May 18, 2024

Episode #131: Mormon Lore & Stories W/Christopher Blythe (Host of the Angels & Seerstones Podcast)

Episode #131: Mormon Lore & Stories W/Christopher Blythe (Host of the Angels & Seerstones Podcast)
Episode #131: Mormon Lore & Stories W/Christopher Blythe (Host of the Angels & Seerstones Podcast)
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #131: Mormon Lore & Stories W/Christopher Blythe (Host of the Angels & Seerstones Podcast)

Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.

Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products

https://open.spotify.com/search/angles%20%26%20seerstones/episodes

When you look at any society one of the things that binds those societies together are stories. It has been that way since man first gathered around a fire and talked with other people. Not only do those stories bind us together, they inform us and newcomers to the society what that particular society is about. Today on the podcast I have Christopher Blythe on talk about Mormon lore and stories. Now Christopher has a podcast named Angels & Seerstones that dives into this subject and is one of my favorite podcasts. During our conversation we talk about the importance of stories to society, why it is we find a little reluctance to talk about those stories, I share a very personal story of my own, and even end up exploring the dark side of stories and lore by talking about the Chad & Lori Daybell incident.

--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support

0:07 When you look at any society, one of the things that binds those societies together are stories. It's been that way since man first gathered around a fire and talked with other people. Not only do those stories bind us together, they inform us and newcomers to the society what that particular society is all about. Today on the podcast I have Christopher Vlive on to talk about Mormon lore and stories. Now Christopher has a podcast named Angels and Seer Stones that dives into the subject and is one of my favorite podcast. During our conversation we talk about the importance of stories to society today, why it is we find a reluctance to talk about those stories. I end up sharing a very personal story of my own and even end up exploring the darker side of stories in lore by talking about the Chad and Lori Daybell incident.

0:53 That and more on this episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast. So a few weeks back I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running. Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page, or click the link in this episode's show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups and water bottles all with the Mormon Renegade logo as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny. Now this is just the beginning. In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase.

1:35 Now all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast, so head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode. Show notes and get yours today.

2:17 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. So up until now the podcast has really been a one man show. Well, as I've gotten busier, it's been harder and harder for me to get everything done that I need to do. So starting today Mason Vogel is going to be joining me on the podcast. Go ahead and say hi Mason. Hello everyone. Thanks for having me on Dave. I'm really happy to be here, dude. I'm super excited that you're here. Mason will be helping me by controlling all the tech as well as helping out with some of the editing. All right, so let's go ahead and let's just jump right into the episode here. Chris, what's going on, man? How are you? Great to be here. Dude, I'm so happy to have you on. I gotta tell you what I am a fan of of Mormons getting, you know, kind of more vocal, right. I don't care if that's LDS folks. I don't care if that's that's fundamentalist. I'm just, I'm excited because quite frankly, we, I always feel like we need to be a little more forward facing on this stuff. Right as because like Mormonism's kind of weird, right?

3:22 I remember when when I received my testimony of the Book of Mormon, I remember I was like, I don't really want to be a Mormon because you know, there there's so much in there as a Mormon that that has has some baggage and stuff. And so anytime I see someone like yourself that that jumps online and is willing to put themselves out there, I just think it's a great, great thing. What was the name of your podcast for everybody so everyone can hear it? Angels and seer stones. Dude, that is that is a cool name. That is a cool name. What? What was the impetus behind this? The name is just because it represents the peculiar right. This is the 2 two sides kind of folk magic and supernatural experiences that people might raise their eyebrows about. You know we've Christine and I have wanted to do a podcast for a really long time.

4:19 I think it was it was probably it was a 4th of July. We were doing a long walk in Provo to get to the to the parade and we were brainstorming things as we went and I said you know we need to start a podcast named Angels and Seer Stones and I started sketching out some ideas and then we put it on hold for several years. And then this past summer we we had a lot of time around a house. We were with someone who was going to pass away coming up. And I don't know if you've had that experience, but it means there's a lot of time and we just said let's let's go for it, let's do something. And we wrote a few episodes and it's pretty, pretty incredible. You know, we were and in the beginning we were excited that we'd have 100 listeners and now we're at 7000. So it's a, it's a fun thing and it feels good to be able to share ideas.

5:18 And, you know, Christine and I both are professional folklorists. So we write these articles for academic audiences and they get 1000 reads across their lifespan. And now we, you know, and we spent six months putting on an article and now you can put out a video that shares ideas and it comes to its audience the next day. I mean, it's wonderful. Yeah you I I've listened to some like one of my favorites was was the episode you did on and I'm gonna try to remember how it was phrased. I might get this wrong but pre birth experiences. Yeah. And and do that. Yeah, that one resonated me, resonated with me so much because I'm a guy.

6:05 Me, me and me and my wife Amber. We adopted a set of twins 18 years ago now and we we had some incredible experiences and and as you were going through some of that, I mean it just resonated with me incredibly. And so that's the kind of stuff you broach, right. And and some of it. And and correct me if I'm wrong, this would kind of you kind of like look at old Mormon lore, for lack of a better word, right. And you kind of look at that What, what was the impetus for that? What you look at, you know, this is, this is what I do. So I teach classes at Brigham Young University. I teach contemporary legends. I have a class called Myth, Legend of Folk Tales. And then I have an introduction of folklore class and an American folklore class.

6:54 And every one of these we have, you know, 6 lectures or so just on latter day. St. folklore and students share stories. And you know, what I really found as a folklorist is a lot of the stuff I think is old 19th century people don't talk about anymore. And if they do, they talk about hush tones. Well, I think that's kind of true. But people still have these stories, right? People still have miraculous experiences. They've heard them. They're from their mom or their grandma or their missions, and they talk about them, but they don't talk about them at church, right? They talk about them at home, around a campfire, when they're when they're hanging out with a friend. You know, all sorts of different scenarios.

7:36 Maybe you just talk with your kids about it. And that to me is really what being a latter day saying it's about, right? There's this official side of our faith and there's also the side that we consider sacred and we keep it in small circles. And so yeah, I love that sort of thing, whether it's pre birth narratives or dream telling or you know, even visions, right? All of these are or you know, I have a lot of episodes on apparitions in the temple. These are things people claim to have and because we're careful who we tell them, a scholar could just assume these stories dried out, right? We haven't, we haven't had a revelation for 100 years sort of thing.

8:19 But I think once you talk to people on the ground, you find out this is a vibrant faith that's still really charismatic. Maybe not as much as eighteen third, right? But still going on. You know, and and I think as a guy who was never a Mormon at all, right, I'm the first Mormon on either side of my family. One of the things that one of the things that drew me to to being a Mormon was was this idea of of no, no, no. The these experiences that you read about in in ancient scripture, they're still here, right. And and you can still have some of those, you know and and in some ways Chris, I feel like if we're not having those encounters with the divine a little bit, we're kind of missing out on on more the some of the cooler parts of Mormonism.

9:15 Absolutely. You know, I think sometimes I meet lottery Saints who don't believe in the supernatural like I do. And I think, gosh, I have more in common with a Pentecostal or a Roman Catholic than this guy who doesn't believe in the sort of supernatural elements of the faith. And you know, so I I I think that's just, that's right on. You know, both my wife and I are converts too, and we both serve missions and the life of seeking an encounter with the divine is why we're Latter Day Saints as well. So that speaks to me. And I think I know that there's broad audience in the show, but I think right now the LBS Church has never been more active in pronouncing personal revelation revelations from Prophets.

10:05 You know we had a President Holland give a talk at general conference in which he very clearly implied he had a near death experience in the past couple years and talked about that. I I think we we've maybe from Wilford Woodruff. Wilford Woodruff talked about miracles constantly. I don't know from Lorenzo Snow to Thomas S Monson. Have we had that emphasis on revelations, visions, talking to the dead, all of these things? And now President Nelson is speaking actively about that. It's it's kind of exciting. So for me, you're sorry, very neat in the upper core of our identity that's in those experiences and sometimes we lose it, right, maybe mid 20th century. We're not talking about as much, but I think it's on the way back.

10:58 You know, I I think and and certainly from from my faith community, those things are are picking up and accelerating as well, right. And and a lot of people I talk to there seems to be an uptick in this, right. And it's it's almost like we're kind of hurtling towards an event, right. And there's little things that are beginning to happen where where it's like K buckle up son. You know you're about you're you're about to see some stuff the show's coming so to speak, right. And and and I find that extremely fascinating that that you're seeing that on the LDS side. I'm seeing that on the fundamentalist side and and quite frankly I I've spoken to people who aren't even Mormon, who are starting, you know, guys you never would have thought right guys like I I have a next door neighbor right now.

11:49 We're just renting a place. But but he's, he's a Baptist, right? And we always have that uncomfortable conversation, 'cause I'm pretty much in the Bible Belt now, right? And it's like, I see you dress up every week, Where are you going to church? And I'm like, well, you better sit down. This is gonna be a minute. But we we have this great conversation. He's like, you know, in in our church right now, there's a lot of people who are talking about seeing some stuff that's kind of in the realm of supernatural. I was like like bad supernatural. And he's like, no, just just visitations. So yeah we're I I feel like all of us who who who are trying to find the Savior for some reason we're we're you know as time is progressing here and and quite frankly just one guy's opinion.

12:37 I think we're getting close to some major events that have been foretold in scripture. It's it's almost like these these these kind of manifestations are happening and and that's why I think your your podcast is so timely right. Because I think we have become somewhat removed from from engaging with those experiences because quite frankly we've we've lived in an age where I think we've tried to explain everything and man has kind of been like well we got this all figured out you know the this this is caused by this and so it it's fascinating cause a lot of your your podcasts they go back a ways right. They go back to to the 19th century and it's interesting to see how they they handled those and they interacted with with those as well.

13:25 Oh absolutely. You know I I think that's true. I think people are thinking about the supernatural right This and I use supernatural to be the divine to right this otherworldly I think and I think Latter Day Saints are really cautious to say we're not weird right. There's this emphasis to say, hey, you know, and I guess what I want to be is the sort of Latter Day St. that that never hides the sort of radical faith that is my religion, right? There's something here. I know, I know you think it's absurd, not you that angels show up to to teenagers, but I think it really happened. Right?

14:08 So. So I want to own that and I never want to be ashamed of it. And so the podcast plays into that. You know, I don't have a a testimony of any individual story. I share maybe a couple. But of the worldview of this idea, I I really want us to to grasp onto it. And sometimes we have lost ideas. These are, these are people, as you mentioned in the 19th century, that had a very active experience with the supernatural. When they built temples just like we do, they had experiences, they saw things, they heard voices. But the difference is they wrote it down and they talked to each other about it and I think we're we're less likely to do that. And so I think today we do see upticks and that and maybe it's because the Internet makes it so people can again communicate with other like minded individuals. But something's going on for sure. I think it's.

15:10 I think it's a neat thing. When I talk about these experience with students at BYU, they're for the most part really open to it. You know, a few of them will be like, oh, that really weirded me out, Doctor Blythe. But most of them say, oh, I had no idea. You know, I had, I've had several students want to write papers about how there's been a decline in spiritual gifts in the church. You know, like that's the premise of the of the paper. How do how do we explain this? And usually by the end of the class and of course I tell them they can do it by the end of the class, they usually come to me and say, I don't think that's right anymore. I I just don't think we talk about it. And so something shifts in their minds as they think about it.

15:51 But pretty fascinating. That tie with the 19 past is really important for us, of course, Right? Right. Let me ask you this, why is it you think that maybe the the last 50-60 years, whatever it's been, I say 50 years and I'm like we're six years, that's six years away from the 80s is all. But we'll we'll go back a little further, right. We'll say from the 40s to to on to today, Why do you think we've been so hesitant as a people to share those stories or those experiences with with each other? Do you know, in my book Terrible Revolution, I trace this idea of kind of a an idea that if I have a spiritual experience, I should only share it with my stewardship, but I should only share what my family is.

16:39 I should only share it when I feel the spirit tell me it's OK in this setting to share it. I trace those ideas really to to 1913 and 1913. We've already had statehood happen and then the dream mine happens and this becomes a big deal. So there's an official statement that's sent out. In fact, in the book I focus on three statements, right? 19 OO 5 is when we have a statement against the one mighty and strong. 1913 is this dream mine experience. And then 1918 is when Joseph F Smith gets up and says hey I didn't I didn't actually have that vision that's circulating about me.

17:25 And also I know Edwin Rushton and the White Horse Prophecy isn't real right. So we have these three moments in which these the church is kind of saying don't trust unofficial sources even when they claim to come from the Prophet. If your neighbor comes to you and says I had a vision and I want you to invest in my business, you can go ahead and tell him no, that you need to be careful about sort of messianic people that show up and say, hey, you need to follow me. So the in this period, you know, the period of transition is really focused on saying hold up, we need to be really careful. And I think it's about being good Americans.

18:09 I think our prophecy literature for the most part was about the collapse of the United States. And now that we're part of the United States, it becomes it, it becomes counter the big project if we're emphasizing that the United States is gonna collapse, right. And so by reining in these voices, this, these visionary voices, you can kind of control the message that's coming out a little bit better. And so I think that's where we started and once those those policies are around, we stick to it. I I also. Think you know there is. This is it's AI mean. It's a practical rule in 2023.

18:54 I like like when my neighbors might not. I mean I want them to tell all their experiences to me, but maybe I don't want them to publish them far and wide because I don't want people to think their experience represents something. I think right, we're all Latter Day Saints and so if Denver Snuffer shows up, maybe I don't want Denver Snuffer sharing all of his visions at church. Maybe I want Denver Snuffer to be told to chill out, keep it to his home. But that is a problem. So I think for the most part, where we see this is that the church only really does something when visions push against the community goals, right?

19:38 To build in temples, there's no problem If I say I saw my mother in the temple or I heard a voice say do the work for this person, no problem for that. If I have a vision that says you're going to have a baby, nobody has an issue with that. But if I have something that says gather to New Mexico, then the church is going to have an issue stepping out of the thing. So I think it's really fascinating and some people just go beyond that and think you can't talk about anything. Which is not too different than you know, an individual who thinks you can't discuss anything about the temple. Yeah, yeah, no, absolutely. You know, I remember well I'll I'll just share, share one of mine, right.

20:21 I told you I resonated a lot with the with those pre birth experiences so to speak so and and this is going someplace so everyone bear with me out there but we had we had just moved all four of our kids from Boise ID to the Eastern Shore of Maryland not quite across the continent but it's pushing it right. I mean I'm only short by by three or 400 miles going coast to coast and we moved out there and we didn't know anybody right. I mean, if you ever wanna know what it's like to be in the Sanders family, it's we may get that bug and you know what? We're we're we're going somewhere. But we we get out there and and you know, it's it's a strain on the kids, right.

21:07 We're cognizant of that as parents, right? We're we're uprooting them from everything they know. And we're gonna go 2500 miles to the east and we're gonna drop shop right there and and set up and go for it. And so times you know it's a little rough on the kids And so I told Amber I was like let's let's make this Christmas really good. We're making good money. Whatever the kids want. Just get it right. I mean they've been rock stars through this whole process and and I wanna I wanna make sure they know how much I appreciate what they've done here. And so it comes time and and and we tell our our five year old Hannah was her name. I said Hannah. What What do you want for Christmas, sweetheart. And you know what What do you want Santa to bring ya. And she goes, you know what I I'm gonna get twin babies. Not I want.

21:55 I'm gonna get. And I said OK all right, well, we'll we'll we'll see maybe what Santa can do, maybe he can bring you, you know, a couple of baby dolls. And she got really indignant, Chris. I mean, she got way indignant. She was like, no, I want real twin babies. I'm like, well, sweetheart, without giving a whole bunch of biology away here, that's just not possible anymore, right? Like, you know, the medical reasons my wife had to have some surgery. I'm like, look, that's just not gonna happen. And she kind of walked away a little irritated, I could tell, right? She had her mom's look to her. She walked away from me a little irritated. And so, you know, couple months go by and right around her birthday, I asked her again, What?

22:40 What do you want for your birthday, sweetheart? She's like, I want twin babies now I'd forgotten about this, right? Christmas is in December. Her birthday's in April. She's like, I want twin babies. And I said, well, sweetheart, you know what? We we can certainly see what we can go down the store and find for you. And she again, she said, no, they're gonna be real babies. And this time. And she said they're a little boy and a little girl and again was just like, this is going to happen. And so a few months after that, I get the call from Idaho Department Health and Welfare Child Services. You know, my sister had given birth to a set of twins. She kind of left him in the hospital and it was an emergency. So I they asked if we'd be interested in adopting. And you know, because my wife is awesome like that. She's like, yes, absolutely we will. So I flew back to Idaho about a month ahead of time, bought a house, got everything set up.

23:36 Then I flew back out, picked up, you know, all the kids and Amber and we started driving out. And now when when I get to Idaho, these twins are in horrible condition, I mean, absolutely horrible condition. And so I tell Amber, I was like, let's not tell any of the kids about about these twins yet because we don't like, we don't know if they're going to live kind of a thing. And so the time in the in the month I was there, I would go to work and then go right to the hospital, 'cause I have nothing else to do, right? I'm essentially a bachelor again in a five bedroom house with a lawn chair ATV and some ESPN and an Xbox, right?

24:18 That's that's my that's my existence. So I I spent a lot of time up the hospital and as I held them they started to perk up more and and things you know they made great great great advances thanks to the doctors and some blessings and those sorts of things. So then we we end up going to back to to Maryland. I pick up Amber and the kids and we're driving out and we get to we were right on the border of of like Pennsylvania and Ohio. We were in the Ohio River District area or excuse me, Ohio River Valley area. And I'll never forget it.

24:58 We stopped off at an old an old Ruby Tuesdays and I was like, OK, you know we'll tell them here what's happening, right, 'cause they're not dumb, they can feel it. You know we're in a hurry. We're we're not, we're not hanging out. And finally tell the waitress, I want a seat in the back, right. I want something as private as I can get. And and she accommodated me and she was super nice. And I get back there and I just tell them I said, hey, you know, here's the scenario. There's these two babies that we're going to be adopting. And all of a sudden Hannah lifts her head up and her eyes get this big and she's like twin babies.

25:43 Really. And I'm like, Yep, absolutely twin babies. And. And she's going and she goes one boy and one girl. And this whole time I'm not making the connection. Right. And I'm like, yeah, one boy and one girl. And and she like, slaps the table and she just says, I told you, I told you you wouldn't listen. But I told you, I mean, she's shouting it. And so when when I heard yours that, you know, your episode on that, that really resonated with me. But for the longest time, for the longest time, I I was scared to share that, right? Because one, it just seems unbelievable. And two, I felt, you know, if I share this, am I gonna get looked at as a nut job? Am I gonna get looked at as as one of those guys? Right.

26:35 And. And so that concerned me right now. After a time, I found that no, I could share that, but it had to be the right setting, right? And I think setting has a lot to do with with being willing to talk about these. Things. Yes. You know President Nelson Russell and Nelson had this experience I thought around the episode right where his wife has met this child, this male child that's going to be born with their family except she keeps having girls. So you know eventually they think there's no way we're going to have another kid and then it happens and then Russell and Nelson has a dream or some experience with this child right before he comes sort of thing.

27:24 These are these are powerful things. I mean I think we can trace them back a really far in the restoration Dodd is all about family. So I, you know, I'm pretty hesitant to share mine, but I had two dreams about my children before they came. One one is my third kid didn't have a dream and my wife is very upset with me about this. He didn't get his own dream, but he was born during the eclipse. So that's cool. But my first child, I had a dream. You know, Christine got pregnant and I was late to the baby blessing. This is kind of a common theme and and Latter Day Saints dream life, right?

28:09 You're late to your your kids, men, late to the baby blessing. This is like our first responsibility as dads. We go in there and I'm a chubby guy. That's the context for this. If you're just listening, I look up on the stage. I look up on the stage and there's a chubby kid surrounded by others. And I said, oh, that must be my son. And so I'm running up there giving a blessing and a guy steps for me and says no, no, no, that's not your son. And they pull this little skinny kid out from behind him and puts him in front. And I said, oh, and which is just fun, right? So I, you know, I told Christine, well, we're having a boy and of course my son's like a twig. None of my kids take after me in in size, but that was fun. My next son, I had an experience that still really has a major impact on me.

29:07 I woke up in the dream middle of the night. My child has already been born and it's on my wife's thighs. She's still asleep. And I pick up this baby and it's a boy and he has roots coming off of his head, kind of a, you know, like he's part tree. And so I wake up and I think, what is this? And I I didn't know what to make of it. I said maybe we're supposed to name him something, you know, dealing with trees or or roots or maybe there's something else. But then when he was born, he was born on the call. And so he had the root of his, of his growth, right. The thing that made it so he could get nutrients in his mother still still wrapped around his head when he was born.

29:55 So isn't that interesting? I think there are, they're just little signs. I mean, we're supposed to get revelation about the things that that matter to us. And, you know, I've, I've never had an experience that says, you know, start a business or you need to move to this town to be safe. But about family, you know, these are the experiences I regularly have and I can, I can trust God's going to give in to me. I think that's a very latter day. Same thing when I interview people as a folklorist, that's usually where they can pinpoint and say, oh, do you know what? My mom actually met me before I was born. I met, I meet so many people at BYU who have a story about how their mom met them, which I think is very fun.

30:35 Right. Right. Think you were the child from one of these visions, right? You twins that showed up to your big sister. That's crazy. Yeah, yeah, yeah. No, it was, it was one of those things that that I will hold dear in my heart till I die and and something that was really. Yeah, absolutely. Let me ask you this question as a man who's into to folklore, specifically, you know, Mormon folk folklore. What's the one war that we all swear is true that you later find out isn't? Want more from the Mormon Renegade podcast?

31:18 Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the Fundamental News Program for free. Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button. And for $5 a month you can have access to podcast transcripts, renegade exclusives, as well as weekly Life stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes today. Let me ask you this question as a man who's into to folklore. Specifically, you know, Mormon folk folklore. What's the one roar that we all swear is true that you later find out isn't there's? There's probably plenty of these. It depends on the era.

32:12 You know, we do so well in checking a story after it's big enough. And so when did you join the church? 9595. So I joined the church in 95. It was baptized on April 30th, 1995. I was 14. And the story then that was so that's, I mean it started just a couple years later and you heard too, was generals in the war in heaven, right. Right. And the the church worked so hard to squash this and it took about a decade. But eventually, you know, boy, Kay Packer gives that talk. That's like, hey, when someone tells this story, you have to actually tell them it's not true. And I've never done that.

32:55 I like, I like, you know I don't think it has bad principles to it or anything. So I'm not correcting people. But here's here's an example of that just holding on. You know the the surety people bring us back in the day when we were baptized, we still thought Steve Martin was a closet Mormon, right. We still, we still had these. We had these things that we were all sure about. Oh, what else is big now? You know, some things I I think we're so sure aren't true, actually are true. Right. So. OK, you know, that's that's, that's that's an interesting thought, 'cause I do think that in a weird way now, Chris, we live in an age of unbelief, right?

33:42 I I think, I think we have seen a transition that happened relatively quickly that but but we're almost in an age of disbelief and I don't know if that's maybe I thought about this a little bit. I don't know if maybe it's because of all the tech. I mean the tech we have now like when I was a kid there was no Internet, right? Like my kids minds are blown. I was like there was no Internet. There was cell phones, but you worked on Wall Street. If you had a cell phone and that bad boy, that bad boy was a brick that you carried in a suitcase cause the battery had to be that big. And so, so I I think in some ways the fact that we've had all this technological advancement that quite frankly, I think, you know, if if people from the 19th century could see they'd be like that's miraculous, right. And so I think that that it has maybe tempered that or or at least squashed it.

34:37 But I think we are in an age of of kind of disbelief, a little bit there. That's I think that's right. You know, so often people will write me and say I'm so concerned about this story, will you debunk it? And I think, well, I'm not interested in debunking things. I'm interested in why things are important to people, right as a folklorist. And so and as the latter day saying so, I mean, I think there are dangerous things out there. If Chad Daybell stopped by my house, right, maybe I'd set him straight. But the average person who is who's really just trying to have a relationship with God and serve their family and go to church and whatever, I think, you know, I think they need more belief, not less.

35:23 I don't know that the goal is that they should be super cautious with every story they hear. Within limits, sure. But it is. It's we are in a moment I I, I really think, you know the opening of my show we say the Latter Day Saints tradition is about universalism, apocalypticism and radical belief. And I think, I think that really is the the key to our identity. When the rest of the world is beginning to question everything and change everything, we think, oh, God actually still talks. Of course we think Jesus raised from the dead, but he's called prophets of an art today too.

36:14 And I think people question all of those things. And so it's neat to be part of the people who are trying to hold on tight to keep it, the relief around. And when we don't have it, we probably should check ourselves a bit and say, wait a second, 'cause that sounds like doubt, right? Right. Well, yeah, everything. I think that's good. And and again, I think that's the promise of Mormonism, right. I think that's one of the promises of Mormonism. And quite frankly, it's it's something that I see see as a major thrust of Joseph Smith's ministry, right when when you get down to what he's talking about, he's like, I I've had my experience with the divine and you know what?

36:56 You can have yours. And and sometimes I feel like sometimes I feel like, OK, too chubby guys talk and I know we can both relate to this. It's like if you look to this great buffet and there's a whole bunch of steak and yet all you partake of is a salad. That's just dumb, right? And. And and and that's what I worry about is happening to Mormonism. Here is a little bit is that we're leaving the good stuff untouched. Did did you watch Elder Ukdorf's general conference talk a few years years ago about he did a parable of the cruise?

37:36 Do you know? All right, this is about a guy who gets on a cruise. He's never been on a cruise before. He's going across the Atlantic, and he's brought enough food for himself, but just enough. He's really worried about money and so on. And so he sits and he eats his canned food in his room by himself. And eventually at the end of the cruise he realizes everything was paid for as part of the cruise. Right. He could have been out having fun and eating buffets and and he makes the exact same point that you're making there, right there's we need to live up to all the blessings God wants to give us. And this is the essential blessing of the latter day St. tradition It's it's that gods and that we can be part of that. And I think you're right.

38:19 I mean, the message of the temple itself is that we should be seeking after more truths and and God wants to convey things to us. And yeah, it's pretty awesome. Absolutely. I I think the other thing that that is important from from kind of a a sociological standpoint is that since mankind first started to gather around a fire the thing that that bound and even early civilization together we're we're these stories, right? And and we see, we see this certainly in American history. I'm a huge honk for early in American history like a nerd like that was one of the main reasons I went to Maryland was to just immerse myself in it and you know there's the story of Washington cutting down the Cherry Tree.

39:11 Now we're fairly certain at this point that that incident didn't happen. However, there is there. What? What's that I. Didn't know. I said, that's right, yeah, yeah, yeah. It's 100 years. Our first account is 100 years after it happened, right. So. However, I think it still communicates some certain truth there, right? That that Washington was a man of incredible integrity, right. I think that can be proven and and so it it's it's through our stories right and and we hope that we're only telling true stories now. Inevitably certain stories get told that that may be partially true or not true at all and sometimes I don't think that that's with malicious intent.

39:57 I think as things get passed around the old telephone game, you know, those things get get told differently, but. I think with a lot of these stories, there's always an an echo there. I shouldn't even say an echo. There is a truth that is usually being communicated and that may make us have to to parse that out a little bit. As a guy who deals in that, how do you parse that out? How, how do you get to a point to where you can be like, OK, I'm not sure on the details, but I see what the thrust is here. How? How do you? How do you? Extract that. So my principle, the way I principally do this is that I don't debunk. So I'm always if there's a story, I'm always looking for why someone would tell it.

40:41 Why would this mean something to them? And how does it fit in that worldview that me and my audience does believe in, right? That God speaks and that you know, the miracles happen. And so I, I, I take stories seriously, but I work hard not to, you know, So I might tell you the first time we had this is 100 years after it allegedly happens. You know, great example of this is Messiah Hancock or Oliver B Huntington. These are these Gordon Storytellers, right? Their journals are full of stuff. And I hope every word of it's true, but I doubt it because they record incredible things and statements from Joseph Smith that nobody else records, right. But we have tons of journals.

41:29 And so I started to think hmm so when I use those sources I talk about ideas that were present. You know he they think you know one of the great quotes. I think it's Messiah Hancock. Joseph comes to him and says, I'm John came before the flood. I came before the fire. Right. Like I'm. I'm leading the way for the second coming of Christ. Well I think that's true. I don't think Joseph said it. And so. So I think there's about it where, you know, as a sort of historian, folklorist, I can pull back and say, look, this is an ID at the time. It's possible Messiah Hancock even believes, you know, in his memory that this happened.

42:11 But there's just something about storytelling. You know, there's something about the figure of Joseph people sat down. We have so many, you know, the rabbinical literature. It's just full of these stories that rabbis told about the prophets, about the Old Testament, and they're really, really cool. And I don't say, oh, this story about Enoch is thus true, but I say, here's an idea that's circulating at that moment, right? And then I can decide, like it or why someone would would believe this at the time, Where's it coming from? Who would share this and what setting would they share it? There's all sorts of those those folklore questions we do and that's what I have my students really think about in our classes and and it's important that we just pull back and we give, we give a little empathy to these folks sharing stories. I think it's it's tough to be a storyteller, but I also think we should be wary of individuals who are deliberately seeking to harm a faith community, right?

43:20 So Mark Hoffman's the obvious example. Christopher Namelka is an obvious example. Samuel Schaefer, who who went to prison five years ago, you know, had written dozens of forged documents. I mean, they're just online documents, not selling them or everything, but, you know, alleged endowment ceremonies performed by offshoots and so on. Really fascinating material, but all made-up, right. And so someone gets this stuff and then they think, oh, this is, you know, I've, in this case, I've had to correct people several times about different documents and say, hey, if your goals actually tell the story of this figure, you're you're using the wrong source. Right.

44:04 Right. And that certainly happened when we had things like the Salamander Letter or the Joseph Smith Third Blessed, who've who've had major impacts on the faith. And and those are the dangerous ones, right? Those are the ones that that end up doing harm and. Yes. That's something that I think when we're dealing with with Mormon lore and Mormon, Mormon stories, so to speak, we have to be very careful to sort those out, right, 'cause not every guy telling you a story is a guy who is sincere, or sometimes they are sincere and they're just deceived.

44:49 I mean that's that's the other thing and so you have to weigh that out and and I I think this is this is really where where you can use Chad and Lori Daybell as kind of a a poster child or or a case study and what happens when this goes goes bad, right and that's something you've covered as well. Oh this is this is so important. You know, right now I'm if you watch any podcast on Chad and Lori Daybell, you're going to hear that their ideas are all from Tom Harrison and the book Visions of Glory. You know they want, they want some direct link, someone to blame for this.

45:35 As if Chad and Lori aren't good enough, right? But so they want to reach out and bring in other Latter Day Saints stories and experiences that maybe were influential. But when I read something like Visions of Glory, I don't see the danger in it that other people do. I won't subscribe to all of it, but I don't see it as inherently dangerous. I think things become dangerous when people actually bring the extremism to it, right? I don't think it's dangerous if someone thinks we should move to Rexburg. That's not a dangerous story. But if you say sometimes kids become zombies, well, then that's a perfect point to say. That's the sort of story you need to address, right? If you think, if you think God will inspire you to premeditate a murder, well then yeah, that's a point that we should stop and say what's going on here?

46:35 And that is dangerous. It happens. And in this case, my really concern is that all of those stories become such an LDS thing, right? With Chad and Chandler, Dabel. The same thing that happened with the Lafferty brothers, right? The idea. So Americans tell the story of a of a Mormon murder and then they say this represents something about Chris Blythe and Dave Sanders, right? They they they extrapolate that from it. And so one of the things I do with the the the Chad and Laurie thing is trying to make sense of the stories that they're telling, where they're getting their ideas from, making sense of it, but also showing that this is a it's gotten really twisted from a full Latter Day Saints story, right?

47:22 1800 kids are killed by neglect and abuse every year. That a few of those kids might be Mormon and even might be done for psychotic reasons probably doesn't tell you much about my faith, right? Right. You know, I've. I've read. So, you know, as a fundamentalist, that's something I'm always on the lookout for, right? There's a dude down South named Warren Jeffs who did some damage, right? I I like. I know this is super unkind, but, like, when I get to the other side, I'm gonna be like, can I just get one shot at him just just once? I mean, just turn your head for 10 minutes, let you know I just give me some time.

48:12 Lafferty brothers are another thing, right? Where it painted, it painted the rest of fundamentalism in this, in this light of they're dangerous. They're spooky right now. Truth is, it was one. It was one small part. Just like you can't look at Chad and Laurie Daybell and then assign that to the LDS Church. Because quite frankly, as I read, as I read some of the stuff and and I haven't done the research you have to me, Chad and Laurie Daybell seem as bad as Mormon as, I don't know, a good Stephen King novel. I mean, when you dive into it, it's some pretty horrific things, right?

48:54 I mean it, it doesn't resemble Mormonism that I would recognize from the LES Church, from most fundamentalists I know. I mean, it it it bears no, no resemblance to to the religion that Joseph would have started. You know Dave, this this is something you know, as we talk about kind of leaving the academic side here when we talk about how to tell when something's maybe not right, you know, discernment. Joseph Smith is emphasizing our ability to get revelation and then he's emphasizing discernment right. Try the spirits shake angel's hands know what they look like. You know, all sorts of stuff where we're we're being taught to double check revelation. And I think one of the great ones, Brigham talks about this quite a bit is when someone's revelations are really just about how great they are, right.

49:44 If someone shows you and their their major message is that they're special. They're the one, mighty and strong. They should be an apostle. They should be the future you know Levitical servant. You know whatever is you know that doesn't make sense right. The message of just unless you're Jesus unless it's the book of Matthew like the message that you're special has never been the message of a prophet. Right. That that the prophet himself is. And I think this is we see this and it's a really easy way to detect like oh if every one of your revelations is self-serving maybe we need to step back And that's true even of ourselves, right. If we're if we're believing we're getting revelations but they're really just about how great we are. And you know I think there's this this in the LDS church there's a a desire for men to be bishops and stuff right. And so they're constantly thinking about this. And in fundamentalism there's sometimes a desire to be a prophet, right, To hold the keys, to be the one that that's next in line.

50:53 You know, we have dozens of schisms and things and I think those are all those are easy to pinpoint and say, look, this is a really self-serving thing and I think it's unhealthy. And so when I tell my friends, and I've had more than one who come to me and say I think I'm the one mighty and strong, I say I don't think you are. And I said it to their wives too when they say it because I think it's, I think it's unhealthy for them too, right. Like the general belief is my belief. I mean, I believe in messianic figures and the gods bring this all together for the last days and so on. But no, I don't think.

51:36 I think this is something that's all the way back from the 1850s and before Latter Day Saints who want we want to be part of that last day's events. And so we think instead of being like Brigham said, that great man that the Bible says nothing about, we want to be somebody specific. And it's certainly something I read a lot about, so. You know, when when it comes to guys, well, let me say this, when someone asks me how I'm. I'm so certain that the Lord was the one who inspired the Doctrine and Covenants and someone says, how do you, how do you know that for sure? You know what? What makes you say that? Well, I've had some, you know, from from the spiritual aspect. I've, I've had a spiritual witness of that.

52:18 But if we look at this forensically, no leader who's seeking to for just power would ever write documents in which the Lord hands him his rear end more than what Joseph gets it handed to him in the Doctrine and Covenants by the Lord from time to time, right. I mean the the Lord, the Lord gives it to Joseph a few times, right. So going back to this thing of self-serving, right, we don't get that out of the Doctrine and Covenants a whole lot. We you know he he does chastise Joseph as well as others from time to time and and it doesn't have that same feel. The the other thing I would say is that when it comes to the to the one mighty and strong, I've always said if you gotta tell me you're the one mighty and strong, you're not the one mighty and strong. I hate to break that to you, but that's just hilarious to it, right?

53:10 I mean, that should be readily apparent without you having to tell me. So yeah, those sorts of things. See the other thing that that I've noticed as I've encountered a few guys who were off their their rockers they're really good too about not only having a revelation telling them how good they are but sometimes they'll even say oh and and and you're really cool too right. Like I I've I've heard this and they'll kind of flatter you with with that or another term is is kind of baffle you with BS but that's that's kind of thing they'll they'll seek kind of kind of you know vain flattery kind of thing. Yeah.

53:53 You know Dave, when I was 18, I I was exchanging, I was corresponding with a latter day schismatic leader and I can remember him one telling me I was one of the 144,000 saying how are you so righteous? You're so young, obviously you're one of these. And then writing me a letter about how lonely he was, being the only one to know he was a prophet, and how he needs me to get that revelation too. I thought, oh, and as of course, then I said, all right, I gotta get out of here. But as an adult, I recognize that's really manipulative. Right. There's something about that. I think.

54:33 I think that's important that we pinpoint the sort of, you know, the series of events that happens for for some of these moments. But yeah, you're right. Those are the things People have revelations about themselves. And then they point to like, immediate followers and say, oh, guess what? You're really special too. And that's how you that's how you bring people in. Certainly Chad Daybell's a great example of that. In a couple weeks, I'm doing an episode on multiple mortal probations, I guess I'll call it Estates, and talking about how he used sort of mapping out people's past lives in order to to gain more control, right? To bring everybody in and let them know that they were actually his children and past lives and so on. Really fascinated and.

55:36 Yeah but you know that's that's something else I never you know myself I've never bought into is is the idea of multiple mortal probations cause quite frankly everyone who has them have either been Julius Caesar or Cleopatra. Right. It's never like me post the dunkart polar boy who gets run over by the runaway dunkart. It's always somewhat super important the the, the, you know, I've also said before for guys who think they're really special and really important, they have to be crazy. Because as a guy who I try to stay very grounded, that seems like a lot of work and that just doesn't suit who I am. I'd rather be on the couch eating Doritos, but that's just me. That's right.

56:18 Well, hopefully hanging with our kids, right? So like our real, I think Section 121 makes it clear like there's leadership and so on, is a whole bunch of trials. Like, you got to make sure you're not being abusive and so on. You're not practicing priest craft. You're not manipulating. And at the end of the day, like, you know the great thing we've been called to be as fathers, this is the this is the restoration in action. You don't have to imagine being a Bishop or a prophet. You've already been given this work, and you can still get Revelation for it. And so on so. Right, absolutely. As as you've done done your research on on all these different lores, all these different events, what has surprised you the most in doing all the research Cause like your your episodes average about 1/2 hour, right?

57:12 Somewhere between 15 minutes to 1/2 hour I've noticed. But what people don't understand is there's a lot of work that goes into that pre and post production, right? So there's a ton of research that has to be done on the front end. So in all your research, what's one thing that that has just surprised you as you've gone through this? Are we talking about the Chad Devil episodes or the other episodes? What are? Any of them. Any of them. Both of them. You know, I love. I love learning stories. Learning stories that I've heard told to me by someone you know.

57:55 The Temple Apparition episodes. One of my favorites. I once had this woman on my mission say to me, I went to the temple today and the person really didn't want to do their work. And because whenever I tried to put on my clothes, it would be pulled back like she's like wrestling with a spirit in the temple, I thought, that's the weirdest thing I've ever heard of my life. And and then I found that there are many accounts of people saying just this thing. And so often the thing I think so interesting is that the story that I think's obscure, maybe related to just one person, is actually an experience and a a story that resonates with us so much that's actually been told many, many times, even maybe sometimes even when people don't even realize it, that this sort of experience brings similar of similar stories about it and similar experiences, of course with Chad Dabel. Do you know the thing that has surprised me the most is all of the people?

59:05 Well, I'll tell you this, learning where Chad developed ideas. And so we're we're studying, you know, this one guy and the terrible theology he developed that led to the murder of these kids. But he's he's kind of just a a sponge for ideas that he brought in and then twisted and so you know his ideas of four States and exalted gods coming down, he's, I mean he's practically plagiarizing this from people we can just specifically pinpoint, including people that I've studied in the past.

59:49 And you know, on this, this reincarnation episode, I'm going to talk about a man I met when I was a teen who told me I was a fourth estate being and that I was one of the 144,000. And this man, actually, I I said how, How is it? How does Chad Dabell's theology borrow from that thing? I heard from this guy 25 years ago now, and just last week I was talking to one of Dabell's former friends interviewing him. And I learned that indeed he had found this man's writings and they meant something to him. You know, he was, he was developing his theology from him.

1:00:32 And so all the ties that you can find and you know individuals who are out, you know, unfortunately they're seeking, seeking light but making it very, very dark as they do so. But that to me was was shocking. It's very interesting. And of course the biggest shock to this is that this man somehow had so many people believing he was such a great guy. I don't understand how that works. I really want to think that if you would harm a child that there's some way I could see you and recognize the danger, you know, and maybe some of us would have been able to, but it's sure a a tragic story that so many weren't.

1:01:21 Absolutely. And and I think I think that's where this idea of of storytelling can can really kind of go off the rails, right. Because look, I don't know the the the Chad Dabell story and and Lori Dabell story as well as you do. But I imagine that it doesn't start out dark, right? It gets that way over some time, right. And so maybe while it might be a little fringe to begin with, it doesn't end at just being fringe. It goes in a different direction and and I think. That's right. I I also I remember I heard my dad say something once and and he said a madman will always tell you who he is you just have to be willing to listen and and sometimes I think that that maybe not necessarily believe but take them serious right you see something going in a weird direction.

1:02:25 I think it's super important at that point to before it goes off the rails to try to get that guy back on track, right? Put an arm around and be like dude, you are. Flirting with some. Bad stuff. And so that. I think that's part, part that that can be part of the danger, right, is that you gotta, you gotta be able to set some bounds and have kind of a, a, a, a feel for when something's going off the rails. And that's, I think that's hugely important when you deal with with a lot of this. You know, in this case there are there's, you know, energy work and reincarnation and these things. There might be a warning sign they're not things I've subscribed to, but I don't think there's anything inherently dangerous in them.

1:03:12 Right. But the second chat spells second. They're justifying an affair, right? There's moments that happened a year before the murder where every one of his friends should have been saying what? This doesn't make sense, right? What? How? How could you reason this? So I do think we can show a decline. And and I think it does start with often in these stories, it starts with the revelation that you're really special, right? And with that, it's not just that you're gonna be a leader, but it's that morality doesn't function the same for you as it does for other people, right. Dave Sanders needs to keep the capacity, but not me.

1:03:55 I've had this revelation that I'm an exception. So I think you're right. There are these these revealing moments where where people should jump ship. Yeah, all right. I I wanna go back to to to to kind of the the happier side of of lore here for a minute. Let's do it. Hey, Yeah. We we we kind of we we kind of went down a dark Rd. there for a minute. Chris, I don't envy you for having to do the daybell stuff either. Let's just get that, you know, like, you know, the. Daybell stuff. I'm only gonna keep up till September. I I It really bothers me.

1:04:36 This is the third time I'm doing. I'm using this as a rough draft for a book, but you know, I even named it a different name. So it's Angels and Seer Stones is the big podcast, and then it's Demons and Pendulums is the Chad based health podcast. I wanna make sure clear they're separate projects. Yeah, yeah, I was. I was gonna say don't don't get rid of those entirely. Because look, to be honest with you, I thought about doing the Chad and Daybell stuff, and I'm like, so when I saw you were doing them, I'm like, Oh yeah, I'm just going to point people that direction. I don't want to touch it. So good, good, good on you. Well, hopefully the impact dies down. Yep, Yep, absolutely.

1:05:19 So, So back to kind of the the lighter side of this stuff. When when your, your run-of-the-mill Mormon has this, these experiences, what would you recommend they do with them? Right. We we've talked about there's kind of a time and a place for everything, but at the same time you can be too guarded in these things. So, So what? What does the average member do with these things? Well, I think one, we should write them down. I believe that I think we should share them and our families. I don't think we have. I mean I suppose there could be some things we wouldn't share with our families but for the most part I think we want people to know about our interactions with God.

1:06:10 I, in fact I was just got off the phone with someone whose father had told them about a a vision that he'd had. You know this is a faithful church guy you know this the the vision is just about sort of spirit world thing. You think about Russell and Nelson, right before he's called his prophet, does a Roots tech meeting, a Roots tech conference, you know, a genealogy thing. And he brings a vision that his grandpa had about the spirit world, about seeing his own father. And what he does in this meeting is he brings up his grandkids to read them this story. And so we all watch this.

1:06:52 And I think that was sort of providing an example, right? We we share it with our posterity. We share it with our family, and this functions as a really sacred space. This is the homes, a temple, because we can do things in the home we wouldn't do in other settings, and it's a sacred spot. And so one of that is that we can share these great experiences there. I think you can also have moments where you build trust with someone, with this person. And in those cases, you might feel inspired to share something that you wouldn't share over the pulpit, right, Or write in a book. I So I think we should write them. I think we should share them.

1:07:32 So we shouldn't put up these huge, you know, never, never share them. Boyd K Packer says that the key is to make sure you feel the spirit tell you before you share one of these things. And when you share someone else's sacred experience, you make sure that they shared it in a public setting. You make sure that they they're the ones taking the lead on how widely it should be shared. So if they only told you privately, of course you would never share someone else's experience, right? Whereas if they told you in front of a group of 1020 people, you might be able to share that experience at some future time. Gotcha. Gotcha. Yeah, I I guess that would be would be my thing right.

1:08:14 Like I think because we we are living in the time we are an an age of kind of disbelief right. Even within religion which I find which I find interesting right. I've heard people try to to I I shouldn't say debunk but maybe explain you know how Joseph went about formulating the Book of Mormon and those sorts of things and I'm like do we need to do this right. Do we need to go down this road we're all stepping right. Right. Let let's just let the history stand. Let's let Joseph say what it is he said happened happened. But I I guess for me this is something that that I don't think you should necessarily seek after but when they do happen I I I think as long as as the message is is one that that promotes faith in the savior promotes you know family unity those sorts of things. I think that that those are gifts and I think we need to treat them as such.

1:09:17 Right. I've, I've often said just like a jewelry box. You know, I remember my my grandmother had a jewelry box and she would keep really special jewelry in there. And so it might not be jewelry that she gets out every day, but when the occasion calls, it was there. And sometimes I think these stories are kind of like that, right? You want to keep them someplace special and safe, but you also want to wear them from time to time. And you want to be able to to not necessarily show them off, but but to to put them on and to to allow them to speak for themselves. Love it. And. And we should learn these stories too, you know, Especially stories for the 19th.

1:10:01 We should learn them and be able to share those and not not be ashamed of those stories, of course, both our own and last ones. Yeah, I really like that jewels that we bring out from time to time and and and of course in the best settings are when someone wears their jewels. So, right, right. Yeah, that's a great message. Well dude, that's good stuff. Where can where can folks find Find your podcast? They can find it everywhere, but Apple podcast or YouTube is what usually people go to. I think like 60% of our. So you do video or just audios?

1:10:45 Do you do video or? Just only do audio. OK, we just do audio, but on YouTube you can see a nice image as you hear nice her voice. Nice. Yep, I I did that for AI did that for a while. I'm. I'm on Rumble and I I went with just the logo for a while and Yep, Rumble and I I did that for a while where I just had kind of the logo up and then people kept were like well we'd like to see we'd like to see it. I'm like really once you look at me you're you're you're going to regret this decision I'm trying to save you pain but but anyway I I gave them the option but awesome good stuff.

1:11:28 Well, OK. My wife, my wife is beautiful, so people would want to see her. But you know the the contrast isn't something I want won't go in live. No, no, I I will say this, but both both the girls have have declined. They went on somebody else's podcast but they won't come on mine. So hate that for what it's worth. Well, that's they. Yeah. Yeah, they they won't be. I have husband and wife. I will. 'Cause that would be a really good episode. I mean that That's like, I could just turn on the mic and walk away. I mean, that's perfect. But no, that that's good stuff for sure, man. Well, dude, as these things keep going on, as you keep doing these episodes, let's get back on here from time to time, because there's some specific ones I'd like to ask you about, in particular, the three knee fights, that sort of stuff, Right.

1:12:22 Get a little more specific, but I won't, I won't take up any more time, any more of your time tonight. I appreciate you coming on, man. I'd be happy to. Maybe we should do a White Horse Prophecy one down the road. Dude, that'd be awesome. That'd be awesome. I'm down. I'm down. Let's do that. That'd be good. Awesome. All right. Sounds good. Thanks again, Chris. Bye everybody.