Episode #94-ADDENDUM: CORRECTION & CLARIFICATION W/TAYLOR SMITH
Taylor Comes Back On To Correct An Incident Mentioned & Make Some Clarifications
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:03 Taylor, how's it going, man? Oh, hanging in there. Thanks a lot for having me back on for this quick addendum, Dave. No problem. No problem. Sounded like it's something that needed to happen. So definitely, let's get her. Let's get her rolling. Yeah. And and just before we dive in, I'd like to apologize to everyone for having to bring this subject up again so soon. I I'm. It wasn't my intent. But I've just had some people point out some things I got wrong, and I want to own that. So I I asked Dave if I could take just 1015 minutes, because I want to be as honest and fully transparent about everything as I possibly can. So there was one comment in particular that in hindsight, I wish I hadn't made in that in the previous episode.
0:45 And so I'd like to set the record straight about it, and then afterward address a couple other points. So this clip is 28 seconds long. It starts at the three hour, 41 minute and 35 second time stamp on the last episode. I'm just gonna play it real quick so it's fresh in all of our minds as they they're part of the community, a fundamentalist community. And it was very divisive a lot. Even his Blood Brothers, a lot of his Blood Brothers were very critical, especially at first of that decision that he made. And you know, they were. One brother offered to cut off his head like it was literally that degree of of extremism in the in this conversation I I'm not so I just wanted to make sure that everybody is clear that's what I'm going to be speaking to 1st off and so just for the record.
1:40 First off, I did not lie that comment was made in writing, and multiple witnesses have corroborated that it did happen. And when I first read it, it was just on a discussion group that I was invited to, and I really could hardly believe my eyes. I figured it had to be a joke. I mean who offers to to cut off their brother's this, this was on like a messaging. App, right. Correct. Yes and and. But so the fact that it was said even in jest made me wonder. If there was any possibility there that there was something darker involved, because I like I say I don't know the person who said it personally. So you didn't know it was ingested at the time, correct? I mean, how do you take it for serious?
2:22 I mean, I did not know for sure it was a joke, but so yeah, so I have had multiple assurances from mutual friends in the last two days that it absolutely was just a joke and and so like, just in hindsight, I wish I hadn't mentioned it. Or that I would have known to call out absolutely that it was a joke. And for that I just want to say I'm very sorry and freely admit I made a mistake. I think we all make them in in a in a four and a half hour conversation, almost everybody's going to say something that that they regret. And if you do it as much as I do, it's a it's a foregone conclusion, so. Sure, but I I that is such a sensitive issue.
3:03 OK, so this kind of leads into the second. Point I wanted to address because because this the the the concern that was expressed is that that I have accused all fundamentalists who support the ban of being violent people. Now I never said that nor did I intend that to be conveyed. So I'd like to just clarify what I meant. Right now, I do not believe that everyone who sincerely believes in the ban is a violent person or whatever commit an act of violence. However, that said, I absolutely stand by my position that the ban itself is inherently violent. Now in the in the last episode, I didn't read Brigham's words that he used in the 1852 address, which is where he announced the ban, because to be completely honest, I didn't want to make Brigham look bad.
3:52 I mean, I like I've said many times, I love Brigham Young. I'm grateful for all the good he did and and I acknowledge he was an amazing servant of God throughout his life. But in hindsight, I think these words do need to be addressed, especially for listeners who may not have read or heard them before. Or or maybe it's been a while and they and and the the memory is not fresh. So if you're OK with it, I'm going to read some of the words from Brigham's 1852 address now. OK, quote. But let me tell you further. Let my seed mingle with the seed of Cain that brings the curse upon me and upon my generations. We will reap the same rewards with Cain in the priesthood.
4:33 I will tell you what it will do. Were the children of God to mingle their seed with the seed of Cain, it would not only bring the curse of being deprived of the power of the priesthood upon themselves, but then entail it upon their children after them. And they cannot get rid of it. If a man in an unguarded moment, should commit such a transgression, if he would walk up and say, cut off my head. And kill man, woman and child. It would do a great deal towards atoning for the sin. Would this be to curse them? No, it would be a blessing to them. It would do them good that they might be saved with their brethren. A man would shudder should they hear us talk about killing folk.
5:14 But it is one of the greatest blessings to some to kill them, although the true principles of it, of it are not understood. UN quote SO. I am not exaggerating or misrepresenting this in any way. I am quoting Brigham Young's words verbatim. If anyone thinks that these words are not violent, I would ask you to please explain to me how they're not violent, because I can't see any other way to understand them. I mean, he's Brigham. He's plain. It's forceful. It's just his characteristically blunt way that he has. So here's the thing. I do not believe all fundamentalist who believe in the ban are violent. On the contrary. I believe the vast majority of fundamentalists who believe in the ban are nonviolent and peaceful. But it is a fact that some Mormon fundamentalists have been violent.
6:04 There's historical examples. Now, all the fundamentalists I know personally condemn the murders committed by that have been committed by a small minority of fundamentalists in the past. And I'm not saying everyone is like those violent fundamentalists. I I don't know a single fundamentalist who is out of the hundreds and hundreds I've personally met. That that is violent, but it is it possible that somebody out there could there go there again someday. I think nobody can deny that it is a possibility. There are always not cases in any society. But the most interesting thing here to me, though, is the the lack of violence within the vast majority of all fundamentalist groups. Historically and today, there's absolutely no evidence that Brigham himself ever personally acted on the penalty he prescribed in that speech.
6:51 And I personally don't think he would have been capable of doing it even if he'd had an opportunity. That's my belief. I furthermore, I I think all, or at least the vast majority of Mormon fundamentalists who believe in the band today would never personally act on it either. Fair, right. Fair. Yeah. But but no go ahead. But but let's think about that for a SEC, because this begs a really important question. If you do believe in the ban, why don't you believe in the penalty? The penalty in the ban were delivered by the same man, Brigham Young, in the same exact speech. So if you're going to accept the ban as revelation from God, how do you reject what he said immediately after? Like the the penalty for interracial marriages that would be logically inconsistent.
7:43 There's there's a, there's a phrase that's been kind of kind of thrown around. It's become commonplace these days. It's called cognitive dissonance. And I think it applies here. I am advocating a very logically consistent position which requires no cognitive dissonance whatsoever by asking whether Brigham's priesthood man was inspired of God or not. This doesn't mean Brigham was a bad guy or not a prophet that are inherently evil or anything. It just means I believe a good guy, a great man had a bad opinion and and I believe it's our personal responsibility to get the spirit of God within our own hearts and judge righteously. Not condemn the man who taught it, but only condemn the false and violent doctrine. As far as I know, there's not a single fundamentalist group out there today that hasn't rejected the latter half of the ban, the penalty already.
8:33 So. So that is what I wanted to correct and and clarify on the point of the priesthood ban with regards to violence. So, to be to be clear, despite the violence inherent to the doctrine. We as fundamentalists are not inherently more dangerous than any other person in the world, and neither was Brigham Young. I think that reality speaks significantly to the band's legitimacy. Perfect. Yeah. No, I I I think so. And. And you gotta look at when this was delivered. If I'm not mistaken, this comes forward in the Mormon Reformation period, right? And this is in a period where Brigham sees people are slacking a little bit and Brigham was trying to make a point and drive it home. And I I like you don't think Brigham Young would have done it and but but it's worth bearing out and I appreciate you coming back on to to clear that up.
9:30 OK, thanks. So yeah, the the another concern that was raised is whether I should have shared details about the prayer meeting that happened in Missouri. And so, just to be clear, the reason I addressed the issue publicly right now in the last episode is because details about that meeting had already been shared with people in other groups, including my own group here in Utah, from an antagonistic source. So it was already out, but it was being shared from an adversarial perspective by somebody who opposed the decision. If that had not happened, I might not have written that section into the essays, or at least when I did. And and I definitely would not have talked about the Missouri meeting on the podcast but but but because that's what did happen. I felt it is important to give the full story so that everyone who has seen the minutes or has heard rumors about it has access to all the facts before drawing conclusions. I've I've not received a single complaint from anyone who was part of the meeting, only from people who were not part of the meeting and who opposed the decision that was made there, yeah.
10:35 And then the last thing, and this is actually from an anonymous contributor who submitted something to me on the website, so I appreciate that I had missed this in my research. So while it doesn't necessarily change any of the conclusions I've come to, I do believe it's worth mentioning because it shows I was wrong about one of the historical points I made. Because you remember, I attributed Mosiah Hancock's 1855 dream about the, you know, premortal existence and the neutral spirits being the black race here on earth. I I thought that was the first documented instance of this idea being taught chronologically. Actually, Orson Hyde preached a sermon on this subject in 1845. S 10 years before that, the year after the martyrdom in which he said and I'll quote.
11:25 At the time the devil was cast out of heaven, there were some spirits that did not know who had the authority, whether God or the Devil. They consequently did not take a very active part on either side, but rather thought the devil had been abused and considered he had rather the best claim to the government. These spirits were not considered bad enough to be cast down to hell and never have bodies. Neither were they considered worthy of an honorable body upon this earth. But it came to pass that Ham, the son of Noah, saw the nakedness of his father while he lay drunk in his tent, and he with, quote, wicked joy, UN quote, ran like Rigden, and made the wonderful disclosure to his brethren, while Shem and Japheth took a garment with pity and compassion, laid it upon their shoulders, went backwards, and covered their father, and saw not his nakedness. The joy of the first was to expose that of the second was to cover the unseemliness of their father. The conduct of the former brought the curse of slavery upon him, while that of the latter secured blessings, jurisdiction, power, and dominion. Here was the beginning of blessing and cursing in the family of Noah, and here also is the cause of both. Canaan, the son of Ham, received the curse, for Noah wished to place the curse as remote from himself as possible. He therefore placed it upon his grandson instead of his son. Now it would seem cruel to force pure celestial spirits into the world through the lineage of Canaan that had been cursed. This would be ill appropriate putting the precious and vile together.
12:54 But those spirits in heaven that rather lent an influence to the devil thinking, had a little the best right to govern, but did not take a very active part. Anyway, we're required to come into the world and take bodies in the accursed lineage of Canaan and hence the N word or African race. Now, therefore, all those who are halting concerning, who has the right to govern, had better look at the fate of their brethren that have gone before them, and take warning and time, lest they learn obedience by the things which they suffer. Choose ye this day whom you will serve. These things are among the mysteries of the Kingdom, and I have told them not by constraint or by commandment, but by permission. UN quote. Now this we have to consider the context.
13:36 So this was a speech given by Elder Orson Hyde to the High Priest Quorum. In Nauvoo on April 27th, 1845 S just under a year after the martyrdom, but before the big meeting where Sydney rigged in and and Brigham Young addressed the body of the Saints, so before the succession crisis had been kind of resolved. So the the title of this speech is upon the course and conduct of Mr. Sydney rigged in and the merits of his claims to the presidency of the Church. So you know, so of course. Just a few weeks after this, Brigham Young was sustained as the rightful successor. Well, the 12th with Brigham Young as as the president were sustained to lead the church. You know, it was not a unanimous decision. You know, not everybody sustained Brigham Young, but everyone who went W to Utah did sustain Brigham Young and not Sidney Rigdon.
14:31 And so he's using this, this biblical story as rhetoric to essentially. Persuade kind of a little bit through fear the people who were considering following Sidney Rigden to know you shouldn't follow him. He's like Canaan or he's like Ham and and you know Brigham Young and the 12 they're like Shem and Japheth and and so that that is what it is. It was said at that time and so three important details that that stand out to me from this account is First off Orson Hyde. Does not attribute these ideas to Joseph Smith. That's number one that has to be stated. And I read it's a long discourse. It's about 35 pages and I'm gonna put the link on the website so you can read it in full yourself. But I read it Joseph Orson Hyde does not attribute these teachings and coming ideas coming from Joseph Smith. Secondly, this directly contradicts several things Joseph Smith told Orson Hyde to his face. You know, remember that conversation between Joseph Smith and Orson Hyde when he says change their the the black situation with the whites and they would be like them. They have souls and are subjects of salvation. And then later on Joseph says in another conversation that the OR in the same conversation put them on an he would put them on a national equalization, etcetera. So.
15:59 So this flies in the face of things that Joseph Smith did. To talk and say to Orson hide. And then the third thing and perhaps the most important Brigham Young himself refuted that he and like that, that this idea was a thing. And in 1869 he emphatically stated that he had heard Joseph teach the opposite. So. So these are the reasons why the above quote does not change my conclusions about what I said before, but in the interest of honesty and, you know, just. Representing the history as as as accurately as possible, I will be adding this quote to the website as an addendum to the SA at Blacks and the priesthood.com and and I'll I'll include a link to the full speech and you know, the person who contributed this did not leave their name or e-mail, so if whoever submitted it happens to be listening right now. Thank you very much.
16:54 I appreciate it. One other thing I wanted to point out is that it doesn't say anything about restriction of priesthood, just slavery as a penalty, correct? I mean, it doesn't actually go anywhere. It just talks about it. They are cursed. It's a cursive lineage and and he's implying that anybody who follows Sidney Rigdon is basically guilty of the same thing. And, you know, so it it doesn't actually speak to priesthood eligibility or anything else related, but it it is the first chronological documented instance of. The teaching that there were neutral spirits in heaven. So that's why I do believe it is germane to this discussion and investigation. Well dude, I appreciate your honesty.
17:35 So that's good stuff. So thank you. I've had to issue one of these ones before myself and I understand. So it's it's all good. I appreciate it. All right. See ya. Thanks.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox