had any right to examine its contents.
1:31:27 He said that the custodian of my book was John W Taylor, who later married me to my third wife. He told me that my life was generally approved, but that the Lord was very much grieved. At the last recording, however, he assured me that the credits were greater than the debits, even though they appeared to be less, as they recorded the debits more often than they did the credits. My father said that I would live to fill that book and that I would not be taken until it was filled. As it appeared to me to be 1/3 full, I figured I would live to be 84 years old. That's what he wrote. Consequently, he ended up actually living to be 91 years old. But yeah, so he he has this vision where he's struggling with the death of his second wife and the Lord makes him known, makes it known to him that it was ordained by him to take her back and that there would be someone, you know that to fix this situation, you know, or the the John W Taylor will be sent to take care of that.
1:32:29 OK. Isn't that awesome? That is awesome. Holy cow. And this is before he married her. The third wife. Wow. So he's relating this to his posterity in his own family history. Holy cow. Dude. I. Those are the experiences that I feel. Like we're not. Taking advantage of in Mormonism, I I think if we're living as best we can and we are really. Striving. We should expect those to see some of those things in in the course of our lifetime. I think that's the promise of of Mormonism. I think so, to a degree, I.
1:33:09 I'll just say I've had enough experiences in my life that I don't demand them. No, and I wouldn't say anyone. Should, but I do know what. You mean because it's a fine line. I'm just very super cautious when it comes to that. But you're you're you're right though. When you look even at the Book of Mormon, it says miracle. If if you say that miracles have ceased, it's because you have no faith, right? Right. Absolutely. I I'm not saying go out and demand. A sign like the wicked. Generation. I'm just saying we should be more open to it, yeah. And that's a good way of putting it. We should be more. Open to it and. I'll be honest with you, Dave. I struggle with that to a point because I am personally more analytical, bordering, cynical sometimes, and I don't know if that's just the way I am or if I've made myself that way just through my own well.
1:34:03 And I'm not saying we should believe every claim that comes along. Either, right? I I think we do have to have be somewhat analytical, if not downright skeptical at times, but for for personal experiences more than anything else, right? Yes. And I'm I I'm always very cautious. When I hear of a guy. Who's having visions every day, right at that point? At that point, I'm like, Ro, are we OK? Right. But and and you can always tell, right? Like, I remember I had a Bishop who was in Vietnam and he was in the Tet Offensive, right? And there was another guy in our ward who was always talking about his time in Nam, right?
1:34:49 And I remember once he told me. This Bishop told me he. Said, you know what he's like? I don't think he was at the places he said he was. And I'm like, I'm like, why is that? And he's like anybody who was in the Tet Offensive. We don't talk about it. And sure enough, it came came out later that the guy was like a clerk who never left, you know, whatever. But he was right. And and sometimes I look at spiritual experiences like that, right? Like the guys who are out there saying they have them all the time. I get a little skeptical about the ones I tend to believe are the ones that are told to me in private in a very solemn. Environment.
1:35:33 Those are the ones. That that tend to have the spirits, you know the have the spirit testify of truth of these things. So I I guess what I'm saying is, is that we should be in a position to where we shouldn't be surprised when. Those happens not necessarily. Seeking for them. But understand, it is definitely part of the gospel plan. Absolutely. You know, and I'll just say that. The most the period of my life where I had experiences the most frequently was nearest when I was serving a mission for the Church where according according to the light and knowledge, I then had the way that I was acting and being in complete constant service on the Lord's mission.
1:36:16 I was blessed highly of the Lord to receive personal revelation of the Adam, God doctrine of the general beginnings of the my understandings that things are not right where they're at and that where I need to be needs is going to be different. And pleading with the Lord myself. That when I got off my mission I would not lose the testimony I had. And that I would have the strength to do whatever it took to to cling to the Restoration. Because I saw people going back to the world all the time and I was very richly blessed. With with information and.
1:36:59 With a very strong testimony and that I can fall back on from those experiences which came from my own personal sacrifice and consecration, right. And that's so I that's just my testimony. I guess as we're bringing up this is if people want those things, it's going to be through sacrifice and. Consecration. Absolutely, Absolutely So we. Get into the interesting phase with Matthias. Cowley Now On April 13th, 1898, George Q Cannon authorizes Matthias Cowley to perform a plural marriage ceiling for Ben E Rich.
1:37:42 This is the first time that Matthias Cowley receives authority and a Commission to perform plural marriage, he later tells the other apostles when he's brought to trial many years later, President Cannon told me personally to attend to these matters. There was no laying on of hands, but he gave the authority personally. The Commission at this time was to marry Brother Rich, but I was later told by him that I could attend to suitable cases. Kelly. Performed the first of these marriages for Benny Rich. Who was President of the Southern States Mission And he later explained to the Formula 12 that I was never instructed to go to any foreign lands to perform these marriages, although in some cases I did do so. President Cannon told me to do these things or I never would have done it.
1:38:31 Most of them went to Brother Cannon and then came to me. Oh, OK. And so from 18. 98 From 19 O 4 to 19 O 4 When when the second Manifesto was given, We have documented about 40 or 45 plural marriages that Matthias Cowley did. Alone. Holy cow. Which basically is like 30% probably of all the ones that we're aware of that were done by members of the 12th that he single handedly took on himself. That man was busy. Holy you.
1:39:13 Have no idea. I have copies of marriage records from that time. Period. Because they would keep these marriage records in books, out of temple ceilings, books that later would get turned into the off church offices. And he was a busy dude. He was a busy busy busy guy. But I love what he said. There is that president Cannon told me to attend to these matters and that most of them would actually get a recommend from George Q Cann and then come to him. But that is all that. Only that would only apply till the time that George Q Cannon died in 19 O one. And then you have Joseph F Smith kind of taken over the the rains there, so to speak afterwards. September 13th, right after this, so that was April 13th, is when Matthias Kelly performed that first ceremony. By September 13th, Wilford Woodruff and Die and a new First Presidency was organized and Lorenzo Snow is now President of the Church.
1:40:25 And right after that, because of this Commission that Matthias Cowley gets from George Buchanan, Matthias Cowley went to President Lorenzo Snow and asked him about whether or not the authority was legitimate. And President Lorenzo Snow told Matthias Cowley that he did not want to be known in or interfere with Cowley's Commission from George Buchanan to perform new plural marriages. And so he either he completely endorsed it or was willing to turn a blind eye. In either case, at any case, this is the first time we can see don't ask, don't tell. Being implemented, yeah, in a far better way I would say, than that term is generally.
1:41:05 Used, But he said I will not interfere with President Cannon's work. Interesting. And George Q Cannon also dies before Lorenzo Snow. Dies. And if I remember correctly, so when Wolf and Woodruff dies new presidencies or set set apart, he goes to Lorenzo Snow asks is this legit still? And then George Q Cannon dies before Lorenzo Snow does, right and and then Matthias Cowley goes to Lorenzo Snow and says is this still fine that I keep doing this? And basically the same answer. Wow, wow.
1:41:48 So there it's it's a silent endorsement. From Lorenzo Snow, he's he would make strong statements. As well publicly that we're not doing. This anymore, but according to Matthias Cowley in private, that was not the case. According to Joseph Masser, he received a letter from Lorenzo Snow telling him you you've been selected to enter into the principal, and we see instances where Lorenzo Snow takes measures to make sure that local authorities are not cutting off people who are have been found.
1:42:30 And exposed to the. The lawful authorities that they've taken new wives or or entered into a polygamous situation. In fact, I think he told George Reynolds once in private that he admired the grit of any woman who was seeking to enter into the principal during these days. OK. All right. Yeah. Maybe not so. Silent, but no evidence. That he was involved with the. Performing of any of them. So gotcha. Yeah, so he was better doing. His job, in a way. Than Wilford Woodruff and Joseph F Smith were.
1:43:12 Because we have plenty of evidence from them now, at this time has the. Demographics of the quorum of the 12 changed it all. Is it still kind of 6/4 and then you know, no. The vast majority are for. Plural marriage still at this point. In fact, you can even if you give me a second. I can actually pull up who is who at this exact point in time. So we're dealing with 1898. And. Yeah, you have. President Lorenzo. Snow George Buchanan. And Joseph F Smith in the First Presidency? That is a slam dunk for approval all the way around. You have Franklin D Richards, still alive as president of the Quorum of the 12.
1:44:05 You know, from Joseph Smith's day, Brigham Young Junior Francis M Lyman is. 3rd and seniority in the quorum of the 12. And we've seen that up to this point, he is also in favor of plural marriages, right? John Henry Smith obviously carrying them out in Mexico. George Teasdale carrying them out in Mexico. Heber J. Grant being told to carry them out in Mexico by John Henry Smith, John W Taylor, Mariner Merrill, Anthony Schlund, Matthias Cowley, Abraham Owen Woodruff. There is not a single member of the First Presidency Reform of the 12 that is not that has not been involved or will not be involved in the future in post manifesto plural marriages. Interesting my case.
1:44:53 Point in, in, in. September of 1898. All right. Are there any excommunications going down at this point? No, not that I'm aware of, OK. So very much. Is, you know. We're going to keep this alive and we're just going to be really super quiet about it. Yep, Yep. In October of 1898, John W Taylor becomes one of the first people, or one of the few instances. I shouldn't say first, because I don't know when the first was. He becomes one of the very few instances publicly where he is not sustained unanimously in conference because he offended some. He offended the, the, I believe, basically what the time period's equivalent of the Mormon Tabernacle Choir was. And in a conference talk, he basically insinuated publicly that there was some immorality going on there and he told them to repent, you know, and they got really fired up and did not like him and and apparently the way it was. Said or.
1:46:09 Delivered wasn't maybe his best moment and he said later that I kind of put my foot in my mouth on that one, you know, And George Q Cannon got up after him and kind of played some damn, you know, damage control and well, brother Taylor's been very frank with us and so forth and so on, but maybe this shouldn't have been said in a public forum or something like that in any case. But he there was some opposition to his sustaining vote in that conference. I I'm sorry, I had a laugh. I just imagined John W walking by by President Cannon and President Cannon going thanks the SOB. Now I got to fix this right because because the other thing you.
1:46:51 Get and maybe not. So much during this time period, but definitely later on when when things become really hard for people wanting to practice plural marriage is that John W Taylor essentially becomes a pain in the ass to all those trying to subvert plural marriage. He he he's a he. This is not a guy you can paint in pastel colors, right? This guy's a firebrand. He's going to let it fly come hell or high water and and you get the sense that he become almost becomes a liability to the status quo later down the road he he does and it's yeah I mean the. Way that Samuel Wooley, his father-in-law put it to his family is John W Taylor was either born too early or too late, right.
1:47:43 You know, if he was, if he was born during the days. Of Joseph Smith he would have. Flourished. And maybe at some other future day there will be a time where he would have flourished. But he, yeah, he was basically destined to come into conflict with others of his peers. After conference October 25th, Apostle George Teasdale, you know, residents Apostle down in Mexico, marries his fifth wife and it is performed upon the high seas by Apostle Anthony H Lund on the high seas. On the high seas. On a ship? Yep. Wow. Well, it's going to be.
1:48:26 Hard to get busted out there. It's going to be hard to get busted out there. You can technically tell the. People, the government, that we were not married in the United States, all of that, and which is why it was done. And this is the first record I have of Anthony Schwund performing a plural marriage. But he was made aware of that being done earlier because Wilford Woodruff himself took a plural wife under the same circumstances a year earlier before he died. You know, it's really economical because you can. Go ahead and have your wedding at sea and then you go on a cruise for your honeymoon. I'm just saying there's there's there's some wisdom there.
1:49:09 Yeah, there sure is. Right around that time and John W Taylor and Nettie move back. You know, he's released from his mission in Colorado and so they go back to Farmington, UT. Going into the next year, Matthias Cowley marries his third wife, Harriet Benyon. So another relation to modern church hierarchy. You know in the Benyon Irene family when. When later asked, many years down the road. In his trial, who performed that marriage to his, you know, Cowley's marriage to his third wife? He said, quote, Brother Merrill put me under solemn covenant binding me not to tell I was married in the Logan Temple. So I leave you to guess the rest, which is a very much not veiled but jokingly failed way of saying Mariner Merrill married me in the Logan Temple because he was Temple President and he was he had been performing several. You know, the first one as we mentioned earlier was in June of 1894 and he's, he definitely had a record for sure, brother Merrill in performing polygamous ceilings in the Logan Temple during his lifetime.
1:50:34 I don't have an exact count, so don't. Ask, but there was a few. Of them he seems to be a stalwart, right? His name gets. Tossed around quite a bit, Yeah, no, he's one of my favorites, I think. In January of 1890. Nine in a meeting of. The 12th Apostle, Franklin D Richards, promises Owen Woodruff that all of God's promises to him will come to pass, knowing that Owen Woodruff had just received a new patriarchal blessing which stated that he would have plural wives, which he did not currently have. Interesting. April 25th, 1899.
1:51:15 Hebrew J Grant, says I. Think this is from his journal. Talk much on polygamy. And intimated that he would perform the ceremony in Mexico for any man who did not have any children, though he said that president would not consent to it referring. So what he was doing was he was talking. To this is. So funny. He was visiting the Mission field in California and talking to elders because back then. You didn't just send boys. Out to go. You know teach the gospel. And he's he's talking to married men presumably, who don't have children right now.
1:51:58 He's telling them I will go down and perform a ceiling in Mexico for you if you don't tell your mission president. That's awesome and. And and who? Who was that? Again saying he'd do that, John. W Taylor No, that was Hebrew J Grant, dude. See, Heber had so. Much. Promise, right? I mean, he and George Teasdale were called by revelation at the same time. To John Taylor, Yeah, had. So much potential. And then he. Screwed up the end. Game. Yeah, Kind of. Kind of. Sort of. The president of Rick's College. Now known as BYU.
1:52:41 Idaho at this time in May 1899, was sealed to his third wife by Apostle Matthias. Cowley after conferring. With Mariner W Merrill about it. So he arranged the whole deal. Apostle Merrill June 15th, 1899. Local 70s president of Davis County Jaren Pullman and his fourth married his fourth wife and it looks like I don't have an officiator written there, but remember the name Tolman? By the way, he's the.
1:53:22 Son of a very He's the son of a very important person later on. But I was also going to mention, and I forgot to mention because I skipped over it, I guess. So it disrupts the narrative I wanted to have earlier, but I'll go back and talk when in Mission Field in Colorado and when. Nettie was having. Her baby. They sent her sister Phoebe Woolley out to go take care of her while she was pregnant. Phoebe Woolley, who was living and taking care of her sister, becomes very important also later, in the same way almost that the Tolman name becomes important, which is what reminded me. Phoebe Woolley marries a return missionary later who served in the same mission at the same time as Joseph Musser. Interesting.
1:54:15 Yeah, we'll get to that July 11th. 1899 Apostle Mariner Merrill tells the. 12 At a quarterly meeting that the Manifesto is not a revelation from God, and that plural children will always be born in the Church from year to year for all time to come. Nice. Yeah. October 7th, 18. 99 President, Mission president Louis A Kelsch senior and second wife are married in Salt Lake by Matthias Kelly. OK, do you know who Louis Kelsh is? Oh yeah, he. Becomes he, becomes a major. Figure in fundamentalism down the road.
1:54:55 So you may be thinking of his son, Louis. Alma Kelsch junior, who becomes a member of Lauren Wooley's Council of Friends. But this is yeah, this is his father but he is very instrumental in the in the well. I don't know how instrumental but very supportive of the underground polygamous movement. Gotcha, very supportive. So I have a question for. You and and this is going to span. This entire. History here. Do we ever see any instances of anybody inside the church? Any member. Of the 12 or anything like that, arranging marriages like you should marry so and so, that's a good question.
1:55:43 I know in early early history, if you call Nauvoo and early Utah early history. I know I come from at least one of those marriages where Brigham Young arranged. I don't, I don't know how strongly it was arranged, but it was definitely different circumstances. But it did at least happen, at least in that one instance. And it probably happened in others, but it definitely, from what I've seen, doesn't seem to be a normal thing, right? I've encountered a few of. Them, but they seem to be more outliers than the norm. Is that kind of where you're you're seeing as well? Yeah, I don't. I don't see a ton of arranged. Marriages.
1:56:26 OK, right after this. In 1899, John. W Taylor ordains a man named John Anthony Wolf, a patriarch, a few years down the road. He gets commissioned by Joseph F Smith to perform plural marriages in Canada when John W Taylor's Pretty Much Not There. December 12th, 1899. Owen Woodruff. Performs the first plural marriage. Ceiling that I'm aware of for Alvin David Nelson and his second wife down in Colonia Oaxaca in Wara, Stake of Zion. And so it's so interesting to me, there's. A we're going to really get into. So I have some of Owen Woodruff's journal accounts and and entries and all this preface we're about to get into some of those so I'll just preface it first. But you know brought in as a young man 262728 whatever he was into a form of the 12.
1:57:25 He's a monogamist, and he's literally in a quorum filled with polygamist or pro polygamist people. But. And what else could you have expected? But yeah, he gets, he pretty much gets taken under the wing of John W Taylor and Matthias Cowley in particular. And as the tide starts changing, he is pretty loyal to them. The real tragedy is that he dies right after the second manifesto at a very young age. He was like 33 years old. Wow. Yeah, smallpox otherwise. The game could have been severely. Different to have a protege of John W Taylor and Matthias Calley in the form of the 12 after they got cut off. Oh yeah, would have been a big game changer. Or they would have just.
1:58:18 Text him too. Yeah, and he. Probably. And he could have gotten into that circumstance. Too, but he would have lived a lot longer than they did because he was, you know, half, he was half their age at this point. So yeah, he's he performs that ceremony in Mexico in December of 1899. Rodney Badger is a guy. That we're going to talk about later. During the Reed Smooth hearings, I believe that he is down. No, he doesn't go down to Mexico. He gets married in Salt Lake City to his third wife by Matthias Cowley. I believe he ends up being Reed Smooth's attorney, and if it wasn't him, it was his brother or someone else. But I'm pretty sure that was Rodney Badger becomes Reed Smooth's attorney or not. Not attorney clerk.
1:59:01 In any case, Matthias Cowley also performs a ceiling for him. Let's see during during a quarterly meeting in January. 1900 Mariner. Merrill says, Speaking of the principle of plural marriage, said it had to come to it had come to stay in one form or another, you know, That's what he had to say to them. So this guy's hammering him, you know, I don't know how he didn't get cut off because obviously there's some sort of cop, there's some sort of conversation going on because this is the third or fourth time in the last few years we're seeing him bring that up in meeting and this there will be children to the end, born in plural marriage to the end of days in the church.
1:59:49 Or this is coming and it's staying in one form or another, right? He's, he's, he's he's kind of giving him the business. That we're not backing down off this, right? And he never. Did he? Never. Did he died about nineteen O 7 or so. And we'll get, you know, seven years down the road right after that, John Brigham Young Junior tells. In fact, I think it's the same two days later, Two days later, from that meeting, Brigham Young Junior tells Owen Woodruff that the time that plural marriage will be restored. You know, Eric quotes and in that meeting.
2:00:32 Or after that meeting or on the same day of. That meeting after hearing Brother Mary or Merrill say what he had to say in hearing Apostle Brigham Young Junior tell him what was, You know what he said, he writes down in his journal I. Absolutely know that a number of the brethren. Among them, John W Taylor, George Teasdale, and Matthias F Calley entertained feelings in harmony with my own. I owe my existence to the principle of polygamy, and I have some intense feelings regarding the sustaining of that principle. I am indebted to that principle for my life, and anytime my father wants my life to defend that principle and those who practice it in righteousness, God being my helper, it is at his command.
2:01:21 Wow. Wow. Laying it down hard. So in that same meeting, that's when. President Lorenzo Snow had said in that meeting basically any person who disobeys. The law to polygamy. Or unlawful cohabitation. He must bear his own burden and stuff like you've been telling him. You know, you guys do not have my sanction to perform plural marriages at this point. And so that's what kind of gets the reaction out of Brother Meryl. That's what gets Brigham Young Junior to make that promise to Owen Woodruff.
2:02:06 And Owen Woodruff is confiding to his diary. You know that he knows. That there are some men who are stalwarts in the form that feel the same way that he does at this point. What What is your general feeling on Brigham? On Brigham Young Junior, is he all about this as well? Yeah, I think. I think the way he says. That to Owen Woodruff. That polygamy will be restored is interesting. And that's the narrative I always heard in my in my. But we've already seen from this episode that he took.
2:02:47 I think he's taken at least two wives, if not one. One for sure. I remember reading that to you, one if not two wives himself. And he's performed other ceilings down in Mexico visiting with George Teasdale and what have you. And he was very much in favor of of and he's in the loop. And like I said earlier, these things have. Become relatively. Compartmentalized where it's not like. The funny thing is we have evidence at this time showing that every member of the forum at that point was pretty much either endorsing, arranging, or performing post manifesto plural marriages, but that they were not aware that every single one of the others was also doing that.
2:03:31 Which would? There's probably wisdom there, right? Because if, if, if you don't know, you can't spill those beans. And so Brigham Young junior probably said the way that the way. He did to Owen Woodruff, who's now the youngest member of the Quorum, who, not knowing how much he knew regarding what was going on, if that makes sense, right? Yeah. Yeah, I'm just. I'm surprised that like. Brigham Young Junior doesn't get excommunicated When? When? John W. Does as well. He dies too, too soon. Oh. OK, that's why right at. The end of the century, like we're about to.
2:04:13 See the and we'll get to the next episode, but we're going to see a huge drop off in the popular support right now. Like like this is we're entering into that territory in the time frame where George Buchanan is about to die. Abraham Owen, Abraham Cannon had died just before this, but I didn't make notation of that. But he was a member of the Quorum who was supporting it. Lorenzo Snow is about to die. George Buchanan's about to die. Mariner Merrill dies in about 5-6 seven years. George Teasdale dies in about 5-6, seven years from this point. Owen Woodruff dies in four years from this point at the young age of 33 or something, And instead of it being a stacked deck of cards. In favor of.
2:05:04 Polygamy. You end up with a few guys like Joseph F Smith, Anthony H Lund, John W Taylor, Matthias Cowley and Rutgers Lawson, and they're the ones holding the line essentially. At that point pretty. Pretty much at that point, yeah. But authority then begins to be dispersed. To other individuals in other forums, like high priest forums or patriarchs in this at the state level, and it's more distributed at that point and we'll get into that later. Do you have any other questions or commentary or rude remarks? No, no, no, I'm.
2:05:45 I'm keeping the rest of my rude. Remarks for later. So I was. I had a mission companion who always say that at the end of the. Lesson. Any questions? Concerns, rude remarks. That's right, right. No, you gotta spread those. Out. You can't use them all in one shot. So. You you gotta have them equally distributed throughout this series here. All right, Well, dude, that was good stuff. Anything you wanna go over for this episode more than what we covered? I don't know. I think we can start back with another one and we'll go into a more. Detailed account of those meetings being held at the turn of the the 20th century from Owen Woodruff's journals. Yeah, in gold. Go over that Tolman name. Yeah, we're going to get into that very soon. And like I said, we're.
2:06:33 We're now. We're basically where we've approached the end nearly of where the 12 are pretty much in harmony over the principle existing secretly. And we will begin to see contention and division as people are replaced and that and or die and are replaced and as the politics become more increasingly complex again. Yeah. And and I think this is this next episode, Will. Be where where we get to see John John W Taylor really begin to start coming into his own right, because he is gonna stand out and become more pronounced over the next little while. But dude, good stuff.
2:07:18 Can't wait for next time? Sure. Awesome. All right. Bye everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox