Episode #160: Infusing Meaning In Our Worship Meetings
Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.
Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products
I believe that one of the things that we as orthodox Mormons are called to is to preserve truths of the Restoration that have been discarded. Now while that statement on the surface seems pretty straight forward it actually is a little more complex than we might think. In order to fulfill that part of our mission it requires us to look at what we do and then make the determination that what in our practices are Doctrine versus Tradition, then to complicate the subject even more we have to ask the question is this a good tradition or a harmful tradition. Sometimes identifying what is tradition versus doctrine is really manifested in how we conduct our worship meetings. On this episode Justin Francom & Adam Hosey join me for a discussion on this very topic. Through the course of our conversation, we cover the good and bad aspects of tradition and how to tell the differences, what the Lord has to say concerning what must be present in our worship services, differences in Mormonism and other religions and finally what we can do to infuse more meaning into our worship meetings.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:03 I believe that one of the things that we as orthodox Mormons are called to do was to preserve the truth of the restoration. They've been discarded. Now, while that statement on the surface seems pretty straightforward, it's actually a little more complex than we might think. In order to fulfill that part of our mission, it requires us to take a look at what we do and then make the determination that what in our practices are doctrine versus tradition. Then to complicate the subject even more, we have to ask the question, is this a good tradition or a harmful tradition? Sometimes identifying what is tradition versus doctrine is really made manifest in how we conduct our worship meetings. On this episode, Justin Frankham and Adam Posey join me for a discussion on this very topic. Through the course of our conversation, we cover the good and bad aspects of tradition and how to tell the difference, what the Lord has to say concerning what must be present in our worship services, the differences in Mormonism and other religions, and finally, what we can do to infuse more meaning into our worship meetings.
0:57 That and more on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. So a few weeks back, I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running. Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page or click the link in this episode show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups, and water bottles all with the Mormon Renegade. Logo as well as a couple other. Designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU, but you should definitely go check that out.
1:39 Now, this is just the beginning. In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast, so head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode show notes and get yours today.
2:27 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Well, we're going to do the thing again where we get more than one person on. You know, when I first started this, I was really nervous that they wouldn't come through, but they've been some of the better, better episodes I think I've had. But today we're going to talk about something that, that, you know, it, it's kind of funny, both of the gentleman that's here with us, Adam Hosey and Justin Frankham, they, they both talk to me separately at different times about infusing more meaning into our meetings As Mormons and as fundamentalists, we don't necessarily have the blessing of a lot of structure and, and that that's a good thing, but it's also, if it's left unchecked, it becomes a bad thing as well. And so both Adam and and Justin have talked to me, like I said, about being able to infuse more meaning into, into our services as as independent Mormons, because it, it gets tough to do without kind of a bunch of structure, but I believe it can be done.
3:36 We're just going to have to be very deliberate at it. So let's, let's start with you, Adam, What, what was your impetus for this? What brought this to mind for you? So in some way it was like my own ignorance. So I was born and raised a Catholic, right? And so that's still really like, like I got a very Irish family and that's still really important to some of the older members of my family. So my my parents visited. OK, So for anybody that doesn't know, I live down at like the very bottom of Texas. It is a very long flight to get here. You have to connect once or twice, depending on where you're coming from. Traveling here is a big challenge. Well, for the first time, my grandmother, actually, she lives in Indiana.
4:24 She left Indiana and came to to Texas. She'd never been to Texas. She flies all the way down here. She's 85 or 84. I mean, she's getting up there and she's still very sharp, but she's just, you know, like she's reaching the end. And so the opportunity for her to come down here and to visit the family and to see everybody was was awesome. But she had to come over a weekend and she doesn't miss Mass. OK. So she's here. She's visiting. My parents have particularly my mother just kind of has a, a chip on her shoulder about the Catholic Church for reasons we don't necessarily have to get into now. So I, I volunteered to take my grandmother, right. It was, it was a bilingual Mass. She doesn't exactly speak Spanish, but it was the only one we could find that even had any English in it in this area.
5:08 And so I said, that's fine. I'll just, I'll just go with you. And my two older kids said, well, well, you know, we've never seen what Catholics do like to see that too. And so I said, OK, let's all go. So we go to this Mass and I know all the rituals because I grew up that way and I haven't been inside of a Catholic Church in 20 years. But it was like everything just started coming back to me. Like, oh, yeah, we do that. We do that, We do that, We do that. Well, now, now that I've got this very modest religious understanding, right? Like I think I don't even get close to guys like you and Justin or our friends Taylor or Michael or Jeff Wall or just these, these these guys that just know a lot of stuff about doctrine and about the tradition and about the history and spirituality.
5:54 I I'm not there right. I got a little bit, but I have just enough that when I sat through this mass, I could pick out all these little components of meaning that I had never known as a child. And I started paying attention as it was going on and I went whoa. Like, there's a lot here where the, you know, where the they call it the community, but it's the sacrament. It's the bread and wine. Where the bread and wine is, is, is is kept. Where are the priest faces, which prayers you kneel to? The number of times you repeat something like I just started catching all these little things, the design of the church. And I'm thinking, well, wait a minute.
6:35 We as Mormons have this profoundly deep tradition that Hugh Nibbly has proven beyond a doubt goes way far back. How is it that our Sunday services are not filled with a commensurate level of like meaning? Because a lot of times I think the little subtleties of this meaning, although they might be rigidly structured, Orient your soul, your mind, your spirit, just just get you subconsciously oriented to like the atoning sacrifice of Jesus Christ, right? So my, my thought was like, well, wait a minute, we could do better than this, you know, And so then that's when I called you and just started saying, hey, man, here's all these ideas that I have, you know, like what about this thing or what if we did that?
7:24 Or why why don't we do this? And I've actually called quite a few people and had the same discussion. And what I've got is mostly, well, that's not the tradition and, and, and the Bible and the Book of Mormon and the Doctrine Covenants, they lay out some specific details of different components of our meetings. But none of it really adds up to a requirement to say like be ritualistic in the way that the Orthodoxy, the Orthodox people or the Catholic people, etcetera are. And so we don't do those kinds of things, right. It seems almost like like, like structure precludes the presence of the spirit in the minds of a lot of the people I've asked. So that was the thing that got me to think about it. And that is so far where I've gotten to with the conversations that I've had with people who have seemed interested in this. Very cool.
8:11 Justin, what was, what was, what prompted you to have this? Because we've talked about this before now and, and we did do an episode on the Eastern Orthodox Church, but it was from a, a, a place of, you know, we can go back in history and look at splits and, and look at schisms and that sort of thing. But I know that you kind of took a deep dive a little bit on there on, on some of the Eastern Orthodox thing. What What prompted some of that for you? Yeah, so you're right. The main emphasis on that was more of just some interesting patterns and more in the context of, you know, schisms and splits within religious organizations. However, one of my big takeaways from that though, was I I did find the way that they worshipped to be very beautiful.
9:01 And there was there's things of value in the way that they were doing things, in my opinion. I guess for me though, I was thinking more along the lines of how a lot of those similarities and things are more attached to to our Mormon temple worship. However, one of the big takeaways I had from that whole thing was this idea of search franchises, rather than a single monolithic authority micromanaging every aspect of a church's worship, this idea of more of a franchises where different, different churches could meet the needs of their membership in different ways. And I realized when I started going through the scriptures and looking at this, the framework set forth for, for Sundays and, and, you know, going to church and Mormonism is incredibly, incredibly minimalistic, right?
9:58 There's not a whole lot really there. And Doctrine Covenants, it says, you know, do this, do, don't do that. And so well, which church is doing it right? You know, because I mean, in the LDS Church, things are very, very organized and patterned in a certain way. And when I became fundamentalists, started looking at the way the fundamentalists do things are a lot of that was really different. A lot of things are the same, but a lot of things are also really different. And when I went to try to try to figure out, well, which, which one is right? I mean, it's hard to say because this the actual scriptures are pretty ambiguous about a lot of how you do that. And the most definitive things I could find, in my opinion is, is something from Section 59 in Doctrine Covenants where it just basically says and that thou mayest more fully keep thyself unspotted from the world. Thou shalt go to the House of prayer and OfferUp thy sacraments upon my holy day.
10:58 For verily, this is a day pointed unto you to rest from your laborers, and to pay thy devotions under the Most High. Nevertheless thy thou shall be offered up in righteousness and all the days and at all times. But remember that on this the Lord's day, thou shalt offer thine oblations and thy sacraments unto the Most High, confessing thy sins unto thy brethren before the Lord. And on this day thou shalt do no other thing, only let thy food be prepared with singleness of heart, that thy fasting may be perfect, or in other words, that thy joy may be full. Barely. This is fasting in prayer. In other words, rejoicing in prayer. And as much as we do these things with Thanksgiving, with cheerfulness heart, with cheerful hearts and countenances, with not much laughter, for this is sin, but with a glad heart and a cheerful countenance, countenance barely. I say that in as much as you do this, the fullness of the earth is yours.
11:48 And there's more obviously it continues on. But that the main point there though is, you know, there's only a few things in here that are really kind of specific talking about what do you do at church, You know, and it's you're supposed to on the Lord's Day, you're supposed to have sacraments, right? It says that this is a day also for fasting and prayer outside of church. It talks about, you know, confessing. And, you know, I got some different thoughts on that. It's a tightly different topic, but but basically that that's a that's there's not a lot there, right? It's not saying like, you know, you have to have an opening hymn that you have to have assigned speakers or that you're supposed to have the, you know, the person that conduct is supposed to randomly choose people. Or I mean, it's, there's not a whole lot there, in my opinion, in the, in the scriptures defining how this is supposed to be done.
12:45 And what occurred to me is that rather than which way is right, it's more of, well, which way is best because I can see different people having different needs at different times. A lot of the ways, you know, you look at how cultures evolve and develop and you know, there's, I think there's a lot of beauty to different cultures throughout the world. I think that there's, there's beauty and finding, you know, the way different ways that people pray in different ways that people organize socially and, and have holidays. You know, I spend a lot of time in Korea and a lot of their national holidays totally different from American holidays, but they were very beautiful in their own way. And so to me, it was like, I think there's a lot of room here really to, I wouldn't say necessarily innovate, but to apply the principles in different ways.
13:35 And I could see a certain community where something really kind of flexible and, and less organized could be really well. And I can see another community where we're having, you know, more strict and specific ritual even in Sunday could be appropriate as well. So I'm not, it's not so much as that. I I think that this needs to be applied so much as I think that there's more room to improve on these things. So. Hold, hold on one second. I think Justin hits a good point here, which is in, in the conversation we're going to have. I'm not telling anybody, Hey, you need to change up your meetings, right?
14:15 That's not I, I don't think any of us, that's what we're saying. I think what we are saying though, is that there may be some options available to us, right? And fundamentalism is a funny thing, right? Because we're, we're doing our best to hold kind of the old doctrines, right? And, but sometimes it's easy to conflate doctrine and tradition. And I, I think that it's one of those things that, hey, well, this is the way this guy did it and that's the way he did it before him. And when you go back, maybe it's just a matter of, well, that's just kind of how it was done, right? And so again, we're not trying to say anybody has to change anything up. We're just saying that that there could be more flavors to this.
14:59 And all three of us have at least ventured outside the Mormon bubble, right? Adam, correct me if I'm wrong. You lived in Utah for a while, right? No, no, no, no. Missouri, Missouri. Yeah, Arizona and Missouri. No Utah. OK, Justin, I know, I know spent a great deal of time in Utah. I spent a lot of time in southern Idaho, which is northern Utah and Utah itself, right? And so, and you know, I, I was, when I, when I became a Mormon, I was in that bubble, right? And I remember, I, I, when we moved to Maryland, I was shocked, right? In some ways when it came to church because I just, you know, you always hear the line. The church is the same everywhere you go now it that's kind of true, but there are flavors, right? Like I we were, we were out on the Eastern Shore of Maryland and there's a lot of Baptists out there. There was a lot of Pentecostals.
15:53 There was, you know, a fair amount of Catholics, but it it would be nothing to hear, you know, a southern Amen come from the congregation midway through the through you know what whoever was given a talk, right, And that's something as a Mormon, you're just not used to hearing. If you come from Idaho or Utah, right, And you're you just find myself looking back going what what the hell was that? But but there, you know, the the vocabulary was a little different. I remember a woman got up and she in a kind of a southern accent was like, I just got to say, I love my Jesus, right. And I was like, well, I suppose there's nothing doctrinally wrong with that, but it just, it was kind of jarring, right, Because you weren't used to it.
16:36 And then I remember when I became a fundamentalist, you know, on the website, it was like, well, come on over, we're just like the LDS church, we're going to look really similar. And I got over, I'm like, no, you're not, No, you're not. And and that's a good thing, right? And so again, I tell that saying, Hey, we, we're not saying anybody has to do anything different, but more that as Justin pointed out in DNC 59, we're, we're kind of given some leeway with our, with our Sunday meetings here, right? It, it seems to be the big point is keep it holy, have the sacrament and then it kind, then the Lord seems to kind of lead this up to us. So Adam, I, I didn't mean to cut you off there. What were you going to say? No, you pretty much took the words out of my mouth.
17:17 I was just going to say, I mean, yeah, I think I think you hit it right on the head with the idea that different congregations with different people in different places at different times have different needs. And what might work for one group doesn't necessarily work for another one. And the Scripture does not prescribe uniformity in the way that I think that we wind up with it or try to go after it. You know what I mean? Yeah, absolutely. Let's do this. You know, talking about that uniformity, you know, that's exactly right. It doesn't. But it's funny because so one of the interesting things when I was on my mission in South Korea, one of the differences that I noticed over there was they would almost always have a pitcher of water on the sacrament table. And, you know, they'd uncover that and they'd bless the sacrament with that picture there. And they didn't do that in the States. I mean, maybe they do, I don't know. It's been a while since I've been to an all these congregation.
18:13 But typically, I mean, they still had trays and little cups and things like that, but they'd have that set up. And they also would have a pitcher set aside or a tea kettle. And I was a major, I was like, so what's up with this? This is kind of different. And I was told, oh, well, this is in case, you know, we run out that way we don't have to bless anymore. It's still there. And we can, you know, put some more cups in the tray and fill it and pass it around. And I remember the time I thought, oh, OK, that makes a lot of sense. But my companion was like, oh, this is this is this is heresy. This, this is wrong. And, you know, he tried to convince me that that this is a bad thing and that because it's different and it's different for no good reason, it's not a big deal if you need to bless more water and it almost never gets needed anyways.
19:00 And he was saying he was afraid that it would turn into tradition. And honestly, I could kind of understand that perspective as well, though, because, you know, you're at a small little branch in South Korea with 10 people there. They cut a tray with, you know, 15 cups of water and a pitcher. And it's like, well, why are they clearly they're not going to need any more. But it was like, no, you have to do this because it starts becoming tradition. And so I kind of get where where my companion was coming from, but I think that the answer isn't necessarily more conformity, but a release from that belief in the need for conformity.
19:43 Because even there there was that that culture tends to create this, this this kind of standard. And then you have to do it. And then is it symbolic? Maybe maybe the picture represents the body of Christ and these are his parts. Or, you know, you start developing theology around something that was an innovation that was totally. Had completely practical intentions and purposes to then become something else. But then again too, I also wonder, is even that a bad thing to to find greater meaning or connection and in the things that we do. Like when I read a book, I try to understand the author's perspective, but I'm also, I read my own beliefs into what I read.
20:27 And by doing that, I can find a lot of value in reading a, a book that generally, you know, has ideas that I'm completely opposed to, but it can be interesting and I can get something from it by, well, I don't agree with the author's perspective, but man, if I connect with my beliefs on this and my beliefs on that, there's something interesting there after all. And I mean, is that a bad thing? I mean, it's, I don't think it is academically. And so I, I mean, I don't know, it's some interesting questions. Absolutely. What? Let me ask this question to both of you and then I want to move on to what each of your experiences have been as you've kind of ventured out Adam's experience at Mass.
21:07 And then Justin, did you ever make it out to a Eastern Orthodox service? I can't remember if. I haven't had a chance. But you've read a lot. About it, I studied it quite a bit, yeah. Yeah. So I, I would like to get after, after I asked this first question, I want to then go to, OK, what, what would be some things that you guys have noticed in those other faith traditions that you feel like can, can maybe enrich us as Mormons right now? I know a lot of people right now are cringing super hard, but I think it's important that we remember that both Brigham and Joseph had made a statement, something to the effect of all truth belongs to Mormonism, right?
21:49 And certainly in our, in our articles of, of faith that talks about, we look forward to all things being revealed to us, right? So I, I think this is one of the gifts of Mormonism that we got to be careful not to shy away from too quick because we, I do believe we can learn things from other folks, right? And as Mormonism continues to grow, especially fundamentalism, it's going to be hard to create that monolith that the LDS church it has. And to be quite honest with you, I'm not sure that's something we want to do anyways. Create a monolith, right? I think the monolith comes when the savior comes back. And until then, we we've all got to do the best we can.
22:31 So I want to start here by by kind of talking about doctrine versus tradition and what the danger is in conflating a tradition with a doctrine. Whoever wants to jump in first is fine. So one of the, one of the, so I, I feel like coming from completely outside of the LDS world and getting to like having the doors of so many of the fundamentalist people open to me and to my family and people that want to, you know, bring us in and have us for dinner. And, you know, I don't know, sit by the fire and play music and talk to us about this or that thing and, and, and, and, and tell us about their own experiences.
23:15 One of the things that I have come to realize is there is a, there is a long history in this world of doing things because that's how dad did it and that's how grandpa did it. And later people find out, like when they really go to study the scriptures that, oh, wait a minute, that that's something that we do as part of our practice, but it's not actually prescribed anywhere, right? And I think the danger of that which Justin was talking about, what the picture is, that you can imbue some kind of meaning and require some kind of rigidity that actually has nothing to do with your commitment to playing your part in the eternal plan of salvation. So let me give you an example.
24:11 One of the things that I had heard from, I won't name any names or any groups or anything like that. But one of the things that I had heard from a guy who was a part of still is in this world, but was a part of a group that we would all know was that there was a time where when the the guy who presided, right, the one man in their world would, would walk into church and everyone was already there. And if you were sitting, you stood. And if you didn't stand, you were considered to be in bad, no pun intended, standing with the congregation. And I, that's a great example of something that like you could, you could see the value, right? Especially if you read 132 and you go, OK, so one man on earth at a time holds the keys to this priesthood, yadda, yadda, yadda, all that stuff.
24:56 And you and you and you and you believe in that. And then he comes in and in some way to show your respect for the gravity of the work at which he is the head, it would make sense that you, you might stand you, you could see the idea at play there. But the fact that that is in some way tied to your standing, I can't help myself, I laugh when I say that it's tied to your standing in the work. Is the dark part right? Like that is not in the scripture. You know what I mean, that that doesn't exist. So the fact that you don't do that does not actually make you on God's bad side. And so I think that's kind of like the danger of the tradition and the reality of the world that we live in is so much of it is tradition. You know, there's, there's, there's quite a bit in the Scripture, but, but in the example of doctrine in the scripture, but but in the example of like, you know, what do we do on Sundays?
25:54 Most of that is tradition. And and that's not to suggest that it's wrong or right, just that if it came from D and C-section, whatever, and it started with thus sayeth the Lord in my own mind, that carries a lot more gravity than well, grandpa did it and great grandpa did it, etcetera, etcetera. And that's where we can get lost, you know what I mean? Absolutely. Well, let me OK, now I am going to name some names and name the group when I just just right before Thanksgiving, I had, I was on TikTok, you know, 'cause like I can't help but scroll through everything Mormon, right?
26:35 There's times I hate myself for it, but I can't I came across this one TikTok of of this this woman telling her of her experienced young woman that she had just had at a BYU Idaho devotional. And David A Bednar was there, right? And David A Bednar had picked out the hymn, and he had told everybody, I want to sing this with some enthusiasm. So everybody stood up to sing, right? And as they were singing, David A Bednar cuts it off in the first verse and then goes and tells everybody, if I'm not standing, none of you were standing. And if I'm standing, you all stand. And I mean, he was very forceful about it and then even went and played a few games with it where he like would finish talk, but he would just sit at the like at the podium for a few minutes just I guess to test everybody, right. And it's that sort of stuff that I I feel like can be a danger a little bit right.
27:42 Obviously I feel like one man ISM is a bad thing. I think everyone on here knows that by now. And so with with that said, that's where tradition can go off the rails a little bit, right? Where where tradition can be used as kind of social conditioning and and that is, is somewhat disturbing to me. So, so I agree with you totally. Adam, what were you going to say? So this was in the church like in the LDS church. Yes, just recently. Who? I'm sorry, I have no background, who is David Bednar? David A Bednar is, I believe, no, he's not the acting president of the Quorum of the 12 yet, but he's up there, right? He's up. There, he's one of the guys, OK.
28:22 One of the 12. Yep, Yep, he's one of the 12. So, but, but that's one of those things where I can see it being very, you know, really dangerous. I, I think that maybe the bulk of our traditions aren't dangerous, right? I think they're just that traditions. So Justin, do you want to weigh in on this at all? Yeah, sure. Actually I thought of another example here, kind of. This is from Korea again, but it's another way to look at this because it has, it has relevance because even here in fundamentalism, you know, do you break the bread first or do you break the bread after the prayer, right? Different, different ways, 1 cup, multiple cups, how you pass it. You know, there's, there's differences in that. And you know, I'm kind of personally, I don't think those things necessarily matter, but I think there's danger in the assumption that they do.
29:17 And that's, that's really where I think things can become a problem, right? But the point, the point of the meeting, the point of the sacrament especially, you know, is to create an atmosphere of holiness, I believe, right? And so, and this is where things got a little bit interesting, right? So in Korea, when you shake hands with somebody, you bring your other hand to your elbow. When you shake hands as a sign of respect, you're bringing your other arm into it. Not like you really need to hold the other arm up, but it's it's, it shows greater respect. It conveys greater respect in that culture, right? It doesn't here in the US, nobody D be offended if I just shook their hand and didn't bring my other arm up.
29:58 But I got so used to it, you know, I come back and start doing it by habit, sometimes even, right. It's just like, oh, that's how you, that's how you shake hands with somebody when you want to convey respect especially. And because that's a cultural thing, when passing the sacrament, the deacons will bring their left arm to their elbow and pass with their right arm. Like when shaking it, they're shaking the hand. And you know, that's not prescribed, that's not in the scriptures, right? But at the same time, culturally it creates an atmosphere among that culture.
30:39 Right of this is being passed with great respect. Right. And so I don't see anything wrong with doing that because that speaks to that culture and that creates a, a more holy ordinance. But I also don't believe in the rigid enforcement of it. So you, you take that and then try to enforce that in the United States or something like that. It's not you're going to add holiness in the United States where that's not the culture. It's just a suddenly becomes a rule for the sake of being a rule. So yeah, I think there's a fine line right between changing and challenging tradition and also kind of going along with it. And I think ultimately, I think that's one of the points.
31:22 I think that's actually one of the reasons why our meet our Sacrament meeting isn't laid out explicitly in Scripture, because I, I believe that God wants us to figure this out. He wants us to figure out what speaks most to us in our congregations, what conveys these ideas in the most powerful way. And he wants, and God wants us to have that flexibility and freedom to do those things and try and see what works, see what doesn't work, maybe make mistakes even. That's part of growing. Absolutely. Adam, were you about to say something? Yeah, I was just going to say, you know, you, you say a fine line, right? It, it's, it's, it, it, it's, it's, it's the, the, the cliche, the double edged sword, like the fine line is literally the blade. Because on the one hand you're what you just said was that it's it's dangerous to believe that the little minutiae of the ordinance matter much greater than they do. So for example, you know, whether you use a little cup or you use a big cup, but it's also dangerous to believe that they don't because then that opens the gateway to how do we change those?
32:30 So it's like, how do you, I think I think like one of our tasks, right? One of the things that I think the Lord wants us to go figure out is what is, what is the, how do you perform an ordinance in a way that resonates most powerfully with the people I'm performing the ordinance with without undermining the revealed elements of the ordinance, right? So as fundamentalist, we might object to many of the recent changes in the temple ordinances. However, we might not have an opinion about small cup versus big cup when it comes to sacrament, right? So the, the like our eternal challenge from God is how do you walk on the blade, on the edge of the blade, right? Like how do you make sure that you're not abandoning tradition like you just said, while simultaneously not being so rigid as to preclude yourself from connecting the others, that connecting with the others who are participating in these ordinances and in these meetings, etcetera, in a way that you might otherwise be able to if you just had a little flexibility, you know?
33:53 Sure. OK, so, so let let me let me bring this to the real world then in in the real world of Mormonism. And I want to get each of your guys's take on this. OK. Prior to the Spanish flu epidemic that swept all the world, Utah included, they were not spared. Sacrament was done with the communal cup. After the Spanish Flu hit, the First Presidency came out and I believe it was, it was either Joseph F Smith or Hebrew J Grant, I can't remember which one, but one of them when when that hit, they said, OK, we're going to do away with that and we're just going to use the little cups, right, that we see in modern day LDS church, just little disposable plastic cups.
34:42 Is that something that we should look at and say, oh, we lost something there? Or should we look at that and say, Oh no, we're good? I think you lost something if there was meaning associated with the way you were doing it originally. I don't think anything really. I don't think you lost anything if there wasn't, right. So it so like if if the communal cup was symbolic of the way that as it was intended to be symbolic of the way that as a community you partake in the sacrament as a symbol of the blood of Christ and you're doing it together and you're kind of all in this together. And in some ways it even makes it more symbolic if there's Spanish flu going around because you're really all in this together come hell or high water, life or death. But if that's symbolic, then yeah, you did lose something. But if that was just kind of like a matter of convenience, like in the 1830s or whenever that ordinance was first revealed or the 1820s or whatever, I don't know if my timelines, I'm not a historian very well. But then and that was just like, you know, people couldn't afford a whole lot of little cups, then I don't think you lost it. So I mean, I think it kind of, I think part of it matters like, like what's the meaning?
35:52 What's like the intent? What is the symbology? Like what did you do away with when you did it? That isn't just like a matter of logistics, a big cup or small cups. Sure, Justin, you got a thought on that? Yeah. So I guess again, culturally, so in Korea, I'm going back to Korea, but it's just, it's so relevant because it's such a different culture from American culture that it's, it's really easy to, to draw some of these distinctions in a way that matters. So in, in Korean culture, you share plates all the time when you're eating, you know, you'll have side dishes that are always, almost always a shared plate. Everybody's eating out of that same dish. And even a lot of main meals where everybody, you know, there's one big bowl and everybody is everybody's partaking of it.
36:41 And so culturally in Korea, the idea of a shared cup wouldn't really be that big of a deal because the communal style of eating is already relevant in the culture. You know, interestingly enough today though, I could see issues with a shared cup in that for a lot of people that's uncommon and that could be an ick. And I think in sacrament, the last thing you want to do is have the congregation sitting there thinking, no, no, this is awkward, feeling awkward. Instead of focused on, you know, on Christ and the, and the sacrament and the atonement, they're focused on man, that that 2 year old just slobbered all over that thing. And now it's coming to me. And I could see that being a distraction. You know, also though, you know, with small cups, individual cups, you know, maybe that's wasteful. I mean, maybe that's not great for the environment to be manufacturing a whole bunch of 1 use mini cups and something more sustainable would be worth considering and thinking about. It's AI think it's kind of a complicated topic, a complicated subject.
37:39 And again, I think that's why even that it's not directly prescribed. I mean, we obviously see instances and and scripture of an individual cut being used, but I don't, but I don't say it declared anywhere as part of the ordinance. It's not it's not declared as this is how you do that anywhere. And so I think, I think individual communities can tackle that problem in a way that that suits their needs. And there should be an openness. The real, the real solution here is though, is, is recognizing and having an awareness of what part of this ordinance is, is ritualistically prescribed and what things are being done for convenience and having awareness of that. Because, you know, if it doesn't matter, then it kind of doesn't matter, right?
38:28 If I'm at a congregation and they and they bless the bread before breaking it or break the bread before blessing it. And I've got a different idea myself on what I think's better if I'm, you know, if I'm in another congregation, they're doing it differently. I don't think I don't have a problem with that because I know that it's not prescribed. And so I might prefer one or the other personally, but I'm not going to. I don't think that it's invalid being done differently if if a different community has a different reason for doing things differently. But I think it requires and kind of puts the burden on us to have an awareness and to be aware of the intended symbology in the in the, in the ordinance and know the things that are prescribed and understand what things we're doing because it's it's convenient, because it creates a better experience.
39:16 Because I think again, the, the point of all this is so that we have these spiritual experiences. The ordinances are are created to guide us to have these encounters with God, right? And if there's things that are getting in the way of that, then I think it's OK to look for solutions as long as it's not violating the ordinance. Right. Well, let me, let me, I want to push back a little bit on both of you on, on a couple of these things. Adam, when, when you when you were answering the question, you said if you lose symbology right now, my question would be, is that group symbology, you know, is that a symbol to the whole group or is that to 1, you know, a couple people who, who understand the symbology, right?
40:04 We get into kind of some some choppy water there, right? So I, I was kind of thinking about that when you said that symbology only really hits home in something you do if it's kind of out of the ordinary, right? Like there's, there's no real meaning in something you do constantly all the time. And so in, I think some of that depends on to go back to Justin's point. And I feel like I almost sound like a multicultural liberal talking about all these cultures all the time, but it, but it makes sense. So like, if your culture is one in which the shared communal cup is this thing you use all the time at your own dinners, well then maybe it makes sense to have small individual cups because it might represent to you the fact that you individually are renewing your covenants with the Lord, that you made a baptism and not anybody else.
40:59 It's just you, and it's almost like a symbol of your own agency, etcetera. But if you come from a culture that does not share a cup, that it may well be symbolic when you do share one, that you as a group are doing this together, right? Like this is religion is a social activity. And so I don't know man, I guess maybe group symbology, individual symbology, I guess the the symbolism in the ordinance or the tradition that you are performing. This goes back to the concept of church franchises that Justin talked about.
41:41 Because like some of the stuff just isn't going to land in other places, you know what I mean? Like, it it just, I think it just depends on where your church is. And that's probably the problem with the monolithic church. You know, I mean, you said all truth belongs to Mormonism as the quote. And I think that's a really challenging thing for people to get their heads around because I've heard people quote that and what they think it means is that Joseph Smith is born and then he has the vision in the Grove and then he reveals to us the Book of Mormon and the doctrine of covenants, etcetera, etcetera. And he's and he's revealed everything like it's all been defined. So now we're good. And I don't think that that's I've actually heard that interpreted that way. Like basically, if it wasn't said during his lifetime or, you know, by Brigham Young or John Taylor, then it we don't need to worry about it.
42:28 And I think what that really meant is that the tradition of Mormonism is the all-encompassing tradition of the ages restored. And it doesn't mean that all the things that were written down between 1821 and 1844 encompassed all of everything that was ever intended to be practiced, just that this tradition accepts that truth is truth, and meaning oriented to truth is meaning.
43:10 And in so far as other traditions possess truth, it's valid because it's all part of the same thing. It's just been corrupted over time by the offshoots and this and that thing. Does that make sense? Yep, Yep. Justin, one of the things you talked about was was you know what? What lands in one culture might not land in another. And I'm, I'm a firm believer in that. However, shouldn't, shouldn't there be something be said for, well, you know, Joseph Smith was aiming for something a little bit different than just going to church on Sundays, right? He was looking at making cities, communities, that sort of thing. At what point does do we have to look at this or do you think we have to and say, OK, there's got to be kind of a culture associated with, with Zion, right?
43:56 That's what we're all aiming towards. Should that factor into the equation anywhere? Right. Well, see, I don't, I don't really think that it does actually enter. I don't I don't believe there's a one true culture. I don't believe that's how how God created us. I think God finds beauty and and diversity within a certain degree, right? As long as things are in accordance with eternal law, if they express themselves in a manifest multitude of ways, I think that I think there's beauty in that. I think that's, that is almost the definition of beauty to me is, is, is diversity within, within certain bounds and constraints.
44:37 And so I, you know, there is a place for conformity and that has more to do with the theology and, and the things that are basically brought out through ordinances. And I think that's one of the, to me, one of the big ways that see, I think there was a problem, right? And this is one of the beauties of, of the Orthodox Church, probably, probably the Catholic Church too, is, is, you know, you go to their Mass or something like that. This whole thing is this, this liturgy, it's this beautiful pattern that's always the same and it's always the same pretty much, right? It's, it's these aspects in that when you do the same thing again and again and again, it creates an opportunity to really reflect on it and to go deep into what it's conveying. And early Mormonism didn't really have that right. How, however, with the Kirtland Temple, you know, Joseph organizes the school of the prophets and I think that's one of the first places where you really start seeing a little bit more of a of a ritualized practice going on with greetings and becoming a member, you know, these foot washing things. And I think he's building structure in and ultimately with the culmination of of the endowment ordinance, we see a highly structured, very detailed, specific ordinance that's done in a certain way.
