Episode #146: The Importance Of Brigham Young W/Kimberly Watson Smith, Sean Anderson, Jacob Vidrine, & Taylor Smith
Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.
Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products
There is a movement today in much of the Restoration to either distance itself or in extreme instances completely throw out Brigham Young. The problem is if you throw out Brigham Young you also throw out anything that is uniquely Mormon because its during Brigham’s administration that many of the deeper doctrines of the Restoration taught by Joseph are expounded upon by Brigham Young. So to help talk about the importance of Brigham Young I have put together a powerhouse panel to have this discussion. Joining me for this is Kimberly Watson Smith, Sean Anderson, Jacob Vidrine, & Taylor Smith. We discuss Brigham’s life before he joins the church, his early ministry, his missionary efforts, his pivotal role in the succession crisis, his leadership in getting the saints to the west and finally finish up by talking about what Brigham Young’s legacy and importance is in the Restoration of the Gospel. That’s next on this episode of the MRP.
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support0:05 There is a movement today in much of the restoration to either distance itself or an extreme instances, completely throw out Brigham Young. The problem is, if you throw Brigham Young out, you also throw out anything that is uniquely Mormon because it's during Brigham's administration that many of the deeper doctrines of the restoration taught by Joseph Smith are expounded upon by Brigham Young. So to help talk about the importance of Brigham Young, I bought together a powerhouse of a panel to have this discussion. Joining me for this today are Kimberly Watson Smith, Sean Anderson, Jacob the Dream, and Taylor Smith. We discussed Brigham's life before he joins the church, his early ministry, his missionary efforts, his pivotal role in the secession crisis, his leadership in getting the Saints out West, and finally finishing up by talking about Brigham Young's legacy and importance in the restoration of the gospel.
0:53 That's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. So a few weeks back I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running. Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page or click the link in this episode show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups, and water bottles all with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU, but you should definitely go check that out.
1:35 Now this is just the beginning. In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast. So head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode show notes and get yours today. The. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. All right, so tonight I'm going to do something that's a little different.
2:33 We've done it a few times before, always had good luck with it, but we're going to do a kind of a panel discussion, not a debate, just a discussion. And we're going to do it about Brigham Young. To help me with that, I've brought on some big heavy hitters, right? We've got Kimberly Watson Smith, Jacob the Dream, we've got Sean Anderson and Taylor Smith that are all joining us here for for this podcast. And so as we have this discussion, just know in advance, these are folks who have done their homework. They understand the gospel really well. And we all come from a little bit different perspective on Brigham Young.
3:15 Certainly some of us have had our differences in the past and that's OK because we're going to have those things. But I, I think I wanted this to showcase that even though we have our differences on certain things, on these big important issues, we can come together and kind of have each other's back. I mean, I'm a fundamentalist, Sean's a fundamentalist, Jacob and, and Taylor both fundamentalist. Kimberly is an active member of the LDS Church and we can all kind of come together on this and, and really kind of back up Brigham Young here because he I think you'll see by the end of this podcast just how vital he is to the restoration going forward. So with that, I think I think everybody knows who everybody is, right?
4:04 I mean, we, we've all worked together, talked together at some point. So I don't think there's much need for, for an introduction, but I'm just going to be tossing out some questions. And then as, as you guys have thoughts and, you know, ideas or, or whatnot, feel free to jump in. We'll, we'll keep it orderly, but by no means is this a raise your hand to participate sort of a thing. So with that, let's let's just dive right in. I want to throw this question first out to the panel and, and I want to get everybody's feedback here. So we're we're living in a day and age today where Brigham is under immense attack.
4:45 People would be happy just to chop Brigham off and not have him be part of the gospel story at all. First, I want to ask this question. Why do you think that is? Who wants to take a first stab at that? I actually just had somebody ask me about this today because there's just so many railing accusations that are made against Brigham Young. And he pointed, this friend of mine was asking, he said these people with many a diverse set of views that they don't really even agree on. The only thing they really agree on it seems is attacking Brigham Young. And so he was wondering why all these different people with different beliefs about authority, different break offs, different modern movements that have come forth.
5:34 And I, I kind of what came to mind when this was just asked me a few hours ago, I said, well, I think Brigham Young, he, he was the most successful in perpetuating what Joseph Smith was teaching and restoring out of anyone else. And he got the biggest following. And so he was, he's by far the biggest target for people who are disgruntled or looking for someone to attack or demonize or tear down in the restoration. I think that's, that's probably the biggest reason in my opinion, is that he has the biggest target on his back for being the most successful and having the most followers, if that out of all the NABU break offs and, and, and Mormon and when you get into the succession crisis and all that. So I don't know.
6:25 Does anyone else have any thoughts or? One of the observations that I can make is he's often charged, you know, and those who follow him, you know, where they refer to us as Brighamites, they like to claim that the victors write the history. And the, the thing that makes me, makes me laugh at that is the fact that Brigham and the Saints that had to leave Nauvoo and leave their homes behind didn't, at that time didn't seem like they were very victorious. As a matter of fact, they're the ones that were run out.
7:06 And, and the fact that given the time that's that's passed, even in his day, the church continued to grow. They continued to build the Kingdom of God. They established it and they still have the same goal. And if you look at those that stayed behind, they just kind of fell back and became another Protestant movement in my opinion. And I think in some ways, there's a certain amount of I'll, I'll go ahead and call it jealousy. But anyway, that's just an observation I have about that. Taylor, did you want to take a stab at that at all? Yeah, I'll, I'll speak to that.
7:51 So the reality is that there are some difficult doctrines in the Restoration and they're not for everyone. And one of the things that seems to elicit the most emotional and just major response of anything is polygamy. And so we have this situation today where the, the church has disavowed polygamy for 135 years or four years, give or take. And, and a lot of members of the church are not familiar with the history. But if they start to have concerns with maybe the church's authority and, and legitimacy, then they, they look for any weakness, any area of weakness and you know, getting people upset about polygamy or anti polygamy. That's something that politicians have been doing since day one in this country.
8:49 So I mean, you look at even in the, in the 1860s, I want to say it was the Stephen Douglas debates. I guess it would have been the 1850s. Lincoln and Douglas were were asked about the Mormons and Stephen Douglas said, well, I'm going to, you know, it's like a cancer. I'm going to cut it out with a knife and, you know, get rid of the the twin bar relics of barbarism, slavery and polygamy. And so polygamy is, is a is a very easy thing to bash. And you know, you have a lot of people who are, I guess you could say they, they, they, they want to believe in some parts of the gospel, like Joseph Smith and, you know, seership book of Mormons.
9:35 Some, some of these, you know, very positive and frankly don't require quite as much of A sacrifice types of principles. And, and if they can find a way and, and find a a way to do it and not have to touch anything that's distasteful or that would challenge their, you know, propensities and things that they would be be interested in. You know, if they could get rid of polygamy and keep Joseph Smith, I think there's a huge market for that. And so that has especially with recent movements like Denver Snuffer ISM and the Doctrine of Christ group with Justin Griffin and so forth, I think that there is a probably sincere desire to cling to the gospel, but they don't realize that they are absolutely destroying it because of their disavowal and trying to remove polygamy from the equations. That's that's I guess maybe another. And, and if you can kill, if you can discredit Brigham Young, that is the ultimate ad hominem.
10:40 And because they, they like to pretend that it was just a conspiracy by the 12 to take over things and, and institute polygamy for, you know, probably carnal reasons and whatnot, which is just silly. But it is it is a a a very prevalent thinking that I've encountered in discussions with various folks in different groups. Oops, sorry Kim, do you have a take on this at all? I maybe have a unique perspective. I'm sure maybe you've considered this, but just being as being a a mainstream member of the church, I would say that because I in in the church as a whole, I think there is a very negative view of Brigham Young, even among the faithful.
11:26 And the reason why I feel this way is because, number one, I feel like we're so far removed from the doctrines today that most people just didn't grow up with like what Taylor was saying, kind of those hard, you know, those the mysteries of the gospel, they weren't passed down from one generation to the next. We've kind of just dismissed them. And and so I think as far as just we, we're living also in a generation where we're, you know, this is fifth wave feminism now, right? And I think the more people are a victim of feminism than they realize. And so they, so reading Brigham Young is very hard for them.
12:09 It's very, it goes contrary to culture, to everything they've grown up with. And I mean, you go tell someone to read Brigham Young and do they even understand what he's saying? It it goes against, you know, everything they've been conditioned to believe for, you know, even about the Restoration. People talk about Joseph Smith, but how many people even really know his teachings? I mean, let alone Brigham Young. But when Brigham Young's teaching the the teachings of Joseph Smith, that's what they're dismissing ultimately is what Joseph Smith revealed. That's awesome. I, I want to probe this a little bit because it, quite frankly, I'll be honest, shouldn't be a surprise to anyone out there in the audience. This isn't something I put together. How does, how does feminism kind of kind of make someone more prone?
13:03 I guess if I'm understanding your, your premise here a little bit, Kim, how does, how does feminism make someone feel maybe more at odds or put someone in a position where they might be more at odds with Brigham Young. And the other thing I'll say is I was not aware that we're into the 5th wave of feminism. I, I thought we were still back on the 4th. So. Right. Well, I think about it, Brigham Young, it's a nobody. Even if you were to ask someone what is the patriarchal order, what kind of response are you going to get it? It would be that you're going to hear whatever you know, the feminist view is it's patriarchy, it's bad, it's male domination. Toxic masculinity.
13:44 Yeah, toxic masculinity. I mean, you just have to look at even in today, people can't even they can't even wrap their their minds around even a, a marriage where you have a man and a woman that's 5050 even to them. That is, you know, that that tramples on the right to the women, even if they're in an equal partnership. She has to be completely free, independent of a man. And I've actually seen this in just recent, you know, LDS podcast where, you know, women are talking about, oh, we want, you know, the priesthood or we want to, you know, there's this priestess, this, you know, priestess hood that we need to be seeking after.
14:29 And they don't realize that that is part of the patriarchal order. They don't even know what it is. So, and that I, I believe it's because of feminism. And even if you, if a woman says she's not a feminism, a feminist, she carries ideas. Both men and women today, I believe, carry those ideas and they look at it through that lens, the gospel through that lens. Wow, that's, that's some profound stuff. That's awesome. You know, I, I think there's a book by, by Hugh Nibley called Brother Brigham Challenges the Saints, right? And I think that that Brigham constantly challenges us, right? He has to, he's, he's a prophet.
15:12 That's what his calling is to a large extent, is to challenge us in terms of living the gospel more more fully, but also the things he taught. Let me ask this question and then we'll we'll move on to something else. Many, many, many things. Almost all things that Brigham teaches, you can find Joseph teaching as well. Why doesn't Joseph get the same pushback as Brigham Young? And that's for the whole panel. Whoever wants to take a stab at that, All of you, if you'd like. Yeah, I'll, I'll, I'll dive into that first because I, that's some excellent, you know, perspective, Kimberly. The, the reality is even the Saint, it's not just modern Saints that struggle with Brigham, even some of the early Saints really struggled with some of the things that he was teaching, even when he said I'm just teaching what Joseph taught me.
16:10 And and so the, the reality is, I can't remember if it was was Jacob or Sean. Somebody mentioned earlier about the deeper things. I think maybe all of us may have touched on it. But but some of those deeper things are when, when Joseph the the nature of having of of being a martyr is that kind of you get a pass, you get kind of your memory is unsolied, as it were, from anything that could. And and so people just have a tendency to paint with rose colored glasses some of the things that that Joseph did.
16:51 And, and the reality is he he did teach some very challenging things to the Saints, but he did it in private. And Brigham kind of when the church relocated to Utah, they were out a side of the direct threat of mob violence and, you know, government oppression back east in the United States. And when they established kind of, you know, an autonomous nation of Deseret, there was certainly a little more freedom. People, I think Brigham and others felt that they could speak a little more freely. And so it's not that Joseph didn't teach things, but he didn't teach them publicly.
17:34 And, and so even the contemporaries of Brigham Young struggled with a lot of the deeper, more challenging things that that that Brigham Young kind of brought out in public. So no, that's that's good, Sean. Yeah, What I wanted to point out is to follow along with what Taylor was saying. One of the biggest claims from from that group of people is that they actually say there's no evidence contemporary with Joseph Smith that he taught any of these doctrines.
18:16 And actually there is. And I found that anytime you find anything, they they look for a way to invalidate it by calling into question the credibility of whoever wrote it down. And it doesn't matter that people testify to these things from different camps. You have people that were inimical to Brigham, friendly to Joseph. You had people that were inimical to both, all saying the same thing. And yet they like to paint it as a conspiracy from Brigham Young directing everything. And to me that's he's got to be the best conspirator ever because he gets all these people from different camps to agree on the same thing.
19:00 And it doesn't matter to them that the lens from which those people are looking at it, those that those that are against it are definitely critical about it, but they point to the same facts. And then you have others that are amicable to those principles also relating the same facts from that perspective. So to me that goes well beyond the law of witnesses to establish a truth, especially when you have people that are not in no way able to what's the to conspire with each other because they're in opposite camps. So.
19:47 So one of the things I would add, why I think it's people think it, why it appears that it's there's, it seems baffling to us, but why it seems to be easy for some people to try to. Blame everything they don't like on Brigham Young and make Joseph Smith in their own image is the reality is we don't have really good records for everything in Joseph Smith's lifetime. And you know that there was no Pittman shorthand records of Joseph Smith's sermons. You have brief summary notes that different people kept at different times. And by the very end of his life, you start to get some more detailed shorthand reports in 1844.
20:30 But even those are not anything compared to the detailed stenographic reports we have of Brigham Young sermons. And so not only is there, it's not as well recorded, but you also have twice as over twice the amount of time of Brigham Young teaching throughout his ministry and having recorded teaching. So like with Joseph Smith's ministry, we have 1830 to 1844, four, 14 years really With Brigham Young, you have over 30 years. He was the, I think is he the second longest serving president of the church behind Heber J Grant, if I'm not mistaken. So he, you know, had a lot of years and he was very open and about his views. He was he was on the rough frontier and he was a lot. He was very abrasive in his language and how he talked. And he often would admit that he said things that were harsh or more callous that in order to get the Saints to ignore for the his what he's trying to convey to the Saints to get through to him.
21:38 And he would say that often he would use harsh language and not actually mean what he said. But people, especially when it comes to the feminism issue, because I do think that's a big issue of behind attacking Brigham Young is, you know, there's obviously the culture that he's in, but you can take you can cherry pick when you have that 30 years of stenographic reports of what he's saying at various times, you can cherry pick that to almost create whatever Brigham Young you want. You can check, take the harshest statements to make him out to be a monster. You can take the the, the nicest statements that make him out to be, you know, fuzzy Unicorn, but the the truth is somewhere in the middle. But he definitely, but I think that you need to not just judge him by his words, but by his actions. And so with the feminist attack on him, they really want to take something out of context.
22:33 And I saw this happen actually just today with a post that was made trying to take something he said and, and use it to say that he was trying to silence women, telling them to just shut up and accept polygamy when that is not the context of what he was trying to convey. He was basically saying that it's not good to have a grumbling spirit. And if you are, he basically said, I was I'm willing to let everyone who is unhappy with the system leave the territory and, you know, get have your bill of divorce, have your property and be taken care of if you know, and this is your opportunity. But if you continue, if you choose to continue to live this way, you cannot have this eternal rumbling about it.
23:16 And so that kind of actually. And so some people pointed out in response to that attack that it contradicts the narrative of this idea that women are being pressured or or forced or imprisoned into polygamy because he was or into Mormonism in general in the in the Rocky Mountain West, this idea that he was oppressing people and forcing him into the system. Brigham didn't want to pressure everyone into Mormonism. If you were disgruntled and you weren't giving your heart to it, he wanted you gone. He said I want apostates to clear out and he wanted people to not be having their influence poison the rest of the Saints. And so, you know, and so some people will take some things he says about, you know, he says in certain discourses to try to malign his character.
24:03 But when you look at his actual record and how women were treated in early Utah, the very, you know, this is record of allowing women to very easily get out of bad marriage situations if they are in bad marriage situations compared to the rest of the country at that time. And the empowerment of the women with the Relief Society and with the political participation that he encouraged during his lifetime. I think there's a much more complicated picture than what the simplistic demonizing image some people try to create. So. Good stuff, Kim, did you want to take a shot at that?
24:44 I. Just want to push back a little bit about like even the idea that, you know, there were a lot of people that even in early Utah that didn't like Brigham Young. I'm sure that's the case. I don't run into a lot of that when I study church history. And I just want to speak to the women because I actually gained my testimony of Brigham Young by reading some of the women and what they had to say about Brigham Young. And for example, Eliza Snow, she's written many poems in praise of Brigham Young. And it's not just her. There's a, a story of Emily Partridge, who we know, I think was a, is it Emily that was up her wife, She Josephs, his poor wife. And then she married Brigham Young. And she tells this story of how she needed to go to Brigham Young 'cause she needed money and she was kind of intimidated by him and didn't know quite how to approach him. And then she relates to experience how she had a completely opposite experience of, of what she was told of, you know, how he was going to be overbearing and, and she was afraid to approach him.
25:47 And he turned out to be, you know, loving and kind. And, and so I, and, and it's not just some of the, it's not just the plural wives. There's many women who who said, I entered into plural marriage because Brigham Young had the voice of an Angel. And when he spoke of this command, I knew it came straight from God. And so I could, I could list hundreds of sources where you have women testifying of how to them Brigham Young was a prophet. Brigham Young was a leader. He was loving and kind. And, and those that actually followed his counsel, you'll see that those are the women that actually had the gifts of the Spirit.
26:30 Those are the ones that he trusted to go out and give healing blessings to the other women. And it, these are the women that he trusted to go and build the 1st hospital. I, I don't know if people realize that Brigham Young, he organized a group of women to build the 1st hospital Deseret. And it was it, it was Eliza Snow in charge. And it was, and she had just women. And and so the way it I just, it's just mind blowing to me how we look at women and how they want all of these rights. And then when you read the women in early Utah, they had all of those rights and more under Brigham Young. Absolutely and and he was he also, if I'm not mistaken, actually sent women back east to be trained as doctors, right. It not just, you know, you're in charge of the hospital, but felt like women should be doctors, right? Especially, you know, for delivering babies, that sort of thing.
27:30 So there, there's a lot that Brigham doesn't get credit for. The the other Brigham quote that I love is they were talking about he was given a lecture and or, or, or a talk, and I believe it was at the Tabernacle and the subject of, of disciplining children came up. Now, this is a guy who lives in the 1800s. Sparing the rod and spoiling the child are very much on the forefront of everybody's, you know, lexicon as far as raising kids. Brigham says something fascinating. He says, I found that that the use of the rod on our children too often is the result of a spoiled parent more than a spoiled child. Try reasoning with your children, right? This is, this is a guy who's not necessarily even fitting in his time in a lot of ways.
28:21 And in a little bit forward thinking. I, I have a slightly different opinion on why people are targeting Brigham over Joseph. And that is because you can't really, and, and this is because I think that that these actors are a little more nefarious, to be honest with you, and a little more disingenuous than just being willfully ignorant. I think they know they can't discredit Joseph and keep the gospel, period. I do think they, they have either subconsciously or a very real thought that if they can unhook from Brigham, then they can take that gospel that Joseph restored and kind of twist it into whatever they want.
29:02 Brigham is a linchpin within the gospel and, and his, his place has to be secure if we want any of those blessings that we as Mormons, albeit a, a, a mainstream LDS person or a fundamentalist have come to hold dear, right. This idea of eternal families of ceilings, these sorts of things that it, it all hinges with Brigham after Joseph's death. And if, if you can get rid of that, you can really remake the gospel into anything you want. So, so anything anybody else got anything they want to add to that before I move on here? Perfect. I. Just want to know what. Oh, OK, let's let Kimberly go and then Jacob, then you. It's.
29:45 Really a quick thought. I just want to know what teachings of Joseph Smith we'd have if Brigham Young didn't preserve them. Amen. That's the biggest thing is that the the the whole reason we have the records of the church, the history of the church, the sermons is Brigham Young and the apostles. Willard Richard is the church historian. Absolutely preserve them. And so, yeah, I've, I've seen the same quotes you've seen, Dave, about Brigham Young on raising children. And I was actually surprised when I been reading the journal Discourses, I ran into those quotes. And, you know, it goes against my sensibilities personally. But you know, he definitely cultivated some more, some very different ideas from the time that he was in regarding child rearing.
30:30 And one quote that I really liked that he said, he said, he said he, he said in several different quotes that it's important to cultivate your children to be free thinking and independent. And, and he said never check a child for questioning, cultivate that principle. And that he said it's, it's important for them to get their own character and to get their own, their own independent moral character and, and able to get revelation for themselves. And so I think that is one of the best things, in my opinion, that contradicts the view of Brigham as the tyrant, besides the fact that he's constantly telling the Saints to get revelation for themselves and that they aren't supposed to blindly follow him and that everyone needs to be independent and to not follow your leaders if they're teaching you bad things. But you know his instructions on teaching the importance of children gaining that independence, so. Perfect.
31:23 Thanks, Sean. You had something. Yeah, maybe one of you can check me because I'm just going off of memory and I read this about 20 years ago, so bear with me on that. I remember a quote by Brigham Young where he says, has a master spirit ever arisen in a family where no one can go to the left or the right of the straight and narrow path? He says, nay, a master spirit would seek to to leave such an environment. He says nobody wants to see virtuous young men and women more than I do. But he says, but in doing so, we should never kill their passion. We should guide it.
32:16 We should instruct it, but not kill their passion. Of these wild young men that we see roaming the straits of Salt Lake City, you'll see some of the greatest men that ever that ever lived in Israel. Something to that effect. All right, so with that, I want to, I want to kind of turn to, to some life events here because I think there's some things that set Brigham up and I want to just throw these out and talk about these just a little bit. So he's born in Vermont. He is, by all accounts, very destitute growing up.
32:58 His mother dies when he's like 14 and he goes almost straight to work as a Carpenter from there. He he's he kind of, you know, does his thing. He's a Carpenter. There's really, I haven't discovered a lot about like his dealings with other people, but in this instant, I kind of think no news is good news. You know what I mean? He doesn't seem to be exceptionally remarkable in any way. He joins the church in 1832 and then just shortly after that, his wife dies. And then he he ends up marrying again. And then it's like a captain on Zion's camp. So I want to talk about those, those years where he was either a Mormon or just became a Mormon a little bit. How do you feel that that these life events, his mother dying, he has to go to work really early, gets married, his wife dies.
33:59 How do you think that impacts who Brigham Young is as he's coming into his own within the gospel? Well, I, I can't speak from personal experience. I've never, my life is pretty cushy comparative to that. But we know from various other people that have had to deal with those types of, of challenges and trials in their lives that it's, it's, it's unquantifiable. Like it is just impossible to really comprehend just how challenging that can be to to somebody's growth and development. And so, you know, the the reality is we all have heavenly parents or our earthly parents are so important to the plan of of Father in heaven.
34:56 But like these stories like Brigham Young and some of the other pioneer stories that I can't remember any names just for off the top of my head. But people that that had to go through those types of challenges and and endure such great losses personally in their families and who were able to kind of prevail over them like that is that is not normal. That that to me, that shows a great measure of of divine Providence. And, you know, heavenly help to be able to, you know, survive those types of things without like becoming a criminal or without becoming just jaded beyond beyond everything. And so like those to me, yes, those are are terrible tragedies, but it it doesn't it can't take anything away. If if anything, that actually increases the the amazing achievements that he accomplished in his life. So.
36:00 Absolutely. Jacob, Sean, Kimberly, you guys got anything you want to add to that? Well, oh, Kim, go ahead. Sean, go ahead first. I was just going to say that experiences like that usually have a tendency to either make or break you. We always experiences like that have a tendency to make, put a fork in the road for you. And one is to basically curse God and die and the other one is to actually rely on God even more. And what I can see the principles of the gospel, especially when we talk about eternal ceilings and the eternity of family relationships, an experience like that, I think could, could galvanized somebody like Brigham Young to be even more committed to the principles that would bring that about.
37:24 Because to reject Brigham Young, Brigham Young and, and the way he preserved these, especially these types of teachings is to basically put the, the axe to the, to the root of the hope we have and eternal families. And there are many that are critical of Brigham Young that are also taking the position that that temple work is is invalid. And with people that have experienced this type of traumatic loss, that's a great hope for them to know that not only will they see their loved ones again, but they will be able to have relationships with them throughout the eternities by the virtue of the ceilings that take place.
38:16 Anyway, that's all I have to say on that. Kimberly, would you have to say there on that? Well, definitely along those same lines as I think that for sure, I see when you study the early life of Brigham Young, you really see the Lord trying to shape and mold him to become the servant that God needed him to be. And I don't know if you're going to touch on this. I was, I was going to brush up on this, this story before and I didn't have time, but there's an account in the life of Heber C Kimball. I think it was. I'm getting it right where what happened? What? Does anyone know the experience that Brigham Young had the day that Joseph Smith got the plates? No.
38:58 Why don't you go go ahead and fill us in. I mean, I'm just hoping if someone else heard the story, they, they can fill in the details that the night that Joseph Smith got the plates that they, there was this miraculous event in the heavens. And I believe it was Heber C Kimball and Brigham Young. They went out and they basically saw a a a battle in the sky. And so they knew that, you know, that this something was take gonna take place, something significant was taking place at that time. You know, and I and I think that was just a prophesying of who Brigham Young was and his place is his role in this great, you know, last days battle. If anyone can fill in the details please do so I it's been a while.
39:43 I've seen a lot of three, I've seen a lot of sources for that. They, they share that throughout their lives that that story of that vision. So they didn't know what was significant happening at the time, but they later realized that it was the same night that Joseph was retrieving the golden plate. So. Yeah, I, you know, I, I can kind of speak to this one personally a little bit. My old man passed when I was was 13. Now, my old man, he was a great dad in a lot of ways. He, he kind of reminded me once I joined the Church of Brigham Young. He could definitely be gruff. He could definitely be in your face a little bit. But he also had a tremendous passionate side, a compassionate side, Excuse me.
40:29 And the old man was really good at making money, but he was horrible at paying taxes. And so when my old man passes, he's got a couple of businesses and those just go away, 'cause, you know, there's SPAC taxes that are owed. And that left us pretty poor as a family. And so I remember at the age of not quite 14, probably 15, I honestly start working, not out of, hey, I want money to go goof off with my friends, but I've got buy my own clothes. I got to help out my siblings. I was the oldest of those. And so there was a sense of growing up fast and, and Kimberly used a good word, which was molding, right?
41:13 I look back on those Times Now, and while they were certainly tough, they were very formative in who I would become. And there is this idea of, of molding or forging a person through, through adversity, right? And, and I think this sets him up for such a thing, right? He, he, he gets tough, he gets, he begins to understand how important work is from the very beginning. All these things start to, to play a part in who Brigham would become. The the other event I wanted to touch on was it's just shortly after his, his baptism, him and his wife's baptism, that his wife just dies.
42:02 She passes away of consumption, which if I'm not mistaken, someone can correct me here if I'm wrong. I think that was cancer, what they call cancer in the old days, right? Consumption. Or does anyone else know? Anyway I I could be wrong on that so a doctor out there listening can correct me, but I I think it was like a a pretty nasty disease to watch someone die from. It would have been real easy to throw in the towel at that point if you're Brigham Young, right? It would have been way easy to be mad at God. But he doesn't. Instead, he double s down in inside the gospel. And I, I think in some ways, if, if the death of his father or his mother, excuse me, is, is something that hardens him, I think this event might, might kind of soften him back up. Right.
42:57 One, one of the, the shows that I absolutely love and it's a guilty pleasures or there's a show called forged in Fire where they, it shows them making knives and that sort of thing. And a blade has to be strong enough to take some abuse, but still soft enough that it's not brittle. And I think, I think we can see this in people's lives. And I think we see this with Brigham Young is that he's, he's tough enough to get the job done, but not so tough that he, he becomes dispassionate that he, he can't relate to people. And so I see these formative events as, as Brigham's forging process where, where the Lord is making him into more than he would otherwise be. And I think we have to recognize that the, the other reason I think it's important to look at Brigham's formative years is because by the time all of us know Brigham Young, he's we've kind of turned him into a marble statue, so to speak, right? He's, you know, he seems to be a legend and just larger than life.
44:05 And we sometimes forget about his humanity. And I think that has to be brought out here. I want to ask this question here with with Brigham Young. He, he, he goes through these processes. What is it you think Joseph sees in Brigham Young? Because there's a very real sense that that Brigham comes along and Joseph kind of gravitates to him from the very beginning in In your guys's opinion, what is it that Joseph sees in Brigham that attracts him to Brigham? Jacob, you want to take a stab at that one?
44:46 So there's the saying that's repeated. That's several different sources, all recall this, that when Joseph saw Brigham for the first time, he said, you know, there's one of the greatest men that will live to preach redemption to the inhabitants of the earth and he will yet lead this church. So a prediction that Brigham Young would someday be a leader of the church. And after meeting him for the first time, you know, I think there was this zeal, zeal that Brigham Young had for the gospel. He he just, he was excited to be in the restored church. And he said I wasn't even in, he said, and he was very humble about it too. He said I when he said I got baptized and he goes and ordains me an elder and I, he's like, I didn't feel qualified to be an elder at that time. I just, you know, but I was grateful and I felt it was a responsibility that.
45:35 But he anyhow, he meets Joseph and they're doing family prayer together. When he's meets the first time, he meets Joseph Smith. And Brigham is actually the first person in this dispensation to have the gift of tongues in that he's there in saying the prayer, he starts having the spirit come upon him and he starts speaking in the Adamic language. And some people thought that would that might be, you know, that's that, right? That's that's not, you know, that's not normal. And but Joseph said, no, that's the gift of the spirit. That's the gift of tongues that is mentioned in the scriptures. So, so Brigham had spiritual gifts throughout his life and you know, and I do think that Joseph saw him in the in him the capacity to be a great leader and a great missionary for building up the church and Kingdom of God.
46:27 So I I have that quote, I'm just going to read it because I think it's great upon seeing. So this is from the Diary of Charles L Walker, page 134. It's dated September 1832 and he says upon seeing Brigham Young for the first time and while yet some distance away, the Prophet Joseph stopped his chopping on a beach log, straightened up, studied Brigham for a moment and then remarked there comes the greatest man, whoever lived to teach the identity of God to the world, and he will yet lead this people. Now the Providence of this prophecy has been called into question by by some people, but I've looked at the original just on the, the the church archives. And I mean, maybe it was written in afterward, but it is dated to this time. And so it's, it shows that not only was there a personal connection, but I think that there was a spiritual like to say that he was, you know, basically had never met the man, but just sees him coming from a a distance and can say that prophecy.
47:27 That's pretty amazing. So I think that Joseph Smith had a lot of enemies during his lifetime. And so the other thing I would just point out is there were only two, I want to say of the of the so the the quorum of 12 was organized a couple of times during Joseph Smith's lifetime. Once was like at the very beginning, you know, eighteen shoot one was Oliver Cowdry giving the Apostolic charge Jacob. It's probably about 1830, 2:33, somewhere around there. 35 OK, so the First Quorum of 12 was organized in 1835. And of that original number, I want to say all but two apostatized and some of them came back, I believe. But but the two that never came, that never, never faltered, I guess, were Brigham Young and Hebrews C Kimball. And so I think Joseph, he had been betrayed and, you know, disappointed by so many people throughout the course of his ministry that he, he just valued Brigham Young's steady influence in his life and, and just appreciated his loyalty. So I guess that that's what I would add to that. Perfect Him.
48:47 You got anything you want to add to that? Yeah. And I, most people don't know this. Well, you guys might, but it's interesting when you study 1835, when you know Joseph Smith chooses the 12 apostles, they actually ordains Brigham Young 1st and he actually does it in private and he relates. And so he anoints him first. First of all, he anoints him and then he ordains him to be the 12. And then he goes and he's and then he chooses the 12 and acts like this is the first time Brigham Young's being chosen. But it wasn't. And he also, Joseph Smith writes in his journal that he had a vision of Brigham Young in the social Kingdom. And he sees him.
49:30 And and I'm assuming this is like, you know, last days during Zion where Brigham Young is out gathering the elect and he sees the Savior, you know, on his right hand side as he's as he's preaching the gospel and people are trying to kill him. Wow. Jacob, I got a question for you. Would what kind of events are you aware of that that Brigham had? Because really the next significant, I shouldn't say significant, the next major event we have in Brigham's Young Young's life is he sent on a mission to, to England. Do you, are you aware of anything that goes on during that mission that that is especially of note or anything like that?
50:12 Well, I, I do think that's an important aspect to Brigham Young. You know, he actually served missions before that. He, he actually talks about that, how he was always striving to be willing to go without purse or script in the summers to be preaching the gospel. And he said that when he met Joseph Smith, and he said after he met him in 1833, Joseph Smith kind of gave them the counsel to never again build up a Gentile city. And he said the those have told them to gather and to build up Zion was the big instruction and and Brigham took that to heart. And so he moved to Kirtland when Kirtland was, you know, very, you know, it wasn't, you know, it didn't have thousands of people yet. It was still, you know, relatively it was it was just barely starting.
51:00 And he he said, and and you got to remember when Brigham's what Brigham Young's wife died shortly after his baptism. You know, he's left with two young children from, you know, that he's having to take care of. And he said that his friendship with the Kimballs, that the lake Kimball was actually very helpful to being able to help take care of his children when he's working or when he's on serving missions. So he he goes to Kirtland and he basically doesn't really have any prospects all the time. And it's, you know, they're all poor And he's, he said, he basically said, I, I went anyway. And he said there's a brother Cahoon there. And he was, he, he basically said I'll work for you and, you know, so that I can be doing something to help build up Zion.
51:46 And Brother Cahoon said, I, I'm just, to be frank with you, honest, I, I don't even have money to pay you. So, but Brigham says, I don't care, I'm willing to work with you. And if you will just share what you have with me, then I, you know, then we'll, you know, if we're, if we're unsuccessful together, we'll, we'll be unsuccessful together. If we're successful together, we'll be successful together. And so that's kind of his zeal that he had for the gospel. And so, but I agree with you. The, the mission to England after the Kirtland Temple is built and they received the endowment of power and the spirit in the Kirtland Temple that, you know, the next big thing is Joseph telling the, the preparing them to go and gather Israel across the ocean in England.
52:27 And that had to take a ton of faith to do that. And the thing that I think is significant about the mission to England is that there were nine members of so so out of the 12 apostles that were the 12 at Joseph's death, nine of them had served successfully in the England mission. And there were three other apostles that Joseph's death who weren't involved with it, William Smith, Lyman White and third one, Johnny Page George. So all the other ones, they were willing to take that big leap of faith of, you know, taking that treacherous journey. You know, sailing in a boat across the ocean in that day is not an easy light task to do.
53:17 And you often got seasick. It was, you know, and I think that's recorded in their journals. Actually, they were Brigham Young and Hebrew C Kimball were both, I think, very ill when they were set, set off for their mission, that they were willing to take the leap of faith and set off anyway. But anyhow, so nine of the 12 that were the apostles under Joseph and Nauvoo, they went and they served their missions in England. And that really united that form. And they never really divided again after that. You know, they had their their doctrinal spats, their difficulties every once in a while, but they stayed a united body after that. While the other three who weren't involved with, you know, that sacrifice and that leap of faith and that mission, you know, they, they went in totally different directions. And so I think that that I think that mission was very important as a leadership opportunity for Brigham Young learning. I think it was Brigham Young, Heber C Kimball and Willard Richards who acted as a presidency over the England mission.
54:22 And so they had a that was almost like a precursor to them later becoming a new First Presidency after Joseph's death. But I think one thing that's significant with the England Mission 11 fascinating story that Heber C Kimball shares is that they, they saw this vision of all these evil spirits in, in England. And that's a significant story that they share throughout their lives in their, in their sermons. And Heber C Kimball said he shared that with Joseph after returning to Nauvoo and that Joseph said that the more you're trying to, the closer we approach the Lord, the more the adversary is going to be trying to attack us. And so that was a significant thing. And then I guess another, just to briefly summarize, there were other principles that were made known to the apostles envision in England.
55:17 And it's one thing the the polygamy deniers will try to say is they started doing polygamy in England, which isn't true. That's there's not evidence to substantiate that, even though they tried to to pretend there is. But they did get a revelation that Brigham Young said that was a precursor to Joseph explaining polygamy to him in Nauvoo, that he had the promptings of certain things from the spirit that he did not then understand. But then when he returned to Nauvoo, that Joseph was able to teach him polygamy and that he was he was receptive because he had that experience. But that isn't the only principle that was revealed in England to Brigham Young. He's the principle of baptism for the dead was actually the, the the event that sparked Joseph Smith getting the revelation of baptism for the dead was a convert in England actually got a vision of seeing the the apostles and priesthood holders preaching to spirits in the spirit world and, and doing baptisms and for the spirit spirits in the spirit world. And they, the word of that vision spreads like wildfire throughout the church and it gets back to Joseph Smith and Joseph says that it's true that there is preaching in the spirit world.
56:30 He said the one thing he disagreed with was them doing baptism in the spirit world. He said that that's an ordinance that has to be done in the flesh. But he said the, the, the vision was expressing the importance of baptism and, and, and trying to prepare for the, for the revelation of baptism for the dead. And so that's how Joseph Smith got the revelation of baptism for the dead. And so the apostles said they first got, you know, learned about baptism from the dead while they were still in England. And they said another principle that was revealed to them in England is as man is, God once was, as God is, man may become. That was another revelation that the apostles that Brigham Young said that he received in England, and he shared it with Lorenzo Snow. And sure enough, they get back to Nauvoo and Joseph Smith starts teaching them the higher principles about God, which they were prepared for because of those experiences in England. So yeah, I don't know if anyone else has anything else to share on the England mission, because that's an area of Church history that I personally have not studied a whole lot on, but I think it's an important period for Brigham Young. Kimberly, is there anything you wanted to add to that? You know what, Yeah, One thing I'll say and, and I think this is one of those areas where I think we need to look real close because I think it's as him and Heber, if I'm not mistaken, are, are getting ready to go to England. They're very ill and so is their
58:01 family, right? And, and I think this is the instance where they're like riding out on the cart and one looks to the other and says it's a hard thing we're doing. And they have this idea that they'll just get up and give kind of a, a religious exuberant display and, and basically 3 shouts for Zion kind of a thing is what they do. Or offer Israel Thank you. That's it. I I Yeah. See. And that's why Jacob's way better than me, because he's got that off the top of his head. There's a, There's a. Painting of it that I love. And so that's how I remember what they said, OK. All right, nice.
58:42 So yeah, I mean, in those days, it's not like you could say, well, I'm just going on a trip and you just got a cold, right? That that cold could kill you, right. People were dying of of things that we consider kind of minor today. And so Brigham's going to head out and he's going to do this despite him not doing well, right. I mean, from the account, they're very, very ill and the their families are very, very ill. I look at that and I'm like, I'm a wuss, right? I mean, if I got a case of the sniffles, I'm like, yeah, I don't think I'm going to church today. I think I'm going to stay home and pack it in. These guys are like straight up gangster, right? Like, oh, no, burn the boats.
59:28 We're going. We're gone and just have success while there. What what do you think it is that that truly separates guys like that from, say, people who are lukewarm? What? What is it about Brigham's desires that are different from from, say, everybody else? And then how do we cultivate that? Sean, any ideas? Yeah. OK, give me just. Well, one thing I'd like to say about that is it's very easy to speak in platitudes throughout your life, but when actually put to the test, many people fold under those circumstances.
1:00:11 I remember in 8th grade. I moved up from Mexico and started attending 8th grade in Bisbee, Arizona, and it was kind of a rough town, but there was this boy there that was mercilessly being. To say the word being picked on is an understatement. I mean, being picked on is being teased, being shoved around or whatever, but he was literally being punched and hit not just by one person, but by several. And this was going on. It went on for about two weeks and I remember thinking to myself, why won't anybody do anything about it? It this happened around the teacher and when this kid tried to say this is happening to me and all that just basically got ignored.
1:00:57 And I saw this happening and I started feeling really bad because I have to admit I was afraid to stand up because I was I was a pit squeak. And in that, in that grade, I was, I was one of the smallest guys in the class. And but it got to the point where I just felt like I couldn't stand to see that anymore. And they started in on him one time and I just got a surge of courage. I walked up and I, I shoved a couple of guys away and said, leave this guy alone. What's wrong with you people? And I knew in doing that, I was going to make myself the new target. And that's what I was afraid of. And, and, and that that worked. They left him alone and they, they started in on me.
1:01:38 The difference between me and this kid is that my dad had been a boxer in his youth and he taught us how to box from the time we were very little kids put the gloves on me when I was four years old and living in Mexico the way I did. We got in a lot of fights. So I I had experience in doing it and within a month's time I got in about 3 fights. Two were small skirmishes where a few blows were thrown. Nobody really got hurt. People broke it up, but the third one was against the guy that was the biggest guy. He was almost a whole head taller than me and he was actually pretty, at least in my, from my perspective at the time, he was pretty scary. But I fought him and I didn't back down. And to my amazement, I actually won the fight and won it convincingly.
1:02:27 And well, nobody picked on me anymore. But the good thing is that they quit picking on this kid. And so that kind of had a happy ending, but I didn't know that going into it. And in situations like that, I think most of us can have moments in our lives where we're put to the test that way to see to see if we have integrity, to see if we have valiancy. My dad used to say to me, son, it's easy to be honest when you have the means to pay everybody back. But the true test of your integrity or your honesty comes when you don't have the way to do it or it's very hard to and you do it anyway. And so that that has been, and I haven't always lived up to it, don't get me wrong, but I've had moments of weakness.
1:03:13 And we we say weakness a lot, but the reality is it's cowardice. You know, the I really understand the words of the song in in a poor wayfaring man of grief where it says he asked if I for him would die. He said the spirit is willing, but the the flesh is weak or the blood ran chill, but the very spirit in me said I will. And to me that encapsulates how that I think we'll all be faced with that at some point. And what we should do is is to nurture that type of courage in our life.
1:03:54 So when the time comes, we can't stand for that which is right. And no statement is truer than to say that the only thing that evil needs to flourish is for good men to do nothing. And I believe that Brigham Young encapsulates that to a great degree. With all his faults or anything that he might have had, I believe he was a man of courage and a man of integrity and a man of honesty. And the more I read him, the more I see it. And it doesn't bother me that he was at times considered harsh because I have found in my life that the kind of men you can count on and women a lot of times tend to be a little rough on the side anyway. All right, Thanks, Sean.
1:04:39 OK, The, the next place I want to go is to to the secession crisis because I, I look while certainly I you can't say this is where Brigham's ministry starts. Is, is at the secession crisis 'cause he has those other experiences. He leads, he's a captain in Zion's camp. He, he is going on missions. He's he's Joseph's ardent supporter when everybody else ditches him. But this may be at this point, Brigham's Young's greatest test. And Jacob, this is one of the reasons I brought you on is because you're so good with the history here. Talk to us what it's about what it's like when Brigham first receives the news.
1:05:27 He's in Boston, if I'm not mistaken, or Massachusetts somewhere. And then he gets to Nauvoo, talk a little bit about how he hears the news of the prophet's death, and then talk about what he finds when he gets to Nauvoo. So I absolutely agree with what Sean said about Brigham's courage. And that's that's a big thing on the succession crisis is that he really was the one who had the courage to stand up and to make a stand for Joseph's measures and Joseph's principles. But I I do think we should probably circle back to the Brigham Young in Nauvoo is an important church leader, right? But yeah, so, so in Nauvoo Brigham, actually, so when we talk about the Korum of the 12 apostles, we, we often just think that they're the de facto church leaders because that's how it's understood today and that's how it's systematized since, you know, after Brigham Young's death. But it wasn't actually formally laid out that way in 1835 and, or even 1844 for that matter.
1:06:38 It was something Apostolic succession was something that developed over time. And I agree with what Taylor said where Brigham Young, it was because of his loyalty to Joseph Smith that he gained Joseph Smith's confidence and was involved with more and more things and given more and more responsibility. There's a quote where Brigham Young said that when the apostles were first called in Kirtland, that Joseph, he said that the president of the quorum, I think it was McClellan, if I'm not mistaken, complained about how they were, you know, not really treated with any real importance. And Brigham said, yeah, we were, we were snubbed for power back then.
1:07:19 He says it wasn't until we could prove ourselves that we were the servants of all that we were would be trusted with authority to be, you know, you know, to given full authority over, you know, church matters. And so, you know, the apostles initially started off just as traveling missionaries, but then by the Nauvoo period, they had proven themselves in England in their mission. They had converted more. There were more Saints in England converted than there were in the United States or at least gathered in Nauvoo. So the the church was actually larger in England than in the United States for a period of time. And so Brigham and the apostles get back to Nauvoo and Joseph starts to really magnify them. And at at the conference, I believe this is in August of 1841, he says, I want the 12 to, you know, they've they've labored hard in the mission field for years and not entrusted their families in the hands of the church to provide for their families while they were gone. Now it's their time that they should be here in Zion and direct their work from here in Nauvoo and send, you know, instructions abroad to other missionaries. And they should take time to provide for their families and stand next to the First Presidency in the affairs of the church.
1:08:34 I don't think that was necessarily appointing them as the, you know, successors of that time, but I do think it was magnifying their responsibilities in Nauvoo. And there's a number of things that Brigham Young was involved with in Nauvoo that I think is very significant. Like obviously the temple ordinances are important factor into why the apostles were what the best choice for the succession crisis. So it it was an 18 the endowment ceremony, the the marriage ceilings, anointings, work for the dead. All of that Joseph began to hint at in public discourses during the Nauvoo period. But it was in his private councils that he began to reveal actually begin to confer these ordinances and teach about these ordinances and principles to his close followers.
1:09:22 And so the first meeting of the body of men that would include women that would that would come to. Want more from the Mormon Renegade podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the fundamental news program for free. Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade. Locals. Page by clicking the red join button and for $5.00 a month you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes today. And so the first meeting of the body of men that would include women that would that would come to, you know, be, you know, come to have, I think 66 or slightly more than that members by Joe Smith's death.
1:10:20 There's a body of men called the anointed quorum or the holy order where Joseph began to confer the temple ordinances because he said that he had premonitions that he might die before the temple is completed. And so it's important to begin to initiate other men into these ordinances. And so Brigham Young is there that in a very first meeting on May 4th, 1842, you can find that in teachings of of the Prophet Joseph Smith. Page 237 Brigham Young, Heber C Kimball, Willard Richards, you know, three of the apostles. Then the two bishops, Newell K Whitney and George Miller, you know, obviously Joseph Hiram Smith, I think.
1:11:01 And then William Marks and William Law and George, George Adams or James Adams of, of Springfield or the, you know, nine men with Joseph Smith. We revealed those ordinances to. And I think what's significant is that Brigham Young is involved with the endowments and the anointings and the ordinances from, you know, 1842 to 1843 to 1844. So he is actively involved with the temple work that's going on. He's getting to hear Joseph's instructions in his public sermons as well on what he was envisioning and what was important. And he was also involved with the Council of 50, which was organized in 1844.
1:11:42 And so there were all these secret forms and developments that were going on. And new doctrines are being introduced to the Saints. Like I guess celestial marriage is important in that that was revealed in 18 to the apostles when they returned from their mission in, I think, 1841. And then Joseph revealed, taught them plural marriage shortly after they returned from England. And so he's right at the center of all of these developments that Joseph Smith is revealing to the Saints or is preparing for the Saints. Like a lot of the secret stuff in the Anointed Quorum and Council of 50, that stuff the Saints only heard rumors about and didn't have a whole lot of information on, but the public stuff as well.
1:12:26 He was getting this instruction and he was absolutely right there in the center of all of Joseph Smith's activities of of of these new doctrines that Joseph was preparing for the Saints and ordinances as well. So. So when Brigham, for all intents and purposes, kind of seems to be coming, Joseph's right hand man here through the whole thing. He, he goes back East and that's when, when we, when, when Joseph is assassinated, right? That's when the martyrdom takes place when he comes back, right? Because it's not like the old days. I mean, today where you could just hop a flight and be back in six hours, right? It's, it's a little bit of a, a, a process to get out Jacob, What does he walk into when he gets back after the martyrdom? What, what, what's what?
1:13:21 What are the conditions on the ground look like? So you know, you mentioned the missions and so I think what's another thing that's significant to Brigham's character is Joseph actually dictates a revelation in Nauvoo saying that Brigham had basically is calling elections made sure and you know that he had been faithful to that point and that he the Lord was not going to require him to leave his family to serve missions anymore. But Brigham still wanted to do it anyway. He still felt that missionary desire. And so he was active in the summers in Nauvoo going on shorter missions. And so when Joseph is running for president in a so there's two different projects in 1844 that he's looking that Joseph is really starting to emphasize that first that they need to have a gathering out West where they could live the laws of God as God has revealed to them without anyone else interfering with them. And so that was a big the the Rocky Mountain expedition was a big thing in 1844 that Joseph was starting. And the other thing was presidential campaign because of the constant political persecution the Saints had received and not being able to receive any redress from any government and not even the federal government. And none of the pres, none of the presidential candidates were willing to, you know, be willing to give Joseph a satisfactory answer that they would help the Mormons in in their plight for their rights.
1:14:46 And so Brigham and the 12 actually were more than willing to go out and serve, you know, these stump campaigns for Joseph Smith's candidacy for president in 1844. And Brigham's out West when that back east. Excuse me when that happens. And when they get the news in July that Joseph and Hiram were killed, Brigham's initial reaction is he said that he felt like his head was going to crack. He he said, I didn't cry, but I I had never felt deeper sorrow in my life. And he said his initial thought was, are the keys of the Kingdom taken from us? And he said it came like a clap and that he said Orson Pratt was sitting on his lap on his left.
1:15:31 And he said it came to him that the keys of the Kingdom are still here with the church. And he actually said he didn't think it was with him, but he knew it was the Lord's business. And so he had that comfort and that revelation that the keys were still on the earth and that they hadn't lost their authority with with Joseph's death. So the apostles start to return to Nauvoo. And in Nauvoo, there's actually some there, there's conspiracy going on in Nauvoo. And this is very significant in William Clayton's journals that I think is not those kind of overlooked is that Joseph had intended, if he were to die for his brother Hiram or his brother Samuel to lead the church. And he that's recorded in William Clayton's journal. But what's significant to me is that even before Samuel Smith is still alive, he doesn't die until the end of end of July. Emma is already trying to conspire to have William Marks be the next leader of the church shortly like a week after Joseph Smith's death.
1:16:38 And I think the reason she's wanting William Marks to be the next person in charge is because she knows that William Marks is against polygamy, like she's against polygamy and against the temple doctrines that Joseph is revealing. And so she's starting to get into this conspiracy with William Marks and then Sidney Rigdon is is there very quickly and they're trying to form kind of a party to take over the church and to get rid of these NABU doctrines that Joseph was restoring that were very controversial, in which William Law felt that Joseph, you know, you know, needed to be stopped for for introducing. So William Law conspired with the, you know, the anti Mormons to get Joseph Smith killed over these teachings. But then there's internally there's Emma and William Marx and Sidney Rigdon who want to get polygamy and temple ordinances and theocracy and all these doctrines out of the church.
1:17:31 And so they're conspiring and the, and, and basically they're wanting to do a meeting to reconvene to, to select the guardian for the church before the apostles get back. And this is the beginning of August that after Samuel Smith's death, they are preparing to select Sidney Rigdon as the guardian. And they plan a meeting for August 8th, 1844 to appoint for where for Sidney Rigdon to advance his claims to be sustained as guardian of the church. And fortunately, the apostles that were away got back to Nauvoo two days earlier on August 6th, 1844, the apostles that were abroad were able to get back to Nauvoo. And the day before the August 8th meeting, on August 7th, there was kind of a precursor meeting where Sidney Rigman starts to advance his vision, his claims. And Brigham says, you know, his comments in response are very interesting and and significant in my opinion, where he says he didn't really care who ran the church. He said it could even be old Ann Lee, but we need to get revelation on it.
1:18:46 And he said I know who has the keys to get revelation. And he's talking mentions the significance of, you know, that the apostles had and others had been given the fullness of the priesthood by Joseph Smith. And so that played a big factor in in what was going on. And so he said actually on August 7th, 1844, I know there are those are myths who will seek the lives of the 12 as they did the lives of Joseph and Hiram. We shall ordain others and give the fullness of the priesthood so that if we are killed, the fullness of the priesthood may remain. And so that's one of the, you know, the temple ordinances are a key factor in the apostles succession claims. So on August 8th, 1844. And what's what's interesting is that we're we're on the anniversary of the date they had the meeting and Riggan advanced his claims.
1:19:38 And I think Brigham said that he only last minute heard about the the Riggan speech. And so he went and he was kind of last minute came to Riggan speech while the other apostles weren't even aware. And so he Riggan advances his claims to be made guardian of the church. And when Brigham Young stood up after. Sidney Rigdon spoke and he he started addressing the Saints and how they needed to come together and have the the priesthood meet together and to discuss this matter more thoroughly. Those Saints who had oil in their lamps and had who had the spirit. There were many Saints who had a miraculous experience of seeing Brigham Young transfigured to both look and sound like Joseph Smith. And that's one of the most well attested miracles in church history is the transfiguration of Brigham Young. There's well over 125, if not way more. Lynn Jorgensen has 129 sources she compiled of witnesses to the transfiguration of Brigham Young. But it showed those Saints who were without a shepherd that they that Brigham Young was the one they could trust to carry out Joseph Smith's measures.
1:20:50 And I think that was a big contributing factor to why the Saints that afternoon when they did the second meeting where they actually had all the priesthood convene and and Brigham Young got up and talked about the authority issues and running the church. I think that is why they almost unanimously accepted the 12 to lead the church and to as a quorum, the quorum of the 12 to act as the first presidency and to carry out Joseph's measures as he had laid them out. And so, so, so, yeah, I think that's, you know, very, you know, a a very significant event. And I think it's interesting today is actually the anniversary of that, you know, August 8th when we're of, of the transfiguration of Brigham Young starting.
1:21:38 And so, yeah, I just think it's, you know, there's it's, it's a very important part of church history. So. Sure. Taylor, let me go to Kimberly and then we'll go to you. Sorry, I had texted him and said I had something to add. So it's just been like, you know, that impression. I just have to share this. So I mean, that was the, you know, really great explanation by Jacob and I just before we move forward, I just kind of want to backtrack it just a little bit. So what was one of the the what was one of Joseph Smith's greatest mission? What is the purpose of the Book of Mormon? The sign that what? I think she's talking to you, Sean. I'm just talking to you who who will answer what is. I'm.
1:22:25 Just I'm no, I'm just kidding. What did Joseph Smith say? It was the sign of what? Wasn't it the gathering of Israel? Yep, the gathering of Israel. And so it's significant that in, I believe it was 1841, Joseph Smith issues the proclamation to gather. And because of the the laborers of Brigham Young and England, we have seen the largest gathering of Israel that the world has ever seen to this date. I believe to. This date. I believe it's to this date the largest gathering of, of a body of people, right?
1:23:08 They're gathered in a, in one location and it's, it's, it's Brigham Young's converts and it's Israel being gathered home. This is like we're missing the exodus that we're, we're all waiting for this exodus or you know, of gathering of Israel. And we've already seen the first one. And this is Brigham Young, right? His laborers in, in the other apostles in England. Those converts are they're, they're Israel, they're coming home. They're being gathered and they're being gathered to Nauvoo. And, and then when we talked about the beginning of the podcast, why there's so much animosity against Brigham Young, and it's because of his success. It really is his success.
1:23:50 He gathered Israel. The keys were given to Joseph Smith. He went out and did the work. Joseph Smith has given the keys. He's given the vision delegates to Brigham Young. Brigham Young goes out and fulfills the mission, if that makes sense. And then just leading up to the succession crisis. I, I just, I think it's significant to point out because everyone thinks it was like, well, the church had to choose between Brigham Young and Sidney Rigdon, right? And like Sydney, Reagan was just He was gypped. But most people, I am shocked haven't heard this statement from Joseph Smith On August 13th of 1843. He actually sent out a, whatever you call it, a proclamate.
1:24:34 I don't know it wouldn't be a proclamation, but he set out a notice to the Saints and he said, quote, we've had certain traders in this city who have been writing falsehoods to Missouri. And there's a certain man in this city who has made a covenant to betray and give me up to the Missourians. And that too, before Governor Carlin commits his his persecutions. That man is no other than Sidney Rigman. So not only did Joseph Smith, he publicly calls out Sidney Rigdon as a trader, but then he withdrew his fellowship from him and he asked the Saints to proclaim it abroad that he would no longer accept him as his counselor. And this recorded in the history of the Church.
1:25:17 So I mean, not only was Sidney Rigdon not like the rightful successor, but he's also, he was named by Joseph Smith as one of the traders who betrayed him and that he and Joseph Smith withdrew his fellowship. And then Jacob talked about how ensuring that that the fullness of the priesthood would be preserved. And it's, it's also significant that when Sidney Rigdon was rejected by, by the body of the Saints, that he then made a false prophecy that not, not another stone will be laid on the temple. So you can see that Brigham Young is the one who's trying to carry on the work of of Joseph Smith, and Sidney Rigdon is the one that's trying to tear it down.
1:25:59 There's a plan to drop him from the First Presidency at the October 1843 conference. Kimberly, thanks for sharing that because I was unaware of of Joseph's proclamation about Sydney rigged and that's interesting. Taylor, what would you have? Yeah. So just a little bit more detail on that those events. So I was not aware of this because, you know, I've, I had just heard the church accounts talking about, you know, it's, I thought it was a 2 horse race between, you know, Sidney Rigdon versus Brigham Young and I was going back to the, the Joseph Smith trying to release Sidney from the first Presidency. So that happened and the church wouldn't they, they wouldn't sustain it. They voted it down.
1:26:48 And Joseph being the man of principle that he is, was like, OK, well, if common consent, that's a, that's a true principle. So he, he, he basically said, OK, that's, that's their choice. OK, we'll roll with that. But that didn't stop. That didn't mean he was forced to not have no counselors because it was his counselors in the first presidency that time were Sydney Rigdon, who abandoned the church was a traitor, and William Law who also basically got Joseph killed with an odd expositor and, and all of that stuff. So, so Joseph called the third counselor and he only had one, you know, guy that he could rely on. It happens to be my ancestor, Amasa Mason Lyman. And Amasa Lyman was a, a, a real interesting figure because he's kind of been written out of church history. He stood up at that October 8th or excuse me, August 8th conference.
1:27:48 And, you know, Sydney stood up for hours, you know, and, and gave apparently some really verbose sermon about it. And, and Amisa Lyman stood up second. And he basically talked for two minutes and said, OK, so the reality is Brigham Young is the rightful heir, you know, and, and this is actually backed up. This isn't just, you know, family history, you know, hearsay or whatever. This is backed up in the records because he Amisa Lyman call was was present at a lot of these Holy quorum anointed quorum meetings and when Joseph Smith was absent, Brigham Young presided and that's in in the records.
1:28:36 And you know, that goes for the quorum of anointed and the council of 50 minutes. And so, but but Amos alignment stood up for two minutes and he just basically bore his testimony that before Joseph's death, he gave the keys of the Kingdom to the 12 and Brigham as the president of that quorum. And so he just basically threw a support to Brigham. One of the other concerns are I guess objections that I've seen people make of this transfiguration because of course, very few of these accounts were recorded contemporaneously. Most of them were recorded, you know, decades after the fact. And, and there could that could call into question some of the reliability of some of these accounts of the transfiguration of Brigham Young.
1:29:20 Nevertheless, he there are some contemporaneously recorded just like a few, I want to say weeks or months. I know, Jacob, you actually wrote a paper about this that I read a few years ago and it basically talks about how it was not necessarily like a flash and like instantly hundreds of people heard Joseph Smith. It was, it was more of a, an ongoing, like it wasn't an event. It was a, it was an ongoing thing that that people were testimony to. And so I think that it's just really important to keep in mind that these types of accounts are just because they weren't contemporaneously recorded necessarily doesn't mean that they're not valid because there are some and then people who were present at these meetings definitely recorded later on of the, of the truth of what happened. So I just wanted to just throw in the, the importance of spiritual witnesses.
1:30:23 It'd be one thing if Brigham Young was just told to, you know, it just took the took the reins and abused, I guess you could say abused his position of authority, but that's not what happened. And he rather instead he was just, like it has been said, perpetuating the work that Joseph Smith commenced with the temple and so forth. So that's all I had. No, that's good stuff. Something else that that jumps out at me about this this time period is that with enemies of Brigham, it's often portrayed that Brigham came in and seized power in this moment.
1:31:07 I think it's worthwhile to point out that it's not like Brigham just set himself up as president of the church. The church operated under Apostolic direction for a number of years, clear into the Utah period before Brigham is named president of the church and then sustained as prophet, seer and revelator. So this idea that that Brigham just comes in and just seizes power and this was his plan from the from the beginning, it doesn't hold water, right? And we can see that that Brigham, true to the man he was, he counsels with with those other members of the 12th. Now, I want to be clear here. There's no doubt that the rest of the 12 deferred to Brigham, right?
1:31:52 And I think that's because everybody understood who Brigham was, right? I don't get the sense that that Brigham had to stand on authority. So, you know, so to speak a a great deal, just who he was was enough that people naturally want to follow him. Now that transfiguration moment, that's a huge moment, right? Because it's a a kind of a stamp and seal of approval from Joseph on Brigham, right, is I think how a lot of people viewed this and that that it was very much this idea that Brigham would continue the work that Joseph had started. And so I think it's important that context, especially because it's one that we find a lot that Brigham's just power hungry and he's just waiting for his opportunity to pounce on that power. It couldn't be farther from the truth. All right, So Joseph smarter we have we have these events as Jacob put everything together.
1:32:54 I want to now go to really one of the the the best revelations that that in my opinion, that Brigham ever gets, and that's the section 136 of the Doctrine and Covenants. And this is one of those times that I think because Brigham gets this and and what's amazing is, is that it sounds very much like the rest of the revelations that had been given previously, right? And so much like the transfiguration event, this also is an event at which I think a lot of the other Saints were able to say, look at that. The Lord still speaking through through this, through this leadership. One of the things I find so interesting is how he's able to lay out how the camp is supposed to be govern, so to speak, right in their exodus W how they're to do this. And he patterns it a lot after the Old Testament when he gets that revelation from the Lord.
1:34:00 My question to you guys is this, do you guys know you know? Well, let let me rephrase this not so much question. I had somebody reach out to me once when we were talking about Brigham Young. I can't remember what episode it was, but somebody had got upset. This was a person who lived in Ireland of all places. And I got just a scathing e-mail blaming Brigham Young for more deaths on the trail than needed to happen. You know, he, he, he was a horrible leader. And that's why a whole bunch of people died on the trail. This got me thinking real quick. And I was like, OK, I should probably go do some research.
1:34:41 So I went ahead and I looked at the Mormon Trail versus the Oregon Trail, and the deaths that happened on the Mormon Trail were far less frequent than what was happening on the Oregon Trail. On the Oregon Trail, I believe the the numbers were somewhere, and this is according to the government's own numbers, is that you're looking at about a 12% chance you're going to die on that trek W to to the Oregon Country. With Brigham Young's Mormon Trail, it's less than a percent. You got a 99 point something percent chance you're going to reach your destination alive.
1:35:26 What is it about Brigham Young that you think people responded so well to on this trek W both during the vanguard company as well as other people coming over? What? What does Brigham do that makes this so wildly successful? I guess I'll dive in first. I think so. Of course Joseph Smith had unparalleled gifts and his ability to inspire and just obtain revelation and commune with heaven are are just unequalled. Brigham didn't have those gifts. He was not the visionary, but I don't think Joseph Smith himself could have done the job that Brigham Young did as far as organizing and preparing every needful thing like actually doing the revelation. What what's outlined in I think it's Section 88 and and it's he, he was just a master of organization and bringing people together, uniting around the a common cause. Like, I don't know if if we've ever seen, if the world's ever seen a guy more gifted and capable than Brigham Young of bringing people together to work toward a common goal. And so I think that, and I would, I would even go as far as say Joseph Smith is included in that number. And that doesn't take anything away from from Joseph. But it's it's just foolishness in my mind to criticize Brigham Young's leadership when like the
1:37:01 proof is in the pudding. By their fruits, you shall know them. What you just cited, you know, over over 12 times more deaths on the on the pioneer trail. I mean, yes, there were deaths, but to try to say that they're the at the, you know, Brigham has blood on his hands or something. I don't understand that. And I guess I, I, I'm just kind of shocked at the ignorance somebody would have to have to, to even think that that was like a historical number or, or claim or anything like that. So. I'd like to say something and yeah, I think many of the, I think many of the things that are brought up against Brigham, like, like was just mentioned that this person from Ireland, is that what you said?
1:37:57 Yeah. Oh, he has blood on his hands because of all these things that happened. I I sometimes wonder if they've ever read their scriptures, because if you, if you look at Lehi and his family, they're called out of Jerusalem and they don't, they don't get called out. And then all of a sudden they're in the promised land. They go through years of trials and tribulations, even to the extent that you have brothers, you know, threatening to kill their brother. And, you know, outsiders looking in can see this is kind of a dysfunctional family. But when you begin to read the lives of of prophets throughout the Bible, Book of Mormon, you see that these kind of things happened because opposition exists. And I don't understand the, the way people view religion to say, well, they have to be completely free of any of that for me to ever believe them.
1:38:53 Even any success story that you find in life, I doubt that you find them in a vacuum, free of, of any kind of trials or, or controversies that that surround these people. Because pretty much anything worthwhile is going to be met with opposition. And, and sometimes, like the savior said, those who will oppose you the most come from your own house. And so I think that those arguments are really naive. There's this a man from from Israel, his name is Joseph Ganat, and he was a minister in the, a cabinet member of the Issac Rabin, Issac Rabin administration. And he was giving a talk in in Salt Lake and he made the statement that in 1948 he was just, he was pretty young at the time.
1:39:57 He was born in the 30s, early 30s. And he said they handed rifles to the women and children to defend themselves against the attacks coming in from the Arab neighbors. There was this lady that raised her hand and said why would you make your women and children fight? His answer was there was 10/10 to 15,000,000 Jews. And they were surrounded by 800 million Muslims. He said we had to even up the odds to the best of our ability. Then she answered saying, couldn't you have made a treaty with your enemies so that they would respect your women and children?
1:40:41 His answer was, our enemies vowed that they wouldn't stop until the Mediterranean Sea was red with Jewish blood, man, woman and child. Does that answer your question? So the point I'm getting at is there is a naivete with people that have this view of life and they seem to negate reality in their considerations. And this reality gives a ton of context to things that happen. So we can't just see isolated incident incidents and, and say, well, this guy was evil, this guy was good or anything like that.
1:41:22 You have to look at a a broad spectrum of circumstances, attitudes, culture, all kinds of things to make a determination of what really happened. Anyway, that's that's it. Thanks, John. Jacob, anything you want to add to that before we we move on here? So, yeah, I agree with everything Sean and Taylor said on that. I think, you know, obviously there's trials and difficulties, but, and I think what you brought up is, you know, compare it to the other tracks and other trails going West. You know, the Saints had a lot less difficulties comparatively. And I think that's actually kind of miraculous because they were not prepared in any real sense of the word for that exodus they had, you know, they they labored and and spent all their means to get that temple completed.
1:42:20 I think people don't realize how uncomplete the temple was when Joseph died. It was they didn't I don't I'm as far as I understand, they didn't even have the first story all the way completed. They they had the walls of the first story, but they didn't have it. You know that that's less than you know that that's very uncompleted. But they went and they finished it all the way up to the capstone and then finished up the interiors to the point they were able to do ordinances in there. And all the while they know that they're facing, you know, mob threats. And even the governor of Illinois is about is wanting to call in the, he's trying to ask for federal assistance to drive the Mormons out of Nauvoo. And the president of the United States said I can't be involved with with with using U.S. troops to persecute a religious community out of out of a state.
1:43:16 But so they, they, as Brigham said they had to complete the temple with a trowel in one hand and a sword in the other, essentially. And they were able to, and, and they were basically getting robbed of their property. Their property was going to be worthless and they had to sell it for hardly anything. And a lot of it actually didn't get sold for hardly anything, from what I understand. And so they were again being robbed of everything they had built and created again, just like they were in Missouri. And they, but they tried to be as prepared as they could. I think that's one of Brigham Young's strengths as a leader was that he was really great at organizing and really great at trying to unite their efforts to first complete the temple and then secondly to start the exodus westward and to concentrate their efforts and their, you know, not just spiritually, but their temporal efforts working together.
1:44:10 And you said in the temple, they actually all made a pledge after the endowments that they would help all the poor who were in the church gather out West with them. So that would take an enormous sacrifice to not just, not just those who had some means to be able to travel out West, but help everyone else who does have means to travel out West. But Brigham really tried to prepare. And I think even in spite of his desire to prepare, he, he, he probably felt that he they could have been a bit more successful. He might have had some unrealistic expectations, but what he was able to accomplish was really miraculous. And the the initial pioneer party, as I understand it, they didn't have a single person die on the initial pioneer expedition. I think they had over 150 men right on the initial expedition to the Salt Lake Valley and a couple women. And they were able to do that relatively safely. I think we're, you know, Brigham got and some of the others did get sick at certain times.
1:45:13 And Brigham was actually on his deathbed from whatever sickness he contracted, but he was fortunately able to recover. But I do think that there are others who kind of wanted to push things a little bit more. So on the second trek, W there was Brigham had given strict instructions that they needed to have like three years worth of provisions before coming out to Utah. And they need to try to make sure they have enough. They're they're taking along a certain number of the poor with them to fulfill their covenant in the temple. And what kind of happened was he set John Smith in charge of the second pioneer company out to Utah while the Brigham and the 12 LED the first pioneer company. But John Taylor and Harley Pratt were a bit over that kind of took over the second pioneer company that kind of about we need to have a certain number of years of provisions, you know, just to make sure that everyone's safe. And they kind of got bit overzealous and they enlarged it to a lot more people than they had rather compared to their provisions.
1:46:22 And so I think that somewhat contributed to some of the difficulty in the early years. But I do think that in spite of the difficulties that it is nothing less than miraculous that they were as successful as they were. And I think that to try to blame the handcart. So the handcarts were actually relatively successful. What as well, There was only that one season where there and it wasn't Brigham Young telling people to leave late in the season. It was other local church leaders that were involved with making the decision to. And it was to a degree with the Martin and Willie handcart companies. They kind of knew that they were taking risks with it because there was actually one church leader who who said, hey, I think it's wiser for us to winter. And he he did convince some families not to go late in the season, but unfortunately most of the others went anyway. But they did it on their own kind of prerogative. And you know what?
1:47:20 What one of the strengths of Brigham's character was that he really was able to what's the term for get all the Saints? He he really got the Saints on their feet to immediately go and rescue those Saints that were stranded out on the plane. Yeah, mobilized. He really mobilized the the people to to rescue those who encountered that tragedy. And if you if you discount that tragedy, which Brigham Young felt was unnecessary because his instructions had been never to leave late in the season, you don't want to risk being caught in the snow in Wyoming. You know, it was without any supplies or anything. And so, you know, I do think that Brigham really is great at mobilizing the Saints to work together. I think that the perpetual immigration fund that he set up was actually just an, an ingenious way to continue to facilitate the principle of the gathering that Joseph Smith taught was so important was that they were able to get all the Saints to continue to donate and support additional Saints to be able to come out and gather.
1:48:31 So, yeah, I, I think that it's, you know, there's, there's difficulties, but I think that's nothing short than miraculous that they had the success that they did. Absolutely. Kimberly, did you have something you wanted to add? Yeah, I just have to add this really quickly. So just Speaking of the Martin Hancart Company, there was 576 he began on the trek and says at least 145 died. And I just have to read you this quote because it says that years later that several Saints were conversing about the incident. Their criticisms of the leaders fell upon the ears of an elderly man who had been a member of the company. After listening for a while he finally rose and said, I ask you to stop the criticism.
1:49:16 You are discussing a matter you know nothing about. Cold. His cold. Historical facts mean nothing here for they give no proper interpretation of the questions involved. We suffered beyond anything you can imagine and many died of exposure and starvation. But did you ever hear a survivor of that company utter a word of criticism? Not one of the company ever pasta sized or left the the church. Because every one of us came through with the absolute knowledge that God lives for, we became acquainted with Him in our extremities. Wow, Brigham, in my opinion, does not get enough credit for getting the Saints West. And not only does he not get enough credit for that, there's there's there's a moment within Nauvoo where Brigham, it's telling everyone, get ready.
1:50:09 Like Jacob had pointed out, get as much provisions as you can, three years worth, whatever it is, get ready to make that trip. But there's something else Brigham does while in Nauvoo in preparation to go across the plains into the Rocky Mountains that he does that I think gets overlooked. And that is as soon as the temple's done, that thing's operating 24 hours a day, right? Brigham himself makes a journal entry that I was in the temple all night performing ordinances. Brigham understands how important those ordinances are. And he also understands that just like you need temporal preparations to to get through this, the Saints are going to need those temple blessings as well.
1:50:58 I could only imagine what Brigham must have thought as as he's getting ready to do this. He knows right? Look in in our modern day society, by and large, unless you're caught in a, in a horrible active shooter situation or whatever, we're not really exposed to massive death, right, folks, in Brigham's time, this was a very real thing. Not necessarily shootings, but you know, just from pervasion, privation and from exposure, those sorts of things. Death is always there. So I imagine Brigham looking out on that congregation of Saints understands they're going to need these blessings because some of them aren't going to make it to where we need to go. And he wanted the Saints to be spiritually prepared as well as as temporally right that that they could lose, you know, if someone was lost along the trail, it's not the end. And I think that's something that that gets really overlooked.
1:51:58 The, the other thing is, is that Brigham does something that it's really quite extraordinary. And we have a lot of accounts of this where he actually talks about, you know, as they circle the wagons for the night, they have dances, right? They, they spend time together, not just in, in working, but in, in forging bonds of friendship through those sorts of things. Brigham is masterful, not just at the the nuts and bolts of, you know, just getting people from point A to point B, but also keeping their spirits up along the way. There's accounts of him giving blessings on the on the trail as well. One lady in particular who had, I believe a wagon had rolled over her leg and she was suffering a lot. And Brigham tended to her in such a tender way, going back to the Martin Willie handcart company. That was a horrible winter.
1:52:59 Look, all winters are horrible in Wyoming. I've done enough surveying in that state to know that that's a rough place. But that winter was especially rough. Now, by the time Brigham finds out that these Saints are in trouble on the Plains, it's conference time. The weather's still pretty decent. But Brigham, there's something with Brigham where he knows something far worse is coming more than just the average cold. And had Brigham not acted when he did in that very moment, there's a sense of urgency when Brigham says we're stopping everything. We've got to go get these folks off the planes right now.
1:53:42 And, and, and pardon me, I, I get a little choked up when I think about because he's really their only chance at that point. And, and people don't understand that without Brigham's decisive leadership at that moment, coupled with what frankly, I believe is, is a prophetic mantle that fell upon him, especially in that moment, he gets an inkling of how bad this is going to be. And he acts with such decisiveness in that moment that they're able to go get him. Does anyone else have anything they want to add to this part before we move on? OK. Well, you could say he received the revelation, right?
1:54:23 Right. I mean, people will say Brigham Young didn't have any revelations, but it's he had revelations all the time. It's just not the kind of revelations they're hoping for. But when you're you receive a revelation to go out and save the Saints, you know, if you're that St. being saved, then you're thankful. You know that he's a prophet at that time, receiving revelation. Absolutely, absolutely. And I just feel like he doesn't get enough run and enough recognition for how much he loved his people and, and how much he sacrificed personally for him. So we've been at this now two hours and we could go on for probably another six just talking about all the cool stuff he did during the Utah period.
1:55:09 But we're we're we're kind of wrapping up on time and I quite frankly don't want to keep anyone up any longer than than I have to. Does anyone want to speak on anything that they they think is important before we move on talking about what what Brigham's importance is to the restored gospel here, OK. I can share a maybe a personal. So I was raised in the church. Obviously I've I've always kind of had a testimony and knowing the gospel is true and committed to the church and served a mission and all of that stuff. Right. And you know, and going back to something Kim brought out at the beginning is that a lot of members are just not acquainted with the things that Brigham said and did. And I as a history lover and it's something my family always prioritized and like I was probably one of the better informed members of the church even at a young age on on a lot of those historical details.
1:56:08 But but Brigham, even then there was, he was a controversial figure and, you know, 'cause I had before my mission, I was at college and, you know, met some anti Mormons and they brought up the Adam God doctrine. And I was not acquainted with that. I mean, I'd heard vaguely, and I think I might have asked my seminary teacher once as a kid, Hey, what's this? I, I heard there's this thing that of Adam God. And he's like, oh, you know, he, he was just, you know, people claim that Brigham Young said stuff that he didn't actually say. And, you know, as a teenager, I, I accepted that. Well, I met these anti Mormons and they were showing me some quotes that looked like, came from the Journal of discourse.
1:56:53 I was like, my grandma has those on her bookshelf. My grandpa had a set of those that seems kind of official. And, and I, I tracked it down. And so I asked my institute teacher, Hey, you know, is, is this a thing? Like it looks like he actually did say it wasn't taken out of, you know, and, and Brigham and, and my institute teacher was trying to help me, you know, prepare for my mission. You know, you don't want to get your head out of the game at that stage. And so he was just like, yeah, but it's, it's it was taken out of context. You know, the anti Mormons, they're not honest in the way they represent things. And, you know, I was like, OK, I I get that. Well, I got home from my mission and met some more anti Mormons and I was just like, OK, so he he wasn't he, he did actually say these things.
1:57:41 He wasn't taken out of context because I actually read a lot more of the source material at that point. And I was just like, well, if it's like for me, I didn't care if it was controversial. I cared if it was true. And you know, I was, I was doing a summer job down in Texas. I was reading and, and I just decided to read the discourses of Brigham Young and there's so much just meat on that bone. Like he talked about building up Zion, getting out of Babylon, you know, establishing autonomy and self-reliance and preparedness. Like all of these things that really resonated with me at that point in my life, especially as kind of like, you know, getting ready for the apocalypse, doom days, doomsday prepper type, you know, and, and, and it just, I was just on fire reading this, the discourses of Brigham Young and it got to the Adam God. And I just remember I got a testimony of Brigham Young. I mean, I always had had kind of that testimony and I had some powerful experiences witnessing personally to me of the truthfulness of the Book of Mormon and Joseph Smith's prophetic mission.
1:58:47 I, I had not had the same experience with Brigham Young until this, that summer when I was reading those discourses. And it's the same spirit that that I had a testimony of Joseph Smith and, and the Book of Mormon and the the rest of the restoration, that same spirit testified to me that Brigham Young was a prophet of God. And, and so it took a little bit more digging and kind of working through some of these contradictions because, you know, there are some prominent leaders of the modern church that, you know, claimed that it was a heresy to believe that Adam was God and, you know, just various things like that. And I was like, what I thought that prophet, you know, and I thought the prophets were, couldn't say anything wrong, you know, when they were acting as a prophet. And, and so I, it took me, it took me a little bit more time to kind of reconcile and work through some of those contradictions.
1:59:44 But I, I could always fall back on that, that testimony that I got just plain reading the source documents, reading the discourses of Brigham Young for myself. And it's just an undeniable spirit, to be honest. So I I just wanted to, I guess end with that. No, that's good. Kimberly. What? What's Brigham Young's importance to the restored gospel? Well, like I kind of said earlier, without Brigham Young, what? What do we? Without Brigham Young, There's no temple, there's no temple ordinances, there's no stealing power. We don't have hardly any of the revelations of Joseph Smith.
2:00:27 I mean, really Brigham Young, I would say, is the Restoration, like I said before, Joseph Smith, he gets the vision. Kind of like Lehigh, right? Lehigh gets the vision. Who carries it on his work? Nephi, Joseph Smith is getting the vision. He's getting the revelations. Who's doing the work, President Brigham Young. He is the only one that carried on the work of the Prophet Joseph Smith. And I, I think we all owe him, love him or hate him, we all owe him a debt of gratitude. And I was going to say one thing about Brigham Young. I relate very well to Brigham Young when we talked about like his early, like, you know, his early life and his challenges.
2:01:15 And I'm, I'm different. I'm, I'm not, I wasn't raised in a, the typical LDS home where the gospel was handed to me. You know, I, she had to fight for it a lot. And so when I wanted to learn about what my religion was, you know, the gospel that I was baptized into because I wasn't taught in my home, I went to Brigham Young to learn the gospel. And that's who converted me to not only to Joseph Smith, but to Jesus Christ. And a lot of people talk about that. We can't trust the historical record because they're they're, they're, you know, later reminiscences.
2:01:57 And I just want to say that they're forgetting about the power of the Holy Ghost. The Holy Ghost has the power to bring all things to the remembrance. And this work is a spiritual work. And a lot of the experiences people had were spiritual, even if they didn't understand them at the time. And so when people are writing reminiscences, it's being brought to the remembrance by the power of the Holy Ghost. And so I believe our history is a prophetic history. It's written just as the scriptures are written by the Holy Ghost. And so it takes the Holy Ghost in order to understand our history and to appreciate Brigham Young for the modern day Moses that he is. And, and I have a lot more to say about him, but I'll just stand there. Fantastic.
2:02:43 Thanks. Sean, you had something. Yes, the one thing that I wanted to mention and I, and I think it can't be emphasized enough, when you look at the contending parties at, at the, at the death of Joseph Smith, previous to the death of Joseph Smith and around his, his death, those contending parties, those who stayed behind, some let went to other States and and so forth. The vast majority of those for all practical purposes are defunct because even though they may still exist, if you look at the character of what they preach, it hardly resembles anything of the Mormonism of Joseph Smith's time. You look at the community of Christ, which used to be called the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. I watched this several videos from a historian from that organization and he basically stated when they were they they found out that Joseph indeed lived, that he indeed received a revelation, taught and lived plural marriage. They decided to start distancing themselves from Joseph Smith and nowadays they they look at the the Book of Mormon as inspired fiction.
2:04:11 I, I went through their, their temple that they have in, in Independence and I went through their visitor center and everything. And that you watch a short video kind of like you do when you go through LDS visitor centers. And it was interesting. They're talking about the the account of the first vision, but they said that Joseph Smith just had an experience with the divine and that's how they left it. And I was thinking to myself, wow, this is dry. And it seems like they're completely ashamed of that whole history. And it's like Kimberly brought out Brigham Young is very instrumental, instrumental in preserving all that.
2:04:58 And to those critics of Brigham Young about how he wanted to revise all the history and, and, and everything, why did he leave in all the entries where Joseph Smith is saying things that are, can be perceived as being contrary to the principle? Those things weren't hidden from the record. They, they were there. And, and as far as remnants, reminences are concerned and everything, most of us, most of our lives are undocumented. Nevertheless, these things did happen. True, we can't prove things happen if there's no record, but you can't prove that it didn't happen either. And when you compare people's recollections, especially when you have such a vast variety and you begin to connect the dots and see a lot of common denominators, you can establish with a great deal of confidence that certain events did take, did take place.
2:06:02 And so I for one, I'm, I'm very grateful that Brigham Young did what he did and did what he had to do to preserve it. And so that that's all I have to say. Thanks, Sean. Jacob, go ahead, man. Well, yeah, there's just, you know, I have got a deep, I think the way you get a deep perspective, Brigham Young is to earnestly study his words, you know, that they are available and it. It takes the time commitment to start to read his sermons, but there is so much light and truth in there that that is why so many people have an unshakable testimony of Brigham Young as a prophet of God in spite of all the railing accusations that could be made against him.
2:06:50 That all the you know it, it doesn't matter when you've got that testimony and you know what is in his heart from the spirit bearing witness to you. Just, you know, I, I absolutely agree that as was mentioned early in the presentation, that basically, you know, over, you know, 95, maybe 99% of what Brigham Young taught doctorally you can show had its links to Joseph Smith in some way. I think that so a lot of people will criticize blood atonement when I think when it comes down to, I think blood atonement was just a mixture of capital punishment and the the violent Western rhetoric that could, you know, those were what that was. And I think there's a great quote that kind of addresses the accusations of Brigham Young being a tyrant and also the Utah, early Utah being a period of violence. And this is in Thomas Alexander's recent biography of Brigham Young and the expansion of the Mormon faith. He said all too often critics of Brigham Young have assumed that he controlled the Latter Day Saints through fear, coercion and violence.
2:08:00 We should understand, however, that these methods can control a people only if they have no way of escaping the system. In Utah, most of those who want to leave the territory generally either did so, or they remained and fashioned their lives according to their own persuasion. Clearly, a few who want to leave cannot do so because of violence. The parish Potter murders are witness to that. Many of those who left Utah chose moderate Mormonism by joining with Emma Smith in the reorganization under her oldest son with Joseph Smith, or like Wilford Woodruff's friend Alexander Badlam, some moved to California to engage in business. Some businessmen, like Brother Samuel, David Joseph and Matthew Walker, and the Godbyites, an LDS offshoot of business people and intellectuals, remained in Utah to run businesses outside of the Mormon fold. Violence did exist in Utah, as historians Scott, Thomas and Polly have shown.
2:08:49 Michael Quinn has argued that Utah harbored a, quote, culture of violence. Most of it, however, is, Thomas's study has shown, was uncoordinated vigilante action or commonplace criminal activities. Available statistics show that Utah was less violent than other areas of the West. In fact, Brigham Young wanted apostates to leave the community so he could build Saints. You now see apostates clear out, he said. As Polly Arid has reminded us, she has given us case studies of seven individuals who wanted to leave and succeeded without too much difficulty. All of them believed that violence existed in the community, but Eric cited only Swiss immigrants, Frederick Loba, who made specific charges there clearly questionable. In many cases, those who wanted to leave could not because they were too poor or they owed debts and they could not pay. At times the creditors and debtors could not agree on the extent or even the existence of the debt. Such disagreements led to some cases of property confiscation by bishops or in several instances, a demand by Brigham Young that the debtor pay what Young believed he owed before leaving.
2:09:49 A more pertinent question is why would the Mormon people persevere by traveling 1000 miles to Utah and then dispersed throughout the Mountain West where they chose to and relative poverty on on hardscrabble farms, house their families and wagon boxes and dugouts and dig irrigation ditches? They might have abandoned Mormonism and remained in the Midwest on prosperous farms blessed by summer rain. It seems ludicrous to believe that they did what they did because of coercion. Rather, they found it in Mormonism and Brigham Young's teachings of philosophy and way of life that offered happiness in this life and the expectation of an exalted one after death and the resurrection. So I, I think that's a good quote that I think summarizes the contrast between the spurious allegations that can be made of or criticisms versus the reality of how things actually were in Utah. And I think that that's truly what it comes down to is, you know, life is messy and there you can always find things to nitpick or criticize about different historical figures and no one is perfect.
2:10:54 But I think what's more way more important is to find the truth and the light and the revelation and the knowledge that they that you can really glean from Brigham Young. And that's my testimony. And I say that in the name of Jesus Christ, Amen. Amen. As, as I look around the landscape of Mormonism right now, one of the things that concerns me most is how people are quick and somewhat eager to throw out Brigham Young. And that spans the gamut of Mormon expression from the LDS church on down to to to fundamentalist.
2:11:38 Now, I want to make this as clear as I can, and I also want folks who are Protestants to know I'm this isn't meant as a slam, but quite frankly, if we unhook Brigham Young from the Restoration, we don't have anything that resembles Mormonism as we've come to know it and as it was revealed by Joseph Smith, period. Joseph revealed a lot of things, and then Brigham went on to organize those things by Joseph's Commission, I might add, especially when we start talking about temple ordinances. Joseph's direct Commission to Brigham Young was systematize and organize the endowment, which he did. It's under Brigham's, Brigham's administration that many of the things that we have come to hold dear as Mormons come to full fruition.
2:12:39 Look, they were willing to kill Joseph just for saying the Canon of scripture is closed. Now you start getting into the nature of God. You start getting into plural marriage, which upsets Victorian era sensibilities. Joseph didn't have the freedom that Brigham did to expound on these topics. And these topics would come to define the Mormonism that I think all, all 55 of us, yeah, five of us now enjoy to its utmost. When a loved one passes, as Mormons, we can look back on ceilings and we understand the plan.
2:13:22 That comes because Brigham Young held the line. When things were at their worst, the Lord and Joseph turned to Brigham because in Brigham, you had a guy who was just stubborn enough to keep those things going. You have a man who comes forward, who carves out a magnificent city in the desert, out of rock and sagebrush, right next to a great big salty lake that Bridger told him he would never turn a a single crop in. And so for those who want to unhitch to Brigham Young, I would say be very careful.
2:14:05 Understand what it is you stand to lose by throwing Brigham out of the Restoration. Because once you do, you've lost a lot of these things. You want to call DNC 132 Brigham's invention, which it's clearly not that came from from from Joseph. But Brigham was the one who was able to expound on it because he had the freedom to do so in the space to do so. What he got left, you got Protestantism with some different buildings. And again, I'm not trying to slam Protestantism. I'm just saying that's what you have left. So you have to be very careful if you decide you want to throw Brigham Young out. The other thing I want to say, don't be afraid to teach your kids Brigham Young, right?
2:14:55 So many times people turn away from Brigham because he says uncomfortable things. We have to wrestle with those. We have to make peace with those as adherence to the Restoration. But never be afraid to teach your kids Brigham Young and teach the significance of Brigham Young. Nothing broke my heart quite like watching. And I'll just call it out the the LGBTQ protests at Brigham Young University where they scroll the name Racist across Brigham's statue. We are dangerously close to throwing him out. And if it gets done, there will be hell to pay. Quite literally, I fear in the afterlife, we must preserve his legacy.
2:15:45 It's worth preserving. Do your research on Brigham. I promise you he's not as scary as what what others would would point out. There's a lot of things about Brigham that are that are beautiful that are that are. That's a confirmation to his prophetic column. And that's my testimony, and I leave it in the name of Jesus Christ, Amen. All right, before we wrap up, does anyone have anything else they want to add? There's a new movie actually coming out defending Brigham Young. I don't know if you're aware of the new movie that the Interpreter Foundation is releasing in October. So the, the new movie is 6 days in August about the succession crisis and it's going to be in theaters on October 10th of this year.
2:16:38 So you can look up that trailer online. And I'm, I'm really excited for that. It's from the so, so it's like a follow up to the witnesses movie. If you guys saw witnesses, I, I actually still need to see that one. I'm, I'm bad for having a dozen people recommend it and haven't got around to seeing that one yet. So I need to watch that first about the Book of Mormon witnesses and then six days in August is about Brigham Young's faithfulness and the succession crisis. So. Perfect. All right, well, look, I love and respect each one of you. I I'm, I'm a big fan of the work you do in defending the gospel. And I thank you so much for being home.
2:17:18 So all right, bye everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox