June 8, 2024

Episode #134: Joseph W. Musser W/ Cristina Rosetti, PhD

Episode #134: Joseph W. Musser W/ Cristina Rosetti, PhD
Episode #134: Joseph W. Musser W/ Cristina Rosetti, PhD
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #134: Joseph W. Musser W/ Cristina Rosetti, PhD

Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.

Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products

https://www.amazon.com/Joseph-White-Musser-Fundamentalist-Introductions/dp/0252087755/ref=sr_1_1?crid=353SRZYAXAWAZ&dib=eyJ2IjoiMSJ9.qbgNPMbtYa-qWerWf9SvsNFTXafH8eU0s4NrIirnTviH7Tc0CkTEl6vPZR6_hApqNoG2jSM9g7Qgm-qTFqWlvYIyDBmuJxlCWGyR9SdehF-73oWplzt15wvfS1nuB65G.kvDLBzRLnWXhyFhmQbCAKgCSS0taOiQ_8cJeDxcK43Y&dib_tag=se&keywords=cristina+rosetti&qid=1717197405&s=books&sprefix=cristina+rosetti%2Cstripbooks%2C109&sr=1-1

https://restorationtorahconference.org

About a year ago I released two episodes on Joseph Musser with Michael Ness. Recently Cristina Rosetti released her highly anticipated new book about Joseph Musser. Now if you know anything about Cristina you are well aware of her scholarship and how she has approaches the study of Mormon Fundamentalism. She has always done a very good job of portraying us fairly. Well today she joins me again on the podcast as we talk about her new book which covers Musser’s ministry, his personal life, his relationships with the Woolley’s, John Y Barlow, and even end up touching on the organization the new with Rulon Allred. From time to time in our conversation you will get to peek inside to the man he really was and just how much he both loved and sacrificed for the original teachings of the Restored Gospel. After listening to this conversation and reading the book I think you will find that your admiration and appreciation for Musser will only deepen.

--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support

0:06 About a year ago, I released two episodes on Joseph W Muster with Michael Ness. Recently, Christina Rossetti released her highly anticipated new book about Joseph Muster. Now, if you know anything at all about Christina, you're well aware of her scholarship and how she approaches the study of Mormon fundamentalism. She's always done a very good job of portraying us fairly well. Today she joins me again on the podcast as we talk about her new book which covers Muster's ministry, his personal life, his relationships with the Woollies, John Y Barlow, and even end up touching on the organization of the new council with Ruin Allred. From time to time in our conversation, you will get a peek inside to the man he really was and just how much he both loved and sacrificed for the original teachings of the restored gospel.

0:49 After listening to this conversation and reading the book, I think you'll find that your admiration and appreciation for Muster will only deepen. And that's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast. So a few weeks back, I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running. Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page or click the link in this episode show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups, and water bottles all with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU, but you should definitely go check that out. Now, this is just the beginning.

1:40 In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast. So head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade Supply button or click the link in this episode's show notes and get yours today. The you're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.

2:33 Christina, how's it going? Hi good. How are? You good. Thanks for coming back on of. Course. You've been busy. That book took a while to get through peer review, didn't it? It did. When, When you and I first did our episode two years ago, that was like on the way, right? And I thought it was like right around the corner and it's my fault because I don't understand peer review and all the all these other things. So I was like, I kept waiting. I kept waiting, I kept waiting. And then I saw it got released. So congratulations. I mean, you and I both. We're waiting.

3:13 Yeah. Peer review. I mean, it's here. There it is. There it is. There it is. Little Cutie Yeah, it peer review was a journey, which I can definitely get into. But I mean, the long, the bulk of it, one of my reviewers was great. So it's 22 reviewers reviewed it. It's blind, so I don't know who they are. They don't. I mean, everyone knew that I was writing this book at that point. Who else was writing a book on Joseph Musser? So two people reviewed it. One of them loved it. One of them was like this is great, 2nd reviewer comes in hot and is like she's a bad writer.

3:56 I mean, but not just that. The title was not this. Initially. This book was supposed to be called Joseph White Musser, a Mormon prophet. Now can you guess how that went over? I'm only going to guess where this woman went to church. Well, the, I think the Revere was a guy, I don't know, but I was told that I needed to change the name. It was a long review that centered on the name and it said prophet is only reserved for the president of the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints and it's inappropriate and no one would call him a prophet. And I was like, well, that's not true. People definitely do call him a prophet. Anyway, I had to change the title. I ended up getting around today.

4:47 I dedicated it to all the Mormons who call him a prophet. So I did. I did kind of weasel that in. But it did finally get through peer review, which I didn't have to change much. I did have to change. I did have to cave and change the title. Yeah, it's done and it's out, and I'm really grateful. I mean, people have read it. I mean, I wrote it mostly for the community, mostly for fundamentalists who let me in their homes and like, let me hang out and like be nosy about their lives because really, what was I for the last 10 years other than just like a really nosy person? And so I'm really, I mean, I wrote it for them.

5:30 And so I'm really grateful that so many fundamentalists have bought it and have read it and showed up to the book launch at Benchmark Books. And so, but it's done. It's out in the world. Joseph Messer in order to do this, Brian Buchanan and I at Benchmark Books, we spent years retranscribing all of his Diaries and every single letter between him and John my Barlow, every single letter between him and Heber J Grant, all the letters between him and J Golden Kimball. And so we do have a contract that Signature Books is publishing all of his Diaries. They're annotated, they're beautiful, an annotated set of a full set of multi volume Diaries and letters from Musser, which is great because they are in the LDS Church archive.

6:18 They are restricted. You can't like go see the originals. So we transcribed everything. They will be coming out. It is called St. 'cause he was his name when he was, when his baby blessing happened, his dad blessed him with the name St. And so it's called St. the Life and Correspondence of Joseph White Musser. And so Signature Books is going to be publishing it and it should be out probably next year. Nice, nice. So when, when, when you sit down to to think about OK, I, I want to write a piece on, on Mormon fundamentalism. Why muster? Why not woolly? Why not Barlow? Why muster? Great. Yeah, I mean, great question. So I mean, with Woolly, Woolly never kept a diary.

7:00 So there's that. And I mean, that's an easy answer is Woolly didn't keep a diary. I mean, there's three reasons for Woolly. He didn't keep a diary. Everything Woolly said was written down by Musser with School of the Prophets book remembrances. All of that is in Musser's handwriting, and this is going to be a little bit of a spicy take. Woolly told some stories. Woolly said some things. And. It's very. Hard to know if they're true. And so as much as he is kind of like, you know, he's the originator of the story, of the narrative of fundamentalism, it's hard to keep the story with him.

7:43 And so for all those reasons. We couldn't. It didn't make sense, but also because Muster is the one that wrote it. John Rye Barlow, we don't have his Diaries. We have Zitting's Diaries. But the reality is that when we think of who is the early promulgator of Mormon fundamentalism, I mean, Muster developed pamphlets, Muster wrote Truth magazine. Muster did. I mean, he's what gets it off the he's the visionary for like when I think of a lot of the major doctrines of Mormon fundamentalism, even even something as simple as parsing out how do we theologically make sense of the priesthood and the church being separate things. It was him. It was him who did it. The idea that Joseph Smith is the Holy Ghost, certainly Woolly talked about that. But like Musser talked about that, like we have testimonies of him saying, I testify of this and explaining it and making sense of it and tying it together. And I mean his pamphlets circulated in Sunday school meetings.

8:41 I mean, he was the visionary for Short Creek when he wrote The Economic Order of Heaven. I mean, he he was the pen on the paper that made the movement something coherent and compelling and cool for people. And, and so when I first saw all the pamphlets that he wrote, I was like, this is the guy, Like this is the story that needs to be read. I I've often said this in some ways, maybe in all ways, he's the granddaddy of us all as far as fundamentalism goes, right? Whether? Not me. Right, right now, so much you right. I'm Yeah, yeah, but but you can't talk about Mormon fundamentalism. Like, OK, stupid football analogy. I once heard someone say how you tell if someone should be in the Hall of Fame is you can't tell the story of the NFL without that person, right?

9:37 And I don't you can't tell the story of fundamentalism without talking about a Musser. And it goes even deeper than that because whether whether it's down in Short Creek and subsequently all the break offs that happened there, whether it's up north with the new council that's set up with Allred, his fingerprints are all over it. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah. And I mean, even figure, like, figure out a tradition of the doctrine without tying one of his pamphlets to it or one of his ideas or one of his sermons to it. I mean, he was a force to be reckoned with. He was charismatic. He was dapper.

10:17 I mean, when he's in the pictures of him in prison, like he looks like someone that you'd you'll sign up to go with him. Like he was a guy that was interesting. He was cool. Now, he wasn't boots on the ground in the way Barlow was, and he certainly wasn't kind. I mean, Leroy Johnson was compelling in that he was a farmer. He was a rancher and he was down there and he was with the people. Who's a man of the people. And so he was Mustard was different that he wasn't like that, but he looked like the guy that knew what he was talking about because he did. Yeah, he had a great mustache too.

10:57 I'm envious those that younger picture and. I'm sad this one doesn't have it, but he. Did have a killer stash. I I gotta give it to him. He he, he rocked that thing, especially if. He lived. He lived the thing like he did the thing like he did the thing. He lived the principal. It was hard on him. It wasn't easy. His wives weren't into it. My one of my favorite lines ever was Mary C Hill, one of his wives, his second wife, when he leave, when she leaves him, he writes in his diary and this is about the movement. He was like, she finds my work obnoxious and I was like. And I was like, well, my friend, I don't know. If that's fair.

11:46 But I mean, he struggled with it and he lived a life that like he, it wasn't easy for him and he was willing to do it anyway. And that in itself is something to it's an auditory thing. Yeah, You know, the the other thing that that I do like about Musser, and it's a reason I feel like we can tie authority back, priesthood authority back to Musser real easily is he doesn't get his authority from from Woolley. It it comes directly from the LDS Church, right. I mean. And I, I mean Lindsay Hanson Park and I will disagree on this, but I mean, he's the only one in the Woolley Council with a second anointing.

12:34 He's a he's AI mean. Find the other guy, John my Barlow's excommunicated very early. Woolly my Woolly probably said he did. I don't know. I don't know. That was a mean slight on Woolly. But Muster gets his second anointing early. He's 27 years old when he gets his second anointing with Rose in the Logan Temple with under George Joseph F Smith. Like, he's young and I mean, in his diary he just writes temple blessings, but he he's really young. We know that. I mean, there's, I think he does pass on the second anointing. I know that that's another kind of big question mark in fundamental history.

13:19 I think he does simply because of one vague reference to Lucy, one of his wives performing ordinances. What's Lucy doing? What's Lucy doing? Kind of a dead giveaway. And so I think that, you know, for that reason, he's of course significant because he's the only one that I think the only one that has received the highest blessings of the LDS church, the highest authority in the LDS church. And the reality, and I talk about in the book that the reality is that the 2nd anointing is a problem for the leadership of the LDS Church. And it's why we do have the numbers that second anointings have a sharp decline at Heber J Grant.

14:06 Because it is a problem for the institution that how do you get rid of a man that you tell can never be gotten rid of. Right, right. And, and for like the two people who listen who aren't Mormon ever on this podcast, those second anointings are huge because basically what it is, while you may never get the call as president of the church, you hold every key in office that the church has to offer. And so you are essentially under under no man when it comes to this. You can do anything you need to as far as Mormonism goes. If you have that ordinance. And it it's an interesting, he comes, he comes into his own in a very interesting time in Mormon history, period, right.

14:56 In some ways, Musser bridges the gap between pioneer Mormonism and then what we what we ultimately end up with with Heber Jay Grant, he bridges that gap and it and it's fascinating to. Watch. And, and he knew that. I mean, there's kind of two moments that I think are really indicative of his life. I mean, when I look at his life, these are the two moments that I'm like, oh, this was a guy that knew what he was about. It was his 1909 disciplinary hearing where he walks into the room and he specifically names and it was in the Salt Lake Temple, which I realized for a lot of Mormon people that seemed strange to do your disciplinary hearing in the temple. And he notes that everyone was late to calling him into the hearing. He just has a lot of like pointed commentary about the leadership, but he's called into the to the temple and he notes certain men that were in the room. And he notes those men because those are the men that had either married polygamously after the manifesto or solemnized plural marriages.

15:59 Like he knew that if you're going to come at me for this, I'm going to note that you were one of these men. Like you are me. We're the same person. And he's like Hebridge J Grant, polygamist, Ruger Clawson, polygamist, Anthony Evans, polygamist. And so he he notes this and they start going after him for being out of harmony. That's the language they used. And in the most kind of passive aggressive way, he's like, you're not my stake president. Who are you to try to discipline me? This is out of order. You can't do this. And they were like, and they have to concede because it's true. Like they're not his stake president. And that is how discipline works in the LDS church.

16:41 And of course, the bummer for them is his stake president is also a polygamist and he and his take president are secretly plotting to like live United Order together. And so he's not going to get disciplined in 1909. And he leaves that meeting. Nothing happens, which is very interesting. 1909, no discipline happens. And he leaves the meeting in the last line in his diary after that meeting is I'm prepared to lay down my life for this. And that's bold move. But the other interesting thing in his life, I think, is in 1921, he has excommunicated finally. That's very late. It is late. Very late.

17:21 And I've talked about this quite a bit that I was so interested in. What is the diary entry gonna say? Like the day that it's over, the day your life changes, the day that you're cut off from the church, the day you're cut off from everything, from your family, from everything you've ever known. What's he gonna do? And he taped in the Deseret News clip because of course, it was published in the news. That he had been. Excommunicated and he just writes very busy day at the office because he didn't because it didn't matter. But it didn't matter. I mean, and I'm sure it did in that like his children suffered, he lost his job. Like, you know, being an excommunicated Mormon in that time, you're going to lose your job. It's going to be hard on your kids. It's going to be hard on your family. But when it came to what he believed about his spiritual life and about his eternity, that didn't change with his excommunication, right?

18:20 Wow. The the. And. That's the thing I think doesn't come through a lot, right? Certainly as fundamentalist, we look at at Musser with, with adoration, with, you know, thankfulness that he kept all this alive, right? And and it's just not plural marriage either, right? No, he. He. Is now beginning to see in this time that a lot of the teachings that he had been brought up with, they're, they're being shoved to the back now. And Oh yeah. And. Does he ever make any mention of that in his Diaries about anything other than plural marriage? About trying to preserve.

19:02 Plural marriage is the big one, certainly, and I think a lot of that is because he was a believer in the vision of 1886 that he was tasked with keeping polygamy alive. He was tasked with like this was the goal, right is keep the principal alive. And so he did believe that that was the crux of the matter because the vision of the early and I you know, what is a fundamental depends on the group now, but early on, like the reality is the fundamental was the principle of plural marriage. Like that was the thing. And so for him that really everything right like wrote on that. But you know, how do you the secondary thing as soon as you figure out that plural marriage has to keep going.

19:46 Next question is how and so then you have to figure out what is the priesthood? And once you deal with what is the priesthood, then you and if you say it's the power of God, great, but who is that? And so then you got this big question of who is that? Like who is God? And so he was interesting in that of course, he believed that Adam was God. He really expanded how that worked. He really expanded how Joseph Smith fit into that as the third member of the Godhead, which he had ardent. Resolve in, I think that's actually one more interesting things that he really promoted is at the end of his life especially, he had an ardent resolve that Joseph Smith was the Holy Ghost.

20:29 The Holy Ghost has a body in this dispensation. We know who it is, it is Joseph Smith. And so that I thought was really interesting and kind of explaining how the cosmology works, how the office, the idea of God's having offices. He did a lot of work with that, which is very interesting. He outlined then, so now that you know who God is, now you have to figure out how to live like him. And So what does it mean to like live communitarianism? What is it? And so he argued that you cannot, you fundamentally cannot live the order of Abraham without living the order of Enoch. And so he really had to set out this vision for living communitarianly what he called the economic order of heaven and so and the Kingdom of God.

21:12 And so he had this very kind of holistic vision of what the fundamentalist movement was supposed to be in a way that I don't think a lot of other people had really grappled with the fact that, all right, once we're living polygamy, what else does that mean? Right, right. Is there a moment that you can tell that he. He all of a sudden. Do you feel like that that with with Joseph Smith being being the Holy Ghost in in in his eye, in his mind? It certainly didn't originate with Musser, right? This was on the lips of pioneer era Mormonism. But is there a moment that you think you can point to in which he he's like, Oh no, this is definitely true? Or do you think this is something he builds up to? I think it's, I think he believed it very early. I mean, Woolley certainly taught it. And so in the Book of Remembrances, Woolley's talking about it.

22:06 And so I think that had to be the thing. But 1937 he wrote a full issue of Truth magazine kind of commemorating Joseph Smith and he titles it The Witness Infestator. And I mean, that's thirty 1937 is very late, but that that was a bold move to write a full thing of Truth magazine on this is where we stand on this issue. This is the doctrine of the Church, but this is this is what it's supposed to be. And so I think he definitely believed it earlier, wrote about it earlier. But I would say in 1937, he's like, this is the teaching of the church, and on it we're gonna stand as a people.

22:48 Wow. And you know, back to to him losing his job and everything. I think it's so hard for us today because. In some ways. Those who have been raised fundamentalist, they've just grew up kind of in that right where where you're kind of on the outside a little bit. And then by and. Large most LDS people look at fundamentalists as as maybe their crazy cousin, if not downright, you know, evil apostates. But. In those days, I mean, it's not like Utah is what it is now, right? There's, there's no diversity of thought that you know, there, there's, you know, there are other churches, but they're few and far between like they are now, but even more pronounced. So he's putting it all on the line, his livelihood, all of it. At what point do you think that that he realizes he's gonna have?

23:48 Well, let me. Rephrase it this way. You talk. About him? Now reaching. A point where he, it's more than plural marriage, right? Talking about United Order, those sorts of things. Does anybody else catch that vision or is it just him? The whole council, certain. I mean, the whole council absolutely does. In 1931, Huber J Grant takes to the podium and he's like, look, we're not polygamous anymore. And I mean 1933 then a lot of people call it the third manifesto where Huber J Grant is like, listen, we're done and we're done in that you have to sign a loyalty oath or you're out and we're sending the cops after you. And that's a, that's a game changing moment. And that's, I mean, that's the birth of Short Creek is that the council sends men down to kind of look out the land to check out the Arizona strip.

24:41 Land is purchased, land is handed over and Short Creek is born. It's, I mean, Joseph Messer watches the LDS Church very closely, which let's be real, a lot of fundamentalists watch the LDS Church very closely. But of course they do like, of course they do. It's the mother church for, I mean, in this generation it was still referred to as the mother church. And so he he would write very rigorous notes about General Conference and what they're up to with a lot of disdain for Huber J Grant especially. And so in 1933 when he sees Huber J Grant do this and he talks a lot about like when Huber J Grant does this in 1933, he writes, he's like, you're a polygamist. Like, say it, say what you are.

25:28 And he like, I think that's all that. I think that's actually why Heber J Grant received so much ire from the fundamentalists is because Heber J Grant was a polygamist. Heber J Grant is going to die assumably, and be united with all his wives and attain some degree of glory. But he's causing a lot of men to lose out on that suddenly. And so Heber J Grant got his in their mind, like, what are you doing? And so that's, that's almost, that's worse than having never been one. And so in 1933, when Huber J Grant starts to kind of buckle down, and then, of course, in 1935, police start rounding up people. Charles Zitting goes to prison. Charles Zitting's wife is excommunicated. Price Johnson goes to prison.

26:15 We start to see Musser's friends get disciplined. Ultimately, of course, Musser goes to prison, too. In 1944, he actually serves the same sentence for the same crime that his dad did in the territorial state prison because but his dad, of course, was a polygamist like when you were allowed to be. So it's a little different. And, and I mean, that's also kind of a badge of honor for him that he did what his dad did. And so I think that I think that I think 1933 is his turning point moment where he's like, I'm these aren't my people anymore. Like my people are the Mormons that are willing to like die for something and see. This is This is where Musser.

26:58 I think. I think. Anyone who's come out of the LDS Church and became a fundamentalist and, and certainly as, as I thought about This is why I can resonate so well, I think with Musser more than any of the other council, because in some ways he had to do the same things I did, right? I had less to lose, I will say that, right? I didn't have to worry necessarily about my job. I didn't have to worry about, you know, going to prison, those sorts of things. But some of that angst is the same, right? Guys you used to hang with that you thought were kind of like your ride and die homies all of a sudden aren't, right?

27:38 And you start finding out real fast who, who's, who's interested as you as a person and who is just there because you hung out in the same Pew or whatever. And, and I think in that way muster, muster can anyone who's come out of the LDS church, or for that matter, if you've left any church within Mormonism, right, fundamentalist or whatever. Muster's your guy, right? You can, you can, you can identify with him better than than perhaps any of the other council because he's gonna go through the same things you're gonna go through. Yeah. And I, I think, I think people are also, people are very quick to, you know, whenever I've talked to people who follow the Barlow line, people are very quick to point out that Mustard caved and signed the loyalty oath in prison in 1844. And therefore his priesthood is whatever and he's a Woodruff for another time or whatever look.

28:35 I got something. To say to all those people, what would you have done? You have 7 something wives and you have how many kids? And you're the sole provider and you're sitting in a prison cell. Of course you're going to sign a document with your fingers crossed behind your back. Of course you are of. Course you are. Like, of course you are. I mean, and he's signed obviously with no intent of ever living it because he kept getting married and he kept telling other people to get married. Like we know that he did it just to appease the like we know that he was doing it just to get out of prison. But it is interesting that I do hear a lot of people point to that as a that Muster also conceded, like Woodruff. No, he didn't.

29:17 He he needed to get out of prison. No. And he? Needed. To reminds. Me, one day I'm gonna write a book called The Five Stages of Becoming, the Fundamentalism of Becoming a Fundamentalist. And one of those is you're gonna have a deep, white hot, seething hate for wood Wilford Woodruff. And then you're going to get to a point to where you're like, oh, I see what he did there, 'cause even Woodruff, I mean, let's face it. The the. When, when they signed the manifesto, they had no, no intentions of stopping plural marriage. You know, I mean it was, I mean the only. The only reason I have a hard time with Woodruff is 'cause you're coming right on the back of John Taylor, right? Yeah, well, that's true.

29:57 I mean, right. Like. If, if it had been like Lorenzo Snow, it'd be a little different. But like right on the back of John Taylor, you're gonna cave. I don't. Know man, like I don't know I'm. I'm with you. I mean, look, there's no, there's no doubt both John Taylor and his son John W, they were straight up gangster in Mormon terms, right? They are not, they are not caving. They are. They are in it to win it and and like and. Matthias Cowley, like he, I mean he did Muster's plural, one of Muster's plural ceilings, at least one, we think his third was under his authority that Judson Tulman did it under the authority of Matthias Cowley. It's a.

30:41 Weird document. I don't know. That's the only document's a little weird. But yeah, I mean, there were people certainly willing to. I mean, that's why it's such a weird time. But also, like, Hugh B Brown's dad is out there, like giving patriarchal blessings to all of the councilman's wives and his daughter is marrying rural. And Jeff's like, what's going on? Like, what is this period? Well. Yeah. And and. That. That's what. Makes this time even more fascinating 'cause it's got a little cloak and dagger involved too, right? You don't know who's on your side, but you know you got boys up there somewhere, right? And, and they'll come out of the woodwork for you at certain times. But it's not a church that's united during during this time whatsoever.

31:22 It's no. It's Muster says that. Muster says that after his 1909 councils, you know, he says I'm willing to die for this. Also, the council is not united like he's and I think that is kind of one of his early cracks in his shelf, to use a Mormon metaphor for this, is that that is a hard realization to realize that the 12 apostles don't agree on something that is like that is as significant as the mechanism of your exaltation, right? Like. The marriage system of the gods. They disagree on the marriage system of the gods. Yeah. Yeah, it's. Like. I I gotta? Ask this question cause too often I feel like.

32:06 With. With people that we we admire in history. It's one of my big pet peeves with George Washington. I love Washington. I I could read books on Washington all day long. But we've. Turned him into a marble statue, right? We don't see any of his humanity come through. And that concerns me somewhat with some of our early fundamentalist leaders, right. Let's not turn the men into marble statues. These were guys who had passions who were embroiled in some serious stuff. Is is there. And and that's why I'm gonna ask this next question. Is there ever a point in in your research where where you can see first maybe a down day, so to speak, when when everything looks just absolutely like it's going to come undone for Musser?

32:59 Every time one of his wives left him. Really. I mean this is a. Man who like the reality right is his wives left him, his first wife left his second wife left his third wife like not great, not great and and they not like Rose never had her ceiling cancelled. She never cancelled her ceiling when Mary left that. I mean, that would have been weird. You couldn't cancel that 'cause that was done like Rogue by Matthias Cowley. So I don't, I don't even know what the mechanism for cancelling. I mean, that's like, how do you cancel a ceiling that Patriarch Judson Pullman did in your house? Like how do you I?

33:41 Don't know. How you do that? But his wives weren't happy. His wives weren't into it. And. Certainly later ones were, but like Myrtle Anderson was married to him for like just like a couple months and she left. And I think that's something to kind of I think that I mean, I would hope that that would at least give some pause to people of this is someone who ardently espouse before marriage. Why couldn't he do it at least with his early wives now? Certainly, I mean, one of the kind of interesting things for me. I don't know how many wives he had. So that's also an interesting phenomenon is I have no idea how many wives he had. I remember when I I remember when I when Brian Buchanan and I discovered Myrtle Anderson and we were so excited and, you know, we talked to Marianne Watson and Marianne Watson was like, yeah, we know that.

34:35 And I'm like, how many did he have? So I don't know. But I mean, that's also kind of a weird situation. It's like, how many wives does he have? But we do know that the early ones weren't happy. Gotcha. Well. And I think. This goes back to this idea of making marble statues out of men, right, 'cause let's face it, we don't want to see anybody that we Revere get drugged through the mud. I mean, it's just not something we want. But I think. There's value in, in knowing this, right? I, I think, I think it's one of those things that that should give us pause. Those of us who have entered or or will enter, you know, plural marriage, it's not. It's not for the.

35:17 Faint of heart, and I'll be, I'll be honest. I'll, I'll, I'll expose some things here a little bit about myself. I, I, it was, it was over a decade before I ever really thought seriously about it again after the first one went bad, right? I, I, you, this is stuff that, that will break your heart. If, if, if you can't hold it together, so to speak, and everyone's not committed or, or what, whatever. I think everyone could be committed and it's still gonna be hard. But it takes, it takes, it takes a little bit of gumption, but the fact he goes through that.

35:59 Just like. I look at Peter sometimes, and you know what? That that's a flawed guy. Out of all of scripture, I can relate to Peter, right? I'm gonna try my damnedest and I'm gonna fall on my face just as hard. And yet there's still hope. And, and I think that's, that's one of those things that I feel like we do ourselves a disservice by painting men as as infallible, so to speak, as we don't get to see their pain. And and I think that is worthwhile. I mean, we also have to remember that Muster wouldn't have wanted to be viewed that way, right? Muster. Muster was. Deeply. Against the direction, Barlow was going very against it.

36:43 In terms of. In terms of Barlow, I mean the two kind of big when I think of like the early fissures in the movement that eventually led to the split in the 50s that eventually becomes the AUB and the FLDS. The two things Barlow does that really start to raise eyebrows for Musser and for Lewis Kell. I mean for a lot of them. But for certainly for for Musser it is there's a big question of like what does the president of the priesthood do? Does he have control over eternal issues or does he have temporal authority too? And Barlow certainly thought he had a temporal claim. The United border, the United effort plan was Barlow's vision and who should who should be the leader of it? Who should have the claim over it? Charles Zitting and Lewis Kelch, notable notably, didn't sign over their land.

37:37 They didn't they didn't want to be part of it. Lewis Kelch, of course, now father of the independent movement, but Charles Zitting OG Councilman, does not participate in the United ever plan. He he says a big no to being part of this kind of consolidation of power, which eventually will become one man rule. I mean, over time will turn into that. But this consolidation of not only eternal power, but also temporal and the temporal power manifesting itself in united effort plan, but in the terms of the eternal control that Barlow had is Barlow's beginning of placement marriage. That's not Messer's dream. That was a Barlow dream. And we know that from, I mean, Marion Watson.

38:17 I think one of the greatest articles that about the Mormon fundamentals movement is Marion Watson's article on the origin of FLDS placement marriage, tracing it to Barlow, which is very early. And she does this because it's one of Joseph, Lyman, Joseph's daughters. And he goes to Muster and he says, what do I do? Like this is this is wild. And Muster radically disagrees. And so placement marriage becomes Barlow's hold on eternity and the UEP becomes Barlow's hold on temporality. And together that eventually will kind of become, I mean, every time, usually when there's those two things together, it will become one man rule eventually, or at least kind of start to look like that. But Muster was not interested in either of those things at all. Muster didn't think he had the authority to do that. Muster was a member of a council. Now, of course, Muster does end up kind of going rogue and ordaining people outside of outside of the hierarchy and the famous Allred ordination.

39:14 But Muster wouldn't have wanted to be viewed as he didn't want to be. Heber J Grant in southern Utah. Like, he didn't want to be the other Hebrew J Grant. He was something different. He was doing something different. And so I think, you know, I think my criticism of like, keeping your house in order or whatever thing that can sound harsh, but I think muster would have been, would have been like, yeah, like, I'm not. I'm just a guy trying to keep Joseph Smith's vision alive. Interesting. You excuse me, you brought up. The him ordaining men from outside the council, 'cause that's been one of my contentions.

39:59 Is that it? As I've said, and I'm not a trained historian and there's a ton of guys out there who aren't a trained historian who are way better at history than I am. Michael Ness being a shout out to him but. To me. Just on the. Surface it looks like Musser's breaking point is the placement marriage thing and. He he's got some. He's got one spicy quote I can think of where he's very forceful. On. On not doing that, is that kind of what you saw as well? Do you think it's something else or do you think it's a combination of them? I think the, I think, I think the UEP was only because that came first.

40:43 And now what I'm about to say I realize is from Muster's perspective, I realize this is Musterite line biased, but it's also in the diary. So it is what it is. When the UEP started going, you know, loose Kelch isn't signing over anything. Like, of course, loose Kelch isn't. And he, Muster and Kelch go to Barlow to talk about this UEP conundrum of like, what authority are you exercising? Like, does the priesthood have control over the earth? Like what's going on? And he goes to Barlow and he says, do you hold the keys to the priesthood? And Barlow says, no, Wild.

41:31 Now, I've told this story many times, and I most recently told it. I was, I did a tour of Short Creek with a group of people and you know, some former members of the FLDS were there who are. Incredible. In the work they do, I mean, Mayor Danya Jessup and Shirley Draper, just incredible people. And I told the story and they were like, all right, that's that's a may you be propaganda, but it isn't that I mean, and of course, you know, I mean, it is from US perspective. Would Barlow told the story the same? Of course not. But you know I. Mean Barlow does. Concede and he's like, I don't know. I don't know. And I mean. Barlow is. The reality is Barlow is senior in terms of his ordination. But like, is Barlow senior to a guy that got his second anointing at 27?

42:17 I don't know. That's a. Yeah, yeah, that's a good point too. Like what is? Senior What is seniority in the Council? Yes, Barlow was ordained first, technically by woolly, but like, once you're all ordained high priest apostles to the whole world, you're pretty much. I don't know if. Like if you got it done a few years earlier, if it's like that different maybe, but also like you got your second. Like what? What's going on? Like, yeah, Barlow's older, but like. I don't. Know, I think there had to have been. No, he doesn't know that he never talks. I, I mean, I think to his credit, in terms of his humility, he never, he never doesn't seem to ever wield his second anointing over people. Right I.

43:01 I would have I in that moment, but of course I would have, I'm a, you know, I would have, I'm a miserable Sinner. But yeah, I I mean what I I don't. Know. I I think that that was kind of his big concern and then the placement marriage broke him. OK, All right. What after he suffers his stroke? This has been something I haven't been able to to find out one way or another. After he suffers his stroke, he still continues in his ministry. I mean, he slows down somewhat, but he's he's still he's still putting others to shame, right? I mean, like, honestly, if, if I suffer a stroke, I'm I'm going to sit in my chair and watch a lot of football. But he kept going.

43:49 Absolutely. Absolutely was. Was were all of his faculty still pretty much intact at that time? That's a. Good question. I mean, it's hard to note until he doesn't. His diary kind of is over at that point. A lot of women's Diaries from Allred's wives, Allred's sisters, those are kind of really significant. Of course, the Joseph Lyman Joseph Diaries are really the bulk of what we have about his life then. And what is hard is it would seem like it is. I do want to know. I know the I know the all red ordination is incredibly contentious because it's it is out of order.

44:34 But it is worth noting that John White Barlow did the same thing that John White Barlow also is kind of like ordaining men in the council that were not in the traditional line of authority. Allred also wasn't no one like Allred wasn't a nobody. Allred's kind of earliest activity in the movement is Allred was commissioned by John Y Barlow in 1935 to go to Mexico, or I'm sorry, to go to California and perform plural ceilings. He goes down and he he does plural. He's does a lot of missionary work in Mexico. He does a lot for the movement. So he does have authority under Barlow to be perpetuating the movement. So he certainly wasn't on the council, but he wasn't no one. And I think sometimes when we hear the controversy over all red, it's framed as though he's this random nobody doctor in California who no one has ever heard of before. And suddenly he's on the council. And that's really not true.

45:32 He's he's doing things under Barlow's authority in 1935, which is very early, very early. Let let me ask. This question 'cause this is something I've wondered about a lot within fundamentalism. It takes a good chunk of time before anyone starts thinking about a church again. Now as. Far as I can tell this is in in Part 2 reasons. One is the 8 hour meeting where it's like, hey, you guys are here, just keep plural marriage alive. This is what we're gonna do. And then also in when there there's a meeting that's held in the Celestial Room, if I'm not mistaken, in the Salt Lake Temple with the first counselor in the First presidency of the LDS Church, where it's basically said just keep your records 'cause we're gonna bring you guys right back in as soon as this whole polygamy thing blows over, so to speak.

46:32 Right. And that never happens, right? But, but it's always kind of in people's minds, it's gonna go back. Did Musser ever come to a point at which he understood we're gonna have to do everything on our own? Did did that promise ever wear off in his mind, so to speak? I don't think he ever saw the church going back. Really. Ever I. Don't. I don't think so. I don't think so. I mean. If he did. Think it he never wrote about it in his diary. OK, I mean. I don't have any sense that he was holding out hope for that. Muster died. Muster died believing the church was out of order.

47:15 So everybody. Remembers Joshua Erickson. I've had him on the podcast quite a few times and I think highly of both him and his family. They're some of the best people I know now. Every year they host an event where speakers give talks on a variety of gospel topics. This year, the 2024 Restoration Tour Conference will be happening on June 14th and 15th on the schedule. This year there are 14 speakers on a variety of topics. Now you can attend either in person or virtually. And while it's always free to attend, I couldn't strongly recommend you enough to go ahead and donate because things like this aren't easy to put on, nor are they cheap. So head on over to restorationtourconference.org or hit the link in this episode's show notes and get all the details and Sign up today.

48:00 Want. More from the Mormon Renegade Podcast Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the fundamental news program for free. Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button and for $5.00 a month you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes today. Muster died. Muster died believing the church was out of order. Now.

48:41 I mean, I think I think he would. I mean, I think he would hope for a day, but I mean must have met a lot of one mighty and strong's in his life. I mean he hung out with a lot of men that made this claim. I don't, I don't. I think he thought he certainly would have called it the Mother Church and now he did. He died thinking it was the church. Don't get me. Wrong. Like he did die believing this is the church, but he certainly died believing that the priesthood exists outside of the church. And it's it's with us, it's not with them. And I, I don't, I don't have a sense in which he thought that they would be united again in at least in his lifetime. I think he was very like, yeah, this is, this is what it is. I don't really think.

49:28 I mean, I don't, I also though, I, I don't think Massa ever would have want ever would have wanted people to start a church. The idea of incorporating into churches, like formal incorporations as churches, I do not think Massa ever would have wanted that. Now, he also could not have foreseen later, quote, UN quote, apostasies. And I say that because, you know, what people do as apostasy is very different depending on the group. But, you know, I know he couldn't have foreseen the changes to the LDS church and what was to come. And so maybe he would have changed. But certainly when he died, I don't think he ever thought because he spent so long writing that there's a difference between the church and the priesthood. Like he spent so long articulating this difference that to then say, well, it'll get healed, it'll be fine in the end. I don't.

50:14 I don't think he saw that ever coming in any substantial way. Do you ever think that it's on 'cause like? Everything. In Mormonism, at some point leads people to the temple or those ordinances that are contained in the temple. Does he ever express any interest or thought into organizing into something that would resemble the church, a temple, a building, anything? No. And so they were content just to do those ordinances outside of, of a temple. I I. I mean, now, granted, I started transcribing his Diaries in 2018 with Brian Buchanan.

51:01 It's been a while. But no, I mean, so he does, he does, he does do some things with Margarita Bautista in Mexico, who ultimately does kind of have a vision of a temple. How much of that is master's vision? You know, those are kind of different realities, but there is no indication that Muster wanted to. I mean certainly the idea of of incorporating as a corporation with the government what I I cannot imagine Muster have becoming A501C3. Well, I I'm not necessarily talking about about that, but meeting houses just infrastructure, right. I mean, so they.

51:47 Did have the priesthood home in Salt Lake City where they would meet a temple. I don't I don't think so. Certainly I don't think a temple. I don't I don't think that would have ever happened. I mean, they the reality is you don't need a temple. You don't need one. You don't need one. I mean, if Joseph Smith can get sealed down by the river to Luisa Beeman, certainly you can too. Like I don't there's no there is so much precedent for absolutely the Kirtland like early school of the prophet's foot like that was happening. You know, I mean, do you need a temple is a big question in Mormonism generally.

52:30 The answer is no historically, and I think must have recognized that. And so most of what was happening was happening in his home. So and I mean, especially because from us or at least, you know, he got sealed to his wives in his house under Matthias Cowley. So he also in the in an LDS context had a precedent for not needing a temple for ordinances. So I don't see him ever thinking there was kind of a necessity. He was contented in his home. Would he have been opposed to it? I don't know. I think I, I do think he would have been concerned with things being too much of A church because he was concerned about the direction of Barlow and he was concerned with he he really believed that they were not the church. He really believed that. And I think he also had a close enough relationship with the council men who were really opposed, like Lewis Couch would have absolutely never stood for it. And so I think he was too close to the Councilman and Charles Zitting would have never.

53:29 And so I think, I think he was too close to those men that would have kept him in check had he decided to start making a church. Gotcha. As you read through through those Diaries, is there? Do you get a? Sense of where he falls on things like one man ISM, that sort of thing. Does he ever say, hey, this could have been one of our downfalls? Does he ever? No, so the term one man rule doesn't isn't really there yet. He is concerned about Barlow. He does believe in a council. He believes in a council. I mean that is the vision of fundamentalism. I mean that's that is the vision. If you know, I have.

54:10 People know this. I have a quest. I don't know if ordinations happened by John Taylor. I think 1886 revelation happened. I don't. No, I don't think he ordained. Anyone sorry, we cannot agree to disagree. I don't think so from John, from that moment and then the Woolley Council, the vision of fundamentalism was a council. And yes, there was going to be a president to kind of to ensure everything works out and to because, you know, too many hands in the pot, too many cooks in the kitchen is can be hard. And so certainly having a president of the priesthood makes sense. But the vision of fundamentalism was a council And I, I don't, I think there was always kind of weariness of one guy ruling the show.

54:52 And the reality, the unfortunate reality is they were right to be weary of that because we have seen the example in Barlow's line of what happens. Yeah. Absolutely, absolutely. It's it's fascinating that that they understood that clear back then, right that they were they were cognizant the the fact that there was a a council was not by accident. And. That, that is, is pretty, pretty telling, I think in a lot of ways. So. Muster muster. Also, he when he was outlining the distinction between the church and the priesthood, he did trace the idea of a priesthood council back to Joseph Smith. Now is it super grounded in the historical record? I think it's a you know, there's some interpretation to be had in what's going on in Muster's vision of the Smith Priesthood council.

55:52 I think it's, I think it's a retrospective look at what Smith was doing. Of course, people who are faithful to the idea of a council, people from a faith perspective will look at it as as master did. But it is, I mean, it's also the case that Joseph Smith always had counselors and like, there was never A1 dude in Mormonism, right, Right. With no oversight. There was always some kind of check and balance in Mormonism. Gotcha. Gotcha. OK, I want. To switch more now to the book itself. What was the? Hardest part of getting that thing wrote as you tear into it and and you get the idea. OK, I want to do this on Musser.

56:37 What was the the? The big. Thing that that caused you the most heartburn, Well I mean the 1st. Hard thing was so all the books. So it's a series of books. They're the Intermorman thought series, and so there's a book on a range of people, and all the series are the same, that chapter one is a brief biography, and then there's three chapters on their three main ideas. What are Musser's three ideas of just three? And so choosing what are his three greatest contributions was hard. I ultimately chose priesthood, polygamy and United Order as his kind of three most significant ideas to the detriment of Adam God, which is in there, but it's not, you know, Sure.

57:21 I mean, I think the hardest thing was realizing that this is someone who most people in Mormon studies have never heard of. Right, this isn't. Writing a book on Huber J Grant, people would at least have a point of reference for Huber J Grant. Musser is someone who's beloved by many. He's someone who is a prophet to many people. He is someone who's people's family. He is someone who's the priesthood leader for people. He's the like the figurehead for so many Mormon movements. And yet he's someone that most people have never heard of. And so that was challenging to kind of how do, how, how do you tell this story for people who've never heard of him, but also who have no idea what Mormon fundamentalist history is, who think that there's a straight line from Joseph to Russell Nelson and that there aren't kind of alternate ways of telling Mormon history, notably that things go awry a range of points. And so, and there's like there's a whole, I mean, when you tell Mormon fundamentals history, as you know, there's a whole other cast of characters than than the LDS history, like who's who's Nathaniel Baldwin?

58:32 Like who are all like, who are all of these, who's Nathan Clark? Like, who are all of these like characters that are just a different set of secondary characters than when you tell the LDS story. So that was really, that was a challenge. But I mean, the thing that mattered the most to me is that, you know, this isn't a devotional book. Certainly I don't believe Messer was the president of a priesthood, and yet. But yet I needed. Mormon. Fundamentalism is so often brushed off as crazy, and I needed I needed, I needed people to take him seriously. And so I needed to find a way of ensuring like, this isn't my guy, I'm a Catholic, but I need you to realize that he is beloved and significant and he matters as much to the story of Mormonism as Heber J Grant, believe it or not. And so trying to figure out how to write it in a way that people would believe me that he is as important as Heber J Grant. That was that was the hardest of how to strike that balance. And hopefully I did.

59:38 I mean, I, it certainly doesn't come across, it probably comes across as more sympathetic than people might like. Definitely. I mean, I definitely Heber J Grant gets thrown under the bus quite a few times. But I I mean, that was definitely the hardest part is how do I make this not devotional but also make people like him as much as I do? And that was. Probably your biggest fear going into it as well, right? Because like, I can only imagine what the man must have been like in real life. Because as you read about him and you learn about him. You. Can't help but like the guy, right? I mean, not, not a perfect guy, right. I, that's an unfair standard to hold anybody to.

1:00:20 But you can't help but like him a little bit. And so that must have, that must have also have been a little bit of a fear too, right? Is that you know, how do you do it justice with with maintaining that that impartiality, so to speak? Right. And I mean, Mormon studies is a field of predominantly by LDS people. There are some Community of Christ there are, you know, but it is predominantly LDS. And the story of Joseph Messer ultimately is the story of how the LDS Church is wrong. Like, right, that's the story. That's the. Story like that's that's the story here is that the LDS church is out of order and an apostasy. That is the story of Joseph Messer. And so that's also kind of a challenge of someone who is part of Mormonism but also, like, is deeply defiant against it. And how do you show people that?

1:01:21 And that's something that I think a lot of people now in Mormonism try to grapple with, is how do I love this institution that I also like cannot stand? That. That's an interesting, that's an interesting take on that because I think that I think those days are here, right? And I think like, I do believe that we're kind of coming into a fundamentalist moment almost. And I see some of the questions that get asked today in the LDS church, and people are a bit surprised that those questions kind of already were answered a little bit.

1:02:04 With. Fundamentalism, right I mean look for Mormons, Heavenly Mother's a big thing, right and so when you start saying well who is she what'd she do well, if you believe the Adam God doctrine kind of know right but also. Who are they right? Who is she? Who are they right and and? And these are things that I feel like fundamentalists can can kind of answer in a way, right? Like it's one of those those conundrums that I think the church faces now, right? Like, well, we kind of have the answers, but if we go back and look at the answers now, we got to admit that maybe these guys over here who we labeled as crazy and carnal and devilish and, and all those other things, they got the answers to it.

1:02:51 And, and that becomes even down to women in the priesthood, right? I mean, you follow out the 2nd anointing to it's a logical conclusion and there's, there's a lot of stuff going on in there with, with women in the priesthood. And so a lot of those questions I feel like get answered there. But but that's an interesting take and one that I think is worthy of, of pondering here a little bit. Because certainly I'm a guy who loves to look forward for answers, but sometimes those answers are actually behind us and we gotta kind of stop for a moment and go where, you know, where we at. Yeah. And I mean, I think I, I talked quite a bit about this and I think it's worth articulating. Mormonism is not unique in terms of from a sociological standpoint, like it's unique in terms of it's religious doctrines, things like that. But in terms of like how religions operate, it's not super unique.

1:03:43 And what I mean by that is Mormon fundamentalism is having a moment right now. I mentioned to you, I think off air that it's an interesting thing where you read the Journal of Discourses and you have two choices. Yeah. Are you leaving or are you fundamentalist? Gotta pick one if you if you're gonna take Brigham Young seriously because Brigham Young said that the only. Men who become gods or the sons of gods? Are those who enter into the principle of plural marriage. So like he said that are you leaving this thing or are you joining the fundamentalist movement like you ought to pick one. And when I say Mormonism's not unique is that, and especially in the time Muster was living, Muster lived in a really interesting time in that it was the birth of the evangelical fundamentalist movement. It was, I mean, the turn of the century is a weird time in that it's modernity.

1:04:35 Like we're a modern people now. What does that mean? How are you going to be modern in the modern world? Is polygamy something that can exist in the modern world? How do you do like? And so for Christian evangelicals, the big question was, are we going to believe in evolution now? Do we think the Bible is real now? What? What are these big questions? And for a lot of people, a lot of people caved to modernity in the modernist controversy, and a lot of people doubled down and became fundamentalist. And Mormonism is doing the same thing is that they're trying to figure out how are we modern? Are we? Going to kind of look. Ahead and go through the path of progress, the grand trek towards secularism. Or are we going to double down and be what we are?

1:05:18 I mean, Catholicism, my own tradition, has seen this, and it's still seeing this. Right now, we're seeing a upswing in traditionalist expressions of Catholicism. Of what? What does it mean to be a religious person and be modern? And Mormonism did that in the time of muster. And I think it's doing that again now that younger people are having to grapple once again with how do we do this religion in the year 2024? And for a lot of people, it is that question of do we continue forward in the grand trek toward secularism, or do we decide to turn around? Right, no. And and young people are the ones that are kind of holding the key. Now I may edit this part out later. I'll have to think about this, but as of as of today, there have been count em 12.

1:06:13 No, no, I think it's closer to 10. Let me let me make sure I'm right here. I think it's 10 missionaries that have reached out to me while they're being missionaries, right? And they're they're discovering all this and they're like, well, wait, wait a second. If this isn't right. And now everybody in the LDS church calmed down. I told them to stop listening to the podcast and focus on their mission but. I may have. Told them to look me up when they're done but as of right now I'm like just stay doing your mission thing kiddo. But. But yeah, there. That's happening. There are no more secrets. And I keep trying to tell folks, hey, the cat's out of the bag.

1:06:54 There's nothing that people can't find now. And at some level, this, I believe is, is kind of the, the, the calling of the time, so to speak, is to wrestle with this a little bit. But I think I think that's why your book is so important, to be honest with you, right? Because we're not the first ones to do it. And I think, I think this is 1 vantage point that we can look at and at least take some, some. Pointers. From so to speak. Yeah. I mean, I think, and I think Muster's a kind of good picture of this because he really is. I mean. I think, I think the sentiment I'm gonna express most fundamentals feel this, but Muster was really the 1st to he doesn't say it this way, but it is the case that Muster realizes in 1921 that he doesn't, he didn't leave the church, the church left him. And that's a different experience. And that's something that a lot of fundamentalists in a in different words have expressed that Muster didn't change, right.

1:08:01 Muster Muster's living the same family system his dad did. Musser's doing what Joseph and Brigham and John and Wilfred and Lorenzo all did. Like he's living the same life all these people did. He's doing the same thing all these people did. He wasn't the problem. Something else was the problem, and it was the institution that he loved dearly. And in some ways that's a betrayal that the institution betrayed him. Oh it. It's it's absolutely a betrayal, right At look, I was an active LDS guy for about 20 years, right? I mean, I worked the program and in that 20 years you see change, right?

1:08:44 And and it's not insignificant change, right. One of one of the big things that that I constantly had to kind of deal with was, oh, it's the two hour meeting. You're not happy with the two hour meeting now. And I'm like, actually, I was really a fan of that. But you know, there's other big changes that have happened, right? The disavowing of certain doctrines that that as I became a Mormon were bedrock to to what I was joining. And when that starts to go away, that's rough. And then to make it rougher, you feel kind of gas lit, right? And this is where I can identify with Musser as well. When they say, well, the church doesn't change. Well, doesn't it?

1:09:28 Though I mean. Because. Doctrine. Does policy does right? Right. Right, yes, sorry, my bad. But you know, when, when they go away from the idea of, you know, exaltation and redoing the plan kind of all over again, only at a different station. And that goes away now, right. There was just an article a year or two back where where they're like, well, we're not so sure about this anymore. Well, then what are we sure of, right? Yeah, I mean. That's The thing is like you can't, you can't teach people for 65 years that you need polygamy to become God and then get rid of polygamy and also get rid of the become God part. Like both.

1:10:11 Like Brigham Young said. That. No one becomes God without polygamy. Both of those pretty key factors are gone. Like Brigham Young vision of the cosmos is got like Joseph Smith said that Joseph Smith said that God has a God. Joseph said that Joseph said that absolutely. They all said God has a God in a long chain of deity. Like, that is Mormon doctrine, right? Right. And and. See and and then you get the. Gaslighting effect where they say well, the church really doesn't change policy changes but not doctrine and then when you point to the doctrine you get gas lit again and and so I think that's exactly what Mormonism is facing now, right and I also think that we have to get really serious with our history here a little bit and sort out what is doctrine and where did things certain practices came from and then really.

1:11:15 Start. Saying, OK, So what is what does it mean to be a Mormon, right? Whether that's a fundamentalist person, whether that's someone in the LDS church, What does that mean? And what does that look like? Can it be codified anymore? Look, if if I didn't feel this thing to my core, I am a lazy person by nature. And so this idea of going to church for endless hours and donating time, I'm like, there's so many other things I would love to do. But I. Feel at my core, right. And and so when that, when that gets gets jostled with, I think it's, it's, it's and this isn't the natural outgrowth of it. Oh.

1:12:00 Yeah. I mean, yeah, absolutely, absolutely. So we're we're getting kind. Of close on time here a little bit is there anything Well, let me. Ask a couple. More questions actually, now that I think about it. What's what's your? What was? Something that you discovered in doing research for the book that floored YA that. Floored me. That you just didn't quite see coming. How candid he was in his Diaries and of course he probably never in his life imagined a gentile girl in the year 2023 reading his Diaries, that probably was not something a foreseeable part of his life. And so, but I, so of course he was candid, but I was surprised that he was candid.

1:12:59 I think the most, I mean, I, I think he said I was surprised how compelling it was. Like I've said many times that if I was LDS and I read Truth magazine, I wouldn't be LDS anymore. Right, I just I. Wouldn't have been. I mean, I think the most notable, I think about it all the time is when he's dividing out the priesthood existing outside of the church. For a lot of LDS people, that kind of sounds scandalous, but the reality is what happens first, the restoration of the priesthood or the organization of the church? It's the restoration of the priesthood happens first. Yeah. And therefore it can exist without a church and. Therefore.

1:13:41 It still can. And that was, that was wild to me when I first read him articulate that. And I was like, oh, that's like a, that's a good point. And so I, I think I was surprised by how compelling I found it. I think one of the really interesting things as well, you know, one of the the something that a lot of people talk about is how the LDS Church has kind of shifted what is kind of the most significant aspect of the faith. And in the 20th century, things like the first vision become real, like really important. The Book of Mormon takes kind of more central stage. And I did find it really interesting how little Joseph Messer talks about either of those two things, particularly, particularly the Book of Mormon. Yeah, I was surprised that he doesn't talk about it very much. Do you think?

1:14:31 That maybe that's an outgrowth of just having been raised with it for so long. Maybe, but like his pamphlets never really talk about it. OK, like it's a. Lot like he really focuses on the Doctrine Covenants. Certainly he really focuses on the on the lecture on the journal discourses, the the words of the prophets. But I was surprised, I was surprised about it until I talked to people who really kind of have written about the development of how Mormonism presents itself in the 20th century. And it really is in the 20th century that we start to see the first vision really take a central stage as a primary significant thing, and the Book of Mormon becomes really important.

1:15:15 I mean, it was always important, obviously, but it because it takes really kind of new significance in the 20th century. And so. It should. In hindsight, it shouldn't have been surprising, but I was initially kind of interested in the fact that that was never kind of the cornerstone of his faith. The cornerstone of his faith was Joseph Smith. It wasn't the Book of Mormon. Gotcha. And I mean, those two are, you know, the what makes Joseph Smith important. But the Book of Mormon, the Book of Mormon's important because the prophet receives it. You know, they're, they're running the same in a lot of ways, but I was surprised that it's not referenced. Interesting. Interesting. Yeah. That's that's fascinating. Yeah.

1:15:55 The only thing I could point to on that is it was kind of wasn't his fight though, right? He wasn't fighting. He wasn't fighting people who were critics of the Book of Mormon. He was fighting people who were critics. Of. Of other doctrine. Yeah, I just. I just looked at the my the index for my book. There's not, I don't think there's any reference to the Book of Mormon. Wow. I think that's OK. I think, I think that gives us a peek into what, into what was on his mind at the time, right? I mean. He's not. About trying to convince people that the Book of Mormon is true.

1:16:36 He's trying to convince people that these old things the church are giving up are are important. He's also, I mean. He's also distinctly not a missionary to non Mormons. Like he's he's not. He's not trying to convince me of Mormon fundamentals, and he's trying to convince you of Mormon fundamentalism. Like he assumes that if you're reading Truth magazine, you're already sold on the Restoration. And I think that is the reality. And I mean, I think This is why ultimately a lot of the groups that end up forming around him do view the LDS Church as the missionary arm of the fundamentalist movement, that you have to get into that first before you can jump to fundamentalism. It doesn't make sense. Like it makes no sense to send a fundamentalist missionary to my house.

1:17:20 Like I'm I have to, I gotta believe in the basics first. And so there is something to be said about that. He he assumes you believe in the Book of Mormon if you're in it. Right, right. No, that makes sense. But I guess he doesn't he all he does he, you know, he goes to his church meetings, he talks about going to Sunday school, he talks about going to all of his church meetings. He doesn't really talk about like family prayer or scripture study. A lot of those kind of like things that we imagine a the daily life of Mormon people. He really doesn't talk about that. But he is going to a lot of church during the week like he's always gone from home. Right, right.

1:18:03 Which would make it tough to to do that if you're gone that often. And. Finally, this one What's? His. Legacy, I mean, his legacy is. The Apostolic United Brethren, the single largest cohesive movement in the Intermountain West. I think that's his legacy. I think his legacy is, is the AB. And I know that, you know, for other groups, other groups love him. Don't get me wrong. I realize that. But when I think of, you know, his legacy is old. I mean, he wanted his legacy to be all red. Like he he chose that.

1:18:47 He pointed to it like that's that is the reality is we don't have to guess who he want, who he like imagined his legacy to be left with. He he picked the guy he picked it's all red. It's ruling all red. We know the answer to this question. He chose his successor. And that's so rare in religion generally. I mean, Joseph Smith didn't do that, but we have a concrete example of a fundamentalist leader who has chosen his successor and it was ruling all red. Now, we can disagree, but then you're disagreeing with Muster's ordination. You're disagreeing with his choice. And you're welcome to do that, of course. But the answer is, is he, he told you who his legacy was and it was ruling all red. And therefore it's the Apostolic United Brethren and therefore also every group that breaks off from that while recognizing that, you know, of course, many groups also acknowledge him as a significant priesthood authority leader in the 20th century. But I think his his legacy is the largest cohesive branch of the fundamentalist movement, which is there's something to be said about that.

1:19:52 There's something to be said about about the fact that his, and certainly there are break offs of the AUBAUB is not. You know, known for. Not having that, certainly there's different expressions of, you know, different AUB groups or different branches of AB. I don't know, you know, there there's been contestation certainly, I guess that's what I meant to say There's there's been contestation over authority and different break offs. But the AUB is not nothing in terms of size. No, they're. Yeah, they're, they're good size for sure. I mean, I think the biggest operating one still so. And people.

1:20:41 And people, I mean, the FLDS was the biggest for a while, but that didn't I mean. We don't know how that works out conditions, right? I mean like, you know. How that turned out, Yeah. I mean, yeah, it was big. But it also like you had to live under, under Warren. And so I mean, I, yeah, I think his legacy is successful. I mean, the other thing is his legacy is one that I don't hear a lot of. I don't hear people from any group really hate him. And that's. And I mean get one member from every fundamentalist group and have them like someone from their past. All of them have a shared sense of we like them.

1:21:23 Like that doesn't happen. That just doesn't happen, I mean. And especially like, you hear, I, you know, I have heard former FLDS say like, he signed the document, you know, he's, he conceded. That's a very different vibe than people in the AUB being like Barlow did placement merit like it's there's a different kind of level of why we wouldn't like certain people. And Muster is pretty much well loved or at least respected. And in the same way is you can disagree with the ordination, but I don't know people that dislike ruling all red. Right. No, no, I like, like. Yeah, you can disagree with the ordination, but people like the guy. I had a guy on the on the podcast who knew him personally as a young man and sounds again hard to find anyone that disliked him.

1:22:20 Just what it was. Yep, and. That's, I mean, what a legacy that you die and it doesn't matter if people didn't believe you were the priesthood leader, but people still like you. Right from a range. Of groups, I mean, like the Kingston's, like members of the Kingston group like him, members of the Lebaron community like him, members of Centennial Park like him, independents like him. Like, goodness, you get all those people to agree on one guy. Like, let's talk about who that guy is, right? Right, absolutely. Do you do you see? Do you see?

1:23:02 Musser's importance getting bigger, I guess, as time goes along. Well, I think one of the difficulties is for so long the primary sources weren't available. People couldn't, you know, for a long time there wasn't a lot of access to his writings. And now at the age of the Internet with various things, people can read about him. And so I do think that as people are becoming more interested in fundamentalist history, as people are reading more generally about the movement, I do think that there will be a up growth, an upswing in interest in his life and his legacy. And I mean, I think that's only to the benefit of the fundamentalist movement to see, I mean, people like their history.

1:23:48 People like seeing where they came from. And and so I, I think that this is AI mean I'm lucky in that it's a perfect time to have a book titled A Mormon fundamentalist. Thanks like given to net, given to Netflix. It's been a great, it's been a great run. But I think it is, I, I think now is a great time for people to who are interested in the movement. And so I do think that there's going to be renewed interest in who he was as people realize that. I mean that shocking thing that people think Mormon fundamentalism begins with Warren Jeffs. And then? They learn it doesn't, they want to know who it is. And so I, I have seen kind of interest. I mean, I even, I took a group of people down to Short Creek on a tour and like, I had students of mine buy my book.

1:24:36 And I don't think it was just because of me. Like they got extra credit for being on the trip. They didn't have to buy my book and just kind of realizing like, oh. Where does? Modern polygamy come from why are people doing this? Who are these people? And so I think it's AI think it's an interesting time for people to learn about the movement. Why? Why do you think the? There's there's renewed interest in the movement, I mean. It. Seems to be that the more modernity would creep in, the more we would move away from this right, so to speak. People like. Spectacle, though. That's true. And what's? More spectacular than polygamy. I mean, people also like knowing about people's sex lives. Come on.

1:25:24 People are people are nosy. People are nosy. People are. Nosy people are nosy. And we also like spectacle. I mean, why do humans slow down at car crashes? People are nosy and they want to see, they want to see what's going on. And I mean, there have been, there have just been so many. How many Netflix specials are there about Mormons and like? And about Mormon. Mormon fundamentalism and like escaping polygamy is on TV and like, and like sister wives, like everyone is interested in polygamy. Everyone's interested in polygamy. And then I when people Google it, they're like, wait, there's more to this story than just than just sister wives Where?

1:26:07 I mean, I remember, I remember when I first watched Sister Wives, I googled what religion they were. Like years ago. Years ago, before I even knew what a Mormon was. What is this? And so, and I mean, now I now I definitely know what a Mormon is, but yeah, I remember Googling like, what are who are they? Why do they, what's going on at this point? Yeah, people are. People are interested in people who aren't like them. No, that's, that's true. I, I didn't even think about that, but I gotta probably, I worked with a guy for years who's not a Mormon of any stripe.

1:26:48 And when he found out I was a polygamist, he's like, what's that like? Dave, what's it, What's it like? And I was like, OK, get ready, 'cause I'm gonna blow your mind. You ready? It's like being married twice and he was just let down. So. But yeah, no, there there is something to be said for the spectacle end of things, but where can people find the book? I, I, there was a funny moment. My, my fiance is, you know, not Mormon. He's an Anglican priest. And he came to visit most recently and we went to lunch with a fundamentalist family that was so kind to come and talk to my students about their life for me, just a great family. And before we went to before we went to lunch, I told my fiance what his profession is split.

1:27:40 It's the Colton Winder and his family. I don't know if you know them, they're great. And Colton is a a compounding pharmacist, which is he makes medication just out of thin air. Like he just it's wild. Like what is compound pharmacy? What's going on? I mean, he was so generous. He he helps like he made my dogs chemotherapy when she got, I mean, he's just, they're such a great family. But I told my fiance I was like, we're going to go to lunch with his family. I have to talk to my students. It's great. There's his two wives. They're wonderful.

1:28:22 And he's a compounding pharmacist and my fiancee Googled compounding pharmacist and we both kind of read what that is. And he was like, well, this is what I want to ask him about. This is crazy. Like making Medicaid. Like he, he makes chemotherapy and like we're reading like he makes this eye medication that you inject into your eye. Like what's going on? And so it was so funny that we were sitting there and he's like, this is what I care of. Like what? This what? And so it's. Like all of a sudden, the fact that it was like polygamy, he was like, well, this is the, this is the crucial thing right now is what is this phenomenon, right? Yeah. And so that's. Also kind of a funny. Thing, but like, suddenly the polygamy was not the most interesting thing about it, right? Yeah.

1:29:05 Yeah, no, I it. It's been hard to tell people from time to time that, you know, really, with the, with the exception of of I have two wives, my house probably looks a lot like yours, right? I mean, there's it's not I, I hate to burst people's bubbles, but it's not, you know, the illicit thing they want it to be. I don't know, I don't know what to say. But anyway, well, good stuff. Where can people find the book? I recommend getting it at Benchmark Books since they little ship, but just to support them. They sell a lot of fundamentalist books so and they're a great independent booksellers. So I highly recommend supporting them.

1:29:46 Brian Buchanan works there. He's who I'm doing the Diaries with. You can get it on Amazon. There's a Kindle version if you'd like that too. But I do recommend Benchmark. You can also get it on like walmart.com. You can get anywhere anywhere books are sold. Barnes and Noble has it apparently on the Internet. But I would like, can I read you a poem, a little bit of a poem, please. So it's six stanzas, but I'm just going to read you the last three because they're my they're my favorite. It was written in 1944 by a man named Deacon Jarby I. Don't know. Maybe someone listening is related to him, who knows, But it was. It's a poem written about Joseph Muster, and I think I put it in the book as kind of a way to shine a light on how beloved he was 'cause there's, it's hard to really wrap people's head around how much he was loved. So it's a long poem, and I'm gonna read the last three stanzas.

1:30:41 So we hope he stays with us for a long time to come. But when he goes on to the glory of the sun, there'll be Joseph and Hiram, Brigham and John to welcome him home to the place he has won. The Lord will receive him and say to him then well done, good and faithful brother JWM. They'll all crowd around him and close to the throne the torch he'd held high when to him it was thrown. He'd never reviled those who sought his downfall, but he kept his eyes straight and ignored one and all who tried to persuade him to desert what to them was the wrong path to take. That's JWM. He's loved by the faithful, despised by the false. He's human, so he has his virtues and faults. When his life's page is written, we're sure that you'll find his faults will be minute, his virtues sublime. For his faith in the priesthood, we'll all say Amen. A true gospel champion is JWM.

1:31:39 Wow. You know, that's the guy that is the. Guy. And I asked. You a few minutes ago what was his legacy certainly when you talk about Joseph Smith, I can tell you what his legacy was on a personal level, right as a 13 year old boy whose dad passes away. I don't know what happens to my dad. I have a minister who's a well meaning minister. This is not a slam, but he under he he described it to me as he understood it right that unless he said, you know, I accept Jesus on as my savior on his deathbed, he's lost.

1:32:26 So for me. Joseph's legacy is no. No, no, no, no, no, no, no these. Ties are deeper and God, God is mindful of all his children. Likewise with Musser. For me personally, his legacy is what's just in the other room, right? It's, it's a chance to live a life that quite frankly, I never even thought about, right, but has brought me exquisite joy and at times exquisite pain, right? I've had one of these collapse. I know what that's like. But it's because of men and men like him, John W Taylor, Howie, those guys who who gave it all, who said, you know what, consequences be damned, we're gonna do this come hell or high water 'cause we feel like God's told us to do it. And I think.

1:33:18 That's the legacy, right, At least from a faithful perspective. My perspective will will be a little bit different, but but to me, that's the legacy is that he he really is kind of the grand pappy of us all in one form or another. And at the end of the day, that that has a lot, a lot of weight, but. Yeah, well. Christina, I hope. I hope my story, the story I told of him, hope people who love him feel like I did right by his legacy and by him. I think. So I've I've I've been able to read the book and it was done. And and.

1:34:00 I'll say this, by and large, for your work, there's a reason. Not that it should matter, but I mean, there's a reason I respect the hell out of what you do. And that's because I feel like you're, you're you're not gonna paint us. Horrible. You're gonna be truthful and you're gonna show the warts and all and as well as the good. And that's, that's all anybody can ask for. So, and I feel like you did the same thing with, with Musser here. So and, and quite frankly, we need these books as a people. For so long we've, we've been left to our own devices in the wilderness, so to speak. And there's no one that's really, you know, there's been a lot of oral tradition, a few notes and Diaries, but that's changing with, with your work, the work that Michael Ness is engaged in. I, I, you know, a couple other folks. I, I feel like those tables are turning and, and I'm super excited for it.

1:34:57 But anyway, thank you so much for being here. Thanks so much, I appreciate it. Enjoy. Canada, hey. Thanks. I'll try, yeah. Yeah, you like hockey. I do. I do. Well, that's. Good, because you'll get a lot of it. So awesome. Thanks again, Christina.