April 13, 2024

Episode #126: DNA Research & The Book of Mormon W/Ken Peterson

Episode #126: DNA Research & The Book of Mormon W/Ken Peterson
Episode #126: DNA Research & The Book of Mormon W/Ken Peterson
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #126: DNA Research & The Book of Mormon W/Ken Peterson

Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content.

Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products

https://gofund.me/37ee9079

One of the things that often rocks the testimony of Mormons is when the historicity of the Book of Mormon is questioned, and it appears that there are some conflicts between science and the Book of Mormon. The truth is however that usually what is thrown into question isn’t the historicity of the Book of Mormon itself but rather narratives that we as individuals read into the text. This is never more on display than when the issue of DNA raised as a critique to the Book of Mormon. I mean if the Book of Mormon is true and details the account of a Middle Eastern family’s settlement of a portion of the New World, we should expect that DNA from Middle Eastern people and some native American populations should match right? Well maybe not as much as you would think. Ken Peterson joins me again on the podcast to break all of this down. By the end I think you might find out like I did that many of the so-called conflicts between the Book of Mormon and DNA research are more conflicts between the narratives we read into the Book of Mormon and the DNA research then with the text itself.

--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support

0:05 One of the things that often rocks the testimony of Mormons is when the historicity of the Book of Mormon is called into question, and it appears that there might be some conflicts between science and the Book of Mormon. The truth is, however, that usually what is thrown into question isn't the historicity of the book itself, but rather the narratives that we as individuals read into that text. This is never more on display than when the issue of DNA is raised as a critique to the Book of Mormon. I mean, if the Book of Mormon is true and details the account of a Middle Eastern family settlement of a portion of the New World, we should expect to see that DNA from Middle Eastern people and some Native American population should match, right? Well, maybe not so much. Ken Peterson joins me again on the podcast to break all of this down.

0:48 By the end, I think you might find out, like I did, that many of the so-called conflicts between the Book of Mormon and DNA research are more conflicts with the narratives that we as people construct about the Book of Mormon and that DNA research. And that's next on this episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast. So a few weeks back I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running. Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page, or click the link in this episode's show notes, you'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups and water bottles, all with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU.

1:41 But you should definitely go check that out now. This is just the beginning. In the coming weeks, more designs and styles will be available for purchase. Now, all the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast, so head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode's show notes and get yours today.

2:31 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Ken, what's going on? Everything. Everything. Just living, you know. I hear you. Doing live and watching it. You have to keep my eyes over the end of the world. You know, all that stuff. Yeah, just just that stuff, right? Well dude, have you heard about the red heifer? Yes. That's to me, that's crazy, right? Like, they don't show up often. Like, there's been like nine of them and there's only supposed to be 10 before quote, Messiah comes according to Jewish tradition.

3:11 And yeah, I'm just saying we got that going for us now, So we have red cows. A lot going on, yeah. My first thought was, do they taste like normal cows? Like, I'm kind of intrigued now, right? Like, what's your first my Yeah, right after is Jesus's coming back? My next thought was, how does that cow taste? I wonder how red heifers taste. Yeah. How would I prepare that? Right, right. Are we talking like 2 minutes each side get the nice grill mark, salt and pepper? I mean, what are we talking? But. True carnivore, True carnivore. Anyway, dude, I am so jacked up for this one DNA in the book of Mormons.

3:54 So for for the longest time, believing Mormons have kind of been beat up over this issue a little bit, right? Oh, and it keeps coming back. Yeah, like people keep saying show us, show us somebody with Middle Eastern DNA here. And so with when when you told me about this, I was like, oh, we gotta do this one, We've gotta do this one. So I remember the morning it first hit the papers that I was aware of. I was teaching elders quorum at the time and I was preparing the lesson. Then the I got the Sunday paper and the headline was the DNA Proves the Book of Mormon False. I changed my priesthood lesson.

4:39 In a way we went but but we'll we'll get into all of that. I once again I'm I'm always grateful for these chances with you to get all my ducks in a row so to speak. To get all the information together and look at it again and you'll always learn something new in the process and and always and struck with a sense of wonder the marvelous work and a wonder that the restored gospel is ultimately coming out the other side. So so we're we're gonna we're gonna go down some rabbit holes. I'd like to start with just a primer. It's gonna feel like a biology class for a minute by a nucleus headquarters of the cell and within the nucleus as you can see are chromosomes and those chromosomes are comprised of DNA.

5:36 What is DNA? Deoxyribonucleic acid is the molecule that Canary that carries genetic information for the development and functioning of an Organism. It's the computer code that determines, that determines every aspect, physically, mentally and otherwise, of who and what you are outside of behavioral traits that we are influenced. Within life, you know. It's made of two links. It's like it's like a ladder that twists around like a twisted ladder. The double Helix is what it's called. DNA was first discovered back in 18 about 1874 by this Doctor Who was cleaning up, saw some pus on a bandage and noticed some stuff on it. But the the double Helix hadn't wasn't identified until the 1950s.

6:28 Nineteen 54 by Doctor Watson and a couple others and they won the Nobel Prize. DNA analysis was first used for identifying perpetrator of a crime in 1986 to show you how kind of how recent it is. And we won't talk about the these four bases that create the rungs of the ladder. The sequence of the bases encode the biological information, such as the instructions for making a protein or an RNA molecule, which is the messenger molecule. The person who wrote this, that I'm quoting here from thegenome.gov then says this very, very interesting thing. Is there a more amazing molecule than DNA? It makes each of us who we are.

7:22 The DNA from any two people is 99.9% identical, with that shared blueprint guiding our development form a common thread across the world. That's kind of neat to know, yeah. The diff, the differing .1%, contains variations that influence our uniqueness. Which one, combined with our environmental and social context, give us our abilities, our health, our behavior. How can one single molecule contain so much mystery and wonder? I'll think about it. Every cell of your body has this computer code, this genetic fingerprint that is responsible for who making you who you are.

8:03 There are no two of us that are the same. Now, a little more detail just to talk about the complexity of this molecule. So what you're seeing is a chromosome, which kind of shows you how the DNA is coiled around inside of it. DNA usually occurs as linear chromosomes and eukaryotes and circular chromosome. In prokaryotes, the set of chromosomes in a cell makes up its genome. The human genome has approximately 3 billion base pairs of DNA arranged into 46 chromosomes. A gene is a sequence of DNA that contains genetic information and can influence the phenotype of an Organism, which are its physical characteristics or always characteristics. This this image here is a diagram of how the DNA cell replicates itself.

9:02 Reading from left to right, it divides itself in half and then reassembles itself with another half, thereby creating 2 strands of DNA where there was just one. So not only is it super complex, the way it replicates, it's like a machine. Look at all the parts and the processes involved, the things that the things that we utterly take for granted in humans. The total female diploid nuclear genome per cell. So one nuclear genome in one cell extends for 6.37 giga base pairs, that's 6.37 billion base pairs.

9:49 It is if you if there's so many of them that it would stretch 7 feet, you couldn't even see it, but it would be that. That's how much male value is a little less, anyway. Yeah, Holy. Cow. 208 centimeters. Each DNA polymer can contain hundreds of millions of nucleotides, such as in chromosome #1, which is the largest human chromosome with approximately 220 million base pairs. It would be 3 1/2 inches long if it were straight. Now, all right, you get So as as I was putting this together, the sense of awe and wonder.

10:33 I mean, the first time I heard about some biology, I was going to sleep. But as an adult, I'm going wow. Yeah. This is miraculous. This is evolution. Is is amazing, isn't it? Yeah, Evolution. Yeah, Yeah, it's, it's fantastic. How? You know private prior in one of our earlier discussions we talked about there are various scientists who are jumping ship from Darwinism, most of them being molecular biologists.

11:13 And just looking at what we've looked at in terms of how the cell is run and how the body is coded and how it's produced, how, how in the hell is this stuff supposed to self assemble from nothing? How does that happen? Well, and just the just the complexity, right? Yeah, just the complexity of alone is is enough to say no, it's computer code, right? And just like all code, there has to be an author. Billions. Right. Billions of bits of code. So the Wikipedia website on DNA, It's really it's more information you'll ever want to know.

11:57 But one of the sections that I really wanted to quote because I thought you would find it interesting is how DNA and its relevance to human evolution. And here it is. DNA contains the genetic information that allows all forms of life to function, grow and reproduce. Duh. However, it is unclear how long in the 4 billion year history of life DNA has performed this function as it has been proposed that the earliest forms of life may have used RNA as their genetic material. Why would they say that that that is a straight up admission that abiogenesis life spontaneously generating on earth, especially in the form of DNA is impossible.

12:47 Yeah, I mean that's what that that's an admission. Oh well then it must be something simpler that evolved like RNA. RNA is. Half of the of DNA. So instead of the whole ladder, you only got one side with the rungs attached to it, right? You know what the problem is with RNA? What's that? It doesn't replicate. It doesn't replicate. It can't recreate itself. DNA replicates, RNA does not. It would be a lot like, again, creating something out of nothing. Yes, the complexity of that, let alone to get it to work, let alone to have a male species and a female aspect of the species combined to reproduce. Which is also interesting because each cell has different forms of DNA in it and they never interact. They stay in their own zones until reproduction occurs. Only then does the DNA recombine the male with the female. Interesting evolution is evolution is miraculous. I was gonna say how.

13:58 It can do that. I know, I know, I was gonna say. Now it is taking into account things like guys who think they should be women, right? The DNA is taking in. Taking. Account. Of then there's that aspect of it. I I'm just curious. I mean, I'm just wondering how the DNA does that. I I don't know. Well, and here's the sad, But I don't know what's sad, but the fact of the matter is, it doesn't matter what you do to your body in terms of its appearance, of what kind of hormones you take to try and imitate or mimic the opposite sex. Every single cell in your body is either male or female, and that's not going to change.

14:51 Wow, the hate that comes from DNA. Just the hate. Only two genders. Sorry, I mean, but that's and that's a hard fact. I and I and I say that not to condemn. I have good friends, dear friends, who are experiencing transgenderism and it's a hard thinking. I have all the care and love that I can muster that I have for these people. I really do care about them and I don't. I don't have answers for them.

15:39 But the the the fact that the the sad fact for transgenders is you. You really can't. You can't change your structural cellular DNA makeup. You just can't. No. If if you're born a guy, you're always a guy. There's no way around that. So getting back to how evolution addresses DNA, well, so it must have come. RNA must have somehow done it first, which led to DNA. This ancient RNA world, where nucleic acid would have been used for both catalysis, catalysis and genetics may have influenced the evolution of the current genetic code based on 4 nucleotide bases. However, there is no direct evidence of ancient genetic systems as recovery of DNA for most fossils is impossible because DNA survives in the environment for less than 1,000,000 years.

16:36 This is amazing. The oldest bit of DNA that has been sequenced thus far is over a million years old. It survives that long from a woolly map. Pretty crazy. We'll talk more about that. Here's my favorite part. Building blocks of DNA may have been formed extraterrestrially in outer space. Complex DNA and RNA, organic compounds of life including Eurosol blah blah blah blah, have also been formed in the laboratory under conditions mimicking those found in outer space using starting chemicals such as pyramidine found in meteorite. OK, so I'm gonna put put forward a crazy idea. So let's just say there was this all omnipotent being who then placed another individual in some place, I don't know, like a garden.

17:30 Is that what they mean by extraterrestrial? This is what I think is funny. That I mean, you read the rest of the article and it's highly scientific and very technical. Then you read these two paragraphs and they're just dumb. They're dumb. We've just read about the incalculable complexities of how the cell reproduces, how it even operates, and how it the complexity of it, and the the interconnectedness of all of those systems. It's so mind boggling. You know what mechanical engineer would take a week to get that all figured out. Yeah.

18:12 It's so mind boggling that you know that couldn't self assemble. No. Statistically, and this is a fact statistically, that those all of those billions of bits should come together in and of themselves to produce complex life forms like us is statistically impossible. Absolutely. That's not an exaggeration. No matter it doesn't. 4 1/2 billion years wouldn't even come close, right? You give it an infinite amount of time, it's not gonna happen. Sorry. Anyway, so and they admit that right off the bat? Well, then maybe it was RNA. Then realizing that that couldn't happen on Earth too.

18:53 Well, maybe it happened in outer space. Let's kick the can down the road. That's how it happened. I mean that's just that's desperate. It It is desperate, right? For a football game, it would it would be a punt, you know. Anyway, I thought you'd appreciate. No, I I do cause 'cause it's like, hey, we might have this possible explanation in this dusty old book and they're like, Nah, get that out of here. The aliens did it. That's what did it. And it was in in Darwin's era, it was easy for him to come up with that theory of human evolution because they did not have any knowledge of the cellular structure of microbiology.

19:36 They didn't know any of that stuff. The molecular biologist are looking at this and going now. There's no way. All right, DNA profiling. Forensic scientists now can use DNA in blood, semen, skin, saliva or hair found at a crime scene to identify the matching DNA of an individual, such as a perpetrator. First time in 1986. This process is formally termed DNA profiling, also called DNA fingerprinting. And may I also add, it made for great TV when Maury Povich would say with 99.9% certainty you are or not the father.

20:19 So I mean it did give us that Jim, so. Well, we'll get to that. So DNA profiling is also used successfully positively identified victims of mass casualty incidents. Like the Twin Towers. DNA profiling is also used in DNA fraternity testing. Pardon my asthma. It's all good. The probability of parentage is typically 99.99%. That's how accurate it is. But here's where the Book of Mormon comes into this discussion.

21:09 Because DNA collects mutations over time, which are then inherited, it contains historical information. And by comparing DNA sequences, geneticists can infer the evolutionary history of organisms, the phylogeny, the physical traits. This can be used in studies ranging from ecological genetics to anthropology. Human migration, genealogical DNA testing methods have been used on a longer time scale to trace human migratory patterns. For example, they determined when the first humans came to North America and what path they followed.

21:50 And we'll talk now the science, the science of that is not finished. There probably never will be in this life. But what we have is fascinating. For several years, researchers and laboratories from around the world sampled indigenous populations from around the globe in an effort to match. In an effort to map historical human migration patterns, the National Geographic Society's Geographic Project aims to map historical historical human migration patterns by collecting and analyzing DA samples from over 100,000 people across 5 continents. You want to see the map. Yeah, I do.

22:30 There you go. Looks like a quilt. They. Categorize these these DNA traits into groups called haplogroups HAPLO haplogroups and they label them with the letters of the alphabet starting with A. And the further into the alphabet you get, the closer to our time it becomes. So haplogroups B&C are derived from haplogroup A the originate the original haplogroup. OK.

23:11 Getting down to like, Z now, what you'll notice we'll talk more about this in a minute, is that the Western Hemisphere looks less like a patchwork quilt than the Old World. Yep. Interesting. Yeah. In fact, the South, Central and North America, with the exception of Canada, Alaska is essentially 1 haplogroup Q is what it's called. So we'll get to that. But that I I could stare at this for hours. You know, just consider especially the biblical history and that sort of thing about what's going on here. So Ken, let me ask you this, have they found a way to date DNA right?

24:02 Oh yeah, cause 'cause I would be interested. Obviously there's some mass migrations we're well aware of, right? The settling in the world, that's pretty easy to go. OK, This happened here and then we saw see this influx here. But anciently can, can they, can they date that DNA to say, OK, it's some time between this date and this date. Yes. Yeah, very precisely, which is why you'll notice like just look at the Americas again, we'll talk in more detail later on. In the Americas, you'll see the predominance of two haplotypes, haplotype CC-3 and haplotype Q3. OK.

24:42 All right. They happened at different times. C came first, they're the progenitors, and then Q happened. Most currently believe that the new world of the Western Hemisphere, the American continent, was populated in three waves. And I'll just let you Stew on that for a minute while we we'll come back to it. But let's let's get on with. Pete, can I ask one more question about this map? So where where they're mapping, we'll just look at at at the new World here we look at Q3 and like QC 10 and that sort are those native populations or are those the populations living there today?

25:26 Those are the indigenous, the native populations. Yeah, this is, this is pre European. Colonization. Which that's what they're trying to do is determine the, the origin of these indigenous groups, which is really, it is the coolest thing ever to see them do this. You know, right or wrong, I would totally do this. I mean, just to see, right? All right, let's go on. So here begins our story of of the Genesis, the beginning of this straw man argument that people use to disprove the Book of Mormon. And this is the argument. The understanding of Joseph Smith and of traditional Mormonism is the Book of Mormon.

26:08 Book of Mormon reveals that some American Indians are descendants of the Lamanites who descended from Lehigh and are therefore a remnant of the House of Israel. So far so good. Yep. Mormon researchers such as anthropologist Thomas Murphy and I, I'll point out here. We'll talk about him in more detail, but he's not a practicing Latter Day St. No. Yeah, he hasn't been doing it for a. Couple of years. Yeah, and ex. Mormon plant geneticist Simon Sutherton state that the substantial collection of Native American genetic genetic markers now available are not consistent with any detectable presence of ancestors from the ancient Middle East.

26:52 They have argued that this poses substantial evidence to contradict the account of the Book of Mormon. And they have both come out and said, essentially that Joseph Smith is a fraud and that the Book of Mormon is a faith-based on that. And we'll just say right now that the majority, the vast majority of Native American indigenous DNA is Asian. Asian right, Which includes them at least, right. No, but we'll talk, we'll talk about that too because there is that we'll get to that after all this. But no, we're like East Asian, so we're talking. About East Asian OK.

27:37 And I have to tell you, my understanding is that Native Americans don't like that. I think I could understand. But yeah, it's Asian DNA. Well, we're good. So this is Thomas, Born in 67, earned his PhD in anthropology, University of Washington in 2003. His dissertation was this study about the Lamanites and trying to find this. And they're both nice guys. I mean, they're not out there starting fires. I mean, they have hit back because there have been some insensitive Mormons who kind of come.

28:17 After them and. Sure. But even and and they've both been on John Daylon's Mormon Stories podcast, and they're not. They're they're humble about it. They're not. They're not trying to pick fight. They're just trying to live their lives. And I have, I empathize with him. If I were an anthropologist or a genetic scientist and I saw an opportunity to double check the Book of Mormon claims, I would have jumped at that chance just like they did. And I don't have any issues with their findings. I I I think their findings are accurate.

28:59 I don't want necessarily their findings, but findings of others and and it has been confirmed over the decades since they first published in 2003 and 2004. What I take issue with, and what we'll talk about tonight, is the application of what has been found, #1 and #2, the premise for the study, which is the straw man. Right. Right. And then, of course, as professionals, they should also recognize the limitations of the study that they were trying to do. And we'll talk more about that. So his dissertation came out first, and then he published his book, Lamanite, Genesis, Genealogy and Genetics.

29:44 He posited that DNA evidence suggests that Native Americans are descendants of individuals from northeastern Siberia, and it's we know more that it's more Asian than that. Now, corroborating conclusions of the anthropologist of Long Hill, so that's his story. He writes that DNA and other research contradicts numerous LDS doctrinal claims, such as Native Americans are descended from Middle Eastern people. And there's his first error. Native Americans are descended for Middle Eastern people, immigrated to the Americas in 600 BC Is that what the Book of Mormon teaches Well?

30:25 Doesn't it say that in the title page that the Lamanites were of the seed of Lehigh who came out of the Middle East right in? 1981 In the introduction The Book of Mormon, which is written in 1981, which is not a part of the gold plates, Bruce Mcconkey or someone under his direction, wrote that the Lamanites were the principal ancestors of the Native Americans. In light of this discovery, that was changed in the early 2000s to read that the Lamanites are among the ancestors of the Native Americans. Does that make sense?

31:11 Yeah. We'll talk about that, too. So he has likened the Book of Mormon to inspirational fiction. It's a problem. His view of genetic research was expanded upon by molecular molecular biologist Simon Sutherton, a former Mormon Bishop, with his study Losing a Lost Tribe, Native American DNA in the Mormon Church, published in 2004. Mormon scholars and concessions by geneticists from BYU Let's see accounting, the current status of Allegis, and Native American in context of national studies. Other researchers, like Scott Woodward from BYU, who's a genetics A geneticist, are critical of Sutherton's work. And we'll talk about those.

31:59 But that's Thomas Murphy's story. So far, so good. Yep. So his state president asked him to recant his position or to resign from the church. He declined to do both. So they were going to call a a council to disfellowship or excommunicate him. It received widespread attention and less than 24 hours before the scheduled meeting where he would be excommunicated his fellowship, they indefinitely postponed his disciplinary council. So he's still a member of record, even though he doesn't believe it and as unattended him, and he really, I mean you watched the interview. He really seems like a nice and a thoughtful guy. So there's a Simon Sutherton.

32:52 He was a member of the church, converted at age 10. He was a Bishop in Melbourne, and he tells a story while he was a Bishop. He woke up one morning and didn't believe it anymore. After pondering some of his stuff, he resigned. His Bishop in 98 left the church after his book was published. The church charged him with apostasy. Sutherton stated that he was, and this is neither here nor there, but he was excommunicated for being too vocal regarding the results of the genomics product project DNA. However, those who attended his disciplinary council contended that the excommunication had nothing to do with the book. In an interview with Mormon podcast host John Delenn, Southerton explained that he was prevented from talking about his position regarding the DNA evidence in connection with book.

33:44 Morning clarified that the excommunication was not for adultery, but rather for inappropriate relations with a woman. During a period of time he was separated from his wife. This was after he'd left the church and his wife left with him. Although a little delayed from him, I'm pleased to say that they have been happily married 50 years. Since so, I'm I'm glad. That they're happy together. According to him. Anyway, so that's his story. And for those of you who want more information, his book, by the way, doesn't talk just about DNA again, because he I I think he clearly felt offended by the reaction of many Latter Day Saints, you know, for him attacking their faith through this DNA thing. He actually wrote a book.

34:34 His book looks a lot more like the CES Letter than it does a scientific book about DNA. DNA is only a single chapter of multiple chapters of of criticisms about the Church of Jesus. Christ of Latter Day Saints. Anyway, So what fair Latter Day Saints has done, and you can see the summary of claims here. They do this with these anti Mormon works that make this doughnut. 14% of his book is fact, 36% is spin, 30% are mistakes and 20% are flat out falsehoods of the book. And they and they refute his book line by line. I mean it's a law, but if anybody wants to look at that, you can find it on fair Latter Day Saints and there's the website I list here.

35:24 Or just look up Simon G Sutherton and it'll take you to that refutation page. Kevin Barney, who sits on the board of Fair and other places, He's an attorney, practicing attorney Chicago. He paints with a broad brush, but I think he kind of characterizes what's happening with these two guys here, he says. Murphy and Southerton appear to be nice guys. I would agree they are sincere and they believe in what they're doing. Both seem to have had a similar experience. They apparently grew up with Narrow, what I would call more binary, simple assumptions about the Book of Mormon believing in and presumably knowing only of the hemispheric model, which prior to the 1980s, nobody knew anything really about ancient America.

36:21 We were all flying blind, we were all ignorant. And everybody who reads the Book of Mormon for the first time thinks the narrow neck of land is Panama, the land of the first inheritance of South America, and the land northward is North America, until you realize there's no way the Alma could traverse. Right. 2000 miles in a month, you know what I mean? And other things. So the the hemispheric model, I mean, everybody kind of believed in it. And fortunately the church itself never took an official position. We'll read about that, too. But when they learned that the hemispheric model was scientifically and tenable, each experienced unfulfilled expectations and an ensuing crisis of faith, upon which each lost his belief in the antiquity and historicity of the Book of Mormon and the Church with it.

37:12 Now they desire to align others under the banner of science, and that's when the Church, in an effort to protect the membership. If if practicing members are using the Church to fight against the Church, that's when they have to be cut off and excommunicated. Any questions about that? It's kind of a a a simple illustration of what's going on with these guys and and I I can't blame them if that was my belief and understanding. Fortunately for me and others, like others like me, we had a more complete, nuanced, archaeologically based understanding of ancient America before these DNA studies came came out. Does the Book of Mormon teach that all Native Americans are descended from Lee Heights?

38:03 No, not not in my opinion. Not I I Look, I know I'm gonna piss certain people off, and I'm kind of used to that here, but I I don't think that North America or South America, wherever they landed, was uninhabited, right? I don't believe that for a minute. I think there were already people here. And therefore to say that all descendants, all Native Americans or descendants of Lehigh just wouldn't hold water? However, do you think many in the church actually believes that?

38:44 I think there's there's some that definitely do believe that, yeah. I I think most did. I think I was one of them because in the 1970s, what did we know? You know we had. No Internet. And we certainly didn't have the view of ancient American Society and culture that we have today. All I had was the Book of Mormon who talked about these people, people in the Americas and having these populations of the millions. So you you can see why people would come up, make up these great stories about how the the Nephites, the Lamanites were everywhere, you know. So here's Doctor John Sorensen. He was the chair and founder of the anthropology department at Brigham Young University.

39:31 I think history will look at this man and recognize him as being under appreciated, under celebrated 20 years, what I'm going to quote him saying, he said, 20 years before Southington and Murphy published their DNA. Stuff. OK, 20. 20 years 1984, he said. One problem some Latter Day St. writers and lecturers have have had is confusing the actual text of the Book of Mormon with the traditional interpretation of it. The Book of Mormon explicitly, clearly teaches, unmistakably teaches, that at least two other groups of people had arrived on the American continent before Lehigh.

40:20 There were already people here. The Muelekites, right? But the Muelekites would have been one. That's right. But the other and the most significant who arrived 2000 years almost before Lehi, were the Jaredites. And we forget them. They're just in this one book, but they arrived right after the Tower of Babel, shortly after the flood. Between 2500 and 2200 BC they had 2000 years to roam this continent and to settle. And, yes, the central, the capital of their society, killed each other.

41:00 But that by no means suggests that everybody, whoever came over 2000 years ago, was dead, right? There's no way they could possibly know that, right? In any case, So I love what Sorensen says. They confuse the actual text with traditional interpretation. The traditional interpretation of some is that all all Native Americans are Lamanites. In fact, the early brethren, including Joseph Smith referred, routinely referred to Native Americans as Lamanites. Sure, right? Which genetically is not true. But in terms of being Native Americans, they just use those terms interchangeably, he goes on. For example, a commonly heard statement is that the Book of Mormon is the history of the American Indians, is it? He says.

41:47 This statement contains a number of unexamined assumptions that the scripture is a history. Is the common sense a systematic, chronological account of main events in the past of a nation or territory, that the American Indians are a unitary population, and that the approximately 100 pages of text containing historical and cultural material in the Scripture could conceivably tell the entire history of a hemisphere? He says sarcastically. Gotcha. It's not. It's No, it's not. When he's when he's talking about a unitary population, he's talking about a population that is the same, right? Right, right.

42:28 Well, one solid unitary population. That is simply not true, he goes on. Here's the significant point for me. When unexamined assumptions like these are made, critics respond in kind. He was prophesying. Here, critics respond in kind, criticizing not to the ancient texts itself, but the assumptions that we have made. So 20 years before Sudderton and Murphy did this, he prophesied that it was going to happen. Right. And that's exactly what they've done. They didn't they didn't attack what the Book of Mormon text is telling us. They attacked what many of us had come to believe. I think you bring up a good point here and and I forgive me, I'm slow, but I'm gonna try to restate what you said here. We're gonna be doing this a lot because it is complicated. So, so basically, a lot of times what this DNA is pointing out isn't falsehoods within the Book of Mormon. But maybe falsehoods about what we believed to the Book of Mormon was saying.

43:39 Agreed. That's exactly right. That's exactly right. So, going on here, does the Book of Mormon teach that the Lehighs were the only people in the New World? No. No, we've talked about this. The Book of Mormon explicitly reports that there were already people in the Americas when Lehigh arrived, and the some had been here for nearly 2000 years prior. That's twice as long as the Nephites existed on the. God. The church has never taught that the Nephite civilization was Pan American. Right. At least as early as 1929, Anthony Ivan's a member of the First Presidency, prophetically stated, the Book of Mormon teaches the history of three distinct peoples, or two peoples and three different colonies of people who came from the Old World to this continent. It does not tell us that there was no one here before them. It does not tell us that people did not come after, and so if discoveries are made which suggest differences in race origins, it can very easily be accounted for and reasonably for.

44:49 We do believe that other people came to this continent. OK. That's pretty good 1929, right? Right, Absolutely. So and we'll talk about the implications of that and the implications of what the DNA really is saying. But now we need to take a step back and look at the limitations of the historical DNA analysis. This is Terrell Gibbons commenting on this. Quite simply, DNA would be a relevant tool in the debate only if a number of extraordinary conditions were present. The science can get quite complicated, but the assumptions of which it is based are not. As Michael Whiting, a molecular biologist and member of the Scientific Review panel for the National Science Foundation, points out, at least ten factors make the hypothesis of American Indian Israelite connections untestable. Period.

45:49 You can't really test it. Number one among these are the unlikelihood of the Book of Mormon people's remaining genetically uncontaminated by any other peoples during their thousand year presence in this hemisphere. I'm out. I'm gonna, I'm gonna interject something here. Make sure I I'm understanding. When he says uncontaminated, is he talking about like Ross crossbreeding if you will, with? Right. Intermarrying. Yeah. Sharing DNA? Intermarrying is a is a better way. The book, The Book of Mormon explicitly teaches that yes, Yep. And it's the time of Christ's coming. Yeah, all one. Right. And so. If if that's the case, right, then that answers another question.

46:34 In engineering, specifically civil engineering, there's an old adage that the solution to pollution is dilution, right? And so is there such thing as diluting DNA, so to speak, right? Absolutely, over time. With all the. Intermarrying that's going on between Lehigh Seed and and and Mueck, the the people of Mueck and and and the Jaredites. If if they are intermarrying with other try indigenous tribes, we would expect then to see if I'm understanding correctly, that that you're you're not going to get a pristine sample so to speak of that's exactly. That's exactly true, right?

47:18 And that is only the tip. Of this. Iceberg. OK, goes on. One would also have to ignore the effects of genetic contamination among indigenous populations that doubtless occurred in the 15th centuries after Book of Mormon History ends. KK So Book of. Mormon history. Ends 400 AD. That's another 1100 years before the European show up. I mean, it's not gonna remain Christine over that time either. K Thirdly 1. Would also. Have to know precisely who among the vast American Indian populations of the day are the descendants of what the Book of Mormon calls Lamanites, the very small. Size of. The founding genetic pools and the shifting genetic identity of the Middle Eastern host population also present challenges to experimental validation, meaning how do we know what 600 BC Middle Eastern DNA look like? OK, that's a good point.

48:18 Talk about talk about genetic. Mixing. I mean, the Middle East has Middle East has just been this campaign sweeping? Through it. I mean for for 3000 years, right? 2600 years? Well, just here's. The other here's Go ahead. I was gonna say just think about. It in the last 100 years, right? You have the you, you have the Jews going back to Israel, right? And most of them would have been classified as probably European at that point, right, because they're coming out of Europe and there's been connections and intermarrying. And so now they introduced back into the Holy Land and yeah, so that's that's probably the single. Well, they're all insurmountable problems. Now.

49:04 Here's what no one is really talking about, which is something that really should be considered, was Lehi. Jewish. He was not. The book of Alma states that he was from the tribe of Manasseh, one of the. Lost 10. Tribes. We have no record of what that. DNI. DNA might look like, which is especially important because Manasseh and Ephraim would have had the most distinctive DNA of all of the tribes of Israel because of their mother, their father. Was Joseph their? Mother. Was Egyptian. Not only was she Egyptian, he nibbly believed she was the well her father was of the priest class, he nibbly. Suggested the Priest class.

49:46 In Egypt were black. So right it was. So what was? What was? If the northern 10 tribes had already been carried away, what was Lehigh doing in Jerusalem? Well, of course he had fled well, or his his predecessors had fled to escape that right? So he had a home in Jerusalem, and he had an ancestral home up further north from Jerusalem. But that's also significant. He's not Jewish. He's not of the tribe of Levi, so he's not a colon. It could even if they had a pure genetic line of the the tribe of Judah or of the tribe of Levi, it wouldn't necessarily apply. In fact, it would be quite distinct because of Asanet, Joseph's wife.

50:31 OK, so so just for a. Second, let's let's break this down a little further, 'cause I think this is super important because when you start talking about Judaism, I do believe at some point there was a bloodline. Obviously, I believe that there still is, you know, a little bit of that that's ethnocentric, right, if you will. And then there is kind of the cultural aspects of it, right? Just like you would see people because there are converts into Judaism, right? Correct. And so we hide by every sense of the word. Could be a practicing Jew, but not necessarily not necessarily of Israelite lineage. Is that is that kind of well understanding. OK, so he.

51:15 Is Israelite because he's one of the 12 tribes, right? And he practices. Judaism. Which is the name of those who worship Yahweh, right? But he is of the tribe of. Manasseh. He's so he's Israelite, but he's not Jewish. Jewish is the tribe of Judah. OK, but he would have still. Cause in the Book of Mormon it talks about him keeping those those customs right? He offers sacrifices in the desert, correct? And and all those things correct. OK. Anyway and until and I don't think you're watching early like we're we're about a. Half hour in and my mind's already blown a little bit here, right? Breaking down the complexity of this, it gets it gets much. Worse or better, it's pictures and everything, but I would be.

52:01 Completely and utterly surprised. If there were a single human being alive today that was of an uncontaminated lineage, I I don't believe that's possible. Over thousands of years, we're Yeah, especially. In the world today. And I'm not saying it's a bad thing, and that's just the way it is. On the other hand, we're all descendants of Charlemagne, right? We don't have any of his DNA but. But in terms of genealogy, yeah, we're all related to him in that sense, Native. Americans are probably. All descendants of Lehigh? Well, yeah. Because then then you look.

52:42 At the whole intermarrying thing. And you, you realize it kind of goes both ways, right? So while we hide, well, look his his sons Lehman millenial. Most likely intermarried and recruited from the native populations, which would explain why they continually outnumbered the Nephites. Yeah? And why? And why they? Ended up why they're generated. Within a generation, their kids would have darker skins than the skins of the natives. Yeah. And then also I I. Think this is maybe an important point here. If it's not, you can correct me, but we don't know what Native American DNA looked like before Lehigh would have been there, right? Well, I think we do.

53:25 But we'll get to that. OK, now here's the cool thing. Simon Sotherton, the guy who wrote the book in 2004 claiming the Book of War was a fraud because of this, in 2005, said this. And I quote in 600. BC which? When? Lehigh arrived. There were probably several million American Indians living in the Americas now. Since that time because of Lidar. Discoveries. That number has been revised upward. By a factor of at least 10. There were hundreds of millions of Native Americans, he goes on. If a small group of Israelites entered such a massive native population, it would be very, very hard to detect their genes 202,000 or even 20,000 years later.

54:17 Hey, I'm not gonna put words. In your mouth. This comes from me. So if he makes this admission here, then to me and and fine however you want to get through it, that I I'm fine with you doing whatever you need to do. But I just ask that you be honest and not drag people with you to me. If if you're if you're basing your sole testimony on the absence of DNA in the Book of Mormon, but then you make an admission at from a scientific point of view here, just call it what it is. You probably want it out, and you needed a way to get out and this. Who could? Say I'll type. From his book, though, his issues are far more complicated than just the DNA issue, right?

55:03 I mean it like it's. It's the CES Letter. Type stuff, right? You know so. Like. The Book of Abraham, you. Really relies heavily on that, and you and I have discussed that until midnight, but so here's Wikipedia here. Defenders of the Book of Mormon have made arguments that center on the idea that Book of Mormon peoples from the Middle East formed only a small portion of the population of the Americas. OK, now people say the limited geography model was made in response to this DNA attack. But as I will show you, that model was well, and it says here in the quote, top models put forth in 1984 by John Sorensen in the enzyme and their genetic heritage may have been diluted beyond what cannot be detected.

55:57 The limited geography model of the Book of Mormon supports this position. This geographical and population model was formally published in an official LDS magazine, The Enzyme, in a two-part series published in September and October 1984. And anybody can read it for free online. Yeah. People when they talk about John Sorensen, someone. Once described him as if he he inhaled the Book of Mormon. That guy. And and I I knew people who were his home teachers that talk about intimidated that guy. He he knew the Book of Mormon so well inside and out and probably had all 600 geographical references in the Book of Mormon memorized. His work stunning up until the point that he died a few years back, but an early American setting. For the book of.

56:52 Mormon, an ancient American setting for the Book of Mormon, came about in the early 1980s. He was so far ahead of everybody. We're still catching up to him. Here's the other issue. It's called the population. Bottleneck which is the. Loss of genetic variation. That occurs when a natural disaster, epidemic, disease, massive war, or other calamity results in the death of a substantial part of a population. These events may severely reduce or totally eliminate certain genetic profiles. In such cases, a population may regain genetic diversity over time through mutation, but much of the diversity that previously existed is irretrievably lost. Can we think of any? Of those circumstances regarding the Native Americans. Well, if you follow the Book of Mormon. The Nephi sure did dwindle in numbers, right? So yeah, you would you would expect. With that kind of war that that whittles the population down that much, that's the perfect environment here that I think is being talked about.

57:58 Yeah, the term for. That is called genocide. The Nephites were extinguished, haunted. Down even after the record. Was finished. Of course we. Know that 400 years earlier they were all one when they began to distinguish themselves as Nephites and Lamanites. After that, it had nothing to do with their lineage. It had to do with are you a believer or are you a non believer? You're right. That's how it. Started. But still, that's a significant calamity happened to that population in addition to. The catastrophic war at the end. Of the Book of Mormon. The European conquest of the Americas in the 15th, 16th centuries touched off just such a cataclysmic chain of events.

58:44 As a result of war and the spread of disease. Many Native American groups experienced devastating population losses. 1 Molecular anthropologist observed that the conquest squeezed the entire Amerindian population through a giant through a genetic bottleneck. He he concluded this population reduction has forever altered the genetics of the surviving groups, thus complicating any attempts at reconstructing the PRE. Columbia. Genetic structure of the most of most New World groups approximately. Now this is the crazy part. Approximately 90% of the Amerindian population died out following.

59:26 Contact with Europeans. Most most of this was due to infectious disease against which they had no defense. It may be that eliminating 90% of the pre contact gene pool has significantly distorted the true genetic picture of Lehigh's descendants. From this fact alone population bottleneck, it is impossible, I mean. Let's say by the. Time the Europeans got here. There were still a little bit. We might have had some Manasseh DNA in there somewhere, right after 90% is wiped out, they're gone. There's no way. That that would supply that? Right. Question. About that, Nope, no, I think that's pretty. Clear.

1:00:10 So this is going. Back to the the. Change to the introduction of the Book of Mormon. And I think Thomas Murphy, the first author, takes pride in the fact that he feels like he made the church do this, and he's not wrong. Here's the interesting thing. Even though it was devastating to their own faith journey, what they did has taught us about our own Book of Mormon, made it richer and better and more accurate. Our understanding of it, right, without disproving it as they would like to have everybody believe.

1:00:52 And we'll talk about why that is. When the introduction Book of Mormon was pinned in 1981 under Mcconkey's direction, or by him personally, it reflected the popular view. But the Book of Mormon was. About the. Origins of Native Americans across the whole atmosphere and that ancient Lamanites were the primary ancestors of modern Native Americans. The updated version will add 1. Word that makes the introduction a more accurate statement of what the text itself says or doesn't say. The word is among now. The Lamanites are among the ancestors of the American Indians. Bravo. This word corrects that 1981 assumption, actually an old assumption dating to the earliest days of the church, about the scope of the text. It is not a correction of any doctrine or principle taught in the Book of Mormon itself, this author goes. On I'm.

1:01:43 Proud of a church that can recognize the limitations of men past and present and take advantage of advances in knowledge, I'm pleased that improved understanding has allowed old but possibly sloppy assumptions to be revisited and substantially improved through the use of the word among to more accurately reflect what the text actually requires. This change in the introduction should be applauded. That's what he said. I agree with him 100% as many of you know a few weeks back. Robert Lefevre passed away. Now Robert left quite a footprint in Mormon fundamentalism. He is responsible for helping hundreds, if not thousands of independent Mormon fundamentalist get their ordinances as well.

1:02:26 Robert, I know for a fact, has helped out two separate groups of Mormon fundamentalists with getting their ordinances. Now, we all know funerals can be expensive, and Robert's family's in need of some help with those costs. So if you go to this episode Show Notes, you'll see that there's a GoFundMe page link. Click on that link and let's. Help. This family out. Look. These times that come along every so often, these are times that we get to show not just the world, but also our heavenly Father that we're willing to take care of his children. So again, go to this episode, show notes, click that link and make a donation today. Thank you. Want more from the Mormon? Renegade Podcast Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the Fundamental News Program for free. Still not enough?

1:03:15 Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button. And for $5 a month you can have access to podcast transcripts, Renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show Notes Today the Church made the change in wording to the. Introduction Book of Mormon To remove the assumption, which inserted into the Book of Mormon introduction in the 1920s and not part of the original text, that all of the inhabitants, the Americans were exclusive to. Sentence of Lehigh. This had been that generally held belief from the time the Church was restored. And why wouldn't it be? It was most information anybody had about ancient America. This chain makes the Book of Mormon introduction compatible with current DNA evidence and acknowledges the fact that Lehigh's group likely intermingled with the native inhabitants of the American continents based upon current knowledge of the DNA composition of the inhabitants of the New World.

1:04:14 There is substantial scientific evidence of habitation in Americas for thousands of years prior to Lehigh's arrival. If Lehigh had any descendants among. Amerindians. Then after 2600 years, all Amerindians would share Lehigh as an ancestor, even though his DNA didn't survive. Even if as is. Probable the Lehigh group was a small drop in a larger population ocean of pre Columbian inhabitants. Lehigh would have been an ancestor of virtually all modern day Amerindians. If any of his descendants married into the existing New World population, that's just genealogy at work. So oh, I love this.

1:05:01 I wish everybody could see this photograph on this slide. They they can get rumble, they can go to. Rumble. They can see it. I the Olmec which most Latter Day St. scholars associate with Jaredite civilization because their dates coincide exactly the the Olmec ancient American civilization predates the Maya. They're the. Progenitors. And they're this. The capital of their culture was in southern Mexico. This and and. They we have very little of what they wrote, almost nothing.

1:05:41 But we do have much of their artwork that remains. You know those giant heads that you see pictures of? All right, Those are the Olmec. This is a mask, a stone mask, a Jadeite made of Jadeite, depicting a very accurate Olmec slash Jaredite face. It's gorgeous and it's very, very accurate. I mean, you could. It's like you're staring at the person and they are clearly Asian. Yeah, I love that. According to the. Book of Mormon, I'm. This is Wikipedia again. The Jaredites were a group of people that left the Old World after the fall of the Tower of Babel. Some Mormon researchers believe that Jaredite, survivors of the war that destroyed their civilization as described in the Book of Eder, could be ancestors to some Native Americans. John Sorensen was saying that in 90. Two, some writers theorized that American Indians received their Asiatic genetic heritage from the Jaredites. Interesting.

1:06:49 That's a. Nibbly taught. In 1988 and on the slide I have the sources there. This is what Kim Peterson personally. Believes. That when we say that Native Americans. Predominantly are Asian in terms of their DNA. That's a reflection of Jaredite ancestry. Interesting. OK. And I'll tell you partly why I believe. That partly because of this. Mask. And other artwork like that, that the Olmec, whose phrenology parallels that of the Jaredites almost exactly, were clearly Asian, I mean. Judging judging by this. Mask and the rest of the artwork. So not only does their DNA point that out, but their their physical aspects also are obviously Asian. No, no.

1:07:43 That mask is. So beautiful. Let. Me finish this thought real quick and where did the? Jaredex come. From. They were at the Tower of Babel. They prayed that they could stay together and keep their language unified. And then what did they do? They went. East. OK. And the Tower of Babel presumably was. Near Turkey. You go east from Turkey. Where he headed? China, That's right. Into Asia. East Asia. And they were probably not the only people to do that right? And. And who knows, they probably had people. Sorry, they probably had people. That were with them, that stayed in Asia along the way while they continued on across the Pacific.

1:08:32 OK, what were you gonna say? So there are. Pictures of Olmec heads that don't necessarily look like that mask, right? Well, they're a bit distorted. They're a bit fatter. I mean, they're just big fat heads. And you know, 'cause as I looked at those. Heads. I was like, maybe more Pacific Islanders, right? Well, which which guess? And. And guess what? The DNA of Pacific Islanders is? Asian. Asian. Right. Yeah. So that so that genetic. Same genetic material would run right through that, right? This mask. Is stunning. I still when I I just stare at it and go that it's like they're standing right in front of me. It's crazy. Genetic diversity and population. Structure in the American landmass is also measured using. Autosomal.

1:09:19 ATDNA microsatellite markers, markers, genotypes sampled from North, Central, and South America and analyze against similar data available from other indigenous populations worldwide. The indigenous American population show a lesser genetic diversity than populations from other continental regions, just like we saw on that map. It's kind of a homogeneous. Thing. Now, is that because they were the only people there predominantly or is that because of genetic bottlenecking? All right, it could. Be some of both. While their overall strongest affinity for the other populations is observed, for East Asian people, observed is a decrease in genetic diversity as geographic distance from the Bering Strait occurs, as well as a decrease in genetic similarities to Siberian populations from Alaska.

1:10:08 So the further South you go in the American continent, the more homogeneous it looks and the more different they are from the Siberian DNA, the overall pattern. Suggests that the. Americas were colonized by a small number. I love this by a small number of individuals, an effective size of about 70, which grew by orders many orders of magnitude over 800 to 1000 years. How many? How many? Barges. Did the brother of Jared make shining stones for 16 like it would be 16?

1:10:49 Stones for 8 barges. Right, right. Yeah. Yeah. And so that would. Yeah, That good #70 people. Yeah. Isn't that crazy? Isn't that crazy? And they had two, and they had 2000 years to fill the continent before Lehi showed up. And then another 2000 years after that. According to a study from 2012, indigenous Americans descend from at least three main migrant waves from East Asia. Most of it is. Traced back to a single ancestral. Population called first Americans. However, those who speak inward languages from the Arctic inherited almost half of their ancestry from the 2nd East Asian migrant wave, and those who speak Nadina inherited a tenth of their ancestry from the third migrant wave. The initial selling of the Americans was followed by a rapid expansion southwards along the West Coast with little gene. Flow later.

1:11:45 Especially in South America. Here's what that looks like. So this is that. Same map we were. Looking at before Only only it's only showing the Native American DNA haplogroups. And this the purple. Is haplogroup Q. And as you can see, as they were saying, as you proceed southward along the coast, you see that it just gets more and more purple, right? I hear the interesting. Thing the yellow color represents haplogroup C, which never really goes into the southern US, Central America and South America.

1:12:27 What this shows me, and I've read other articles that indicate that this Haplogroup Q didn't expand northward, extreme northward at all. Meaning that it's quite possible that they didn't go through Beringia, the Bering Strait, but that they actually it was a trans Pacific crossing, a transoceanic crossing. It would have to be Pacific because they were Asian, right? That brought them to the. United States, and they spread. Southward and northward. And if I when I look at that map, that's. What I see right? And what does it and what? Does that describe? That describes the path of the Jaredites. OK 'cause? Yeah. 'Cause they went east. Which would have took them through China.

1:13:10 They would have hit the Pacific at. Some point. And made that journey across. That's right. And landed. And if the OLMEC? The the center, the heart of civilization was southern Mexico, just north of. The Yucatan where their final. Battle occurred. That's presumably where they might have landed on the West Coast, southern Mexico. Anyway, I I think it's beautiful now regarding these three waves. Haplogroup Q. Chronologically. Is the latest, so they would be the latest population to enter the Americas according. And now this is going to go. Strictly according to LDS teachings, what was the? Previous group that.

1:13:54 Inhabited the Americas prior to the Jaredites would have been the Mulekites, right? No, the Mulekites came. Just about the same time that Lehites did. OK, OK, Paulo, Jerusalem. What group inhabited the Americas according to LDS teachings, before the Jaredites? Adam and his posterity, right, I was gonna say. Adam and Eve, right? That's that's it. Isn't that crazy? Yeah. Now before that they're going. Back to pre Adamites. The Clovis people, the Cavemen, right. Those go back 12 to 18,000 years. In Kent Peterson's view, they are unrelated, even though I'll.

1:14:40 Put that on pause. And that there was. The the last. Extinction event on record, according to archaeologists, happened at 12,000 BC, right? At the end of the Ice Age? Which? Did, which destroyed many species like woolly mammoth, Saber tooth, tiger. And my opinion is it probably did away with Cavemen, but Darwinians have to believe that they somehow survived and went on And so they're trying to make this connection between that prehistoric DNA with our ancient DNA of the Jaredites and and the posterity of Adam. Well, and now I think I. Think even now Clovis first is under some duress, right? I mean, things keep getting a little bit older the more we look.

1:15:30 Yeah. Yeah, that's true. Well. We can talk about pre Adamites all day long and what and and some of the things that implies. Why would we be? Surprised that. Other humanoids would have similar DNA to Adam, Adam Adam was not. Built from scratch. He was brought from another world and and our. Our our humanoid. Species was created in the image and glory of God, so it's not like the DNA would get reinvented every single time or yeah. And if, if. There's preadomites and some of Adam's seed mixes with their seed. I well, I've seen that's. That's another possibility, one that I don't believe in. And I believe that the Earth was void and without form when Adam was placed upon it because it had been erased by the extinction, the extinction event of the 12,000 BC. To be prepared for this last creation that would fill the measure of its creation, as opposed to previous worlds on the earth that did not fill the measure of their creation and were destroyed to be made over again, ultimately in preparation for this great and last dispensation. OK.

1:16:41 For everybody out there, who? Right now is typing me a hot e-mail telling me how badly I suck for just throwing ideas against the wall. Just chill out. We're just talking some stuff here. This for me. This is the fun part. Yeah, the, the, I mean the stuff. That we. Know is interesting, but the stuff that we don't know but that we do have significant clues about, like this map that blows my mind. I love that stuff. And you see the purple spot over in northern Russia. I mean could. That be a faction of the. Jaredites that chose not to go across the Pacific, That's why their DNA, the Q haplogroup, you know, remains there. That's.

1:17:22 I love that. Love that stuff. OK, so here's the. World map again. Showing all of that. Yeah. I'm sorry, can you go back to that last? Slide for me real quick 'cause I I got a couple observations here. I wanna spit at you real quick, so my. My thought is. If there was a if there was a massive flux of migration from the one purple area to the Americas, why don't we see some sort of trail that goes through there, right I. Can't imagine. That. These folks would be making that trek in a couple of days, right? I mean. Well, you what we have to take.

1:18:05 Into account. The only population groups they studied are where you see those black dots. OK, but for one. Reason, so 'cause they're. They didn't study population groups in those intervening areas, perhaps, if in fact they crossed. Over. By the. Peninsula by the Korean Peninsula. They don't have any studies right there. Number two, we're talking about a distance of. Time. Of 4500 years, so dilute more So who knows what could have happened in the meantime too to release that you brought. Up something else and I'm sorry I keep I keep asking questions here so I'm looking I love your questions I I'm. Looking at this map.

1:18:47 And I'm. I'm seeing where. All the black dots are and you say that's where they took samples from the the studied populations. Is what it says on the key down at the lower right? Well, how? How then if? And forgive me, this is one of those things that I think is kind of important to to figure out. So let's just look down there in South America, right. They got a cluster almost and South in a cluster up in the northeast, and then the entire West side. They just make the assumption then that it matches. That's gonna match what they sampled. Yeah, connecting the dots. Coloring in the spaces, you know, right? I I guess, yeah.

1:19:29 I, I, I But at the very end I'm gonna show you something else. That'll kind of blow at least one hole in that. OK. All right. This is the science isn't perfect. The science isn't perfect. The science isn't finished, but what we do know is pretty cool. At the very least, it's a good beginning. Yeah. All good questions. All right. So here we have the. The the world map of all known haplogroup types, including the queues. And there's the CSA much earlier haplogroup, and we see some of the queues up where it showed on the other map. Mm hmm. And over here near.

1:20:10 Turkey. What by the Caspian Sea, that's, Yeah. Well, remember when they left from Turkey, they built barges to cross an inner sea, which could have been the black or the Caspian, right, the line. And so there's. Some of your. Tracings of where they were, right? Yep. Very interesting stuff to me. Asians. So let's pause here just for a second. So the the primary issue that has caused many people to lose their testimony of the Book of Mormon and forsake the faith. And I've said this before, people who who don't like being Latter Day Saints and who want to leave, I don't. Have any I mean.

1:20:55 Not everybody has to be a Mormon, right? And if. It's not your thing. You don't need any excuse for me to leave the faith, and I hope we'll all still be friends and all that sort of thing. But the thing that that breaks my heart are people who love being Latter Day Saints or Mormons. Whatever you want to. Call us and who? Who with great sorrow. Divorce themselves from a faith that they love because of a supposed fact.

1:21:37 And it's for that reason that. I. Among others that I love to engage in this stuff, to give people at least the other side of the story. So the assumption is because the vast majority of Native American DNA is Asian and not Middle Eastern, the Book of Mormon is false, OK? What we've demonstrated. Number one is the Book of Mormon itself has never taught that. What the Book of Mormon teaches directly, not tangentially, is that there was another race that preceded the Lehighs by 2500 years. Who came?

1:22:18 From the east, we know that. And the archaeological remains of whom, if they are the Olmec, indicate that they're Asian, so. That flips the whole argument. The what? The DNA Native American DNA proves is the Book of Mormon is true. Nice 'cause it shows the Jaredites were genuine. And they had come from the east, right, Right. And then and then to understand. Why we don't find even a single? Semitic DNA. There you have to understand number one, they were from Manasseh, at least half their DNA. Came from. An Egyptian, possibly black mother, so it wouldn't look it. Wouldn't look like.

1:23:00 Jewish DNA in any case. And then we have pop genetic drift dilution and bottleneck some of the worst. Examples in history. We see in Native America, right? So. My dear friends who love being a lottery St. who lose sleep over this please sleep well, right? The book of. Orbit is accurate. And that's. And I'm grateful. You know, I'm grateful that Sutherton and Murphy did these studies. I love. I mean, their studies were only confirming what we're seeing on this map, that the American population was homogeneous, which also brings to mind a book, more of a scripture, that the Lord has preserved this promised land.

1:23:49 Speaking of the Western Hemisphere. And you look in this map, or better yet, you look at this map, you can see what he was talking about. Yeah. Where there are all kinds of people traversing the Old World, the New World, we see basically one group of people. It wasn't nearly as acclaimed as the Old World. It's kind of interesting in that perspective, you know, and and. I I think this is one of those things where where we need to really take a step back and understand the difference between exegesis and I said Jesus, right, what we read into the scripture versus what it really says, yes, we don't think.

1:24:38 About the book. Of Mormon in those terms and we really should. And the and the other thing. That, I will say, is that we all. Come up with hypothesis. Right. And most of them aren't even stupid hypothesis. They're just they're they're just the straightest line and and OK this this makes the most sense and here they are right and sometimes what these studies can do right even though I think in the case of of Sutherton and the the other guy I'm blanking on his name Murphy, even though I disagree. With their. What? What this data means, right, It it should give us an opportunity to pause and reflect and say, OK, So what is it that I read into the scripture versus what the Scripture actually tells me?

1:25:33 And. And there's. Certain things that. We as as Mormons all know, right, For the most part. And those. Things we know. Everything else I think we have to start getting real comfortable with calling an idea right and and the things that are confirmed to you by the Spirit, go with those. Everything. Else you you may want to make sure that you're not tying your faith to an unstable anchor. Amen. Well said. That's exactly. True and. And Speaking of Murphy and Southington's work, I personally bear no grudge against them personally, and they seem like really likable people and sincere people and the. Scientific.

1:26:26 Results of their investigations. I don't disagree with that either. I mean it's I agree and it makes sense to me now from a more informed viewpoint of Native American archaeology and anthropology and history that yeah, the majority of them are Asian. I don't have a problem with that at all. And that actually fits better with the Book of Mormon text that what may have been previously believed. Right. Right. What I take issue? With. Is the premise of their study mm hmm that. We would find. Significant remnants of of Semitic Israelite DNA amongst the Native American populations we discussed scientifically. Why, That's probably never going to happen, right? Because the population.

1:27:10 The. The Lehigh population was a drop in this bucket. Yeah. And that's that's without bottleneck, population issues with bottleneck and genetic drift that that would be an impossibility. And so yeah, those are the only issues that I have. So and and I've said this already, but I'm grateful for what they did. I mean not to other people's testimonies, but. But that they. Brought this topic to light that we could learn more and it helped me understand better and learn more about the Book of Mormon and pre Book of Mormon time for that matter. Which brings us to the secondary issue of Book of. Mormon DNA.

1:27:51 And that is the DNA claim of Rod Meldrum. Who I also like. I like to meet him someday. Just, hey, we're Facebook friends though. He's a great guy. He's a great. I believe that I. Had him on here a couple weeks ago. And he was absolutely a blast to have on. I would do. I I listen to that and he sounds. So fun he is, he has an he has an infectious laugh. It just sounds like a such a good guy. So. If you look at this diagram here, this is not one that I made. This is taken off if you go to Wikipedia and search for haplogroup X. This is what you. Find. And when you look at this and you realize. What this is saying you can absolutely understand why Maude or why Rod Meldrum is out of his mind, excited about this. Haplogroup.

1:28:46 X which is after Q. This is mitochondrial DNA from the. Mother side showing that they were haplogroup X. Guess where? The Middle East and in the Great Lakes region? Not only would that substantiate Book of Mormon claims, it would substantiate Heartlander claims. Sadly, he left something out. In his in his first quote. He's talking about the SUB Haplogroup X2 and then he leaves those ellipses. dot dot dot.

1:29:31 That's the problem in the third paragraph. This is what he left out. I have it bold the the phylogenography of subclays of haplogroup X suggests that the Near East is the likely geographical source for the spread of sub haplogroup X2 in the Great Lakes regions, and the associated population dispersal occurred around or after the Last glacial Maximum when the climate ameliorated or improved. So what he left out is stating that that. Haplogroup X dates. To 18,000. Years ago Final paragraph. So it is true that the American subgroup of X2 is related to the Middle East, but it is also clear. That the.

1:30:23 American Group broke off from that Middle East group around the time of the last glacial maxim, the point where the last ice ages glaciers reached their furthest southern extent. About. 18,000 years ago. This clearly means that the X2 haplogroup is unrelated completely to Lehigh's group. How can a group from 18,000 years ago be related to a group from 2600 years ago? Sure, Let let me. Ask you this and and again I'm gonna get blamed for questioning the science, but Hooray, how? How certain?

1:31:04 Are we that we? Can date this accurately. I I suppose there are always questions. In the dating. Their. Their. Carbon dating is one way. The genetic dating is done by by turning the clock backwards. You can these mutations that I that identify one haplogroup from the other happen. At intervals that can. Be calculated back in time. Is it foolproof 100%? Nobody can say. But it has proved thus far quite accurate. So I don't.

1:31:48 I don't. I don't think it's to answer your question. I don't think it's possible to answer it at a hundred 100% sure that it's not percent. Accurate. But I don't have reason necessarily to doubt it at this point, OK. OK, so the science is still unsettled for the most it sounds. I I wouldn't say it's unsettled. I would say it's the best we have and it's fairly it's reliable enough that we continue to utilize it. So, and now if if the difference in time was 1000 years or 2000 years, I would be more inclined to accept this Rod's claim.

1:32:28 But the fact that the difference between Lehigh and this haplogroup X2 is 16,000 years. I mean. That's not even close. So yeah. That's a harder. Thing to say. Still interesting. Still interesting, though. Yeah. Who were this pop? Who wasn't? Clovis pre Clovis population. Why were they at opposite sides of the world? Who would want to know that, right? Yeah. So we've. We've told you about the main. Haplogroups that we know about and what and what science currently knows about them. Recently there have been two what we call outliers. DNA outliers in ancient America. In November 2013, Nature published a discovery on an UPO paleolithic Siberian site linking western Eurasians. So that would be like around Turkey and that sort of thing in the Middle East and Europe to the indigenous Native American population.

1:33:29 What so they could be that Native Americans and Western Eurasia. Let's see, According to the study, the genome sequence showed distinct genetic markers that are unique to the indigenous Native Americans and western Eurasia, but with no but but with no relation to East Asians. The study indicates that between 14 and 38% of Native American ancestry may originate through this gene flow. So now this. This upsets the apple cart again. Is this? What we've been looking. For in terms of Middle Eastern DNA, our findings are significant on 2 levels. First, it shows that Upper Paleolithic Siberians came from a cosmopolan population of early modern humans that spread out of Africa to Europe to Central and South Asia. Second, Paleo Indian skeletons like bull woman with the phenotype traits atypical of modern day indigenous Americans, can be explained as having a direct historical connection to Upper Paleolithic Siberia.

1:34:31 So there's an outlier group, and it doesn't give us a good date, but well, that's interesting. Study indicates that 14 to 38% of Native American ancestry may originate through that gene flow. Wow. Holy cow. Go back to that one. One real quick, I got another question here. Oh, the that one, right? There this one here and it's in. That lower paragraph, where it says first it shows that Upper Paleolithic Siberians came from a cosmopolitan population of early American humans, of early modern humans. That. Spread out of Africa to Europe, Central and South Asia? Yeah. How would they know that? I don't know. Are they? Are they using the word?

1:35:13 Cosmopolitan the same way we use it, meaning civilized. Civilized. I So. We're talking about a civilization, right? Yeah. And I. Don't know how and I wish there. Were more detail there, but is it because of the circumstances of finding the remains of clothing and possessions? And you know, who knows? That was my question. What? What? What's? Making them say that that this was a cohesive societal. Unit so to. Speak, that's a very good question. I wish I had the answer for you. OK, this one's cool in 2020. One very recent.

1:35:54 South Americans share ancestry with the ocean and populations that is not seen in Mesoamericans or North Americans. When I read that, I'm like, wow, things couldn't get more confusing. There's a population and you can see the color code, the dots, the, the burgundy and the red dots, right? What are? Australians and. Indonesians doing in Central South America, right of all the. Weird things well, Clint. If you look. Like there's like one like way up over by. India on the coast. Right and.

1:36:34 It's like OK. So how in the hell and do do we have some sort of reference of time on this? Do we know how long this group has been in these? I'm sorry, I don't. I don't. Have that, I'm sorry. Isn't that isn't that interesting? I mean. So clearly there I think is happening in the world and in the Americas that the Book of Mormon has absolutely no knowledge of. Well, yeah, and. Now we start. Talking about diffusion on a much larger scale, yeah, right. Now we start. Talking about. Diffusion happening in the Americas from all over, Yeah. Yeah.

1:37:19 Which and and this is a thing we need to. Point out about the Book of Mormon. The Book of Mormon is only. Capable of telling us about the people around the authors, right? What Defi experienced What? Lehi experienced what? Jacob what? Alma experienced, right? What Mormon and Mirona experienced, what Mahanrai experienced, what ether experienced with. Some. Very rare exceptions like. In 3rd Nephi. When God tells them about the destructions to these other cities, how else would they know? You know they don't have drones, they don't have satellites. How would they know?

1:38:01 Because Jesus told them the cities in the north were buried and this city was sunk, and and Jerusalem was the city was swept out to the sea, you know those sort of things. Because God himself was explaining to the Nephites what happened to these other cities, their destructions. That's otherwise they. Wouldn't have known. That's an important thing for us to remember. The Book of Mormon was not, is not a history of the Americas. It's not a history. Of the Native American. Peoples, it's not possible. It's a 300 page book to do that. It's a history of Lehigh's people. That's right, all. Right, final.

1:38:43 Photograph here or picture. This is taken from. A mural that was painted on the the archaeological structures in Chichen Itza, the Mayan population. That's a little diverse, yeah. You got some people who have darker skin, others who have way lighter skin. Yeah, so. Just just so we thought we figured everything out. I'm upsetting the applecart again. So this is 1100 AD, so this is a good 700 years after the destruction of the Nephites as accounted for in the Book of Mormon.

1:39:32 And here we have for whatever reason. Different skin tones. In in the in these Mayan murals, these paintings, and in each case the lighter skinned people are subservient. They're doing, you know, they're paddling the boats, they're carrying the loads, they're doing those sorts of things. Isn't that crazy? And here's another mural from that same structure in Chichen Itza. Same thing. Only in. This case. The lighter skin people are actually bound by or enslaved by the darker skin. And only their faces.

1:40:18 That would appear in some case are not black, but the darker skin, which is a very recently discovered thing that ancient mines before warfare, they would cover themselves in black, right? Which? Might have. Relationships of the Scriptures referring to the. The darkness and and. You know at this point the like. We don't know what. This mural was right. Was this propaganda for another group? Was this mural trying to show a history? Because the dates don't. You couldn't look at the dates and then pair that and say, Oh well, they're telling the story as it happened.

1:41:01 No, this is, this is either propaganda or this is the read their history. Yes. So to read. This this is a wall fresco on the Temple of the Warriors in Chichanita, Mexico, showing a major raid on a village near the sea. Note that the Elite and Commoner structures are being assaulted with both male and female captives stripped and captured of the lighter skin tone. Anyway, that's all I got, you all I have on that. That's awesome. I. I'm gonna try to to put a bow on this, so to speak, and you can tell me if I'm off base here.

1:41:44 After. Looking at all of this. Right. What we have is we have Lehigh seed coming. To. To the Americas, right? Where, Wherever. Take your pick wherever. You want to go north. Or South America and they. Aren't. Alone. When they show up, there's. People here, Yeah, there's a wonderful article. I mean. And then another. John Sorensen wrote a lengthy oh, here it is. When Lehigh's party arrived in the land, did they find others there? And I give you the website that's a free download, and he goes into all of the textual suggestions that they were not alone.

1:42:27 I mean, it mentions the obvious. It teaches the Melekites are already there, and the Jaredites have been there for 2500 years or 2000 years. 1900 years. So that's a. That's a delightful. Article And so they're they're. Obviously not alone. There's probably indigenous populations here, right? Maybe even before the Jaredites? Possibly. Possibly. You know what, Kim Peterson? Thinks do you care what Kim Peterson thinks about that? I I'm always care what Kim, if we believe that Noah's flood was worldwide and you and I have talked about there is a mechanism by which that could happen which would. Sweep the land masses.

1:43:12 Clean without leaving everything subverged for every killing, all the all the flora and fauna. It would be a a massive worldwide tsunami triggered by an asteroid. Impact. Or the northern polar regions, whatever. In any case, if that were true, North America would have been wiped clean of any previous inhabitants, which would have been the Adamites, you know, the. The. The sons and daughters and the the the pre the offspring of Adam and Eve which is 1. Reason there are a. Couple of differences between the, the, the.

1:43:55 Jaredite. Migration to the New World and the Lehite migration to the New World. The Jaredites had to build an ark like Noah's. It was built just like Noaa's so it could be submersible. And not only did they have to bring seeds, they had to bring all these animals with them and they had to bring bees with them. Why did they have to bring the Deseret? Why did that bring bees pollination? And they also had to bring. Fresh fish, freshwater. Fish they had to bring with. Them, right? Because if if what? I'm thinking is true, possibly that the American continent had been swept clean by this title tsunami.

1:44:38 It would have. Any freshwater fish would have been destroyed by the salinity of the tsunami, and it would have swept the continent clean of any bees, insects and other life forms. So any and all of the life forms that we have indigenous to the Americas today would have been those very things that the Jaredites would have, of necessity brought with them bees. Drought and that sort of thing. Has there been any research done on? That to see if. If. Certain fish or certain insects come from certain regions. Yeah, Yeah, I.

1:45:19 Don't know if that would be a trick. But. Anyway. So so. Lehigh seed gets dropped in here and. Because they intermarry. With the the locals who are already here, yeah, we expect to. See. Some sort of degradation? If you will, I hate. Using that term that way, right, it's not degradation, but. A dilution of their a dilution. Thank you. A, a dilution of their gene pool that way, taking into account also that I think we may have been looking for the wrong thing, right as you included to Lehigh. 'S not Jewish. Right. So we keep no Jewish DNA, whatever that looks like, whatever that looked like back or even Levite or even.

1:46:05 Israelite, of all the and of all the 12 tribes, Manasseh and Ephraim are gonna be the most distinct because of their because of Asanet, the Egyptians, right? And so. We're. We're looking we're we're looking for the wrong thing to begin with, right? And then and then we. Have all this this. Intermarrying, going on now, having said. That. If there is all this intermarrying happening, then if if there's even a a drop of blood, so to speak, of of Lehigh's running in any of these tribes, probably all of these tribes at this point, then aren't they all considered Lehigh seed at that point, right genealogically speaking?

1:46:53 I mean, you and I don't have any of shark King Charlemagne's DNA in US doesn't change the fact that he's still our ancestor, right? That's still that's still true, right? DNADNA is. Not. Necessarily ancestry, right, Right. And so. It it feels to me almost like just. Looking for a smoking? Gun in in DNA may not be a good way of saying it. It could be good supporting evidence, right? Yeah, yeah, yeah. But I don't think it could ever be something where you could just say, OK, this rules out the historicity of the Book of Mormon. Now you know no if. If you, if you. Wanted to play the naysayer.

1:47:35 You could use that and certainly people still do, but they're assuming the ignorance of the people they're debating with, right? You know that we that we don't know better, that we don't know about bottleneck, that we don't know about genetic drift and genetic dilution over time, that we don't know about that stuff or that we don't know that the Americas were completely, it looks like they were completely populated by by people before Lehigh ever thought of going there thousands of years and that. And that Lehigh's little. Party of however many it was about 20 maybe that, that that that drop in a bucket, 20 people amongst 100 million, you'd never find him again, right?

1:48:20 Right. Especially if especially if they were all killed to genocide. Well, and and really you can think of. Two massive bottlenecks within the Book of Mormon, just right off the top of my head, right? There's probably some sort of bottleneck when Christ comes back, right? Yeah, that's true. That's true. That level of destruction. I can't imagine, 'cause it says in the Book of Mormon that it it basically takes care of all the wicked, right? Like, done, right. And that's why they have that 400 years of of just peace and tranquility so well, at least 100, at least 100 of them that first. 100 you were great, right, right and and so. Yeah, yeah, that's more accurate. You're right.

1:49:01 But But anyway, so there's a bottleneck that happens there. And then a few 100 years later, there's another significant bottleneck. Yeah, massive. In in that in that. Genocide. So, so gosh, I feel like we just went a long way to say, yeah, I wouldn't expect to see a smoking gun one way or other alphabets. Well, I mean the truth. Is, and it sounds like a weak answer is that in terms of DNA evidence, there's not enough information to to test one way or the other for certain that DNA can't possibly answer that question because we but we really, but it's so informative, right?

1:49:44 Because. The other thing I'm thinking we don't know what what Lehi's DNA would look like. We don't know what Ephrimite or or Manasseh's DNA makeup would have looked. Like, right. So even if we did find it, we wouldn't know what we were staring at. True. True. Very true indeed. Well, I want a fascinating study, though. DNA is quite a wonder, and the fact that we can make any sense of it at all is endlessly. Fascinating. And the further back in history we go, the more interesting it becomes to me. Yeah, yeah. Who are these humans? What are they doing here? You know? Well. And then? And then it's all fascinating. Yeah. And then you couple.

1:50:25 That with the fact. Of like you were just showing, we got two sets of haplogroup X clear across the the hemispheres from each other 18,000 years ago. What the heck yeah. Yeah, Clovis first doesn't. Seem to be a viable model much anymore, now that things continue to get older, even within America, right? And so we. We have all. Of this data now that's coming in. And for I feel like for a long time there was this idea through archaeology that that, hey, we've got this stuff all figured out, right? That that really was it, right? Like, we forget that archaeology is like just over 100 years old, right? The and.

1:51:08 And within 50 to 75 years, most of them went, Yep, we got human history figured out, right, Right. And. And that doesn't seem to. Be the case. Any longer, it's only getting it's only getting more and more complicated. Yep, in one of our older in one of our previous discussions. And I looked this up because I kept finding articles about different species of humanoids, you know, prior to the biblical. Well. Prior to the biblical Adam, right. The two most famous would be, well, I mean, there's Homo sapien and then there's, Oh my gosh. I completely glizzy. Denis Denisovian, right? Neanderthal, right?

1:51:51 Right. Completely different. Species that at one point we thought couldn't even interact or or reproduce together, you know, But now they think they kind of do. But that those are only three of 23 known humanoid pre Adamite speak humanoid species 2323. Different humanoid species. What in the heck was going on? Well, it was like this humanoid party. For. 300,000 years, OK, so. I'm gonna make an admission now because some of my that some. Of my my. Critics will like, so here, here's your gift.

1:52:33 For me, it's it's an early Christmas. You get, you get to. Use this on me. Because of some. Extenuating. Circumstances. I'm not real. My My genealogy is tough. Yeah. So I thought it'd be fun to take. One of those DNA tests? Oh yeah. And I'll be damned if some. Didn't come back, like, literally, with like, Neanderthal markers like, oh, you're awesome. And I shared that with both Amber. And Tanya and they were like that tracks. That makes sense. That tracks, right? That's awesome.

1:53:13 But. Yeah, I'm so. And and yeah, like I said, I gave that just to my critics. There you go. Have fun with that. You can, you can post all the the the stuff you want with that, but that is so fun. Yeah, but, but. And I want to say this. Too we we think we got some good capabilities now, but if there's anything that history has taught us when it comes to this kind of science is there's a good possibility somewhere in the future, if we last that long, somebody might. Develop. Something else which completely overturns all of these models. Oh yeah. I love that. Yeah. You know, you know. 10-15 years down the road someone could have, you know make a discovery of like oh that completely changes how we read all I I'm.

1:54:03 I'm not only open to that, I anticipate stuff like that. Yes, that's what keeps. That's what keeps it interesting to me. Yes, whenever anybody says. The science is settled. I tend to be like, no, it's not. That's the whole point of science. It's never settled. No, it's true. It's not science if it's settled. Exactly, exactly. Science is open-ended, yeah. Yeah, and and here's. The other thing, I think this is one of the gifts of the Restoration, right, is to do what you and I just sat down and did. Do we know any of this for certain, Ken? I mean, oh, it's all facts. If you ask me, I'm telling you it's all absolutely all absolutely true baby, but but in all actuality taking. Myself on it, yeah.

1:54:47 In in all actuality. I mean, we're making do with the best data that we have at the moment, but this is the gift. I think this is one of the gifts of the restoration, right? Is that we can sit down and bounce these ideas around, but I think the most important thing in doing that is, is remembering that until you've had some sort of spiritual witness to some of these an. Honest. Spiritual witness. They're just ideas, right? And there's nothing wrong with bouncing these. It's a. Tradition, that is. As Mormon as funeral potatoes, if not older Joseph Smith, That's what it was favorite. Things to do, yes.

1:55:29 What was the phrase that he used to wow theologize to prove? Contraries, OK. Yeah, that's what he called it. Yeah, Prove contraries. And then he loved doing that. I mean, that's, or as a friend of mine once said, if you're prepared enough to ask the right question, the answer can't be far behind. So if we're not probing and if we're not pondering right, that's a loaded word. If we're not doing our own best thinking and seeking for these answers, let us let us receive truth from wherever, no matter. Wherever. It comes from from whence it comes. That's what that is. You're right. That's a great Mormon tradition stemming from Joseph Smith himself.

1:56:14 Yep. Absolutely. So if we're asking. The right questions. And if it and if it is God's timing that we should receive answers, we'll be prepared to receive it. We have to prime the pump or God doesn't, was it? Mcconkey said. God does not pour revelation into a vacuum, right? Right, right. Well and. We. Forget this whole thing, got kicked off by a young boy asking some questions, right? And I don't think that tradition ends with Joseph Smith. Well, I I want to go back and. Say one thing because as we've talked about before, the the geological record, the prehistoric geological record shows mass extinction events, right?

1:56:56 So we have. So we have these creations. Like the the the Cambrian period. Then we have a mass extinction event and all that stuff disappears and entirely new life forms suddenly spring up on the planet. Right The I forget there's the Triassic, Jurassic. And then we have the Cretaceous period, which was the last period of the dinosaurs mass extinction event. They all disappear. And then the Cambrian explosion. Right now the Cambrian was way before the. Dinosaurs, right, That was 500. Million. BC and now. We're talking dinosaur. The end of the Cretaceous was 65 to 70 million BC and right after that the tertiary, the KT boundaries, what they call it a whole new life form, mammalian life forms spring up in platforms and so the geological record instead of being this continuous.

1:57:50 Small, gradual. Changes like they talked about the Darwinists. It's not. It's like explosive creative periods. Stagnation, extinction. A new explosive? Creative period. With new life forms stagnation. There's not any abolition going on extinction. So it's a repeated introduction of new life forms. Wow. As Eric, as Eric Scowlsen would put it, and that is so stark in the geological record that that anthropologist. Archaeologists have a term. For it. And it's called Oh my gosh, blew my mind, but but there's a term for it.

1:58:37 What does the term mean? Past my. Bedtime, I think. Oh. It'll come to me. Anyway, they. They actually have a term. For it they've they've codified the theory of this repeated introductions, and I'm so embarrassed I can't think of it. In any case, I personally believe that's what happens. These mass extinction events are so profound and so catastrophic that I don't think anything survived and and God or somebody was preparing for a new creation, a new world in any case. So which would? Explain.

1:59:19 So I I would say that before Adam was placed on the Earth, that the earth was again cleansed and prepared for the presence, you know, cleansed of the caveman and all that sort of stuff. And prior to that Neanderthal, prior to that Denisovian, could they have been on the Earth at the same time? Why not, right? But the real question if there was this repeated introduction of new life forms, why would the humanoid species bear any resemblance to each other if they were from different worlds of time periods, right? My question is why not? Right. If we're. Humanoids created. In the image and glory of God, why would that change? Now yes, there are different species, but as we approach the time of Adam, those species appear more and more like Homo sapien like Adam, and so why shouldn't And if Adam was brought here from another world like. Brigham Young speculated.

2:00:15 Why would he? Not Why would there not be that? Commonality in the form of. In the form of mortal man. Yeah. So that shouldn't surprise me or anybody else. No, no. Oh man. It's on the tip of my. Tongue. It's almost happening. Oh, I'm not gonna get it. It's all right. It's all right, Ken. As always, dude. This was good stuff, my man. Well, thanks I I was. This was a lot of fun. It was a lot of homework. But and and really, I mean I I lose sleep. All this stuff rattling in my round of my brain and trying to make sense of these migration patterns of these haplogroups and how that would relate to LDS teachings, you know, and biblical history and all that sort of stuff.

2:01:04 So it's been a delightful tour for me as well. Awesome. All right, man. Well. Everybody. And we'll see you next time. Bye. See you. Thanks.

2:01:46 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.