Jan. 6, 2024

Episode #109: The Making of Ervil LaBaron W/DeWayne Hafen author of Gods Executioner The Tragedy Of Ervil LeBaron

Episode #109: The Making of Ervil LaBaron W/DeWayne Hafen author of Gods Executioner The Tragedy Of Ervil LeBaron
Episode #109: The Making of Ervil LaBaron W/DeWayne Hafen author of Gods Executioner The Tragedy Of Ervil LeBaron
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #109: The Making of Ervil LaBaron W/DeWayne Hafen author of Gods Executioner The Tragedy Of Ervil LeBaron

Go To http://patreon.com/MormonRenegade368 For Exclusive Content

This week Hulu dropped a new documentary about Ervil LeBaron. I think over all the documentary was pretty well done. However, it was produced in a way that would appeal to a very large audience and had to be told in a way that would make sense to a largely non-mormon audience. I had other questions about this story. Mainly what was happening inside the Joel LeBaron’s Church of The First Born that set the table for Ervils insanity. Fortunately for me DeWayne Hafen has just published a book on the subject. DeWayne was a member of that church and got to see firsthand how things went off the rails. In this episode DeWayne and I talk about the LeBaron family, How Joel established the Church of the First Born in Mexico, what Ervils role in that church was, and the surrounding tensions that ultimately led to Ervil ordering the deaths of many people. My hope is that by examining all of these topics we as Mormons can take away some lessons and be on guard so nothing like this ever again happens in Mormonism.

--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support

0:00 This week Hulu dropped a new documentary about Ervil Lebaron. I think overall the documentary was pretty well done. However, it was produced in a way that would appeal to a very large audience and had to be told in a way that would make sense to a largely non Mormon audience. I had other questions about this story however, mainly what was happening inside Joel Lebaron's Church of the First Born that set the table for Ervil's insanity. Fortunately for me, Dwayne Hafon has just published a book on this subject. Dwayne was a member of that church and got to see first hand how things went off the rails. In this episode, Dwayne and I talk about the Lebaron family called Joel established the Church of the First Born down in Mexico, what Ervil's role in that church was, and the surrounding tensions that ultimately led to Ervil ordering the deaths of many people. My hope is, is that by examining all of these topics, we as Mormons can take away some lessons and be on guard. So nothing like this ever happens again inside Mormonism. That's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast. So you've decided you want to make a podcast. That's great.

1:08 It's exciting stuff, but it can also feel overwhelming. But good news for you? Spotify's got you covered. Spotify's got a platform that lets you make a podcast really easily and then distribute it everywhere and even earn money. It's all in one place, and best of all, it's for free. It's called Spotify for podcasters, and here's how it works. Spotify for podcasters lets you record and edit podcast right from your phone or computer. So no matter where you're at or what your setup is like, you can start creating today. Then you can distribute your podcast to Spotify and everywhere else podcasts are heard. They have options for video podcasts as well. Now, if you want to take your podcast to the next level, you can have conversations with your fans with Q&A polls, which are the best way to get them talking to you and to each other with Spotify.

1:57 For podcasters, you can earn money in a variety of ways, including ads and podcast subscriptions. And best of all, it's totally free. No catch. Ever since I discovered Spotify for podcasters and I've been hosting on Spotify, I feel like that I get great audio quality and have all those features that are right at my fingertips. It allows me to take the podcast to the next level, download the Spotify for Podcasters apps or go to www.spotify.com back slash podcasters to get started today. Look, it's no secret that our society has become much more crude and coarse. To become and raise men and women of virtue and character is a herculean task.

2:38 To help with this I've recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior and Company and Conversation. It was a book with 110 rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society, something that today's society is sorely lacking. What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So the book is laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule. Right below that is my explanation for the 21st century, and below that you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, to go along with this, there's a workbook that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids.

3:24 To find the book, go to mormonrenegade.com, go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post, and order your copy. Today I can bear personal testimony from personal experience that this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Hey, Duane.

4:21 How are you? I'm good. How are you? Well, I'm not at home. I'm in my daughter in But. I'll bet your weather, I'll bet you your weather's a lot better than my weather right now. But anyway, it's good to talk to you again. You too. You too, you. I'll bet you your weather up there is a lot better than mine is. Maybe the sun? The sunny and beautiful and I'm up here in the cold and the and the and the inversion so. Hey, I went swimming yesterday.

5:05 OK, that's enough. We don't need to go there and I. Thought the water would be cold and disappointed, it was a little too. Warm thanks Dwayne, I appreciate that. Way to make me feel worse about my situation here, so. All right. And there's chill. There's children here. I hope they don't cause a problem. No, no, it'll be fine. It'll be just fine, Dwayne. So OK, when and as we all know there's a Hulu special coming out about Ervil Lebaron and about what happened there as far as his target assassinations and whatnot. I want to 1st get the back story on who Ervil was.

5:47 I I want to start with what his upbringing was like, how he he came of age, and then move into kind of what his, his, his religious life was like. Does that make sense? Yeah, I think so. Perfect. So what kind of home did Ervil grow up in? Was it a good home? Was it troubled? It was probably typical of the time he was raised Mormon, LDS, Mormon. He actually went on a mission for the LDS Church when he was young. Yeah, his two older brothers both went on missions for the eldest church. But Ervil was born and mostly raised in Mexico and Chihuahua, Mexico in a place called Colonia Dublan, which is a Mormon colony and of course it living in the Mormon colony. He went to the Wardens Academy, which was a Mormon run school. Right.

6:58 Wow. Go ahead. No, no. I was just saying saying wow. One of the interesting things that's worth knowing is he wasn't supposed to be able to go on a mission at his age. He was under age and his brother went, and he was so upset that his brother was going without him that they managed to get him a special appointment with the future president of the Church, the chief apostle at the time at the head of the apostles, and got special permission. Really. So they had. They had contact with the leaders of the church. So, so they weren't just kind of your run-of-the-mill membership, They were able to have have interactions with the higher ups of the LDS Church?

7:51 That's what I'm trying to tell you. Wow. Benjin F Johnson was the grandparents, and he was a special person in the church, and the father was also a very special person in the church. So you know, it wasn't such a strange thing that they would have contact with the higher ups in the church, but they did. Wow, so was it was was Ervil's dad practicing the principal at this time or anything like that? Well, Ervil's dad decided he wanted to leave plural marriage a number of years before, and he had managed to get a copy of the 1858 Taylor revelation, which said, hey, use your own brain, use your own judgement, and do what you want to do about plural marriage.

8:52 But it's still the law. It's still what you're supposed to do. And so he did. He got himself a wife, got himself married to her, and immediately moved to Mexico because of the fear of being arrested. Wow. So was it. Again, being a noted name in the church, it wasn't a good thing to be a polygamist. Sure, Sure was. So was was is Alma Dyer Ervil's dad? Or is that Joel? I I'm sorry. Yes. Alma deyer lebaron, OK? So was Alma Deyer?

9:35 Yeah. Was he practicing plural marriage while his boys were on a mission? Yes, yes, they both. Both he and Dad's two wives had been excommunicated long before that. Well, long being like about 1010 years, OK, but or maybe more. And the one wife had deserted the family. It was down to just the mother and the whose name was Maude. It was Maude and Taylor and the children. OK, all right. So he wasn't living plural marriage, though during the time that his son was on a mission.

10:17 He the father? Well, he wanted to, OK? Gotcha. Gotcha. OK, So what was it like growing up in Alma Dyer, Lebaron's home? What was what was Alma like as a father? His father, his father was a very strict disciplinarian, I mean fanatically so. And a lot of people in that time were hard, hard. A hard pioneer life called for some pretty tough parents. But the father was extremely, very, very, very disciplined, very strong disciplinarian.

11:01 My mother, when she was 8 years old, happened to live next door to them in Dublin, Mexico for a while and she had. She said that she would never die, or very well, the meanest son of a bitch she ever met in their life, according to her. Holy cow, that's a that's a pretty that's a pretty harsh indictment. Do do you get the feeling that that Dyer Lebaron was was abusive at all or was he just strict? I don't know, I can't say. But I can say that the other thing that you have to not forget or miss here is his mother.

11:46 And I loved his mother, by the way. She was a terribly nice woman to me. But his mother had aspirations or desires for her children. You are going to be the best. You're going to excel. You're going to be somebody. All of the girls competed in piano and one they would consistently have to win and be the best piano player in the whole area. The boys, I mean the oldest son was named Benjamin Lebaron and Ben Lebaron was very athletic, very competitive.

12:29 He ended up being the school, the high school president, his last year of high school in the what is Academy. Very competitive, these people. But Mama pushed them. I can't leave that part out. Mama expected, very, very expected them to sell all of them. You are expected to do well. You're expected to be better than those around you. Was this, do you think that this was a a healthy push because look, I I'm a big believer in sometimes our kids don't don't meet expectations because we as parents don't set them. Was this in, in your opinion, was was his was Ervil's mother, was it a healthy push or was this kind of maybe over the top? Oh, she was a terribly loving person. She just you can you can push without pushing, right? Right.

13:35 So this this. Was maybe a little bit over I. I love you. I expect you to be the best. OK. All right. So it sounds. Like disappoint me. Sure, sure. So it sounds like Ervil was raised in almost kind of a pressure cooker. For for lack of a better word, you had a a very strict disciplinarian, disciplinarian of a father who by your your own mother's account said he was the meanest SOB she'd ever met. And then you have a mother who although is very loving, kind of drives her children, so to speak, really pushes them to A to excel. So we can kind of get this feel for, based off of what you said there, that that maybe he's raised in a pressure cooker kind of a situation.

14:23 Would that be a fair assessment? He was. She just plain expected them to excel among among some of us, we say the Lebarons have an attitude that they were born to rule, and that's probably just because of the way they were raised. They expected to be #1. I got you. I got you. OK, so where does Ervil end up serving his mission at? In the South part of Mexico, in the in the Deep South of Mexico, Puebla in those areas, Puebla and the poor parts of the state of Mexico, Ozumba places where they had a lot of the Mayan people actual. OK, what?

15:20 What was it? A successful mission in terms of baptisms. Yeah, it was. They were good missionaries. He served with his brother. He served with his brother Joel. He joined his brother. And you got two blonde, big, tall, blonde American boys who speak fluent Spanish. So they were impressive and they had learned how to preach. And they had, following their brother, Alma the older, the Alma Junior, Alma Dale Lebaron Junior had just finished a mission in the same area.

16:01 So these boys kind of, oh heck, there's another one. And they knew how to preach. They knew how to talk. They had been trained to be in front of people. That's why I'm talking about the influence of the mother. You can stand up, you can talk, you can preach, you can do anything. Gotcha. Gotcha. So at this time, Herbal still, even though he's on an LDS mission, he's probably still, for the most part, understanding of of what we classify as as Mormon fundamentalist principles, right? His dad was a polygamist. When they went on their Mormon mission, I think they believed in the Mormon Church.

16:48 Even Alma, when he went, wasn't too happy with the fact that his father was a polygamist. But after he had been there and on his mission and he managed to read a bit, the older brother Almond said, hey, you know what, Maybe dad's right. He got to see some situation, he says. You know, my father's right. And then he came home. And in the meantime, Joel and Ervil are on the same in the same missionary he was. And they're doing a good job. They're sending home good reports of how good they're doing in the nation. I'm sure they believed in what they were doing, but Alma decided to start to preach for a marriage and a couple other things and he got in trouble.

17:37 So he had a disciplinary council called. So what he do? He got hold of his brothers, sent a sent a telegram or however he's they communicated. This is about 1945 or 6 or somewhere around there. No, no earlier than that. The war was ordered 45 anyway, about 1943 and 44. I don't know. And somehow he got word to them. Hey, I need you to come home and help me. So they immediately abandoned their mission. They didn't bother to say goodbye or we got an emergency or nothing else. They just went home and all three of them ended up getting excommunicated. Whole they got excommunicated because they left their mission early.

18:26 Because they abandoned their mission without permission and went to defend their brothers. OK. All right. I got you. I got you. So they get home from their mission. How long was it was was Ervil out on his mission? Exactly. I'm sorry, try that again. How long was Ervil out on his mission? Oh, they were probably there a couple of years, I'm not sure. This was probably back in the time of like 3 year missions, right? Yeah. Or maybe they were a year. OK, I'm not sure of the time. OK. But they were definitely doing a good job up until that. Point. All right. So when they get back home, what happens next?

19:08 They get excommunicated. Where does their faith journey take them from this point? OK. The interesting thing is we're in World War 2 still. It's getting close to the end, but there's still World War 2. And when they were on a mission, they apparently had some sort of an exception, a draft exemption. But immediately after they came home that excommunicated Alma and Joel get a draft call. You got a report for service and they both said no.

19:48 Is this through the Is this through the Mexican government or the American government? No, they were. There's a difference here. Alma and Joel were born in the United States. Ervil was born in Mexico. OK. All right, so. So Ervil Herbal was a Mexican citizen and an American citizen, OK, but Joel and Alma were only American citizens. Gotcha. Gotcha. OK, that makes. Sense they had no rights in Mexico. I gotcha. And that's an important thing. OK.

20:29 All right. So they they get back, they they all say no, they're not going on there into the service either. How? How did they manage to get that without serving time 'cause this is a time when they? Were both arrested and their time. OK, they they claim conscience and objectors. They use the Doctrine Covenants where it says that you don't go to war unless you've done certain things and claim to be conscientious objectors. They both went to jail for a period of time. Fortunately, the work was over pretty soon and they went home OK all.

21:12 Right. In the meantime, in the meantime, the older brother Ben, who had had some serious problems, came home. He took his family and went to Mexico and some followers he had decided he was the one minding and straw and he had some followers. He was he was still he he was already certified crazy. OK, and that's another story, but excuse me, he he had gone to Mexico, he had some followers, and Ervil became one of his followers. OK.

22:00 And then when Alma came home, he became one of his followers and they were both working with their brother Ben. Joel came home, begged for forgiveness and got re baptized into the church, the LDS church, and went to do his own thing. He was making a living by purchasing corn and other commodities in the mountains and selling it to the people around in Chihuahua that were raised in animals and stuff. So they kind of went up their own their separate ways.

22:44 Gotcha. But Ervil and Alma became a couple of apostles for their brother Ben, who had visions of being the one mighty and strong that was going to set the church in order. Interesting. And some of the things that Ben did were really, really bizarre. I don't know how else to call it bizarre. Strange. Bizarre How? What do you mean by by bizarre? Well, he had apostles. Alma Junior was his right apostle. Ervil was his left apostle. And they had to always sit on that side of him at the dinner table or wherever.

23:32 And then he had a cousin named Owen Lebaron, who was his number 2 apostle. And you know, he was #1, This guy was #2, and he could sit anywhere he wanted. Even on Ben's lap, that is his Ben was very, very, very domineering. He had to have his meals just a certain way. He had to have his clothes just a certain way. And his apostles were expected to wait on him and wouldn't eat until he was true. You know, it was he was really abusive.

24:12 And the women that were around were abused even more. Oh. Man. OK, so answer me this, we know that Ben has some medical, I mean some some mental issues, right? That's that's beyond debate. He, if I'm not mistaken, he was the one that was like out in State Street, in the middle of State Street in Salt Lake doing push ups, right. Yeah, yeah, he's the one that Dan Lebaron went on the corner there and stopped traffic so he could prove that he was the one minding strong by doing I don't know how many push ups there in the intersection. And when they come to take him away, he challenged the policeman to Hey, let's see if you can do it. Gotcha.

24:54 Gotcha. He. Was pretty wild. So why would Look if if he's certifiably crazy, why does Ervil and and his brother? When they joined, they didn't know he was crazy, OK? He was their older brother. They loved their older brother. Their older brother had always been their idol when they were growing up. Their father. If he was gone, then her older brother was a de facto disciplinarian. Her father. What do we want to call it? Got you. Was was this did? Did mental illness run in the family or is this kind of a A1 off thing?

25:39 I'm sorry, what was that? Was was this mental illness? Did this run in the family or was this kind of a one off incident? That is the worst piece of propaganda that anybody ever put out. I've had some crazy people in my family. I bet you have two. Now if I put, if I decided I was the one mighty and stronger, the one man on the earth at the time, you might just go find some of those people say, hey, crazy runs in the family. Gotcha. Gotcha. OK, so this seems to be isolated. But let me tell you about Ben. Let's back up and talk about Ben for a minute. Ben had been the class president.

26:23 He had good grades, and we're talking about during the Depression. He went out to the United States. He gets himself into college. She's going to college. He has his own car now. This is where cars are just being slightly available. He owns his own car. Yeah, he's making his own living. He's selling full of brush and he's doing and he's in college and he's getting ready to get married. His life is a really going good. He had lots of expectations, He was his mother and his father's pride and joy. They were so proud of him.

27:05 But his mother apparently had a fuss with the father one time and sent a message to Ben that his father, his father, was abusing her. Think that's what Ben did. He dropped everything, ran home to confront his father, and after he gets there and raises heck with his father, he comes back and turns around and he goes in the house and his Mama sitting on daddy's lap and they're very, very loving. And he says, what is going on? Well, don't you know that I adore your father? We we love each other. OK? So he returns to the States to go to school, but he's got to try to pick up his job and his girlfriend he had he was engaged to be married, but she just, you know, the bird that when the cat cats away them to the mice play or whatever, she she found somebody else and got herself married. So here's Ben.

28:12 He's disappointed with his father and his mother. He feels like they made a fool of him. His girlfriend has found somebody else, and all of his expectations, all of his desires, all the things that he had hoped that would happen, they weren't going to happen and it broke him. Now if they have a propensity for something, it's a propensity to have high expectations which which whether or not realized, they can't handle it. That's one of the dangers of having unattainable goals and expectations. You might, you have to be willing to say, hey, I guess I can't do that right And apparently that's a difficult that was a difficulty gotcha, gotcha. And but still Ben had had push with Ervil and with with his other brothers.

29:23 He he was still the oldest son. He was still the one that they all looked up to. Are you the oldest in your family? I am do. You have younger brothers and sisters that look up to you. Not so much anymore. We my, my family is kind of a mess, so. Well, yeah, but you understand what I'm saying. Right, I do. I'm an old son, OK? And until I got out of the church, I had a lot of influence in my family. Right. When I was excommunicated back in 1964, three, whatever it was, I lost a lot of that influence.

30:08 Gotcha, gotcha. In my own family. OK, so Ben comes home, well, goes back to the States, starts this church, and then decides to go back to Mexico. Is that correct? Yes. So he brings a couple of his followers and begins to set up a deal in the in Chihuahua. The father hadn't. They had a place, some place in the mountains, I don't know where, and they decide they would go there and start to live whatever it was they were going to live. Set up, set the church in order. Servo is immediately put to work translating and publishing information for Ben and his second in command, Owen Lebaron. And if they're publishing pretty good stuff because they're steaming it all for the fundamentalist movement, In other words, they're they're reading stuff that was written by Muster and broadband and other people. Oh, that sounds good.

31:16 We'll just reword it a little bit. And now we're going to going to send this out to the world. So Earl was doing that in Spanish. He was translating and publishing, and one of the followers, A fellow by name of Joseph Morrison, had managed to get a printing press, which became Earl's toy. So he was translating and publishing, publishing, spending every dime he could get on doing the work of the Lord. He was happy that he was doing what he felt he should be doing, and his mother was happy with him.

31:58 His father was happy with him. All right. So so this is a time where where Herbal's invested in this new fundamentalist movement with with his brother Ben and his his his other brother, and things seem to be going well, right? He's like you said, he's spending a lot of money on printing this stuff. My question is, is on that stuff that you said they were taken from Musser and whatnot and then just changing it, were they crediting Musser and those other guys or were they saying it was their own work? I'd be kidding. Of course not. OK. All right. And this was straight from God, OK?

32:41 OK. All right. So they were. But they were leaning heavily on fundamentalist literature. OK. All right. But no, they the idea that you do attribution, that you show where you get all this stuff that wasn't very famous in the 40s because I knew it was it wasn't something that people did. You could you could quote the everything and oh, you're so smart. What do you mean you got it for Shakespeare. I thought you made it up, you know? OK, all right. It just wasn't wasn't done. Gotcha.

33:22 Gotcha. Well, it looked like it was theirs. They were publishing it as it was theirs. Plus Ben was throwing in his own little 2 bits worth. That's say it's a large you do this or you do that. What was the set up there in in Ben's movement or Yeah, I can hear you. Can you hear me? Yes. What? What was the set up there in Ben's church like? Did did everything flow through Ben and including marriages, including, you know, everything? Nobody was getting married particularly. OK then had full control of everything, especially any woman that was associated with them. And some of the women says OK.

34:09 I said if he said goodbye and they laughed. Joseph Morrison's wife and took her kids, her girls and left and left the son behind. A guy by the name of Nephi Morrison got to stay, but she and the girls got the heck out of there in a hurry. Ben's wife had some serious problems and eventually got away. Owen, Laban's wife, had some serious problems and eventually got away. It was very, very abusive. OK. All right. So as as. Of course, Ervil and Alma both learned from that experience. OK.

34:58 All right, Alma Baron Junior became a very abusive person as well. All right, that's too bad. What? What was the father's role in this church? Alma Senior. Senior. Yeah. He was just watching. He was, he wasn't excited about it. He was in colonial, Colonial Juarez doing his thing. They had, look, colonial Baron didn't exist quite yet. OK, so all right, we're just starting. But he was busy doing what he needed to do. He was trying to make a living again. You've got a just coming out of the out of the depression type situation and people had to make a living any way they could And he he had to work.

35:55 He had to work at getting to make a living. He did a lot of things. He wasn't always home. He had he he had Ben and his group in a different location like they had a couple of ranches. He was in some property in the mountains and colonial Baron was just starting to come together. Eventually Ben moved to Colonial Baron, but for a while he wasn't there OK. OK, so so Alma senior's not involved in this church whatsoever or anything. No, no. No, Not really, No. OK, so after.

