Episode #159: The Great Omission Part 2 W/Taylor Smith
Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.
Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products
This week on the podcast Taylor Smith and I finish our conversation about the book The Great Omission which was wrote by a sectarian Christian advocating for plural marriage and boy do we cover a lot of ground in our conversation. We talk about how and why monogamy became the norm in Christianity, Plural Marriage in early Protestantism, Population Collapse and the role it played in the Ukrainian/Russian war and it becoming a problem here in the West, the definition of Patriarchy and what it really is, The omission of Plural Marriage in the King James Bible, the implications for living Plural Marriage today.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:07 This week on the podcast, Taylor Smith and I finish our conversation about the book The Great Omission, which was written by a sectarian Christian advocating for plural marriage. And boy oh boy, do we cover a lot of ground in our conversation. We talk about how and why monogamy became the norm in Christianity, plural marriage and early Protestantism, population collapse and the role it played in the Ukrainian Russian war and it becoming a problem here in the West, The definition of patriarchy and what it really is, the omission of plural marriage in the King James Version of the Bible, the implications for living plural marriage today, and much, much more. Stick around for a fascinating conversation on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. So a few weeks back I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running.
0:54 Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page or click the link in this episode show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups, and water bottles all with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU, but you should definitely go check that out. Now this is just the beginning. In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast. So head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode show notes and get yours today. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. We're back, dude.
2:19 Yeah, been a while not. Really. Yeah. Yeah, Not really, but yeah, no, Too long. Too long, Yeah. So where'd we where'd we leave off last time? Do you remember? Yeah, so we've been discussing the Great Omission by Clyde Pilkington and it's basically a non Mormon's biblical defense for polygamy. And and he uses kind of rational arguments and just talking about the New Testament and how basically the translational decisions that were made, I believe intentionally kind of obfuscate the, you know, cloud the proper understanding and interpretation of a lot of these things. So next, I think we're going to talk about the just moving along into chapter 6, the religious systems destruction of the biblical family. We kind of we kind of foreshadowed a little bit on of that.
3:11 Is there anything that you want to maybe recap or or? Yeah, I do. You remember the part that we talked about where you talked about the Jews ran into this problem when when the the edict came down about. Rabbi Gershom. Yeah. Can we can we go over that again and and get what the solution was 'cause that was kind of gurgly in that first episode, so I kind of had to splice it out of there. So maybe, maybe we can. We can. Recap that. Yeah, you bet. So that comes from an article ontime.com/datanomics. It, it analyzes 2 kind of religiously very conservative communities, Hasidic Judaism and the LDS Church.
3:58 And it looks at how they both have this basically dating crisis of, of where there are too many women and not enough men to provide spouses for, for these, for, for the marriages. And so basically the, the Mormons have handled it well, quote UN quote, handled it by basically glorifying spinsterhood and just saying, hey, you can still contribute to the to the work of God, the church, the Kingdom, if you are single and and it's OK to just basically be single in eternity.
4:40 And the challenge with that is of course that, yeah, that may be, there may be truth to that. Like, yeah, I'm not saying that you have to be married to be able to contribute to God's Kingdom and, and his work and all that stuff, but marriage is an integral part of the of the plan. And you know, certainly you can't be exalted without marriage. And the other thing is that people that just sincerely desire to be mothers and wives are being deprived through no fault of their own. And and so that's been the LDS kind of solution, quote UN quote. But the Hasidic Jews are kind of unique because they're also a very religiously conservative.
5:30 And by conservative, I'm not just talking about like political or whatnot. I'm talking, you know, they have they, they value large families, They value family and being married and having a lot of children. And they also have, I guess, lack of a better word, they, they just desire to marry within the group there. I think there's a term for that. I'm just blanking on it. But like, they, they want people, they want Hasidic Jews to marry other Hasidic Jews that, you know, marry. They don't want to marry outside of the covenant, so to speak. And so, and so the way that they've handled it is matchmakers. And I actually wrote a blog post. So the guy, how much of this did you end up having to cut out? Do you want to kind of go over everything that we covered last time around or?
6:21 No, just basically how the Jews fixed it, right? Because. Because I found that kind of fascinating, but it was something that couldn't translate real well. Gotcha. So, so basically the way that they chose to handle it in and in that way is they have matchmakers and the matchmakers tell, you know, arrange the marriages. And so, you know, let's say you're a 22 year old young lady who desires to be married and there's a 26 year old young man who desires to be married. They ship, they generally won't pair people of a different age with each other because in a, in a conservative close group that marries amongst themselves and not outside of the group, it's very rare or I don't even know if it's rare. It's just basically it's, it's inevitable that there will be women.
7:19 There's, there's going to be a positive birth rate. So there will be more, you know, 10 year olds than 20 year olds, more 20 year olds than 30 year olds as the birth rate is positive. If you're valuing families and if you're supposed to marry within the group, when you allow free choices to be made, then just biologically more women choose men on average about four years older than them and meant on average tend to select as marriage partners women that are four years younger. And that's kind of obvious for natural, just biological reasons. Younger women are going to be more likely to be able to bear healthy children. Older men are going to be more likely to be able to take care of a woman and protect a family.
8:00 And so those are just kind of the natural reactions. But, but if you're trying to control this and you, you have a positive birth rate and you have this kind of inevitable situation where there are there, if you allow free marriage choices to be made, there will be a surplus of women who just kind of miss out. And, you know, and because let's be honest, not all men, there are fewer men who desire marriage and the responsibilities of life than women, right? And so and so there's just a leftover surplus of women who are deprived if in a, in a forced monogamy situation. So, so basically that's, that's it. The Hasidic Jews, they took away the choice. You know marriage decisions are by arrangement rather than by choice for Hasidic Jews.
8:48 Which? Yeah, yeah. And it's different from marriage in the, you know, the, in the, in the sense that Mormons would use that. So I'm, I'm not saying it's necessary. It's, it's working for them. You know, they still have families and they have successful marriages. Their divorce rates are not even anything close to what the, you know, the rest of even Mormons divorce rates are So, so it's, it's working for them, but it takes away agency, which whose plan is that, right? That's just not ideal, but it is what it is, so. You know, and the birth rate is like, OK, I won't, I don't make many predictions on, on this sort of thing, but I'll, I'll make one here.
9:33 Not a prophecy, just a prediction. You, you know, more like a Vegas style prediction than a than than than anything like property. Yeah, just a good guess. I think within the next four to five years, we're going to start encountering a crisis about our, you know, population collapse. There was a fascinating article that came out about Russia and its incursion into Ukraine, and there's a lot of people now saying that that was about population, that Russia has been in a negative replacement rate for population and one of the ways that the Russian government thought that they could fix this.
10:22 I'm not saying this is the only reason this they invaded, but it was one that was somewhat under the radar that was discussed. They could go in and annex those other parts of Russia that they deemed ethnically Russian and then that would bolster their their population. What they didn't count on was the war taking this long. And so now they're even if they even if they walk away with those other provinces, they're still going to be worse now than they were before they invaded because they've lost so many men in war, right? Elon Musk has come out and said, and you know, Elon's not a classical conservative guy, right?
11:07 Very big on the free market, that sort of thing. But he's come out and said, yeah, we better start having as many kids as we can because the replacement rate in the United States is getting low. So I would think within about four or five years, you're going to see this creep into the States. It's a trend in all of the West, not just America or Russia. It's a trend that is going those bigger socialist countries, they'll feel it first because they rely on the replacement rate to fund the program. So everything's funded from the past into the future and they'll you'll start seeing those, those. That includes the. US. Yep, that. Includes the US Yep because Social Security funds it the same way right and and that will become an issue in the coming in the coming years I think yeah so mark that down write that down I could be wrong but that's that's where I'm going with it so anyway awesome so OK let's let's pick up where we left off then there.
12:10 All right, perfect. So, so moving on into chapter 6, this is there's a book called The Mothers by a guy named Robert Briffault. Early Christian moralists who accounted marriage as a necessary evil favored monogamy as a reduction of that evil to a minimum. See. So this is driven by celibacy and Roman stuff. So there's a guy concerning the historical perspective, Professor John Karen Cross wrote. Not only is there nothing in the Bible contrary to polygamy, in early Christian times it was common. Even Charlemagne had several lives. Gradually, priest craft became more and more powerful. The Church imposed not only monogamy, monogamy, but the celibacy of the priests, and also church control of marriage. In 1532, Charles the Fifth made polygamy a capital offense, and the Council of Trent ratified the condemnation of the practice.
13:17 And yet whoremongers and adulterers go Scott free. How wickedly unjust. Can can we explore that for just a second? So I I want to know why it is that the Roman system was so antithetical to plural marriage. Rome was a lot. Ancient Rome was a lot like modern America. OK. It's, it's basically it's, it's, you know, late Republic nonsense is a term that a guy named Steve Days kind of uses to describe this phenomenon. And, and it's basically it's a situation where in late in a Republic, all republics have an expiration date essentially. And late in a republic's history, the devolves into decadence.
14:12 It devolves into, you know, hedonism and secularism and and the IT loses that moral foundation that that made the Republic possible and strong, you know, and this is something that was basically prophesied by our own American founders. John, was it John Adams, I believe, that said this is or Benjamin Franklin, I think is attributed when they were walking out and some lady at least said, Mr. Franklin, what kind of government have you given us? And he says a Republic, Madam, if you can keep it so. Yeah. Benjamin Franklin, he understood the American founders understood that a Republic, to survive a Republic must have a moral and virtuous people.
