Episode #102: Changing Ordinances, Changing Priesthood W/Drew Briney
Go To http://patreon.com/MormonRenegade368 For Exclusive Content
One of the biggest things we as fundamentalists watch for is changing ordinances. As Joseph Smith said, “If there is no change of ordinances, there is no change of priesthood.” Now this seems simple on the surface but when does something become a change, verses cleaning up the language of an ordinance? Well today I have Drew Briney back on the podcast to talk about his new book “Changing Ordinances, Changing Priesthood?” that tries to explain just that. Drew breaks down historical incidences of change both in and out of the LDS Church and evaluates what those changes mean to us as Mormons and disciples of Christ.
Go To deseretflag.com to get your Deseret Flag Today
https://www.amazon.com/Changing-Ordinances-Losing-Priesthood-Briney-ebook/dp/B0CN2LLBDL
https://www.facebook.com/groups/1387509248835311/?ref=share_group_link
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:04 One of the biggest things we as fundamentalists watch for is changing ordinances. It's pretty important stuff. As Joseph Smith said, if there's no change in ordinances, there's no change of priesthood. Now this seems pretty simple on the surface, but when does something become a change versus cleaning up the language of an ordinance? Well, the day I have Drew Briny back on the podcast to talk about his new book, Changing Ordinances, Changing Priesthood, that tries to explain just that. Drew comes on and breaks down historical incidences of change both in and out of the LDS Church and evaluates what those changes mean to us as Mormons and disciples of Christ. That's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. OK, just a couple of quick announcements here. If you're looking for a place to attend sacrament meeting and don't know where to go, I want you to reach out to me, me and other stand ready to help you find a spiritual home, whether that's a new church, a gathering spot of independence, OR even if you just need a soft place to land for a time to learn how to have sacrament meaning in your own home. Myself and others stand ready to help you find that place. All you got to do is just drop me a line at mormonrenegade@gmail.com and we'll quickly reach out to you to help you find the place you want and need to be next. I have felt for a while now that the sisters haven't had a good place to go to have their questions answered without a bunch of dudes creeping around to fill this need. My wife, Tanya has set up a Facebook group just for women to talk about questions about fundamentalism. The name of that group is Mormon Fundamentalism for Women. Now just a warning, if you're a
1:38 dude thinking about trying to jump on this site, I'm going to give this to you in my best Liam Neeson impression. I have a certain set of skills and I'll find you and I will publicly mock you endlessly without mercy for many, many weeks. So whether you're a fundamentalist woman seeking sisterhood or a woman investigating fundamentalism, this place is for you again. The name of that Facebook group is Mormon Fundamentalism for Women. Look, it's no secret that our society has become much more crude and coarse. To become and raise men and women of virtue and character is a Herculean task. To help with this, I've recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior and Company and Conversation.
2:22 It was a book with 110 rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society, something that today's society is sorely lacking. What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So the book is laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule. Right below that is my explanation for the 21st century, and below that you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, to go along with this, there's a workbook that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids. To find the book, go to mormonrenegade.com, go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post, and order your copy.
3:05 Today I can bear personal testimony from personal experience that this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.
3:53 Good. Welcome back, big guy. Thanks, sorry I got a pop up on my on my computer. No problem, it happens. Yeah, everything going good. Most everything. Yeah, super glad to. To you know I'm I'm out here kind of sort of on my own and it's it's so good to have somebody to chat with about the gospel and and visit about these things and even just stay and pray together is super cool. So yeah, I'm happy. It's good. Well dude, if you're happy to talk to me, you need to get better friends. So, well, I'll take that under advisement.
4:35 Yeah. Well, dude, I'll tell you what, your project that you were working on with the Doctrine and Covenants, I know a couple people who grabbed, grabbed some of that. They were astounded. And so when I saw that you had yet another book coming out, I was like, oh, we got to talk about it because the title of it, the title of it even, is intriguing because this is one of those things that that I find you have to really dive into when you get into Mormon fundamentalism, Right? Is the and I'm pulling it back up, 'cause my phone kind of died is kind of here. It is the changing ordinances and losing priesthood. This is something you have to contend with when you first come into fundamentalism.
5:24 This, this is what I like to say sometimes, might be most people's first, oh, crap moment as they begin to really look into this because. Yes, this question throws into doubt for a lot of folks like is it valid? Is it not valid? So when I saw the title I was like I had, I had to get you on. But So what? What? What prompted this book? Oh gosh, you know, a a a few things. I actually and I I I tease in the introduction and I I tease on Facebook that I wrote it on accident, but it really is kind of true. I tend to do my gospel studies and keep everything written down and prepared so I can annotate it, write cross references, that sort of stuff.
6:07 And so I've been compiling stuff for this for literally for 20 years. But there's, you know, there have been a couple few books that got put out in the interim, excuse me, that I was intending to write all together. So originally my concept for writing a book on changing ordinances was going to be. Kind of with Debri Anderson wrote the development of LDS temple worship and and burgers, mysteries of godliness, you know, kind of expand on that. That was kind of my initial intention and I I just perceived it as this monster big project. But that was really kind of what converted me to fundamentalism. I mean, to me that was that was the doctrine that really mattered.
6:55 Adam God teachings converted me to that doctrine and that understanding of the Godhead and those types of things, but it didn't move me to be a fundamentalist. When I read about changing ordinances like you said, that was my, oh crap moment. What does this mean? So I I've been intending to write that part for a long time. The the second part of the book I I didn't intend to write at all. That was the real accident. And pulling it together was kind of what what what happened here. So, you know, I I think for fundamentalist, it's not very uncommon for them to know that Joseph Smith taught if you change your ordinances, change the priesthood, change the priest to change your ordinances.
7:37 If there's no change of priesthood, no change of ordinances, you know, all these makes like 4 statements that modus tollens tells you you can you can conclude the world from those things. And when I say modus tollens for anybody who doesn't know. I mean if you say if it's raining, there are clouds, that's always true. But if you say if it's not raining there are no clouds, that's not true. So Modus Tolland says the way to find truth out of things. And this is a old just logic construct, you know, developed by the early Greeks as far as I understand. They say if the if the if you negate the the second part, it negates the first part. So if you say that if there are no clouds it is not raining, those are always true as a as a matter of logic.
8:22 And with the statements that Joseph made, every everything becomes logically put there. If you change ordinances, that's that will change the priesthood. But if you change the priesthood, that will change the ordinances. If you don't change the ordinances, if it's the same, there's no change. There's been no change of priesthood. And you know, all of those things you can extrapolate the world from from all of those, but they're all very, very strong statements. And you know, if you if you have any sort of mind at all. You you have to be concerned about that and and there are ways to get around it and there's some actually I think better arguments than people usually use that I put in the book to get around it. But they're they're very far from satisfying. OK, now I don't want to give away the book here, right? But I do maybe want to go over a couple of examples, maybe someones that that you find especially problematic with with the changes that that you have seen that that are really kind of rough stuff to have to deal with. Because, look, about 40% of my audience are active LDS folks who are coming in to listen.
9:35 They're they're coming in because they obviously have concerns and some of these come up, some of them don't. To you, what was? What are some of the more problematic changes here to ordinances that you've saw? Shoot if you want while you think about it. I can give you mine. OK. Probably the one, the one that I'm, I'm most concerned about because its implications are so far reaching. This was between 1921 and 19. I want to say 53 or 57. I can't remember. But they changed how men were received the priesthood. Yes, they They stopped conferring the priesthood and just ordained straight to an office. Yes.
10:27 Yeah. Well, on the surface people might say, well, it's just semantics, right? It doesn't. It doesn't change anything. Well, I dare to disagree. Right. I believe it was Brigham Young who said you can't give something you don't have right? And so ordaining straight to the office throws into question the validity of actually holding the priesthood. Right now. That's a good 30, right around 35 years. Right now I have a buddy who's who's a a physicist of all things, so he deals a lot with statistics and certainties. And that was like, OK, I need you to do something for me.
11:10 I I remember I concocted like this story to try to veil what it is I was looking at. Not that he was LDS, but I was like, I don't know how I feel about it. And he just finally said, just tell me what you're really looking at. I was like, OK, here's the deal, right? And I explained this thing to him and he says, OK, let me, let me, let me run some numbers. So he goes and gets like, Mormon birth rates for the that period of time. And he, you know, starts doing, excuse me, doing some averages and those sorts of things. And he came back and I'm like, well, how many people today do you think actually hold the priesthood in the LDS church? And he's. Like just about under 1% now.
11:51 Wow. If you extrapolate that time out, 'cause they never went back and corrected it, they just started ordaining the correct way again under I believe it was McKay. And so you have essentially two generations that never received the priesthood correctly. They don't go back to correct it, and you have no idea who has it and who doesn't. But it's a very small number as it gets perpetuated through and. Let's let's fascinating on that. It's cool. You got those numbers. Yeah. Yeah. So it's it's pretty it's pretty stark. And and that was one of the changes that I saw. That was one of my severe, oh oh crap moments like.
12:32 So now that, what does that mean for temple rites? What does that mean for baptisms? What does that mean for any number of things? And then I believe it was Taylor who had that prophecy about there'd be a day in the church where you wouldn't know who had the priesthood, I think he said. Or. Or they thought they had the priesthood, but they didn't. And I wondered if that tied directly in with his revelation. Interesting. Yeah. You know, I I paused so long. Would you ask me that? Because I. It kind of at some level, I think they're all equally problematic, right. And and you're talking about not giving my book away and and frankly I think it's just maybe necessary to address some of those issues here. The book is actually pretty short by the way it's 108 pages. So this is not a a monumental huge. Does it have pictures, Drew?
13:27 No, no pictures. There are a couple headers that you have some good space, so you know, I'm never Green Eggs and Ham kind of guy myself. So there's no pictures. I don't know. This is the. You know, a lot of people really like the shorter books, and I just want to get a nugget and I don't tend to write those. That tends to be really hard for me because I want to hit everything. And this was actually kind of difficult for me because I didn't. But let me let me throw throw out some early examples. Of of kind of how I approach it in the book. So there's a Times in the Season article and it's written by Junior. And so who's junior?
14:11 It's probably Joseph Taylor's the editor. The it's it shows up in four different installments of the magazine, and the basic thrust of it is all of Christendom lacks the priesthood because they don't do baptisms right? Paul clearly says it's by immersion, and if you read Romans 13, it's very clear it's by immersion. And if you don't do it like that, then you're doing it wrong. And I I've thought about this long and hard for multiple reasons. This whole idea of changing ordinances, especially the last few years because there have been a few new documents, come out to really challenge this idea as to what does that mean?
14:59 So I think this was really significant because he says, well, you changed baptism because it was by immersion and now it's not. He doesn't talk about symbolism. He doesn't talk about anything else, just about immersion. Sprinkling's not good enough. You know, it says you're being buried. How are you being buried? If you're getting sprinkled, you know, maybe by a tsunami, that's OK. But you know it needs to be underneath. So he's pretty adamant about that and and that gives us one clue of what does it mean by a change. But the thing that struck me, that I've been reading over the last few years and finding more and more evidence of made me kind of rethink this whole teaching, this whole, this whole doctrine.
15:45 So let me give you one example here. How how do we know baptisms by immersion? Well, because Paul said so. OK, well that's great. As Mormons do we believe in non canonical texts? Oh no, those are wicked. They haven't been sustained by the prophet or something, you know. But frankly I can find temple ordnance stuff all over non canonical texts that aren't in the New Testament. Really deep awesome stuff. Read the Apocalypse and Moses, Read discourse on Abaddon, Read the Fall of the Archangel Michael. Really great stuff there that teaches Mormonism. That is anti Christian in as much as it's Mormon and it's non canonical. There's great stuff there and and and as I study early Christian history I I stop and say OK so so Paul said it's by immersion but what does Paul give us a baptismal prayer.
16:38 We don't have a baptismal prayer in New Testament. Does he tell us it's for the remission of sins? Well, yeah, it kind of says that, but. You could also argue that that's he's talking about something a little bit different because of the context and, you know, getting Greek and argue about stuff like that, but does it tell you that it makes you a member of the church? Definitely does not clearly state that. So what about these things? You know, if we read about early Christian baptisms, they don't say these things. They don't have our baptismal prayer, so. You know, if you trust Joseph's Revelator, then you say, OK, well we've got the baptismal prayer. Great, OK. But did you reveal everything?
17:23 Did you reveal everything in baptism or was that one thing at a time too? He didn't do re baptisms immediately. He didn't do baptisms for health for a while. Those were the things that kind of came later. So so that this question of how do we know what the original was? Is a really big question. Do we have an 1843 version of the endowment? Joseph wrote his notes. No. Do we have Brigham Young's 1877? February was February 2nd, 1877. He finishes up in the L John Nunn Journal and he says this is the one that'll be the example for all temples for all future generations.
18:04 Do we have that? No. So wow. So we had some problems. We do have some. Some. Some talk about Brigham tampering with some of the dialogue, but it doesn't show up in any of the modern versions, so that doesn't constitute a change, at least. We don't know if any of anything. And we have Joseph giving him the junction to put everything in order, 'cause it wasn't in order, right? But did he give it to him word for word? Did he? Did Brigham have to find some of those words were later? Did he receive a vision that says, OK, this is when Adam says this. We have none of that information. So what constitutes change? So this question is where mainstream LDS people are just like, well, in fact somebody even wrote whenever I announced the book, they said, well, what was the word they used? They said it's it's not a change, it's a adjustment. And I'm like, right, Everything's an adjustment. I mean, you look at the synonym under change, you find adjustment there.
19:13 It's there's some reason to make me feel good that I don't have to worry about this. I don't want to worry about it because I want to believe I'm in the right spot. But none of the arguments of change really make a whole lot of sense, frankly. But there are two things that I bring up in the book, and I'll I'll spoil them because I'm not not too worried about them. But that I think are super fascinating and one I I didn't. In fact, when I sent it out to all my editors, I didn't even include this and I ended up using it for footnote. And then I got all excited about it and did a bunch more research and this was it. It it anyway it's it's maybe too far off topic for the book to hit it deeply, but I think maybe for podcast it's OK.
20:00 So for about 400 years, Christian baptisms were done in the need. And that's news to a lot of people. And they're like, oh, that can't be true. Guess what? The very first pictures we have of Christ's baptism, He's nude. Guess what? When we have people talking about baptisms, in the earliest church, they're doing it in the nude and the and for about 200 years they were Coed nude, baptisms. But then after about 152 hundred years, we don't know exactly. You know, we don't have super good records of those things. They started separating the man from the women. And I just found one night, I quote it in the book that's thanks. What's it? There's a new book out.
20:43 I I don't know how new IT is. I was super excited about it, 'cause I was planning on writing it and it saved me writing the book that was going to take me 20 years to get to. But it's Mormon doctrine is found in pseudepigraphal and apocryphal writings of the. I think I may have had that guy on multiple times. His name's Ken Peterson. Yeah, yeah, Peterson, that's what. I was. I've had a a few times and we covered just that book and some of his stuff. And especially like the Pista Sophia, which has some amazing temple doctrine in it. Yes, yes. And so, yeah, he's been on, he's, I'm a huge fan of him. He's he's a great guy. Yeah. So I'm not met him. I don't know anything about him, but I was shouting his praises. I was so excited he caught it.
21:23 I bought that book and as I was writing I thought footnotes. I thought, you know, I wonder if there's anything, you know, the the baptism of prayer maybe shows up in one of those and he's got a little excerpt in it and he's got a a place in there. I don't want to say it's an occiped or something, but whatever it is, I cited the book. You can find it. But the the priesthood holder, it tells one of the women, he says take her and and get her a girdle or something like that so that she can be baptized. So she's wearing a girdle and nothing else to get baptized. So basically she's topless, but she's got, you know, towel on the bottom type thing. So that's really disturbing to a lot of members of the church, disturbing to a lot of Christians. Nobody likes to talk about it, but that seems to be universal. And all the records that we have all seem to point to that. They didn't like that.
22:23 And then they poured like it sounds like a bucket of oil on them, you know, like it wasn't just a little bit of oil on the head. It was like all over their body. And then they said baptizing in the name of Father, said the Holy Ghost. Amen. You know, so it's not a full baptismal prayer, but it's, it's got part of it. So that well, that's that's really interesting. But how do we know if that's important? Is that a change or not a change? Right. Did they attribute any significance to that? Yes, they did. In fact, the significance they attributed to us, if you're getting baptized with clothes on, you're trying to hide your sins from God. You're trying to hide your sins from all these people.
23:03 It's better just be open. And I am who I am and I am not hiding anything from God and I'm being born anew. I was born naked. I'm gonna be re baptized or you know, come be born again naked. That was their symbolism. Well, I think it was Peterson's book that led me to a citation. I looked up, citation went up to the original source, and it was like early Christian practices or something. And then there they cite another reason and they say, well, you were baptized in remembrance of Christ who was crucified naked, and that's why you were baptized naked. So it wasn't just that they were doing it as a practice.
23:46 It's not like a cultural thing, you know, which would be so far beyond our culture, even comprehend they had doctrinal significance attached to that part of the baptism. It meant something to them and it was doctrinally significant and it made the ordinance more meaningful to them because of it. So is that a change to the ordinance? And you know, if it is a change to the ordinance, it wasn't revealed to Joseph to do it that way. He never says anything about it. Closest thing we've got for Joseph is an ordinance in Nauvoo saying quit skinny dipping at the within city limits, you know. So you know that's the closest clue we could possibly have, which I don't think means anything by the way. I'm just saying there's there's nothing there. And and so if we didn't reveal it, does that mean it's not good or does that mean that our generation is not deemed worthy to receive it?
24:44 You know, I'm not, I'm not promoting one way or the other. I'm just looking at this and saying, is this a change or is it not a change? So that's one type of approach that I think is interesting and somewhat problematic in in looking at changes to ordinances, because Joseph himself is the one mocking Christians, because you changed the ordinance, because you don't do it by immersion. But when we read the ancient documents, none of us did the same way the ancient earliest Christians do either. So that was one thing that got my attention that I thought was of interest. The second thing I, I, I, I originally this has been a couple years ago.
25:25 I was either talking to the Jacob the dream or I was reading something he posted or something. I don't know, I don't remember. But he was talking about how Brigham did sacrament prayers extemporaneously. And so anyway, I I kept some of those citations and looked them up, and I looked up other sources for, you know, Brigham teaching of these things. And I I I frankly didn't find all the original sources that Jacob talked to me about originally. But I I don't think it matters. I got plenty there. But there was a there were a couple quotes I found at Brigham complaining to the Saints saying, you know there were scarcely 3 words in that sacrament prayer that that are in the scriptures.
26:13 You need to follow it more closely. So in modern church they're like you got to say word for word. We've got like 3 of Brigham's prayers in in documented and he doesn't say word for word once but he does rebuke people because they didn't use enough of the words, it wasn't close enough to it. So that suggests this idea that the wording itself, and I'm not talking about whether it's One Cup or 4, two cups, or whether it's broken 1st and blast first, bless, then break if you use the signs or not. I'm not talking about any of those details, but the wording he suggests is a template, not a word for word.
26:56 Mandatory, you know this is how you have to say it. But of course, with baptisms, that's exactly what we have. However, there's example #2. Joseph Smith instructs Oliver County, DNC 20 is in the making and we're putting some of the ordinances there. So that's where you find sacrament, prayer and all that sort of stuff. He says, I want you to get the baptismal prayer and put it in DNC 20, get ready for DNC 20. So Oliver County does, Where does he get it from? It's it from third Nephi, right? But there's a problem. He doesn't copy it word for word and put it in DNC the same way. So and I don't I don't have the exact thing in my head but the one says having been commissioned of I think this is DNC 20 having been commissioned of Jesus Christ had baptized even in father's right that's not what it says through Nephi. Through Nephi it says having authority from or having you know well they mean the same thing so we we we just OK with that.
27:58 The church says stick with DNC 20 because we like it and they don't really give any justification for it. But actually Joseph told him to copy from Book of Mormon. So isn't the Book of Mormon one more accurate? But you say, well, Oliver Cadery made several changes to the Doctrine of Covenants that Joseph did not approve and we've got Ors and Pratt complaining about that later whenever they did a later edition. And and Joseph made hundreds and hundreds of changes to the Doctrines of Covenants to fix what Oliver Cadery was doing. And when Oliver Cadery did DNC 120, he didn't make a really technical change to the baptismal area like in that verse or the verse before or something. But he doesn't change that.
28:44 So that maybe does that suggest that it's a template to it doesn't have to be word for word because he changed the wording and he didn't care. Oliver Catter changed the wording and Joseph didn't care. Now we can argue, and I don't know, did did Joseph not notice? It's possible. Did Joseph read over it? Say it means the same thing? close enough. That's possible. I mean, we certainly don't insist that you say having been commissioned to Jesus Christ. I'm baptizing the name Father said Holy Ghost. If you're Swedish, nobody knows it, so you translate it, you get the meeting and that's close enough. So there's something there. Suggests the words were intended as a template.
29:27 So the third example I think is interesting and and again to make this point, it's something to think about. I'm not saying right or wrong, it's something to think about is we recently thank you Joseph Smith papers, my heroes. They published A revelation given from Joseph to oh shoot, won't say Sydney Rigdon, but that's not right. Again, I quote it in the book. So shoot. Oh, acceptance drive me crazy. Dang. Anyway, Joseph was going to marry this guy's daughter. No, K Whitney, I think. So he's going to marry his daughter. So he gives him, he writes him a letter and he says these are the words that you use for the ceremony. So he gives him the sealing ceremony. But guess what?
30:17 There's scarcely 4 words in there that are in our sealing ceremony. It's very, very different. I mean, you can see parallel ideas and that sort of stuff. If you go back and look at the sacrament prayers that Brigham was giving, you can see him following the general idea of the sacrament prayer. You know, he's using it as kind of a guidepost of what he's going to say. But he adds some extra stuff. And you know, he treats it like, you know, the the priesthood manual where it says when you bless somebody, this is what you do. You say I could for the priesthood, I redeem the psalmist and words of blessing. The spirit directs name Jesus Christ, Amen. You know, and I want authority, that sort of stuff. It's all, it's all in a linear fashion. But if you mess everything up but you get all the parts in the, you know, maybe the wrong order but you get them all there, it's good enough.
31:03 We'll just let it slide. The Bishop's not gonna say too much, right? So it it seems to me that's kind of what he's saying. The sealing ordinance is a blessing to you and it's supposed to be offering you greater blessings than not getting you sealed on blessing. If you just went to a local Bishop and said hey Marius for time, you're gonna get a different ceremony you know. But it's it seems to be offered more as a template so Joseph Smith writes a a letter essentially kind of a revelation form to I believe it was new K Whitney who's going to marry his daughter and he's basically says here's the sealing ceremony.
31:44 But if you compare that sealing ceremony to what we have that or some published unpublished revelations of how it's done in the temple, not nearly the same. There's some basic guideposts there and it's very, very different. That was really challenging for me because as a as I had, a big portion of the reason I became fundamentalism is because of this doctrine. If you change your ordinances, change your priesthood, well that's a change, right? It is a change. I mean, you might be OK, but it is a change. Now I have to say, well, maybe there's some argument here. There is a good reason to say nothing important was changed. Just you know the prophet knows what's important to change or what's not important to change.
32:31 At some point that loses all validity. It just sounds like stupid. You know that that the endowment used to take 6 to 8 hours, now it takes less than two. Nothing important got taken out. Right. You know, the Brethren, the 12, went to Joseph and said, is there something we could do to shorten the endowment's awfully long? And and and you know what Joseph's response was? We have to do things precisely as God set them down. We can't be changing stuff, you know, so, so this, so we have these. This brings up some questions in my mind here. Now that let let me let me ask this. I don't mean to cut you off, but we have Brigham who is it sounds like adding stuff more than not saying things in the in the sacrament. In the baptismal thing, you pointed out that the ancients did it somewhat differently than what we do, clothing optional, if you will, and then we have this thing with the sealing ceremony.
33:35 My question is this because as I've looked at history and and I want to defer to you here because you're far more knowledgeable than I am about the progression of these things. How much of this is just Joseph receiving a little and then? Refining it. Likewise with Brigham, he was asked to systematize and organize the endowment it. I think it would be somewhat silly to assume that some words or something wouldn't have to be added to get quote the temple drama quite right. And and so.
34:16 If if if I'm understanding correctly here, then we have to start making a decision on what's outside the pale of Orthodoxy, right? And then how do we decide where that line is? Where you are? You are now not within Orthodoxy when it comes down. Yeah. Yeah. And that's challenging on multiple levels. So first of all, Joseph in teaching, in introducing this teaching and I should have said this earlier, I mentioned it in the book. It's super crucial. I I think from my perspective, I can see a lot of people not seeing it. So, but Joseph started teaching this doctrine first because he was restoring the fullness of the priesthood. So he was teaching the people.
35:04 There's no change in ordinances if there's no change in priesthood, if there's if there's a change in priesthood to get new ordinances. So I'm going to be introducing the endowment, I'm going to be introducing the fullness of the priesthood through the 2nd announcement and that requires new priesthood. And he didn't have it and he speaks about receiving it in the future tense. Even though he received his sealing power in 1836 from Elijah, he he he said I'm going to get new priesthood and he speaks about Elijah coming to restore a fullness of the priesthood in like the 1840 or something 1841. So I think we read about this in DNC 132, verse 45, DNC 132 verse 45 and I'll read it to you because I think it's glossed over, but it's super crucial. So he's he's basically DNC 132 is kind of a blessing that he's receiving, right?
36:06 And God's speaking to him. If you want to say it's Jesus, or if you want to say it's the Lord, you want to say it's God, I don't care. But this is what verse 45 says. I have conferred upon you the keys and the power of the priesthood, Wherefore I restore all things and make note unto you all things in due time. Joseph repeats this wording in the last charge over and over and over and says, and we find this, and it's just all over my book, the the Lord himself set his hand to establish the fullness of the priesthood on the earth in the last days. And that's what he means by restoring or whatever he means by established. So he's saying here, how, where did Joseph receive the fullness of the priesthood keys? You know that he says I'm gonna receive more priesthood, that I'm gonna that that's gonna give me more ordinances. Elijah's gonna restore it.
36:54 Maybe Elijah restores it, but God seals it upon his head. OK, And I think this is crucially significant for for multiple reasons. But now I'm going to get back to verse 5 briefly, and we gloss this over is this, this is a casual statement, but I don't think this is casual at all. All who will have a blessing at my hands. So we think, oh, it's being metaphorical. You know you would. This is DNC 130 verse 20, right? There's a lot of revocably to create in heaven. If there's any blessing we can receive, it's because of beating a commandment. That's not what it says.
37:36 It says you want a blessing at my hands, You want me to lay my hands on your head. And he says you shall abide the law that was pointed for that blessing. And the conditions thereof were instituted from before the foundation of the world. So I was reading that and I understood. So he's saying DNC 132 is about how to receive your calling election. Sure. Receive the ceiling power from God himself. And that's what it's about. But and and so later I was as I was researching DNC 132 for my DNC Annotated, which I haven't finished that section. So that's a ways away. But as I was reading that Brigham Young when he introduced DNC 132, he doesn't say, hey, here's a revelation about plural marriage.
38:23 Neither does he say here's a revelation about celestial marriage. What it says. Here's a revelation of how to be exalted. Interesting. This is teaching you how to be exalted. If you do read DNC 132, it talks about sealing power. It doesn't just talk about the plural marriage, it talks about Emma's temptation. It it specifically says I have converted this priesthood upon you to restore for the last days. So you know there's more going on here than just how we usually read it. And so at any rate, so this to me is a is a really, really big challenge and a big problem for the church. When was the last person that you said Christ laid his hands upon my head and conferred upon me this, this blessing, right, Joseph Smith?
39:16 In the teachings of Prophet Joseph Smith, he, he talks about this, but in the words of Joseph Smith, he says God himself ordained all of the prophets, not some of them, all of them. So the apologist just says, well, that's because God, you know, God's laid his hands on all the prophets since Joseph. And so that's they just don't talk about it. Well, that's nice. But if that's true, then guess what we would expect? We would expect there's no change to the second endowment, right. So exact same now as it was before. Is that what we find to be true? No. Werger's mysteries of godliness has the whole chapter donated to him saying, I was asking the church leadership, do you guys do this anymore? And they could have said none of your business. They could have said that's too sacred. We don't talk about it.
40:08 They could have said, you know, we're not talking to a story about these things, but they didn't. What they said was it's not essential to your exaltation and it's really nothing more than just a blessing. And it's not necessary. So you know, it's not really happening. And we also have in Hebrew, J Grant's time. What's the brother's name? Some of my friends will make fun of me for not knowing that I'm sure they'll know. But one of the members of the 12 went to Hebrew J Grant. They said President Grant, like 9-9 of the 12 haven't had the 2nd anointings. We were taught when I was young that this was essential for our exaltation, that we could not be exalted without this ordinance.
40:50 And nine of the 12 don't have it. Can I give it to them? And he would jig around. It's like, OK, I wasn't really excited about it. Well, guess what one of the requirements for plural marriage was before then? You had to be plurally married. So I think Grant's looking at it and saying, well, these people aren't really qualified and that's why they haven't received it. And it's you know, I, I don't I don't know he's a he's an enigmatic figure in church history but at the end of the day he's not really doing it in in Borger further outlines in his book how many second my things were given, you know throughout 780 years of history or something. And it goes from like one in eight in Nauvoo time received their second endowment to like 3A year in like 1970s or something or 60s or whatever.
41:50 It was almost nothing. Is that a change? Well, the the ordinance itself is not being shown that it's a change. But you're you're telling people you have to have this to be exalted, and now you're saying you don't. Well, that's a change of doctrine, a change of principle, which also we have teaching, saying gospel principles don't change. Gospel laws don't change. Expectations of God for you don't ever change and you know these things. So and there's there's some challenges there I addressed in the book too. But at the end of the day, that is kind of a change. But the bigger thing Werger's got from them writing him and saying, well, it's not essential for exaltation. It's just really a blessing.
42:31 It's it's not just a blessing if you read the, if you read the ordinance from the earliest accounts we have, there's more going on here than just a blessing. For one. There's a conferral priesthood, and for two, there's other stuff going on. And for three, there's stuff that happens between the husband and wife after after it's done. And for four, all of Calgary teaches, and Joseph Smith, I I mentioned earlier, teaches. If you're going to have this priesthood sealed upon you, it has to be done by God. It's not done by your priesthood leader. It's not because President Nelson says, hey, I'm going to give this to you and I get everything. You might have all the priesthood, but you don't have all the power.
43:14 That only comes from the Lord himself. And you know, that's that's important. So to me, at the end of the day, that's the most important one for me because I look at it and I say, OK, so the church has basically admitted we don't have it. So a couple years ago, people are saying the mission president goes and says, I resume my second meaning for the priesthood, you know, blah blah, blah. And the people are saying me too. I'm like, well, even if you did, they've admitted they changed it. And here's the problem there. And this is to me the most profound issue that really hit me is it is I was originally learned this and as I've come to understand it better, Joseph says I'm going to introduce the 2nd anointing and 2nd, whatever you want to call it, I'm going to have to receive more priesthood to give this to you.
44:08 So is teaching them about this. And he's teaching them in context of Paul teaching it in Hebrews Chapter 7 in Galatians 3, where he's saying the early church only had Levitical or God was going to give them a Kesnick. But then they all had Levitical and they had to have more in the New Testament or else because it wasn't able to save them. And I'll talk more about that in a minute, but he's, he's saying I have to receive all this priesthood. Well, what is the second endowment for those members of the Church who don't know? Joseph taught and very clearly Brigham taught and shared and we have accounts of other people saying what Joseph taught including apostates and and members of the 12 and nine members of the 12.
44:49 All the like they all say the same thing. He gave Joseph gave the fullness of the priesthood there could ever be bestowed man on earth. Everything that Joseph had is all that God ever gave any man and all that any man on earth will ever receive. Not only did they teach this, but they also taught that was saved for all eternity. So if you're a mortal on earth, fullness of the priesthood is all you're ever going to get. So if you change that priesthood, what does it mean? You lost it, right? Maybe. Maybe you. Yeah. I mean you. There's a lot. I mean, you got Deacon, teacher, priest, you know, you've got, you know, elder high priest, 7012, you know, blah, blah, blah.
45:30 Then you got fullness of the priesthood. So maybe you only go down to 12 apostles or something, you know, but you still lost something, right. And. And that's a big problem. So, you know, some people say, well, OK, well, we lost some priesthood, but we've got enough to carry on the Kingdom, So it's good, right? Right. And that's where the second part of my book became more interesting to me. So let me backtrack briefly to this idea in in Hebrews 7 and Galatians 3 where Paul says and and Joseph Smith talks about this in teaching the Prophet Joseph Smith quoting the same scriptures as well, he says Moses in in in the GST I think is Deuteronomy chapter 10.
46:13 Moses comes down and he's going to give the fullness of the gospel to the Israelites, right? But they're worshiping a golden calf. He's like Danks breaks the tablets, he goes back up, He comes back with 10 commandments, which frankly, is a super lame compromise if you ask me. I mean, if I say what, what would I rather have all the light knowledge of the endowment and the fullness of the gospel or the 10 commandments? It's really a dismal deconstruction of the gospel. So he gives them this. Joseph Smith says, why did he give it to him? Well, because they they. He says God gave it to the Israelites as a curse for their unbelief.
46:55 And he further says the ironic priesthood never could bless. It could only administer cursings. Now in Hebrews 7, Paul says, well, we had the Aaronic priesthood, but you know, it couldn't save men. Only the Melchizedek Priesthood can save men. Joseph kind of pulls out of that, that section and and that's what Christ gave to them whenever he restored the gospel and his dispensation, you know. And so now they have the mochestic priesthood again, the early brethren and Joseph Todd that Peter, James and John received the fullness of the priesthood and their endowments on the Mount Transfiguration.
47:35 So when mochestic priesthood is restored, now they can save people, now they can bless again. So this, this idea comes up again in Galatians and says if the ironic priesthood was able to save people, then why did we get more, Why did why did Christ come? You know, it wasn't enough. We had to have more. So this is how Joseph is teaching and and and there's this idea that there are laws under the ironic priesthood and we're supposed to obey those. That's the Old Testament. But then those laws can only administer cursings. So we have to get the Mochesde priesthood, which is the only priesthood that can bless, so that we can bless people and give to ceilings and all this sort of stuff, Right?
48:20 We can actually now give people ordinances unto salvation and ordinances unto exaltation. So this is a huge part of the teaching about why he's getting new priesthood and why there's these new ordinances. It's all kind of interconnected. So if we turn around and say, well, had the fullness of the priesthood, but now we don't get it anymore. Dang. Well, what about the Apostleship? Well, we've got the Doctrine Covenants. I think it's section 112. It's in the book, if I had misquote that, but it basically says the apostleship will never be lost on the earth. It's not super clear. It's a little bit vague, but it seems stupid for, from my perspective, for it to be there.
49:02 If that's not what it means, But you could argue the point, that's not what it means. So you can say, well, there's no clear promise the Apostleship's gonna remain on the earth either. So now what do we've got? We got High Priest. We've got McKenzie Priesthood. Well we've got two very strong statements that the ironic priesthood will never be taken from the earth. And John promised that when he ordained all recounting Joseph and then when Peter, James and John come and they ordained him to the elder and given the mochestic priesthood they give them the similar promises will never be taken in from the earth. So if you, if you're like, well, shoot, at least we got mochestic priesthood. But how far? Because mochestic priesthood Elder, because the priesthood high priest, because the priesthood apostle, because priesthood.
49:48 Fullness of the apostleship, fullness of the priesthood. What, what does that mean? So now we've got that challenge. So this is where I got involved in the second-half of the book. In the second-half of the book, you know, we've got, if you look at most every Restoration group, and maybe all of them depends on how you want to argue, ordinances have all been changed. So they've lost priesthood, right? That's that's just what Joseph taught. Or the changes don't matter at all, which again, I think it's pretty problematic. And OK, don't don't let me forget promises about the fullness of the priesthood. That's also in Joseph with actions and insights. Last charge of Transfiguration book that's frankly better source for it.
50:38 But my book, Changing Ordinances, Losing Priesthood, takes all the pertinent stuff, puts it all in one spot. So that's that's how it's useful. So when we look at the sacrament prayer like you were talking about earlier, Brigham's complaining they're not using enough the sacrament words because they're not having the meaning intended in the sacrament prayer. When Joseph allows the change to the baptismal prayer or doesn't notice and it's just been perpetuated, it conveys the same meaning, right? It's the same idea. And you could look at the ceiling blessings that Joseph gives to Mill K Whitney comparing to what we have recorded from Orson Pratt this year in unpublished revelations and say it conveys the same meaning.
51:26 You know, there's an intention of retaining the teaching. But if you look at the changes to the endowment and you're like, OK, so the covenant between husband and wife is basically emasculated, eviscerated, maybe even reversed with all the feminist revision stuff that was happening there, does that change the meaning? Oh, yeah, it very much changes the meaning. I I don't think you could reasonably intelligently argue it doesn't change the meaning unless you wanted to say, well, the earlier brother and were just showing his pigs and they didn't really get it. And the true prophet knows better. In which case, like, well, it's changed anyways.
52:08 Joseph's the one that revealed that, and Joseph is the one who said you can't change it or you're changing priesthood. I think that's problematic 'cause that is not the same meaning. Now if you want to take out the preacher and say, well, you know, the preacher see, was just offensive and it's anecdotal, maybe we can get away with that. Maybe he said, well, yeah, wasn't that important. It doesn't change your understanding of the plan of salvation on Earth that much, you know. But then we start looking at other things to say, well, you got rid of all the all of the penalties.
52:48 Well, you still have the injunction that you shouldn't share it. Yeah. But you know what the symbolism behind those penalties is? Because people don't. But when they do understand those things, I think there's a massive significance to that. Yep, absolutely. And and and then you go on with the the signs and you know there's some changes there and you go through the entire endowment. So much has changed. It's like, is the same meaning there anymore? Well, I don't know. Let's, let's look at this objectively speaking. We have Brigham Young's endowment that says Adam is God the Father, and then you have a church position now that says that is a heresy and it's one of the deadly heresies and you should be excommunicated just for believing it.
53:36 Now some people get honoring with me about saying that, but I know people that were excommunicated for believing it even though they promised never to teach it. So can you say that you changed who is God and that retains the meaning? It just it gets hard to look at all of these things and seriously honestly, look at the changes in the endowment saying, yeah, it's it's pretty much the same teaches all the same stuff. You know, I've I've had way too many conversations with people in the temple about the changes in the temple and some are like, I am so glad they got rid of that chauvinistic stuff. I am so glad they got rid of the covenant to the husband because he doesn't know what he's doing.
54:18 He's such a dork. And you know all these types of things and you know they are happy about the changes because it what it changes their behavior, it changes their understanding, it changes their belief and it changes how they interact with their partners, their spouses. And that is a fundamental change. You cannot argue the meaning was changed. Why else were they griping about it and asking it to be changed, right. So then you have in in connection with that you have the brethren say can't change the garment. The pattern was revealed by heaven. It's it doesn't say. And when we do have accounts of that argument, you know proving that's that was what Joseph said.
55:02 This was revealed to me by heaven, by an Angel you know and they said this was revealed by heaven. The exact pattern. But but we're going to change it. That's not a change. I mean you know it's it's completely mutilated from from what it used to be and that's the exact word Joseph F Smith used. He said you cannot mutilate or change the garment. So again we're we're changing all these things. One more thing that I think is super interesting and I don't know how far afield this is from what I was writing in my book versus just interesting for the podcast that when I read Debri Anderson's the The Development of LDS Temple Worship, I was heartbroken over it.
55:46 It was really really hard for me to read that I've I've been told and I haven't met Devery. I I don't know if this is true but I I've been told that he's happy about the changes. He's like yeah this is so glad the church has got profit that's making these changes and getting rid of bigotry or whatever is in there. You know, I don't know if that's true or not. He's he does a really good job of kind of keeping his personal opinions in a minimal in the footnotes and that sort of stuff. But it it really was painful for me to read and I noticed two things that maybe were of note that that really struck me about it. And the first one was Wilfred Woodruff changes the law of adoption and he says, Joseph reveals you were to be sealed to a living man who's got a fullness of the priesthood and that's who you're going to be sealed to. And Wilfred Woodruff says, Nah, just get sealed to your dad, you know, That made sense when the church was restored. But now everybody's got a good dad. We'll just be sealed to our dad.
56:50 Well, that doesn't work for a lot of people because their dads never received the fullness of the priesthood and they don't even care about that anymore. That that doesn't matter either. He doesn't have to be have fullness of the priesthood. You can, you know, get sealed to him after he's an elder now. But anyway, he made this change and and he left room in his journal for the change to be recorded, but never recorded any revelation on the matter. So I thought, you know, this is really interesting because this is this seems like it was a source for a lot of changes for the this is what I'm thinking when I'm reading the book. As I'm reading the book I'm recognizing and and and I didn't do this for every single thing that I saw. But I'm recognizing that pretty much I would say 8090 at least 80% of the got to be more like 95% of all the changes that were ever made to the endowment can be traced back to that one changed And in the 1960s some mathematicians came to Wolver Woodruff.
57:58 Sorry, I think it was David O McKay. I'm not positive. And they said, you know, we're mathematicians and mathematically speaking, we're never going to get the temple work done. And they said, well, wait a second, but how are we never going to get the temple work done? Are you saying we're not inspired and doing temple work? And I said, no, no, we're, you know, we're, we're following brethren guides, but mathematically can't be done unless we shorten the endowment. And so they started looking at shortening this the length of the endowment so it could all be done. And then, and I understand that they also made it to where they put it for a while to where you could literally get your endowment, get baptized for the dead, and then, you know, get your second anointing and be ordained an elder and that sort of stuff too.
58:44 And they're like, well, as long as it all gets done, doesn't matter what order. That's fundamentally contrary to every understanding I've got of the purpose of the ordinance to the previous two. But anyway, that was going on for a while. I don't know if it still is, but as I as I was looking at all these things, they're like mathematically doesn't work. We gotta shorten the endowment. So let's shorten this and let's shorten this and let's shorten this. And so I'm looking at all these things. I'm like holy Flip. You know, all these go back to the law of adoption because if you're not doing ancestry work for all of your dead, they didn't used to do it that way. They said pray about it and your ancestors will come to you and the ones who come to you do the work for them. That that's a whole lot less work than what we do now. And if we do that and then we get sealed to a living person with the fullness of the priesthood, that then we don't have to do that work for our dad, you know who maybe won't accept all of that, or a grandpa who maybe won't accept all that, Or on and on it goes.
59:46 So all these changes can be changed or can be brought back to the law of adoption because it needs to be short and short and shortened. And so Heber G Grant in his administration, he writes down in his journal that he's, you know, contemplating getting rid of an ordinance, doesn't say which one, but presumably the 2nd anointing because that's essentially what he did, and changing some of the others to make it shorter. And then we compare that with Joseph when the 12 approached him and said, can we make the indomitable shorter? He says no. So either Joseph's right or Heber J Grant's right. And that goes back to the follow the modern prophet. But for me, if you've got to pit the prophet against one another, there's a problem. And guess who's the one who warned us of the problem? It wasn't Hebrew J Grant, it was Joseph. And he said don't do this, this is bad news, man. So I think that's fundamentally a problem. And and two more quick points here. One of the things that that I read in Deborah Anderson's book that really struck me is when they were, they were talking about that they did a street garment for a while that was different from the temple garment. And one of the temple presidents as I recall was asking, I think it was Joseph F Smith, I'm pretty sure. Sorry, Joseph Fielding Smith.
1:01:02 Hey, we've got this tradition that when we put on the temple garment in through the initiatory ceremony that we do it right foot first and then right arm and then left foot first and left arm. Is there anything to this? And and again, I could be getting some of the details wrong. I'm pretty sure it was the temple garment, not the street garment they were talking about. But the the order is the important thing you say and we're trying to get rid of all the the innovations he called it that have snuck into our temple work. So that's why the temple president's asking is this an innovation or is this important? And Joseph Fielding Smith said I see no significance and no importance to that.
1:01:46 I don't know of any and and I I just that really hurt me. I felt so badly because the symbolism behind that in in receiving the full garment is very profound and in in, let me just give you in terms of Hebrew symbolism. In Hebrew symbolism your foot is the direction you're heading. Your right foot is your spiritual side. It is your, you know the the the God side the Godhead side.
1:02:27 Your left side is the temporal side or the wicked evil side or things of the world side. Right. So if you do the right foot first, it's saying do the gospel first, live, you know, take care of your teach your kids the gospel and teach your wife the gospel, and those things go first and then. But that's just the direction your foot is first, right? So what's what is that symbolism in the hand? Well, that's what you're doing. So you're moving your body in the direction of spiritual things, and then you're doing spiritual things first. Then what do you do now? You move your left foot. You do temporal things secondary, you know, you move to do temporal sigs, then your hand is what you're doing, so you're doing temporal things secondary. That's not symbolism that you can't figure out in life, right? Put the put the first, the Kingdom of God, blah, blah, blah, you know, that sort of stuff. But the fact that it's part of an ordinance and then that's being taken away.
1:03:28 I I start looking at all those things and say there's a lot of beautiful stuff that was left out because people didn't understand how. How cool is that? Is that OK? Does that not matter? You know, So here's, here's the here's the big clincher for me on all of these things. So I can make an argument that all the changes to the temple endowment, whether in the church or in the in the stringites or in the cut rights or whoever's doing it, I I don't know if stringites doing or not or I don't remember, but I know the cut rights were and they changed it. Whoever's doing the changes, they can't be getting more priesthood. That's not possible. So any change is giving them less priesthood. So let's assume that all these changes are OK because they're just following the template and these other little things were just superfluous.
1:04:22 You don't have to have the preacher saying he gives somebody $500, you can change it to 10,000 now, and then you might be more modern, accurate. Maybe that doesn't matter, so we can make that argument, you know? But if that was the case, wouldn't you expect that we're growing closer to God than the early Saints? Wouldn't you expect that modern Day Saints would know more about the plan of salvation than the Saints of Joseph's day? This episode of the podcast is brought to you by Deseret flag.com. I've said this before, and I really mean it. Mormonism isn't just a religion, it's a culture. As such, it has its own vernacular and practices, but also its own symbols. And those symbols become even more important and prominent when you look back into our history.
1:05:06 Perhaps one of the most recognizable symbols of Mormonism is the Deseret flag. This is the flag that I use as cover art in this podcast. This was also used for a good chunk of time during the Pioneer era in Utah. Now, today we have people who want to replace the existing Utah flag with some other progressive monstrosity. Well, I think it's damn past time that we start pushing back here a little bit in Utah. Our friends at Defending Utah are here to help you with that. Now, if you go to deseretflag.com, you can now purchase your own Deseret State flag. It's time here that we start making ourselves known and join the resistance against those who seek to rewrite our state's history. Go to deseretflag.com or check out the link in this episode's page Show notes and get yours today.
1:05:51 Can't get enough of the Mormon Renegade podcast? Well, good news. We're on Patreon and there's three packages that you can choose from. The first one, the Slightly Rowdy package, allows you to hear the podcast without all those pesky commercials getting in the way. For those who want a slightly more in depth experience, there's the Stirring It Up package where you can hear ad free audio, ad free video and transcripts. Finally, for those who want to go full Renegade, that package is available too, where you can get everything in the previous two packages, plus an extra show where myself and Ben Winfield breakdown the news of the day from a very Mormon point of view. You will also get exclusive access to Renegade Chat and on there you'll be able to talk to others about the show or whatever topics are on your mind.
1:06:37 Go to Patreon today and get your exclusive content. And indeed, that's kind of what the Church teaches. We know better. And you know, they were just learning and growing, but we know better. But if you sit down with it, pick anybody and, you know, average, just randomly take a sample of 100 Saints from the whole planet and maybe you get a scholar or two in there, whatever, and you say, OK, tell me everything you know about the plan of salvation, Let's map it out. You can write your little diagrams and all that sort of stuff. And then I want to compare how much, you know, I'm going to ask questions when you're done. For instance, what is the ceiling of a father to his daughter? How is that different than the ceiling of a husband to his wife in the eternities?
1:07:22 When we're making worlds together, like, how is that different? Like, does the daughter ever make a world with her dad or is she forever lost to him or do they make it together? How does that work? Well, I've asked lots of Latter Day Saints, that kind of question. Like I never thought of that. And in fact I don't think I've ever met a Latter Day St. that I've met that was mainstream. Who could ever give me a decent answer on that at all? That's that's pretty much. I never thought about it. I guess they'll do it together. Where you just said, I guess, you know, you just said, I speculate that means I don't know. The early brother knew and the early brother taught these things. They had doctrines that were way deeper on all of these issues with a lot more explanations.
1:08:03 So who understood it better? What we do because we know what we don't know. That's possible. We can be Socratic about it. But it doesn't ring true. When I meet brethren who are fundamentalists who've studied the gospel as Joseph taught it, as Brigham taught it, as John Taylor taught it, they've got a vast array of material way beyond anything in the church. And I think even whenever I was writing DNC 76 and DNC Annotated 76, man, I was, I was loving it. I learned so much writing that, I mean, it's kind of more edited than writing. But you know what I mean? Yeah, I was constantly finding these quotes from the early brotherhood and teaching stuff, and I was like, sweet.
1:08:46 I've been teaching that to my family for 30 years or 20 years or whatever. I'm not quite that old, but teaching it for 20 years, I believed it for 30 years. I never found a quote. And here's a quote where somebody's teaching that thing, you know, and it's happened to me over and over and over again. Just things the spirit teaches. Here's some of the early breadth of teaching it. But go through the last 6080 years of conference talks, You don't learn any of those things. Not even remotely close. And and so to me, if I'm looking and saying, OK, at the end of the day I can argue that all these changes are template changes, they don't really matter.
1:09:26 That's what most mainstreamers believe. But if I'm going to take that position, I've got 2 problems. One is mainstream churches admitted they got rid of the second down it or they changed it and it doesn't matter to me. You can't just get rid of an ordinance. They got rid of revamped baptisms. They got rid of baptisms for health, which is not self ethic. So you can say that doesn't matter. They got rid of mother's blessings. You know, they they're they're dumping stuff and they're losing, you know, priesthood according to Joseph. And if that was true, if that perspective was true, I would expect them to lose light knowledge.
1:10:06 And that's all I see. I don't see them. They've produced nothing new that didn't discount something earlier for for any revelation or announcement that they've made. Nothing has added something that wasn't there before. They've only taken away what was there before, and that's the actions of God to the Israelite. You didn't believe it takes them away, Alma 12-9 to 12, says if you don't believe, I'm going to take it away. If you believe, I'm going to give you more. That's what I'm saying. If if we're actually progressing and getting more light knowledge by rejecting the early brethren, then I then where's the more, where's the better understanding and it's not there. I mean changes from from administration to administration and when we do have requests for ordinance changes, why are those changes coming?
1:11:06 We don't like the government. Why? Well, you're making us work 24/7, which frankly, I don't think is original either. But you're making this morning 24/7 and we want to look like the Gentiles. So they say no, we can't change the ordinances. Well, maybe you already changed that. But at any rate, they're complaining about God's gift to them. That's how you're going to get more light knowledge. You know what He's? Already giving you? Yeah. In 2005, I received a letter as counsel for AUB saying that these these people were going to sue AUB and they were going to sue the church because there was nudity in the endowment in the initiatory. And I looked at this and I and my my clients said what are we going to do this.
1:11:53 Well this is easy. This is looks pretty pretty stupid lawsuit by some snowflake. You know if if people are upset about this, then you just disclose to them beforehand and you're good. Make sure a woman discloses it to the girls and a man discloses it to the boys and get it writing, get it done before they go there So they can't say they were pressured and it's good. Who's going to sue you for a stupid lawsuit anyways? But you know what I mean it's dumb And and they said, well what do you think the church is going to do? And and I said, well this isn't this isn't my genius that came up with a solution here. This isn't any competent attorney would tell you that you just get a disclaimer first you have them sign a a waiver of and and knowledge and understanding what they're doing and then they can't later claim you humiliated me. I didn't know because they were told beforehand this is this is like first grade law school.
1:12:50 I mean you know this is the basic of the basics. And then a couple months later, I'm hearing that the church is changing the now to get rid of the nudity. And they changed the ordinance so that it's all symbolic. And, you know, there's no longer, this is like way shorter. So you got somebody complaining about the ordinance and that's why you're gonna change. I don't like the preacher there offends the Christians. So we take that away. Is that how you gain more light knowledge with God by complaining about what he's given you? No, it just doesn't. It doesn't sit right, you know, it doesn't feel right. You know when I get a lot more light knowledge is when I'm in this stage and say, God, thank you so much for teaching me this. I am so grateful for all of this light knowledge and it's really changed my life and it's made me a better person. And maybe I'm still a Sinner, maybe I'm still a bad guy. But all this gospel light knowledge you've given me has made me a better person.
1:13:49 It's made me a better dad, it's made me a better husband and but right now I need more something. I can't figure out how to overcome this problem. Can you teach me something? That's when you get light knowledge. But if you go to God and you're like, you know what? You told me this and that didn't work. You told me this and that doesn't work. And I'm frankly sick and tired of this life. It sucks. And I've got all these problems. And can you just tell me how to fix it? You know, when I do that and you know, it's some level, we all gripe and complain. You know, I don't get an answer, right? Maybe you do, but I don't. I get it Whenever I'm saying I'm and I'm grateful for what I've got. Please give me more.
1:14:31 That's when you get more. And and that's same thing with Joseph Joseph saying I'm reading the scriptures and it seemed to me that there must be something here. And so I'm praying and asking tell me more. And that's what God says. Oh you're grateful for what I gave you. I'll give you more. Just like any father your kid comes and says Mom made the stinky breakfast and I don't like it. Will you give me something like. No. You know, if I made the Super yummy breakfast, can I have some yogurt too? Sure, right? No, it's just a gospel principle. And so looking for all these things, that's what I would expect. So now is the big conundrum.
1:15:11 I mentioned earlier that we have quotes saying Kazak priesthood, ironic, Christian state forever on the on the earth. All right, so I had a friend, I was just chatting with him and and my understanding was that his group of people had the 2nd anointing. And so in passing, talking about some priesthood issues, I said, well, you know, we've got it at least a really solid quote that the fullness of the priests will never be taken from the earth. And you know, as I was read writing Joe Smith doctrines and Insights, Last charge of Transfiguration, I found probably, you know, several of these, but at least one that was super clear. And he said, I don't know what you're talking about and we don't have second anointing and I'd love to see the quote.
1:15:55 So I thought, all right, shoot, that this is something that I was planning on in in my second, third volume on teachings of the Joseph that Arnon, the THPTPJSI was going to include all these quotes because they're journals or reminiscences talking about the the priesthood not being taken from the earth. But now I'm thinking, you know, I sorry. So they were just going to be, you know, randomly inter dispersed. But I was figuring I would in the index make a special entry and collect all of them and make sure to point out where they were and put it all together. So I'm going to do this work sometime right? Anyway, I'll just do it for this new friend.
1:16:36 So I started compiling all the stuff. This is actually why I ended up writing the book. I I compile all that stuff together and I I sent it to him and I was like, I've got more than that. I know I've got more than that. And so I looked deeper, found a bunch more, put them all together and I had all these cross references and notes and and thoughts going through my head about this. And then I realized I've pretty much written the book. I just need to stitch it together now. So that's kind of how it how it works. But the whole key that that that got me pondering about this and I never, I never addressed this clearly in the book because I'm I'm not about telling people what to do with their lives or shoving stuff down their throats and just present stuff. You can think about it make of it what you want. But my question mark here was Joseph says if you change the ordinances, change the priesthood, which means if you change the ordinances you lose priesthood. Right.
1:17:39 But then he also says this. The fullness of priesthood will never be taken from the earth. So somebody's got it. It's out there. Maybe some of somebody's got it for my rubbing shoulders with people and guesstimating, I guess there's less than three dozen guys on the planet have it, but they're out there. And you can receive those blessings if you really want them, if you're looking for them, if you're trying to find them, if you're whatever. But when you find him, you then you got to discern, right. Well, I, you know, like I, I anecdotally a guy who says, well, you know, I give second anointings while smoking a cigarette to kind of put make a point, you know, like, well, I don't know if I really receive a second anointing from guys smoking cigarettes. Something about that feels wrong, you know. Right.
1:18:32 And I I I get what he's trying to teach and there's maybe some truth there but it doesn't ring true to me that that's the proper way to receive your second. So you know, so you still you have to exercise discernment. You have to think about it and at the end of the day you got to look and say who hasn't changed the ordinances and and maybe then you have to say well who's changed them the least who's who's kept the template at least, you know and and go through that piece of things and the search is is kind of tricky. And I used to see it a lot more black and white and it was a little bit more clear to me because you know, if immersion is a change, then Dang it, change in the wording and sacraments change, Right, Right. So now I have to look at a little bit more carefully and nuanced, but still at the end of the day I I come to the same conclusion.
1:19:28 I I can't conclude that the people who have changed the ordinances the most are the ones with the most priesthood. Unless they're growing and giving more light knowledge and taking away pieces that really don't matter much or are are inconsequential, but instead they're taking out massive pieces of stuff that are hugely important, including covenants. Now you know, and those people as a whole don't understand the gospel better than the people of Joseph's day. Sorry, they they don't. Any anybody who bothers to to spend some time reading on these topics will know that. And and frankly, I mean even if you read DNC 76 annotated, which isn't my opinions and thoughts by the way for anybody who doesn't know, it's just those are the early brethren teaching cross references to the scriptures and interpreting them. So early Brethren interpreting.
1:20:24 Not me. Yeah they give a whole boatload more information than I've ever heard in general conference like 100 times. It's amazing how much more they offered. So so anyway you just you have to look at all of those details with a little bit more nuance than before. But you know, I mean it's it's a it's a challenging teaching. It's it's challenging on multiple levels and and and even like in my position, I'm saying well Joseph restored the baptism. But you know it is it possible that Joseph didn't restore part of that ordinance the way it was supposed to be done because he grew up in a Victorian age where people couldn't accept it and the Church never would have started, never would have ticked off the ground maybe, you know. Right.
1:21:16 So it brings up a lot of questions in my mind now that that weren't there 20 years ago when I was first learning these things and 1st starting to study them. So if if I might be a so this bowl here and correct me if I'm wrong, I think at least for me when I look back at stuff I tend to look at kind of I I look at it with this idea of the waters are purest at their source right And and certainly from a latter. Day tradition. Those waters start with with Joseph Smith and then trickle down right. Yeah, In your opinion, what's that?
1:22:03 I said I view it the exact same way. OK, I I think the the fountain is purest to the the good source. OK. All right. So if if that's the case, then is is the safest assumption as as we analyze these changes is to see how they square. With what was originally revealed and then in the absence of when they're originally revealed, right, because we don't have a ton like on the endowment on on what Joseph was doing exactly with those other brethren. And if I'm not mistaken, the ordinance really wasn't written down. It was kind of given to men to memorize certain parts of it and then later was compiled. Is that correct?
1:22:52 I don't think we really know that. I think we we we guessed that. I would love to know the answer, but from the records we've got, I I don't see any evidence that we've got a written record of what Joseph did. But at the same time, Joseph was really meticulous about record keeping on multiple, multiple levels. I have a hard time thinking that he said. Brigham we don't have this quite right, but you know we figured out and and you'll you'll get it together and add 3 hours worth of teachings, right? You know, I I just it's possible but on a theoretical basis I don't see I don't see.
1:23:37 Joseph didn't wasn't like that. No, I don't see him being like that. He took such good records. It was super important, he says dozens of times in the last charge. I'm just completely crawling out of my skin. I'm really stressed. I've got to teach you guys all these things you know and and and he had meetings with the 12 where he's teaching them all these things about the fullness of the priesthood. So it's possible he delineated all those things there but didn't write them down but but they were keeping notes and he maybe instructed them to or something but to have none at all. Just it doesn't square with what I what we know about Joseph to me. Yeah, yeah, the. The other thing that that I tend to look at and again I'm willing to be wrong on on on this right.
1:24:25 I tend to make Joseph kind of the ultimate authority here when it talks about this. So while we certainly can look at things like apocryphal records and those sorts of things and say, OK, so we have record and and I want to say that that I know that there I did have a friend who converted to Judaism. And one of the things was a ritualistic bath in in living waters so to speak so not in a font where where you would bathe essentially naked to to enter enter that if if that's and Muslims do that as. Well, right, right. However, who's to say that getting naked wasn't to change as well?
1:25:14 Right. Did it start with having clothes on and then and then later was changed to no, we should really do this without clothes on. And at some point, Drew, don't you have to be able to draw a hard line somewhere and say, OK, this is what I'm going to to hedge to, so to speak, right. And so when I think of restoration, I think of a a bringing forward what was lost. And that's why I tend to look at Joseph Smith and say, OK, I'm going to stop and end it here, right. This is, this is kind of my guy. But and and I think you kind of alluded to it before, but and I want to point this out that I don't see a lot of places where the Lord takes away a whole bunch, right.
1:26:04 We have, we have. Exodus Where? Where you know Moses comes down and it was like like you were saying we're going to get, you know, not give you the higher law but the lower law. So I tend to look at revelation as being. And again correct me if I'm wrong here. I'm only be wrong on this because Joseph does say that we've we believe in everything the Lord has revealed and things He has yet to reveal in the articles of faith. I'm butchering that, right? Yeah. So I do think that there can be further revelation, but I feel like that revelation has to add to what we have and not take away, yes?
1:26:46 And and that's where I kind of fall on this and and the other thing would be is does it square with what's already been revealed as well, right. I don't think a revelation that completely overturns something Joseph did is. Is within that pale of orthodoxy and that's where I tend to to run into issues is I I think, I think there is more revelation out there to be had, but it has to square with what's already been revealed. They can't conflict necessarily, right? I and I agree in theory. However, anytime we've had a clarification of doctrine, it's also seemed contrary to things that were there before.
1:27:35 Let me give you an example. When DNC 76 was introduced to the Saints, a lot of them were really upset about it because they said we've been taught in the scriptures say you either go to heaven or you go to hell. And now you're telling us that these guys that were going to go to hell might go to Celestial Kingdom or they might go terrestrial or they might go Celestial, but all these places are good places. You know, this isn't like hell as we know it and just said, well, hell is actually a temporary place except for for the sons of perdition. And so most people are never really going to stay in hell anyways.
1:28:17 And in DNC 19, we have the Lord clarifying and saying, well, by eternal and everlasting punishment, I didn't mean that they would last forever. I meant it was eternal in nature, not in duration. That felt like a fundamental reversal of 2000 years of Christian history. So while I agree with you, it doesn't when when you get to specific details of doctrines, it really does look contrary a lot of times when when Joseph is revealing something that's lost and being restored. And because of that, I think when you see, you know, Brigham says he didn't teach anything, but Joseph taught. So I take him at his word for the most part, with some similar nuanced challenges there.
1:29:08 If he's revealing something that is a little bit further with what Joseph taught, but he just had a better understanding of those details, might also look a little bit off compared to what we understood, you know, how we interpreted revelation or scriptures before DNC 19, Verse seven is one of my favorite scriptures for this reason. This is the one I was just talking about everlasting punishment, where he talks about that and says that's not what I meant. But then he says some scriptures are more express than others, meaning they're more clear, they're more detailed. Sometimes the prophets just kind of mouthed off something. They didn't say it very well and it looks like they were saying one thing, but it wasn't really clear.
1:29:52 But this scripture is more clear than others. And so that's the one you hold on to for this particular teaching at at any rate. So. So I agree very much you go to the source, the closer the fountain the better and and it should square with what's been revealed before. But it squares if we have a an open mind and we're really careful about how we're reading and interpreting things, because we all of us have habits and traditions of how we interpret things. And a lot of times they're bad. They're they're not well thought through and they're problematic, but we think we really know it really well, you know? I should have been more clear there, what I was saying in terms of, oh, I don't think so.
1:30:42 Just the Restoration era, right? So the teachings of Joseph, right? And from a Mormon context, I would expect. To see some things that fly in the face of quote traditional Christianity because you did have Joseph coming and restoring the God, you know the the religion of Jesus. And so I would expect to see some conflicts there. But with within the Restoration going forward from Joseph Smith, I tend to look at it and say, OK, any new revelation that that is is given, I think has to square somewhat, not somewhat pretty well with what Joseph talked. So if, if, yeah, if.
1:31:22 I wasn't clear that I wanted to make sure I was when Well I I think I think it's just common a common issue that that comes up a lot and and even with your clarification I again, I agree. But we we do have a talk of Joseph saying you know people say I have poor wives but I I'm looking in the audience. I can only see one. He had seven in the audience at the time at least. And I think he had like 38 wives at that time that he said that. You know so we've when we're looking at history, we do have some challenges of what Joseph taught publicly versus privately because we do have conflict.
1:32:03 I believe it was Benjamin F Johnson, could have been Clayton but at one point they he said, Joseph, if I look for a marriage, I get caught. What's going to happen? He says, well I'll give you a severe public chastisement and when the water settles down I'll, you know, we'll reinstate you in good standing, you know. So even then we've we've got to be pretty well read in in each of the doctrines to to make sure that it's really squaring because we we do have challenges like that. And further, we've got words like intelligence and spirit that were used interchangeably and incorrectly multiple times by Joseph as he was learning and understanding that principle. And the term salvation was used to mean both exaltation and salvation in celestial Kingdom and salvation in the telestial or terrestrial kingdoms, which didn't mean in the passage. It's not always clear, but we always assume it means celestial Kingdom.
1:33:02 But maybe not So you know when Christians say if you believe you will be saved, yeah to Lestre Kingdom at least Terrestrial Kingdom may be next. It doesn't say celestial Kingdom, but they don't have that perspective so they can't read it that way. But that's how the term was used by Joseph but not consistently so even then I, you know, again I'm, I'm not disagreeing with you at all. I totally agree with you. It's just one of those things that I've thought about over time. I'm like Dang, it's still it's still a challenge. You know there's there's very little black and white and restored gospel, right? It it's when you get to the details, I should say, obviously there's strong black and white atonement's real praised. It's important you know that when you start nailing down these little details, there's so many rabbit holes to go down. Yeah.
1:33:52 And and one of the things I learned early on when I became a fundamentalist was you. You almost have to, for your own sanity at some point, hedge somewhere. Right. Hedge on. You know, for me, it was Joseph Smith, right? I'm gonna, I'm gonna hedge there because if you don't, you will start. It's it's like the guy who finds one conspiracy is true and then he doesn't trust anything ever again. Right. And then it's, you know, going down every ground. Hole yeah you go from from holy crap maybe there was a second shooter in the Kennedy assassination to now the earth is flat right and and so for your own sanity you almost have to to peg to somebody and I always felt like Joseph Smith was the strongest stake we had to or the strongest anchor to to put to. For someone who's getting into this right, who? Who's discovering these changes, what kind of sources would you direct them to when it comes to changes in ordinances and changes in priesthood 'cause that's really what this is about, right?
1:35:05 Like don't get me wrong, I love the doctrine, the Adam God doctrine. I feel it puts me in proximity to deity. I love it about that. I love the principle of plural marriage. I feel like that's a godly principle that has certainly helped me become a better man. But when you whittle it all down, it really does kind of start with the ordinances in the priesthood. So you you have your book, which I can't recommend enough. Anything you write I can't recommend highly enough. But when it comes to to other source material, where? Where do you normally direct people to go when they want to start doing their own research?
1:35:47 Werger's mystery of godliness is #1. I think he did a fabulous job. I haven't read that frankly, in probably 20 years or so. I refer to it once in a while and look things up. But I thought he did a really good job and and objectively just saying it was changed. So that's that's to me, that's the number one place #2 is Debre Anderson's The Development of LDS Temple Worship. That's the third book in a series that starts with just Smith's Cormac anointed and then the endowment companies and then the earliest history of Elias temple worship.
1:36:27 Sorry Glitch there. But that's that's both of those are indispensable. The latter of course is only temple stuff. So you know that's that's maybe a limitation there. Mysteries of Godliness really focuses on temple stuff too and and you know I I haven't read that in in so long. I don't remember the tone of of the book if it's kind of anti brethren if it's objective but I think it's either very deferential toward the brethren or fairly objective or I would wouldn't remember it so highly because I I tend to get offended when people are ripping on the puzzle and and then the third source is not published but it's the Saint George temple minutes. I don't I mean people I know I just say e-mail me I'm not begging for 100 emails right now but I just tell them e-mail me I'll get you a copy I don't remember where I got mine. I've seen it from time to time when sharing sources with other scholars I've, you know, they'll they'll send me a new copy with new formatting.
1:37:34 But it's the same stuff. It's it's it could be a little bit dry. It's letters from somebody to somebody else in the, you know, people saying today we had a temple meeting and this is what we discussed. And later on it says somebody asked whether or not baby needs to be endowed. They died before they were eight and one says yes, later they say no later, say yes again, you know, things like this. But I think that was very telling. One of the most interesting details in that book that I recall was somebody was asking how much do we wear the garment. And he said, well, we wear the garment when we want to receive revelation.
1:38:17 So wouldn't you want to be ready to receive revelation at any moment of the day? So you should wear it 24/7. And personally, I think that's where the innovation came from, that they were garment 24/7. I don't think they're Joseph. Joseph never taught that. He taught them not to wear it when they were in danger for wearing it, which you could say is an anomaly. Fair enough. But he also didn't wear it when he was going to martyrdom, knowing he was going to be martyred again. You could say it's an anomaly. But when Benjamin S Johnson in 1904 writes to things George S Gibson the the First Presidency, they said, was Joseph wearing the garment at this time.
1:38:57 This time in his response wasn't well. There was this anomalous situation or there was an exception to the rule, he says. Have you ever been in Nagavu in the middle of the summer you know are you kidding me? What idiot is going to wear that long sleeve long pant like thing in the middle of late July in Nauvoo. It's too hot. You can't breathe. You can't move in it. You know that's kind of I'm I'm adding to his words a little bit but that's his point you know. So I absolutely think that's an innovation and that's the thing you get in Saint George Temple minutes is is it's it's an amazing source. So many good things in there and but those are the three primary sources.
1:39:40 I'm I'm sure there are articles out there that are really good. I've seen some on different topics that look really interesting and skinned over there and said wow that's that's really cool. But I, I, I kind of quit looking at all of the actual changes that were made when I when I read Devry's book because it it it it did it just it was super depressing to me. It made me just feel awful, right? It woofer woofer, Woodruff makes abundantly clear, and I think some of the other brothers were similarly or equally clear. These ordinances aren't just for this earth. You don't go make another earth and give different ordinances. They taught all the gods through all eternity use the same ordinances.
1:40:31 And you know, even if you're looking at a template format as opposed to specifics, I I don't think we've got any business changing those. And and I I think especially at this time of our dispensation, even if somebody is inclined to want to change something that maybe is OK to change, I I I won't do it anyways. I read the sacrament word for word every time I give it to my family. I know I don't have to. I hate King James English. I think that's a destroyer of of many of our understandings. But I I use the King James English just as it's found in DNC 20, even though I know Brigham didn't do it.
1:41:15 Because I I I just really want to retain that kind of concept with my kids. And I I think if we're going to err, I'd rather err by being too strict and insisting upon a detail that maybe wasn't necessary rather than being the one necessary to say, Oh, well, you know, Drew's family like having a priest about here because he started changing crap, you know, put that on somebody else's shoulders. I don't want it on mine, you know, at any rate. So those are the resources. I would, I would suggest people read my book is just kind of like what we discussed today to say this is what Joseph taught about it.
1:41:57 This is what he said was OK and maybe not OK and this is what's unclear but the he also taught don't change principles. He also thought don't change laws you know said don't change the gospel at all. They're all eternal but then we have pieces of them that aren't eternal and that are changed. So you know I I address issues like that and and let me just throw out 11 quick example of that that I, I, I throw these things out for people to think about and say how do I reconcile that. So we recognize Old Testament laws were changed by Christ right. He says. So I've tried to not destroy them, but to fulfill them. And then he says, don't do this anymore. Do this instead.
1:42:40 Don't do this anymore. Do this instead. Well, then we're in the temple endowment. We're told to obey laws as contained in told testament. Hello. OK, so I'm supposed to if if I if I'm in the army, then it's OK for me to go kill somebody, steal his wife and take her home with me. As long as I shave her head cutter nails and make it put ashes on and and and they don't touch it for 30 days, it's OK. You know that's an Old Testament law. I'm supposed to follow that. Still those changing laws are part of the unchanging ordinance. So that could mean one of two things. One, it can mean you're expected to figure it out and and know which ones are superseded and which ones aren't.
1:43:24 Or two, you're supposed to follow it anyway. So either way there's a big challenge there. But understanding that challenge has me approach it differently, right? Right. So when, when you put this book out, what do you hope it does for people when they pick it up, let's say the average mainstreamer when they pick this book up, what do you hope they get out of it? You know, usually this has been a challenge for me. Usually when I write a book, I'm like, this is what people are going to learn from this.
1:44:06 And this is what I, you know, when I wrote Joseph Smith's Doctrine, Insights, last track, Transfiguration, I thought this is what people are going to learn from this. This wasn't an isolated meeting. This was not a council of 50 charge. This was given at least a dozen times on from the hundreds and hundreds of people in our understanding that this is proof of lebaroniteism is false. Maybe there's something there. I'm not discounting all their claims, but that's not good enough. We've got too much information. So that's kind of what I expect people pull out of it. And plus I would hope that they would read and see that Joseph was preparing the Saints to follow the 12. And and you know that Transfiguration, all those accounts are very faith promoting that that would help strengthen people's testimony and restoration through the entire Brigham Young administration. That's something I'd hope to get out of that this book's different, this book.
1:45:08 I I would, I would love to be able to say hey, here's where you can go get your second writing, but I don't. I don't feel like that's that's my place, nor is it the purpose of the book. At the end of the day, that's what we should be striving for and and I would hope it would at least awaken in people to look at whatever organization they're at, say, well, have they changed things? Pretty much, yeah, somewhere. How much is it? Enough. Is it not enough? The the 2nd Anointing Ordinance itself encourages you to give that ordinance to other people. Is your organization standing about it or they trying to perpetuate the priesthood on the earth? And I, I, I grant you, don't want to give people unworthily. You don't want to be throwing it on people who are schmucks that don't really care and aren't going to live the gospel and get get stuck in the head that they're awesome now and start doing crazy crap like a lot of fundamentalists do, you know, You know, there's that too.
1:46:13 But do they understand the injunction that they're supposed to be preparing people on giving that ordinance to them? That's an important part of it. Then that should be part of their teachings. And if it's not, you know, I whatever level people are at, I just hope that they would look and say Joseph's either a prophet or he's not. He's a prophet. He's warning me something here, he's warning us. And Paul warned the Jews, too. That's where Joseph got this teaching from. And is there anything to these warnings? And I think if we look at our history, we say fortunately, yeah, Isaiah prophesied our generation would be changing the ordinances and the earth would be cursed and devoured because of it. Do I blow him off too?
1:47:06 Jesus says greater the words of Isaiah, follow him and you'll listen to him. Well, except for that he was wrong. You know, the modern day prophets know better. I would hope people at least stop and think about it. And if you come to the conclusion, well, I think these are just template changes. It's the template's there. It's OK. I hope you're at least a little bit better off than being lazy about it, not caring at all, you know? But I I hope it just opens eyes to people and and and get them to think deeper about these things. I also think at the same time, I think it's important to recognize that Joseph and giving us these warnings also gave us hope. This priest did.
1:47:49 The fullness of the priesthood won't be taken. So where you going to get it? Where you going to find it? Well, pray about it. Find out. But at the end of the day, he promised us it would be here and it would be available for people who really want it. And I think that's important for people to know. It'll especially a lot of new fundamentalists. You know, you you're like, oh, mad at the church for a while, which I don't think is healthy, but I understand. I get it. But, you know, they're mad at the church for a while and they're like, well, I gotta find the guy with, gotta find the one guy with the keys and they look around and they don't find it. And they're like, shoot, like, yeah, I gotta find two guys with the keys. Like, what's going on here? And, you know, they go through all these angsty, stressful transition periods where they're trying to figure this out because it's everything's contrary to what they've been taught in the Church.
1:48:42 But then they find all these things substantiated by the early Brethren. And the deeper you dive in the Early Brethren, the more substantiated you find. All this fundamentalist teachings, broadly speaking, you know, 'cause obviously we contradict each other. You know which group you're in or whatever. I I think a fundamental, important part of the gospel is that God is not a God of despair. He's not a God of well, you get to suck you into the deal, so tough luck. He's not a God of well, I I I gave the opportunity to Joseph, and he promised everybody to keep it. You know what? They they would have these. But you're not going to get it.
1:49:22 You know, God's not like that. He's given a promise through Joseph that the former priesthood would not be lost from the earth. Why? To give you hope. You know, maybe it's maybe you're not going to find who's got it right away. Maybe you're going to join a group and think they're just awesome and then you find out how corrupt they are and you got to deal with that and then you go somewhere else. You have the same problem, whatever. Maybe that's your journey that that happens to a lot of people and frankly, you know it's a difficult time to be a follower of Joseph. And and so if that. But if that's you, then at least have that knowledge of hope that he offers in those prophecies and get a testimony of it.
1:50:08 Pray about it. Find out for yourself, you know. And once you've got that, you've got something to hold on to. And then you just look around and say who's changed the priesthood ordinances the least or it looks like they kept the template as much as you possibly can. I don't know how else to describe that, but there there are standards he offers to hold on to. There's one more message in the book that that I'd like to throw out there that I haven't discussed at all, and that's this. There's a a book called The Gospel of Coilote. It's got its own controversy because what in fundamentalism or Christianity doesn't have controversy but it purports to be written by the original apostles gathering together and saying let's remind each other of everything Christ ever taught us.
1:51:00 And there's something in there that that well there are a few teachings in there that have really impacted me personally and it goes back to this idea of of God gave the Israelites the the Old Testament laws as a cursing to them and further Christ in in in the gospel of Kylie. It says it even better in in in Mark chapter 10, Pharisees come and Sadducees come to to Jesus, whatever it was, religious guys come to him. I can't. I think it was just the Pharisees and they come to him and said, Moses said that we could get a bill of divorcement.
1:51:44 But what do you say? It was a trick question because they're they're trying to trap him in it. And in the Gospel of Cailate the answers the same as Mark chapter 10, and it adds this. He says, what says the spokesman of God on this issue and he's talking about Moses and they said, well, he he allowed us divorce and Jesus responds. He says he allowed this because of the hardness of your hearts and the beginning was not. So then he quotes Genesis 2 which is rabbinical technique to quote the earliest source you possibly can that proves your point. But but basically he supports Moses. He says, yeah, Moses taught you falsehood.
1:52:26 Moses gave you a bad law and he condemns in the gospel of the extras like you know, any type of divorce. Whether it's formal, formal, a blessed by a priest or not, doesn't matter. You leave it alone. Don't you touch that. If they're committed to it, let him go for it. And and you know, so he he says. So Moses gave this law that I don't approve of on some level. I'm telling you it's wicked. But he says he gave it to the heartless of your hearts. And then he says a couple a couple different things. In one place he says marriage laws are given unto men because their failure to love and to empathize. And then he says in another place all the marriage laws are given because men are in their fallen condition. And also there are three other scriptures induction covenants that modify that.
1:53:20 So, you know, you can argue all day long about it, but we we have this attitude that this is what the Scripture says, you know, and we're we're OK with divorce because Jesus said it's OK in Mark chapter 10. You know, he condemned it. And and so we tend to be pretty dogged about things like that and say, well, Joseph taught this, right? Well, what I see Christ teaching here is is not to say everything's relative. And Joseph kind of taught that too, right. He said what God says is right in one circumstance might be wrong in another. And you know, whatever God tells you to do is right. That's not my point either. What he's saying there is I'm giving you light and knowledge according to what you're willing to receive. I gave you DNC 42 on consecration. You weren't willing to do it, So I gave you tithing. You weren't willing to do that.
1:54:13 So I gave you lower law. You know, I gave you a piece of it or something. So he's he's trying to say, look I give you laws to help you to progress and lighten knowledge until you're perfect in light knowledge. That's Alma 12 verse 9 to 12 again and it But in this verse he's saying don't say it's right or wrong. Don't assume this is how I read it. Don't assume I gave you the highest law on this matter. Assume this might be a stepping stone to a higher law on this matter and that if I were to reveal more to you then you would have even more like knowledge and more reasons to try and look differently, right? And and I think this is super crucial in the book I mentioned briefly if the only the law was given first then you have people be like well if I see that you paid according to your net value and I really think you should be paying according to your gross income.
1:55:19 Right. And then you have somebody else say, well brother Dave does pay according to his gross income but that's he's supposed to be doing it on his surplus or his increase. Well I don't think he's doing it right And we bickering ripe about all these things. Right. Right. And and we're we're trying to live perfectly according to this law but isn't that missing whole purpose Tithing isn't about that you this certain percentage tithing is if you do it the way Joseph taught through Edward Partridge and you do it on on increase that income it's a tiny amount What's the purpose When you pay tithing you feel good like brother so and so needed that money and now he's got some and he's not hurting now and I love brother so and so and I'm glad that he's doing better now and I contributed to that because I pay tithing and I feel good. Well that's that's what it's for right. Right now Are you ready to consecrate now You want to give more of your meaning now to more people and and bless more people.
1:56:24 That's the purpose of tithing. It's a stupid law by itself. It's maybe not even an eternal law. It's a stepping stone to consecration. You know if you're consecrating you're paying more than tithing. You don't need tithing. You know you're automatically you're not calculating anything. You're just saying I've got all this extra money and I'm going to give it away to whoever needs it And you're not worried about what the percentage is and how many points it's going to take off of your tax deductions and crap. You're just doing it because you love your fellow man and and so his point there and there is saying look at this law not as the end all, be all and bickering about the details. Look at it as a stepping stone to your exaltation. You're stepping stone to your salvation and ask if Christ were going to reveal more to me, how would that change how I live? Well, how?
1:57:18 How would that make me better? And that's a totally different attitude. Now. I'm not saying, well, Brother Dave pays up gross. And I think that's really pedantic. You should be paying on that, you know. And, you know, get rid of those stupid pharisaical attitudes about the gospel and look at it more as I'm trying to improve you as a person. Another thing the Gospel of Kylie points out that's similar to this that I really love is he's got multiple people coming to him for advice and one guy. He says, I want you to stay and keep your business because you employ a lot of people. Another time, he says, sell all that you have and follow me. Another time, he says, well, do you give charity or do you hire people?
1:58:09 Says, Well, I do charity, says well increase, do more charity. And he's giving all these guys different advices. And 111 of the disciples says, Lord, you tell people different things and and he says, well, every wealthy person has two responsibility to either give a lot of charity or to hire people because he's taking care of other people, helping other people feed their families. That's the the whole point, you know. But he says I give different laws to different men because some men are good businessmen and can make more money and and and hire more people and some guys make a boatload of money, but they don't like supervising people. So OK, you don't reinvest in the new business, just give the money to charity, you know.
1:58:54 And so he's tailoring those things so that they live. What's the principle here is consecration. Right, right. He's, he's not saying the way for Dave to consecrate, same as brother so and so and so and same as Drew. Everybody's got a different talent, a different way of consecrating. I'm broke 3/4 of my life I'm I'm better consecrating my time talents and efforts. You know go to you want to consecrate some money go to so and so he's got a lot of it and and and so I think that attitude about the gospel really effects how you view people around you your relationships and and I think that's something throughout this this whole as I've been writing this book it's really it's really been kind of deeply impressed upon me. The more I see it there are eternal principles and there are mortal principles there are eternal laws and there are mortal laws and if you don't know which is which then just obey him to the best of your ability and ask right. But if you can start seeing and perceiving the gospel as God giving direction not of it's an eternal principle that when you. You didn't know war with your neighbor, that you can kill a guy and then take his wife, shave her head, take her home and she's yours.
2:00:11 You know, that's not an eternal principle. That's a stepping stone for a cultural group of people who had that legitimate question. What do we do when we find, you know, extra women now that we've conquered people, We love them, starve and die, or we take them home? And he says, well, in your culture, this is probably the best thing to do. Leave her alone for a while. Give her time to grieve, you know and and treat her so. Cut her hair off so she doesn't look enticing to you and you know put her in sackcloth mashes so she looks ugly to you so you'll leave her alone for a month. Give her time to grieve her husband. Jeez, you know and then you know if you still want her then then she can be your wife. That's clearly not an eternal principle and and that's an easy example that's why I give it because it's super easy to see that's not eternal principle.
2:01:00 But when we get stuck looking at commandments and laws as everything's an eternal principle. But wait, this one contradicts this one. Wait, this one, then we lose our testimonies or we look at it saying that I agree with this, not this, and let's petition the church to change it. You know, then we're missing the point. You know, tithing is a stepping stone to consecration is a stepping stone to just loving your neighbor as yourself. That's it. It's that simple. And if we're if we can see all the gospel like that, then it it softens our hearts and it it gives us the opportunity to ask for revelation.
2:01:41 You're like, well, God, you know you say here that I can I can forgive 70 * 70 but you also tell me on the 4th time that I'll be justified if I want to beat the hell out of the guy that hurt me, right. So what's the better law, you know, and and and maybe find some distinctions that surprise you. There's the obvious thing. Well, just keep forgiving. But sometimes that's not the best thing because then they abuse other people. So you know, you might pray about it and give an answer you're not expecting, but if you're not thinking about it that way, you're never gonna ask the questions. So to me, that's that's the whole important thing about the gospel for me is constantly asking those questions.
2:02:23 What are you trying to teach me? What our society, the restoration. You know if we're not asking those questions will will the brother and said do this, the brother and said do this. I'm going to just do this. And we're constantly doing our checklist stuff. We we lose the whole spirit of what it's all about and and I think it's super important not to do that. And so anyway, that's the third message and it shows up in the book that's in the section he's talking about changing laws, changing principles, changing gospel, coming to a better understanding as to what that's for and to where we get to the point where Paul said to the pure, all things are pure and to the impure all things are impure.
2:03:12 And he further said in the in it's easier to read the NIV or NRSV or anything with the King James Version probably he he says maybe I should look it up so I don't misquote it. I don't I don't want to misquote it but it basically says the law doesn't apply to me anymore. But I I neither am I willing to do things that are not good or not useful. And I point out in the book, he talks about the law in terms of Levitical law, Mckessic law and that sort of stuff. And how I'm reading that is, is him saying we've got all these lower laws, that's, you know, Old Testament's lower law, New Testament, even some of that's lower law.
2:04:03 I'm, I'm not subject to that law. I have a fullness of priesthood. Fullness of priesthood tells me that some of these laws that you are subject to are not good enough. I need to do better than that. I need to live a higher principle, these things. So I'm not subject to your law anymore. I'm not subject to a higher law and but neither am I going to waste time to do bad things. You know, just because I'm not subject to your law doesn't mean it's useful for me to break your law. And and again that's this perspective of of there's there's more out there.
2:04:45 You know what's yeah, I might be justified to do something but am I sanctified by doing that thing or am I gonna be more perfect for doing that thing that that's really an important attitude that that that Paul's kind of exhibiting here. That's that's my reading of it anyway. And and we see this at DNC 7684 and 88 you know, saying all things are theirs. You know things past, present or in the future. Well, how are all things yours? And how have you overcome all of the law? If you overcome all the law, are you not given something higher? Are you not given a bigger law, a better law, a more perfect law? And you know, maybe you're going to struggle with that too, but still, you know, shouldn't you expect to be progressing all these things in any regular?
2:05:41 Yeah, So that's my long winded answer. No, no, that's that's that's great stuff. That's good. That's good stuff, Drew. All right, dude, that's beautiful. What was the name of the book again? Where can they find it? Changing ordinances? Losing priesthood? It's on Amazon. If you just type my name and then if you type my name you you get all my books. sci-fi, fantasy and all that sort of stuff too. But all my all my stuff pops up. Currently I'm waiting for approval on the hardback paperback. I expect that in a day or two they can be kind of quirky. Sometimes they they give you a template, say make it exactly like this and make it 1 pixel off and they complain and you get exactly right and it doesn't work. So sometimes it takes a few mess arounds and this time they're really giving me some grief.
2:06:31 So perfect. Hopefully it's just a couple days. I'll throw a link in there so people can just go right to it and get it, but dude, that was good stuff, my man. Awesome. Thanks. Appreciate that. Thanks, Drew. Super fun chatting with you. Always. All right, man. Bye, everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade Podcast.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox