Episode #123: Seeing Through The Deception Of The Mormon Revisionist History-A Breakdown Of The Debate Between Taylor Smith & Justin Griffin W/Taylor Smith
Go To https://rumble.com/user/MormonRenegade for free video & access to exclusive content
Renegade Supply Store: https://renegade-supply-shop.printify.me/products
So about ten years ago I remember sitting around the dinner table with my kids and I remember they said something about the Founding Fathers that was just patently false. I asked where they heard such a thing and they said school. This caused me to look at their curriculum and what I discovered was that certain power brokers on the left had infiltrated public schools and one of their agendas was to discredit the founders so they could “progress” past the constitution. Unfortunately, we are now seeing the same thing happening to Mormonism. There is a movement right now within Mormonism (The Doctrine of Christ Group) that is doing at best revisionist history and at worst just telling flat out lies about Joseph Smith, Brigham Young, John Taylor and others that were so influential and vital to the Restoration in those early days. They are doing this to discredit that early leadership, by discrediting them they then can turn the Restored Gospel into something that appeals more to their own hearts desires. This type of tactic is not only wrong but insidious. Now a while back Justin Griffin and Taylor Smith had a debate about Griffin’s movie “Who Killed Joseph Smith” where Griffin accuses John Taylor & Willard Richards of killing Hyrum & Joseph. But darn it wouldn’t you know it Griffin marked that debate as private. Well, no need to worry because Taylor still has his copy and is still available on his YouTube Chanel. Today Taylor joins me on the podcast to have a discussion about the debate. During the course of our conversation, as we breakdown the high points of that debate I think it will become apparent why Griffin might not want this out and circulating. Oh, and just for good measure I have included the link to the full debate in the show notes.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdeoB5I0V7
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HzINMcws8zM
--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support
0:00 So about 10 years ago, I remember sitting around the dinner table with my kids and I remember they said something about the Founding Fathers that was just patently false. I asked where they had heard such a thing, and they said it was at school. Now this caused me to look into their curriculum. And what I discovered was, is that there were certain power brokers on the left who'd infiltrated public schools, and one of their agendas was to discredit the founders so they could, quote, progress past the Constitution. Unfortunately, we're seeing the very same thing happening to Mormonism right now. There's a movement among Mormonism called the Doctrine of Christ movement, and it's doing at best revisionist history and at worst just telling flat out lies about Joseph Smith, Brigham Young, John Taylor, and others that were so influential and vital in those early days of the Restoration.
0:45 They're doing this to discredit that early leadership because by discrediting them, they can then turn the restored gospel into something that appeals more to their own hearts desires. This type of attack is not only wrong, but insidious. Now, a while back, Justin Griffin and Taylor Smith had a debate about Griffin's movie Who Killed Joseph Smith? Where Griffin accuses John Taylor and Willard Richards of killing Hiram and Joseph. But darn it, wouldn't you know it? Griffin marked that debate as private. Well, no need to worry. Taylor Smith still has a copy and it's available on his YouTube channel today. Taylor joins me on the podcast to have a discussion about the debate. During the course of our conversation, as we break down the high points of that debate, I think it's going to become pretty apparent why Griffin might not want this out there and circulating. Oh, and just for good measure, I've included a link to the full debate in the show notes.
1:38 I mean, you wouldn't want that to get lost, right? That and more on this episode of the Mormon Renegade podcast. So a few weeks back I told you about a new online merch store I was putting together and that I would let you know as soon as that was up and running. Well, after a few weeks of working on designs and testing it out personally, we're ready to launch. So if you go to. Mormonrenegade.com and click on the Renegade supply button in the top right of the landing page or click the link in this episode's show notes. You'll see that we have 16 items right now that you can choose from. We have shirts, hats, bags, cups. And water bottles. All with the Mormon Renegade logo, as well as a couple other designs that I think you'll find really funny, and maybe even one where I take a slight shot at BYU. But you should definitely go check that out. Now this is just the beginning.
2:23 In the coming weeks, more designs and styles. Will be available for purchase now. All the proceeds I get from this are going to go right back into the podcast, so head on over to mormonrenegade.com and press the Renegade supply button or click the link in this episode's show notes and get yours today. Look, it's no secret that our society has become much more crude and coarse. To become and raise men and women of virtue and character is a Herculean task. To help with this, I have recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior and Company and Conversation. It was a book with 110 rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society, something that today's society is sorely lacking. What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So the book is.
3:16 Laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule. Right below that is my explanation for the 21st century, and below that you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, to go along with this, there's a workbook that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids. To find the book, go to mormonrenegade.com, go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post, and order your copy. Today I can bear personal testimony from personal experience that this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast. Taylor, my man, what are you doing? Oh, living the dream as always, brother. How are you, Dave?
4:34 I'm. I'm good. I'm good. I I am getting a little some heat, you might say, from certain folks that maybe don't think plural marriage is historical and that crazy things like people who believe like, and I thought this was over, right? Like I was like, this is done. But those folks who were like, Oh no, Brigham and John Taylor totally conspired to kill Joseph Smith. So I went looking for Justin Griffin's stuff, 'cause I knew he had debated you. And when I went on his channel, I couldn't find anything. And then and then you said you still had it. So I was like, well, there you go, We should just do an entire breakdown of this, right?
5:23 I'll put on my best John Madden hat and I'll just color, comment, commentate this thing all the way through. Well, I'm here for that, brother. Let's do it. All right. And I'll just say before we kind of dive in it, it is very interesting 'cause these are all like 100 and 6070 year old narratives that be were the predominant narrative of the RLDS branch after the. So after the martyrdom, everything scattered, right, you know and and Brigham and the 12 tried to hold the body of the church together but there were thousands if not 10s of thousands who didn't follow Brigham and come out West and and you know settle Utah and so the RLDS. So James Strang was a was a guy.
6:08 William Smith was was involved. Sidney Rigdon had some claims and then eventually after the dust kind of settled and everybody was like, well, now what they formed, they came together. A lot of them. Those different factions united and created the RLDS. Now the the thing that gives the RLDS any shred of credibility is Emma of course renounced and denied to her dying breath the Brigham and the 12. The the documented history of the Naavu period. And, you know, and Emma is a pretty credible witness if she's honest. And and as we, you know so it it's I don't have necessarily a whole lot of negative things to say about people in the 1850s who said I would I would take Emma's word for something over Brigham Young's or you know John Taylor's or those guys 'cause, I mean she was very close to the prophet.
7:03 She would know. But but at, you know as time passed and especially so basically the RLDS narrative shaped by Emma Smith and her testimony was that the 12 were liars and that Joseph Smith did not teach or practice polygamy in secret and that you know and polygamy's evil, it's a sin And you know and and Hiram didn't either and and all of these things. And so this narrative was was a very strong narrative for a lot of people that didn't like Brigham Young didn't follow the people out to Utah and and and even Joseph Smith the third. Now he was young when his father Joseph Smith was killed at at Carthage and his mother obviously had massive influence on Joseph the third growing up.
7:56 And so Joseph Smith the third also believed his mother's testimony and and bought into her narrative that Joseph that his dad was not a polygamist and all these things. Well so the so this these are age-old narratives and of course they have to like throw shade and and you know try to question the credibility of Brigham Young and John Taylor as much as Paul and Willie Richards on all the 12 as much as possible. So this like conspiracy theory of will the 12 were complicit with the martyrdom because they were trying to get rid of Joseph and Hiram so they could take over. Like this is an age-old narrative. This is something that originated in the early 1850s, even as early as the late 1840s, just a few years after Joseph and Hiram's martyrdom. So I call guys like, just like, well, and so I I called polygamy deniers in general, RLDS fundamentalists. That's very cool.
8:50 Yeah, I like that. But you know, Justin Griffin, in this Doctrine of Christ movement, they actually take it even further, 'cause, you know, so there's the RLDS Fundamentalists, which would be like your Denver Snuffers and, you know, people that deny polygamy, but they they kind of, they believe that Joseph Smith died a prophet. You have your the Kirtland apostasy, though, which believes that Joseph was a fallen prophet. And so then the, so I would call these David Whitmer, fundamentalist people who still buy into this narrative cause. David Whitmer, Oliver Cowdrey. Like the the Three Witnesses apostatized during the Kirtland era, they kicked Joseph Smith out of his own church and he had to, you know, get out of town.
9:31 He left Kirtland, went down to Missouri and you know, during all of that period of persecution and and trials. Well, so David Whitmer believed, believed that Joseph Smith was a true prophet, translated the Book of Mormon by the gift and power of God. But then he fell from his calling in Mantle as a prophet and and so this doctrine of Christ's narrative that that as Justin Griffin explained to my face is much more akin to David Whitmer fundamentalism, Whitmerite fundamentalism, then even the RLDS fundamentalism. Now both of them are very anti polygamy obviously. And so there is flavors of the RLDS fundamentalist narrative in Griffin's message. But I would actually because because they actually talk about how they think that the church lost the priesthood and Joseph fell as a prophet.
10:21 Now on all that stuff, we might not get super deep into that, but anybody that listened to any of the Phil Davis interviews or has listened to Justin Griffin over the over the time knows what exactly what I'm talking about. So. Interesting. So because Phil Davis was was the one who kind of picked off this whole doctrine of Christ movement, right? Yes he he became a very early I guess founder influencer within that movement and he has since parted ways with that movement not by his choice he he kind of got kicked out by by others in the movement and and I don't I haven't followed him I I don't really keep super close tabs on the on these you know polygamy denier movements but occasionally I'll kind of bump into him and and or hears things about him and things that's going on. I'm also off social media.
11:17 I I deleted Facebook a few years ago and so I kind of am out of the loop on a lot of that stuff and but hey, I'm actually a lot happier and like my life so. Sure. Sure. You know, I've I've said of this movement for a while. They are eerily reminiscent of modern day. And when I say modern day, I mean the last 100 years modern day progresses because of the tactics that they use, right? If we look back at what the progressives have done to the Founding Father and the founding documents of the United States, what you find is that in order to discredit their message, they have to discredit the messenger.
11:58 So you get this narrative of rich white slave owners and and some of them did own slaves. I want to say that. But but the way they paint the picture is, is that there was no moral conundrum about it. They didn't think about it, all these other things and you get much the same thing in this doctrine of Christ movement, right? Because even though they still try to keep Joseph Smith, it's a very different Joseph Smith than what is borne out by actual good history, right. And I've I've talked to a few historians about this. You've been Privy to to a couple of those conversations and and I just don't find any sort of veracity to their claims. They they point to obscure things, the and, and that flies in the face of multiple accounts on many of their issues. And so I find it a bit insidious that way. And then they can, they go on to completely try, try to discredit Brigham Young, which if you're looking at remaking Mormonism into something closer to your heart's desire, that's exactly what you would need to do.
13:04 Because Brigham Young is a linchpin between Joseph Smith and the rest of the Restoration on down, whether you're LDS, whether you're fundamentalist, whatever the case is, you hold to Brigham Young on some level. And so if you can discredit Brigham Young and you can discredit John Taylor, you now have and and your Joseph Smith is different than the historical Joseph Smith. You now have the ability to recreate Mormonism into anything you want it to be. And I find it very disturbing and and I find it disturbing because because of the blatant lies that come through and people who might feel like there's something wrong in the church. And and let's face it, I believe there's something wrong inside the church, right?
13:50 I I don't, I don't believe that that all is well in Zion. But what I attribute that to is a departure from from those those orthodox principles they would attribute it to. No, it's always been wrong, ever since Joseph Smith died. Totally. A lot of thoughts on that. I'm just gonna First off, when you talked about progressive tactics, they're they're using these progressive tactics, 100% agree. You know, George Orwell put it this way in his book, I believe it's 1984. He says those who control the present control the past. Those who control the past control the future and and you know and I'm not saying that these doctrine of Christ people control the present but but the the, the the church has, you know for generations they kind of had that, you know, stranglehold on the history. But they have you know in just recent years, this last couple of decades really opened up those archives. And so it has been vindicating for a lot of the fundamentalists to to basically say, yeah well this is what we've been saying all along but, but so going back though to you know, it is insidious.
15:07 It is lies. It is, it is just pure evil. But if we just look at it as you know they are exerting their will that's not very empowering. That's like that's like basically playing the victim card. Like we couldn't control this and this and that and and what I actually would encourage people, especially those listening or anybody within this, you know, any of the listeners here of influence is this is a meet, this is an US problem. Let's look inward and say if I actually studied history, if I actually studied my scriptures, if I actually was well familiar and acquainted with these principles, I could have never been touched by these lies because I would have already known the truth. And so like we obviously this the, the whole point of having this conversation today is to expose a lot of those lies and to inform and educate people so that they can have all of the the the information necessary to come to a correct conclusion and make a correct decision moving forward. But but it's not like you know nobody's dependent on me. None of the things that I'm going to be presenting or talking about or showing you guys today is is like I'm more qualified than anybody else.
16:17 I just put in the homework. I it's something I do think is important and feels important. It's something I will say definitely I felt inspired to engage in this in this debate, these debates and join the conversation and so yeah, we'll do the best that we can, but I just want to encourage everybody. You're you don't have to take my word for it. You don't have to take Dave's word for it. You don't have to take anybody's word for it. All of these things are available. It just comes at a price. You got to put in the time and the effort to study and learn and figure things out on your own. Awesome. Now we're going to, we're going to watch an old debate that you had with with Justin Griffin. How long ago was that debate? How long ago would that take place? Let's see, this was this would have been in 2022. In fact, I'll just go ahead and share my screen, 'cause we're going to be playing share sound, OK, perfect. I'm going to be sharing multiple clips from this and so when did I publish this?
17:16 A year ago, I think it's been almost two years ago. This would have probably been in 2022 for sure, probably like April, May, May or something like that. How did you get wrapped up? In in doing the debate with them. OK, actually, so this is my YouTube channel. I haven't, I'm not super active on YouTube or anything. I created the channel because of Justin Griffin. So what happened was IA mutual friend of ours Kevin crowd. His wife Beverly is a is a friend of ours. And she got in touch with me and was saying, hey, there's this new documentary that was just put out called Who Killed Joseph Smith and it claims it.
17:58 It makes the case that John Taylor and Willard Richards killed Joseph Smith. And I'm like, what? Well, surely nobody's going to buy you that. I mean, that's that's absurd. And she's like, well, a lot of people are getting pulled into it. And, you know, and I I watched it and it was actually kind of, you know, convincing. I I didn't buy. I didn't. I didn't accept it. I didn't believe it. But man, it raises some hard questions. So I was like, oh crap, I've got to watch this. So I watched it. And then I was talking to her or Kevin, I can't remember. And and I was just like, OK, this is high production value. This is going to you know and but the most the, the main reason I think that it is as influential as it has been is because it gives people permission to give voice to a lot of their concerns that they've had about the church.