14:55 And, and so that's, that's kind of the price of admission if you want a Republic. And we know what happens when you lose that moral and virtuous foundation of, of the people, you cease to be a republican, you become an empire. And so that was the Roman history was it basically became an empire. And you know, because early Rome, Roman history with the Roman Republic, late Roman history is the Roman Empire, which later became absorbed into basically a theocracy with the Catholic Church being the, the actual de facto rule. I mean, there were a lot, of course there were all these European monarchs, but they all were held sway by the Pope and the Catholic infrastructure.
15:42 And so the Church was dictating policy, even though the monarchs technically wielded the political. Power. Gotcha. OK, All right, that makes sense. I was just curious why, why it was the Roman influence that was so that that carried such a heavy stick in this idea of of chastity. I shouldn't even say chastity. That's not the right word. But celibacy, yeah, yeah. And and whatnot. But I think that kind of answers the question there. So. All right. So, yeah, the, the Roman Empire has sway on on the early church and that's when celibacy starts being the, I won't say the standard, but the the ideal. And then marriage.
16:29 Monogamy is the next best thing. Yep. So I'm going to read another excerpt from James Campbell in 1869. He says I have demonstrated that monogamy is not commanded in the Bible and that it is not the doctrine of Christianity. I shall now account for its origin by proving that it is the joint offspring of paganism and Romanism. The social system of European monogamy is proved to be derived from the ancient Greeks and Romans, especially the latter, by the early histories of the nations of Europe, and by an uninterrupted descent of traditional customs from them to our own times. It is one of those Pagan abominations which we have inherited, which the Roman Church has sanctioned and confirmed, and from which we find it so difficult to emancipate ourselves. Take monogamy as it is today in Protestant countries, and we see that the old Roman 11 is still in it. Christianity has not reformed and purified that system so much as that system has corrupted Christianity. Most of us in these countries are accustomed to congratulate ourselves upon our happy escape from the bondage and the bigotry of the Papal Church.
17:37 Yet we are mistaken. We've not escaped. Rome binds us in stronger shackles than the iron chains of the Holy Inquisition. Her shackles are upon our consciences. They are intertwined with every fiber of our social life. Who? This was written in 1869. Whoa, that it's a it's kind of interesting that they that. Who was that again that said that? James Campbell, we read. He had some. OK, he had some other stuff. Conversation. Yeah, it's interesting that that he sees that as an issue that early, right.
18:18 And that, that they're still operating under that Roman system, right. Wow. Yeah. And total the, the, the thing that, that I find most interesting that goes along with this is that from the early days of Protestantism, there was some flirting with plural marriage, right? I know Martin Luther solemnized a plural union, right, 'cause he looked at the Bible and said, I can't find anything wrong in here with it. It doesn't prohibit it anywhere. So I think it's valid, right? And so I find that very fascinating that it seems like early on they're looking at this and, and at least the founder of Protestantism, Martin Luther, was like, I don't see any issues with this, but yet it seems to revert back to monogamy as the movement continues.
19:14 Yes, Yep. And so let's let's also back up to another really starting point for this. How, how did this become so entrenched in modern Christian Protestant Christianity? I mean, we can see how Rome, you know, they hid the scriptures from the people and so nobody could actually study. But, but Protestants, they claimed, I mean, Protestantism is based on the, this concept of Sola scriptura that you don't need a priest, you don't need priesthood. You just need scripture and, and a man and his Bible can get closer to God than, you know, anything else, like a, a, a priest or an intercessor. And there is truth to that, But it but it's also, it also leads to idolatry of the scriptures. And and and, and so let's let's dive back into this. Are you familiar with the term Gnosticism Starts with AG. Yeah, yeah.
20:11 That's that's where the idea of sacred knowledge is the saving mechanism. But not only that, yes. So like esotericism and stuff like that, but not only that, Gnosticism was a tradition. It was like basically a philosophy of men mingled with some scripture. You might say BYU and it, I don't know. Well, so, but Gnosticism, ancient Gnosticism basically viewed that everything physical was evil. OK. OK, the body was, you know, is fallen and, and, and sinful and wicked and evil. And so taken to that logical conclusion, marriage, which is the union of, of a man and woman's bodies is at best a necessary evil. Cause of course, if nobody married and nobody joined their bodies, then there would be no children and we'd all die off in a generation.
21:05 But so the ideal upheld in Gnosticism and so they, they tie righteousness to how celibate are you? And so it, it enshrines celibacy. And particularly this is what initially led to the Catholic practice of celibate priests. And, and so like the priesthood at least even if even if the the low ranking members are carnal, meaning that they are married and have children like that, at least the priesthood was going to be celibate. And those, the origins of those types of teachings within Catholicism which later certainly influence Protestantism actually originated with Gnosticism, which is a Roman philosophy of men.
21:54 So in, in at some points in Christendom's history, marriage was barely tolerated and those married who were most spiritually minded strove for abstinence within marriage. So obviously with celibacy and abstinence, given such grand spiritual ground, polygamy was an excess of evil not to be tolerated. Who? So this is from a book called Attitudes to the Body in Western Christendom by a guy written by an author, Frank Bottomley. He says early in the church's life a conflict arose about the nature of evil that wasn't resolved until the end of the 4th century. The mainline Christians accepted the Old Testament of Scripture and believed that the God revealed there was ultimate spiritual reality.
22:42 Along with the Hebrews, they believed that the physical world was an expression of the divine, the direct creation of God, and therefore good. The Gnostic attitude toward creation, on the other hand, sprang out of Persian thinking that saw 2 equal and opposite divine creative forces, the light and the dark. In the Persian view, both the light and the dark were present in the spiritual world and in nature. The main purpose of human morality and religion was to support the forces of light and so enable them to conquer darkness and bring salvation to the universe. Ultimately, however, a perversion of this Persian viewpoint developed and became a seductive Christian heresy. The dark force became equated with physical matter, the physicality, and with the God of the Old Testament, while the light force became equated with spirit, spirituality, asceticism, and Jesus Christ.
23:33 In Gnosticism, matter was seen as ugly, irredeemable, and evil. The creation of human beings, in this point of view was an imprisoning of pure and Holy Spirit in vile matter. If we believe that spiritual reality is a realm of bliss, harmony and ecstasy, what the agnostics called Laroma, then the mingling of spirit and matter becomes a cosmic catastrophe rather than purposeful, orderly, and good. So in other words, they're denying this duality of, of mankind because we, you know, Mormonism teaches that we are basically spiritual beings having a physical temporal existence there. And this Gnostic tradition throws that completely out the window and says, no, we are we are are imprisoned in these physical bodies and we need to do anything necessary to free ourselves, free our spirits from this prison. And, and so asceticism and like depriving ourselves and, and shirking all forms of pleasure and joy and happiness like this is the that's Gnosticism and the so gradually the idea developed when within early Christian Christianity, specifically the Gnostic influences that anything to do with conception or copulation or sexuality or genital organs was evil or ugly. Saint Augustine was a friend, member of the Manichean sect for nine years, and although he eventually disengaged himself intellectually, he never fully disengaged himself emotionally. His book, The Good of Marriage
25:06 has some passages on marriage that are, well, not unbelievable. Even normal intercourse within marriage can be a venial sin. The quicker married people abstain from all relations, the better for their souls, according to Augustine, One of the early, you know, Christian fathers. Not only that, there's another guy trying to remember his name. There was another of the early Christian fathers who bought so much into this, this idea, this philosophy that he castrated himself. Do you remember? Do you happen to remember off the hand? I'm just going to Google that I'm I'm just. Dude, I may, I may have read it. That may be one of those things that I really wanted to forget, but it it's interesting that I I just can't help but compare and contrast right? You have this one ideology that is really. Origin.
26:02 Origin, OK. Origin. OK, it's interesting that you have one ideology that is prominent, quite frankly, until the restoration that your humanity is by its very nature unholy, right? That it prevents you from seeing God. The Joseph Smith message that he receives from, from God, right? I'm I'm not just saying it's his. We believe he restored restored this through through divine means is that your humanity does not have to be doesn't have to be the reason that you can't see God.
26:45 In fact, your humanity is required to to get to where you want to go. And that's a a radical departure from what what it had been. But you can see the almost like the seeds of human destruction sewn into some of this early doctrine that that these early Christians were espousing. Yeah. So, yeah, I mean, clearly, it didn't take long for the early church to lose its way. You know, Origin himself made himself a eunuch. And then in the 12th, so later on, hope.
27:27 Gregory the Great issues an edict who says that married people cannot receive communion after intercourse unless they had first done penance. Later writers, including the standard Catholic theological authors of the 12th century, argued that passion actually transmitted original sin by corrupting the seed with its heat. So if you're actually passionate with your wife, the claim is that that corrupts your seed and so the offspring are like hellish chimps instead of children of God.
28:07 Holy. Cow. So going on, Speaking of the attitude toward marital sex regarding the obligation of Catholics at the 4th Lateran Council, this isn't 12:15. A guy named Gardelia states that quote sexual pleasure. Pleasure with one spouse remained a venial sin. Venial sin did not destroy the saving work of God's grace in the soul as mortal sin would, but taking pleasure even in married relations weakened and stained the soul, and so required that the Sinner do penance on earth or after death. Pope Gregory the Great had forbidden this during this forbidden relations during nursing, lest the milk be spoiled or contaminated. Holy cow. So in so the the conclusion here, enforced monogamy was the doctrinal invention of Roman Catholicism. Wow.
29:02 And in 1563, the Council of Trent. So I mean, here's the thing, we, we can be grateful for our Christian heritage as like these councils, they were trying, I think very sincerely to do what was right, to try to give guidance and, and establish the correct principles to govern a church. But they had they, they had some real misses as along the way as well. So 1563, the Council of Trent reclarified the Catholic position by declaring anyone who held polygamy to be lawful, to be anathema. And anathema is just, like, a really strong word for you're just as evil as it gets.
29:45 You're just, you know, irritable. Essentially, religion is the source of bigamy laws. So Samuel Chapman is an author. He wrote polygamy, bigamy and human rights law. And in the book he wrote, he says the roots of bigamy laws extend deep into the past and are as much entwined with established religious organizations as they are with social or democratic concerns. Polygamy is recorded in the Bible as a practice of the patriarchs and kings, and the text speaks of the relationship between God and Israel, and later between Christ and the Church. In polygamous terms. Polygamy itself escapes any form of Scripture condemnation and instead appears to attract support. After the Bible was completed, as one church or another became established as rival authorities in law, and as the Roman Church itself married the empire, condemnations of polygamous behavior began to become more common.
30:36 Bigamy has been a criminal offence in England and Wales since 16 O 4, when the first Parliament of James the First took action ensuring that anyone found guilty would receive a sentence of death. Remember what we were talking about, translators? So in in the Acts of King James in 16 O 4, this is the guy that commissioned the King James version of the Bible. Right. Just this Like any translation of the Bible, the King James Version finds it impossible to conceal the polygamy of the patriarchs. But some of the polygamous references in the New Testament are rendered with sufficient ambiguity to let the reader pass on without noticing their polygamous content. Wow, may I get one?
31:24 You get into biblical history and it's not cut and dry, right? We have this idea that that the Canon of Scripture that we have the King, the King James Version, anyway, I should say, comes down in a pristine line, you know, with some scribes that screw some stuff up, maybe some evil men who wanted to for power, and it's just clean, right? Other than that, that's not the case whatsoever whatsoever. And the King James Bible, we have seen where, where there's issues there, right? I'm, I don't want to throw it all under the bus. That's not what I'm saying. I believe it's a valid form of scripture, obviously right? But. Honestly, it's it's my favorite because it has the the old Shakespearean, which I think is the most beautiful form of the English language.
32:09 So absolutely. But yeah, obviously it has to be translated correctly, as in with integrity and not with all of these biases and other issues otherwise. You know, it's interesting that most of the founders of the country didn't use the King James Version. They either used, I can never remember this. I think it's the Geneva Bible. It might be Gutenberg, but I'm about 85% or 90% sure that it's it's the Geneva Bible. And the Geneva Bible was really hard on kings. I mean, did not like kings. And so it's interesting that as as you look at at biblical literature and biblical history, there seems to be a few different flavors out there of essentially the same text, right, Depending on how the translation goes. But it it that's that's super interesting that the first guy who translates the Bible into English also has an edict to kill all polygamists.
33:14 Yeah, it's nuts. Yeah. So obviously, and this is back to the author, obviously, if one starts their view suspecting marriage to be tainted or evil, it will follow that polygamy is therefore very tainted or evil. Whereas if one starts their view acknowledging marriage is a loving and gracious gift from God, it will then follow that polygamy is an added blessing. Polygamy is not an issue of sin, it's a religious issue forced upon society. It's rejection is rooted in the viewing of the human body as evil, ultimately calling all marriage into question as evil, but especially it's morality. So in Christendom's historic Gnostic influenced view, physical world is evil, physical body is evil, marriage is a necessary evil, Polygamy is an ultimate evil. Whereas scripture, and we're not talking about Mormon scripture, we're talking strictly biblical scripture. In In the Bible's divine view, the physical world is good, the physical body is good, marriage is good, and polygamy is therefore an ultimate good.
34:16 Yeah, it it really did turn that that completely upside down did a 180. Yeah, so it's religion that has destroyed the biblical family and left multitudes of women in forced celibacy, not being able to fulfill their divinely given roles of wife and mother. Now seriously, who are the ones really being immoral? What a shameful disgrace. Proverbs 1822. Who? Whoso finds a wife finds a good thing, it obtains favor of the Lord. The principle of plural marriage finds its dark side not in God of the Scriptures, but in Christendom's Gnostic deception. Marriage is honorable in all Hebrews 13 four. So he kind of, he repeats these scriptures at the end of chapters, but I think they're worth repeating. Absolutely.
34:59 So now let's let's let's move ahead in church history into the Reformation. Got you. OK, So the early reformers, some of the early reformers dealt with the issue like you were saying, Martin Luther of plural marriages. In fact, the three leading figures of the German Reformation, Martin Luther, Langfan and Buser, signed the Wittenberg deliberation, which was mostly taken up with an examination of the biblical authority for a man having multiple marriages. They jointly gave their public blessing to Philip the Magnanimous of Hesse to marry a second wife. So Martin Luther. So this was a different guy named James Stivers, but he says I It was not till I read Martin Luther that my prejudice against polygamy was disarmed.
35:49 Not only did Luther defend polygamy as a remedy for fornication, but it was far preferable to divorce. Luther's did not stand alone in these opinions, but was supported by other and Melanctin and the Lutheran clergy in general. He insisted that whatsoever was not specifically forbidden by Scripture was optional for the Christian. And not only is there no biblical ban on polygamy, there are positive examples of it in the Patriarchs. In January 1521, Luther had written to a friend whose marital life was wholly asexual owing to the illness of his wife, and had been asked whether he might take a second wife. Luther had responded that in this is his words Martin Luther's writings. I confess indeed, I cannot forbid anyone who wishes to marry several wives nor is that against Holy Scripture Luther OK, it just more more stuff. Interestingly, in in view of the overwhelming forces militating against Luther giving his approval to Phil because got to remember this is pretty much almost contemporary. This is just before the King James Version of the Bible, but it's this.
36:53 It's all within about 80 years of each other. And Luther's given decision to consent to a bigamist marriage is astounding because at this time in Germany, bigamy was a capital offense. He knew, and Luther clearly knew from the outset in 1526, that such a thing could cause a great scandal. Right. There's an Italian reformer named Bernardino Ochino, and he's he writes that David was reproached by the Lord for his adultery, but never for his polygamy. So again, this is Bernardino Ochino live 1487 to 1564, contemporary of Martin Luther. And he says, indeed, God clearly says to David that he God had given him David many wives, though you read the whole Bible over, you shall never find that God has forbade the having of diverse wives.
37:46 In short, God bless the plural marriages of those holy men, the first fathers of the world. These are Ochino's nick words. Moses, far from mentioning such a ban, sets forth provisions for the treatment of children in cases where a man has two wives, one beloved, the other not. And from these passages it follows by the word of God that all the children are legitimate from diverse wives by the same husband. Anabaptist John Milton now John John Milton was the author of Paradise Lost. Maybe I guess it may not be super familiar to everybody, but but I'm sure some listeners are familiar with that He was a supporter.
38:27 He was a defender and advocate for polygamy in his so this is what he wrote quote for the that for that the husband is in a condition to perform his conjugal duties to the wife after having taken another to her is shown by God himself in Exodus chapter 21 verse 10. If you take him, another wife, her food, her raiment, and her duty of marriage shall not be dismissed, diminished. John Milton also observes that God himself, Ezekiel 23 verse 4, represents himself as having espoused 2 wives, which would have been unthinkable had the practice been intrinsically dishonorable or shameful. On the contrary, Milton maintains polygamy is, quote, lawful and honorable. Not that Milton was demonstrably inclined to polygamy. He was thrice married, but in succession after the death of the 1st and subsequently of the second wife. There is nothing particularly significant about this, except perhaps that Milton did not like living alone and was fond of female companionship.
39:19 In fact, he never made any secret of his delight in the quote apartment and cheerful conversation of man with woman to comfort and refresh him. For him, the text, the key text applicable to marital life was not to increase and multiply, but that quote. It is not good for man to be alone. Right who? His marriage is not just about having children. Right. Handyship you it's counsel it's just the joy I mean I feel bad for guys that that are not married because literally you're missing out on one of the greatest joys that's that there is available in this life so and you know if that's their choice that's fine, but if if somebody sincerely wants to be married and just.
40:04 You can't find a companion that's compatible like that's. That's sad. Yeah, yeah. And so we we have all these early Protestant leaders who seem to be on board, right, so to speak. What what do you think halts that? I mean, do you think that it's just social pressures of the day? Do you think it, you know, it sounds like in Europe there's several countries that have edicts like, hey, you're practicing plural marriage, you're done. Is is early? Protestantism was the counterculture, right, like early Protestantism was, was revolutionizing the religious world, the environment there. And so, but it was founded upon education and scriptural mastery.
41:01 And it was founded upon all of these, these principles of, for lack of a better word, just like scholarship and and knowledge. Because coming from the the background of Catholicism, like all of those things had been squelched for generations. And so and so, but unfortunately, the founders of the Reformation, like the early Protestant leaders, they, they, they did the work, they knew what they were talking about. They, they had done the homework, whereas the, the people who followed them were sadly more following the man than the, the scripture and the principles.
41:47 And so I think that within a, a generation or two, I mean, not saying that there were no other scholars and no other people who really studied the Scriptures, There were clearly, but but these, the, the founding generation of the Rif of the reformers were unique in that they were so well acquainted with and and familiar with the, the Scriptures. The Bible. So here's here, there's another few names I'm just going to they have, he has some excerpts from their works. But so John, I, I talked about John Milton, a guy named Martin Maidan. He he, his claim to fame is he wrote the hymn Hark the Herald Angels Sing. And he wrote a huge weighty volume on polygamy called Celithoria.
42:40 Anyway, so then there's another one. Sir Walter Raleigh and Sir Thomas Brown. Hugo Grotius, Samuel Puffendorf, John Dunn. Oh, so John Dunn the poet I don't know if you've heard of. Yeah. Interestingly, he wrote favorably of polygamy and King James's own grandson, Charles Lewis, Elector of the Rainish Palatin. It married a second wife without apparently divorcing the 1st and at least sponsored and possibly wrote a defensive polygamy himself. So the poet John Donne, one of his poems says how happy were our sires in ancient time who held plurality of love. No crime.
43:36 So anyway, that's, I think that's good enough for that. Let's go, let's move forward. So anything else do you want to cover? Anything else? Nope. That's good. Let's move into chapter 8, which this is where he addresses the cultural issue. OK, so in so in the majority of the world's cultures, polygamy, polygyny, which so polygyny is a specific form of polygamy because technically polygamy could be a woman having multiple husbands, a man having multiple wives. You know, it could be more of a polyamorous type of a situation where as polygyny is the biblical principle of one husband, multiple wives.
44:20 So anyway, so this in the majority of the world's cultures today and in throughout history it is it's a viable and in many it's circumstance is the ideal option. This is from a book called Plural Marriage for our Times by Philip Kilbride. It should be noted that polygyny as a marriage form is prevalent throughout the world. In historical terms, it is monogamy that is in need of explanation, not polygamy. That's from another book. All the sources are in this in the book. So just by the book, everyone listening. So of the 1154 Human Societies in the Human Relations area files of Yale University, more than 1000 practice some degree of sanctioned polygamy, and polygamy is the preferred choice in 70% of those. Wow.
45:09 So monogamy is by far the minority in in history and even modern history. Even these these are also including contemporary civilizations. Through cultural domination, American European social structures are projected as superior and those of other peoples as inferior. Interesting. The pride of Ephraim. Right. So I'm just going to read a couple other things. Let's see. This is from a book, a 24 volume set called Understanding Human Behavior, published by Columbia House. A Westerner would find it hard to reconcile the rivalry and inbuilt possessiveness of his monogamous experience with the life of peaceful polygamy.
45:56 To people of monogamous Western background, polygamy seems an extraordinary aberration from the natural state of things. But man is a creature of his environment and where the circumstances of our lives to depend upon it, Polygamy might simply become the rule in our society, as it has in many others, and what we now see as emotional prohibitions would evaporate. Dude, that goes along with what I told you that in that last episode where where that guy basically told me, oh if, if society collapses, polygamy is the default mechanism. Yeah, this theme article this this 24 volume series goes on and says in some societies a man may marry several wives. Western society does allow this, just in a different way. In what is sometimes called serial polygamy, a man may marry several wives, so long as he legally divorces the current one before marrying the next.
46:51 Arguably, the Christian form of polygamy is a more primitive and callous arrangement for the man's existing family than ordinary polygamy. In polygamist societies, the first wife and their children remain viable parts of a viable social entity. In serial polygamy, the children are brought up in a broken home. The wife is discarded in a difficult social position. It does seem unjust when it's put that way, right? I mean, there's just no other way around it, right? I mean. It's kind of like it's, it's, it's, you know what it kind of reminds me of? It reminds me of the Olympics where you had this brave tranny competing in women's sports, in women's boxing, right? And you have all these feminists or people claiming to be feminists cheering him on and saying he's so great and so brave and just historic and all this. When you break it down, we're just, we're watching a dude beat up a, a, a woman.
47:56 Yeah. What's brave about that? You know, and, and, and I think it's kind of the similar concept of when you have what's truly pro woman. Right. Polygamy or polygamy? What's pro Children right or Pygmy? Yeah, yeah. Like. So I don't know if you caught it, but I did an episode with a guy named Randall Edwards, who's an attorney in Salt Lake there. So shout out to him. Dude's a great, great guy. But we did an episode on what what some of those early fights against the Mormons were all about by the time the Utah period rolls around and they're talking about, you know, all the polygamy in Utah that's going on.
48:46 One of the things they say that I find fascinating is we don't want to be like the mongrel races of, of the Middle East and Northern Africa by espousing polygamy because it'll just lead to, to anarchy and chaos, right? And I find that it was interesting kind of founded in that xenophobic kind of language that that's what that decision was couched in. It's it's pretty fascinating. Yeah, so let's go back to James Campbell again from the 1869 book I am called by the Justice of God and the Sufferings in Mankind in behalf of a greater freedom to marry and a greater purity of the marriage relation.
49:35 Let us have such marriage Laws, that whatsoever relations any honorable man shall determine to form with the other, sex, can be honorably formed and honorably maintained. By attempting to deprive 1/2 the women of any lawful and honorable means of amorous Pleasure, and by allowing the Men only partial and inadequate means, it impels a multitude of each sex, whose secret Transgression or else to open profligacy. Now which social System is the more honorable and manly, the more virtuous and pure? The one more in accordance with nature and the laws of Nature's God, A pretended and a corrupt monogamy, or an open and honest ligamy, which manifests the more base and selfish passion.
50:21 The man who espouses the partners of his love, and takes them to his home in his heart, and provides for them and their children? Or the man who steals away from his house in the dark and indulges his dishonorable and degrading passion in secret dark places, and then abandons the partners of his guilty pleasure to a life of wretchedness and shame and want. Well, and and there's a point to that too, right? Clear up to Victorian times, it was considered gentlemanly to visit the local House of ill repute, right? I mean, it was just what quote boys did. And I find that rather disgusting. And, and I want to be careful to never use something as, as, you know, noble, as plural marriage, as, you know, a license to just have a guy be carnal, right?
51:18 Obviously sex is a part of marriage. There's no way around it. But but I don't want to give anyone the the idea that hey man, this is just a way for you to get satisfied without any real work because this does take work. 100% Well, and not only that, like the the people who the the people who would accused a man who believes in or is interested in in living the plural marriage principle of being motivated only by lust. Like what does that say about that person? I think it says more about that person and it says about the practice because because one of one of the most God ordained motives for marriage, at least for a dude, is gratification of the sexual urge, right?
52:23 And and it's not Christianity that has a problem with that. It's Gnostics, Gnosticism, right? Gnosticism is, is the problem. It's not Christianity, it's not the scriptures. And so we need to kind of reframe that narrative as well, the guy that any man who is against polygamy, I think if he fights against it, then that says a lot more about his, you know, probably marriage situation than it says about, I think it's just a revealing of the true condition of people's hearts.
53:04 No, I think, I think you're right. Because I mean, you don't have to lust a woman to marry her monogamously. No, I highly recommend against. In fact, I think that, you know, lust. We shouldn't objectify women for any reason, even if it's a wife, even it's you know, that's that's kind of a no brainer in my opinion. But but lust, you can have a desire and attraction without lust and anyone else otherwise. So they're they're less. If they're married then I guess they are admitting that they married for lust. I mean what else? What else can you say? About that, yeah. Yeah.
53:46 No, I see where you're going there. That makes sense, yeah. All right, so a guy, Samuel Chapman writes in. Polygamous groups throughout history have tended to offer a better better deal for women than their monogamous contemporaries. Friedman, Bergstrom, and Becker state that this is not without reason, as in economic terms it raises the demand for women while increasing the supply of men. So simple supply demand economics meaning that men who that men have to do more to attract women and keep them, and are therefore inclined to treat them better than under monogamy.
54:28 Right. No, you, you go to BYU, there is a, an absolute deficiency of men and an absolute overabundance of women. And so then what happens? Dudes can play, they can be picky, they can wait, they can do, you know, they can do whatever they want because because they're God, they're they're the king in that environment. And, you know, we need to, we need to reframe this. Men should be the ones having to earn the trust in regard of women and be able to, you know, have to have to merit those blessings.
55:11 Anyway, you got to kind of work for it, right? I mean, showing up, showing up is not going to just give you, get you a medal. You, you're going to have to have to work at being a good guy and, and a good provider and a good husband and, and, and all those things that go along with that. Despite our society's hypocritical objection to plural marriage, serial polygamy is freely practiced and approved by both civil governments and religious institutions. Sadly, even the LDS Church leaving in their wake the countless broken lives of deserted women and children. Really, who is immoral here? What a shame. Yeah, so.
55:54 Now in Chapter 9, so that was kind of some of the and looking at some of the negative aspects of, of, of our cultural abandonment of polygamy. Now Chapter 9, let's look at the benefits and the positive aspects of plural marriage. This is from a lady named Doctor Joyce Brothers. Interestingly, she said this on Bill Maher's Comedies show in 1994. She says polygamy is not as bad as people think. I would much rather be third in line of a good man than the only wife of a jerk.
56:38 Well. Put Yeah, hard to argue with that. So, based upon our study so far, the most obvious benefit of polygamy is the provision it supplies to unmarried women who desire marriage in children. No woman would be forced by default to live in celibacy or live alone, or be required to steal another woman's husband in order to have one herself. Godly polygamy provides that all women who want a husband and family can have them. It would assure that all women are cherished and adored. The repercussions of such a provision produce an incalculable windfall. Adriana Blake, the attorney that we've quoted before, says plural marriage would improve the quality of men. The quality of men. Plural marriage would mean that a woman would not have to settle for any man rather than none at all.
57:22 Her choices will not be confined to those men who are single or divorced or willing to deceive their wives. Assurance that she will have a place within a family and a husband and father for her children means a woman will have more and better choices. The man who is kind, considerate and caring, gentle and loving is the man who will attract women to his household. Women will want to be with him. And if we look at section what is it 121? It's describing it one of the statements that it's talking about, and this is talking about priesthood, but I think it applies to any form of leadership or parenthood or, you know, husbandship. And it basically the the the point that it makes is that the the.
58:06 Want more from the Mormon Renegade podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the fundamental news program for. Free. Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button and for $5.00 a month you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode Show notes today. And if we look at section, what is it 121? It's describing it one of the statements that it's talking about, and this is talking about priesthood, but I think it applies to any form of leadership or parenthood or, you know, husbandship. And it basically the, the, the point that it makes is that the, the, what is the, the point I'm trying to make is I'm just, I just blanked on.
59:07 Oh, yeah, without compulsory means. Sorry, my mind just went blank for a second there. Without compulsory means, it, it shall flow into thee forever and ever. So without compulsory means means that there's no coercion involved. It's just basically what the so 'cause reality is, if you want to have a celestial quality marriage, you have to earn that. You have to BA celestial quality person if you want a quality marriage. And so so she's just talking about the IT. It will be completely by desire, not by, you know, a lot of girls stick in their marriage because they feel like they have to. They've made a covenant or whatever. And, and I'm not saying that covenant should not be taken very seriously, but covenants are not unconditional. I guess that's maybe a way to phrase that. If a man is breaking his covenants, being an abusive piece of garbage, the woman is not under obligation, covenantal obligation to just be cool with that and accept that and and just endure that forever.
1:00:21 So with plural marriage available, more women would be content within the marriage and would remain because they'd have the opportunity to choose men who would treat them well. Plural marriage means that if a woman could share a husband, her chances are better of getting a good one. The familiar line all the good men are taken won't be valid anymore because the good men can be shared. Rotten men won't get wives because women won't have to settle for what's available. Women will no longer fear that they will be left out of the marriage lottery. They will not have to settle for who is available rather than the chance of facing life alone. Plural marriage could improve the quality of marriage. The quality of marriage would improve the quality of life for women by improving the caliber of the men they choose for husbands.
1:01:06 If men were allowed to have more than one wife, then the good men who treated women well would be the successful man in attracting wife. Where we have a society that demands A1 to one relationship for marriage, there simply are not enough men to go around Whenever you have a demand that it see exceeds supply and inflated value attaches to the item in short supply. In the present case, the man. Unattached women compete with each other to their detriment for a chance at the marriage lottery. Those men who do not treat women well will do without. There would be no reason for a woman to stay in an abusive and punishing relationship. She could leave free to find a household that would welcome and cherish her.
1:01:48 It just gives women more. Argue with all that. Yeah, it, it, it just gives women more options. I mean, I don't, I don't know how, how else to put it right. I mean, look, I, I've had the opportunity, not just my own, but to see other, you know, polygamous households, right? And, and just talk about their lived experience. And one, one of the things I noticed is that one of the benefits are there's like not just the opportunity to marry a better man, but an opportunity to have different roles at different times of your life, right? I talked to one woman who was like, oh, I, I love it. She's like, right now I'm in a stage of life where where my kids are grown and gone. I can go to work, you know, somebody else can, can do this. And, and those roles can often shift and rotate, right? So what's interesting is that if there was a slide that was sold about, well, you can have it all. Well, you sure can, but it might not necessarily be what was peddled to you, right?
1:02:52 And, and so I'm, I'm, I'm always very, very hesitant to like be like, hey, come on, it's great over here. But I mean, there, there, there are options, right? And I, I think it's important that those get get talked about a little bit. Well, and to me it's it polygamy, you know, a polygamist society does not mean that every man is, is practicing it right. You know, if, if times are peaceful and you know, people are healthy and there's a degree of safety and stability and security, and there may not be an, A, a huge excess of women who need a, a, a husband.
1:03:37 Like that's an actual ideal situation, right? That's, that's what we would all strive for and, and hope for. But the, and So what I would say is people who maybe they would never live the principle personally, but they really ought to never be opposed to other people consensually living it. So even if it's something that they are personally not interested in, nobody's I'm not, I certainly, I'm not suggesting that we force anybody to do something against their conscience or what they want. We need to provide agency to those who may have different choices or different values or different beliefs, like let's be respectful and honor that. So we've talked about some of the benefits that this system provides for women.
1:04:31 It it just ensures that every woman who wants to be married can be married to a good man. Right. Alice Pivot restored headship. The divine principle of headship in the family has been destroyed by Christendom's monogamy. Men have been emasculated in their roles as husbands and fathers. Their God ordained placement in the home has been replaced by supposed partnerships. Divinely established patriarchy has been usurped by what is, for all practical purposes, matriarchy. The family will never function as designed by God until there is a return to biblical patriarchy.
1:05:13 As unpopular as this is today, this is God's order of things. I mean, this is something everybody understood for generations, but somehow we've forgotten in the last generation. There is nothing quite like polygamy to emphasize this crucial aspect of headship. He quotes another author, Tom Shipley. The unbiblical monogamy only doctrine is an irreconcilable conflict with the Bible's teaching of the headship of the father and husband. Male headship, when legally enforced monogamy is in effect, is a delusive fiction. Legally enforced monogamy is in operation, a logical and de facto negation of the hierarchy of the biblical family.
1:05:57 A patriarchal law order without polygamy is patriarchal in name only. Coligeny is patriarchy in action? So, OK, I, I want to, I want to unpack something here real quick and this is going to be a side tangent, but I feel like it's important pertaining to this part of the conversation. The term patriarchy today is loaded, right? I mean, it's, it's one of those things. So I want to as a guy who believes in plural marriage, as a guy who who says, hey, this is this is good and there is a divine order to the family with, with the husband standing at the head of the family.
1:06:43 What does when when you hear the word patriarchy, you tell me what you think that looks like in a healthy situation? You know, there's all these jokes about how, you know, the husband is the head, but the wife is the neck. You know, there's all these jokes about how basically, you know, you can't ever expect that you're, you're, you'll be able to preside in your home because your wife will wear the pants. You know, there's different phrases and, and kind of expressions in our, in our kind of vernacular, but, but essentially they all mean the same thing, which is that, you know, women just allow men to think that they're in charge.
1:07:32 And this is I, I, I don't, I, I don't think anybody listening can deny this. This is very much just as much in the LDS Church as it is in Christianity as it is in secular. Like everybody, women have been exalted at, at the cost, at what cost? At the detriment of men. And you know, I love women. I'm not suggesting that we don't exalt women. I'm not suggesting that that, you know, that this was even an intentional or a nefariously motivated thing that women have done. But it is a direct consequence of abandoning biblical patriarchy, the patriarchal order, and certainly not what Brigham and Joseph Smith and John Taylor in the early Mormon leaders were, were after.
1:08:17 They would just short shudder at the modern state of the church and men and women and families. But going back to your question, what do I think that a patriarchal, a healthy patriarchal system looks like? It looks like a man who does not view his role as a husband, as a head of his household, as something to do that gives him coercive power over anybody else. It makes him responsible to make sure that everybody has a voice and every voice gets heard.
1:08:58 It makes him the primary responsible party of who is going to settle disputes. You know, cuz there's a lot of times that there's, there's conflict there. You know, kids are arguing, a wife is arguing with, you know, if it's a plural situation, wives might be arguing. It's the role of a husband to be an impartial arbiter that who loves both parties, allows everything to be said and who has earned the confidence of his wives to the point where he can, can just basically make a decision and, and both parties will accept it because he is that reliable. He has earned that trust and is worthy of their trust.
1:09:40 So I don't know, I, I didn't have like a succinct answer prepared. That was a good question. But does that kind of answer what you're, you know, give, give? I, I think so. I think so. And, and look, I'm going to talk about this now from a very Mormon perspective, because I feel like Mormons have a, a proper view of this to frame, to frame it in. Every time a man gets priesthood or priesthood advancement into another office, almost always it isn't accompanied by more responsibility, more service, greater service, more charity, all those things.
1:10:34 Now in in Mormonism, we understand that the term patriarchy or patriarchal is kind of a priesthood title, right? Yes. With that being said, it's one of the higher, higher positions within the priesthood, I guess, if that makes sense. Oh yeah. So if the system has been with patriarchal IR, excuse me, priesthood advancement, that there comes more service with every step. Why would that be any different? So as I think about, you know what, what would patriarchy look like?
1:11:18 And it's something I try hard to instill and and practice here here in my family. I'm not always successful. I try very hard is an idea of how can I serve my family today, right? Not you're simply here for my own self aggrandizement, not from any showy, nasty, weird sort of a way, but more from how can I make these people I love in my home even more happy today than they were yesterday? And approach it from a very service oriented mindset, a a provider and a protector and and all those things that go along with it. And I think what we've done is we've allowed kind of that radical feminist side of this equation to be able to take and redefine what that means to be a patriarch in your own home or patriarchy in general.
1:12:23 And, and it's one of those things that I think deserves some attention and maybe to have it defined back to what I believe God intended it to be, which was I'm just here to serve and love my family, no matter how many wives or children are there. That's my job as the patriarch within my home. God tells us very succinctly in the Pearl of great price. My work in my glory is to bring to pass the immortality and eternal life of man right now. If that's the the ultimate patriarchs goal, I think as humans that's what we should pattern that after as human men if if we seek to be a patriarch in our own home.
1:13:12 Yeah, I would say that the the the first step that led to getting so far off the path off golf course is forgetting the true nature of leadership and headship. And when you start equating headship with a positional type of authority that gives you, you know, license to give orders and expect to be obeyed and gives you control and compulsive influence over those around you. Like whether that's ecclesiastical or familial or political or any of that, like that is that is where things went off the ropes.
1:13:54 That is where the problem I think originates with all of these things. So, you know, if we're wanting to fix things, we need to heal the proper perspective and definition of patriarchy, which which requires us to heal and, and gain the proper perspective of polygamy and kind of go hand in hand and then we just need to apply it. So, yeah, I was going to say if, if, if anybody thinks that plural marriage is all about the dude just barking out orders. Come hang out at my house, right, Right.
1:14:36 Come, come hang out at my house, right, Right. It doesn't work that way. There's more of the girls than there are of me. And and here's. Nevertheless, nevertheless, you have a responsibility that if they're if they if they are maybe perhaps being influenced by excessive emotion or if they're being influenced by the like you were there to protect them essentially from themselves, right. And and so yeah, like that, that sword cuts both directions. And, you know, and I, I just don't understand a woman, how a woman would not want a dude to protect her from getting out of, you know, excessively emotionally involved with this or that and, and that sort of thing. So yeah, I.
1:15:27 And, and, and you're 100% correct, right? And this is where we could have a conversation. We won't 'cause it would take too long, but a conversation about, about how the divine feminine and the divine masculine really do come into balance, right? I'll, I'll just use use use my my case as an example. We came out here to Missouri to visit and we went back home to Utah. And I'm like, yeah, I think, I think we can do this right. I think this will work. Let's give it a good year. Let's settle everything down. And let's you know, it was a very rational, it was a very orderly, methodical man, right? Methodical, like the way most dudes like to do it, right? Yep.
1:16:20 Girls were feeling something completely different than I was completely different, right. And I was holding my ground. I'm like, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, no, this is what we're going to do, right? And there was one night they just, I, I'd finished up a podcast and they came up to the, to that upstairs office where I had, and they just sat me down and they just said, we are really feeling like we are, we're to go sooner. And I was hesitant. I was like, no, no, I, you know, this is the orderly exit, right? And in my dude brain, right, this rational makes sense, whatever. But in that case, they weren't tuned to something that I wasn't right.
1:17:06 And after I prayed about it again, I was like, Oh, they got something here right now. There's been times where, where, where, you know, there is that thing about, OK, too much emotion. Let's inject some logic into this thing, right? But, but those are the kind of balances you want, right? And, and that can happen in a plural, plural marriage. I've seen it it it does work still so. Yeah. Well, I mean, at A, at a really practical level, it, you know, if this is an eternal principle, which I believe it is there, then if it's true, then it will be supported by reason, by practical experience, by the Holy Spirit within us that, you know, the, the, the, the, the whisperings of the Holy Ghost to our, our own heart. Like if it's true, we then we can have confidence in those realities.
1:18:06 So the the idea of I just don't understand. Well, I do understand there are those who want to exercise authority over the over other and you know, they might see polygamy as an Ave. to be able to, you know, have all their wildest dreams come true of exercising unrighteous dominion over others. And we've seen horror stories like that with Warren Jeffs and whatnot. But it's not the practice. It's the man. It's not bigamy that is the culprit in that situation.
1:18:47 It's a fallen and broken and evil perspective of leadership and headship and and you know, priesthood and all of it. So if we can basically get over our emotional response to polygamy, we have a chance of being able to heal some of these things that have been wrong with our society forever, for generations now. So, you know, and just to kind of finish up with this chapter here, it talks about greater family stability, which totally benefits children.
1:19:29 It's a it's a safe haven for older wives, for widows. I'm just going to read this. It says the plural marriage household can provide a safe haven as well as solace for a woman as she gets older. She will not be left alone through divorce or or if she becomes a widow because there's no need for another wife to displace her in a divorce situation. She'll have her own place within the household. Instead of being rejected, she assumes a position of respect within the family. True benefit of plural marriage is available for the widow. She is not the only widow. Wives have been widowed together like you know. You know, in hopefully like 50 years, when it's your time to go, Dave, your ladies will not have to mourn your loss alone. They'll have each other and be together. With so two of the biggest problems for widows, loneliness and depression will have less opportunity to develop. For the wise, we'll have each other. Her sister and marriage will be there to support her. She will not face these times alone. If the husband had been ailing for some time before his death, all of the burden of care will not have fallen on the shoulders of one person.
1:20:34 The burden of the ailing spouse will have been shared. So anyway, there's one last chapter and it's pretty short. I'm going to read maybe four or five paragraphs from it. This is his kind of closing argument. And then the the index has like a lot of the sort or it's not the appendices, like this whole book is less than 100 pages long. It's more like a big pamphlet. But then he has all of the source documents that he's inciting from in the second-half of this book, so. That's a lot of sources, yeah. So chapter 10 who is immoral?
1:21:17 The single woman's genuine need for a husband can't be patched away with a singles ministry or a lady's fellowship. She still goes home to face life alone. The mother who is a single parent will not have her basic needs met by church, daycare, Sunday school, Awana's vacation Bible school, or even by assigning her someone to occasionally visit and help out around the house. Neither will her most fundamental needs be met by WIC, welfare, or other social services. These are all band aids on a serious wound. She needs a husband. Her children need a father. The social and religious culture that denies a woman the right to marry is the actual cause of the single woman and the single mother's problems at the outset. This system then sets about to dress the very wound that they have inflicted.
1:22:06 Just who is immoral in these situations? A man who would love a woman and marry her? A man who would cherish, care for, and protect her? A man who would be a loving and dedicated father to her children. Are these the immoral ones? Or is it an entire society, religious and secular, who is immoral? A society who denies her the open, honest and respectable right to have a husband? Who really is immoral? Here Jesus Himself railed against the religious leaders of his day. Woe unto you scribes and Pharisees, hypocrites. He indicted them for having omitted the wait. Here, matters of the law, judgement, mercy, and faith.
1:22:48 So should our social and religious leaders be called into account for their immoral actions. First Timothy chapter 4 verses one through 3 states. Now the Spirit speaks expressly that in the latter times some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits and doctrines of devils, speaking lies in hypocrisy, having their conscience seared with a hot iron, forbidding to Mary. So the unscriptural limiting of marriage to monogamy forbids the scriptural marriage of many women. According to Paul, this sad and ungodly teaching is a doctrine of devils. Shame on Christendom and Mormondum for their spiritual arrogance and evil presumption to condemn what God Himself has ordained, and for the tremendous immoral repercussions of their godless teaching. Wow.
1:23:42 In conclusion, the last one is again from Adriana Blake, the attorney. She says the decision to enter a plural marriage will require courage. Friends and family may be discouraging. It seems to be an element of human nature that we are not willing to allow our friends to seek a solution to a problem in their lives that is different from the one we have chosen for ourselves. The first Cavalry men through the pass is the one that gets all the arrows, goes the old saying. Pioneers in any endeavor are always targets for criticism. However, the rewards can be great. Perhaps this book will make your choices and your decision easier because he's basically advocating you know what? Oh, there's all sorts of legal and other risks and hazards. This is a great omission.
1:24:35 This is a great sin of omission and we need to repent as a people so. Absolutely. You know, I, I'll say this too, I, I don't, while certainly there's some, some legal intricacies, right, that have to be navigated, right, that I've, that I've dealt with as far as, you know, OK, if there's a will, that sort of thing, spelling that out, beneficiaries on life insurance policies, those sorts of things, by and large, it, the legalities aren't what they used to be. And quite frankly, none of us these days really have to worry about anyone coming to take our kids over this right? If you're not a dirtbag.
1:25:20 And you're not days anymore. Right, right. If you're not a dirtbag and you're not abusing your kids, chances are you're going to be just fine. And likewise, and you know, this is something I saw personally with with both of my wives was there is the the fiercest push back will come from those who are closer to you, closest to you. That's just what it is. But I'll say this. One of my mother in I did enjoy it a little bit that for six hours because I could tell everything was really awkward for her.
1:26:22 But afterwards, I think there was a softening, right? There was a softening that happened towards towards the other wife that was I didn't see coming, right? I'm not saying everybody's the best of friends or whatever right now, but typically once somebody that cares about you finds that, hey, this is what makes me happy, right? And this is, you know, what I have chosen, those things tend to loosen up a little bit. And so I would just say if, if you're pulled in this direction, go in with your eyes wide open, right? Don't, don't have on rolls, rose colored glasses and think, oh, everything will just fall into place and it'll be OK and, and whatnot.
1:27:10 Understand that if you're a dude who who feels this, feels that call from the correct place, which is your heart, gentlemen, and you're, you know, a woman who, who desires this form of life. I mean, go for it. We only get one shot at this thing. And if, if it's what makes you happy, great. And to those who who think, you know, don't want to do this, I'm not telling you you have to do it. I'm not telling you you even have to condone my lifestyle. I don't care. I'm secure enough in my, in what I've done. And so this shouldn't be a threat to anybody who doesn't want to join in.
1:27:54 We're not, we are not out there banging for litigation to make this the only valid marriage system. That's not what we're out for. We just want to live and, and be left alone to, to live to the dictates of our own conscience. I guess right at the end of the day, that's, that's just what we're after. But I think I think the times are coming where this will be more socially accepted than ever before. So. So, yeah, marriage let's let's look at the term because I mean, it's, it's one of those things that most people like you don't need to define or qualify the term marriage because it's just familiar and like ubiquitous, right?
1:28:37 It's everywhere. However, living in the modern USA, we have certain traditions that have become taken for granted as being required for a marriage to be legitimate. Specifically, I'm talking about marriage licenses. Have you ever considered the questions, Are marriage licenses required for a marriage to be a legitimate in God's eyes? No. Are marriage licenses an eternal principle? So let's look at a brief let's let's brief look into the history and development of marriage. It's kind of surprising if you haven't studied and and thought about this before. So in the LDS church, at least since 1890, the standard for whether or not a marriage is regarded as legitimate is whether a couple possesses a government issued marriage license, at least within the USA.
1:29:23 Biblically and historically, and even legally, this is a strange and arbitrary definition. Today, 10 states in the USA, namely Alabama, Colorado, Iowa, Kansas, Montana, Oklahoma, Rhode Island, South Carolina, Texas, and Utah, don't require a couple to obtain a marriage license to be considered illegally and lawfully married. In these states, all that is legally required for a couple is to publicly say that they are married to each other and to cohabit with each other. The legal term for such a marriage is a common law marriage. Being born and raised LDS, when I first learned about this fact I was shocked. But if you think about it, it makes sense. Marriage in the family predate all government.
1:30:05 Adam and Eve didn't get permission from the government or a marriage license. Like. Hello. OK so you might be thinking so if a state issued marriage license isn't a God ordained requirement for a legitimate marriage, surely at least a religious ceremony is required right? So question, what came first, the marriage of Adam and Eve or the founding of the first church? What about cultures that don't have organized religion involved with marriage? Does that make them all guilty of adultery? For example, among Native Americans prior to European colonization, government was a very fluid and uncentralized concept. When a man and woman decided to be married, they didn't ask the chief or anybody to be married. They for permission.
1:30:47 Like they just had religious. I mean many tribes had religious ceremonies that surrounded the marriage to make it publicly known that the woman and man were starting a family. But if a couple eloped, IE ran off into the woods and came back announcing that they were now married, it was just accepted as lawfully binding, as if it was accompanied by the most elaborate religious ceremony and celebration. Would these marriages be less legitimate in God's eyes because they lacked a government issued paper, document or ecclesiastical endorsement? Absolutely not. Scripturally speaking, I believe it's self-evident that what constitutes a legitimate marriage in God's sight is along the same lines as a common law marriage.
1:31:30 That a woman not be married or espoused to another living man, that she and her husband consider themselves married to each other and are faithful to another, and that they have conjugal relations with each other, nothing more or less. Now there is a difference between marriage and sealing. OK, so this book is about polygamy, the marriage. As Mormons, we know that there is much more to marriage than just marriage. It's it's about the sealing, right? So, but, but, but The thing is, whether a marriage is sealed or not doesn't matter if it it doesn't change whether or not it's a marriage or not, right?
1:32:16 So just because a marriage is not sealed doesn't make it an adultery. I mean, you look at all of the people who have been married today and all throughout history that didn't get it sealed by the priesthood. Are we ready? Are we really, like serious? Would would we? Would anybody seriously consider accusing all of those marriages of being adultery? No, because they will. No, right? So marriage is marriage if a marriage, if a monogamous marriage is a legitimate marriage and acceptable in God's sight by those qualifications outlined above, why not a plural marriage? It absolutely is.
1:32:58 Yeah. So. So in Doctrine Covenant section 132, verse 15, the Scripture, this revelation does clarify that if a man marry him a wife in the world and he marry her not by me nor by my word and the covenant with her, so long as he is in the world and she with him. Their covenant and marriage are not a force when they are dead and when they are out of the world. Therefore they are not bound by any law when they are out of the world. So if you want a marriage to last beyond this world into eternity, it must meet additional requirements. Just this applies to monogamous marriages, applies to polygamous marriages. So just like so if if a monogamous marriage isn't sealed for eternity, it doesn't make the marriage adulterous. If a polygamous marriage even isn't sealed for eternity, it doesn't make that marriage relationship adulterous. Because here's the thing dude.
1:33:46 There are polygamous groups, Mormon polygamous groups, who think that if you get married not by their dude that you're adult, then then you're an adulterer. That's like the LDS church would accuse anybody who is married without their priesthood and authority of adultery. There are polygamous and the and the like. What's worse, stupidity or hypocrisy? Like I, I think God has just AI feel like God detests hypocrisy above any other type of sin out there. Like hypocrisy just really is a problem. And so like as fundamentalist, we have to be real careful that we don't fall into the same erroneous thinking as the LDS church has. So if so, just moving on and some of my notes. If a marriage is to last beyond this world into eternity, it must be additional requirements applies to monogamous and polygamous marriages.
1:34:46 If a polygamous marriage isn't sealed for eternity, it doesn't make that marriage relationship adulterous. So, so if a monogamous couple, one is faithful to each other, two, builds a celestial quality marriage relationship, and three desires and is worthy to receive the sealing ordinance by proper authority, yet hasn't had that opportunity to receive the ordinance. Maybe they were raised Baptist or Catholic or whatever, or maybe they just live in a group that has lost the priesthood. You know, I think that's a very real thing too. Would the God you worship deprive that couple, that monocamous couple of the blessing of eternal marriage and damned them to singlehood, apart from each other for eternity? Or would the God that you worship provide them with that opportunity, either in this life or the next, to comply with the ordinances if they're worthy in every other way? So that's applied to A and the crux of the matter, and this is maybe primarily directed more to the LDS audience here. If a polygamous man and his wives are not faithful to each other, one, or excuse me, are faithful to each other two, build a celestial quality marriage relationship among each other.
1:36:03 Three desire and are worthy to receive the ceiling ordinance by proper authority 4 but yet haven't had that opportunity to receive that ordinance by proper authority in this lifetime. Because even if you're LDS, if you think that it has to have have the proper priesthood authority to be to be legitimate, it still doesn't make it. Would the God that you worship deprive that plural family of the blessing of eternal life and damned them to singlehood apart from each other for eternity? Or would God provide them with an opportunity either in this life or the next to comply with the ordinances if they're worthy in every other way? So a plural marriage relationship, even if it's not sealed by proper authority or or entered into with a priesthood ordinance, it can't be called adultery by any scriptural or rational definition of the term. I, I just, I think I've just proven that. And there's a scripture in the, in the Old Testament, Exodus chapter 20, it well, of course we know the 10 commandments. Thou shalt not bear false witness against thy neighbor. But then in Deuteronomy, it actually spells out that if you make false so it and the judges shall make diligent inquisition. And behold, if the witness be a false witness and have testified falsely against his brother, then shall you do unto him as he had thought to have done unto his brother. So shall thou put the evil away from among you. That's Deuteronomy chapter 19, verses 18 and 19. OK, so what's?
1:37:34 So basically, if you make a false accusation, what's the penalty? It's whatever the penalty was going to be for the sin that you're making the accusation. Right. What is the penalty? What is the biblical penalty for adultery? Or, yeah, for adultery. That man that committeth adultery with another man's wife, even he that committeth adultery with his neighbor's wife, the adulterer and the adulteress shall surely be put to death. So the biblical penalty for adultery is death, and therefore the biblical penalty for falsely accusing anyone of adultery is death for the accusers. So this is a very serious thing.
1:38:16 So of course we don't. I'm not suggesting that we, you know, start killing anybody who falsely accuses people of committing adultery, but I mean, it's and our governments like that just would not fly. Our governments don't enforce the biblical law, but I believe that God is interested in our day and he's watching. And, and so even if our government doesn't enforce the biblical laws, I think that they're there for a reason. And Christ himself warned that with whatever judgement you judge, you shall be judged. Matthews Chapter 7, verse 2. So in other words, wise people would be very reluctant to judge the relationship choices of sincere consenting adults. And that goes for LDS Mormons.
1:39:03 That goes for, you know, fundamentalists who think that only their guys priesthood is legitimate. Like this just goes all the way across. The last thing I want to cover is Jacob chapter 2, because this is the only scriptural place that that, that this idea of monogamy is, is even a thing. So it's interesting that the the word chastity is very rare. It it only appears like three times in the New Testament in the King James Version from our our modern kind of puritanical world Western worldview, the word chastity is almost exclusively tied to the sexual connotation of virginity or celibacy.
1:39:55 But from a Hebrew perspective, the Hebrew worldview has much more context and nuance. So the the the in verse 27 of Jacob chapter 2, we find that the restriction from practicing polygamy was actually limited to the people present at the meeting where Jacob is addressing them. Because he says, But wherefore, my brethren, hear me hearken to the word of the Lord? There shall not any man among you have, save it be one wife and concubines. He shall have none. So to apply this Scripture beyond this intended scope is just untextually supported. In verse 30, Jacob includes the caveat. For if I will, saith the Lord of hosts, phrase up seed unto me, I will command my people to live it, otherwise they shall hearken unto these things. Can you think of a single other commandment God's ever given where he's included a caveat or exception? Like the fact he did so in this case is pretty much proof that monogamy is not an eternal Prince of truth or a natural state.
1:40:54 It was a commandment specific to this limited group of Nephites, and it was required for them to obey it until it was rescinded, IE until God commanded otherwise. Right? Also also worth mentioning in this verse chapter 30 if for anybody who might have had the thinking like I mean this is how I was raised. I was raised LDS and and so anyone who thinks that complegamy is the same thing as adultery unless commanded by God. Let's try a word replacement and see what happens for if I will say if the Lord of hosts raise up seed unto me, I will command my people to commit adultery. Otherwise they shall harden these things. Like sometimes God can give commandments that defy our limited wisdom and and understanding.
1:41:39 But can you point to a single instance in all of scripture where God commanded a man to violate a moral absolute? Adultery is a moral absolute. The God of Abraham, Jacob don't doesn't command anyone to violate a moral absolute. Therefore, Jacob too actually proves that monogamy is not a moral absolute. Very good, I like it. And then the last thing point on this is that repeatedly throughout the Book of Mormon, the authors note that the Nephites obeyed the Law of Moses. What almost all modern Mormons forget is the fact that the Law of Moses requires polygamy under certain circumstances.
1:42:19 Right. The Jacobs restriction of the specific group of Nephites to monogamy is a singular anomaly, an exception to the rule of polygamy, which was the natural state for all other people who live the Law of Moses. Interesting. Oh, that's a juicy nugget to chew on. You know, because I never made, I never made the connection with polygamy to the law of Moses. But they are instructed to keep that many times in the Book of Mormon. And that would be, that would be one of those things. Yeah, until of course, until it Christ comes and then it says the law of Moses is done away in me and it should not expedite you should live anymore. But up to that point, these guys were some of the best Jews in in, you know, outside of Judea, right?
1:43:06 You know that they were very faithful at living the law of Moses. Yeah, so puts a new connotation on it to those who like to use Jacob too. To beat, beat Go got plural marriage over the head. Well, and the other thing I don't have. Maybe I can find the reference real quick. Do you remember what Lehi says? The the point when God LED Lehigh and his family out of Jerusalem? You remember why? Do I remember what? Sorry. What, Why? Why did Lehigh say God was instructing him to take his family out of Jerusalem? Wasn't it because he was going to be killed? Well, that was definitely part of it. But this the the verse and I'll when I say I think you'll recognize it, he says to raise up a righteous seed. Oh, that's right.
1:43:57 OK, yeah, Yep. And what? Does Jacob chapter 2 verse 30 say? To raise up a righteous seed. If I will say that the Lord of hosts raise up seed unto me, I will command my people, otherwise they shall hearken unto these things. Yeah, no, no, it's definitely there. I did an episode with Jacob the Dream that really, really showed, you know it, there's a lot of implications there that polygamy was going on in the Book of Mormon as we should expect to see, right? Even some stuff that that showed that Lehigh was most likely a polygamist.
1:44:42 I can't remember what those were off the top of my head. I have to go back and listen but. So I, I can tell you, I can tell you that. So Lehigh, remember when the, they're on the boat, they're, they're coming across this ocean and they like Lehman and Lehmi will just go stupid and they tie the you know, Nephi and, and, and, and Nephi is describing his mother and it says and my mother and he says my parents. So referring to Lehigh and Soraya were weighed down with their Gray hairs almost unto death, right? It was, it was, it was.
1:45:26 And and then it says, and Jacob and Joseph, their mother did suffer exceedingly. That's right, because she, you couldn't give them milk to nurse, right? Like, like that's kind of that's pretty. I mean, it doesn't say it, but it's pretty darn. It's pretty darn conclusive, isn't it? Yeah. No, no, I think it, I think it's there throughout, certainly in Mormonism, obviously more than 132. It's in, it's in the Old Testament, it's in the New Testament. It's it's it really is kind of ubiquitous within the the Christian Hebraic tradition, whether we want it to be or not.
1:46:12 It's only our our our modern sensibilities, I think that make it seem so icky. Yeah. And I again, there's there's. So much good like by their fruits you shall know them. And so, yeah, Warren Jeffs, his fruits expose him as an evil SOB, right? And but the sad thing is because he was because everybody doesn't like polygamy already. And he was do practicing polygamy, it kind of gives everybody a pass to equate. And so like he did such a disservice to to truth and to righteousness. And, and, and the other thing is with like with these you, you look at a guy.
1:47:06 Well, I mean you and there's other guys that we know. I'm not going to drop any names, but I know, I, I personally know dozens. Some of the best men alive breathe, drawing breath, breathing oxygen right now. And they are living this principle. And so you look by their fruits, you shall know them well, Yeah. And if the fruit is good, let's let's give credit where it's due And, and so like these are these are really important things to consider. Joseph Smith in he gave a speech on August 27th, 1843. He says those who limit the designs of God as concerted by the Grand Council of Heaven cannot obtain the knowledge of God.
1:47:51 And I do not know, but I may say they will drink in the damnation of their souls. All those who are disposed to set up stakes for the Almighty will come short of the glory of God to become a joint heir of the air of the Son. A man must put away all his traditions. We look at so many traditions like till marriage, till death do us part. You look at the other traditions of people infallibility and you look and like as Mormons, we're like, there's a temptation to be like, man, those guys are so dumb and so ignorant and ill informed and all this and we, and, and yet what traditions have we not given up?
1:48:35 And I would say this tradition of marriage is a huge, massive, massive one. We need to look at, we need to revisit our traditions, including how, what that what's a legitimate marriage look like. And we need to just realize that these are the things that God expects of us. And if we want to progress and be like my God, we have to put away all of the things that are ungod like within us. Absolutely. I'm a guy who likes living in the time I'm living in genuinely, right.
1:49:20 I enjoyed moving without pulling a hand cart or riding in the back of a wagon. I really did. Air conditioning is awesome, right? Having said that, sometimes we can think that we're so far advanced that we trick ourselves out of the most basic of things, right? I've always said having as many kids as I've had, I firmly believe you could stick a group of boys and a group of girls on an island and there's predictable outcomes. The girls will pick flowers and the boys will hit each other with sticks and laugh.
1:50:03 That's just all there is to. It and maybe throw rocks at the girls. Right, yes, yes, by violin. Right, right, right. It's, it's just kind of a, a natural outgrowth of, of things, but also our, our, the way we conduct our families, the way we, we define marriage. We're trying to, we're trying to put in a square peg into a round hole and it doesn't fit and it doesn't work and it creates anxiety and it creates all sorts of problems.
1:50:45 And again, I'm not saying that plural marriage is for everybody. So if, if you have those feelings, I'm not saying that that plural marriage is going to solve all those. And if you don't feel that call, I'll be the first one to say don't do it right? Don't do it. If you don't feel called to it, do not do this. And if your, if your first marriage isn't healthy, do not do this. Adding, adding another marriage thinking we'll fix the first one. That is dumb. I, I have no, no other words for it, right? But for those that do it, it is a call back in some ways to certain, I don't know, factory default settings.
1:51:35 And, and for those of us who feel that, I think it's incumbent upon us that are living it or are in favor of it to, to, to be a little more bold and just saying, you know what? My family is every bit as legitimate as yours and stand your ground on that. Nobody can take that from you. They can try, they can rail. I mean, they can do all sorts of, you know, talking and whatever. But the end of the day, if it makes you happy, I mean, that's what it's about. And I believe it's divinely sanctioned. It's certainly been a blessing in my life. I, I'll be honest, as a guy, I pray every day and I work every day that I might be worthy of my wife. And that's just the truth of it.
1:52:28 And if there's one common thing that I've seen is that the guys who do this and do it well often kind of feel some similar feelings. And it takes work, but it's worth it 100%. But anyway, Taylor, what do you got, man? Oh bro, that was, I think enough. There's Part 2. I'm tired, it's late. I think I've said my piece. I just, I guess I hope that it, you know, it's CS Lewis's like, you know, good logic must exist, if for no other reason than to answer bad logic. I think there's a lot of bad logic out there maligning and just unjustly vilifying this sacred and honorable practice. And so I hope that what we've covered tonight and, and and Part 1 can help those of us who do have this testimony to be, like you said, a little more bold and, and not and to hold our heads high and to just embrace it, own it. This is this is our gospel.
1:53:38 This is this is what we claim to have a testimony is truth of God. So let's start acting like it. Let's not be wussy about it. Absolutely dude. Good stuff as always. Let's. Let's bless as many women and children as we are reasonably capable of. That's right. Absolutely, dude. Good stuff. Name of the book again was The Great Omission by Clyde Pilkington. Is that right? That is correct. And it's available on Amazon or you can just Google. I think there's if you wanted bulk orders, there's that available as well. So Clyde Elkington, Junior. Yep, and I and I got a link on the first episode to the Amazon page, so I'll I'll throw that on there. Again, I've never met the man, but he's got to thank me at some point.
1:54:25 Just a little letter saying thanks for pimping my book bro. That's all so. Hey, we need to work that out in advance, Dave. What were we thinking? I know, I know. I mean, look, I mean, don't get me wrong, this podcast has netted about 300 bucks. I'm just saying, you know, Clyde, you, if you're out there, if you're listening, help a brother out. That's all I'm saying. You, you won't. But you know, really if, if, if I could meet the guy, just shake his hand because I think it's a great, a great book that he's put together. And, and dude, he did his homework, right. All those footnotes. Dude did his homework. So anyway, all right, dude. Well, that was good stuff. Oh yeah.
1:55:09 All right. Well, thank you soon. All right. Bye everybody. The.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox