March 21, 2025

Episode #176: The Temple Covenants Series-PT.6 The Oath Of Vengeance W/Ben Shaffer

Episode #176: The Temple Covenants Series-PT.6 The Oath Of Vengeance W/Ben Shaffer
Episode #176: The Temple Covenants Series-PT.6 The Oath Of Vengeance W/Ben Shaffer
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #176: The Temple Covenants Series-PT.6 The Oath Of Vengeance W/Ben Shaffer

Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.

On this installment of the Temple Series we are going to be discussing perhaps one the most controversial and for sure the most misunderstood portion of the original Mormon Temple ceremony and that is the Oath of Vengeance. With portrayals of Mormonism such as Under The Banner of Heaven and American Primeval this part of the Temple Ceremony makes a lot of Mormons squeamish. The truth is however we don’t need to feel that way. Today I have Ben Shaffer on the podcast as we discuss this portion of the Mormon Temple experience in depth. We talk about what the Oath really is, how it has been misused, how it became taboo, how it helps us become a more civilized people, and also how it actually helps us focus on relieving the suffering of the oppressed.

0:26 The you're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Ben, how's it going, man? Going well. Good. Glad to be on with you. Me too. So I got to tell you that last episode we did on, I think it was the King Fall at Discourse. Yes, King Fawlett, one of the greatest speeches I think Joseph Smith ever gave. Maybe ever, right? I mean as far as content just found. Maybe one of the greatest speeches ever given, right, Right. It's it's up there with a Sermon on the Mount in my mind as being like central teachings that really define what it means for us to have a relationship with God. Absolutely.

1:11 But anyway, I got great reviews off that. They loved what it was you you had to say on that. So good on you and I'm excited for this one. This is a can't remember what number it is in the installment, but we're recording this in January and I imagine this will be out mid to late February. But we're going to talk about the the Oath of Vengeance. And this is something that, I mean, I've seen it make even fundamentalist a little squeamish at times, right? And so something that as I dove into it, I found super important that this is more than just something ugly or something even just necessary, right?

1:58 This is something that I think we can benefit from for sure. Yep. So take us away, brother. OK. Well, there, it's interesting because a big part of the con text here is that Mormon temple ceremonies, right, have a lot of things in them that are not for the uninitiated. The idea is, is that these sacred ceremonies, these sacred covenants are supposed to be made for people who are, are supposed to learn something deep and profound out of it. And therefore it's not something that's just paraded for the world, right? It's sacred. And that's why people often say, well, it's also secret, therefore, right. So there's a lot of things that we promised not to disclose, but the oath of vengeance is interestingly something that you promise exactly the opposite, or at least again, when I say people promise exactly the opposite, it is worth pointing out that the LDS Church has not used this oath for a very, very long time. There's, I, I think in the mainstream LDS church, I'm not sure if there's anybody still alive even who would have done this oath.

3:06 But there was one of the covenants of the temple and it's still one of the consequences of the temple in my belief. But the mainstream of this church just has done away with it. And, and instead of promising to keep this secret or, or private or only for the temple, the oath of vengeance, you promise exactly the opposite. You promise that you will teach this to your children and your children's children to the third and 4th generation. In other words, you will teach about this sacred principle to everybody, right? And, and even to make sure that you carry it on generation after generation that everyone will know about it. So, so this is something I feel that I can speak very openly, very freely about is this temple covenant. And, and hopefully it will be enlightening and, and, and helpful to others because I really believe that this is a sacred covenant that is meant to really help the whole world. It's a beautiful thing, in my opinion. Now it's also become a controversial thing. So we got to talk about that too. So, Gee, where should we start the history? The let's let's start, let's start, let's start the history. Well, I guess we could, we could hit the actual oath itself a couple times through this, right. So let's start out with what the oath actually is. And again, because, because it's, it's one of the few things in in the temple ceremony, like obviously we receive tokens and signs and those things, but we're commanded not to reveal those outside the temple, right?

4:38 Exactly. This oath and our garment is really the only thing that leaves with us so to. Right. And and right. And like I was just saying, we're supposed to talk about it. So it's providing, right. So the oath itself, the oath itself, there's been a couple different, slightly different versions over the years that that'll we'll get into that, into the history. But it basically is, and these words are in every version, is that we covenant and promise that we will pray and that we will never cease to pray, and that we will never cease to importune high heaven to avenge the blood of the innocent. Right.

5:19 Now then there's a couple of differences. People talk about whether or not the blood of the innocent refers to the prophets. So one of the things they did in pioneers times was at that point they would say eventually the blood of the innocent prophets upon the heads of this nation. That's where it got really controversial. That was one of the earliest versions had that phrase in there and that that phrase was considered controversial because they're saying, wait a second, are you saying that you are hoping that God punishes the nation? Maybe literally the United States of America for, for killing the prophets. Of course, the assumption would therefore be that's probably Joseph and Hiram and things like that. So there was there was a pioneer version that included those those words and that made people very nervous that came up in the rude, the rude Reed Smoot hearings. It was called right.

6:12 Reed Smoot was an apostle. He was also elected to become a senator and the Senate was trying to decide whether or not they were going to seat him or not. I would say The funny thing about those hearings, this was in 1904, in 1904, one of the funny things to me about those hearings is that they were basically trying to answer the question of can you be a Mormon and be an American? And that's something we take for granted today, of course, right? Almost all Americans, almost all Mormons are red blooded Americans that love this country and we're considered the most American religion. I mean, Americanism and Mormonism go so hand in hand in so many people's minds.

6:53 It's kind of bizarre to realize that at the time that was considered to be possibly completely incompatible. You know I find this interesting, right? Because it's not really that long ago that we have a very similar discussion around JFK and his Catholicism, right? JFK has to go out and have a whole speech where he basically will say, look, I follow the Pope in terms of my, my spiritual journey, right? But he's not necessarily going to be able to call the shots in my presidency, right? Right. And so. Because people were worried. Can you be a Catholic and be an American, or at least an American president?

7:37 Right. And and so this is this is something that comes up from time to time, right. And I would expect that if we ever had a a Muslim candidate for president, it would come up again, right? Well, and sadly, not too long ago when Mitt Romney ran for president, there were a lot of people talking about can you be a Mormon and be president? And I was disappointed at the time. There were several major research organizations, right, that do polling. And they did a poll of would you be comfortable with, you know, setting aside present candidates, would you be comfortable with any Mormon ever being president? Would you be comfortable with any woman ever being present, regardless of the candidates? Would you?

8:21 And Mormons actually scored the worst. Yep. Mormon, are you comfortable with a Mormon being president? Was right up there with things like, would you be comfortable with a Muslim president? I forget exactly how much, but it was a substantial minority. Like 30% or something of Americans said that they would never be comfortable with any Mormon being president. And I thought, Oh my gosh, I can't believe it's still that much prejudice against the, you know, just based on religion. But there is a lot of prejudice out there. Yep, Yep, No, it's interesting that this that, that these, these this idea of of kind of being mutually exclusive, right, Being being an American and a Mormon can, you know, aren't really compatible, right? You're looked at like maybe kind of like American Light. But but so this is one of the.

9:10 This is one example of one of the interpretations that's caused this to become controversial. And yet, what is the oath really? What did I just say the oath was? The oath is to pray, right? It's to pray that God will do his justice for this world. And so this is actually an important theme throughout the entire Bible at beginning in Genesis chapter 4, OK, so right at the beginning of the Bible as well. And so throughout the Torah and then throughout the prophets, Old and New Testament, this theme about the blood of the innocent, not to shed the blood of the innocent, or that the blood of the innocent cries from the ground for vengeance upon those who shed that innocent blood. Is, is this major theme, right?

10:01 What, what is it that we we see in the book of Genesis, they leave the Garden of Eden where there's no death. And then one of the very first stories we hear, one of the very first things we hear is that there is death in this new world and there's murder. So right after they leave the Garden of Eden, one of the first things we hear about is this story of Cain and Abel, that Cain shed innocent blood. And then God says to when God confronts Cain, God says, what have you done? The voice of your brother's blood cries out to me from the ground, right? So this is in Genesis 410. He's basically saying there this, this, this broken world, this world of death, this world of sin, it's best exemplified by this story, a story of murder and a story of innocence lost and innocent blood shed.

11:00 And but God doesn't leave us hopeless that when we go out into this lone and dreary world, there's some temple phraseology for you with that when we go out into this lone and dreary world that God will no longer care about what happens to us. Quite the opposite in fact. The very first thing that the very first great sin that occurs in the world, this murder of Abel by his brother, God immediately takes notice, right? The same way that Jesus says the Father notices the fall of every Sparrow, right? He immediately notices and he says there is there are consequences to sin, but there's also a redemption promised. Right.

11:41 And so I think that when we think, OK, so when we think about not just the temple, when we think about gospel learning, it's almost always wrapped up in these sacred symbolism stories. There's a lot of things they could have told us about. They could have told us how the first harvest went. They could have told us about what kind of technology they used or where they lived or how they lived. But that's not what they tell us. What Moses tells us in the Bible, there was a became the world became a fallen world, and then there was death in it. And so the first thing I want to tell you about what this means about the world that we live in is I'm going to tell you this, this terrible story of murder, but a murder where the blood of the innocent isn't shed in vain. God hears cry of innocence.

12:27 God hears the the sorrow and the pleading of those who are harmed, and God executes judgement upon the wicked. And so even though judgement is always isn't always swift and there's a lot of complications in this world, this is the one of the first lessons that Moses and God try to teach us in the Scriptures from the very beginning so that God cares and that there is going to be a consequence and a redemption. And so This is why I think this is so central to the covenants of the temple. Another thing that I don't mind talking in general terms, one of the main themes of the temple of course, is that it is about this creation narrative, right the the temple is about the creation of the earth, the Garden of Eden, the fall and the redemption from the fall.

13:16 And so just like Moses in the book of Genesis lays out this story of fall, sin, redemption, that's what the purpose of the temple is, is to walk us through that plan of salvation, to walk us through those principles. And so central to that, just as it's central in the book of Genesis, is this question of the blood of the innocent. And what happens when, when we face injustice and death and sorrow in this world. And I think it's telling that the oath isn't take the law into your own hands and get the bad guys.

13:57 You know, this isn't, you know, like, like when you're a child, like there's a game of cops and robbers. You know what I mean? And what is the first thing you do when you're a copy freeze and then you shoot the robbers or whatever? Because we're all looking for justice. We all want swift justice. The Lord's telling us if you want justice in this world, you actually don't get to do it yourself. It's not an oath that I will execute justice on the wicked. It's quite the opposite. It is I promise that I will pray and I will cease to pray and I will never cease to in between I have. In other words, this should be the constant motivating force within us should not be toward vengeance of our own. A constant motive should be look to God for justice, look to God for salvation, right?

14:48 And so people call the oath of vengeance and it becomes controversial because of these various political things, right? People assume that it means that we are looking for vengeance because we're praying for the Lord's vengeance. And I would say, no, the Lord's vengeance is not like man's vengeance. The Lord's vengeance is justice. It's peace. It's an end to sorrow, Right? And this whole context of the blood, the blood of the innocent really centers on Jesus Christ and the central and and that that's one of the other reasons why I think this is interesting. The oath of vengeance is actually right in the center of the endowment. So what's the central message of something usually means? Of course, it's main theme, right? But another way of looking at the center is what's exactly in the middle.

15:38 Exactly. The center of the Book of Mormon, I love to point out, is the place where the anti nephile heights make their oath and promise that they will never again shed innocent blood. Right and right in the very center of the endowment of the of the covenants that you make the middle one. The middle covenant is the oath of vengeance. And I think it's trying to say the same thing. And the Book of Mormon also has this exact same theme in it. The Book of Mormon is saying right in the middle. If you want to see the message, right in the middle is the covenant not to shed innocent blood, and right in the middle of the endowment is the covenant to pray for the blood of the innocent.

16:21 In other words, not to shed innocent blood, but instead to pray that the Lord will be our deliverance, right? And so in that sense, the the Book of Mormon itself is set up very similarly. And Jesus is also said to have come at the Meridian of time. So the central message, the central theme of the entire gospel of Jesus Christ, of course, is the sacrifice of Jesus Christ, which is what? The sacrifice of innocent blood. Jesus was innocent. That's the, that's the part of the whole point, right? Jesus committed no sin. And Judas, for example, when he sees that Jesus doesn't just throw off the oppressors, but instead he goes and he dies. Judas is so distraught, right?

17:11 He goes and he, he kills himself. And there's a couple different versions on how that goes. Either he's hung around his neck or his bowels gush out. But he's he suffers these penalties, which of course is also a temple theme. And Judas says this quote in Matthew chapter 27 for Matthew quotes Judas as having saying, I have sinned. I have betrayed the innocent blood. That's. Interesting. And so again, what is this whole thing, right? What it what does it mean when he says that he's the one to blame for shedding the blood of the innocent? He's basically pointing out that that's the dichotomy. That's the ultimate dichotomy.

18:03 There's death and there's resurrection, right? And those who ascent unto the crucifixion of Christ, who bear that responsibility, that is, that is the ultimate sin, right? And in fact, this is something, Gee, I'm just, I'm just, I'm just running with this. But this is also mentioned in the Doctrine Covenants that the unpardonable sin is that they ascend unto the death of Jesus Christ, which is a new way of putting it. The unforgivable sin has often been described as denying the Holy Ghost. Right. But what does that mean exactly? I I really strongly disagree with the Protestant view of that. They usually think that means that anybody who gets started in the Christian life and then doesn't and then turns back to sin is unpardonable.

18:52 And I think that would apply to almost everybody, including some of the best Christians I know, because at some point we all make mistakes. But no, I think the this and so Mormonism has this much broader, more robust version of what the unpardonable sin is, and that it and that it can really only be committed by those who know God. Right. Who are witnesses of His glory, who are deeply connected to Him, who know Him and then turn all together therefrom? Right. So a lot of that doctrine comes from the Doctrine Covenants, but it also says that the ascent to the shedding of innocent blood is the unpardonable sin.

19:36 And I think that the way I kind of interpret this to a sense to Jesus death being unpardonable is it really is one of those questions of like orientation. Are you headed toward God or are you against God way? To truly commit the unpardonable sin is to lust after innocent blood, the innocent blood of Jesus Christ. To have so much hatred and and also knowledge of God like Perdition and and Satan do that they know who God is but they hate who God is so much that they just wish that they could kill him. Right. Right. And so that's why, that's why the unpardonable sin, this one little exception to the universal salvation of Mormonism is this, this rare carve out for someone like Judas, and maybe even not Judas, but for somebody who says, I want to fight God, it's not going to take away your free agency.

20:37 If you're willing to accept God's grace, then great, come into the kingdoms of heaven. There's room for everybody there. There's many mansions, there's the different degrees of glory and all of that, right? So everybody else, this universal salvation, everybody else gets to come in, but God's not going to take you away. Your free agency. And if you stand there at the doorway of heaven and say to God, I hate you, I want to destroy you. I would fight you. I would kill you. I want to shed your innocent blood. I will never enter your rest. God's not going to force you to go to heaven. Right. That's why it's unforgivable, because no matter how, because it's not about whether or not God can forgive. God can forgive. God is like God has arms wide open to forgive, but there is no forgiveness for them. Why?

21:22 Because they don't accept it. Right, right. You know. I made some tangents there, sorry about. That no, no, no, no, no, you're, you're good. You're good. This is exactly what I was hoping it would be. Right? Because this is one of those things that really does have to be unpacked through, through the spectrum of human history, as it were, right to, to really grasp, get, get a good grasp on what it is we're talking about here. To go along with what you said about, you know, talking about what it is we are actually praying or, or what we're actually covenanting to do here. Again, it's not that we're saying, you know, the, the oath of vengeance does not empower somebody to pick up the sword, right?

22:09 That's not what that's about. Yeah. Now let's talk about the benefits of that, right? Because I'm a guy who does believe in in righteous indignation, right? God feels that I think we feel that from time time to time the. Danger is of course, you want to make sure that your indignation is actually righteous. I'm not just self-righteous, because then that opens up a different kind of worms. Made right? Absolutely. And and let's look, let's look at the breadth of human history, right? I think too often we, we sit here and we're really super comfortable in our 21st century trappings, right? I mean, look, mankind in a lot of ways has never had it so good, right? By and large in the United States, I'm there are people who are hungry, right?

22:59 I don't want to diminish that, but it's a small percentage, right? And we need to do what we can to eradicate that. We don't live under warlords, right? By and large, thank goodness. Right. By and large, there's some. There's definitely some injustice and terrible tyrants in this world, but most of them hopefully are, well, we're blessed to live in this, in this land where we have a Republic, a free Republic. Right, if, if we look at but, but this is an aberration in human history, right? If we go back in time, it's history's bloody, right? And it's bloody in the sense of you wronged me and my people.

23:42 Now me and my people are going to go extract our pound of flesh, right? And what what that does is that does not allow for any sort of peace, right? The Hatfield and Mccoy's, right. They went at it for the better part of what, half a half a century? They were at each other's throats, right? We look back at at, you know, early Europe, Middle Eastern history, it is a bloody, bloody mess because someone feels like they're offended or something. And and maybe so maybe it's a legitimate offense, right? But what happens is, is if you do that all the time, there is no peace and there is no time to build a civilization, right? And what is it we as Mormons here are really trying to do, Ben?

24:32 We're, you know, we're ultimately aiming for Zion, right, which is a society, a good society without bloodshed. And so by by basically saying, you know what, I was wronged. I was, I was absolutely persecuted. I was, I was hurt, I was damaged. But the Lord does something different than what man does, right. Man's knee jerk reaction is give me my sword now I'm going to go get even. The Lord is saying something else. He's like, let me take care of this. Now, what does that do for a society? I think it allows a society to take root, right?

25:13 It allows a civilization, a civilization to begin to flourish because it's not always at war, right? You don't have warlords running around. You have appealed that to a higher power. And so in some ways, in a lot of ways, the Oath of Vengeance is a very civilizing oath that you will take. Yeah, 'cause, you know, there's, there's the old an eye for an eye and a tooth for a tooth. And some people say, well, then I should be able to meet out judgements with the same measure that was needed to me. And, and as Tevya says right in the in the very popular musical Fiddler on the Roof, right, he says. But then the whole world will end up blind and toothless. Yes.

25:58 Because there's always someone to exact judgement on. And yet we still want to believe in real, real consequences, real justice, right? I've got another scripture for the listeners here that goes into this, and it's the words of Jesus in Luke chapter 18. Christ says it asks the question, will God bring about justice for those who cry out to him day and night? And, and it's worth pointing out that I think that Jesus, when he often talks about these things, there's, there's like temple passages throughout the Scripture where there are strong allusions to specific parts of the temple. And I believe this is one of them because again, he, he's referring to some kind of oath that the righteous have taken to cry out to God day and night.

26:45 In other words, to never cease to pray, right? I'm like, Oh well, this is so Luke 18, he says, will God not bring about the justice for his elect who cry out to him day and night? Will he delay in helping them? I tell you he will probably carry out justice on their behalf. Nevertheless, when the Son of man comes, will he find faith on the earth? So Jesus is saying that like. God is. What you who is, who you look to for justice? And God will answer us if we will fulfill our part of the oath. And I feel. You know, but that doesn't mean it happens in our mortal time, in our mortal way. You know, Jesus, Jesus was innocent blood, but that doesn't mean he didn't have to die.

27:31 It didn't mean that the Lord sent armies of angels to go down and and kill all those Pharisees who cried for his blood. Instead, the Lord allowed Jesus to suffer what he suffered in this world. But. Then the. Lord, but then he still did justice. Jesus did not deserve to die. And So what did he do? He rose again, right? So I think that's the interesting thing about justice. Justice doesn't necessarily mean that bad things don't happen. Justice means that it'll be. Worth it? In the end, justice means that bad things do happen, but then we get restored in the end to what is what is good and what is right and what is what is fair. Yep, it just doesn't.

28:19 Happen. All at once, because we have to go through the sorrow we must pass through sorrow that we know the good from the evil right. And there's another, there's another potentially tumble reference, right, because those are the words of Eve when when she left the Garden of Eden was that it is better for us to pass through sorrow that we might know the good from the evil, right and. So Justice. Doesn't mean that bad things don't happen, it means that when you pass through them and you trust in God. That. In the next World, in the perfect world that we're praying for, every time we pray the oath of vengeance, we're praying that Jesus will come and and heal the world.

29:01 So from there I'd. Like to jump to the Book of Revelation the. Book of Revelation. In chapter 6 is it's the 5th seal of the book for those who follow this, basically in John's vision, he's seeing a vision of how is it that any of this will come about? And what does he do? He sees the holy temple in heaven, the divine temple. And so most of the Book of Revelation with this vision of the divine temple, a lot of it is temple commentary. So it actually is commentary on the endowment. And so once again, here's another ancient example to, I'm going to make this point in more detail later, but here's another ancient example that I believe that these covenants have existed in temple liturgies, not just in this dispensation, but throughout time, right?

29:46 So the. 5th. Seal which is right in the middle of the seals, right, because there's 7 seals and he and so the middle seal is the 4th or the 5th right And in the 5th seal we have the oath of vengeance, right. And so he's making commentary on this vision of the, of the celestial temple and when the Lamb opened the 5th seal. So when Jesus opens to this next part, this next covenant in his book. John sees. That under the altar of the temple. Were the souls of. Those who were slain for the word of God, all those whose had, who have been the martyrs, those whose innocent blood had been shed, right.

30:28 And. And he hears the cry of the innocent blood crying out of the ground, and they cry. How long, O Lord, holy and true, until you avenge our blood and judge those who dwell upon the earth, right? So. This again, this isn't about the petty justice of of mankind. This is about the divine justice of God. They're saying we were robbed of our second estate. We were robbed of our mortal lives. We how long must we wait until we have the chance to regain the life that we've lost to to have every opportunity that we were promised that was stolen from us, right? How long until you put an end to all of this evil on the earth so that we can live again in this millennial world and have restored to us everything that was stolen from us by those who shed our us in blood, right?

31:22 And so, but here's the interesting thing, verse 11, God doesn't just say, OK, immediate resurrection, immediate justice, immediate everything he doesn't. Each of the martyrs is then by Christ is given a white robe. Told to rest. A while. Until the full. Number of their fellow servants, all the other martyrs are killed just as they've been killed. So instead of God saying I'm going to put a swift end to the evils of the world, he says. You have to wait. Until more people die, basically. Which sounds terrible to me at first. But he's saying.

32:06 Rest, be at peace, don't fear. Because I will. Restore to you everything. But it isn't. Yet the time for your redemption isn't yet. So he gives them the white robe, right? And to me, that's this beautiful temple symbology again, Absolutely. What we receive is. A. White robe, but we're also told that. When we receive. These blessings, right we were, or when we go to the temple for our dead, and some of whom may have been these righteous martyrs, and they receive the robes of the priesthood, they receive the garment of the holy priesthood. They receive this white robe. They're also being promised that they are clean, that they're innocent, right? Don't forget, even the martyrs didn't live sinless lives, right? They're being redeemed even even in death. They're receiving the promise that their sins are washed clean in a lot of.

32:59 Lamb and so the. Lamb himself gives the robe and says don't fear, you will receive everything you would have received. And this is this is fairly essential, I think, to the whole concept of Mormon temple theology and why we do work for our dead. It isn't just about, you know, power in this life. And it isn't just about like, oh, the dead didn't get a chance to do it while they were alive. A lot of them didn't, of course, have that chance. I think it's about this idea that no matter how bad this world gets, God is greater than. Any sin. Any darkness, Any suffering? Any death that this world can deal out, God is greater than it all. Yep.

33:43 And that. Even the person who lived and died in obscurity and and sinned like everyone else and and the martyrs who were had their lives stolen from them. No matter who you are, if you approach God, God can overcome all of the lack. Yeah. Gives you the white robe. With the promise that you shall sit down upon my throne with Thrones, kingdoms, principalities, dominions and exaltations, not because we and of ourselves are worthy. Right, Christ. Is worthy. And Christ chooses. To bring us up with him? Yep.

34:23 You know it's. Interesting, right? The same pattern we see set there in Genesis. It's the same pattern we see it. And I think it's 121 of Doctrine and Covenants where Joseph's in Liberty Jail, right? And he's like, how long, O Lord? How long? How long going to let this happen, right. And he lists the grievances again, right. And what's the Lord's response? Just wait. Endure it a little longer. Yeah, just wait, wait, be patient through your. Suffering. And then if thou endure it well, thou shall be exalted on high. In other words, I'm not going to, I'm not going to take you out of this suffering. In fact, I'm hoping that passing through it will. It will be for your good.

35:07 Yep, Yep. But but again. He but, but if I'm not mistaken, the Lord does say, look at some point I'll deal with this right, but your job is not to dwell on this. I've got other things for you to do, Joseph. And in the case of Revelation, what they have to do is just rest. You've done well. Just rest in my glory for a little while here. And then I will, I will deal with it. You know the the. Other thing is, is that we've talked a lot about justice here, right? And I've often said that that, well, why didn't we call it the oath of justice, right?

35:48 Because to me that sounds friendlier, right? I'm like, why not call it the oath of justice? The problem with that is I talked about it being. Called the Oath of prayer because we're promising to pray, right? Right. There's there's all sorts of things there that that it could have been called. However, it in in my own folly in thinking of that and as I did my own scripture study into this well, man's allowed to deal in justice in this life, right Judges right. We know that it's a valid system. The Lord kind of installed something like that amongst the Nephites. There were judges in Israel. So maybe justice doesn't fit and it wasn't until I did a deep dive where I'm like, wait a second, hold on. There's a scripture that says.

36:36 Vengeance is. Mine, saith the Lord, right? Meaning you don't get to play in that arena as a mortal. This is mine. Right. And again. Because I think as humans, we have knee jerk reactions to things that make us feel, you know, that that sounds kind of ugly. I don't want to boy, that's that sounds brutal. But if you look at it, it's a massive blessing to humanity again, because we're going to leave that up to a higher power. The other thing I'll say. Is that we get wronged. And often times, and I am super guilty of this, Ben, we get wronged and we don't ask the question, what was the intent of the person who wronged me? Well, and to a certain extent.

37:27 Sometimes when you're angry, you're like, I don't care if they didn't mean to. They did it right, man. I'm mad about it, right? Right. And, and we don't have the ability to look on the heart all that much, right or no mind man. Looketh on the outward. Appearance. But the Lord looketh upon the heart, right? That's in Samuel. So yes, yes. And so we can't. We can't, ultimately. Look and see what. That person has done what, what, what the intent of that person's heart was right. Maybe it was to inflict damage. Maybe it was right. And sometimes you have guys who actually say, yeah, my, my whole thing was I just want to inflict as much pain as possible, right? But sometimes, and I would say a lot of times when we get slighted, it's not so much that, it's just. The person went about.

38:24 It the wrong way or we didn't, you know, there's all sorts of extenuating circumstances that we as mortals don't get to look at. And so again, it's a way that the Lord can sort that out because he does know best, because he does know best. Otherwise, as as it said in The Fiddler on the Roof, there's going to be a lot less people with a whole lot more bloodshed going on in the world and it's going to look a lot more war-torn than what it already is. Well, and it's bad enough. As it is, you know, one of the things that I, I often try to say to remind myself when I'm upset with somebody is that you don't make peace with your friends. You make peace with your enemies.

39:05 Yeah. And, you know, there's, it's, it's one thing to be like, oh, well, I'd make peace with them if they would say they're sorry and things like that. And but the problem is, is that someone has to go 1st and it's kind of our job to be the one who goes first as much as possible, right? If we're, if we're to be true followers of Jesus Christ and we're supposed to be turning the other cheek and so forth. It's usually our responsibility to the one who goes 1st and says, hey, I'm sorry. Even when you're like, yes, I'm not guilty and I'm not apologizing and I didn't do anything wrong, but I'm still sorry. This is one of the things I like about it in English. Sorry in English is really the same root word as sorrow. In other words, I'm sad about it. There's a breach.

39:48 And there's sorrow for what this is. So when you say I'm sorry, you're saying I have sorrow. It doesn't have to be the sorrow of the guilty. It can be the sorrow of just recognizing the harm. And sometimes you have to be the first one to go forward and say it if you want there to be peace. Because again, yeah, you don't make peace with your friends. You make peace with your enemies. And that's the hard part because your enemies are your enemies, they're not necessarily going to be helpful. And and I think that part of that is turning back to the earth of vengeance is prayer. You know, when we're when we have a more immature faith, not no, no offense to an immature faith, right. There's, I see the stages of development, an early stage of prayer development is when we kind of say, dear heavenly Father, please help me to pass my test and do good in school and please help me to get the, my, the toy that I want and stuff like that right.

40:41 We, we think of prayer sometimes in the earliest stages of development as a way of telling God what we want and hoping that God will give it to us because we've been taught that God is good. There's nothing wrong with that, but it's, it's, it's a less mature form of prayer. To truly reach a higher level of spirituality, we have to recognize that what we're doing when we even when we do that very shallow kind of prayer, even any kind of prayer that we're doing, what we're doing is we're we're starting to reconcile ourselves to God by talking to him about it, by talking through what's going on in our hearts. We begin to start to wonder, what does God want? What is? Right.

41:22 What is it that I should be asking for? Not just what do I want, but what should I want? And until eventually, prayer becomes a way of reconciling our hearts to God and subsuming our own will into the will of the divine. Instead of just trying. To get our own way or get something that we want, right? Well, I think it's the same way with this oath of vengeance. It's a prayer that God will avenge the blood of the innocent. At first, that might sound like to a lot of people like we're praying for those who killed the prophet to, to get their comeuppance because we're really ticked off at them and it's appropriate to be upset with people who murder your friends. I mean, of course, that's not easy to deal with. But if you pray and never cease to pray, eventually I think you reach a point in that prayer where you say, well, God, what do you want to do, right?

42:14 And if you never cease to pray, eventually you reach the point where you start to receive it, revelation. So it's not just a one way St. of prayer. It becomes a reconciliation. How is it that I want? How can my heart desire the things of God the way God wants them to be right? Now. That is not just and, and, and sometimes people will say, Oh, well, I don't like the sound of that because that means I'm going to have to come to some place where I just forgive everybody all the time. And I don't, I don't care about the outcome. And it's like, whoa, whoa, whoa. That's actually not what it is. God actually cares about the outcome. God has promised us that his vengeance will be perfect, that his justice will be assured, that he will put an end to all suffering, all sorrow.

43:01 He will dry every tear and he will make a millennial world where there will be no more violence, right? So there's going to come a time when and, and This is why in the Book of Revelation, people worry about the judgments part too. There's God will execute judgment, but we have to want it the way God wants it. So the way we want it, right? Absolutely. And so, yeah, I think that's. Why, it's prayer. And yet, you know, it wouldn't just sound so much more friendly to outsiders who don't understand the endowments if we were to if if we were to call it the oath of prayer, right? But it has to be more. Than that. Because I don't think I'm sorry.

43:42 This is a world where terrible, terrible things happen. If we can't use harsh words to describe a harsh reality, we're kidding ourselves. I'm not so politically correct that I think that that's a wise choice. I think it's good. It's good for us to challenge hard truths with harsh words. Sometimes I think so too. You know, the, the other thing I've thought about the, the oath of vengeance is I've looked at it. One of the, the, the things that's talked about even in the Doctrine and Covenants, as well as as one of the central themes within the temple liturgy itself, is, is this idea of having the blood and sins of this generation taken from us, right? And that's, I think, I think yes. And I think that this is one of those ways in which that is done right.

44:35 I think it's a way that we can shake off the blood and sins of, of our generation by turning this back over to the Lord, right? And, and not holding on to it. How likely are you to shed? Innocent blood. If you're constantly yourself thinking, I wish to God, I hope to God that there would be no, no such pain, right? How likely are you to become to allow yourself to get into the mindset of shedding blood yourself if you're supposed to be constantly in the mindset of praying that God will have judgement upon people with that who who do? Such things. Right. You know. And so I do think that that would that would change the way we think about.

45:21 A lot of things. In life and so I think about this on veteran's day because of Armistice Day and they talked about a war to end all wars. And I think to myself, you know, when I pray the oath of vengeance, as I do most of the time, I mean, I know I've covenant to pray and never cease to pray and never cease to return to heaven. But you know, I'm not always saying it out loud or I'm not always even thinking about it. But sometimes I'll, I will remember as I'm praying, I did this morning, for example, and I would pray and say to God, please, please bring your justice. And then I'm hoping that that reminds me to try to be on the right side of God's justice so that his judgement isn't coming on me, which makes me aware of my own sins, my own shortcomings.

46:06 And then I and then I pray that the Lord will forgive me so that I might be worthy to be one of the forgiven right. Instead of one of the people. Who gets the comeuppance right? Absolutely. You know, and, and look, there's something else we talked about kind of the physical realities of, of doing the whole thing of I'm going to go get my pound of flesh, right? I'm going to go get mine. But there is a spiritual toll that gets paid when we're constantly in that mindset, right? Where where I do think that that we, we do kind of maybe even add to the blood of this generation of our generation by holding on to that. And one of the things that I look at with the oath of vengeance is it's kind of liberating, right? As, as I pray for God's justice to be done, I get to just leave that right there at his feet, right? I can just set that there.

47:06 I can back away knowing that God is true to what He says. Right, 'cause let's face it, if you're going to the temple, you probably shouldn't at at any rate have any. Question at that. Point that God is both real and what he says he's going to do. So you've established that fact in your in your discipleship with the Lord. So. If you. Have that in mind and then you pray for his justice, his vengeance to be done. You can leave that right there and then you can take a step back. You can breathe and you don't have to worry about that anymore. You get to unload that, you get to say because then yours and it's not your burden to carry.

47:53 Anymore, but you have to do this right And now you. Get to go. Continue on. You are no longer damned by your own personal quest for vengeance. Now you can. Focus on being a better person. You can focus on being more Christ like. You can make that walk in a deeper way because you are no longer held back by by the, the, the injustice that was done to you. And I think that's a very beautiful thing. I think it ties right in with forgiveness, right? And, and we've, we, we talk about vengeance, especially the oath of vengeance, and I think we failed to make the connection back to forgiveness sometimes. And I think that's a big thing, right, is that that they're that, that we're able to leave that there. And people have kind of a misunderstanding of what forgiveness is, right?

48:48 You know, oftentimes we think of forgiveness as, Hey, we're going to be boys again, right? We're going to slap high fives. We're going to, you know, go hang out together. And certainly when, when you can do that, you totally should. But sometimes for your own health and the health of others, that's not possible. But I still believe forgiveness can be had without, you know, again, slapping the high fives and hanging out together. And I think the Oath of Vengeance is one way that we can can forgive in a way and and just move on. Right. So there's a there was an interesting statement by an early guy about this being, you know, some people will say, I was thinking about it as you were, as you were talking.

49:34 I was thinking about how some people are going to listen to this episode and they're going to say, well, yeah, that's what you guys believe now about the oath of vengeance. But what about back in the old days? I bet those those early pioneers, they were pretty bloodthirsty. And this is especially relevant right now, unfortunately, because there is a new and it was number one for a while on Netflix, a new show called American Prime Evil that starts with the Mountain Meadows Massacre. OK, time out. Time out for just a second. Hold that back. Have you ever noticed we talk right as one of these shows come out? We did this with Under the Banner of Heaven. Somehow we think this all up. Anyway, go ahead, it's all synced up anyway. This this show is out right now. It's very popular.

50:15 And of course, it centers on this mountain, Mountain Meadows Massacre, which was the most bloody part of the conflict of the Utah War by a long shot. It was a terrible incident. It was a battle. And that might have sounded justified, but then after the battle, there was a massacre because they killed their prisoners of war. And that's totally inexcusable, especially since many of these prisoners of war weren't even really combatants. They were, some of them weren't even, I mean, some of them were just children, really. Supposedly they tried not to kill anybody over the age of 8 and under the age of eight because of, again, Mormon ideas about the age of accountability. But there were a bunch of people killed, including small, including small children. And it was this terrible, terrible thing. And so I just don't feel like we can have a talk about the oath of vengeance without addressing that elephant in the room. That's where.

51:04 I was going, yeah, yeah. People blame the Oath of Vengeance is a big part of why that happened. And I do think that there were people who very seriously wanted to see death dealt out at the time, Right. So there it was a problem. This isn't just and the Oath of Vengeance may have played some role in the sense that some of these people who were involved. We're endowed, John. D Lee is the one who got actually got executed for his role in ordering the massacre. And he he complained that it was his understanding that we needed to do vengeance against people and things like that. And so he connected it as well.

51:54 But I found an interesting quote from a guy named David H Cannon. Now, David H Cannon was never a general authority, but he was one of the early Saints from the beginning. He joined the Church in like the 1830s, OK, so a long way back. And he served in the temple presidency when Wilfred Woodruff was the temple president of the Saint George Temple, so very involved in temple things. And then later on he served as the temple president after, I believe it was only after the death of Wilfred Woodruff. And so normally we think of Oliver Woodruff as being president of the church or remember the crime of the 12. But he was also temple president and had David H Cannon as his counselor.

52:38 And then David H Cannon took over that work later on, I want to say in the in the in the teens and 20s. And so this is right when there was a lot of animosity and confusion and upset about, about the oath of vengeance, right? So I think that this I'm, I'm painting this picture because this is a very, very authoritative voice about what they were really thinking at the time, the Mountain Meadows Massacre in southern Utah, about the oath of vengeance and what the temple president was teaching at the time about it. OK. And he says, We pray for the Father to avenge the blood of the prophets and the righteous men whose blood has been shed. And I fear that this oath given to persons who go to the temple only once, is not so strongly impressed upon their minds. He says, but as.

53:31 It is given in the Book of Revelation. We must do this, and in that language we must remember that we importune our Father, that He may. Not that we may. But that he, our Father, will avenge the blood of the martyrs shed for their testimony of Jesus, right? So you know. Even then at the very beginning of this temple stuff, he, you know, here's a guy who worked in the endowment house, who was in Nauvoo. He, he believes that this oath of vengeance wasn't just something that they, that they drummed up in order to avenge Joseph Smith or to justify things like the Mountain Meadows Massacre. Even he said from the beginning that even, you know, basically, therefore, as far back as Nauvoo, this oath was about the Book of Revelation. It was about therefore the blood of Jesus. It was about seeking that God will do his justice, not and that it's for us to pray, not for us to take action in vengeance.

54:32 And, and so I'm, you know, I, I recognize that John Dee Lee made a lot of accusations in his book before he was executed, trying to justify himself saying the oath of the vengeance justified what I did to the, in the Mountain Meadows Massacre, because these people were enemies of the Mormons. They they, they actually the, the party that had done it, the the wagon train that was massacred. Again, it it. It's it's not popular to speak kill of the dead, right? So we don't normally and they and they didn't certainly, certainly did not deserve to have their entire group massacred. That's totally inexcusable. It's inexcusable, but for context, they killed somebody in Fillmore on their way through.

55:20 They got in fights. They were commissioned by the US Army. When Buchanan was talking about invading Utah, he commissioned officers in their party were military officers. OK. And they? Their job was to scout it out and to send letters back and to be part of the invasion during the Utah War. So the Utah War wasn't a bloodless conflict as some historians have tried to make it out, or at least tried to whitewash it. And the end. And the the party that was massacred wasn't entirely innocent random bystanders either. They were combatants.

56:03 But again, that still doesn't excuse the massacre, because the massacre occurred after their surrender, right? You do not get to. Kill the prisoners. That's a massacre. It's a war crime, period, right? So John D Lee deserved what he got, and a bunch of other people didn't get what they deserved. A lot of people, you know, this is something that we learn, again, not that early on in history, but we learn it through things like the the trials at the end of the Nazi regime, right? The Nuremberg trials. The Nuremberg trials. They said, look, if someone gives you an unlawful order, you're not supposed to follow it. And saying I was just following orders is not a defense, right? It's not a defense. And so everybody who participated in the Mountain Meadows Massacre can't just say, but I was following orders, doesn't matter.

56:50 Not a defense, right? War crimes transcend. That you're supposed to say, no, Sir, I will not follow your orders and things like that. But John D Lee was the head of the that division of the military that was engaged in that. And, and yeah, he, he, he tried to justify himself by saying, look, I took an oath of vengeance. And I thought, and I thought these people in as much as they're guilty of the blood of the prophets, the blood of the innocent, and they're coming here to destroy us in our homes. I, I felt justified in shedding their blood. And and yet you still have these statements even from early people and his own generation saying that is absolutely not what that meant and not even by their interpretation, not according to their teachings in the temples at the time, absolutely.

57:37 I'm glad you went there because I, I did want to go there because I felt it was important to to not just straw man this thing, so to speak, right, right. Just make. It look totally we have to steal man in a little bit by looking at the criticism, right? Absolutely. And one of the other things I'll say to this is that religion has been used to do a lot of horrible things, right? You can justify. Yourself doesn't mean you're right. No, no and. It doesn't mean that you're actually walking up to the to the standard that's actually set, right? I think, I think one of the fascinating cases of this, and I know this is up for some debate and speculation, right? But the little bit of research I've done on Islam is, you know, the, the, the concept of jihad, right? So when when jihad is first mentioned in the Quran, if I'm not mistaken, this was more or less a a a war with the with the self right of of it's the righteous. Struggle.

58:41 Not even necessarily war, but struggle right to overcome evil. Absolutely. And then it's twisted, right? And then as we see everywhere, it gets twisted and it gets the, the results of that are disastrous, right. And and here's and here's what I've I've said for a long time on this. Let me, let me. Back up a little bit and I'm going to come full circle. I'm going to connect this, I promise. But, but hear me out. There's. A lot of people who love Andrew Jackson as a president, I do not. I feel like Andrew Jackson was probably one of our worst presidents. And I'm going to risk being stoned now, and I'm going to explain why. Well, I'll.

59:23 I'll give you one reason why as a lawyer drives me crazy is that what's the purpose of a court or even a law or the rule of law at all if you won't follow it? And one of his most famous quote, that's what Andrew Jackson said. The Supreme Court made their decision, Let them enforce it. And it's like, whoa, whoa, whoa, buddy, you're. President of the United States. Your job is to enforce the law, not whatever the heck you please. And the law at the highest judge of the land said you can't do this. And he was like, I'm going to look, I, I, I'm not going to use the executive branch to do the executive functions of government. If they they want to, they, they're going to have to overthrow me. I'm just going to ignore the law. And it's like, oh, bad precedence, buddy, bad precedence.

1:00:04 Yep. Going back to. Our founders there, there was this idea of, of being reliant upon the protection of divine Providence, right? And as you follow this idea out, what you get is you get Washington making statements. You even get our perhaps our most secular founder in Franklin even voicing this a little bit where, where, where he's saying we have to be on God's side right now. When Jackson comes around, Manifest Destiny comes into play right now. I, I, I want to say this, it was kind of always there. But it was like his job was to take over the wilderness.

1:00:46 I mean, like Andrew Jackson wanted to displace the natives and just take over, right? Right, and and I I was going to say I'm not AI don't dismiss divine. I mean manifest destiny out of hand, right. I understand that we did have this land given to us. It was prophesied right to a certain extent, but that didn't give us car Blanc to do horrible crap right And and what you get when you read about how people felt about manifest Destiny is it turns that divine Providence thing of us being on God's side upside down and what it said was God's on our side right.

1:01:28 Well, when you right instead of we. Need to be on God's side. It was God better be on our side because we've right whatever we please. We just want God to back us up or something. Exactly. And. So as you get to that point where where no, no, no, no, God's on our side, you don't. You can do no wrong, right? You can right? You'll just justify. You'll say, well, God wants us to, so we're going to do whatever we want to do. Absolutely. And what does that lead to that leads? Look, I don't care how you feel about the Native Americans. If you can look at the Trail of Tears and feel like that was a good thing, I would force you to go back and reexamine the Book of Mormons. Right. Besides, the fact that not just the suffering of the people on the Trail of Tears is the reason that they were on that Trail of Tears was an unlawful seizure of their private property.

1:02:12 Who wants to live in a country where the government can just seize your all your land and say get off and what was? Joseph Smith's major one of his major gripes about Missouri. The the well that all their land was. Stolen. I mean like their land is the same thing. The Mormon. Trail and the Trail of Tears have a lot in common. They do they. Do and again, it's done right and you can see this in the way that that that the mobs treated the Mormons in Missouri. It was it sounded as you go back and you read the their accounts, their ideas. Well, we're ridden our land of these godless heathens and whatever it takes and we'll do that, right.

1:02:54 And so my point in this is that the same motive, right? It is the same. Motive. It's 100% the same motive, right? And, and in in a very real way, it is contradictory to the to the covenant that we make in the temple with the oath of vengeance, right? The Oath of Vengeance puts you squarely. On God's side. Not God on your side, right? And that pray that God. Will do it what is right right now if God wants to tell you I am now revealing that you need to stand up for your rights raise the title of liberty and stand up for yourself, then that's it's one thing but that's supposed to be only after you prayed for God to do it first and in.

1:03:39 Some. Cases you'll be like the Antony Fairleigh Heights and you will lay down your life and say God, you have to fight my battle for me. I swore I would never shed the blood of the innocent again, and in as much as you've seen to make my sword bright again, that then forgiving me of my sins and giving me that white robe, I would rather be one of the martyrs then shed the shed blood. Well then, then that's what you got to do. You know, it's like sometimes the Lord throws you in the fiery furnace and he saves you. Sometimes you get thrown into the fire like the people were thrown in in the city of Amnaiha and you get burned. But. You're supposed to. Be letting God decide? Yep. And. So that that's what I would say to to anyone who feels justified on this is are you on God's side or are you trying to get God to be on your side?

1:04:26 Because there is a huge difference in that. Yes, there is and. One will. Lead you to peace and prosperity and and maybe even forgiveness and reconciliation. The other is going to lead to bloody, bloody conflict that you will get your hands dirty with. And so when when someone starts talking to me about, well, this is what we need to do and we need to go in there and we need to do XY and Z, I'm like, did God tell you that? Or is that what you want God to tell you? Because those are two very different things, And well, and. That's basically the whole dichotomy between idolatry and worship, right? Yes, that.

1:05:09 We. If we create a God of our own making that, that God's going to do whatever we want, whatever I say, then that's an idol. It's a false God. It's, it's me making God in my own image so that he will be like, you know, I, I do whatever Benjamin wants, you know, and no, no, no, the other way around. I, Benjamin, better learn to do what God wants. Absolutely. Absolutely. And, and again, if, if you go by the actual covenant you make in the temple there, it's designed, I believe, to put you squarely on God's side, not, not, not God on yours. And that's, that's a huge, that's something that we all need to make make darn sure of in everything we do that what we do is according to his will, not our own, right.

1:06:00 And so, you know, if we think about this in terms of temples, what is it that we're doing in the temple? We're learning something about reconciliation with God. And I think that if we take that big picture view and understand that central to that is this oath of vengeance, we can look at this in the terms of the ancient temples, the ancient worship in in the Bible, in all Hebrew worship, animal sacrifices, and even in the New Testament without the shedding of blood. Viewing Christ as our great. High Priest, in other words, like our temple president. These offering. The these temple worship always centers around these offerings to God, right?

1:06:41 The ritual serves as a mean means of atonement or thanks or worship to God. It reconciles us to God. It brings us into God's presence. And that's like the purpose of temple ceremony, bring us into God's presence. And so I think one of the reasons why I'm so sad that the mainstream LDS church abandoned the the oath of vengeance, and they did so way back in the 1920s. And so we're talking pretty far back. Most people who grew up in the mainstream LDS tradition are not going to have ever even heard of this. Which sadly also means that their grandparents or their great grandparents broke their oath because they promised not only that they would pray, but that they would teach their children to pray.

1:07:23 And their children and its children. And to the third and 4th generation, that's what they covenanted, that they would teach their children to pray. And they didn't. Because again, there was all this confusion, all this upset after the Mountain Meadows Massacre. Everyone was so ashamed. If you were in the Cedar City area where it occurred, Enterprise, you know, heroin. Whatever if. You're from any of those areas where people from those communities participated? They didn't talk about it. They didn't talk about anything about it at all. And when John D Lee connected it to the oath of vengeance, saying in his defense, hey, you know, these people were bad guys.

1:08:06 They were our enemies, that we were at war. We were justified. And he tried to justify himself as saying, I took an oath that IA vengeance. And so I think I'm justified in taking some, you know. They didn't pass it on to their. Kids, it did not become a robust tradition in the LDS church. I, for example, was raised LDS and I wasn't taught, oh, don't forget to pray for the blood of the innocent. Don't forget to pray for the martyrs. I wasn't taught that as a kid, I. Should have been because that that. Because there were people alive when I was born in the 1980s, There were people who would have been alive in the 1920s. They should have been very, very old. But you'd think that they'd be getting up and vesting testimony and saying don't forget to pray for the blood of the innocent. Yeah.

1:08:50 You know what I mean? But I'd. I'd never heard that in fast and testimony meeting when I was little, you know. And so I think that that's part of it is that people were ashamed. They were ashamed that this went badly. They were ashamed that we didn't always live up to the ideals. And so they cut it out. But here's the danger when you cut out something, even when it looks like it makes a lot of sense to cut that out right now. Franklin directors also really thought, look, this is a great time to cut the South of vengeance thing because we are hot on the heels of excommunicate members of the CARM of the 12, the solar tribunes breathing down our neck. The Reed Smoot trials just a decade before were a total embarrassment of the church. They were talking about the oath of vengeance in there. You know what?

1:09:34 Let's just let's just chill out. Let's not include this anymore. One of the reasons why that is such a catastrophic mistake is these things aren't something that just was invented recently. They might have thought. They might have thought, oh, our present need is to not look like we're bad Americans. We need to look like we're good Americans and we're not praying for the government to be destroyed or something like that because of the justices that we've been suffering. We need to make sure that we look like good neighbors is one of the ways they put it a good neighbor policy. We need to look like good neighbors. And so let's let's just get rid of this. They're forgetting these covenants existed from the foundation of the world we're taught.

1:10:16 And then you look in the Scriptures and it's like, Oh my gosh, in Genesis, we're talking about the oath of vengeance. In Genesis, we're talking about the oath of vengeance. In Leviticus, we're talking about the oath of vengeance throughout the entire Bible and it and, and what does it end with? It doesn't end with, Oh, by the way, the Old Testament doesn't matter anymore. Forget the oath of vengeance. We literally have chapters on the oath of vengeance in the Book of Revelation, in the last book of the Bible in the New Testament, oath of vengeance, oath of vengeance, oath of vengeance all over the place. It's because in the ancient temple, and that's why I so harkening back to what I've already gotten away from, is think about this in the context of broader temple worship. What? Were the ancient?

1:10:56 Israelites doing what was what were the ancient peoples before Israel doing the ancient patriarchs. They were going to the temple to offer these offerings and one of the offerings, one of the central offerings and one of the most important offerings in the middle, the whole thing is to give up. The sacrifices of that are the sacrifices of the heart, right? And and Jesus explains these things as the broken heart and the contrite spirit. This is the this is the ultimate offering of the temple. And and so. You have things like penalties as well in the temple and covenants and the oath of vengeance. And when you? Take those things out. The modern temple.

1:11:37 No longer resembles the ancient temple. See the ancient temple with these animal sacrifices and all of these steps that you had to take to approach the throne of God. There was a system to. It that we no longer relate to because the Maidenstream LDS temple now no longer does penalties. Well, I understand that Jesus was saying you don't have to actually kill the animal to demonstrate the sacrifice. I want you to be the sacrifice. Instead of us killing the innocent lamb, you put yourself in the place of Adam, yourself in the place of Jesus Christ. You become the sacrifice yourself. Yep.

1:12:21 And. And what would have happened in the ancient temple is, yes, they would have killed the lamb, they would have performed the these ritual penalties, they would have actually performed them in the temple. But then the priests would have told you this is a token of the covenant that is a symbol so that you will understand sin and death and the consequences and redemption and purity that comes because of it. And so blood is the central theme of all the all of the covenants. Blood is the central theme of all of these sacrifices. Blood makes you unclean because blood represents death. But then blood makes you clean, because blood represents life.

1:13:06 Right. And so. By the blood of the lamb, we are cleansed. And so throughout the New Testament, they talk about the blood of the lamb still, they talk about the great high priest, Jesus Christ. Why? Because they're trying to say, they're trying to say to people who are familiar with temple ceremony, they're they're who are from who were familiar with the animal sacrifices. This is what it means. Yep. But now. We're so far divorced from that. We've become a Gentile Church of Gentile people all around the world doing ceremonies that are so disconnected now from that original ritual that we don't even see it. So much so even that in the 1920s, they're like, I guess we don't really have to do this oath of vengeance where it's like, whoa, whoa, whoa. If you understood the ancient temple service, this is a central theme.

1:13:48 And if we don't have something to hearken back to, to look to the ancient temple, to look to the sacrifices, how are we supposed to understand the sacrifice of Jesus Christ? How are we supposed to understand the hard things that in this world there is death and in this world there is sin, and in this world there's murder and and war and suffering? What we've done by. Putting the gloves on instead of taking them off, I guess, or by whitewashing it or something like that. By by making this easier to digest, we've taken the meat of the gospel away. By doing that, we aren't equipped, I think, anymore to face the hard reality of what evil actually is.

1:14:32 So when evil rears its ugly head, we don't go, oh, I know what that is. I pray that God save us from war. We look at war and we go, oh wow, my religion didn't prepare me for this. Maybe God has abandoned us and people don't have Therefore the fortitude to face the fact that religion is not designed just to make us feel good and sit around and hold hands and sing go by. Ah, religion is supposed to fortify US against the true, the true difficulties of this world, so that we can look the devil in the eye like Moses did and say, where is your glory that I should worship you? Right to to face.

1:15:14 Evil in the face and not be overcome by it, because that's what we're supposed to be doing. And and yet we've all become a milquetoast because milquetoast ceremonies no longer make us face hard questions. And if we don't face the hard questions, right, I mean, so and so, you know, I look at, I look at things like. I look at things like. War in the middle. East. Like we've talked about as well. And I think to myself, if only these people really understood. The consequence of. Sin. Yeah. If they only understood. That it is their own life that is sacrificed. The animals only vicarious for you, right? That it is you who.

1:16:02 Must place your own heart on the altar of God's temple. For as we were taught in the New Testament, consider that you are the temple of God, your body. Think of your own body as the temple itself. Therefore, the heart is the altar. Are you willing to place your heart on the altar? Are you willing to be the animal sacrifice is you? Are you willing to, to realize that if you will become innocent through the blood of the Lamb, through the, through Jesus Christ, if you are the innocent 1 you have to also be willing to be like the martyrs in the Book of Revelation that you're you, you are crushed beneath the altar of the temple and your own innocent blood, Christ out from beneath the altar for justice. We all have these losses in our life. So when we pray and we reach out to God and say, God, give me justice, please help me in your, in your own Gethsemane, you have to recognize that what kind of God is going to answer you? Only the kind of God who has the power that is greater than this world, greater than the God of this world, greater than you know, because the devil makes himself the God of this world, right?

1:17:11 Yep. Our true God has to be more powerful than him. Yep. So that no. Matter what. Death is meted out no matter what injustices are done. We can real safely rely and place. Our faith in a. God who can overcome it? Absolutely. And I think that. Without the oath of vengeance, we no longer understand. That God can. Do that for us and that we should put our trust in Him. Yeah. Yeah. There, there were so many. Things that you hit on right there that I, that I want to take a look at, I won't go back to, to the Mountain Meadows Massacre thing, right? Yep.

1:17:54 Because the one thing that that very rarely gets pointed out is John D Lee has kind of a close relationship with Brigham Young. It does. And there's another temple ceremony involved there, too. He was seals him by the Law of adoption, which is a ceremony that was discontinued in the 1921 Ordinance Book at the same time as the Oath of Vengeance was discontinued nonetheless. Brigham says, you know, we're going to let justice take its course here. And my son or not, you did wrong, wrong on this issue. And you have to, you have to pay for this, right?

1:18:35 Yeah. Which is blood. Atonement. So so if. People start getting too excited about Brigham just giving the wink and the nod and being like, you did good, son. I would, I would back that up a little bit. That is not what Brigham was doing at all. The, the, the, the, the next thing I want to say you talked about, you know, because of the removal of the oath of vengeance, we no longer have a complete narrative, right? One of the things that I love about Mormonism is it completes the story. It's like in this life, we are kind of dropped in right in the middle, right? And without these ceremonies, without these knowledge, without this knowledge we're we're, we're kind of like.

1:19:24 Put in a helicopter. Blindfolded, taken out in the middle of somewhere and just dropped off without a map and said now good luck on finding civilization, right? And and so. That narrative, that's apostasy. Yes, exactly. You don't have a map. This the the. Narrative becomes super important, right and I believe God speaks to us through narratives a lot of times, right especially in scripture, right and so by by getting rid of of the oath of vengeance, we have upset the narrative we have we have made what was supposed to be 1 continuous story into. Not even a sequel, right?

1:20:05 It's it's just a different story altogether. It's like a different story and. And this is the danger, right? Is that are we saved by the gospel of Jesus Christ, or do we make another gospel? And if we're making another? Gospel. Then there is no power in it, there's no salvation in it. It has to be God's or it's man's. Right man's false gospel. And so and so, yeah, I think that's exactly, you know, the the danger of making your own thing and modifying history, making your own story up. It might sound comforting. Right. There's a lot of comfort in lies because it makes us very comfortable with wherever we are. Truth, on the other hand, says I'm never going to let you be comfortable until you make yourself conform yourself. Yep to.

1:20:56 To me, lies are. Soft and squishy, they let you be comfortable wherever you are, and the truth instead prods you to to make your life in conformity with it. You know when I and. You know this is one of the reasons. Why it's a big frustrating frustration with the American Pride and evil right now is that it is not good history. It is fiction. It isn't even historical fiction. It's fictionalized history. It's more like the man in the High Tower was that fictionalized history about what we lost in the Second World War. That's basically what American Pride and Evil is, is it's anti Mormon alternate history. And that's why it's so dangerous right now to have these kinds of alternate histories going around because it really encourages the same kind of prejudice again, which is going to do what?

1:21:38 It's going to get a bunch of people to say, Oh yeah, Mormons are bad. Let's do violence to Mormons. And then what are you going to get? You're going to get a bunch of Mormons who are going to say we're justified in fighting back. And, and it leads into that same downward spiral that will make the whole world blind and toothless. We don't it's it's a dangerous. It's a dangerous thing. So, I mean, I do not recommend anybody watch the show. It is nothing but violence. Pornography essentially is what it is. Yeah. I, I I took. That trip myself. Oh, did you grew American Prime? But it's it's it's ugly. It's really very ugly to me, Ben. It was, on some level it was even worse than Under the Banner of Heaven. Oh yeah, definitely. I think it's very much worse under the matter of heaven is supposed to be about a couple of people who justified who use religion to justify their violence, But that doesn't necessarily mean that all religion is violent.

1:22:27 But I think American primeval is basically trying to say everybody in the Wild West was a psychotic murderer, all of them. And you know, and that's really scary. You know, just it's a mockery of our ancestors. I, I don't appreciate it And, but, but even then, if it, if that was the worst of it, I, I could live with it. The reason why I'm frustrated with these types of things is because it's not about the past. It's not about whether or not Brigham Young was a good guy. These types of shows are about whether or not you get to mistreat your Mormon neighbors today. And the encouragement of that kind of violence is why I worry that we're very that a lot of people who make media are very irresponsible or maybe they're being deliberately harmful because a television program, it programs people, that's what they call it, the television program, it programs the way you think it changes your worldview.

1:23:17 And if your worldview of Mormons is American primeval, well, then you're going to start justifying yourself in being very unkind to your Mormon neighbors. And that is not the kind of world that we want. Why do we want to encourage that in the world today? Absolutely, absolutely. So yeah, there's there. There is so much there to look at there. There's one other thing I wanted to look at with the Oath of Vengeance, and this dawned on me actually just this morning, as I was just saying, you know, reading my scriptures, getting my morning prayers in, and that's this. I'm going to ask you a question. Jesus really hung out with people who in his mortal ministry, right? So I'm going to focus.

1:24:03 On the New Testament, he's hanging out with sinners. He's hanging out with really the oppressed class right of, of, of people in, in in the old world. And he's very. Cognizant of their plight, now we can certainly even go back further. We can go back to Isaiah and we can go back to, we can go back to Ezekiel. We can go back to Jeremiah and all three of that, all three. Of those prophets talked a lot about this temple theology, but again in veiled terms Yep, and that's why I believe it's ancient but yes and and one of the. Big things and and especially Jeremiah, right?

1:24:46 Like, I am thankful every day I didn't have to be Jeremiah because that dude was not a happy man, right? Yes, well, he wrote. The Book of Lamentations, right when, when, when your. Book is entitled essentially Sorrow. Yeah. You're not, you're not the life of the party, right. It's. Very sad. But. One of the big critiques that the Lord tells Jeremiah to tell Israel is you've abandoned the widows and the orphans. Right, you've just. Turned your back on them. Now we go forward to Christ's mortal ministry. He's basically telling everybody the same thing, right? Oh, you're a Pharisee.

1:25:28 What does that mean? How you treating these folks? Sadducees, same thing. Rome, what are you doing right? And so in some ways. The Bible itself. Is a book about what we should do to the oppressed class. Right, Right. I'm going to make a connection. Here and you can tell me if I'm off base. We pray in. The oath of vengeance for the blood of the innocent. Right and in. Essence, that's what we're doing it. It may have different verbiage, but it's there and there's various. And, and, but, but yeah, there's a theme there, right? About injustice, Yes. Yes. And so I think in in a way this this is also helping us to be more vigilant for those in that class who have been the oppressed, who have been the damaged. Now the Lord's very careful in that covenant that we take to be like, don't go look for vengeance. So OK, so we're not going to look for vengeance. We're going to pray for that.

1:26:33 God does what the the meeting out of the the just deserves. So what am I going to do? Well, if we're looking for something to do about that, maybe this is a way the Lord is trying to spur us on to be like, go relieve their suffering, go relieve the distressed. Go relieve the distressed. Because now we're, we're, we're, we've kind of had our eyes open to this injustice that has happened, right? Well, in fact, let me let me give. A little bit of context for that in the temple, right? Obedience. We I'm. Going to list some covenants. Here covenants obedience, we covenant sacrifice, we covenant to give up every unholy and emperor practice we receive. We receive in return the oath of vengeance and then we say that we will consecrate.

1:27:23 Well, what is it that? So what is it where? So there's a sacrifice. There's always a give and take in a sacrifice, right? You're giving something up, you give up your animal, you give up your sin, you give up something, and then in return you receive a blessing. Well, what are we doing? First we have to pray. So we're cleansing our inner vessel, and then we cleanse the outer vessel of the world by doing what consecrating all that we possess to for the establishment of Zion, we covenant. So right after we say that we're going to pray for justice on the earth, then we covenant to give up all our earthly goods, all earthly things. For the building. Up of the Kingdom of God on the earth and the establishment of Zion.

1:28:05 That is the next covenant, right? Why is that? Why is that comes right after? I think it comes because, yeah, exactly like you're saying, right? So all these things are interconnected. You can't pray for God to do justice and then do injustice yourself. And you can't pray for God to save the innocent and not feel pity for the innocent and do your best you can for the innocent that are still among you. Yeah. Right. And so. And So what is what is Zion that we're covenanting for is that there shall be no poor among us, no oppressed class, right? We will all be. Made rich in the riches of the blessings of God. Yep. Yep.

1:28:45 And so in in in a very cool way. If we're. Mindful of the covenants we're taking and we follow again, the narrative of the temple, right the the story that it's teaching us. And I want to be careful here to say it's not just a story, right. I believe many of those things took place and so sure and so, but we're dealing. With we're dealing with even things that exist in Israel history, we're dealing with them as allegory, at least, yes. As a lesson. Yep, and. So. And so as as we're looking at this, it opens our eyes to the plight of those who have been oppressed, those who have had injustice done. And now that we've given the vengeance portion to God, well, what's left for us?

1:29:31 What's left for us is to go bind up the wounds of those who have been hurt, bind up the hearts of the broken hearted, to minister to the widows and to the orphans and to all of those those people who have had injustice done to them. And as Mormons, if there's any religious class within the United States that should understand what it feels like to have injustice done should be us. I mean, sure. Well. And Jews, of course. And Jews is a major problem still, right? And so we you. Know and again, right and and we can see that in in, in, in Jewish history, right, their history is one of, of them being oppressed of, of being enslaved or of being under subjugation to another, another ruling power, right.

1:30:29 Well, and this is one of the reasons. Why it's so sad that Temple Judaism was lost in the apostasy as well, Because again, these themes are so intimately connected to the ancient temple service that you know, you're, you're historian types, maybe even textual critics to a certain extent. But these people who try to look back and say what, what? What was this stuff in the ancient times? Hugh Nibbly. Nibbly, of course, is one of our favorites. That's a Mormon who wanted to talk about how the ancient Egyptian mysteries and all these things are vestiges of ancient temple practice. What do you find in those? You find in almost all of those things an oath, some kind of.

1:31:13 Oath. That you will be the defender of the innocent. The Sikhs, for example, the Sikh religion was really only established in the 1600s. But even the Sikhs will talk about how it is their job to defend the innocent. Yeah, right. Because all of these temple practices, whether in Islam or Christianity or, or even the ancient Egyptian mysteries, almost always have this element, this element of the oath of vengeance that your duty is to pray and then to enact in the world justice, to enact in the world something better. And you know, I think This is why, This is why the temple was the center of difficulty in the ancient world.

1:31:59 This is why the Babylonians destroyed the temple. This is why the Selyucids destroyed the temple. The temple is this symbol of freedom. It's a central portion of the faith that becomes a symbol of saying we will do what is right no matter what. Absolutely. When? You do that, you're not you're not so easily subjugated, right. Anybody who's a tyrant who wants to subjugate mankind must fight the temple must change the must do something to alter it so that it cannot inspire those who go to fight against injustice to pray for the end of injustice. If you know otherwise, you're you are setting up your own downfall because these institutions have always existed.

1:32:45 Another one that's worth bringing up but deserves its own deserves its own episode. Is Freemasonry right? Freemasonry of. Course also tries to preserve and talk about ancient mystery schools and things like that. Doesn't always do them in exactly the same form that every archaeologist does or Hugh Nibley does, but it's another one of those. And interestingly enough, in the Scottish Rite, of which I'm a member, there are additional teachings about the Book of Revelation and the book and, and other books of the Bible, right. So Masons look to the Bible generally for their, for their themes. And wouldn't you know it, it comes up again in Freemasonry as well. That's the one of the degrees that I'm in reenacts portions of the of the Book of Revelation and we talk about the martyrs beneath the throne that cry out for vengeance. And, and it was an interesting reminder to me to see this parallel between the the temple and Mormonism and Freemason traditions that look, there it is again. You know, the same themes brought up. That's not to say that it's an.

1:33:58 Exact copy. It's not even remotely a copy. The Mormon temple ceremonies simply there are themes in Commonwealth Masonry, but I I again, it takes, it'll take another episode, but I strongly refute the idea that Mormon temple ceremonies are Masonic RIP offs or something like that. People will make this accusation. It's false. Yeah, but in as much as Mormonism and Masonry and Christianity and Judaism and the Sikhs and tons of other people all come from the similar themes of looking to God for justice, you're going to see a bunch of themes repeated over and over again in all faiths. Right. Absolutely. That's really the. Main thing these parallels are about divine truth that I think you can find in all religions.

1:34:42 Yep, Yep. You know, I'm, I'm going to end with this and I'll turn it over to you to, to, to, to say what you want to say at the end here. Or if we've missed something. You can, you can bring that up there too. But as, as we look at the Oath of vengeance, right, and as as people who, who follow Christ, we, we cringe at the word vengeance sometimes and so, well, a lot. Of times there's this religion of nice, I think, where people are like the only thing Jesus ever said was don't judge. And so don't you dare judge me for my evils or my sins or whatever, because don't judge and ignore the rest of the Bible, yeah. Because the religion of.

1:35:22 Just be extra nice. And Jesus was just a hippie who said be nice and and don't you dare quote anything else. And it's like, I'm sorry, this is way deeper, way more involved in that. But yes, I I think that there's a strong impulse in our world today to make that religion become the centerpieces, not. The only theme. Right you. Know I will I when people start getting because look, I'm a guy who loves unity, but I'm not a guy who believes in unity at all costs, right? That was tried unity through tyranny. No thank you. Unity through conformity. No thank you. That was tried. That was tried with Nimrod, right? And the Lord had to come down, every tyrant ever since. Right, the Lord. Came down and said, look, the people are one and nothing will be withheld from them.

1:36:06 So we got to scatter them and we got to confuse our language, right? In that instance the Lord wasn't real cool with unity and and 'cause they were united. Against God is what it was right and. And and even the Prince of Peace himself, the savior in Matthew 10, I want to say it's 33 through about 38 talks about don't think I'm come for to bring peace. I came to bring a sword, right? I'm going to divide mother and against daughter and father against son, right? It's there, right. And again, back to your point, you know, it's not the cult of nice. It's it's, it's the religion of Jesus. Now I know that vengeance. Sounds spooky and scary, but I think we've done a really good job of one tying this back to the ancients all the way back to to Genesis.

1:36:55 We, you know, and, and we've done a really deep dive on how this is not only beneficial for us as people physically and spiritually, it benefits society. It's a civilizing oath, right? And I think so, yeah. Despite. What It's a. Prayer for peace is what it is. Absolutely. And and if we don't pray for that, what are we left with? Right, Right. And so my hope is, is that through this discussion, people out there who who you know, because let's face it, unless you've been a fundamentalist who's been really well schooled in temple theology and taken those ordinances, which is rare even amongst. Fundamentalists. Unfortunately, it really is. It really is we. Hopefully it's been.

1:37:39 Demystified now, right? It's been right. So if anybody. Came into this episode being like, what's this oath of vengeance thing? I think that's about the mountain mountains massacre. Something terrible. Hopefully they've gotten at least a general picture of kind of right. Right this. Is a good thing. This is there for for quite frankly, the establishment of Zion as well as your personal growth and your personal progression as a disciple of Jesus Christ and, and take it for what it really does and what it really says. Not judging it based off of one word so well, not basing off. Of the lies that have been told about it, like absolutely no, that's. It it's based that. 'D be basically like ignoring the history books and watching American private evil instead. It's you know what I mean?

1:38:24 It's like, right, what is it really versus what is it's the sensationalism of our enemies have turned it into that's just a that's just a caricature that's based on on lies, right? What is it really? What is it really? And well, in fact, that's why it bears repeating again. What is it really? It is that I pray, and I never cease to pray, and I never cease to number 2, and I heaven to avenge the blood of the innocent. That God will avenge. The blood and that God will. Yeah, that I. That I pray that God will avenge them. Why? Because I'm praying for God's justice. I'm praying not just for some temporary peace. I'm praying for God's peace. Yep, absolutely. Ben, as always, dude, that was good stuff.

1:39:05 Anything else you want to add? Well. You know, I think that there's one more thing I would like to add, I think. About. All that is lost and how valuable and important this has been to me. I think I'd like to end this by saying I only know of two, maybe 3 temples in the world where you can still come today and receive the fullness of the covenants and make the all of these covenants according to the same pattern that people have been doing since the time of Adam and Eve. That, that, that certainly the archaeologists and, and the textual critics can say certainly existed in the ancient temples of Solomon and Zurbable and at the time of Jesus and amongst their early Christians, right. If you want to come and you want to take the oath of vengeance, if you're ready to pray for God's peace on the earth, then I would say come to the temple.

1:39:55 And I want that open invitation. Come to the temple. And there's only a few temples in the world where this is still available. But I wanted I want to leave the listeners with the knowledge. There still are temples. There are. Enter. And you can receive the fullness of the Lord's covenants. And I believe the Lord will bless you if you will do so. And so, yeah, and that's my invitation. Come, come and receive the endowment as it was meant to be so that you can see what it means in its full context. It's full glory. Be a temple going person and don't put up with the. With a temple that. Claims that it can save you when it doesn't give you the fullness of the ordinances. These ordinances, these covenants bring blessings of heaven, and without the fullness of those covenants, you cannot receive the endowment, the true endowment which is the gift of God, which you receive in.

1:40:49 Exchange. For these covenants and so find them, there's only maybe three places where I know that that's possible and yeah, probably. Then there's Christchurch, the branch which I invite you to come and learn about. Then there's also the new Temple of Missouri. I understand is is doing the ordinances correct. Yep, we. Are Yep, you know, Ben and there and there may be. Others who've still received it, who are still teaching it. I know. But even amongst Mormon fundamentalists, it is rare for anyone to be able to teach you these things that we've talked about today about the other vengeance, because many of them have lost it themselves. You know Ben, you. And I are, are are are unique in the sense that we have been through the LDS temple at length, right.

1:41:31 You were a temple worker. Yes, that's right I suppose. That's worth reiterating, right? I was a temple worker. I was there to see the changes to the initiatories, as was I. Right. We, we've seen how this is all, all come about, right? And sometimes I take for granted that I've seen both sides of this, so to speak, right? But. So many people have not and they don't even know there's anything else. They'll go into the temple today where all the, all the penalties have been removed, all the covenants have been changed, all of the instruction has been altered, even to the point now where they're like giving explanations that contradict the explanations in the, in the earlier versions. It, it, it's, it's just absolutely a cacophony of chaos now. But they'll go in there and they'll think that's all there ever was.

1:42:16 That's all it ever was. It's always been like this, right? Because they don't know. Yep. Yep, you know, I, I, I couldn't help but think about this the other night. Well, the. Last temple. Session we did. I can't imagine now that I've experienced the endowment in its fullness. Of ever going back. Right. Like right? Because, because it's almost nonsense. I remember, I remember looking at it and going, Oh my goodness. When I was in the Ileus Church and I was a temple worker, some of my biggest questions ended up being about things that I wouldn't have questioned if I'd known the context. But I questioned because I had no idea what they were talking about, right?

1:43:01 Yep. And then I realized. Oh my goodness. No, there is. There is truth to be found just in knowing, having the context or at least being able to talk about. That's another thing too in Christ Church also called the branch right? We when we have temples, we can talk about these things. I know and I'm. Hoping that. Your temple there in Missouri, right? Exactly the same. About it, It's supposed to be a. House of Learning and, and in the LDS church, you kind of get, you know, you feel like cattle. You kind of get, kind of get herded into a room. They do a couple of things and then they tell you never talk about this ever again. Yep. Yep, and if you can't? Talk about it frankly, like we have today. How do you begin to understand?

1:43:46 Because there's got to be. Because there's plenty of people, even in my church that have taken the vengeance who might learn, who might learn several new things by listening to this episode. Right, right. Or or so there's. A lot to learn, yeah. Or even just from a preparation standpoint, right? You just usher people through and without any real preparation and it blows their hair back and they never want to go again, right? And I know that out here in Missouri, that is something that we have really taken steps to make sure that we avoid. You can't talk about this. You should talk about this and struggling with that since.

1:44:29 With the news, Yeah. Prepare people. Yep, Absolutely. Prepare them and then and then let's and if people are prepared. Then they will see the. Yep, and. And look, really, Ben, as far as I can tell, there's only a few things that we shouldn't be talking about outside the temple, about the temple, right? There's there's a plethora of things that we can talk about and we should talk about because if you think and I think. That here's the other thing about secrets. I'm sorry we had we. Had an unstable connection. Sound like this is the and I thought it was my turn. This is the other thing about secrets that I want to point out. Secrets aren't just about not talking about it outside the temple. It's about the fact that if you want to know the mysteries of God, you learn them through the Holy Ghost. And so it's not about so much about the me not being able to talk about things or try to help help you learn, it's that the true learning of the temple will only come to your soul when moved upon by the Holy Spirit.

1:45:26 I can talk about it all day long. We can go into the temple and do the ceremonies all day long and you still will not know the secrets of the temple unless you learn those secrets through the Holy Spirit of God to your soul. There's a, this is called gnosis, knowledge through experience. If you do not gain gnosis of God, the knowledge that comes only through the Holy Ghost, through your own experience, you won't know the secrets anyway, even if you've been to the temple 1000 times. Well, yeah, and. And that's dangerous. And let me explain why you're going to take a covenant that you do not understand, right? It's like signing a contract on a big loan and you don't know the terms.

1:46:10 Right, right. So. Let's learn the terms of salvation. Let's learn what it really means. And the temple is the symbolic way for you to learn to experience that for yourself. Absolutely. Absolutely, Ben, as always, dude, good stuff. We'll have to do one on the, on the on masonry and the and. Yep. And so, yeah. I invite everybody, Everybody please come to the temples and you'll learn something new because and you won't just learn it from me and you won't just learn it from this podcast. You'll only learn it if you learn from the Holy Ghost by doing it, experiencing it and, and in sincerity, offering that sacrifice of a broken heart and a contrite spirit.

1:46:50 Absolutely. Absolutely. Then hang out for just 5 minutes. All right, all right. Bye everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.