18:47 There's and there's a lot of reasons especially during COVID to have concerns about the church and some of the things that the church has done And so this gives you permission to basically distance yourself from the church and and think that you're getting closer to the original gospel of the Restoration and and and and basically if the because if the church is in apostasy now it's not a question of if, but when did it go off course when did it go astray And you know and if you can trace it back to Brigham Young and throw him in the 12 under the bus. The other advantage to that is you don't have to deal with polygamy, which is not people's favorite subject to confront. And and I get it, it's it's not something that is a pleasing doctrine and it's something that was very challenging spiritually and all this.
19:35 And so it's like it's like the perfect storm of all of these things. I think it it was people were vulnerable because of COVID and the Church's response to it. They had these concerns with politics and and corruption and and people like the church was changing ordinances right and left and so and then the Justin Griffin puts out this documentary and it feeds into that dissatisfaction and and gives you permission to accept Joseph Smith and you can get rid of polygamy. It's like the perfect storm. And if I think it was very exploitive, the way that it came about at at targeting people in a very vulnerable position.
20:17 And so anyway, so I'm talking to to to Kevin and Beverly. About this and I'm just like OK, he was absolutely wrong and I wasn't even just looking at it from a doctrinal scriptural perspective. Even though I it's something I believe doctrinally and and historically and and scripturally but but I I have some experience shooting I I own rifles and I like to try to hit targets from a long ways off and so I've studied Ballistics and it's and I've I've done applied Ballistics. I I can target things from a long ways off And so his I was looking at it just from a forensics Ballistics perspective and I'm like this doesn't hold water this is just an absolute sieve and and they're like well that's cool you ought to like put that information out somewhere. I'm like how where you know I don't I don't have a channel I don't have an audience or nothing. But I was like yeah if you if you come across anybody that is having concerns and is and is sincere have them give me a call.
21:18 I'm happy to talk. Well, I think it was just a couple days after that, Beverly Kraut asked me, hey, I have a, a friend who's a a Joseph Smith Foundation historian. Her name is Kimberly Watson Smith. And and so she has been following this Justin Griffin Doctrine of Christ movement. And you know, she would talk with you and and she's got a like a Facebook group and she, you know, you could get this stuff on YouTube and and just get some information out there. So. So Justin, Francom, Kimberly Watson, Smith and I sat down together and I think, can you see my screen? I thought I was stupid. I see. Down there in the lower right hand corner, there's some guy that you're listening to on a podcast.
22:01 Very, very right. Yeah, I would be careful of that. That's. Yeah. It's a little fringy a. Little fringy, A little cringy. You know, I hear he got banned on YouTube, so. Close. close. He got banned. He he ducked out before he got his third. Oh, you got your second strike. OK, so anyway, so I've only uploaded a handful of these videos, and and they're pretty much most almost all of them are directly related to this doctrine of Christ. Polygamy denial. Justin Griffin. John Taylor? Accused of murdering The Smiths. And so this first one was about two hours and 17 minutes long and we just go through and we have an an unscripted conversation. That's why I called the name of the channel the gospel unscripted.
22:43 And I didn't have a channel, but we recorded this and and then I created the channel so I could upload it. So that's how basically this channel got started and and so anyway on this video of who killed Joseph Smith debunked whoops. I wasn't intended to play it, but anyway, we there was oh, that's what it was. So we post this video, right. And we're having this conversation. And then so Justin Griffin hears about this video from his I summoned in his network send him the link and and it's like, hey Kim Bruce Kim Smith is coming after you and she's got these two guys that she had this conversation. So Justin Griffin takes out of this two hours and 17 minutes conversation.
23:31 He targets 10 minutes and he does a 40 minute episode on his YouTube channel debunking us debunking him. But again, he focuses in on 10 minutes, ignores the other two hours plus, and he spends 30 minutes talking about it. And over the course of the 30 minutes, he doesn't actually debunk anything. He just says I I don't. I think they're wrong. Over and over. Well, in that video that he posted though he said, you know I talk with these guys they seem like, you know honest, you know sincere guys that and I'd, I'd, I'd be happy to talk with them well. So I got of course got wind of him doing that response video from Kim actually.
24:18 And so I hop on there and I'm listening and I hear him basically invite me on to his channel. And so I could I get in the comments. I'm like, hey Justin, I'll take you up on that invite. Just tell me when and where I'll be there and and and so there were some conditions. He absolutely refused to engage with me if Kim Smith was on the call. And and and so I said OK I I talked to Kim and you know like she made sure she was cool with it and I said, so Kimberly, Justin will not meet with me if you're involved. I mean no offense but do you mind if I just go on alone and fly solo. She says no.
24:58 No not at all. So I I I sent him all of my talking points all the questions and. And he So there was no, I didn't want him to accuse me of you know, engaging under false pretenses or a bait and switch. I was extremely clear and upfront. I I think you're wrong. I think your theory doesn't hold water. I think your presentation is is a lie and it sucks. And and I was very upfront with that and I sent it all in advance and he accepted the terms of engagement, so to speak. And then he like flipped things right at the last second like the day of the night of. And I almost was like Dang, do I back out of this, like, is this really going to be worth my time? And I prayed about it and I just felt like you know what it needs to happen.
25:47 And so I I went through with it anyway. And so that is how this first video came to be. And so I I left it uncut. There's it's over 2 hours long, 2 hours and 5 minutes long. So and then there's a Part 2. So at the end of this first one, we didn't quite cover everything and and so there was a second part. And then I I dialed in just a part of that second conversation of of just me presenting 'cause he challenged me at the end of the first one to come up with my own theory and to present it. And so I so if people are at all interested in kind of seeing the whole thing for yourself, you know, it's all up there on YouTube. What's interesting about it?
26:30 And you kind of alluded to this earlier, Dave. We both consented to recording this conversation and we both guaranteed that, you know, you'll send me a copy of the recording, I'll send you a copy of the record, We'll both have a copy of this full conversation recording so we can both upload it to our respective channels. Well, so Justin Griffin uploaded the the the videos to his channel, but I don't. I'm not sure if he ever actually did upload the second-half this round two. If he did he has completely pulled it off and then a few months after the first one dropped because he did have it uploaded onto his channel.
27:15 At first just public. But he has said since set this round one conversation to private you have to request access from him, the owner, before he would allow you to watch the round one on his channel. So effectively he has tried to hide or or bury this information from his followers. Fortunately, I have my own independent channel that he has no control over and so it's still available to anybody that's interested anyway, does that, yeah, that's kind of a long answer of it. One one other question. And then we'll move on to the video here and and stop and and you know, make some commentary here. He he produces 2 movies, right?
27:58 And I've heard rumors of 1/3 in the works. I'm not sure if that's factual or not, but. He. He. You're right, those movies, do you have some pretty good production quality, right? You know, anyone who's done any sort of of film work knows that that stuff's not cheap, right? Do we know who's funding him? Is this self funded? Do we have any idea? Cause a lot of times I'm like, OK, where's the money? Let's follow the money and see where this is coming from, 'cause normally that'll tell you what the the what the, you know who, who the real power players are. Yeah, I actually don't know who funded it. I I know that Griffin.
28:43 I don't know if he's like wealthy enough to fully independently fund this himself. I but I I I think he's doing OK financially. I we have a mutual friend who who used to know him 'cause he was a a senior manager at Cutco years ago and and so like he has a background in sales and marketing. He has a background in upper management at those at in those capacities. And you know, I know speaking a little bit from personal experience or just personal observation, those guys are doing pretty good financially and you know and if that's been his career for several years, I I can imagine that setting himself up pretty good. So I don't know if he actually did fully fund this independently on his own or if there were other people that kind of pooled resources.
29:37 Either way it it is. I mean I don't know if it was $1,000,000 but it was certainly a a large investment to produce his his part one Part 2. I mean, it was expensive because they hired the guy. Back in New York. The forensic detective, I can't forget his name. I I have notes of it somewhere. But anyway they they did hire him and he's not cheap. I mean that had to have been 10s of thousands or more to to get him to come on. And unfortunately it didn't really do, it didn't strengthen their narrative or their, you know, further their agenda because he basically said yeah, the eyewitnesses accounts could be fine and I don't think your theory really holds water, says the, the forensic expert who paid as a consultant for that.
30:25 But so part one I would definitely say was far more effective because he tried to lock in and and and really dial in on just the 2-3 minutes in the Carthage jail and tried to build a case in that vacuum that the the the mob was not responsible for Joseph's, Empyrean's murders. But it it was John Taylor and Will Richards. It was an inside job. And the 2nd movie is a lot more about like him getting excommunicated and him taking heat and getting criticized and him, you know, going to this forensic detective expert guy and and being told that his theory sucks. Like that's that's what Part 2 is all about. And it's hilarious cause during the conversations that I had with him he refused to to tell me what Part 2 'cause I was like, dude, I know where you're going with this. Why would you frame John Taylor as the murderer if you weren't gonna just you know then use that to to see to be go to go anti polygamy to prefer the push the narrative that Joseph Smith was against polygamy and it was just the 12 and so I and and he was like no he denied it over and over to my face and and then hilariously at the end the closing scene of part two of his of his second documentary it says part three anti polygamy. So he created Part 2 just to get
32:01 me and Kimberly Watson Smith to prove that we were wrong. But it wasn't gonna be about polygamy when it was always gonna be about polygamy. But he had to prove us wrong first. So he comes up with filler content that really looks, makes him look terrible. And then at the end he teases the anti polygamy thing is and that's what part three is supposed to be about and maybe he'll produce it. I don't know. I I have no insight on whether that's in production or or if that's gonna ever come out. Gotcha. But so this conversation that I had with Justin Griffin was before Part 2 came out and it was just the his, his first video had just come out. I think he dropped part one in like January of 2022 maybe somewhere, you know, give or take a month. And then he dropped Part 2 in January of 2023. And so this was this would have been probably May Ish, April, May, June somewhere in there of January of 2022. And then the second conversation we had was was like within a month or so after this first one, but we'll start with part one.
33:10 And and so like the I, I didn't know Justin, I had never met him before, I didn't have first hand information. So a lot of the conversation that Justin Francom and and Kimberly Smith and I had had, we were dependent on Kim for a lot of the like back story and context and like who is Phil Davis and who is this doctrine of Christ's movement and what is this all about and and what do they believe and what's their angle? Why are they coming out with this Who Killed Joseph Smith documentary like we were dependent on Kim. And so I spent a lot of this first part of this conversation just asking him so that I, it wasn't hearsay based, that it was just straight from the horse's mouth. So who are you?
33:53 What's your story like? Where are you? What's your background? And in the first few minutes of this, of this conversation between Griffin and me, he said that he began producing this documentary in early 2021. So his journey, you know, out of the church and questioning polygamy and all this stuff he said began in early 2020. So he was fairly new in this journey, you know, in his discovery of of whatever when he began producing. About a year. Into it. And so the two major events that he talked about in the start of his journey was #1 encountering the concept, the idea that Joseph didn't practice or teach polygamy and I don't know if that came I I forget if he if he specified.
34:42 But I mean that's a very old narrative. If you go back to RLDSI know the Snufferites and you know Denver Snuffer in that movement has kind of really adopted that. And so he says that that was a a massive idea that that he encountered that led him on this path that he's on. And then he found the Carthage conspiracy, which was produced by a literal RLDS fundamentalist in the 90s or maybe it was 80s. I don't know if you've seen that on YouTube. It's like VHS quality this kind of guy that gets up in front of a chalkboard and and is like talking about Ballistics evidence, even though he doesn't know anything about Ballistics. And he's like saying that yeah it was an inside job.
35:25 The mob didn't kill Joseph and hire him and and it was a hostile takeover like basically stuff that the RLDS church now the the community of Christ has officially disavowed and recanted and and has acknowledged that they were wrong for many decades now. Once they first got trained historians, they realized they can't. They have no leg to stand on to try to cling to that old narrative. But anyway, but this is a guy from the RLDS church who was a true believer and he thought that his church had sold out to the progressive movement or you know, even though it was, they were just acknowledging the truth about the history and and so he was perpetuating the original narrative, the fundamentalist RLDS narrative about the Carthage conspiracy. So Griffin admits that he that this is what inspired him and and got him going.
36:20 And he he admits that he was affiliated with The Doctrine of Christ and with Phil Davis before beginning to produce the documentary. Interesting. And and I actually just so I wanna play this. So this idea of him just like finding out with everybody else as he does his research like it it was an inside job, is is bunk. He came at this knowing full well what what the Shtec was, so to speak. He had his answer before he started filming, but he so he so it's it's very disingenuous and dishonest the way that he presented 'cause he was trying to, you know, if you watch the if, if anybody here has watched the documentary, I don't recommend it if you haven't. But if you have, you know that he spends the whole first part like pretending to be a sincere truth secret and just having like serious questions and this and that. Meanwhile, he admitted to me that all along he he he already had come to his conclusions and he was just trying to prove these assumptions through the course of making this documentary.
37:26 But you know, it's not not very scientific when you start with the the answer before you do the tests and before you look at the evidence. So and especially when evidence contradicts your conclusions, you have to either revisit your conclusion or you have to throw out the evidence. And as you'll see as we go through this conversation he threw out evidence and still continues to this data threw out evidence. So but let's just play. I got about a 1520 second clip or so but it kind of and so you can just you know if if you can't hear the audio coming through the recording, just let me know. But hopefully it is. No, I was already a part of Doctor I had met, remember? We filmed a year later, so in that preview, here is when I started meeting all those guys and. Hanging.
38:15 Oh, OK. So you were you were pretty closely affiliated by the time you began creating the documentary? Yeah, I mean, I I, I love those guys. I think they're awesome. Anyone that talks about doctrine? Christ, I just think it's fantastic. So. OK, so again, just to to I just want it to come straight from his mouth that he admitted to me on this recorded conversation that he already was buying into these narratives before he began producing his documentary. I'm gonna. He he says something there that I think is is super important and kind of super telling, right. The fact that he says, well, anybody that talks about the doctrine of Christ, right, you know, good guys, they give this the most innocuous sounding name so that it it just, you know, like who would?
39:07 As if Brigham Young never talked about the doctrine of Christ, or John Taylor or any of those guys. And and it's. Something that we, you know, let's face it if someone said, hey, do you want to talk about the doctrine, you know, pre this stuff, you want to talk about the doctrine of Christ, I'm like well yeah, that that's exactly what I want to do. But you don't realize it's it's back loaded with a whole bunch of bad history and quite frankly flat out lies. They've tried to Co opt it. They haven't succeeded, but they're giving it their best effort. And so we need to push back on that and 'cause they don't, they don't own like the, the trademark on the the doctrine of Christ that nobody can.
39:48 But so this is a very counter narrative that they're trying to promote and they, you know, and they're putting money into it and they're pretty decent recruiters and they find people that are in that position of vulnerability and then they exploit it. So, you know, be warned, anybody that's listening or if there's anybody that, you know, warn your neighbors. So I'm gonna, I'm gonna just play this next clip is a little bit longer just like a minute and 1/2 or so though and and the question that I ask is OK. If you were affiliated with the doctrine of Christ before you began producing this documentary, why didn't you disclose that? So let's let's listen to his answer to that. Question Was it a conscious decision or just an oversight? But like, why didn't you disclose your affiliation with Doctrine of Christ Phil Davis in the film? I think, I don't know.
40:46 Again, I was affiliated not with doctrine of Christ, with all sorts of different. I was in probably 50 different Facebook groups. I was on all sorts of different forms. There was all sorts of people I would listen and talk with, so. You didn't want to limit yourself to just one. But I mean there is a point that you're making which which is I could have said, look I'm not, I'm not the, I'm not the Mormon that wrote this that you can be safe listening to where we grew up in the church. And it's like, oh, is he a Mormon or not? That's how I'm going to determine if I read the book and is he apostle or you know, that's the judgment you make. I'm not that guy and I didn't, I didn't make that clear in the movie. And you know why?
41:30 I was still a member. If I had said something like that, it would have been all over. I was not trying to lose my membership. I didn't want to lose my network. I didn't want to. I mean, that was everything. That was my whole life. I was not trying to ruin that. Now, you know, I'm a little bit more like, OK, I'm OK. I'm OK to say what's on my mind. I'll speak my mind. And even if it goes against what you leave, I'm OK. But but then. So that's good enough for there. Any thoughts on that, Dave? Oh, OK. So here's the thing, right? As you know, as a guy who's out there and open, I can totally respect somebody who wants to stay in the LDS Church, but you know, may have some some differing beliefs and want to keep that secret, keep that on the down low, right. I get it, I get it.
42:22 And I'm totally good with allowing somebody that latitude because quite frankly. We all have. Our various callings to fulfill some in the church, some out of the church, whatever the case may be, So I'm good with that. However, I feel like once you take a different approach and you start putting out content and you expect people to take that serious, you now step into another another realm, so to speak, right? You've crossed the line. You've crossed the line and now you have to own your crap, OK? And and for those who listen to this podcast regularly, this is the whole reason that when I left the branch, I came out very quickly after that in a little 2 minute blurp and said I'm out of there, right. So that there was never a false pretense under which I was operating.
43:15 Now to say that, well, it was just a Facebook group and I was, you know, looking to stay in the church. OK, let's just take that at face value. You wanted to stay in the church then. Do you think that maybe producing an entire movie that destroys the character or attempts to destroy the character of two of the of the the 1st 3 presidents of the church may present a problem? I mean, if that's what you're really worried about, Justin, I don't think you were really on the right track there. So I would say you got to kind of own this, right? And what what he says there doesn't hold water. At some point someone's gonna see the film and they're gonna realize it's your face all over the front of that bad boy and you're gonna have some questions to answer anyway. So why not just come right out and own it? And so when he said.
44:07 Answer about I wanna. Stay. You know I wasn't looking to leave. I call bullcrap. Well, and the the ironic. The ironic thing is, he actually got excommunicated before the video dropped. Oh, wow. So at that point why not disclose your affiliation up front. Otherwise it's it's very it's very manipulative, it's very dishonest because you're you're you're exploiting a relationship of trust. You know Mormons, we tend to think that other Mormons are trustworthy. You know we we you know if if you if you understand that you're a member of the same church there's some baked in expectations with that and he abused he exploited those that position of trust even though he had been exed and he he knew and he admits this I'm not that guy I'm not a safe person for somebody that believes in the church you know doctrines and and history.
45:09 He he admitted and he knew he admitted he knew going in that he was being manipulative and dishonest. And so I think that that is a very big problem and and it I'm glad that he admitted to me on this recorded conversation that the truth about that but it doesn't undo all of the hundreds of I don't know thousands maybe. I don't know how many people watched his show and it shook him and you know maybe they he he they got recruited to join his movement or maybe they just went atheist or anti Mormon or maybe they stayed in the church but it just caused him a lot of spiritual turmoil. I don't know but that is reckless and irresponsible and and so I'm I I just wanted to call him out on that and then as you were saying you know take some ownership dude like men own their crap if we do something wrong.
46:04 If we if we do something you you you need, it's it's a very important aspect of manhood to own your actions. And and so I kind of pushed back on this cause, 'cause he was like trying to basically play the victim card. I didn't want to lose my membership in the church. And so, you know, like, and I understand why, 'cause he had his network like that was he loses his credibility as a recruiter for his Doctrine of Christ movement. If he's gets exed you know imagine if if he was still a member to this day and he could like DM people private message people and like talk about basically hey what do you think about you know President Nelson's mask encouraging and you know and just exploiting people who already are you know struggling with things that the church does and and and to have that you know position of trust to claim that you're that you're a member of the church it gives him an in to a lot of people.
47:09 But anyway, so I asked him. In fact, I I'll just. But. Before we go to that clip, I just want to make sure 'cause I think this is a huge point here. We need to keep in mind that whole, that whole first movie. He approaches it from the standpoint he's an active member in good standing with the church, and during that filming process you're saying he was ex somewhere in that process. He was excommunicated before the movie was released. I don't know. I I don't know. And if I did, I don't remember how long like he he. I presume that he was still an an active, you know, member in good standing, like he hadn't been exed at least when he had started filming, but before he finished filming, 'cause he in the movie, he actually at like the at the very towards the end he admits that he just got excommunicated and in part one and so it's like, OK, so you got excommunicated, but you didn't disclose that at the first part like that.
48:16 To me, that changes everything. He should have gone. That changes absolutely everything 'cause I was like OK, even if it's in post production. Yes. Throw a little disclaimer on the at the very beginning or the very end of the movie saying I, you know, I'm not affiliated with the LDS Church anymore, but instead he plays this out all the way through until the very. Yeah, and he does. He does have at the end of the movie, like the the he discloses that he was excommunicated in part one. But to me, the damage has already been done at that point. That should have been disclosed up front. And he's certainly was dishonest in the way he presented 'cause he was he like he had just admitted, we just listened to the clip. He admitted that he was affiliated with Phil Davis and the Doctrine of Christ movement before he even began filming anything on part one.
49:08 Yeah, So that's that's just a private agenda or a, you know, dirty, dirty. Pool. Dirty. All right, so let's let's listen to this next clip. Surely you weren't surprised that the church took action after, I mean. Because you came out and basically accused their second and third, possibly more presidents of conspiracy or or murder. Like, did you really think that the church wasn't going to do anything in response, like as a response to that? Yeah, I mean, I'm not crazy or naive, but you know, if I if I had my dream come true, it would be them putting resources that I don't have into this.
49:57 Hey, let's investigate this and figure out. So he's not naive, but he wants to the church to put resources into investigating the Carthage conspiracy. But he's not naive. I mean, really, I don't. Yeah, yeah, I'll, I'll stop there. I was gonna say something else, but I'm gonna, I'm gonna stop there because the the fact that look, had I started this podcast when I was still, you know, an active member of the LDS church, I would fully expect to get hauled in, right. I would fully expect to get, like brought in.
50:40 There should be no doubt in your mind on this. And so he acts like Golly Gee Wally. I just wanted him to do some more research and it's just too bad it didn't go that direction. Yeah. So and and as to so Well I'll save that there's we're gonna kind of come back to this theme here in a little bit with some future clips. But so let's just keep moving on here 'cause we could go we could just watch the whole thing and like pause it every 30 seconds and just comment and and insert. But but there's a few specific clips I want to highlight that I think are worth examining together and and I just want to stay focused on that. So.
51:24 So this in in at the 33 1/2 minute mark or so. I asked him the next question so we'll just go from there. So what I, I, I, I I guess, you know, in our Facebook or our YouTube comments back and forth, I. You said I was making some assumptions. I don't. I just want to hear it straight from your mouth. So what? What do you believe John Taylor's motive was if he murdered Joseph and Hiram? So I'm not ready to comment on that. It would, I can't say, I cannot say with as much confidence on the motive as I can on the evidence. So that's one thing I want to get stronger at as the motive and explaining all of that. But for right now, I I don't want to do that until I'm ready.
52:08 OK OK so this I think is really key because this is I think the first time. Remember I I sent this to him days in advance. I did not blind side him with any of these questions. He had days to think about his answer and he chose to not comment on the motive and because but but but the real the reality is like I have a friend his brother was a homicide detective for 20 years and and I asked my friend to ask his brother do do homicide detectives investigate a murder and only look at forensic evidence and in a vacuum and ignore motive and and and you know other context and and and circumstances and he said are you crazy. Nobody ever does that.
53:05 You when you're investigating a murder you're always looking at motive as you're analyzing evidence and collecting you know evidence And so like a good detective would never divorce those two and and look at them in isolation of one another they're they're inextricably interwoven and so so basically what Justin, if if this is accurate, if he's being honest with me here and he does is expressing maybe a little humility like I just am not ready. I'm not. I'm I I don't know for sure. I haven't thought it through enough. I haven't. Whatever. The fact that he's declining to comment on motive at all at this juncture proves he was not ready to release part one 'cause you're if you're not prepared on motive, you got no business accusing somebody of murder using 160 years ago whenever it was on the basis of only forensic evidence, even if the even if the evidence was like solid you.
54:08 It's premature to to jump to murder accusations and so go ahead, let. Let me ask you this, during this time when as you're getting prepared to have this exchange with with Justin Griffin, are you hearing any rumors or reports or anything that that maybe he's already spilled the beans to other people about what he thinks the motive could be? Kimberly Watson Smith had shared a couple of things that he had posted in Facebook. I was not on Facebook, but yeah, but so cause 'cause like like she was kind of trying to keep tabs on things that was going on in those groups in those circles. And so and so I think it was actually he was not being completely honest with me, but I think he, I, I, I'm open to the possibility that he, he did not feel prepared to engage with me on the motive.
55:12 But again then why are you putting out a documentary? Yeah, So anyway, so let's let's keep jumping ahead cause on this same topic, I've got a time stamp here at the one hour 11 minute just right around here. Whoops. So this next section I'm trying to pivot back into motive. So we've been talking for over 1/2 hour. Between then and now and then, what we do know, I'm going to push back on and. Try not to speculate too much about things we don't know. Fair enough. And and let's pivot into motive if you if you're OK with that.
55:54 Like telling me what you think motive is. Or sure, I don't want to discuss motive. I'm not. The point of the movie is to discuss motive. It's. Just. But you can't accuse men of murder without motive. I'm not trying to accuse anyone of murder. I'm trying to say here's what I think happened in that room. Which is a murder. So but it. It's holy crap. This is right out of Bill Clinton's playbook. Depends on what your definition definition of is is OK, I'm just saying they're in the room. Well, no. In the movie you actually portray, you know, Willard Richards and John Taylor firing at Joseph and Hiram, so.
56:39 Yeah, in his reenactment. Yeah, in his reenactment. So, no, you you are accusing them of murder. Now tell us the motive. Why, Why is this? Why is this happening? And here's the other thing, you you were very generous in saying, even if the evidence was rock solid, but the evidence isn't rock solid. I mean, realistically, I mean, you've got to do suspend some serious reasoning and go completely on faith. I mean, you need more faith to believe in the evidence that he presents you. You need to exercise more faith in that than you do in just reading the Book of Mormon. I mean, holy cow, that's. And the reason it's seductive it's it's it's seductive because it's a pleasing doctrine that it the idea that that that you you can accept Joseph Smith's prophetic mission cause a lot of people sincerely have a conversion story like they they have a a witness or a spiritual experience and they've you know and they've spent their whole lives investing in that spiritual experience this this narrative is so pleasing to the carnal mind because it allows you to retain that but reject everything to do with polygamy and and but the the 1st is if you get exactly the the the at at what cost you know the only revelation that ever talked about eternal marriage is the same revelation that talks about polygamy and so you throw out polygamy and it's like now you
58:10 have to be a complete like buffet style selective. Oh I like I like the idea of eternal marriage but you know I I'll I'll pass on the polygamy. The gospel is not a buffet that you can just pick and choose the things you like about it. It is either true or it's not. And if you if you decide to reject a peace, then, well, you pick up the other end of that stick too. But this is this. This is why it's so seductive, I think, and persuasive to a lot of people, is it? It gives them an out so that they can think that they can, you know, have their key cake and eat it too. Right. So this next is a quick clip. I'll just play it, yeah.
58:53 And there are. Multiple plausible models. Oh yeah, I I presented how many? Seven in the movie 6 or 7? Yeah, but you picked the six arbitrary points that Youth seemed to say disproves. Each again, you say arbitrary points, and I'm not. I just picked the evidence. I picked the physical, hard scientific evidence to base them off of. That's right. But you didn't. Actually, I didn't do. I didn't do. You know what I get so many historians so pissed off about? You didn't follow his story. I'm like, what if I care about historians? How does that tell me this blood in the back of the What is a historian going to tell me about the blood in the back of a crime scene? Nothing.
59:35 So I'm like, this was not about history and everyone tries to bring in history and testimonies from this guy and the mob said they did it. And I'm like, I'm not trying to prove any of that. I just want to look at the 2 to 3 minutes in that crime scene, what happened? Because we've gone all this time thinking it's what the two eyewitnesses said and everyone says that can't be possible. So what happened? That's what we're trying to figure out. OK, so in that little clip he he does admit that other models are possible, but then he denies the value of history. Like, you know, history has no bearing on a on a forensic analysis.
1:00:16 And he claims that there's sufficient forensic evidence to reach a definitive conclusion. But but he had just admitted that other models are possible. But then he argues that his model is the only one that's possible. Like it, just the level of cognitive dissonance and intellectual double standards and dishonesty that we just observed is is astonishing. He's just talking out of both sides of his mouth and I don't even think he even is aware of of of how absurd these statements because they're incompatible. They cannot all be. You can't have other models that are pause, plausible but his model's the only one. Those are mutually exclusive statements. And yet he's just making them one after another and and he, you know, denying the value of history like this, this crime scene as he calls it, is 160 years old. That's the definition of.
1:01:14 History that that's that's his like it's not like it's not like there's some you know yellow caution tape saying crime scene active investigation in progress like that for the last 180 years. So we are completely reliant upon historical documents and affidavits and testimonies and you know evident historical evidences to have any hope of understanding what happened in that location 180 years ago. So, so he he just throws out the value of history blanket, which is very interesting, claims that there's now that was another key thing in this clip. He claims that there's sufficient forensic evidence to reach a definitive conclusion about what happened. But as we're going to see in in the next like I think 2 clips or two or three clips there, three clips down. He completely walks that back.
1:02:08 So let's just keep moving along. I have the next clip queued up here. If I can get to the, there we go. Theory. I just wanted to know if there I'm in your shoes. I just wanted to say, is that possible or not? And the first thing I did was prove that the Carthage conspiracy theory could not have worked. It could so he. He claims here that the first thing he did was to prove that that Carthage conspiracy like that that VHS quality 1980s RLDS Fundamentalist presentation on the Carthage conspiracy that that he's he claims that he proved that that didn't work yet in in the movie, like in the documentary, in the film Who killed Joseph Smith, Justin Griffin says that Sam Weston was the one who convinced him the angles could work, basically disproving that, you know, 1980s theory from the RLDS guy. So, so just so Griffin just told me at the beginning of the conversation he didn't go to Sam Weston first in his investigation.
1:03:09 So. So he's all over the place with this. Either he's lying in the film where he attributes to Sam Weston the credit of proving that the Carthage conspiracy couldn't work, or he just lied to me, to my face saying that it was the first thing that he did was prove the Carthage conspiracy didn't work. So it's just I get I I wanted to highlight that little you know, 20 seconds as it just another example of revisionism and gaslighting. Like this is what emotionally abusive people do to victims. Is they just gaslight and get you to question like your sanity, your memory, and and and and and also self aggrandizement 'cause he's basically now, instead of attributing to Sam Weston the credit of convincing him that the angles could work and so therefore debunking the Carthage conspiracy by the RLDS guy, he's now taking credit unto himself for disproving that. Jeez.
1:04:08 OK, so the next clip. Backlash for that, but I don't care. That's the more integris thing to do and if you go do the work to create a theory, that's when you'll start saying oh man, I can see why he said what he said. You'll see how I came up with it. OK, so Justin Griffin, whether he intended or realized it or not, just made a prophecy. He prophesied that if you go to the work to create a theory, that's when you'll start saying, oh, he's got a point. As we'll see in the next few minutes, this was a completely false prophecy and he actually admits it. So just for the record, next clip.
1:04:50 Said what? He said. You'll see how I came up with it and I had to fill a ton of holes in because there's only so much evidence and it was a long time ago. So you have to fill in and I'm like, maybe his body was here, that's how. And that that, yeah, I made a bunch of assumptions in the way that I made that reenactment for sure. I made a bunch of assumptions starting. With and he filled in a bunch of holes. Yeah, I said. Oh jeez, I had to make a bunch of assumptions starting. With he literally just admitted he made it up, 'cause there's not enough evidence like that's that is literally what he just said, what just came out of his mouth and now you understand why he set this conversation to private on his YouTube channel. Right, right.
1:05:41 Oh, it's despicable, right. Because I mean if you watch that, that first film and and in Full disclosure I couldn't get through the second one. I kept falling asleep. But in that first film I mean as he's showing what what he purports to have actually happened. Right. He's not doing this with well this might be it. I had to I had to fill in some holes here This is this is just my opinion. No he's coming strong in the paint, right. He's saying, this is the way, this is the only way this could have went down. And he goes to great lengths to show that his narrative is the only one that can make sense, both from a forensic standpoint as well as a historical one.
1:06:33 And so for him to backpedal like this and be like, well, yeah, I had to fill in the holes. There's nothing there. Yeah, well, no, no crap. I. Mean, I had to make a bunch of assumptions for sure. Yeah. His words. OK. Next clip with a series, that's just how it's gonna be. And so then you measure all of them against the evidence, and that's how you start to measure which one is most likely. So what's available today? There's one that is clearly the most likely. What happened? Is it perfect? No, it's just most likely. OK, I'm gonna pause it right there. This I think is actually very significant because what he just revealed to us is his epistemology and and by epistemology I mean like what How does he arrive at what he perceives as truth.
1:07:23 You know some people there's there's all sorts of different epistemologies reason you know empirical you know you have to touch feel see it taste smell it. You know there's there's all sorts of epistemologies and and and so his epistemology here is probability. He just said that it's not a it's not about it's it's it's not about what could have happened. It's not what is most likely to have happened And so it's not about the documented facts and and what people who were there said happened. He's only looking at you know mathematical and you know ballistic probabilities and and and he's saying if it's not the most likely thing it couldn't have happened but this is ridiculous because every day extremely improbable things happen all the time in real life right. And and and I present some documentation so anyway I don't wanna do spoiler we're gonna get to that point let's let's move on to his next ridiculous statement and you know Dave you're gonna you're gonna love this one. Just the.
1:08:31 Absurdity. His head. Mm hmm. All while the mob is in the door behind him and guys on the outside are shooting at him. Willard's a pretty big guy. He would have filled that window if the bullets were buzzing by his head. Where were they hitting? Somewhere in the room. No. He filled the window. They would have. OK, so so Dave, you're a big guy when you're standing in a window and you're looking out that window, and if there were bullets being shot at you as you were standing in that window that didn't hit you, they were whizzing by you. How is that possible 'cause you were filling the window? Well, I can.
1:09:25 I can tell you what my response would be, which is to get my great big fat ass out from in front of the window and maybe hit the deck. But hey, I don't live in in 19th century America either. So I I mean, maybe, maybe those things stop at the 19th century. I mean. If people were shooting at you through a window from down below, do you think you'd just, like walk over and and your whole frame would come fill the entire opening of the? You would probably be like crouching down and peeking over the sill, right? Or even if you were standing. Here's the thing, if you're standing, unless you're unless the window at the the top end of the window comes below your chin, like if you're actually seeing through the window or looking out the window. What do you think all this space is? Yeah.
1:10:13 Yeah, you know, to either side of your head. And he's just throwing that. I'm like OK. Well, and and let's talk about this from a Ballistics point of view, OK, yeah, those are not, quote, sniper rifles. They are using in the 19th century, right? They they are. They are able to to take down a deer or an elk at at a pretty decent distance, but you're aiming at a big target, OK? You're not aiming at some dude's head. And I don't care how fat that dude is, I promise you, his whole head is not taking up the window. And so it's it's just a falsehood. It just doesn't hold water.
1:10:55 Again, they're aiming at a small target with less than precision instruments, right? Firearms. And I mean they don't even have scopes, right? And so. Well, and it wasn't that far of a shot. I mean with a long gun, even a musket of a period musket, like, it's actually not that hard of a shot, 'cause they were within 50 feet, you know, many of them but, but but The thing is like, because why was he, why was this even coming up? He was trying to say that the eyewitness accounts, one of which is Willard Richards, are impossible and and and and and where he's targeting in on the eyewitness account is Willard Richards saying that bullets were whizzing past his head as he glanced through the window like and he's and he's trying to persuade me that that discredits the eyewitness testimony. So anyway.
1:11:50 Willard doesn't say. While I was standing in front of the window as bullets were whizzing by me. He just says as I was looking out the window. Bullets are flying past my head that there's. A huge difference there. And I I don't remember. I can't remember if he said he was standing near the window but but I mean even if you were standing up you wouldn't just like, oh I I see a mob out there with a bunch of guns and they're trying to shoot us in here. So I'm going to just you would still like peek around the corner of the window and and you know because you're not trying to make yourself a huge target. So anyway we we're going to keep moving on. There's a couple more clips in this conversation that I want to hit. Possible is Joseph, because we have no evidence of what those shots were, No clothing, no description of the nothing like that.
1:12:33 But everyone else, we know the description of their wounds. We had their clothes, we had the measures, We know they weren't muskets. And that's a big. What were the? What were the size of the bullet? Holes in hiram's clothing. So the one in his back, God, that's a good question. I think it's, I think it's musket size, musket ball size. So how was that explained? Cause in the movie I put that as a pistol. So I guess, oh, This is why my feeling is so the eyewitnesses say that that was, that was a shot that came through the window. I'll, I'll just stop it right there. Holy cow, if you made a whole documentary about this, wouldn't you kind of try to cover your bases if you thought you were really presenting historical evidence right when?
1:13:24 When you go to, like the He was just trying to hang his hat on this a few minutes ago. In that one clip where he says I ignored history, I just looked at forensics. OK, great. Let's look at the forensics. What size was the ball that hit? Hit higher. Oh, gosh. You know what? That's a darn good question. I should look into that. Whoa. And he Well, he knew. He knew the answer. He was just kind of being a little cagey there, 'cause he knew for he knew absolutely that it was .69 inches in diameter, which is a musket ball caliber, not a pistol. And and and that was the point here, is he was trying to defend his theory that like cause in his theory he had him using pistols only for all of the the gunshots. And I'm like, you know, have you ever seen that Dave Chappelle clip where he's like, gotcha.
1:14:15 That's what this moment is is is he is just talk about inconsistency. He he repeats ad nauseam that the eyewitnesses are not credible. Yet when he gets caught lying, what did he do? He defaulted immediately back to the eyewitness accounts. Well. And here's cause, 'cause if you caught that, he was like the eyewitnesses say that the shot that that was a shot, that it came through the window. So that was, you know, when I called him on his, on his lie, on his bluff, he deferted. He reverted back to that eyewitness account on saying that, yeah, that ball must have come. So that was the one and only ball that came through the the window, the one that hit Hiram in the back. Nice. That's that's convenient. That's convenient.
1:14:56 Now now let me say this too. The one thing that that seems to be beyond doubt is the firearms that were smuggled in to John Taylor and Willard Richards and Joseph Smith, right? That's factual beyond reproach cause not only do we have Willard Richards and John Taylor talking about it, but also if I'm not mistaken, we have the guy's testimony who dropped those firearms off so they didn't smuggle in a musket, right. So the fact that the shot that that gets Hiram in the back is a musket is very telling and quite frankly pokes pokes a lot of holes in in Justin's argument.
1:15:36 I mean, that alone is smoking gun roof that his theory as as presented in his re enactment is impossible. Yeah. OK. All right. So this next little bit, I I love these these. So there's a short little clip and then I'll play another longer one. OK, here we go. Then when I shot mine, but I was like, well, mine's not a musket. So I had a bunch of ballistic. I mean, I had at least 10 gun experts call me afterwards and say you did that wrong, you needed a musket. And I was like, you're right, I'm not an expert myself, but whatever, it's fine. I'm not a Ballistics expert, but OK. So twice there within a minute he he repeats that I'm not an expert.
1:16:20 No Justin, you're not. I I will agree with you on that one thing if nothing else. So The thing is when he's setting up his like you know replica shots with the ballistic dummy gel heads, you know with with loaded with all the blood colored dye for dramatic effect, you know those are apples to orange comparisons. They do not reflect accurate reenactments of of the shots that that we know occurred at Carthage. And so like those are are not he. He's just revealing his ignorance and he is acknowledging that to me in this. So at least he's being honest about that one thing. Well, and and he to to his credit, he says, you know I had 10 different ballistic experts call me and call BS on it and that should give people pause in that moment. Yep.
1:17:24 All right. Next clip. He was trying to get out of the room for whatever reason. His motives, you know, we're not going to speculate on that. And in doing so was struck by balls in front and behind, and it's so if he was. In they were active, trying and out. I can agree with that. He was struck inside of the room and outside of the room he was also shot by the mob. I agree with that, OK. This is interesting cause previously he had had taken the a position that no one was shooting from outside or would have been capable of shooting from outside and in his re enactment all of the shots originated from inside the room. So this. So wait, did he change? Did I change his mind? Or did he lie in his film?
1:18:05 Or is he lying to me now? Like, take your pick, 'cause they can't all be true. Like you can't be being honest in all of these. So like, 'cause earlier he was saying, let's see, Yeah, earlier he had said that the mob wouldn't shoot in the direction of the mob. I don't think I played that clip, but that was one of the things that he had said in the conversation. So what happened to the mob wouldn't shoot in the direction of the mob or what happened to, you know, his. When he claimed that Hiram wasn't shot from outside, it was too hard of a shot. It was like too hard of a far of a range, or the angles were too hard, or the what happened to Willard? Richards lied when he claimed that shots came in from the window or the OR you know, Griffin's claim that the lack of damage on remaining walls disproves an external mob's involvement or or his reenactment showing all the thought the shots came like what happened to all of those positions that he has taken on camera. He's on the record taking all of those positions, and yet he just acknowledged and agreed with me that Joseph was shot both inside and outside the room, Right I I considered making a video compilation and calling it Justin Griffin versus Justin Griffin.
1:19:24 Dude, that would have been. Awesome. So anyway, all right. And I'm just gonna keep going from this clip, so. OK. Those are the all. The points of the eyewitness accounts and you know, like maybe they they maybe they were not 100% factually accurate on all the minutiae, but that does not invalidate the main data. OK. OK, no, if that's where you were going, cool. I'm I'm totally fine with that. OK. OK. So, so again, all of that is easily harmonized with John Taylor didn't kill Joseph and Hiram. OK, that's a bit of a leap, but OK. How is that a leap?
1:20:07 Like so. So the eyewitness accounts. OK, so the let me go through what you said was the main points. There was a mob there. There were men that came up the stairs. Hiram was killed first. Joseph was shot in the room and outside of the room. And what was the other one? You said that John was also shot inside the room. OK. That is for me can mean there's now 1000 million possibilities if that's your main what you have to go on. So yes, one of those is exactly the way they described it is that John has nothing give you.
1:20:50 There are lots of possibilities. There, there's lots of possibilities, but the eyewitness accounts are just as possible as your theory. Wait, as stated, no impulse. So we just established that. The minutiae. Let's throw out the minutiae. Let's not get hung up on the minutiae of the eyewitness account. It's getting dark in here. Let me turn on my light. But yeah, so I thought we had just established that the eyewitness accounts are not necessarily the value. There is not the minutiae, the fine. Details the value of the eyewitness accounts are the main. Events. That the things that they got right allowed them to be good, good guys not doing what I suggested.
1:21:33 Yeah, OK. OK, so they're equally possible. We weren't there. So now let's take a step back and look at. Based on the island accounts, right? Yeah. OK, I get where you're wrong. Dude, that was a major concession. That was a major concession. But he couldn't. He couldn't wriggle out of it. So I called him on the carpet cause like his whole his whole claim crumbles. If he can't disprove the credibility of the eyewitness accounts, his whole narrative doesn't hold up until he can shoot down the credibility of the eyewitness accounts. Which again you know he says he he's not ready to talk about motive.
1:22:21 But if if you can't make this argument that the eyewitness statements were were were lies, what do you what do you do right. Because if if you're looking at this in that direction you have to have motive, right. And there's nothing we find in journal entries anything else that would indicate that John Taylor and Willard Richards had anything but utter fidelity and loyalty to Joseph Smith. A. 100, Yep. All right, So, so this next little clip, so you know, I've been skipping around you.
1:23:05 Everybody is welcome to watch this start to finish. Uncut. I'm just taking some highlights here to to analyze, but it's all available. The Uncut version is on my channel. It's the gospel. Unscripted. On YouTube, You could. I'll throw a link, I'll throw, I'll throw a link in the in the episode notes and people can go right to it. Yep. OK, so at the in this next clip, So we had been talking. So Griffin had brought up the two Mormons that testified at the trial, and he was making a big deal out of the fact that the mob didn't attack them and basically saying that, Well, yeah, so Jon Taylor was a wuss for not showing up at the trial. And so I explored the actual details that are documented very thoroughly about that the trial and proved that the two Mormons that testified at the trial actually ended up working out in favor of the defense. In other words, the the mob, the mobsters that were on trial for the murder of Joseph and Hiram were acquitted and and so like and the the testimony that these two Mormons gave at that trial helped them get acquitted, you know, let go instead of instead of found guilty.
1:24:16 So let's let's listen to this next. Effect of Eliza Graham's testimony was. Actor. And that's what ruined her testimony. OK. So again, the net effect of Eliza Graham's testimony was actually in favor of the defense. Yeah, it didn't. Yeah, exactly. OK, so that's important context because if their testimony had not strengthened the defense and in fact had, you know, not resulted in an acquittal and you know, if if the mob members have been convicted as a result of that testimony, do you think it's very plausible that the mob would have taken violent action against them individually and as the church, as a body? Yes, I do think that's possible. Absolutely.
1:24:57 OK. Well that that's that's the point is that it was an extremely hostile environment. Want more from the Mormon Renegade podcast? Head over to the Mormon Renegade Rumble page to see all the videos from the podcast and the Fundamental News Program for free. Still not enough? Then join the Mormon Renegade Locals page by clicking the red join button. And for $5 a month you can have access to podcast transcripts, renegade exclusives, as well as weekly live stream show with the host Dave Sanders. Click the link in this episode's show notes today, OK? Did you catch that? Another massive concession 'cause his whole, he's trying to build the case that John Taylor is revealing guilt. You know, he's he's revealing his culpability by not testifying at the trial.
1:25:56 That's like that that that was his point that he's trying to make is, you know, John Taylor avoided the trial and yet he just conceded this massive point that, yeah, it was a hostile environment. And so, in other words, he's admitting to me on camera that he lied in his documentary 'cause he completely distorted and misrepresented those facts. Look, it's so hard for us to put ourselves in the situation of John Taylor or any of those early Saints back in those days, right? Because we don't live with frontier justice, OK? So this idea that you would go to court and not feel safe to a lot of us is really, really foreign. OK, Joseph in the Mormons had stacked against them, not just mobsters and vigilantes, but the backing of certain state governments.
1:26:49 I think you can even make a case maybe for the federal government on some level, just because Joseph was threatening to upend a lot of the political dealings of the day by his candidacy for president. And so if you've seen them, just take out the guy, right? The the the two guys that were at that point most important to this movement, you think they're going to think twice about killing John Taylor or Willard Richards? No. No. And and Brigham Young understands, we got to get out of Dodge and let's not make life harder for ourselves until we get out of Dodge. And Griffin just seems to blow right past that point until you call him on the carpet on it. He is he.
1:27:35 He just ignores it if. You know I the. Best thing I can come up with on this part is it's just a blatant conflation of history with presentism, right? I'm not thinking this through really. Well, start to finish like, well, is it really? Is it really a stretch to say, gosh, it's it's really damning for John Taylor not to be there? If anything, if anything, if you were guilty and you were John Taylor and and you had killed Joseph Smith and Hiram Smith, you would want to be there to point the finger at the mob because that gets you off the hook, right? If John Taylor was not the one on trial for the murders. Right.
1:28:18 Right. So John Taylor's testimony, if he was guilty, could have sealed it up to make sure that somebody else took the fall. Right. And he stays away. Well, why would he do that? There's only one reasonable and plausible explanation in frontier America in that time, and that is they just got rid of Joseph and Hiram. They won't think twice about getting rid of us. Yeah, and that's that. So this next clip I I basically wrap up that point, 'cause there's a guy this you can just Google it. Famous trials. He's an attorney and he he looks at famous. He's not even Mormon or he has no connection to the church or the restoration or nothing.
1:29:02 But he was just looking at really significant cases in U.S. History and he he looked at this trial for the of the mob members for the murder of Joseph and Hiram and his conclusion was this was a kangaroo Court Justice was never going to be served and and so basically it exonerates John Taylor's personal decision to not testify and and and John Taylor also counseled to other church members to not attend and and at the the trial and to testify because doing so would accomplish nothing. They were gonna get acquitted according to this non member attorney analyzing this trial they the the Bob members were gonna get acquitted regardless of whatever testimony or evidence was presented and so they had nothing to gain and everything to lose 'cause they would be personally putting themselves and the whole church as a body at risk and and you know I won't play it but Justin's Griffin's response was so whatever.
1:30:01 OK cool. I mean, you make great points. So again, it's a a concession. But anyway, it's it's it's very revealing. So the the next, the last couple of clips I'm gonna pull from this, oh, you know, I'm gonna skip this one. He just basically goes into dodging. Oh, you know what? This is actually kind of funny and it's only gonna be a minute long, so I'm gonna play it anyway. OK. What the content? Of that section, I know where you're going. And I don't know how this, if you're working towards motive again. I I can't. I'm not going to discuss motive. I thought we were going to discuss what happened in those two to three minutes in evidence. So if you want to do motive, we can do that. You know what I'm not trying to deny, I'm not trying to hide anything.
1:30:48 But that's all. That's another conversation. The point of this movie was it was scientific evidence. What does the evidence say? Wasn't all the surrounding. I am not an expert in the surrounding. OK, well, so but. But you're not an expert in the ballistic forensics either. No, I am not. What I'm an expert in is in those two to three minutes. Whoa, that's a big claim. Yeah, and and I just. I just. Dodging around stuff, man. He was dancing. And The funny thing is I again, just so that everybody fully understands, I emailed him all of these questions, three of which were very centered on motive days in advance of this conversation.
1:31:31 So he's kind of gaslighting in real time here saying that, you know I thought we were just going to discuss the evidence and blah blah blah cause anyway. But I I just loved. I'm not like an expert on motive or the context or the history. Yeah, well you're not an expert on the Ballistics evidence either. So what are you? So if you're not an expert on Ballistics, if you're not an expert on or forensics, and if you're not an expert on the history, what the bleep business do you have making a documentary about it? Well, and he says he's an expert on that. Two or three minutes inside the the, the, the room that Joseph and Hiram were were shot in.
1:32:13 OK, well, let's go with that. But you still have to cover either motive, Ballistics or any number of things or at least provide expert witness to that, right. I do believe in in expert witness. But if I I. Remember and correct me and and correct me if I'm wrong. I'm sure you've watched it a a few more times than I have he he doesn't really provide much expert opinion. In his in his film Who Killed Joseph Smith? Part one. I've only actually ever watched it twice. The first time I watched it as just I'm watching this cause Kevin and Beverly told me about it. And so I was just like, I gotta see what this is all about.
1:32:54 The second time I ever watched it, I was taking notes, marking time stamps and stuff like that. And because I was preparing for this conversation with Justin Griffin. But but so I I've only seen it twice. But I was paying very close attention. But yeah, you're right. He does not present expert witnesses or testimony and so it's just really the the audience if you don't understand like the the, you know standards of credibility and like how to make judgments of who to trust and versus who's not, you know credible and worthy of trust not a reliable witness that's that's something that he preys upon.
1:33:34 You know, most people are not very, you know, experienced in criminal trial proceedings and and not that I have experience with criminal trials, but but, you know, my brother's an attorney. I I have access to people and I I have, it's something I have studied a bit. And so it's I'm not, I'm not claiming to be an expert on anything. I just claim to know a hell of a lot more about Ballistics and forensics than Justin Griffin and history because I do. And and really he is a he's acknowledging this like he's actually conceding all of these points. So let's take this next little bit 'cause this is really key, This is really the linchpin of this whole conversation. Let's let's check it out.
1:34:16 We've already concluded that the physical forensic evidence is not conclusive. Yeah, yeah. Great. And you can't really do forensic evidence on 109 year old crime scene K So him conceding that it it it just again exposes that he's making this crap up. He's pulling it right out of not the history. It's not credible. There's there's just not sufficient evidence remaining on this hundred plus year old crime scene to come to a definitive conclusion on what did or didn't happen. And so he's admitting that he's agreeing that, OK, this is the last clip from this conversation. Here we go.
1:35:08 Only shaping different theories as I went that yeah, absolutely. But I mean, but we've we've, we've you've agreed with me on a few points throughout the course of it that that you have, that you've acknowledged. Yeah, like on the trial, John Taylor, Why he was afraid. OK, OK. Yeah, yeah. Nevertheless, you're not questioning your narrative. You're not questioning your conclusions. Well, I was hoping you would bring something new. It's something I hadn't thought about on an angle or piece of evidence and I don't think that, I don't think that's what you were trying to do in this conversation. But but I. Mean the my point, the my intent with this conversation was #1 to hopefully help you understand that you don't know what you don't know about like Ballistics.
1:35:53 And that's fine. But the the the, the evidence that you're presenting in the film is actually not conclusive at all and I think that you've acknowledged that throughout the course of this conversation. The other thing is we're not going to find the truth from looking at forensic evidence only. And if if, I mean you've you've been pretty consistent saying let's not talk about motive but we have to look at things holistically, You have to look. No, you don't. Not if you're a forensic detective. You don't. You just look at the evidence. You look at the evidence. You don't try to determine motive. You don't. There's. Not enough evidence left. These men were dead and buried hundreds of years or over 100 years ago, right?
1:36:37 All of them. Yeah. The the forensic evidence alone is not conclusive, is my point and to present. It as such is not supported. So he just conceded again that the evidence, the forensic evidence, is insufficient to come to a definitive conclusion and he agreed. Then why did you put out a documentary taking a very authoritative, definitive position and presenting it as the only possible scenario? You know, the other thing he tried to do there that I found really disingenuous is when he tried to turn the tables and said, well, I thought you were coming with new evidence.
1:37:24 No, no, no, it's not on you to present new evidence. He's the one right? If we want to approach this thing very scientifically, anytime you challenge a current narrative, right, something that's been accepted. For a while. It's incumbent upon you. To provide proof. That absolutely discredits the old narrative, yeah, the. Burden of proof is on him, not me, you know. Yeah, the. Burden of proof is on him. You are arguing for the accepted narrative, and he needs to be able to disprove that. Which to this point, he has done a woeful job, a laughable job, and until he can get to that point of presenting evidence that would be enough to overturn the the historically held narrative, That narrative has to stand.
1:38:13 That's the hierarchy of evidence. That's actually scientific method. And until that gets done, dude's pissing in the wind. Yep. Yep. If only he knew what he does. If only he knew what he didn't know, then it would make this whole process a little bit easier. But I I actually had a question if he may actually know and he's just. He's He's dancing. Being deceptive. Look the fact that he tried to turn it around on you that's you know and and you know he he is presenting this as in his excuse me, that his narrative is the accepted one and it's just not it's it's full of of holes. I mean, to be right, honest.
1:39:07 I mean it's it's laughable and that's what I keep coming back to when I watch the film, when I listen to him talk about this, it's laughable. And or in the the the thing that's most disconcerting is the fact that he's willing to continue to ride this out. Totally. So there's a couple of comments I I was gonna just really quickly touch on, but maybe it's on this one. So so that was round one. You know it was getting late. We've been going for over 2 hours. So and like I was trying to kind of bring things around and and like put the screws in and kind of just try to button 'cause he made several, like at least four massive concessions throughout the course of that conversation that just absolutely broke down.
1:39:58 And it was just blowing my mind like, OK, you're making concession after concession on these key points that that that completely discredit your narrative, but you're not questioning it. You're just kind of doubling down and and you can't just repeat something and that makes it true. That's not proving anything. And but anyway, at the end of this conversation, I said, well, motive. He did finally say that he was willing to have a conversation on that. And and so he said, you know what? Maybe we can do this again. And he ended up challenging me parting parting challenge. Why don't you come up with your own theory. And and so I spent the next couple of weeks studying, reading the eyewit, all the eyewitness accounts like looking at all the evidence that I could get my hands on that was available online and and praying and just asking Heavenly Father to open up my mind of what is the you know most likely. I mean not not not like, not like, you know, I I didn't see a vision of what happened or anything, but I was just kind of like trying to envision, envision I should say is the word I'm using.
1:41:04 Like how could all of these facts come together into a cohesive story and and how could I present that in a very credible way. So this is round two and the 1st 45 minutes of this second round, he's asking me all sorts of questions and to be honest, I think he's trying to poison the well a little bit. Like if he could discredit me, you know, if I if he could get me to say something that would discredit people listening or watching that you know, that would discredit my complaints against him and his theories. And so like he asked me all sorts of questions that that I ended up answering if if people are curious, like, you know, he asked me to elaborate on my perspective, the LDS church, if the church goes along with Babylon, if I'm active or sustained the leadership. He asks me if the spirit tells you something that's contradictory to the church or president Nelson says which would you choose to do?
1:42:05 He Griffin asked me if the president of the church is infallible. I mean he he asked me all of these questions. He asked me about my stance on polygamy and Adam God doctrine, on blood atonement, on Brigham Young and and various other things, black and the priesthood sorts of things. And so he asked me all these questions, I think trying to to trap me or poison the wells to to destroy my credibility with the a mainstream LDS audience. And you know, I actually haven't listened back through to my answers but if anybody's curious, you know, I reserve the right to be to correct if I said anything wrong or or if I've changed my perspective on any of them. But that that's that's available. At the 45 minute mark I present my my theory, which, you know Full disclosure is simply the eyewitness accounts theory.
1:42:57 But I present it in such a way with supporting documentation, using modern forensics as evidence and standards and and guidance. Right. But let me let me ask you this, you in, in that first debate you had with him, you said that you sent him all of the questions that you were gonna ask him, all the stuff that you wanted to go over. Did he reciprocate and and send these to you before you jumped on? Oh no. Just curious. No, just curious. OK. I was just curious. No. So these were all just completely extemporaneous off the cuff. OK, all right. And. And so, so yeah, this is the uncut full footage of round two. It's over 2 and almost 2 1/2 hours long. I'd uploaded a separate video of just me presenting my theory that people wouldn't have taken 5. Oops, I have caffeine pills every day, but like everyone around me, I was consuming the same amount. But OK, so this is where I present my rational theory. And as you can see, I got a lot of engagement. Lots of comments.
1:44:05 There was one comment I wanted to bring out. Oh, here it was. Dude, check this out at Neil Jones. I don't know this person, but he says I'm a dentist who also got a masters in forensics. The maxilla or upper jaw is less dense than the mandible or lower jaw, but it is still bone and will surely change the path of a projectile. All the historical evidence must be considered before one tries to credibly determine what happened in those two to three minutes. So I don't know, Dave, it's so it's about 25 minutes or so long of me presenting my theory. Should we just direct the audience listeners to go to the YouTube channel and watch it there, or should we just play it out?
1:44:49 That's that's your call. Do you think you could give a summarized version of what you thought happened, or do you feel like it's better to just listen to the whole thing? I do think it's better to listen to the whole cause, 'cause I I have to frame certain and I have to lay a foundation before I just start walking you through the step by step, blow by blow account of of what I think happened. Are you good on time? I'm good on time. Yeah, it's up to you. Let's let's go ahead and just play it out and if we feel like we need to stop anywhere to to to ask a question to make sure we're understanding, I'll do that. Let's do it. OK. All right. Here we go. I'm going to go through. And start off with, you know, just dive right in.
1:45:32 So in Carthage, so we know that the door hinges are on the right side of the door. If you're viewing from inside the room and there's evidence that a shot was fired through the latch and lock by the mob attempting to enter the room, we know that Hiram could have sprung backward two or three steps as reaction to that shot. As the eyewitness accounts like John Taylor's account states That or you know if they shot through the lock and latch and then the mob members just pushed through the door it, you know it could have pushed him back two or three steps, which is about 10 feet if you're a man my size. So anyone else that was to Hiram's right wouldn't have been knocked back as far if that. If Hiram was knocked back and didn't just jump back a couple of steps because you're closer to the hinges, there wouldn't be as much mass displacement.
1:46:19 So it it to me makes complete sense that Hiram was pushed much further in, back into the room, away from the door and that position. I mean that we we know that room is not very big. So that position 10 feet back from the door would put Hiram's back just a few feet away from the window, making it a target to anyone outside the jail. I believe it's most likely that the first bullet that struck his body was the one in his back, which would not have to cause very much external bleeding, 'cause there's no major blood vessels in that area of the body. And and since we know it didn't exit the front of his body, we can be fairly confident based on the evidence, that regardless of the cause, the bullet that struck Hiram's back had low terminal ballistic energy. If it had higher terminal ballistic energy, we would expect it to have exited and had a, you know, an exit wound. So we don't know the caliber of that bullet that struck him in the back.
1:47:11 We don't know the firearm that it was shot from for sure. I mean, the hole in his shirt is .69 inches, which would be a perfect match for a period musket ball that was shot. But the low terminal Ballistics could also be explained by it traveling a much further distance, like for example, if it had been fired from much further away from the jail. So like John Taylor, he never claimed he knew the exact source of the bullet that struck Hiram's back. But he conjectured in in his account that it could have come from the Carthage graze which he estimated at 11:50 rods, which is about 165 to 200 feet or roughly 60 yards away, which is well within the effective range of a musket.
1:47:52 You know, rifles even of of that period were accurate to, you know, hundreds of yards, you know, 23400 yards away a good Rifleman could hit a target. So an alternative but equally plausible argument, like you agree. You said that you had agreed with Sam Weston that he disproved the RLDS angles from the Carthage conspiracy. It's possible that the shot front in the back could have come from a mob member much closer to the jail, but again, it would have had to have a much lower powder load to explain the low terminal Ballistics causing it to not exit the front of his body. Another possibility is if the shooter was shooting from the top of a wagon or or some from some other elevated position, he could have been much closer to the jail than the 50 to 70 feet away that Sam Weston calculated was possible. But regardless, either way, Hiram would have known immediately that his gunshot wound to his back was fatal given the internal damage he could probably feel and also due to the lack of medical technology back in those days. So, so Hiram said I am a dead man and and he still had a tongue, 'cause that was.
1:48:59 The whole ball. That had struck him. So now it's what's interesting. So my background professionally, I I deal with medical code code data. I manage medical coding databases, and I I studied quite a bit about human anatomy and and such and and so it's a common and widely known phenomenon that people who get shot with the firearm collapse immediately, even if it it. Which kind of is a little counterintuitive 'cause if the bullet doesn't strike a lower extremity, why do people fall down? Well, a neurologist named Dennis Tobin was asked by a journalist investigating this phenomenon in 2013. And Doctor Tobin theorized that an area of the brain stem called the Reticular Activating System or Ras can become overloaded by by pain impulses.
1:49:49 You know, so if if you're if you have intensely pain, a lot of pain impulses, it comes in actually the Ras is at the base of the of the brain stem. So. So the agony of being shot triggers the Ras to send out a signal. Weakening the muscles of the legs causes the person to collapse. And I fact I I was prepared with a source link. So I'm gonna just stick that right here while we're talking. So anyway, that so I posted that in the chat of the Zoom, but it's also in the description on my YouTube video, so you can check out all the source links there. At that you know, so that would explain Hiram collapsing, you know, falling to his knees. So he it wouldn't necessarily have caused him to move forward. I mean, it may have given him a slight push forward, like IE towards the door, but it's very likely he fell to his knees and began to fall forward simply because, like anatomically, men fall forward.
1:50:52 When we get shot by a gun, our center of mass is in the front, just right below the sternum, kind of at the top of the stomach. And so men naturally fall forward when they're when, when they fall, when they collapse. Women fall backwards because a woman's center of gravity is, you know, in the the region of the buttocks and so it's much lower and in their rear center of gravity, so they fall backwards. So now as he was falling to his knees and then began to fall forward Hiram would have also had a a natural like biological reaction to to investigate. What he probably would is was expecting to see is an exit wound. I mean we know it struck his pocket watch in his right breast pocket and so like if if you do it, if you just start to you know I don't have a pocket right here. But if I did, if I started to glance down at my bright right breast pocket, you'll notice that I am exposing the left side of my nose to you know, shot directly in front of me. So while Hiram's head was beginning to bend down and to examine his chest, and while likely beginning to fall forward and and so immediately after uttering the words, I'm a dead man, that's when I believe the ball that penetrated the door was fired and struck him, entering on the left side of his nose.
1:52:13 And so like basically Hiram was 10, being 10 feet back from the door. That addresses the angle of the the bullet hole in the door and and that would also account for there being no muzzle burn from the muzzle flash and no splintering from the door etcetera. So the ball exit entered on the the left side of his nose exited below his jaw but above his neck. So now it's important to note that the only point of evidence against the neck that the the neck wound was an entrance wound was the coroner's report and he identified it as as an entrance wound. But what's what's very interesting and what I found doing some research was that modern trauma surgeons have determined that entrance and exit wounds are misinterpreted over half the time, even today, 52% of the time to be exact, which I have that source link I'm going to post here in the in the comments as well.
1:53:12 And so, because of this phenomenon of misidentifying it over half the time current, I'm quoting from another journal article, the current forensic recommendations are that trauma clinicians not document the interpretation of a wound as an entrance or exit. The wound should only be described in detail and if possible, photographed UN quote. And so that that article was published on the National Library of Medicine. Are you a Rocky Mountain Power customer? Oh, come on, How would you like to get paid to put a backup battery in your home? Sorry about that. We're just rolling this live here, but. You're you're good.
1:53:54 You're good. So National Library of Medicine for those who may not be aware is like the standard data source for clinical, forensic, any kind of medical related data. This is something that is extremely peer reviewed as the gold standard for, you know, scientific evidence in the United States in the world today, so. Gotcha. And there's that link right there. So basically the modern surgeons and forensics experts are, I mean I don't think it's a stretch to say they're far more trained and have far more technology, technological tools at their disposal then existed 180 years ago on the American frontier.
1:54:41 And so I can only imagine that even more than 50% of the time entry and exit wounds were misidentified in the 1840s. So that doesn't necessarily discredit the coroner or you know, it's not intended to be a criticism of him or her him. It's just that these things are difficult to identify and so modern protocol is to not identify or interpret those things. So now in addition, so we know that bullets are not lasers, so that same peer reviewed article that was published in the National Library of Medicine that I just linked, it says quote, bullets that strike rigid changes in density such as bone, will often be deflected from their initial course. So these are not my words.
1:55:26 These are the words of actual forensics experts in a printed, published, peer reviewed study in the National Library of Medicine. In fact, that same study goes on to reference a specific case where, quote, a bullet had penetrated the chest, entered the left pulmonary vein or you know, the vein on the left side of the of the lungs and embolized to the left femoral artery. I mean, just let that sink in. Imagine somebody gets shot by a gun, a modern firearm, not a, not a, you know, 180 years ago firearm and it hits him in the chest and they're, you know, there's no exit wound in their back and they're like, where's the bullet? They find it in his left thigh.
1:56:09 I mean, you know, truth can be stranger than fiction in other words. And so it's not uncommon for bullet trajectories to change in unpredictable and and sometimes dramatic ways after impacting or penetrating a human body. And and so given that this particular bullet that struck the left side of Hiram's face was most likely a roughly 50 caliber or half inch diameter musket ball that had just passed through 3/4 of an inch of solid hardwood. So upon striking Hiram's face bones, while his head was angled slightly downward, the ball's trajectory changed slightly more down. And as it exited here, it grazed Hiram's vest in two places, which we we know from the shirt there is evidence that a bullet grazed him.
1:56:50 It didn't penetrate the skin. There's no record of that, but it did graze his vest in two places. So those two graze marks can't could be examined today. I haven't examined them. I don't think you have either, but so after receiving that wound. To his face. Hiram then fell to the floor. I believe it was face down, at least initially. And you know the the eyewitness accounts do put him lying on his back. I think it's very possible that he could have been rolled over onto his back at some point in all the chaos. But I do think that he fell on his face initially because that matches the biological center of mass argument. And I'm not faulting the eyewitness accounts for getting that little detail wrong, 'cause, you know, he could have easily been flipped over to to, you know, positively determine that he was deceased.
1:57:40 Flipped over by then. Or. Yeah, by by anyone. So, so, so I believe that he bled out and the actual cause of death was deprivation of oxygen to the brain. Now. Head wound. No, because see, here's the thing, like to bleed out there are actually, it's a surprising amount of of blood. I mean, imagine in your mind like 1/2 gallon jug of milk. Imagine dumping that onto the floor once a full half gallon jug of milk and then filling it halfway up again and dumping it out. That's about how much blood is in a a full grown male human being. And so to bleed out would would cause from his face there would be a huge puddle and so but because the the back wound you know there would be very little external bleeding. But inside your body, inside your abdominal cavity, there's a lot of empty space that your guts are just kind of you know floating around him.
1:58:38 And so I believe the the the majority of him bleeding out happened internally which was not externally visible and so and because he was laying on his face, at least initially it was, it did not exit the the hole in his back. So and then when the mob returned and opened fire at John Taylor and Joseph's hiram's corpse was struck twice more in lower extremities. But you know no sign of blood. So you you believe that? The MOP came back. Yeah. OK. So I guess before I, before I go on to the the evidence that you know after Joseph fired the 6th shooter through the door went begat. So but before we get to that, I do think it's cool to mention like actually and I'll I'll attribute this, I'll give credit where it's due.
1:59:30 So Kim sent me some sources that showed that there's documentation that both Joseph's and Hiram's bodies were placed on ice after they were martyred. Now, of course, back in those days, people didn't have freezers or fridges or electricity, so. So what they'd do is in the middle of winter, they'd go to the nearest lake or pond or stream. They'd cut large blocks of ice. They'd carry them by wagon or sleigh to the local ice house, which as the name suggests, it was a special like extra insulated structure designed to store ice long term. And they'd pack the ice blocks in sawdust. Now amazingly these ice blocks would last well into the summer sometimes through the summer. And you know and you can Google this stuff like if if this isn't it's this I I I like to read old Westerns and and you know pioneer types of books and so.
2:00:21 I I grew up. You know, being aware of this, But you know, if if it's not something that you've ever seen before, feel free to Google it and and just kind of validate this for yourself. So the reason that this is important is, you know, as any mother would know, if blood gets on to fabric like your kid gets a bloody nose or whatever, you don't want it to permanently stain the outfit. You take it off and soak it in cold water. So in other words cold temperatures arrest the staining effect of of blood. Now the reason I think this is noteworthy is because you know, while I did say that there were no major blood vessels on in in, you know, the region where Hiram was struck in the back, there are small capillaries in the skin that I would expect to see at least some bleeding.
2:01:05 And yet Hiram's shirt has no blood stains on the back whatsoever despite a .69 caliber bullet hole being there. So I believe that the explanation there is is that when they placed his and and Joseph's bodies on ice, it prevented the the blood stains on his back from becoming permanent and so they were able to be washed out later. OK, so back to the room in Carthage. So immediately after Hiram was struck with the first bullet in his back, hearing him cry that he was a dead man, Joseph exclaimed. Oh my dear brother Hiram and made the decision to fire his six shooter revolver at the men trying to enter the door. I I believe Joseph would have never left the room because from his point of view.
2:01:48 There was, literally. A mob of armed men on the other side of the door that he knew were intent on killing him, that he they had just killed his brother. So he he drew the weapon shot through the opening of the door, hitting three mob members and and apparently it misfired three times, but that caused the mob to temporarily retreat. You know how long? Maybe a few seconds, maybe a minute or two. I don't know. But they I believe that the mob quickly regrouped and could be heard coming back up the stairs to finish the job they'd come to do now as they could hear the mob returning. That's when John Taylor decided to check if there is any hope of escape from the window and he was struck by bullets shot from the mob members at the door coming into the room and and he thought he would fall out the window because he was like leaning forward. He thought he was going to fall out the at the time and he didn't under he didn't know why he didn't and fell down inside the room.
2:02:44 Now later on it was discovered that his pocket watch was broken and had a small caliber bullet hole in it which was speculated had been struck by a bullet from outside and that was the reason John Taylor hadn't fallen out the window. Now since your documentary attempted to to portray that that could have never happened, I'm I'm going to just say here that the results of your experiment the the you know you shooting the pocket watch don't surprise me at all because you 'cause it was a a apples to oranges comparison. So the reason I I'm gonna say that is because to actually replicate and test the effect of a shooting a pocket watch in that was on a human person's body, you'd need to use some representation of a human body as the backdrop 'cause when a bullet strikes a target there there's forces which in the laws of physics are defined as, you know, mass times velocity.
2:03:36 Bullets are small in mass but very high velocity. So there's an amazing amount of force packed in a small package that that now that force when it encounters an equal or opposite force gets transferred that that kinetic force, that movement gets transferred into the target. Now, not enough to blow a guy back 20 feet like in Hollywood, You know, that's just fantasy. But if a man was off balance, like falling forward and and a bullet struck and was brought to a complete stop by something in the man's pocket, is it plausible that it could change the direction he was falling? Absolutely yes. In addition, if that energy was dispersed through the human body behind the watch and the watch didn't absorb all of that energy, it it wouldn't necessarily have to be blown to shreds like.
2:04:24 So in your experiment you had a a wooden board behind it and so all of that force from the bullet impacting was absorbed by the watch and predictably it blew. It got blown to shreds. That's expected by anybody that understands terminal Ballistics, but but so my point is that your setup was was fundamentally flawed. Now also the caliber of the bullet that struck Don Taylor's pocket watch. It was not a 69 caliber musket ball, which would have a lot more force 'cause it's a lot more mass. And so the hole in his pocket watch is pretty small. Like I've never I've never actually handled the pocket watch and and measured the diameter, but it to me it looks more like a 22 type of a caliber which would have been fired from a sidearm, not a musket by one of the mob members below. OK, so so John is is struck by 4 balls, falls to the floor, rolls under the bed now.
2:05:22 Oh, there was a point of there being 2 windows in the room. So if John went to the smaller window, that could explain why Joseph would go to the other larger window. But regardless, even if John Taylor went to the larger window, which would make more sense in my mind, that he was afraid that he was going to fall out. What do you mean? You mean there's there's three windows? Which two windows are you talking? About, I'm referring to, there's the the large window which is directly across from the door, and then there's like if you're if you're. Like we always put the door on the left. Side all the painters depictions and because the you know the doors in the far left corner and so we always look at it from that perspective. So if the door's on the left, the window's on the right, there was another window behind above, like the where the bed was right.
2:06:09 So he jumped on the bed and tried to go through that window. Is that what you mean? Possibly. Like, you know, he doesn't. There's no I I didn't see any indication from either the eyewitness accounts, him identifying specifically which window he went to. I'm just saying that regardless, like if he went to the window above the bed, that could explain why Joseph would go to the other window across from the door, right? But even if John Taylor went to the large window directly across the, you know, the opposite wall from the door, I think it's still reasonable given that there were no other possible exits or escapes from that room from that situation besides a window. So anyway, as Joseph rushes to the window, the mob which has breached the door fires upon it from behind. And Willard, of course, was hidden from view of the mob because he was on the hinge side of the door. So the mob forces the door open, forces him into the corner behind the door.
2:07:11 He is out of sight. Out of mind maybe? But do you believe that's just your theory or because he said he was on the other side but then told the coroner that he was behind the door so? You I I think. That in the heat of the moment and the stress, it's very likely he could have misremembered upon later recollection. He misremembered that he was behind the door the whole time. Yeah, yeah, OK. Especially if, especially if you know human nature is to embellish over time. And in fact, it would be remarkable if people didn't, you know, that's why they they call them the big fish stories, right? The fish gets bigger and bigger the more times you tell the story.
2:07:58 And that's just a natural part of human nature. That doesn't mean that it wasn't a big fish to begin with. It just means that over time things get tend to get exaggerated and that's just human nature. So I have no problem. I'm not, I'm not accusing Willard of being like a a malicious liar for making embellishments if if he did that. I just believe that it's far more likely the fact that he was never struck by by balls unless possibly the ear grazing. But you know, I think that it's far more likely that he was behind the door at the time that Joseph was was fired upon. And so anyway, so in the act of of Joseph trying to jump out the window, he was struck by balls shot from behind, you know, from the mob at the door of the room as well as in front.
2:08:47 And as a result of those shots, he stumbled and and fell head first out of the window, hit the ground with his forehead first. And you know there's evidence that he was not instantly killed because he leaned up against the wall and was beaten, at least according to one of the mob members, before he died. And and you know, so Willard, if he was behind the door, the and the mob immediately rushed out after Joseph was their target, clearly. And so as the mob saw that he was no longer in the room, they would have rushed out and down the stairs and so Willard would have been relatively safe. Now he's a big guy for sure, you know, about ��300 by accounts, but but like we discussed last time, nobody's going to approach a window casually when you just saw your friend or two of your friends, or maybe 3 like so. Hiram, John and John Joseph were all shot through this same window minutes before He would have crept up and he would have, you know, peaked over the the bottom of the sill. Now you know today the ledge might have a larger overhang. Maybe back in 1844 it was the same ledge, or maybe it was replaced in one of the multiple remodels since that time. Regardless, it's possible that his ear was grazed by a stray shot.
2:10:07 It doesn't necessarily mean that if it wasn't it, it makes him a liar because again, human nature is to embellish things over time. But he wouldn't have just been sitting there like staring. He would have glanced quickly and then ducked back undercover. So the the the idea that he had to fill the window is just unsupported by human nature let alone any historical evidence and and so now so if the martyrdom happened today I think this is important. Another important point is like in a modern forensics team went to the untampered with crime scene.
2:10:47 Sure, it's likely they'd be able to determine tons more facts than what we have access to today. But the facts of this matter is that the the martyrdom happened nearly 180 years ago. Modern forensic tech did not exist at the time the the bodies had been buried. There's no crime scene. It's been 180 years. The jail's been remodeled. So like, we don't have the bullets, we don't have blood splatters we don't have pictures of. Of. The bodies, where they were lying, the the crime scene has been tampered with. Obviously we don't have the the murder weapons or the muskets that were involved. We don't have the pistols. I think I already said that, but it was like multiple remodels in the time.
2:11:30 So there was a blood stain apparently on the floor up until I think it was President Kimball in the 60s or 70s or something said let's, let's clean that up. And so we know that the, the window and the frame were replaced and so that could have easily included the window ledge. You know, also another important thing is back east. Like I I served a mission in Detroit and I've spent time working in the South in the summertime and stuff. It's very common to pressure wash the exteriors of buildings out there just because of the climate. And so, like, in addition to 180 years worth of weathering to me, pressure washing could explain why.
2:12:11 You know, modern visitors, we don't. We go, and we don't see visible evidence of musket balls striking the exterior. OK, so. That's that's kind of the the the theory but I have, I have just a few final statements if that's OK before you dive in and and ask questions. Is that cool? Yeah, absolutely. Right on. So I think it's important to say that it's impossible for me to prove to actually prove my own theory that that's what really happened as you stated multiple times in our last conversation.
2:12:51 Now you're you said like I kind of tried to ask you a couple of different times couple of different ways about motive like asked you to to speak to motive which you declined to do and but as as a quick aside I have a good friend his brother is a has been a homicide detective in Arizona for many years and I didn't no context I just asked and he he said that as a homicide detective he would never consider investigating forensic evidence in a vacuum like without investigating motive. So anyway as I thought through all of these points I I anticipated several possible objections that you could bring up to discredit my story my theory and as I was thinking about it I realized something very important that you said a few times in our last meeting and and that's about epistemology.
2:13:45 Are you familiar with that term? Kind of a scholarly So epistemology just being how do you determine what is true? And I think you know that well I I heard you say many times that you you believe that what is most likely is probably what is true. So your epistemology would be what is the most likely the what is probable that you know probability would be your epistemology in this situation and and explicitly like exclusively based on the forensic evidence. So to kind of just illustrate what that means, you know the implications is like if we take two dice and we roll them, it must be a 7, the result must be a seven. We don't look at the results and and look at it, we say it has to be a 7 because that is the highest probability outcome. You know it, it couldn't be a two, couldn't be a 12 because those are less probable than A7.
2:14:43 There's way more combinations of dice to to get to 7 and so that's most likely. Or similarly, the odds of a person who buys lottery tickets, or who, like, goes and plays a slot machine in Vegas. Their odds of winning the jackpot are statistically minuscule. Like, infinitesimally small. And so by your epistemology, it would be impossible for anyone to ever win the lottery or the jackpot, because it's so unlikely. And yet we all know it happens every day to all sorts of people. So. So this is my objective analysis of a fundamental flaw to your approach. In addition, let's define another term that you like to throw around the the forensic science. Like forensic science is scientific, meaning there's no room for conjecture.
2:15:36 So this requires being able to examine and, you know, positively identify the bullet location of impact, trajectory or trajectories involved in a pristine, uncontaminated and controlled scene. That being the case, as you said in our our last conversation, that like, you had to make a bunch of assumptions and fill in holes in your conclusions as you presented them, that's not forensic science. Science is disciplined, It's reproducible. It's, you know, neither of us has actually seen the bullets. Neither of us has actually handled the murder weapons. Neither of us has physically examined the shirt or the skull or the pocket watch. But maybe you, maybe you have. I don't know. I haven't.
2:16:16 We're examined the room in its condition immediately after the martyrdom. In other words, neither of us has any business to even claim the forensic evidence can provide a scientific answer. We have very little. I I mean, we have a hole in a door, we have some pictures of some skulls and we have a shirt with some holes and blood stains. That's about it. But anyway, so despite your epistemology being what is the most probable thing, I I don't believe your documentary is even about that cause. Like what's the probability that John Taylor and Willard Richards were armed when we know there was no evidence whatsoever they had guns with them in that room? You know, also motive. Motive is a massive aspect of probability. Like, anybody, I, I, I like enjoy reading and and watching murder mysteries.
2:17:02 We anybody that sees a murder mystery knows that if you know if I had told you that a guy had threatened to divorce his wife and was not going to give her support and then the next day he's found dead probability would make the wife the widow a leading suspect in that in that investigation. So like in the context of Carthage what is the probability that two guys are going to stage a murder of two friends while they're in the room with them and a mob with guns is shooting at the at their targets like they you know there are so many more probable ways that if John and Willard wanted to kill Joseph and Hiram they could have poisoned them.
2:17:43 No, no risk to themselves. You know, Joseph and Hyrum we know were unarmed on their trip from Nauvoo to Carthage, meaning they could have killed him in transit, like at any point on that road where there's no witnesses. A mob wasn't shooting at them. They weren't possibly in the able to be able to get caught in the crossfire. So why pick a room when you're right next to your intended victims and incite a mob to to only hang him? And yet you did acknowledge that shots were fired from the mob outside. So, so to me a much better epistemology than probability is reason. Like for example, our our legal system is more concerned about finding the truth than any other, you know, earthly institution, because justice cannot be served, cannot prevail if the truth is not reached. So for this reason, the standard of our justice system is reason, not probability.
2:18:39 So we'll that that was just the me presenting my theory only the the uncut version has a lot more and and I actually go in and I I I do some other stuff but but so the bottom line is in a court if you're accused of murder and you're a living person you must have the guilt be proven beyond a reasonable doubt and and you know Justin Griffin can't even can't even make probable cause without just if the narrative falling apart upon a little bit of scrutiny let alone prove things beyond a reasonable doubt and so and you're thrown around murder accusations.
2:19:26 I will say this false accusations going back to what you said at the very beginning of this conversation is is woke ideology. It's it's progressive tactics like it's the me too movement. It's just that you know we're gonna just claim something happened. Nobody's going to cross examine the the witness or or validate the claim or or anything along those lines. We're just going to make the accusations. And no, no trial. No no examination no due process. Oh that person's abusing has has been an abuser. We're going to cancel them. Like no process, no trial. No, no ability to defend yourself. And many people have been victims of woke cancel culture, right?
2:20:13 Some probably deserved it, but not everybody. And you know, in the founding of this country, the founders were much more concerned with protecting the innocent than punishing the guilty because they believed that God was the ultimate arbiter, that that if people were guilty of sins or crimes that they would not escape being held accountable for that with, if even if it wasn't in this life, that they would account to God in the next. And so their primary concern was they would much rather accidentally let a guilty man go than to accidentally punish an innocent person. Right.
2:20:55 And and you know, and this is very biblical, like in the Old Testament, yes there were a lot of sins but they all required multiple witnesses. You couldn't just take and the and the witnesses had to be cross examined and and it had to be validated and and basically false accusation. You know thou shalt not bear false witness. We usually can we usually interpret that commandment to be thou shalt not lie, you know say a falsehood. But that's actually not what the commandment says at all. Bearing false witness would be akin to, you know, lying underoath. You're making a witness, you're you're making an accusation falsely.
2:21:36 And the biblical penalty for bearing false witness is actually really interesting. Whatever the crime that you're accusing somebody falsely of committing, whatever the punishment for that crime is, that is the penalty for you if you bear fault, false witness. And so I am extremely cautious to to make accusations or or to, you know, accuse people of this or that because especially murder, because what's the penalty for murder? Right, right. It's capital offense. It's like it's death and you know and not that every jurisdiction in the world today enforces the biblical penalty. But biblically, scripturally, you know, thou shalt not commit murder.
2:22:23 And if you do, you die. Like your life is forfeit. It is a capital offense. And so if you falsely accuse somebody of murder, the biblical penalty is that is a capital offense. And I think that people that throw around these accusations do so very lightly. And I think that it is symptomatic of, again, that progressive woke culture that that leftist tactic and there's really no place for that in the gospel in in the Kingdom of God. And so I guess that's just, that's pretty much everything I wanted to kind of cover and and say but yeah, any of your thoughts or any other? Questions. So I I just jotted down some notes here as as I was listening to to your hypothesis. Right.
2:23:10 Yeah. And it's important here to to point out that that your hypothesis holds to the traditional narrative, right? So you have a narrative, and then with that narrative you have all the extenuating circumstances, all the minutiae that go into filling up that narrative. OK, Griffin, He tries to to fill in his narrative with all of this minutiae. Right, The the clock test. Right, the watch test. I should say. I remember looking at that and thinking to myself, you see John Taylor's watch, right?
2:23:56 But yet, and and you can still see it to this day, if I'm not mistaken, I think it's still displayed at the Church History Museum. And as you look at that, there's no way that thing's shot with a musket ball. It just no. But that's what he uses. Yeah. So it's a red herring, right? He's setting. Or a straw man. That's what I I meant. Like it's a straw man. You're putting up a really weak, easily disprovable argument. You're obviously disproving it. And now you're claiming victory. Like, oh, I just did this great thing and and proved this this thing right. Like that's a straw man fallacy. Yeah, the The next thing I would say is you came with things that Justin Griffin never did. You came with like citations from, you know, medical journals.
2:24:49 Those sorts of things went into great detail to to support your your the that minutiae that goes into creating that narrative. I was thinking about, you know, 'cause this one I always have wondered about if he gets shot here, how does it come down through here? Right. I've been a hunter. I understand bullets do weird things, but by and large, you know that's that's not hugely common. However, you you point out that that Hiram was looking down, maybe checking, you know, OK, where else did I get hit? And if he's down like this, maybe he falls to his knees, right?
2:25:30 And as he's going down, he's on his knees or whatever. Maybe he gets struck then and it's kind of at a downward trajectory, right? Well, and he's falling forward. So yeah, it's it's really not that much of a difference of the trajectory, change of the trajectory if he's if it enters on the left side of his nose and exits down here, it only has to be about a 1520�� change of angle for it to not penetrate the chest and just graze his vest as, as we know happened. And and the other thing I would say is that unlike and and you can correct me if I'm wrong here on this, most guns of that time were still using ball, right. They weren't using what we would think of as a traditional bullet that we would think of.
2:26:14 Today, yeah, because yeah, that is a true thing. They're both projectiles, but musket balls are not bullets. Right, exactly. And so those are gonna do different things, right? Yes. The, the, the the calibrated. Fine tooth precision that is used in in making a bullet today wasn't what was involved in those times, right. You're talking about literally melting down some lead and then clipping off the obvious J jagged angles and like, Yep, that should work in this caliber of rifle. And so they're going to, they're going to have all sorts of deformities on them.
2:26:56 That's going to cause them to do different things. The next thing that that I pointed to the OR that I that I thought it jotted down here was the human memory. The human memory is notoriously. Degrades over. Liable, right? It's not reliable. It's just not, I know, especially in in a traumatic situation like that. Right, high stress. Yeah, I look. I've been in one auto accident, just one. But it was enough that like once I got home, I'm like, wait a second, did I really see that that way? How did that happen?
2:27:39 Right. And and as as time went on, it became fuzzier and fuzzier, right? And so to expect that the story would never change, Well, if you're gonna, if you're gonna say well. That doesn't seem. To to make sense with the the other narrative, well, then you might as well throw out these scriptures, right? Because the New Testament in itself has, I wouldn't say, contradictory evidence, but because the witnesses were different, there's different points of emphasis that are put on it. Totally. Now let's talk about epistemology here for a minute. OK, if you're going to go with the well, the most likely scenario has to be the true scenario, right? Throw out the resurrection 'cause I can tell you from a natural world world perspective, you're you know and you're gonna use the most probable.
2:28:35 Well, the most probable is, is that the disciples broke in there, stole Jesus's body, and then feigned A resurrection that is most possible. Right, most probable. Most probable so if. If. Yeah. So if we're talking about doctrine of Christ, we're we're. That's a double standard. That is a double standard, yeah. So you gotta throw that out. And then the other thing is, is that that that it in my estimation looking at this, Griffin never uses forensics. Ever. Ever it. It's never anything that that that comes close to forensics. You might say some scientific thoughts were applied there, but I wouldn't call that forensics. The other thing I would say he's been disproven over and over and over again.
2:29:25 Not just by you, but I sat in in in a conference and listened to a former. I can't remember what city for sure. I want to say LA back to a degrading memory. I I think he, he said somewhere in California. I want to say Los Angeles County, but I could be wrong where this guy has investigated hundreds, maybe even thousands of shootings and looked at the overall account that was given by Taylor and given by Richards that it happened pretty close to what they said, right?
2:30:07 And we would expect to find some variance in their stories over time. If, to be honest with you, if we didn't see variants, I would get a little worried at that point. I'm like, OK, they really, really rehearsed this. Now let's move on to this. And and I'm trying to sum all this up since since you said you that was pretty much what you had. The other thing I would say is that in this case especially motive is going to be a big deal, a huge deal. We have no evidence promotive from Taylor or Richards or Brigham Young. Period. None. It does not exist. No one.
2:30:48 And in fact all of the adverse incentives 'cause you know and and of course people like Griffin and you know Snuffer and these people that are anti Brigham they always say well man Brigham died a multimillionaire and he plundered the church you know resources for personal gain and and you know and he had all this power over thousands of lives and and had all of this and it's like yeah decades later. Right dude there was no that that was no guarantee that that was gonna work out that it it was touch and go. They they were fighting for survival for years and years. They had all of the they had an army coming after him from Johnston's army that from the US threatening their lives and their safety. They Brigham lamented all the time that yeah he had all this power and yet people didn't wouldn't accept Adam God doctrine.
2:31:43 So it's like, wait, I I thought he was such a brutal dictator and was just so dogmatic and everybody just hopped and and got in line when he told him to do stuff. The the church as a body rejected him when he tried to preach a doctrine called the Adam God theology. And there was other things that they pushed back and just wouldn't have. And even polygamy, to be honest, the vast majority of the church membership never bought in and in fact were highly critical and against polygamy. You know John Taylor died for his religion and just I think it would if I recall, it was like within a year, just a few months later the first Utah State constitutional draft was proposed and in that draft polygamy was criminal was illegalized in the constitution of the state of Utah.
2:32:35 Now it's a it would have I, I, I if I'm recalling correctly which again memory might be degrading but if if I recall correctly that might. If I I'm pretty sure he died just shortly before that happened cause what a heartbreak like you just bled out for your life and and was living on the underground for all those years. All of that risk all of that stress And you know to preserve this principle and then your people just immediately throw it out and and reject it like official on the record 'cause it was it was heavily supported by like 90% of the population in in Utah. Yeah. When that when that draft proposal was released. So like talk about a slap in the face but yeah so they and and Speaking of John Taylor died.
2:33:25 So maybe Brigham Young died in relative comfort and affluence. John Taylor didn't dude. He died. He died in hiding running from the feds and from the all this persecution A pauper essentially. So, so yeah, Cui Bono. And that that really doesn't line up with that narrative. They they were trying to just get all this power and and wealth and it was all a conspiracy to for personal development and and aggrandizement like get out. Yeah, forget. Yeah, no, they're. Look, if if you're going to off Joseph Smith and then your next thought is OK, let's go find maybe one of the worst places we can find on the continent to settle. A barren desert.
2:34:13 Yeah, it does. It does not hold water. And and I just look at this over and over and quite frankly, this thing sinks faster than the Titanic. I mean, it just does not get to where it needs to be to be taken serious. And again, the onus is not on you, it's not on me, it's not on the historical narrative, it's not on historians who provide context for this, which, by the way, we have plenty of evidence on the other side that it was the mob and it was other politicians that wanted them dead. The mob was bragging about it.
2:34:55 Yes, the mob took credit. I mean, this is like the Taliban, Like unless they didn't actually do it, they're just like trying to take the credit for like they're they were not denying it and they were clearly, you know, celebrating, you know, and Thomas Sharp of the the Warsaw Signal was like basically just exalting that this had happened and taking the credit, like sharing in the glory, so to speak. Like this was something that they considered a massive achievement. Right, but. The mob and the the anti Joseph. And here's the other thing, right? John Taylor and Willard Richards didn't go originally with Joseph Smith and Hiram to the jail.
2:35:37 If, if memory serves, they came in later. OK, so if you want Joseph and Hiram dead, and you know that everyone's already pissed massively because of the destruction of the press, because of all the other things, why not just feed that mob? Yeah, I think that. I think John Taylor was with them. I can't remember if Willard was. Was he OK? But. Yeah, I think he accompanied them. But but still. I mean, why not find a reason to leave? Hey Joseph, I'm gonna go run down some boys to help protect you. And then? The other guys were coming and going. Yeah, and then feed that mob, right, And be like, oh, he's in there unarmed. Good to go.
2:36:18 Why the hell? Would you put yourself in that in in that predicament? That's just stupid. Again, you have to suspend so much common sense and so much just reality to get to this point that John Taylor and Willard Richards on the Order of Brigham Young was able to get this done that, you know, I I can't say they're not faithful people, 'cause they have to suspend a lot of common sense and reasonability to get to this point. And let's be honest here too, I would really at some point like to do a deep dive to find out exactly what, what Justin Griffin's motive is. Maybe what what's, what's, what's in this for him? Because you've got to stretch awfully far to get this done and he has not done a good job.
2:37:18 So the reward must have been great, whatever it is or whatever he thought it was. But I I I think by this point anyone who wants to see what most likely happened there sees it right and and the prevailing narrative still wins at this point which is Joseph was was sought out by that mob one for his religion 2. For destroying the printing press and that's it. That's where it lies. And until somebody and we have we have evidence of like them plotting you know the that group plotting to kill him.
2:38:02 We know Joseph inserted young men as spies into the ring who warned him several times. You have motive right there. You just don't want to look at the motive because it does not fit your narrative Justin. Period. And until you're willing, you look at all the evidence without bias and just say what does this point to? You can bark up this tree all day long. I think the next logical step is to say the aliens did it, I think at this point. We have to go with. Funny, funny. Bring that up. If you go to the, if you go to the uncut, round two, I I kind of did that, you know, I was just poking a little bit.
2:38:50 No, that's the truth. I I don't see where else you go at this point because his his narrative doesn't hold water. It answers all the questions that he raises perfectly. The aliens did it. The aliens did it, absolutely. I I do. I did think of one other thing I wanted to cover real quick. So this is not a person that I know I, but he apparently somehow came across my video and watched it and he he's his name is Leif Harris. He says I've heard very few, few people speaking about these events that actually know anything about what they're talking about, including Mr. Griffin. You're one who does. Thank you very much. That's very kind. As a pertinent example, unlike modern firearms which use high speed and bullet deformation to kill, historic ball ammunition, use deflection and percussion to kill, ball ammunition deflects more easily than all other types of ammunition in the high percussion of lower speed but higher mass bullets does a significant amount of internal damage. Very few animals, for example, who are haunted with traditional ball ammunition muzzle loaders from any significant distance have exit wounds, and they frequently bleed to death internally.
2:40:00 This brings an important corroboration to your discussion of Hyrum's wounds and the likelihood as to what what, what it was that killed him, etcetera. Mr. Griffin contradicts himself when he claims that the lack of an extremely destructive exit wound at the back of Hiram's head means that the face wound was an exit wound. By that same logic, the face wound would necessarily have to have a destructive and large pole, which it didn't. Well, and also. Yeah. And so then he gets pushed back from this guy. He changed his name. It used to be Patrick Morris but he he's like, where are you getting your information? And Laif backs it up. He says. I get my information from 1 multiple sources on ballistic research which I've read some of the ballistic research. Not nearly as much as this Mr. Harris but but two.
2:40:42 My own experience shooting black powder rifles since my youth around 40 years, that dude that carries some weight. Lead balls only flatten if they hit something very solid with backing that is perpendicular to the path of travel. Otherwise they deform and deflect all around the body and someone actually did mention something about a significant distance. The speaker indicated the first shot Hiram received was, in his opinion, shot from outside the building that hit him in the back and likely at some distance. The room is on the second story of a flat area Nobody could have hit someone shot someone in the middle of the room from right outside the building. They would have had to been a fair distance away from the building, or up in a tree, or on top of a ladder, or something similar, or some distance from the building to get an angle to a shot at someone in the middle of the room.
2:41:24 They weren't literally a few feet away. So anyway, it goes back and forth, but I just think that that brings valuable perspective. And, you know, if I had an expert witness, like if I had known this Leif Harris in advance, I might have had him maybe record a little testimony as far as as an expert witness, give his credentials, show his experience, maybe even do a couple of replicating shots to to, you know, because this is the the problem that Griffin has is he's praying upon ignorance. And the people that fall for his lies do so out of ignorance. And so it's really important to bring actual, credible, reliable expertise to this conversation. You know, and and speaking about the blood, right. You know, I could see why there wouldn't have been a lot of blood if Hiram would have been shot in the back and he was bleeding internally, right?
2:42:20 You're not getting the same amount of blood to your head as you would normally have if that would have been the first wound. The the other thing I was thinking about and maybe this is a you know maybe this isn't right for anyone out there who knows more than I do. I'm I'm welcome to hear it again. Most most of the ammunition was ball, right? It was ball. OK, I I'm just thinking about this from a pure physics perspective here, so I I probably don't have very much room to speculate this on this at all, but wouldn't that ball kind of act like a plug in some respects as well? Not necessarily. If it if it met obstruction and didn't fully penetrate then I could see that you know having some potential but we know that it actually did it.
2:43:08 It didn't exit but what they what they found is that it dented the back of Hiram's pocket watch which was on his right breast pocket. So it didn't it didn't break the skin but it did cause a dent And they so they say they say that that was caused by the bullet that came in through his back. So the bullet clearly passed through. Now who knows where it bounced around and deflected after it struck the back of his pocket watch. But it it certainly I don't I it wouldn't have been a hole. It wouldn't have plugged that hole. I think that the like I presented is far more likely. There had to have been some bleeding around the hole.
2:43:50 There had to have been. But we know that he yes, ice, ice and sawdust would have. So the sawdust would have absorbed a lot of that away. The ice would have kept it from the stain from like seizing in and becoming permanent in the fabric. And interestingly, we do have all those blood stains around his neck from the the the head wounds that Hiram sustained. And so it's not that it's not that they just scrubbed harder in the back. No, it's because with he was laying on his back, only the back would have had the cold. The benefit of that cold which are resting arrest the staining effect of blood, Whereas up here they weren't able to wash out afterward. Absolutely, dude. Good stuff.
2:44:30 I like it. I hope everyone can see past this now. Yeah. It's just it's borderline silly at this point. And. It's just you have to. It's what you want to believe if you if you're gonna buy into this, it's 'cause you want to and you really want to not have to accept polygamy. And I get it. Polygamy is not an easy principle. It's not a pleasant thing, involves incredible amounts of sacrifice. And you know, it's it's not easy by design. But that's the only like, getting back to Justin Griffin's motive.
2:45:12 I think that this is all basically a ruse that he was trying to lay a rational seeming foundation to lay the groundwork for his eventual anti polygamy narrative. I I can't. I mean and that's what he has now on the record admitted that's what his Part 3 is going to be about is anti polygamy and you know and and basically anti Brigham and the 12 which now becomes like you said at the beginning, anti temple ordinances, anti higher principles. And if you if you throw all of that out, there is still a lot of depth and beauty to Mormonism. But Dang, you have lost the fullness. You're just settling for the partialness. You know, I mean, I'll be honest, I I guess I see that a little worse than what you do.
2:45:58 You get rid of the higher ordinances, right? The the temple worship and everything else you're left. And this isn't a slam on Protestantism. I know a lot of great Protestants, but you basically get Protestantism with a few extra things. It's regression, not progress, for sure. Yeah, absolutely. You know, eternal progression. You know that You're taking steps several steps back. Awesome. So. Yeah, All right, dude. Well, good stuff. I'll let you get to bed now. It's pushing 11 I think. I appreciate it, brother. Always worth it though. It is. It's always fun. I I like it. So, and I wanna say this, if someone wants to really try to present other evidence, I'm here. Give me a call.
2:46:44 I'm off. I'm off. I'm here for that too. Dude, I'd love to. You know, if you wanted to have a debate, anybody, it's this is a standing invitation. Anybody from that side and and sees that perspective love to have that conversation. Let's do it on the record though. Perfect. All right, man. Well, you have a good night. Likewise, all right. Bye everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.
Spotify
Apple Podcasts
YouTube
Amazon Music
RSS Feed
Castbox