46:02 It's and honestly, that's what I find the biggest, the biggest thing to me was I'm looking at at these orthodox masses and things and these meet their meetings. And I'm just astounded how similar they are to the endowment or other temple ordinances. And to me, it looks like that what the the Catholics are doing is basically an equivalent of of Mormon temple worship. And then if you look at like the Protestant style worship where things are more flexible and who know, maybe there's a maybe there's a rock band, who knows, right. Or if people are calling out Amen in the congregation, that freedom is more, I think, I believe what was intended for the, for our, our more regular meetings where you could have that diversity and that expression.
46:48 However, you also have other things like the temple worship where you conform to the ordinance rather than having the meeting conform to maybe a culture. And I think there's, there's wisdom in having both of those things 'cause we all grow in different ways. And there's times in your life where you know, having things the same creates stability and structure. And we all need stability and structure in our life. Having things really open and liberal, though, creates opportunities for, for, for a different type of growth and exploration, for inspiration to strike at just the right moment. And you know, somebody, some, I've had it before all the time where you're sitting in Sacramento, even as a fundamentalist right, where people kind of generally get randomly called right from the congregation to come and say something. And you know, you're thinking, huh, what, what would I want to say if I get called up?
47:38 And I mean, nine times out of 10, even if I don't get called up, somebody gets called up and addresses the same thing I was thinking, which shows that it's allowing the Holy Spirit to be the correlator to, to guide and direct us. And we need experiences with that as well. I think in order to grow as, as children of God, we've got to learn how to follow that inspiration, know how to read it correctly. And to do that, we need a playground where we can do that. And I think that's what our regular meetings kind of can become. But there's also a place for highly specific ritualized actions and behaviors for worship as well to create that stability and, and to create that structure that we need as well. And so I think we kind of to a certain degree have the best of both worlds as Mormons with our Sunday meetings being flexible and then but then having these beautiful highly ritualized practices in the temple.
48:33 See, and I, I, I have, like, I see where you're going with that, but I have, but I have, but I, I don't, I don't think of it as the best of both worlds because a lot of these groups, a lot of these fundamentalist groups don't have a temple, which is a problem. And if you don't have a temple, then all you're getting is the Sunday meeting. And a lot of times in those Sunday meetings, I'm with you 100%. You got to be guided by the spirit and there's value in allowing people to say, give their testimony or to give their thoughts on, you know, some scripture that was really sticking in the craw that week or something important to him. But but a lot of times, and I'm probably just going to make a lot of people salty in our world when I say this, but like a lot of times, those Sundays feel like therapy sessions, man. People get up and they just talk about how they feel. And sometimes it's scriptural and sometimes it's doctrinal. And some of the most inspired things I've heard people say have come in those settings.
49:34 But there are also plenty of Sundays that I can remember where I left church going. Yeah, that was good. But it's different from like when someone really nails it, you know what I'm saying? And I think that that's kind of the beauty of some of this ritual. But it's also see the problem in our world, as far as I can tell, and and I have the least authority to be able to opine in the problems of our world because I've only been here for a couple years. So, you know, like take everything I say with a grain of salt and just disregard me if if you know makes you feel better. But the problem that I see with our world is people are very, they're very, very cautious, like to a fault. And one of the things they are cautious about is this idea of vain and repetitious prayer.
50:19 And they seem to think that like doing something over and over again, even if it's over, you know, weeks or months or whatever. And it's not just like 100 times in six hours is like somehow opening the door to like obligatory ritual and closing the door to being guided by the Spirit. And I don't, I don't agree with that because the endowment is scripted, the temple work is scripted, right? Like there's like there's a script to this stuff. There's a basic outline at the very least, if we're talking about say like the dedication ordinance or something, it's a basic outline. So, so the idea that like repeating something is inherently bad, which I think is kind of like this implicit idea that exists in the minds of many of the people in the fundamentalist world is it's incorrect and it's proven incorrect by the by the temple ordinances.
51:05 But then, OK, so the reason I think that like some of these rituals that say the Catholic Church performs have value is on those days where we had a day as a group where we're like, no one really got up and just nailed it, right? No one got up and said something real profound. We may invite the Spirit to be present and to work on our minds and on our hearts and our souls in a way that we wouldn't if we would do the kinds of things that very subtly and subconsciously Orient us to our place in the plan of salvation or to the atoning sacrifice of Jesus Christ or to the you know, I don't know the different levels of glory or to the on layers of the onion of the meaning of Scripture.
51:52 Like if we could have a Sunday, like a Sunday template where there were things that were intended to be meaningful in the context of our individual cultures and our individual groups or our church franchises, to use your word, I think we'd have a lot If there was then like, you know, those rituals existed. And then we have a space for people to get up and just give their testimony or to speak on something they were guided by the Spirit to speak about or to give a blessing or dedication or whatever. I think we'd have a lot more impact in those moments where someone is just kind of like free form and unscriptedly given the microphone to opine on the thing that matters to them or the thing they were inspired to say at that time.
52:40 If we did the work to like subtly Orient or subconscious to what we're all there to do, right? It's almost like there's this this continuum between the informality of like a regular Sunday meeting and the temple. And it seems to me that there would be benefit in attempting to move us a little closer to the temple ordinance on that continuum in terms of its ritual symbology, but still stay very firmly in the camp of this is Sunday. Does that make sense? Justin, you want you want to respond to that. I I got a few things to start. Go ahead. Yeah, yeah. Let me, let me let me comment on this a little bit.
53:22 Let me get a little salty here to understand. Well, OK, I'm going to go back to that. It is the best of both worlds to have both. First of all, and the real issue with a lot of fundamentalism, not having temples or not practicing temple worship regularly is a problem. That's a problem. I also completely agree with you that sacrament meetings are not always the best when there's a lot of flexibility given. I've seen a lot of that too of, you know, people come and they talk about their feelings. Interestingly, there is some specific instructions given in Scripture, a lot of instructions on, on, on what it on what it is we're supposed to be preaching.
54:06 And, and it's very simply we're supposed to be preaching repentance. And my understanding of that is that basically it's not that it should be fire and brimstone calling people to repentance all the time, but basically, if you're going to speak, you need to be speaking about those things. You're talking about our place in the universe, where we, where, where we are in relation to God and how we can improve that relationship, how we can how we can we come closer to Christ. We've all been presumably at this point, we've all been baptized, we've committed, we believe in Christ and we've committed to this path. So what is the point of only preaching repentance to this generation?
54:47 Well, I, I think it's because we haven't committed to that path. We've got to now follow through and following through is one of the hardest things. And it's something that individually I don't think we can accomplish. I think we actually depend on each other cooperatively for our spiritual growth. And we need people who can, who can lift us up when we're struggling and we need to be able to lift other people up when they're struggling. And, you know, this is a different topic, but it's also maybe a weakness sometimes in our priesthood quorums where we're not really supporting each other as individuals and we're more just kind of dogmatically, you know, pushing these messages forward. And it goes again back to this idea of what I think, you know, confessing is supposed to be and why we're supposed to be confessing on Sundays.
55:34 I don't, I don't think we're supposed to be going into detail about the individual, specific gory details, but I think we should be able to be open and always aware that, hey, you know, we are not, we haven't made it. I'm not at the top of, I'm not at the top of the of Jacob's ladder. And, and I'm meeting with, with, with Elohim and Jehovah, you know, every Sunday night when I pray, I'm not, I'm not there yet, you know, And so repentance matters to me too. And what is repentance? It's the things that matter most to bring us to Christ and bring us to God. And by preaching repentance, we're keeping the focus where it needs to be for those meetings.
56:15 And you know, when we're but when we're talking about, you know, our feelings and stuff like that, like you're saying that's it's a quality issue, right? But I think it comes from maybe a lack of awareness or understanding on how what makes preaching. And I think that doesn't necessarily require strict, you know, more temple style rigid ordinances in a Sacramento meeting. But again, I don't think there's necessarily anything wrong with having those elements either though, but I would be cautious about thinking that they're necessary. They might be necessary in certain congregations, maybe right for a while, especially if they don't have a lot of temple worship.
56:55 That might be a really great idea, right? But as a principal, I think the main thing is, is better focus on how to have quality sacrament meetings, whatever that whatever that might be. So we have less talks or you know, they're not really talks and aren't edifying. And then also to have more temple activity. So, you know, when I was in the LDS church, it's not prescribed like I, when I was in the LDS church, nobody ever told me how often you're supposed to go to the temple, right? They tell you you're supposed to go to church every Sunday, but it's not like they said, hey, this is this is your temple schedule. This is what you need to do to be in good standing. And you know, for me though, it quickly became a weekly ritual as well.
57:43 And it was beautiful that there were temples pretty much anywhere you go open every day of the week. So, you know, depending on the week, there was a way to, to fit that into my schedule. And, and I made a, a, a very deliberate point of doing that. And it was a very beautiful and significant part of my, my own growth, spiritual growth and development. And I think it's a tragedy that it's not a higher priority in a lot of these fundamentalist circles. I think that especially if the attitude is, is that, hey, we've got, we've got even more. Well, then you got, you kind of got to show it, right.
58:23 If we, if we've got more than the LDS Church has, then that should manifest in, in ordinance work and, and the availability of, of doing those, because I do believe it's absolutely crucial, these ritualized ordinances and this and nothing more of the endowment. I guess that's my biggest concern, I guess, with the changes the LDS Church has made to the endowment, because by changing it so much and optimizing it and streamlining it, it's maybe more efficient if the point is numbers, but it's a lot, I think less efficient if the point is you connecting with God in a, in a structured, ritualized manner by optimizing things and, and, and trying to shorten things and make it as efficient as possible.
59:10 Well, that's not the point. The point is maybe it's going to be 4 hours, but that's four hours you're dedicating to the Lord and that's four hours that's feeding your soul. And if we can cut it down to two hours, should we? I think you're losing something by doing that. Absolutely. A couple things I had is it's interesting, we did see where COVID did have an effect on the temple ordinance in the LDS church, right? And if I'm wrong on this, someone please reach out to me and correct it 'cause I, I'll, I'll, I'll correct it on here. But it's my understanding now and, and I'm trying not to, to be gentle here, not to reveal too much, but I think I'm in, in OK here. The tokens used to be passed out to every person that was in the, in, in the endowment session.
1:00:00 So you know that you'd stand up, they would pass out the token. And then you would sit back down when COVID hit, they stopped doing that. And instead they just give it to the witness couple and then show a picture of it, I guess in the video. And again, if I'm wrong on that, someone correct me. But I, it's my understanding now that that's not received by everybody. That's just part of that streamlining effort, right? And so streamlining, I agree with you. When, when I hear that in conjunction with ordinances, I start getting pretty nervous. Now the, the other thing I'll say, and Adam, I'm, I'm going to push back here a little bit. You, you'd said, OK, somebody gets up at church and nails it.
1:00:42 And that, that really constitutes a good meeting. But shouldn't, shouldn't some of that fall back on us as individuals? Like, look, there's been times I've gone to church and I can't remember a thing the speaker had said. But because I had kind of prepared myself beforehand to go into sacrament meeting, that after the ordinance was done, I had a stroke of revelation. Sit in the pews, right? Shouldn't some of that finding meaning fall back on us as individuals rather than say, you know, it's, it's the, the structure's responsibility or the church's responsibility to make sure I get something out of it? Want more from the Mormon Renegade podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the fundamental news program for free.
1:01:36 Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button. And for $5.00 a month, you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes today. Now the, the other thing I'll say, and Adam, I'm, I'm going to push back here a little bit. You, you'd said, OK, somebody gets up at church and nails it. And that that really constitutes a good meeting. But shouldn't, shouldn't some of that fall back on us as individuals? Like, look, there's been times I've gone to church and I can't remember a thing the speaker had said.
1:02:17 But because I had kind of prepared myself beforehand to go into sacrament meeting, that after the ordinance was done, I had a stroke of revelation. Sit in the pews, right? Shouldn't some of that finding meaning fall back on us as individuals rather than say, you know, it's, it's the the structure's responsibility or the church's responsibility to make sure I get something out of it? Yes, but. It's like the one time a week when we actually gather together. So it seems like the very fact of our togetherness should do something more than the remaining however many 100 hours are in the week, right? So, so, so I don't, I don't disagree with you. You know, you got to be in the right mind state to receive the spirit when you're at the whatever meeting on Sunday, sacrament meeting, testimony meeting, I don't know, discussion meeting, priesthood meeting, whatever. But if you're going to meet once or twice a week, say twice a week for priesthood and then and then sacrament, and each one is an hour and a half, that's three hours. I don't know how many hours are actually in a week. Now, this is going to kill me.
1:03:27 I'm just going to do this math real quick. So it would be there's 168 hours in a week. So the remaining 165 hours, I think you should be doing all that you can to do your part to be ready and willing and able to receive revelation through the Spirit that is pertinent to your life, into the life of your family, into the life of the people you know, in sort of your locus of responsibility. But I think without imparting the responsibility for me to experience something onto the other members of the body, I do think that the fact of your togetherness ought to facilitate something different than the remaining 165 hours that you possess in the week. Does that make sense?
1:04:16 It does it does. I just, I never want to AB you know, abdicate my my responsibility for for receiving revelation on to somebody else, right. I, I always go by a general rule of thumb. If, if, if I walk out of sacrament not feeling fulfilled in some way, I got to look first at me and go, OK, what, what where was I at right. And then let me and then and then address that issue before I try to find fault with a leader or something like that who was trying to facilitate that. So let me say this, I don't really think about it so much as finding fault with a leader or with any individual that you know, gives, gives a testimony, gives a talk, something right?
1:05:05 What I think the, the, it's almost like because the whole of the community is greater than the sum of its parts to have a community in which your priesthood meetings or your sacrament meetings or your discussion meetings or whatever consistently like get to this place of really elevated, intense, like revelation, understanding, enlightenment, connection with the spirit, however you want to describe it. There's almost like this this collective.
1:05:46 I, I really hate this right, because agency sort of negates this. So it's this weird conflict, but there's almost like this collective. That's that's what Zion is. It's like this collective responsibility to be prepared in in unison to like do the work and receive the and to be closer to God and to receive revelation, etcetera, in some way where the whole is greater than the sum of its parts. You know, one of the best examples of this is I was at a priesthood meeting and I'm going to name names because I think this is great and I think people deserve credit. So with a, a friend of mine, you guys probably know him higher. I'm sitting and another guy, I forget his name. He was a Foster and he had like long hair and they, they got into this discussion about the, the, the purpose of temple symbology.
1:06:33 And I won't go into any of the details about the points that were made, but but these two guys like disagreed and they disagreed in good spirit, right? It wasn't contentious or anything like that, but it was, it was like this fascinating conversation to listen to because everything that came out of both of these two guys mouths, I was just like, wow, I've never thought about that that way, you know, and it was just like one thing after another after another after another. And maybe I just, I don't know, maybe I'm just not purified or sanctified enough to receive revelation to make me that smart that quickly. But like our presence together and the spirit in that room gave me so much more about that topic than I think I would have ever got on my own in that same window of time.
1:07:21 That like, I guess what I, what I think of is not so much that it's somebody else's responsibility to like get my brain there, but that, but that if we are as a group, sanctified, purified, in tune with the spirit enough, the whole is so much greater than the sum of its parts. And I know everyone that sat in that room that day walked away with something real powerful, you know what I mean? Sure, sure. I, I would say this, that was a priesthood meeting though, right? So you're not going to get the same sort of of interaction in a in like a sacrament meeting, yeah, as you would in a priesthood meeting where you can, where you have a chance to respond, right. Typically we don't see responses coming out of sacrament. And I think that's good, right?
1:08:06 Because quite honestly, in a sacrament meeting like that, you would want things a little more orderly than just having kind of a discussion. I think there could be a time and a place for that as well in a sacrament meeting. But I, I, I do see what you're saying there, though. We are edified by each other, definitely. So I, I yeah, I I see what you're saying there. Justin, I saw you lean in at one point. Did you have something you wanted to respond to there? Yeah, I yeah, I've got some thoughts on this too. You know, and it kind of actually goes back to the, again, the purpose of having these meetings because ultimately, you know, as preset holders, we could, we could just do Sacramento in our own home. And in fact, there's really nothing preventing us from doing that.
1:08:51 The, the purpose and the point, in my opinion, of, of having a congregation meet is so that they can strengthen each other because we all have strengths. We all have weaknesses and point of the gospel is to help us overcome our weaknesses and magnify those strengths and to create an opportunity to do that. I believe that this sort of sandbox is set up. It's a playground. I, I think sacrament meeting is kind of a playground and it's a playground where God wants us to figure out what we're doing. Figure how do you go down the slide? I don't know. You got to figure it out. You know, maybe you can climb up the slide. Maybe that's fun. You know, what are we doing here is we're, we're trying to support each other in, in our growth and our development spiritually.
1:09:36 And so, you know, often if, if I see a sacrament meeting speaker and it's just doesn't land, you know, I think that that's OK because they're probably learning something through that process themselves. And they're they're given an opportunity. And, you know, I've been given a lot of opportunities in my life. And some of those opportunities I didn't take, but I've never had an opportunity that I took, whether I succeeded or failed, that I didn't learn and grow from. And so the very, I mean, because here's the thing, if we want to get more highly optimized, you know, a, a paid ministry would make a lot more sense with a, with a speaker who's who's, who's, this is his job.
1:10:20 So he can basically read scriptures all day and find the most spiritual messages to share. And it's his job to show the spiritual message on Sunday. That would, I think that'd be way more effective. And we probably could have a lot more spiritual sacrament meetings for, for the whole if we were to implement something like that. But I think it would work against the purpose, which is US individuals, whoever we are, whatever our skill set, whatever our comfort level is with things. It's it's a pattern that allows us to grow and develop. It's an opportunity to figure out maybe public speaking. It's not, it's not everybody's thing, right? But it's an opportunity to give that kind of thing a shot and, and deal with your insecurities.
1:11:02 And it's an opportunity to maybe remember that you need to be more prepared, right. I mean, I, I wonder if some of those people who go up and speak about their feelings don't come back down and think, man, that was kind of embarrassing. I wish I had something more spiritual to talk about. And then they're looking back and thinking, oh, maybe, you know, this last week, you know, I haven't really read my scriptures at all. We haven't really been praying very sincerely. And may I need it. I want to turn that around. So I mean, you know, we don't really necessarily know the outcome and the effects of even what appears at its surface to be a sacrament meeting that just doesn't land. We don't know who that's helping and who that's uplifting. And again, as far as personal responsibility goes, I also kind of, I, I get both sides of that.
1:11:49 You know, when I was, when I was converted, fully converted to fundamentalism, it got to the point where I couldn't really bear being in LDS meetings anymore because I'm just biting my tongue the whole time and it never lands and the whole time. And it got kind of wearying almost to a point dealing with that, that contradict these contradictions, right. But on the other hand, there's been also plenty of times where, you know, I've, I've started watching some general conference again here and there, not out, not at with an intention to see what's wrong or what's, what's to find fault and disagreement, but to actually look for the things that are still working and, and see how, you know, the largest body of, of, of restorationists are, are being fed.
1:12:41 And I found, I found, I found the spirit sometimes in those talks and that there was there's value to be had. And I mean, I think if the spirit is with you, even if somebody says something completely false, you're still being fed because the spirit whispers to you that was wrong. Here's how it really is. And you were still taught you, or you're still reminded of, of, of the, of the, of the true principle or, or gospel or doctrine, I guess whatever, whatever you might look at. I mean, even with the, with looking into the Orthodox face, that was one of the things I could find is like, I found it pretty beautiful. And I, I didn't focus on the, the theological differences, though. I was focusing on, on the things that we shared and seeing those things inspired me.
1:13:29 And so, but I think I could probably feel the same if I went to a, you know, a Baptist Church. I might not agree with all their theology being presented, but I thought I could find the spirit present and that I could, you know, get spiritually fed through the experience. Got you, Adam. Justin, I just wanted to tell you, and I mean this in the absolute most enduring way, you need to start your own podcast and call it the Mormon Hippie Man, and everyone's going to listen to it. I'm telling you. Nice, nice. There you go to your next project, Justin. I don't think I want to speak to that right now, but we'll see. You know, it's, and I think that's what this, this conversation is bringing out is that it's a, it's one of those things where it, it's kind again, a razor's edge, right where where you got to skirt that thing.
1:14:25 And Mormonism is unique in the sense that a lot of our most sacred liturgy comes inside the temple, right? Our, our Sunday meetings are open to all, everyone come on in, right? And but the temple is something different. And I do agree with you, Adam, in the sense that there's a desire to infuse more, more of symbology into our, our sacrament meetings. However, sometimes I've wondered if, if, if because I've seen a couple different faith expressions here within fundamentalism and without a temple there, that's where a lot of that starts to happen. And so I've always kind of looked at that pretty interestingly.
1:15:15 And also, excuse me, I've always found that very interesting. And to go along with that, there is some, some early things that were said that, that you know, when, when you're dealing with things that are your Sunday meetings and, and what not, that stuff that's really geared towards the Savior, right? Repentance. And then as you progress towards the temple, that has more to do with the, the, the work of the Father, right? And a, that's where a lot of our ordinances come in at is, you know, 'cause you'll never see an altar in a, in an LDS or a Mormon kind of setting, right?
1:15:55 Why will the altar is reserved for the temple? And that took me forever to wrap my head around. Like I remember talking to, oh, who was it? It was right after I joined the LDS church and I was like, well, been to a couple other churches. Where's the altar right. There was always what was called the altar call coming from a Protestant kind of thing where you go up to the altar and you're kind of saved by the laying on of hands and and that sort of thing as you accept Christ in your life. And I found it odd that it wasn't in, in, in Mormonism. Well, it was it was just in in the temple. And then you go back in time and find out that every family usually had a family altar in their home, but that was something that was reserved for something outside those meetings. And so I guess with the absence of a temple, I could see where someone would want to reach out for that a little bit more and see that more present in a in a Sunday meeting. You were going to say something, Adam. I, well, I was just going to say, you know, that's an interesting idea that we don't have an altar because we kind of do have an altar, even if we don't mean to, we have a table and we do sacrament on it.
1:17:07 And if that does not parallel the purpose and function of an altar, I don't know what would. So in some way we, we do, we just kind of like casualize. Is that a word? I made it in a word. If it's not a word, it's a word. Now we can't. Casualize. We're we're running with it. That's a word, yeah. Yeah, yeah. No, I, I, I get your point. I think you're, you're correct there. It definitely is a type of altar for sure. I guess. I guess it comes down to the type of ordinances being done though, right? I suppose that again, thinking from a largely Mormon mindset, when you think of the altar, you think of the one in the temple, right? And that just comes from the vernacular. You know, you take your, your wife to the temple and you're sealed across the altar and, and that sort of thing. But you make a valid point.
1:18:01 There is a type of altar already in there And, and you know, typically it's just the, the, the emblems of the ordinance that's, that's there for that. And so that's a good example of the symbology. So let me, let me just go ahead and explain this. So in the Catholic Church, there are very much the franchises that Justin described, OK. So for example, the traditional and, and also not just franchises, but there are varying degrees of what is called communion with the Church. So essentially, if a group is in is out of communion or is excommunicated from the body, or more specifically from Rome, then that group is not considered within the church.
1:18:44 But there are varying degrees of this. So there's the Society of Saint Pius, the 10th or something like that, that that does the traditional Latin Mass in a very specific way and very specific churches. And they have these missions that are designed to sort of evangelize the Latin Mass in the Western world or re evangelize the Latin Mass. Because for those who don't know, in 1963 through 5 or something like that, in the mid 1960's, the, the, the Vatican is what calls all the shots. So the Vatican is like the Roman version of Salt Lake City. OK. And so the Vatican one day says we need to convene a council because there's a lot of dissatisfaction among, you know, Catholics globally. And we want to make some changes to the way that we do things. And so very similarly to the way that the LDS Church comes out and says, hey, we're going to change these temple ordinances, the Catholic Church after 1962, it would be like 636465.
1:19:33 I think some Catholic in your audience or former Catholic is probably just going to hate me for this, but somewhere around there changes the Mass and it includes a whole bunch of different changes. But there were groups that said, no, no, no, no, we don't really accept the changes of the Second Vatican Council. They're in like partial communion. And then there are groups that are in full communion, say for example, like the Diocese of Brownsville, TX, where I live, that are authorized to do certain things that the rest of the church doesn't generally do because it's sort of like a franchise, the Bishop of the diocese. Makes those decisions. So for example, there is a traditional Latin Mass here in Brownsville and there's one over in McAllen. And those are, those are administered by the diocese. So there's, there's these Latin Masses that are administered by the, the Society of Saint Paul, the Saint Pius the 10th or whatever it is, I forget the exact name of the, the group.
1:20:18 It's abbreviated SXSSSPX. But then they, they have their own Latin Mass and it's sort of like kind of in the church, but kind of outside the church. And then there's like Church Latin Mass, but there's, there's all these, you know, different ways, slightly different ways of doing basically the same thing, which has been mostly unchanged for like 1500 years or 1400 years or something. And in the Latin Mass, there is a rule that there's this, there's this, this, this box, they call it the Tabernacle. And the Tabernacle is where the Eucharist, which is the bread and the wine and they bless it in advance is stored during the times that Mass is not happening. And that Tabernacle is central in the church. It is central and it is higher than the actual physical heads and bodies of the church body.
1:21:03 And then when mass happens or or I guess inside of the church, the altar is placed front and center to the to the like physical, you know, construction of the building. And that's because like all of Mass is 1 long run up to the Eucharist, the Eucharist, which is communion, which is the sacrament. It's like the culmination. It's like the whole point of the reason you came was it all culminates in this, this it's like a crescendo to the apex, which is the Eucharist. And thus the altar where the, the, where the ordinance occurs and the Tabernacle that houses the the the the Eucharist after having been blessed is front and center in the church. We have our own altar, at least by my argument anyway, because it does contain on it the symbols of the body and the blood of Christ, and it's supposed to represent the atoning sacrifice.
1:22:03 We stick it off in the side of our churches and then we do the ordinance over off on the side and then we administer. You know, we have rules about how we administer with the right hand, for example, and it must be administered by a member of the priesthood, etcetera. OK, well, another, like an example there is like, why would our altar, because we have an altar, whether we like it or not, or we describe it that way, why we have an altar? Why would that not be front and center in the building? It's like the most, it's the reason we're there for sacrament meeting, you know what I mean? And then another thing is in the traditional Latin Mass, the, the priest who performs the blessing. So the, the, the, the, the, the, the blessing and the, and the, and the Eucharistic prayer will be performed with the congregation, including the priest on their knees.
1:22:48 And, and there's, there's a few different things. There's, there's on their knees and they stand and they, they do some different things ritualistically. But generally the prayers are performed on the knees. And the priest is facing east. And the reason he's facing east is 2 reasons. Number one, it is supposed to symbolize like the rising sun, the second coming of Christ. And 2nd, the idea is the tradition holds that, that Christ was crucified facing West. And so we face Christ symbolically in his moment of the atoning sacrifice, which is the purpose for which we are all there in the performance of this ordinance. And because the church and the altar also generally face east, and there's like they have a crucifix that faces W, that means that the body faces E, which means that the priest has his back to the people. Well, the reason he has his back to the people is not because he doesn't care about them, Maurice, you know, sort of holier than thou or something.
1:23:32 But the idea is he's leading them in this ordinance, and they are orienting themselves in physical space in a way that points you to the atoning sacrifice, or as the Catholics would call it, the gift of the crucifixion. And there's so much meaning packed into all those little things. And none of that would be in violation. I mean, maybe I wouldn't, I wouldn't hang a crucifix in our churches. OK, fine. But like the idea of like, you know, the table where the blessing is performed, being in the center and kneeling and facing in the direction that symbolizes the second coming of Christ during the performance of these rituals are little tiny examples of things that why wouldn't we do something like that, right?
1:24:24 Why wouldn't we imbue more meaning rather than last into the things that we do? You get what I'm saying? Like that's kind of like been, that was sort of my reason I called you in the 1st place. As I said, hey man, there's nothing that says we can't do some of this stuff, and it makes perfect sense. Sure. Justin, I saw you leaning in. Is there something you wanted to say and then I won't respond? There sure. I personally, I, I, I don't necessarily disagree with any of that. I don't even think there's necessarily anything wrong with the with the cross. I think it could add more, you know, relevance and spirituality to the ordinance. My only concern would be tradition, that becoming tradition and that becoming an enforced thing. And basically maybe you'd say becoming a Rami emptim and the, you know, as described in the Book of Mormon. Whereas often, often among us mortals, you know, when we take steps to try to become more holy, it also can correspondingly bring a a holier than thou attitude perspective to our to our lives.
1:25:31 So I'd be a little bit concerned about about that. But yeah, you know, and you brought up orders in the Catholic Church, which I was, you know, that's all something that I found. I find very, very interesting these different ideas because, you know, you've got one body, but the idea is, you know, you've got the the hospitalers who are focused on healing people physically. You know, you've got the Carmelites that are taking, you know, certain vows, you know, and not wearing shoes and things to to to bring about God's work or got fulfill, you know, Christ's Commission to them in different ways and to approach their spirituality in in different ways.
1:26:14 And I think that's actually the kind of a a cool thing in in in Catholicism. And I think that again, like, you know, you're talking about a more ritualized after. I don't think there's anything wrong with that at all. And I could even see, you know, a church that does their sacraments in a, in a more ritualized manner like that to bring more emphasis into that ritual. And yeah, I think that's something that maybe people should. There's, there's some ideas there I think are worth considering. Absolutely. I just be cautious that they don't become overly dogmatized tradition, right? And a lot of the benefits from that highly ritualized Mass, you know, and they're, they're Eucharist the, you know, our, compared to our sacrament is I guess is a difference made in the temple or temple worship. And personally, I actually kind of have a feeling that that, you know, the Mass is more of a of a carryover from the old ritualistic temple ordinances that they, that they had the fragments that they were able to piece together and hold onto and they brought it into their, into their weekly meeting. And, you know, there's definitely some, some beauty to that.
1:27:30 It could be very powerful spiritually, but again, it, it also though would take away a certain aspect of the, of the sandboxiness I think of, of our, of our, our Sacramento ordinance. And I think that if you look at the Last Supper itself, this was a, this was a dinner, right? I mean, it was a, a Hebrew holiday, right? And there was a, it was a semi ritualized dinner, but also it was also kind of a dinner. And I the, the feelings I get is that the sacrament isn't intended to be, there's a reason the sacrament isn't an only temple ordinance, I believe. I think it's out of the temple because this is something that's intended to be done potentially even more casually to the point of with your own family in your own home, if you feel the need to, or if you've got friends coming over and they're believers as well. And it's a Wednesday and you're gonna, and you know, and you're gonna watch a game, but you also wanted to talk theology. And hey, you know what, maybe we watch the game and then maybe we do a sacrament and then we'll talk some theology and have a more spiritual meaning.
1:28:35 I think there's if, if it becomes overly ritualized, it might be harder to do it more casually, like in your own home or in, in other types of contexts, I guess. So that would be a, a caveat I'd be slightly concerned with. But I think an opportunity or an experience or at times to do it that way could be really cool. And I think that's a great idea. Adam, let me ask you this question because you were just there. You have a grandmother that's still active in it sounds like in the in the Catholic Church. Does the Catholic Church have what's considered an open Canon? No. OK. So yeah, well, I'll just, I'll say no and then I'll let you ask the follow up because I'm sure there's a follow up.
1:29:19 Coming there is so Mormonism is, is unique and and I think this goes back to the symmetry or the, the, the geometry of or geography, if you will, of certain reasons on why things are laid out. Because I was thinking about that as you were asking the question. Why is the, the, the, the, the stand or, or the, the podium, if you will, front and center there? No other church I can think of within Christianity puts as much weight on personal revelation as or revelation period as Mormonism does. To the extent that we don't say that we have a closed cannon, right?
1:30:06 That that cannon is still open depending upon, you know, meeting certain criteria and whatnot. And so maybe the the answer to that question is, well, the reason the stand is where it is, is because our canon's not closed, right? And we have instances in DNC where the Lord is specific, you know, when when you know someone speaks by the spirit, it's as if it was revelation, right? So maybe it's a different emphasis in that, in that in that camp, I guess, right. Catholicism versus Mormonism, a closed Canon versus an open Canon. This idea of both personal and general revelation still to come forward. Does that make sense?
1:30:53 It does the one thing I would say. So I think that that problem, that is probably part of the reason. But I would also say that when you ask the question, that the question of does your church possess an open cannon probably mean something different to a Catholic than it does to a Mormon. You know, I think as Mormons, at least the Mormons I know, you know, the the way I would describe it is like this. And and the other time I ever came on your podcast, I mentioned this. You know, I think of scripture is kind of like a continuum. There are things that I very, very obviously define as not inspired. You know, I don't know the a Joe Biden speech is not inspired, You know what I mean? But the Book of Mormon is very obviously inspired. It's it's sort of like, you know, there, there are things that I would consider not inspired at all. And there are things that I would consider absolutely, unequivocally inspired.
1:31:49 But then there are things that are kind of in the middle, right? There are, I don't know, like you ever read the book of the law, the Lord by James Strang? Like there's some really good stuff in there. And then there's some really weird stuff about like the coronation of James Strang and that kind of a thing that just get me like, I don't know, man, but there's some good stuff. Or you read the Quran, right? There's stuff in the Quran where I go, hey, man, I get that, that makes sense. And maybe there's like some subject on which I had, you know, sought for light and I couldn't quite find an answer in our scriptures because they just didn't spell it out in the same way. And then and then you find it there. I have no problem with the idea that that's, you know, if, if, if you pray for confirmation and it makes sense and it's consistent with eternal principles and the Lord gives it to you, I see no reason why the things that are contained in there may not also be sort of like augmentative truths to the Canon that we possess.
1:32:36 And I think that what I just said is totally acceptable to most Catholics. Like, maybe the Pope wouldn't admit that, but I think that what I just described is probably something that most Catholics are completely fine with. I don't think anybody would argue that, like, inspiration is found literally only within the Catholic Bible, which, by the way, is different from the King James that has extra books. But I think they would probably say, well, yeah, but like the actual church is not going to recognize new bodies or volumes of official scripture at any point in the future. And that's what they mean by closed Canon. You know, there's there's guys like Aquinas and Augustine and these people that have gone and written these really, you know, important, you know, summa theological and these kinds of things that have really added to the church's understanding of theology.
1:33:25 And the church will get kind of like a wink and a nod to, well, that's not an official doctrine, but it's pretty good. And so it's a closed Canon, but it's not as inflexible as that sounds. Meanwhile, in Mormonism, the basic idea is like, no, really, God will continue to just reveal things to people forever, basically. And at some point, you know, the one mighty and strong or the second, you know, the, the millennial reign or whatever it is, at some point we may get like really important revelation that applies to all the members of Zion. And so it's it's a lot more like overt and open in the Mormon church. But I don't know that your average Catholic really thinks that like the Bible is the only inspired thing that exists. But that lack of official openness would explain why, like rituals are defined and they're not going to change unless the guy is in charge changing.
1:34:28 Whereas in the Mormon church you have a lot more latitude because we expect you to get personal revelation. Gotcha, sorry, I was about to talk and I realized my mic was muted. Still, I I could definitely see that. I, I do think that I'm a guy, I guess and and take it for what it is. I've seen where where, you know, certain innovation has led to apostasy and I'm always a little nervous about that right before we completely reduce something, let's make sure all the unintended consequences have kind of been accounted and accounted for as best as we can. So but but I get what you're saying, right? I was just saying, well, you know, it, it had me thinking, why?
1:35:18 Why is that that, that in in other religious traditions there, you know, the, the, the, the altar is front and center and then the guy talking is off to the side and it seems to be reversed in Mormonism there. Justin, I saw you lean in. What did you have? I mean, not a whole lot, but just thinking about, you know, from my perspective, is Catholic Canon open or closed? I mean, from my perspective, it's open just by the very, you know, in my study in Eastern Orthodox, realizing that this whole stood celibacy thing was, was not originally a thing and it became a thing after the split and the Catholic and why did it become a thing?
1:36:01 Because Catholics had their thinkers that said, Hey, we think that that priests should be celibate. And and it's, they didn't write it in scriptures, right, But they put it in their creeds and things and it basically became candidates. So I mean, I mean, there's definitely whether they recognize it or not. There's definitely innovations agreed to complete. You know, they have a book that happened just to just to just to give you like some real concrete, I mean, interrupt you, I'm sorry. But they have a book called the Catechism of the Catholic Church. And it's like the Doctrine and Covenants for Catholics. And it's all the things that all the councils, the Council of Trent and Nicaea and the Vatican City in Vatican 2 and all these things have agreed on. They put it in the Catechism of the Catholic Church. And that's the rules of official Church doctrine. Right.
1:36:48 And I understand the theology around that is that in these these councils were appointed by God and so therefore these people in these councils are appointed by God to get these answers. And so even though it's not written as Revelation, the underlying implication is that that's it was God's intended pattern to be able to answer these types of. Questions. Well, there's even a doctrine that supports that. So there's a doctrine in the Catholic Church called papal infallibility, which is the basic idea that when the Pope issues an official, I don't want to say an official declaration because that might just piss off some fundamentalists, you know, the official declaration. But but when the Pope issues an official declaration, not one or two, but at this point I'm like official declaration 500, when when the Pope issues an official declaration regarding spiritual matters, he does so only under the inspiration of the Lord, and thus he is infallible in that regard. Now that doesn't mean that the Pope is infallible in things he says, but the basic idea is that when he is inspired to issue a formal opinion and in addition to the catechism to call a council, etcetera on spiritual matters, he is doing so at the hand of the Lord.
1:38:11 Well, OK, for the sake of argument, let's say that's true, right? I don't believe that, but let's say it's true. Well, that means he's getting revelation. You know what I mean? Like that's, that's literally what that means. There is no other way to interpret that. So I agree with you. They they may not refer to it as an open cannon, but it is, it has to be, because otherwise you wouldn't have the doctrine of papal infallibility, because all these matters would already have been settled. No, I can, I can see that. I, I, I guess I look at that and I think that's what makes Joseph Smith so unique though, right, Is because it's not merely, hey, we're going to form a council on whatever comes out of this council is obviously going to be gospel, right? If we look at the Doctrine and Covenants, I can't think of another book of Scripture, to be honest with you, where you hear the Lord specifically talking that directly, right? Barely, barely.
1:39:08 Thus saith the Lord. I mean, there is no doubt who's talking to you in that moment. And so I would say that even though they in in that instance where you can say, yeah, well, they get together and obviously whatever comes out of that is the will of the Lord. It's a little in my mind and I don't mean to piss off any Catholics or whatever. There's a difference between, hey, we got together, we prayed a lot about it and this, you know, we think this is a good idea versus verily, verily, thus saith the Lord. I mean, look, let's let's get real specific here, right, John, or excuse me, Wilford Woodruff was very careful that, or maybe he wasn't very careful. However, it was that was not a thus saith the Lord revelation official declaration number one, right. It doesn't read like that.
1:40:01 It doesn't have that same feel to it that the rest of the Doctrine and Covenants has. And so in in some ways I see. Those that council thing there being that, that the Catholics use those official councils as kind of a surrogate for that, but you don't get the same punch that you get in say, the Doctrine and Covenants or something like that. So Justin, anything you want to add to that? I just, I just, yeah, I guess. I wonder though. So going back to the main topic here, there's a couple, I, I guess I have a couple observations.
1:40:43 One of them is that the LDS Church in their meeting seems to do a, a very good job at, at teaching the teaching and preaching the, the important, the basics. I mean, I think they do a very good job at fulfilling that the command about preaching nothing but repentance in a way, because they focus on, on a lot of the, the, the basic principles that apply to us always. And it's always valuable to be reminded because these things are foundational to our, our beliefs and also our lives and fundamentalism. I believe the focus is more on meat rather than milk.
1:41:24 Maybe you could say, and I think that there's a place for meat, but the, but the milk's got to be there. It's got to be there. So like I, so just in regards to the, this idea of, of revelation, right, man, sometimes I feel like people feel like they've got to, if they get called up to speak, then they've got to like introduce some new revelation or something, right? They've got to share something that's never been shared before. That's going to be completely innovative. And, and I think that is a completely wrong approach. I think that like, well, OK, here's an example. On my mission, often we'd have testimony meetings even among the missionaries, right? And we would just do nothing but just share our, our own testimonies and the context of the things that we've been doing and the things that have happened. And they were some of the most powerful spiritual, you know, meetings that I had on my mission compared to sacrament meeting, compared to even like a mission conference and things like that.
1:42:26 I haven't really seen a whole lot of like testimony meetings among fundamentalists where people just get together and we're going to go around the circle and just share our testimonies and, and, and feel that. And, you know, that's kind of a shame. And there's also, like I said, I think I feel like there's an expectation that if you're, if you, if you're called up to speak, that you've got to have something completely brand new and innovative. And I think it's fine if, if there's something there, I don't think there's anything wrong with sharing it. But but then when that's the expectation, it creates a certain kind of pressure, I think as well. And that leads to maybe sometimes talks kind of going off the rails, whether it's because out of fear of not having something like that and and then devolving into talking about feelings or, or a feeling that, Hey, you've got to do that.
1:43:15 And, and some weird ideas start coming out, some weird doctrines start coming out. And, you know, I think it's important to know that it's, it's the primary and totally fine to, to get called up on sacrament. Just say, Hey, I want to share some scriptures about, about faith and how you gain faith. And here's some scriptures on it that are really beautiful. And these apply to me. And you know, here's, here's my testimony of, of how I attain my, you know, testimony of, of Christ as my Savior and, and just leave it at that. It doesn't have to, you don't have to reinvent the revelation. You can just you can innovate on the wheel. You know, has it occurred to either one of you that they just gave us the worst name?
1:44:01 Like the LDS church is the ones that's really focused on the fundamentals. We try to be the MJ, you know what I mean? Like. No, that's, that's absolutely 100% true. Yeah. No, we, we did, you know, I, I do. I think Justin brings up another good point though, right? Which is teaching the doctrine, right. That's a, that is such a, a tricky thing to do, right? Because you have the scriptures, right? We'd all not have a problem calling that the doctrine, right? Certainly we can look at Joseph and Brigham and John Taylor and and go, that's the doctrine. And then maybe it's touched on by others throughout Mormon history.
1:44:51 Certainly guys like Musser, I think you could probably lump in there as well. But in teaching the doctrine and, and let me let me ask you, I, I want to throw this one first at Justin, then at then at you Adam. How do you make sure that when you're in that position of just teaching the doctrine, that it's the doctrine and maybe not the doctrine as you understand it, right? Where's the litmus test there? Because so often I think we can allow our own biases to creep in there. Right. Well, I think it's inevitable that our own biases are going to creep in there again.
1:45:34 I think that's part of the sandbox nature of, of the whole experience, the, and the, the opportunity to learn and grow. However, I think it's important to and, and this is, again, this is something I saw a lot and, and when I was, you know, in the LDS church and I don't see as often and fundamentalism is, is scriptures being shared in, in the things that you're talking about to, to provide a, the baseline standard. And I mean, I, I can't, I mean, when I was in the LDS church, I don't think I ever saw a talk on Sunday where it wasn't. I mean, I guess maybe things started changing. Maybe you're sharing a, a enzyme article for conference, quoting that instead. But, but typically, you know, outside of that, it's mostly, you know, you see a lot of emphasis and focus on scriptures.
1:46:22 And let's start with the scripture. I'm going to read the scripture of the congregation to establish the baseline. And then maybe you innovate on it and you go off on a weird place, but at least you share that that baseline truth and the people listening can have the spirit and they can understand it that way or choose not to understand it that way. But it, it to me that shows a certain amount of responsibility, right? Because I think, I think when you're, especially in church, you, if you hold the priesthood, especially you're, you're essentially speaking in the name of God. And that shouldn't be a light thing. And so how do you, how do you navigate that?