36:36 OK, so this goes along for a while. What ends up happening to Ben? Well, Ben, of course. Eventually he gets committed to the insane asylum his follower Owen gets committed. Oren was a Canadian citizen and he was basically expelled from Mexico. He couldn't go back. Oh. OK, but Ben did on occasion. But he spent a long time in Provo at at at the Utah whatever they call it. Insane asylum I guess in Provo UT OK and he eventually gets got out. I met Ben years later and I actually liked Ben. He was a likable person.

37:29 He wasn't being abusive at that time. He didn't have a wife. He was just him and he would talk and a lot of things he said made sense. I like Ben, OK? Don't misunderstand me about Ben. But by then he wasn't out question that he was the one, mighty and strong, although I think he still thought he was, but he was considerably came down by the time I met him. Gotcha. Gotcha. Man's the one that told me. Dwayne, you know what's the best thing about being crazy? No, I don't know, man. What's wrong? What's the best thing you can say? Anything you want to. You can even tell the truth.

38:14 Yeah. So. And and you know what? There's a lot of wisdom in that. Sure, sure. So what ends up happening to this church that Ben starts when he gets committed? It's done. But about that time they get involved with the Allreds. The Allreds were had just gotten, someone had just gotten out of jail and they were thinking that they might have to move to Mexico or somewhere because they might go back to jail. So some of the Allreds went to Mexico, actually build a couple of houses and became very associated with the Le Barons, and so Alma and and Ervil both became part of the already faction. Ervil and.

39:20 Owen and so Joe. So Ervil's loyalty moved from doing stuff for band to doing stuff for Joseph White Musser and Reuben Allred and Margarito Batista. OK. Yeah, Margarita Batista, we haven't talked about. No. Margarita Batista was the fellow that started a united order poor marriage thing in a Texaco. OK, what was he like? And Margarito had a very, very rigid control over those people.

40:09 And of course, Ervil and Alma and Joel had all met Margarito while they were on missions down there. Interesting. And I don't know whether they with Margarito before they with the outrage or was it all happened at once. I kind of suspect they were with. Margarito first. OK. So in your estimation they went with with Batista and then ended up kind of hooking up with the all Reds and musser and and that. Sort of right and started buying into the the woolly story. OK. You know, right, but not really.

40:52 Margarita Bautista became a member of of Joseph Musser's council, but he never bought into the woolly story. He believed that because he was a Lamanite, he had a birthright reason to hold the priesthood and he'd been ordained an elder way back when, and that's all he needed. But when ruling all red and Joseph, Mustard showed up in Ozumba and they ordained him and made him an apostle and give him some additional authority. Yeah, that's OK.

41:34 He'd take it. He didn't need it, but he took it and he had a lot of influence on the Labarins Mr. Matisse did. When you say, when you say, when you say influence, what kind of influence Are we talking doctrinal influence are we talking influence of in terms of money and success? What? What kind of oh. From from Margarito, yeah. No, Margarito didn't have no money, OK? Nobody had any money. Everybody was poor. But Margarito had some interesting doctrines or policies to begin with.

42:18 If you're going to live there. He had a small united order, and you had to agree that you wanted to join the United order and you had to agree to practice plural marriage to join it. But if you joined it, you had to 1st find yourself a plural wife someplace else. OK? After you already had a plural wife, then you could maybe, if you, if you proved yourself worthy, have a chance at some of the girls within his organization. OK. And he held the key to that.

43:02 And nobody could get married without his permission. He had to decide if they were worthy or not. And he was also extremely abusive of women. All of these people seem to be abusive of women. Women are to be abused. Why do you think this is? Why? Why? Because because I'm seeing a a a thread here, right? Ben's abusive to his women that gets passed on to Ervil and and his brother Batista seems to be very abusive. What? What is causing this? Keep them in line. You and I grew up in a world where women had some value, right?

43:49 There was a long time that women couldn't vote, so he couldn't hold property. They interesting, but women? Women had no value to speak of. So after after Ervil and and his brother kind of hook up with Batista and and ruling Allred, what happens next? Well, they were. They started the United orders in colonial Lebaron. Under the nominal leadership of Musser and Margarita Batista, the Allreds made an attempt to build some houses and stuff there. Then they found they didn't really need to get out of the United States and they were doing as best they could. Joel Lebaron, in the meantime, was doing his own thing. But then a, a couple of things happened in 1955, more or less, they realized that they needed some capital to do some things they wanted to do.

45:13 So 3 little bears were going to go north and approach the Allred group about alone or some some way of helping him out financially and Joel decided to go with him. Now, Joel had been kind of aside, he hadn't been really part of the all of these things. But about that time, the Mexican government put a freeze on the sale of corn and other commodities and Joel went broke. Gotcha. So he joined up with them in this United Order effort.

45:56 And so the four of them went N for them. How many? Let me count again. No, I guess it was Joel and Flora and Vernon. Three of them went N excuse me? And so three of them went N to approach the Allreds. He already said no, so Berlin returned home. He had things he had to do in Mexico. He was trying to form and do some stuff and had a couple wives by. They had three by then, so he had to go home. But Joel and Florin stayed with their brother in Salt Lake City.

46:38 That's Ross Lebaron, Ross Wesley, Lebaron, senior, senior. Let's make sure we say senior. Junior had a completely different story. OK, but they went with their brother. Their brother was wanting to start a church. A Church of the First Born. This was Joel, you said. And they talked and they talked and they, OK, let's do it. And it was definitely going to be a church along patriarchal lines. It was going to be ruled over by the presiding patriarch, who was, of course, Wesley, the older one, and Joel and four, and we're going to be there with him.

47:24 But it was going to be along the lines that Ross Wesley wanted to do it. But remember I said Le Bears were destined to rule. Yeah. They thought they, they they know more than got the thing going. Then Joel decided he wasn't happy with it, so he went to Farmington, UT up Farmington Canyon. You live up there? You are Farmington Canyon, yes? I know where it's at, Yep. Yeah, well, it's kind of a steep walk up there, if I remember right. And you get up there, you're up in the clouds. It's pretty nice place.

48:06 Well, he went up there to pray and get some direction. He was there for a little while and he, he had a whole lot of heavenly visitors and he came back down rather quickly with a whole lot of answers. He showed up at Carl Jensen's place that used to be in the mouth of Farmington Canyon and they call in floor and come and picked him up, took him back to Salt Lake. But that was the end of the association with Ross. Wesley Joel had to go do his own thing. Now what Joel had in mind was to reorganize the church along the pattern that Joseph Smith had used. So Joel, Joel wants to to to kind of reorganize the church to something, right?

49:02 Right. He feels is more historically accurate to Joseph Smith. So he, he starts down that path. How does Ervil get involved with that? Well, Ervil loved his brother. He was probably the first or second convert when he went back to Mexico. OK. And he baptized his mother, and he baptized Ervil. And Alma came along, and some of the others. Pretty soon he had most of the brothers, except Berlin. Berlin didn't really. He was still happy being a run-of-the-mill fundamentalist.

49:43 Sure. But they set up a church, and Ervil was the brains of the operation. OK, a lot of of the stuff that Joel took took credit for was actually done by Ervil. He's the writer. He's the translator. He's the author of what they consider their greatest document preached, expounded, the one that convinced the French missionary to join the church, the first board. He's the author, along with the guy by the name of Noel Pratt, of the 60 questions that the Mormons couldn't answer that Joel took credit for.

50:27 And Joel and Earl's a good, good follower, a good he. He's perfectly willing today, and his brother take credit for everything. And that's what he did. OK, got you take credit for everything. And people began to join. Some of those ideas were pretty strong. Let's let's talk about another point real quick before it gets out of here. I joined the Church of the first born in 1960, three, 64 in that area. But you know why I was able to be converted? I was completely convinced that the Jesus Church of Jesus Christ, the letter Saints, had gone S they had lost it. They didn't know what they were doing, and they had tried to make me do things that I knew were wrong. So when they had church, the first one may strange come along, hey, they're doing what God said to do. And they gave me hope, hope of finding the true Church of God. And I don't think anybody has ever been converted based on somebody's pushing them if they hadn't already decided that there was something wrong with what they had. Right, So it's.

51:44 Hope, hope that converts people. Well, Irvo was able to get some a somewhat logical approach that people could say see it and say, oh, there's some hope, some hope there to live. The church that I believe in to worship God because the Mormon church is gone. They're they're over the hill. Forget them. They're going, they're going straight. They're going to become a mainline Protestant church next week. I think they already have. But anyway, all of that hope is what converted people to be part of the church, the first part, the fullest of times. And there was a lot of them.

52:31 There was intelligent people. There was a whole bunch of French missions became converted. They almost destroyed the French missions. I've heard that, yeah. Bill Tucker was a very smart man and he had some influence. Can't get enough of the Mormon Renegade podcast? Well, good news, we're on Patreon and there's three packages that you can choose from. The first one, the Slightly rowdy package, allows you to hear the podcast without all those pesky commercials getting in the way. For those who want a slightly more in depth experience, there's the Stirring It Up package where you can hear ad free audio, AD free video and transcripts.

53:12 Finally, for those who want to go full Renegade, that package is available too, where you can get everything in the previous two packages plus an extra show where myself and Ben Winfield breakdown the news of the day from a very Mormon point of view. You will also get exclusive access to Renegade chat and on there you'll be able to talk to others about the show or whatever topics are on your mind. Go to Patreon today and get your exclusive content. But the thing that they came for was the hope that they found when they heard about priesthood expounded. I I personally think priests expounded is a piece of crap. But that's just me, right?

53:54 I I see errors in it. I see plagiarism. I see a lot of stuff in it. But to a lot of people, hey, here's somebody who's got some answers and she wins. They're living love. They're living the plural marriage. They're living love consecration. They're, they're practicing adoption. And the Mormon churches give all that stuff up. There's some hope here. And they and they can use their scriptures. One of the interesting things I learned early on with that church is, well, we just handed out a document here, and you're going to come out and then talk to me about it.

54:36 OK Well, fine. That's great. Do you have your scriptures with you? Oh, yeah. Let me borrow. Oh, thank you. Open it up. Would you read that for me? Oh, fine. What does that mean? Every time it was something that couldn't be fed and whoops, well, I'm going to go in and get somebody to know that'll take you on. And the guys are familiar with Badger testimony, and they were gone. Gotcha. It was and and people watching that say, hey, these guys have got it. These guys have got it. They really have the spirit of God.

55:17 And the church elders, all these scriptorians, have to go away with the tail between their legs. That's impressive. So if you're if you're unhappy at the church to begin with, and you have to be a little bit, you wouldn't even listen to it. You might just be convinced. Right. You might not make the jump because it's a big leap. It's a big leap for me. I was associated with for quite a while before I actually joined. Right. I mean, my parents and grandparents, my grandparents all were in the church forever. They're all people that had who were in some of the history books.

56:02 Nah, it was. I'm not going to leave all that behind for a bunch of crazy people. I was convinced that what they were doing was the same thing that I had already been taught to believe. They offered me hope to return to that religion. Right. And Ervil was the man in charge of disseminating all that hope. Because he was the head missionary. He was in charge of the initially just the Southern Mexico mission and then the whole mission. And eventually he received.

56:42 He got this number two position in Joel's church. Joel had offered it to Ludenard, Luna said. No, thank you. He had offered it to. Margaret. H Batista. And he said no thank you. And so after a while, Ervil rose to be the number two guy. And the churches going places, they're converting all kinds of people. Catholic priests, they had dignitaries from different things, two or three bishops from the Mormon church, people from other countries, people from the that work in the state Department of the United States. They had some pretty heavyweight people converting. And Ervil is the intellectual head of this. But Joel's taking all the credit. And Joel's the heart of it.

57:40 He's the head guy. So let me ask you this, how does Joel administer this church? Is he is he kind of like Ben was? Where? Look, everything has to flow through me. Joel Joel was a humble man. He he would talk in a way that people understood him and he would quote some of the early Mormon leaders and people didn't know any better, thought that was coming straight from Joel. He liked to quote Heber C Kimball, for instance, somebody that knew what Heber C Kimball had said was that, oh, he got that from Heber C Kimball.

58:27 But people that didn't know any better thought that came straight from Joel. Interesting. Or one thing you'd like to say, well, every tub has to sit on his own bottom. He got that from one of the early parts of the church, or I I I put my pants on when I get a time. Meaning I'm just another man. Right. But he he he preached a good song and he wanted people to use their own judgement in things. Gotcha. But people, people don't don't like that. Gotcha.

59:12 People want to be told what to do, what you used to having a profit. If I can't get him to tell me what to do. Right. People want to be told what to do. They don't want to may be responsible for their own decisions. They don't want to get down on their knees and ask God, what should I do? It's so much easier to go and see Joe Lebaron or Ervila Bear to say, hey, I got a problem here. What do you think I ought to do about it? Got you, Ervil would say. Well, I just had a revelation.

59:57 You should give all your money to me and let me marry that girl over there. Joel would say, well, you probably ought to think about a little bit and just there. But you know, people would eventually think that Joel had told him what to do and they would do it. Gotcha. It's like we're told that Phil Smith asked God 3-4 times about allowing that first 116 pages to go right, and God finally says, yeah, go And they promptly got lost, right, because Joseph Smith decided that he had the answer that it'd be OK Well, people would do that to Joel to a certain extent. Joel wouldn't come out and say this is what God wants you to do, but he might hint to you know. Well, perhaps you should consider the answer to that. And people go home thinking that Joe told them what to do and that's what they would do.

1:01:02 Gotcha. Gotcha And. People wouldn't do nothing without or anything. They wouldn't do anything. They do nothing is what they do. They wouldn't do anything without the approval of the profit. I understand for a while we we were very we grew a lot. I actually ended up being the Bishop, agent or presiding elder for three different congregations. We had one in San Diego with a bunch of people, I don't know 50 to 100 people show up there. We had one in Tijuana with quite a few people in it, and we had one in Los Molinos with quite a few people in it.

1:01:45 And somehow I ended up being the presiding elder over all three. So I would be one place and then I'd wander around anyway. I would, I was in the one in Baja California at at a point after they'd already brought a lot of the Mexicans from the South to making a hill. And we had a church building down there and it was raining like crazy and water was running in the church. And I said, hey, let's why don't you give me a hand and we'll dig a ditch and we'll send that water down the hill. Oh, we have to ask Joel first. They wouldn't even use enough brains to say let's let's stop the water and dig a ditch without Joel's OK.

1:02:32 And Joel wasn't around. Right. I dubbed the ditch and resigned as Presiding elder in that particular area. Gotcha, gotcha. So you you said something earlier though in that part where you said Ervil was the kind of guy though that would have a revelation to give us money and then and then do that. That's the difference. Ervil understood that if he had a revelation, he he began to make it. Greedy how I put it. Section 121 of the Doctor Covenants, verse 34 and you're called but fewer chosen.

1:03:13 And why are they not chosen? Because as soon as they get a little priest in authority, so they believe or think like I'm not, I'm paraphrasing it, they immediately begin to exercise unjust dominion. Right, right. And that's what they do. So do you think Herbal kind of maybe learned some of this though from Ben watching Ben preside over his church for a while? He he was had come from a very poor situation. He had come from sacrificing everything, but all of a sudden there's money available and he's able to travel.

1:03:55 Not like this. Not hitching a a ride, but he's traveling in a nice new car. He had afford. He could afford afford. Gotcha. OK. And he was traveling around. He could afford nice clothes. He wore very nice clothes. He wore shiny shoes. He was sleeping in motels. Unless he was sleeping at somebody's house, he was eating good food. Now every have you ever met?

1:04:35 Have you ever met a poor preacher or a poor politician? No, they tend not to exist a whole bunch. I mean, there's a few, but not really. Of course, every one of them are doing it in the name of the Lord or to protect the Constitution or something. But somehow they all get money. I have a a son-in-law that's an evangelical preacher. Oh, pastor, preacher, reverend. He speaks Spanish. I'll have to change this. We just made this nice bowl of pozzoli. Can we leave a little bit with you?

1:05:18 Here's enough to feed your family for a week. OK. Thank you. Oh, preacher, Pastor, we just made this cake. Would you like some cake? People want to impress the preacher. They want to gather approval from the preacher. They seek approval. Everything that we do, we do because we want to seek approval from God's servant. It's it's true with any religion in any country, with any God. If I were in India, I want to please Krishna or somebody. If I was in Arabia, I want to play. I want to impress the local, what they call any, the guy who runs the mosque, the, the.

1:06:25 I think they call him clerics. I want to impress the rabbi. It's a it's a worldwide, universal trait of people. They want to please the person that they admire. If I'm a politician, if I was a Republican, well, maybe last year I wanted to get, what's his name, Trump's approval. This year, maybe I don't care. But if I was a Democrat, I definitely want to impress Biden, you know? Right. That's people. That's people. So if I was had been poor all my life, if I'd had to maybe wear used clothes, maybe use a wire to hold up my pants for a while that's that's a lie that somebody told me you had to use barbed wire fence when they'd hold your pants up. But anyway, if if I had come up from a very poor situation, which everybody from that era did, they came out of the Depression, for crying out loud, and all of a sudden, hey, I I can do anything I want.

1:07:46 I've got money. Where'd it come from? Well, people just hand it to me, right? And that's nice. Right. And now I'm. I'm the alpha male and Irwin was a pretty nice looking guy. You've seen him. I think I probably got a picture of him here if you didn't. He was a tall, muscular, beautiful man. I suppose. I've never had much taste in men. But anyway, he was a good looking man. He was the alpha male. He was the one out front doing things. He was the smart one. He was the intellectual head of the Church. Gotcha.

1:08:29 Gotcha. OK I. Think I'm glove. OK, so we've kind of set the stage here of what where ervil's at at this time. When does things start going off the rails for Ervil? What? What? What? What? Got him off the rail. Yeah. What? What? What is it that gets Ervil off the rails? What causes? That's. Ervil to go down the. Path Ervil was doing everything he could for the church, everything. He was a church's agent. And important factor if you live in Mexico is that a person like you or me cannot own property along the beaches or next to the borders.

1:09:17 It's 50 kilometers from the beach. It's 100 kilometers from the borders and the church had invested pretty heavily in Baja California. Thousands, thousands of Victoria and Victoria is 2 1/2 acres. More or less. Thousands of Victorias. All in the name of guess who? Herbal. Herbal, The Mexican, and no problem. It's all church property. It's all going to be used, and your Ervil is pushing everything he can to make the church go.

1:09:59 But there's some women that weren't happy with their husbands for one reason or another, and a couple of them were perfectly willing to go be Ervil's wife. So these women were flocking to Ervil? OK. Pretty soon he's got 13 wives. I see. And how many kids? I don't know. But a whole flock of kids and you got to feed them. So he's around hitting everybody up for money. Oh, we've got a project over here. It's going to take about $5000 and we really like you to help. Oh thank you.

1:10:41 Oh, we've got this project there. It's going to take about 5000. We'd like you to help pretty soon. He's got $15,000 towards that project. Gotcha. And another thing that happened. Most of us only joined OK, we're going to leave the United order. Here's everything I own. All I've got now is my wages for my work. Some people didn't. Why not? Oh, I need money to keep my my business going. I'd buy property, I build houses, and it takes money to do that. So I can't give all of my property, but I can give some profits.

1:11:30 Right. Or I got animals that I buy and sell. Or I raise chickens, turkeys, cows, it don't matter. In order to do that, I have to have capital, so I'm going to end up keeping my money. So pretty soon you've got an economic disparity. Some people that have money and some people that don't, and for some reason most of the people that had money were in a church position. Sounds like the Mormons, huh?

1:12:13 They were on what was called the Standing High Council. The standing high council was the equal to the traveling high council, but the Standing high council was in Zion. The Traveling High Council is supposed to be out in the mission field. Right. So somehow most of those men got on the standing High council and somehow I got to be on that standing high council that was poor as can be. But I was on that same council, so I saw this myself, all right? And people were complaining about Ervil's and his constant looking for money.

1:13:04 Gotcha. And there was also some people that were very unhappy about him constantly dealing in women. How I put that be good to me and we'll get you a wife, right? People didn't like that. Or worse than that. Suppose you're on the standing high council and your wife is wanting to leave you to go marry Ervil and take your kids with her. Gotcha. Yeah. So all of this pressure was there. So we're sitting in a high council meeting and basically what I hear, my interpretation of what I heard is you've got to put some brakes or some reins.

1:13:52 Reins like to drive a horse on Ervil because he's completely out of control and and if you don't, well, guess what we're not going to invest in nothing. I see. And they had thousands of acres in Mexico that they were going to build a big resort hotel with the harbor and the whole bit and let's get some rings on verbal or it's not going to work the next day. The next day her Joel came back and had a revelation and released Earl of all positions, all positions. And Earl didn't believe it.

1:14:44 Earl had served his brother in every way possible. He loved his brother unconditionally. He had devoted his entire life to religion and especially to the success success of his brother church. And here it was doing very well, with a lot of people coming, with lots of money and property and everything, and Joel turned on him. How do you think? He felt. So let let me ask this though, let me let me just from an outsider looking in, let me ask this question, 'cause I based on what you just described to me about what Ervil's doing and then people saying you've got to reign in Ervil here, yeah. Well, what happened is he lost his best friend. His best friend, His brother turned on him. I'm not going to argue whether he deserved that or not. All I'm going to say is that there should have been some other way to deal with it.

1:15:57 So Ervil, when he hears this, he don't believe it. He finally gets to his brother and he says is it true? Yes. And he woke down and cried like a baby. He couldn't believe it. OK, but but I'm. I'm going to push back here a little bit, Dwayne. OK. Because to me, it sounds like Ervil is already practicing a form of priest craft right with. Again. It seems to me that as you described Ervil, the way he was, quote, rescuing women, the way that he was going around getting money for projects that would later line his prop own pocket to to to finance his family, that was.

1:16:39 Wrong. That was wrong. This is Priest Craft. Let's call it what it is, right? It's priest craft. Yes, it is. I don't doubt that. And so we wouldn't if, if, if this happened inside any other religious organization, basically excommunicating that guy because what you've done is you've essentially taken the Lord's money and screwed around with it. Right. So yeah. So so in in this way I I don't I don't see a problem with the way Joel handled this right. I think that's. Probably. The only way you could. Handle like I said, they could have. There was other ways he could have handled it. How else would you have handled that? Let me ask you that.

1:17:24 Well, what did they do in the Mormon church? They put them on a stipend. Is that the word they use? So it's not. An income, A stipend? Yeah. They they give them an allowance, they could give everyone an allowance and says OK, let's figure out what you need, this is what you get. Right. But nonetheless, he did commit a pretty serious transgression, right? It it deserves some sort of discipline and. It could have been. It could have been nipped in the bud a whole lot sooner. That's where I was going, right? Is nipping this in the bud sooner because. But Irvo loved his brother. His brother loved him.

1:18:08 And nobody was innocent. He wasn't the only one that was taking advantage. Sure. Some of them that's still there were taking advantage. Other brothers were not hesitant to take advantage. Any chance they got. Joe called one of his brothers said. You have the soul of a pig. He was that greedy. That was to the brother, Alma Junior. OK, gotcha.

1:18:49 Irva wasn't the only one. Gotcha. A lot of the others were getting money one way or another for different projects, and sometimes the project should make it. Most of the time they didn't. But every there was a whole lot of people getting money from a whole lot of other people. Earl was not alone. Gotcha, Gotcha 10 four. OK, so. Neither was Joel innocent. OK, All right. So let me ask you this. Obviously now he's broke, right? He's broken, so to speak, because he's had everything taken away now because all the property was in the church's name, right? That, that IRVO.

1:19:36 The church's name? No, the church didn't have any property in its name. That's a big that's the big point about Irvo being a Mexican in 1917, nineteen 15/19/17 in Mexico, they had a revolution. It was because of the church. The Catholic Church owned almost all the land, and after that revolution it became against the law for any church to own any land in Mexico. They've let that slide a little bit. Now, the Mormon Church actually owns some land in Mexico. But the Catholic Church uses all those churches as a concession from the government.

1:20:23 But they don't own them. They belong to the nation. Gotcha. OK, so. Who's? Well, let's chase this a little further. All of that land was in Earl's name because the church didn't own anything. OK. Every Earl's had all the land and and after Joel was killed and Irwin was gone, I got to watch the Lebaron's fight over who got to Church's land because it wasn't going to be anybody. It wasn't going to be the church. Right.

1:21:04 So Irva wasn't the only one. So if you're in a band of thieves, are you going to actually mitigate the one that is the head thief? Right. I see where you're going. Let let me ask you this, Ervil. And and I'm seeing kind of a repeat here with Ben, right. Ervil loses and then he kind of he, he loses a lot, right. And then he kind of loses it. Where At what point does he not just decide? You know what?

1:21:45 This sucks. I'll just take the land that I own, sell it off, and then I can at least take care of my family. How does he go from, from, you know, my brother's wronged me to it's time for me to start killing people. Standard stages of grief. I don't believe it. Oh damn, I'm going to cry about it. I'm going to get even. I'm going to get mad. I am going to there. I've been done wrong. I'm going to get even right. And that spirit can turn into the spirit of murder real easy. When a husband and a wife get divorced, it's never a pretty picture.

1:22:31 No. They hate each other. Yep. And it's it's an ugly, ugly picture. And in some cases it does turn to murder. Sure. But not not not very often Let's. But it's apart from that, apart from that, Ervil still felt like he he could do some things, so he immediately decides to rearrange the church. Nobody paid him any attention. So OK, I can't do that. He he he got himself a small following, but he's cut off from his number one source of income.

1:23:17 In other words, he went from a whole lot of people that he could leave a bit of money on out of to a very small group of people that he'd get a little bit of money out of. Gotcha. That wasn't a pretty picture. But he still has the land, right? He still has the land. No. The Land's in his. You you said the land was. In here, I I didn't finish the story. OK, Joe decided that he would get that land away from her. How? Mexico at the time had a law that allowed the poor people to petition for unused property, and this was native land. It wasn't being used and the president at the time, a fellow by name H Maria, had had said, we're not going to do this anymore, it's over.

1:24:17 But as soon as he became president, all the all the poor people went on strike and he changed his mind and he ended up giving more land to the poor people than anybody since Lazaro Cardenas, who had been the the big guy that gave the land to the poor people way back when. OK, so Joel said, OK, I'm going to start in a heel. So we sent some of the old Mexican members to Mexico City to petition the government to start in a heel, and it looks like they're doing pretty good. About that time, Orwell decided he's going to steal my property.

1:25:00 People, just because it was his name. It was his. It's it's like you. Were you in the military? No. Oh, then you don't. You won't understand this. I was the store keeper. The guy that's got all this stuff on the ship or on the base. He decided that's all his and he's going to let you have it. Unless he's got an order from some superior person to let let it go. He takes a owner's viewpoint of all that property. Well, Ervil had decided all that probably was his, just because it was his. It had his name on it. Legally, it was his.

1:25:45 Never mind. It was paid for by with church money, with contributions, with tithing, with all that stuff. It was his. It's like in the Mormon Church if, what's his name, Rusty, anyway. He's the soul owner of that corporation. Right, right. Yep. He could take the whole thing and run if he wanted to, I suppose. Sure. Well, Ervil was the sole owner of thousands of acres of land that the church had paid for, but it was his, and he felt like it was his. So Joel's going to win the game by taking the property away from him.

1:26:33 He's going to do that by bringing in a bunch of poor Mexicans and petition the government for that property. And Ervil says that is a criminal act. He shouldn't be allowed to do that. If he does that, he is a is a criminal. He's a thief because he's stealing my property and he deserves to die. Gotcha. And if he's successful, he will die. Gotcha. Two days. Two days after the ajito thing was approved, Joel was killed. 2 days. Interesting.

1:27:20 Now let me ask this question. How did Ruben Allred get on his on Joel on Ervil's list? I'm sorry. How did ruling Allred get on Ervil's list? Let's run a while. Ruling Allred, of course, was part of the people that were over the Lebaron's when they were in the United Order in 1955. And before ruling, Allred was the first man that Joel asked to be his number two man. Ruben Allred was the head of the group that the Lebaron's felt was the legitimate fundamentalist group, and Ervil wanted to get them into his group. But even more importantly is that Verlin was married to 22 two nieces of ruling Allred and they wanted to get rid of Berlin.

1:28:36 They they had job dead already. All right. So who do you want to get rid of Berlin? The second the brother that became the leader of the church after Joel died. So I know what let's do. We'll just kill ruling Allred because he doesn't want to get in line and follow us. And when Verland shows up, the funeral, we'll shoot him. Wow. Wow. So. When that happens, they had every cop in that in Utah County, I guess there and they lost their nerve. So they killed Ruin Allred just to get to Verland.

1:29:18 Yeah, wow. That's the official story. I believe it. OK. All right, holy cow. And where are you? Still part of the Church of the First born when all this is happening. I was IA member. Yeah. Were you still a member inactive during this whole time period? I got out after Berlin was dead just before when I when I had when I, as a member of the High Council set in on the meetings where the the barons were fighting over who got the church's property. Joel's property. OK.

1:29:59 Or villain's property. Whoever's property which which was barren got it. I I I think I realized it. I don't think I want anything to do with these people. Right. Right. And I left. Gotcha gotcha. And so, yeah, I I. So I ended up deciding. I think Joel was right. When he started, I'd hoped that some of the people that followed him would write, but they all choose this one man on the earth at a time. OK, I'll shut up. Your turn. You're good, you're good. I got two questions here before we wrap up. The first one is this in your as. As I'm listening to the story here of how Ervil got to where he was, to me there there seem to be a couple key factors. Before I tell you mine, I want to know what yours are. As you look at what set the stage for Ervil to do what he did.

1:31:09 What do you think it was? I think that it was disappointed expectations. He expected that the church was going to conquer the the Joel's church was going to completely conquer Mormandom and all of the fundamentalist groups. He believed that, and it looked like it was going to be true. They they were really doing well in the 60s and the early 70s and all of a sudden it stopped. Gotcha.

1:31:49 And so his expectations of doing this great and wonderful thing for God and for the church was God. And just like his brother Ben, when everything went wrong, everything went wrong for Ervil and he snapped. I talk about another person in the in my book, a guy by the name of Bill Tucker. He was the another intellectual. He was doing great and wonderful things. He fully expected that when Joel organized the church, he would be in the First Presidency or he would be this. He'd be that. When Joel organized church, he was just another apostle. He was even the head apostle.

1:32:36 And he left the church within weeks after that. And he became an atheist, if you will, question whether even God lived. He went from being the number one one of the greatest supporters of the church to wondering if God even existed. And he died. Well, he he, God took him. That's what we thought. He got an appendix, a burst of Penix, and died within a month or so of leaving the church. And that really put a scare on us. OK, OK.

1:33:23 And I think Ervil and Joe believe that as much as the rest of us did. And so Ervil felt he did not. He he could do no wrong. Right. And then it all got taken away from him. So let me push back here, because there's a lot of people that get disappointed, right? I've been. I've been wealthy and poor several times at no and and got screwed over too, I should say in in the process. But I never went to that dude has to die now.

1:34:06 Neither have I, but other people have. Right. And and and and that's where I tend to be like well while there are certainly circumstances that that surround this, I I think that that herbal is ultimately responsible for, for the actions that were taken there, right. I don't ever want I I'm not a big believer in you're a product of your environment that we see people all the time that are able to to exercise upward mobility and get out of their their bad situation and better themselves.

1:34:49 So I I don't ever want to excuse quite frankly in this case just horrific actions because he felt like he was wronged. There's lots of people who get wronged who end up making it still as I've looked at the story as as we've sat down here and talked and and I can't thank you enough for taking the time. It's not often you get to talk to someone who was there while it happened and here's here's what I I take away. I think that herbal was years in the making right.

1:35:30 I think that that he's raised in a household that in my opinion sounds an awful lot like a pressure cooker. You got dad who's who's super a a super disciplinarian. A mom and her, her her kids are not going to be second. Second place looks like the first loser to her. So he has these pressures. He comes back, he he watches his brother Ben fail at starting a church that had to leave a mark. And then he he does put in a ton of time into the church that Joel starts and you know, does a lot of The Dirty work.

1:36:12 But somewhere along the lines hubris seems to set in for for Ervil, right where he starts looking at things going, I'm entitled to these things and and then when that all gets taken away, he snaps, as you said, not excusing what Ervil did 'cause there there's no excuse for the shedding of innocent blood. There's one other thing that I think this all can kind of hinge on as well, and This is why I've come to a point to where I'm not a huge fan of this. Now I want to specify this.

1:36:53 There are plenty of people that adhere to this doctrine that don't go crazy. There's plenty of leaders that adhere to this doctrine that don't go crazy. But I I will make the case that most things bad that happen in Mormonism stem from a place where the one man doctrine is is adhered to. There is this idea that that that there's only so much authority to go around, and if your authority has been challenged, you have to respond. And as I look at this one man doctrine and how this fits in with this, I see Herbal being being, you know in, in his mind screwed over by Joel. He he's he's really angry about this. And he I'm sure at some point he's like, I'm justified in this.

1:37:53 Ervil's not the guy. There can only be one guy on the earth. I should be that guy now, Ervil Joel's disqualified himself. And then. And Ervil's that guy, Yes. And Ervil's that guy, right? He believed that, and that's the worst doctrine that exists in the Mormon Church as far as I'm concerned. Yeah, yeah, cause 'cause when when you adhere to the one man doctrine, whether you want to believe it or not, my opinion is this, you no longer about are about principle. You're you're about whoever the man is in charge and and one man ISM often gets accompanied by infallibility.

1:38:36 I I waste a lot of pages against that particular Dalton in my book. Right, right, absolutely. Yeah. So those, those are the main things I can see here that kind of helped set the table. But for me, at the end of the day, this all lies at the feet of Ervil Lebaron. Certainly the table had to be set for him, but he seemed more than willing to go down this road if he had to. Let. Let me ask you this, Dwayne. Why did you write the book? When I in the book, I said why? Because I share grandkids with Ervil, and those grandkids are negatively impacted because they're Ervil's descendants. Everybody judges anybody that is associated with Ervil in any way, even if they weren't even born yet with that kind of nonsense.

1:39:41 Gotcha. That's one of the reasons. The other one, we are the people that made Ervil. Why? Because we went along with it. How come Warren Jeffs got away with all his nonsense? Our prophet. Right or wrong, our prophet. He's got the keys. Parker's brains Parker integrity and follow the Prophet because he just talks to God, right? No, I think there's, I think that they're there and again that's a product of that one man doctrine, right. Yes, it is. And and we've got and and that's been the one thing within Mormon fundamentalism certainly since I joined it that sometime has been the most disturbing to me is this idea of and to be fair, it's in the LDS church too, right. They're they're a one man church. But that's been probably the most disturbing part of the whole Mormonism thing is just how quick a lot of us are to park our well, as you said, your integrity, your common sense, and just go with what the one man says. And I find nothing in the writings of Joseph Smith that would suggest that that was the end goal, was a one man thing. I see Joseph being much more inclusive with passing that authority along.

1:41:09 Well, that was the whole idea of the Anointed Quorum is it should have a church, if you will, of priests and priestesses who had the authority to do whatever needed to do anywhere in the world, right? Right. That's the second anointing that all of those people were going to get. Right. Once they qualified, absolutely, absolutely. But they took it away. Yep. Well, Dwayne, this has been awesome. I can't tell you how excited I am to get this one released. And we'll we'll get it released the same week that that that new Hulu series comes out. OK.

1:41:53 Because I think there's some important things that have to be talked about here. And I I feel like we've talked about a lot of them real quick. The name of the book is God's Executioner. The the Tragic story of Ervil Lebaron. Where can they find the book, Dwayne? On Amazon. On Amazon, Barnes and no neighbor supposed to have it, but I don't know if anybody bought any from them. Just go to Amazon, there's a ebook, there's a paperback, there's a hardcover, and in another week or two there'll be a Spanish version. Fantastic.

1:42:33 Fantastic. Bye everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.