March 2, 2024

Episode #119: Doctrine & Covenants 42 Annotated-How Did The Early Leaders Of Mormonism Understand It & What Does It Mean Today W/Drew Briney

Episode #119: Doctrine & Covenants 42 Annotated-How Did The Early Leaders Of Mormonism Understand It & What Does It Mean Today W/Drew Briney
Episode #119: Doctrine & Covenants 42 Annotated-How Did The Early Leaders Of Mormonism Understand It & What Does It Mean Today W/Drew Briney
The Mormon Renegade Podcast
Episode #119: Doctrine & Covenants 42 Annotated-How Did The Early Leaders Of Mormonism Understand It & What Does It Mean Today W/Drew Briney

Go To http://patreon.com/MormonRenegade368 For Exclusive Content

Ok I got an amazing conversation for you today. If you remember back to the first episode, I ever did Drew Briney it was about an amazing project that he was working on making an annotated version of the Doctrine & Covenants. Well today Drew comes back on to the podcast to have a conversation about the latest installment of that project, D&C 42. D&C 42 is all about Consecration and United Order. As we breakdown how Drew went about annotating this particular section, we dive head long into what the early leaders of the LDS Church thought about these principles, how it was lived in both the Missouri & Utah periods and what our responsibilities we have as Mormons today have in regards to Consecration & United Order.

--- Support this podcast: https://podcasters.spotify.com/pod/show/dave-kirkenbower/support

0:04 OK, I got an amazing conversation for you today. If you remember back to the first episode I ever did with Drew Briny, it was about an amazing project that he was working on, on making an annotated version of the doctor and covenants. Well, the day Drew comes back on the podcast to have a conversation about the latest installment of that project, which is DNC 42. DNC 42 is all about consecration in United order. As we break down how Drew went about annotating this particular section, we dive headlong into what the early leaders of the LDS Church thought about these principles, how it was lived in both the Missouri and Utah periods, and what our responsibility is as Mormons today in regards to consecration in united order. Get ready for a deep dive into the subject on this episode of the Mormon Renegade Podcast.

0:51 Look, it's no secret that our society has become much more crude and coarse. To become and raise men and women of virtue and character is a Herculean task. To help with this, I've recently wrote and published a book. Now, back in the 1700s, Washington had a book called Rules of Civility and Decent Behavior and Company and Conversation. It was a book with 110 rules that talked about how to conduct yourself like a civilized person in society, something that today's society is sorely lacking. What I did is I went back through the book and I reinterpreted his original sayings for the 21st century. So the book is laid out in a way in which you see Washington's original rule.

1:31 Right below that is my explanation for the 21st century, and below that you'll find two or three examples of where to use this in the real world. Now, to go along with this, there's a workbook that helps parents teach these principles and practices to their kids. To find the book, go to mormonrenegade.com. Go to the bottom of the page, search out the blog post, and order your copy today. I can bear personal testimony from personal experience that this is an invaluable tool to help you raise men and women of virtue and character.

2:32 You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast, True. Back at it again. Yeah. You're a busy man as. Hard as I can. You're a busy, busy man. I mean, I am. I am astounded at the amount of work that you were putting out. We were just talking. You said four books last year. Yeah, 4 four books and put out a couple new editions of some of my older works. Yeah, it's been super busy on top of working for as a woodworker. Yeah, yeah, that's crazy. And see here, I thought I was doing good by, you know, getting above 100 episodes, right.

3:17 And what I do is way easier than what you do. I mean you're you're running circles around me, but so DNC 42, that's the next one in the annotation that you're doing. Yeah, it was it was unexpected that I I sat down, I've looked over all the sections and I have kind of an idea of what I was going to do. And 42 was not on that list. And in fact, actually at the point when I started doing it, I I didn't have a full list of what I wanted to do. I just had a couple and I was talking to somebody at at Centennial Park and he said, So what do you make of all the changes in DNC 42? I said, well, I haven't got there yet. And he said, I'm really curious who made all those changes to the Doctrine Covenants.

4:05 They're not small ones. They're and there are lots of them. And they're substantial. They're like very he. He didn't get into all the detail, but they're substantive, you know, they're doctrinal, they're substantive, they're act, they're administrative. And it's not just grammar and commas and stuff. Like usual said. I want to know who did that and why. And you know, all that sort of stuff. And I was like, I don't know, but so all of a sudden I said, well, I'm going to find out for him. And and I I didn't figure I would just do the whole section 'cause it's huge. Yeah, it's like 92 verses. Yeah, I was like, I don't want to do another one like that. I want to do a couple small ones, you know. And it's almost like a small pamphlet or book. Yeah, yeah.

4:49 So, well, I I've been doing well. My intention was to do monthly updates for the DNC project. And so, you know, I did the Amman revelation, I did the Apocrypha. I, you know, I did some smaller sections just to kind of get some momentum going. So I didn't want to bog myself down with this gargantuan section. But I thought at least I could do is go over the original manuscript, find out about the changes, which ones got approved by Joseph, which ones didn't give it to him and move away, you know, And by the time I and that I was sucked into it, it anyway, it was huge project, much bigger than that. Did you ever, did you ever figure out who made the changes? Was it one person?

5:32 Was it multiple people? Yeah, it was. That was actually pretty straightforward and I was really surprised. So basically Oliver Cadre just made all the changes and he made the changes and said I never, you know, I made a bunch of changes from the original published version of this but they were all in the in the original manuscript basically Big Fat Lie. I mean just wasn't true at all. It may be true, and I think it arguably is true, that the intention behind the original manuscript was not changed. But there were a lot of changes.

6:15 And and for instance, you know, they when when DNC 42 was originally written, there was no high council. There's no revelation on the high council. And so it says, you know, if you disagree with the Bishop on consecration, they grab a couple elders. They can, you know sort it out well or or sorry, all the cowdery changes. It says take it from the the high priests, you know, accounts of high priests or something like that. Well, that was after you read the, the revelation on the high Council and how it's supposed to work. That makes sense. That's kind of their job, but that's also not original. But is it the original intent? I mean, the idea is to have a supervisory board set up to oversee what the Bishop does, to make sure he's not being a bully.

7:01 And and or to say to a person who's disagreeing with the Bishop, you're a beating, unreasonable. You know, the Bishop's being a good guy and you just make his job hard. Knock it off the the intention appears to be the same so that part was pretty easy and and you know I've I've got some quotes that that I you know about those changes in the in the introduction that just basically say yeah all over the counter He did it all. Now the next question is did Joseph change those? Did he accept those? And and the answer is yes. And so then I was like did Joe, was Joseph careful about editing these sections What, what evidence do we have, you know, and and for the most part, you know, it's not like we have a record of Joseph saying, well today I went over the doctrine of confidence for publication in 1844, which is of course after he died, you know, and in that process I went through sections, blah, blah, blah. And we just don't have a record like that. He didn't, you know, he wasn't that meticulous. He just say worked on DNC or you know, went over to the the office and he doesn't say what he worked on. So there's no way to know that per Southeast, except for one thing.

8:14 And I I wish it was on the top of my head, but it's not. There was one place where he changed one letter, but it completely changed the meaning of the word by changing that letter. And and it was so. It was such a meticulous change that he made. It's clear that he was paying attention. He didn't just pass off all these changes absentmindedly. He was reading over it carefully. Yes, this is the intention behind what I wanted and you know that he so he in in my estimation looking over all the original documents he approved all of those changes and frankly if you read them you know they it it makes sense and and maybe I could just I'll read over a couple while we're talking, it's OK. So I'll I'll just I'll just read part of it. The the consecration starts in verse 29. Before you do that, I got one question on this. If Joseph approved, if Joseph approved of these changes, why do you think it is we need to look back then. Do you feel like that there was like, I guess and and correct me if I'm wrong here, Drew, I imagine that Joseph's making changes 'cause, you know, he wasn't, he wasn't comfortable in one part of where he received the revelation or he's like, you know, I think I may have gotten that wrong and and as I was dictating it.

9:46 What if, if he's okaying these changes? Is there anything that we're going to see in in this annotated version of 42 that's going to be counterproductive, if you will? No, I I if I'm understanding you correctly, no. So first of all I I think it's helpful actually to look at the original changes and and I guess that's kind of like why why do we want to even want to look at this if Joseph proved and why even look at what it used to be versus what it is now. It's basically what you're saying. Yeah, yeah, 'cause my thought would. Be It's a fair question, yeah.

10:32 And so I think there are, there are two things and and this gets into a really big rabbit hole I'm sure we'll talk a little bit more about later. But DNC 42 was not liked by the membership. It was wholesale consecration as outlined to DNC 42 was wholesale rejected by the church and has never been lived by the church. And the Saints still didn't want to live at 20-30 years after even after they, you know, they've been through the temple. They got their endowments. They the cabinets consecr operation, they still didn't like it and and I'll talk about some of those talks later and and kind of how they how they approach that. But so I think from that context I think the changes are significant because you look at it and what I see when I see the changes is Joseph and all over Calgary probably.

11:29 Thank you. Sorry, what what you see, sorry for the audiologist start. What I just was saying over again, what we see is Joseph and Oliver Cadre saying part of the problem with the membership is they don't understand the principles behind what we're doing. They don't understand what the Doctrine Covenants is trying to say. And so we're going to interpolate and mostly add a bunch of new material so that they can understand it better. And I'll give you some examples of those. That's why I was going to share some. And I I don't have the original manuscript in front of me, so I have to literally look at each one of these and and see what it is.

12:16 But in verse 30, it starts out and behold, thou will remember the poor and consecrated thy properties for their support. OK, that's not in the original. It just basically says that will consecrate thy properties and in which thou hast with a covenant deed. You know, that's the original. But now it says which thou hast to impart unto them with the covenant, and a deed which cannot be broken. So he's saying, you know, why are you consecrating? It's for the poor. Verse 31 starts out all this is new, and in as much as you impart of your substance unto the poor, you will do it unto me, right?

12:58 So the original is basically saying consecrate it to God. That's what it's saying, OK, but but they're saying you're not understanding that if you're consecrating it to God, you know what it's really saying is give it to the poor people and that is giving it to God. He doesn't need your stupid donkey, He doesn't need your mule, doesn't need your 10 lbs of flour once a week. You know, this is for the poor. OK, so he's he's talking. So so in verse 30 and 31, he's actually ascribing intent what this is for? Right. OK, that makes sense. All right. And then and then he says in verse 32, which is long for something to start in the middle, he'll just say the properties cannot be taken from the church, agreeable to my commandments.

13:48 Every man shall be made accountable unto me, a steward over his own property. So, you know, at first it's just saying basically you consecrate some of the property, get some back, right. But he's he's saying, OK, you're missing the point. You know, you're laying them before the Bishop to show him what you've got. He's taking all of it, everything. And then you're receiving part of it back, but as a steward over it. So it's not like you own it. Again, the and and and Orson Pratt went to great lengths to explain this doctrine to the people He does. I'm not an Orson Pratt fan, but he does an amazing job in in in his commentaries on the section to really explain the principles behind it really well. And he says like, the only way you can get an equality among the Saints is if they recognize as the principle everything belongs to God.

14:43 I'm giving everything back to God. And we all recognize that no, whatever we're doing in our respective parts of the vineyard, we're all working for God and furthering his purposes. And so we received back what we need and everything else goes towards building God's Kingdom. It's his anyways. And you know, people weren't understanding that they're like you're just giving charity to the poor people and and and they're teaching and. And one of the one of the talks in particular focuses and says the first principle is get rid of the poor among you, right?

15:30 Like, don't get rid of the people. Get rid of the poverty. That's the first thing you know. And and that's where a lot of people struggled right away is they're like, wait a second, why am I giving all of my everything to the Bishop? Like, what's he going to do with it, you know? And the Dachshund covenant says he's going to give it to the poor. First of all, get rid of the the poverty. We got to get that out of our out of our midst and then after that's taken care of then whatever's left over then we use that to build the Kingdom. So, but in the original version of the Dachshund Covenants, that's not super clear. OK. And and and so, you know, we have to have these clarifications.

16:16 Gotcha. Gotcha. And at any rate, and then, you know, there's some corrections, there's several corrections about, you know, if you have a disagreement with the Bishop and all that sort of stuff, then, you know, it goes before High Council and this sort of sort of thing. But verse 33 is a good example of interpolation. It says again if there shall be properties in the hands of the church or in the individuals of it more than is necessary for their support after the first consonant consecration which is a residue, All that's new that wasn't in the original. So it just says and again with the residue, you know give it to the Bishop.

17:02 But now it's explaining after your first consecration if there's still extra that's a residue or that's you know then that's something that you're you're consecrating. So again you know it's it's not a one, one off thing And so I I think when we look at these changes and recognize and the Saints were not willing to keep the original law. So Joseph makes an attempt to to make it or Oliver Cadre sorry. And I I think frankly Oliver Cadre was under Joseph's direction to do things. He did take some liberties with the DNC, got chewed out for it and and and frankly the editors in the 1844 basically said some people change some stuff without proper approval and so we had to fix that.

17:51 And so there's a little bit of a spat about these issues. But at the end of the day, what the clear effort is, if you look at the the actual changes in this section of the DNC is just trying to get people to understand it better. It's like you you don't understand the purpose of consecration. You don't understand what we're doing and that's really the problem. And if you understood better, maybe you'll live it right. So I think that's why it's it's helpful to look at all these changes and and literally like I was saying if I'm looking on the paper and I've I've got all the changes in blue and that's just a format thing for digital versions of the in my software half of the page is blue because there's literally that much was changed and it's not commas and punctuation or capitalizations or bad grammar it's interpolation over and over again. So do you find that that most of these and 42 are additions rather than?

18:54 Yes, almost no deletions, almost all additions, OK. And they're very interpretative. They're very clarifying there. There are some that are changing. Here's the administrative things that have changed with the church, like I mentioned, High Council, just several of those things. But mostly it's just trying to get people to understand this is what the Bishop is going to do with your your your money. If you're going to go give the Bishop $10,000 today, you're going to be like, I want to know what you're going to do with $10,000, you know? And if you're with $100,000, he's like, I'm giving all of it to the Bishop. He's going to give me 30,000 back because that's what's an average, you know, amount that Saints get. Where what's he doing that $70,000? I'm working my butt off.

19:40 You're going to take 70% of my money. I don't know where it's going. Right. And and so I think that was their first effort was to say, OK we we need to help people understand what the bishops doing with this. And in fact, if you look at the other sections of the doctrine, confidence that address consecration, we see them kind of amending and back stepping from the original DNC 42 to to make it easier to understand, to explain what the bishops doing and to make it less hard, less difficult. And that's that didn't work either, but that's that's kind of the next stage of of of of of the historical record I guess. Gotcha.

20:28 This is fascinating because we get a glimpse like what you're doing here. I think really a lot of people, including mainstream LDS folks, have been asking what was the process for the Doctrine and Covenants, right? Because I've I've made this contention for a long time. The Doctrine and Covenants is unique in all of Christendom, probably in religion generally, right? Because got to be close to 90 some percent of everything that's said is coming direct from the Lord, right? There's no, there's no real interpretation going on. It's Joseph asks a question. Joseph gets an answer.

21:13 They get published right with some editing, that sort of stuff. Right now I think that that that why this is so interesting is that this gives a glimpse into the process of how Joseph Smith received revelation. And just as we were talking here, it seems like he's he's, he's not getting so much words as he is ideas and principles, right? And then as as he dictates it in the moment, he's not thinking about it, are other people going to be able to understand this? Right. Or how are they going to misinterpret it? Right. He's just spitting it out as it kind of comes, so to speak, right?

21:55 Yes. And so this is fascinating, 'cause this shows that Joseph will will receive these revelations and he knows what the intent is because he's the one receiving it. And then he puts it forward and then he's like, well, wait a second, That doesn't necessarily express, express the, you know, the the the 10th there. And so this is fascinating because because this kind of forces Joseph to go back and almost reanalyze what he had got in the moment and could look at it and go, OK, so I'm gonna have to add some explanation here because this is what I really received. That's that's fascinating.

22:37 Yeah. Can I interrupt there? Yeah I that's that is such a big part of of what's happening here in in and we we're going to see all throughout church history with consecration but I I just ran across a passage with with that on the baby resurrection doctrine the other day as I was reading in the words of Joseph Smith and looking at some out external accounts of the baby resurrection doctrine which was that you know babies that died would be resurrected as babies and stay babies you know raining on Thrones. Well one one of the interpretations has been well Joseph changed his mind he learned better and later he said that they would grow right. Well one of the original accounts is and and the original accounts are pretty vague right.

23:30 But one of the original accounts, they're the thing it published as the TPGS or whatever, you know, that account basically suggests that the baby will grow when it's resurrected until it gets its full stature. It's not super clear, but it it throws that somebody heard that as part of the discourse and they understood it at that time. The same thing he was teaching 10 years later. Well, there's another account of Brigham Young saying, well, Joseph said they wouldn't grow and later he did said did grow. And I I can't make any sense of it. And he's disturbed by it. Well, I think it was William Clayton's journalist, the one that picks up from the first count when everybody else said Joseph's, they they wrote down Joseph, said the baby's going to be resurrected and reign on the Thrones as a baby.

24:16 He was the one, I think so subject to correction, who wrote in his in his journal entry. Joseph taught the babies to be resurrected and would grow, you know. And so he caught the nuance, but most of the others did not. And so then the formal record sounds like, you know, he's going to be resurrected as a baby and stay that way. But he's telling mothers, you know, grieving mothers privately when when your baby, when your baby's resurrected in the Millennium, you'll get a chance to raise the baby until they're fully grown, you know? And then later he preaches that publicly because people are confused because they misheard it. But he's not learning.

24:58 He's correcting. He didn't express it well the first time, and maybe it wasn't recorded well either. And we're stuck trying to decipher all that. And there's a lot of effort going back historically for historians to try and say Joseph was just learning. True, he was learning. We have evidence of that, but that's not always the way you need to interpret the historical record. And I think DNC 42 is one of those situations where historians and people talking about consecration want to say, well, Joseph was just learning. He wrote down this idea. It sucked really badly. It didn't work. Nobody liked it.

25:38 And so he tried to a new version. And so he writes, you know, in this other section, the doctrine cabinets, well, you don't consecrate everything, just your surplus, OK, So that makes it easier. Now people are quite so scared. They can still, you know, keep stuff and not lose it by deed and all this sort of thing. And but if you read the discourses of the early brotherhood talking about what happened, that's not how they understood things and that's not what was going down. And I I think that's super, super interesting all by itself to explore that question of what they were teaching in terms of what you were saying earlier. This is God giving a revelation.

26:18 And what we have is Joseph Smith expressing his understanding and then correcting some details later. But God's still the one in charge telling him the details. Joseph's not making up the details. He's making up how you express the details. So you you know is is God learning? You know, he's, he's not being surprised here, right? He's not learning it's. And you know, so that nuance of how you look at the text changes things. And so this is where it gets really interesting to me. And what really changed my perspective doing the research for this book was mostly Orson Pratt.

26:58 And and to be fair, I'll kind of reiterate, I've been an anti Orson Pratt person in my mind for multiple reasons. He got in trouble with Joseph. He got in trouble with Brigham. He's he fought with Joseph over doctrine a couple times, not as heavily as he did with Brigham. Fought heavily with Brigham, Repented said. I'm so sorry. And then he published against Brigham again on the same issues again later. Anyway, you know, I mean so I'm just I'm not a big Orson Pratt fan and you know it it at any rate, you know, it is it is what it is it he's a good guy. I'm not trying to badmouth him. I'm just not a big fan of him. And I don't always trust what he says doctrinally because he's very well read, but he didn't always understand what was being taught. And then he adjusted from there and that that's fine. But I I want somebody who's inspired, that's somebody who's thinking hard.

27:52 You know, I can think hard and and I like to think hard and I like to trust myself when I think hard. But at the end of the day, after I think hard, I pray and you know, ask for correction. And it seems like a lot of times Orson Pratt didn't do that, and in fact Brigham Young taught him. At one point he said, I I don't remember the exact thing, but Breaking said something to the fact if I haven't read the Bible in 30 years, then you'd be better off if you didn't either. You need to spend more time praying on your knees in the woods. And then maybe you'd be more doctrinally strong because you could get some revelation instead of all your stupid ideas. They they anyway, yeah they exchanged words they it wasn't quite quite maybe that harsh but maybe it was. It depends on how you read it.

28:35 But. I I find the interactions between Orson and Brigham fascinating. Right. Especially when they're contentious and the reason I I find them fascinating is I think that that he what we see is we see two guys who are passionate about what they believe right. And I'm with you. I, I, I'm not a terrible fan of Orson Pratt, which breaks my heart because he was a surveyor. But but but at the end of the day, you know, I I side with Brigham on way more things than I do with Orson. However, I think that that kind of a sidebar here, 'cause there's a few things I want to unpack on what you just said. You got two guys who who you just get the feeling are kind of the same in some ways, right?

29:42 They're going to come to their conclusions and then they're going to hold to those conclusions unless you can prove 100% that you're off base, right? And they go. At it. What's that and? They're both very passionate for the gospel. Yes. And they go at it right. They go at it hard, right. There are certain things that Orson said about Brigham that had I been Brigham, two things could would have probably happened. One is I'm going to excommunicate you and then we're going to fight in the street, right. But, and and this is where I I also think that this is fascinating because you can see, you know, Brigham gets the, the rap of not having any patience whatsoever. But someone asked Brigham once, why don't you just X him, right? Get rid of him.

30:33 And he's like, you could cut that man into 1000 pieces and each one would testify that Joseph Smith was a prophet. And I I think that's a lesson we need to learn, especially within Mormonism. We're gonna have different ideas. We're gonna have different beliefs, and that's fine. As long as we can kind of stick around those basics. We can work with each other a little bit, right? We we may not be able to hug it out on Sundays, but we can sure work together on Saturdays and. Yeah. And and I I find that fascinating. The the other thing I I wanted to to ask about is as you studied 42 here, because consecration's a touchy subject even today, right?

31:16 Yes. What was your take away there? Right 'cause 'cause there? There seems to be two two overarching narratives with this. With consecration. It was either a really bad hippie commune that never got up off the ground really well or it was a a power grab. If you're on the the the anti Mormon side of things. In in your opinion, after studying 42, seeing the original record, seeing and then comparing with what we got now, and then maybe looking at at at practice, what was your idea of how the Saints and Joseph especially envisioned consecration being lived?

32:02 Yeah, That's a a great question and I I would say that the biggest thing and and and and for me what really makes the books that I'm doing on the subject valuable is I'm providing all of the known commentary from the brethren on that section in the book so that you can see what how they interpreted it. So in answer to your question, I would say originally before I began studying and unpacking this section, my understanding was and and and and.

32:42 Frankly I hadn't delved into it super deep. I was. I was heavily involved in the Rocky Ridge order as an attorney. I was heavily involved in attending their meetings every week for a decade or closer to 15 years. I listened to all their their thoughts and arguments many times in priesthood about what consecration was, but I felt like I hadn't really researched it well. But from that perspective, it seemed to me that Joseph introduces consecration in 42. The Saints try and live it, they screw up and it doesn't work. So Joseph goes, asks more questions, tries to implement that, screws up, doesn't work.

33:31 So Brigham Young tries to to do the same thing and you know, experiments around with different united orders and it just never really worked. I don't see it at all like that anymore. So let me, let me read to you a couple things that worsen, Pratt wrote that were key in changing my perspective on this. And then then the next thing that I I wanted to point out was kind of, you know, why did God reveal something that he knew the Saints were going to reject, right. And and and especially wholesale in the way that happened. I think that's a fascinating question. But first, let's go back to what Orson said. Let me double check that.

34:16 This is Orson Pratt. While while you're doing that, I I just want to give you a warning. You want to be careful quoting dirty surveyors. We're We're all over. And so, yeah, I've, I've, I've, I've previewed all of this, so we'll be good. This is Journal Discourses volume 16, page 5. When he saw the hold that the traditions in which he'd been trained to head upon our hearts, he meaning God, revoked for the time being the law of consecration says when what God revoke A commandment. Yes, that is the way he did in ancient times, and he's the same God. Yet he did it for our good. For if the law had been fulfilled in, or had been in full force for this, people would not have been in the mountain.

35:00 These Sorry. If that law had been in full force, this people would not have been in these mountains this day. Our selfishness and covetousness are so great that as a people we never would have complied with it. A few amongst us might have done so, but as a people we should have been overcome and ruined. But owing to that law being revoked, many of us will now perhaps be saved. OK, so I don't know if if that's doctrinally accurate that it was revoked. That actually doesn't seem to be the case to me. But it is Orson Pratt saying God threw this out there for us because this is the fullness of times.

35:45 You want to know what the full doctrine is, how things work. God doesn't appoint us partial errors. He doesn't say you will receive most of what God has. He says you will receive all that God has. You will become an heir, a joint heir with Jesus Christ. That a joint heir, legally speaking, means you get equal division. Orson talks about that and distinguishes that a little bit. It does a very good job by the way of talking about joint airship and and what that might be different, but that's that is the the order of heaven. And so he's saying, I'm giving you the order of heaven here. And so then we can't live it. We screwed up.

36:28 We're like, this is too hard. And frankly, I think the major reason is because we don't trust. If if God was the one who's the Bishop, then we'd be like, OK, take it all, you know, And we wouldn't be so covetous, maybe. But because we're appointing a man and saying, OK, Brother Drew is going to be the Bishop and say, well, brother Drew doesn't know how to manage his money. He's been poor his whole life. You know, I'm not giving him my $100,000 to give to somebody. He doesn't know the right person to give it to you and you know that sort of stuff. So I think that's a big part part of it. But still he's given his commandment we can't keep. So Orson Pratt goes on to explain a lot of what it's about and and and he says we need to get two things to get this figured out.

37:16 What first is we're consecrating to God. And so he says, this is Journal Discourse 2 page, I don't know, 300 and something looks like 7. Maybe. When a man wishes to give anything, let him give the best he has got. That's a principle the Saints did not get, and Brigham complained about it quite a bit. He's like, you know, some people's idea of consecration is they've got, OK, I've got 100 horses, so I'll give you 10 horses. And one of them's got shoe rot, the other one's got a bad knee. And the other one you know is so old it can barely do things. You know and it complaints people had consecrated cows that had all the teats bitten off by the coyotes and so it no longer could be milked well and you know this sort of stuff and and so people are kind of giving their junk to to the Bishop and so or some products like first of all you you don't give you know your worst stuff you give the best. That's that's what sacrifice has always been like that. So you don't get that.

38:22 And another principle that he hit really, really heavily was to say, look, this is what you don't get. It's the King Benjamin thing. The air that you breathe, you owe to God. Every particle of this planet belongs to God. However, it's been reorganized in the form of a wheel or paper or steel or fork or whatever form those elements are. They're gods. You are just a steward over them. Your wives, your children, you're they're borrowed. They are borrowed. Those are gods, and you are borrowing them. And you need to understand they are gods. Until he himself, with his voice, declares that they are yours.

39:03 They are not yours. The horse is not yours. The house is not yours. Get it through your head. It's God's. And if we understand that, then we begin to understand consecration. And they were just giving back to him. What's his In letting him decide through his Bishop what you get back and what you need. And you know then at that point you get what you need to survive and what you need to do for your business to increase your income and to make more income and more surplus for the next year. That's what you're giving back in excess of your needs, so that every man is developing his talents and producing as much as possible for the order by dipping that up in a way that's the most wise.

39:57 That was the idea. And he said if you understand that the idea is everybody to give their surplus and then we divvy it out to those who are able to generate the most and make the most increase with it, and it's all for the Kingdom and you're all going to benefit from it. If you could understand that principle, then you're you would struggle with consecration. And everybody's like, I earned it. I want to keep it. And the poor feel entitled to help or something. And so they're like, you know, he's got all this extra money and it's not right for me to live underneath him. You know, you shouldn't live above your brother. And they're doing it so they get bitter about it. So everybody's griping at each other. They said you, you're just not understanding the principles here. And so he, they really tried to.

40:41 And Orson frankly did a better job than any of the other commentators and and hit the topic more frequently than any of the other commentators. So this is where it gets interesting and I'm just going to read one quote for you and it's in it's in Journal Discourse 13, page two, it's Brigham Young brother Pat and his discourse had considerable to say with regard to the property of the Saints. I would like very much if the time was now when the Lord would say lay down your substance at the feet of the bishops and find out who in this church would be willing to give it all up.

41:24 So he's basically saying, I would like it if now is the time when DNC 42 was in action. That's basically what he's saying because none of the other sections of the Doctrine Covenants really says that. It says give your surplus or something, but this one just says lay down all of your substance at the feet of the bishops. But this is the key thing. He says that it was so fascinating to me. This cooperative movement is only a stepping stone to what is called the Order of Enoch, but which in reality is the Order of Heaven. So the reason that's significant is because people are saying, well, Brigham Young was trying to figure out the United order, so he started up all these different united orders, trying different things to see what would work.

42:07 That's actually not what happened and there's several commentate connotations in in, in in the book that tell you more of what happened. But this is, this is as good a summary as any as far as being short and pity. What Brigham did is he went around to the different individuals and said what are you willing to do? This is what Doctor Covenants tells us. What are you willing to do? And when the people that he spoke to talk to him about spoke to him about consecration in terms of the the cooperative movement that was then kind of going around, you know, they're like we like a Co-op idea that works. He says, all right, well let's start a Co-op here and we'll do these rules and they're like, all right, we'll try it. And so he went around the different communities and started these different co-ops with this kind of an attitude of saying what are you willing to do? They they weren't that clear in saying it like that, but that's basically what was going on.

43:14 And so Orson Pratt says, I'm really excited that we're gaining some momentum. But what you guys don't realize is Brigham Young is not putting your nose to the ground and making you live consecration. He's putting a nose to the ground to see what you're willing to do so that we can have a stepping stone towards doing what's right. And I just want you to do what's right. So I thought that was fascinating. So instead of looking and saying Brigham's experimenting, trying to figure out how in Hades is where we were supposed to apply the Doctrine Covenants, It's just not clear about these details. It actually, it is pretty clear about what to do. The Saints just didn't want to do it. And there's several discourses where the Brethren are saying you guys rejected consecration, so God gave us some modifications.

44:01 You rejected those two. So it gave you tithing and how many of you are either paying full tithing? You won't do that either in in in people. You know, you've got some few people who say they want to live consecration, but you're not. You're not really doing it. You know, you're you're doing some baby version of it and and they're saying we want to go back to the real thing. That's what Brigham's saying. That's what Orson Pratt's saying. But they're saying we're just working with you at your level. That's what we're doing. And so I I I thought that was really interesting. And so now I look at it more as this is the Saints again not doing their duty and the Brethren trying to get them to do their duty, you know, Right. So so kind of jumping forward in time. So I'm now living in Colorado City which it's it's not because I'm FLDS it's because I'm not it's just a pragmatic living quarters situation found some place that was just worked well for a family.

45:12 And so I've I've been making some some friends out in Centennial Park and I asked to talk to some of them and say you guys have United order that seems to be doing really well. If you drive around the neighborhood down there and you can see they're doing really well there, there's several gargantuan mansions there that might as well be castles there. I mean, they're huge and a lot of the properties are really nice and well kept and very large and everything in their community for the most part is at least middle class and mostly upper class. So they're doing very well financially and that was the case 30 years ago.

45:56 They were really poor and struggling from what I've heard. So I was talking to them and saying and I'm having ongoing discussions with them because this is an ongoing issue for the Doctrine Covenants. I'm going to cover more of these sections as time goes on. I said, you know, I was with Rocky Ridge order for about 15 years working with him on a regular basis and talking to. They were my friends, you know, And there are several other orders in AUB. And I did a lot of legal work for them, and I met a lot of those people. And they're also my friends. So I kind of have an idea of how they've implemented the United order and how they've done things.

46:36 So what did you guys do, you know? And I kind of expected him to sit down. And I. And I told him, you know, I'm wondering if somebody has this kind of information that can sit down with me and say DNC 50 says this, 45 says this, 70 says this, 78 says this, 107 says this. And so we, we did these things. You know, that's kind of what I was expecting because that's that's what I saw, you know? And when I would go to the United orders and AUB, they would say, well, doctor Kevin 78 says this and 107 says this and you know, whatever. You know, they'd all have their two or three verses that they really liked. And you know, they think everybody was messing up and and that's what they would focus on. And and that's great.

47:19 That's how we learned the gospel. And they're just doing the best, you know. So I sat down and I, I talked to them and said, how'd it start with you guys? And and they've got an actually very interesting history of it. But the Long story short is a lot of the people there didn't have a strong doctrinal grasp of the United order. They had kind of tradition and all. A lot of that was FLDS before they split and and so they had a really strong feeling about united order and serving and helping one another but didn't have a strong doctrinal grasp of it. So any rate they had a they they had a a kind of a fledgling version of United or started up. But they're they're they're I don't I don't honestly know their how they call their titles and stuff but I would say they're their senior apostle basically got a bunch of committees together and said I want you guys to figure out and draft up a united order that that that you guys cannot live with.

48:28 And he basically told them I don't want some scholar to come tell us all the things that we're not doing that isn't in the doctrine confidence and why we're wrong. What I want from you is tell me what you're willing to live what are you willing to do and and when he when the guy I was talking to told me, I said told this said this. I said that's genius. You know that's what Brigham Young was trying to do which I had known to tell us researching this section and reading all this commentary because I've I've read some of the histories in the you know the articles and I've listened to a lot of them summarized in meetings and stuff and you know they're saying well bring them out tried this but it didn't really work. So he tried something else for this order and that didn't work either.

49:13 And you know they're they're making all these things out to be human error. And and really what Brigham was just saying is what you guys willing to do and we'll we'll get started And and like I think what I just read, he said this is just a stepping stone to do the real thing and and that's what this guy did. He basically said, you know what, What are you guys willing to do? And because of their traditions, you know, and because the whole concept of consecration is pretty selfless, they had from what I understood and and I've only kind of had a few conversations, so nothing major. But my understanding from is, is they just looked at it and said, well, first of all we don't want any poor among us And so that principle really stood out.

50:01 So you know when when they calculate their tithing historically speaking, I think it's far from accurate. It's kind of how the church does it. If you want to say how do they calculate consecration, Honestly, I've got a quote from Joseph says they're doing it exactly wrong but but the principles and the purpose and intense behind what they're doing is precisely right and so it's working really well for them. As far as as from an outsider's perspective looking into their community I'm super impressed and and and their main principles are first of all we don't want any poor So if we've got somebody who's struggling we they don't just say OK how much money a month do you need to give them a check right.

50:50 Right. They say and and I don't know the all the workings of it but I kind of gather they sit down with an individual and say you know what's the hang up for your business how can we help you be more successful so you don't need our money You know how can because nobody don't you know nobody wants to get a handout anyways if they're really trying to live the possible you most people you know I'm always appreciative if I get it but I feel ashamed right. And I think most people are like that in the gospel they don't they don't just want to check every month and be emasculated. They want somebody to to say, well I just need this equipment or I need this. And so then they work and and they find some resources and they help them with what they need to get them on their feet so they're not poor anymore.

51:37 And then and then everybody's got everybody benefits now because the 4000 a month that was going towards that poor person is now not needed and can go somewhere else. And that poor person's generating money and giving somebody else and you know the idea of what is what is poverty keeps becoming an increased bar, You know, like it used to been somebody makes 20,000 a year, now it's 50,000 who knows, you know. So I thought that's that's that that being their first, primary principle is precisely the feeling that the very first verses that I read to you, it's like if you're giving to the poor, you're giving it to me, you know, take care of the poor. That's what the purpose of this is for. And so you know, whether or not they're following all the technical guidelines, the purpose is exactly what God's trying to do.

52:28 So that's the first thing, and. Oh God, sorry. I I was going to say it it it's fascinating to hear that account because as you talk about consecration, you get one of two answers. The one answer is, well, we'll all just be poor together, and so we won't realize we're poor. Right. Right. And then there is and and I don't describe to that. Right. I don't think that's what the Lord's intent was. I think the Lord's intent was when he said there'd be no poor among us. I don't think he's saying I'll just make all your situations miserable and you'll have no reference.

53:10 Right, He promises. They'll be the wealthiest of all communities. Yes, if if you look at what the Lord's saying, he's like, you really want to want to live this order. Buckle up because you're you will all succeed. You will all go forward. But you got to live by these principles. So I appreciate what you what you point out there that that this isn't an idea of well, we'll just all be poor together. We'll we'll we'll all live in hovels and no one will be able to tell if he's rich and who's poor. And because we'll all be poor, yeah, it's. Quite a faithless view of consecration. Well and. And I'm not saying it's not common or not uncommon. I'm just saying it's a faithless version of it. But, but I think this feeds in a larger narrative, Drew, and it's something that I've seen creep out of BYU more and more, is this idea that consecration was nothing more than socialism with a religious bent.

54:09 Yes, yeah. And and I've been one to that said, I don't think that's it. Right. And and as I dive in and I read 42, the Lord is talking about you know, the harbor raising all ships, right. This isn't just again, we're all going to be poor together. This is about. No. Together we will all succeed and we will all rise. And I find it fascinating that that the history bears us out as well. Yeah. And and and you know I what is the is the brethren are talking too. They're like if we will do this, we will be one of the wealthiest communities there is.

54:54 And to me, that's one of the reasons why I was interested to talk to Centennial Park. Because if you drive around their community, I've driven around a lot of fundamentalist communities. And frankly they on a on a picturesque level, they on driving by community. I mean, you know, and I realize that's a very superficial thing, but they look like they're doing a Dang good job compared to everybody else. I've been through several United order areas and you got junk trailers and junk cars and things piled up on the side and things aren't camped and you know, that looks like white trash.

55:35 And I commend them for trying to do their best and trying to build up and stuff. And sometimes you got to start from somewhere, you know? And sometimes that's all it is, is people are just barely starting out and you know, they're just, they're trying and there's nothing wrong with that. But when you see a community where everybody's apparently everybody's wealthy and they're living United order, you say, you know, that looks an awful lot like the fruit that God promised if you're doing it right. You know, so that's what that's what really got my attention talking to them and and has has had my interest from a historian's perspective and a doctrinal perspective is whatever their feelings are. And I don't know.

56:19 I I don't I I don't know what all their doctrines are and you know all this sort of stuff that they they've got good fruit on their consecration. And I've meet a lot of really good people there too. And and so I have to look at that and say it looks like they're doing something right. And what I perceive it that they're doing right is precisely what I was perceiving from the early Brothers Discourses is saying, look you need to understand the principles behind this to live it right. If not, you're just going to be upset and stuck in your traditions and, you know, worried with the scarcity mentality, What's the Bishop gonna do with all my extra money?

57:01 I gave him, right? And if you have that attitude, you're not gonna make it. You have to understand everything's God's. You have to understand that everybody's attitude in the order is to build God's Kingdom, and you're working together to, to maximize that effort. The farmer isn't gonna bring it up as much cash to give to the Bishop at the end of the year. No matter what you give him, he's not going to produce as much of a cash surplus as the industrial guy is going to do or the banker, you know, Right. And so you give the most money to the banker. You give the most money to the industrial guy who owns the, you know, big company who's going to buy a new machine that's going to create a lot more jobs and and ultimately bring a lot more money into the community. You know, And if you look at it like we're all building together, he's going to pay 100,000 toward the new church. And I'm going to put 2000 towards in our church. But we're both going to worship there and we're both going to learn there.

57:59 And, you know, we're both going to benefit from there. And with if everybody's got that attitude that we're working together to build a community and to build Zion, that's when you can actually make it happen. And then also, you know, the point of this is what you're doing to others, you're doing to God. So take care of the poor and the widows and the orphans first and, you know, do that. So on that level, on just the principal level of what the Brethren were preaching is this is the whole point. That's what Centennial Park's doing, right? Interesting. Now if I wanted to be a cynic and be a jerk, probably, and say, well, you're computing your tithing wrong. You're computing your consecration wrong. You're, you know, you're, you're focusing on these things that aren't even in the Doctrine of Covenants. You know, if I wanted to poke and be critical about it, I could find things to tell them they're not doing right. But at the end of the day, what they are doing so well is what the brethren were saying.

58:58 This is what the consecration's trying to get you to do. It's trying to teach you these principles. And it's the same thing like the letter to Edward Partridge where he's describing how to count, calculate, tithing. It's such a small number compared to what everybody teaches you to pay tithing. And when I was looking at it saying what's going on here, I'm, I'm what? This is what I'm seeing. Tithing is a baby doctor for consecration. What's it trying to do? It's trying to teach you to get ready for consecration. Well, what's consecration trying to give you to you? And Hebrews and Kimball described it like this, trying to get you to learn to love your neighbor more than yourself. It's trying to get you to learn to love, to give and to find joy, compersion in the joy and success of others instead of just your own success, your own success.

59:52 And that's what it's trying to do. And that's all tithing is, right. You know, it's supposed to take care of the poor. Frankly, if you calculate it right, it's not going to take care of the poor. You know, you're going to need more than that. But it's it's trying, it's a stepping stone to get you to feel good about it, you know? Right. And yeah, and and so. Go ahead. Sorry, no, go ahead. That's what I see with the, that's what I see with consecration. That is the principles behind it. That's what the community is getting right. And that's what the early brother were teaching about DNC 42. Whether they know that or not, you know right. That's because they've got good hearts and they're trying to take care of each other or whatever their attitude is.

1:00:34 They get it. And so even if they're not doing things right, they're being prosper because the principles they're planning are right. And that's what the early Saints were not getting. They weren't understanding the principles. And that's what that's that's what the changes we read in the DNC 42 are aimed at, is teaching the principles. And that's what all the discourses about DNC 42 were about. As the brethren saying, guys, you know, you're quibbling over all these details, but it's the principles that you're missing, you know, worrying about what the Bishop's spending the money on. He's just trying to build the Kingdom, you know? That's what everybody's doing and well. I think I think to get to that point to where you would trust and and and this is I'll be honest, this is part of the this is part of the hard part about it right is that you have to have if if you're going to live consecration you have to have you have to be very comfortable with the organization that you're part of right.

1:01:41 That there's no corruption that everybody is on the up and up and doing the best they can. And and I think that is is is the hard thing with that there is is trying to find that organization right and then being able to say OK you have one bad actor but he's just one bad actor and they removed him or whatever and then have that kind of nuance as well but I think something else and and and you've you've gone back to this a couple of times and and I really like what you say there that that at at some point it's about understanding the principle right of of what it is we're doing.

1:02:27 I I looked for a lot of years for a church after my old man died. Want to get more out of listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast? Then go to the Mormon Renegade Patreon page or click the link in this episode Show notes for access to one of three packages for $3 a month. Slightly rowdy options will give you access to add free audio. Still not enough? Then for $6 a month, sign up for the Stirring it Up options, which gives you add free audio and video as well as transcripts. Finally, for those who really want to get crazy, sign up for the $12.00 a month full Renegade option which will give everything in the previous two plans, plus access to a weekly news program which will break down the news of the day from a Mormon point of view, as well as access to a community page where you can talk about all things Mormon and private. Go to the Mormon Renegade Patreon page or click the link in this episode.

1:03:21 Show notes and Sign up today. And I think I probably would have drove those early brethren in the church nuts, 'cause I know I drove some of my leaders in the LDS church nuts because I kept asking the question why? Why? Why explain this? I remember I had a girlfriend in high school who was like, you should come check out my church and she was Catholic. And so I kept asking why. And I remember I got told you're not interested in learning. You're interested in picking this apart. And I'm like, well, if it's God, I think I should be a little choosy, right? I mean, I think I, I should have this kind of figured out. But those principles, right.

1:04:10 It it. And you pointed this out earlier, it was about trying to, you know, consecration was still a stepping stone to that that city of Enoch that people were trying to do that community, that society. And I think Heber C Kimball spelled that out. Well, if you want, you want Enoch City, you want to be those people. Well, this is what you got to do. You got to love your neighbor at least as much as yourself, if not more. And though we, we can talk about rules, regulations, programs, covenants, conditions, restrictions, all those things all day long. But if we don't grasp the principle behind it, good luck, good luck.

1:04:54 Nobody was ever won over by a program or a rule. And if they were, they didn't last very long because at some point every program and every rule loses its varnish, right? It it, it always becomes at some point somewhat burdensome unless you understand the principle behind it. Do you think that's what the early Saints really struggled with more than anything else? Was getting the principle or do you think there was other stuff there at work with it? Yeah, I don't think they they got the principle at all. There was, you know there there was a core group of half dozen families that were interested in. I don't see earlier Candlelights, but now I forgot.

1:05:37 I should just go off the top of my head. But my my brain's already on a different project. The they they had been interested in a in a kind of a communal group they called the family that was started and they were asking Joseph about it. And so he that's when he got the revelation about it. So some people were very interested in the idea of consecration and you know what? I'm sure they gave it a different name and they wanted to know more about it. But most of the Saints were clueless. They had no idea. And then you've got of course, the immigrants coming from across the the globe coming in and and converting and they had no concept or idea of what it was.

1:06:20 And then you've got all these different cultural traditions of who takes care of a family and how's it supposed to be done. And they all have to up into that and do something completely different with, you know, the way the the revelation comes out. It was just it was they just didn't get it. And frankly I don't think the concepts were outlined that much in the original version and I I haven't compared to see what the 1844 version that is the subject of my book, how that compares to the modern DNC. I've done that with other sections and seen changes and stuff. But I I just, I don't care anymore. I just want to know what the early brethren were teaching. So that's as a historian that's what I'm interested in. That's what I look at.

1:07:06 But yeah, it it appears to me they just didn't get the principles. And the Brethren said that multiple times and said, so let's let me drill this point into your head so that you can understand the principles. But, you know, there's a lot of changes constantly going on. They're getting kicked out of Missouri. They're getting kicked out of Nauvoo. They're going across this country. They're getting threatened with, you know, Johnson's Army and they've got Indian problems. And you know, people again, immigrating from all over the world by the thousands and trying to learn basic principles and then add to that consecration and temple building and there's just a lot to learn. And and you know I've, I've been kind of amazed working on this particular project, the DNC Annotated project, because I've been I've been studying now very heavily nearly 20 years and it put out like I don't know 1213 books or something like that, whatever that whatever it is now.

1:08:12 And I'm still learning tons, you know and and I'm constantly running across new things that I haven't seen before. And, you know, somebody from Centennial Park said, well, have you seen the quotes by Joseph that, you know, he, he wouldn't even do a United Order organization anymore? And I was like, no, I haven't seen those. So I said, well, it's a Lyndon Cook's book, Joseph Smith and Law Consecration. So I ordered it just showed up today and I already found those quotes and looked at them and that's not quite how I read it. You know, He said while we're in poverty in Nauvoo, we're not going to try and live consecration as outlined in 42 because we're all poor and interesting and we can't live that law.

1:09:00 We don't have the wealthy to take, you know to start it off and we've got to have a certain degree of wealth to get that going at any rate. And also you know at that point another one of the quotes and I I haven't fully delved into this so I'm, I'm not gonna, I don't want to represent the entire book 'cause I haven't read it yet. But he's he basically says we need Saints that have already covenanted in the temple and who understand what it means. That's your foundation to starting a united order. Interesting, which is you know, that's interesting all by itself. But you know from experience, you you, you have a united order and you get in generations 234 and you have kids growing up who aren't endowed but whose parents have been in the United order and they want to join the order too, you know. But nobody says we have to be endowed first. You just kind of let you start, you know, join them, get a doubt.

1:09:59 When you get a doubt, you know and some order. Some groups don't have the endowment, and so that's not a starting point for them either. No, that's fascinating that Joseph kind of put put a a few litmus tests, I guess, if you will, on on living, the law of con, the living united order, right. This idea of, well, you can't start out with nothing and put it together and then also go to the temple first. That's fascinating. Yeah, yeah, I thought that. I thought that was very significant. And you know, when Joseph Smith originally learned about the law of tithing, he's, he said and I don't, I don't have the quote in front of me, but he said, Lord, I covenant to live this law as soon as I get out of debt.

1:10:56 And the reason he said that is because you can't pay on surplus if your debt, because the by definition of debt is you have no surplus, you have a deficit instead of a surplus you can't pay tithing. Well, now we've got all sorts of problems. Well, what about borrowing for leveraging and you know, all this sort of thing that's, is that really debt or is that an asset that you're really calling? You know, I mean, we modern society's got a lot of little tricks like that they didn't have in Joseph's day. But he understood the idea that you can't pay on a surplus if you don't have one. So he says this as soon as I get one, I will do that, but I don't have one yet, so I can't do it. And so NGU, he's looking at a higher law that's kind of like tithing that requires everybody have a surplus in the 1st place and says none of us have a surplus. How do you even consecrate if you don't have a surplus? That's the whole point is you give your surplus, you know? Well, I think that's interesting too, right? 'cause for for some of my mainstream LDS audience, they're not.

1:12:05 That's something that that you have to look that that. Let me rephrase that. That's some doctrine that's buried deep this idea that you play tithing on your surplus not just wholesale right. And and that that can blow blow people's minds and the fact Joseph said you know makes that covenant as soon as I'm out of debt shows that there's some sort of order to all this. Right. So often I think people have conceptions of what they think tithing, consecration was and and united order, which was well, you just showed up and you just, you you gave everything to the Bishop and then you got a little bit back and you know, you, you, you pay your tithing no matter if you're making money or not, 'cause you got to, you got to pay it, right?

1:12:54 You got you got to be able to to be worthy to see your son get sealed to his wife or you know, baptize your kids or something like that, right. Very much. It's kind of an entry fee, so to speak. Yeah. When when Joseph talks about tithing it's a different picture and I think it's even a different picture within 42. I I think it's in 42. You could tell me if I'm wrong or not where it talks about consecrating your your your surplus right? Yeah, well, technically, and I I kind of misspoke on that in 42, it does say you give everything to the Bishop and he gives you what you need for your support back as a steward in in pragmatics. You know, that basically means you're giving your surplus, you know, 'cause you're getting everything you need back. And nobody's going to take your fork and your razor and you know, your, your, you know, your stuff that everybody's got. They they want to look at what you have above and beyond what everybody else has to see what's usable for something outside your home.

1:13:59 Because if I gave my stove to the Bishop, I don't have one. It's not going to, you know, I'm going to now be the poor and we're trying to get rid of the poor. So but later editions of the sorry later sections of the Doctrine Covenants made that you only consecrated your surplus. And you know, Joseph speaking later, Nauvoo, that's what you know he was speaking toward. So he you know. Go ahead, sorry. So, so to be clear, technically you gave everything in DNC 42 and you received what you needed back. And if you had a disagreement, then you go to high council or something. And Joseph specifically said it's not just the Bishop's decision, but it's not just the steward's decision either.

1:14:45 You know, they come to an agreement and if they can't, then they have a mediator. But later it attended that to say, OK, don't give everything because people are stressed that they're going to get kicked out of the order and they go apostate then they're not going to have a house, they're not going to have cattle. They're not going to have anything, right. And that that's what they were worried about. So they didn't want to do the United order at all. So I said OK, just give your surplus and frankly that's really the principle behind it anyways. You determine what your surplus is and then you give that or most of that to the Bishop and Joseph's looking at it, recognizing you're you're in a standstill. If nobody has a surplus, we've got nowhere to start. You can you can band together like and this is really common with Mexican families you know they come across the border and and I've I've met a number of families like this and each month they get together and frankly the Rocky Ridge order started this way too.

1:15:43 They get together and at the end of the month they say, OK, how much money do we have, You know, and everybody throws their whole paycheck in cash on the table, is it who needs what? And then everybody just kind of says, well, I need this much. And if they've got enough, everybody divisions it out. And usually there's a deficit. And somebody says, well, I can hold off on the daughter's dentist till next month, you know, And then they separate their ways. Well, that's consecrated at heart, but it doesn't get you very far out of poverty until somebody's really got a surplus. And I think by the time Joseph was making these comments, in my view, he recognized if you don't have a surplus, you know, you're just doing like those groups of Mexicans and and it's usually extended family. It's not like there's any hard feelings or anything, but they're just kind of I'm giving you everything, right? And who needs it the worst.

1:16:35 Did they get it first. And and we'll we'll all suffer for whoever needs it the worst if necessary. And if that's so and so's immigration fees, you know, so they can get an attorney so they don't get deported, then that's the most pressing issue. That's what we pay for, right. We'll all work overtime and make it happen. And that's not prospering. That's just scraping pie and and that's why I think Joseph said as long as we're poor, we're not gonna try and organize anything. It's not worth it. Let me ask you. That. That recognition that Joseph had that that hey we you know it it's on you know your surplus right.

1:17:16 Do you feel like that that is kind of the the way it was supposed to be lived or do you feel like that that's like taking a step back maybe like with the children of Israel, not receiving all the covenants, just receiving a portion? Yeah, kind of both. OK, so here's here's how I see. And and this is where I I, I take a step further back from all of this and say why did God set up the consecration like he did in 42, right? Why not just say determine what your surplus is and give that to the Bishop. That's what he did later. But he didn't. Why? What principle was he trying to teach in 42 that we don't get if we just look at our surplus?

1:18:03 And I that that principle as I see it in the early brotherhood talked about, I've already alluded to, but it's all things are gods. If you give only your surplus you say I calculate my surplus. Now I'm going to give some of that, OK, that's a good step. That's beyond tithing. That's good. But what do you, what's your mindset? Your mindset is this is my stuff and this is what I don't need, that I bring in as my income that I've earned. This is what I'm creating for somebody else or for the for the order or whatever. But I created this and and now you can have it well, that that can be a giving heart. That can be a good thing.

1:18:51 But it's not understanding the principle that everything is God. It's not saying God gave to me the talent to make this money. God gave me the resources to make this money brick. God made me healthy so that I can make this money. You know, he didn't allow all these disasters these other people are having into my life so that I would be poor or crippled or unable to make this money. They're not recognizing all of these things or or they're able to not see those principles with the later version of of consecration. So I see D and C42 as God saying I'm trying to teach you this principle and the net result is the same as what I teach later in, you know, in the later versions of the Doctrine of Covenants consecrate just your surplus, you know, that all shows up and the the net result is the same.

1:19:47 You know, if I say give everything to Bishop, he gives me everything I need back and the surplus is what he keeps versus I. We determine what surplus is, then I give him the surplus. The end result is the same amount. But what's different is my understanding of what I'm doing with one understanding. I'm saying everything's God's. I'm just giving it back to him and I'm saying steward over what I need. The other attitude is saying I created a surplus because I'm a good guy, pat myself on the back and I'm I'm, you know, talented or I'm awesome because I can make a lot of money or whatever and I'm giving my surplus to other people who aren't as good. As me gotcha and. I'm not saying that's what everybody's attitude would be, but you can have that attitude.

1:20:34 And so that's why I see God revealing DNC 42 as is and then later changes as things go on. He's, he's just saying, OK, he didn't understand the principles behind here. So let's get to the nitty gritty, 'cause that's what you're so worried about. What percentage of my surplus do I get for for consecration? That's what you want to know. So let me help you with that. And and then after you do that for a while, you'll get the spirit of it. You'll say, oh, this is what it's really about. Give all of my time, talent and efforts. I see. OK, same thing as tithing. It's a small amount to encourage you to say. I felt really good when I gave that money to the beggar.

1:21:16 I felt really good brother. So and so just had an accident. He's been really poor this month. We brought him over this big meal and a couple coats for the kids because winter just started. As kids grew out of last year's, it felt so good to be able to Co give to them and help them out, you know? And then you want to do it again. You know, I know I had, I had some experiences like that early in the church. I grew up Pagan. I didn't know anything about these things. And I I remember a couple times being able to to help other families out and and doing a secret Santa's type stuff, you know, and and just seeing somebody who's really struggling just being because they got help, you know, and you just feel so good. You're just like, wow, I want to do that again. That's to me what hiding is about and and and same thing with the modified versions of consecration. He's saying OK maybe you don't understand the principle. Let me let me give you kind of a Kickstarter here. Let me give you something to spark that understanding in yourself and and maybe you don't get a full understanding of it but at least you're on the right track. That's how I see the emendations to the to the DNC that that show up later and and when Brigham Young and I think it's John John Timpson in Centennial Park come along and say what are you guys willing to do.

1:22:47 You know this is what we're supposed to do but what are you what are you really willing to do. Because at the end of the day that's better than doing nothing. It's at least stepping stone and and you know I to me and then I said to the bill and then when he told me that was his stance. I'm like that's genius right? Because I don't think like that and and and this is where I I I have a really strong weakness this way. Grocer Smith said two things and they're heavily impactful on me and and I forget to step outside of him sometimes. The one is he said I will stand by true principle even if I'm the only one and the other one he said is I've made this my rule with God commands I do it well.

1:23:36 Those two statements those two attitudes are not compatible with what are you willing to do right. That's not what God's asking you to do. Like, what are you willing to do? You know, and and I think it's in TPGS One 49150 where Joseph says when is a man? He says when a man proves to God that he's willing to obey regardless of the consequences, then he will have his calling election mature. So the attitude against God commands, I do it. It's not well, God commands. And well, this is what I'm willing to do, right? That's not part of the equation.

1:24:18 And and you know, there's a different attitude that's required there. And so I don't get past that. I was on my mission one time and I was interviewing for baptism Russian. It wasn't exactly family. It was kind of family and friends and I was they were really poor. And it is. I looked at this situation. I didn't want to talk to him about tithing. I I I was just like you. You guys need help. We shouldn't be asking for your money. Which at the time I didn't realize this correct principle and it's just how I felt about it, you know. So I asked them what they understood about tithing and then it comes, you know the $1000 question, are you willing to pay it?

1:25:00 You know were you coming to do this and you're going to get baptized, right. So prerequisite And two I think out of of of the three family heads that I spoke to said, I said well how do you feel about paying tithing? You know, one of them basically said I don't like it, it's not enough. And he said, God gives us everything. We have our freedom, we have our health, we have all of these things. I've got my beautiful family and I have to give him back. 10% is nothing. And I think I'm a missionary and I'm like completely humbled by his attitude.

1:25:46 It's way better than mine is you know my attitude is a is a 18 year old boy joining the church was see see whether or not I will not open the windows of heaven for you if you pay your tithing you know. And I paid my tithing for the first time because they said just test him like broke man and and I did and I got this huge scholarship to college like boom right away way better than I expected. And I was like, there you go, see. Prove me now herewith, whether or not it will open up the windows of heaven and pour down blessings upon you. You know, I was like, OK, that's my attitude. That's how I learned. And he's saying it's nothing.

1:26:28 How could why even make a rule of 10? That's just like baby doctrine, man. You got to understand. God gives you everything. And and any rate, that attitude is, is what I see germane in in the original section and in what the early Brethren are teaching, complaining the Saints aren't getting it. It's like this is what you don't understand. And here it is, King Benjamin, right at the very beginning. You know you're you're unprofitable servants. Even the air you have is borrowed everything that's made of the earth. Everything that you have in front of you is God's. You're just a freaking steward.

1:27:09 You're borrowing it. And when you die, it goes back to him. You know, get rid of all your pride. Who do you think you are, man? You got caught up in the world thinking you're some awesome something rather and get over it. You're not that awesome you know and and anyway that's that's what I see over and over and over and and and in each change and each page. I just see that kind of a message coming from the brethren saying, OK, this is the the pinnacle of discipleship after after plural marriage consecration. That's that's the pinnacle of discipleship. When are you willing to say I'm not? I don't have a duty just to myself. I don't have a duty just to take care of my children. I have a duty to take care of any of my brothers and sisters who need help.

1:28:06 And it's not a it's Oh, good for you. You're a good boy, man. You're just what a kind, charitable person you are. No, that's my duty. That's something I'm supposed to do because I'm supposed to adopt the principle of understanding, to love your neighbor as yourself. And would I allow my neighbor to be cold in the winter? You know, Would I allow myself to be cold in the middle of winter? You know, No. So why are you letting this brother live that way? Because he's poor. We brought it upon himself. No, let's let's not think that way, you know? And as soon as we get rid of all this pride and we start thinking this way and we receive it as a duty, not just as a good job. I'm, I'm awesome.

1:28:52 You know, let's name the foundation after me because I gave all the money. Let's, you know, write down on the Burger King thing that I, I donated money to this cause and put it on the wall, you know, so that everybody donated some money. Get over yourself and just do it because you love them, you know, It's the same attitude as as the savior. He doesn't get anything out of the deal of the atonement. He doesn't, you know, I mean, maybe he gets more glory, but, you know, really, what does he get out of it? He's not alone in heaven. That's when he gets out of it, you know, and it's it's all for us, you know? I mean, it's unless you just want to say he's selfish because he doesn't want to be lonely, you know? But the the whole gospel program is let me lift you all up to be where I'm at and let me help you to achieve what I've achieved. Let me bring you, God says I will make you join heirs. I'm going to give you everything I've got. The whole gospel program is to bless everybody with the blessings you have and and increase that, enlarge that as much as possible.

1:30:02 And if you have that attitude then you look at consecration, you're like well that's just the whole point of the gospel. It's just to to bring everybody up to the same level and to keep continue to do that. It's the opposite of crabs in the bucket, right? Absolutely. You pull each other out of the bucket instead of keeping each other in the bucket. Absolutely, Yep, 100%. Let me ask you this question. We we kind of started here reading Orson Pratt and Orson makes the statement that that the Lord rescinded so. Does, yeah.

1:30:42 Living United Order. Do you think that's he revoked? This. Revoked. Thank you. Do you think that that's correct what he said there? Sort of. You know, I look at it like this. 'Cause that's a dangerous precedent, if that's correct, right? Right. Right. Well and and I think and and there's no revelation saying I revoked this law. So I I think Muslim Pratt's extrapolating a little bit and frankly he he was pretty from about rebuking the Saints for not living it and saying we need to get back to it. But I think his point is correct and it in a so this is this is kind of how to say this and we talked about this in a previous podcast but God gives the Old Testament law in in Deuteronomy 10. Joseph translation roses comes down from mount with fullness of the gospels sees people worshipping gold cows breaks the fullness of the gospel tablets comes back with 10 commandments. Well that sucks.

1:31:42 The the 10 commandments are pretty chintzy version of the gospel. You can you can laud them and say well you know the if you take the principles behind them expands the whole gospel. You know love your neighbor as yourself is a lot better thing than saying don't don't worship idols. You know I mean there's just they're different levels of the gospel and they were cursed. That's what God says. You know, that was a curse, Justice said. That was a cursing to those people to have a lesser law. But at the same time, if God would have given them the fullness of the gospel while they are worshipping a golden idol, they would have all been a condemnation for all the new light and knowledge they had and were not willing to live. So this, this is what I see in the Doctrine of Covenants. Is God saying, OK, I gave you the fullness. That's what this dispensation is about. It's about the fullness of the gospel. But now that I've given you the fullness and you see that you're not willing to live it, let me give you a a, a pacifier and make it a little bit easier for you to swallow and a little bit easier for you to understand and a little bit of a lesser law. But it's not too much of A downgrade, you know, Let me give you something else that you can do so that you're not under condemnation for not living everything. You're doing your best.

1:33:06 And then he says, oh, you weren't willing to do that either. Let's do it again. And then ultimately, here's tithing. And and to be to be fair, and I think tithing is an important principle at some level. I make the argument for it. But at the end of the day, I don't like tithing because tithing to me represents the baby version, that what you do if you're not willing to live the fullness of the gospel, you know, it's being a Christian instead of being a Mormon. It's being a Muslim instead of being a Christian, It's a lesser law. And I don't want to live the lesser law, I want to live the higher law.

1:33:49 And if I'm screwing up and falling and skinning my knees all the day long, that's OK with me as long as I know I'm trying to live the fullness. And if I'm doing something less than, I'm just disappointed with myself. So I just got lost somewhere in in the question, I apologize. No. But do do you feel like like the commandment to to live united, order still still enforced? I don't. I don't think it was revoked. But I I I appreciate Orson's perspective and I see it more like this. God took consecration from the Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints, and He gave it to the Church of the First born. If you're endowed now, you have the consecration upon you. You've taken a covenant to live it, live it, it's expected of you.

1:34:44 But if you haven't been to the temple, then tithing is what is expected of you in the Doctrine Covenants. I I would. It seems to me what the early brethren taught, that no, you don't have to live consecration, just live tithing. It's OK. Oh, now you've been through the temple. Well, we don't have a formal way of living consecration. Just do your best, you know, and that sounds nice, that nobody really does it without a structure. You know, I I was in the church for a good dozen years and or more, I don't really remember. I'd have to go back and think about it. But you know, I there's a lot of amazing people in the church. But to say that you're consecrated, give all of your surplus, or 80% of your surplus, or whatever, you're focusing all of your extra effort to make your brother as yourself. There's too, way too much wealth disparity to even begin to make that argument in the church.

1:35:45 You know individuals, sometimes, rarely. You know, most of the individuals in the church that I met who were more consecrated than anybody else were frankly just wealthy and they still had way more surplus that they could have done more with, right? And that's that's not ripping on them saying they're bad people. I benefited from some of those people and some of those were really good friends of mine. But it's that's different than say, their living consecration as outlined in the DNC, right? You know, even without a formal organization to have the attitude everything's God's, I make 4000 surplus a month and or 10,000 surplus a month.

1:36:30 Are you giving 10,000 surplus a month? Are you using that surplus to make an even greater surplus of giving a huge portion of that to to poor people every month or to a, you know, building the Kingdom somehow? Or do you have 100,000 in your 4O1K? Do you have a three quarter $1,000,000 house? Nobody needs a three quarter $1,000,000 house. I've lived in one before. It's really, really nice. But you don't need that, you know, Right. So you know, that's that's a very, very different question and it seems to be kind of what I'm seeing with Joseph Smith too with those quotes I was alluding to earlier.

1:37:12 And I haven't fully investigated the depth of him and checked around the original sources and that sort of stuff to get context. But she seems to be saying, you know, you, you committed consecration in the temple that you're on your own, figured out, well, that's OK. But how do I figured out I have to go back to Doctrine Covenants, right? I mean, that's the revelation, but it's also kind of like, you know, the 1886 revelation on plural marriage where it says I'm, I'm taking away that burden from the church and now it's on the individual. It's the same kind of attitude. It doesn't necessarily mean that's the best. That's just pragmatics of how things are working. Saints aren't willing to live consecration. So the three of you who want to live it, good luck, You have my blessing, do whatever you want and I will be proud of you, 'cause it's better what everybody else is doing. Gotcha, Gotcha.

1:38:12 No, that makes sense. Well, dude, that was good stuff. Yeah, it's it's. I've really been excited I'm working on this project. I never thought I would be learning so much. That's awesome. You were saying earlier that you know is is is the changes of the revelation Joseph expressing himself or you know learning to express himself better. DNC 76 is even more like that because we've got the poetic version rewrites 76 and says this is what it means, you know, and and gosh, it's such a blessing to have that. And and that's why I started going to find all the commentary of the Brethren about the Doctrine Covenants is because they're saying this is what Joseph meant or Joseph talked to me about this principle and this is what he said. And so I understand this DNC verse differently because of what he taught me.

1:39:12 And you know, you get all these gems and it just completely expands the understanding of what was going on. I was totally sold on this historian's perspective. That consecration was just everybody's just giving it a shot. Trying it didn't work out. So he gave it up. You know, I I mean, I wasn't 100% sold on that, but it looked like there's a lot of. Evidence that way A. Lot of humanity behind those efforts and how else do you interpret it? But now that I've read what their commentary is, I see the humanity behind it was them saying, OK, I'm not gonna tell you what to do, brother, I'm not gonna tell you. The doctrine Covenant says to do it this way, and the Bishop says this. I'm coming to you and saying what are you willing to do? And I'm going to get a group of people together and whatever they're willing to do, we'll use that as a stepping stone. That's that's what they were teaching. And now that's, that's my perspective, that's what the humanity is.

1:40:11 And and I think it's significant difference because now the humanity is not on the Prophet, now the humanity is on people. Absolutely. And I think that's an important distinction. It's something to be aware of, you know? Yeah. Let me ask this last question before I leave because I I I'm gonna go back to this because I find it disturbing what I'm seeing. And I you're you're you're a real intelligent guy. You're well read you're you're you're an author. Explain to people how consecration and united order is different than socialism.

1:40:59 I I think the PAD answer is a good one. I think the PAD answer is one's voluntary and one's not. But I I think the real thing is socialism is an administrative form of government and economics. The United order is in an effort to teach people principles to make them closer to God and that's a fundamental difference And and if you you know, for anybody listening what I would have been trying to express when I asked the question why did God reveal DNC 42 as is knowing we would reject it.

1:41:46 Knowing the Saints would reject revision #1. Knowing the Saints would reject revision #2 because he was trying to teach them principles first and when they rejected the principle he gave them more administrative direction to try and give them something you could do with your hands and in with your body to make a difference in in in how you're living the gospel To give you a kick start to learning those principles. The the one of the things that is not taught very well in the church it it it's actually had some opposition by some some of the brethren about 50-60 years ago and isn't very well taught in a lot of fundamentalism is the purpose of the gospel is to learn truth, receive it, and then live it. The early brethren taught that a lot. I even even found some quotes from Joseph Smith that weren't published very well and some of them hard, really hard to find, saying, you know, knowledge is the power of salvation. You know you're learning principles, and the more principles that you learn, the more you become like God and you find the joy and blessing in it, DNC 130 verse 20 says, You know, that's the famous every, every blessing is predicated upon keeping a commandment.

1:43:14 So why do we have the commandments? They're to teach as principles, but when we live by them bring us blessings. And so the purpose of consecration is to teach us to love our neighbor as ourselves or more than ourselves or whatever, and to acknowledge that all things are God and it's we can get that lip service and that's another thing that Orson Orson Pratt noted. He said what DNC 42 did is he taught the people that they said that they were willing to do stuff but what they found doubt is their lips believed it but their hearts did not and and so it's really easy to say well love others it's yourself OK I can I can do that It's you know you should recognize all things come from. OK I can do that all right.

1:44:02 So you you make $1700 extra month that you don't really need for food or clothing or anything What are you doing with it. Well, I just keep it in my bank and and you know, sometimes we go on vacations and you know we do all these nice things say well, your brother so and so downs. I I don't care what ward branch, I don't care what part of the restoration you're at. You know, somebody who's not as well off as you are. You actively trying to make that person's life as good as yours 'cause if you're not you don't really your lips believe but your heart doesn't because if your heart really believed you would be trying to make sure that Everett that there was no pour among you and and you would be trying to do that because you know that's true principle and you love them And that's that's really what I see with consecration. It's it's not the administrative forms of it are are there to kick start us.

1:45:01 And and that's where I see that's where I was getting at earlier that's where I think Centennial Park really nails it. Maybe they're not getting the administrative details correctly and and I can make a very strong argument they're not if you believe Joseph's the prophet, they are not. But they got the principle behind it well, and they got it right. And that's to me, that's why they're succeeding, because they learned a lesson even if they didn't learn, you know, the the maybe they took a, a path that was waving back and forth on, you know, on the way upward instead of a straight line. But they're still getting, they're moving in the general right direction and their course correctly as they move on and their hearts are right.

1:45:46 And that's the big difference to me between consecration and socialism. Socialism doesn't care about principle. They don't care about where your heart is. They don't care about what you're learning. They don't care if you understand that God is the owner of everything. They don't. They don't care about any of those things. But that's the whole point of consecration it. At the end of the day, God doesn't care if you've got two houses or three. He doesn't care if you've got four cars or a beater. He doesn't care about a lot of these details. So long as there's no poor among you, so long as people aren't suffering below you, and so long as you're willing to give to somebody who needs it, right. That's, you know, I'll give you another example, Rocky Ridge, I had a friend and one of the one of the founders there and his daughter came to him once and he bought her a car for her birthday.

1:46:43 And she came to him and she said, dad, I feel really guilty have this car because, you know, I know that there are families that don't have as nice of a car as I have, you know, And and he said, well, let me ask you a question. If one of these families had no car and really needed one, would you give it to them? And she said, well, sure. And he said then it's a righteous one. And. And to me, that's that. That's the attitude, you know, OK, people, you know, what's his name? Christian Bale drives like some nice truck, but it's not, it's a beater.

1:47:30 I mean, doesn't look like a Lamborghini Maserati. It's not a fancy looking car. It's just it it, it, it's, it's really what's the word? It's mechanically sound. It doesn't break down, right, right. And this guy could buy any car he wants in the world, but he buys a nice pickup truck because he can carry stuff for people once in a while and you know it doesn't fall apart. And and so he's got this attitude. He's not living above his neighbor, you know, and and she she's like the same thing. I have a nice car. It's not a fancy car, but it's better than what other people have. Is that OK? Well, who's are you living above everybody else?

1:48:10 Kristen Bell's like, no, you know, Keanu Reeves. No, I ride the same subway as everybody else. I give people seats whenever there's an open seat. That's the attitude that that makes the difference, you know, and and that's what he was trying to teach her. And you know you could nitpick over details of that, that principle and how he's teaching or whatever, but I think for a 16 year old girl, that's a really good explanation and understanding and that's really what Consecration's trying to teach us. And and frankly Latter Day Saints as a whole, we we don't get that. I I see pockets of it. I saw a lot of that in Missouri, in in those building the temple. Those are some very consecrated men and you know best top notch people in the world very impressed with them. It some of the people at Rocky Ridge you know I've I've seen people that could be multi millionaires living high on the hog and they walk around like everybody else and they give all their money to the order and best people in the world you know so there there are some out there and I'm I'm not suggesting we're not but as a whole all the restoration movements looking at us are we consecrated truly not not even close not even close. We have so many poor among us.

1:49:36 Yeah. And. And for what, You know, I mean, if the church can have whatever $4 billion shopping center across from the temple, surely, you know, and I read a stat once that, you know, all their extra money could buy a house for every member of the church. You know, I mean, imagine what you got rid of the mortgage payment for every member of the church, what that would look like 10 years from now if they were consecrated in giving even just tithing their money. You know, at any rate, they're we're just, we're not consecrated. We're not living these laws as a whole. And I I think that's really sad. We.

1:50:19 Talked about I also get it, you know, Do I want to take my kids on vacation? Yeah, brother. So. And So's car broke down. Do I buy him a car instead? Dang it. I haven't been on vacation for four years, you know? Yeah, brother So and So's. You know, I think this is just me looking at it from a very academic point of view, having never lived fully consecrated within a community, my guess is, is that once that community is up off the ground, right, and it's raising all ships, so to speak, right?

1:51:01 The tide, raise those all ships. I don't think there would be a lot of want of not being able to take your family away for a vacation for a week or whatever. Right. Right. That's a temporary sacrifice. That's a temporary sacrifice for for a long term benefit. Yeah, that will. Becoming the most wealthy people on the planet. Right. I I think those things would come in time. And I I think that's been largely 'cause if we look through history, we have places like Orderville that weren't very successful and were in some ways downright harsh.

1:51:46 But then you got the Brigham City model that seemed to do very well for a long time, like it could have kept going had they chose to do it sort of a thing. And I think too often there's been a extra focus on the ones that didn't do so well, right. Those, those cooperatives or whatever. The the other thing I would I would say about about this whole thing is that and and I've been banging this drum for a while and I'm not. I'm not so dense as to understand that.

1:52:31 It may seem somewhat hypocritical, but I've said for a while, we better start figuring out how to live around each other, right, Gathered like minded people. Because if I think there's also this, this misconception of, well, when the hard times come, right, if if you're LDS, you're like, OK, when the hard times come, we'll just all figure it out at that point, right? A lot of fundamentalists have the same point of view. I tend to be the other direction, like we better figure this out now. Right. So that when it's time we can't right. It's it's kind of like working on the play and football that you really need in the fourth quarter that you never practiced and you're like OK we'll just roll out and do this. And so I, I, I've, I've, I've been feeling for a while that that while it yes it may be hard to gather around like minded people and and get this done.

1:53:33 We better start understanding these principles very quickly, at least if we have the understanding of the principles, we have a point at which we can start from. And so in some ways, I feel like the problem we have now is almost the exact opposite of what those original Saints back in the Pioneer era, their problem was, right? I think if we really wanted to be educated on all the principles, well, now we don't have the federal government trying to kick us out. We don't have mobs kicking down our door. We're not, by and large, we're not subsistence farmers, right. We got some spare time.

1:54:13 We can figure these principles out, right? And and so it's it's the, you know, the living it portion that that's the toughest because a lot of us aren't like minded and if you're in the LDS church, you gotta wait for those orders to come down from Salt Lake to do it. So in some ways the Saints could could kind of live them but didn't necessarily grasp grasp the concept and the principle. So we're in kind of a reverse thing here, right? Where if we really wanted to know those principles, we could. And and that's why I was so excited when you when you texted me and told me that 42 was the next one coming out. Because we we need to understand these principles way better than than we have up to this point. Yeah.

1:55:02 And you know, I I really appreciate that thought and and I'd like to augment it a little bit. To my knowledge, Rocky Ridge Order is the longest standing order in all the history of Mormonism. They started in the 70s I think late 70s and so they've learned an awful lot about how to live the United order and they still struggle and and not in minor situations they they have some really every every few years. You know they they have a few months where they they've got to debate some point of doctrine and the idea that we'll be able to just kind of get together and we'll we'll just pull together when we need to.

1:55:52 It's it's kind of laughable you know when you're subsistence level living and and and I've I've had first hand experience with this last several years off and on after I I quit my law practice we we just hit some really bad Financial Times and we've had our ups and downs but we've had some really subsistence level stuff And and let me tell you when your focus of the morning is to go downstairs and start a fire to heat the house and then your next level is to you know try and figure out how are you going to pay this bill and how are you going to get enough food to get you the rest of the the month.

1:56:35 You don't have time to be sitting down and saying this function of our united order is not working very well. How do we make it more efficient? Right. You know and brother so and so really offended me because he was saying because Jesus is Jehovah, even though I don't believe that he keeps insisting on it and now he's saying because of that he wants to do this thing and he interprets the scripture this way and that's going to completely change how we do our order. You think you're going to just move on past that easily? No way. You know, the closest I've seen to that is, is in Missouri. They have very strong doctrinal disagreements in their community from time to time, and yet they are so awesome to throw that aside and say brother so and so needs a load of mulch in his yard and three hours later somebody's got a low emulch that's in your yard and doctrinally different or not, they don't care.

1:57:31 They love each other and so, you know, you want to learn to do that. Those are the people that I've seen that know how to do it, but that doesn't come overnight. No, that comes. With yeah, they've been they've been going at that for a couple few decades now and they're still struggling in a lot of ways. But they're really good. It's at those basics of helping each other. But even then, you know, I I ran a grocery store there and and we were, you know, working with people to exchange goods and you know, get this resource from this person, this resource and try and make connections and make things happen a little bit better than they were there. And you know, some systems they already had in place, they're doing great. But some systems there's nothing there. And you're trying to find out who can we get eggs from, you know?

1:58:22 And whatever the situation is, it takes effort and work to get the system where somebody's making enough eggs for the community, even if everybody has one or two chickens of their own, because, you know, they're they might need 100 chickens and they only have 50 or whatever the situation is. Those types of pragmatic things take a lot of your time and to think that, oh, we'll just pull together when we need to and make it happen. No, you won't. We will sure want to and we will sure hope to. But it's just things, things like that don't just pull together simply, it's not that easy. Ask anybody in a management situation, you know how easy it is to manage people. Or ask a polygamist with five wives how easy is it to manage your family?

1:59:10 And they're not going to give you a pat two second answer And and that's, you know, when you get in the survival mode and everything's falling apart and all of a sudden you realize, wow, we we don't have anybody. The manufacturers metal stuff and I need a Smith. What am I going to do that's going to be 3 days of researching for you or four days a week or you know and then you might have trouble getting them to do it because they're backlogged. It's just that the solutions aren't that simple. We really do need to be banding together more now like you're saying. And and I've seen a lot of people move by the spirit to try and do different things to get groups to work together that way.

1:59:50 And I I think it's necessary and commendable. I'm I'm super supportive of any of those efforts at whatever level. You know, I've got a lot of doctrinal disagreements with Lebara Knights and with the Kingston Knights and whatever. But I don't care at some level if they're trying to live the gospel the best they can. You know if if if they're just saying I'm just trying to get closer to father, then put it, put that aside. I can. I can put shoulder to shoulder with you and dig a ditch. I can shoulder, shoulder with you and. You know, research something for you so that we can talk about, you know, the best way to approach the situation or whatever.

2:00:33 You know, share our talents together in any type of a fashion. There's, you know, we work with Babylon all the time. Why can't we work with each other? You believe some doctrinal thing. I don't because you think you got priests, took keys from a guy who thinks you know a a schwindler. Who cares? You know, I can still. I can still associate with you. We can still be friends. You know, I've got friends who are pagans. So why can't I have a friend who's Lebaronite? Why can't I have a friend who's kinks tonight? Just because we disagree about who holds the keys or what keys they hold or whatever. And So what? It's just. It's just. Dude, you're you're you're you're explaining exactly what I meant when I said we may not be able to hug it out on Sundays, but we better figure out how to work together on Saturdays. Yeah, 'cause.

2:01:21 Exactly. Because I feel like it's it's it's getting time. We, we, everyone I talk to, everyone that I have an opportunity to sit down and talk with all describe the same feeling. It feels like our society is hurtling towards an event. What that event is, I have no idea. But I can tell you from the general feeling, it ain't going to be great. And so this is the time to kind of prepare and and I would say start with just learning these principles. Go get Drew's annotated version of the Doctrine and Covenants and sit down and read that thing. Read not only what's in your Doctrine and Covenants but read what the early Brethren were talking about because they lived through it.

2:02:09 They heard Joseph talk and they will have insights that we aren't necessarily Privy to until we read those things. But dude, good stuff. I don't think we've ever I've ever done quite this deep of a dive on on consecration and and United Order before. So good, good stuff. Thanks for thanks for coming on again, man. You bet. Super glad to do it. And and you know, I I just, I am so grateful for what you're doing. And I'm so grateful to see other people out there doing the similar stuff. You know, just talking about these things, airing him out. I listened to the debate between Taylor and Was it Michael Ness you? Know there was 1 Jacob Vedrine.

2:02:52 And Jacob, Vedrine and Taylor on. Justin Frankham. Yeah on on blacks in the priesthood and you know I I think that stuff is so good to have out there and to see you know what different people are thinking and and stretch our minds a little bit and and just just to open that dialogue there's so much anti Brigamite stuff out there there's so much anti Mormon stuff out there it's to have a faithful venues where people are disagreeing but trying to come to the truth. I I'm just I'm so grateful to see it out there. I I personally don't do well listening to podcast regularly I it just doesn't fit my work very well. I'm I'm writing and thinking all the time my brain gets clogged and I've got to you know listen to some sci-fi fantasy or something to get myself going but and I'm horrible with auditory stuff but I I love that that we've got the the venue for for people that do and I know a lot of people commute and that's you know their mainstay of learning and anyway super grateful for it and glad to see your your talents go in that direction too.

2:04:05 Well, I sure appreciate that. I I appreciate the sentiment and and dude, our conversations, I always enjoy them a ton. I always end up learning weigh something more. So dude, let's keep in touch as always. And when you you crank out something new, which should be in about 6 hours, right? I mean, if you keep. Yeah, I'm, I'm planning on it. Six hours. So we'll, we'll get you back on. We'll talk about that as well. Where can people find that annotated version of the Doctrine and Covenants? So every everything is on Amazon. Everything's print on demand these days and if I could mention mention on that I'm doing the entire Doctrine of Covenants and dozens like I think there's 60 or 70 or something unpublished revelations all annotated in the same way.

2:04:53 Eventually, as part of this project, I'm I'm doing them digitally so everything's hyperlinked so you can look at stuff super fast. I've got a video on on how that works on Forgot Mormon teaching on Facebook. But I'm I'm ultimately going to be doing this on a whole series. And so if there are any of our listeners, readers, whatever who are reading DNC 76 Annotated, whether it's Joseph Smith edition or Early brother or whatever, if they're formatting things or something you'd like to see change or different, I am super open to critique, criticism, whatever. I'm not super happy with every little detail myself and I'm just I I don't know how to change stuff because of the project I'm doing is so huge. But if if anybody has has thoughts that way understand I'm super open to ideas and thought.

2:05:49 I want this to be accessible to a teenager to read and and understand and follow and learn. And I I'm especially sensitive for the new generation. That's why I'm doing digital versions. But I I anyway, just want to throw that out there that I'm. I'm open to any ideas of how to make it better so that the final product for the the whole Doctrine Covenants when it's done is something that feeds the needs of everybody. Whether it's the mom who's not super well educated, or it's dad who's got a PhD, or it's a teenager just trying to figure out where am I in fundamentalism, you know, Right. So anyway, I just, I just wanted to throw that out there and reviews help help me somewhere.

2:06:37 It helps, helps me get people who are not familiar with what I'm doing to buy, but it also gives me the opportunity to know what my readers will want so that I can put out more. I put up four books last year in 10 editions of new books total and next year I want to match that, do something the same. I've got some really big some topics coming up, and any critique and feedback I've got will just make what I'm doing better for for everybody else. So anyway. Perfect. All right, everybody, go. Go to Amazon, Get your version of of of the annotated version of the Doctrine and Covenants. Drew.

2:07:18 Dude, it's epic as always. And we'll talk at you next time, all right? All right. Sounds great. God bless. Take care. Bye everybody. You're listening to the Mormon Renegade podcast.