Nov. 25, 2023

Episode #103: The Symbology & Significance Of Wine In The Restored Gospel W/Joshua Erickson

Episode #103: The Symbology & Significance Of Wine In The Restored Gospel W/Joshua Erickson
Episode #103: The Symbology & Significance Of Wine In The Restored Gospel W/Joshua Erickson
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #103: The Symbology & Significance Of Wine In The Restored Gospel W/Joshua Erickson

Go To http://patreon.com/MormonRenegade368 For Exclusive Content

Today we are going to pick back up on the Word of Wisdom series. Later in this series I plan on having a fitness expert on to talk about exercise and over all physical health. Now if you recall a few weeks ago we talked about what the Word of Wisdom says about the consumption of meat with Joshua Erickson. Well today Joshua comes back on the podcast as we talk about wine. We talk about its prescription in the Word of Wisdom, from there we take an even deeper dive into what constitutes a sacrament, then our conversation turns to the Old and New Testaments as well as the Book of Mormon to see what scripture has to say about wine and its symbology in the Restored Gospel. That and more on this episode of the MRP.

Go To deseretflag.com to get your Deseret Flag Today

https://www.facebook.com/groups/1387509248835311/?ref=share_group_link

--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support

0:04 Today we're going to pick back up on the Word of Wisdom series. Later in the series, I plan on having a fitness expert on to talk about exercise and overall physical health. Now if you recall, a few weeks ago we talked about what the Word of Wisdom really says about the consumption of meat with Joshua Erickson. Well today Joshua comes back on the podcast As we talk about wine, we talk about it's prescription in the Word of Wisdom. From there we take an even deeper dive into what constitutes A sacrament. Then our conversation turns to the Old and New Testament as well as the Book of Mormon to see what scripture has to say about wine and its symbology in the restored gospel. That and more on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. Look, it's no secret that our society has become much more crude and coarse.

0:51 To become and raise men and women of virtue and character is a Herculean task. To help with this, I've recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior and Company and Conversation. It was a book with 110 rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society, something that today's society is sorely lacking. What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So the book is laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule. Right below that is my explanation for the 21st century, and below that you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, to go along with this, there's a workbook that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids. To find the book, go to mormonrenegade.com. Go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post, and order your copy today.

1:49 I can bear personal testimony from personal experience that this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character. OK, just a couple of quick announcements here. If you're looking for a place to attend sacrament meeting and don't know where to go, I want you to reach out to me. Me and others stand ready to help you find a spiritual home, whether that's a new church, a gathering spot of independence, OR even if you just need a soft place to land for a time to learn how to have sacrament meeting in your own home. Myself and others stand ready to help you find that place. All you got to do is just drop me a line at mormonrenegade@gmail.com and we'll quickly reach out to you to help you find the place you want and need to be next. I have felt for a while now that the sisters haven't had a good place to go to have their questions answered without a bunch of dudes creeping around to fill this need. My wife Tanya has set up a Facebook group just for women to talk about questions about fundamentalism. The name of that group is Mormon Fundamentalism for Women. Now, just a warning, if you're a dude thinking about trying to jump on this site, I'm going to give this to you in my best Liam Neeson impression.

2:55 I have a certain set of skills and I'll find you and I will publicly mock you endlessly without mercy for many, many weeks. So whether you're a fundamentalist woman seeking sisterhood or a woman investigating fundamentalism, this place is for you. Again, the name of that Facebook group is Mormon Fundamentalism for Women. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Joshua, dude, it's good to be Have you back again, Yeah? It's always good to be here.

3:57 So when we when we did the the episode about the word of Wisdom and meat, one epic, right, I just, I went, I went out right afterwards and threw steak on the grill. In celebration. In celebration, right. You'd mentioned wine and I was intrigued. Cause 'cause wine is all over the scriptures and not in a prohibitive way, right? Right. It's it's very much a it's there and and use of symbolism you know just off the top of my head the the blood of the savior right the. Flesh and blood. Yeah, exactly. And it it's it's, you know, even a symbol of of the gospel itself when it talks about new wine and old bottles. And so it's all over the place.

4:44 So as we dive into this, I'm super excited to see where this goes. It's like meat in the scriptures, like, right? It's all over and and and there's gospel symbolism in the meat. And yeah, So. And the Word of Wisdom has something to say about it too, right? Yeah. And the Word of Wisdom kind of like this, I guess this is like our Word of Wisdom series, Part 2. Yeah. Word of Wisdom series, Part 2. Right. Yeah. The, the symbolism about wine is is good for the most part. There's exceptions. We can talk about that. But the Wordism doesn't really say what a lot of people think it says, just kind of kind of like the meat too. So a lot of a lot of those, those prohibitions in the Word of Wisdom or what we think of as prohibitions are not actually prohibitions, but rather it's wisdom about how to use these things in an appropriate manner, right? The other thing about the Word of Wisdom that I find very interesting is that so often we think we focus on what we deem the prohibitives right.

5:53 Don't. Don't do this, this or this right. And we really don't focus on what it tells you to do. Prescriptions, right? Right? Do this. Yeah, do this. And so I find that very interesting as well when it comes to this. Yeah, interesting. So so with with alcohol in general, I think the the usual latter day St. interpretation of the Word of Wisdom is that alcohol of all varieties is prohibited. For all time and all purposes, right? Yeah, but that's not, that's pretty far from what it actually says, right? So I'll just read the the first part here, Section 89.

6:34 Let's see, of course there's there's an introduction and and it talks about evils and designs in the last days and so on. And and then in verse five is where really the the instructions start. And it starts off with wine. It says in as much as any man drinketh wine or strong drink among you. Behold, it is not good. Neither meet in the sight of your father, only in assembling yourselves together to offer up your sacraments before him. And behold, this should be wine, yeah, pure wine of the grape, of the vine, of your own make. And again, strong drinks are not for the belly, but for the washing of your bodies.

7:14 So. So those opening verses have to do with. Alcohol, right. So a couple of things first First kind of misconception I guess is is when we when the average latter day St. reads this and reads strong drink, what do you think the like what's the? The interpretation of strong drink, wine and strong drink, I would think Liquor, OK, liquor. That's good. I agree with that. Actually. I think, I think for many people they would interpret that as alcohol in general. And maybe people don't know that there's a difference between there are different kinds of alcoholic beverages, right.

8:01 And liquor is what it's referring to when it says strong drinks, so. OK. So what is the difference? So you know so how are, how are, how is wine and other alcoholic beverages made? Well, you have something that has sugars in it like fruits like apples or grapes or or honey or whatever malt, barley malt or whatever. And then and then you you have yeast that's added to it either nowadays often times the yeast is like kind of cultured separately from. The fruit or whatever. And then those things are mixed together. And then the yeast, the yeast eats up the sugar and produces ethanol.

8:51 And that's where the alcohol comes from. So that first step where you add the yeast and the yeast does its thing, it produces the alcohol, but it also produces a bunch of other things too. It gets rid of the sugar, for one, or reduces the sugar. And also there's a bunch of vitamins and you know. Enzymes, antioxidants, and all these other good things that come from all kinds of fermented foods. OK, so that first step is called fermentation. And that's where wine and cider and Mead and beer and ale. Those are all things that the Word of Wisdom calls mild drinks. These are things that are fermented. OK, now the strong drink. Wait, they weren't drinking wheat grass, smoothies and Joseph Smith's time?

9:35 That's not the kind of grain based drinks they were talking about. Oh, no, no, I don't think so. I think it's pretty clear that the mild drinks. So this goes over to verse 17. OK, And we can talk. That was a good time to mention that, I guess. But yeah, so that's actually the read. 17. Nevertheless, wheat for man, and corn for the ox, and oats for the horse, and rye for the fowls, and for swine, and for all beasts of the field. And barley for all use for animals and for mild drinks as also other grain. So barley and other grain are useful for making mild drinks, it says. And those are those are recommended for our consumption. Yeah. And that's absolutely just good old fashioned beer and it's many varieties and you know, a lot of sometimes there's a lot of people feel like they have to. Make excuses or explanations for Joseph Smith and the early brethren drinking beer.

10:34 You know what I'm saying? Joseph Smith's journals and stuff like that, you know? But there's really, there's really no contradiction with the word wisdom. In fact, it's totally in line, right? Well, if I'm not mistaken, I think what were the two things that Joseph sent for as he was in Carthage? I know wine, wine and he asked for a couple of pipes. OK. Yeah, Yeah. Yeah. And so you you you look at that and you're like, how am I supposed to square this, right? Yeah, it's it's almost like we pretend it doesn't exist. Right. That's not part of the the normal narrative. No. No it's not. We're not always going. Yeah, interesting. So OK, So what is the difference between a fermented beverage, which is a mild drink, and a strong drink? It is a separate process.

11:27 That process is distillation. So mild drinks are fermented, strong drinks are fermented and then distilled, and so distilled liquor are things like whiskey, vodka and rum and Brandy and so on. And when you distill fermented things, you really actually remove. All the You actually remove all the nutrition 100%. There's no vitamins, there's no minerals, there's no antioxidants, there's no enzymes or whatever other healthy things. The only thing that comes out of the distillation is alcohol, and there'll be water as well that comes over. And you know some like aroma and flavor molecules and some of those could be, you know, you could argue those, some of those things are.

12:21 Have health benefits, but not really. I mean the purpose of distilling things is to make them strong and the usual use of those things is to get drunk like that is that is the purpose of distilled or strong strong drinks. Now I will say though that even the word wisdom doesn't actually forbid strong drinks, it actually well what it does is gives their proper use and it says strong drinks are for. The washing of your bodies and whether whether we realize that or not, we do that. You know we use alcohol for hand sanitizer and mouthwash, right?

13:03 And those, those are just two examples of a physical aspect of washing your bodies. Now, I do think there's a spiritual aspect to that as well, which we'll get to later, but a Sacramento aspect. Gotcha anyway. OK, so that's important to to realize here that when when it says alcohol, when it says strong drinks, it is not giving us a it's it's not telling us to avoid alcohol, it's just telling us to avoid whiskey and Brandy and things like that. OK, so that's important. And it's important too, to realize that when you read the scriptures.

13:50 Drinking alcohol is actually never forbidden. But I'll tell you what is forbidden and what is frowned upon Drunkenness, right? So it's really the excess. And this is true of so many, many things, you know, So many things in this world are just kind of neutral and have. Good and evil uses, right? The Internet. That's a perfect example, right? Podcasts, right? For example, Right, right, right, right. You can use the Internet to be uplifted, or you can use it to find porn. It's up to you.

14:31 That's exactly right. So and there's this argument rages about all kinds of things. Guns is another one. That's. Commonly debated, right? But these are, you know, the Internet and guns and alcohol, These are all just inanimate objects. And there's a there's an agent behind those things who's making choices one way or another. So even things that we, even things that we might normally think of as good, can certainly be abused, you know? Right. Are churches good? Sure. But they can also be bad, right? I mean, Oh yeah. Right. Yeah.

15:11 So that's naming names. Right. Without naming names, right. All their creeds were an abomination. OK, so OK, so another misunderstanding. OK, And this is in those verses there, actually, let's see verse five. OK, it says wine is. Wine and strong drinks are not generally good. But when you assemble yourselves together to offer up your sacraments. Sacraments, That's right. And it's not sacrament, It's sacraments. So what in the world is a sacraments? Well, I What are sacraments?

15:57 To be more grammatically correct, yeah, I think. I think in looking at it, you can look at weddings, wedding feasts. That's right. You can look at baptisms. You can look and and I I guess I should say, and whether I'm right or wrong here, I'm willing to be wrong if someone can show me this. But I don't see where the extension of the actual ordinance wouldn't be part of the sacraments, right? So you have a wedding and then you have a wedding feast. That is part of the sacrament. That's exactly right, the baptism. I don't see why a celebration would not attend part of that, right? Right. And then. And then I I've even come to this as I've thought about this.

16:43 You have sacraments that are institutional, if you will, OK, marriages, baptisms, those sorts of things. But I think you could even make a case that is your wedding anniversary a sacrament. Yeah, I, you know, we know that the Lord is big on remembering, right? And and and you know, going back to the beginning, we see that in the feast days. Yeah. Amen. And so it those are nothing more than anniversary celebrations. So if if that's a sacrament, then why is not your union to your wife a sacrament?

17:23 Maybe birthdays. I, I it just goes on and on, right. And so it it's one of those things that as I look at, I think we're really too almost pharasitical in some ways about what is and what isn't. And the issue what what makes it pharasitical is that it gets really hard to say, you know where it is in scripture that it shouldn't be done right. And in my opinion, it becomes more the traditions of men than anything else. Yeah, I like that, you know, I think.

18:04 One of the amazing things about the Word of Wisdom is it says right when you're talking about why it says it should be of your own make, which kind of like just puts the it's of your own make. And it is for Sacramento purposes. And I think there really is. I like what you said there about there are institutional sacraments, but there can also be. Familial sacraments, right. And and each, you know, each head of the household is going to kind of determine that. And I think that is their prerogative actually. And so I like that and I think that goes right along with making your own. And I think this is a, this is a this is a message of the word of wisdom.

18:52 At least this part is, is this personal responsibility. I know a lot of times people look at the of your own make and they think it's. It's to avoid poison, and we'll get more to that later. But I I don't think it has as much to do with avoiding poison as it does have to do with taking spiritual responsibility for your own religion and your own worship. Oh, that's fascinating. So wait to get into that. OK, so let me go. Let's go. Just keep you on this theme of sacraments. Here. I have I have here in front of me Webster's 1828. Definition of the word Sacrament So definition one.

19:37 Among ancient Christian writers, a mystery sacrament is a mystery. Two, an oath, a ceremony producing an obligation. 3 In present usage, an outward and visible sign of an inward and spiritual grace, or more particularly, a solemn religious ceremony enjoined by Christ. Ahead of the Christian Church, to be observed by his followers, by which their special relation to him is created, or their obligations to him renewed and ratified. Thus Baptism is called a sacrament, for by it persons are separated from the world, brought into Christ's visible Church, and laid under particular obligations to obey his precepts. The Eucharist, or communion of the Lord's Supper is also a sacrament, for by commemorating the death and dying love of Christ, Christians avow their special relation to him and renew their obligations to be faithful to their divine master. So there we go.

20:36 You know, the first one is a mystery, second one is an oath or ceremony producing an obligation. And #3 is I'm going to kind of shorten it down here, but it is a let's see, where is it? A solemn religious ceremony which you know creates a special relation to Christ. So in you know our our language has has changed in in Mormonism what Webster's 1828 which was the usage in the Doctrine covenants of the word sacrament kind of reflected this. Now our our language has changed and now for these things we use the word ordinance. We say baptism is an ordinance and the sacrament of the Lord's Supper is an ordinance and priesthood ordination is an ordinance and marriage is an ordinance and so on. And so we've kind of lost connection to what the scripture is actually saying because our vocabulary has changed. But yeah, not until the 4th definition in Webster's, as it say, the Eucharist or the Lord's Supper, which is what we would in LDS terms, we would call the sacrament. But in the broader Christian context, the more proper term for that is the sacrament of the Lord's Supper, OK. And so like in in Catholicism, they still refer to what the LDS folks would say, ordinances.

22:11 The Catholic Church and the RLDS Church calls these things sacraments. So. So that's exactly right. So there's all kinds of things, and you mentioned a bunch of them. You know the the very first miracle that Jesus does. Turns water into wine. Water into wine. Yeah, same. Same miracle as Moses. Like the very first one, right? Water into blood and and And what was the occasion? It was a wedding. It was a wedding feast. The wedding? Yep, Yep. And you know, the the bride and groom are hotly disputed, as in that in that count in John.

22:54 But regardless, that was that was a sacrament. And that was a perfectly that use of wine that the Savior did was actually perfectly in line with the Word of Wisdom, which is as we expect, OK, but it is strange, I would say, that our modern definitions and understanding of the Word of Wisdom has crept to the point where we would we would now consider the Savior's actions questionable, wouldn't we? Oh, we we 100% would, I mean without a doubt and that's that's been my contention on this for for a while and and I'm going to zoom out here for a little bit to maybe a 1500 foot view if you will. Through our practice, we have changed what the Word of Wisdom is.

23:52 If, if if you look at the very opening statement, the Lord goes out of his way to say that this isn't a commandment, let's let's get that straight right now. He He opens it by making that distinction. Now, I'm not saying that you discount any of the Lord's words whatsoever, but there's a reason he put that in there as well. He also says who it's designed for. Right, which is probably someone like me who's got an addictive personality, right? I I don't think it is a commandment and I don't think it's a rule that can be applied universally.

24:35 And we know it wasn't universally asked on recommend questions till till Grant and prohibition. Yeah, well, and you know what too even that it's. I believe that the questions, as far as adherence goes, don't actually reflect what the what the verses say. So it's we're asking people to keep a standard, keep the Word of Wisdom in quotes, which is not even the which is not the Word of Wisdom. It's not what the word wisdom says. No.

25:17 It does say not to use tobacco. It does say hot drinks. I have my opinion about that. I think it is just referring to the temperature. I'll just say it and and prohibition on alcohol is actually not a thing in the word wisdom. Well, and and even tobacco, it gives a few. Oh yeah, says It's just for an herb to be used for bruises, sick cattle. And you know, it's great for. It's great for sick people too. It's super good anti parasite. Do you remember back in 2014 when we had when there was that massive Ebola outbreak going on in South Africa and we had a couple of doctors come home that were really sick? Did you ever hear about the therapeutic with that? No.

26:08 Oh, this is fascinating. So you can still find this article both on Fox News and CNN. OK, they had all the compounds there. They were trying to make it therapeutic, right? Because Ebola's got like a 98% death rate, A death sentence. Basically, you're not coming out of it. Well, this one pharmaceutical company had said we got all the compounds, we just can't get them to it here to to stick together. To long enough to to do what it needs to do. So they looked high and low for a chemical that would help it make it adhere. Well, they found a couple, but they were also toxic and so they were actually debating on on what they should do here and someone says I think that compound's found in a tobacco leaf, OK. So they took all the other compounds and they injected it into a live tobacco plant.

27:05 And within 48 hours, they were able to extract the therapeutic. And all those doctors lived. No way. I kid you not. OK, I'll have to look that up. Look I'll, I'll give you the article before I leave. But yeah, it's that was the therapeutic at which they were able to administer and and they they nursed him through it. They were still really, really sick. Right. I don't want you to think they were taking a shot out of this, but by injecting it into the tobacco leaf and then extracting it. It was able to to save a few lives. So I love that I think so much of the gospel actually is is not not strictly or not in not in. All in all, I'm stumbling over my words here. We we like to sometimes think of the gospel as a list of do's and don'ts.

27:56 But I think very often it's it's more like a a list of what is the proper use of things. Not that one thing is forbidden always or another thing is acceptable always, but learning in what context a thing is acceptable and in what context it is not. And so that's kind of a mature skill I think, to be able to pull that out of the scriptures for things you know. Absolutely so anyway, so Jesus first miracle was turning water to wine.

28:39 And sometimes I like to joke that Hebrew grant did him one better and turned it back. That was so in in 1921. This is a good year for the word wisdom. I guess in 1921, that's when abstinence from wine, That's when sacrament was officially water. Right. Yep, and that's when abstinence from wine, even for Sacramento purposes, became compulsory. I wonder what was going on in society at that time, Josh. Like in the 1920s, Yeah. I'm drawing a blank.

29:20 I don't know. Do a Google search. OK, we all know, I think fundamentalists especially love Isaiah 24 because, you know, it says the earth also is defiled under defiled under the inhabitants thereof because they have transgressed the laws, changed the ordinance, broken the everlasting covenant. OK, And then, you know this starts at verse 5 and it goes on through. But if you keep reading, like for through verse 11, I'll just pull out a couple pieces. There Isaiah's talking about the changing transgressing of the law, changing the ordinance and breaking the covenant. And he says also in this stream of thought here that the new wine mourneth the vine languisheth. All the merry hearted do sigh.

30:14 They shall not drink wine with a song. Strong drink shall be bitter to them. To drink it. There's a crying for wine in the streets. All joy is darkness. The mirth of the land is gone. Wow, so these these things that he says here where basically the use of wine is has been put aside, this is a sign or at least a a symptom or a a repercussion of the ordinance being changed. OK. Wow. And the law being transgressed and so on. And so, I mean, you as fundamentalists, we usually just think this is talking about or something, right?

30:55 Right and and now, but it's just but the the next lines that Isaiah does just connect it with wine. Right. And and look, could it be symbolic? Sure. But it could also be literal, especially given our history now. Right. I I think we have to look at it maybe with a little more of a textualist mindset. Yeah, right where we say. He could be talking about something very real. That's right. So, OK, so back to sacraments and weddings and so on. There is evidence for this in our own history. So January 1836, I believe this was the first set of marriages performed in this dispensation.

31:44 Joseph Smith performed marriage of John Webb to Catherine Wilcox and also Thomas Carico to Elizabeth Baker. This is in History of the Church volume to page 369. So they have this double wedding and then afterwards it was reported that the wedding party then quote partook of some refreshments and our hearts were made glad with the fruit of the vine. This Joseph Smith says this is in accordance with the pattern set by our Savior Himself, and we feel disposed to patronize all the institutions of heaven.

32:26 Now now see, that's a little different, right before, before the Isaiah verses and that quote by Joseph Smith, I think we could say, well, it's kind of, you know, here. There's just like freedom into it or something. Right. Yeah. Now, now it seems to be like, no, no. The use of wine in this was kind of directed right? I would say so. And and so if the way Joseph made that sound is is if we want to keep all the ordinances in heaven, this is kind of part of them. Am I misunderstanding that? That is exactly right? So now in in the Word of Wisdom, In the Word of Wisdom it is It is not given by commandment or constraint.

33:09 But we can see that the Lord says it's pleasing to Him. Actually, you know, in verse five it says, let's see. So in verse five it says it's not good to, you know, be partaking of wine or strong drink, except when you assemble yourselves together to offer pure sacraments. Then it is good, right? Then it is pleasing, and this it's not. But still the language is not commandment, it's just pleasing the Lord. And I mean, I mean that that alone is enough, maybe that we want to please the Lord and then we also we want the blessing too. So you know, the Word of Wisdom has blessings attached to it, right?

33:53 So as those who do these things and keep the commandments, we'll have all those things that the Word of Wisdom mentions at the end there. So I mean, that's two good reasons right there. But I am going to contend that at least this part of it, wine for the sacraments is a commanded thing. Now certainly if we look at the Old Testament sacraments or ordinances, wine was explicitly commanded for many of those things. The offerings that were made, they would offer an animal and along with the animal there was always bread and wine as part of it or or flour, you know, some kind of grain and wine offered as well. And those were certainly commanded things. And I think, and I think I'm going to make an argument here, that the other sacraments have that as a commanded component as well.

34:51 So let me ask some questions here. Let me play the other side of this argument here, OK? Why wouldn't the Lord just say, well, just have water? With your celebrations, water's more readily available, right? I think there can be an argument made of, you know, purity of water and those sorts of things. And you don't have the risk of intoxication. Yeah. Why wine? Why wine? I think wine is, I mean wine in. And again, this is in moderation, so I don't want again, I said it before already, but I'm just going to reiterate that I am not approving of or justifying drunkenness. So wine in moderation is and always has been just this symbol of joy.

35:48 Actually, I have a reverse here. Where was it? Well, Psalm. This is Psalm one O 414 through 15 talking about the blessings that God gives to us in abundance. He causes the grass to grow for the cattle, and herb for the service of man, that He may bring forth food out of the earth, and wine that maketh glad, the heart of man, and oil to make his face shine, and bread with bread which strengtheneth his heart.

36:29 So the wine is just connected to glad hearts and joy, and has always, has always been a symbol of that, and not only for man. So Psalm 104 says for man, but I love this verse from Judges. Judges 913 says this is actually from the the parable of the parable of the trees. OK, but the the Grapevine is you know, they want to make him king over the trees and he says no, I shouldn't be king of the trees but stick to making wine which he says which cheareth both God and man. So which is quite a thing to say if your God has no body parts or passions. But so wine cheers both God and man. So what?

37:20 This is where I'm going to irritate some people, but I'm used to it by now. So let's let's let's run with this. So as a guy who was a pretty accomplished drinker in his day, there is difference in the spirits that you partake of. OK, there just are. There's a reason whiskey fueled the West. And all the murderous rampages that happen there. There is something about wine in the right context where I wouldn't even call it a buzz, but it does loosen things up a little bit, does allow for maybe a greater feeling of love and camaraderie. It helps the walls come down a little bit. And when the Lord says, make.

38:15 Make it the heart. Glad. I think that's what he's referring to. Oh yeah. Right. It it does, you know, even even just one glass. Or as as you drink wine more and more, you become more accustomed to it, A couple glasses and all of a sudden, you know, you got people hugging it out, right? Not in a drunken stupor, right? I I don't want to present that. And I know this is foreign for a lot of people, especially my LDS listenership. I get that. But if you're ever at a wedding feast, just watch, just watch. After about the second glass, the smart ones back off, but everyone's a little more loving and and the hearts are a little fuller.

38:58 And I think that's why the Lord prescribes this, right? Not just says it's OK, but says use this, use this. It does produce kind of an altered state of consciousness, but I'm not sure that's always a bad thing. Oh yeah. And so I think this is one of those times where the Lord is like let some of those walls come down. Let the hearts speak to each other and and rejoice in that. Yeah. You know growing up latter day St., the the line that I was always kind of taught or either whether implicitly or explicitly was you know if you if someday you stray and you end up taking a sip of wine like you're going to go you're going to become an alcoholic you know and there it goes your life's just going to get flushed down the toilet and and so so this this will be strange to some of your listeners to to hear this but but that did not happen. OK, and my my.

40:12 You know, dipping my toe into the waters, so to speak, of, of making my own wine for Sacramento purposes was done with much trepidation, like very cautious about it. But you know nothing of the nothing of the sort has happened and I actually think that that that kind of teaching is actually quite dangerous. It's hugely dangerous. Because what what you've done now is that rather than give an example of what moderation looks like and temperance and those sorts of things, true temperance, all you've done is created forbidden fruit for your youth.

40:56 Yeah. And that's that's a dangerous component as well. Oh yeah, it's, it's, I mentioned guns earlier. It's like it's like making the guns forbidden in the house and never teaching the children how to use it and then you're just asking for a disaster. But the the safest way to have guns is to teach them how to use it responsibly to be, to be, to be safe and let them know that they they can and you know, use the gun. You just ask the parents, you know, under the parents supervision or whatever. So anyway, I think that's, yeah, that's just a lesson that can be applied in so many ways.

41:36 So OK, before before I move on, I actually just want to go back a little bit and just talk about sacraments because it in the word wisdom says wine or strong drink is not good except for in your sacraments. So you know, wine is kind of obvious, I think because you know, we we have the wedding feast at Cana. We have the sacrament of the Lord's Supper. We have those things in the Old Testament, you know, and Passover. Some people are familiar with that, like wine is a part of those ceremonies. But what about the strong drinks? Interesting there is, there is a temple ordinance that the mainstream church at least has lost, and I think most fundamentalists have lost this as well. I don't know if I can speak for all of them, but there was there was in former times an ordinance in between washing and anointing called the Ordinance of Purification, and we have a couple of accounts of that, so I'll just read one here. This is from Oliver Cowdery's sketchbook, January 16th, 1836, says.

42:48 And after pure water was prepared, we called upon the Lord and proceeded to wash each other's bodies and bathe the same with whiskey perfumed with cinnamon. This we did, that we might be clean before the Lord for the Sabbath, confessing our sins, And he goes on. Wilfred Woodruff's journal has an an account of this ordinance as well. But this I think is actually, you know, the deeper meaning of what verse five in the Word of Wisdom is talking about with strong drinks for Sacramento purposes. And it says for the washing of her bodies. And this is actually this is actually Temple stuff there that's it's kind of a a part of the washing anyway. So I just want to put that out there. I've.

43:44 I've heard of the the proverbial cinnamon whiskey bath. Yeah. And people have to understand this also filled a very. Practical part, right? Because this is given in a time where people weren't bathing real regularly. And if it was winter, if it was winter, you weren't bathing until late spring, right? And so you wouldn't want to file the Lord's house that way. And however, I think it deserves a second look because it was in there, right? And and it it it deserves. It deserves scholarly attention for sure.

44:26 OK, All right. Now, so you said what I think earlier. You said something like, why doesn't the Lord just come out and say use wine for these things? Did you ask a question kind of like that? No, I said. Why not use water? Oh, right. No, we use water. That's what you said. OK, OK, so actually I asked. So I when I when I started actually reading what the scriptures say and decided to start making wine, I still kind of kept it on the down low and but I kind of polled this is an informal poll of people and I asked this question. I think it's telling. I said if if the first presidency came to you, OK, so I'm taking the authority out of it, OK They came to you and asked you and they said, you know we're thinking of going back to wine for the sacrament and you know you get to make the decision what what do you think? And the responses I got were are quite telling. So some some people are like, like, so I asked my siblings and some of my siblings are like, well, I guess, you know, if it's up to me, I guess so you know, that might be OK And and some of my siblings are like, yeah, that's what scriptures say. And some of my siblings are like, says no way like I would have to like Jesus would have to

45:59 tell me that that's OK Yeah, I would. There would have to be a revelation from Jesus and and my thought was did. He already give you one? Oh all yeah, a dozen times there's a revelation from Jesus saying wine. The interesting thing is that in the scriptures, every single time the Lord's Supper at least is mentioned, it is always bread and wine that are not just recommended, that is, that is what's commanded, always. And every time where the sacrament of the Lord's Supper is partaken, it's always recorded that that is what was used. And water is never recommended.

46:42 Nope, never recommended. So. So where do we get, you know, where do we get that? Of course, it comes from section 27. We'll get, you know. Well, we'll get to that in a minute. But just as an example of a commandment. So this is in 3rd Nephi 18. Jesus is there discoursing with the Nephites and giving them instructions for various things, and he gives them instructions on the Lord's Supper as well. This is in I said third Nephi 18 starting at verse 8. And it came to pass, that when he said these words, he commanded his disciples, that they should take of the wine of the cup and drink of it, and that they should also give it unto the multitude, that they might drink of it. And it came to pass that they did so, and did drink of it, and were filled.

47:44 And they gave unto the multitude, and they did drink, and they were filled. And when the disciples had done this, Jesus said unto them, Blessed are ye for this thing which ye have done. For this is fulfilling my commandments, and skipping to verse 11 And this shall ye always do to those who repent, and are baptized in my name. Verse 12 And I give unto you a commandment, that ye shall do these things. And if ye shall always do these things, blessed are ye. 13 But whoso among you shall do more, or less than these are not built upon my rock, but are built upon a sandy foundation. Verse 14 Therefore blessed are ye if ye shall keep my commandments.

48:28 So doing any more or less than what Jesus said, put you on a sandy foundation. And I think it is. The irony is so incredibly thick that when we partake of the sacrament, and I mean this for most Mormons, so the entire LDS church and I've been to, I'm going to call out some people here. I've been to the AUB, their sacrament meetings. I've been to Peterson group, I've been to, I know the Kingstons, I know most of the big groups. They just use water.

49:11 And yet we have this not as a recommendation, a word wism, but a direct command to do this and to always do this. And then the irony is so thick because we're take this, we take this water and just and like while we're saying and always remember him and keep his commandments, which he has given them, right. So we're like promising to keep his commandments while we're not, right? That's a good point. That's a very good point. While we are changing the ordinance, it's it's amazing, but we don't think about it, you know, in those terms because. Right now, isn't there someplace in the scripture that said that you could use different? OK, emblems or not emblems, but different materials, so to speak.

50:01 So that's Section 27. OK, OK, so here's the story, right? Joseph. Joseph is going to a meeting. He's going to get wine for the meeting. He's met by a heavenly messenger. OK, And the Angel says, this is a Section 27 starting at verse 2. For behold, I say unto you, that it mattereth not what you shall eat, or what you shall drink when you partake of the sacrament, if it so be that you do it with an eye single to my glory, remembering unto the Father my body which was laid down for you, and my blood which was shed for the remission of your sins. Wherefore A commandment I give unto you, that you shall not purchase wine, neither strong drink of your enemies. Wherefore you shall partake of none except it is made new among you.

50:50 Yeah, in this my father's Kingdom, which shall be built up on the earth. So there it is. We're all kind of familiar with that, But do you know what happened after? So I've actually read this in more than one place. And your listeners, if you've studied this, you've probably read this too. You've probably read that the this was the beginning of the use of water. I've read that before. Or you know that OK, Joseph got this revelation and so instead of going to get wine, they just had their meeting with water or something like that. Now you can read this revelation in context in history of the Church.

51:39 This is in volume one, history of the Church. So this is what Joseph Smith says after he received this visitation. And I think it's amazing because this just shows what Joseph Smith thought that the Angel was saying. OK, so Joseph did not go back to the meeting with water, nor did he purchase wine from like some trusted source. Like as opposed to enemies, Joseph says in obedience to the above commandment, we prepared some wine of our own making and held our meeting.

52:20 So rather than taking the words of the Angel to mean go ahead and have water or go ahead and have beer or go ahead and drink olive oil or whatever, Joseph understood the revelation as make your own, you see. So that's quite a different thing real. Quick. How are they making their own that quick though? Oh, OK Ah, good question. OK, this. Let's see, I don't have it written down here. This revelation was given. I want to say it was in about September. So in other words, the grapes were on the vine and ready to be picked.

53:13 So they just pick some wine or some grapes and press the juice out of it and have that for the sacrament. OK, now that so. But that's grape juice. That's not wine, all right? That is new wine, OK. And I'll explain more on that in a minute what I the point that I want to say here is that, well, OK, well, I'll just say what new wine is first. Let's say that accent.

53:54 Yes. So new wine is from the moment, from the moment the juice, the grape juice is mixed with the yeast until a year from that time, when the next harvest is ready, that that space of a year that wine is new wine. Oh, OK. So from the moment the grapes are crushed and then mixed with the yeast, which is when the fermentation begins, right until until the next harvest, the next annual harvest, That's when the wine is new. And then after that it becomes old one. OK, OK, now between those two broad categories, old and new wine, which one? Which one can you buy?

54:43 The old Well, yeah. Buy buy both. Well, no, no, just old wine. Yeah, new wine is not for sale, right? Nobody likes new wine, right? I shouldn't say nobody drunks like new wine, right? Because like the in on the day of Pentecost. Like making fun of the. Some of the the naysayers are making fun of the apostles saying these guys are just drunk on new wine. It's the middle of the day and they just, they just want alcohol so bad, they'll even drink it new, you know? Right. So new new wine does not mean non alcoholic. OK, All right. Although it could be if it's very, very like right after it's crushed, Right. OK, OK. Now, here, here's another.

55:26 Here's another. Can't get enough of the Mormon Renegade podcast? Well, good news. We're on Patreon and there's three packages that you can choose from. The first one, the Slightly Rowdy package, allows you to hear the podcast without all those pesky commercials getting in the way. For those who want a slightly more in depth experience, there's the Stirring It Up package where you can hear ad free audio, ad free video and transcripts. Finally, for those who want to go full Renegade, that package is available too, where you can get everything in the previous two packages, plus an extra show where myself and Ben Winfield breakdown the news of the day from a very Mormon point of view. You will also get exclusive access to Renegade Chat, and on there you'll be able to talk to others about the show or whatever topics are on your mind. Go to Patreon today and get your exclusive content. This episode of the podcast is brought to you by Deseret flag.com.

56:22 I've said this before and I really mean it. Mormonism isn't just a religion, it's a culture. As such, it has its own vernacular and practices, but also its own symbols. And those symbols become even more important and prominent when you look back into our history. Perhaps one of the most recognizable symbols of Mormonism is the Deseret flag. This is the flag that I use as cover art in this podcast. This was also used for a good chunk of time during the pioneer era in Utah. Now, today we have people who want to replace the existing Utah flag with some other progressive monstrosity. Well, I think it's damp past time that we start pushing back here a little bit in Utah. Our friends at Defending Utah are here to help you with that. Now. If you go to deseretflag.com, you can now purchase your own Deseret State flag.

57:06 It's time here that we start making ourselves known and join the resistance against those who seek to rewrite our state's history. Go to deseretflag.com or check out the link in this episode's page show notes and get yours today. Well, let me go back to the old versus new. So new wine is not for sale. So when Joseph said he was going to purchase some wine, old wine was the kind he was getting. That's the kind that people drink. And so my interpretation of this, which is in keeping with the rest of the commandments of Jesus, like we just read in 3rd Nephi and in the New Testament and in other places in the Book of Mormon and the Doctrine Covenants and so on, is that when it says it mattereth, not.

57:51 What he's saying is it doesn't matter whether you have old, old or new wine, you can drink new wine. And so Joseph says, well, in obedience to the commandment, we made some of our own right there. So you know that's that's sort of so OK. So let me ask you this and maybe you're going to cover this down down the road here, there's a ton of people who either don't have the knowledge or don't have the space. To ferment their own wine? Yeah. In that case, what would be your understanding then of what they should use for the sacrament? Would they be OK buying old, You know, buying old wine only if it was made new among you?

58:45 So now you can use old wine as long as it was made new, which means originally made among your fellow Saints. It doesn't even doesn't have to be made by you, it has to be made among you. OK, it says so in verse or in the. In the word wisdom it says let's see in the in the words wisdom it says of your own make, yes. And then in in section 27 it says it clarifies a little more, says made new among you. So it means that the wine was made by a fellow St. fellow Israelite. Maybe you could say. And then if you don't have the equipment or the desire or the space or whatever to make your own, then you know, then there's some guy in your group or you know who's the designated wine maker.

59:40 And that's totally good, OK? And old wine is fine. It just needs to be. It can't. It doesn't say that it can't be aged among you as well, just that it needs to be made among you. OK, OK, so it's interesting though in section 27, Jesus actually says what he's going to do and this is kind of further clarification because scripture page turning sounds. That's all good. They know it's real. Right, so like in verse two it talks about you know it mattereth not. What you shall eat or drink.

1:00:21 But it's kind of like those bracelets, you know, the WWJD like what would Jesus do? Right. So Jesus says, you know it doesn't matter what you drink, but just so you know, I'm going to tell you what I'm going to do. OK? And he says, Marvel not, this is verse 5 marvel not for the hour cometh that I will drink of the fruit of the vine on with you on the earth with. Moroni and Elias and John and and he goes on and and Joseph and Jacob and Isaac and Abraham and Adam and Peter. James and John. So he's Jesus is like saying, hey, you know, even if you think it's water, even if you think water's OK.

1:01:09 Yeah, Which is, which is I would say, an interpretation. I don't think it's a good interpretation, but it's an interpretation. Even if that's your interpretation, Jesus is saying. Go ahead and do what you want, just letting you know when, when me and my buddies come for the party at the end of the world, we're going to be drinking wine, right? And so, and you know what else? He says, says, he says, he says. And all those who my father hath given me out of the world, we're going to all be drinking wine. So you can do what you want, but if you want to be in that party, just letting you know. We're going to be drinking. I'm just saying it's a hell of a time to be trying to find your limits on what you can drink, so.

1:01:51 So yeah, you know when we when my family kind of first started doing it, actually it's kind of funny. The the very first time that I made wine, it was for it was for Passover. OK. So growing up, you know, we, we done the Passover, but you know, but we were Latter Day Saints and so you know we'd all just have grape juice. You know that we we, you know, steamed, juiced our. Her own grapes. And, you know, that's all good. But, you know, I was reading more. And then my my father passed away and kind of I'm in charge of Passover. And so I decided, you know, with much study and trepidation, like I said, we're going to try making a batch of wine and we're going to have wine with the Passover. But I have no idea what wine is supposed to taste like.

1:02:33 Oh, OK, hold on first. How'd your mom take that? Well, my mom had passed away. Oh, OK, so. So, no. So, so it was me and my siblings, OK And actually we just had wine at my table and you know, my siblings had juice. I got you. And they didn't know the difference. I got you. So she didn't, she didn't know anything about it. Well, I guess she knew. She know. Know she knows. She was. I should have just answered you. She was proud. Yeah. There you go. There you go. She was proud that her boy was doing the right thing. So anyway, I had no idea what because I'd never. Touched a drop of wine in my life, so I actually went to the liquor store right, and just kind of bewildered to look at all the selection and just picked out something that was kind of mid range in price. Seems like a safe bet.

1:03:23 And yeah, we tasted. So then when our first batch was done like fermenting, it was done bubbling and it seemed like it was ready to drink. Then we tried some of the store bought stuff 1st and it was horrendous. Yeah, it was like, it was like nail Polish remover or something like boat cleaner. And man, I immediately appreciated wine of your own make because it was actually quite a bit better. Yeah, yeah. And this is where I feel like a public service announcement is needed. If you're going to try buying old wine, stay away from wine that comes in boxes. Not a good look, so. It was in a bottle.

1:04:05 It was in a bottle. I know, I know. I'm just. Yeah. But yeah. OK. There's another little service announcement. Yeah, very good. OK, man. So yeah, I know there there is such thing as bad stuff, I mean. Oh, so, OK. So you know, and I, I will say too, just just kind of going back to if someone doesn't feel like they have the equipment or whatever, I actually have a book, OK. And I'm kind of flipping through it right now as we're talking. It is called wine of your own make. By Joshua Erickson It's spiral bound. I used to have it like bound the regular way, you know, with glue or whatever. But people like to spiral bound better because in addition to like scriptures and history like justifications for an arguments in favor of. This is also a recipe book.

1:04:58 Gotcha. So this has recipes for both bread and wine. OK, so you can. So it's a recipe book so we can lay out flat on the kitchen counter or whatever. So this book is how do they get ahold of you if they want to buy a copy? Yeah, you know, probably the best thing is to shoot me an e-mail. OK, so. And the best e-mail would probably be Restoration Torah Conference. At gmail.com. I'll throw that in the show notes, OK. All one word. And I don't check in that every day. But now if you're down kind of southern Utah County Confetti Books has some.

1:05:38 And also down in Santaquin, Kevin Kraut at old Pioneer Press at his print shop. They've got some copies in there too. Right on. Actually, Kevin printed it for me, so OK, All right. Now so there is there is a there is a debate in the Christian world, and certainly in the Mormon world too, about about whether new wine is alcoholic or about whether like Jesus at the Last Supper. Like I've heard that you know, the New Testament says wine. But of course Jesus wouldn't do that because Jesus obeys the Word of Wisdom and so didn't end in the account. And.

1:06:23 And I could be wrong. I'm just. I'm not a scripterian. I don't play one. Yeah. Didn't it say? Didn't he tell his disciples to go purchase one? No. Right before the. Passover. You know what? Yeah, He said go purchase things needful for the feast. Yeah, OK, Yeah, that's right. But that was that's totally fine. I what I guarantee you is that they were not purchasing Roman One. Gotcha. OK, They were perching Israelite wine. OK And you know, actually I'm going to, that has a beautiful little aside there because oftentimes in Word wisdom lessons, you probably heard this, like, story of Daniel, Shadrach, Meshach and Abednego that gets brought up all the time because they refused Nebuchadnezzar's wine and meat. Right.

1:07:07 And so we're like, oh, look at this perfect Word of wisdom example. And then and Daniel was keeping the Word of Wisdom. But it it wasn't because it wasn't because he was avoiding alcohol. Jews, I'm sorry, like Jews do not have a problem with wine, OK, Daniel did not have a problem with wine. That is just, I don't know what there's words that we're just reading into that from our own culture or something. Some weird interpretation. But Daniel was perfectly in keeping with the Word of Wisdom, like especially I guess Doctrine Covenants 27, that you shouldn't be having wine from your enemies, should be of your own make or made among you.

1:07:53 OK, so he was keeping it, but not for the reason that most people suppose. And and same with the meat too. It wasn't necessarily a Word of Wisdom thing. But this is other commandments from the Torah that you're not in in a lot of these Pagan countries. Like, every. Every bit of meat is offered to bail first, like when, like the priests are the butchers and they say a prayer to bail before they slit the animal's throat and then, you know, then the meat goes on the market, but it's been consecrated to bail or Molech or one of the other. Whoever. Yeah, yeah. So coast to hell. That's exactly right.

1:08:35 So, so Daniel was. He's not concerned with the things that we think he was concerned with, OK? Didn't they also eat a lot more pork in in Babylon, in those areas? Yeah. And those, Yeah, pork and shellfish. And who knows what other kinds of, quote meat was being eaten? Horses and camels. And. Right. I don't know. I'm no historian of that. But yes, certainly unclean animals were part of that meat. So, OK, so. So yeah, so I've heard people say even like, probably the, like the Last Supper was just grape juice or grape syrup or something like that. But you know what?

1:09:20 That was in a time on this planet when there was no such thing as pasteurization nor refrigeration, right? OK. And the Passover is in springtime. And the grape harvest is in fall. The fall time, the grape harvest is basically six months from. There's no way that stuff is staying. That is not, that is not unfermented juice that they're having at the Last Supper. That was 100% alcoholic wine. Yeah. And there's no problem with that. There's nothing to be nothing that Jesus needs to be ashamed of, you know? Right.

1:10:01 OK. Now if we if we weren't sure then. So in in in section 27, right, Jesus says he's going to be drinking of the fruit of the vine with all his besties. And if you want to be there, you're going to be drinking of it too. So go back to my story about buying the the store bought wine. So sometimes we we joke that it would be good if you would try some wine for the sacrament now, so you can kind of get used to it because the last thing you want to do when like there's the wedding feast and Jesus hands you the cup. You don't want to make a face, you know, You don't want to do that soon to be embarrassing. So OK, so but some people might still say, you know, well, yeah, when it says fruit of the vine in section 27 is still Jesus is going to be partaking of grape juice.

1:10:51 OK. But we go to the doctrine of covenant, section 58 and it says talking about the the marriage of the Lamb, the Big, the Big feast at the end. It says also that a feast of fat things is Doctrine of Covenants 58, verse 8. A feast of fat things might be prepared for the poor. Yeah, yeah, a feast of fat things. Of wine on the leaves, Well, refined. So what is wine on the leaves? You know, what are leaves? So again, this is a word that Latter Day Saints are not generally familiar with. I'll tell you what leaves are, though. Leaves is the sediment. That is leftover after grape juice has fermented into wine leaves is mostly made of dead yeast cells that kind of settle to the bottom.

1:11:40 So the kind of wine that Jesus is going to be having is going to be wine on the leaves. In other words, it's fermented because that's the only kind of wine that. Has Lee's right is after the fermentation is complete. OK, OK, so there you go. Lee's That word. Lee's definitely wasn't Welch's. Not Welch's. That's right. There's another interesting one. I'm gonna have you read this. OK. Isaiah. Isaiah 65, verse eight. It's like I've had people point this out to me before and it's, you know, it's. I have an argument for it, so OK, just one second. Yeah, no problem.

1:12:29 Isaiah 65 What? Verse 8. Now this verse is not talking about, you know, using wine for the sacrament or anything like that. OK, But it has, you know, an interesting footnote. So go ahead and read the verse, OK? And thus saith the Lord, as the new wine is found in the cluster, and once saith, destroy it for a blessing it is is in it, So will I do for my servant's sake, that I will may that I may not destroy them all. OK, so it says right there the new wine is in the cluster, right? Right. And So what do you look at? You look at the footnote for a new wine.

1:13:10 Yeah, a a grape juice. New wine is ta da grape juice. And how do we know that? Because it says. The new wine is in a cluster. Of course. Grapes aren't alcoholic, right? OK, ah, but a cluster of grapes has actually more than just there's juice inside the grapes, but it's more than just juice. So you've held handled grapes before. You know that on the outside of the grapes there's kind of a white film, kind of a powdery film. That's called Bloom, and that is a layer. And all the grapes in the world have this, this is naturally occurring layer of yeast, really. So when you say the new wine is in the cluster, yeah, that's because as soon as you crush those grapes, boom. Then the juice touches the yeast and fermentation begins and it is.

1:14:06 So the new wine is right there. It's like grapes are made to be wine. It's like a little wine making kit that God made for us. Now if if anyone's listening and you want to try making wine and you go to the store and get grape juice, which is totally fine. I've made wine that way a bunch of times. And you you pour it out like you're going to have to add yeast to that because the the juice at the store has been pasteurized, so they've killed the natural naturally occurring yeast there. But if you just take grapes and stomp on them or whatever, right? Or put them in a winepress. Then the yeast is right there and you don't need to add anything, it will just turn into wine automatically. Wow.

1:14:53 So let's talk about holiness now. So back in section 27, verse two says. Behold, it mattereth not what ye shall eat, or what ye shall drink, when ye partake of the sacrament, If it so be that ye do it with an eye single to my glory, remembering unto the Father my body which was laid down for you, and my blood, which was shed for the remission of your sins. Verse 3. Wherefore A commandment I give unto you, that you shall not purchase wine, neither strong drink of your enemies. Verse 4.

1:15:40 Wherefore. You shall partake of none of it, except it is made new among you. Yeah, in this my father's Kingdom, which shall be built up upon the earth, so. Oh, you're going to say something? Yeah. So I have a question about who would be classified as our enemies. Is that anybody not Mormon? Well, I that might depend on who you ask. I, as you know, am a very big tent. Mormon, Right. So I'm. I'd be happy with, I'd be happy with any Israelite. OK, OK.

1:16:20 So I'd be happy with, you know, yeah. Any any a Mormon of any stripe or or any Jewish winery or whatever. Like, I'd be fine with that too, actually. OK, OK now. Verse 3 mentions enemies. OK and you just ask a question about that and usually we think like what do we think? Why does it say not to purchase it? Because of your enemies? Well, First off I would. There's a couple of reasons that spring to my mind. 1st is it's like buying oil from Saudi Arabia.

1:17:05 It's the it's like getting the belt for your old man before he whoops you with it. It's kind of a a a a silly exercise to give him a club that they're about to beat you with. Second, they might have some special Mormon wine, right? And yeah, I got something for you. You're gonna love this one. Yeah. And and maybe maybe less than sanitary conditions. Right. So I think that those are certainly. Valid reasons like the the fear of poison, like actually someone doing you harm. I love that you brought up the the financial thing too, because I think that's actually. I think that the first answer you gave is actually closer in my mind, to the the primary reason is we don't want to be dependent upon our enemies for the practice of our religion, Right.

1:17:59 OK. You know I work for the for the army and you know this just is my opinion, not speaking for the US government or anything, but for a long time I think still like the the TNT that the military uses to fill our munitions right is all, it's all made in China. We get our the raw materials to make ammunition from. China instead of making it ourselves because it's just because it's cheaper or whatever and I'm like that's not really a good trade off. I would pay. I would pay a little more to be self-sufficient in our defense.

1:18:42 Yep, absolutely. So we use a lot of TNT. But anyway, so I love that. I think that's a big part of it. It is important to. I've talked to people who. Believe the poison idea is so ingrained that I've talked to people who even say that poison is mentioned in section 27 as the reason, which is not. And people have been surprised like a Mandela effect. Like I swear it said something about poison which it does not. Now section 89 also says conspiring men and stuff, right? Right. But here's an interesting thing. Is like if. If section 89 says conspiring men and you know section 27 says don't purchase of your enemies, why is it?

1:19:27 Why is it only the wine like, But it doesn't say anything about the rest of your food, Your bread? Your your your wheat? Sure. Yeah, you can poison fruits and vegetables and meat and grain and beer just as well as you can poison wine, right? So. So why is it that that we're not concerned with? Purchasing those things from enemies or gentiles or outsiders or whatever. But we are. But wine is some something special, and my contention is that it's something special because it is related to our religious observance and we do not want to be reliant upon Babylon for the practice of our religion, right? We want the Kingdom needs to be independent, right? OK Of all other.

1:20:18 Towers Under. Heaven, I don't know what your problem is. I'm sure the UN would do a fine job. It's like a great way to give people vaccines or something. Yeah, yeah, they. Do great. Put it in the beat. OK, OK, now it is an interesting that verse two it says yeah, it doesn't matter what you eat or drink, but it says to do it with an eye single to my glory, remembering my body and my blood shed for the remission of your sins. And then in verse three and four it has this one. Verse 3 says don't purchase it from enemies and #4 says make it new, but both of those are prefaced 3 and four by the word wherefore? So what does wherefore mean?

1:21:06 It's a word we maybe don't use that often anymore. But wherefore just means therefore, which means because of this right? So now if poison is the concern, then what those verses are essentially saying, and I'm kind of paraphrasing here, but it'll say verse two says do the sacrament with an eye single to my glory, remembering my body which was laid down, my blood which was shed for your sins. Make this a holy, sacred experience because of this. Wherefore, watch out for poison, OK? It's like this sort of kind of incongruent ideas, right?

1:21:48 Make this a holy experience. Therefore, because of that, because I want you to do that. Watch out for poison. Right. So let me push here a little bit because I'm curious how far we, we take this. We don't have the same prohibition on olive oil, and that's used heavily in our sacraments, even in the temple, correct? There's There seems to be no prohibition against buying olive oil at the store that's extra virgin and consecrating that. Yeah, that's Wouldn't the same pizza good? Why? Why wouldn't the same be true of wine if you consecrated it first? Yeah, yeah, I would.

1:22:34 Although you are correct, Sir, that there is there is no specific injunction to make your own olive oil, I do believe that that is the intention of the scriptures and certainly this was. Certainly this was explicit for ancient Israel and all the scriptures that apply to ancient Israel. So when I say it doesn't say it in modern revelation, in the Doctrine Covenants or whatever. It does say it in the Torah. Right. Says to the Israelites, bring your oil and your wine right from your harvest for these sacraments, for these ordinances. So, and you know, you couple that with also what I believe is the desire, the Lord's desire for the Saints to be independent in all things.

1:23:37 Yes, the Doctrine Covenants may not have a specific revelation even about even about simple things you know about making bricks or you know or having a a sawmill or whatever. And yet I still believe that it is the Lord's intention for the Saints to have all of those things and to be fully independent in all of our manufacturing. That was Brigham's idea. That was Joseph's idea, right. Yes. We are going to build not necessarily going to set up a church, we're going to build a city and then we're going to build a nation and we're going to re establish Israel, right. Yeah.

1:24:17 So. So that's kind of a that was an excellent question. But I think, I think the scriptures would support even having now if you if you don't have your own olive press, what do you do if you don't have your own vineyards? What do you do if you if you don't have, you know these things well you do the best you can, right? OK. And. And I think that's what 27 was speaking to there, right? It's like here's the preferred method. Absent this, you can go to that, right. And I think yes.

1:24:59 So actually I'll say, you know, so, so Brigham, just to bring him up, that was the whole. Point of Saint George in a lot of ways. Oh yeah, that's right. Yeah. So down Saint George and Tocerville. Yeah. They had the Dixie wine mission. Yep. Yeah. And actually when the when the Saints first arrived, they actually found grapevines growing down there. Native native plants and they're like, oh this is good country for growing grapes. And so yeah, Brigham sent sent missions down there to cultivate grapes and supply wine for the territory.

1:25:45 Now that was never, that was actually never quite fully achieved, I guess, but they but that was the that was the goal. So journal discourse is 19 Brigham verse or page 92 Brigham's talking about this. He says. Consequently we use water as though it were wine, for we are commanded to drink not of wine for the sacred purpose, except it be made by our own hands. So now even though Brigham said that he was not content to just keep on using water right forever, like, I mean we've heard, I kind of liken this to and you've probably heard stories of soldiers in foxholes or whatever, sure. Having the sacrament with water from their canteen and potato peels or something like that.

1:26:41 I think I don't have any judgment for that, no, you know. I would think the Lord would rather you do that than go without. Yeah, but. But when we get to a place where we can have bread then, and we persist in eating potato peels, then I think that would be that becomes displeasing, yes. And when we get to a point where we could have wine, but we persist in drinking Gatorade or having water or anything else, then I think it becomes displeasing. Yeah, so, so, OK, so now there's only, so, you know, we want to please the Lord, we want blessings, There's commandments behind this.

1:27:45 And there's also, there's also symbolism right behind this. So these are all reasons to to actually obey the word of. Wisdom, right? Yep. And by obeying the word of is what I mean having wine for sacraments. OK, so and of course I mean you can probably you can probably think of some like what is some symbolism in of grapes and with wine? With wine, well. Let's just go to the sacrament right here. That's the ones. Give me some ideas. As you know. Mormons of most stripes are going to use it's blood, right? I mean, you look at it. That's right.

1:28:25 It's a symbolic equivalent in the scripture. Symbolic equivalent. It's, you know, and certainly I'm kind of a big believer that if you use wine for the sacrament, it probably shouldn't be, shouldn't be the the sweetest wine out there either, right? I think there's something to be said for the Bitter cut, Bitter cup. And so I think I think that that. This is my own opinion and mine alone. I don't want anyone to think I'm, I'm preaching gospel here, but I'm thinking for those kind of things, right? I think. I think you'd want a little bit of a bitter cup. Interesting. I would also say for things like weddings and those sorts of things, probably something a little bit sweeter, something that that that goes pair up the occasion right. I like it.

1:29:14 I have a friend, Richard. Anyway, he he says he he he he thinks that exact same thing for the sacrament. He says this that, like the cup itself is symbolic of the of Jesus's suffering, because at first it's bitter, but then afterwards there comes joy, right? Right. And that's kind of the order that things happened with the atonement. Bitter at first, but then once it's finished then it's time to celebrate, right? Well. And, and, and let's say this too, right? I think there's symbolism also that that with with the sacrament maybe something that causes a little bit of burning in the bosom. Oh yeah, that's right.

1:30:00 To have the spirit be more abundantly with you, yeah. How is the spirit often described? I I think. I think there's symbolism here and it's rich and deep, right? And until we we stop to think for a minute and say. Are we missing out by just using water? We need to. We need to really take a good hard look and and take a step back. So sometimes, sometimes alcohol, usually distilled things are called spirits. Yep. Right. And so, so that the wine has spirit in it. Yeah. And you can feel that burn, right, right. And so that's that is a part of the. Symbol Alcohol's got a different burn, right? I would say that's more of a could be more of a a fire, right.

1:30:54 Yeah. If you're. If you're having distilled. Yeah. Right. Yes, yes, yes, yes. With with wine, it's very, it's a very subtle, it's warm warmth. That's right. Yep. Yep. But it's part of the symbolism. It is. Yep. And we call it spirit. Yep. So that's cool. You know another another bit of symbolism that I love is that that wine is a symbol of, of course it's of course it's the it's connected to the atonement, but it's, I think specifically and beautifully a symbol of death and resurrection, right? OK, so the difference between mortal and immortal bodies go. Well, the difference is that you're not as far as as far as physiological differences.

1:31:42 Right, physiological differences. Well, we could go back to some things that I more specific what's in the. Veins, veins, spirit at that point, right. Yeah. So it starts out so blood becomes spirit. Yep. Yeah. And you know, when blood is in the veins, in the vessels, then then the flesh, the body is corruptible. And so when you make wine, first you crush the grapes, the blood quote, blood of the grapes comes out. And then there's a transformation that takes place and the blood turns into spirit and then it's becomes incorruptible because there's this thing that ferments, which I mean, ferment is kind of a polite way of saying rot, right?

1:32:40 Fermentation is the kind of rot that we don't mind eating or drinking, I guess. Right. Right. But but that really what is what it is? Microbial action, right. So, but then it turns into something that actually gets better with age, right? Right. Which is something that improves and and maintains and doesn't and doesn't spoil anymore, right? Which is what wine is versus grape juice, you see? Yeah. Well, and and, and here's, here's the other thing I'll say right there was a quote and I can't remember who said it, but I want to say it was one of the later leaders of the LDS Church. And I'm sure allusions to this were made by both Joseph and Brigham.

1:33:22 Those are early brethren, that Levitical order. The, the, the ironic priesthood, I should say, that administers the sacrament. I remember someone said you have to picture yourself as offering, not offering, but offering up the sacrifice, right? Yeah, the tearing of flesh. The bread, right. The the, the bleeding of the of the Gray heavy stuff. Right. It's heavy, heavy stuff. I think it's also symbolic of that broken heart, right? That tearing that. Oh yes, that breaking apart, right. And out of that and and there's certain symbols that are to be used that I think are best for that, right.

1:34:10 And and wine is certainly among them. Absolutely actually love what he just said. I'm gonna skip ahead a little bit, but in ancient times, when you know in Hebrew, when you know in the Old Testament when someone quote makes a covenant. They cut a covenant. That's right. It's correct. Now, if you're familiar with the old school garment, yeah, Amen. Right. There is some rich symbolism there that's not necessarily there in the in the the street garment if you will, right. Yes, that's exactly right.

1:34:52 So that actually it's it's interesting because when when like when people would make a covenant, very often what they would do they they would yeah they would cut the covenant and like we get you know that's a Hebrew idiom gets translated as make a covenant. But in English we have similar idioms cut a deal. We say we cut a deal or we strike a bargain. Right. Right. And this comes from this, the Hebrew idea of of covenants and they would they would kill an animal and when they would make it an agreement and actually cut the animal into two pieces and walk between them. Yep. And and the agreement was if if we keep our end of the bargain, then the animal dies.

1:35:41 Right. But if we break it, then we will die right then. Whatever was done to the animal, may it be done right to us. Right. And so there's a beautiful thing about that like, and and the Bible actually has examples of this, like when when God, when Jehovah makes the covenant with Abraham, right, he actually cuts the animal in pieces. And Jehovah actually goes in between. It says in Hebrews the New Testament says God swore by his own life. Yep. That he would make Abram a great nation, basically. OK And in Jeremiah, there's another example of this. In the Book of Mormon, we have Captain Moroni, right? Raising the title, literally.

1:36:31 And all the men come running and they tear their garments and throw them at his feet and basically say we will keep the commandments and defend liberty. Otherwise, may those garments be symbolic of us? Like, absolutely. So yeah. So when you tear the bread, if you're faithful, then that's Jesus flesh. Yep. And if you're not, then what you're doing is saying May this be my flesh? Yep. And that's what it means by eateth and drinketh damnation to your soul. Yeah. And my blood. Yep. Yeah. So. Which unlocks a whole new meaning to wine of your own mate, because wine is blood.

1:37:22 Right. So if you. Yeah, again, you partake of the sacrament, you do it honorably, you're upholding your end of the bargain. You're not doing it frivolously. I don't mean you're perfect, OK? That's not. That's not what the covenant requires. No, but but you take it honorably, let's say, then that's Jesus's blood. If you don't, that's your own blood. And who made your own blood? Jesus, I'm well, look, God you. Yeah, OK. Oh, that is wine of your own make, OK? All right.

1:38:03 Yeah. OK. I see. That's wine in your own. That's you in your own vein, your very own, your very own. Flesh and blood is what is what is on the line. So the Word of Wisdom is actually there's, you know that phrase of your own make is. Carry some some significance, some weight. Yes. So, you know, this goes, this goes back to, I mean, I mean Doctrine Covens 19. Here's another good example of that. Right. If they would not repent, they must suffer even as I Right. Right. It's going to be you. Isaiah 49. I will feed them that oppress thee with their own flesh. They shall be drunken with their own blood as with sweet wine, and all flesh shall know that I the Lord and thy Savior and Redeemer the mighty one of Jacob. So you know even of course the the sacrament has echoes of the the Passover sure too and the Word Wisdom at the at the very end has the Passover promise.

1:39:09 Right. Destroying Angel passed by and you know the the children of Israel how did they how did they protect their houses? They got a lamb. Whose lamb? Was it their own lamb and they would get the blood of the lamb. How would they get it themselves, right. That was their own. That was their own blood. That was blood of blood of their own make that they put on the door. OK so. So there's a lot of that kind of symbolism there. So heavy stuff, that's heavy stuff. So that's I think we that's probably maybe a good, a good spot place to stop I guess.

1:39:54 I don't know if you got more questions or. No, I don't think so. I think we we covered it pretty well and as was with most things as as time goes along it seems to get diluted right And so I always look back and I say. Why aren't we doing the things that they did in the early days And a lot of people like to just say, well, it different times, right? I mean we you didn't have, you know, I've heard all sorts of excuses, right? Like, well, the water was dirtier back then. You didn't want to use that and and just all sorts of excuses that ring hollow. Certainly. I've used wine in the sacraments we've done at home and there is a different feel. There is a different, a different level of sanctity because of that.

1:40:48 And it's not like we're drinking a lot, right? We're still using the sacrament cups, right? Essentially. But it is different. It is different that it's his own blood becomes a little more literal in some ways, right? Because of just its appearance and and the bitter cup. I think it's worth pursuing. It's worth looking at. Hey, man, I'm. I'm gonna say. I'm gonna, I'm gonna throw your listeners a bone here, because some people may still, despite everything I've said, everything we've said, still be just uncomfortable with proper wine. OK?

1:41:29 Used juice. Yeah, It's better than water. And you know what? I will even. I will even grant you a loophole exemption. Because it is true that grape juice is pasteurized, but it is also true that yeast spores are in the air. And so as soon as you pour the wine out of that hermetically sealed bottle, you know that Welch's Grape Juice or whatever it is, Winco or Walmart, as soon as you pour it out, there's actually yeast spores in the air that are going to land in there. Yeah, and. You know, the definition I gave earlier of new wine was from the moment the juice touches the yeast until a year. So.

1:42:17 So I would, I would grant, yeah, juice even from a bottle. If you opened up the bottle yourself and poured it out. Yeah. And then it touched the air. There you go. New wine. Yep. The newest possible wine and. And here's the other thing I'd say, 'cause I I I have heard this before and it was something quite frankly, I was scared of as a guy who used to have and a horrible drinking problem. You're a little hesitant, right? You're a little twitchy, right? I'll say this, It's pretty hard to turn back into a raging alcoholic from a sacrament cup full of wine. It's a different animal. Not to say there's no such thing as winos 'cause. There are, but it's it's pretty Chances are if if you're practicing A sacrament, you've probably worked your way beyond that a little bit.

1:43:14 Right? So. That's good. The other thing I'll say too, you mentioned like space constraints or equipment or whatever in this book. Actually, the recipes that I have, I recommend actually that people's first experience making wine is in a 2 liter bottle. Right. So you get A2 litre bottle with juice and some yeast just bread yeast is fine and and a balloon stretched over the top to keep the air out with a hole with a pinhole in it. That's that's all the space and the equipment that you need basically. So it's not, it's not hard if you get if you get online and try to read about making wine, it's going to be overwhelming and it's going to be.

1:44:04 Technical and there's going to be all these terms that you never heard of and it's going to be intimidating. Those aren't made for the religious user those are made for. Those are wine snobs. Yep, we're talking about you need you only like people do this in prison. OK, so it's real easy. Don't do it in your toilet. It's real easy. It's nothing to be intimidated over. I think a lot of that stuff is. Like just snobbery for the purpose of snobbery for the purpose of luxury? Sure it is. Yep. You know, and that, I mean, that's OK too, but but it doesn't need to be intimidating or difficult. It's quite easy. So that's what I got to say, you know, awesome. Repent if you're, you know if you're using water. If you've been using water and means are available to have wine of your own make, then you should be doing that. It is.

1:45:02 It is what Savior directly commanded. Yep, directly commanded. And I think there's there's not really an excuse. So if you're if you're in a, you know, a group or a church that doesn't allow it, then then do it at home. You know, because you know you don't want to following the prophet or your leader, whatever is great. But you don't want to. But you're you are responsible for your own soul as well, right? Work out your own salvation before the Lord with fear and trembling. Yeah, yeah, right. Joseph kind of famously said, let's see, I don't know if it's in the book, I think here, but you've kind of famously said that, you know, the Saints were kind of. Their minds were darkened, right? Because they were just following their their leaders, even in error, I think it was he was referencing Moses when the people were refused to follow Moses up the mountain. Yes, yes, yeah, he read from Ezekiel. Anyway, can't find it right now.

1:46:19 But I think you're familiar with the quote, but I, you know I think that's the last thing that any. Any the leader of any church would actually want, no one would actually say, yeah, follow me, even in error, no one wants that. Right? And everyone makes errors, you know, I'm not, you know, disparaging that. But when when you have received greater light and understanding, then, then don't refuse that. Be cautious, but be bold. Absolutely, absolutely. There's there's and. And like you said, I mean, like we talked about, there's rich symbolism there to be had.

1:47:03 And look, if you're a POWI, we the Lord gets it, right? Take the sacrament with what you got. But if you have the means, you have the ability. There's there's what the Lord will accept, and then there's the preferred method. I have heard. OK, and maybe you know something about that. I've heard that baptism by sprinkling was first out of, like, expedience, because I think it was Constantine. Yep, he's on his deathbed and they can't really go dunk him. So he gets sprinkled just out of a because of the situation.

1:47:44 Yep. And then that becomes the norm. That becomes the standard. And you think is God happy with baptism by sprinkling just because it He tells you he is not? Yeah, yeah. When, when there's water available, you, you better not be doing something contrary to what was commanded. Absolutely, yeah. If you're out in the, if you're in the middle of the Sahara Desert and you know you're a fellow, you got someone else stranded there with you and they've never been baptized, you know, maybe maybe sprinkling's appropriate then. I don't know. But I would say that when you get back to civilization, you better don't. Come do it properly, right? Absolutely. That's exactly right. Good stuff. Well, dude, that was awesome.

1:48:25 Thank you. Yeah, My pleasure. Awesome. All right. Bye everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.