Aug. 3, 2024

Episode #143: The Book Of Enoch W/Adam Stokes

Episode #143: The Book Of Enoch W/Adam Stokes
Episode #143: The Book Of Enoch W/Adam Stokes
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #143: The Book Of Enoch W/Adam Stokes

Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.

Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products

There are many things that we find echoes of Mormonism in. If we believe in Joseph Smiths prophetic mantle one place we shouldn’t be surprised is to find those echoes is in the apocrypha. One book of the apocrypha is the Book of Enoch. Today on the podcast I have Adam Stokes on to talk about the Book of Enoch. Adam is not only a believer in the Restoration but also has degrees from Duke & The Yale School of Divinity and is also a professor. He recently has been doing some work on the Book of Enoch. In our conversation we talk about what the Book of Enoch is, how it was found, It doctrinal emphasis, the striking “bullseyes” between the Book Of Enoch and Joseph Smith translations of the Book of Moses, and finally what we as Mormons today can take away from it.

--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support

0:05 There are many things that we find echoes of Mormonism in. If we believe in Joseph Smith's prophetic mantle, one place we shouldn't be surprised to find those echoes is in the Apocrypha. Now one of those books is called the Book of Enoch. Today on the podcast, I have Adam Stokes on to talk about the Book of Enoch. Now Adam is not only a believer in the Restoration, but also has degrees from Duke and the Yale School of Divinity and is also a professor. He recently has been doing some work on the Book of Enoch. In our conversation, we talk about what the Book of Enoch is, how it was found. It's doctrinal emphasis is the striking bull's eyes between the Book of Enoch and Joseph Smith's translation of the Book of Mormon. And finally, what we as Mormons today can take away from it. That and more on this episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast. So a few weeks back I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running.

0:58 Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page or click the link in this episode show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups, and water bottles all with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU, but you should definitely go check that out. Now this is just the beginning. In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast. So head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode show notes and get yours today. You're listening to the Norman Adam. How's it going, man?

2:23 I'm. Doing good Dave. Thanks for having me. Thanks. Thanks for coming on, man. It's it's I'm super glad to have you here. I saw your presentation on the book of Enoch and I was like, oh, I got to have him on because that sounds awesome. So again, thanks. Thanks for being here. So as, as we dive in, let me ask you this question. You're, you're not a member of the LDS Church, you're not a fundamentalist, but you are part of a Mormon branch, right? A branch of the Restoration? And what branch is that? The official name is the Church of Christ with the Elijah message, the Assured way, the Lord. That is an extremely long name.

3:06 So we just call ourselves the Elijah Message Church and we trace ourselves, yes, like you said, a branch of the restoration. But we trace ourselves back to David Whitmer and then to Granville Hendrick, and then to our two kind of founding prophets, Otto Feting and WA Draves, who received revelations from John the Baptist, which make have a book of scripture for us called the Word of the Lord. But we also accept the Book of Mormon, which we call the record of the Nephites and the King James Version of the Bible. So we're similar to the other Restoration branches, the other Latter Day Saints traditions in that regard. What about like the Doctrine and Covenants do you guys? Excellent question.

3:51 So we accept the 1st 15 or 16 of the Doctrine and Covenants. We prefer. We have a preference for the Book of Commandments, the first kind of 15 revelations of the Book of Commandments. But what what eventually becomes the 1st 16 chapters of the Doctrine and Covenants we do accept officially. Unofficially, we have accepted different parts of the Doctrine and Covenant. So Section 84 where it talks about the temple being built in Missouri is extremely important for us and was referenced in past church literature. But officially, we only accept the 1st 16 revelations of the Doctrine and Covenants. 10-4 check All right, so let me ask you this because I'm curious now. Now I got to ask some questions.

4:37 So do you guys, so I'm I'm guessing if it's just that first sixteen and then kind of 84, you guys probably aren't into plural marriage in is that correct? No, no. Ironically, it's interesting you mentioned that, Dave. We don't think that Joseph practice what plural marriage, how can I put it? We don't think that Joseph Joseph his big his big sin was plural marriage. Joseph Smith's big sin for us was not building the temple in Missouri. So we think that Joseph had a threefold mission, one to re establish a church as it was in New Testament times. The 2nd to bring about the Book of Mormon to translate the Book of Mormon so that modern readers can read it. And then thirdly, to build the temple in the temple in Missouri, almost at Jerusalem, but in Missouri. So yes, no.

5:37 So Joseph Smith didn't fulfill that third part. So that was where he committed a major sin. But we don't really talk too much about the polygamy part. Gotcha gotcha. Now let let me ask you this, do you guys have a temple currently or are you waiting for that temple to be built in in Jackson County? We are waiting for the temple to be built in Jackson County on the temple lot grounds. So the temple Lot is our most sacred spot. That that's very special to us. In fact, I was telling you earlier, when I go out to General Conference I will always try to make a stop on the temple lot. Gotcha. Gotcha. Dude. That's fascinating. So do you guys have like other revelations other than that that like 16 and like kind of 84?

6:24 Do you guys have like an open cannon? Yes, well, the worst. So our third Scripture is called the Word of the Lord, and those are the revelations that John the Baptist gave to Otto Feting and to WA Dre. So that's our third book of Scripture. And if you read it, it's very similar in some ways to the Doctrine Covenant. It's revelations. It's revelations given to specific people within the church, as well as talking about current events in the world. So it's kind of very similar to that type of format. But that's our third book of Scripture. And so that's kind of what distinguishes us from the rest of the restoration branches. 10-4 dude, that's fascinating. That's good stuff. All right, Well, cool.

7:07 So were you raised in this in this faith tradition or did you convert or how did you get here? I was not raised in the Larity St. tradition. I was raised a traditional black Baptist. And yeah, I was baptized when I was a teenager, late in my teens, around 16 or 17. I was, I was a member of a wonderful Baptist Church for many years, Zion Baptist Church in Baltimore, MD. And I was a member of that up until my mid 20s. And then I kind of had a crisis of faith, Dave. My life kind of went to kaput. Just things, a lot of things fell apart. I was dating a girl in Missouri, in Kansas City, MO, that fell apart.

7:50 My academic career, the trajectory I was on fell apart. And I kind of had a faith crisis. So I wasn't any religious affiliation for many years. And then I found at a conference I used to go to, the Society of Biblical Literature conference, there was a kiosk that BYU had, and they had a copy of the Joseph Smith translation. I was really interested about it, in it because I didn't know anything about the Joseph Smith translation other than that it was a modified version of the King, King James Version. So I was curious about that because my research, I was in religious studies at the time and my research was on kind of the history of interpretation of the King James Bible.

8:30 So I got this CD-ROM with the Joseph Smith translation on it, and I was just kind of blown away because the perspective and basically the retelling or the alternate version that gives the Genesis story was for me so uplifting. I guess it's kind of goes to kind of your fundamentalist background with Adam, God, etcetera. But just the fact that, you know, God doesn't reject Adam, but God in fact exalt forgives Adam, exalts Adam to the, you know, the stats of the priesthood, exalts him to become the Ancient of Days was something that was, was was really comforting for me coming from a Protestant background where we always look at the story of Adam and Eve was this irreversible sin that Adam did and God never forgave him and Adam's this total loser for eternity and turning eternity.

9:20 So that was that was something that was really comforting and amazing to me. And that was my that was kind of my my Segway into the book of Mormons. So I've told others about this. I'll tell you about it, but I was celebrating my wife's one. Well, our one year anniversary of marriage, this is back in 2013. We were at a Marriott Hotel in Princeton. My wife had went to get Chinese food and I started, I found a Book of Mormon at the at the room in the room, excuse me, that we were staying in. And so I start reading it and I literally have this mystical experience where I'm pulled into the world. I see I'm in some type of woods and there's some Lamanites running around.

10:00 Now take that as you will, you know, believe me, don't believe me, but I would go, I would go on record as saying I even be psychologically evaluated and saying, you know, that's what happened. That's exactly what happened. So after that I knew the Book of Mormon was was true and I knew that I had to be part of a community for which the Book of Mormon was true. So I scouted around a little bit. I hung out with some bicker tonight's but their church was kind of too far away for me to get to. I was economically struggling at the time. I couldn't even get decent gas money to go a long trips. So I ended up going to a community of Christchurch down the street, which I loved. Very traditional, believing in the inspired version, AKA the Joseph Smith translation, the Book of Mormon and adoption and covenants. But I had some larger problems with the denomination as a whole, namely they're kind of rejection of the Book of Mormon. And so that led me to be in conversation with some elders in the Elijah Message Church, and I was in communication with them for several years, and then I decided to join them in 2020. Wow, wow.

11:05 So it's a very, that's a very long story. No, no, no, no. That's that's awesome. It's always good to to let let the people we're talking to, so to speak, know where you're coming from. I wasn't born a Mormon either. I'm the only Mormon on either side of my family. Oh wow. And yeah, so I, I joined the LDS church as a kid, but I can, I can really resonate with with what you're, what you say there in terms of especially dealing with Adam. There's there's this idea that that the father of us all is within Protestantism is the the the catalyst for all of our pain and sorrow and and even more than him, Eve and I didn't I didn't get down with that right as I looked back through history and I studied Western sieve. What what I noticed was is that the, the, and I'll use this in quotes, traditional telling of, of the Adam and Eve story is, is a, a mechanism for really doing some pretty horrible things to women throughout time, right?

12:14 It's women's fault. Joseph comes along and Joseph turns that on it on his head right through revelation. He says, no, no, no, no, no, we don't. They're not the cause of our pain. They're the source of us being here. And not just that they're, they're exalted individuals. And, and that, that was wild to me, right, That that something could be turned up the, you know, and the, and for me on, on my end. The other thing was I lost my, my dad when I was 13. And my dad wasn't particularly religious. He believed in God, right? And it's not like we read the Bible a whole bunch, but we talked about God a little bit in our house.

12:57 But the thought that my dad, because he didn't say, you know, the magic words of, of I accept Jesus as my Lord and Savior on his deathbed. He's he's gone now. That didn't sit well with me. I'm like, if God is both just and loving, well you're really missing the loving part here on this. Yeah, yeah. Right. And so I found Mormonism to be one of those things that allowed me to really, you know, find hope and peace. Yeah. And I think message. Yeah, I think our journeys are very similar in that regard. I could believe it was precisely because of Mormonism that I could believe in a loving, kind and compassionate God again after so many years.

13:38 I, I think my initial rejection of God when I was going through everything was a view that, you know, there's ultimately no loving God that existed. And I think Mormonism, when I was exposed to Joseph, the translation, the Book of Mormon, they revealed this, that this very loving God, who and one of the most powerful statements, I think, Dave, that I've ever read in the Restoration scriptures is that, you know, they heard the voice of the Lord calling to them. Even though they were shut out from their from God's presence, God never stopped having a relationship with them. If you read just the simple King James Bible where you read the mesoretic text, you know, God kicks them out. It's done. God never even speaks to Adam and Eve again. But in the Joseph Smith translation, he sends angels, he speaks to them.

14:22 You know, they can't see him, but he still speaks to them and he has a relationship with them and a very intimate and he exalts Adam to this. Basically, we go with fundamentalist thought to as high as as you as you can go. So you know that that was just, that was really powerful for me and really, really comforting. One of the things that always struck me about that account, even in the King James Version, is that Adam and Eve, they they take of the fruit and Adam and Eve don't go seek their God out. Their God seeks them out. Yeah, even. And, and look, God wasn't surprised, right? Even though he, he asked them questions and whatnot, he's not surprised at what just went down, right? I mean, he, he knows exactly what happened. And in that moment, even in, in that moment when Adam's partaken of the fruit and disobeyed a commandment, even though they were kind of given two competing commandments, he, they disobeyed that one.

15:23 God's like, I'm not done with you, right? And, and God is the one seeking them out, you know, and, and, and I think that's so indicative of, of who God really is, right? So often we, we, we think that that this return to God is like he, he's far away. He, he's, he, you know, I'll never be able to get back. That's not the case, right? He's right there. He's like, just turn around, just stop what you're doing, turn around and come back. And, and I, I think there's a certain beauty there that, that I think we should all be able to resonate with being mortals and fallen and, and having to, to make that return back to God. It's not as far as what the adversary would have us believe.

16:06 I, I think the story about Adam and Eve is really the story about us. I think whenever you read the scriptures, you know, it's not just a story about these ancient people who lived long ago. Yes, it is that, but it's also our story. And we, we see our, we see our own struggles. We see our own situations and their situations. Absolutely. So you you're from Baltimore originally? I'm from Baltimore, yeah. So I lived for about two years out on the Eastern Shore of Maryland. Oh, we're on the Eastern Shore. Salisbury. My my people are actually from my my mom's side of the family is from Salisbury, a small town, dim, witty, I think. I know where that's at. I know where that's at. So I so I worked in Salisbury for a time and then I I lived in Princess Anne. OK.

16:51 And then I later switched jobs and worked in Ocean City as well. Yeah, I love the Eastern Shore. I love Ocean City. Yeah, I used to when it were years ago, I was a page for the Maryland General Assembly, which basically you could call the legislature to legislators and mayor of Ocean City used to come in all the time. So I was actually buddies with him and my I had an aunt who owned this very small hotel down Ocean City and we would go like every year. But I, I, I love the Eastern Shore. Absolutely beautiful and I loved Ocean City. So you know what? I've been there. Did you ever eat at Anthony's? It's right. Yes. Yes, I did. Yes, dude, Anthony's. I miss those sandwiches. Yeah, those grinders.

17:34 Oh, I miss those sandwiches. I wanted to fly back from time to time just to grab a grinder from Anthony's so. Yeah, yeah. Not that I expect it, but if anyone in you know that works at Anthony's, shout out to you guys. The last time I was in Anthony's was 2017. My son Gavin, who's 7 now, he had just started walking and I was there with my with my mom and dad, My dad since past now, but that was kind of that was one of the last times that we were together before his health went to went to kaput. So, but yes, I, I loved Anthony's, I love Ocean City. Yeah, no, Ocean City was fantastic. Their boardwalk was awesome. I mean, yeah, I definitely enjoyed my time out there. So awesome. Good stuff.

18:15 Yeah, die hard Orioles fan and Ravens fan. I like the Orioles more, but also a Ravens fan. You know, all right, so I, I got to see a few Ravens games while I was there and we, the company I worked for, if you did a really good job and your projects came under budget and everything else, one of the rewards that was on the table was either going to see an O's game or a Ravens game. And so I would go see the Ravens play. And once as kind of a added bonus, they had a few of the players walk up and meet everybody in the in the suites. And what I remember is Ray Lewis is a scary, scary man.

19:00 So nice guy, but man that dude was intense. Yeah, yeah. So I never met him. I met some, I met some other players, but I never I never met Ray Lewis. So yeah, yeah, No it. Was it was good stuff for sure. But so dude, what was your fascination with the Book of Enoch? Yes, yes. So that kind of goes to the Joseph Smith translation. So I'm, I was really interested in kind of the Enoch material in the book of Moses, chapters 6 through 867, Genesis six and seven in the Joseph Smith translation. And the, the chapter Chapter 7, especially for me has always been very powerful with this notion of the city of Enoch and this place of perfect peace and perfect rest, the city of God that God takes to itself.

19:57 That's been very powerful for me. And I think, you know, even though we don't officially acknowledge in my tradition the Joseph Smith translation or, or book or the Book of Moses. I think that that kind of undergirds a lot of our theology about the temple and the temple lot in my own tradition. So Moses seven has always been something that's been very has always been a very, very special text for me ever since I was exposed to restoration. But I was always kind of curious as to what's going on with some of the racial elements in there. So you have this beautiful description of the city of Enoch, but then you have these people, these people of Cain who are, who are described as black, whom Enoch is not preaching to. And I was always like, what's going on there? What's up with that?

20:48 And so that kind of got me into, you know, further researching this. And that's where the, the, the article, the people of Canaan and Interpreter Journal came up. So, and that's how that was created out of my interest in that. So I had a wonderful, wonderful time writing that article, researching for that article, and I think it even brought me even closer to the Joseph Smith translation. Awesome. So let let's get some historical background here on the Book of Enoch. Then real quick about what about when is the book of Enoch discovered? Or maybe the the right word is rediscovered, right, Because it, it, it kind of, it obviously disappears out of out of what would be considered the, the King James version of the Canon, right? I don't think it gets put into the Geneva Bible or the OR the the other one.

21:42 I'm blind. So we we have the Book of Enoch explicitly mentioned in the Epistle of Jews. So Epistle of Jews written in Greek, it quotes from it. I believe it quotes from the first or second chapter explicitly of the book of Enoch. But yeah, and we we know that it was popular among the church fathers they cited from time to time. But then it just like you said, man, it just disappears for like centuries and kind of re emerges with modern biblical scholarship in the 18th and 19th centuries. So people find the Greek text again, they translate it into French. They translate it into English.

22:22 After Joseph Smith's time gets translated into English. After the publication of the Book of Mormon, it gets translated into English. And so now we have a bit, but nobody really makes reference to it. You know, in the Middle Ages, the medieval, medieval fathers, the medieval writers, they don't really make reference to it at all. The only church that's really caring about the Book of Enoch, I would say, is the Ethiopian church, for whom it's part of their Canon. Not even the, you know, the Greek Orthodox don't even have it as really part of their Canon. I don't believe. So for Western Christianity, it just kind of falls off the map. And it's not really, yeah, discovered until modern biblical scholarship where you get an interest in apocalyptic text, apocalyptic scriptures, and then it becomes popular again. I think it's gained really a lot of prominence in the 20th century when you've had the finding of all these apocryphal texts, Nakamati, the Dead Sea Scrolls, etcetera. The Book of Enoch has has really gained popularity. One of my teachers when I was in Vedic school, he published a translation of the Book of Enoch, John Collins, I believe. Well, first Enoch, as he calls it. So, yeah, very, very popular now. But most Christians, I would say for most of Christendom in the West, didn't even know what it know about it or even know it was quoted from that the book of Jude was was quoting from it. How was it rediscovered?

23:54 I'm not, you know, two things. I think that, you know, when people start retranslating Greek text into different languages during the advent of modern biblical studies, the Book of Enoch comes into play. The Dead Sea Scrolls, I know this is later, this is way after the 19th century, but in the 1940s when they're discovered, there are some fragments of Enoch which kind of shed light on the Greek version of Enoch. And so people start to do a comparison studies, and so that becomes popular. So I would say, you know, rediscovery in the Greek text in the 18th and 19th century and the Hebrew and Aramaic fragments of the Book of Enoch that we get in the 20th century kind of revive interest in that.

24:43 So I think that, you know, in some ways people know about the Book of Enoch, but they don't know about it. They know that there's a Greek text of Enoch that exists, you know, in prior to the 18th century, but nobody's really sought to like translate it. You can't really read it unless you know Greek. And so people, people just don't unless you're, unless you're a scholar, you don't really touch it. So when when it is discovered, you said it was just a fragment within within the the Dead Sea Scrolls, correct? Yeah, So the, so the Greek text, it wasn't like the Greek. So I, I should probably clarify here because I, I'm, I'm probably sounding a little bit confusing, but no, the Greek text always existed. It was just that if you didn't know Greek, you didn't have access to it, you couldn't read it.

25:25 But then there were alternate versions of Enoch that were found among the Dead Sea Scrolls in the 1940s that were written in Hebrew and Aramaic, which are likely the original language that the Book of Enoch was written in. So the Greek that we have is probably a translation, but there's also, there's Hebrew and Aramaic versions of the Book of Enoch. And so people start comparing those with the Greek. And I think that's one of the things that and just as general interest in apocalyptic literature in the 20th century, that's one of the things that revises, that revives interest in the Book of Enoch. I got you so so we there's that fragment that's discovered with the with the Dead Sea Scrolls. We know that but but we have the full codec, so to speak yes with the with the Greek right now.

26:16 This is a OK, spoiler alert. This will come into play a little, little later to really testify of Joseph's prophetic mission. Joseph would not have any access to the Book of Enoch in his day, correct? No, there is possibly a French version. I've checked the dates on this stage, but I I'm pretty sure you're 99.9% correct. I think there might have been a French translation. There is no English translation until after the book publication of the Book of Mormon and several years several decades after the founding of the of the Latter St. Church. And I think it's probably pretty safe to say that Joseph was not fluent in French. Yeah, he, you know, you you read some of his notes. And and again, because of the times we're in, we're in, we're in colonial, you know, just past colonial America, where he's living pretty much his whole life on the frontier. He's not going to have access to this book. Got you.

27:14 OK. Now let's move in. Move into this. Adam. What? Let's talk a little bit about what the book contains. Yeah. So the Book of Enoch, the original Book of Enoch contains. It's basically, it's got a little bit of everything. So there's narrative, there's poetry, there's basically prophecies of Enoch. So we get the story of Enoch interacting with these guys called the Watchers, who are these really cool beings. There's a lot of in reception history. So in movies and in film we talk about the you see the Watchers in like sci-fi movies. In the Darren Aronski movie Noah that was made in 2014 with Russell Crowe. You had the the Watchers, the kind of these rock people. Yeah, it was kind of, it was kind of cheesy, but they were originally these beings of light. So you have these Watchers who are really fascinating. You also get the watchers in the book of Daniel, but you get them very prominently in the book of Enoch. And then you have an alternate Noah story where Noah seems to have been conceived by the Binay Elohim or the the sons of God who were mentioned in the biblical book of the biblical, excuse me, the biblical Noah story in Genesis chapter 6 through 9.

28:33 So you have you have basically Noah, even though he is in the biblical story said to have been spared because he was the one righteous person or his family were the one were the righteous people away from the sons of the sons of God who are having intercourse with the daughters of men. He himself seems to have been born from these Binet Elohim. So he has a kind of this supernatural type of lineage to him. So there's kind of an alternate, alternate Noah story there. And then you have a kind of this apocalypse towards the end of the book where you have the righteous, the children of the light, the righteous who are fighting against the children of evil and the children of evil persecute them and oppress them. But at the end of the day, God comes and delivers the righteous.

29:25 So there's a lot going on there. Some of it's toll through, like I said, narrative through prose. Other things are told through kind of poetry. So Enoch's prophecies are very kind of poetical, but it's all kind of mixed in there. It's kind of a hodgepodge, and we know kind of from the choppiness of the Book of Enoch, that's probably not just one author writing it, but a bunch of sources that were combined to one book. OK. And, and, and this, this brings me to another question, when, when we're looking at those various codexes, right, whether it's that portion of the Dead Sea Scrolls or the Greek or the Ethiopian, do we get a sense that there's some continuity that seems to be there in those different codexes?

30:07 Do we find major differences that should concern us? What, what? What do we find there? There are major differences, but there is basically the structure is the same and the overarching theme of the righteous being persecuted by the wicked and the wicked having absolute power on the earth until God comes. That's a theme and that is a current that runs through all these traditions, but they do have different things to them. So Slovakian Enoch, for example, which is another version of the Book of Enoch has some some significant variants. So there's an ascension of Enoch in this the Slovakian version of the Book of Enoch that you don't get in other versions of the book of Enoch.

30:50 So there are some, there are some significant differences, but the main, the main theme, the main arc of the story is the same in all of them. OK, all right, and and I think it's important here to to point out that IA lot of these stories, we we get this idea that that everything is always written down right now, now, certainly, you know, there there's some things that that we find in the Pearl of great price where Adam is commanded to keep a book of remembrance, right? But you, you get a sense that some of this record keeping, so to speak, stops for a time, right, which would make sense with just how people are. I mean, we're look, I'll be the first to admit I'm horribly lazy.

31:35 Given the opportunity from doing something good to sitting on the couch and watching football. I'm taking the second option all day, right? Excuse me, but a lot of the the biblical narrative that we find, especially it it when it comes to Genesis, that seems to be a lot of oral tradition that gets passed down 1st. And so I'd imagine Enoch would be much the same way. Yeah, yeah. I think, you know, I always tell my students this. I used to teach an Old Testament class at Saint Joseph's University. Shout out to the Eagles. But I used to tell my, I used to tell my, my students in that class that, you know, back in the day, Jesus, the Lord, Jesus, the Apostle Paul, the Apostle Peter, they had the Old Testament in their head. They weren't really writing it down. Now it was written down.

32:24 But this was stuff that people memorize through like oral tradition. And that's why you get so many, especially with the Bible itself. That's why you get so many variants at times. But this was stuff that they memorized. One of the things I like to, I'm also a Latin teacher and one of the things I like to torment my students with is making them memorize passages of the Latin Vulgate. And I'm like, you know, if Paul could memorize the entire Old Test Old Testament in his head, you can memorize, you know, these little passages, so. Yeah, you're, you're rough on those kids. Holy cow. No, it's. Latin by the end of it, yes, that's. That's awesome. Very cool. A lot of this was oral tradition. So like, so Genesis especially, that's a great example. So scholars would say there are multiple sources that and I don't know how much I buy this.

33:11 I, I don't really buy this, but I'll just give the scholarly consent, the Skali view that, you know, there are multiple sources for the Pentateuch, multiple sources for Genesis. So J we call them J&E, the Yahwest, the Eloist, and that these were originally oral traditions that were written down and combined into combined together. So and I think the same thing is going on with Enoch and that would explain some of the differences and discrepancies that we have with the different versions of Enoch. Want more from the Mormon Renegade podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the fundamental news program for. Free. Still not enough?

33:53 Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button and for $5.00 a month you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes today. So and I think the same thing is going on with Enoch and that would explain some of the differences and discrepancies that we have with the different versions of Enoch. So let me ask you this as a guy who's both a man of faith as well as a scholar, when you look at the Book of Enoch, do you see it would be unfair to say it's, it's a complete historical record, right? But do you see something there that lends credence to, hey, this is important, and some of this might be a little more literal than we would like to admit? Yeah, well, I take, you know, I, I take the Book of Enoch very seriously.

34:53 I know some of in academia, most people would say that's mythology, it's metaphor. I don't see it like that because I view Genesis. I take Genesis 6 and 9629 very seriously as a person of faith. You know, I believe in the supernatural. I believe in supernatural beings. And I think that with the book of Enoch, we have a testament just like we do with with the material in Genesis. We have a testament of somebody who is experiencing the supernatural and having encounters with supernatural beings. And so I think that, you know, there might be different at times different agendas and different emphases in these different versions of Enoch. But at their core, they are relating for my, in my view, a historical event of a person's encounter a, a, a biblical patriarchs encounter with the supernatural. OK.

35:52 There's there's one particular part in in the Book of Enoch that I found fascinating, and that's this ascension. He seems that he that it's the seven heavens, right? Yes. Yes. Can you explain that a little bit to the listeners out there? What what happens in in that part of the story? Yeah, I'm a little bit rusty on that part. It's been a, it's been a while. But yes, he ascends through, he ascends through the different heavens and there's kind of different things in each of the heavens. And then the last heaven he actually sees, I believe the throne of God is now, like I said, David, it's been a while. I believe he sees the throne of God. And there is some in kind of Jewish lingo, some murk of a mysticism, so throne mysticism that that Enoch experiences.

36:41 And it's a very kind of esoteric passage, a little bit confusing, and I think deliberately so, because this is a mystical vision that Enoch cannot really fully explain, that the writers of the Book of Enoch cannot fully explain. Gotcha, gotcha. So let me ask you this because because this is something I've always kind of wondered when we start looking at at Moses 6-7 and I believe 8, don't quote me on that. We find a lot in there about Enoch. Yes. Now here here's what I want to talk about for for just a minute. How many bullseye again, Joseph not having access to this text the the book of Enoch.

37:22 Do we find any places where we see Joseph get it right in the Book of Moses that would lend credence to this idea that he knew maybe a little more about Enoch than just about anybody at that time? Because what are those? Absolutely. I think, you know, I think that Joseph focusing on Enoch himself, that's not something that anybody would have done at that time. Like I said, Enoch's not very popular at the time that, you know, Joseph was receiving the revelation that will become, you know, the Pearl, the material in the Pearl of great price. If you look at other kind of mystical thinkers before him, Emanuel Swedenborg, for example, they're not quoting the Book of Enoch. They don't even care about the book of Enoch. They don't even know about the book of Enoch. So that the fact that Joseph is telling us about Enoch, that Joseph chooses to folk that whatever Joseph is receiving focuses on Enoch, I think that in of itself lends credence that that he is he is onto something here, that he's tapped into something here.

38:28 The way that Enoch is described in the book of Moses in chapters 6 through through eight is very similar to the way that Enoch is described in the book of Enoch. So as being someone persecuted for his righteousness, but is ultimately protected, but someone who is also ultimately protected by God. So God tells in the book of Moses, God says open your mouth and nobody will harm you. Well, if you read the book of Enoch, you know, Enoch is this righteous person. He faces his persecution from the from the wicked, from the children of darkness, but he eventually overcomes through God's help, through God's guidance. And he has a mystical vision of God's throne. And this is very similar to what happens with Enoch, Enoch chapter in, excuse me, in the book of Moses.

39:12 So in Enoch chapter 6, Enoch is this righteous prophet being persecuted and then he has this mystical vision of the city of God, of the city of Enoch that God takes up to himself. So there are some very strong correspondences between the material and the book of Moses. And in the the apocryphal Book of Enoch, one of my dear friends, David Linsley, sorry, David Hocking, David Hocking, he has written a few books on the on the Restoration scripture. So he has a beautiful annotated Book of Mormon. He also has an annotated book of Enoch and he compares the material in the Book of Enoch with the material in the Book of Moses.

39:58 He shows and and Doctor Hocking shows in his work. How basically? Joseph seems to have known stuff about the Book of Enoch that it would have been impossible for him to know. Hugh Nibley as well, who I know you know about the great, the great ancient American, excuse me, the great Mesoamerican scholar. He's written a lot on the book. He wrote a lot on the Book of Enoch. And he shows where there are certain names and certain titles that are used in the Book of Moses that are also found in the Book of Enoch. But nobody knows that until much later when these names are found in the Dead Sea Scroll fragments.

40:38 So I think there's a lot. I I say all that to say that there's a lot that seems to point to Joseph Smith being on point in his depiction of Enoch. This doesn't seem to be something that he created, but it's something that gels very well with the text that he would not even have known about in his time. And see, that's, that's impressive, right? Like there's a certain point at which, if let me back up, I remember I took a a course once that of American history that really dealt with Jacksonian America. And you really can't talk about Jacksonian America without talking about the Mormons. He just can't, right. And, and one of the things that that this professor said is he says when, when you're dealing with Joseph Smith, you got come to one of two conclusions.

41:28 He was either exactly what he said he was or he was the most raw genius that America and maybe even the world ever produced. Now I would add one other thing. He's either exactly what he says or he is one hell of a good guesser, right? Like stupid good guesser. Because to to nail all this, right? And, and not just the Book of Enoch, if we look at certain certain things in in Egyptian mythology, right, that, that Joseph later reveals again, Joseph's not going to have access to this, right? Yeah, Egyptology doesn't really start till after the Napoleonic Wars, right?

42:08 And and. In the early 20th century, honestly. Yes, yes. And so for, for, for this farm boy to, to be able to have all these bull's eyes, it, it, it leaves one a little perplexed if you, if you're not willing to encounter the divine there. I, I totally agree. I totally agree. I didn't realize, you know, with the Egyptology stuff, I did not realize that, you know, Joseph had a Egyptian alphabet manual that he was, that he was using with the Book of Abraham. You know, I was always taught that, oh, he just did. He just looked at the papyrus and it was just, you know, spontaneous. But that's, that's actually not the case. There's a lot, there's a lot more there than than just what people make it out, you know, make it out to be. Right, right.

42:56 So why, why don't you dive into a little bit of the presentation that you gave here a little while back and, and let's go over that because I found that to be extremely fascinating. Yeah, yeah. So I, in the, the article that I wrote, I talked about, you know, what's going on with Enoch and the children of Cain. And basically coming to the conclusion that Enoch doesn't preach to the children of Cain, not because of any fault or any flaw of themselves, but because the children of Cain are kind of despised, as the text says, as Moses says, by the other people in the land.

43:37 So because they are, because they are despised, Enoch preaching to them would have been something that would've been very, very difficult to do and would have have put would have caused a lot of kind of contention and strife in a situation that was already full of contention and strife. So one of the things I wanted to emphasize was that the the children of Canaan hadn't done anything wrong. There's the text never says that they're under any type of curse, but it just seems to be Enoch's preference for preaching to other people versus preaching preaching to them.

44:19 And I basically say, you know, the residue of the people that God mentions has cursed don't include the children of Cain or the children of Canaan because since Enoch has not preached to them, they are not under the same obligation to repent and to follow God's laws as these other people who Enoch has preached to. But they've still rejected his rules. They've rejected God's rules and regulations, if that makes sense. Yeah. Yep, that makes sense. So. So what was it in the text that you were finding that lead you to that conclusion? Yeah, yeah. So, well, first the the mention of the residue people. So in Moses Chapter 7, it says that Enoch looked on the residue of the people and they were a mixture of all this of all the seed of the son of of the sons of Adam. I should really have the I should really have the text to him right now.

45:18 But they were all they were all the seeds of the son of Adam, except for the seeds of Cain. For the seed of king were black and had no place among them. But then earlier on it said, God says Zion, I have blessed, but the residue of the people I have cursed. So that residue of the people include the races that Enoch has preached to, but not but not the the children of Canaan. Because since Enoch has not reached the message of repentance to them, they are not obligated or they are not. They do not come under the same condemnation, the same judgment as these other groups of people whom Enoch has preached, to whom Enoch has told to repent, and they still refused to repent. OK.

46:02 All right. So is this something that we see that we talked about the, the residue of the people versus the people that Enoch preached to? Are we finding like this has to do with like, you know, certain tribes, so to speak, that that maybe he's preaching to to tribes with maybe a, a, a familiar kind of relationship with Or are we seeing that that maybe this has more to do with with region and geography? That's that's a really good question that I think that's a very good question. I think that it could possibly be both region geography. So the, the children of Cain seem to be, you know, not only despised by the other people, but they're kind of, they're kind of in their own region, separated from other people. And if they come into the presence of others, then people seem to seem to despise them, but they kind of seem to be separated.

47:03 So they're there. There seems to be kind of a regional, how do I put regional distinction being made perhaps over and against a tribal one, But I think that that might be something that's going on as well. Well, that's a really good question. I didn't dive as much into detail about that when I was writing the article. No, no, no, it was good that that article was still good, by the way, I really, really enjoyed it. When when you, you take a step back and you look, you look at the, the entirety of the Book of Enoch, What, what do you think that book is trying to convey to the reader? I, I think there's several things, but but what jumps out at you?

47:45 What's as you look at it, What's the one thing you you really take away from? Yeah, I, I feel towards the Book of Enoch similar to how I feel towards the Book of Job, which is you have, or the Book of Toba in the Apocrypha, which is where you have a righteous person who is being persecuted but eventually rises above that persecution. And I think that Enoch was composed, one of the reasons it was composed and one of the reasons I think it was very popular with an early Christianity, Apostolic Christianity, and even a kind of Second Temple Judaism with the Dead Sea sect is, is this message of in not only endurance, but victory in the face of, in the aftermath of persecution. And I, I think that's a very, very powerful message. I think that, you know, you, you see that not just in the book of Enoch, but in a lot of, in a lot of texts, both ancient and modern, the original Star Wars, which comes to mind. Episode 4 has a, has a similar theme. So after Luke Skywalker goes, goes through all this stuff, you know, his, his aunt and uncle get burned to a crisp, he loses Obi Wan, he loses his best friend, big star fighter. But at the end, but at the end he's victorious. He blows up the Death Star and and he's victorious. I think that idea of being being persecuted by evil, of being oppressed by evil, but rising above that oppression, I think for myself that is the central

49:17 theme of the Book of Enoch. You know, and that should really, no matter which, no matter which branch of the restoration you're in, there's plenty of persecution go to go away, right? I mean, look, because it continues all the way out. You know, it starts very early on in Palmyra, goes to Kirtland or Pennsylvania, excuse me, then to Kirtland, then goes to Missouri, Missouri. Missouri's the worst, yes. Missouri's the worst, then goes to Nauvoo, and when they leave the United States, it's still not enough, right? Like Brigham's got to say, yeah, we got a, we got bury the temple foundations now, right? And, and so no matter what branch of the restoration you're in, you should be able to resonate a little bit with this, this idea of, of persecution, right?

50:05 Because it, it, it is part and parcel to the, to the Mormon narrative. It, it just is. Absolutely. And and that's something we should should all resonate with, right. But I, I think that's the beautiful message is that. I, I think, I think that's also what I think for, if I may speak for, for the prophet, rest in heaven. I think that's what drew him to the book of Enoch as well. And again, like we talked about before, seeing your own experiences and the experience of the of the ancient, I think Joseph Smith saw his own prophetic calling in a manner similar to Enoch. And I know that in some editions of the Doctrine and Covenants, he even calls himself that the name that he uses for himself is Enoch. So, so yeah, I, I think, I think the, the, the Patriarch Enoch resonated very strongly with the Prophet Joseph Smith.

50:53 Well, and and their missions are are very similar in some ways, right? I mean, I went back once and, and look, I could be wrong on this. I don't think I am. I mean, it's possible something's floating out there I haven't seen yet. But I went back through and I was like, OK, how many just church buildings did Joseph Smith build, right? Like chapels? Well, you can kind of make a case for Kirtland, right? Because there was a grand assembly hall in Kirtland in, in, in that temple. But outside of that, we don't have any record that I can certainly find where Joseph is in the business of building, quote, churches, right, as we think meeting houses, right?

51:38 His view is a little more expansive than that, right? He's more interested in community cities and temples. Yeah, yeah, Ming habits don't really come into play until after, like after Mormonism gets settled. Right, right. And so this this idea that that that Joseph, much like Enoch, is more interested in whole societies. Yes, yes. And lastly, I think he saw Kirtland and especially that VU as kind of, you know, the RE, you know, the revitalization of the city of Enoch. I think that ties into, you know, going back to Joseph Smith translation, when you look at Genesis 9, when God talks to Noah, God says when men keep my commandments, Zion will again come down from heaven.

52:26 The General Assembly of the first born. I think that Joseph saw, like you said, I think he hit the nail on the head, Kirtland and I vu as this re this, this city of Zion coming back down to earth in this General Assembly. Yep, absolutely. And, and I mean, I know it's not your faith tradition, but that continues on even with Brigham, right? As, as they get out, get out to, to, to the Utah Territory. There's this idea that that they're leaving, leaving behind Babylon, so to speak, And they're going to do something different, right? This idea of being set apart to be something different.

53:06 And and that's keeping with what Joseph Smith taught with with Kirtland and Nauvoo and Far West. He had it in mind for Far West as well, this idea of coming out of the world into a more holy society. I love one of my favorite hymns is Mormon hymns is the Spirit of God. Yeah. And there's that line there. I think it's in the spirit of God. We'll find a place that God for us prepared, prepared far away in the West of the place that God has prepared for us far away in the West. And I think that for me, that ties directly into the city of Zion. Yeah, I I think so too. And, and to be quite honest with you here, Adam, I think it's something that we as Mormons, we've got to get back to.

53:53 Yeah, I absolutely. Absolutely. I, I think, I think we've, we've for far too long started looking at our faith traditions as simply either kind of a quasi club or and this is across the spectrum, right. This isn't just LDS, this just isn't fundamentalist. This isn't any other rest, just rest duration movement. We all do this right? We all get kind of complacent and then it gets turned into a club or a social activity, right? And we? Include some people and we exclude others from our from the social club, yes. Right. And, and the message here that I see in Enoch, as well as the, the message of the Restoration as taught by Joseph and those early Mormon leaders are ones in which it's like, no, we're going to leave the world behind and we're going to set up something different. And it's going to be a holier existence, so to speak. What what are some of the challenges that that the common reader will encounter and, and let's get specific, the common Mormon reader will encounter when they start diving into the Book of Enoch?

55:05 Yeah, one of the things I think most notably is that it's not officially a part of our scriptures. And I think that this would, this would be the same problem with, you know, with process or Catholic Christianity. So it's, it's kind of a, it's kind of an outlier text that people don't really know much about South Mormons know what we, I mean, of course we all know about the Pearl, the great prize, you know, about the Joseph Smith translation. But the book of Enoch we're less familiar with just because in the West, the book of Enoch wasn't popular until, you know, really this this past the 19th and 20th century. So I think that that might, that might be a challenge and I think that, you know, certain going to certain texts like Joseph Smith's revelation on the Apocrypha and the Doctrine Covenants might be helpful. There's a wonderful, I am a member of Deseret Books, so I get, I get their publications all the time. And there's a wonderful audio book called, I think the Apocrypha for Mormons or for Latter Day Saints, Understanding the Apocrypha for Latter Day Saints. And I think that one of the books that's mentioned there is the Book of Enoch, and the person gives a great introduction to the Book of Enoch for Mormons. I think another thing that might hold up some people is that, like I said, the Book of Enoch, first Enoch is a really kind of choppy text.

56:32 It has some poetry, it has some prose. It's kind of all over the place and you have to be patient with it because it could be kind of frustrating in that regard. We're used to either, you know, things being straightforward. So either the Book of Mormon, which for the most part is is prose. There is some poetry when Nephi, when Nephi, you know, praises God and stuff like that. But for the most part it's a narrative. Or we know we have the Psalms, which is just poetry. The Book of Enoch is kind of a hodgepodge of all these different genres. So that might be something that's kind of a challenge. So I would say for, for Mormons encountering it, to be patient with it. And there's a lot of kind of Angel angelology, if I can use that term, descriptions of the different types of angels in the heavenly realms and stuff. And you know, from, for me, I, I really like that stuff. I think that stuff is really cool, but it could be, it could be kind of tedious for, you know, your reader who hasn't been exposed to this stuff before. So maybe reading a book on kind of apocalyptic scripture, apocalyptic literature would be helpful as well. I'll put you in touch with a guy because because you're into the Apocrypha.

57:41 It's a guy I've had on the podcast several, several times. His name's Ken Peterson, so shout out to Ken. He wrote a book called Mormonism in the Apocrypha where he goes. It's an exhaustive work. I mean, he really went for it. And he just lists all the teachings in the Apocrypha that are kind of bull's eyes with Mormonism, and it's just astounding. I'll I'll hook you up with him. Yeah, yeah, I'd love to read that. He's a great guy. I think you'd really, I think you'd, you'd really resonate with him. Super smart, intelligent. Yeah. What about certain teachings within the Book of Enoch that might challenge Mormons? Right. Because because I, I want to say this, you're, you're not going to read the Book of Enoch and be like, oh, this totally sounds like Joseph Smith. Because that's not it right Now you can look at Moses 6-7 and eight and see some very good similarities there, some very good bull's eyes, right?

58:35 But this is not a restoration list text. Let's put it like that. So with within the text of Enoch itself, are there going to be any teachings that might throw Mormons for a loop? I think the most shocking thing would be will be Noah being half half human, half Benet Elohim or son of God or watchers, however you want to categorize these beings. That's that was that was always very shocking for me when I read when I read it. So and I know that you know, Noah, I mean he's held in greatest team. He's in Moses, chapter 8 in the Pearl of Great Price. He's considered the Angel Gabriel. So he's held in very.

59:19 So Noah is held in very high esteem. Did I say Moses or Noah? I said Noah, right? You said Noah. Yep. I said Noah, OK, so Noah is held in very high esteem. So that he is a descendant of the Binet Elohim of the sons of God might be kind of might be kind of shocking. I honestly think, Dave, I think there's a lot that's going to resonate with, with Mormon readers, especially with kind of the understanding of angels and exalted, the exalted righteous. I think that that, you know, that ties in very well with the with the, with the kind of the Mormon concepts of, of exaltation. So I think that at the end of the day, if you excuse me, if you weigh the Book of Enoch in the balance, there's going to be more stuff.

1:00:03 I think it's going to resonate with Mormons then that they will find offensive. But you're absolutely right. This is not a restorationist text. This is not a restorationist text and all, but I do think that there are parallels that Mormons will appreciate. Perfect. And then do we have any ideas at all? Because I'm a, I'm a guy who believes context matters a lot, right? We can see the certain times even in the savior's teachings, like the one, the one that always got me, that it, it took me years to wrap my head around and I didn't get my head fully wrapped around it until I, I began to understand the, the, the kind of socio political climate in which the savior is preaching. The, the one where he says, if someone asks you to carry his, his pack, carry it for him.

1:00:55 Not just one mile, but two, right. That's actually really fascinating when you get to know the, the political climate 'cause that has to do with Roman soldiers. So Rome had a law that said basically they could demand any citizen carry their pack for up to a mile. Now here's the interesting part. If it was more than a mile, the Roman soldier would get in trouble and so would his commanding officer because they, they, they didn't want, Rome itself, didn't want rebellion, right? And so they, they tried to be like, OK, you can oppress them a little bit, but you can't oppress them too much, right? And so it becomes very interesting when you see maybe what the savior is saying.

1:01:39 They're like, yeah, if they tell you carry that thing, carry it 2 miles, yeah, you know, and that sort. Of thing push back. It's more a push back than. Exactly right. And and it puts, it puts the scripture into a, into a different light. So now with that, do we have any sort of historical context, you know, really archaeologically Speaking, of Enoch's time period? Yeah, not of Enoch per Southeast. I can say more about the communities for which the Book of Enoch was popular. I think that the reason that you have the Book of Enoch at with the Dead Sea or Quran community is that they see themselves as the children of light versus the wicked children of darkness.

1:02:26 So I think that they equate the children of darkness with the Roman Empire, with the oppression that they're feeling, that they're feeling from Rome. OK, so I think that that's why it's popular saying with kind of how why it's popular for Christians. So this they they see themselves as kind of the righteous and their enemies, the Roman Empire, the Jewish authorities, those are those are they are those are their their enemies. So I think that they're seeing their own situation and their struggle within kind of the, the what's the word? I'm looking for the context of Enoch's struggles as described in the Book of Enoch.

1:03:07 But the community of Enoch, you know, I don't think we, we can know too much about them outside of, you know, the primeval history itself. And you know what was going on with the sons of God, the doors of men, and just the corruption that was going on in the world at that time. OK, all right. No, that answers. It is fascinating, though, that even even the writers in the New Testament are finding that they can identify with this book. Right. Yes. And and that to me is also fascinating, right? I'm not a guy who believes that. Certainly we change and we make advancements in society, but really we we struggle against the same things, right? Nothing really changes here.

1:03:59 And it is fascinating to see that that some of the same things we struggle with were some of the same things that that early New Testament writers were. Struggling with yes. Let me ask you this question. Do we know why the Book of Enoch falls out of favor? Right, Because as we just said, this is a book that is obviously popular during, during, you know, the, the Old Testament period. It's obviously popular in the New Testament period. We have, like you were saying, mentions of it in the in the New Testament. What happens? Why does it fall out of favor? I would say the culprit, Dave is really the Council of Nicaea. So when it makes that decision to make an official Canon, especially of the New Testament works, yeah, I think it's making a deliberate decision to push the Book of Enoch aside.

1:04:49 And I think one of the reasons for that, going back to this question of historical context that you raised, is that, you know, by the time of the Council of Nicaea, and I'll, I'm just biased here. I hate the Council of Nicaea. So I think by the time of the Council of Nicaea, you know, Rome is completely merged with Christianity. So you don't want anything, any text that is going to possibly suggest that Rome is acquainted with the Children of Darkness. So I think that there's a deliberate effort to push the Book of Enoch out of the Canon and in and one of the evidences I would say for that is that after this time, after the Council of Nicaea, you don't really get quotations from the Book of Enoch from any of the post Nicene Fathers.

1:05:38 So I think that, you know, they don't. I think this book is in some ways, and I'll use this, I use this word sparingly. I think this book is dangerous for the post Nicene Church because it's so tied to the Roman Empire. Interesting, you know, and again with what I just said nothing being new. I know that one of the big push when when during oh kind of coming out of the Enlightenment, so to speak, or let me phrase that coming about the time we start discovering the new world, that sort of thing. The Geneva Bible isn't really favored by a lot of monarchs of the time because the Geneva Bible is hard on kings, right? I mean, it is not pleasant to kings and so it. I love the Geneva Bible.

1:06:32 I actually have a copy of it downstairs in my basement. Dude, that Bible is, I don't know if this is a good way to describe it, but there's times I've read the Geneva Bible and that thing's straight metal. I mean, that thing is, is, is rock and hard and, and it it takes to task kings and tyrants pretty hard. So obviously if you're a a monarch of any kind who believes in the divine right of kings, that sort of thing, the last thing you want is a Bible floating out there that's going to challenge your authority. So it's not out of the realm of of reason of being reasonable that that if you're Rome, you certainly don't want a book that that has dispersion on on yourself.

1:07:17 With that said, why does it keep keep in favor with like the Ethiopian church? Is it just that that they're kind of isolated? In that case, it's geography. I think that they're because they're isolated, they don't have any connection to the Western church, whether Latin or Greek speaking Western or the Greek speaking church. So they're just kind of doing their own thing. And their Canon is not just with, I mean, they have a bunch of books that, you know, we don't even have in our Canon, 1st and 2nd Ezra's for example, and then some like books that are solely within the Ethiopian Bible. So they're, they're just doing their own thing. But because they're so isolated, that allows the Book of Enoch to to persist and endure in that tradition.

1:08:02 What about the Greek text? I mean, somebody translated that thing into Greek, right? Yeah, yeah. And I mean it does. I mean, scribes and I, it does get, it does get preserved, but nobody's really doing anything with it. I mean, they're not even writing commentaries on this thing into, you know, the Middle Ages and into the Enlightenment. Nobody is really talking about this book. And so it, it doesn't become popular again until close to our into the modern era. OK. Now, for someone who wants to pick up a copy of the Book of Enoch, right, they listen to this podcast and they're like, oh, I got to scope this out. I would imagine that there's different versions of that thing floating out there now, right? Yes, yes.

1:08:46 So there's a couple of versions. There's a book called The Lost Books of Adam and Eve, and that has a copy that has a translation of the Slavonic Book of Enoch. That was the very first version of the Book of Enoch that I read. There's also the Hermeneia translation of the Book of Enoch done I believe by John Collins. It's called First Enoch. That is a modern translation that was done in the past, like 15 years or so, which is modern for biblical studies. Highly recommended. Beautiful English translation. Really, really easy to read. And then there is another edition by Joseph Lumpkin, the Book of Enoch that you can get on Amazon. It's probably the most popular version of the Book of of Enoch.

1:09:29 It's just you just type in the Book of Enoch by Lumpkin and that is the addition. A lot of people have that, including myself. OK. And and so you'd recommend those ones more than than any? Other. Yeah, especially the Hermeneo 1. There's also, there is a book, the Ethiopian Apocrypha, and that also contains the Ethiopian translation of the Book of Enoch, but very, very choppy and very, very, yeah, yeah. I don't. And I've talked to other people about this fact. There's a guy I talked to every couple of weeks. We don't really like the the Ethiopian Apocrypha book, the English, the English translation because it's just it's very choppy.

1:10:13 So with with the one that you really recommend, do you recommend it just for the ease of reading or is there other stuff in there that maybe isn't in the? Excellent question. Excellent question. So the ease of reading and also it tries to combine the different manuscripts. So it doesn't just give you the Greek, but it'll also give you the variance in Hebrew, Aramaic and Ethiopic. OK. All right. Would there be like accounts that are in one that's not in the other that you find that are helpful? The the Lumpkin book of Enoch is very helpful because it will give places in where it's where it appears to quote the New Testament. I mean, excuse me, where the New Testament seems to have parallels with it. So if there is a verse in the book of Enoch, the Lumpkin version will have like a example of quotation from the book of Jude that's similar to it, a quotation from the book of Matthew that's similar to it.

1:11:08 So for Christian readers, I think that's a really kind of good. That edition is a good segue for getting him into the Book of Enoch and making it feel less hard. Perfect, perfect. And then finally, as, as we come to the to, to this point here, is there anything that you would caution people about when they go to read the Book of Enoch, right? Like, is there anything there that's going to take them down a weird rabbit hole or anything like that that they need to be concerned about? That, that's a great question, Dave. I've known so many people who get caught up in kind of the star mysticism and the Angel, you know, the Merkava, the throne mysticism and stuff.

1:11:48 I would say, you know, what's the word I'm looking for, be thrifty, OK, with that type of stuff. Don't, don't go down the rabbit hole in it. Just appreciate it for what it is. It's a mystical vision. Don't try to use it to, you know, have your own mystical vision of the divine throne. Just, you know, appreciate it for what it is because a lot of people really, really get into that stuff. Gotcha. Gotcha, dude. Good, Good stuff. I appreciate it. This is great. I love, I love talking about this stuff. I do.

1:12:28 Me too. I could do it all day long. Is there anything that you want to throw in there that we didn't cover? I'm trying to think there's I would, I would say that, you know, if you, if you like the book of Enoch, please read the rest of the Apocrypha, especially second Ezra's, the Testament of the Patriarchs, stuff like that, because they're very similar to Enoch. And I think that, you know, looking at the relation between Enoch and the Restoration scriptures, the Mormon scriptures, you'll see a lot of parallels which I think will will serve to strengthen your faith, especially if you're from Latter Day St. tradition. Sorry, I keep coming up with questions here as I'm sitting here thinking and and listening.

1:13:12 Do we find any reference of a savior kind of figure within the Book of Enoch? Yes, absolutely. So you have the Son of Man who is seems to be so this isn't what Ezekiel talks about when he says Son of man. That's clearly, that's clear. Your reference to himself as a human being. This son of man seems to be more in line with what Jesus talks about the Son of man, this apocalyptic divine figure that Jesus even appears to identify himself as. So yes, you have the Son of Man who's this kind of messianic figure who intercedes for the righteous who are being persecuted by the wicked, and a very, very important figure in the Book of Enoch. OK, all right, good. All right.

1:13:54 And where can they find those, those versions that you were talking about, those those versions of of the Book of Enoch? So type in. If you go on Amazon, type in First Enoch Hermenea HERMENIA, type that in that should pop up, type in Book of Enoch Lumpkin that that additional pop up, and then type in the Ethiopian Apocrypha. And I think they're Kindle and paperback versions for both of those. Perfect. And if anyone wants to find your work, where do they find it? Yes, so I have an Instagram page, Adam the Giant Guy 2019. I post about all of my articles and books there. I also have an Amazon author page. If you just type in Adam Stokes it should pop up. Perfect.

1:14:43 Well dude, this was good stuff. I appreciate it. Yes, yes, I, like I said, I, I, I, I love talking about this stuff. I, I, I love, I love the Apocrypha. I love my, my can of scripture. I have an official can of scripture, which of course is the Bible, Book of Mormon, and the word of the Lord. But my unofficial can of scripture is is much much bigger. That's awesome. That's awesome. Well dude, let's do this again. I would love to do this. Yes, yes. All right, good deal. I'm hang out for a few minutes. Everyone else will see you next time you're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.