1:47:05 I think with a lot of time and experience, you can get these great, great orders like we saw in the early days and the restoration and, and you know, a few here and there nowadays in fundamentalism and in Mormonism. But you get there through experience, right? And you get that experience, I think by starting with taking, saying, OK, this is the big responsibility. I don't want to spread, I don't want to preach lies. And so therefore I'm going to lean heavily on the scriptures. And there's nothing wrong with that as a, as a way of, of speaking and, and preaching in in to the congregation at church to say, Hey, I'm what do I know about repentance? Maybe I don't know a whole lot about it. Maybe I don't have any great ideas on it. So I'll just share some scriptures that paint the picture and I'll just help connect the dots and put them in this order and talk about frankly, even even just sharing the context, right.
1:47:58 One of the easiest, simplest ways to give, in my opinion, of giving a powerful talk is to share a scripture, but explain the context first and go into the details about the story around how this first came out. What was going on in the society and the culture in the world at that time. What was the person preaching? What was he up against? What was he facing? What was his life story that brought him here to give this, you know, to give this message. And I think when you do that, it's it's, it's really easy to have a very powerful spiritual message that's going to feed the congregation very well wherever you're at.
1:48:40 And even if somebody's. I'm. I'm way beyond needing to talk about baptism. It doesn't matter though, because it's still founded on these foundational truths and it's still inspiring the same spirits going to testify of the truth of what you're Speaking of. So to long answer short, I think a heck of a lot more scriptures in our talks, using that as the foundation of our, of the things that we speak about. And I guess again, that can be tricky if you're called up on the spot and you know, you haven't opened your scriptures in, in the last few weeks and that that can be a bit of a problem, right, which shows the need to be prepared. And, but I think that's also how you improve that is, is the emphasis and focus on preparing for, for our worship meetings.
1:49:27 And that's something that was something that I imagined is also in the Catholic Church, but I saw in the Orthodox Church the this is around preparation for for your Sunday meeting. We're taking are taken very, very seriously. The prayers you say beforehand, the diet. There's a there's a, you know, these certain days you eat this or you don't eat that. And all of these things are culminating throughout the week in preparation and focus on when you go, when you, when you go to, with the congregation to worship together to make sure you're prepared and, and in a spiritual place. The wrote, even the wrote prayer books, which I, again, I, I also, I, I talked about those, I believe where, you know, there's these wrote prayer books.
1:50:08 And I think there's something kind of beautiful to some of those prayers. And if you got a really beautiful prayer, I don't think there's anything wrong with repeating it and really digging deep into it again, because how often do we pray and we're not even paying attention to what we're saying or the person praying. But when you do the same prayer again and again, it's creates an opportunity to, to get in that place of feeling that prayer and, and really experiencing it. So anyway, yeah, that's what my thoughts on. Adam, you got any thoughts on that? I mean, Justin hit it on the head like I'm not very smart. And so I only ever say things like this is true if it's in the scriptures. Otherwise I say, well, this is what I think, but I'm very careful to not be like, let me tell you a statement of fact when I know that, like that ain't a statement of fact, bro.
1:50:58 Absolutely. I, you know, I'm a fan of ritual. I really am, right? I think that's why I, I gravitate towards the temple so much. I think there's not just beauty and ritual, but it's a very solid way that you can make connections with deity. That said, there is like official ritual and then there might be ritual that you adopt in your own home or in your own family, right? That I think can also be beautiful, right? I remember I went into to one person's home and everyone just prayed sitting down on the couch.
1:51:41 Nothing wrong with that. That's what you do. Went to another person's home and everyone got on their knees together. Doubt for me was even more beautiful. That's what I've tried to instill in my own family. And so sometimes I think we look at the rituals that are held within church or the temple as as the only ones, right? I do believe in, in a ritualistic preparation, right? We, we certainly have scriptural foundation for that, right? If we look at what the priest had to do before he entered the temple, there was there, there was some stuff he had to do. And I think likewise, we need to get to a point to where, you know, maybe we're asking ourselves, you know, because it's easy.
1:52:27 Let's face it, I think we've all been there, right? You just go to church because that's what you do. And I think that's even good, right? Because sometimes that's that's part of that whole faking it till you make it thing, right? This is just what we do and we go through the motions. But at some point, you got to go deeper than that. You're better not going. Right, exactly. And so I, I do think that there's value in that in that too. But if we're trying to have that relationship with deity that I think quite frankly is promised through Mormonism, right, we've got to, we've got to dig a little bit deeper and, and there takes some preparation for that. You can't just just do what you do and expect to get there. I think there's got to be a lot of work put into that kind of preparation.
1:53:18 And, and I see nothing wrong with with making it, you know, kind of a personal ritual to get prepared to go to the temple or preparing to take the sacrament and have a spiritual encounter there. But it's one of those things that that I feel like we as, as Mormons, definitely need to take a more active role in and, and preparing ourselves for that or else we will be found wanting something that that we're not getting. So all right, fellas, we've been at this for just about two hours now. Adam, what, what do you want to say in conclusion? Or is there anything else you want to go over?
1:54:02 I, I want to say that if there's anything that I am any value that I bring to the Mormon world, it's, it's probably not all that much. But one thing is that I come from a generally non religious background. Like I have this Catholic stuff in my head, but I was born and raised in that and I left when I was 15 and for 20 years I had nothing to do with it. And so I spent more time as a totally non religious, non believer than I ever did as a Catholic and certainly as an understanding Catholic. And I would say that there are things that we do as fundamentalist that we could do a much better job of.
1:54:49 And one of those things is resistance to change because it is not prescribed in the scriptures. Like to me, the scriptures give us a baseline. There's nowhere in the scriptures that says this is all you can do. I certainly think it's blasphemy and sacrilegious to take away things that are in the scriptures or to deny things that are in the scriptures, or to take away revealed ordinances from the body of work that we are here to do. But adding something to it that doesn't border on idolatry, that doesn't border on blasphemy, that doesn't border on any of the other things that we should very obviously avoid as dedicated and devout Mormons, adding something to it, I cannot possibly see a way in which our Heavenly Father would object to us going for more and not less, doing a better job and not a worse job.
1:55:54 And we can we see this in our daily lives. Imagine that you call a guy to do some cabinets at your house and you say, yeah, here's the quality and grade and style of the cabinets that I want. And then you find out that out of the goodness of his heart, he just did a better job. You know, maybe he added a some kind of detail of refinement or some kind of finish that you didn't pay for. But you're going to go, Nah, sweet. You're not going to be like, these are too damn nice, man, You suck. You know, like, it's not how that works. And I think that as fundamentalist, we could do a much better job of acknowledging that the scriptures gave us the baseline.
1:56:36 We can add more to it and we can imbue it, our rituals and our meetings, etcetera, with more meaning and with more value and Orient ourselves more specifically and intentionally towards the Father and towards the atoning sacrifice of Christ and towards the plan of salvation. And there's nothing wrong with that. That's what I would say. OK, so I I want to make sure I understand correctly here your in in your thought. You you think, hey, we can get more revelation on this. When you say we you don't mean we you mean him, right? Him capital H God revealing more to us and we can strive for more as long as it doesn't compromise what's already been revealed is that a fair assessment is a. Much more succinct way of putting that, yes. OK, perfect.
1:57:27 Justin, what? What do you want to say in conclusion here? Or bring up something else we didn't cover? Yeah, I'd say I'd build on that and say, you know what, even if sometimes, even if we don't have direct revelation for some of these things, even I'd I'd even make it a little even more flexible and say there's there's room for for exploration and a trying things and seeing how they work. And because I think, like I said, I think we're supposed to learn God doesn't want us to just obey in everything. He wants us to figure stuff out for ourselves in certain ways. But building off of what Adams said, I agree, I think we could probably do, we can all do a lot better. But specifically to me, I think that that the solution to that better specifically is found and we need to be we need to be doing a lot more temple work.
1:58:15 We need to spend a lot more time in the temple doing ordinances there. That is one of the places where by failing there, there's ramifications and other aspects of our worship and in our services. And then the other one is in our services, getting back to the basics, getting back to preaching the mouth of the gospel and rejoicing in that and loving that and enjoying that. And so, you know, again, scriptures, testimony, things like that, things that that are anybody, that things that are accessible to everybody that can bring a spirit and give people an opportunity to, to be a teacher and to share their testimony and to uplift others. And that's, that's what it's, that's what the that's what the meetings are supposed to be about. It's not about trying to trying to, you know, innovate and be the, you know, I've got a brand new revelation. I'm going to wow everybody with how great I am. It's we're all struggling with different things at different times in our lives.
1:59:17 And it's good to be reminded even of the simple things. It's really good to be reminded often and frequently. And so I agree, I think we can do better. And I think that that better is going to be found in the temple. And, and I think some more milk, you know, can't all, you know, it's all meat. You know, it can get a little indigestion. So instead of trying to inside, instead of trying to, to make everything meet all the time, there's great opportunities for that here and there. And I like, you know, like in a priested meeting and having a discussion with people with different ideas, that's a great opportunity for the for the meet. But the milk we all need, we all need milk all the time as well.
1:59:59 We don't evolve past that. We're not better than that as fundamentalists, we're that we don't need that. At the very least our children need that, right? And so. I think we can do a lot better job of inviting the Spirit into our meetings through having regular accessible temple worship and and bringing back the milk and focusing on testimonies and scriptures. Absolutely, absolutely. And and look, in my estimation, fundamentalism is only going to continue to grow, right. Based on the emails, I see everything else. And I think we do have to be open that, you know what, not all meetings are going to look similar. And that's OK, right? That's a good thing.
2:00:39 And and I am also a believer in what Washington said about, you know, kind of meeting on the beat battlefield of ideas. There's going to be things that you're going to encounter that you're like, you know what, that's just a little too far for me. And that's OK, right? Because chances are you'll gravitate towards somewhere else that does kind of meet those needs. But that doesn't mean that there's not beauty or truth there to be found. And I think we do need to be open that as fundamentalism does continue to grow, we need to be open to what other people have to bring to the table on this. Look, Zion, as far as I can tell, it's a big, big tent. And Brigham and Joseph were both clear.
2:01:22 There's going to be a lot of people in Zion that you're going to be surprised to see there, right? Even people of different religions. And we have to be willing to to get along with those folks and, and to not just get along with them, but incorporate what it is they do right, And then be willing also to share with them what what we think we do right. There's no reason we can't do that, I think. And and I think it will, will just make all parties involved so much better. So, all right, gentlemen, thank you so much for jumping on. Love both of you guys to death. I really do. It was a good conversation and thanks for being bold enough to talk about it. Right.
2:02:05 And I I just want to re emphasize again, this isn't a criticism level that anybody if what you're doing is working for you, fantastic. Just, you know, keep your eyes out. There could be more beauty and more truth to be found to be gathered into your circle. So, all right, gentlemen, I appreciate it. Thank you Sir, it's been fun and I wouldn't say that I'm bold enough to say any of this stuff. I'm probably just dumb enough to say it, that's all. Dude, that's what this podcast is about. Is a guy dumb enough to talk about really uncomfortable things from time to time. So here we are. Here we are. So awesome. All right, gentlemen, have a good night. Thanks you too.
2:03:16 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox