Episode #148: Schisms & Splinter Groups In Ancient Christianity & Connection To The Modern Mormon Landscape
Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.
Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products
Sometimes as people when we encounter a problem, we tend to look forward to try to get perspective on the issue we are facing. Now that’s not a bad thing, sometimeshowever the perspective we desire is found behind us. Now let’s look at Mormonism. Could it be that perhaps other religious traditions have gone through something similar that Mormonism has with splits from the mainstream that has led to different groups and churches? Well today I have Justin Francom on to talk about the split that happened in early Christianity that led to the development of what is today known as Eastern Orthodox Christianity. In our conversation we cover the history of the early Christian church, then move on to discuss the reasons and doctrinal disagreements that precipitated the split, we then draw some very interesting connections between the split that happened almost 2,000 years ago to what has happened to Mormonism today that should give us the perspective we need to move forward. Finaly we wrap up by talking about opportunities moving forward that just might help the various groups and independents find common ground while allowing us to disagree more agreeably. That and more on this episode of the MRP.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:00 Sometimes as people, when we encounter a problem, we tend to look forward and try to get perspective on the issue we are facing. Now that's not a bad thing, but sometimes however, the perspective we desire is found behind us. Now let's look at Mormonism. Could it be that perhaps other religious traditions have gone through something similar that Mormonism has with splits from the mainstream that has led to different groups and churches? Well, today I have Justin Frankamon to talk about the split that happened in early Christianity that led to the development of what today is known as Eastern Orthodox Christianity. In our conversation, we cover the history of the early Christian Church, then move on to discuss the reasons and doctrinal disagreements that precipitated that split. We then draw very interesting connections between the split that happened almost 2000 years ago to what has happened in Mormonism today.
0:50 That should give us the perspective we need to move forward. Finally, we wrap up by talking about the opportunities moving forward that just might help the various groups and independents find common ground while allowing us to disagree more agreeably. And that's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. So a few weeks back, I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running. Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page or click the link in this episode show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups, and water bottles, all with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU. But you should definitely go check that out now. This is just the beginning.
1:47 In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now, all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast. So head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode show notes and get yours today. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Dude this is the first one we've done in person. Yeah.
2:42 I was thinking about that today. I was like, wait, have I done with one with him in person? And I don't think we ever have. I think by the time I think the first one we started doing, you were still up there in Morgan. Yeah, I was in Utah still. You were in Utah and then and then you were like out to Missouri like months after that, right? So everything after that had been had been pretty much online. So yeah, kind of a momentous opportunity here. First one in person. Right, pretty fun. So dude, when you hit me up about this, this one particular subject, I found it fascinating and I found it fascinating because it, it has some parallels to us today, right? And I think it's very applicable. And I'm a big believer in, you know, we need to learn from those things because if we don't, we're going to do the same crap.
3:39 Because I don't believe humanity changes a ton. It changes a little bit, but those same habits, those same. Human nature. Doesn't change. It doesn't change, right? But anyway, so you went deep into like the Eastern Orthodox Church and the Catholic Church and the split that happened there, right? Right. All right, go ahead. OK, well, I guess first, you know, I maybe I should share why I started looking into it. I was looking at kind of I'm, I'm usually looking at kind of big picture things and big picture, I was wondering what's going on with Mormonism and fundamentalism. Like, why can't we all get along? It was one of those kind of questions. That that I've been.
4:24 Pondering for a long time, and I had a dream one night after pondering that specific, those kind of specific questions. And in that dream, there's a lot of weird stuff going on. But primarily what I remember at the very end of the dream was I was looking for something and something had some answers that could explain what's happened with Mormonism. And I was, that's what I was looking for, right? And so I was going after it. And at the very, very end of the dream, right before I woke up, I find out that I'm looking for Peter, Peter, you know, the apostle Peter.
5:04 And I didn't, I woke up and like, I don't know what that means. What does that mean? Peter, what's, what's Peter have to do with anything? And I was talking with a friend about it and I chaired the dream a little bit. And he suggested, well, have you ever looked into the Eastern Orthodox Church? And I've, I've, I've, I'm pretty familiar with Catholicism and, and Catholic theology, but I've, I've like, I don't really know anything about the Orthodox Church actually. Isn't that a Russian only church? And so I started doing some research and it just blew me. It blew me away. It just really blew me away. And I found a lot of really, really cool things, so. So what? What'd you find? I mean, I guess we should start at the beginning, right?
5:44 Right, right. So now I guess I should be clear. I am not an expert in this history. I'm not, you know, most of the information I'm getting is, you know, you know, YouTube and books written by various, you know, well, they call Saints and things. And so I don't claim to be an absolute expert in this, right? But I, I found some stuff that's very applicable to Mormonism, right? And that's what I wanted to focus on is the application into, into Mormonism more so than necessarily like, 'cause I'm not really qualified to speak on, you know, the Eastern Orthodox theology. I'm.
6:25 Not I. I'm just a I'm just a guy. Into this, right. So, so maybe not so much and correct me if I'm wrong here, not so much the theology versus the splits that happened, right? Right. So that was what was really fascinating. So I, it was kind of under the presumption that you got the Catholic Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church and the Eastern Orthodox Church is basically Russian and a Russian state church. And, you know, I, I really didn't know a whole lot about it. And so I started doing some research and I find out that the Eastern Orthodox Church really encompasses a whole body of churches. It's not just the Russian, there's, there's a Greek Orthodox, there's Ukrainian Orthodox, there's Romanian Orthodox, there's just all these different churches. And to be honest, it's hard to talk about them specifically because, well, in general, because they're different, but they all fall under the heading of the Eastern Orthodox Church and they all recognize each other. And that was the first thing that really kind of blew me away was the organizational structure of that. OK, so let me ask some questions about that real quick, 'cause if there's one thing, Mormons and Catholics, kind of especially LDS folks, one thing that they have in common is that they're highly organized, higher, highly hierarchical, right? So with an Eastern Orthodox, is there one guy that they they all say this dude's above reproach, so to speak, or not necessarily above reproach, but this dude,
7:55 when he talks, he's the boss. Right. And that's what was surprising because no, OK, I assume there must have been, I, I assumed it must probably be some guy in Russia, right? But it turns out that the the Orthodox Church has patriarchs and these patriarchs are supervisory over a variety of different churches which are headed up by bishops. And their version of the history of, of Christianity is that this is the original structure, that Peter and the original apostles were basically kind of in an advisory role. And they set up independent churches with bishops. And their role was more of kind of a directing role, but the churches were kind of independent. So it was kind of like a franchise model. Yeah, like a franchise.
8:48 And I thought that was kind of fascinating because I mean, I look at the writings of of Paul, for example, and we think of Paul as an apostle. And yet in all the writings of Paul, you don't really see Paul like saying, hey, get get this stuff in order or I'm going to come back and I'm going to defrock you all. I'm going to. We're going to revoke your franchise. Defrock is not a bad word. You're right. You gotta make sure you pronounce all the syllables, but it's not a bad word. Yeah. And so, you know, you look at Paul's writings and he's he's teaching, but he's teaching through exhortation. He's appealing to truth. And but what he's not doing is he's not threatening, He's not exercising what we would consider Mormonism, like ecclesiastical authority, like, hey, I'm the boss, you have to do what I say.
9:36 OK. And you see the relationship with the churches. The churches seem to be writing in questions. They, they, it's a position based off of respect. The bishops of these churches respect the apostles. And so therefore they're going to them for help. But they're not being like it doesn't to me. When I read, when I read the New Testament and all those epistles, it doesn't appear to me that it's focused on a hierarchical authority as much as it is giving guidance and direction. Well, no. And and even if it was hierarchical in nature, Paul isn't where the hierarchy should stop. If that was the case, it should be Peter, right? Right, right.
10:17 And, you know, Paul talks about wanting to come and visit these churches, but why does he want to visit that? He, it sounds to me like when I was a missionary, you want to go back to those areas where you served and, and reconnect with those people because you fall in love with them. It's based off of that. It's not so much of as like, hey, I'm the boss and I want to come and I want to, you know, get you guys going better. Clearly Paul realized there's some issues here with some of these churches, but his motivation and all of that, it seems to be through exhortation, through patients, through long-suffering. Does that sound familiar? Right. Yeah. And to me, a perspective of the priesthood that is based off of not coercion, but through the exhortation and patience, long service, stuff like that, that actually lines up, I think, with Mormon theology and the vision I think Joseph Smith had on how the church was in, you know, supposed to be organized and how priesthood authority is supposed to be exercised. Not as a not as a whip, not as a like a coercion, no force. And so that was interesting right away. And now, so the Orthodox perspective, the orthodox history is that basically the apostle set up these churches, these franchises, as you might say, and with these bishops that were in charge of their the bishops were the the ones in charge.
11:40 And then when the apostles are all martyred and there's none left, the bishops still have authority. They've been ordained by these apostles to leave these congregations. And so based off of that authority they received from the apostles, they continue to do so. And as new churches are formed, you know, new bishops are ordained. And as the church starts spreading and growing, they realize that, well, it's a little bit hard organizationally to keep things. You want a certain amount of what the LDS Church would call concordance. And so you see these metropolitans and patriarchs to the church that are basically heads over areas, you know, like district, district, like area authorities in the LDS Church might be kind of seen as. Right.
12:36 Oh, it's kind of lightly correlated. Lightly correlated, but still very, it seems very lightly correlated. And without having apostles, when they come up with theological issues, they don't have anybody to turn to anymore at the way I see it, right? And so the solution they came up with is we're going to take our patriarchs and we're going to have our patriarchs all get together. These bishops that are recognizes exemplatory over maybe some of the other bishops in that area that represent the other bishops in the in various areas. And they would get together and have councils to try to hammer out theological. Points and issues. And I think that's where we get, that's basically where we get like the Nicean Creed and it was a, we've got theological issues coming up.
13:26 We can't appeal to the apostles anymore. And they basically determined among themselves that if we get together and we try to figure this stuff out, then what we come up with stands. And they kind of all agreed that they'll come together. They'll the decisions will be made and those decisions will stand throughout the other churches. But there was one church in particular that was a little bit different, just a little bit different, and that was the church in Rome. Because by tradition, that's where Peter Peter was that. Was the seed of Peter. That was where Peter was before he was martyred. And so the Bishop in Rome was what they what they say is first among equals.
14:13 OK. And from what having read this various orthodox writings on what they understand that to mean, their understanding of that basically seems to be what we would call presiding. OK. It's not that Peter has executive, it's not that the the Bishop in Rome has executive authority over the other bishops in the council. He just is the has a special place of honor and is basically responsible for the organization. So it's a lot like what we'd say Mormonism would be presiding, you know, and somebody presiding in a council or in a in a even just a general sense with, you know, Robert Rules. You have somebody who's presiding over a meeting their job.
14:56 They don't get extra votes. Often times they actually abstain, abstain from that in order to appear neutral so that they can unbiasedly help organize the decisions that need to be made and the council that needs to happen. So their perspective was the Bishop in Rome had a special position as a first among equals. So it looks like the church for quite a while kind of operated under this pattern, which is actually kind of pretty cool. It's very it it's, it's it's structured and organized. But in another way, it's kind of anarchistic because, you know, ultimately bishops, even individual bishops still held authority over their respective churches.
15:44 But the, the bigger the issues that would be deferred to these councils that would happen. And that's where we get things like, like I said, and I seen the, the various creeds were were brought and the theology's kind of hammered out by these guys coming together. So all was good for a while. But every once in a while there were issues. And it looks like to me that a lot of these issues had to do with the ordaining of bishops. So the church in Antioch might ordain a new Bishop and then the church in Rome says, hey, we don't really like that. We don't think that guy's qualified. We don't think he should have ordained him. We got issue with that. And and then there were also more minor theological things that would happen and it would cause something that they'd call schism. And a schism is basically where.
16:35 So prior to this, even though the churches are all independent, basically they you'd say the priesthood was recognized across all the of across all the churches. So a priest in one church could be traveling in another church, and they could exercise their priestly authority while visiting that other church, and that other church would recognize it. Yeah. OK. And then and then deference would be given to the Bishop that was in in that thing. Right. But when schisms occurred, various churches would have, and it's complex relations. So, so the church in Rome might say we're in schism with the church in Antioch, but we're not in schism with the with the church in Jerusalem. And the church in Jerusalem says we're fine with Antioch, but we're also fine with Rome.
17:20 And so you got these weird kind of relationships going on, but it looks like over time they basically would work it out. Schisms would resolve, and they'd come back together again over time. Let me let me ask a question here, Let me play because look, you and I are both guys who who don't necessarily subscribe to the one man doctrine, right? We see it as being being one of those things that gives opportunity to abuses. Now, I've looked at this a couple of times. I mean, I looked at this hard before I settled on on this side of it because I think that we have to acknowledge that some bad things can happen without a one man either. Oh, absolutely.
18:08 Right. Yeah. Because because let's just say that the church in Antioch ordained a Warren Jeffs kind of guy, Right. Right. And that dude is hurting people. But if those other churches don't necessarily hold authority, if there's not somebody to put that guy in to check, how does that work, right? Do you just write that church off and be like, sucks to be them, right? Yeah, well, it looks like that kind of was the attitude. So, OK, the church in Antioch, they've gone astray. We're going to stop recognizing them while they work that out. But the interesting thing is over time and then we're talking big time, right?
18:50 And then we're not just talking like five years later necessarily, but over the course of hundreds of years, they come back together again. That stuff gets resolved. Or basically, I, I suppose you eventually you reap what you sow, right? So if you've got a war in Jeffs, if Antioch's got a war in Jeffs type guy, eventually their congregation's going to realize something's off. This isn't right. There's a, the abuses are going to start. The bad fruit is going to start up here. And with that bad fruit, you're going to see a rejection of whatever caused that bad fruit. And things eventually can reharmonize. And they can. Oh, yeah, we made it. You're right. We made a mistake about that guy. Or hey, you know what? Turns out that guy wasn't so bad.
19:32 And you know, he came back in harmony again. OK. So with that, I mean, if you look at the history, typically this the, the big, the great schism was between the church in Rome and then all of the other churches and it's over a doctrine called Filioque, which is it seems weird looking at when I first was researching this, it didn't make sense to me because I'm like, is this really that big of a doctrinal issue to schism over? And the the idea of Filioque is in the Nicene Creed. They determine that the Holy Ghost emanates from the Father.
20:13 Pretty simple, right? Well. The cat, the Romans, the Roman Church and their their patriarch decided that actually the Holy Ghost emanates from the Father and from the Son. Was this before or after like then the sea and creed and the other? Council after after then I see and creed this is this is. Interesting, right? Because in theory, if they were really believers in the Trinity, you say tomato, I say tomato, right? They're the same dude, right? Which makes this schism all the more interesting. Exactly. And that's the that's the weird thing is if you look at the orthodox doctrine today, they're not really at odds with that type of a theology.
20:59 They don't endorse it explicitly, but they're also not necessarily opposed to it. So I'm like, well, why did they schism over it? Here's the fascinating thing. The real reason for the schism was because it was the Patriarch in Rome saying that he had authority to amend the Nicean Creed. Oh, OK, that's that's. What it really because they didn't actually have a new council and it was proposed by the Bishop in Rome that the Holy Ghost emanates from the Father and the Son. They they changed the Nicean Creed and the other churches. It wasn't so much about the doctrine that really I think upset them. I think what they were concerned about is like, well, why do you get to amend this creed that was created by our by a Council of Churches when you're just one church? Well, see, and this is the danger of a one man, right? Because you can obviously see that with, in this instance, the Roman church was like, no, our guy's the guy, right? Our guy is the guy that gets to dictate if any of these things get changed.
22:09 Right. And the other issue thing is at the time this was just a schism. It wasn't the Great Schism. It was just a schism, just like World War One wasn't World War One at the time. It was the Great War. Nobody was called it World War One, nobody was anticipating World War 2 and schisms were happening in the church. So at the time, it was just a schism and it was all the other churches kind of versus this, this Western church in Rome. Gotcha. And presumably it was a schism that would eventually be reconciled. OK. But it didn't. And what it looks like, and this is this I'm, I'm sharing this from the perspective of the Orthodox Church.
22:53 Sure, I can't, I can't assert the validity of any of this history. But what it looks like is the Roman Church started saying that their patriarch, their Pope, so to speak. Cause if the prior to this there's, there's various popes, right? The the Pope is just patriarch. Yeah, that's all Pope means. It's just patriarch, right? They started saying, well, he's not first among equals, He's he's, he's superior. And so other changes start happening instead of and instead of What normally happens with schism is that the the bad fruit eventually reconciles. The Roman Church starts doubling down. OK.
23:36 And some and it wasn't, it started with maybe the Filioque way, but over time there were other changes and differences that started appearing and and they became more and more separated. And I was listening to a Orthodox, I don't know what he was, Bishop, pastor, not pastor, priest or something talking about the subject. And he said that the really the the separation between the Catholic and the Orthodox didn't really happen with the Filioque. Way. That was just a schism when it really finally was a, a true separation happened with the sacking of Constantinople. And so this is basically when the Roman Church send and and the government in Rome sends military and that military goes and they sack Constantinople, which was the seat of the of the way.
24:35 I think it was. I think what appeared to be the basically at the time was like the seat of the of the Eastern Church. Right. And so it wasn't, it was no longer just a theological difference. They literally took up arms. They were according to accounts, right, these soldiers that were sent under this under this holy war type argument where, you know, they were sacking and pillaging and raping and. They went for it. They went for it, bad stuff. And that's really when it became more of a permanent schism. It was no longer a schism. Now it's the great schism and it's a completely inseparable, irreconcilable difference.
25:16 And, and then just over time, from what I can tell, the Orthodox Church has tried to hold to their traditions and you start seeing changes and, and, and innovations happening in the Catholic Church. What kind of innovations? Well, yeah, and I don't have the timing of all this, but consider some of these interesting things. One of them is forbidding marriage. Interesting. So this was fascinating to find out among the Orthodox if, if you, if a priest is not married when he's ordained, he's not allowed to marry because they see that as I, as you can understand, potentially problematic, like if you got a Bishop, an award who's single and he's the steward over all these single women.
26:04 I mean, there's. You're asking for trouble, Yeah. You're asking for trouble. There's opportunities for and who else would he would a priest potentially marry, right? However, in the Orthodox Church it's perfect and it it's common for priests to be married before they're ordained. Well, that's because I think of an injunction, Paul said. Right. If you're going to be a Bishop, you have to be the husband of at least one wife, and you have to have your family life in order. Right, Yeah. So the Orthodox kind of helped that the Catholic Church started saying actually we think there's some kind of a holiness, a greater holiness in not being married and we want our priests to be more holy. So priests are not allowed to be married, generally speaking. There might be a few exceptions here and there even today. But standard doctrine in in the Catholic Church, standard Canon or policy is that priests are not allowed to be married. And so I thought, well, that's an interesting difference. Well, yeah, that that carries some, right. I mean, within the LDS Church, it's you can't get married. It's that you can only be married once, right? But you see a parallel.
27:14 But there's a parallel, right? The split occurs essentially over marriage, right? And the regulation of that ordinance right now? This is kind of anecdotal, right? I'm not saying like it's a perfect parallel, but what's fascinating to me is you can see these similarities that are fascinating. So here's, here's another fascinating 1 Papal infallibility. The church in Rome says, starts saying, actually, you know what? Our Pope, our patriarch is infallible, incapable of being wrong in, in these in certain contexts, of course, right, right, right.
27:56 Otherwise it'd be too easy to debunk. You know, it's a fascinating thing. I have. I still have a good buddy who's Catholic. He lives back in Malden, MA, Right, Right. And he said, you Mormons are fascinating. And I said, well, why is that? And he says, well, you guys say that your prophets aren't infallible, but you treat him like he is. He's invaluable speaking. And, and in the Catholic Church, we say the Pope is infallible, but we don't treat him like he is right. It's an interesting thing, right? Because one thing you'll see throughout Mormonism, especially with the one manners, is that they pretty much treat him like he's he's infallible.
28:45 You know what they'll give Mormonism 1000 years or so and I'll bet the culture will shift too. Even it's already, you already see it starting to shift where there's a lot of technically completely committed true blue Mormons. They're starting to be like, well, I, I, for example, how many Mormons took the backs? Right. Right. And the excuses, well, he's only a prophet when he's speaking as a prophet. He's only infallible when he's speaking as a as a prophet. And so it kind of creates an excuse, right? And the Catholics have the same thing. They're they're the Pope is only infallible when he's acting in the, in the, in the role of the Pope. So a modern Catholic can excuse the Pope's behavior or teachings or things based off of Well, at the at that moment, he wasn't acting as.
29:45 But see, that leaves so much room, right? Too much room in my opinion, right, both on the Catholic side and the Mormon side. Because look, when Russell M Nelson came out and he sat in that chair and he said, you know, our only way out of this is for everyone to take the vaccine. And then he publishes that to all of his followers. What else are you supposed to take that ask, right? Is that, is that a, is that a revelation? Is that just counsel from a guy? Is that prophetic counsel? And So what we see is we we see these varying degrees of this. Right. And to me the point. The point is, why even make the assumption right? Why even make the assumption of infallibility? Right.
30:31 Because if if the assumption's only true in certain criteria, then it might as you might as well throw it out entirely, because you're going to have to decide ultimately what you should be doing regardless, even with the standards you should be deciding for yourself. Yeah. You should be getting your own witness, your own testimony of whether that is true or false. I can see that. The assumption of infallibility. Ultimately, to me it seems like a kind of cheap. Trick it is. It is. Right. And it creates a. It creates a certain amount of laziness. Well, sure it does, right? And because, let's face it, I don't care what anyone says, humans are wired to be somewhat lazy, right?
31:11 We want, you know, if we were to look at this from a purely primordial standpoint, our bodies are kind of engineered to take in as many calories as we can with the least amount of expenditure of calories to prevent starvation, right? And I think we do the same thing in this sort of instance, right? We want the most quote caloric intake of prophetic counsel we can get without doing much work ourselves. With the least amount. Of right. And, and I think it's a very similar kind of thing. And I think that makes humans very susceptible with that sort of thing. Right, absolutely.
31:51 And so the fascinating thing was the so in the Orthodox Church, so they don't believe in infallibility, so their patriarchs are not considered infallible. They that assumption isn't even there, which I'm like, wow, that's kind of cool actually. And the interesting thing is too ultimately we, we've got it right now, even though the Orthodox Church might not be as big as the Catholic Church, it has withstood the test of time. They are still here, which means they must be doing something right. You know, they might not have it all figured out, they might not have all of the truths of the restored Gospel, but but even organizationally, they must be doing something right because they they're still here and they are basically still united.
32:34 They still recognize the various churches that comprise the Orthodox Church, are still united and recognize each other. So, and that was my next question. So they do still recognize each other's authority. Yeah. So the Ukrainian church is totally cool with the Greek church. OK, Yeah. As far as I know, I, there might be some schism that I'm not at work 'cause I'm not getting, I'm not from this world. But even if there's a temporary schism right now, it's all being considered temporary. But, you know, Speaking of the schism, see, that's, that's another interesting parallel because early fundamentalism essentially is a schism and early fundamentalism also believed it was just a temporary schism.
33:15 You know, you look at the writings of, of, of the Woolies, They thought that they, well, it may not the right, but you know, Leslie Broadbent wrote a lot of what Woolies said and, and taught. And if you look at those teachings, the idea was that this is temporary. We're going to, we're going to end up back in with the mainstream church. Give. Give it a little while. Just, you know, give it a few years. Well in the mainstream church even said that right told told that meeting muster was in in the celestial room. Just keep your records. This is going to blow over in a few years. You're be brought right back in and everything's going to be cool. Right. And so the fascinating thing is the schism really became permanent with the Catholics and the Orthodox, from what I can tell, again with the sacking of Constantinople, right?
34:03 And I'm looking at this looking for parallels and I'm thinking, Oh, well, you know, the fundamentalists kind of split and at first they're split and theologically, doctrinally, you know, you know, these got we're, we're all at, on at ends with each other. We're all, you know, there's this conflict, but you know, with the short Creek rates. Right. And the Church's apparent support of the persecution of the fundamentalists. Right. All of a sudden it's no longer a temporary. All of a sudden it's like. You know it's not. Yeah, these are irreconcilable. It something becomes irreconcilable. Right. Right.
34:43 And that was another really fascinating parallel. So, you know, here's another interesting one. Changing the ordinances. This was another thing that happened. So traditionally, from what I understand, in the Orthodox Church, baptism, for example, is done through immersion. And that is still the standard, the standard in the Orthodox Church today. And they have exceptions, but the exceptions are basically just based off of, well, like, so like if a baby's born and the baby's sick and the baby's going to die, you can't really take a sick baby and baptize them by immersion, right?
35:28 There's certain situations where they decided it'd be better to baptize them with sprinkling of water than a full immersion that that's better than nothing. But the standard in New York black church is still baptism by immersion. Whereas the Catholic Church started saying, you know, they also probably had those initial exceptions, but over time, it became, hey, you know, sprinkling is a heck of a lot easier. You know, it's funny because in the change in in what they're doing now into the Salt Lake Temple, it was done under the the banner of efficiency, convenience. We want to get as many people through there as we can. So we're going to chunk up those rooms or they're going to be several different instruction rooms now rather than a select, you know, rather than a creation room and a garden room and all this.
36:21 So it can just be more efficient. Right. Yeah. So changing ordinances for efficiency, that was another of these differences that you start seeing happen between the Orthodox and the Catholics now. So obviously. So I, I mean, I got a list of a few things. So there's a forbidding marriage and papal infallibility. This overstepping of authority of the, the Pope being better than the other Pope, one man is an essential essentially rewriting what they, well, you search essentially kind of scripture, like the Orthodox consider like the creeds as, as scripture because a bunch of bishops came together and decided they, you know, an agreement on, on things.
37:05 But you can kind of see that as basically kind of changing scripture and, and changing the, the underlying theology. There's changing in ordinances. There's this priest of ordination. They changed the way that that they changed the ordination. Well, they didn't change the ordination, but there's issues of ordination because they've got the, well, maybe it's not exactly as black and white as that, but a lot of times even previous to the schisms, like I said, happened because of ordinations. Right. And concerns over whether that's authorized or not, right? And you certainly see a parallel in Mormonism and fundamentalism that way, whereas the LDS church would say you don't really have priesthood yet that ordinations.
37:54 Doesn't it's outside of the church, so we don't recognize it and God doesn't recognize. Right. If you are a Daniel son of Melchizedek, crease it. The LDS church is going to say no, no, that don't count. Right. So splitting over ordinations and, and then culminating in in basically war and, and again, like I said, you know, the Shore Creek raids even today, like before I was, before I became a fundamentalist, I was, I went with a friend of mine and we were protesting against the government's abuse of the FLDS in Texas. And it wasn't that we were friends of the FLDS in their theology and what they were doing, but we weren't friends of the government without any justifiable cause stepping in there and taking those children away from the parents and sending them away. And we're doing genetic testing on them to find out. I mean, you know, if if one of those women said that, yeah, I was being abused, I don't want to go back to my thanks, fine. You know, but that's not what the government did, right? They went in there and they went in there to break up families that didn't want to be broken up. Right.
39:04 And so me and my friend were protesting that even before it's just as Mormons and not as a religious issue but as a political issue. And we went to a jazz game where Houston was playing, and we were there to protest the government abuse and kid you not, we were literally being spit upon. Oh, I don't doubt it. We. Were literally being spit upon by by the general, by our own fellow Mormons as they were going to the game because they perceived me and my friend as fundamentalists. They assumed we were. And so that kind of antagonism, this justification of abusing and persecuting is really kind of undeniable as a, as a cultural promoted thing in the LDS church. And it up until recently it was largely even enforced through temple recommend interviews.
40:01 Right. Right where you're not worthy of a temple recommend if you associate with anybody that's that's you know. A fundamentalist. Really. Yeah, that wasn't the word they used, but that was why they added that question. Well, yeah, that's exactly why they added that question. That question doesn't come into being, I think, until right around Huber J Grant and Cause the Fundamentalist threat became very real all of a sudden. Right. And a policy like that suddenly creates a culture of persecution. Yeah, yeah, because let's face it, there's not anyone outside of Mormonism that's making claims to what we would consider keys of the priesthood, right?
40:43 They're not worried about you hanging out with a Baptist. They were worried about you hanging out with other Mormons. Right. Which really doesn't make sense because they'd have more in common with a fundamentalist than a Baptist. Unless you're trying to consolidate power. Yeah, yeah, exactly. And that kind of thing creates schism. It's not, it's not a good thing. It creates permanent schism. It breaks, it breaks the church apart again. The whole point of this research was like, why is this happening and and how do you prevent it? So I mean, so I guess that's that's the history. That's my understanding of the history. It's mostly that's probably an Orthodox perspective. I mean, I'm sure the Catholics have their own version of how and why that schism happened and maybe theirs is true. I don't.
41:33 I can't say one way or the other, but I tend to lean towards what the Orthodox Church saying making a lot of sense because we literally can see the exact same thing happened in Mormonism. Right. And outside of Orthodox, Catholic and Mormonism, there's really no other churches on the planet that claim priest authority. No, no, I mean, yeah, in in the Christian tradition, it's the three of us, right? Interesting. So as you looked at all this history, what do you think the overarching message message about it is? Well, I've got, I've got some ideas. OK, But maybe before I get into that, I think it might be it might be fun to share some of the interesting things I found about Orthodox theology.
42:23 That. I mean, because I, I, I did find beauty there. And I'm not, I'm not suggesting, you know, Mormons or fundamentalists or go join the Orthodox Church, but I think there are things that can be learned there 'cause one of the things a lot of Mormons and fundamentalists turn to Judaism and really, really research that stuff looking for truths to pull out. And I, you know, I think that's a fantastic thing is as long as you don't take it too far, right, I think that's a fantastic thing to do. And I, you know, there's, I've learned a lot of stuff from friends that are heavily into researching, you know, Hebrewisms and, and, and pulling the truths out of that and finding those correlations with, with Mormon theology. Well, what's surprising to me is we don't see the same thing happening with Catholicism and Orthodoxism. We don't see a lot of people that are in Mormonism that are really interested in that subject that that have done because a lot of the stuff that I researched, it blew me away. I had no idea.
43:26 But it's an amazing testament to me of the truth of Joseph Smith. Because here's something else to realize. When Joseph's, when the restoration happened, there was, there was Catholicism in the United States, right? And you had a lot of Catholicism down in Mexico. It's pretty much state religion. So it wasn't a foreign thing. So for Joseph Smith to be able to pull ideas from Catholicism wouldn't be that surprising. But what it would be surprising is if Joseph Smith's pulling ideas from the Orthodox Church because that was not really in America at that time, even at the, I mean, at that time even it was if, if, if Catholicism is a state religion of, of Mexico, you know, Protestantism is the, is the state religion of, of, of the United States.
44:20 And so you don't, you know, at the time, I mean, even, I mean, I remember like JFK was the like, I believe he's the first Catholic president. And when he was running, there's a lot of fear and skepticism. Yeah, they were worried about his allegiance being to Rome, right? Not to the United States Constitution. And that wasn't that long ago. No, no, it's like what, 60 years ago now or something, I mean. Right. So America's clearly heavily a Protestant nation with very, very little Catholic influence. Right. Even. But even with that orthodox influence, even into modern times, very, very small.
45:00 Right. And so finding these parallels between Mormon theology and Orthodox theology has really been a very fascinating witness of the truth of the Restoration. Because it, I mean, you know, people can argue, well, Joseph Smith pulled that out of the, out of these, the cabalic teachings 'cause he had a, a rabbi that was helped teaching him, or he pulls this out of that, or, you know, people make these claims that he's deriving the, the, the theology that was revealed to him from these other sources. It's you even pulling some of this cabalic stuff, though, is really a stretch in my opinion. I, I find that a stretch. But to try to make that claim to Orthodox, that's that's beyond the pale in my opinion. Yeah, 'cause I don't think there's an Eastern Orthodox presence in the United States during his time. I mean, there may be some people hanging around, but it's not. I'm not seeing a whole lot of Orthodox churches being set up right.
45:58 Right. So, and so one of the things too, that I found with, with when I was looking into the Orthodox Church is I found a certain beauty in their, in their methodology of worship, which is very, it's hard to put a word to it, but it, there's a certain kind of a piety and sincerity to the what I would maybe say the ordinances, because in Orthodox worship, that's the primary thing and Protestantism, it's all about the sermon, right? The sermons. That's what you're going to church for, right? You're going to church because you want, you want to hear your preacher give this amazing sermon that's going to get you fired up and get you inspired.
46:42 And that's what it's all about in the Orthodox Church. Well, I guess so. First of all, it should be understood. So the oral they build their churches facing East. Interesting. Yeah, very interesting. And their their form of worship. It's not that they don't have sermons because their priest will. There is an aspect of sure in their in their worship. But first and foremost is their literate is the liturgy liturgy. And I mean, that's I guess in common with the Catholics too. But the liturgy, that's why you're going, you're going there for the sacrament, for the liturgy. And the liturgy is a lot like an endowment. Really.
47:27 It's a lot like an endowment. They see the, I was hoping to actually attend one of their, one of their services to get a, you know, some personal experience and that that hasn't worked out yet. But their liturgy is more of a it's a it's a presentation. OK. Of theological truths that the there's not an audience, there's they participate. OK. At this point, you sing this song all together. At this point, you all say these words and you're sharing this specific prayer. OK. And in that process it's it's, it's the same every time.
48:12 Right. Right. A lot like, and so I, I, I see a lot of similarities with that with, with our temple worship in Mormonism where, you know, we have Sunday and we go to church there and, and that's where we, we take the sacrament and we, but mostly Sunday we take the sacrament. But most of that time is we've got sermons, we've got Sunday school, we've got programs and young men and priesthood meetings and all of that stuff going on. But when we want, but when we go to worship in a prescribed manner, in a more of a literature, liturgical, liturgical, liturgical fashion, we go to the temple. Right.
48:55 And if you look at how they build their, their, their, their churches, you look at how they adorn their churches, you look at how they worship inside their churches, It's, it looks a lot more like it like temple worship to me than it does what we would consider like standard Sunday services in Mormonism. Really. And they hold to those, what do you call it? They they hold to that process in a very pious and reverent manner, right? It's not you're just there and you're just hanging out, but it's you're involved in this. You're supposed to be having an experience. You're.
49:39 Having it, yeah, You're having an experience, a prescribed experience. Interesting. And you know, I, I don't think it's like 100% correct, obviously, but sure. But there's a certain amount of, of beauty in worshipping that way. And you see that in this in this church, and you certainly don't see this at all anywhere in Protestantism. No. And I was going to say this. This could be the reason that this upset so many Jacksonian Americans, right? Because Mormonism looks different, right? Like Mormonism is unique in the sense of you're going to get a flavor of American Protestantism by showing up to church on Sunday.
50:23 And like you were saying, you go to Sunday school, then you you go to what could be considered the General Assembly where a certain someone is going to give a sermon, right. But then there's something different that would resemble more of what you were just describing in the Eastern Orthodox phase where you have ordinances and it's not enough just to show up, right? Like I think for so long, that was the thing, right? You show up, you throw a couple bucks in the collection plate, you make sure you and the preacher are on good standing, you're good to go right Now, all of a sudden Joseph Smith comes along and goes, no, no, no, there's more, right? And now, and, and I think that's the part that really freaked people out, right?
51:07 Wasn't so much the Sunday to Sunday thing, but it what was? It's what they were doing the rest of the week, right? Sacred ordinances participate. Participatory ordinances that all of a sudden starts to look very foreign to Jacksonian America, and I've often wondered if that wasn't part of the rub. I could definitely see that, and it's fascinating. You look at Joseph's emphasis, right? It was. We need to build a temple. Community. Temple How many churches did Joseph Smith build? 0 right. So if you want to hear Joseph Smith preach, he'd go to the Grove right on Sunday and you and you hear him preach and you hear the sermon. But when you're when, when you're serious about worship. You go to the temple.
51:51 There's a dedicated space for that. And you don't. You don't get sermons in the temple. That's not a place to explore interesting ideas or to learn the gospel. No, that's a place to participate in prescribed sacred ritual. Right. That is designed to connect you with God. So let me ask you this, do you see anything? And, and I, I understand you haven't had a chance to do a super deep dive, but the other thing Joseph was big on was community, right? We're going to build a community. Does does the Eastern Orthodox Church seem to have anything that's similar to that?
52:32 A quest for Zion or a quest for a holy? Community, you know, nothing in particular actually stands out. There might be something that I'm missing it nothing stands out. But again, I'm looking at the Orthodox Church as what can, what can be gained from it. But I don't think they they had it all right. So I didn't expect necessarily to find everything. For example, I think there's great value in the sermon as well, right? And that's the thing, right? You have Protestantism and you have Catholicism and Orthodoxism, and there's a schism between them. The way they worship is entirely different, right? And Joseph Smith doesn't reject everything from Protestantism. Right. Neither does he adopt everything from Catholicism. He brings them together in my opinion. Right.
53:15 And so you, you kind of get a what I would call temperance. Right. You've got both. It's not one or the other or this one's good, this one's not as good. It's not overly weighted, not. Overly weighted it's bringing it together because where would we be in in Mormonism today even if we didn't have those amazing sermons that the few that we have record record of that Joseph. Smith gave and well, so yeah. Some of those were written down right. Right. But some of them probably weren't. Right. I can't imagine how cool it would have been. Oh yeah, day to just, you know. Oh, Justin is giving a sermon today. Let's go check it out, right? Hear, hear the man just riff on on spirituality and spiritual principles. Yeah.
53:58 And honestly, personally, I see this as a balance between this, these opposite, these polar things that aren't that they don't necessarily have to be opposites like liberalism and conservatism. You know, the Protestantism is a very liberal religious movement, while Catholic and Orthodox is very conservative. And well, which one's right? Well, Justice Smith's revelations were that will the both bring them together? They're both necessary. They're both necessary. So let's not throw the baby out with the bathwater, right? So, you know, and this might apply to Catholicism. Some of this stuff might apply to Catholicism as well. So, you know, I apologize to anybody out there that might, might get offended.
54:39 I'm not just trying to, you know, Catholicism is pretty cool too. They got some neat stuff actually as well. So one of the things that really struck me, that really helped me understand a certain aspect of Mormonism was actually confession. So in the growing up as a Mormon confession was just this, this thing that you needed to do to be forgiven. You know, the your very first experience with with a Bishop interview is probably going to be so you can go do work for the dead of the temple. Is it? Is it a bad or young woman? Right. Baptism, I think, too, yeah. Yeah, but you're, you're a young man or young woman, then you're, you know, you're still pretty young, but you know, you're like 12 or older and, and, and in order to go to the temple and do baptisms for the dead, you need to have one of your one of your early, well, I guess baptism too, right? Yeah, you're right.
55:35 Baptism is probably the very first. But usually the baptism isn't so much focused on confession. No, no, because realistically at that point you're still good, right? You're going to. It's after that the confession. But it's when you're a teenager and you need to recommend to do work in the temple for the dead that you need to recommend. And for me, this idea of, you know, that's where you're going to get asked questions and you're going to go through these temple recommended interview type stuff, right? And you tie that to this idea of of confession. You read the miracle of forgiveness. Something. Like that, right? And you get this idea that forgiveness for your sins is between you and God and your Bishop, and that you can't really be forgiven if you don't talk to your Bishop about this kind of stuff.
56:29 Right. And so one of the things that it's, it's it's something that's always irked me to a certain degree, to a little bit, even even in the church, because that doesn't work theologically. Like I can't find any. I have yet to find a revelation in Doctrine Covenants that explains the necessity of confessing to your Bishop in order to be forgiven. Right. I can't find it in Scripture. So where, where is the, you know, I've always wanted like, where is this coming from? And, and as I became a fundamentalist, this is something I've, I, I threw out completely, entirely as this is garbage. This just, this doesn't make sense. Why do you have to have a man in between you and God to be forgiven?
57:14 It, it's, it didn't make sense, but I was, as I was researching Orthodox, I got the Orthodox perspective on confession, which really kind of blew me away because they, from what I what I studied, yeah, I don't want to speak for the Orthodox Church here, but. From what I understand, I'm sure they won't mind. They love a Mormon fundamentalist letting them know what they are. What they tell them, what they Yeah, they tell them where they stand here. Here's their here's the teaching. I understood from them that confession is not about receiving forgiveness, that basically you should repent on your own even before confession.
57:55 The point of confession is not about is not a requirement for forgiveness of your sins. It's a, it's a tool to help you overcome your sins. Interesting. And so one of these guys that I was studying explained that a proper confession begins the moment your last confession ends. And he suggests that you keep a journal. And when you find yourself struggling with things in life, struggling with temptation, struggling with sin, you know, I got, I got upset at the kids and blew my top and I'm not feeling good about that. Write it down. And the point of confession is you're, you're conferring with basically a priesthood authority to help you on a, on a well, I'll get into that later.
58:39 But a path of sanctification. And so you're not confessing because God won't forgive you. Christ won't forgive you. You're confessing because you want to do better next. Time. And this man is authorized to give you counsel and guidance to do that. You know what it sounds like and and I'm going to get heat for this, I think, but sounds like a sponsor in a a right, right. He's not there necessarily. Pass. He's not there to judge. He's not there passing judgement. He's just like, well, next time don't go to the bar, right, right. Or if it's too hard to walk by the bar, pick a different route home, right? That was something to, to, to give you guidance, you know, or this is what worked for me when I was kicking the booze, right? Whatever it is, there is somebody there that that is able to help you pick up the pieces again, right? I I exactly.
59:34 And I and with that perspective, looking back in Mormonism, I realized I'm not actually completely opposed to this anymore as I as I originally was, but I'm like, why? Why does it, why is it bothering me in Mormonism? And I realized it's because the judgement is there because of recommended interviews, which are absolutely question, you know, questions of, you know, judgements. Yes. You are not good enough to go to the temple because you did that and you've done that. You need to confess it so you can be forgiven, but that also disqualifies you. Right.
1:00:15 This one, let me push back a little on this, OK, because recommends were issued from the beginning with Joseph, Oregon and Brigham, right? So how do we rectify, reconcile those two things? Well, policy in my opinion is because from what I can tell recommends were originally. The idea behind a recommend is the bishops using his own spiritual discernment and what you discuss as far as what you need to receive that recommendation is, is between you know, you and, and your Bishop and your bishops exercising his own priesthood to discern whether you're prepared or not. At a certain point in time, though, I, I think he actually even started with Brigham Young.
1:01:02 There were requirements placed policy requirements. It's no longer between, you know, you your Bishop having discernment, whether or not you're worthy or not. It's now your your Bishop having discernment plus a checklist. And over time, the ethicist becomes the checklist. When you bring a checklist into that, when you bring in a policy into that like that, I mean, I don't know every I had, I never had a single temple recommend interview where it went beyond the checklist. Me neither. It was always really just about the checklist. Me. Yep.
1:01:43 Was I really prepared? Was I really worthy? Were there things that that I needed help with at that time? There absolutely were things I needed help with at that time. Every time there's, there's yet. And see, that's kind of the interesting thing with the, with the orthodox perspective of this too, is you're doing this regularly. Why? Because there's always something. And so when it's not about judgement, it's just about being, hey, I'm a man, I'm a mortal, I'm fallible, I've got weaknesses. And this is a method, a process in which I can receive counsel and guidance to help me on my path towards Christ. That's a beautiful thing. Yeah, and, and it look, a certain level of accountability is a good thing, right?
1:02:29 That's why personal trainers exist, right? Because if dudes just kept, if there was no accountability, speaking from personal experience, it's a lot easier to just be like that. Let's have another cheeseburger, right? Let's, let's, let's toss another, another donut back. We're good, right? But having someone you know you're going to report to, it's a healthy thing. Right. And this is I, I remember discussing on my mission with my companions was like, you know what, what do you need to go to your Bishop for? What don't you need to go to your Bishop for? Well, it's only you only need to go to your Bishop for the big things, right? And I don't know where the policy is today, but there's probably a a list, there's probably somewhere a list of these sins you have to talk to your Bishop about to be forgiven these sins you don't. And that also creates what I, in my opinion, a very broken dichotomy.
1:03:26 There are great bishops out there and you have guys that maybe a guy's an alcoholic and he's struggling with and he's abusive and he knows he is and he's not happy with who he is. And he goes to his Bishop for help. And, and those opportunities, you'll see a lot of great bishops step up and, and they'll deliver that ministering that that the people need. Right. Right to help them out. But who's going to their Bishop? Because, you know, I got, I got, I got in a fight with my wife. And I'd bet it might be my. Fault, right? Nobody is. You're not going to schedule an appointment with your Bishop because you got in an argument. No, and, and to be fair to the bishops, they don't have time for. That no, that's true dude.
1:04:07 They don't. Have time for that. They're like, look, dude, you're at some point, right? But I think this is part of that too, right? Is to have somebody who you're confessing to who can be like, look bro, I'm here to help, but at some point I don't even know everything, right? Like go work out your, your, your, your issues amongst yourselves and it gets really ugly. Then call me, right? Right. But when you have a practice or a ritual, right where in this ritual you're going to talk about these things, whatever those things are. Right. Or for wherever you're at, whether you're you're you, whether you're you don't work, you're alcoholic, you're abusing your family, or you're, you've got it all together. Either way, you've got flaws and weaknesses. Nonetheless, you've got things that you're struggling with and you got somebody who is part of this practice you've developed a relationship with to help guide you through that. I think that's a really cool, beautiful thing. That is a cool and beautiful thing. And I'm not saying I think Mormonism should adopt it one for one, but what we've already got in mainstream Mormonism compared to the Doxy I.
1:05:15 Look there, there have been plenty of times that confession or the equivalent thereof has been used to breakdown people. Yeah, right. Let's look. I hope they don't come after me. Mr. Miscavige, I apologize ahead of time. If we look at Scientology, right, you go in you, you, you hold the cans, right? And they hook you up to the meter and then like, look, any religion that makes a Mormon go, dude, that's back crap, crazy. You may want to reconsider anyway, 'cause we believe some off the wall stuff. But you grab the cans, they start asking you really deep, probing questions and.
1:05:59 A tape recorder's. Running and a tape recorder's running, right? And files are kept. We know that that does happen in religious organizations from time to time, right? It can be used as a club. Absolutely. Right. And so I'm like you, I think there's got to be a happy medium somewhere, but that has to be really defined. And those lines have to be really stark so that nobody crosses over. There can't be a Gray area with that. That's got to be black and white. Yeah. 100% and the main, the main reason I bring this up though is just again, I had completely discounted the idea. You know, I looked at the way this works in Mormonism. I can't find a theological justification. I see a lot of harm in this.
1:06:43 There's a lot of people that suffer all kinds of unnecessary guilt and trauma, I believe, over a culture that expects everybody to be perfect. And if you mess up and, but if you do mess up, you also you got to you got to talk to somebody who may or may not be in a position to to relate, help understand. So I'll I'll confess something here that really bugged me in my time in the LDS church. Have you ever been part of a disciplinary council? No. I had to sit in on one once.
1:07:27 It was the most disturbing thing I ever witnessed within the church because it was a woman who wasn't married. She had broken some chastity stuff with someone she wasn't married to, and they asked the most graphic questions I have ever heard. And as I probed deeper, that was the norm for those things, right? Right. And it was humiliating. Now look, I think if you mess up bad, there should be some humbling right on your part. But the way in which it was done, like there were times I'm like, is the Fuhrer about to make an entrance? Because this is getting damn spooky, right? But I'm always very nervous with with confession. But I do think it's it's an important part that has we have to find that happy medium with.
1:08:28 Right. And I had completely thrown it out, right until I saw this Orthodox perspective on it. Suddenly it's like, OK, there's I can see some value here potentially, right? It's not, maybe this isn't something to completely throw out, but it's got to be done right, as you were saying. So that was a kind of a cool one. OK, this is this is really interesting. So baptism already, so in a disagreement with Mormonism, right? You've got infant baptism in the lyrics and the Catholic Church, right. But there actually is a, there's a difference between Catholic and Orthodox understanding of original sin. So in the Catholic Church, original sin entered the world because of Adam.
1:09:16 And because of that, we're all fallen and we are born guilty, right? Right. We inherit that sin from Adam. The Orthodox Church does not believe in original sin like that. They believe that we all suffer the consequences of the fall. Sure, but that. But there's no inherent initial guilt. So kind of like men will be punished for their own sins and not have transgression. Right, which is fascinating because not only is that a Catholic thing, that's a Catholic thing. And that's why you have to be baptized or you're dead, right? Protestantism, though, carries that over from Catholicism. The, the, the Protestant churches also believe in original sin that we enter this world as as in a sinful state, you know, a newborn baby Sinner because of Adam.
1:10:06 The Orthodox Church doesn't hold on to that. And so you got this religious organization going back nearly to the times. Maybe it does go back. It depends on, you know, whether you believe claims, certain claims or still ancient Christian Church that has that doctrine. The Catholics change it. The Protestants keep that change. That becomes the norm in America. And then you have Joseph Smith comes along and starts teaching, Oh no, there's no, you know, there's no original sin like that. We're all fallen and we're susceptible to sin because of that fall, But we don't, we're not guilty because of what Adam did. That's revel. That was revel.
1:10:47 That's revolutionary Mormon theology. But it's, but it's been a part of the Orthodox Church from the beginning. So that's, that was pretty fascinating. So I I just had a quote on that. I forgot to put the reference though, maybe I'll share it anyways. So this is this is a quote from some Orthodox teacher some sort. But a child that dies before it is baptized does not mean that it too cannot receive deification. It is born pure, and when it dies, it continues to exist in pureness. Its soul has not become infected with darkness caused by sin.
1:11:28 Thus its soul remains healthy and in its natural state, and is not prevented in any way from partaking in the divine light. Now there's a word that jumped out at me, which was deification. Yeah. That's been understood for a while to be an exclusively Mormon kind of doctrine. Yeah, right. This idea of becoming like God. Yeah, right. Well, sure, let's jump over that real quick. This was this was the probably the biggest thing that blew me away because in my mind, there's a few keys of Mormonism that were absolutely just groundbreaking the revolutionary and in Christian and Christian thought.
1:12:14 And you know the idea, you know, this original sin stuff, that's that's a big one, right? But the biggest of all, and probably the greatest heresy of Mormonism is this idea that exaltation means godhood. Right. That's the greatest heresy in all of Mormonism. This turns Christianity and, you know, turns it on its head and it's it's probably one of the theologically one of the greatest reasons Mormons are rejected even today among Christians. It's not so much continuing revelation. It's not so it's this idea that men can become gods. That's just utter blasphemy.
1:12:57 So turns out the Orthodox have this thing called theosis. And I'm going to paraphrase some of this here, but the idea is, is that when you are baptized, you enter into a, a kind of a path, but it's a path that you need to reach the end of. And from a, from a basic worldview perspective, one of the big difference Orthodox has is that from most of Christianity, especially Protestantism, the what is the purpose of the Gospel? That why do you have a church?
1:13:42 Why I, I've been born again. OK, so now what? Well, moral improvement, moral improvement. The Orthodox, though, don't buy into that. It's not about moral improvement. It's about Iosis, which is a it's becoming, it's a personal experience with God now it's a it's a it's an interesting topic in Orthodox. It appears to me that this isn't actually. Widespread. Understood even among Orthodox parishioners, but it is a part of the theology and there's certain people in the Orthodox Church that are are strongly kind of pushing and promoting this idea because they want the rest of of their congregations to understand that when you're baptized you begin a path, but the objective is a personal encounter with God.
1:14:45 It a quote that I found it was really beautiful. I there's a book on theosis written by I think some some St. or monk or Bishop in the Orthodox Church. But it is a beautiful quote. It totally reminds me of something Joseph Smith would have said, which is that God became man so that man can become God. You got some echoes of As God is now man may become right. Interesting. So apparently that wasn't completely just off the cuff from Joseph Smith. Apparently there's an ancient, still existing tradition of Christianity that has always believed that.
1:15:35 And they teach that in Genesis when it says that man is created in God's image, that means something. The dogs aren't created in God's image. The horses aren't creating God's image. The trees are not created in God's image. Man is created in God's image. And what that means is that we are, we are intended to become. More. More and that this this yearning that man has, cannot be satisfied through moral improvement. There's nothing wrong with moral improvement, but to what ends? Right. Like if you're a born again Christian, OK, great. And let's say that, you know, you still have, you know, you, you get you have a temper and you get and you get in these fights at work and and you're kind of a bully. OK, well, that's not very Christian. So we should overcome that, right? Moral improvement.
1:16:34 But to what ends? You've already been saved. Right. Well, and and that's, that's always been my point of contention, right? Like if look, once I'm saved, I'm good. Well, I'm not going to church anymore. I got done while I need to get done. So I'm just going to sit on the couch and watch football. Right. Right. If Mormonism required something more right, And I've always said that one of the, the things that Joseph restored that was absolutely genius was this idea that our humanity didn't need to be unholy, that we could be holy as human beings. And I and from what you're describing within Eastern, in the Eastern Orthodox, we can see echoes of that for sure.
1:17:18 And if you think about the idea of an image, right, I mean, we're not supposed to have graven images, right? That's an idol. But what is that? Why? What is that idol? Well, that the idol is a, an embodiment of what? It's what it's an image of, right? And if so, if that's what an image is and we are made in the image of God, that has profound theological. It's not just that, hey, we kind of we share the same shape. Right, right. You know, and I've heard so often that this idea of we're created in God's image is you're just talking about your ability to reason, right? And I'm like, that still seems really in person.
1:18:01 Right, right. It's a part of it. It sure it is. But as a whole, you got to take all of that stuff. Our ability to reason, our creativity, our capacity for love. You got to take all of that and realize that that's a manifestation of something divine. Of of our origins. And our potential and what we were created for. So that just blew me away. The greatest heresy of Mormonism is as is, as ancient as the Catholic Church. Yeah. And see that's. Well, and I say Catholic before they split, right? Right. It goes all the way back. And I've said this before on the on talking about these sorts of things.
1:18:45 Oh, Joe Smith, man, he was a hell of a guesser, wasn't he? I mean, he, he's able to hit all these bull's eyes all over the place and we don't know about him until hundreds of years later. You know, and something else really important to this, it's not just more so, you know, Gnostic Christianity, Cabalic Hebrewism, there's other places that have a, a, a glimmer of this idea as well, right? But I, those are things that I've never really accepted. And a lot of people look at that and say, well, I'm good with that because that matches my beliefs. And so, oh, I guess I'm a Cabalist. So I guess I'm a, a Gnostic. The process is different, right, Right. If you look at the Cabalic ascension to divinity, what's it based off of?
1:19:32 Knowledge. Right. What you know, gaining knowledge, gaining secrets, going through this process of, of learning these mysteries, right? Then. You're you can become ascended. Well, and that fits with what Joseph Smith said, right? It does, but it doesn't. But Joseph said man cannot be saved any faster than he can obtain knowledge. Right, but I guess the difference is, is that in the Cabalic? In the Cabalic idea of this, there's no morality involved in this whatsoever. OK, that's a problem, right? Yeah. Yeah. No, that's a problem. I see what you're saying. It is. It is sacred knowledge above all else. Right.
1:20:14 It's magic, right? It's like Wiccan or Warlock. OK, if you learn the magic word you've got control over. Fire I. See, you can make that. Yeah, I see. I see what you're saying now. It's, it's knowledge above everything else. Maybe knowledge exclusivity, right? So. In Mormonism, how do you attain to godhood? Well, it's through knowledge, right? What just calls what it is, but also there is, right? But there's also, there's also a code of conduct that is expected, right? You're going to get married, you're going to have children, you're going to perform ordinances, which is going to give you that knowledge that you need, right?
1:20:54 There are certain places in the endowment that talk about you got to know these things to get to where you want to go. And so in Mormonism, I would say it it, it strives for the balance between the gnosis, right, the knowledge and the participatory ordinances, as well as our ability to continue to gain, in my opinion, better morality to emulate the Savior more in our lives. Right. So from an academic perspective, you can look at great literature and you can analyze and be an expert at it and understand all of that, right? But to me, what makes the reason I study classic literature is because it's transformation.
1:21:40 Right. It's not about being able to be like, oh, look, I'm so smart. I can tell you I can, I can quote War and Peace. It's about, well, what can you learn from War and Peace? Right. It's about how will that change who you are? Because ultimately, Mormon theology, we become gods through becoming like God. And obviously there's a certain amount of knowledge required to do that, but it's not really an issue of intelligence or knowledge or how smart you are. It's ultimately a matter of who you are on the inside. Do you share the same character as God?
1:22:21 Well, and, and let's talk about that, right, Because we don't get to that place without practicing, right? It's like anything else. You could pick your sport. You can break down all the game film you want, but until you go and you get on the field or on the court and you try to implement that. Want more from the Mormon Renegade podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the fundamental news program for free. Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button.
1:23:01 And for $5.00 a month, you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes today. But until you go and you get on the field or on the court and you try to implement that right, that video is not going to help you much. It's experiential. You're right. Exactly. You can be an expert in in football and you can know everything there is to know about different plays, different strategies, tactics, character, physical characteristics that are needed to do this and that and the other.
1:23:41 But can you play the game right? Entirely different? Yep. Entirely different skill set. And you kind of need both to be, really. Good. Kind of. You absolutely do, yeah. You really got to, you got to have it both. And so that's why to me, Gnosticism and Cabalism has never been appealing, because I like the objective. I believe there's truth in that objective of becoming. Gods, it's just unhealthily, unhealthily weighted towards knowledge and and no experience. Exactly. So with that, what's the Orthodox perspective? Well, it's pretty interesting because they believe that this process happens through the Church. That's why you have a church.
1:24:23 The Church is the body of Christ, and so it's through participating in these ceremonies over and over again that you start developing this perfected, improved character. I gotcha. And while in the Orthodox Church, there's no statements on who, who is and who isn't, you know, who made it right, who's achieved theosis? I mean, they've got there, there's claims of certain Saints and monks that have done things. And I, I disagree with certain aspects of that because it's very, very aesthetic path to, to theosis proclaim. But for the, for the general body, it's, there is that moral improvement, but it's moral improvement through grace in Christ and through this ceremonial process. And that ceremonial process happens in the church. So that's why you go to church, because the church is the body of Christ, and that's how you're going to eventually attain Christ's presence, possibly in this life. But see, OK, I just have kind of an issue with saying you just got to show up, right?
1:25:43 Just keep coming to church and it's going to get you there because I don't think that's enough, right? I think, I think if there's one place I feel like evangelicals kind of have some really good points, it's on this idea of a personal relationship with deity. It's not something you hear a lot about in, in the LDS Church, right, Or, or in, in a couple other sects of Mormonism. I do believe that has to be there. I, I feel like what church should do and, and that's both in the physical meetinghouse as well as the church, so to speak in its teaching is to equip, equip people to have to get to a point to where they can foster that relationship with deity.
1:26:28 Right. Well, and that yeah, absolutely. And I guess this is to me, this is one of the key. So so Joseph Smith taught the self aggrandizement. It's not a false. Principle. No, as long as you seek to bring everyone up to that same level around you. Right. But that's actually the process, yes. That is, that's not just a requirement, a moral requirement. That's actually how you actually do achieve self aggrandizement. And so again, you know, there is a certain amount of importance in church because that's where you get those opportunities to serve. And that may or may not be in the Orthodox Church, but regardless as principle that I, I do see the importance of church in that regards, but even more so it's family.
1:27:17 And see, that's the fascinating thing, because in Mormonism, this, this path to theosis has a huge prerequisite. Right this. Barrier that you you know you can go so far, but you shall not pass unless you're sealed. Yep. Because without that, I think that the the the the path's not there. No, you can't. No, men can't get there on their own and women can't get there on their own. The only way you're getting there is to be paired up. Right? Exactly. And, and look, that's one place I will say that Mormonism is completely unique in Christendom.
1:28:01 Is no other church or no other theology places as much emphasis on the marriage covenant than Mormonism? Yeah, period. That's also part of the genius, too, of what Joseph did, 'cause not only did he upend things in the ways we've already talked about, but he upends it by recasting Eve in her proper light. No longer is she the mother of our sorrows. She is the reason we are here and she is just as divine as Adam. So you you bring up Eve and Adam this. So here's here's something else interesting in in Orthodoxy that I found that I'm I'm now kind of questioning a little bit. I'm a little more interested in this, but then I was before when you, when I, when I look at Catholicism, there's a few things that I've always had issues with, right? And currently one of them is this, this veneration of Mary and this praying to Mary and stuff like that. Always kind of, you know, kind of wrong. And you get a lot of that in Orthodox, in the Orthodox Church too, but.
1:29:08 The divine Feminine. Right, but I was looking at some of their teachings on this from and then call Catholics might share this, I don't know, but from the Orthodox perspective, they see Christ as a new Adam. So Adam, the original Adam is the creates this fall and this new Adam creates an opportunity for a man to ascend, right. They're they're and when Mormon theology, you understand they're both key components. You can't have one without the other. They look at Eve and Mary the same way though, because without Mary there can be no Christ. And I am actually fascinated by the Orthodox perspective on on Mary, this veneration, because there's some truth to that, right?
1:30:05 Without Mary there's sure, but there's no Christ. And but to why such a high level of, of veneration? There's a an understanding and there's some pseudepigraphal work. I don't know if anybody's ever talked about this before, if you're familiar with it. And I'm not an expert at this, I haven't actually read it, but I've heard it explained that there's some pseudepigraphal works that describe that tell the story of Mary, that she was basically consecrated to the temple as a child. And she grew up in the temple as a basically, you know, her job was like an ordinance worker, like a like a permanent ordinance worker in the temple. That's for everything.
1:30:51 And she's consecrated her life to that. And her life's been consecrated to that. Well, when she's at a certain age, she's suddenly pregnant. Well, how is she pregnant? She's not married. There's no. Right. How did this happen? It looks like a scandal waiting to happen. But the priest at the temple knew Mary and, you know, had this love for her. And one of these priests was Joseph, and he's this older man who's married and has a family. And the priests decide we've got to do something for Mary. You know, we're not sure exactly what happened here, but we think there's something God's working in this and she needs to be married so that this isn't a huge. Smile.
1:31:46 So the priests draw lots to decide which one of them will take Mary as their wife. What book is this out of the Apocrypha? I don't remember. I wish I remember this. I'll you know what? I'll hit up Ken Peterson, the dude literally wrote the book Mormonism in the Apocrypha and I'll see. I'll see if I. Can't get an answer on that. I do. Know that we call it apocrypha, but this is more of a of a of a standard work in. In the Eastern Orthodox religion, OK, it's. I I believe that I believe it's considered. If it's not Canon explicitly, it's certainly more so than than Mormonism is looking at it. See. That paints a different picture than what the New Testament does though, right? Well, does it though?
1:32:28 Is it a? Is it a different picture or a different context? I don't think anything's contradictory. I don't know, though, because if, if, if these priests are sitting around the temple going, OK, whoever draws the short straw, they're going to marry this woman. But if you read the New Testament, Joseph's distraught over this. Right. Right, That is a different context, right. That's not necessarily being like guess I'll have to marry her versus the guy going marry. Well, I think you screwed around on. Well, maybe. But is he distraught because he thinks he shrewd around with her? Or is he distraught because she's pregnant and he cares about her? He doesn't want these consequences. She's going to get kicked out of the temple. Well, I think, I think both, right? I think, I think if we look at what Joseph's up against here, he stands to being the laughingstock as well. Like you couldn't even keep his girl from screwing around, right?
1:33:24 The other thing is is that by marrying her according to Jewish custom, he is admitting I'm the one that screwed around with Mary. He is saying, yeah, it was mine. I was not chased. So there there is some they don't necessarily completely jive here. But however I want to say this, I don't think that discounts that right. I think that there I think there could be a a happy medium in there somewhere. I I need to get with with some guys to figure this out 'cause this is fascinating. Yeah. And so from what I understand, Joseph's first wife is actually becomes Mary's midwife. OK.
1:34:07 When Christ is born and Christ's brothers are essentially half, well, not even half brothers. Kind of step brothers. Kind of step brothers, yeah, they're essentially step brothers, which I'll be honest, for me, this actually, I, I, I like this idea because it does sort of resolve something. Because in, in Mormonism, we have a very unique perspective, very unique perspective on the conception of Christ, which is that Christ was not miraculously conceived through the spirit, through the Spirit, right. But that God the Father essentially Adam is comes to her and that is the by and and and Christ is the byproduct of any just like any other pregnancy which presents this idea then in my mind that Mary essentially is becomes the wife of Adam or a wife of Adam.
1:35:12 And if Mary's the wife of Adam, then why is Mary fooling around with Joseph right later on? Well, that's a good point too, right? Because as I said, and, and this is the part of the the nativity story, if you will, that I found fascinating, we concentrate, and rightfully so, on Mary and on that birth. But I feel like Joseph gets glossed, right? Because there's some uncomfortability here for Joseph. Right. Because he's about to take on himself sin. That's not his right a a perceived sin. And he has to be OK with this either way. Either way, he's got to be OK with people probably talking about him, right?
1:36:01 Like Joseph, he couldn't keep it in his pants. You know what I'm saying, right? I mean, there's all sorts of things here that that stand to make Joseph's life absolutely miserable. Right. But it's even. But it's even in here. OK, this might be a little bit blasphemous, but imagine being Joseph though. Oh yeah. OK. And take the traditional narrative. OK, and your here's your wife, but really, your wife is God's wife. Yeah. And but now she's your wife. I I I can see certain really uncomfortable situations arising arising from that. Well, yeah.
1:36:47 But I, I also think if that's the case, I don't think it'd be any more. And if if Joseph's a polygamist as well? Well, if he's a polygamist and he's actually kind of an old man, and he's just doing this to help Mary save, and that's why he disappears early in the New Testament. And, and that could be too, right? That's that could be a possibility. Nobody get their panties in a bunch either. We're just two dudes talking crap. OK, But if, if, if that's the case, then yeah, that, that, that seems to, to clean that up a little bit. So there, there is something there to think about. The the other thing I would say as well is that that's a lot of pressure, right?
1:37:34 I want you to put yourself in the place of Joseph right now. You know whose kid that is, right? Are you cool with letting him be born in a Manger? He's the King of Kings, right? He's heaven's King. And you know what? Dude's going to be born in a Manger. There must have been a complete sense of failure on Joseph's part, right? Until you realize it's just fulfilling prophecy. Yeah, absolutely. So as Christ becomes the new Adam, the Orthodox view Mary as the New Eve. And you know, I'm not, I'm not advocating praying to Mary or worshipping Mary. But if she's Adam's, if really she's Adam's wife, then she's she's not just a somebody.
1:38:30 Yeah, well. She's beyond that she's she's essentially a a goddess. Well, yeah. And I think that early brethren kind of pointed to that, right? I don't I don't think this is completely new territory. For more on this. No, but it explains where to me though it it explains is like what if What if the early church understood this? Right. Well, but it was lost over time. But the tradition of honoring Mary as essentially a divine being, not one that saved our souls like Christ did, but nonetheless a divine being? Suddenly that makes a heck of a lot more sense. Right. You know, and this puts us again, as fundamentalists in a very unique position.
1:39:12 And let me explain why. Just a couple years ago, there was a talk in General Conference by one of the newer apostles. I can't remember who it was, but he had basically said, look, I know we're all excited about Heavenly Mother, but nobody get too excited because we really don't know that much about her. Well, if you're a fundamentalist, you can say, all right, we know some stuff. Which one are you talking about, right? Eve, Eve or Mary, Right. I mean, there's, there's some stuff here that that really is, is pretty profound that that quite frankly, no one else in Mormonism is equipped to answer except fundamentalists. Right. And without fundamentalism, I get. If I was a Protestant, I would just absolutely, you know, this Mary, veneration is just absolute blasphemy. Yeah.
1:39:58 As a fundamentalist, I have to look at it with certain degree of well. You know, exactly because. Because like you said, right, the knowledge is lost, but the tradition remains. Yeah, right. And that's huge, right? Because then in some weird way, it might become kind of idolatrous. It could be, but you cannot make anything happen. But you can make the church now. You can make Christ an idol. You can make the scriptures, right? I mean, that's just the truth of it. Yeah, so, but the interesting thing is with that too, it almost with the understanding that the Orthodox Church understands this idea of theosis.
1:40:39 It actually kind of to me puts a different spin on the understanding of also the Saints, because not only do is there a, a, a veneration and this prayer to Mary, there's also this tradition of praying to Saints and asking for them. It's, it's a, from what I understand, I don't want to, I don't want to just completely throw these, throw them under the, it's not a worship of the Saints. It's a, you're praying to them for intercession. So you're praying to them so that they can approach God. And but the presumption there is that they have a place where they can do that. And to me it makes me not wonder if it's not knowing that if you don't have this idea of theosis then. It's just it.
1:41:28 It's pretty. Blasphemous in my mind with the idea of theosis though, Well, what if these Saints are people who achieved theosis and that's the difference. That's the the significance of why these Saints are special. Or at least originally that wasn't the original. I'm not saying that's how it is now. Obviously, they don't have the same theology we do, but what if that theology existed at a certain point? And that's what kind of led to this concept of, of this kind of what we see as worship of the Saints, because the idea is that a St. is somebody who has achieved theosis. OK, so let me ask this. Did any of the Saints that we know of today that are prayed to in like the Catholic Church or wherever, did any of them exist before the great Apostasy?
1:42:23 Well, yeah, like Peter, OK. But other than Peter, going forward, can we point to any? Could we point to Ignatius? Could we point to those other ones? Well. I have to look into that, but I think where we're at today with declaring Saints is probably not accurate. Right. But, but you see what I'm saying though, right? Because they're going to be missing key ordinances. Right. That would be needed to achieve theosis right from a Mormon point of. View from a Mormon point of view, but from an original church point of view, if there's an understanding of theosis and understanding that certain people achieve that and that these people achieve this, are called Saints.
1:43:04 Right, OK. And now they've lost these ordinances, they've lost priests, but they still have this kind of theology that's. OK. I see what you're. I see what you're saying. Not so much Saints as in they're actually, I don't know, deified, right. You're saying that that it's a holdover from the days when they understood theosis a little bit more. Right. OK. And it was and and they were attaining it in those days. In what days? In the days when the. Church was established by Christ before the Great Apostasy, as you said. See, I we'd have to go back and do some looking to see who was around for that. Well, like Peter, Peter, Peter.
1:43:49 Absolutely. I I but that's not the only St. in that. No, no I'm not. But I'm not suggesting that they all are. What? I'm OK, you're saying what? I'm suggesting is that if you're alive and Peter just died. And. The church says Peter's a St. We're canonizing it as we know. He that we, we, we can hang our hat on because he was running around with a big JC, right? Exactly. I was talking about when you said Saints. I went to host Peter, right? Or post apostasy Saints, right? No, no, no. I'm saying that tradition of venerating these Saints to me looks like it's a it's a corrupted form of what originally was recognition that some of these mortal men and.
1:44:36 Women had achieved that. Theosis. It basically did become deified. Right. Yeah, Yeah, No. And and then and then again. The knowledge is lost, but the tradition remains. Yep, Exactly. OK. And then with that, if you look at that as a as an idea, suddenly you say, well, so what's the name of the church today? The Church of Jesus Christ. Of latter day. Of Latter day Saints, what's a St. Isn't that funny that we don't have a definition despite it being in the name of our church? We don't really have a hard and fast definition, and frankly neither do the Catholics or Orthodox in my opinion, but it's pointing to something in my mind.
1:45:19 I think you're right. I think you're right. And if that's the case, sure makes an interesting it. It starts to make you wonder about Joseph Smith a little. Bit right, Right. I mean. So is this Christchurch only or is it Christchurch and Joseph Smith's church? Joseph Smith achieved theosis if Joseph Smith was deified. Yeah. Then is he not a St. Right? And is this not his church in a way too? Well, yeah, and I mean. It's not the Church of Jesus Christ for Latter Day Saints, right?
1:45:59 She said. Jesus Christ of Latter Day. Saints, you realize if I keep, if we keep going down this road, I'm I, well, I don't care about trouble. I what I'm going to have to do is be like, put a great big disclaimer on it and be like, I want to see your Mormon cred before you get a hold of this because I don't want to blow anyone's mind. But no, no, this is good stuff, right? And I think this is what, I'll be honest, I think this is one of the gifts of the Restoration, right? Is this being able to sit down. This is what the old guys meant by reckoning. When someone say, I reckon what they're saying is, is I've thought this through. I've thought with guys, this is what this is. But yeah, that's interesting too. And, and if you take some interpretations of, of how theosis works, you know, maybe Joseph, if Joseph Smith is the testator, you know, is, is, is, would he be part of that church as well, Right.
1:46:54 And there's, there's all this, oh, it's all, it's all open now, right? It something comes open. And you know, personally, I believe that John Taylor is another one who achieved the OSIS. Sure. And so that would be. It's it's it's of. John Taylor too. Yeah. So here's another interesting Here's some So Speaking of. Now here's here's something else to think about because I do believe men even today, I don't know who they are. I just have AI just have a feeling that that that is the case. Some must have had their calling an election made sure. So they're part of it too, right?
1:47:36 This is the beautiful thing about the restored gospel. That's a thing. Well then we can all be part of that. Yes. Right. It's an open invitation. You just got to be willing to pay the price, right? And so in order to understand our own theology, and I'm just throwing this out here, maybe we should be looking a lot more at the Orthodox Church and its teachings as well as Catholicism. I think we've looked at that to a certain degree, but especially the Orthodox Church and that stuff, because again, my understanding is the Orthodox Church is like fundamentalism is, is the Catholic, is the Mormon, is the LDS Church. Right. And they were like, yeah, we're not going that way.
1:48:19 We're holding on to some of these things. Right. But something just dawned on me. If the quote Catholic fundamentalist in Eastern Orthodoxy can lose their way, then there's no promise that we as fundamentalists. Oh, absolutely. Just because we adopt that tile right, fundamentalist, orthodox, just because we adopt that title, does not ensure that truth gets carried on. Right. Right. That should be a cautionary tale in this moment, right? Like, oh. Absolutely. Just because I'm claiming this doesn't mean that I'm entitled now, right?
1:49:03 Well, and that's why I started this whole journey and again, in the 1st place is because I'm looking at a certain degree and, and something seems wrong. Your bigger picture. But before I get back to that, I want to go a little bit more into some of these fragments that in an, in the Orthodox Church I found that were fascinating. So, so I guess first going back to baptism. So their baptismal ordinance has a few things. I found one thing they blessed the water, and we didn't do that in the Mormon. Church. No, that was but. Fundamentalism, this is white pretty widespread. You know, when, when you're doing a baptism, you, you bless the water before the baptism is done. And as I was researching, and this is straight off of an American Orthodox official website script for baptism, and I was, I was researching, going through and there's some neat stuff.
1:49:54 Their, their baptismal ceremony is actually kind of awesome. It's it's not like maybe a temple or if it's in a way that there's, there's different parts and there's pieces. It's, it's pretty cool. I I thought it was part of part of that's really neat. One of the really fascinating parts though, was they, they consecrate some oil and they do an anointing on the person being baptized beforehand. And this is I'm just going to read the script. OK. The priest proceeds to anoint the one to be baptized. He dips two fingers or the brush into the blessed oil, and traces the sign of the cross on the child as follows. On the forehead, saying, Priest, the servant of God, fill in the blank is anointed with the oil of gladness. In the name of the Father, and of the Son, and of the Holy Ghost.
1:50:44 Amen. On the breast and shoulder, saying unto the healing of soul and body. On the ears saying. Unto the hearing of the faith. On the hands, saying, Thy hands have made and fashioned me. On the feet, saying that he or she may walk in the way of thy commandments. You've been initiated in Mormonism through the temple. That should be very familiar. That should be very familiar. And, and this backs up something that I, I have thought personally for a while, right?
1:51:24 Because so often I would see these echoes of this, what happened, right? Well, obviously if you start to lose access to a temple, but you want to keep those things alive and things start getting conflated over time, things start becoming a little murky. Like, you know, I remember I did this thing. Well, when did you do it? Well, it was in, in, in the sacred ordinance in my house because we didn't have a temple. And then you do it to your kids, grandkids, your great grandkids. Give it 1000 years or. Two, 200 years, right? And eventually someone's like, yeah, I think you do it right before baptism, right?
1:52:10 And, and that's just where it comes from, right? And it's a conflation of of these ordinances, right? And I think that's where those echoes come from. And also I think because I think originally it was really hard to think about being from that tradition of Judeo Christianism, right, without a temple, right? And so I think there was an innate something that said we got to keep it alive. We got to got you something to keep it alive. And I think that is a little bit of overcompensation along with conflation, right? But going back to the point you made earlier, this is something that, especially in fundamentalism, we need to also be watching out for.
1:52:53 Yes, yes, For so long we've done what we've had to do. And that's great because you know what, Those old timers kept us around for us. We're in a different time now, right? Look, you and I both go to the same community and we're about to have a temple for the first time in a long, long, long time. And we need to make sure that that folks are getting there because it's important, right? So important. For so long, we've done what we've had to. Now we get to do it the way we should. Right. And you know, the other thing is the fullness of the gospel has also been, in my opinion, and trusted in the fundamentalism.
1:53:37 It absolutely has. And with that, a proper. So here's something that never made sense to me in, in, in Mormon and, and when I was in the LBS church, which was this idea that you're baptized, you receive your temple ordinance and the and the pinnacle is you're sealed, right? Yeah, your endowment, all that stuff and you're done. And now you endure to the end. Yes. Well, what does that mean? Well, stay active. Stay active. Don't lose your temple recommend. Keep working the program. Keep working the program. And honestly, it's, it's, it's more like that's kind of more of a Protestant type of an attitude when we have been given the fullness to understand that the Joseph Smith restored everything necessary that we can actually achieve theosis. Every single one of us can.
1:54:29 But we have to have the the knowledge and we have to have the ordinances. And the Orthodox Church over time has lost these things. And they still have this understanding of this. They still have an amazing understanding of the theology of it, that God became man so that man can become God. But they don't have the path. The path's not available to him. And in Mormonism, we've we've been granted all that, but there's not a lot of emphasis on my opinion. No, I don't think so. There's not even an understanding of it and and when I was because again, back when I was in the church, that was the end. I didn't know I had to study doctrine covenants on my own without the church prescribed study guide to gain an understanding of theosis and I did on my mission and it was had nothing to I I just took the scriptures at face value. I took the revelations at face value and I'm like, oh TNC, Oh, this is telling us how we can have a personal encounter with God, how we can attained, how we can truly be joint heirs. Right.
1:55:32 In that divine promise of godhood. But it was secret. Yeah, it's it was. It was not. I mean, I I when I got I asked companions about. None of my companions knew about. I got home from my mission, I started talking to people about it. Nobody knew anything about this. And so it's not really well understood, right. And then along with that, in fundamentalism, becoming a fundamentalist, you get learn it, you gain some, I've gained some knowledge of the fullness of the ordinances as well and realize that, you know, the ceiling is not the capstone ordinance in the restoration, that there's a second anointing. That's a part of that process as well. And so it's tragic to me.
1:56:23 And it's funny because even the Orthodox apparently, from what I can tell, are struggling with this as well, of trying to teach their congregations this idea of the potential of what it's really all about, what our, what our life is about. We came down here not so that we could live a moral life. We came down here so that we can do all the things necessary so that we can become gods ourselves, right? Anything short of that is a complete missing the mark of why we're here and what what our purpose is. Absolutely, absolutely and. And again, it needs to be pursued properly, right? Otherwise you end up with Gnosticism and Cabalism. It needs to be pursued properly.
1:57:05 But these things exist. These things are real. And this opportunity, it's, it's, it's insane to me to a certain degree how much even Mormonism and fundamentalism is not focused on that big picture. You know, the other thing that I would say to this, and, and I'm going to get Flack for this comment. And so if I apologize to anyone who's offended, this is the danger of being completely quote independent, right? Because I've seen too many guys get like down a weird rabbit hole and then all of a sudden they're no longer Mormon, they're new age.
1:57:51 Right. Right, even if you're independent and I am, right, I, that's what I ascribe to you need to have boys around you to pull you back in, right? To be like, bro, you got to stop, right? Like we got to talk this through because you might be going down a weird rabbit hole and and you got to wonder if if some of that didn't happen in in like Eastern Orthodoxy, right, right. Just guys going down the rabbit hole and no one's there to be like, bro, come in there. There's. Absolutely. Because that's exactly what you do. See. So OK, there's another topic I want to get to which is tied to this. But this is what you're seeing with this aesthetic monks, right?
1:58:34 Right. They're going to forsake everything. They're not going to have families. They're not going to have jobs, they're not going to experience anything in life. They're just going to go up in the mountain by themselves and pray 24/7 so that they can encounter God, right? That's that's not the way. That is not that is a rabbit hole. And even today in the Orthodox Church, that's considered acceptable. In fact that as far as they know, that's that's your best bet to achieving theosis as far as they know. You know, and you know what that reminds me of? That reminds me of the oracles up on the mountain, right? They're just reject everything else in society.
1:59:17 We're holier than the rest. You go to them when you need some special knowledge. Dispensed. So that was the really cool thing to me that Joseph Smith really presents as far as how you attained theosis because he didn't just restore the ordinances. Building communities, community is involved in this process. He resorts the ordinances. He there's, there's the church. He does establish a church and the church is plays a role in ascertaining to that and the emphasis on family especially. You're not going to attain the theosis by hiding from life. You're going to attain theosis by experiencing life and experiencing all of it and then coming out the other side.
2:00:01 You know, and I think he, I think this is huge too, because this, this should shift how we view the gospel, right? Too many guys I know lost their testimony when the hard times came, right? And I thought, why, why did that happen? And when I got to the bottom of when I really asked some of them was they looked at the gospel as something that was supposed to prevent hard times. That's not the truth. The Gospel is supposed to help you get through the tough times, right? Same sort of thing with them, with the monks that ascend them out, right? Well, you're seeking after more holiness, and that's great. But how you're getting there isn't going to do it because look, dude, you.
2:00:47 Got to find the holiness and changing dirty diapers. Yes, you have to. And, and this is where I think Judaism really has it dialed in because they'll tell you even when we're performing our jobs, it's supposed to be a prayer to God, right? You're supposed to find the, the, the holiness in every facet of your humanity. And if you just descend the mountain to just hang out and fast and pray and you don't have to worry about anything else, well, and especially if you take a vow of silence, no one's going to say anything that's going to piss you off, right? I mean, that's kind of no. Trial no tests. No, no, you're just you're there, right checking out right.
2:01:28 And I don't think that's the case right. I think there there's no great test if that's to be now, sure, there might be the test of you know what, I'd really like a wife, right. That would be rough. But we get that testing and we don't go up the mountain, right? At least some of us do. We get the tests we need. We get the trials and the challenges, whatever that may be. Whether it's you wanted a spouse and you couldn't find one, whether it's you had a spouse and you lost them, whether it's you have a child and you lost them, you didn't get a child. You want to. These things happen in life and you don't experience that through avoiding it. No. And, and the other thing I'll say is this back here, what you said about temperance, right? Balance.
2:02:11 Yeah. What does, what does it say in in first year, second, if I can't remember which one men are that they might have joy. Yeah. Look, it's hard for me now to imagine a full measure of joy without relationships, right? Without relationships with my wives, with my children, with my brethren, all those things, right. It's hard to have a full measure of joy without those. Right. And I'm, you know, I'm honestly, I'm great. I've had dark times in my life. I'm grateful for them, looking back at them now, because I wouldn't be the person I am if I hadn't gone through those things. I wouldn't experience joy to the same degree I do now if I hadn't had that sorrow back then. You know in in athletics, it's a true principle. You'll always learn more from your defeats than you will from your victories.
2:03:07 And no pain, no gain. Right, You don't. Look, nobody's really interested in breaking down game film if you're just toasting everybody around you, right? You might be good enough to beat everybody in your division or whatever, but that doesn't mean you're perfect at the game. That doesn't mean you can't improve. And it's usually only after a humbling that you're like, you know what, we better go back and we better watch the, the, the game tape, right? We better start seeing where we're deficient so we can become better. And I think our trials do that for us, right? Absolutely. You know, and going back to that quote from Joseph Smith, you know, as as God is, as manna is now, God once was. Well, the ramifications isn't just that God went through a probation.
2:03:59 The ratification is that as I am now, as you are now, with all of the baggage, with all the crap, with all of the trials and the challenge, the stuff that went wrong, when all of it is a part of who God is. You know, I think we can sometimes I think we put God on a pedestal and think that God is just this perfect being with no character, personality or past. That's just this perfect goodness, that's always. We turned him into a white statue. Yeah, I think we turned God into a white statue. And I don't think God's that way. And if you look at, you know, you look at the promises Christ, Christ promises us to, to drink wine with him and to feast with him. That's not something that a white statue does. No, no.
2:04:45 And, and the other thing I'll say is that there has to be proximity to deity for this all to really work, right. And we get that proximity. If we're Mormon and we're lucky to understand the Adam God doctrine, that's where that proximity comes from, right? And we can really say, OK, so if God is here, I am here. OK, so now, now I have a trajectory I can. Trace that. Lion, right? I have a trajectory of not only where I came from, but where I want to go. That's revolutionary, absolutely. So, but as far as going down rabbit holes and stuff like that, right, there's a couple, excuse me, there's a couple of things in in Orthodoxes, in Catholic and Orthodox.
2:05:34 It kind of, it bugged me at first. And I think this is an extreme right. And this is something that I completely reject. You know, you read What is it Osama Conky's book? Mormon Doctrine. Not Mormon doctrine. Or maybe it was Talmage. The Great Apostasy. Me yeah, the great you read something like that and you get these really strong anti Catholic sentiments, right? And you started rejecting a lot of these things maybe potentially off hand with the bias. But you know, there is a so a long time ago people didn't have their own copies of scriptures, right? And so you learned your scriptures through going to synagogue or going to church, and they'd be read to you and they'd be interpreted for you. I don't think that that's ideal.
2:06:16 I think it's great that we all have scriptures of our own these days and we can study them on our own. However, I've seen a lot of twisting. Of scripture Both. Both of them. Mormonism, Protestantism, and so looking at this more of a tradition that, you know, so the, the Catholic Orthodox there, there's an idea there that scriptures aren't to private interpretation. There was a discouragement of, of personal scripture study to a degree because they were concerned about people going down, going down those kinds of rabbit holes. And I think it here again, there's got to be a balance. There's got to be a balance.
2:07:02 You can't just say, well, if I can understand the scripture this way, then therefore it's true. And because, you know, you got to have something to hold onto. And I'm not a huge fan of tradition based off of my character, but I, I, I recognize that there is value. There is a value to tradition. And that's something I interestingly enough can see in, in the Orthodox Church, as far as you know, they don't have like gospel, you know, study groups, Bible study groups, like you do in, in prosodism and, and to a certain degree in Mormonism as much there the focus isn't so much on can you find your own interpretation in scriptures as much as it is understand, you know, understand what, what the scriptures actually mean. Well, and I think and.
2:07:52 Obviously that can be twisted if the person teaching it's off right, and that's certainly an issue in in the Orthodox Church. Otherwise there wouldn't have been a need for restoration. Right. And, and, and I'll say this too, right. Sometimes the best way to do that, sometimes we, let me phrase this, most times I think we think of revelation as very personal and it is. But sometimes revelation comes in councils or it comes with a group of fellows sitting down with the scriptures going, you know what, I think this means this and it's, you know, the other five guys look around at each other and go, did you bump your head this morning, right. Or wow, I never looked at it this way. This deserves some more thought and some more consideration, right?
2:08:39 But there has to be a healthy tension between, I'm just going to interpret them the way that I feel like I, I want to or the way I feel like I'm supposed to versus the other extreme, which is you're not, you're not thinking with the group, and that's bad. If that would have been the case, we never would have had Joseph Smith. Likewise, if it was too far the other direction, then we have no cohesion wherewith you can build that holy society that he was so anxiously engaged to build, right? So there's got to be a healthy tension. Absolutely, and I think when I look at the Orthodox Church I can see an extreme. Right.
2:09:24 But when I look at Mormonism, fundamentalism, I also often see an extreme there too, right? And so that's why I found it interesting to look at one extreme. It, it can almost be a mirror sometimes to recognize the, you know, the, your own fanaticism. And so the scriptures, reading the scriptures, studying the scriptures, that was one thing that was kind of interesting. And I don't, I still don't like it because it's, I think it's way too far extreme, but I can to a certain degree respect it. I understand where I understand where it's coming from, and it's not necessarily it's. It might not be the right solution, but it's certainly trying to solve a real problem. So you look at that like you look at Wilford Woodruff, right? You can see where he came from.
2:10:09 You just don't agree that that's the solution. Right, OK. And so one last thing along those lines is this idea of rote prayer. Is what? Rote prayer. OK. This is something that's really, really kind of foreign. I think generally speaking in Mormonism, there is there are certain world prayers, right, like the Sacramento blessing and things like that. But when we pray, we generally aren't repeating the same prayer every time we pray individually, right? Well, there's a practice, you know, they call the Jesus Prayer and there's not. This is just one of many, many. In fact, they've got entire books of full of prayers that you know that you would repeat. But the basics of the Jesus prayer, this is a version of it. You know, there's others, but you know, it's basically Lord Jesus Christ, have mercy upon me, a Sinner. And this prayer will be repeated and repeated and repeated and repeated.
2:11:10 And you know, my initial reaction to that is like, well, this seems really apostate, right? Vain in repetition. Exactly you think Matthew. Matthew 7. It's in Matthew. It's there. I can vouch for you. Yeah, Matthew 6-7 right. But when ye pray, use not vain repetitions as the heathen do, for they think that they should be heard for their much speaking. So I thought my first impression is, OK, this seems weird, It's foreign, so it's weird, and then I think it's wrong, right? But I wanted to really understand it. So what is why do they, why? Why do they do this? From their perspective, from an Orthodox perspective and.
2:11:51 I have an idea on this. There's some. There's some neat stuff. So first of all, you got to look at that scripture a little more closely, right? It says when ye pray use not vain repetitions and they make a point that vain is that descriptions or repetitions are being described as the vain thing or wait, not that it's vayne is the adjective describing repetitions. Right. Right. So if it was just repetitions in general, you know, it would be used, used not repetitious vanity or something, right?
2:12:34 It's, but it's, it's the other way around. Vayne is describing the repetitions. I mean, the issue here is, isn't necessarily with the repetition, it's with repetition and vanity. And the vanity being seen before all a bunch of people. Right. Seen before men. And so you know, they go into this and if you look at the Greek, the strongest concordance, it's like 945. And I can't pronounce this, but it's something like Battleogio. And their definition is properly to blubber nonsensical repetitions, to chatter, to be long winded, and to use empty words. Someone who's really flowery and very maybe even flattering a little bit. Exactly.
2:13:15 Suddenly, you know, you ever you ever been in the middle, you know been in a prayer, somebody's going and you just keep going. It's almost a sermon. And going yeah, right. It's like OK, I especially that long winded description of. This word. It's like fascinating, but you know from the Greek there's nothing here that signifies there anything, that the problem isn't the repetition, the issue is the vanity. So you're having it because let's look at Mormonism. There are many prayers that are repetitious, right? Sacrament every week. Baptism. Baptism has to be prescribed the same way.
2:13:57 The entire temple liturgy, as far as I'm concerned, right, right. Has to be there Baptisms for the dead. There's a a order to this that's repetitious every time you do it. Now, let me say this. I once OK, horrible admission time. There was once a girl I was super into and she she was Catholic. I may edit that part out so I don't tip her out who it was, But she's like, you should come to church with me. And I'm like, well, you're hot. I'm totally down with the Pope, so let's go. And I went and I was listening.
2:14:45 It was in one of the classes. It wasn't in the in the Mass. But one of the things they had said was your prayers should almost act like a mantra to put you into a state to where you're kind of meditative. Now what you just wrote, what you just read I can totally get. Right. So this is the practice. So they in the Orthodox Church, they've got this thing called, they call usually based off the tradition, which, you know, the Russians got their word for it, the Greeks got their word, but basically a prayer rope. And it looks more like a necklace here, but it's kind of made of wool and there's these little knots across it.
2:15:26 This one's got 30, but they've got different, different sizes and a standard is 100. And the practice is basically you repeat the Jesus prayer. Until you complete the loop. As you go across each link in the loop. See to me that that that almost is a gateway to a meditative state. Exactly. And that's the intent. And as you're doing it, you know that they'll make the sign of the cross by the Orthodox version, which is right, left, not left, right. But so I was thinking about this, right. And all of a sudden I just, this thing hit me.
2:16:06 And this might be completely anecdotal, but it's fascinating nonetheless. So, well, actually, maybe I should explain first. First, you're not supposed to do this without guidance. OK. They they're concerned about people taking this to an extreme. OK. Going down a rabbit hole, so to speak, right? And so you're supposed to have a, you know, your priest or Bishop that's going to tell you how many and how often, how much time to spend doing that so you don't end up, you know, making an idol. Out of prayer, the other. Thing is, you know, they'll wear these around their wrists and you know, but they they'll be hidden as well.
2:16:47 They're not many things. This isn't an icon to show like hey, I'm orthodox. It's supposed to be used so that while you're at work and nothing else is going on or something, you got a moment, you can kind of slip it out and sit back and and focus your thoughts on Christ and your relationship with Christ and go and have a little meditation. You know, on your lunch break and you know, you got to close your eyes, but maybe you're dry. I don't know. It's just you find opportunities. You wear it with you as a reminder that when you have opportunities you go through and you focus on your prayer to be praying always to. Always.
2:17:28 Have a prayer in your heart. Once you described wearing that, it's got some echoes of the garment. Sure. Right. I mean, look, as Mormons, there ain't no getting around that, right? I mean, you're going to see them and you're going to be constantly reminded. Right. So first of all, again, there is they do recognize you can take things to extremes. And so they're they're very careful about, you know, you know, they don't recommend people do this on their own. They prohibit it, which I can kind of understand. You know, I'm not Orthodox, though. I thought I'm going to give it a try. Why not? And I actually found it was really fascinating the first time I, I, I was doing it, you know, your mind kind of tries to wander and you have to pull it back. But as you pull it back, the words you're saying, you know, asking Christ to have mercy upon you really starts sinking in. And I start to feel it more emotionally and even intellectually at a, at a, at a deeper level as I kind of continue going through it.
2:18:40 And so I, I honestly don't think it's necessarily a bad practice. I'm not prescribing it to anybody, but I'm saying it. It was pretty interesting, sure. And. And look, I think, I think Joseph gives us precedent here for looking at some of these things, right where he says, I, I don't want anyone to abandon any truth that they have. I'm just saying bring your truth and combine it with ours and let's get closer. Right. Right. And so certainly, you know, like you were saying, I'm not saying folks and I don't think you're saying folks should run out and get a prayer rope, right? But maybe the principal maybe behind it, maybe. There's something you can. Do is more in line, right with, hey, maybe there's something I should do?
2:19:25 Do I concentrate on my covenants as much, right, Right. Maybe instead of a prayer rope and a prescribed prayer, maybe what you do is find something like your garment, right? That might remind you of your temple covenants, right? And then contemplate on those. Sure. You know, one of the thoughts that came to me personally was rather than a strictly wrote prayer, what if I just have a prayer in the moment That's significant, but I'm just going to repeat it to really, really focus on it. What I found is when you keep repeating it, you're increasing your intent. Yeah.
2:20:06 You're actually focusing your intent. Absolutely. I mean, how many times have you prayed and you get done with your prayer and you don't even remember what you said, right? It happens to me quite a bit, right? Even more so, Even more so how many times does somebody else pray and they get done? And the whole time you were thinking about, you know, guy, get the kids loaded in the car or what are we going to do for dinner? And. That's where my mind goes. Like do I have steak at home? Right. That's that's typically where I go. And it's really hard to have faith and intent when you're really not focused. And so you don't necessarily need a prayer rope to focus, but certainly I find repetition to a certain amount can actually help in that focus. Well, and look, we're going to struggle with different things at different times, right?
2:20:56 And in doing that, in understanding that there's times that your prayers are going to sound awfully familiar. I mean, repetitious, right? If I got someone in the hospital, I don't know how many times my prayer probably sounded the exact same when one of my kids was in the hospital. God just helped me be strong enough to help them get through this. Fix them, please, God. I mean, it was pretty repetitious. It doesn't mean it was vain. I mean, it was coming from a place of primal fear and worry and angst and I, I don't think that's ever repetitious. Well, if you really think about it, too often the most desperate prayers are repetitious because you're in it. You're in it.
2:21:41 Yeah, you're in the middle of something and it needs to pass. Yeah, and there's nothing else to focus on. There's nothing else to think about. Nope. Well, look. You need that connection with God, You need it now, and nothing else is going to suffice. I've often wondered. We look at Joseph's prayer in the Grove as a singular event. I wonder just how many times he actually prayed for guidance before it showed up. For sure, right? I don't think that there's anything wrong with repetitious prayers. It's the vanity. It's the vanity. That you need to worry about could be seen. Right could be seen doing it or to.
2:22:21 Some or sometimes you just get into the habit of this is just what I do right? And I think that can be as equally as dangerous. That's equally vain. Yes, Yep. And so I think the intent has to be really explicit all. Right, so check this out. I'm going to, I'm not going to comment on this explanation, but so to put this practice, one way you could describe this is, is that you have a circle, you're going to make a sign making signs, and then there's going to be a prayer and it's going to be repeated around the circle. Interesting. Interesting. Another echo, another.
2:23:04 Echo yeah, that's all I'm going to say about that. But yeah. It's interesting, yeah. Absolutely. So, yeah, All in all, it was, it's a fast and there's I, I, I'm sure there's a lot more to be gleaned from an, a better understanding of, of the Orthodox faith. And I'm going to continue to explore this. I hope other people might maybe get inspired and maybe more academic and qualified people to jump, jump on to this and see if we can't find more echoes and truths and, and application. And but going back to the original question that I had when that started me down this whole rabbit hole was, you know, what is wrong?
2:23:47 What, what what is it seems like things are going wrong and why? What do you what do you do about it? You know, on the one hand, you've got incredibly authoritative perspectives of Mormonism where there's there's no agency to grow, no opportunity to receive the fullness. On the other hand, you've got versions that are just off the wall. And it's a new theology every day. And, you know, we're starting to Add all kinds of insanity, like, like, like, you know, serpent seed or reincarnation or just all kinds of heresies. And they're, and now these are, you know, you got people that are just adopting this and, and, and melding it in. And it's like, where is the where is that whole trueness that can last, that can be prepared for Christ that's coming?
2:24:41 Right. And what I've, what I discovered is an idea here. And this is something that kind of came to me, But you know, I, I've studied, you know, US Constitution, politics, things like that quite a bit. And the founding fathers were no, were no idiots. They didn't come up with our form of government through just luck. Oh, they weren't just some crap against the wall to see what sticks. No, no, they they studied history, they studied philosophy, they studied economics. They had a good an understanding of what does not work for government. Who you thought they had spent that much time on it? That's weird. Well, a lot of people on Twitter these days.
2:25:24 Nice. But that's not the case. And so our form of government was carefully crafted. And it might not be perfect, but the idea was to get as close as they could. And they knew what doesn't work. They've looked at theocracy, they looked at monarchy, they've looked at aristocracy, they've looked at all these different ways you can have government anarchy. Democracy. Democracy, They looked at all of that and they're like, this doesn't work, this doesn't work. Why? Because at the end of the day, human nature exists. We're all flawed. We fell well with Adam's fall. We're we're born into a world where we, we're going to have these natural inclinations to be selfish, to be greedy, to take advantage.
2:26:11 And, and unless we're all angels, government can't fix that problem, right? There's no form of government that can work, that can't be abused, that can't be corrupted, But they want to get as close as they possibly could. And in my studies of that, one of the interesting things is this, the reason for the separation of powers, the reason for that separation of powers is because they, they understood that man will fail. This is, it's an assumption that man will fail that, that you're going to, you know what, you might have a George Washington, but you're also going to end up with, I shouldn't say anything. I don't want to offend anybody but either. A Karl Marx.
2:26:57 Yeah, sure. There you go. But you're gonna, you know, you might end up with some Karl Marx as well, right. So they understanding that human nature will corrupt and fail, they came up with a system with that assumption from the beginning that this is going to break Nan is going to abuse power. So how do we organize this in a way so that that's that when that happens, it can be caused the least amount of damage. They can't solve it. Absolutely, it's impossible to completely prevent this kind of corruption, but they, they, they wanted a system. And the underlying assumption is, is that things break. Well, you know, my perspective and I think a lot of people's perspective and on religion, Christianity from the beginning and up until this day has been focused on how do we create a church that won't schism, what kind of organization? And you know, you got solutions to that that become terrible, horrible.
2:28:08 In. History. But hey, for friends, schism. They can't schism if they're dead. Right. Yeah, and then you've got lesser forms of of, of of this kind of tyranny. We want freedom, but if we have freedom, we're going to scatter and schism. And so this was the thing that I kept pondering over, right? How do you, how do you solve these kinds of problems? And I actually think we have a potential answer. And looking at the early organization of the Orthodox Church, which is this idea of franchises. And I think it's, it's, it's, it's, it's an assumption that there will be schism. It's not a form that can't handle schism. It's not a form that's going to prevent schism, because that would take away free agency, but it's a form where schism can be allowed to happen.
2:28:58 In kind of a healthy way. But in a healthy, in the most healthy way that it can, right? Right. We see that with our states, right? Or that why are there 50 states? Why were there? Why? So states could try on different codes to see what works best. Yeah, our, our government was organized in schism, right, For that intent. And so rather than how do we stop them from apostasizing, how do we stop the splits, right. If you're a fundamentalist group and you know, how often do they split? That never happens, right? No, no, that's never happened. No. We're we're a giant monolith. You know, we, we preserve the truth, right? As a single unit, single hole with with no descent and and fragmentation. No, you, you got a plan for it though. Yeah, that's that's what came to me. You got a plan for it.
2:29:46 And how do you organize so that you can plan for it? And I think, I think that franchise model makes sense and well, honestly, it's still working for the Orthodox. Well, here's what I'm going to say. If you look at the way the Church was set up by Joseph Smith, that was the model. Yeah, I that's the other thing that. Was the model. I believe that was the idea. I I believe that the churches, the Bishop. Yeah. Was intended to be, to a certain degree, sovereign over that church, right? That church was independent, local leadership. And that's the other principle we learned studying government. What works? The government that governs closest to the people, right?
2:30:28 And how can you have that when you have well, to a certain degree, part of the issue is, is one man is. Yeah. When you, when you've got an, when you have a Pope, you cannot have that. Right. But if you get rid of this idea of a Pope and instead you have patriarchs. Right. All of a sudden, you know, we can kind of get along and we can still be different. We can still have schism and hey, you know what? You believe that doctor? And I don't think so. That seems crazy to me. But we can still be friends. I can still as long. As it's not dangerous and it doesn't degrade the faith, right? And that's the thing. So what? What is the commonality holding together the Orthodox Church? It's their sacraments. Right.
2:31:10 It's their ordinances. It's. Their priesthood, yeah. And and that, look, those would be the things that would hold Mormonism together, right? Right. Because with Mormonism, I feel like we have a really good defined end goal, right? Yeah. We have a very well defined where we want to be. What, what comes into play at that point is the best way to get there. Now, obviously there's the straight and narrow, the iron rod, right? That was in the Scripture for a reason. I think that it takes a lot of prayer, a lot of revelation to find out what that rod is exactly. Right with with that real quick you know what life is messy. My life is messy.
2:32:05 Your life is messy at least not maybe maybe everybody listening has got a different experience. My experience life is messy to get where I am today, I went through all kinds of crap and it wasn't always pretty, but it was beautiful nonetheless, because eventually it sort because of that it sorted stuff out. How do we expect to get to that iron rod to a certain degree without a certain amount of messiness? Well, yeah, yeah, no. And, and look, I would love to tell everybody, oh, just let's all just gather in one place. Problem is, good luck doing that today without some judgments first. Sure, Right.
2:32:47 Does that mean we stopped trying then? No, I don't think so. I think that franchise model works really well. Right. And the beauty of that is that you can still have certain differences as long as it's not going too far. I mean like, so you know, do you break the bread before you do the sacrament prayer or do you the sacrament prayer and then break the bread does? It matter. Well, maybe it does, and maybe somebody feels that it does, right? I think that's OK. Yeah. And somebody else can feel differently, and that can be OK. It doesn't invalidate the ordinance, no. Does the entire congregation have to stand or kneel? You know, I think I've got my ideas on it, but what it is, it completely invalidate the ornaments. I don't think it does.
2:33:32 I don't think it does 'cause I think it, I think you probably should kneel. But nonetheless, when I was, when I was in the LDS church, we didn't kneel and sacrament still worked. So, you know, there might be ideals, but if it's functional, if it's still working, it'll produce fruit. And if it produces fruit, people will gather to feed. If it produces bad fruit, then people are going to want to get away from Warren Jeffs. And look here, here's the thing, as long as we don't allow it to go to that level of tyranny that we saw down in Colorado City, people will vote with their feet, right? Right. If something's not working for people, they'll be like, you know what?
2:34:12 They're not bad people, but this ain't working for me. And they'll go down the road somewhere. And it could be a matter of of, of what you need for your personal journey at that moment in life. You know, this group over here there might be really charismatic and really Lucy and just kind of, you know, disorganized. This one might be super structured and well, what one do you need? Depends who you are, which one's right. Well, it depends on what you need in the moment potentially. And there's nothing wrong with either of those things inherently by them in and of itself. I don't think as long as you're not distorting the ordinances, as long as you're not rewriting scripture, as long as you're not saying our guy's the only guy and he gets to tell everybody else what to do, then I think we can actually all get along and agree to disagree. And that actually agreeing to disagree might just even be the key to to further lighten knowledge. I think you're right.
2:35:13 I think we read, read the scripture that Zion is Zion because it's people of one heart and one mind. Yeah, but that's not a real good description of everything. But is it of one family culture? That's why I'm saying it's not a real good description of everything, right? Are we of one heart and one mind when we all have the same goal in mind? Yeah, yeah, I would say so. Are we of one heart and one mind when we all agree that these ordinances shouldn't be tampered with and they should remain as pure as possible? Yeah, I think we're of one heart and one mind on that, right. Now, where do I find a litmus test on how far that goes, right, And how much room is left for dissent if you have one guy who dictates what it is?
2:36:17 I get a little nervous, right? I get a little twitchy. And, you know, I was just thinking, as you were were saying that talking about this, you know, maybe there's times when a representative from each council of those churches come together, right? And, and have the opportunity to hash some of those things out, right? And maybe it does leave with, we're going to agree to disagree on this, right? Or maybe hearts and minds are changed somewhere, right? And so. And it can be, hey, we tried this and it didn't work, right. Oh well, we were thinking of doing that. Thanks for sharing. We'll that maybe we won't then, right? Working together.
2:36:58 Yeah, yeah. Coming together to me, the, the, the organization of the Orthodox Church is beautiful and I think it's the vision that Joseph Smith had in mind and it's a vision that unfortunately got lost. And as fundamentalist, it's not something that we have ever really recovered or retained. But I you're always, there's always going to be differences, but I think it would be a really beautiful thing if you know, somebody from the Kingston's can go and, you know, go to the AUB and, and participate in oranges there and be recognized and respected and vice versa. And with all the different groups that there's a certain level of, Hey, we're all in this together.
2:37:39 We all have the same ultimate objective. We all believe in the value of the things that get us there And and hey, you know, you can maintain your sovereignty, but let's just respect and recognize each other. And our current common ordinances, yeah, yeah. On the basis of our common ordinances and our Common Core theology. Yeah, absolutely. And you know, the FLDS can try something, come back, say, hey, yeah, we tried placement. Marriage didn't work. Didn't work. Don't do that. OK great, good to know they tried it out, not me. Right, exactly. But now let's all come together and decide that hey, you know what? This is something that we probably don't want to do in our churches. Have the leaders of those churches come together and we can have other churches.
2:38:27 New churches can spring up. Fundamentalism doesn't have to be a this group or that group, and splits can happen and they can still be respectful and recognize things. And if things get really bad, you know, there's still always schism. Well, if necessary. I suppose if it ever got really bad and my definition of really bad is Warren Jeffs 2 point O right, right. My hope at that point would be that there would be enough of a council mentality that the rest of the council would come together and be like we got to go help out those people. Right. And the people are going to want to look for. That's the other thing. If a system like this is in place, the people are a lot more are a lot more aware that they can vote with their feet.
2:39:09 If you're in a word like I don't like what's going on. This seems wrong. And even though I like the people in the culture, it's getting spooky. It's getting spooky. I'm going to go fellowship with the other group. Right. Even though I don't like people as much with the culture, but it's not as spooky. Things like that will resolve themselves and it's going to hold leaders even more accountable because their congregations sort of speak, can go with their feet. They have their agency again. We've tried the pyramid model, right? And it doesn't work. It doesn't work. We know that doesn't work. It it's not working for the LDS church always schisms it. Always. Splits and it's bad. It's because it's all based on cult of personality, right? And yeah, it hasn't worked before successfully. It's always ended up in some sort of disaster. And I think it's going to continue to do that until we recognize that Joseph was on to something when he started talking about councils and we got to get back to that. Yeah, So I don't know, maybe it's just a vision. I I don't think I'm naive because I realized that I don't know how realistic this is given the different groups and the relationships and even with the LDS Church. I mean, even though that might be the great schism as fundamentalist in Mormons, nonetheless, I mean, certainly as a fundamentalist, I don't, I don't discount that they have priesthood, right.
2:40:40 Like I, I don't have any issues. I would have no problems, you know, participating in a, in a, in a priesthood blessing with people in the LDS Church. And you know, I don't know if that go would go the other direction, but if we can get to that kind of a place. Look, and just because in the past schisms has happened that were irreconcilable doesn't mean they have to stay that way, right? They're, they're look as believers in an atonement that works on the, on the micro and the macro. And I think we we owe it to this work to be open to that.
2:41:22 And have faith, yeah, that atonement at one can happen with the. Church as well. Yep, absolutely. And. Just one last thing on the on the beauty of this kind of a model in my mind is, and this is a little bit different because of this great schism, but you know, the Orthodox Church is not big on proselyting. Right. Whereas the Catholic Church does a lot better job at bringing in new conforts, the Orthodox attitude sounds. Familiar. Right. Doesn't this sound familiar? Sounds familiar. The attitude in the Orthodox Church is kind of like, you know, if, if they're prepared, they'll find us.
2:42:05 You like it's like you're not wrong. But I don't think that's the whole story. Yeah, but, but so, but, you know, there can be value even in a church that says, hey, you know, this is what we're, this is what we're emphasizing. This is what we focus on. And other churches. I mean, if we think of the church as the body of Christ, well, what does a body have? Parts? It's got hands, it's got feet, it's got elbows, it's got ears and noses and mouths and eyes and all kinds of stuff like that, right. It almost seems like ideally a perfect Christ Church would have that individuality across the different congregations.
2:42:48 Right, right. One that's more missionary oriented, one that's more temple oriented. Or however it is. Right. Yeah. Those are my thoughts on it. Dude, that's good stuff. Well, man, that was awesome. So I guess, you know, and, and this is what I want to drive home to folks, right? Because inevitably there's going to be someone who's going to point and say heresy, right? These are just thoughts, right? There's nothing wrong with exploring ideas, right? No one's saying here that this is the way it has to be or the way it's going to be. They're just thoughts. And if you don't ever think outside the box a little bit, you're going to stay in the box we're in. And right now that box I don't think is. It's not very comfortable.
2:43:35 It's not working for a ton of people. Got some sharp edges? We, we see some folks doing some really great things and we see some other folks doing some really crappy things. And I think we, we have to be willing to entertain ideas to, to get to the bottom of this and ultimately establish that one heart and one mind that Joseph talked about. But dude, good stuff. Thanks for coming on Anytime, Dave. All right, ma'am, we'll talk to you later. All right. The.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox