Jan. 18, 2025

Episide #167: An Examination Of The Nemenhah Record Part 2 W/Justin Francom

Episide #167: An Examination Of The Nemenhah Record Part 2 W/Justin Francom
Episide #167: An Examination Of The Nemenhah Record Part 2 W/Justin Francom
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episide #167: An Examination Of The Nemenhah Record Part 2 W/Justin Francom

Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.

Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products

The Savior warned us that in the last days there would be false Prophets and false Christs that would lead people astray. To ensure that we don’t become misled it is important that we understand truth so well that we can spot a counterfeit a mile away. It is for this reason I wanted to do this two-part series on the Nemenhah Record. With that said last week me and Justin Francom broke down the Nemenhah Record and explored some pretty problematic teachings found in this alleged book of scripture. Today Justin joins me again as we finish our examination of the Nemenhah Record, and spoiler alert we are about see where the Nemenhah Record really disagress with the Book of Mormon and other principles of the Restoration as taught by the Prophet Joseph Smith. Today we cover what the Nemenhah Record says about changing the ordinance of Baptism, Plural Marriage and some damning evidence on timelines that really puts the record at odds with what has already been revealed by the Prophet Joseph Smith. I would ask that you please share these episodes with your family and friends who have bought into this record so that they might not be deceived

0:01 The Savior warned us that in the last days there would be false prophets and false Christs that would arise to lead the people astray. Now, to ensure that we don't become misled, it is important that we understand the truth so well that we can spout a counterfeit a mile away. It is for this reason I want to do this two-part series on the Nimenhall Record. With that said, last week me and Justin Franklin broke down the Nimenhall Record and explored some pretty problematic teachings found in this alleged book of scripture. Today Justin joins me again as we finish our examination of the Niman Ha record. And spoiler alert, we are about to see where the Niman Ha record really disagrees with the Book of Mormon and other principles of the restoration is taught by the Prophet Joseph Smith. Today we cover what the Niman Ha Record has to say about changing the ordinances of baptism, plural marriage, and some pretty damning evidence on timelines that just don't match up with what's already been restored by the Prophet Joseph Smith through the Book of Mormon. I would ask that you please share these episodes with your family and friends who maybe have started to buy into this record so they might not be deceived that much. Much more on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. Want more from the Mormon Renegade podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the fundamental news program for free.

1:18 Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button and for $5.00 a month you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes today. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. I want to talk about baptism because this is, to me, baptism. Baptism is really, it's fundamental in our Christian faith as Mormons, right?

2:28 This is the way that you enter into the straight and narrow gate that leads to eternal life. This is the baptism is a really, really crucial step. There's a lot of important steps on your way to eternal life, but baptism? That first step? Hugely important. Huge, right one small. All right, that's nothing of a clever Buzz Aldrin quote, but I can't come up with it, so never mind. OK. One, one small step for for man 1 giant leaf for exaltation. It's it's where we start. So let's look at their take on baptism. So this is from volume 1, the ways and customs of the Ammonites, Chapter 7.

3:12 So the Ammonites are again in the Book of Mormon, the Ammonites are those Lamanites that that convert and due to Alma the younger, not Alma younger, the sons of Mosiah's ministry, right? And they bring a bunch of Ammonites back into the Nephites. They form their own city and they're the Ammonites. So the Ammonites had their own ways and customs. And I, I tried to find this quote, but I couldn't find it. But basically when they, according to this record, when they show up, Alma gives them permission to continue some of their existing practices, which I think is totally fine.

3:57 Right. As replacements for priest ordinances, not not so down. To not so not so good. No, no, not. So good, not so good. So there's a lot where there's a lot in this record that describes Indian culture, Native American culture. OK. How and a lot of it's close to at least, you know, the modern perspective of how the Native American people lived, right? And it draws a lot upon their traditions and their beliefs. I mean, I think this woman's council thing is totally connected to that. A lot of this really does. But the the point I'm bringing up here though, is so there's this whole section in here where it describes the ways and customs of the Ammonites, which is basically described as Lamanite culture, but they're Christian. Gotcha.

4:49 OK. So in Chapter 7, man, OK, this is the description of something of their sweat lodge basically, and I'm not going to read this whole thing, but if you know what a sweat lodge is, if you ever done I've I've participated a few times. So I have an uncle does them. It describes a sweat lodge I don't have. I don't think there's anything wrong with it with a sweat lodge ceremony. I've had great experiences doing that, but I don't think it's the same thing as being baptized. And they make that assertion here.

5:31 And that's what we're going to see happen here. So here in verse 18, this is Chapter 7. Behold, this is the manner of sacrifice among the Ammonites and it is known as the purification after the manner of the Ammonites wherein each person so actually here it's maybe not replacement for baptism here it seems to be a replacement for the the law of of sacrifice, the Moses law of 'cause this is this is pretty Christ still right, right. And so they're still the Nephites are still doing animal sacrifice according to the Law of Moses. As they should. As they should, wherein each person gives not a Bullock or a lamb or a flight, but rather they sacrifice of themselves in remembrance of the creation and declaration of the intent of their hearts and in honor of the sacrifice of the Son, which sacrifice shall be made for all according to as the prophets have written.

6:22 So at least here in this instance, they're saying instead of doing the the sacrifice as well as came through the law of Moses, as we see performed by Abraham, as is instructed to Adam and Eve, They've got they've got their own the one that that Abel performed that sacrifice. They've got their own version. Now this is a better version even because here they sacrifice themselves because the sweat lodge is is is hard, is a hard thing to endure. It's a it's a sacrifice. So now this sacred manner of sacrifice is usually done by men, for women make a greater sacrifice. Nevertheless, on special occasions or for special purposes, women may also make women make the sacrifice also. Behold, this they do in order to at once fulfill the law of Moses and also to look forward to the day of redemption, when the Creator shall become the Savior and redeem the world. Yeah, He was created.

7:23 The heavens and the earth shall descend and bow and take up all suffering. By this you are all made part of this covenant he made with the Father and the Holy Ghost. So I mean, I don't know. To me, I don't see how this is different from Cain's sacrifice. That's exactly where I was going. What was Cain's ultimate downfall, right? Well, you could say it was pride, right? But. But. There's a character flaw, but how did that character flaw manifest? Right. It manifested in saying, no, no, I'm special. The Lord's rules don't apply to me exactly the way they apply to everybody else, right? This is no different than Cain offering a sacrifice that is not prescribed by the Lord. But here in this, in this record, it is said, no, it's totally fine.

8:18 They're they're they're doing just fine. They don't need to do animal sacrifices. They they do sweat lodges. It's just as good. And I don't have it like you. I have nothing against the sweat lodge. You know, it's not the same obviously, but you know, there's health benefits to that. Like there is a sauna or something like that, right? And and you know, I've even. Heard of people I find spiritual value in? It yeah, I think, you know, people have talked about finding spiritual value there and that's great, but don't pretend it's a substitute for what the Lord has prescribed, because it's not. And that line of thinking will get your butt in a sling the same way it got Keynes in a sling. And I don't care how nice and flowery you couch the the verbiage they're in in this record, it is still the same problem.

9:13 You are changing the ordinances and that always leads to suffering every time. Well, sympathy's going to have a word with you later on. Maybe one of the three knee fights is going to have a word to say to you later on. Maybe, maybe it, you know, if, if this is, yeah, if, if he shows up at my door, then at that point I'll have a talk. But until that happens, I think I think I'll go ahead and stick with what God has said. OK. I know I'm crazy that way. We'll see how that strategy plays out. All right. 21 by doing this Baptist or by doing sacrifice this way instead. Essentially, right. And the Lord has rewarded those who sacrifice in this manner with the administration of angels, with great gifts of the Spirit, and with the renewing of health and strength. Nevertheless, the temple sacrifices are still performed by the Nephites, and they are greatly blessed in their observances.

10:10 So good to know. Good to know if you're going to do the spot lodge instead. If you're still doing animal sacrifices like God told you, that's OK too. That's still OK too. Jeez. So at least we're not calling out the Mosaic sacrifices. No, we're not. Throwing them under the bus. Yeah, they're just saying there's a different way of doing them. They're just they're just saying this, this motorcycle is a bus as well, right? And in 22 and this is good for of all the ordinances of the Lord, those that prepare the people to abide the presence of God are found in the sacrifices, whether they be centered in the temple or in the community or in the individual.

10:53 And these ordinances demand purity and good intent, else they are ineffectual. So as long as you've got good intent, any kind of sacrifice really is it counts. Right if if this is. True, they prepare you to any kind of sacrifice prepares you to meet God in some way or another. And so it's it's all good. If this is true, the Lord owes Cain an apology. That's. An interesting point. Right. I mean, if that's true, he owns. He owes Cain an apology. Yeah, well, I don't know, Maybe we'll learn more about the real reason Cain fell in volume. 7. Especially since it got brought up. OK, so anyway, let's learn more about baptism.

11:34 Or, or that's not baptism. Let's learn more about Not Baptism, volume one Second Shimul, Chapter 7 Samuel, verse 21. And when a child reaches the age wherein they begin to understand my gospel, they shall be held accountable for that understanding. Sounds good? Wherefore you shall take them, and cleanse them every whit with water. And this may be done after the manner of Alma, when he baptized the people in the waters of Mormon, or after the manner of the purification of the Ammonites. For I will accept such baptism or such purification, and sanctify it unto you. And behold, if they do this, accepting this ordinance with understanding, then I will baptize them with fire, and with the Holy Ghost.

12:21 And by the way, this is Christ speaking, supposedly. So the first one it's it can replace animal sacrifice. It also is a a substitute for baptism. Straight from the Lords of of Christ. Straight from the mouth of Christ, apparently. Holy cow. But there's more. But wait, there's more. Volume 3, Book of Manatee Chapter 4. Now this is more on the the cosmology on why it counts, why any sacrifice works. OK, it's it gets it gets I wouldn't say it gets complicated. OK, So you know, you know, Lehigh teaches, you know, man is that he might have joy, right, right. There's these beautiful truisms that kind of come out of the Book of Mormon that, you know, wickedness never was happiness. And one of my favourites of those is when Alma's teaching Coriantin and he says basically that, that what you put out comes back to you.

13:27 It's essentially a Mormon perspective of, of karma, basically saying if you do bad things, there will be there will be bad consequences. And you know, I find that pretty deep, but I also find it pretty simple. But we're going to look at something very similar to that. And this is might be really hard to follow if you're listening, it's hard to follow if you're reading, but we're going to do our best here. So on verse 25, wherefore, and I'm not sure who's some some prophet's teaching here, wherefore if a man chooses to do evil, the matter does not end with the choice and the action. Do you see how any action creates in its own sphere a disturbance in the universe?

14:08 The universe. Yeah, it's like the Force, a disturbance in the Force. Disturbance. In the universe, right? Yes. I don't actually. I, I, I do see how there are consequences to actions that I don't. Some kind of a, a, a metaphysical universal disturbance. Not, not so much. I haven't, I haven't. I have never experienced that myself. Right. Like somebody in the universe commits a sin, suzes evil. I don't, I don't. It's not, it's not affecting me. I'm not picking up on that stuff. And maybe it is, but this disturbance continues beyond the actions of that one decision. Yeah. It continues outward and effects all things created, which is fascinating because basically it's saying the consequence of sin effects everybody and everything.

14:54 All things created will be affected when when somebody chooses evil. I don't know. I mean, there's definitely a ripple effect, don't get me wrong, right? Like if I if I go and and and beat my kid and he grows up and he has a bunch of kids and he beats his kids and and they grow up and they beat their kid, you know, definitely things magnify. But does that affect all things created? I don't know. I don't see how it could. I have a problem with this, right? Because it seems to be recreating the conditions of the fall all over it. Yeah, right. That to me is again, a little problematic, right? I didn't think that there's a certain arrogance to this too, right?

15:40 Like, how important are we that we can affect everybody else with one of our bad decisions? Again, I get the analogy of if you beat your kid and then he goes on to be just a complete jerk to everybody else. I get that. OK, that that makes sense. But the way they're talking about it here, it seems to have a much more metaphysical reaction. Right. And it does. It kind of denies agency on the things affected as well, right? Because what if I beat my kid, but he grows up and he comes to Christ in a way I never did and decides that beating beating children are wrong and so he doesn't beat his kids? Right.

16:21 Is that not possible? Oh, it's it, It happens quite frequently that that someone gets better. Yeah, right. But this kind of denies that and says that no, it just grows and it expands and effects everything, right. And behold, when it returns again, it may have been magnified into a much greater evil. And again, as far as return, you know, as far as returns again, I mean, I, I think it potentially returns again in that there's a, there are consequences to sin, right? Right. But this is a little bit more cosmic and it gets it gets more complicated. So who among you has not seen this magnification? Look unto the knee fights of the land southward. You notice they like to rail on the knee fights. They like to, yeah, yeah.

17:09 They like to rail on the knee fights a lot. Which is funny because I mean. They're. Technically the same people, they just gave themselves a different label. But I look into the knee fights in the land southward and the great evil that came that became of just a few men and their evil acts gay. The whole face of the land was laid waste, most especially in the northernmost reaches in the land southward. Yay. There's not one place in that part of the land that has not been altered. Let this remind you of the consequences of your actions at all times. OK, so it's just a, it's just a couple bad people. That's not what, that's not what Mormon says, right? The, the, you know, the whole of the, the civilization became bloodthirsty at some point, right? Right.

17:58 I thought they were all bloodthirsty, Yeah, for the most part. And that's why they fell. Yeah, not just if. If you want to take the Book of Mormon's word for it. Sure, right. But maybe it was one or two men who just did some evil and it just magnified. Right. Yeah, and. Everybody else had to pay that price. Right. That's sad if that's true. So in 27 and behold, the same applies when a man chooses to do good for the same law operates in the case of good as it does in the case of evil. What you apply in the universe, be it good or evil returns unto you. So, you know, kind of again, copying Alma message Coriant in there, but it's in a very more, you know, again Alma Coriant. I understood that when I read that it made sense. It was enlightening.

18:44 It was like, aha, it it's so deep, but so simple. This seems really complicated and I, I, I don't follow it personally. No. Regardless what you apply in the universe be a good or evil returns to you. And if evil is multiplied in the application of the universal law, so then is good. Let your actions for good go out and come and go into the cosmos and return unto you so magnified that not one particle of your matter is left unaltered. That's I don't, I'm not sure what that is like. I've never had a good deed go into the cosmos, no, and into the universe and then come back to me and affect every particle of my existence.

19:26 No, but it's an interesting idea I guess. Look, there's no doubt you're blessed when you do well, right? What that blessing is may be different each time or or whatnot, but the way they're describing it here is really quite New Agey. That's what I. Thought seems very New Agey too, and I don't necessarily think it's that complicated. I think it's a lot simpler than that personally. Actions have consequences. You know cause effect and we can I can comprehend that I can't comprehend a good deed going out, mingling among the stars and then coming back and affecting the particles of my matter that one just. No, it makes.

20:09 Doesn't make sense to me. No, it makes no sense. So continuing, this gets into baptism, I promise. No, you're good. Or at least their baptism. So now this law has greatest effect when the motion caused is greatest. I guess I'm not sure what that means, motion caused, but maybe it's like a really good deed creates a bigger. Yeah, Yeah. Wherefore the Lord has commanded all of His children to seek an understanding of the law of sacrifice. For it is by and through this law that the most significant change is made upon the matter of mortal man. So now we went from good deeds and evil deeds to acts of sacrifice. And an act of sacrifice, as opposed to a good or evil deed, apparently causes the greatest motion, and it goes out into the universe, and therefore it comes back even harder and transforms you even more.

21:10 And this is the principle behind acts of sacrifice, right? So in 29. Yeah. For with all sacrifice comes a crying out of the soul. And this crying out or distress of the soul causes the greatest movement of the spiritual matter of the universe. But this matter exercises faith according to the natural law of which we have spoken. I don't understand what that means at all. That's how matter exercises faith. Now, when this matter returns, it seeks faith with which to cause equilibrium. I don't understand that at all either. I'll be honest, it's way over my head and behold, all matter is imbued with this intelligence. I guess it's talking about the Holy Ghost people. Maybe if it returns to the point of sorrow and finds their sorrow still, it will cause that faith to return into its own and the consequence will be more sorrow and greater. So apparently it can be really bad too though, even though it, you know, it's supposed to be this good thing going out and coming back and being a good thing. If it comes back and, and you're in a state of sorrow, apparently it'll create even greater sorrow for this does cause for this cause.

22:26 Does suffering bring about greater suffering if left unmodified, which is odd. In that case, then why suffer? Why sacrifice? If if sacrifice is going to go out there and come back and hit you and 'cause your sorrow to be even greater, then why? Why are you doing it? I don't know. But behold, if the matter returns and finds in the place of suffering great acts and utterances of faith, this is that which is utilized to bring about equilibrium. This faith is magnified and edified such that great miracles take place. Wherefore we are commanded to sacrifice that through our suffering a better creation comes into being. I don't know, but this bothers me.

23:07 It sounds a lot like what's their name? There's that Catholic order that I like to hurt themselves. Oh yeah, I can't remember, can't remember who they are, but they were the ones that would like whip themselves and that sort of stuff. Right. They're like the bad guys. And that, that Pulp Fiction style. What is it? The Davinci. Code oh Opus day. Opus Day? Yeah, that's it, Opus. This sounds a lot like Opus Day. And I don't, I don't think that's a true doctrine. I don't think that's a true principle. I don't believe that we have to make ourselves suffer and sacrifice in a way that makes us suffer. And then to for it to transform into faith to bring about miracles and this idea of bringing about a better creation through our suffering.

23:57 Also it sounds a little sacrilegious too because Christ, Christ's sacrifice is is the one and only sacrifice. You know the things that we sacrifice aren't really sacrifices cause all things have been given us of God. The only sacrifice we have available is our agency. We can't sacrifice and make the world a better place. We can obey God and be used as a tool to love God, and God can bring about a better creation through US. And that might require sacrifices at times, but it's not this inherent metaphysical principle of sacrifice that somehow they did. I made a sacrifice, therefore I have I participated in some kind of a of a global atonement.

24:46 Well, yeah, and that's, and that's the the other place I was going to go doesn't in a weird way, seem to cheapen what the Savior has done in his sacrifice. It seems that way to me. I mean, 'cause that's the thing, if if Christ's sacrifice didn't bring a better creation into being, right? When once Christ sacrificed, it's not like all of a sudden we went back to Eden, right? But it seems to allude here that if enough of a sacrifice, and that sacrifice is massive, well then it brings about a better creation. Right.

25:27 Right. You you see. Brings about doomsday cult vibes too to be honest. Yeah, it's that well there. It's at too, right? All right. Everybody line up at the gallows. We're going to we're going to give the lasting great sacrifice and bring this world in the terrestrial sphere. Yeah, yeah. This is, this is problematic based on where it puts Christ and Christ's sacrifice, right. It's no longer front and center as the pivotal moment in human history, but yet something that maybe we could emulate in a way. And through our sacrifice and suffering, if we all do it, it will be even more efficacious than what's the Savior did. This is blasphemy, to be honest with you. Yeah.

26:11 I kind of agree, kind of agree, but you might say, what does this have to do with baptism, right? Well, this is what has to do with baptism. Knowing that you get a choice baptism, do you want to get baptized or do you want the purification of Ammonites? The the. Right when your kids 8 years old, you get to ask them that question in the Nemenha society. Oh, OK. So for this cause is the purification of the Ammonites recommended unto you? Yeah. And for this cause was it so highly favored and justified of the Lord, which of you having placed yourself in the suffering of this purification, and say that you returned from it without a miraculous intervention? So they actually say it's better to do a sweat lodge than to be baptized.

26:59 Yeah, because they're suffering and that's you're now you're a mini Christ essentially, I guess in that suffering. And it will coerce a miracle because apparently, I mean, I don't know, I didn't have a miraculous intervention. When I've done sweat lodges before, they've been challenging. Don't get me wrong. It's like a sauna, right? They're very, it's very warm in there. You're in there for a long time. It's dark. It's not necessarily what you want to do to unwind after a hard day's work, but I don't think it requires miraculous intervention to endure a sweat lodge, at least not the kind that I have. And if they're doing that kind of the sweat lodge, that again brings concerns to me. If surviving the sweat lodge requires miraculous intervention, I.

27:48 Don't. Know what to say about that? Yeah. It is for this cause also that fasting, study, meditation and prayer are also highly recommended unto you. So I guess those things are also sacrifices that require bracket of the tradition. So I can't help myself. In fasting a soul suffering is caused and that soul cry moves upon the matter of your body at I mean like OK hold up, what about fasting and joy? Right, right. And and didn't like this sets up everything that the Lord said to be wary of when you're fasting, right. This sets up a kind of a weird well, in a weird way, it's still the the same same principle here, right? The new the new social currency are those who will have suffered, right?

28:42 That's that's the, the, the new social currency, the the victim class right here. But if you listen to Christ, he tells you, you know, when fasting don't go looking like, you know, you death warmed over, right? That's not the purpose of fasting. And I could see where this would kind of give way to a virtue signaling through your fasting sort of a thing, right? Because right? You're right, throwing yourself into dangerous situations so that God can save you, so that you can be a part of the atonement and help restore the world. I mean, there's some very scary ideas that can be derived from this in my opinion. Yeah, and and it's you're right, it does got that, you know, self torture kind of vibe going on to it here that that is super problematic. Right.

29:31 Not to say that there isn't suffering. Christ tells us to take up his cross. Sure, all of him. So sacrifice is a true principle, but I think they're taking it and turning it into something different. They are. They are. Yep. And that's the issue I've got with it. And so real quick here back in Moron High, this is another interesting thing. When a young person has received our remission of their sins, they are baptized in the name of the Father and the Son and the Holy Ghost. That's Morhonia chapter 17 verse 7. Just a quickie, but it seems like they got it backwards. They do have it backwards. Pretty sure that you're baptized so you can receive a remission of your sins, not that you receive a remission of your sins so you can be baptized.

30:14 Right. There's a few other things in there, but anyway, let's keep moving on. Here we go. Here's here's where it all comes down. And they spell it out as clear as as clear as day. OK, this is, I believe it's Lehi who's one of the three Nephites among the Nephites who's come to the Nemenha people and he's teaching them. And he's also brought an an epistle of some kind from Europe because he was visiting Europe. And while he was in Europe, he met his meeting with some woman who was a descendant of Christ. And so she says hi to them and hi from Europe. And but then Lehigh gets into a sermon and they they write, they, they tell him what he wanted to send us back to say hi to hi back to her, I guess, or whoever's alive by the time he goes back again. But anyway, so that's the context. And so Lehigh's teaching here, I believe, or maybe Nephi, it's one of the two.

31:13 They're both there at the time. Wherefore judge not the nations, First, because you know not judgement, and 2nd, because in the midst of the thrall of your judgement, you will likely lose the common thread of truth and that in which you stand in judgement. Keep your eyes wide open and seek diligently in all books and in all traditions, those truths that guide the Spirit even into the contemplation of higher things. So I don't have an issue with looking for truth in all things. No, no I don't. And. That's where this, that's where that verse ends. But the verse begins by saying you're not allowed to judge. And I've got issue with that.

31:54 Not, do not judge the nation's, you know, there are, there's some bad things that have happened in time. You know, there's, there is a slave trade that happened in, in Africa and I feel like I can judge that. I, I feel pretty comfortable judging that. You know, Japanese, what do they call them? Samurai, you know, having authority, wantonly murder anybody they want legally, you know, that kind of stuff. There's, there's some things that I, I think I can absolutely judge the nations. Look, I think I do know what because God tells us how to judge, right?

32:35 This is actually ironically one of the messages in the book of Moroni that Moroni is specifically writing to the Lamanites is how to properly judge and how to properly give a good gift. Originally, I think that was a sermon of Mormons, but Moroni copies and pastes it in his record directed to the Lamanites specifically because these are important. You need to understand how to judge correctly and you need to understand how to give a good gift or basically a good sacrifice, right? And he spells it out and it does not say this. This is this is different. Right.

33:16 But I understand why he's saying it right? Because us wicked Gentiles might be like, hey, you know what? This purification of the Ammonites, who are we to judge that is a valid baptism or not? Right. Right. And I mean, I would agree we should be careful in judgement in the context of the baptism. I, I do judge it falsely under the context of a ritual that can be spiritual and help you connect with God. It can be productive. I'm, I think it's OK to, to look at certain things. Sure, I guess what lodge and judge them that way. But this is a thought. This is trying to make it so you can't take that middle ground, right? You can't, you can't, you can't pull the truth out of cultures and incorporate them into your own faith. No, no, no, no.

34:02 You've got to accept everything of other cultures and including their perspectives on this and pull it all in. So behold the animate. So you get talks about the Ammonite purification. It's different from the Nephites, and it says that Jesus the Peacemaker justified both. Right. And it talks about how the purification of the Ammonites is even more holy and it's OK, let's go through this act. This is interesting. So he talks about the Ammonites and says the Ammonite sweat lodge is equivalent and justified right now. He goes on and talks about the the Twil Ha.

34:43 I can't remember who they are, but there's some other people that are around. And behold, the Twil ha, do dance a ceremony most diligently. Yeah. And they do dance around and around all day long. And over and over do they cross the shadow of a tree that they dance their ceremony unto the peacemaker. And they do sweat, as it were, great drops of blood at every pore. Yeah, their living sacrifice is great as they dance the hoop over the cross of the tree over and over again. And some do even make a piercing of the body. And they do all this in similitude of the great sacrifice made by the peacemaker. Yeah. They dance over and over the shadow of the tree, and they sacrifice the water of their lives. And they do shed blood, all in remembrance of the unrelenting eternal nature of the living sacrifice. That being described there is called a Sundance. You know, it's a it's a thing.

35:30 It's a thing. I'm not going to judge it in and of itself as a thing, but it this is not what a Sundance is. It is not done in similitude of Christ's atonement. Right. The people who perform sundancers don't know who Christ is. OK. And this is certainly not an equivalent of baptism, no, but it goes on. And The Who is she? Only people make yet a stranger ceremony where in they do costume or they do consume a holy sacrament, which does cause them to see most clearly all of their greatest fears and even their sins. And they are buried up in them Even so much that they do swoon. And they do give up all of these things and sacrifice, even as King Lemoni of old offered to give all of his sins to know the Great Spirit. Yeah.

36:18 In this strange way, they are buried up in their own hurts and ills, even the fear of death, and they are delivered up out of these things because of their living sacrifice. Now the Hoshioli oblation of purification is different than that celebrated by the twilhah, and the twilhah ceremony is different from the purification of the Ammonites, as the ceremony of the Ammonites was from the washing and anointing of Jerusalem's at Jerusalem's Temple. And yet it you may be assured that the peacemaker does also justify them. Therefore, judge not all the good works of people whose tradition is different from yours, but seek instead to understand of their ways and their unity of faith. And behold, the baptism which you now make is not the baptism once performed in the land of Jerusalem. Behold, for many generations, when men and women would come into the path of your ancient fathers, they do walk into the water and are taken up in boats with Nets and blessed by the priests.

37:23 What? First time I've heard of that, but apparently that's how they did baptisms in Jerusalem. Does this sound strange to you? Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, it does. Of course it does. But shall you judge such things? Yeah, I'm, I'm going to. No, come on. No, no, I, I will. Judge yet instead the principles taught by such a strange thing. There's some good to be found in it, I'm sure. I'm sure. 56 And look, you, Batilda, that's the the descendant of Jesus in Europe, the daughter of the peacemaker, has sent you an epistle proclaiming and testifying with patents the reality of the man Jesus. And they who passed judgement would assume that their ceremonies ought to be ever the same as their own, and must be OK.

38:21 But the whole Bathilda did kneel herself before a priest, and received a burial with but a sprinkling of water. Holy cow. We're going to justify that to them, too. Yep. Now judge you yourself if you think you can. Can you, Dave? You place the body of the departed deep within the stone, or in a jar, all stopped and covered. And this is the immersion which you do in sample with all of your baptizing. But the people of Bathilda do enter their dead in a grave, and do sprinkle first the earth upon them, and this also does signify immersion for them. Can you see how the sprinkling of water might have the same truth as the immersion of the whole body? Can you not discern the likeness of these things then as well? Indeed, that you leave off all judgement of such things. You know, I was recently studying Catholicism, right, and and the Orthodox Church.

39:20 The Orthodox Church still prefers baptism by immersion as the standard, but they do allow for baptisms by sprinkling. But here's the thing, unlike early, early church things, right? Like the first 100 years, you see, I mean AD. Right. We don't know a whole lot about Christianity at that point, right? But once you get a few 100 years in, we get the church, the Catholic Church, right? And you get the Orthodox. Basically it's all, it's all one at that point still, right? And they're growing and they're expanding. We. Know the evolution of sprinkling baptisms.

40:01 We know what they are. The evolution of them is recorded in the history of the Catholic and Orthodox faith that basically people on their deathbed or a newborn infant on its deathbed that has not been baptized is at risk in their in their according to their theology of eternal damnation. Right. And so if they're willing to be baptized, but they're physically incapable because you're in in the hospital, they wanted to make an arrangement. And that's where the sprinkling came in. Right. And over time, it became the standard in the Catholic Church. The Orthodox Church still holds, though, that it's allowable and still in those contexts, but it's just a special rule in those contexts.

40:46 You should still be baptized by immersion. But we know where it came from it they don't say anything about it signifying death because they sprinkled dirt over people's graves. That's that's not where where the sprinkling baptism came from, historically speaking, here by the people who kept that history because they invented the practice. Dude, it's the same argument every time you change the ordinance every time, right? No, no, no, it's not about the ordinance. It's about the meaning behind the ordinance, which is kind of a true thing, except for there are times when the ordinance and the way the ordinance is performed carries the deeper message, right? And so what's happening here is the same thing that's happened throughout time.

41:40 It's an excuse not to do the ordinances as is prescribed that that's it. And they seek just to exclude it. And then there's a, I'm sorry, a a weak kneed attempt at justifying everybody's traditions, right, right. And look, I mean, there's. A wide variety of traditions here. You've got sundances, you've got sweat lodges, you've got what looks like an ayahuasca ceremony. You've got sprinkling. You've got some absurd thing about wandering into the into the lake and getting caught up in Nets, I mean. I have no idea this is this is insane. Yeah, but it gets very clear, right. So first it starts with either acceptable sweat lodge is kind of preferable.

42:32 And then it's just like full blown like anything, right? Like, well, what are, what are what are the, what do Muslims do? Because I'm sure that counts too. Sure. I guess Buddhist, Buddhist, Buddhists, oh, they don't eat meat, some of them, right? So that's a sacrifice. So I guess that counts for them. I mean, I guess everything everybody does. So it's like we're all saved. Man. And I guess they all have the priesthood potentially too, right? I mean, it might not have been, they might not have received the token of it, but they received it 'cause they meditate too. So it's kind of the theology of the justification of rejecting the restoration. Yeah, yeah, yeah.

43:22 And, and let's. And that's a good point too, right? The restoration, per what God revealed to Joseph Smith, was to get rid of this kind of confusion. Right. This is why Joseph Smith got so confused and went to pray in the Sacred Grove. Yes, through this, this alleged record, they are undoing some of that and it can only serve to just, it's depressing in some ways. Holy cow. Yeah, so I've got, I've got one more topic that we need to hit which.

44:03 Is plural marriage, Yeah, let's hit plural marriage. We definitely need to do that. OK. We'll try to go through it quick, but it's a big section here. You're good. There's a lot on it. Whatever it takes. All right, we're in Volume 3, the Book of Manatee Chapter 3. This is the Nemenha people have just established themselves, they're kind of new and that we're going to being organized and they're getting, they get a visitor from Asia like East Asia, Asia. OK. On this flazen and he comes over and visits with them and it turns out they've got a lot of things in common. In fact, he knows of Christ, he preaches of Christ.

44:45 They have the same, they like having all things in common too or something. And they they, they mesh doctrinally. But on one point, he's got his own ideas, OK? OK. But behold, he did teach one thing against which our prophets had been warned, and about which our Scripture spoke. Yeah, he did teach that a man might take to himself more than one wife and be justified in it. He taught that the man is the head of the woman, and if the head of one woman, why not the head of many? Yeah, the principle of his teaching was the doctrine that the salvation of the woman depended upon the worthiness of the man to whom she was wed. It was his belief that an honourable man could feel free to take as many wives as his resources would allow, and that it was the duty of all men to conduct their lives so that their business to afford the man this luxury.

45:40 Right. Right off the bat. Right off the bat. So here's what really bothers me about this. Yay. Principal to his teaching was the doctrine that the salvation of the woman depended upon the worthiness of the man to whom she was wed. Do you believe that's true, Dave? Does woman marry matter? Well, I, I think it matters, right? But I think if, if a woman marries a guy and the guy turns out to be a dirtbag, I don't think that affects her salvation necessarily. If she's walked up to her covenants, I think something will be made, you know, that whether she gets remarried or whatnot, right?

46:26 I do believe marriage is necessary for exaltation, right? But to assume that the guy she married, because let's face it, sometimes marriages happen and one spouse turns out to be a dirtbag, right? It happened. And so because she was married to somebody who she thought was good, who turned out to be a dirtbag, I don't see that necessarily affecting her salvation. Right, but the the man isn't without the woman, or the woman without the man in. The war right at some point does. She need a. Does she need a worthy man? Yes, if he led to. Yes, just like you and I need a, a, a worthy woman right now, whether whether that gets taken care of here or in the next life. One way or another, if if we want to progress, we have got to be married to a worthy spouse.

47:16 Right, and therefore I I agree with this. Right. That the salvation of the woman depended upon the worthiness of the man to whom she was wed. I also likewise believe that the word the the salvation of the man is dependent upon the worthiness of the woman to whom. He is led. I agree totally. Yep. These things matter if they don't matter. If they don't matter, then it really doesn't matter who you marry. No, no, no. If, if these things don't matter, then don't worry about marrying in the covenant. Don't worry about marrying someone who's equally yoked with you in your religion. Just go get married. Just find somebody. Doesn't matter. Exactly. Find somebody the insight to this is fascinating because you you just did that podcast with Taylor. Yep.

48:02 Or those podcasts with Taylor, right. And you discussed all those, I would say natural arguments for polygamy. Yep, right. If they're not, they weren't theologically centered. They were more of just like, hey, natural law, cause and effect, consequence. This is why this makes a lot of sense and it made a lot of sense when I was listening to it. It seems like this guy kind of understands that to a degree, but he's rejecting it, right? Because there's wrong doctrine. Because I think it does matter. I think women should be able to work, marry worthy men, but he's saying they need to. And therefore it makes sense for polygamy.

48:44 And I, I completely agree, right? Yep. So I agree. But where, where does it go? 26 And I say unto you, even though I justify the taking of more than one wife to fulfill my purposes, still shall a man be sealed by the Holy Spirit of promise. Two, but one woman, and a woman shall be sealed by that same spirit. 2 but one man. And this is the manner of marriage in the eternities, regardless of the customs of men and mortality. OK, so they're saying there can be no eternal ceilings for a plural family. Yes. OK, I'm going to say that again so everybody can hear it. According to the Nimenhau record and those who say that they are hitching their wagons to the Nimenhau Record, there is no plural marriage in the eternities.

49:31 So if you're a practicing, if you're practicing the principal like I am and I'm you're. Going to have to pick one. I'm spending all this time to nurture relationships and the girls are spending time to nurture their relationships. It counts for nothing, according to the Neiman Hall record. And people who say that it's a true record and they hitch to it, let's just call it what it is. Right. And you're going to have to pick one. Yes. You want to talk about a sadistic God. I do not want to worship the God of the Nemenhau record.

50:12 That is a sadistic God. You are going to live your whole life as a family. And then in the end he's going to say, oh, pick one, Not a God. I want to serve Justin. I agree. So let's let's see what it what they have to say about it. And I declare, declare unto you, if you base your marriage upon property or the getting of gain. Yeah. If the number of husbands or wives devolves upon the means of a man or a woman the same as wickedness and abomination. Yeah. I shall not justify it. And surely this practice shall bring down the nation. Behold, I am Jesus Christ and I have spoken it. I made a jump there by the way, I was at verse 16. I skipped to 26 because just there's a lot of filler. Yeah.

50:53 So 26 is now this is the answer. And so this is the Lord's answer. So the assumption is is that plural marriage is based upon getting gain and then after. Stupid assertion. Right. So afterwards the Nemenha people tell this Chinese dude, you know, hey, we asked Scott about this full marriage thing you've been preaching and it's wrong. And so this is his response today. I have learned a great lesson. I have learned that the wisdom of the wise cannot compare with the gifts of the Spirit. For though the practice of my people of taking as many wives as one can support is a corrupt practice, if only because of the tendency it might cause for a man to concentrate on the things of this world over the things of heaven. OK, so so the the assertion there is is if you practice plural marriage, you must be by definition a materialistic worldly individual who can is only concerned with getting gained to have more wives.

52:02 Is that is that just OK? Yeah, yeah, if only for the very fact that, you know, it makes you concentrate on the things of this world. But by that argument, then, well, see, if I wasn't married and if I didn't have children, I wouldn't have to worry about my job. And you know what sucks me into the things of the world more than anything else? My job, the hours I spend be able to support a family. I mean, that's me in the world, you know, traversing the world, navigating the world, dealing with those things, wishing we were living in Zion society, but we're not. But if one wife, if two wives, is going to drive you from God into the world supporting 2 wives, then surely so what's supporting 1 though?

52:52 And so wouldn't that also be right? Corrupt. Yep. I mean it's he's really arguing ow, maybe we found the first Buddhist. Maybe. Right, because the Buddhist, you know, the Buddhism is this belief of we're going to subdue any kind of desire, right? The ultimate stoicism. Right. So we can focus on holy things. We won't have families, we won't have wives. We won't eat food that tastes, well, good. We're going to just make life as miserable as possible. So we can focus on heavenly things. Gosh. So yeah, and it goes on a little bit more, but. Not only do they say it's not acceptable, acceptable to teach or or to live, they're telling you that it is an evil.

53:40 Foolish is a doctrine that centers one thoughts on the accumulation of the things of the world. You know, I'd really like to talk to the guy face to face because here's the thing, that dude don't know me and that dude don't know the intent of most guys hearts who engage in this practice. And it's you want to talk. You know that last line there in 31 is how foolish, How foolish is the guy who wrote this because he doesn't know I'm. I'm going to stop right there before I start saying some bad things, OK? All right, all right. Move on, because I'm. Let's move on. I'm. Going to get through. This I'm a little pissed now. So yeah, we better, we better get. All right, it's going to get better. Oh good.

54:21 Oh good. Do I just need to get like duct tape and just tape my head up so I can have all the pieces after it explodes maybe? Maybe. So. OK, they're talking about law of chastity and they basically are going to wrap anti polygamy into law of chastity. This isn't anything that new here, but basically it's it's a, it's a standard Christian arguments. Actually, it's interesting. It's the exact same standard Christian arguments you see against polygamy today. One is, well, Adam and Eve. It's not Adam and Eve's. Right. And argument #2 is well, Abraham did practice polygamy, but look at how big of a problem that all turned out. That's why we have Ishmael and all that.

55:04 So therefore we can know that it's wrong even though it's not prohibited, right? And they're just going to repeat those right here. That's what they do. They're saying, hey, this is a oh, actually this was fascinating. This is fascinating here, right? So I would have you also observe that she Elohe did not covenant with Pennsylvania and it's Elohe or the first woman, but he did covenant with Pennsylvania, Elohe and she did give him a new name. Even Elohim, which being interpreted means they are one. They're saying Elohim means they are one. What does the Hebrew have to say about that? Well, we are not so centered from the Jerusalem of our past, nor from that spoken tongue of our fathers. Lehi and Nephi spoke, that the structure and form of the name Elohim escapes our understanding. So they don't they understand it, for it is the same in our tongue today as it was anciently so hey, they understand it. The name of a woman and one denoting more than one person. OK, so they're.

56:20 It's funny, they're even kind of admitting that the name Elohim denotes masculine and a plural feminine. Right. They're acknowledging that. Yep. Now from the revelation of the temple, we learned that this did not denote more than one wife. Oh, OK, never mind, never mind. For when this was done by men without the direct time of command of God, great evil came upon the people. So in other words, we don't know what it means. We don't know what it means because what it clearly means can't be what it means because, well, our temple ordinance says that polygamy is bad.

57:01 So anyway, I thought that was fascinating. I don't know what was going on there, why you would bring up an argument, a counter argument you couldn't answer. Yeah. But nonetheless, there it is that can make you a little happy. Now consider to me the consequence of God playing this outside the bonds that She has set. When men take upon themselves many wives simply because they are able, they cause an isolation to develop between them and other men. They strengthen themselves, or so they suppose, by the weakness created in others. The idea here, I'll get into that this is we're going to look at a little bit of their temple ceremony here, just a second, where it explains this better. But basically by practicing polygamy, you injure your fellow man, and you also raise up a generation devoted to you by blood, not by love.

57:51 So your children won't love you if you're a polygamist, apparently. OK. Apparently. What they who are deprived of that wholesomeness that comes of the relationship of wife and husband, they are driven into excesses and then into unnatural love. So here's the thing, right? I practice. So here's the thing, right? Let's say there's let's say I'm in a I'm not on a deserted island, OK? And there's me, and I'm trying to think of somebody. I'm thinking more fictional character. Probably it's you and Andrew Tate. How's that? OK. All right. You're on a deserted island with Andrew Tate and there's three women with you. OK.

58:34 There are two women. There's two women there. OK, you, Andrew Tate, and two women. And you're on this deserted island and Armageddon happens and the nukes go off and you're the last people on earth and you're trying to get by on on this deserted island. And you're like, all right, I guess it's kind of up to us to repopulate the world. It's 2 girls. Look over and Andrew Tate, the two girls look over at you and then they look at each other and they go rock, paper, scissors, right? And they play rock, paper, scissors. One of them loses and she looks over at your tape. She looks back over at you. She looks back over the other girl. She's like, that's two out of three.

59:16 And you know, a year later, they're still doing rock, paper, scissors, right? Because they're just like that guy, that guy. No, no, that ain't going to happen. That just ain't going to happen. So finally they they both will come to you, right? And they're like, look, we can't, we can't do this in any kind of fairway. But it's not fair to to make one of us marry Andrew Tate, OK? That would just be the ultimate injustice in this world, right? Right. And so the that's the Nemetha. The the Nemetha solution, though, is they have to marry Andrew Tate. It doesn't matter. A woman doesn't need to marry a righteous man. It's OK for her to go with Andrew Tate 'cause you know why? We already talked about this universal exaltation. Right, right.

59:59 We'll get there. He'll get there. Andrew Tate's good enough for you, right? So, but here's the thing. Let's say that both girls go with you and they're like, yeah, we're not, we'd rather be polygamous wives to you than than marry Andrew Tate, right? How's Andrew Kate going to feel? Angry, probably. He might feel a little bit, you know, simpish, right? What if there was another guy on the island and he was also a lot like Andrew Tate and he didn't get a girl either? And now you got Andrew, Kate and some other incel. Yeah, they would probably team up and both be mad, but they. Probably team up all the bad well, but what this is suggesting is. And what are they who are deprived of the wholeness that comes from the relationship of husband and wife? What about the incels dude?

1:00:46 Right. Well, they are driven into excesses and then into unnatural love. So, so they're basically making the the contention here, the Nimmenha record. And again, I want to be very clear on this. The Nimmenha record supports the idea that when men practice plural marriage, it forces other men to become gay. Is that what I'm picking up? Yeah, that's what I'm picking up. Yeah, that's what I'm picking up too. And they spell it out so in their endowment, right? This is the relation of Heavenly Father and Heavenly Mother. Chapter 4 starting on 29. Satan says, look at what your sons and daughter do. The stronger men take all the young women, their sisters, daughters, and granddaughters to their own lodge and make wives of them.

1:01:32 Then Adam counselled with his sons. Adam says this thing is not right unless the Creator himself commands it. You have not sought the presence of the Creator. For whom then have you received this practice? And the mob says the old one is wise. He has taught us this thing. And Adam says Satan has flattered you. This thing is not wise. You do it only to gratify yourself, so that you do not have to control your passions. No good can come of it. Do you not see that God has given us a pattern? We call his name Elohim, Heavenly Father and Mother. We call Elohim Heavenly Mother. It is not Elohim Heavenly Father and many mothers. The mob says you are foolish and follow a foolish path.

1:02:12 Soon you will not be strong and you will lose the your place among us. The old One has shown us how the strong survive, and you should also listen to him and obey his counsel. He has taught us that there is but one truth and only one way. By following this way, in strict obedience to the voice of the Old One, we will be strong and we will rule the earth. Adam says. You will bring suffering upon all the people of this strength and wisdom. Then let me remain forever weak and stupid. Adam's got a wit, narrator says. Then many saw the error of the thing that Satan had taught them, and they turned to the lodge of Adam and Eve, and began again to give thanks at the sacred hearth, But the majority followed the way of the world. Then did many of the younger men become angry because there were not enough woman for all to take wife because of this wickedness of the way of Satan, and they separated themselves from among the people after that.

1:03:07 So this insults form a club. After that every young man who could not find a wife, because they were all given in marriage to the stronger men, joined the lodge of the young men and lived apart from the people. They listened to Satan, and he was often seen screwing back and forth between the lodges of the mighty and the young men. And the young men began to accuse Satan because they were alone, and they found fault with him. And Satan says you are foolish, you young men. The strong are made to dominate the weak. You know. This is the truth. The stronger men ought to satisfy, the stronger men ought to satisfy themselves. Satisfy yourselves as befitting the strong and you weak. Men ought to submit yourselves as do women.

1:03:50 Whoa. So Satan's like, all right, well, the strong men should be plogamists, and you weak men, well, you should, you should be homosexuals. Dude. Then the lodge of the young men became a place of evil, and even Satan ceased to visit there. After some time following the wicked council of Satan, many of the young men began to sicken and many died. I guess AIDS. Yeah, something. Those that remained were very angry, and they rose up in one body and made war upon the lodges of the Mighty, because they were many. And the Mighty were caught alone with their wives. The angry young men came through them like a strong wind through the willows, and they killed the mighty men, and took their wives to themselves.

1:04:34 And all the children of the mighty men they made their slaves to do labor for them. And Satan says, See, it is exactly as I taught you, Only the strong may rule. And they made Satan their chief, and called their lodge the Snake lodge. But in all these things Adam and Eve kept aloof of all the people. And because Adam was not considered a mighty man, the Snake watch people do not assail them, but all others they did torment until all of the mighty men were destroyed from off the face of the earth. Holy crap, I must have slept through that. Part of the endowment. Dude, there is like so much to unpack in that little who.

1:05:16 So let's just get this straight. According to their theology and their endowment, polygamy is one of the worst evils to ever hit the world and introduced. Basically introduces homosexuality and introduces slavery and introduces murder. Wow, I don't see how if you're a fundamentalist, you could read this and be OK with this, right? This this has got some severe problems. I mean honestly, even if you were anti polygamist, I don't know how you could read this and think this is a a rational argument.

1:05:58 Yeah wow. But stare nonetheless. So some more understanding here of, of, of plural marriage, just to make sure we really understand it clear 'cause this comes up a lot. I don't know why for people that don't practice this, some reason all of their prophets need to, to repeat it again and again. But here we are and we've got one of the three Nephites, Timothy preaching to the Nemenhan. Behold is Nantai, volume 3, Nantai chapter 653. Behold, I would exhort you now take this knowledge. He's just taught why polygamy is wrong. Take this knowledge and the consideration of the subject and subject it to the confirmation of the Holy Ghost. I would ask you to request of the Holy Ghost even a vision of Father Abraham as he is today, and tell me, what do you see? Do you see him alone or in the arms of his eternal companion? Or do you see him in one day with one wife and in another in the arms of another woman and in the eternities? How does he divide his days and his affections? If you can't imagine polygamy, it must be false then, right? If you can't imagine how it, how it can function in a way that's basically it's prey.

1:07:17 Prey upon your, your, your, your western bias. OK. I'm, I'm going to be honest here, this is, this is starting to smack of a guy who quite frankly can't wrap his mind around it and he's projecting. Yeah, yeah, I makes sense. So for 54, I say unto you, if you have the spirit of revelation in you, OK, this is, let's apply this to ourselves, OK, As I asked this, ask if you have the spirit of revelation in you. If you have the Spirit of revelation in you, yeah, if you can claim the gifts of the Spirit, then you will declare unto me the same as that which the Spirit has shown unto me.

1:07:59 Yeah, you shall not deny that Father Abraham now resides in the bosom of eternity, and is is become Elohim with the wife of his bosom, even that same woman whom he made covenant, bound by the Holy Spirit of promise. And you shall declare unto me that the covenant that they made was one to another, then they made one to another, is owned by the Lord, and has become His own covenant where they are concerned. Wherefore heaven and earth may pass away, but the covenant shall remain, because it is His own covenant pertaining unto them. But behold, those other women whom God gave unto him in order to fulfill his own purposes, has Abraham, Abraham given into the hands of their own husbands, with Thanksgiving in his heart for the part which God did ask him to perform in his great work, or on behalf of his brother? Oh, so we got an extra extra explanation for for something Abraham did, Huh?

1:08:58 So you so. Yeah. So you're going to get to give your plural watch. You get, you only get to pick one, Dave, but you get to give one of your other ones to some in cell who didn't get a chance. And isn't that isn't that holy? No. And if this is still hard for you to understand, is this hard for you to understand? Yeah, it's, it's, it's pretty tough, I'm not going to lie. Yeah, I would ask you to consider in what other ways the Lord does require the children of men to act for on behalf of others and order to form perform His holy purposes unto them. I mean, I guess baptizing, giving, giving somebody a blessing, baptizing them doesn't count raising, raising your having relations with their wife and raising children unto them. And it's all the same, all the same. Dude, cool.

1:09:48 So, and it it gets more clear to where this is goes. So now we're at generations of the Minnesota chapter 2, volume 6. This is again, they're they're now organized in Missouri. And narratively what's what happens here is there is a people nearby them who have a Viking visitor, I believe. And after the Viking goes back, they all get sick and I think it's like 3/4 of their young men and, and like 4/5 of their adult men all die to this disease. And so now you have this huge population of, of widows and they, they live kind of nearby to where the Nemenhah are living here in Minnis Taurit. So this is what happens.

1:10:42 Oh, well, well, well, what happens is they, here's what happens, all these widows pour in and the demon are like, what are we going to do about this? Because they've, they've had problems in the past with a lot of refugees. And it's a, it's a burden upon their system. And so like, we've got to do something about this. And they asked their prophet, we'll go, go upon the way and ask the Lord what we should do about it. And this is so he does and Jesus comes to him on the way. And this is what Jesus tells him to do about all these widows, each family that taketh into his into its harbor. Any of those who seek refuge among the Nemenhab Minnesorat. And they are not required to do this, but as many as do shall be blessed. Behold, the woman shall be joined with the family with a ceremony of adoption.

1:11:28 But behold, let them build yet a separate house for their new families and for the man and the woman. For the man and the woman shall not be man and wife in the way of the world. Yeah, they shall be joined in a type of adoption and they shall be numbered among the Nemenhan families, but they shall not be as the first man and first woman. So this is interesting. So they provide a case study here, a perfect case study of of where? I mean even an anti polygamy person would see like well it it might make sense in this kind of a context, right? Right. Right. Like if there's ever going to be a time when Cod would authorize polygamy, some reason God authorized polygamy for, for, for some of these guys.

1:12:11 And it was a disaster to them and, and they didn't really even need it. But these people, no. No. No polygamy, fear not to take unto thee the widows and the fatherless, for this is true religion. But remember, I shall justify charity and love, blah blah blah. Behold, this is a marriage of necessity and of charity. But the union cannot be sealed by the Holy Spirit of promise, right? You remember theologically you only get one. Therefore let them who have ears to hear, listen to the words of my mouth, sayeth the Lord. The love and charity sealeth unto them, unto the man and the woman, but the man and the woman sealeth not, for I will it not. So why not? Why can't a man be sealed to multiple women? Because God wills it not, that's why. All right, all right.

1:13:01 I mean, that is a theology. But behold, Yep, it's a theology. Behold, my servant, I know thy heart. Thou reddest that which is found in the Scripture concerning one time and people, and thou wonderest, why do I command one thing for them and another for thee? For bear this judgement for thy sake. Thou knowest only the ways and customs of thy own time, and cannot but speculate upon that which is not the plight upon that which death applied to the ancients. And in other words, don't ask. Yeah, yeah, no, this, this totally turns God into a respecter of persons as well. And then in 36 it gets better, it gets better. Be not troubled in my heart, for there is no changeability in this thing, isn't it?

1:13:48 Behold, I had given to the them wives and concubines, that they might build a nation quickly in a place where the nation could have easily ceased to be. Yeah, to save the nation, I will call upon men and women to sacrifice even their own happiness. That's. That's a doozy. To me, that's a doozy. Justin, I'm just going to ask you a question. You've seen my family. We've had dinners together. We've hung out together. Do my wife's look unhappy? Do I look unhappy? I mean, I've got a pretty healthy family right now. That's more that's more because the girls are awesome than me. But I'm just saying that that this idea here really, really, really sticks in my craw that OK, you know what? Sometimes plural marriage is going to have to happen. But just know that in the end, I'm going to force you to give up all but one.

1:14:49 And then also, you're not going to be happy living this way. I'm requiring to sacrifice your happiness in order to do this. You know what? Yeah. Oh geez. Just that, that little high underlying section right there, it just blows me away. You need to save a nation. I will call upon men and women to sacrifice even their own happiness. Is that the plan of salvation? Is that the gospel? Is that the good news? Hey, good news. That's that's. If you've ever seen Futurama, that's Professor Farnsworth. Good news, everybody. It's never good news. Right. Yeah. Yeah. No, look, I believe what the Lord said, that men are, that men might have joy. Right.

1:15:29 And plural marriage has brought me great joy. My wives have said to many people it brings them great joy. And so the dude who wrote this, and I'm sorry, I'll call it now, it wasn't God. He didn't know what he's talking about. He's got no clue. No clue. He knows about as much, I guarantee, about plural marriage as I do advanced physics. Yeah, well. This sticks in my craw. This it. It is wild. It is wild. It it doesn't make sense to me. I I don't worship a God that calls upon men and women to sacrifice their happiness in this life to save a nation.

1:16:17 I believe in a God that leaves the 99 and goes after the one. Right. Look, there's no doubt God requires hard things from us, right? At times. Right. But I don't believe God would would institute a system of marriage that was designed to be miserable. Here's the thing there is sorrow and joy are not opposites. Right, right. I I. Believe you can be in a state of sorrow but still have joy. You still have peace. You can still have a connection with the Spirit. Right. Unhappiness, though, that is not what we were created for.

1:16:59 No. And we were taught that wickedness never was happiness. Right. If that's true, if that's true, if wickedness never was happiness, then if God asked us to do something that makes us unhappy, right, He's asking us to do wickedness. Yep. And yeah, that's not the God that I worship. And yeah, so he tells us. Now, this thing shall be a stumbling block for many among you. Yeah. And in the latter days, many shall question the Lord in this thing. Behold, they shall ponder the things they shall read in the holy books and in the commandments of God, and they shall apply them according to their understanding. Yeah, even the elect of God whom I call to do my own work, shall be confused in their hearts concerning this matter. And in the last days when I shall bring again thy records, many shall be offended by these, right? By these writings, by their writings, because they shall have already interpreted that which they have read in other places to have meaning and understanding that they should not have.

1:18:04 And many will be LED astray by their own understanding, for they seek not my face nor my counsel. You know, I know that you're a podcast, Dave, but I want to ask you a question here. Yeah. Did you ask God before entering into the principal? I certainly did not more than once. To make sure I was doing it correctly, I asked the Lord. I got on my sorry if you. Want go ahead. I got on my knees and asked. Amber got on her knees and asked. Tanya got on her knees and asked as well. Yes, we consulted the Lord in this. Right. And I haven't entered into the principal myself and don't know when or if I will because I consult the Lord on these things too. I'm not looking for an extra wife, but I am willing to take an extra wife if it's God's will for me. And so the default here is absolutely not leaning upon my own understanding of old scriptures. So let me ask you this.

1:19:14 Does this offend you? Does that. Predict it will offend you. Does it offend you? The the connotation of of that thing up top there about their own happiness. It irritates me a little bit, mainly because it it delegitimize it. It attempts to delegitimize what I do but offend me. No, I think it's laughable in some ways. I worry for those who might be on the fence and read this sort of thing right, but I wouldn't say necessarily offended. OK, tell you what, I'm offended. Are you? I'll tell you why, because I know a lot of, I know numerous, numerous good families living the principal and I know for a fact, I know for a fact that they asked God.

1:20:08 They entered into that in an attempt. To follow God. They prayed about it. They sought the Lord's counsel on it. And I am offended that this writing here is saying, no, they didn't. Yeah. Who are they to judge whether somebody has sincerely prayed about that or not? Yeah, yeah. It's funny. You know, Justin, it was really funny because apparently if you take the Nimmenha record to be true, you're fine with replacing all sorts of ordinances with sweat lodges and sundances and getting baptized with Nets and everything is fine and everything is good except this principle. Right.

1:20:50 And it's not just that this principle isn't good, it's this, this is it's, it's, it's completely off limits. Yep, Yep. So. Don't worry, it's going to get a little bit better because we're going to have somebody come in and and represent us and our views on this. So I'll skip reading. I'm going to skip down here though. Yep. It's 40. Oh, we jumped to 44. So this is the that that's was the word of the Lord to their prophet. Afterwards, their prophet now comes and shares it with their counsel. OK, And he shares it with their counsel. It's basically the same thing. Oh no, this is still Jesus. This is still Jesus.

1:21:31 I'm sorry. It's still going on about it. So, OK, so let's clarify this. It's in 45. I'm just jump to the jump to the highlights. And I do perceive that some of the men of Nemenha have looked upon the widow and the fatherless, and have been that have been created because of this calamity to make them wives, as many as pleased with them. And they justify themselves in this because of the custom of the Tuilha, that a woman is not without shame unless she is married and can lay claim to her husband. Behold, this is abomination, for they do it to satisfy their own lusts. So Jesus is saying, I know that some of your people already got it into their head that they want to take these, some of these widows to wife.

1:22:15 And that's an abomination, for it is This is my will concerning them. If there is found any man who taketh unto himself women among you, and justify the taking of many wives, as was done of old, and is still done among the children of unrighteousness, it is a perversion, and shall be deemed an injury upon the woman. Crime, in other words, and children, and upon the woman, the children, and upon the foundation. What is this foundation you're sitting against? I don't know wherefore let them stand before the council, as all who make injury upon other another, and defend their own case. And if the council findeth them guilty, they must repent, or let them be cast out from among the people.

1:23:00 Let them live as they seemeth good, for they make a law unto themselves, but they shall not pollute my people Zion. Wow, so. We're now adding to the legal code. Yep, Yep. And so. Well, I love, I love how they say that that plural marriage is an injury unto their unto women and children and children. And and the foundation, apparently it injuries the foundation. I guess it injuries Jesus. Is Christ not supposed to be our foundation? I think that's the foundation I'm going to stop. I'm not going to do that. OK, let's let's. It's hard, isn't it?

1:23:42 It's hard, hard. It's hard, OK. We're going to make it through this. We're almost there. OK, I'm going to jump down to verse 50. So they they share this stuff, right? And, and he repeats, actually, I'm just going to skip that. He basically tells them, he comes out of the revelation and tells the people what it should be, OK, how they need to do it, what the rules are. Oh, wait, no, it's not there. OK, so and and he tells them that also this is supposed to be a law. And as he explains, Yeah. And and so for people who try to live polygamy with these widows. Yeah. And he is to be cast out from among the people if he so much as teaches such things. And behold, the same applies even to the woman who teaches such injury.

1:24:30 Wherefore it appears to me that the Lord will sanction the Leverite marriage, for it is a type of adoption, but nothing else. They start calling this the the the Leverite marriage. Not the leverite marriage. It's like that's the exact opposite of the love right marriage. Can I just the? Point of the love right marriage was to produce children to the brother. Do OK, I, I, I got to say this. I I'm sorry, I got to say this. Somebody hurt the guy who wrote this. This dude got rejected somewhere. I don't know how, but I just know because he, this dude has a major bone to pick with the principal of plural marriage. And to me, I think that dude got spurned somewhere. I'm just saying, all right?

1:25:19 All right, OK, so he shares it, the share, he shows it to the council, OK, And one of the council rises up. OK, This winniset. He rose up from his seat, took the feather, and spoke these words on behalf of Dave Sanders. Behold, I do not hold with covering the spirit with that which has already been established by written word. Behold, this council has made a thing law, and it is the prerogative of this, of this council to do so. But I do not believe in the authority of this council in dictating my religion. Behold, who and how many women I marry and join to myself is a matter of my religion as doctrine and as precept. I am satisfied that the Lord spoke adequately to our ancestors.

1:26:06 Yeah, and I believe that what He speaks to 1. He speaks to all. Wherefore what shall be done with me, and with them that follow my example, and have taken unto themselves the widows of Twil, Ha, because they've already done it even before they went and asked for. They are my wives, and I have lane with them. In the manner of husband and wife, I'll be it, if they should, if they should have conceived. Shall the children born of our union be given to another? Shall I not have claim upon the fruit of my own loins? Behold, am I not the head of my house? How then can you make a division of my household?

1:26:47 Now I am not alone in this question. Behold, many have done as I have done, and taken in the widows and the children of our brethren who have died, and we have made them our wives and our children. And if the Lord wanted us to keep ourselves from them, then why did He teach us differently in the holy books? Behold, I do not believe that He did. I believe that He saw our day and our necessity, and provided doctrine for us. Yeah, He taught that the righteous should build up his posterity and righteousness, just as He built up nations in righteousness. I stand as representative of those who have been, who have done as I am done, because of their understanding of the teachings of the Lord to our ancestors. Behold, you may not take our religion from us by making a new law.

1:27:32 I kind of like this dude, yeah. Right. I mean, it kind of makes sense, kind of makes sense, which again, right, like we did that law section. But basically he's saying that we're also there's no free speech. Not only is it wrong to practice plural marriage, if you even preach it, man or woman, you're cast out, you're out. You have no right to preach your convictions. Now, the Nephites didn't do that when they came up with somebody who had contrary beliefs. Their prophet was able, by the power of God, to witness the truthfulness and to testify the truthfulness of his theology.

1:28:14 Right. These guys, though, apparently they need to cast out something like this. I mean, I mean, I mean, seriously, I'm reading this and it's just like, it kind of like makes me think as you know, I don't know, this is my personal political stuff, I guess, but it kind of makes me think of like a, a Ron Paul or or Ron DeSantis. Right. I mean, what a speech but or, and, and when Winnisset had said these words, behold, I did answer him saying behold, you know that the Council has voted on the matter and the law is added. Close curtains does over Yeah, too late now. The law will be given to the people to ratify. And you also know that if the people do accept this new law, you and those who followed your example and took the widows of quil Ha unto yourselves as wives in the manner of men, must find a way to obey, to abide by the law. But behold that what you have done was accomplished prior to receiving the word of wisdom from the Lord concerning the matter.

1:29:29 Could the people ratify the new law? And we can only ask you to set aside your wives. We can. If the people ratify the new law, we can only ask you to set aside the wives of your bed and before them and become for them the loverite husband. If you will do this, then there is no disturbance. What say you when said for you? Well, know that the people will hardly vote against the Council of the Great, the Council of the Great Council of the great Council of the Minnesota. So in other words, yeah, we've got the political power. We've got the political power. The votes are already in. You know that the people are going to ratify it because they do everything we they're going to do everything. We, we, we tell them, and I mean, technically you violated this law before it was a law, but it's on you to find a way to abide by it, even if we pass it retroactively.

1:30:21 So you know, if you'll repent of this right now, if you'll forsake this immediately, you know, and make them leverite wives, which makes no sense because if they were leverite wives, they would have to produce children for them. That's the whole point of the left, right being a right husband. But regardless, right? And he doesn't say what'll happen if they don't. But you know, the implication is pretty clear. I was going to say, are are are these some of like the the ancestors of the people that would persecute the Mormons in the 1800s? I don't know. Making laws against polygamy and you know. But supposedly the the translator Philip Landis, I believe he claims he's a descendant of the Nemenha himself. Oh, good, good, good and legit, right? So how?

1:31:13 Is when is it going to answer that? Behold, the number of widows and children that have come into our village has yet to be counted. They are so great. Yay, the catastrophe was so great among the Tuilha as to cause that nation to completely collapse in their economy and their villages. And the number of refugees is great even in the 10s of thousands. Now I see that the Lord has provided a way of dealing with the situation. But I do not believe the word which you have taught this council, words which were your own, but you put them in the mouth of God. And I say unto you that the twil ha widows ought to be consulted on this thing. Many of them have accepted that to be wed to one man, and have accepted to be wed to one man and share him with many women, is not so bad as to be alone.

1:31:57 What shall you say to them that you call them malefactor and cast them out? And I ask you again, what is to become of the children conceived already in such unions as have already taken place? Shall they not know their fathers? It is a hard thing that you put upon us. Yeah, it is hard that you should seek to dictate our religion and our most personal and private lives. Behold, I can only say that if the Nemenhah of Minnesota ratify this new law, I shall take my family and all the families that followed me and I shall move with them into some new country and we shall build up a new nation after the dictates of our own heart and confidence. And thus it was and it was. They didn't have to address any of the issues that Minnesota presents.

1:32:39 He doesn't, he doesn't make them cast him out like they would have by law. He, he goes willingly on his own as if it's his own thing. It's a complete cop out. It sets up this really interesting case study in law and their application of some of the more complex theology ramifications of forbidding plural marriage. And then it just completely just drops it. Wow. But but I'll have you know that the even though they were essentially cast out, the Nemenha of Minnesota at least gave them provisions and help them establish a a new settlement somewhere else.

1:33:19 And, and it just so happens they end up becoming friends with some rebellious neighbors too, who were previously kidnapping women and children for the sex trade slavery. But they they become friends with the polygamists and don't know why they had to. What the implication? I wonder what the implication is there, but whatever, whatever. Holy cow. I mean, I could go on for hours and hours and hours still addressing various different points, but I think this. No, I think this is sufficient. Yeah, this is sufficient. And quite frankly, I can't take any more. I'm just going to cover a few other topics though real quick. I'm not going to go in depth.

1:34:05 I'm just going to say. So some other ideas that are present. What are some other things that the NEM and how record presents? There is a a strong disdain for free market and industry. Their version of this United Order is one that keeps everybody in poverty, literally, and they even kind of brag about it. Is This is why the Gideon's don't bother us? Right. Because because there's nothing here to steal. We're not. We're not rich. There's a huge environmentalist slant. In fact, I'm trying to remember. Well, specifically, men are told that they are not.

1:34:52 We're supposed that they're supposed to be stewards of the Earth. They're not Lords. They're not to be Lords of the Earth. Basically, there's a this idea that the environment can only sustain so many people. Yeah, and if it gets more than that, it's it damages the environment. That's what I mean by environment. They're not talking about like real environmental issues like oil tankers leaking all over the ocean or, or trash in the ocean. They're not talking about, you know, mines dumping toxic waste into rivers or factories or, or farms with GMO crops and GMO insects. They're not talking about that kind of stuff. No, they're talking about there's too many people living in this community.

1:35:37 It's too hard on the land, and so we need to have smaller communities. In fact, the numbers that they give vary, but it's basically between 102 hundred families per city Max. See, that would cause more economic, more environmental damage than anything else, right? Because you get sprawl at that point. Well, yeah. Well, well, when you create a new settlement, you got to it's. I also believe it's supposed to be a day's travel away, so. So you're just going to have the land just covered with a bunch of tiny villages I guess, right? Right. And since, I mean, they're going to fill up, and once they're filled up, all your children, when they want to get married, they're going to have to leave home, that might be a good thing. Depends on the mother-in-law, right? Yeah.

1:36:23 Yeah, somebody might be. But you don't get a choice. Right. But you don't get a choice. You know, your city's full and you want to get married. You got to go leave your home, leave your siblings, leave your family and go off. And I'll be honest, that's a hard thing to do. That's not an easy situation to be in. There is throughout the text, there is constantly this, this epistemological view of testing everything by the Holy Ghost. But it really kind of devolves into this your own truth thing, even as we saw right there, right? If, if this polygamy thing was wrong, you would expect a prophet to rise up like you see in the Book of Mormon, Alma, when confronted with an Antichrist, actually confronts his arguments and shuts him down, right? You don't see that happen because there's this well, everybody has their own truth and we need to respect that, even if we're going to take their children away from them and cast them out.

1:37:21 Right. There's a doctrine of seeking Christ's face from childhood, essentially seeking Christ's face, Seeking a personal audience with Christ is the first step, and then maybe repentance or remission of sins, and then baptism, eventually an endowment. Which is the exact opposite. Right. It's yeah. It's also very anti constitutional government. They have their own system and they constantly, it's one thing to have to present a different idea and say, hey, this works for us. This is how our government works and that works for our small communities. But they constantly point out that because the Nephites don't have, because the Nephites let men vote. That's why they're wicked all the time and that's why they've got all these problems.

1:38:09 And they they, they're constantly comparing their civilization to the Nephite civilization, showing how theirs is better. And in every opportunity they get right, they've got well, and this is interesting too. I don't know if you caught that, but it's basically it, it is. It is dependent on a South American Book of Mormon geography. It is absolute on that right or central, South Central, whatever you there is. This is completely incompatible with the Heartland model. So anybody that believes in the Heartland model, this is absolute contradiction, not does not compute, right? Really. Yeah.

1:38:50 The Nephites are basically the, the Mayans and the as whatever you know, they're the, those are the Nephites and the Lamanites, the Nemenha are the North American tribes. They're the ones that are living in places like Utah and Missouri and the Great Lakes. And the only time the Nephites and Lamanites show up is during the their final destruction and battles where apparently the the Lamanites chase the Nephites across the entire continent. Right. That sounds hard, you know, I mean, Napoleon didn't get that far with a with a a country behind him supporting him and the when he went into Russia. I can't imagine how the Lamanites chase the Nephites all the way from down there up to the Great Lakes area. But multiple paths of salvation, we kind of covered that, right? Like kind of again, do your own thing, do your own baptism, do your own priesthood.

1:39:49 It actually tells you not to preach of Christ. Now, one of the things that was striking to me in comparison to the Book of Mormon is the Book of Mormon is full of these amazing discourses on Christ, powerful discourses on Christ, right? I mean something like Alma 57. 32 how to gain faith you've got nephi when nephi talks about his struggles with after his father dies and. His. Faith and his testimony, I mean the the Book of Mormon is undeniably a testament to of Jesus Christ. This record, it doesn't really talk about him much other than authoritatively. Right. Finally, well, may not It's, it's, it's also what kind of anti police?

1:40:35 Yeah, there's one point in the civilization where they have a lot of refugees coming in. They feel like they need some police so they bring in, so they start having some police officers and they essentially immediately turn on them and oppress them. And so it's kind of defund the police type of idea going. It's kind of odd to me, but they don't mention apostles anywhere other than basically when I think when Christ visits, there's really no other reference to apostles. And I'm not quite sure why, but their priesthood does not have an apostleship. It's basically just the high priest and it seems everybody else is essentially equal. I kind of mentioned anti population, anti civilization, anti city.

1:41:19 It's also very all or nothing with the law of consecration it constantly, you know, it's not a higher law that creates a Zion that the Zion society can live. It's the only acceptable law essentially. And they're constantly judging other people, mostly knee fights for not having all things in common or not having all things in common enough, right? Because even when the knee fights are when it says the knee fights have all things in common, they're no, no, that's not good enough because their cities don't intermingle, right? They're separate and that's a separate and that causes a problem. I didn't get into it, but they're also very anti military and or pro pacifism and there's a lot of places where it implies that if you were, if you've ever been a soldier, it's going to permanently scar you.

1:42:07 There's a section where Moroni says I have, I have trouble entering the way because of the, the because I was involved in warfare and I have to have a special ceremony begin to to to enter into it. Now there's a story of a of a of a Mayan priestess who brings the people up who were who engaged in a bloody revolution to rescue her. And after they rescue her, she's like, I'm going north to the Nemenha people. And the rest of the people are like, oh, well, we want to go. And she's like, oh, you can't go. You guys are wicked. You, you murdered people to rescue me. Your hands are dirty. You don't get a go. You know that's they. Don't get a go, but they wander in the wilderness for three generations.

1:42:49 You know, the whole pacifism thing. Don't don't get me wrong, I, I want peace as much, if not more than than a lot of people. But I wouldn't call myself a pacifist, right? When someone says that they're a pacifist, I say to what end? Are you a pacifist when they're taking your rights? Are you a pacifist when they come and take your children? Where, where does that stop for you? And, and I don't see it as being a very logical or quite frankly, even Christian thing to, to do, right? I think we should always strive for peace, but this idea of peace at all costs I don't think is a thing. And I do believe that sometimes the Lord instructs his people, sometimes you got to go to war, right? Right.

1:43:42 If we didn't, we wouldn't be here having this conversation now. So in the another episode in the Nemenha record, there's a time where the knee fights are falling apart and the Nemenha apparently are watching them and they see that there's still relations coming to an end and they're worried that they're going to come up and bring the war up to them. And so they decide, hey, you know what, let's start organizing an army and let's set up defenses in case the Lamanites, the knee fights, come up here and the war spills on the and our land. And they start doing that. But then their prophet realizes it's a mistake and repents, and they disband the army and tear down their defenses. Wow. Because to to have an army and defenses provokes your neighbor and it causes having a military sets requires rank for there to be order, which sets men above other men and basically implies that it just destroys the soul that if you are a soldier, if you ever, you know, if you ever have to kill somebody, that it's just going to kind of break you in a way that that can't be healed. And so instead they tear down their defenses, they disband the army.

1:44:48 And when the Nephites and Lamanites come up, they just hide and they don't get noticed. Wow, holy cow. Right. So that's the theological. So now let's move on to the historical. I'm just kidding. I actually do have the historical section. I want to run through it real quick. Are you still up for that or are you 2? No, I'm good. Are you good? This is worth bringing up 'cause this is historical. This is just, you know, theology. You can argue, right? Maybe I'm this, maybe I'm interpreting this wrong. Maybe you're interpreting this wrong. Maybe it's not what we think it says. We know how difficult theological debate can be. I've done the debate on your own podcast on theology, right?

1:45:28 His story history is not quite so cut and dry though. History it it either is or it isn't, right? So what I want to talk about is the origins of this record. OK. The Nemenha people are supposedly derived from Hagoth, who builds a ship and goes north. And we read about that in the Book of Mormon, Right. Right. Though I'm going to share my. Am I sharing still? Yeah. Oh, I'm still sharing. OK. I want to share Almaphybes 45. So this is because this is the 19th year of the reign of the judges. OK, now it came to pass after Alma had said these things to heal him and he blessed him and also his other sons and he also blessed the earth for righteousness sake. And he tells what what he blessed the land about. And then Alma blesses the church and then he departs out of the land of Zarahemla as if to oh, here's the wrong section. I want Hagos departure, not Alma's departure. Well, this is worth worth reviewing too, right? So what happens to Alma in the Book of Mormon? He blesses his sons, he blesses the church, he goes off as if he's going to, to the land of Melik, and he disappears and nobody ever hears from him again, right, And says, Behold this, we know that he was a righteous man, and the same went abroad in the church, that he was taken up by the Spirit or buried by the hand of the Lord, even as Moses. But behold, the Scriptures saith, the Lord took Moses unto himself.

1:46:51 And we suppose that he has also received Alma in the spirit of himself. Therefore for this 'cause we know nothing concerning his death and burial. And it came to pass that in the commandment of the 19th year of the reign of Judges, or the people of Nephi, that Healman went forth among the people to declare the word unto him. So Healman his son Healman takes over right 19th year of the reign of Judges. This is when Alma disappears. So let's look at Hagoth's departure. Now in the Book of Mormon, we're now in Alma 36. This is the 38th year, 19 years after Alma departs. And it came to pass that Hagoth, he being an exceedingly curious man, therefore he went forth and built him an exceedingly large ship by the borders of the land Bountiful, by the land desolation, and launched it forth into the West Sea by the narrow Neck which led into land northward.

1:47:33 And behold, there are many of the Nephites who did enter there. And it did sail forth with much provisions and with many children, and they took their course northward. And thus ended the 30 and 7th year. And in the 30 and 8th year the man built other ships. The first ship did also return, and many people did enter into it. And they took much provisions and set out again to the land northward. And it came to pass that they were never heard of more, which is interesting because the Nemenha are constantly interacting with them. Right. But apparently they were never heard of more, and we suppose, we suppose that they were drowned in the depths of the sea. And it came to pass that one of that one other ship did also sail forth. And whether she did go we know not. So this is here's the thing.

1:48:18 This is in the book of Alma, right? Right. But is Alma writing this? No. No. Who's writing this? Who's narrating the history? It was Mormon, right? It was an abridgement by Mormon. Yep. Yeah, Mormon's writing this, which is an important thing to remember. Because wait, it wasn't. No, it was Moroni that was in in the the Newman Hall record. Right. Well, Mormon. Mormon does not show up in their record, no. Right, that's why I was saying it was. Well, he referenced, but he's not a. He's not a character. Right. So it can't so and and it came to pass, and this is also important verse and it came to pass in the 39th year of the reign of Judges Stidla.

1:48:59 Oh, so by the way, Helenman died at this point, and Shiblon is his. The other brother Shiblon is now leading the church, right? Well, Shiblon's now died also. And Corey Anton had gone forth to the land northward in a ship to carry forth provisions unto the people who had gone forth into that land. So let's look at the timeline here, right? Alma finishes, gives his sons blessings, he blesses the church and he vanishes 19 year. His son takes over Helen and his son takes over. Eventually Helen dies, his son Shiblon takes over. We're now 19 years after Alma left and Hagoth builds ships and goes up north and within two years, 39th now Shiblon dies and it says Cory Anton had gone forth to the land northward.

1:49:56 So somewhere in here, right? Should Corey Anton went north? Right. In the 38th year. So here's the issue. This is a chapter, volume 4, Chapter 5 of Heineman, it says. And Mormon took with him his son Mormon even a boy no more, no more than eight years of age. And he travelled with him wherever he went in the land southward. But the rest of the family he left in the city of whipped him for their safety. So they're saying that Mormon and his son Mormon and his son Mormon I, they're all Nemenhah and they're, he went down with them to, to keep an eye on them. And we know that his young son, the Mormon who wrote the Book of Mormon has grown into a great man. For the Nephites of the land South were chosen to be their captain and to lead their armies. And from all reports of his family, he was a prophet and a seer.

1:50:48 Nevertheless, he does not preach unto the people for the spirit constraint. So that's where they're at in the Book of Mormon, right When Mormon stops preaching. I'm. Just going to jump down here to verse 25 now. But but now his son, whose name is Moroni, but our people call him Morhonaya, is gone also into the land southward to join his father in the fight. So where is Moroni when this is going on? He's with the Nemenhah. He's up north with the Nemenhah. And then he goes down to help his father. His father originally goes down with his father when he's 8 and it sounds like he's but does he have discourse? Is Moroni is Mormon going back and forth between the Nemenha and the Nephites? You'd have to How did he have the son? If he if he goes to the Nephites when he's 8 years old, how does his son Moroni come South?

1:51:38 Right. No. So so Mormon and Moroni have interaction with the Nemenha so when they know who the Nemenha are. Right, so when Mormon said I know not where Hagoth went. How can you say? That how can you say that because he would know otherwise. Exactly. He would know otherwise, Absolutely. That's a red flag. That's kind of a red. Flag, isn't it? But that's not even the real historical issue, that's just a contextual issue. So here's the problem. Corey Anton's story. So in the early days of Nemaha of Mintonah, the and founded some of them go off and they find the city of Corey Anton.

1:52:20 And because we read how Corey Anton went north too, right? And so they find his city and he's he's become a king, but he's a good king. He's like the Nemenha. And they join with the Nemenha because they're the same culture. But when they meet him, Corey Anton tells them his story of how he came to be up there. OK. And this is that same Corey Anton who is brother of Shiblon, who is a prophet in Zarahemlon, OK. Right. Here he goes. Now when I was a younger man, my father Alma sent me unto our brethren the Lamanites, to preach the word of God unto them. Now the mission was exceedingly hard, and my brothers and I suffered privations, beatings that were impoverished and starved. In short, for one young as I, the mission became very hard. Nevertheless, we remain steadfast in our desire that the Lamanites received that light which cometh from the knowledge of God in Christ.

1:53:10 Wherefore we were diligent and faithful. That's verse 27 of volume one, First Seam Oil, chapter 6. I'm going continuing 28 Now there was a woman whose name was Isabel, and in her company we were always made welcome, and she opened her home to us. She had been a harlot, but she repented nevertheless. Her reputation was always esteemed the same after she received the gospel as before, and she was despised by the Nephites. Because she had received the word of God. She was despised by her brethren the Lamanites, and because she had been a harlot she was despised by the Nephites. Wherever her situation became pitiful indeed. Nevertheless, she always opened her door to us, and whenever she had and what and whatsoever she had in the house, she did always offer to us for our comfort. Now, because of her pitiful state, I did visit her often and and did comfort her.

1:54:01 And behold, many seeing this, it spread abroad the rumor that I did consort with a harlot while presuming, presuming to be upon the Lord's errand. And even my own family did condemn me for a time. Yeah, so sharp with his tongues and so prolific the rumors against me that I was constrained to leave my mission in order that I might find safety for her and peace for myself. For I had grown to love Isabel and desired not to see her suffering. Now this thing greatly displeased my father, Alma the Younger, and I did receive great chastisement from him. Oh, we, we, we remember that chapter in the Book of Mormon, right? Yeah. Nevertheless, I must believe that he did not wholly believe the murmurings of the people, for the gifts of discernment were strong in him.

1:54:45 Nevertheless, once I had made arrangement for the care of the lady, he did command me straightly to take up and finish my mission to the Lamanites. And behold, I did as my father commanded, and great has been my joy because of it. But Isabel suffered greatly, for the Nephites, into whose care I placed her, esteemed her to be a harlot still, even though she had abandoned her sin and come unto Christ. Yeah, they cast her out of their churches, and she was restrained from worshipping, and isolated from all fellowship with them. Even they did refrain from any concerns with her, and her state became exceedingly very miserable. Now she was a Weaver of. Baskets and her work was. Exceedingly fine above all the artisans of the Nephites. Cause of course she's a girl boss. Right. They would not buy her work because she was judged by them beneath their feet and unworthy of their association, And she became poor and wanted much, and had it not been for the little provision that had made for her, she surely would have perished because of her great want.

1:55:35 Behold, when I finally did return for my mission of the Lamanites, behold, I found her homeless, friendless, and hungry. Then was I ashamed. I had spent over much time crying repentance unto the Lamanites, for barely had I seen anything the like among them, as I had seen of the poor woman and her suffering at the hands of the Nephites. Wherefore I did take up this poor woman under my own bosom, and I beseeched her that she become my wife, and we departed out of the land southward forever. Now behold, the Mantel was touched by the story, and knew that it was true. For who among the people of the land southward had not heard how the son of Alma, who ought to have followed his brother as prophet, took the harlot Isabel? Isabel into the land northward was never heard of again. And also, who had not heard of how the prophet Alma, having heard how his harsh words of judgement had driven his son into the wilderness, did believe that he had sent his son, his own son, to his death?

1:56:30 And believing this, did he up himself, give up his place as prophet of God, and walk in the wilderness, never to be seen or heard again? And I want to clarify, it is explicit in another section. It's me. It's down here. Yeah. And for Allah belief that he had sent them into the wilderness under their deaths and that knowledge that he had misjudged them did break his heart. So that part in the Book of Mormon where he's talking to his son about his sexual improprieties, we're we're to understand, we are to understand that he was falsely judging his son. One of the greatest dissertations to ever be placed within Holy Writ, in my opinion, in a my estimation, according to the NIMA record, accounts for nothing more than a man who misjudged his son. Right.

1:57:20 And so when Hementa heard these things, he understood the more and wondered at the great wisdom of Coriantin. For he knew Coriantin from the people of Ammon. And the rumor was still had among them of the defection of the son of Alma from among the people because of the harlot Isabel. And his heart was sorrowful because of it. For behold, a generation believed the rumor, and he kept all these things in his heart and remembered them in later years. So yeah, yeah, the good guys are bad guys. The bad guys are good guys. Alamo goes off and offs himself in the woods. Dude, this. He's so upset because he thinks he drove his he misjudged his son and drove him to his son to suicide that he then goes and commits suicide. This, this plays perfectly in in today's society, right? The good guys are bad.

1:58:09 The bad guys are good. You know, calling evil good, calling good evil. I mean, it's. It's that simple. So somebody's an unreliable narrator here though. Yeah. And The funny thing is it's either Mormon or the Nemenha. But then but Mormon is a Nemenha. So that becomes a really, really sticky issue when you consider that Mormon included that story of Alma. Yep. Mormon says we don't know what happened to the people of Hagoth.

1:58:53 Mormon says we don't know what happened to Corey Anton. How does he not know that? Right, because he's not. He's hanging out with, they're his people. He's been to the city of Corryanton, most likely. He lives in the in the city of Mentenah where they've got records. They know this stuff. They know where Hagoth came from. They know what happened to him. But that's not even the real issue. That's not even the real issue, OK? The real issue is what we just looked at in Book of Mormons. Remember that that that chronology chronology asked you to look at. Yeah. Let's look at that again. Alma departs in the 19th year of the reign of Judges. And it says, and now it came to pass that after Alma said these things to Helam and he blessed him and also his other sons.

1:59:39 So Alma is blessing his sons. So Shiblon and Corryanton as well as Helaman, right, in the 19th year of the reign of Judges. When does Alma off themselves in the woods? That same year, That same year. Yeah. That's interesting because I thought he offed himself because Corey Anton left and he thought that he died. When does Corey Anton leave? Well, he couldn't have left before Hagoth. When does Hagoth leave? 38th year, 19 years after Alma offed himself. So they couldn't keep the date straight. They couldn't keep the date straight. Yeah, they they botched it.

2:00:23 They wanted to they wanted to have their cake and eat it too. All of the great prophets from the Book of Mormon are their prophets actually. And even the bad guys in the Book of Mormon are their good guys. Some of the good guys in the Book of Mormon are actually bad guys. But in playing that game, they, they screwed up the dates. They they missed this. There's no possible way this is right unless, unless one of these one of these narrators is unreliable. Well, look. But if Mormon lies is lying about this history here, well, he isn't. He is Nemenha according to the Nemenha record.

2:01:05 So they're lying. They're impeaching themselves. Their own history, impeaches their own history according to their history. So I mean, this was a there's other issues too, where you can find historical contradictions with the Book of Mormon. They're all over the place, but this one is kind of seriously smoking a gun. Like, how on earth does Alma kill himself after Corey Anton departs? Corey Anton? Well, maybe Corey Anton left and he came back, and then he left to the land northward to carry provisions. Maybe that's what happened. And when Corey Anton did abandoned, the Nephites disappeared land northward, never to return. Nope. Nope, they didn't come back. Corey Anton never returned.

2:01:47 Nope. So if he left to deliver supplies to the people northward who went with Hagoth, how? How did that? Why did Alma kill himself again? Because he thought he drove his son to commit suicide. Yeah, I mean, somebody's lying here. Corey Anton's lying or Mormon's lying. But if but if Corey Anton was lying, you'd think Mormon would point out that lie. Well, look, that's supposing that this record's true to begin with. Right, right, right. Well, as I said, I'm trying to give it the benefit of, of the doubt to a degree, right? I'm, I'm trying to, but this is a historical consistency. So again, my main point here is, you know, if you like this record, if you like the things that teaches this is the God you want to worship, all power to you, right?

2:02:33 I've got no problem with that. But if you're going to tell people that this is compatible with their faith and these people believe in the Book of Mormon, or if they believe in the New Testament, or if they believe in the Restoration, Joseph Smith, any of this stuff for a little great price, it's not. It's actually not. This is a different gospel. It's a different doctrine. It's a different Jesus. These are different prophets. And you know, you're free to choose what you want to believe, but these are things you cannot reconcile. You know, you either believe in free speech or you don't believe in free speech. Yep. You believe in universal exaltation or you believe in a universal salvation. You believe total marriage is a is a something that God gave or you don't.

2:03:26 You believe priesthood being an order as is defined in Doctrine Covenants or and is taught by Joseph Smith or you don't. You believe in baptism or you don't. This record for as much interesting theology as it has within it. It is absolutely historically and theologically incompatible with the restoration. And to be honest, I actually see a really interesting connection here with Islam of all things. The reason I say that is Islam is kind of also a, it's a religion that kind of formed off of Christianity and Judaism. It copies and pastes some of the characters in, right? Like, you know, they, you know, they believe in Moses, they've got Abraham, Jesus was a prophet. So they're checking the boxes.

2:04:18 But their theology and their gospel is entirely different. And their theology and their gospel is different because it's designed to cater to a specific people, right? Because the Jews were God's chosen people. Well, what about, what about the Ishmaelites? Well, well, I mean, I think ideally they should convert to Judaism, but that's not what Islam proposed. Islam proposed. Instead we're going to copy and paste from Christianity and Judaism into our own religion that sets up a specific people as superior to any others, a specific culture. We're going to change the doctrines to fit a culture and that's that. And that's what that's how you get Islam, unlike Christianity where Christ quotes the Old Testament, well, all the time, right? It's, it is, there's probably hundreds of references to the Old Testament.

2:05:11 Christ explains how his theology builds and fulfills the law of Moses. It's a completion. It's adding to, right? And we can see how the restoration theology adds to what we previously had left of Christianity and it expands it and adds to it and it connects it and it fulfills all of these things. But when it comes to Islam, it's not right. It's kind of this other thing that contradicts Christianity. It contradicts Judaism, but it lays claim of their it lays claim on their theology while contradicting it. Well, I'm seeing the exact same thing here. This does not expand Mormonism. This does not enhance the restoration. It does not add to the Book of Mormon. It actually detracts and it contradicts those things while copying and pasting aspects of it. Which?

2:06:04 Present so that it presents this idea as if it's in addition. It's a completion, it's a fulfillment, but a true fulfillment, a true restoration of any of these kinds of things would still have to be compatible with everything else. The eschatology here time and time again is it they keep in the Book of Mormon. At the end of Moroni chapter 10, Moroni asks us to to pray and get a witness of the Holy Ghost and know if the book is true, right? Right. The Nemenha record, at the end of almost every single book, they bring that up and say, hey, pray and ask the Holy Ghost if this is true, Pray and ask the Holy Ghost. It's all over the place.

2:06:48 But I have a bit of an issue with this because here's the thing. Before you pray and get a witness of the Holy Ghost of the Book of Mormon, you're asked to ponder those things first. And I will argue that Mormonism at its core, is it a religion of rationality. Right. We've got answers to things that a lot of other religions don't touch. I was just watching some some Christian debates and with atheists and they get in hot spots sometimes when when an atheist says, well, why did God make man some men wicked? If God made everything, why did he make some men?

2:07:28 That's a hard thing for Christianity to come to terms with. Yep. Why is there an eternal hell? It seems a bit much for making a mistake in this life. Those are things that Christianity really has to struggle to come up with explanations for and answers for. But it's it's very simple. These answers are simple in Mormon theology. No, Hell's not Eternal hell is a state of being, of separation from God. It's not about why does God give us commandments? Well, because he's God. According to Christianity and Mormonism, we believe God gives us commandments because they're in our best interest. It protects us obeying the commandments, protects us from the effect of the cause of sin. But all of this, all of this in Mormonism, it brings greater light and knowledge. It is adding to and, and our theology isn't just based off of the Holy Ghost told me I had feelings and the Holy Ghost told me that the Book of Mormon is true. It's that when you read the Book of Mormon, the truth of it resonates in your soul.

2:08:28 This answers questions that you didn't have answers to before. This answers theological problems. It makes the gospel simpler. It makes you understand who God is that much more accessible. And I see the exact opposite happening here. It's more confusing, it's more distracted. It's more, it's harder to understand. And so I, I think that our, our faith, it is Mormons shouldn't be just blind obedience to a feeling from the Holy Ghost that is a part of it. But it's not the whole picture. It's not the only origin of our faith. We also have faith in the Book of Mormon as a scripture. Right. We have faith in the New Testament, the the depictions and the the witnesses of Christ given in the gospel.

2:09:14 And we have faith in the theology, the restored theology that Joseph Smith brought forth, that it answers questions so that we can have faith in our hearts and an understanding in our head rather than just faith in our hearts, right. And that are full of question marks. Yep. And so anyway, I guess it's a hard thing to to cover this stuff. I think it was a hard thing to study. It took a long time to read through it all and to organize this, organize my thoughts on it as well, just because it's not a pretty thing. Even if I disagree with the faith, it's not a pretty thing to, to, to, to analyze it and, and deconstruct it. And so I really wasn't trying to do that. I just want to be as open and honest as I can because I'm worried about how this is being presented. Yeah.

2:10:07 Right now, today, I could careless about this record, having read it now, I could just go on, move on. Except there's people out there talking about this right now. And mostly what they're saying is, is that hey, this is an enhancement of fulfilment of Mormonism, right? And I think people should read it if you get a chance. I mean, it was, it's kind of dark. It's very aggravating in some places in some ways. But I do think it's it's potentially worth reading if you have questions or doubts because this is a different gospel and anybody who's saying otherwise is not being honest. And, you know, one last thing I want to end on this is a quote from from John Taylor. And it's kind of in relation to how we know things are true, right, Right.

2:10:57 This is from Journal Discourses 13 verse 1415. I believe it is good to investigate and prove all principles that come before me, prove all things, hold fast to that which is good, and reject that which is evil, no matter what guise it may come in. I think if we as Mormons hold principles that cannot be sustained by the Scriptures, and by good sound reason and philosophy, the quicker we part with them the better, no matter who believes in them or who does not. In every principle presented to us, our first inquiry should be, Is this true? Does it emanate from God? If He is the Author, it can be sustained just as much as any other truth in natural philosophy. If it is pulse, it should be opposed and exposed just as much as any other error.

2:11:50 Hence, upon all such principle, upon all such matters, we wish to go back to the first principles. Absolutely. And I think that directly applies to to this record and how you approach how you approach it. Yep, Yep. So, Mason, are you still there? I am. Did you want to add anything? I mean, really, I, I think Justin closed it up really well. At the end of the day, you know, we have Joseph Smith talking about how we can set aside anything that that does preach anything separately. We have that verse in Galatians 18 where the apostle Paul, I believe it was, warns about even angels coming and disseminating different doctrine than what has been previously established.

2:12:45 I think even if this came by way of revelation, whoever received it was not in tune with the right sources. And I think we can plainly see that just given the things that Justin has kind of outlined for us. Absolutely. All right, here's what I want to say about this and then and then we'll wrap up here. So I'm a big believer in you shall know them by their fruits. So let's just tally up the fruits that we have seen thus far in the record, OK? Changes ordinances, calls good evil and evil good. The dates don't line up. Its teachings do not correspond with the restored gospel as given by the Prophet Joseph Smith.

2:13:31 The book is clearly not Scripture if it I I agree with Mason, if this thing was received by revelation, the source of that revelation has to be in question. And none of those standards that I just said that are their fruits are standards that I set. Those are standards that quite frankly, the Lord has revealed through his, his the, the early brethren of the Church. So given that whole thing, I'll just call it like I see it. I'm not, I don't take pleasure in this. I'm not happy about this, but this is not Scripture. Now, I have no doubt that some people will read this and they will get some warm fuzzies from it and maybe even draw out a good life lesson or two.

2:14:21 But that doesn't mean it's true. OK, you can go to a movie and get a good feeling from a movie. It doesn't mean that movie is true. It just means that that movie had a a message that resonated with you. And I also want to speak to this because I feel like it's the time that we're times we're living in right now. You can want something that's good too much. I firmly believe that when we look at at this particular record, what this tells me is this is what happens when you want something to be true so badly that you're willing to suspend good sound judgment at times to pin your hopes to it.

2:15:09 I get it. We all as Mormons want to live in that time where new scripture bursts forth from the earth and it it comes forth and it edifies and it uplifts. But just because we want this to be so doesn't mean that it is. And just like that quote that Justin read from John Taylor, Mormonism is unique amongst Christendom in the sense of it's going to connect the heart with the head and it's going to make sense in both of those places. We see that this does not make sense. The dates don't line up. And quite frankly, look, I'll, I'll be honest, this was a good attempt at new scripture, right? And despite how hard they worked at it, and I have no doubt that whoever wrote this really worked hard at it, but it should tell you how unique the Book of Mormon truly is in the sense it can stand alone, It doesn't disagree with itself. It's a, a continuous story.

2:16:11 So as I look at this in summation, I think you have to look at this this this document, the Neiman Hall record with a raised eyebrow, understanding that it's got severe doctrinal flaws, severe flaws when it comes to ordinances. And quite frankly, if anyone says, hey, I'm hitching my wagon to this record, I think you really need to call into question that person's judgement because I think that that it's easy to be LED astray in these things. And that's that's pretty much where I'll leave all this. If you want the restored gospel, go to the trusted sources, go back to the Book of Mormon, go back to the Bible, go back to the Doctrine of Covenants, go back to the Pearl of Great Price, go back to the Journal of Discourses, the words of Joseph Smith and those early brethren. That's where it lies right now.

2:17:10 I, too, look forward to the day when new scripture comes forward and we can, you know, look at it and see that it meshes perfectly with what's already been revealed. But this one isn't it. And I don't take pleasure in saying that I love people who love this book, and it breaks my heart having to do this. But I have to call a spade a spade. And this has severe problems that needs to be looked at and it needs to be weighted when you're making your decision there. Lead with your heart and your head. Seek God in your answers, and you'll come out OK on the other side. Justin, anything else you want to leave with before we wrap up? Just reiterate some of those points that you just made. Yeah.

2:17:56 I think the appeal, one of the potential appeals of this record, in my opinion, is it does call out issues in the LDS Church. And because those issues are real, it's, it can become easy to hear what you want to hear and then build immediate trust. This is something that I think that we struggle with in this post truth world because nobody's sure anymore what's true, what isn't. You know, I think the media, can you trust the media? Can't you trust the media, right? The COVID vaccines, are they going to help us? Are they going to kill us? What about the 5G towers? Are those going to kill us? Are they actually aliens under the earth coming up and the UFOs?

2:18:37 And we don't know what to believe. And we want grounding. We want something to believe in. And a lot of people have reasons for feeling very disaffected with the LDS Church. And somebody proclaiming a message that is critical of that, that presents, it's easy to latch on to that saying, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. But you got to look at the whole the whole picture here, right? I mean, I can write. I could. I could write what I know would be fake scripture that was supposedly an ancient record criticizing the prophesying of, of, of criticisms in the LDS Church.

2:19:20 I mean, I can even do that. Anybody could do that really, right? And to me, the biggest litmus test of scripture to knowing if it's true or not is, is it in, is it enlarging your, your understanding? Is it bringing, is it really bringing you closer to God? And this record for me was the exact opposite. I was hoping it would be legitimate. I really, I really was. And I was, and I'm hoping that something happens here between Mormonism and the Native American. I'm, I'm a native descent myself, like I said, and these are topics that I, I really care about, but I want to see my brethren brought into the fold.

2:20:03 And they don't have to. I don't think they have to change their culture, but they need to accept the fullness. That was restored by Joseph Smith, and that starts with baptism. Do they need to be members of the LDS Church? I don't think they do. But they do need to receive the ordinances. They do need priesthood. They need these. This is the way that Christ has laid out. And he said He is the way, the truth and the light. No man cometh unto the Father, but by Him, and He's laid out that path. And we don't do a service to anybody, especially our Native American brethren, by changing those standards to appeal to them and, and, and, and presenting a polluted gospel that's easy to swallow, that makes them the heroes, that makes everything that they're doing right. That doesn't require repentance.

2:20:51 Because the truth of the matter is we all need repentance. I have a lot of respect for the culture of the Native Americans and the things that that were good in their culture, but there were bad things as well. And you cannot deny that we live in a great world today in large part because of the Western advancements that the things that have come from technology. And there's again, there's bad sides to it. But you know what? I I enjoy a warm shower, right? I enjoy being able to, to all these things, right? I like having the computer right here to be able to do this podcast and they can the Internet and all of this technology. These are these can be wonderful things. And so I don't think we have to throw it all out. We can recognize that there might be problems in the LDS Church and recognize that that's true, but that doesn't mean that everything in this record is true. And you have to then tie yourself to that. And to me the one of the most interesting things that I've learned through this whole process was there's a scripture in DNC Section 9 and in verse 8 it says, and this is Oliver Calgary trying to translate the Book of Mormon. And it says, but behold, I say unto you that you must study it out in your mind.

2:22:04 Then you must ask me if it be right. And if it is right, I will cause your bosom, I'll burn within you. Therefore you shall feel that it is right. It says study it out in your mind. Right. And then you ask if it's right. The Mavinar record says, ask if it's right. Don't think about it too much, maybe because if you're not thinking about it, you're going to immediately reject it because it doesn't fit with your existing testimony and faith. The other part of that is right. After this it says, But if it be not right, and you shall have no such feeling, but you shall have a stupor of thought that shall cause you to forgive the thing which is wrong. Therefore you cannot write that which is sacred.

2:22:46 Save it be given you from me. That blew my mind. You cannot write that which is sacred. Save it be given you from me. That's the Lord speaking there. And what I never really understood was, I mean, the Book of Mormon. It's great, all right? It's, it's great. It's fantastic. I never really appreciated, though, how great it really is when you consider other books, like I'm a huge fan of Tolstoy. War on Peace is one of my favorite books. There's a lot of good stuff have to pull out of that book as well, but ultimately it's got flaws as well because the book, the truths presented in the book, can only rise to the standard of the person writing it.

2:23:29 So if Tolstoy writes a, if Tolstoy writes a book, it can only cut it. It can only have a quality up to the level of Tolstoy. If Joseph Smith writes a book, it can only be as good as Joseph Smith is himself. If I write a book, it can only be as good as me. So where on earth do we get scripture from? Right. What makes it scripture? You cannot write that which is sacred, save it be given you from me. Why? Because Joseph Smith, Oliver, Calgary, me, Tolstoy. We're fallen men. We have weaknesses. And those things manifest when you're trying to. If you're trying, if you were to try to write sacred texts, your own flaws are going to manifest. Your own weaknesses are going to manifest. I have immensely gained an appreciation for the Book of Mormon and my testimony of the Book of Mormon through going through this process.

2:24:24 Yeah, but. It does make the Book of Mormon more more remarkable. It really does. It really does, because I don't have you don't have these issues in the Book of Mormon. Yep, absolutely. And you have. Stuff that fills your soul as you read these testimonies of Christ and these teachings of Christ. But again, I want to see, I want to see our Lamanite brethren restored just as much as anybody because I'm a descendant myself. Right. But I will just say this is not the way. Polluting the gospel to try to win converts among Native Americans is not. How it's done? That's not how it's done. We can do better than that.

2:25:05 I know we can do better than that. And we can still have faith and hope that we're going to restore those people, that they're going to be recovered, that more Scripture has yet to come forth. But we don't need to force it. We don't need to do it this way. Nope, I agree, Justin. That's what I want to say. Good stuff, dude. I know that was a halt to go through. I appreciate that. Good stuff. Next time, let's talk about a happier subject. Yeah. Let's talk about a temple or something. Something, something good. All right, man. Stick around for just a few minutes. Bye everybody.

2:26:08 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.